Professional Documents
Culture Documents
[Document
title]
[Document subtitle]
name
Abstract
The study aim relates to the understanding of the relationship of the profit
risk due to Money Laundering financial crimes on banks financial
performance in UK, assessment of the Customer-focused ML Risk
Management solutions for developing business value for the financial
institutions, and evaluation of the integration of AML risk management
and AML compliance for effective and operationally profitable financial
institutions. The methodology is designed to accomplish understanding of
the relationship of the profit risk due to Money Laundering financial crimes
on banks financial performance in UK, assessment of the Customerfocused ML Risk Management solutions for developing business value for
the financial institutions and evaluation of the integration of AML risk
management and AML compliance
for
effective
and operationally
techniques
for
Table of Contents
Abstract................................................................................................................. 1
Chapter One: Introduction..................................................................................... 4
1.1
Problem statement....................................................................................... 4
1.2
Study background........................................................................................ 4
1.3
1.4
Research Aim............................................................................................... 8
1.5
Research Objectives..................................................................................... 9
1.6
2.4
2.5
2.6
Introduction................................................................................................ 19
3.1
Research methodologies............................................................................ 19
3.1.1
Research philosophy............................................................................ 20
3.1.2
Research approaches...........................................................................21
3.1.3
Type of investigation............................................................................ 21
3.1.4
Research Methods................................................................................ 22
3.2
Research strategy...................................................................................... 23
3.3
3.4
3.5
Ethical considerations................................................................................ 24
3.6
4.1
Data Findings............................................................................................. 25
4.2
Industry condition...................................................................................... 26
4.3
4.4
4.5
4.6
4.7
4.2
4.8
Conclusion.................................................................................................. 36
Conclusion.................................................................................................. 38
5.2
Recommendation....................................................................................... 39
5.3
References........................................................................................................... 41
1.1
Problem statement
Financial crime is a burning issue for the financial sector which has caused
major crises over the financial sector. Considering the establishment of
worldwide monetary and political steadiness and the operation of law,
budgetary wrongdoing is dangerous, obstructs vote based system, and
seriously harms the worldwide economy. The allegations against Standard
Chartered come as United States authorities work to take action against
the stream of cash to remote nations, organizations and people joined
with terrorism, weapons of mass decimation and medication trafficking.
Money related wrongdoing's belongings fluctuate yet can be isolated into
three, occasionally covering, classifications: a marker of fizzled states
empowering rebel pioneers and administrations to plunder national
resources and take part in infringement of human rights; (b) jeopardizing
popularity based improvement, great administration and monetary
development; and (c) heightening the danger of unfortunate financial
outcomes because of between connected budgetary markets.
Then again internal revenue Service (IRS) evasion encourages terrorism
on the grounds that money related support is the way to terrorist
movement. IRS evasion is the procedure of camouflaging criminal
continues and may incorporate the development of clean cash through
the United States with the goal to carry out a wrongdoing later on (e.g.,
terrorism). Banks are fundamental to IRS evasion. Both elected and state
government
organizations
are
researching
few
huge
American
1.2
Study background
On 1 April 2013, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) and the Prudential
Regulation Authority (PRA) authoritatively came into power. The two
controllers supplanted the Financial Services Authority under the Financial
Services Act which was gone in December 2012. Since its race in 2010 the
Coalition Government had been redesigning the UK's money related
administrative structure. The Financial Services Authority was disbanded
and obligation regarding monetary security went to the Bank of England.
Inside of the Bank now sits the Financial Policy Committee (FPC), in charge
of skyline filtering for systemic dangers and the Prudential Regulation
Authority (PRA) in charge of the dissolvability and determination of
systemically essential foundations. The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA),
is in charge of guaranteeing shopper insurance and markets regulation,
and prudential supervision of littler firms.
Worldwide money related wrongdoing influences a large number of
monetary end-clients, causes billions, if not trillions, of dollars in
misfortunes, and empowers maverick pioneers to loot national riches. Late
confirmations, settlements and examinations have revealed far reaching
worldwide racketeering and misrepresentation by expansive worldwide
enterprises taking after composed wrongdoing more than managing an
account. The budgetary institutional movement incorporates: affirmations
of value altering (Barclays), settlements of offer apparatus claims (J.P.
