Professional Documents
Culture Documents
292
IM
33
1996 pp
ap 21
2133
21
curriculum
michael lessard clouston
gakuin university japan
kwanyei
kwansei gaduin
introduction
112
2 education this
using the literature of curriculum studies and second language 12
article discusses the fundamental role of vocabulary within the 12 curriculum in doing
so certain aspects of curriculum will first be outlined and then the 12 curriculum will be
considered in light of the field of curriculum studies next 1I will argue the central place
of english vocabulary within the english as a second and foreign language ESLEFL
curriculum finally some of the educational implications of this reality will be noted by
arm
are encouraged to reflect on and
arc
suggesting topics and questions that ESLEFL educators amm
what is curriculum
in the educational literature curriculum is viewed in both a narrow sense and a
broader one as jackson 1992a makes clear tyler 1975 for example declares that the
term is used both as an outline of a course of study and to refer to everything that
transpires in the planning teaching and learning in an educational institution writing
in a major curriculum journal egan 1978 noted that curriculum specifically centers on
two essential questions in educational practice what is taught and how it is taught
beyond this point however curriculum is the study of any and all educational
phenomena it may draw on any external discipline for methodological help but does not
allow the methodology to determine inquiry egan 1978 p 71
curriculum handbooks like jacksons 1992b reveal that writers in the field of
curriculum studies use both narrow and broader conceptions of curriculum in order to
produce knowledge which is relevant to their respective areas of specialization beyond
these perspectives curriculum specialists in various disciplines have found Sch
schwabs
wabs
schlabs
1960 four curricular commonplaces particularly valuable in conceptualizing curriculum
in their fields these commonplaces are the subject context learning and teaching
whatever ones specific area curriculum within a specialized discipline involves these
essential aspects Clandinin
clandinin
clindinin and connelly 1992 have expanded our current
understanding of curriculum by declaring that they have two views of curriculum one
as a course of study and the other a course of life they have distinguished what one
TESL reporter
22
both in and
usually experiences in school the former and what one experiences in life
out of school the latter in this view there is an obvious interaction between the two
with what one leams
learns in life affecting what one experiences in school and vice versa
curriculum as both a course of study and a course of life leads to an understanding of a
Clan dinin and connelly 1992 p 365
clandinin
out cian
clindinin
curriculum which teachers and students live oufclandinin
ibis view is also important in considering the 12 curriculum
this
12 curriculum
turning now to the 12 curriculum it is important to state as nunan 1988 does that
until recently there has been a comparative neglect of curriculum theorizing in relation to
ese
ESU p 15 he believes that this is because
ESL
such influences from linguistics have been reflected in work on 12 curriculum see
yalden 1987 and trends in 12 pedagogy as with the direct audiolingual
audio lingual and
communicative language teaching methods despite a general lack of attention to
curriculum studies some authors within 12 education have nonetheless incorporated
general curriculum principles
other writers in 12 and ESLEFL education have also been influenced by the larger
field of curriculum studies stating that the current need is for language curriculum
designers to look beyond linguistics to the general field of educational research and theory
23
me
the ambiguity of the larger field of curriculum
TESL reporter
24
is often divided along the lines of the four major skills listening speaking reading and
writing although sometimes culture a fifth dimension damen 1987 is added despite
its importance within the ESLEFL curriculum vocabulary is seldom explicitly
programme
pro
mentioned yet is always present A glance at a programma
gramme or its materials will not
necessarily reveal this reality however nor will much of the literature on vocabulary
learning and teaching
mccarthy 1990 begins his vocabulary book by stating that it is the experience of
most language teachers that the single biggest component of any language course is
vocabulary p viii whatever skill one is teaching in ESLEFL education vocabulary
whai we teach equally important
whal
represents a major part of ones course content egans what
khal
is the fact that in ESLEFL contexts where english is the medium of instruction english
means by which we teach and students learn egans how we teach
vocabulary is also the wans
however vocabulary has only recently begun to attain greater stature in the ESL and EFL
