Professional Documents
Culture Documents
point of view
perspective
repetition
synonym
6. In this article, the author combines facts about the expedition and rescue and
background information about the two men with comments from other interested
parties.
a) To start with, are these statements true or false?
The men ditched their helicopter in the sea at 1am (British time) on
Tuesday 28 January 2003.
True / false
True / false
b) Use the correct versions of the statements and use them to form the start and
end of your timeline. Add any other events and developments, bearing in mind
that you may not be able to specify the exact times.
7. Complete the table below to show whose views or comments the author has chosen
to include in this article.
www.teachit.co.uk 2013
14675
Page 1 of 7
Explorers or boys messing about? Either way, taxpayer gets rescue bill by Steven Morris
Who said it?
Direct quotation or
reported speech?
Showing men in
positive/negative
light?
Gunter Endres,
expert on
helicopters
www.teachit.co.uk 2013
14675
Page 2 of 7
Explorers or boys messing about? Either way, taxpayer gets rescue bill by Steven Morris
Direct quotation or
reported speech?
Showing men in
positive/negative
light?
Ministry of
Defence
spokesperson
www.teachit.co.uk 2013
14675
Page 3 of 7
Explorers or boys messing about? Either way, taxpayer gets rescue bill by Steven Morris
8. Either: What conclusion can you draw about the authors intentions and attitudes in
this article, based on his selective use of comments and quotations? Write three or
four paragraphs, remembering to support your conclusions with references to the
text.
Or: Looking at columns 2 and 3, can you complete this sentence to show how the
author influences the readers opinion of the two men?
Most of the comments or quotations included by the author give readers a
positive/negative (delete one word) impression of the two men, for example (add
an example or two).
Challenge: Can you add a sentence or two to explain how your example(s) creates
this impression?
9. The writer includes facts about the experience and qualifications of these two men.
He reports that Mr Brooks, for example, has been taking part in expeditions for 15
years.
Which statements apply to which man? Add any other details from the text that could
complete the table.
Steve Brooks or
Quentin Smith?
Flew a helicopter from Alaska to Chile
Hiked solo to Everest base camp
Is a qualified mechanical engineer
Kayaked on the Zambezi river
Has twice flown round the world in a helicopter
Walked barefoot for 3 days in the Himalaya mountains
Won the world freestyle helicopter flying competition
a) Look over the facts in the table. How does this information give readers a
positive impression of the two men?
b) Could you use these same facts to describe the men in a negative way? Explain
your answer.
Questions on structure
1. Look at the structure by dividing the article up into sections. To begin with, number
the paragraphs and draw a line after paragraph 3. What is the subject of these first
three paragraphs? Write it in the margin.
www.teachit.co.uk 2013
14675
Page 4 of 7
Explorers or boys messing about? Either way, taxpayer gets rescue bill by Steven Morris
2. What do paragraphs 4-7 deal with? Mark and label this section on your text.
3. Now read on through the paragraphs dealing with the events of the crash and rescue.
Once again, indicate on your text where this section ends and a new subject is
introduced. What do you notice about the way these paragraphs have been written?
Annotate your ideas in the margin.
4. Look at paragraphs 15-17. How does the subject matter change? Mark it on your
text.
5. How would you describe the content and the style of paragraphs 19, 20 and 21?
6. How would you sub-divide and label the last 4 paragraphs and why?
7. What parallels or connections can you find in the way this article has been
structured? (look closely at paragraphs 4, 5, 6, 7 and 22 and 24) What effect might
these paragraphs have on the reader?
8. As you know, introductions and conclusions are very important. With a partner, read
just the first and last paragraphs again. Discuss the effects of:
www.teachit.co.uk 2013
14675
Page 5 of 7
Explorers or boys messing about? Either way, taxpayer gets rescue bill by Steven Morris
Further teaching ideas
The article uses the standfirst Helicopter duo plucked from liferaft after Antarctic
crash. This refers to the news event that inspired this article. Ask students to
create the original news report by selecting relevant facts from the article,
omitting irrelevant or inappropriate content, adopting an appropriate style and
structuring the report properly. Activity 6 in the main resource is useful
preparation for this task.
To introduce the text, get students to analyse the first paragraph in isolation.
Prompt them with questions such as:
Is this what you would expect from an opening paragraph of an article in a
newspaper?
What expectations do you have of the rest of the article?
What is the effect of using their rather than identifying the subject of the
article?
What does farce mean and how does it steer the reader to an opinion of the
people referred to?
Tell the students the men referred to have been on another expedition then give
them the final paragraph from the article. Prompt discussion with questions such
as:
What
idea?
What
What
What
do you think happened on this recent expedition and what gives you this
links the two paragraphs?
adjectives would you use to describe the men why?
do you think is the authors opinion of them why?
Allocate sections of the article to pairs of students in such a way as the whole
article is covered. Students should decide on the key idea of their section and
choose from it a single word or a short phrase that could function as a sub-heading.
As there are 25 paragraphs, one option would be to work together on the first
couple, with the teacher modeling the first one then all students working on the
second; pairs on one each thereafter leaving a few at the end for early finishers or
allowing more able to work on their own. Alternatively, use the whizzy matching
activity for the first ten paragraphs and ask students to work out which description
fits each section of the text. Either of these suggestions could be combined with,
or done instead of, the Questions on structure section.
Use the whizzy activity before task 9, to look into the mens previous experiences.
Use the extension activities to explore the impact of this information further.
www.teachit.co.uk 2013
14675
Page 6 of 7
Explorers or boys messing about? Either way, taxpayer gets rescue bill by Steven Morris
This article was used in the May 2005 exam (Paper 2H) and some candidate answers
with examiners grades and comments are available in the Exemplar candidate
responses from the May 2005 examination session (Jan 2006), available at the time
of publishing at:
http://www.edexcel.com/migrationdocuments/Current%20IGCSE/261903_Eng_Lan
g_exemplar_booklet_final_draft.pdf . Students could try to rank the answers,
grade them, and correctly match them to the examiners comments. What targets
would they set to improve? Can they redraft sections to improve the answers?
Are they explorers or just boys messing about? A few ideas for speaking and
listening:
Create a line of agreement with the two interpretations at opposite ends of
the line. Ask students to stand on the line at a point which reflects their
opinion, then invite individuals to justify their position. As students put forward
supporting arguments, other students may shift their positions (literally) and in
turn be invited to persuade others to do the same.
Have pupils collect evidence for both sides of the argument and stage a debate
in pairs.
Hot-seat the two men (students in role) with teacher or another student taking
on the role of interrogator using questions prepared by other students.
www.teachit.co.uk 2013
14675
Page 7 of 7