The book is particularly strong on the statesocialist period in and the manner in which the Ne Win regime moved to control and suppress dissent. The lack of detailed attention to this important theme is compensated for in the where identifies the junta's expertise in crisis and short-term as key to the longevity of military rule in.
The book is particularly strong on the statesocialist period in and the manner in which the Ne Win regime moved to control and suppress dissent. The lack of detailed attention to this important theme is compensated for in the where identifies the junta's expertise in crisis and short-term as key to the longevity of military rule in.
The book is particularly strong on the statesocialist period in and the manner in which the Ne Win regime moved to control and suppress dissent. The lack of detailed attention to this important theme is compensated for in the where identifies the junta's expertise in crisis and short-term as key to the longevity of military rule in.
the final years of British colonial rule, and the SYED MUHD KHAIRUDIN ALJUNIED disappointing experience or ‘self‐rule’ under Colonialism, violence and Muslims in Southeast Japanese occupation during World War II, Asia: the Maria Hertogh controversy and its merit consideration as a single ‘era of Aung aftermath San’ (p. 2), during which Burma's modern London: Routledge, 2009 nationalist politics took form. 208 pp. ISBN 978‐0‐415‐48594‐4, hb £75
The book is particularly strong on the state‐ socialist period in Burma (1962‐88), and the Reviewed by A.J. Stockwell manner in which the Ne Win regime moved Royal Holloway, University of London to control Burmese society, and suppress dissent. Charney focuses on the relatively At about noon on 11 December 1950 rioting ‘ideology‐rich’ nature of the Burma Socialist broke out in the vicinity of Singapore’s Program Party’s rule, usefully comp‐ Supreme Court and spread to the area of the lementing the account provided by Robert Sultan Mosque. The violence lasted 48 hours Taylor (op cit). and during it 18 people were killed (nine by rioters and nine by the police or military), For this reviewer, a more sustained emphasis 173 were injured and much property was on ‘the ethnic question’ would have been damaged or destroyed including well over welcome. However, the lack of detailed 100 vehicles. attention to this important theme is compensated for in the conclusion, where The innocent victim at the centre of the Charney identifies ‘lowland‐highland, and uproar was Maria Hertogh, the thirteen‐year thus Burman‐minority, bifurcations of the old daughter of Roman Catholic parents, a country [as] … an important determining Eurasian mother and a Dutch father who factor in the trajectory of Burmese history in before the Japanese occupation had served in the twenty‐first century’ (p.202). He also the army of the Netherlands East Indies. correctly identifies the junta’s expertise in When the Japanese invaded Java her parents crisis management, and short‐term were interned but Maria escaped, having strategising, as key to the longevity of been entrusted by her mother to Che Aminah military rule in Burma (pp. 204‐6). binte Mohamed. The nature of this arrangement was disputed after the war, A deeper and more specialised history of with Che Aminah claiming, and the Hertoghs Burma would need to reference Burmese and denying, that Maria had been handed over for minority language sources, which Charney permanent adoption. In 1950, having rarely cites in his footnotes or bibliography. discovered that his daughter had been taken Such omissions perhaps explain the ‘outsider by Che Aminah to Trengganu, Adrianus account’ nature of the narrative. However, it Hertogh requested the Dutch Consulate‐ is easy enough to find emotionally engaged General in Singapore to initiate court tracts on Burmese politics. Charney has proceedings for her repatriation to the achieved the much rarer and highly valuable Netherlands. By this time, however, Maria goal of producing a systematic and reliable had been brought up as a Muslim; she had historical overview. changed her name to Nadra binte Ma’arof and 32 Aseasuk News no. 46 Autumn 2009
was betrothed to Mansoor Adaabi. The tussle than that in any other tumultuous
over her custody swung one way and the disturbance in Singapore between 1945 and other. The colonial high court first ruled in 1963. Furthermore, these riots were no mere favour of her natural parents, later restored rocket that quickly burned out but rather a Maria to her adoptive mother but rescinded warning shot that altered the course of that order on her marriage to Mansoor. She colonial rule in Singapore, as Syed Muhd was then escorted by police to a Roman Khairudin Aljunied (Assistant Professor in Catholic convent where she remained until the Department of Malay Studies at the 12 December when she was put in a plane for National University of Singapore) com‐ Holland while Singapore burned. Maria did pellingly demonstrates in this revised version not return to Southeast Asia until 1999 when of his recent SOAS PhD thesis. she visited Malaysia in connection with the filming of a Dutch documentary about the Deftly situating this episode in the socio‐ controversy. Maria Hertogh was for ever political circumstances of post‐war Singapore marked by her disturbed childhood. and drawing on an impressive range of Marriage to a Dutch soldier brought her unpublished sources in the United Kingdom, many children but also much unhappiness. Singapore, Malaysia, Holland, Australia and Acquitted of plotting the murder of her