learning and teaching literature a fact which is reflected in the appearance of various
pedagogical works on the sub
subject
act such as carter and mccarthy 1988 morgan and
ect
1992
19901992
rinvolucri 1986 nation 1994 and taylor 1990
in a survey article on 12 vocabulary maiguashca 1993 declares that even in the
recent communicative approach vocabulary continued to play a marginal or ancillary
role p 84 she then summarizes why
me
the
in her article maiguashca 1993 goes on to declare that the study of vocabulary is
perhaps the fastest growing area of second language education in terms of research output
and publications p 85 while this appears to be true she then mistakenly from my
perspective suggests that vocabulary has therefore become the guest of honor of
maiguasbca appears to have missed two important points
language teaching in essence maiguashca
that I1 believe must be addressed within 12 education generally and the ESLIEFL
ESLEFL
curriculum in particular
25
first while it is true that publications reveal greater research interest in vocabulary
Bejoint 1992 hatch and brown
within applied linguistics see for example amaud
arnaud and bejoint
1995 huckin haynes and coady 1993 meara 1992 and schreuder and weltens 1993
both observation studies and curriculum materials suggest that it is inappropriate to equate
such academic and research interest with a greater focus on vocabulary in the 12
26
TESL reporter
27
in addition ESLEFL texts need to be developed which present and deal with
vocabulary more creatively and which present real life vocabulary usage mccarthy
1996 word lists and translations in texts may be useful meara 1995 but arm
amm
arc insufficient
are
where we are dealing with learners who have a variety of learning styles As sanaouis
Sanaouis
sanaoufs
1995 studies indicated that ones review of vocabulary is important in lexical learning
course materials should review both implicitly and explicitly vocabulary presented
earlier while williss 1990 lexical syllabus does this at earlier stages a particular need
exists for such curricula at advanced levels of english proficiency as well as in english
for academic and specific purposes materials As nunan 1988 noted above 12 learning
involves both process and product ESL and EFL materials need to address this fact by
incorporating both vocabulary items and ways for students to develop and use vocabulary
learning strategies on their own beyond their texts and courses in their course of life
research
turning briefly to research teacher researchers should understand both the narrow
and
nd broader conceptions of curriculum discussed above and consider specific what
vocabulary is being taught in this lesson as well as broader research questions what
incidental vocabulary learning may be taking place here which include and reflect both
Clan
dinin and Con
clandinin
connellys
clindinin
nellys 1992 course of study and course of life perspectives in
connellis
doing so we also need to recognize the centrality of vocabulary in ESLEFL teaching and
learning by maintaining and increasing recent interest in 12 vocabulary research A better
understanding of what it means for students to know a word especially in terms of breadth
TESL reporter
28
and depth of vocabulary knowledge see nagy and herman 1987 wesche and paribakht
forthcoming is needed and we must move beyond models in linguistics and recognize the
individual nature of vocabulary learning and knowledge lessard clouston forthcoming
As maiguashca 1993 has rightly noted much of our understanding in 12 education
a coherent
centers on grammar which amounts to a system of rules and constitutes
and structured whole the same cannot be said however for vocabulary p 91 we
thus need to study both incidental ESL and EFL vocabulary learning and teaching in a
variety of educational contexts ellis 1994
the
with the development and use of technology in ESLEFL education research into
vocabulary learning and teaching must also consider varied means of vocabulary
instruction and acquisition with computer programmes in courses for example the
teacher is no longer necessarily the main source of lexical input in some contexts of 12
education while some work on vocabulary learning and teaching through such means
does exist see green and meara 1995 and kang 1995 for example much more
research needs to be carried out on such educational technologies before a more
comprehensive understanding of vocabulary acquisition and use with such materials is
attained
much LI research has focused on vocabulary size nagy and herman 1987
although there are various estimates willis 1990 asserts that educated native english
29
speakers are likely to have a vocabulary of some 50000 words p 39 in addition they
may have encountered the 88500 distinct word families which appear in printed school
materials in english carroll davies and richman 1971 given these realities research
