Professional Documents
Culture Documents
OBJECTIVE: Preexisting spinal arteriovenous malformation nomenclature can be confusing. The aim of this article is to present a modified classification system for spinal
arteriovenous lesions and to discuss its implications for microsurgical strategies.
METHODS: Based on the literature review of prior classifications as well as on the
experience of the senior author (RFS), the authors delineate an anatomically and
pathophysiologically based classification to facilitate the description and treatment of
these uncommon entities.
RESULTS: Spinal arteriovenous lesions are composed of arteriovenous fistulae and
malformations. These lesions are classified as extradural, extradural-intradural, or
intradural. Intradural lesions are characterized further as ventral or dorsal fistulae or as
intramedullary lesions. Intramedullary lesions are characterized as compact or diffuse.
A new category, conus medullaris arteriovenous malformations, is described as a
distinct entity.
CONCLUSION: This updated classification system eliminates confusion related to
older nomenclature and is based on the anatomical and pathophysiological features of
these lesions. When treating these lesions, the neurovascular team must collaborate
closely with their microsurgical and endovascular colleagues. Finally, treatment
should be individualized, depending on lesional angioarchitecture and the patients
clinical status.
KEY WORDS: Classification, Nomenclature, Spinal arteriovenous fistula, Spinal arteriovenous malformation,
Surgical management
Neurosurgery 59:S3-195-S3-201, 2006
NEUROSURGERY
DOI: 10.1227/01.NEU.0000237335.82234.CE
www.neurosurgery-online.com
CLASSIFICATION OF ARTERIOVENOUS
FISTULAE AND AVMS
Spetzler et al. (44) proposed a modified classification system
for spinal arteriovenous lesions based on specific anatomical
and pathophysiological factors. Descriptions are based on extradural or intradural, ventral, dorsal, or intramedullary locations of the lesions and on the presence of single or multiple
feeding branches.
KIM
AND
SPETZLER
FIGURE 2. A, axial illustration of an intradural dorsal AVF demonstrating an abnormal radicular feeding artery along the nerve root on the
right. The glomerular network of tiny branches coalesces at the site of the
fistula along the dural root sleeve. B, illustration of the posterior view
demonstrating the dilatation of the coronal venous plexus. In addition to
venous outflow obstruction (not shown), arterialization of these veins produces venous hypertension. Focal disruption of the point of the fistula by
endovascular or microsurgical methods will obliterate the lesion (courtesy
of Barrow Neurological Institute, Phoenix, Arizona).
www.neurosurgery-online.com
Intramedullary AVMs
Intramedullary AVMs are analogous to intracranial AVMs,
located entirely in the spinal cord parenchyma. These lesions
may have single or multiple feeding arteries from branches of
the ASA and posterior spinal artery. They are classified further as compact or diffuse (Figs. 5 and 6), depending on the
angioarchitecture of the nidus.
DISCUSSION
Extradural-Intradural AVM
Extradural-intradural AVMs (Fig. 4) correspond with juvenile or metameric AVMs. These formidable lesions are in-
NEUROSURGERY
KIM
AND
SPETZLER
FIGURE 5. A, axial illustration demonstrating a compact intramedullary AVM. In this figure, an arterial feeder from the anterior spinal artery
is identified. Note the discrete, compact mass of the AVM. B, posterior
view demonstrating additional feeding branches from the posterior spinal
artery and reemphasizing the compact nature of this type of spinal AVM.
Portions of the AVM are evident along the surface of the spinal cord. Surgical resection is the mainstay of treatment. Preoperative embolization is
reserved for select cases only (courtesy of Barrow Neurological Institute,
Phoenix, Arizona).
www.neurosurgery-online.com
NEUROSURGERY
grading system (11, 13, 22, 29, 37). Type 1 lesions are dural
AVFs in which a dural branch from a radicular artery forms an
abnormal communication with the dural veins at the nerve
root sleeve. Arterialization of the perimedullary coronal venous plexus results. Type 2 refers to glomus or intramedullary
lesions. Type 3 lesions are juvenile or metameric AVMs associated with both extradural and intradural extension of the
spinal AVM. Type 4 spinal AVMs, as first described by Djindjian et al. (12) and categorized as Type 4 by Heros et al. (22),
refer to perimedullary fistulae. These ventrally located fistula
primarily receive arterial contributions from the ASA.
Borden et al. (8) described a three-point classification for
both intracranial and spinal dural AVFs using the term dural
arteriovenous fistulous malformation. Type 1 referred to extradural AVFs or epidural types, with direct drainage of the
feeding artery into Batsons venous plexus. Type 2 referred to
dural artery feeders draining into both epidural and intradural venous systems. Type 3 referred to what is known as
intradural dorsal AVFs, or Type 1 AVMs, according to the
description of Di Chiro et al. (11).
