Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Petroleum Geology
ELSEVIER
Abstract
The relative importance of petroleum emplacement in inhibiting diagenetic processes and preserving porosity and permeability
in Lower Cretaceous, Thamama Group (Kharaib Formation) carbonate reservoirs of Abu Dhabi, UAE, and in Callovian Kimmeridgian carbonate reservoirs of the Amu Darya Basin in Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan, has been evaluated by combining geologic,
petrophysical and geochemical data. When petroleum emplacement is synchronous with and prior to significant burial cementation
in carbonates, primary petroleum inclusions are trapped in the cements. The process appears to be characterised by steep intra-field
porosity~:lepth trends within a more gradual regional decline in porosity with depth. This has profound implications for the
prediction of porosity in carbonate reservoirs.
Reservoir quality is better in grainstones and packstones compared to adjacent wackestones and lime mudstones in the Kharaib
Formation because of preserved macroporosity (intergranular, vuggy, mouldic); the pore system in the finer units is dominated by
micropores. These features indicate a primary textural control on porosity and permeability. Within the grainstones and packstones,
macroporosity is variably filled by late equant sparry calcite cements. Porosity and permeability variations in grainstones and
packstones at a reservoir scale are therefore controlled by the variation in amount of equant sparry calcite cement. This in turn
depends on the timing of the precipitation of this cement relative to petroleum emplacement, as shown by fluid inclusion data. Where
petroleum emplacement has occurred relatively early, at migration foci, prior to significant burial cementation by equant sparry
calcite, reservoir quality is preserved. Where it has occurred after significant burial cementation, reservoir quality has been destroyed.
In the Amu Darya sequences, primary macroporosity is commonly preserved down to depths of I 1,000 ft (3.5 km) with differences
in the porosity and permeability characteristics of grainstones being controlled by variations in the amount of early, probably
freshwater, cement and the extent of associated dissolution. Small volumes of burial cements do occur, but they do not contain
petroleum inclusions. Consequently, there is no firm evidence that petroleum emplacement has inhibited diagenesis in this area. This
part of the study has shown that it is not always possible to obtain conclusive evidence from the diagenesis to pin down the processes
responsible for the preservation of reservoir quality and that petroleum filling may not always be the primary cause.
The relationships documented here show that the +race for space' between diagenetic waters and petroleum is a major control on
reservoir quality in the Thamama Group carbonate reservoirs, but is not so important for the Jurassic carbonates in the Amu Darya
basin. ~ 1998 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
Kevwords: Carbonates Reservoir quality; Diagenesis; Petroleum; Abu Dhabi; Amu Darya; Thamama Group
I. Introduction
The controls o n the spatial v a r i a t i o n s in porosity a n d
permeability observed in c a r b o n a t e rocks have been
u n d e r s t o o d for m a n y years. Special Publication N u m b e r
36 o f the Society o f Economic Paleontologists and Mineralogists ( S c h n e i d e r m a n n & Harris, 1985) d o c u m e n t s
most o f the processes that can potentially act u p o n car-
58
2. Geologic setting
2.1. Kharaib b~rmation reser~:oirs (Lower Cretaceous),
Abu Dhabi
59
,,,
Legend I "",
....
Boundary
Field
",
I
&
Abu.
Dhabl
~
~'Asab
__
.........
..........
I SaudiArabia
.~rShah
~ - --" _
-:llb. . . . . .
Oman
,,
(,,'
.
Qusahwira
;
)
,~.~.
jMender
0
I
50km
I
Fig. 1. Generalised location map showing the position o f A b u Dhabi fields, UAE.
2.2. Jurassic reservoirs in the Amu Darya Basin (Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan)
60
0
I
~l
E <
t-0
m
u}
co
o
0
-. ,,~,-
.o
,~_~
.~
i.-
a~
~)i::5!}JJ22
ILl
r" ,..,,,_
i=
Itl
o 7'
....
,/
E)
/
\
u.
r~
\
i
\_
\
o
,,0
~,
<
i%
~L__
(0 o
z
o~
W
<
CENTRAL OMAN
MOUNTAINS STUDY AREA
ABU DHABI
Z
,<
0..
