You are on page 1of 38

Workshop I

Inspection and Condition Assessment of Railway Bridges


23.10.2006 24.10.2006, Berlin

RAILWAY BRIDGE DAMAGES


AND DETERIORATION PROCESSES

Jan Bie, Krzysztof Jakubowski, Tomasz Kamiski, Maciej Maksymowicz, Pawe Rawa, Jarosaw Zwolski

Wroclaw University of technology

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

CONTENTS:

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.

CONCEPTION OF HIERARCHICAL CLASSIFICATION


MAIN TYPES OF RAILWAY BRIDGE DAMAGES
CLASSIFICATION OF CONCRETE BRIDGE DAMAGES
CLASSIFICATION OF STEEL BRIDGE DAMAGES
CLASSIFICATION OF MASONRY BRIDGE DAMAGES
DETERIORATION MECHANISMS

Wroclaw University of technology

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

1. CONCEPTION OF HIERARCHICAL CLASSIFICATION OF RAILWAY


BRIDGE DAMAGES

Wroclaw University of technology

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

2.
MAIN TYPES
OF RAILWAY BRIDGE DAMAGES

Wroclaw University of technology

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

DEFINITIONS OF MAIN TYPES OF RAILWAY BRIDGE DAMAGES (1)

Contamination
appearance of any type of a dirtiness
or not designed plant vegetation

Deformation
geometry changes incompatible with
the design, with changes of mutual
distances of structure element points

Wroclaw University of technology

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

DEFINITIONS OF MAIN TYPES OF RAILWAY BRIDGE DAMAGES (2)

Destruction
deterioration of physical and/or
chemical structural features in
comparison with designed values

Discontinuity
not designed break in continuity of
a structure material

Wroclaw University of technology

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

DEFINITIONS OF MAIN TYPES OF RAILWAY BRIDGE DAMAGES (3)

Displacement
not designed displacement of a structure
without changes of distances of structure
element points (without deformation),
also restriction in designed displacement
capabilities

Loss of material
decrease of designed amount of
structure material

Wroclaw University of technology

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

3.
CLASSIFICATION OF
CONCRETE BRIDGE DAMAGES

Wroclaw University of technology

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

CLASSIFICATION OF CONCRETE BRIDGE DAMAGES


LEVEL I

LEVEL II

LEVEL III

LEVEL IV
Aggressive

Inorganic
Neutral
Concrete
Penetrating
Organic
Superficial
Contamination
Aggressive
Inorganic
Neutral
Protection
Penetrating
Organic
Superficial

Concrete

Deflection

Protection

Deflection

Deformation

Wroclaw University of technology

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

CONTAMINATION
CONCRETE
ORGANIC
PENETRATING

Wroclaw University of technology

SUPERFICIAL

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

10

DEFORMATION
CONCRETE
DEFLECTION

Wroclaw University of technology

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

11

CLASSIFICATION OF CONCRETE BRIDGE DAMAGES


LEVEL I

LEVEL II

LEVEL III

LEVEL IV
Calcium hydoxide reduction

Modification of
chemical features

pH factor reduction
Salt concentration increase
Absorbability increase
Elastic modulus change

Concrete

Embrittlement increase
Modification of
physical features

Frost-resistance reduction
Permeability increase
Porosity increase
Strength reduction
Calcium hydoxide reduction

Destruction

Modification of
chemical features

pH factor reduction
Salt concentration increase
Adhesion reduction

Protection

Embrittlement increase
Modification of
physical features

Fading
Frost-resistance reduction
Permeability increase
Porosity increase
Bond reduction

Reinforcement and
prestressing system

Wroclaw University of technology

Modification of
physical features

Strength reduction

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

12

CLASSIFICATION OF CONCRETE BRIDGE DAMAGES


LEVEL I

LEVEL II

LEVEL III

LEVEL IV
Irregular

Crack
Concrete

Longitudinal
Skew
Transverse

Delamination
Fracture

Discontinuity

Crack
Protection

Delamination
Fracture

Reinforcement and
prestressing system

Crack
Fracture
Rotation

Excessive
Translation
Displacement
Rotation
Limited
Translation
Concrete
Loss of
material