Morgan), admissions of government evasion (HSBC), and settlement of IRS
evasion charges (Standard Chartered) (The Economist, 2015). The money
related foundations ought to consider budgetary wrongdoing dangers
inside of its incorporated danger administration structure. As needs be, it
ought to offer thought to the interrelationships and interdependencies
between dangers (Ellen, 2012).
The
coordinated
danger
administration
methodology
obliges
that
danger
administration
of
the
Basel
III
accord
have
between
tax
evasion
and
lessened
overall
revenues
giving
benefits
embodies
how
worldwide
money
related
Research Aim
1.5
Research Objectives
The research aim would be helpful to understand the need for proper
financial crime risk management as well as the intensive pressure put by
political and regulatory author to minimize the risk exposure. The
following objectives will be helpful in conducting the research:
1.6
wrongdoing
counteractive
action
procedure
and
that
government
way
of
thinking
towards
debasement
and
also
wrongdoing, and the like. She concedes until this type requires
exceptional scaled-down size institution, but your woman unmistakably
contends that the primary Tinbergen's exclusively equipped formula had
been down the line of course miniaturized size set up.
In this way, Brigitte Unger gives a first speculative reason of the Walker
model, applies it and shows that she can reach possible assessments of
duty avoidance and sorted out wrongdoing. (Unger et al., 2006) appraisals
the measure of IRS avoidance in the Netherlands from 18 to 25 billion
Euro (year 2004/05), which is pretty much 5% of the Dutch GDP. The
report of Unger et al. (2006) presents a summary of 25 effects of expense
avoidance on society, which are both positive and negative and have an
effect in both the short and whole deal. This once-over joins results for
wrongdoing
rates,
money
related
improvement,
imports,
conveys,
Van Duyne (2009) and his collaborators' work is all in all exceptionally
basic and pose the question about the condition of our present
information about composed wrongdoing and/or tax evasion, which can be
managed in an extremely basic way: There is no hard or showed learning
of the size and headway of IRS avoidance or sorted out wrongdoing.
Neither the FATF, nor FIU have placed assets into changing over the photo
of hypothesis into moving nearer investigative comprehension into the
wonder of IRS avoidance and formed wrongdoing (Van Duyne, 2003). Van
Duyne battles that every part state delineates the washing and sorted out
wrongdoing sensation as an overall means, yet none has contemplated a
multi-country joined key information organization structure (Demiranda,
2002). The inherent unlucky deficiency of finding out about IRS avoidance
is composed by the nonappearance of solidarity and straightforwardness.
From now on, this care has not been deciphered into any further
movement so far. Van Duyne contends, though there is minimal
observational learning, one ought to at any rate concur on what
government evasion should mean. Be that as it may, as it is the situation
with the term sorted out wrongdoing, the substance of an on the whole
saw marvel is regularly underestimated.
Is IRS evasion truly as a reasonable wonder as officials, legal scholars or
financial analysts, think it is? This is an essential inquiry, taking after the
contention of Van Duyne, in light of the fact that if the marvel is
equivocally characterized, one can't focus the volume or degree of its
money related danger. Beside this weakness, there is still (politically) an
expert danger of the impact of the wrongdoing money. Moreover, Van
Duyne censures that another issue, which concerns him a ton, is the
gigantic hole between the enormous totals of wrongdoing money that are
thought to exist, from one point of view (by sensible appraisals) and the
modestly much smaller sums that are truly taken after, then again. There
may
be
two
clarifications:
One
is
the
truly
unsurprising
law
Inside the study, Dobovsek (2007) investigations that will these prison
organizations possess migrated in past times interval towards the
personal places to encourage monetary force, nevertheless he or she is
far more wanting to comprehend that will pounds is before forward state
politic by means of their systems. His evaluation proves that will persons
carrying out categorized out unlawful acts experienced migrated to the
next period of development involving prison organizations to the group of
friends involving financial system. Seeing that mentioned by means of
Dobovsek, it would appear that many people currently possess migrated
that
hawala
saving
money
can
be
portrayed
because
radar
regarding
current
day
guidance
regarding
cost
swaps.
battle
against
terrorist
capital
(Greene,
2009).
To
maintain
bank's money connected well-being and also compel its ability for you to
amplify 'tokens' and also advances intended for effective businesses.
Throughout good conditions, unchecked and also significant prices
involving extortion may induce some sort of bank's discontent.