IAI
<
61
~.
,.,,
SHUAIBA FM.
L.
SHUAIBA FM.
..
HAWAR MEMBER
KHARAIB FM.
KHARAIB FM.
~" ~1
*NASR FM.'
<
LEKHWAIR FM.
HABSHAN F
>'<
HABSHAN FM.
SALIL FM.
[]
n"
LU
,-n
RAYDA FM.
- ReservoirZone
Fig. 3. Lower Cretaceous lithostratigraphy, Northeast Arabia (from Simmons, 1994). Reservoir zones (X) are marked by the letters A I and numerals
V VI of local nomenclature.
3. Methods
62
uoz.uoH
tlId~,
seJ|a,I/~l
0
0
(9
e,
_.1
LL.
'-J
co
"103
t-',
~
...I
I.J_
.~
~--
2
m
LLI
_z
ej
D@D
o
.g
[...
2~
X ~
v
0_
u~
~
o~
O
0..
0
LL m
ILl ~
O0
"1"
Z
ILl
<
-5
"J
LU
b
E
8
~3
"3
.,...
E
I
>
.~
--
o.g
8~
8
q l d e G seJ l.a,~l
u0z!JoH
eBelsqns
elPp!~
NVlOOII:I=~nNIH L
N V I O
U O . : I X O
N V I A O l l V O
.z:Z .'~
~=
eGelS
[...k .x:,
63
64
Fig. 5. (a) T h a m a m a reservoir (oil leg, Field A) in which burial cementation preceded petroleum emplacement, Abu Dhabi. Note extensive
cementation ofintergranular porosity. No petroleum inclusions occur in the sparry calcite cements. Residual microporosity occurs within the sediment
grains (blue). PPL. Scale b a r - 500 Itm. (b) T h a m a m a reservoir (oil leg, Field B) in which burial cementation and petroleum emplacement occurred
at the same time, A b u Dhabi. Burial cementation by calcite has been very limited. Significant intergranular porosity remains unfilled (blue). Sparry
calcite cements (white) contain petroleum inclusions. PPL. Scale b a r = 500 t~m. (c) T h a m a m a reservoir (oil leg, Field B) in which burial cementation
and petroleum emplacement occurred at the same time, Abu Dhabi. Burial cementation by calcite has been very limited. Significant intergranular
porosity remains unfilled (blue). Sparry calcite cements (white) contain petroleum inclusions. PPL. Scale b a r - 5 0 0 / n n . (d) T h a m a m a reservoir (water
leg, Field B) in which burial cementation and petroleum emplacement occurred at the same time, Abu Dhabi. Significant cementation ofintergranular
porosity by calcite has occurred. Microporosity occurs within sediment grains (blue-green hue). PPL. Scale b a r = 125 tim. (e) Oxfordian reservoir
(Field C), A m u Darya Basin. Peloidal-bioclastic grainstone from the reel" talus facies. Significant intergranular porosity occurs, much of which is
solution enhanced (centre top). Minor cementation by equant calcite microspar partially surrounds sediment grains and fills porosity. A thin bitumen
layer (black) lines some porosity as a final phase. PPL. Scale bar = 500 #m. (f) Oxfordian reservoir (Field D), Ainu Darya Basin. Peloidal-bioclastic
grainstone fi'om the closed shelf facies. Significant intergranular porosity remains but occasional burial calcite spar is observed. The lack of early
calcite cements is evidenced by compaction of the sediment grains. Note the absence of bitumen. PPL. Scale b a r = 125 ~tm. (g) Intergranular sparry
calcite, T h a m a m a Group, Abu Dhabi. Large, probably primary, 2-phase petroleum inclusion, containing orange-brown liquid and vapour bubble.
These homogenize to liquid at temperatures much higher than m a x i m u m burial temperatures, indicating heterogeneous trapping, consistent with an
early, phase-separated charge to a relatively low pressure-temperature reservoir. Scale bar=40/Lm. (h) Intergranular sparry calcite. Jurassic, Ainu
Darya Basin. Arrays of 2-phase, probably primary, aqueous inclusions around a r h o m b form growth surl:ace. Consistent vapour-liquid ratios (and
homogenization temperatures) in inclusions of variable size suggest resetting has not occurred. Dark parallel lines are twin boundaries. One linear
array of densely packed secondary inclusions crosses the primaries and twins at an angle. Scale bar = 30/an.