Protection
Reinforcement and
prestressing system

Wroclaw University of technology

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

13

LOSS OF MATERIAL
CONCRETE

Wroclaw University of technology

PROTECTION

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

14

4.
CLASSIFICATION OF
STEEL BRIDGE DAMAGES

Wroclaw University of technology

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

15

CLASSIFICATION OF STEEL BRIDGE DAMAGES


LEVEL I

LEVEL II

LEVEL III

LEVEL IV
Aggressive

Inorganic
Neutral
Contamination

Steel construction
Penetrating
Organic
Superficial
Deflection

Deformation

Basic component

Distortion
Torsion
Hardness reduction

Basic component

Modification of
physical features

Impact resistance reduction


Strength reduction

Bolted/riveted
connector

Modification of
physical features

Destruction

Loosening
Strength reduction
Adhesion reduction

Protection

Modification of
physical features

Embrittlement increasing
Fading
Thickness reduction

Welded connector

Wroclaw University of technology

Modification of
physical features

Strength reduction

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

16

CONTAMINATION
STEEL CONSTRUCTION
INORGANIC
AGGRESSIVE

Wroclaw University of technology

NEUTRAL

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

17

DEFORMATION
BASIC COMPONENT
DEFLECTION

Wroclaw University of technology

DEFLECTION

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

DISTORTION

18

DESTRUCTION
BASIC COMPONENT
MODIFICATION OF
PHYSICAL FEATURES

BOLTED/RIVETED CONNECTOR
MODIFICATION OF
PHYSICAL FEATURES

STRENGTH REDUCTION

Wroclaw University of technology

LOOSENING

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

19

CLASSIFICATION OF CONCRETE BRIDGE DAMAGES


LEVEL I

LEVEL II

LEVEL III

LEVEL IV
Irregular
Longitudinal

Crack
Skew
Basic component
Transverse
Delamination
Fracture
Discontinuity

Bolted/riveted
connector

Crack
Fracture
Crack

Protection

Delamination

CLASSIFICATION OF CONCRETE BRIDGE DAMAGES


Fracture
LEVEL I

LEVEL II

LEVEL III

LEVEL IV

Crack
Welded connector

Basic component
Fracture
Rotation

Excessive
Translation
Displacement

Loss of
material

Bolted/ riveted
connector
Protection

Rotation
Limited

Welded connector
Translation

Wroclaw University of technology

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

20

5.
CLASSIFICATION OF
MASONRY BRIDGE DAMAGES

Wroclaw University of technology

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

21

CLASSIFICATION OF MASONRY BRIDGE DAMAGES


LEVEL I

LEVEL II

LEVEL III

LEVEL IV
Aggressive

Inorganic
Neutral
Backfill
Penetrating
Organic
Superficial
Aggressive
Inorganic
Neutral
Contamination

Masonry
Penetrating
Organic
Superficial
Aggressive
Inorganic
Neutral
Protection
Penetrating
Organic
Superficial
Backfill

Deflection
Deflection

Deformation

Masonry

Slip
Swell

Protection

Wroclaw University of technology

Deflection

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

22

CONTAMINATION
MASONRY
ORGANIC
PENETRATING

Wroclaw University of technology

SUPERFICIAL

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

23

CLASSIFICATION OF CONCRETE BRIDGE DAMAGES


LEVEL I

LEVEL II

LEVEL III

Backfill

Modification of
physical features

LEVEL IV

Calcium hydroxide reduction


Modification of
chemical features

pH factor reduction
Salt concentration increase
Absorbability increase
Elastic modulus change

Brick/stone

Embrittlement increase

Destruction
Modification of
physical features

Frost-resistance reduction
Permeability increase
Porosity increase
Strength reduction
Calcium hydroxide reduction

Joint

Modification of
chemical features

pH factor reduction
Salt concentration increase

Wroclaw University of technology

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

24

CLASSIFICATION OF CONCRETE BRIDGE DAMAGES


LEVEL I

LEVEL II

LEVEL III

LEVEL IV
Absorbability increase
Elastic modulus change
Embrittlement increase

Destruction

Joint

Modification of
physical features

Frost-resistance reduction
Permeability increase
Porosity increase
Strength reduction
Calcium hydroxide reduction