Extortion can expand the working expense of a bank as a result of the
included expense of introducing the fundamental apparatus for its
discovery, avoidance and security of benefits. In addition, committing
important
time
to
shielding
its
benefit
from
fake
men
diverts
it
similarly
impact
on
the
outdoors
conjecture.
Per
equally
debasement.
Peculiarity
(1996)
investigated
the
effect
of
3.0
Introduction
one
of
the
viewpoints
identified
with
examination
theory,
outline in the business research structure. This was connected with the
study strategy for better application in the comprehension of customer
discernment in regards to the value position of a specific on the occasion
of further uses in the comparative business sector.
This chapter is critically important for the study aim relates to the
understanding of the relationship of the profit risk due to Money
Laundering financial crimes on banks financial performance in UK,
assessment of the Customer-focused ML Risk Management solutions for
developing business value for the financial institutions, and evaluation of
the integration of AML risk management and AML compliance for effective
and operationally profitable financial institutions. The methodology is
designed to accomplish understanding of the relationship of the profit risk
due to Money Laundering financial crimes on banks financial performance
in UK, assessment of the Customer-focused ML Risk Management
solutions for developing business value for the financial institutions and
evaluation of the integration of AML risk management and AML
compliance for effective and operationally profitable financial institutions.
3.1
Research methodologies
study
including
the
authenticity,
objectivism,
positivism,
for
example,
the
inductive
methodology,
the
deductive
far
more
well-known
with
all
the
summary
information
Research strategy
Taking
into
accompanying
account
the
techniques
study
have
methodology
been
produced
and
for
systems,
the
utilization
for
These have been used to explore the research questions i.e. This study
seeks to analyse the financial profit and non-financial performance of
financial institutions operating in UK under national and international
regulations on major financial crimes i.e. Money laundering (ML), banking
activities overlooking UN sanctions and terrorist financing through the
banking channels. The investigation will be carried out by looking at the
major financial institutions of UK where the propensity of money
laundering and other financial crime has high risk to those banks. The
research is intended to answer possible questions like what is the profit
risk due to Money Laundering financial crimes on banks financial
performance in UK. If the Customer-focused ML Risk Management
solutions can provide business value for the financial institutions? How
integration of AML risk management and AML compliance will be more
effective and operationally profitable for FI (financial institutions) in major
UK banks?
3.3
The study has considered two diverse information sorts for two
exploration instruments; for study of the workers, essential information
have been utilized, for contextual analysis reason auxiliary information
have been utilized. The significant information for the study has been
gathered from two sources; essential and auxiliary sources. These are
described in brief in the following:
Secondary sources: secondary data have been collected for the
three banks from annual reports and other news sources which are
basically historical data on time series basis for comparison of three
banks
financial
crimes
management
performance
i.e.
profit
performance for last five years and at the same time the
comparison of the firms financial crime management performance.
3.4
Ethical considerations
impact which
could
be measured
through
extensive
4.1
Data Findings
This chapter provides the data findings for the three banks i.e. Case study
of HSBC Bank, Barclays and Santanders banks for evaluating historical
data have been compared for three banks i.e. profit performance for last
five years and at the same time the comparison of the firms financial
crime management performance (with quantitative method). This chapter
is critically important for the study aim relates to the understanding of the
relationship of the profit risk due to Money Laundering financial crimes on
banks financial performance in UK, assessment of the Customer-focused
ML Risk Management solutions for developing business value for the
financial institutions, and evaluation of the integration of AML risk
management and AML compliance
profitable
financial
institutions.
The
for
effective
methodology
and operationally
is
designed
to
353
Barclays
234
Santander
12.4
Source: HSBC Bank Annul Report, 2014, 2013; Santander Bank Annual
report, 2014, Barclays Bank Annual report, 2014
234
12.4
Figure 2: Fines imposed to Banks by FCA in 2014 (in millions GBP) (Source: HSBC Annual
Report, 2014, The Daily Telegraph, 2015a; 2015b; 2015c)
While such compelling movement helps shield banks from true blue
action, it in like manner suggests guiltless customers are cut off from, for
example, sending trade to their families in for cold hard currency diverse
countries. What's more, also hurting banks' customers, it moreover hits
government tries to decrease desperation in making countries. Similarly, it
can drive money moves into parts of the budgetary system which are less
solidly seen than banks, therefore make it harder for the forces to spot
when chaotic money is being traded. As needs be, banks trust they will
have the ability to go to a simultaneousness with the forces whereby
banks which do attempt to stop denied trades will be managed more
tolerantly when terrible trades do persevere, in affirmation of the
necessity for a congruity between the battling parts.
