You are on page 1of 49

Continental J.

Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 1 - 7, 2009


© Wilolud Online Journals, 2009.

THE LENGTH - WEIGHT, LENGTH - LENGTH RELATIONSHIP AND CONDITION FACTOR OF


Oreochromis niloticus IN GBEDIKERE LAKE, BASSA, KOGI STATE.

Adeyemi, S.O, 1 Bankole, N.O2. and Adikwu, A.I1


1
Department of Biological Sciences, Benue State University, Makurdi.
2
National Institute For Freshwater, Fisheries And Research, New Bussa, Niger State.

ABSTRACT
Length-weight, length-length relationships and condition factor of male, female and combined
sex of Oreochromis niloticus in Gbedikere Lake, Bassa, Kogi State was studied. Seventy fish
samples of total length ranging from 7.97cm to 19.50cm and weight between 20.8g and 309.4g
collected between July and November 2008 were analyzed. Results showed that the male,
females and combined sex had regression coefficient (b-value) of 2.76, 2.87, and 2.81
respectively. The males and females exhibited negative allometric growth. The length-length
relationship had b-value of 1.18, -1.29, and -1.23 for males, females and combined sex
respectively. Condition factor of the population varied from 1.53 to 5.62, females were in
better condition than males. Condition factor between males and females was not significantly
different (P>0.05). Gbedikere Lake is a good environment for growth, reproduction and
survival of the Oreochromis niloticus.

KEYWORDS: Length-length relationship, condition factor, Oreochromis niloticus, Bassa,


Kogi State.

INTRODUCTION
Fish found in tropical and sub-tropical water system experience frequency growth fluctuations due to factors such as
food composition changes, environment changes, rate of spawning to mentioned but a few, length weight, and
length-length relationship can be used to assess the influence of these factors in fish. Kulbicki et al, (1993) and King
(1966) reported that fish growth, mean weight of a given body length of fish estimation and the relative well being
in fish can be known through this relationships length-weight, length-length relationships studies have been done in
different water bodies and on different fishes. Notably among these are the report of King (1996) on some Nigerian
fresh water fishes, Taiwo and Aransiola (2001) on Chrysichthys species in Asejire Lake, Fafioye and Oluajo (2005)
on five fish species in Epe Lagoon, Nigeria and Laleye (2006) on Oreochromis niloticus in Oeume River in Benin.

Oreochromis niloticus is a fast growing and highly prolific species, though an indigenous Africa fish. It is also an
inter-continental traveler (Bardach, et.al., 1972). It has high tolerance to environmental conditions and its ability to
accept compounded and natural feeds makes it economically cultivable and viable. It is characterized by the caudal
fin with elongated body and a number of narrow bands on the back.

The study present information on the length-weight, length-length relationships and the condition factor of this
valuable fish species is in order to aid the management of the lake.

MATERIALS AND METHODS


STUDY AREA
Lake Gbedikere is a natural lake located between Latitudes 30240 and Longitudes 5014E and is about 10km to the
East of Oguma the Head quarter of Bassa Local Government Area of Kogi State.

Water enters the Lake from tributaries that run from River Benue during rainy or flood season. When the season is
over, the Lake separates out. The Lake is about 450m north of Gbedikere village. The water body covers about 400
– 450m and a depth of 10 – 14m deep, depending on the season.

The lake is used for fishing and other Domestic activities; consequently most of the settlers around the Lake are
fishermen (Upper Benue River Basin Development Authority, 1985). The lake experience two seasonal periods; the
rainy season starts in the month of May and last till October and is characterized by heavy down pour which

1
Adeyemi, S.O et al: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 1 - 7, 2009

sometimes have an extensive flood action. The dry season is from late October to April and is characterized by cold,
dusty -dry wind followed by intense heat.

The lake contains fish, other aquatic animals and some macrophytes such as wire grass (Cyperus articulatus) which
are used for waving mats.

SAMPLES COLLECTION
Fish samples were identified and collected from the fishermen catches using gill nets, cast nets, hooks and lines and
Malian traps between June and November 2008. Total length (cm) and weight (g) were taken using measuring board
and top loading balance. Length-weight relationship was calculated using the formula:
W=aLb which was transformed to logarithm of the form

Log W=Log a + b log L

Using instat statistics package


Where W= body weight of the fish (g),
L=total body length of fish (cm)
a and b=values estimated by regression formula.

The condition factor (K) was calculated using the


K=100w (Pauly, 1984)
L3
Where K= condition factor, L=Total body length of fish (cm)
W=body weight of fish (g).

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION


A total of seventy species of Oreochromis niloticus were collected for the study. The length-weight frequency
distribution of the fish species in Gbedikere Lake shown in Table 1.The standard length (cm) and their
corresponding weights (g) are: Males 8.4cm – 19.5cm/23.5g – 309.4g, females 7.9cm – 18.6cm/20.8g – 208.5g,
combined sex 7.9cm – 19.5cm/20.8g – 309.4g respectively.

Table 1: Length and weight frequency distribution of Oreochromis niloticus in Gbedikere Lake, Bassa, Kogi State.
Sex Standard Length (cm) Body Weight (g)

n Min Max Mean + S.D Min Max Mean + S.D

Males 35 8.40 19.50 14.01+3.11 23.5 309.4 109.97+2.81

Females 35 7.90 18.60 13.23+3.01 20.8 304.5 97.15+62.75

Combined sex 70 7.90 19.50 13.62+3.01 20.8 309.4 103.56+67.78

n=Number, Min=Minimum, Max=Maximum, SD = Standard Deviation.

The male length-weight relationship is expressed by the regression equation: Log W=0.066 + 2.758 Log L (r =
0.9529) Fig 1.

The female length-weight relationship is expressed by the regression equation: Log W=0.511 + 2.8669 Log L (r =
0.9609) Fig 2.

2
Adeyemi, S.O et al: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 1 - 7, 2009

The combined sex’s length-weight relationship is expressed by the regression equation: Log W=0.587 + 2.8078 Log
L (r = 0.9574) Fig 3.
Log length – log weight of males is expressed by the regression equation Log W = 2.758 – 1.1801 Log L (r =
0.9529) Fig 4.

Log length – log weight of females is expressed by the regression equation Log W =2.8669 – 1.2914 Log L (r =
0.9609) Fig 5.

Log length – log weight of combined sexes is expressed by regression equation Log W = 2.8078 – 1.2313 Log L (r =
0.9574) Fig 6.

The length-length relationship also had a regression coefficient (b. values) of 1.1801, -1.2914 and -1.2313 for males,
females and combined sexes respectively.

Table 2: Length-length relationship of Oreochromis niloticus in Gbedikere, Lake Bassa, Kogi State.
Sex Total length (cm)
Min Max Mean +S.D n a b r
Males 11.2 24.3 17.75+3.04 35 2.758 1.1801 0.9529

Females 11.0 23.9 17.45+2.99 35 2.8669 -1.2914 0.9609


Combined sex 11.0 24.3 17.65+2.12 70 2.8078 -1.2313 0.9574
SD = Standard deviation, n=Number, a=Intercept, b=Slope, r=Coefficient of determination.

The condition factor (CF) ranged between 1.59 - 5.24, 2.14 – 5.62, and 5.62 for males, females and combined sexes
(Table 3).

Table 3: Condition factor of Oreochromis niloticus in Gbedikere Lake Bassa, Kogi State.
Sex Minimum Maximum Condition factor (k) (Mean + SD)
Males 1.59 5.24 3.58+0.68
Females 2.14 5.62 3.71+0.74
Combined sex 1.59 5.62 3.64+0.71

The b-values of 2.76, 2.87 and 2.81 indicate that males and females showed negative allometric growth, based on
Begenal and Tesch (1978) criteria of 3. Similarly Pauly (1984) did report that a slope value greater than 3 denotes
positive allometric growth that was not similar to the findings Anibeze (1995). This indicates that Oreochromis
niloticus did not obeyed the cube law of growth (Le Cren, 1951) which is not commonly obeyed by most fishes.
Etim (2000) and Fafioye and Oluajo (2005) respectively reported 2.951 and 3.042 b-value Chrysicthys
nigradigitatus combined sex which are similar to the findings of the study. The value recorded during this study
were similar with 1.53 to 2.55 reported by Ekanem (2006) for Chrysicthys nigradigitatus (Laceped) from Cross
River and also higher than 0.79+0.15 which is less than 1.0 as reported by Fafioye and Oluajo (2006) from Epe
Lagoon, this could be due to difference in the condition of the habitat such as Physico-Chemical parameters, plants
and animal communities. Females have better condition factor than the males during the period of this study.

CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS


The composition of both sexes gave a better overview of length-weight relationship and condition factor of
Oreochromis niloticus. The result of this study show negative allometric growth pattern, the b-values were generally
in agreement with results for fishes of the same genus obtained from other geographical areas. Confirming that
Gbedikere Lake in Bassa, Kogi State is a good environment for the growth, reproduction and survival of the species.
The study provides basic information on the length-weight, length-length relationship and condition factor of
Oreochromis niloticus that will be useful for fishery biologist and managers in Nigeria.

3
Adeyemi, S.O et al: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 1 - 7, 2009

The in-depth studies on the length-weight, length-length relationship and condition factors; and other aspect of
biology and biodiversity of Oreochromis niloticus towards sustainable management in Gbedikere Lake Bassa, Kogi
State should be further elucidated.

Standard length (cm)


Fig 2 Length-weight relationship of female Oreochromis niloticus IN
GBEDIKERE LAKE, 4BASSA, KOGI STATE
Adeyemi, S.O et al: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 1 - 7, 2009

5
Adeyemi, S.O et al: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 1 - 7, 2009

6
Adeyemi, S.O et al: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 1 - 7, 2009

REFERENCES
Anibeze, C.I.P. (1995). Aspect of ecobiology of Heterobranchus longifilis (Valenciennces, 1840) in Idodo River
Basin (Nigeria) and their application of aquaculture. University of Nigeria, Nsukka. 153p Ph.D. Thesis.

Bagenal, T.B. and F.W. Tesch (1978). Age Growth in Method of Assessment of Fish Production in Fresh Waters,
(ed. T. Bagenal). Oxford Blackwell Scientific Publication. pp 101-136.

Bardach, J.E., Ryther, J.H and McLarney, W.O. (1972). Aquaculture: the farming and husbandry freshwater and
marine organism. Wiley-Inter-Science. New York.

Ekanem, S.B. (2006). Some Reproductive Aspect of Chrysichthys nigrodigitatus (Lacepede) from Cross River,
Nigeria. Fishbyte (ed. G. Silverstre. Fisheries Section of the Network of Tropical Aquaculture and Fisheries
Professionals (NTAFP). NAGA ICLARM Quarterly. 23(2):24-28.

Etim, L. (2000). Length-Weight Relationship of Eight Fish species from the Cross River, Nigeria. Global Journal of
Pure and Applied Sciences. 6 (4): 571-575.

Fafioye, O.O and O.A. Oluajo (2005). Length-Weight Relationship of five Fish Species in Epe Lagoon, Nigeria.
African Journal of Biotechnology. 4(7): 749-751.

King, R.P. (1996). Length-weight relationship of Nigerian freshwater fishes. NAGA: The ICLARM Quarterly 19(3):
49 – 52.

Kulbicki, M., Moutham, G., Thollot, P. and Wanteiz, L; (1993). Length-weight relationship of fish from the lagoon
of Mew Caledonia. NAGA ICLARM Quarterly 16 (2-3):26 -30.

Laleye, P.A. (2006). Length-Weight and Length-Length relationship of fishes from the Oueme River in Benin (West
Africa). Journal of Applied Ichthyology 22:330-333.

Le Cren, E.D. (1951). The Length-Weight Relationship and Seasonal Cycle In: Gonad Weight and Condition in the
Perch, Perca fluviatillis. Journal of Animal Ecology. 20:201-219.

Pauly, D. (1984). Fish Population Dynamics in Tropical Waters: a manual for use with Programmable calculators.
ICLARM Studies and Revision. 8: 325pp.

Taiwo, I.O., and Aransiola, M.O. (2001). Length-weight relationship, condition factors and fecundity of
Chrysichthys nigrodigitatus and Chrysichthys walkeri in Asejire Lake. Proceeding of the 16th Annual Conference of
the Fisheries Society of Nigeria (Maiduguri, 2001), pp.277-281.

Upper Benue River Basin Development Authority, (1985): Feasibility study of Lake Geriyo by Upper Benue River
Basin Development Authority. Authority Information Manual.

Received for Publication: 17/03/2009


Accepted for Publication: 14/05/2009

Corresponding Author (Present Address)


Adeyemi, S.O
Department of Biological Sciences, Kogi State University, Anyigba.
Email: sadeyemi2003@yahoo.com

7
Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 8 - 11, 2009
© Wilolud Online Journals, 2009.

THE LENGTH-WEIGHT RELATIONSHIP AND CONDITION FACTOR OF Protopterus annectens (OWEN) IN


GBEDIKERE LAKE, BASSA, KOGI STATE, NIGERIA.

Adeyemi, S.O1, Bankole, N.O2 and Adikwu, I.A.1


1
Department of Biological Sciences, Benue State University, Makurdi. 2Institute of Fresh Water Fisheries and
Research, New Bussa, Niger State.

ABSTRACT
A total of sixty two samples of Protopterus annectens (Owen) were examined for this study
from Gbedikere Lake in Bassa Local Area of Kogi State between August and November 2008.
The length-weight relationship calculated for species gave a b-value of 2.55 which is indicative
of negative allometric growth. It attained a length of 59cm and weight of 397g. The condition
factor varied from 0.23 to 0.76 with a mean of 0.39+0.08 and shows that the fish is well and in
good environment for growth and survival.

KEYWORDS: Protopterus annectens, allometric growth and survival.

INTRODUCTION
Fish found in tropical and sub-tropical water system experience frequency growth fluctuations due to factors such as
food composition changes, environment changes, rate of spawning to mention but a few, length weight relationship
can be used to assess the influence of these factors in fish. Kulbicki et al, (1993) and King (1966) reported that fish
growth, mean weight of a given body length of fish estimation and the relative well being in fish can be known
through this relationships length-weight relationships studies have been done in different water bodies and on
different fishes. Notably among these are the report of King (1996) on some Nigerian fresh water fishes, Taiwo and
Aransiola (2001) on Chrysichthys species in Asejire Lake, Fafioye and Oluajo (2005) on five fish species in Epe
Lagoon, Nigeria and Laleye (2006) on Oreochromis niloticus in Oeume River in Benin.

Protopterus annectens commonly known as African lungfish is the only species of primitive family Lepidosirenidae
found in West African fresh waters (Reed et al, 1976). Holden and Reed (1972) reported that the ancient fish did not
form any significant part of commercial catches and that the flesh is tasty but many traditional taboos prevent the
eating of the species.

The study present information on the length-weight relationships and the condition factor of this valuable fish
species is in order to aid the management in the lake.

MATERIALS AND METHODS


STUDY AREA
Lake Gbedikere is a natural lake located between Latitudes 30240 and Longitudes 5014E and is about 10km to the
East of Oguma the Head quarter of Bassa Local Government Area of Kogi State.

Water enters the Lake from tributaries that run from River Benue during rainy or flood season. When the season is
over, the Lake separates out. The Lake is about 450m north of Gbedikere village. The water body covers about 400
– 450m and a depth of 10 – 14m deep, depending on the season.

The lake used for fishing; consequently most of the settlers around the Lake are fishermen (Upper Benue River
Basin Development Authority, 1985). The lake experience two seasonal periods; the rainy season starts in the month
of May and last till October and is characterized by heavy down pour which sometimes have an extensive flood
action. The dry season is from late October to April and is characterized by cold, dusty -dry wind followed by
intense heat. The Lake contains fish, other aquatic animals and some macrophytes such as wire grass (Cyperus
articulatus) which are used for weaving mats.

8
Adeyemi, S.O et al: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 8 - 11, 2009

SAMPLES COLLECTION
Fish samples were identified and collected from the fishermen catches using gill nets and Malian traps between
August and November 2008. Total length (cm) and weight (g) were taken using measuring board and top loading
balance. Length-weight relationship was calculated using the formula:
W=aLb which was transformed to logarithm of the form

Log W=Log a + b log L

Using instat statistics package


Where W= body weight of the fish (g),
L=total body length of fish (cm)
a and b=values estimated by regression formula.

The condition factor (K) was calculated using the


K=100w (Pauly, 1984)
L3

Where K= condition factor, L=Total body length of fish (cm)


W=body weight of fish (g).

RESULT AND DISCUSSION


A total of sixty two species of Protopterus annectens were collected for the study. The total length ranged between
22.30cm and 59.2cm with a mean of 34.27+ 6.33 and weigh between 19.70g and 397.9g with a corresponding mean
of 158.0+78.97 (Table 1). This shows that the specie used for the study were relatively matured.