Modification of
chemical features

pH factor reduction
Salt concentration increase
Absorbability increase
Adhesion reduction

Protection

Embrittlement increase
Modification of
physical features

Fading
Frost-resistance reduction
Permeability increase
Porosity increase

Wroclaw University of technology

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

25

DESTRUCTION
PROTECTION

JOINT
MODIFICATION OF
PHYSICAL FEATURES

Wroclaw University of technology

MODIFICATION OF
CHEMICAL FEATURES

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

26

CLASSIFICATION OF CONCRETE BRIDGE DAMAGES


LEVEL I

LEVEL II

LEVEL III

LEVEL IV
Irregular
Longitudinal

Crack
Skew
Transverse
Masonry

Delamination
Irregular

Discontinuity
Longitudinal
Fracture
Skew
Transverse
Crack
Protection

Delamination
Fracture
Rotation

Displacement

Excessive
Translation
Backfill

Loss of
material

Brick/stone
Joint
Protection

Wroclaw University of technology

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

27

LOSS OF MATERIAL
BACK FILL

Wroclaw University of technology

BRICK/STONE

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

28

6.
DETERIORATION MECHANISMS

Wroclaw University of technology

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

29

BASIC DEGRADATION MECHANISMS IDENTIFIED IN RAILWAY BRIDGES

Wroclaw University of technology

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

30

MAIN DEGRADATION MECHANISMS AND STRUCTURAL MATERIALS


Structural material

Degradation mechanism
concrete

steel

masonry

Physical
Creeping
Effect of high temperatures
Fatigue
Freeze-thaw action
Modification of foundation conditions
Overloading
Shrinkage
Water penetration
Chemical
Alkali-aggregate reactions
Carbonation
Corrosion
Crystallization
Leaching
Oil and fat influence
Salt and acid actions
Biological
Accumulation of contamination
Living organisms activities

Wroclaw University of technology

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

31

DEGRADATION MECHANISMS IN RELATION TO DAMAGES OF CONCRETE RAILWAY BRIDGES

Wroclaw University of technology

loss of
material

  


 

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

   



    

discontinuity

displacement

 

  
      
 

      

destruction

deformation



  

 





Physical
Creeping
Fatigue
Influence of high temperature
Freeze-thaw actions
Modification of foundation conditions
Overloading
Shrinkage
Water penetration
Chemical
Alkali-aggregate reactions
Carbonation
Corrosion
Crystallization
Leaching
Oil and fat influence
Salt and acid actions
Biological
Accumulation of contamination
Living organisms activities

 

Degradation mechanism

contamination

Damage type

32

Wroclaw University of technology

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

33

DEGRADATION MECHANISMS IN RELATION TO DAMAGES OF


STEEL RAILWAY BRIDGES
discontinuity

displacement

   

 

loss of material

destruction

 

deformation

Degradation mechanism

contamination

Damage type

Fatigue

 

Modification of foundation conditions


Overloading

Effect of high temperature

Physical

Corrosion

Chemical

Wroclaw University of technology

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

 

 

Living organisms activities

Accumulation of contamination

 

Biological

34

Wroclaw University of technology

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

35

DEGRADATION MECHANISMS IN RELATION TO DAMAGES OF


MASONRY RAILWAY BRIDGES

Wroclaw University of technology

loss of
material

  

  

 

 

displacement

discontinuity

     



   
 

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

 

destruction

  

deformation

    




  

contamination


   

Physical
Effect of high temperature
Fatigue
Freeze-thaw actions
Modification of foundation conditions
Overloading
Shrinkage
Water penetration
Chemical
Carbonation
Crystallization
Leaching
Salt and acid actions
Biological
Accumulation of contamination
Living organisms activities

 

Degradation mechanism

Damage type

36

Wroclaw University of technology

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

37

THE END
Wroclaw University of technology

Workshop I Oct. 23rd-24th, 2006

38

You might also like