questions of interest to those who are teaching ESL and EFL students who will pursue
post secondary education in english include 1 what vocabulary is needed by adult
postsecondary
ESLJEFL learners who will do their academic work in english and 2 how might they best
ESLEFL
team the specialized vocabulary of their academic disciplines
keam
since saville troike
learn
1986 and casanave 1992 have demonstrated that vocabulary is crucial to ESL students
academic success these questions also need to be answered in essence vocabulary
ESLEFL course of study
learning and use in academic contexts is where a students ESLIEFL
interacts with and is fundamental to his or her present and future course of life
accordingly the relationship between general and special purposes vocabulary nation
and hwang 1995 is yet another aspect of
12 vocabulary use and acquisition that requires
ofl2
ofle
further study
conclusion
in this article 1I have briefly considered an essential aspect of 12 pedagogy by relating
the central place of english vocabulary in ESLJEFL
ESLEFL learning and teaching to the 12
curriculum suggestions have been made for ESLEFL teachers to consider in their
pedagogy and questions were raised for their classroom research for ESL and EFL
students understanding thoughts
thought and ideas expressed in english vocabulary and putting
their own thoughts and ideas into english with words and expressions is crucial
in oral
and written contexts both within and beyond the ESLEFL classroom it is time for ESL
and EFL teachers and researchers to act on this reality not only by recognizing
vocabular
vocabularys
ys important role in the curriculum but also by giving it a central place in our
teaching materials and research
ments
Acknowledge
acknowledgements
the author
references
alien P swain M harley B & cummins J 1990 aspects of classroom treatment
ailen
allen
toward a more comprehensive view of second language education in B harley
P alien
ailen J cummins & M swain eds the development of second language
allen
81 cambridge cambridge university press
pp 57
proficiency ap
5781
TESL reporter
30
Bejoint H eds
arnaud P & bejoint
amaud
1992
macmillan
syll abuses for the language classroom in C brumfit ed
breen M 1984 process syllabuses
general english syllabus design ELT documents 118 oxford pergamon
vocabulary
1971
eds
general
new york
ailen and
allen
london alien
casanave C
m P jackson ed
Clan
dinin J & connelly M 1992 teacher as curriculum maker in
clandinin
clindinin
363 401 new york macmillan
handbook of research on curriculum appp 363401
insights for learners teachers and
1990
language learning
cohen A
researchers new york newbury house
eds
1993
heinemann
egana
egan
egankK
1978
what is curriculum
curriculum inquiry
72
6572
81 65
81
ellis R
5l
1996
freeman D & richards J
teacher learning in language teaching
cambridge cambridge university press
ed
31
jackson P
ed
macmillan
1992b
johnson K
A decision making framework for the coherent language
1989 a
23
pp 1123
curriculum in K johnson ed the second language curriculum ap
cambridge cambridge university press
johnson K ed
1989b
university press
kang S 1995
the effects of a context embedded approach to second language
43 55
vocabulary learning system 231 4355
1994
lessard clouston M
121
development TESL canada journal 721
69 80
6980
lessard clouston M
lewis M 1993 the lexical approach the state of ELT and a way forward hove
england language teaching publications
lewis M in press implementing the lexical approach hove england language
teaching publications
luo C
1990
mccarthy M
vocabulary
mccarthy M
1994
1992
111
vocabulary in a second language volume 1111986
III
1990 reading in
1986
19861990
ili 11119861990
837
761
a foreign language 91
91
761837
meara P
1995
8 10
teacher 192
792 810
TESL reporter
32
1986
1987
nation P
1990
nation P ed
1994
1995
cambridge
cambridge
729
richards
1990
press
lockhart C
richards J
&
1994
Sana oui R 1992 vocabulary learning and teaching in french as a second language
sanaoui
classrooms unpublished phd dissertation toronto university of toronto
OISE
Sana oui R 1995
sanaoui
adult learners approaches to learning vocabulary in second
15 28
languages modern language journal 791 1528
processes of vocabulary instruction in 10 french as a second
1996
Sana oui R
sanaoui
199
language classes canadian modem
modern language review 522 179
179199
1984 what really matters in second language learning for academic
199 219
TESOL quarterly 182 199219
saville troike M
achievement
Schmit
schmittn
schmitte
tNN
schmitt
schmitt N
eds
1995
eds
1993
ae
fhe bilingual lexicon
the
amsterdam john
1975
an introduction
to curriculum
33
stern
stem H 1992
press
oxford
taylor
taylorlL
1990
taylor L
1992
vocabulary in action
tyler R 1949
brace
oxford
hall
wellmang
Well
wellvang
weil
weli
G
manG
weilman
wellman
1992
Word
builder oxford heinemann
wordbuilder
1990
yalden J
1987
cambridge