Table 1: Summary of length and weight distribution of Protopterus annectens in Gbedikere Lake, Bassa Local
Government Area, Kogi State.
Total Length (cm) Body weight (g)
Species N Min Max Mean+S.D Min Max Mean+S.D
Protopterus
annectens 62 22.30 59.20 34.27+6.33 19.70 397.90 158.00+78.97

Condition factor (CF), parameter of a, b and r of the length weight relationship of Protopterus annectens is shown in
Table 2 and Fig 1.

Table 2: Condition factor (CF) of Protopterus annectens in Gbedikere, Lake, Bassa Local Government Area, Kogi
State.
Parameters Values
A 0.0183
B 2.552
R 0.9229
Mean condition factor (CF) 0.39+0.08
a, b = regression coefficient; r = correlation coefficient

The exponent of (b) value of 2.553 shows that Protopterus annectens exhibits negative allometric growth this
indicate that growth in length increase as weight increases and also the rate of increase in body length is not
proportional to the increase in body weight. This result is different from the one obtained by Oniye et al (2006)
when he obtained the b-value for male and female P. annectens in Jachi Dam near Katsina in Katsina State, Nigeria
to be 3.12 and 3.22 respectively. This could be due to the condition of the fish caught during different season,
location, sex, sample site and nature of the water body. The regression coefficient of 0.9229 compares favourable
with the 0.86 and 0.84 obtained by Oniye et al, (2006) for P. annectens male and female respectively which suggest

9
Adeyemi, S.O et al: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 8 - 11, 2009

that the findings of this study is valid. Fafioye and Oluajo (2005) also obtained a condition factor of 1.00 for some
other fish specie from Epe Lagoon.

CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS


The composition of both sexes gave a better overview of length-weight relationship and condition factor of
Protopterus Annectens. The result of this study show negative allometric growth pattern, the b-values were generally
in agreement with results for fishes of the same genus obtained from other geographical areas. Confirming that
Gbedikere Lake in Bassa, Kogi State is a good environment for the growth, reproduction and survival of the species.
The study provides basic information on the length-weight, length-length relationship and condition factor of
Protopterus Annectens that will be useful for fishery biologist and managers in Nigeria.

The in-depth studies on the length-weight, length-length relationship and condition factors; and other aspect of
biology and biodiversity of Protopterus Annectens towards sustainable management in Gbedikere Lake Bassa, Kogi
State should be further elucidated.

10
Adeyemi, S.O et al: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 8 - 11, 2009

REFERENCES
Fafioye, O.O and O.A. Oluajo (2005). Length-Weight Relationship of five Fish Species in Epe Lagoon, Nigeria.
African Journal of Biotechnology. 4(7): 749-751.

Holden, M. and W. Reed (1972). West African Fresh Water Fishes West African Nature Book Longman
Publications, London. 68p.

King, R.P. (1996). Length-weight relationship of Nigerian freshwater fishes. NAGA: The ICLARM Quarterly 19(3):
49 – 52.

Kulbicki, M., Moutham, G., Thollot, P. and Wanteiz, L; (1993). Length-weight relationship of fish from the lagoon
of Mew Caledonia. NAGA ICLARM Quarterly 16 (2-3):26 -30.

Laleye, P.A. (2006). Length-Weight and Length-Length relationship of fishes from the Queme River in Benin (West
Africa). Journal of Applied Ichthyology 22:330-333.

Pauly, D. (1984). Fish Population Dynamics in Tropical Waters: a manual for use with Programmable calculators.
ICLARM Studies and Revision. 8: 325pp.

Oniye, J.S., Adebote, D.E., Usman, S.K and Makpo, J.K. (2006). Some aspects of Biology of Protopterus annectens
in Jachi Dam near Katsina, Katsina State Nigeria. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci., 1(2): 136 – 141, 2006.

Reed, W., J. Burchard, A.J. Hopson, J. Jennes, I. Yaro (1967). Fish and Fisheries of Northern Nigeria. 1st Ed.
Ministry of Agriculture, Northern Nigeria. 226p.

Taiwo, I.O., and Aransiola, M.O. (2001). Length-weight relationship, condition factors and fecundity of
Chrysichthys nigrodigitatus and Chrysichthys walkeri in Asejire Lake. Proceeding of the 16th Annual Conference of
the Fisheries Society of Nigeria (Maiduguri, 2001), pp.277-281.

Upper Benue River Basin Development Authority, (1985): Feasibility study of Lake Geriyo by Upper Benue River
Basin Development Authority. Authority Information Manual.

Received for Publication: 17/03/2009


Accepted for Publication: 13/05/2009

Corresponding Author (Present Address)


Adeyemi, S.O
Department of Biological Sciences, Kogi State University, Anyigba.
Email: sadeyemi2003@yahoo.com

11
Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 12 - 19, 2009
© Wilolud Online Journals, 2009.

SOCIO-ECONOMIC FACTORS INFLUENCING THE ADOPTION OF “GURA” FISH TRAP TECHNOLOGY


IN NIGERIA

Sule, A.M1 ; Sanni, A.O1 ;Olowosegun, T1; Agbelege, O. O2 and Olabanji, M. U1


National Institute for Freshwater Fisheries Research, P.M.B. 6006, New Bussa, Niger State, Nigeria.
2
Federal College of Freshwater Fisheries Technology, Alau , Maiduguri, P. M.B 1060, Maiduguri, Borno State,
Nigeria.

ABSTRACT:
The basic premise of extension that agricultural technology will diffuse from more progressive
farmers to others in the rural communities is refutable. What is conspicuous in adoption and
diffusion of most fishing technologies are basically cost and appropriateness for a large
segment of the clientele. A total of one hundred respondents were interviewed using
questionnaire in both Lakes Chad and Kainji. Descriptive statistics of mean, percentages and
ordered ranking were used to analyse the socio-economic characteristics of the fishers, while t-
test was used in determining the significant differences in the socio-economic variables of the
two set of respondents. Analysis of result showed that the means of ages for the two sets of
respondents were 39 and 33 years, number of years spent on education was 2.8 and 2.3 years,
income of N44, 220 and N27, 260 and number of traps as 58.3 and 26.9. The t-test result
showed significant differences in the fishers’ age, household size, income and the number of
traps owned by the two sets of respondents (P<0.05). Perception indices for the “gura” trap
technology attributes were found to be high 0.89 and 0.91 respectively indicating that the
fishers considered all the attributes of the “gura” technology as very important.
Recommendations in the form of regular monitoring and enforcement of appropriate mesh
sizes, identifying and considering the indigenous knowledge systems in technology
formulation as well as conducting environmental impact assessment on the use the fishing trap
were proffered for rational and sustainable use of the technology for fisheries development.

KEY WORDS: Socio-economic, Influencing, Adoption, Gura, Technology, Nigeria

INTRODUCTION
Adoption is defined as the actual use of a technology on a continuous and large-scale basis. The rate of adoption of
improved fishery technologies by fisherfolks is very low. The question is, how appropriate are the technologies
developed at the research institutes? Why is low or no adoption not given a critical thought? Indeed change in
agricultural technology is one of the accelerators of its development.

Improved technologies are usually released with recommendations in addition to their high cost. The high cost and
investment required are some of the impediments for adoption of most of the improved technologies. When
developing technologies there is need for a development strategy that takes into cognizance, the socio-economic
factors as they apply to the situations of the clientele. The socio-economic factors related to the adoption of new
technologies which include personal characteristics of the fisherfolks and the characteristics of the context in which
they act are therefore imperatives.

This paper discusses the highlights of the “Gura” trap or “Guran Mali” fishing technology. “Gura” trap or Malian
trap was introduced to the Nigerian fishermen by the Malian immigrant fishermen around 1980s, (Sarch and
Madakaru, 1995). The trap gained wide acceptance (adoption) in many freshwater bodies in the Northern part of
Nigeria. The traps are mostly used during the rising and receding floods. At the peak of the flood, it is usually
difficult for the fishermen to operate them though; very few fishermen do (Agbelege et al 2001). Malian traps catch
all types of fish species but mostly Clarias and Tilapia (Agbelege, et al.
2003).

Generally, the effectiveness of the technology in trapping the target fish species resulted in impressive adoption and
diffusion rate of the “Gura” trap, hence the desire for the study to probe deeper and understand the rationale behind

12
Sule, A.M et al: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 12 - 19, 2009

the fast dissemination of the technology. Nonetheless, the problem of effectively harnessing new technologies to
meet the needs of rural development is a highly complex one that requires careful management given the two themes
of development. One is to increase fish production to meet the needs of the teeming population and the other is the
conscious desire to prevent the degradation of the natural resources caused by bad fishing practices. The objectives
of this study are to give in sights into the adoption behaviour of the fisherfolk with emphasis on socio-economic
factors; technology attributes and perception of the fishers on the attributes of the technology as they influence its
adoption. It was hypothesized that there were no significant differences between the socio-economic characteristics
of the fishers in Lakes Chad and Kainji.

METHODOLOGY
The study areas:
Lake Chad lies between latitude 120 N 140 20’ N and longitude 130 150 30’ E south of Sahara within the sahel zone
of West Central Africa. It is a very large shallow eutrophic natural lake shared by four West African Countries,
Chad 50%, Nigeria 25%, Niger 17% and Cameroun 8%. The shoreline of the Nigerian portion of the lake is
characterized by numerous islands that extend for about 256km from the north of River Yobe at Malanfatori in the
north to the mouth of El-Beid at Wulgo in the south. The surface area of the lake is not constant as it has been
fluctuating between 6000km2 (Bukar and Gubio, 1985) and LCBC, 1989).

On the other hand, Lake Kainji was formed as a result of the impoundment of River Niger by the construction of
Kainji Dam. The impoundment led to the creation of the largest man-made lake in Nigeria in 1968. The lake is
located between longitudes 40 20’ North and 40 45’ East; and latitudes 90 50’ and 100 55’ North. The lake is 136km
long, 24km wide at its widest point with an area of 1,250 square kilometers. Though the primary purpose of
constructing the dam is the generation of hydroelectric power, the creation of the lake offered opportunities for a
variety of development projects such as fisheries, irrigated agriculture and improved navigation from the coast up to
the Republic of Niger (KLI, 1977).

The study was conducted in two locations, Lakes Chad and Kainji. The research design for the study was survey and
employed the cross-sectional method while the research instrument was questionnaire. The administration of the
questionnaire was in two phases, which were during the rising and receding floods in the months of October and
May, 2007 respectively.

A two stage random sampling technique was used in this study to get the required number of the respondents in
Lakes Chad and Kainji. The first stage involved the selection of five fishing villages in each of the lake areas. The
second involved random selection of ten respondents from each of the selected villages in the two lake areas. In all,

13
Sule, A.M et al: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 12 - 19, 2009

50 respondents were selected as sample size for each Lake area making a total of 100 respondents (Table
1).dministration of the instrument was in two phases, during the rising and receding floods in October and May,
2007.

Descriptive statistics of frequency counts, percentage, mean and ranking were used for analysis. Student’s t-test was
also used to compare the socio-economic variables of the respondents. To measure the fisher folks’ perception of the
technology attributes, they were asked to indicate their degree of perception on seven technology attributes on a 2-
point scale in accordance with Ajayi (1998) and Anyanwu (2002). The response categories and their weighted
scores were as follows: Important = 1; not important = 0. The mean ( X ) perception score for each of the 7
attributes was computed by dividing the total perception score by the total number of respondents (50) for each lake
area. The mean ( X ) technology attribute perception score was dichotomized as 0.0 - 0.49 = not important and 0.5 -
1.0 = important. The technology attribute perception index of the fisher folks was calculated by dividing the grand
mean ( X ) perception score by the total number of technology attributes (7).

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION


Table 1 shows a total sample size of one hundred respondents from ten fishing communities in the two lake areas.
Five communities were selected with ten respondents each making a total of fifty for Lake Chad and same for Lake
Kainji.

Table 1: Names of Villages and number of respondents sampled


Lake Chad Number of Lake Kainji Number of
respondents respondents
Daban Shata 10 T. A. Danbaba 10
Dumba 10 T. A. Angulu 10
Lagos 10 Shagunu 10
Maiyashi
Abuja 10 Wara 10
Madayi 10 Garafini 10

Table 2 presents data on the socio-economic characteristics of the fisher folks in the two lake areas. Entries in the
table indicated that while (40%) of the respondents in Lake Chad were between the age range of 34-41 years, much
younger fishers (26-33 years) were the majority (54%) in Lake Kainji. However, the mean ages of the respondents
in the two Lake areas were 39 and 33 years respectively. Nonetheless, the ages of the respondents in the two lake
areas are in the innovative category of adopters and are in their economically active years as confirmed by the
conventional studies of Roger (1995); Adeoti and Ibitoye (2002) and Fanikayode and Oloruntoba (2002), where
younger people are regarded as more innovative, responsive and adaptive to change than the older people who prefer
to stick to traditional practices for risk aversion.

Educationally, the mean numbers of years spent by the respondents in the study areas were 2.8 and 2.3 years
respectively. Though, there exists disparity in the mean years spent on education in the two study locations, there
was a general low literacy level among the two sets of respondents as a larger chunk of 68-70% were not educated.

The implication of this is that for any technology to be successfully transferred and adopted the technology itself has
to be self appealing in its attributes or more effort has to be put on awareness creation and persuasion in order to
generate the needed interest for its adoption.

Data on household size indicated large mean household sizes for both sets of respondents. While the mean
household size for a respondent in Lake Chad was 9.6 that of Lake Kainji were 7.4. These values are considered
large and a welcome advantage for the fishers as more hands would be available for easing the labour involved in
the use of the technology for fish production in the lakes. The mean monthly income level of the respondents in
lakes Chad and Kainji were N44, 220 and N 27, 260 respectively. This means that by virtue of their income from

14
Sule, A.M et al: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 12 - 19, 2009

the use of the fish traps, the Lake Chad fishers are much more financially buoyant than their counter parts in Lake
Kainji. This is probably due to the difference in the scale of fishing activities using the traps, differences in the size
of the traps and amount of traps owned favoured the Lake Chad fishers.

The mean numbers of traps at the disposal of the fishers from the two lake areas are 58.3 for Lake Chad fishers and
26.9 for Lake Kainji fishers. This observed difference in the number of traps could in turn be explained by amount
of money available with each of the fisher folks for the procurement of the technology.

Table 2: Socio- economic characteristics of the respondents in Lakes Chad and kainji.

Socio-economic Lake Chad Lake Kainji


characteristics
Age (yrs) Freq. % Lake Kainji
18-25 3 6 6 12 ( X ) Age
26-33 6 12 27 54 L. Chad = 39 years
34-41 20 40 11 22 L. Kainji = 35 yrs
42-49 18 36 4 8
50-57 3 6 2 4
Total 50 100 50 100
Education
Tertiary - - - - -
Secondary 5 10 3 6
Primary 4 8 7 14 ( X ) No. of yrs in education
Quranic 7 14 5 10 L. Chad = 2.80
None 34 68 35 70 L. Kainji = 2.30
Total 50 100 50 100
Household size
1-5 7 14 10 20
6-10 24 48 32 64 ( X ) HHS
11-15 14 28 7 14 L. Chad = 9.6
16-20 3 6 0 0 L. Kainji = 7.4
21-25 2 4 1 2
Total 50 100 50 100
Income (N000)
10-30 18 36 37 74 ( X ) = income
31-50 18 36 12 24 L. Chad = N44,220.00
51-70 8 16 1 2 L. Kainji = N27,260.00
71-90 4 8 - -
> - 90 2 4 - -
Total 50 100 50 100
No. of traps
owned
10-30 15 30 43 86 ( X ) No of traps owned
31-50 15 30 7 14 L. Chad = 58.3
51-70 9 18 - - L. Kainji = 36.9
71-90 5 10 - -
> - 90 6 12 - -
Total 50 100 50 100

15
Sule, A.M et al: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 12 - 19, 2009

The result of the t-test analysis of the socio-economic characteristics of the respondents presented in table 3 showed
that there exists significant differences (P<0.05) in the fishers age, household size, income and the number of traps
owned by the respondents in the two Lake Areas. However, the result showed that there was no significant
difference in the level of education of the two set of fishers in Lakes Chad and Kainji. It could therefore be seen that
fishers’ age, household size, income and the number of traps owned are important factors which influenced the
respondents’ perception of the attributes of the technology in the two lake areas.

Table 3: T-test result of the socio-economic characteristics of the respondents in Lakes Chad and Kainji.
Socio-economic Variables Lake Chad Lake Kainji Decision
Age:
Mean values 39.34
t-stat 3.91 33.0 Reject Ho
t-critical (2 tail) 2.00
Education
Mean values 2.78
t-stat 0.51 2.34 Accept Ho
t-critical 2.00
Household size
Mean values 9.62
t-stat 2.50 7.94 Reject Ho
t-critical 2.01
Income
Mean values 44.2
t-stat 5.51 27.3 Reject Ho
t-critical 2.01
No of traps owned
Mean values 58.3
t-stat 5.86 26.9 Reject Ho
t-critical 2.009
Ho = null hypothesis, Degree of freedom = 49, P<0.05.