More recent spinal vascular lesion classifications are based
on descriptive anatomic considerations. Niimi and Berenstein
(35) divided vascular lesions of the spine into spinal vascular
lesions and spinal cord vascular lesions. They subdivided
spinal vascular lesions into spinal dural fistulae and extradural fistulae. Spinal cord vascular lesions are referred to as
spinal cord vascular malformations, of which there are two types:
isolated, which includes AVMs and AVFs, and multiple,
which includes metameric and nonmetameric forms.
Bao and Ling (6) classified spinal cord vascular lesions as
intramedullary AVMs, intradural AVFs, dural AVFs, paravertebral AVMs, and Cobbs syndrome. Intramedullary lesions
include glomus and juvenile forms. Intradural AVFs are subdivided into Types 1 to 3, as the size of the lesion and degree
of AVF flow increase.
Rosenblum et al. (42) differentiated spinal AVFs from
AVMs based on their experience with 81 treated patients.
Intradural AVMs were divided into intramedullary and direct
AVFs. Intramedullary lesions included glomus and juvenile
AVMs. Direct AVFs occupied either an intramedullary or
extramedullary location. Intramedullary lesions were supplied by medullary arteries, and the arteriovenous shunt was
located partially in the spinal cord or pia mater. Dural AVFs
were supplied by a radicular branch along the dural nerve
root sleeve, which drained via an AVF into the coronal venous
plexus.
Our classification system represents an evolution that incorporates our enhanced understanding of these entities in recent
decades (7, 27). This classification system offers several advantages. First, it includes all spinal AVFs and AVMs, including
the recently proposed conus medullaris category (41, 44). Second, the system is based on the anatomic location of each
lesion with its corresponding pathophysiological mechanism.
Finally, it eliminates potential confusion inherent in the older
nomenclature.
KIM
AND
SPETZLER
Treatment Strategies
Three pathophysiologic mechanisms underlying spinal
AVMs can cause neurological injury: hemorrhage, mass effect,
or vascular steal. Venous hypertension tends to be associated
with either intradural spinal AVFs or conus medullaris-type
spinal AVMs. Clinical manifestations can include pain, acute
or progressive myelopathy, and radiculopathy. Magnetic resonance imaging and a thorough catheter-based angiogram
provide the most important diagnostic information.
In contemporary neurosurgical settings, these lesions
should be approached in a team-oriented fashion. Optimal
patient care depends on direct collaboration between open
vascular and endovascular neurosurgeons. The role of each
half of this neurovascular team depends on the lesion, and
treatment must be individualized to the specifics of each situation. The following surgical strategies and technical consideration serve only as a guide.
At our institution, monitoring somatosensory and motor
evoked potentials has become a routine part of spinal AVM
surgery. Intraoperative angiography should be used in selected cases when residual AVM may remain. When intraoperative angiography is unwarranted or indeterminate, immediate postoperative, as well as long-term, follow-up catheterbased angiography is the mainstay of our treatment paradigm.
Surgical Management
Extradural AVFs are treated primarily by endovascular
techniques (3, 18, 21, 32, 35, 43). In our experience, the purely
extradural fistula is an extremely uncommon lesion. The role
of surgery in treating these lesions is limited to patients requiring reduction of local compression.
In 1977, Kendall and Logue (24) accurately redefined the
pathophysiology of intradural dorsal AVFs. They recognized
that the fistulous point occurred at the level of the dural root
sleeve rather than along the dilated coronal venous plexus,
which can be striking in such patients. Earlier, it was common to
perform vein stripping procedures with no benefit or even worsening of symptoms (26) and with no effect on obliteration of the
fistula itself. It is worth reiterating that successful surgical management of these lesions requires a careful and thorough
catheter-based spinal angiogram to identify the arterial feeder(s)
and artery of Adamkiewicz. Although angiographic visualization is paramount, angiographically occult lesions in patients
under high clinical suspicion for intradural dorsal fistulae have
been associated with successful surgical exploration and fistula
disruption (36). These rare instances stress the importance of
recognizing the clinical manifestations of these fistulae.
As soon as the appropriate spinal level has been identified, the
surgical strategy involves its posterior exposure. We favor a
posterior approach and laminoplasty. High-powered magnification and illumination with the operating microscope are used to
perform intradural dissection along the appropriate nerve root.
Typically, an arterialized vein is identified along the nerve root
and can be dissected sharply to its exit point at the margin of the
dural root sleeve. Nonstick bipolar cauterization and microscis-
CONCLUSION
Our ability to identify and treat spinal AVMs has advanced
tremendously in the past several decades. This article describes a modified classification system of spinal arterio-
www.neurosurgery-online.com
venous lesions based on this current anatomic and pathophysiological understanding. Further advances in the treatment of
spinal AVMs mandate an integrated approach with microvascular and endovascular neurosurgeons.