65
66
-1~0
Kh~aib
AinuDarya
Fm.
-1500.
-2000
m
-25~
3000
-3500
IO
-4000
-4500"
-500020
presentdaytemp.]
0
"40'
[]
, ' , , , , , ,
40 60 80 100120140180180
-1000
Kharaib
Fm.
Amu
Da~a
-1500
"
"
"
-2000
-2500
-3000
CI
-3500'
I
4000"
-4500'
-500C
5
10
15
20
25
30
10
15
20
25
30
inclusions were not recorded at all. The absence of primary petroleum inclusions is readily explained if cementation occurred wholly before petroleum emplacement - but the absence of secondary petroleum inclusions is
more difficult to account for, particularly since bitumen,
i.e. residual petroleum, is present in some reservoirs, and
secondary aqueous inclusions have been trapped. It may
be significant that the Amu Darya accumulations are
dominated by gaseous petroleum, and, by analogy with
phase-separated aqueous fluids in metamorphic and
igneous systems (e.g. Roedder, 1984), it may be more
difficult for petroleum vapour phases to be trapped as
fluid inclusions. However, further research is required on
this problem.
6. Isotopes
67
lO
0.714 (fluorite)
0.713 (dolomite)
0.712 (calcite)
0.7095-0.7090-i
0.7085---
C) -lO
calcit
0.7080"~
I mat,,:
0.7075-_-
C,AJ..CrTECEMENT
-20
-30
-20
07o70-:E
MATRIX
0.7065:
0
PRECIPITATED
IN EQUILIBRIUM
Y'd'g'l C~qETAGEOUS
SEAWATER
-1 0
10
a13C
Fig. 8. Stable isotopic composition of micritic carbonate grains and
burial calcite cements in the Kharaib Formation, T h a m a m a Group,
A b u Dhabi.
tliFitll,
100
200
300
Age (Ma)
Sma~etal.(1994)
400
Fig. 9. Sr-isotope curve of Smalley et al. (1994) for seawater throughout geological time. The values obtained from sediment grains and
cements from Kharaib Formation samples are shown by the arrow.
Note how they are more radiogenic than the original Lower Cretaceous
sediments would have been and in some cases are significantly more
radiogenic.
1000
0
100 E
_E_
E
t
n
z
6
00
o
0
IO-
00
00
0
l-
@&
8.
00
.l-
0
8
.Ol -cqQQD
,001
.o
l
O
(3
I
I
10
I
20
I
.
Porosity (%)
-20
-1 5
-10
-5
10
a13c
Fig. 10. Stable
reservoirs.
isotopic
composition
of calcite cements,
Amu
Darya
MICROPOROSITY
MICROPOROSITY
AND VISUALPOROSITY
Fig. I I Porosity-permeability
data for Thamama
reservoirs showmg
how pore type controls permeability.
Where samples contain microporosity only, permeability
does not exceed IOmD.
betM,een petroleum
emplacement
und
burial cementation
(Fig. 5b,c). the calcite cements do
contain
primary petroleum
inclusions
(Fig. 5g), indicating that cementation
has overlapped with petroleum
emplacement.
In the water leg of such reservoirs (no
petroleum
inclusions),
cementation
has been extensive
(Fig. 5d) and porosities are lower than in the oil leg. These
data suggest that an early petroleum charge, relative to
burial cementation,
is required for the preservation
of
economically
producible reservoirs in the Kharaib Formation.
Despite an overall regional decline in porosity with
ddepth which also corresponds
with the distribution
of
primary petroleum inclusions,
average oil leg porosities
are higher at any given depth than dry hole and water leg
data (Fig. 12a). Primary petroleum inclusions are only
found in the shallower reservoirs along the major structural highs. Typically, porosity varies by about 10% in
individual fields, and the largest part of the variation is
correlated with depth, from crest to flank. Integration
of the porosity, permeability
and petrographic
data has
allowed two end member porosityydepth
curves to be
established,
a water-leg and late oil charge curve and
an early oil charge (crestal) curve with individual
field
porosity-depth
curves running between these as shown
in Fig. 12b. Such a rapid decline in porosity across a field
within a larger overall trend has also been observed in
sandstones (Gluyas et al.. 1993: Emery et al., 1993) and
appears to be typical of reservoirs in which cementation
has overlapped with petroleum emplacement.