The sources of information on “gura” technology was sought from the fishermen in both lakes and classified into
personal and impersonal information sources as shown in table 4. The primary goals of the various sources are to
create awareness by diffusing among potential adopters on useful and practical information and encourage its
application. Personal channels involved a one-to-one interaction between sender and receiver and it enables the
sender to tailor the message more appropriately and react to the receiver through a feedback mechanism (Katz, et al,
1963). Thus, they tend to be more effective than impersonal channels in transmitting information on technology
among the resource poor and illiterate clientele.

The result of the study on Table 4 showed that the personal information source (Fellow Fishermen/neighbours) was
the only information source responsible for the “gura’ technology adoption. Hence, 100% of the respondents
obtained their information from fellow fishermen/neighbours. The implication is that the technology did not
emanate from the research institutes. It was based on indigenous knowledge system and therefore enjoyed no
formal extension dissemination strategies.

16
Sule, A.M et al: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 12 - 19, 2009

Table 4: Sources of information


Sources of Information Percentage
Lake Chad Lake Kainji
Extension workers - -
Fellow fishermen/neighbours 100 100
Radio farm programmes - -
News letter - -
Research bulletins - -
Television farm programmes - -
Total 100 100

Table 5 showed the mean ratings and rankings of the seven attributes of the “gura” trap fishing technology by the
respondents in Lakes Chad and Kainji. Analysis of these attributes showed that in Lake Chad the fishers considered
the technology to be cheap and affordable ( X ) = 1.0) with minimum price of N500 and maximum of N1000 per
unit as the most important attribute. The trap being readily available and ease of operation were considered as
second most important attributes of the technology. ( X ) = 0.96). However, the attribute that the catches attract
better price was the least important attribute ( X ) = 0.70) of the technology for the Lake Chad respondents.

On the other hand, fishers in Lake Kainji considered the ease of operation of the technology and its compatibility
with the existing practice as the most important attribute ( X ) = 1.0) of the technology. The perception of the
attribute of the technology that it is cheap and affordable was the least important attribute to Kainji Lake
respondents. The implications of these results are that what the Lake Chad fishers considered as cheap and
affordable might not be seen that way by the Kainji Lake Fishers. This might probably be due to the fact that the
Lake Chad fishers are wealthier than their Lake Kainji counterparts. Secondly, Kainji Lake fishers tended to prefer
a technology that is compatible with the existing practice and easy to operate.

Analysis also showed that the mean ratings of the perception scores for the two sets of respondents in the two Lake
areas ranges from a minimum of 0.70 to 1.0 which showed that all the ‘gura’ trap fishing technology attributes are
considered important by the fisher folks. Similarly, the perception index of 0.89 and 0.91 for lakes Chad and Kainji
equally showed that all the technology attributes are perceived very important by the respondents in the study areas.

The overwhelming importance of the attributes of “gura” trap fishing technology and its acceptance by the fishers in
both lake areas stemmed from the fact that many technologies designed for agriculture are basically inappropriate
for a large segment of the clientele, and therefore the solution lies in the design of appropriate technology (Morrison
et al, 1984). Hence, if technology which is appropriate for the resource poor farmer can be designed, adoption and
diffusion can proceed from that type of farmer to the aggregate rather than the other way round (Rogers, 1983).

Therefore, small farmers will adopt appropriate technology, if it is economically and technically superior for their
farming or fishing systems, just as rapidly as the larger, so called “progressive” farmers (Luning, 1982). Thus,
‘gura’ fishing trap technology tends to satisfy the above conditions of appropriate technology and thence its
adoption and diffusion is self propagating. This finding confirmed with consistency what was discovered in a
previous study by Sule et al. (1994) that for a fishery innovation to be adopted, the equipment has to be cheap or
loans have to be made available to facilitate adoption; the catches have to look attractive; the operation has to be
simple, and maintenance facilities have to be made available while the technique should be compatible with already
existing practices.

17
Sule, A.M et al: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 12 - 19, 2009

Table 5: Fisher folk’s perception of the attributes of the “gura’ trap fishing technology.
S/No Technology Attributes Lake Chad Lake Kainji
Mean rating Rank Mean rating Rank
1 Cheap and affordable 1.0 1st 0.74 7th
2 Readily available 0.96 2nd 0.90 5th
3 Compatibility with existing practice 0.94 4th 1.0 1st
4 Catches very well 0.86 5th 0.94 3rd
5 Catches attracts better price 0.80 6th 0.88 6th
6 Catches are hauled live 0.70 7th 0.92 4th
7 Ease of operation 0.96 2nd 1.0 1st
Total mean scores 6.22 6.38
Perception index 0.89 0.91

Explaining adoption behaviour on innovativeness as an individual trait indicates unwillingness, and conceals the
inability to adopt. In essence, a fisher or fish farmer may be willing to adopt an innovation but his socio-economic
status might be the major factor for his/her inability and not necessarily unwillingness.

For the very low cost and other appealing attributes of the ‘gura’ fish trap technology, its diffusion was like an
inferno even without any formal disseminating efforts from any extension agents. Hence, the resource poor fisher
folks are not only unable to capitalize on the benefits of improved technologies but are placed at a further
competitive disadvantage by those who can.

CONCLUSION
The diffusion of the ‘gura’ technology is simply the result of individual adoption decisions facilitated by
interpersonal information sources. The overwhelming factors responsible for the adoption are the technology
attributes which tallied with the expectation of the fishermen. The observed variation among the fishers from the
two study sites over which attribute most appeal to the respondents was engendered by the differences in their socio-
economic characteristics.

However, the problem of effectively harnessing new technologies to meet the needs of rural development is a highly
complex one involving all the stakeholders with the government as a regulating entity.

RECOMMENDATIONS
The following recommendations are therefore proffered for proper management of Gura fish trap technology for
sustainability.
1. There is an urgent need to check the use of under mesh sizes and water channel fencing by the research
Institutes, Federal Department of Fisheries and States Fishery Departments in their areas of
jurisdiction.

2. The finding of this study tends to underscore the importance of indigenous knowledge system. Hence
for technology generation and adoption to be more successful, there is the need for the participation of
the clientele who are the intended beneficiaries to be carried along from inception and in line with their
indigenous knowledge system.

3. It is necessary to conduct further studies on the environmental impact assessment arising from the wide
acceptance and use of the “gura” trap fishing technology. This will provide avenue for a more rational
decision on ways of regulating the impacts of similar technologies on fish species abundance and
depletion in lakes, deforestation and ecosystem balance.

18
Sule, A.M et al: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 12 - 19, 2009

REFERENCES
Adeoti A.I. and Ibitoye O.A. (2002). Determinants of participation in urban Agriculture in Ibadan North-West
Local Government Area of Oyo State. Journal of Agricultural Extension Vol. 6 pp.34-40.

Agbelege, O.O. and Ipinjolu J.K. (2001). Assessment of the exploitation and Management techniques of fish
resources in the Nigerian Portion of Lake Chad. Journal of Arid Zone Fisheries Vol. 1: 137p.

Agbelege, O.O.; Raji A. and Mofilo M.M. (2003). Fishing gear Survey of Lake Chad. In: Proceedings of the
Annual Conference of Fisheries Society of Nigeria (FISON). Maiduguri 4th – 9th November pp. 87-98.

Ajayi, A.R. (1998). Role perception of Ondo State Agriculture Teachers in Young Farmers’ Clubs Programme.
Journal of Agricultural Extension. A Publication of AESON Vol.2 pp.39-47.

Anyanwu A.C; Agwu A.E. and Ibekwe F.N. (2002). Extension potentials of Traditional Management Practices of
Muturu Cattle (Bosbrachyceros) in Ebonyi State Nigeria. Journal of Agricultural Extension Vol.6 pp.1-9.

Bukar, T. A. and Gubio, A. K.(1985). The Decline of then Commercially Important Species of Clarias lazera in
Lake Chad In: Proceedings of the 4th Annual Conference of the Fisheries Society of Nigeria, Port Harcourt 26th-29th
November, PP35-41

Kainji Lake Research Institute (1977). A Publication of KLI,New Bussa, Nigeria

LCBC (1989). Lake Chad Basin Commission 25th Anniversary Brochure, LCBC Secretariat N’jamena

Katz, E; Levin, M.L. and Hamilton, H. (1963). Traditions of Research on the Diffusion of Innovation; American
Sociological Review, xxviii, pp.237-252.

Luning, H.A. (1982). The impact of technological Change on income distribution in Low-income Agriculture. In:
G.E. Jones and M.UJ. rolls (Eds). Progress in Rural Extesnion and community Development. Vol.1. Extension and
Relative Advantage in Rural Development pp.21-42. Chichester, U.K: John Wiley.

Mohammed S. (1996). Catch Assessment Survey of Kainji Lake NIFFR/GTZ New Bussa, Niger State. Nigeria.

Morrison, D.E; Lodwick, D.G; Harris C.G; and Stonmmel, M. (1984). Appropriate Technology as a conceptual
Framework for social Assessment. In: H. Schwarz Eller (Ed). Research on Rural Sociology and Rural
Development, Vol. 1 Greenwich, Conn. JAI Press.

Sarch M.T. and Madakan S.P. (995). Community Management Systems at Lake Chad CEMARE Res. Pap. No. 89,
49.

Sule, A.M.; Ayanda, J.O. and Madahli (1994). Preliminary Survey on Sociological Problems of Innovations
Adoption of Fishing Technology in Kainji Lake. NIFFR/GTZ New Bussa, Niger State, Nigeria.

Received for Publication: 15/07 /2009


Accepted for Publication: 08/09 /2009

Corresponding Author:
Sule, A.M
National Institute for Freshwater Fisheries Research, P.M.B. 6006, New Bussa, Niger State, Nigeria.

19
Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 20 - 24, 2009
© Wilolud Online Journals, 2009.

IMPACT OF TYPHA GRASS ON FISH CATCH AND DISTRIBUTION IN GUlMBE RIVER KEBBI STATE..

Y. A. Birnin-Yauri1 M.L. Balarabe F. Daddy1, Y. B. Ahmed2 and Owotunse , S1.


1
National Institute for Freshwater Fisheries Research, P.M.B. 6006, New Bussa, Niger State. 2Federal College of
Freshwater Fisheries Technology, P.M.B. 1500, New Bussa, Niger State.

ABSTRACT:
The impact of Typha grass on fish catch composition of different water bodies in Kebbi State
was studied. The experimental fishing was conducted, each water body was divided into A and
B. A was open water while B Typha infested area. Five Malian traps was set in each area (A
and B) for five consecutive fishing days respectively. The fish caught was identified, counted
and measured (weight).The various parameters of the plant (Typha grass) was also measured
and counted. The results on fish catch composition in terms of numbers and weight in open
water was higher than Typha infested area in both dry and wet seasons.

KEYWORDS; Fish catch composition, weight in Typha grass area.

INTRODUCTION
Typha grass can be found in wetland sedges and meadows along moving streams, rivers banks and lake edges. The
plant is found in areas of fluctuating water level such as road side ditches and reservoirs (Morton 1975). It is an erect
perennial freshwater aquatic herb which can grow up to 3 or more meters in height. The leaves are thick ribbon like
structure which has a spongy cross-section exhibiting air channels. The subterranean stem arises from thick
creeping rhizomes. The flower structure is dense, fuzzy, cylindrical spike on the end of stem, with a gap 1-3 cm of
naked stem between the upper, male portion (stamina) and lower, female (Pistillate) portion. Both male and female
flower sections are roughly length. Male flowers lighter brown; female flowers, often green during bloom dark
brown during maturation. Individual blossoms minute and closely on spike (Room 1980).

The surface of water cover by Typha grass prevent light penetration, excessive development of algae bloom also
causing nuisance in cultivated fish ponds and small reservoirs. They even cause fish mortality due to oxygen
depletion or release of extra-cellular metabolites which are toxic (Patnaik 1980).

According to (Bennett 1974) “There is evidence that dense stands of Typha grass may bind up nutrient materials
throughout the growing season so that they are not available for production of phytoplankton and the organisms that
feed upon phytoplankton” This means that although fish hatches would be large, the chances for larva survival
would be greatly diminished. The objective of this research was to study the number of fish catch in two different
locations. Typha infested and uninfected area so as to proffer some management control.

STUDY AREA
Kebbi State is located in the North West Zone of Nigeria. An undulating plain with altitude mainly between 350
and 680m above sea level. The area has one main basin, drained by Sokoto Rima rive. The vegetation ecology is
distinguishable into the Northern Guinea and Sudan savannah. As result of human activities the trees were replace
by shrubs from the South to the Northern boundaries. The area is wholly tropical with abundant solar radiation
(400-500 wm-2) incident mostly as beam radiation, 8 hours per day mean and minimum temperature is (17oC) and
maximum (32oC) respectively

Kebbi has distinct dry and wet season. However they differ slightly in terms of latitude, longititude and amount of
rainfall, Kebbi is located on latitude 12o28’N and long. 04o 11’E. Maximum rainfall range 305mm to 1048mm
(National Agricultural Research Project, 1996).

MATERIALS AND METHODS


The study was carried out in all water bodies in Kebbi State, where Typha was infested. Each river (water body)
divided into two, A and B, A is open water while B is Typha infested area. Five Malian traps were set up in in each
area for five days with dimension of 70cm diameter, 80cm height and 20 kg of baits. The number of fish catch and
20
Y. A. Birnin-Yauri et al., Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 20 - 24, 2009

weight in each area for two seasons were recorded. The plant height, length of leaves width of the leaves, length of
inflorescent, the length of inflorescent tip was also measured, and number of tillers per plant was also counted. The
data was analysed.

RESULTS
Table 1 and 2 shows the number of fish catch and there weight for five days in both A and B for the two season.
The result shows increased catch during wet season in Area B Table 3 and 4 showed the morphological features of
Typha grass during dry and wet season respectively while Figure 1 showed location A and B where the experiment
was conducted.

Table 1: Number and weight of fish species caught in Area Aand B during dry season for five days in Kebbi State
species Area A Weight(g) Area B Weight(g)
Number Number
Oreochromis
noloticus 42 3710 ___ __

Bagrus bayad 1 100 6 95

Synodontis spp 31 498 ___ ___

Mormyrops spp 10 920 ___ __

Hydrognus 9 1700 ___ ___


forskalii

Malapterutus
electricus 6 134 __ ___

Heterotis niloticus 2 780 6 141

Lates niloticus 2 145 __ ___

Clarias species 7 2570 18 3650

ToTal 110 13,068 30 2,736

21
Y. A. Birnin-Yauri et al., Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 20 - 24, 2009

Table 2: Number and weight of fish species caught in Area A and B during wet season for five days in Kebbi State

species Area A Weight(g) Area B Weight(g)


Number Number

Hemichromis 5 4500 __ __
faciatus

Hydrocynus 15 1150 __ __
forskalis

Oreochromis
noloticus 36 1442 8 180

Bagrus bayad 15 1040 9 978

Clarias species 15 1950 17 2400

Lates niloticus 7 6000 6 1350

Malapterutus
electricus 4 1750 2 100

Heterotis niloticus 5 4500 9 539

Synodontis species 13 1900 5 1000


Total 115 24,232 56 7,662

Table 3: Morphological features of Typha grass during dry season in Kebbi States.
Plant height 2m 2.5m 2.8m 2.5m 2m
Length of leaf 2.1m 2m 1.8m 19m 2m
Width of leaf 0.5cm 0.4 cm 0.5 cm 0.8 cm 0.8cm
Length of inflorescent tip 22cm 31.0 cm 19.6 cm 25 cm 30cm
Length of inflorescent 42cm 90 cm 36 cm 39 cm 42cm
No. Of tiller 8 9 10 5

22
Y. A. Birnin-Yauri et al., Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 20 - 24, 2009

Table 4: Morphological features of Typha grass during wet season in Kebbi States.
pH 2.0m 2.5m 3m 1.5m 2m
length leaf 2m 1.75m 1.75m 2m 1.8m
width of leaf 0.5cm 0.8cm 0.5cm 0.5cm 0.5cm
Length of inflorescent tip Non Non Non Non Non
Length of inflorescent Non Non Non Non Non
No. of plant 8 6 5 2 5

Figure 1: A – un-infested by Typha grass in Kebbi State while B –infested by Typha grass in Kebbi State.

DISCUSSION
The result in Table 1 and 2 shows the fish catch and their weights during the two seasons in A and B. The data
analysis showed significant difference in the catch This may be associated with the facts that in B there is always
lower catch because in Typha infested area there is low temperature, dissolve oxygen and light penetration.
Therefore, few species of fish can survive in that area; Little (1979) reported that Typha decreased dissolve oxygen
and lower temperature of the water, which alter the fauna living in water Cook (1976) also observed low
temperature and radiation in Typha infested area only few species of fish can survive.