ending
cash
related
wrongdoing,
considering
budgetary
actualizing
extreme
budgetary
wrongdoing,
administrative
the
fact
that
the
bank
has
business
sector
driving
avert money related wrongdoing and won't lead business with people or
substances in which the organization accept to be occupied with unlawful
conduct.
Monetary
administration
suppliers
are
at
danger
of
a punishment
of 12.4m
on
the Spanish-claimed
moneylender, the UK's fifth biggest retail bank. The FCA likewise
uncovered inadequacies in the bank's preparation and observing of its
guides. Clients trusted Santander to help them deal with their cash
astutely, yet it neglected to experience that obligation. Santander UK has
consented to contact influenced clients and offer change where fitting, yet
the bank expected the level of client misfortunes to be low given the
execution of the basic speculations.
The FCA likewise said that since the estimation of the stock exchange has
ascended subsequent to a considerable lot of the interests being referred
to were first made, that "it is likely that purchaser misfortunes, and thusly
change for some, will be negligible". It included however that clients who
paid for a Premium Investment may be qualified for pay "on the off chance
that they paid for an administration they didn't get". The fine takes after a
year-long
shopping"
FCA
examination
activity
over
the
concerning
UK's
Santander
saving
money
after
"puzzle
area
uncovered
This audit demonstrates that clients are not reliably getting the nature of
counsel on their ventures that they ought to expect when going by a
counsellor in a bank or building society. Whilst there are disillusioned by
the consequences of this audit, we are supported by the activity that the
organizations included have taken to amend the circumstance for their
clients. Since this audit occurred, we have presented new guidelines on
speculation exhortation which have expanded the expert standard of the
counsels working in the business and have evacuated the potential for
counsellors to prescribe items that pay the biggest commission yet may
not be ideal for the client.
The Financial Conduct Authority has fined four banks more than 13m in
the previous two years for neglecting to oversee government evasion
dangers. In 2013, the controller likewise cautioned a further four banks
they were powerless against tax evasion. FCA additionally cautioned four
banks this year they were at danger of tax evasion. After the FCA's initial
mediation, one expansive bank chose to step far from a quarter of 1,500
client connections. In 33% of these choices, the reason was the high
danger of government evasion. All the more generally, generally a large
portion of banks had no reasonable approach for managing exchange
based government evasion dangers, as per the FCA's most recent
assessments.
Numerous incidents were not able to show they had considered the
danger when handling specific exchanges or even made powerful
utilization of client weighs aggregated by staff in different parts of the
bank. At times, bank staff rejected affirmations about their clients and had
all the earmarks of being excessively near high hazard people, the
controller found. Every year 10bn of unlawful stores go through the piece
of
the
monetary
administrations
division
subject
to
tax
evasion
have
uncovered
sweeping
overall
racketeering
and
joins:
attestations
of
quality
adjusting
(Barclays),
Chartered)
(The
Economist,
2015).
The
cash
related
composed
threat
organization
strategy
obliges
that
financial
budgetary
wrongdoing
and
their
potential
impact
on
the
4.2
4.8 Conclusion
Criminal development related to financial organizations impacts the
Bank's business, and also harms our customers and the gatherings. It can
undermine the supportability of advancement and, by fuelling destitution
and unevenness, that of the economies we work in. General Monetary
Fund (IMF) assessments recommend that IRS avoidance thoroughly
speaks to some place around two and five for each penny of the world's
GDP yearly, so taking care of the peril is an essential test for the entire
cash related division. The sparing cash industry needs to respond to this
danger through extensive coordinated effort and helpful association with
governments. Budgetary wrongdoing peril has transformed into an
essential issue for the dealing with a record foundations and the discipline
constrained by the different managerial force like the national banks
affected their shows.
The endemic piece of cash related associations in empowering the
budgetary premiums of free thinker nations and pioneers is certain.
