Professional Documents
Culture Documents
32,APRIL30,1970
547
vs.
548
548
SUPREMECOURTREPORTSANNOTATED
Chaves vs. Gonzales
factualbasisuponwhichtomakeanawardtherefor.
DIRECTAPPEALfromadecisionoftheCourtofFirst
InstanceofManila.Vasquez,J.
ThefactsarestatedintheopinionoftheCourt.
Chaves, Elio, Chaves & Associates for plaintiff
appellant.
Sulpicio E. Platonfordefendantappellee.
REYES,J.B.L.,J.:
Thisisadirectappealbythepartywhoprevailedinasuit
forbreachoforalcontractandrecoveryofdamagesbutwas
unsatisfiedwiththedecisionrenderedbytheCourtofFirst
InstanceofManila,initsCivilCaseNo.65138,becauseit
awarded him only P31.10 out of his total claim of P690.00
for actual, temperate and moral damages and attorneys
fees.
The appealed judgment, which is brief, is hereunder
quotedinfull:
549
VOL.32,APRIL30,1970
549
personallybytheplaintiff.
TherepairdoneonthetypewriterbyFreixasBusinessMachines
with the total cost of P89.85 should not, however, be fully
chargeable against the defendant. The repair invoice, Exhibit C,
showsthatthemissingpartshadatotalvalueofonlyP31.10.
WHEREFORE, judgment is hereby rendered ordering the
defendant to pay the plaintiff the sum of P31.10, and the costs of
suit.
SOORDERED.
550
550
SUPREMECOURTREPORTSANNOTATED
Chaves vs. Gonzales
551
VOL.32,APRIL30,1970
551
552
SUPREMECOURTREPORTSANNOTATED
Chaves vs. Gonzales
andattorneysfeeswere,however,correctlyrejectedbythe
trial court, for these were not alleged in his complaint
(Record on Appeal, pages 15). Claims for damages and
attorneys fees must be pleaded, and the2 existence of the
actual basis thereof must be proved. The appealed
judgmentthusmadenofindingsontheseclaims,noronthe
fraud or malice charged to the appellee. As no findings of
fact were made on the claims for damages and attorneys
fees,thereisnofactualbasisuponwhichtomakeanaward
therefor.Appellantisboundbysuchjudgmentofthecourt,
a quo, by reason of his having resorted directly to the
SupremeCourtonquestionsoflaw.
IN VIEW OF THE FOREGOING REASONS, the
appealed judgment is hereby modified, by ordering the
defendantappellee to pay, as he is hereby ordered to pay,
the plaintiffappellant the sum of P89.85, with interest at
the legal rate from the filing of the complaint. Costs in all
instancesagainstappelleeFructuosoGonzales.
Concepcion, C.J., Dizon, Makalintal, Zaldivar,
Castro,Fernando, TeehankeeandVillamor, JJ.,concur,
Barredo, J.,didnottakepart.
Judgment modified.
Notes.(a) Liability for negligent performance of
obligation.Under Article 1170 of the Civil Code, those
who in the performance of their obligation are guilty of
fraud, negligence, or delay, and those who in any manner
contravene the tenor thereof, are liable for damages. And
under Article 1173, the fault or negligence of the obligor
consistsintheomissionofthatdiligencewhichisrequired
by the nature of the obligation and corresponds with the
circumstances of the persons, of the time and of the place
xxx.Ifthelaworcontractdoesnotstatethediligencewhich
istobeobservedintheperformance,thatwhichisexpected
ofagoodfatherofafamilyshallberequired.
_______________
2 Malonzo v. Galang, L13851. 27 July 1960: Darang v. Belizear, L
22399.31March1967,19SCRA214.
553
VOL.32,APRIL30,1970
553