When data was analysed between A dry season and A wet season.It showed that there is no significant differences in
catch. However there is a change in species and there weights. In B area during dry and wet seasons there is
significant difference. This is as a result of increased in number of fish species catch during wet season. The may
be associated with the fact that there is less population density of Typha grass during wet season. There is increase
in dissolve oxygen and light penetration Patnaiki (1980) oxygen depletion cause low fish catch and fish mortality or
release of extra-cellular metabolites which are toxic to fish.

There was higher turbidity which makes it difficult for the fish to identify the baits Prowse (1962).Observed High
turbidity due to dense phytoplankton lower down catch even sometime lead to total migration of fish.

The height of the plant, width of leaves, and length of leaves numbers of tillers showed that there is no significant
difference for the two seasons. However, the length of inflorescent and length of inflorescent tip showed
significance difference for the two seasons. This is because of absence of inflorescent during wet season. Therefore,
the population of plant was less dense; this could explain the reason why the catch was higher during wet season in
B.

Some of the reasons associated with the higher fish catch in B Typha infested area during wet season because of
changes in dissolve oxygen and improve in water turbidity fish turn to spawn in the area. This could also explain
the reason why there was diversity of species in B during wet season. Cook (1976) observed that during wet season
different species of fish migrate to higher dense aquatic environment. This may be due to season variation in
temperature, dissolve and oxygen.

REFERENCES
Bennet, F.D. (1974). Biological Control. In: D.S. Mitchell (ed.) Aquatic Vegetation and its Use and Control.
UNESCO, Paris. 85 – 98
]Cook, C.D.K. (1965). The aquatic and marsh plant communities of the Kainji Reservoir Site. P. 21 – 42. In: E
White (ed.) The First Scientific Report of the Kanji Biological Research Team. University of Liverpool, Liverpool
United Kingdom.

Little, EC.S. (1969). Weed and man-made lakes. P. 284 – 291. The Accra Symposium, Ghana. University Press,
Accra, Ghana

Little, EC.S. (1969). Weed and man-made lakes. P. 284 – 291. The Accra Symposium, Ghana. University Press,
Accra, Ghana.

23
Y. A. Birnin-Yauri et al., Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 20 - 24, 2009

Morton, J.F. (1975). Cattails (Typha sp.) Weed: Problem or potential crop? Economic Botany 29: 7 – 29
National Agricultural Research project 1996 pp10-12

Penfound, W.T. 1962. An outline for ecological life histories fo herbaceous vascular hydrophytes. Ecology 33: 123.

Patnaik, S., 1980. Toxicity of organic copper compound (cutrine) on some algae and fish. J Inland Fish Soc.India, 12
(1) 136-137

Room, P.M.; Harley, K.L.S.; Forno, I.W. and Sand, S.D.P.A. 1981. Successful biological control of the floating
weed, Salvinia. Nature, London. 294: 78 – 80

Received for Publication: 15/07 /2009


Accepted for Publication: 08/09 /2009

Corresponding Author:
Y. A. Birnin-Yauri
National Institute for Freshwater Fisheries Research, P.M.B. 6006, New Bussa, Niger State.

24
Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 25 - 36, 2009
© Wilolud Online Journals, 2009.

APPROACHES TO STUDYING SEDIMENTATION IN SOME WATER BODIES: AN OVERVIEW

Gwari, B. M. and Ugoala, C.


National Institute for Freshwater Fisheries Research, P. M. B. 6006, New Bussa 913003, Niger State

ABSTRACT
The rate of sedimentation and the consequent loss of valuable water storage is becoming
increasingly important in most developing nations. There are evidences of steady rise in soil
erosion endangering reservoir projects which cause doubts about the viability of existing and
future schemes. The impoundment of water for potable and irrigation supplies, hydropower,
and flood control is a necessary step towards socio-economic development. Untimely
sedimentation process of most water bodies may reduce the benefits and, if it is ignored,
remedial measures may become either prohibitively expensive or technically unfeasible.
Therefore the objective of this research was to highlight the various methods for studying
sedimentation. It is therefore hoped that this paper will help in addressing persistent problems
of sedimentation in many developing nations.

KEYWORDS: Sediments, Deposition, Loads, Water velocity, Aquatic community

INTRODUCTION
A large number of natural and man-made lakes in Nigeria are picturesque and most of them are utilized for human
consumption, irrigation and power generation purposes (Kainji, Jebba, Shiroro). However, increasing anthropogenic
activities in the past few decades have greatly affected the hydrological regime of the lakes. Consequently, inflow of
eroded material and other contaminants from the lcatchments has accelerated the rate of sedimentation and
eutrophication processes. Sedimentary Processes within wetlands are intimately connected with many wetland
functions, the most important effect of which is the influence on water quality (Johnston, 1991; Gilliam, 1994;
Mitsch and Gosselink, 2000). Since wetlands function as sources, sinks, and transformers of materials, they have the
potential to positively or negatively affect water quality by trapping or transporting excess nutrients, harmful
chemicals, and other high material loads. Low water velocities cause wetlands to act as depositional environments
for sediments suspended in water, and thus for nutrients and other chemicals sorbed to sediments (Phillips, 1989).
Higher rate of sedimentation has diminished the usefulness of several small lakes and many others are shrinking at
an alarming rate. Hence, knowledge of accurate sedimentation rate and its causes are of utmost importance for
appropriate management of lakes and future planning. Physico-chemical and biological characteristics of various
lakes in the country have been studied in detail, but few studies have been carried out to estimate
the sedimentation rate and deposition pattern in lakes.

Freshwater wetlands are highly effective in nutrient retention, especially as phosphorus sinks (Mitsch et al., 1977,
1979a,b; Craft and Richardson, 1993; Meeker, 1996). Other studies have examined the physical factors that affect
sedimentation in freshwater systems (Kadlec and Robbins, 1984; Hupp and Blazemore, 1993; Kleiss, 1996; Wardrop
and Brooks, 1998; Braskerud et al., 2000; Braskerud, 2001). These studies have recognized the importance of factors
such as basin morphology, hydrology, and biota, but further research is needed to determine how these factors
interact together to influence sediment dynamics at the ecosystem level. Only very limited research has been done to
date that examines sedimentation in created freshwater wetlands (Brueske and Barrett, 1994; Fennessy et al., 1994;
Braskerud et al., 2000; Braskerud, 2001). More in-depth knowledge of sedimentary processes in freshwater wetlands
is needed for not only answering questions of basic wetland science, but also for practical applications as more
natural and created freshwater wetlands come into use for water quality improvement. Understanding freshwater
wetland sedimentary processes gives insight into the complexity of organic and inorganic matter cycles, improves
created wetland design, and refines predictions about the functional lifetime of these systems.

Much of the existing sedimentation research comes from work in coastal marshes and river deltas and examines the
relationship between marsh or land accretion and coastal subsidence (Cahoon and Turner, 1989; Knaus and Van
Gent, 1989; Cahoon, 1994; Roman et al., 1997; Reed et al., 1997; Hensel et al., 1999; Day et al., 1999; Yang, 1999).

25
Gwari, B. M. and Ugoala, C: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 25 - 36, 2009

This research has generated most of the current knowledge of wetland sedimentary processes and sediment
measurement techniques.

Sediments stored in lakes represent a valuable archive that can be used to reveal the erosion history of watersheds. A
portion of the soil that is moved down gradient during runoff events is deposited in lakes, and the rate at which
sediment accumulates should be proportional to the rate of erosion from the surrounding land. The ability to
calculate the rate at which this sediment has accumulated over discrete time intervals in the past opens several
opportunities for improved understanding and management of watershed processes. Examples include quantifying
changes in erosion and deposition rates caused by anthropogenic or natural shifts in land use or by climate change.
Future efforts to conserve soil resources can be better justified if post-clearing increases in erosion rates can be
quantified rather than simply inferred. Knowing the amount by which management practices reduce erosion rates
can also help to justify expenditures by quantifying the effectiveness of the practices in comparison to ancient
erosion rates. The ability to roll back time and peer into the erosion/sedimentation history of watersheds is a
valuable tool for evaluating current land-management practices.

Recently sedimentation menace has become a global affair (USEP, 1994; Glysson and Gray, 2002). Halstead (1974)
and Adegoke and Kogbe (1974) has identified sedimentation problem in Nigeria. Since then the techniques of
studying this geomorphic phenomenon vary in both approach and conceptualization. This paper therefore employs
literature search to expose prospective researchers to the available methodology in sedimentation studies.

INLAND WATER RESOURCES OF NIGERIA


Nigeria is blessed with a vast expanse of inland freshwater and brackish ecosystems. Their full extent varies with
season and from year to year depending on rainfall. However, these water resources are spread all over the country
from the coastal region to the arid zone of the Lake Chad Basin.

Table 1: Major inland water resources of Nigeria


Types of water bodies Approximate reference surface
area(ha)
A: Major Rivers
Anambra River 1,401,000
Benue River 129,000
Cross River 3,900,000
Imo River 910,000
Qua Iboe River 500,200

Ogun River 2,237,000


Niger River 169,800

B: Major Man-made Lakes and


Reservoirs
Lake Chad (natural) 550,000
Kainji Lake 127,000
Jebba Lake 35,000
Shiroro Lake 31,200
Goronyo Lake 20,000
Tiga Lake 17,800
Chalawa Gorge 10,100
Dadin Kowa 29,000
Kiri 11,500
Bakolori 8,000
Lower Anambra 5,000
Zobe 5,000
Oyan 4,000

26
Gwari, B. M. and Ugoala, C: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 25 - 36, 2009

Table 2: Distribution and extent of Nigerian brackish and fresh water bodies in hectres
Approximate size (ha)UUUuuuu
Deltas and estuaries
Niger delta 617,000
Cross River estuary 95,000
Imo and Qua Iboe estuary 36,000
Others 110,000

Freshwaters
Niger delta freshwater 362,000
Apex of delta to Lokoja 635,000
Niger/Sokoto Basin 470,000
Niger Kaduna Basin 150,000
Lower Niger: Jebba to 385,500
Lokoja
Benue River floodplain 312,000
Hadejia Komadugu Yobe 624,000
Ogun/Oshun floodplains Not estimated
Cross River floodplains 250,000
Imo River floodplains 26,000
Qua Iboe 7,000

POTENTIAL BIOLOGICAL EFFECTS OF SEDIMENTATION IN AQUATIC ENVIRONMENTS


Potential detrimental effects of sedimentation in aquatic environments generally fall into two categories: water
column effects (i.e. exposure to suspended sediments) and sedimentation effects. Most sessile or bottom-oriented
aquatic organisms encounter some degree of sedimentation under natural conditions, and many have morphological,
behavioral and/or physiological means of dealing with exposure to deposited sediments. Natural sedimentation rates
vary widely both within and between habitats and depend on numerous environmental factors. In addition, where
salt and fresh waters mix, flocculation (the aggregation of small particulates such as clay and organic detritus) may
affect settlement rates. Since salinity, temperature, pH, and the type of sediments in suspension influence
flocculation, predicting the transport and settlement of sediments under highly variable estuarine conditions may be
problematic (Galtsoff, 1964).

Effects of sedimentation on biota may be direct, indirect, or both. Direct effects include
smothering (manifested by decreased gas exchange), toxicity (exposure to anaerobic sediment layers), reduced light
intensity, and physical abrasion. Indirect effects include changes in habitat quality; particularly substratum
characteristics (e.g., altered sediment composition resulting in reduced availability of in faunal prey species).

Deleterious effects of excess sedimentation in the freshwater and marine environment are:
(i) Possible reduction in oxygen levels in surface waters, eutrophication, increased acidity and toxicity;
(ii) Burial of sessile aquatic fauna and flora at greater than recovery rates and reduction of suitable habitats;
(iii) Loss of open water, decreased water depth, increased muddiness of sediments;
(iv) Increased turbidity of surface waters leading to a decrease in light penetration of the inner water.

27
Gwari, B. M. and Ugoala, C: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 25 - 36, 2009

Figure 1. Showing how enhanced sedimentation rates can lead to the smothering of benthic communities.

Lagoons. Exchange between the Lagoon and the sea is limited through inlets. The resulting brackish water is moved
more by the wind than by the tide and does not flow from headwaters to a mouth like a river. Lagoons are therefore
delicate ecosystems whose balance is easily upset through excessive inputs of either fresh or marine waters. Being
close to land they tend to be highly polluted and sediments discharged directly into them. They are of high value to
fisheries, since the quiet waters are ideal for juvenile and larval forms of fish and crustaceans.

Submerged Aquatic Vegetation. Loss of sea grass habitat is a major environmental concern caused by various types
of disturbances in coastal and estuarine environments. Declining water quality, including increased turbidity,
nutrient loading and reduced light penetration contributes to the loss of sea grass habitat in many systems (Zieman
and Zieman 1989; Robblee et al.1991; Durako1994). Dredging impacts on sea grass habitat can be acute, i.e., the
direct killing or removal of the plant; or chronic, through the creation of conditions in which individual species lose
their ability to compete with other species for light, nutrients, and space. Sea grasses have the ability to withstand
limited burial through several species-specific mechanisms, involving the growth form, the depth to which the plant
is covered, and the properties of the sediment (particularly the depth of the anaerobic layer). Direct mortality may
result if plant elongation and growth rates are insufficient to surpass sediment accretion rates. If sea grasses are only
lightly covered and the rhizome system is not damaged, re-growth through the sediment may be possible.

Moderate levels of sediment deposition can lead to increased vertical growth relocating the meristems (growth
centers) closer to the sediment surface such that the photosynthetic portions are located in the proper light regime
and effective gas exchange may occur.

Suspension of unconsolidated deposited sediments has been hypothesized to cause the decline of sea grass habitat.
Altered substrate surfaces from dredge and fill operations may reduce the quantity of photosynthetically active
radiation (PAR) available to submerged aquatic macrophytes and other aquatic plants (Onuf 1994, Dawes et
al.1995, Tomasko et al.1996). Reduced PAR may result in lower productivity and limit the depth distribution of sea
grass beds. Zimmerman et al. (1991) reported that depth distributions of Zostera marina could be limited more by
extremes in turbidity than mean turbidity level. Moore et al.(1997) and Longstaff and Dennison (1999) have both
documented deleterious impacts to sea grasses exposed to pulsed turbidity events lasting a month or more. Because
dredged material deposits can initially be more readily suspension than native sediments, the duration of suspension
events and concentration of suspended sediments may be higher near dredged material disposal sites, thus affecting
sea grass populations (Zieman and Zieman 1989; Onuf 1994).

28
Gwari, B. M. and Ugoala, C: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 25 - 36, 2009

Mangroves. They are characterize by the alternation of tidal floods (intertidal areas) and the presence of freshwater,
at least temporarily. Ellison (1999) reported that most mangroves can tolerate sedimentation rates ranging from less
than 5 mm to 10 mm per year. Burial of the aerial roots in 10 cm or more of sediment was generally lethal, although
substantial differences existed among species. Excess input of sediment can, however, cause death of trees due to
root smothering. Indirect degradation of mangroves has been attributed to upstream diversion of freshwaters and
pollution caused by oil spills, heavy metals, pesticides and nutrients.

Fishes. Berry et al (2003) stated that adults and juveniles of most species of fish avoid areas of temporarily high
sedimentation and return at a later time. Eggs of bottom-spawning species, survival of larval stages living in and
around the substratum, and in substratum sediment composition as well as demersal or non-buoyant eggs that may
either remain adhered to spawning sites or be carried by bottom currents are additionally exposed to sedimentation
and burial (LaSalle et al. 1991).

Shellfish. Benthic organisms use deposited sediments as habitat, substrate, and a source of nutrition. This group
includes many commercially important invertebrates including mobile crustaceans (e.g., lobsters, crabs and shrimps)
and sessile molluscs (e.g., oysters and clams).

Crustaceans. Many crustaceans are mobile macro benthic predators that reside on or near the bottom where
sedimentation occurs and can presumably emigrate from an area when it becomes inhospitable (unlike clams and
oysters). Lobsters, crabs, and shrimp spend at least some portion of their life cycle in estuaries or near shore coastal
habitats where they are exposed to turbid water conditions. While these organisms are dependent on the stability of
sediments, they show varying degrees of physiological and behavioral characteristics consistent with the
sedimentation regimes of their respective habitats. The loss of suitable habitat used as shelter by juveniles of both
species may increase competition for the remaining available shelters. Crowding reduces growth rates in lobsters
and increases the time spent searching for non-silted areas, which may prolong exposure to predation and result in
higher mortality rates.

Molluscs. Sedimentation on oyster habitats is a common natural phenomenon due to their


location near the mouths of sediment-laden rivers. Sedimentation impacts to oysters may occur by direct morality
caused by burial in a relatively deep sediment layer, reduction in oyster growth, or by the inhibition of settlement of
oyster spat caused by a deposit of sediment. Sedimentation can also negatively affect organisms associated with
oyster reef habitats such as fishes and crabs that rely on the interstices in the oyster shell as habitat for colonization
and refuge from predation. Larger interstitial areas among the oyster shells are also associated with enhanced oyster
growth (Bartol and Mann, 1999; Posey et al., 1999; O’Beirn et al., 2000).