Without such budgetary organizations, these organizations and pioneers
would not be in a position to allow mass detainment, starvation,
manslaughter of political adversaries or tune in acts planned to crush
confinement. Revelations that generous sparing cash houses have worked
with free thinker organizations are not amazing. Significant advantages
can be made by working with, managing the upsides of, and giving
financial organizations to revolt organizations. Charges and commissions
can serve as a lucrative allurement to broad financial associations to work
with oil-rich failed states, all that much financed terrorists, and cash rich
solution cartels. Overall banks have profited generously from driving
business with human rights abusers, despots, political elites and free
thinker organizations. The budgetary foundations were indispensable in
empowering theft of really billions of dollars in diverse nations. Without
the aid of these overall titans of free undertaking, the distortion and
government avoidance couldn't be master.
brought
out
through
budgetary
establishment
that
5.1
Conclusion
the study aim relates to the understanding of the relationship of the profit
risk due to Money Laundering financial crimes on banks financial
performance in UK, assessment of the Customer-focused ML Risk
Management solutions for developing business value for the financial
institutions, and evaluation of the integration of AML risk management
and AML compliance for effective and operationally profitable financial
institutions. The methodology is designed to accomplish understanding of
the relationship of the profit risk due to Money Laundering financial crimes
on banks financial performance in UK, assessment of the Customerfocused ML Risk Management solutions for developing business value for
for
effective
and operationally
free
thinker
pioneers
to
plunder
national
wealth.
Late
Chartered)
(The
Economist,
2015).
The
cash
related
Operational peril organization of the Basel III accord have underscored the
importance of budgetary risk organization threat has ended up being
greatly essential (Moosa, 2007). All things considered banks and other
budgetary foundations have standard tenets to assuage the fiscal
wrongdoing threats of the banks which open them to managerial powers
and constrained unmistakable laws and regulations relating to the
administration avoidance, sparing cash activities sitting above UN
approbations and terrorist financing through the sparing cash channels.
Government avoidance financial unlawful acts cripples the progression of
budgetary associations for two reasons; to begin with, it disintegrates the
fiscal advantage of the sparing cash foundations because of the
relationship between duty avoidance and reduced general incomes
(Ganegod, 2008). Second, client and budgetary expert's trust get
hampered in light of institutional coercion and defencelessness to IRS
avoidance and unlawful activities hurting the brand estimation of the
banks. Thusly, this particular money related wrongdoing is an obvious
peril to benefactors
Recommendation
The financial crimes trends have escalated over the years and the banks
are incurring both direct and indirect costs from the management and
alleviation of financial crimes in the mass levels. The past penalties have
been indicative of the impact of financial crimes in the profitability of the
banks which should be minimized for better operations management and
Basel III compliance. The following recommendations are compiled to take
into consideration from the financial crimes effect in the banks:
5.3
study. Beside this the use of money laundering prevention measures also
have global
impact which
could
be measured
through
extensive
References
1. Agarwal, J. D. and Aman A. (2004), Globalization and international
capital flows, Finance India, Vol. 19/1, pp. 65-99.
2. Akindehinde, O. (2011). Nigeria Deposit Insurance Corporation
(NIDC) Annual Repot Meeting
3. Alkin, M. C. (2010). Evaluation essentials: From A to Z. New York, NY:
Guilford Press.
4. Altenkirch, L. (2002), Techniken der Geldwsche und ihre
Bekmpfung, Frankfurt/Main 2002.
5. Baker, R.W. (2007), The Scale of Global Financial Structure
Facilitating Money Laundering, Paper, presented at the conference
"Tackling Money Laundering", University of Utrecht, Utrecht (The
Netherlands), November 2-3, 2007.
6. Barclays Bank Annual Report 2014 [online] available at
<http://www.home.barclays/annual-report-2014.html> [August 01,
2015]
7. Berney, L. (2008), For online merchants, fraud prevention can be a
balancing act. Cards & Payments, 21(2), pp.22-7.
8. Bickman, L., Rog, D. J. (2008). The SAGE handbook of applied
research methods. Newbury Park, CA: SAGE.
9. Borrego, M., Douglas, E. P., &Amelink, C. T. 2009. Quantitative,
qualitative,
and
mixed
research
methods
in
engineering
Creswell,
J.W.
(2003).
Research
design:
Qualitative,
12.