A decrease
in porosity with depth within the oil leg reflects gradual
filling of the reservoir from the crest downwards.
This
may be accompanied
by an increase in stylolitisation
with
-4000
-5000
0o
I:IBlac~
-6000
-7000
r-
-8000
-9000
-10000
-11000
-12000
-13000
-14000
d0
1'0
69
40
El OILWELLS
a
Ii DRYWELLS
EXTENSIVE
DIAGENESIS
-4000
-5000
09
09
ILL
cQ.
"O
Xo
-7000
-8000
WATERLEGAND
LATEOILCHARGEL
coRvE
I-
~-
-9000
"E -10000
Q.
"O
- 1500
-6000
///)//
-11000
x
x
7/
-12000
x
EXTENSIVE
DIAGENESIS
-13000
-14000
Xx
10
20
30
Average porosity (%)
- 2000
xX X
40
x
-r
Io.
xx
xx
Xx
(~
xx
eo
i/J
- 2500
o o
=1-='Jo.
00
Fig. 12. (a) Average Kharaib Formation porosity per well versus depth,
Abu Dhabi from oil fields and dry wells. (b) Crestal, water leg and
schematic field trends for the Kharaib Formation, Abu Dhabi
O~
oXxoQeooX
"_ o e |
n
OO
3000
:!.-.
XOx:,: x
.
0
0 000
(~)
20
30
40%
POROSITY
70
ness and character of the overlying KimmeridgianTithonian deposits. Where the overlying KimmeridgianTithonian evaporites are thicker, the underlying reservoirs may be overpressured. Regional overpressure can
reduce the effects of burial diagenesis through retardation
of pressure solution (e.g. Feazel and Schatzinger, 1985).
Very high porosities ( > 25%) in the oil and/or gas legs
suggest that petroleum emplacement may have played a
part in retarding burial diagenesis and allowing primary
macroporosity to be preserved up to 3.5 km burial (Fig.
13), but as no primary petroleum inclusions were
observed in the calcite cement, conclusive evidence for
this could not be obtained from our sample set.
7.3. Comparison with similar studies
A close relationship between the timing of petroleum
emplacement and cementation has been recorded elsewhere in the world, including other parts of the Middle
East, where fluid inclusion data have been available,
though few studies have presented these findings in
relation to quantitative porosity-depth data.
Burruss et al. (1985) used petroleum inclusions in calcite cements as a tool for understanding the timing of
petroleum migration in the Oman-Dubai area. They
showed that petroleum charging of Thamama Group
reservoirs in the area had occurred over a wide range of
time from Late Cretaceous through to the Early Tertiary
(Oligocene). Their work suggests that petroleum charging
in some reservoirs began prior to stylolitisation and burial
cementation. Alsharhan (1989) and Oswald et al. (1995)
have likewise suggested that petroleum generation and
charging began during the Late Cretaceous. This would
agree with the petrographic relationships we have
described which suggest that petroleum charging was
early relative to burial cementation in many of the highest
porosity Kharaib Formation reservoirs in Abu Dhabi,
preserving reservoir quality (Fig. 5b,c), The extensive
burial cementation observed in other reservoirs in Abu
Dhabi, which occurred prior to petroleum emplacement
(Fig. 5a) could be accounted for by relatively late charging (e.g. during the Early Tertiary).
McLimans and Videtich (1989) clearly note that the
more porous Middle Jurassic Great Oolite reservoirs (e.g.
Storrington) in the western part of the Weald Basin,
England, contain petroleum inclusions in calcite cements
while less porous, extensively cemented dry wells (e.g.
Godley Bridge) do not. They note that the pore system
in the Great Oolite is dominated by primary porosity
with secondary porosity being of little importance. This
is similar to the better quality reservoirs in Abu Dhabi.