Corals and Tropical Coral Reefs. Heavy sedimentation on corals is associated with reduced coral species diversity,
less live coral, lower coral growth rates, greater abundance of branching forms, reduced coral recruitment, decreased
calcification, decreased net productivity and slower rates of reef accretion (Rogers, 1990). The distribution of some
coral communities has been related to suspended sediment load (West and van Woesik, 2001). Adverse impacts to
corals and coral reef organisms from sedimentation may extend beyond the reef systems to tropical fisheries.
Sedimentation that impacts corals and sponges may ultimately affect many fish and shellfish that use these resources
for food and shelter. It has long been recognized that sedimentation, due to dredging as well as natural causes, is a
major factor controlling the distribution and abundance of corals. Reefs in areas with low sedimentation rates are
generally better developed, have more coral species, higher coral cover, and faster rates of frame work accretion
than those subject to heavy sedimentation (Loya, 1976; Dodge and Vaisnys, 1977). Sedimentation affects coral
growth in several ways including larval settlement (Te1, 992). Coral larvae settle preferentially on vertical surfaces
to avoid sediments and cannot successfully establish themselves in shifting sediment. An increase in site-specific
substratum sediment load can affect total numbers of individuals recruiting to a particular location as well as relative
species abundance. For adult corals, if sediment accumulates faster than the ability of the coral to remove it, the
ensuing shading may compromise the ability of algal endosymbionts to photosynthesize and an anoxic layer may
develop, which kills the underlying tissue. Even if sedimentation does not result in direct mortality, exposure to
sediments may cause stress. Several species of coral are characteristically found in areas with high rates of
sedimentation and solute suspension. These corals, which include Montastrea cavernosa, Diploriastrigosa, and

29
Gwari, B. M. and Ugoala, C: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 25 - 36, 2009

Siderastrea siderea, are effective at clearing sediment, which appears to bean important adaptation in their ability to
colonize and compete in areas where sedimentation is common (Lasker 1980).

METHODS OF SEDIMENTATION STUDIES


Quantitative assessment of sedimentation is always difficult because sediment concentrations and settling rates are
extremely variable, depending on the detailed history of rain, wind, and waves at each site.

Historical flow and sediment-transport data from sites across the water body can be used to develop sediment-
transport rating relations and substrate-composition data. Annual suspended-sediment loads can be calculated for all
sites to determine regional trends for stable and unstable sites. Trends of bed-material composition can similarly be
identified. Geomorphic assessments can be conducted to determine the relative stability of the stream and to sort
sites into stable and unstable groupings. Statistical analysis of sediment-transport rating relations will determine if
characteristic relations can be enveloped for streams of given stability and bed-material characteristics. These data
can be used to investigate the possibility of establishing empirical, dimensionless sediment ratings for un-gauged
streams. The relative stability of streambeds and the likelihood that rates of bed erosion or deposition exceed
background rates can be estimated at gagged sites using an excess shear-stress approach. Potential links between
sediment-transport rates, bed-material conditions and aquatic indices can be investigated using both an empirical-
statistical approach using historical data from throughout the region where data are available, and by making
simultaneous measurements and sampling of flow, sediment transport conditions and aquatic-community structure at
two stable and unstable sites. These data are compared with existing ecological data to provide a means of
differentiating impacted from non-disturbed systems.

Radiometric dating techniques are reliable tools for estimating sedimentation rates in lakes and are used worldwide.
Although several radioisotopes are useful in geochronological studies of sediments, lead-210 (210Pb) and caesium-
137 (137Cs) isotopes find the largest application. In radiometric dating, sediment cores ranging up to 60 cm in length
are collected from different parts of selected lakes using a gravity corer. Four to five of these cores are selected for
dating the sediment and as representatives of the sedimentary environment on the basis of bottom topography and
drains entering the lakes. The cores are sliced at every 2 cm intervals and analysed for 210Pb and 137Cs activities to
identify sedimentation rates, chemical characteristics, and textural characteristics of sediments. Where needed, high-
resolution acoustic profiling can be used to enhance the quality of data collected from reservoirs. Local and regional
trends in reservoir sedimentation are be defined where possible.

The stream erosion algorithms from the one-dimensional channel evolution model concepts can be modified for
implementation in multi-dimensional computer models of stream morphology. The algorithm is tested for accuracy
on streams impacted by dam and reservoir operations. Physical model experiments are conducted on the storage and
transport rate of sand introduced to a previously established bed comprised only of gravel. The main outputs of this
work are the depth of penetration of sand into the bed in which the sand is stored and the eventual transport rate and
bed surface size distribution. This knowledge is important to improve computer model predictions of streambed
elevation, composition of streambed materials, and fractional sediment transport rates downstream of dams after
sand-sized sediment releases.

SEDIMENTATION RATES
Vertical accumulation (mm yr-1)
Changes in the rate at which estuaries have been vertically filling up with sediment can provide useful insights into
the functioning and health of an estuary. Marked increases in modern rates of infilling may reflect increased
catchment erosion and/or the increased production of organic sediment within the estuary, and indicate that abrupt
changes have occurred in estuarine geomorphology and benthic habitats (Appleby and Oldfield 1992).

Mass accumulation (g cm2 yr-1)


Sediment mass accumulation is a more accurate measure of sedimentation where there are significant changes with
depth in the density of estuarine sediment that may be related to compaction or changes in the composition of the
sediment (Hancock and Hunter 1999, Hancock, 2000).

30
Gwari, B. M. and Ugoala, C: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 25 - 36, 2009

Significance of sedimentation rates


Sedimentation rate data can be used to determine whether a waterway has been subject to enhanced sediment loads
due to changes in catchment land use practices. Enhanced sedimentation rates can bring about rapid changes in the
form and function of coastal waterways.

Some natural controls on the sedimentation rates experienced by coastal waterways include climate (rainfall,
seasonality), geology, slope (or topography), vegetation and the size of the catchment.

Habitats may be smothered where sediment is deposited more rapidly than tolerated by benthic communities. For
example, loss of seagrass and macroalgae destabilises bottom sediments formerly protected from wind and tidal
erosion by the sheltering and binding abilities of macrophyte colonies (May and Stephens 1996, Hancock et al,
2001). Such changes also constitute pressures on fish assemblages and benthic invertebrate numbers.

Turbidity levels and the amount of sediment-bound nutrients (e.g. Total P, Total N and Total Organic Carbon), trace
elements (e.g. Fe, Zn, Pb) and other toxicants entering estuaries from their catchments also tend to increase in
association with increased rates of sedimentation (McComb and Lukatelich 1995). Greater nutrient loads can lead to
periods of eutrophication which can further enhance sedimentation rates because the amount of organic matter being
deposited also increases.

Table 3. Sedimentation rates for some water bodies as observed by the authors
AUTHOR YEAR WATER RATES TECHNIQUE
BODY
McLaughin 2000 Sydney 10-15 M/year Hydrographic survey
Harbour
Hancock 2000 Bega River 3.1-3.4 mm a-1 210
Pb
Jones and Chenhall 2001 Sydney 1.2-3 mm a-1 14
C, 137Cs, AAR
lagoon
Sloss 2001 Illawara lake 1.2-3 mm a-1 14
C, 137Cs, AAR
Jones and Chenhall, 2001 Sydney 0.9-2.2 mm a-1 210
Pb, Pollen
estuaries
Baumber, 2001 Wollumboola 0.47-0.71 mm a-1 14
C,210Pb
lake
Hancock 2001 Moreton bay <6.2, <12 mm a-1 210
Pb, 137Cs
Logan et al 2002 Lake Wallis 1.4-2.6mm/year Pollen
Brooke 2002 Tweed River 0.2, 0.3 mm a-1 14 210
C, Pb, Pollen
Sloss et al 2004 New 0.2-0.55mm/year Aspartic acid
southwales
210
Chin-AnHum et al 2006 Koping River 0.06-1.6cm/year Pb
137
Rogata et al 2007 Nipigon 0-1.5cm/year Cerium
Lake
210
Kostaschuk et al 2008 Fundy Bay 1.1cm/year Pb and 137Cs
210
Kamaruzzaman and 2008 Kemaman- 0.94-1.11cm/year Pb
Ong Chulkan
mangrove
Chuanshun et al 2009 Southwestern 1.8 and 21.2m Ka AMS, 14C
Okinawa
River

Increased sedimentation rates also allow more organic matter to be degraded by anoxic processes because the
exposure time of organic matter to dissolved oxygen in the water column is shortened. Denitrification efficiencies
are lowered under anoxic conditions, and more dissolved nutrients are recycled to the water column. Loss of

31
Gwari, B. M. and Ugoala, C: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 25 - 36, 2009

nitrification and denitrification (and increased ammonium efflux from sediment) in coastal and estuarine systems is
also an important cause of hysteresis.

The net result of enhanced sedimentation rates is an increase in the maturity of coastal waterways, and a decrease in
their overall life-spans. Reductions in the biodiversity, health and integrity of coastal ecosystems may also occur. In
order to make better-informed management decisions there is clearly a need to accurately assess the rate and nature
of sedimentation within coastal waterways and any changes in other sedimentological parameters over time
(Hodgkin and Clarke 1989).

Other geochemical analyses of sediment cores can identify pools of nutrients or other pollutants within the estuary
fill. This is important information for managers because of the potential for the release of sediment-bound nutrients
into the water column, which is also relevant where dredging work is proposed. The identification of microfossils in
sediment cores can provide a detailed record of recent changes in estuarine vegetation communities or harmful algal
blooms (Harle et al, 2002; Appleby and Oldfield 1992). Sedimentological data are especially important where
conservation or restoration actions are being planned and there is a lack of historical information to indicate how the
estuarine environment has changed over the past two centuries or past few decades. Likewise, these data can aid in
the development of models of sediment transportation. The information gained from the analysis of sediment cores,
therefore, needs to be viewed as basic environmental data needed for the effective management of estuarine systems.

CONCLUSION
Sediments stored in water bodies represent a valuable archive that can be used to reveal the erosion history of these
resources. A portion of the soil that is moved down gradient during runoff events is deposited in lakes, and the rate
at which sediment accumulates should be proportional to the rate of erosion from the surrounding land. The ability
to calculate the rate at which this sediment has accumulated over discrete time intervals in the past opens several
opportunities for improved understanding and management of the resource processes. Examples include quantifying
changes in erosion and deposition rates caused by anthropogenic or natural shifts in land use or by climate change.
Future efforts to conserve soil resources can be better justified if post-clearing increases in erosion rates can be
quantified rather than simply inferred. Knowing the amount by which management practices reduce erosion rates
can also help to justify expenditures by quantifying the effectiveness of the practices in comparison to ancient
erosion rates. The ability to roll back time and peer into the erosion/sedimentation history of ponds, lakes, rivers,
reservoirs and even oceans is a valuable tool for evaluating current land-management practices.

REFERENCES
Adegoke, S. O. and Kogbe C. A. (1994) Littoral and suspended sediment of Lake Kainji.The ecology and geology
of Lake Kainji. Geology and Sedimentology.

Appleby, P.G. and Oldfield, F. (1992). Application of lead-210 to sedimentation studies. In Ivanovich, M. and
Harmon, R.S. (Eds), Uranium-series Disequilibrium: Applications to the Earth, Marine and Environmental
Sciences. Clarendon Press, Oxford, pp. 731-778.

Berry, W., Rubenstein, N., Melzian, B., and Hill, B. (2003). “The biological effects of suspended and bedded
sediments (SABS) in Aquatic Systems: A review,” Internal report to US EPA, Office of Research and
Development, National Health and Environmental Effects Laboratory, Narragansett, RI.

Bartol, I., and Mann, R. (1999). “Small-scale patterns of recruitment on a constructed intertidal reef: The role of
spatial refugia,” Oyster reef habitat restoration: A synopsis and synthesis of approaches

Barnett, E. J. (1994). A Holocene paleo-environmental history of Lake Alexandrina. Journal of aleolimnology, 12,
259-268.

Baumber, A. (2001). Holocene infill and evolution of Lake Wollumboola, a saline coastal lake on the NSW
south coast. Research Report, Environmental Science Program University of Wollongong.

32
Gwari, B. M. and Ugoala, C: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 25 - 36, 2009

Brooke, B. (2002). The role of sedimentological information in estuary management. Proceedings of Coast to Coast
2002 - "Source to Sea", Tweed Heads, pp. 31-34.

Braskerud, B. C. (2001). The influence of vegetation on sedimentation and resuspension of soil particles in small
constructed wetlands. J. Environ. Qual. 30:1447–1457.

Braskerud, B. C., Lundekvam, H. and Krogstad, T. (2000). The impact of hydraulic load and aggregation on
sedimentation of soil particles in small constructed wetlands. J. Environ. Qual. 29:2013–2020.

Brueske, C. C., and Barrett, G. W. (1994). Effects of vegetation and hydrologic load on sedimentation patterns in
experimental wetland ecosystems. Ecol. Eng. 3:429–447.

Cahoon, D. R. (1994). Recent accretion in two managed marsh impoundments in coastal Louisiana. Ecol. Appl.
4:166–176.

Cahoon, D. R., and Turner, R. E. (1989). Accretion and canal impacts in a rapidly subsiding wetland II. Feldspar
marker horizon technique. Estuaries 12:260–268.

Chin-AnHuh, Hui-Linglin; Saulwood Lin and Ya-wenHuang (2006). Modern accumulation rates and a budget of
sediment off the Kaoping River, SW Taiwan: a tidal and flood dominate depositional Environment around a
Submarine Canyon. Earth Sciences

ChuanShun, L. I.; Jiang, B.O.; Anchun, L. I. ; Tiengang, L. I. and Jiang Fuquing (2009). Sedimentation rates and
provenance analysis in the South-western Okinawa Trough since the mid Holocene. Chinese Sciences Bulletin
54(7):1234-42.

Craft, C.B. and Richardson, C. J. (1993). Peat accretion and N, P, and organic C accumulation in nutrient enriched
and unenriched Everglades peatlands. Ecol. Appl. 3:446–458.

Day, J. W., Jr., Rybczyk, J.; Scarton, F.; Rismondo, A.; Are, D. and Cecconi, G. (1999). Soil accretionary
dynamics, sea-level rise and the survival of wetlands in Venice Lagoon: A field and modeling approach. Estuarine
Coastal Shelf Sci. 49:607–628.

Dawes, C. J., Hanisak, D., and Kenworthy, W. J. (1995) “Seagrass biodiversity in the Indian River Lagoon,”
Bulletin of Marine Science 57, 59-66.

Dodge, R. E., and Vaisnys, J. R. (1977). “Coral populations and growth patterns: Responses to sedimentation and
turbidity associated with dredging,” Journal of Marine Research 35, 715-730.

Ellison, J. C. (1999). “Impacts of sediment burial on mangroves.” Marine Pollution Bulletin 37, 420-426.

Fennessy, M. S., Brueske, C. C. and Mitsch, W. J. (1994). Sediment deposition patterns in restored freshwater
wetlands using sediment traps. Ecol. Eng. 3:409–428. Galtsoff, P. S. (1964). “The American oyster, Crassostrea
virginica Gmelin,” U. S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Fishery Bulletin 64, 480 pp.

Gilliam, J. W. (1994). Riparian wetlands and water quality. J. Environ. Qual. 23:896– 900.

Glysson, G. D. and Gray, R. J. (2002) Total suspended solids data for use in sediments Studies. Turbidity
and other sediments Workshop.

Halstead, L. B. (1974) The shore lines of Lake Kainji. The ecology and geology of Lake Kainji. Geology
and Sedimentology. Journal of Mining and Geology.

33
Gwari, B. M. and Ugoala, C: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 25 - 36, 2009

Harle, K. J., Heijnis, J.,F., and Zawadzki, A. (2002). Reconstructing sediment and pollution histories of coastal lakes
and estuaries using isotopic, geochemical and microfossil techniques: An important management toolbox.
Proceedings of Coast to Coast 2002 - "Source to Sea", Tweed Heads, pp. 141-144.

Hancock, G. J. (2000). Identifying the source of resuspended sediment in an estuary using the 228Th/232Th activity
ratio: The fate of lagoon sediment in the Bega River estuary, Australia. Marine Freshwater Research 51,
659-667.

Hancock, G. J. and Hunter, J. R. (1999). Use of excess 210Pb and 228Th to estimate rates of sediment accumulation
and bioturbation in Port Phillip Bay, Australia. Australian Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research 50, 533-545.

Hodgkin, E. P. and Clarke, R. (1989). Estuaries and coastal lagoons of south Western Australia. Environmental
Protection Authority, Estuarine Studies Series 5. Stokes Inlet and other estuaries of the Shire of Esperance.

Hancock, G.J. (2001). Sediment accumulation in central Moreton Bay as determined from sediment core
profiles. Report on Sediment Source Project Phase 3, Part A. CSIRO Land and Water, Canberra.