the United States, Syed Muhd Khairudin husband, she obtained a divorce and left her Aljunied sheds fresh light on the causes, children for the United States. By this time course and consequences of the riots. He she was reported to have lost whatever shows how radicals within Singapore’s religious faith she may once have had. marginalised Muslim community were driven Eventually she returned to Holland where to protest and how protest turned to riot as a she died in July 2009. result of colonial negligence, particularly in the areas of intelligence and policing. The The Hertogh riots stand apart from other largest and most original part of the book is violent incidents in post‐war Malaya and devoted to the aftermath of the riots which Singapore. The protests that boiled over into had taken the colonial regime by surprise and violence in December 1950 came from had called into question its legitimacy. Singapore’s Muslims, not exclusively Malays, Chapter by chapter, the author examines the and were directed against Europeans and strategy whereby the British strove to restore Eurasians, not against the Chinese. their authority. It had five features: (1) Moreover, they were not driven by the instilling fear through arrests, raids, curfews communist insurgency then raging on the and the use and abuse of the law; (2) peninsula. Nor did they sit easily within the surveillance by special branch and other context of the island’s secular, left‐wing agencies; (3) self‐criticism through, for radicalism which was associated more with example, the commission of enquiry which labour and, subsequently, student unrest. identified scapegoats while shielding the Perhaps it was because they appeared higher echelons of the regime; (4) atypical of the threats to the colonial state reconciliation in order ‘to balance and rule, during the Cold War, that the story of Maria more than to divide and rule’ p.88); and (5) has frequently overshadowed analysis of the reform of policing, marriage policies, child riots. In fact, however, the death toll during adoption and education. Although the British the Hertogh affair is estimated to be higher by no means had it all their own way in any of Aseasuk News no. 46 Autumn 2009 33
these endeavours, by the end of 1952 they The historical section of the book begins with
‘had turned the aftermath of the riots to their Tony Stockwell’s discussion of the British advantage’ (p.126) This detailed and subtly late‐colonial legacy. From wartime planning argued case study is a valuable contribution for reoccupation in 1942 to the achievement to our understanding of the late colonial of Malaysia (with Singapore included) in regime in Singapore and to the literature on 1963, Stockwell shows that the British were riots in Southeast Asia. ‘equivocal and circumspect’ (p. 12) in their approaches to merger. The exclusion of Singapore from the Malayan Union of 1946, and the Federation of Malaya which TAKASHI SHIRAISHI (ed.) succeeded it in 1948, only served to push the Across the causeway: a multi‐dimensional study two territories further apart, especially as of Malaysia‐Singapore relations Singapore: Malay political dominance on the mainland ISEAS, 2009. and Chinese political dominance on the island 276 pp. ISBN: 978‐981‐230‐783‐5, pb US$29.90 were increasingly confirmed during the 1950s. Ooi Keat Gin takes up the historical legacies further, arguing that the economic Reviewed by Nicholas White symbiosis between Malaysia and Singapore – Liverpool John Moores University epitomised by tin mining and smelting from the mid 19th century – was overshadowed by In 2001, Singapore’s former Prime Minister, political divides. He concludes that ‘owing to Goh Chok Tong, commended Malaysia’s then the different approaches of the political Deputy Prime Minister, Abdullah Badawi, for leadership in Singapore and Malaysia the latter’s analogy of Singapore and Malaysia towards the handling of the contentious as ‘two neighbours living in semi‐detached issues of communal relations and egalitarian houses, separated by a common wall. What versus positive discrimination, it appears that happens to one house will affect the other any attempt at a re‐merger must first resolve house’. Yet, as recent disputes between these differences, if not, the tensions of 1963‐ Malaysia and Singapore over water supply, 5 shall again re‐emerge’ (p. 48). Lee Kuan Yew’s memoirs, maritime boundaries, customs facilities, land Indeed, the origins of the Malaysia‐Singapore ownership and reclamation, and pension split of 1965 are examined in more detail by rights demonstrate, these neighbours living Mohamad Abu Bakar in his chapter focusing in close proximity can often have strained on the 1961‐63 period. For him, the point of relations. This interdisciplinary study of no return came in August 1962 when, after Malaysia‐Singapore interactions – encom‐ winning the referendum campaign for passing history, politics, security, law and merger, Lee Kuan Yew began inferring that economics – is most welcome therefore. the People’s Action Party (PAP) would spread There is much repetition between chapters its electoral web to the mainland, threatening and proof reading leaves a little to be desired, the existence of the Malayan Chinese but the volume represents the most Association and the delicate conservative comprehensive study of Malaysia‐Singapore communal balance of Federation politics relations to date, and will prove a vital work tipped in favour of the Malay electorate. In of reference for any future studies. other words, it was Lee’s ambitions for power