REFERENCES
1. Anson JA, Spetzler RF: Classification of spinal arteriovenous malformations
and implications for treatment. BNIQ 8:28, 1992.
2. Anson JA, Spetzler RF: Spinal dural arteriovenous malformations, in Awad
IA, Barrow DL (eds): Dural Arteriovenous Malformations. Park Ridge, American Association of Neurological Surgeons, 1993, pp 175191.
3. Arnaud O, Bille F, Pouget J, Serratrice G, Salamon G: Epidural arteriovenous
fistula with perimedullary venous drainage: Case report. Neuroradiology
36:490491, 1994.
4. Ausman JI, Gold LH, Tadavarthy SM, Amplatz K, Chou SN: Intraparenchymal
embolization for obliteration of an intramedullary AVM of the spinal cord.
Technical note. J Neurosurg 47:119125, 1977.
5. Baker HL Jr, Love JG, Layton DD Jr: Angiographic and surgical aspects of
spinal cord vascular anomalies. Radiology 88:10781085, 1967.
6. Bao YH, Ling F: Classification and therapeutic modalities of spinal vascular
malformations in 80 patients. Neurosurgery 40:7581, 1997.
7. Barrow DL: Spinal cord vascular lesions. J Neurosurg 96:143144, 2002.
8. Borden JA, Wu JK, Shucart WA: A proposed classification for spinal and
cranial dural arteriovenous fistulous malformations and implications for
treatment. J Neurosurg 82:166179, 1995.
9. Connolly ES Jr, Zubay GP, McCormick PC, Stein BM: The posterior approach to a series of glomus (Type II) intramedullary spinal cord arteriovenous malformations. Neurosurgery 42:774785, 1998.
10. Di Chiro G, Doppman J, Ommaya AK: Selective arteriography of arteriovenous aneurysms of spinal cord. Radiology 88:10651077, 1967.
11. Di Chiro G, Doppman JL, Ommaya AK: Radiology of the spinal cord
arteriovenous malformations. Prog Neurol Surg 4:329354, 1971.
12. Djindjian M, Djindjian R, Rey A, Hurth M, Houdart R: Intradural extramedullary spinal arterio-venous malformations fed by the anterior spinal artery.
Surg Neurol 8:8593, 1977.
13. Doppman J, Di Chiro G, Ommaya A: Selective Arteriography of the Spinal Cord.
St. Louis, Warren H. Green, 1969.
14. Elsberg C: Treatment of Surgical Diseases of Spinal Cord and Its Membranes.
Philadelphia, Saunders, 1916.
15. Foix C, Alajouanine T: La myelite ne`crotique subaique: Myelite centrale
angeiohypertrophique a evolution progressive: Paraplegie amyotrophique
lentement ascendante, dabord spasmodique, puis flasque, saccompagnant
de dissociation, albumino-cytologique. Rev Neurol 2:142, 1926.
16. Gaupp J: Hamorrhoiden der pia mater spinalis im gebiet des lendenmarks.
Beitr Pathol 2:516, 1888.
17. Glasser R, Masson R, Mickle JP, Peters KR: Embolization of a dural arteriovenous fistula of the ventral cervical spinal canal in a nine-year-old boy.
Neurosurgery 33:10891093, 1993.
18. Graziani N, Bouillot P, Figarella-Branger D, Dufour H, Peragut JC, Grisoli F:
Cavernous angiomas and arteriovenous malformations of the spinal epidural space: Report of 11 cases. Neurosurgery 35:856863, 1994.
19. Gueguen B, Merland JJ, Riche MC, Rey A: Vascular malformations of the
spinal cord: Intrathecal perimedullary arteriovenous fistulas fed by medullary arteries. Neurology 37:969979, 1987.
20. Halbach VV, Higashida RT, Dowd CF, Fraser KW, Edwards MS, Barnwell
SL: Treatment of giant intradural (perimedullary) arteriovenous fistulas.
Neurosurgery 33:972979, 1993.
21. Heier LA, Lee BC: A dural spinal arteriovenous malformation with epidural
venous drainage: A case report. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol 8:561563, 1987.
22. Heros RC, Debrun GM, Ojemann RG, Lasjaunias PL, Naessens PJ: Direct
spinal arteriovenous fistula: A new type of spinal AVM. Case report.
J Neurosurg 64:134139, 1986.
23. Hida K, Iwasaki Y, Ushikoshi S, Fujimoto S, Seki T, Miyasaka K:
Corpectomy: A direct approach to perimedullary arteriovenous fistulas of
the anterior cervical spinal cord. J Neurosurg 96:157161, 2002.
NEUROSURGERY