Hancock, G. J., Olley, J.M. and Wallbrink, P. J. (2001). Sediment transport and accumulation in Western Port,
Report on Phase 1 of a study determining the sources of sediment to western Port, CSIRO Land and Water,
Environmental Hydrology, Canberra Technical Report 47/01.

Hensel, P. E., Day, J. W. Jr., and Pont, D. (1999). Wetland vertical accretion and soil elevation change in the Rhone
River delta, France: The importance of riverine flooding. J. Coastal Res. 15:668–681.

Hupp, C. R., and Blazemore, D. E. (1993). Temporal and spatial patterns of wetland sedimentation, West
Tennessee. J. Hydrol. (Amsterdam) 141:179–196.

Johnston, C. A. (1991). Sediment and nutrient retention by freshwater wetlands: Effects on surface water quality.
Crit. Rev. Environ. Control 21:491–565.

Jones, B. G. and Chenhall, B. E. (2001). Lagoonal and estuarine sedimentation during the past 200 years. In
Archives of human impact of the last 200 years, Environment Workshop, Proceedings. Australian Institute of
Nuclear Science and Engineering, Sydney, p. 42-46.

Kadlec, R. H., and Robbins, J. A. (1984). Sedimentation and sediment accretion in Michigan coastal wetlands
(USA). Chem. Geol. 44:119–150.

Kamaruzzanan, B. Y. and Ong, M.C. (2008). Recent sedimentation rate and sediment ages determination of
Kemaman-Chulkai mangrove forest, Teregganu, Malasia. American journal of Agricultural and Biological
Sciences 3(3):522-25.

Kleiss, B. A. (1996). Sediment retention in a bottomland hardwood wetland in eastern Arkansas. Wetlands
16:321–333.

Knaus, R. M., and Van Gent, D. L. (1989). Accretion and canal impacts in a rapidly subsiding wetland. III. A
new soil horizon marker method for measuring recent accretion. Estuaries 12:269–283.

Kostaschuk, R.; Chen, Z.; Saito, Y. and Wang, Z. (2008). Sedimentation rates and heavy metals in a macrotidal salt
marsh: Bay of Fundy, Canada. Environmental Geology 55(6):1291-98.

LaSalle, M. W., Clarke, D. G., Homziak, J., Lunz, J. D., and Fredette, T. J. (1991). “A framework for assessing
the need for seasonal restrictions on dredging and disposal operations,” Technical Report D-91-1, U. S. Army
Engineer Waterways Experiment Station, Vicksburg, MS.

34
Gwari, B. M. and Ugoala, C: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 25 - 36, 2009

Lasker, H. R. (1980). “Sediment rejection by reef corals: The roles of behavior and morphology in Montastrea
cavernosa (Linnaeus),” Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology 47, 77-87.

Logan, G. A.; Fredricks, D. J.; Smith, C. and Heggie, D. T. (2001). Sources of Organic matter in Wallis Lake.
AGSO Research News Letter 34:15-20.

Longstaff, B. J., and Dennison, W. C. (1999). “Seagrass survival during pulsed turbidity events: the effects of light
deprivation on the seagrasses Halodule pinjifolia and Halophila ovalis.” Aquatic Botany 65, 105-121. 12

Loya, Y. (1976). “Effects of water turbidity and sedimentation on the community structure of Puerto Rican corals,”
Bulletin of Marine Science 26, 450-466.

Meeker, J. E. (1996). Wild-rice and sedimentation processes in a Lake Superior coastal wetland.Wetlands 16:219–
231.

McComb, A. J. and Lukatelich, R. J. (1995). The Peel-Harvey estuarine system, Western Australia. In McComb
A.J. (Ed.), Eutrophic shallow estuaries and lagoons. CRC Press, Boca Raton, p. 5-17.
McLough, L. C. (2000). Shaping Sydeny Harbour: Sedimentation, dredging and Reclamation 1788-1990s.
Australian Geography 31(2):183-208.

May, D. and Stephens, A. (1996). The Western Port Marine Environment. Publication 493, Environment Protection
Authority, Victoria.

Mitsch, W. J., Dorge, C. L. and Wiemhoff, J. R. (1977). Forested wetlands for water resource management in
southern Illinois. Res. Rep. 132. Water Resource Center, Univ. of Illinois, Champaign–Urbana.

Mitsch, W. J., Dorge, C. L. and Wiemhoff, J. R. (1979). Ecosystem dynamics and a phosphorus budget of an
alluvial cypress swamp in southern Illinois. Ecology 60:1116–1124.

Mitsch, W. J. and Gosselink, J. G. (2000). Wetlands. 3rd ed. John Wiley & Sons, New York.

Mitsch, W. J., Rust, W. Behnke, A. and Lai, L. (1979). Environmental observations of a riparian
ecosystem during flood season. Res. Rep. 142. Water Resour. Center, Univ. of Illinois, Champaign–Urbana.

Moore, K. A., Wetzel, R. L., and Orth, R. J. (1997). “Seasonal pulses of turbidity and their relations to
eelgrass(Zostera marinaL.) survival in an estuary.” Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology 215, 115-
134.

O’Beirn, F. X., Luckenbach, M. W., Nestlerode, J. A, and Coates, G. M. (2000). “Towards design
criteria in constructed oyster reefs: Oyster recruitment as a function of substrate type and tidal height,” Journal of
Shellfish Research 19, 387- 395.

Onuf, C. P. (1994). “Seagrasses, dredging and light in Laguna Madre, Texas, U.S.A.,” Estuarine Coastal and
Shelf Science 39, 75-91.

Posey, M. H., Alphin, T. D., and Powell, C. M. (1999).“Use of oyster reefs as habitat for epibenthic fish and
decapods,”Oyster reef habitat restoration: A synopsis and synthesis of approaches. M. W.

Phillips, J. D. (1989). Fluvial sediment storage in wetlands. Water Resour. Bull. 25:867– 873.

Reed, D. J., DeLuca, N. and Foote, A. L. (1997). Effect of hydrologic management on marsh surface sediment
deposition in coastal Louisiana. Estuaries 20:301–311.

35
Gwari, B. M. and Ugoala, C: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 25 - 36, 2009

Robblee, M. B., Barber, T. R., Carlson, P. R., Durako, M. J., Fourqurean, J. W., Muehlstein, L. K, Porter, D.,
Yarboro, L. A., Zieman, L. A., and Zieman, R. T. (1991). “Mass mortality of the tropical seagrass Thalassia
testudinum in Florida (USA),” Marine Ecology Progress Series 71, 297-299.

Rogers, C. S. (1990). “Responses of coral reefs and reef organisms to sedimentation,” Marine Ecology Progress
Series 62, 185-202.

Roman, C. T., Peck, J. A.; Allen, J. R.; King, J. W. and Appleby, P. G. (1997). Accretion of a New England
(U.S.A.) salt marsh in response to inlet migration, storms, and sea-level rise. Estuarine Coastal Shelf Sci.
45:717–727.

Sloss, C. (2001). Holocene stratigraphic evolution and recent sedimentological trends, Lake Illawarra, NSW.
Unpublished BSc Honours Thesis, School of Geoscience, University of Wollongong.

Sloss, C. R., Murray-Wallace, C.V., Jones, B. G., Wallin, T., (2004). Aspartic acid racemisation dating of
mid-Holocene to recent estuarine sedimentation in New South Wales, Australia: a pilot study. Marine Geology, In
Press.

US Enviromental Protection Agency (1994). Great Lake Contaminant Assessment Document. Chicago 3. Great
Lakes National Program office.

Tomasko, D.A., Dawes, C. J., and Hall, M. O. (1996). “The effects of anthropogenic nutrient enrichment in turtle
grass (Thalassia testudinum) in Sarasota Bay, Florida (U.S.A.),” Estuaries 19, 448-456

West, K., and Van Woesik, R. (2001). “Spatial and temporal variance of river discharge on Okinawa (Japan):
inferring the temporal impact on adjacent coral reefs,”Marine Pollution Bulletin 42, 864-872.

Wardrop, D. H. and Brooks, R. P. (1998). The occurrence and impact of sedimentation in central Pennsylvania.
Environ. Monit. Assess. 51:119–130.

Yang, S. L. (1999). Tidal wetland sedimentation in the Yangtze Delta. J. Coastal Res. 15:1091–1099

Zimmerman, R. C., Reguzzoni, J. L., Wyllie-Echeverria, S., Josselyn, M., and Alberte, R. S., (1991). “Assessment
of environmental suitability for growth of Zostera marina L. (eelgrass) in San Francisco Bay,” Aquatic Botany
39:353-366.

Zieman, J. C., and Zieman, R. T., (1989). “The ecology of the seagrass meadows of the West Coast of Florida:
A community profile,” U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Biological Report 85(7.25), Washington, DC.

Received for Publication: 15/07 /2009


Accepted for Publication: 08/09 /2009

36
Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 37 - 41, 2009
© Wilolud Online Journals, 2009.

EFFECT OF BAITS TYPE ON FISH CONGREGATION AND CATCH EFFICIENCY OF CASTNET IN LAKE
KAINJI, NIGERIA.

Y.B. Ahmed1, L.A. Argungu2 and T.A. Tagago3


1
Federal College Of Freshwater Fisheries Technology,P.M.B. 1500, New Bussa, Niger State.2Department of
Forestry and Fisheries,Usmanu Danfodiyo University,P.M. 2346, Sokoto, Nigeria.3Kebbi Agricultural and Rural
Development Authority,Birnin Kebbi, Kebbi State.

ABSTRACT
The effect of baits, rice bran (Oryza sativa L.) and corn bran (Zea mays L.) on fish aggregation
and catch efficiency of castnet in Lake Kainji was conducted. 25.4mm stretched mesh size
multifilament (PA) nylon net was used for the construction of castnet. The experiment was
Complete Randomized Design (CRD) with three replications for nineteen consecutive fishing
days. Three treatments were employed; castnetting after baiting with rice bran, with corn-bran,
and castneting without bait (control). Thirteen fish species were caught from eight families.
The number of fish caught was 336, of which 48.5 and 27.1% were castnetting with corn bran
and without bait while castnetting with rice bran recorded the least (24.4%). The biomass of
fish caught was 4627.7g (4.6kg) of which the highest percentages 51.4 and 28.6% followed
same trend as that of number of fish caught. Comparison of the overall number and biomass of
fish capture indicated that Tilapia zilli ranked highest, next by Citharinus citharus and
Hydrocynus forskalii. Recommendations have been made for areas of further studies in these
aspects.

INTRODUCTION
Castnet fishing is regarded as a traditional method of catching fish that has been used since antiquity. The most
widely used artisanal fishing gears in Nigerian freshwater and brackish water as well as coastal waters, are gillnets
and castnets (FAO, 1969). Castnet are conical falling nets with lead (Pb) weights attached at regular intervals along
the perimeter of the cone (Udolisa and Solarin, 1979). It is an active fishing gear; that is it catches fish instantly.

Hayes et al. (1996) reported that a light or bait is often used to attract the target fish into an area within the castnet’s
range. Fishing baits lures and attraction devices, are often incorporated into some fishing gears in order to improve
their efficiency such fishing gears include handlines, longlines, trolling and traps etc (Ahmed et al, 2005). Baits
may include rotten meat, dead or live fish, palm nuts or corn bran depending on the feeding and behavioral
characteristics of the target fish species.

The castnet fishery is probably the next most damaging fishing method to juvenile fish after beach seines (du Feu
and Abiodun, 1999). It caught 34% of the total tilapines, 24% Citharinus and 19% of all Labeo, at a mean size upto
50% less than gillnets in the case of Citharinus. This study therefore intends to assess the effects of two baits rice
bran (Oryza sativa L.) and corn bran (Zea mays L.) and, without baits on the efficiency of castnet in Lake Kainji.

MATERIALS AND METHODS


The experiment was conducted in the lower basin of Lake Kainji about 6.5 km away from the Federal College of
Freshwater Fisheries Technology, New Bussa, Niger State, between July and August, 2008. The description of
study area is adequately made in Ahmed et al, (2006).

The castnet construction was followed by the same method that was used by Udolisa et al. (1994) and Udolisa and
Solarin (1979). Two types of baits were used corn bran and rice bran, and casneting without bait was used as
control. A net was cast, a waiting period of five minutes was observed to allow the weight to settle to the bottom of
the sampling areas. The net was pulled with both hands to retrieve it. The experiment was Complete Randomized
Design (CRD) with three replications for nineteen consecutive fishing days. The fish caught were packed in
separate labelled container for each treatment.

37
Y.B. Ahmed et al.,: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 37 - 41, 2009

The data were collected on species, number, length (cm) using metric ruler and weight (g) using Ohaus compact
scale model CS200 of 200g capacity for each fish caught and recorded according to respective treatments. The fish
species were identified following the description of Olaosebikan and Raji (2004).

Simple statistical tool was employed (mean and percentage) (SPSS, 1999). Species diversity index (SDI) was
computed following Ahmed et al, (2006) modified method.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION


Types of Fish species Caught by Castnet using different baits in Lake Kainji.

The types of fish species captured comprise thirteen species belonging to eight fish families as shown in Table 1.
The fish species diversity index showed that castnetting with corn bran had the highest value of 0.92, while
castnetting without bait recorded 0.77 and with rice bran 0.69. Cichlidae family was represented by five species,
Characidae with two species and the rest were represented by only one species each. Baits, lures or attraction
devices are often incorporated into some fishing gears inorder to improve their efficiency (Ahmed et al. 2005). Fish
species that are dispersed over a wide range area can be congregated or concentrated into a smaller area where an
appropriate fishing gear can be operated to get them. Congregation of fish before harvest had been reported by
many authors using luring methods that are economically and environmentally friendly (Udolisa and Solalrin, 1979;
Solarin and Kusemiju, 2003). The fish species caught are from eight families, this shows that castnet is an efficient
fishing gear for encountering fish species of diverse feeding and behavioral characteristics.

Number and percentages of fish Caught by castnet using different baits type in Lake Kainji.

Table 1 contains the number and percentages of fish caught with respect to the different treatments (baits). The total
number of fish caught was 336, of which 48.5 and 27.1% were caught in castnetting with corn bran and castnetting
without bait (control) respectively, while the least number (24.4%) was recorded in castnetting with rice bran. The
findings in the present study show low catchability compared to that of Udolisa and Solarin (1979) at Ikorodu beach
in the Lagos Lagoon, Tilapia spp are caught in large number about 5-10kg by spreading gari (Processed Cassava-
Manihot utilisina) on marked spots and castnets are thrown over the area. The reason for the low catch in the study
area has already been reported by Seisay and du Feu (1997) who observed a reduction in mean sizes in fish species
and changes in species compositions due to both requirement and ecosystem over-fishing.

Comparison of the overall number of fish caught shows that T. zilli contributed the highest percentage, being 29.5%
next by C. citharus 15.5%. Moreover, the dominant fish in the catches of castnet with corn bran was T. zilli that
contributed 31.9%. In castnetting without bait C. citharus accounted for 38.5% while in fish entice with rice bran T.
zilli accounted for 36.6% ranked next to this species was H. forskalii.

38
Y.B. Ahmed et al.,: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 37 - 41, 2009

Table 1: Types, number and percentages of various fish species caught by Castnet during different baits type in
Lake Kainji.

BAITS
Family Species Corn bran Rice bran Without bait Overall catch
Number Per- Number Per- Number Per- Total Per-
centage centage centage centage
Characidae H. forskalii 20 12.3 17 20.7 15 16.5 52 15.5
Alestes 1 0.6 3 3.7 4 4.4 8 2.4
baremoze
Cichlidae H. 4 2.5 2 2.4 1 1.1 7 2.1
bimaculatus
H. fasciatus 13 7.9 8 9.8 6 6.6 27 8.0
Sarotherodon 7 4.3 5 6.1 1 1.1 13 3.9
galilaeus
Oreochromis 14 8.6 9 11.0 10 10.9 33 9.8
niloticus
T. zilli. 52 31.9 30 36.6 17 18.7 99 29.5
Citharinidae C. citharus 17 10.4 - - 35 38.5 52 15.5
Claroteidae C. 19 11.7 7 8.5 1 1.1 27 8.0
nigrodigitatus
Cyprinidae Labeo coubie 3 1.8 - - 1 1.1 4 1.2
Distichodontidae Distichodus - - 1 1.2 - - 1 0.3
rostratus
Mochokidae S. 6 3.7 - - - - 6 1.8
membranaceus
Mormyridae M. budgeti 7 4.3 - - - - 7 2.1
Total number of 163 100 82 100 91 100 336 100
fish caught
Relative 48.5 24.4 27.1
Percentage
Total species 12 9 10
caught
Species 0.92 0.69 0.77
Diversity
Index (SDI).

Biomass and Percentages of fish species caught by castnet using different baits in the Lake Kainji.