Deloitte, (2012). Indian banking fraud survey: Navigating the
Challenging Environment.
13.
18.
Idowu, A. (2009). An assessment of fraud and its management
in Nigeria commercial banks. European Journal of Social Sciences,
10(4), pp.628-640
19.
IMF, (2001), Financial System Abuse, Financial Crime and
Money Laundering, Washington D. C.
20.
IMF, (2003), offshore financial centers: The assessment
program, A progress report and the future of the program,
Washington D. C.
21.
Paradigms, methods
and
methodology.
Issues
in
Educational
Maxwell,
J.
A.
2012.
Qualitative
Research
Design:
An
25.
Mitchell, A; Keith, J. & Brown, C. (1992). Banking ethics and
their dimensions. In Hortacsu, A. & Ozkan-Gunay, N. E. (2004):
Ethical issues and attitude in the Turkish banking sector
26.
Nwaze, C. (2006). Bank fraud exposed with cases and
preventive measures. Lagos: Control and Surveillance Associates
Ltd.
27.
Ogbunka, N. M., (2002), Risk and internal control,
Management in Financial Institutions, 13(4), pp.187-188.
28.
Ojo, J. A. (2008), Effect of bank frauds on banking operations
in Nigeria, International Journal of Investment and Finance 1(1),
pp.103-117.
29.
Okpara, G. C. (2009), Bank failure and persistent distress in
Nigeria: a discriminant Analysis, Nigerian Journal of Economic and
Financial Research, 2(1), pp.148-158.
30.
Olasanmi, O. O. (2010), Computer crime and Counter
Measures in the Nigerian Banking Sector. Journal of Internet Banking
and Commerce 15 (1), pp.1-10
31.
Owolabi S. A. (2010). Fraud and Fraudulent Practices in
Nigerian Banking Industry, African Research Review, 4 (3b), pp.240256
32.
Perkel, W. (2004), Money Laundering and Terrorism: Informal
Value Transfer Systems, American Criminal Law Review, 41/2, pp.
183-211.
33.
banking era and the art of money laundering. Journal of Arts &
Commerce, 7(14), pp.78-95.
34.
Razavy, M. (2005), Hawala: An underground haven for terrorist
or social phenomenon?, Crime, Law and Social Change, Vol. 44/2,
pp. 277-299.
35.
Reuter, P. (2007), Are Estimates of the Volume of Money
Laundering Either Useful or Feasible?, Paper prepared for the
conference Tackling Money Laundering, University of Utrecht,
Utrecht, Netherlands, November 2007.
36.
Reuter, P. and Greenfield, V. (2001), Measuring Global Drug
Markets: How good are the numbers and why should we care about
them?, World Economics, 2001, 4/1, pp. 159-173.
37.
Reuter, Peter and E. M. Truman (2004), Chasing Dirty Money:
The fight against money laundering, Washington D. C.: The Institute
for International Economics.
38.
39.
Santander Bank Annual Report 2014 [online] available at
<http://www.santander.com/csgs/StaticBS?
blobcol=urldata&blobheadername1=contenttype&blobheadername2=ContentDisposition&blobheadername3=appID&blobheadervalue1=applicati
on%2Fpdf&blobheadervalue2=inline%3Bfilename
%3D213%5C823%5CAnnual+Report+ENG+ACCE.pdf&blobheaderva
lue3=santander.wc.CFWCSancomQP01&blobkey=id&blobtable=Mun
goBlobs&blobwhere=1278707205507&ssbinary=true> [August 01,
2015]
40.
Schneider, Friedrich (2004), The financial flows of Islamic
Terrorism, in: Masciandaro, Donato (editor), Global financial crime:
Terrorism, money laundering and offshore centres, Aldershot (Great
Britain): Ashgate, 2004, pp.97-126.
41.
Walker, John (2004), A very temptative exploration of the
relationship between shadow economy and the production and
transit of illicit drugs, New York: UNODC document, December 2004.
42.
Walker, John (2007), Measuring Global Money Laundering,
Paper presented at the conference Tackling Money Laundering,
University of Utrecht, Utrecht, Netherlands, November 2007.
43.
Wilhelm, W. K. (2004). The Fraud Management Lifecycle
Theory: A Holistic Approach to Fraud Management. Journal of
Economic Crime Management Spring, 2(2), pp.14-29