Primary porosity, and hence reservoir quality in the Great
Oolite, have been preserved where limited burial cementation occurred prior to the main phase of petroleum
generation. Sellwood et al. (1989, 1993) provide
additional data in support of this interpretation.
Acknowledgements
The authors are grateful to A D N O C , V N I G N I and
BP for allowing them to publish this material. The assist-
71
References
Alsharhan, A. S. (1989) Petroleum geology of the United Arab Emirates. Journal of Petroleum Geology 12, 253 288.
Alsharhan, A. S. (1990) Geology and reservoir characteristics of Lower
Cretaceous Kharaib Fm in Zakum field, Abu Dhabi, UAE. In
J. Brooks (Ed.), Classic Petroleum Provinces. Geological Society
Special Publication 50, 299-316.
Archer, J. S., & Wall, C. G. (1995) Petroleum Engineering. Principles
and Practice. Graham and Trotman, London.
Budd, D. A. (1989) Microrhombic calcite and microporosity in limestones: a geochemical study of the Lower Cretaceous Thamama
Group, U.A.E. Sedimentary Geology 63, 293-311.
Burruss, R. C. (1987) Diagenetic temperatures from aqueous fluid
inclusions: Re-equilibration of inclusions in carbonate cements by
burial heating. Mineralogical Magazine 51,477~481.
Burruss, R. C. (1991) Practical aspects of fluorescence microscopy of
petroleum fluid inclusions. Society of Economic Paleontologists and
Mineralogists Short Course 25 Luminescence Microscopy Quantitative and Qualitative Aspects, C. E. Barker, & O. C. Kopp (Eds),
(pp. 1 7).
Burruss, R. C., Cercone, K. R., & Harris, P. M. (1985) Timing of
hydrocarbon migration: evidence from fluid inclusions in calcite
cements, tectonics and burial history. In N. Schneidermann & P.
M. Harris (Eds), Carbonate Cements. Society of Economic Paleontologists and Mineralogists Special Publication 36, 277-289.
Coleman, M. L. (1985) Geochemistry of diagenetic non-silicate minerals: kinetic considerations. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal
Society of London A315, 39 56.
Collins, P. L. F. (1979) Gas hydrates in COz-bearing fluid inclusions
and the use of freezing data for estimation of salinity. Economic"
Geology 74, 1435 1444.
Dunnington, H. V. (1967) Aspects of diagenesis and shape change
in stylolitic reservoirs. In Proceedings of the 7th Worm Petroleum
Congress, Mexico 2, 337-352.
Emery, D., Smalley, P. C., & Oxtoby, N. H. (1993) Synchronous oil
migration and cementation in sandstone reservoirs demonstrated
by quantitative description of diagenesis. Philosophical Transactions
of the Royal Society of London 344, 115-125.
Feazel, C. J., & Schatzinger, R. A. (1985) Prevention of carbonate
cementation in petroleum reservoirs. In N. Schneidermann & P. M.
Harris (Eds), Carbonate Cements. Society of Economic Paleontologists and Mineralogists Special Publication 36, 97-106.
Friedman, I., , & O'Neil, J. R. (1977) Compilation of stable isotope
fractionation factors of geochemical interest. In Data of Geochemistry. US Geological Survey Professional Paper 440-KK, 1-12.
Gluyas, J. G., Robinson, A. G., Emery, D., Grant, S. M., & Oxtoby, N.
H. (1993) The link between petroleum emplacement and sandstone
cementation. In J. R. Parker (Ed.), Petroleum Geology of Northwest
Europe, Proceedings of the 4th Conference.
Goldstein, R. H. (1986) Re-equilibration of fluid inclusions in lowtemperature calcium-carbonate cement. Geology 14, 792 795.
Hagemann, H. W., & Hollerbach, A. (1986) The fluorescence behaviour
of crude oils with respect to their thermal maturation and degradation. Organic Geochemistry 10, 473480.
Hughes-Clark, M. W. (1988) Stratigraphy and rock unit nomenclature
in the oil-producing area of interior Oman. Journal of Petroleum
Geology 11, 5-60.
72