The biomass of fish caught by castnetting using different baits are shown in Table 2. The total weight was 4627.7g
(4.6kg) of which the greatest proportion 51.4 and 28.6% was captured in castnet baited with corn bran and without
bait (control) while castnetting with rice bran recorded the least (20%). T. zilli, C. citharus, and H. forskalii
contributed 25.4, 21.3 and 14.2 percents of the overall weight of fish caught. Comparison of the overall weight of
the fish caught shows that fish entice with Corn bran T. zilli recorded for 29.3%, followed by C. citharus (15.6%).
In castnetting with rice bran T. zilli accounted for 30.7% followed by H. forskalii while castnetting without bait
(control) C. citharus contributed 46.4%.

39
Y.B. Ahmed et al.,: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 37 - 41, 2009

Table 2: Biomass and percentages of various fish species caught by Castnet using different baits type in Lake
Kainji.
BAITS
Species Corn bran Rice bran Without bait Overall catch
Weight Percentage Weight Percentage Weight Percentage Total Percentage
(g) (g) (g) Weight
(g)
H. forskalii 224.0 9.4 182.2 19.6 253.2 19.1 659.5 14.2
Alestes 25.1 1.1 58.9 6.4 46.8 3.5 130.8 2.8
baremoze
H. bimaculatus 30 1.3 22.7 2.4 8.5 0.6 61.2 1.3
H. fasciatus 123.2 5.2 130.7 14.1 61 4.6 314.9 6.8
Sarotherodon 89.1 3.7 46.8 5.0 32.5 2.5 168.9 3.6
galilaeus
Oreochromis 223.2 9.4 97.2 10.5 98.7 7.4 418.9 9.1
niloticus
T. zilli. 696.1 29.3 285 30.7 195.6 14.8 1176.8 25.4
C. citharus 371.6 16.6 - - 614.6 46.4 986.2 21.3
C. 310.8 13.1 89.4 9.6 8.3 0.6 408.5 8.8
nigrodigitatus
Labeo coubie 20.5 0.9 - - 4.7 0.4 25.2 0.5
Distichodus - - 14.5 1.6 - - 14.5 0.3
rostratus
S. 143.3 6.0 - - - - 143.3 3.1
membranaceus
M. budgeti 119.6 5.0 - - - - 119.6 2.6
Total weight of 2376.5 100 927.4 100 1323.8 100 4627.7 100
fish caught
Relative 51.4 20.0 28.6
percentage

CONCLUSION
At the end of this investigation the species caught was generally low, this might be due to overexploitation of the
fisheries resources in the lake as a result of influx of fishermen and the use of undersized mesh. Though castneting
with corn bran recorded the highest number and weight of fish caught followed by castnetting without bait. It is
therefore recommended for further study to be conducted in the lake using corn bran with other animal sources for
inductive luring method,

REFERENCES
Ahmed, Y.B., A.B. Adimula and E.F. Agbontaen (2005). Study on the effects of three fishing baits on the catch
composition of Malian traps in Lake Kainji. In: P.A. Araoye (ed) Processings of the 19th Annual
Conference of the Fisheries Society of Nigeria, Ilorin, 29th November, - 3rd December 2004pp 557-562.

Ahmed, Y.B; J.K. Ipinjolu and W.A. Hasssan (2006). Catch composition of gillnets and baited longilines in the
southern basin of Lake Kainji , Nigeria. In: Ansa, E.J. et al. (eds) Processings of the 20th Annual
National Conference of the Fisheries Society of Nigeria (FISON), Port-Harcourt, 14th – 18th November,
2005. Pp 350-360.

du Feu, T.A. and J.A. Abiodun (1999). Fisheries Statistics of Kainji Lake, Northern Nigeria, November 1994 –
December, 1998. Nigeria – German Kainji Lake Fisheries Promotion Project Technical Report Series 15.
128p.

40
Y.B. Ahmed et al.,: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 37 - 41, 2009

FAO (1969). Fisheries survey in the Western and Mid-western region of Nigeria. United Nations Development
Programme. FAO Rome.

Hayes, D.B., C.P. Ferreri and W.W. Taylor (1996). Active fish Capture methods. In: B.R. Murphy and D.W.
Willis (eds.) Fisheries Techniques, 2nd Edition, American Fisheries Society, Bethesda Marylan. Pp193-
220.

Olaosebikan, B.D. and A. Raji (2004). Field Guide to Nigerian Freshwater Fishes. 2nd edition published by
FCFFT, New Bussa, Unilorin Press, Ilorin-Nigeria. 111p

Seisay, M.D.B. and T.A. du Feu (1997). The effect of long term exploitation by gillnet fishery on the multi-species
fish stocks in Kainji Lake. NGKLFPP Technical report Series 11.58p.

Solarin, B.B. and K. Kusemiju (2003). Fish Shelter as Fisheries Enhancement Techniques in Lagos Lagoon,
Nigeria. Nigerian Journal of Fisheries 1(1): 57-61.

SPSS (1999). Statistical Package for the Social Sciences SPSS for Windows release 10.0.1 Standard Version.

Udolisa, R.E.K. and B.B. Solarin (1979). Design Characteristics of Castnets and Gillnets in Lagos Lagos Nigeria.
NIOMR Occasional Paper Number 31, 24p.

Udolisa, R.E.K; B.B. Solarin, P. Lebo and E.E. Ambrose (1994). A catalogue of small scale fishing gear in Nigeria
. RAFR/014/F1/94/02:142P.

Received for Publication: 15/07 /2009


Accepted for Publication: 08/09 /2009

Corresponding Author:
Y.B. Ahmed
Federal College Of Freshwater Fisheries Technology,P.M.B. 1500, New Bussa, Niger State
Email: ybahmed2003@yahoo.com

41
Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 42 - 49, 2009
© Wilolud Online Journals, 2009.

THE ROLE OF PROBIOTICS IN AQUACULTURE IN NIGERIA– A REVIEW

Kolndadacha, O.D1., Adikwu, I.A2., Atiribom, R.Y1., Mohammed A1., Musa, Y.M1. and Ladu G.B1.
1
National Institute for Freshwater Fisheries Research, P.M.B. 6006, New Bussa, Niger State.
2
Department of Biological Science, Benue State University, Makurdi, Benue State

ABSTRCT
Aquaculture is beset by many problems especially diseases caused by bacteria as the major
deteriorating factors. The use of vaccines and antimicrobial agents have been centered on
disease control, but are associated with problems The development of antibiotic resistance
among the microorganisms have become a global concern as a result of indiscriminate use of
antibiotics. Several alternative suggestions for disease prevention have been on probiotics for
its efficacy, low cost, less side effects and accessible to farmers. Probiotics is gaining a high
priority in the developed countries with the aim of replacing conventional drugs. The principal
bacterial groups tested as probiotic bacteria in culture of shrimps, crabs, oysters, fish and
humans are Vibrio, Pseudomonas, Bacillus, Bifidobacteria and several Lactobacilli.
Experiments have mainly been conducted with fish larvae, adult fish, crustaceans and animals
where significant reduction in mortalities has been obtained. The purpose of this review is to
create awareness of the role of probiotics in disease control in aquaculture as alternative to
antibiotics.

KEYWORDS: Role, Probiotics, Disease control, Aquaculture, Nigeria

INTRODUCTION
Aquaculture is concerned with the propagation and rearing of aquatic organisms under complete human control
involving manipulation of at least one stage of an aquatic organism’s life before harvest in order to increase its
production. This practice has become an important economic activity in many countries. In large-scale production
facilities where aquatic animals are exposed to stressful conditions, problems related to diseases and deterioration of
environmental condition often occur and result in serious economic losses. Prevention and control of diseases
through the use of antibiotics and vaccines have been in practice in many countries of the world. However the utility
of antimicrobial agents as a preventive measure has been questioned, given extensive documentation of the
evaluation of antimicrobial resistance among pathogenic bacteria. The problems from the use of antibiotics have
attracted a global concern in terms of development of resistance among the pathogenic bacteria. Resistance
mechanisms of bacteria can arise in one of two ways: chromosomal mutation or acquisition R – plasmid.

There is therefore an urgent need in aquaculture development for microbial control strategies since disease outbreaks
are recognized as important constraints to aquaculture and despite the fact that the development of antibiotic
resistance has became a matter of growing concern. One alternative to antibiotics in disease control in aquaculture
could be the use of probiotic bacteria. The use of probiotics or beneficial bacteria which control pathogen through a
variety of mechanisms is increasingly viewed as an alternative to antibiotic treatment. The use of probiotics in
human (Anukam, et al., 2004, 2006 and Anukam, 2007) in animal nutrition (Fuller, 1992) are well documented and
recently they have begun to be applied in aquaculture (Gatesoupe, 1999; Gomez-Gill et al.; 2000, Veschuere et al.,
2000, Irianto and Austin, 2002).

POTENTIAL PROBIOTIC BACTERIA IN USE


Probiotics are harmless bacteria that help the wellbeing of the host animal and contribute directly or indirectly to
protect the host animal against harmful bacterial pathogens. A review indicates a considerable potential of certain
harmless bacterial strains to prevent or control fish diseases caused by pathogenic bacteria as well as boosting
growth performance in farmed fish (Ashraf, 2000). It is assumed that uncontrolled development of the microbial
communities in hatcheries is one of the major reasons for the unpredictable and often variable results; the
introduction of microbial control practices by means of Probiotics may have a beneficial effect on the cultures in the
hatcheries. Griffith (1995) reported that following the introduction of Probiotics in Ecuador in 1992, hatchery down-

42
Kolndadacha, O.D et al.,: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 42 - 49, 2009

times between batches was reduced from 7days per month to 21 days annually, production volume increased by
35% and over all antimicrobial use decreased by 95%.

In agriculture the value of probiotics notably Gram-positive bacteria such as lactobacillus has come to be
appreciated as an alternative to antibiotics in disease control. A wide variety of micro-organisms have been found
capable of producing substances which are inhibitory to other organisms. Other organism e.g. Pseudomonas are also
known to be a natural competitor to other organisms like saprolegnia (Bly, et. al. 1997). These organisms that have
the ability to compete, produce substance that stimulate the growth of other organisms or inhibit the growth of
another are probiont and in future may be utilized for biological control in aquaculture as in mammalian probiotics.
It is there for important to consider those bacteria that have antagonistic effect and those bacteria that stimulate the
growth of others as important as potentials for probiotics in aquaculture. Einar (2002) reported that the most
promising organisms for probiotic are Vibrio and Pseudomonas for fish and Bacillus for shrimp systems. Bergh
(1995) added that the isolates that inhibit the growth of other bacteria belong to Pseudomonas /Alteromonas group,
and the ability to produce compound that inhibit the growth of other bacteria may be wide spread among marine and
fresh water bacteria. Austin et al. (1995) reported that a strain of V. alginolyticus was effective in reducing disease
caused by Aeromonas salmonicida and 2 pathogenic Vibrio species. The table below summarizes the common
probiont employed in culture of different aquatic organisms according to Gomez-Gill et al. (2000)

Table 1: Probiotics employed in culture of aquatic organisms


Species of bacteria Target organism Reference
Vibrio alginolyticus Shrimp (Panaeus vannamei) (Garriques and Arevalo, 1995)
Thalassobacter utilis (PM-4) Shrimp (P. monodon) Maeda and Liao, 1991)
V. harveyi, Pseudomonas sp., Shrimp (P. monodon and P. penicillatus) (Anonymus, 1991)
Nitrobacter sp Nitrosomonas sp.,
and Bacillus sp.
T. utilis (PM-4) Crab (Portumus trituberculatus) ( Nogami and Maeda, 1992,
Nagomi, et.al. 1997)
V. Pelagius Turbot (Scophthalmus maximus) (Ringo and Vadstein, 1998)
Bacillus toyoi and B. sp. spore Turbot via rotifers (Branchionus plicatilis) ( Gatesoupe, 1989, )
Lactic bacteria Turbot via rotifers (Gatesoupe, 1990)
Lactobacillus plantarum and
L. helveticus Turbot via rotifers (Gatesoupe, 1991)
Lacobcillus bulgaricus and
Streptococcus lactis Turbot via Artemia (Douillet and Langdon, 1994)
Aleromonas sp. Oyest (Crossotrea gigers) (Douillet and Langdon, 1994)
Aeromonas media Oyster (Gibson, et.al. 1998)
Rosebacter sp (NS107) Scallop (Pecten maximus) (Ruiz-Ponte, et.al, 1999)
Vibrio sp Chalean scallop (Argopecten purpuratus) (Riquelme et.al, 1997)

Source: Gomez- Gill et al. 2000

The highly researched and most used probiotics according to Berger (2002), are Lacobacillus acdophillus, L.
bulgericus,Bifidobacteria longum and B.infantis Some of the commercial probiotics currently available in use
include Aqualact, probela, Lacto-sacc Epicin, Biogreen, Environ, Wunopuo-15 and Epizyme (Abidi, 2003).
However evidences indicate that probiotic effects are strain-specific, therefore a beneficial effect attributed to one
strain cannot be assumed by another strain, even when they belong to the same species (Senok, et.al. 2005). Table 2
shows the probiotic bacteria used in aquaculture fishes.

43
Kolndadacha, O.D et al.,: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 42 - 49, 2009

Table 2: Probiotics considered as biological control agents in aquaculture of fishes


Probiotic strain Source Used on Method of application Reference
Streptococcus lactis and ? Turbot larvae Enrichment of live food Garcia de la Blanda
Lactobacillu bulgaricus (Scophthalmus maximus) et al. (1992)
Lactobacillus sp. and Rotifers (Brachionus Turbot larvae enrichment of rotifers Gatesoupe, et al. (1995)
Carnobacterium sp. plicatilis)
Vibrio alinolyticus commercial shrimp Atlantic salmon Bathing in bacterial Austin, et al. (1992)
Hatchery (Salmosalar) suspension
Carnobacterium divergens Intestine of Atlantic cod fry Addition diet Gibson et al. (1998)
Alantic salmon
Bacillus megaterium commercial product Channel catfish Additid to pond water Queeirz and Boyd (1998)
B. subtilis, B. polymyxa (Biostart)
B. lachenformis
Vibrio pelagius Turbot larvae Turbot Addition to culture water Ringo and Vadstein (1998)
Pseudomonas fluorscens Iced freshwater fish Rainbow trout Addition to culture water Gram et al. (1999)
(Lates niloticus) (Oncorhynchus mykiss)
Lactobacillus rhamnosus culture collection Rainbow trout Addition to diet Nikoskelainen et al. (2001)
Aeromonas hydrphila Digestive tract of Rainbow trout Addition to diet Irianto and Austin, (2002)
rainbow trout
Bacillus circulans Intestine of L. rotifer Addition to diet Gomez-Gil, et al. (2000)
Labeo rotifer

Source: Balcazar et al. (2006)

APPLICATION OF PROBIOTICS IN AQUACULTURE


These organisms can be administered to the aquaculture organisms through feeding, injection or immersion of the
probiotic bacteria (Irianto and Austin, 2002).

Application in Feed
Probiotics are applied with the feed and a binder (egg or cod liver oil) and most commercial preparation contain
either Lactobacillus sp or Sacharomyces cerevisiae (Abidi, 2003). Regular use of probiotic in feed of fish in U.K.
and other European countries has been reported to have several health benefits (Cerrato 2000).

The perception that fermented milk yoghurt is beneficial is already wide spreading within so many regions because,
traditionally these products have been used by local healers for the treatment of diverse condition, such as skin,
allergies, stomach upset especially diarrhea and vaginal discharges.

According to FAO and WHO guidelines, probiotic organisms used in food must be capable of surviving passages
through the gut i.e. they must have the ability to resist gastric juices and exposure to bile (Senok et al 2005). Further
more they must be able to proliferate and colonize the digestive tract and they must be safe, effective and maintain
their effectiveness and potency for the duration of the shelf life of the product (Senok et al, 2005).

Dairy products including yoghurt, fermented milk product and cheese remain at forefront of probiotic food
development in humans. Yoghurt with added live probiotic strains is now available commercially and a number of
such products have emerged as leaders in the European market are now also available internationally. In aquaculture
probiotic can also be encapsulated in feed (Einar 2002) or through live food like rotifers and artemia Another
efficient application of probiotics to aquatic animal according to Einar (2002) is via bio-encapsulation or infusions
in diets. Preparation of probiotic diet has been demonstrated by Yassir et al, (2002).

Direct to Culture Water/ Pond


The water probioics contain multiple strains of bacteria like Bacillus acidophilus, B. subtilis B. lecheniformis,
Nitrobacter sp, Aerobacter and Sacharomyces cerevisiae. Application of probiotic through water of tanks and
ponds may also have an effect on fish health by improving several qualities of water, since they modify the bacteria

44
Kolndadacha, O.D et al.,: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 42 - 49, 2009

composition of the water and sediments (Ashraf, 2000; Venkateswara, 2007). When probiotics are applied in
culture water they multiply and over grow the pathogenic organism present in the water. Beside this Venkateswara
(2007) reported that probiotic bacteria are generally called bacteria which can improve the water quality of
aquaculture and inhibit the pathogens in water thereby increasing production.

Today many researchers attempt to use some kind of probiotic in aquaculture water to regulate the microflora of
aquaculture water, control pathogenic microorganism to enhance decomposition of undesirable organic substances
in the water and improve ecological environment of aquaculture (Xiang-Hong et. al;2000 Venkateswara ,2000).

Einar (2002) identified some ways of using probiotcs either as larval food or enriched brachionus or artemia with
probioics.

Application through Injection


Application of probiotics by injection is a possibility. Austin, et al. (1995) suggested the possibility of freeze-drying
the probiont like vaccine and applied either through bathing, or injection. Except for experimental purposes
application of probiotic by injection has not been widely reported. Even though one of the benefits of probiotics in
fish and animal is to boost the immunity, meaning that there is the stimulation of antibodies of the host. Probiotics
can therefore confer the best immunity through injection as Lamar (1985) reported that injection the best method of
vaccination. However (Gram et al (1999) state that vaccination by injection which some times the only effective
route of administration is impracticable when applied to small fish or larger numbers. Yassir et. al. (2002) has
demonstrated the experimental administration of probiotic Micrococcus luteus to Oreochrmis niloticus by injection
through intra peritoneal route which had only 25% mortality as against 90% with Pseudomonas using the same
route. According to Yassir et al (2002) the use of probiotics stimulate Rainbow trout immunity by stimulating
phagocytes activity, complement mediated bacterial killing and immunoglobulin production (Nikoselainen et al,
2003). When probiotics is evaluated in freeze dried form, it can be applied through injection

BENEFITS OF PROBIOTICS
Although some of the effects of probiotics have been documented clearly, research is still on going in the area with
so many questions on the reality of some of the benefit remaining unanswered. However it is crucial to remember
that different probiotic strains are associated with different health benefits (Senok et al.2005).

Improvement in Water Qualities


According to Venkateswara (2007), probiotics have been reported to regulate micro flora, control pathogenic ones,
enhances the decomposition of the undesirable organic substance, improve ecological environment by minimizing
the toxic gasses like NH3, N20, H2O2, Methane etc, increases population of food organism in the water, increases
nutritional level of the aquatic host and improve their immunity in the culture water. In several studies, improved
water quality has been recorded during the addition of the probiotics especially with Bacillus sp. (Verschuere et al,
2000). The rationale is that Gram-positive Bacillus sp. are generally more effective in converting organic matter
back to CO2 than G-negative bacteria which could convert a greater percentage of organic carbon to bacterial
biomass or slime.

As Growth Promoters
One of the activities of probiotic bacteria is expected to have a direct growth promoting effect of fish either by direct
involvement in nutrient uptake or by providing nutrient or vitamin. However, it has been demonstrated
experimentally that probiotics indeed may enhance the growth of fish. The ability of organisms to out-grow the
pathogens in favor of host or to improve the growth of the host and yet no side effect on the host made it a probiotic
bacteria. Yassir et al. (2002) in attempt to use probiotic bacteria as growth promoter on tilapia (Oreochromis
niloticus) identified that the highest growth performance was recorded with Micrococcus luteus a probiotic and the
best feed conversion ratio was observed with the same organism. So M. luteus may be considered as a growth
promoters in fish aquaculture. Lactic acid bacteria also had an effect as growth promoters on the growth rate in
juvenile carp though not in Sea bass (Noh et al, 1994). Also Enterococcus facium had been used to improve growth
when applied in feed to fish (Bogut et al. 2000). Irianto and Austin (2002) reported that probiotics may stimulate
appetite and improve nutrition by producing vitamins, detoxification of compounds in the diet and by the breakdown

45
Kolndadacha, O.D et al.,: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 42 - 49, 2009

of indigestible components. Streptococcus facium improved the growth and feed efficiency of Israeli carp (Noh et
al. 1994). Probiotics therefore can be regarded as growth promoters in aquaculture organisms in addition to various
benefits of probiotics.

For Good Health


Many probiotic products are used routinely by healthy individuals indeed the marketing of many probiotics food
probiotics is targeted at healthy individuals. The claim that regular ingestion will contribute to a healthy life style,
promote general wellbeing and protect against or reduce the risk of developing chronic gastrointestinal, respiratory
or cardiac problems in the long term has induced many people to undertake regular consumption of these products.
(Senok, et.al., 2005). Selected probiotics have shown to have significant health benefits for humans and thus several
well-characterized strains are available for human use to reduce the risk of gastrointestinal infection or to treat such
infection (Nikoskelainen, 2001). In countries of continental Europe, probiotics are regarded as medicine and they are
prescribed alongside antibiotics, while in other countries probiotics are marketed as supplement and are sold over
the counter (Berger, 2002) for good health.

For Disease Prevention


Probiotics or their products for health benefits to the host have been found useful in aquaculture, terrestrial animals
and in human disease control. These include microbial adjunct that prevent pathogens from proliferating in the
intestinal tract, on the superficial surfaces and in culture environment of the culture species (Verschuere, et.al.
2000). The effect of these beneficial organisms is achieved through optimizing the immune system of culture
organism, increasing their resistance to disease, or producing inhibitory-substance that prevent the pathogenic
organisms from establishing disease in the host. Culture System, Inc, (2002) added that good bacteria in the gut aid
in many important function such as nutrient digestion, immune function and prevention of pathogens.

One of the well established benefits of probiotics is the decrease in occurrence and duration of diarrhea especially
those caused by antibiotics like ampicillin using mixture of L. bulgericus, L.acidophillus ,Bifidobacterium and
Streptococcus bacteria. This is also true for the use of L. rhamnosus GG, L. reuteri SD2222 and B. lactis BB-12 in
the prevention and treatment rotavirus diarrhea in children, cited by Senok et.al (2005). However probiotics is
becoming a popular treatment for the occurrence of urogenital infection in the women. Several studies suggest that
the administration of Lactobacillus either orally or intravaginally is an effective treatment and preventive measures
against urogenital infection (Geldzwis, 2007 and Senok, et al. 2005). Some authors conducted studies in animals
showed that probiotics may be a protective factor against cancer of colon, prostate, bladder and other cancer,
because probiotic bacteria protect carcinogenic activities and L. acidophilus or L. casei are reported to play this role.
Therefore the use of probiotics have a potential benefits for conditions such as gastrointestinal infection,
genitourinary infection, allergies and certain bowel disorders all which afflict a considerable proportion of the global
population (Senok et al. 2005).

SELECTION CRITERIA FOR PROBIOTICS


The initial major purpose of using probiotics is to maintain or re-establish a favorable relationship between friendly
and pathogenic microorganism that constitute the flora of intestinal or skin mucus of fish. A successful probiotic is
expected to have a few specific properties in order to certify, a beneficial effect.
FAO/WHO (2001) guidelines recommend that in the cause of selecting probiotics, the probiont should be evaluated
for a number of parameters such as, antibiotic susceptibility patterns, toxic production, metabolic and hemolytic
activities, infectivity in immuno-compromised host and side-effects

Characteristics of Good Probiotics


Filler (1989) listed the following as features of good probiotic bacteria.
 Its should be a strain, which is capable of exerting a beneficial effect on the host animal e.g. increased
growth or resistance to disease
 It should be non-pathogenic and non-toxic
 It should be present as viable cells preferable in large numbers
 It should be capable of surviving and metabolizing in the gut environment e.g. resistance to low pH
and organic acid.

46
Kolndadacha, O.D et al.,: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 42 - 49, 2009

 It should be stable and capable of remaining viable for periods under storage and field conditions.

A probiotic agent with all these features has considerable advantage over antibacterial supplements such as
antibiotics currently in use. They do not induce resistance to antibiotics which will compromise therapy. They are
not toxic and therefore will not produce undesirable side effect when being feed and in the case of food animal will
not produce toxic residues in the carcass. They may stimulate immunity whereas the immune status remains
unaffected by antibiotics. An essential determinant in the choice of a probiotic microorganism is its ability to reach,
survive and persist in the environments (Charles et al. 1998).

CONCLUSION
Probiotics as an alternative to antibiotics in aquaculture becomes imperative. The most highly researched probiotic
bacteria today are Lactobacillus acidophilus, L. bulgarium , Bifidobacteria longum, and B. infantis

REFERENCES
Abidi, R. (2003). Use of probiotics in larval rearing of mew candidate species. Aquaculture Asia April-June 2003
vol. Viii No.2 Pp15-16

Anonymous (1991). Disease control in hatchery by microbiological techniques. Asian shrimp News 8:4, 4th quarter

Anukam, K.C. (2007).The potential role of probiotics in reducing poverty associated infections in developing
countries. International journalof probiotics and prebiotics 1 (2): 81-83

Anukam, K.C., Osazuwa, E.O. and Reid, G. (2006). Knowledge of probiotics by Nigerian clinicians. International
journal of probiotics and prebiotics 1(1): 57-62

Anukam, K.C., Osazuwa, E.O. and Reid, G. (2004). Reducing the risk of HIV in women, using probiotics as an
alternative strategy. International conference on AIDS 2004 July 11-16, 15: Abstract no. E. 10839

Ashraf, Ali (2000). Probiotics in fish farming – Evaluation of a candidate bacterial mixture. Vattenbruksinstitutionen
. Report 19, Umea’2000, Ph. Licentiate Thesis. Pp 1-18

Austin, B., Baudet, E. and Stobie, M. (1992). Inhibition of bacteria fish pathogens by Tetraselmis suecica Journal of
Fish Diseases, 15: 53- 61

Austin, B., Stukey, L.F., Robertton, P.A., Effendi, I. and Griffith, D.R.W. (1995). A probiotic starian of vibrio
alginolyticus effective in reducing disease caused by Aeromonas Salmonicida. Vibrio anguillarum and Vibrio ordali.
Journal of Fish Diseases, 18: 93- 96

Balcazar, L. J., Blas, I., Ruiz-Zarzuela, I., Cunningham D., Vendrell, D. and Muzquiz, L.J. (2006). The role of
probiotics in aquaculture. Veterinary Microbiology 114:173-186

Bergh, Q. (1995). Bacteria associated with early stages of Halibut Hippoglossus hippoglossus L., inhibit growth of a
pathogenic Vibrio.sp. Journal of Fish Disease 18: 31-40

Berger, A. (2002). Probiotics. British Medical Journal, 224 (7350): 1364, Online

Bly, J.E., Quindou, S.M.A., Lawson, L. A. and Chem, L.W. (1997). Inhibition of Saprolegnia pathogenic for fish by
Pseudomonas fluorescents. Journal of Fish Disease 20:35-40

Douillet, P.A., and Langdon, C.J. (1993). Effect of marine bacteria on the culture of axenic oysters Crassostrea
gigas, Thurberg larvae. Biological Bulletin 184:36-51

Douillet, P.A. and Langdon, C.J. (1994). Use of probiotics for the culture of larvae of the pacific oysters Crassostrea

47
Kolndadacha, O.D et al.,: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 42 - 49, 2009

gigas, Thurberg. Aquaculture 119:25-40

Fuller, R. (1992). History and development of probiotics. In: Fuller, R.D. (Ed). Probiotics: the scientific bases.
Chayoman and Hall, New York, Pp1-8 International conference on AIDS 2004 July 11-16; 15 : Abstract no.
E. 10839

Garcia-de-la-Banda, I., Chereguini, O. and Rasnes, I.(1992). Influence of lactic bacteria additives on turbot (
Scophthalmus maximus L.) larvae culture. Bol. Inst. Esp. Oceanogr. 8:247-254

Garriques, D., and Arevalo, G. (1995). An evaluation of the probiotics and the use of a live bacterial isolates to
manipulate the microbial flora in the commercial production of Panaeus vannzamei post larvae in Ecuador, C.L. and
Hopkins, J.S.(Eds). World Aquaculture Society. Pp 53-59

Gatesoupe, F.J. (1999). The use of probiotic in Aquaculture. Aquaculture 180:147-165

Gatesoupe, F.J. (1990). The continuous feeding of turbot larvae Scopthalmus maximus and control of the bacterial
environment of rotifers. Aquaculture 89:139-148

Gatesoupe, F.J. (1989). Further advances in the nutritional and antibacterial treatment of rotifers as food for turbot
larvae Scopthalmus maximus L. In: de- Pauw, N. (Ed), Aquaculture- a Biotechnology in progress. European
Aquaculture Society Bredene. Pp 721-730

Geslewitz, G., (2007). Probiotics: New Strains amid gowing pains. Vitamins retailer, http://www.vitamins retailer.
Com/VR/articles proboitics.htm P8.

Gibson, L.F., Woodworth, J. and George, A.M. (1998). Probiotic activity of Aeromonas media on the pacific oyster,
Crassostrea gigas, when challenged with Vibrio tubiashi. Aquaculture 169: 111-120

Gomez-gill, B., Roque, A. Turnbell, J.F (2000). The use and selection of robiotic bacteria for use in the culture of
larval aquatic organisms. Aqualcuture 19: 259-270.

Gram, L. Melchiorison, J., Spanggerard, B., Hubber, I. and Nielsen,. T. F. (1999). Inhibition of Vibrio
anguilarum by Pseudomonas fluerescens A H2 G possible probiotic peatiment of fisg. Applied
Environmental Microbiology, 65:969-973.

Griffith, D.R.W. (1995). Microbiology and the role of probiotics in Ecuadorian shrimps hatcheries. In: Larens P.
Jaspers, E. Roelands I. (Eds) posium. European aquaculture society Gent, P. 478. Special Publication No.24.

Irianto, A. and Austin, B. (2002). Probiotics in aquaculture. Journal of Fish Disease 25:633-642

Maeda, M., and Liao, I.C. (1992). Effect of bacterial population on the growth of a prawn larvae Panaeus monodon.
Aquaculture 21:25-29

Nogami, K. and Maeda, M. (1992). Bacterial as biocontrol agent for rearing larvae of the crab Portunus
trituberculatus. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 4.9: 2373-2376

Nogami, K., Hamasaki, K., Maeda, M. and Hirayama, K. (1997). Biocontrol method in aquaculture for rearing the
swimming crab larvae Portunus tritiberculatus. Hydrobiologia, 358:291-295

Okaeme A.N., Mohammed A. Adbulrahman and M. Kolndadacha, O.D (2003).probiotics research as alternative
strategy in the control of bacterial disease in fish production. Peer reviewer. Proceeding of 16th Annual Congress of
Biotechnology Society of Nigeria pp.139-142.

48
Kolndadacha, O.D et al.,: Continental J. Fisheries and Aquatic Science 3: 42 - 49, 2009

Queiroz, J. F. and Boyd, C.E. Effect of a bacterial inoculums in channel catfish ponds. Journal of WorldAquaculture
Society. 29:67-73

Seniok A.C.ismeel A.Y.Botta G.A, (2005). Pprobiotics: facts and myths. Clinical Microbiology andInfection
Diseases 11:958-960

Ruiz-Ponte, C., Samain, J.F., Sanchez, J.L., and Nicolas, J.L. (1999). Thre benefit of a Roseobacter species on the
survival of Scallop larvae. Marine Biotechnology, 1: 52-59

Ringo, and Vadstein, O. (1998). Colonization of Vibrio Pelagius and Aeromonas caviae in early developing turbot
Scophthalmus maximus(L) larvae. Journal of Applied Microbiology. 84:227-233

Riquelme, C., Araya, R., Vergara, N., Rojas, A., Guita, M. and Candia, M. (1997). Potential probiotic strains in the
culture of the Chilean Scollap Argopecten purpuratus (Lamarck 1819). Aquaculture 154: 17-26

Tanock, G. W. (1997). Modification of the normal of the normal microbiota by diet, sress, antimicrobial agents and
probiotics. In : Mackie R. I. with B.A. Isaacson R.E. (ed), Gastrointestinal Micrbiology vol 2, Gastrointestinal
Micobes and host interaction. Chapman and Hall Microbiology Series, International Thampson Publishing, New
York, Pp 434- 465

Venkateswara, A. R.(2007). Bioremediation to restore the health of aquaculture. Pond Ecosystem. Hyderabad – 500
082, India. Pp 1-12

Verschuere, L., Romout, G., Sorgeloos, P. and Verstrate, W. (2000). Probiotic bacteria as Biologcal control agents
in aquaculture. Microbiology and Molecular Biology Reveiws, 64(4): 65-671.

Xiang-Hong, W., Jun, L., Wei-shang, J. Huai-shu, X. (2003). Application of probiotics in aquaculture. Ocean
Universityof Qungo, China. Online pp1-10

Yassir, A.L. Adel, M.E. and Azze, A. (2002). Use of probiology bacteria as growth promoters, antibacterial and the
effect on physiological parameters of Oreochronus niroticus. Journal of Fish Diseases 25: 633-642

Received for Publication: 15/07 /2009


Accepted for Publication: 08/09 /2009

Corresponding Author:
Kolndadacha, O.D
National Institute for Freshwater Fisheries Research, P.M.B. 6006, New Bussa, Niger State

49

You might also like