You are on page 1of 18

1/7/2016

Course Layout
MA4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles
Dr. Rajkumar S. Pant
Visiting Professor

Lectures:
26 hours
Lab/project:
39 hours
Pre-requisites:
MA3701 Aerodynamics
MA3703 Flight Dynamics

Dr. Lou Kok Yong


Adj. Asst. Prof.

COURSE DESCRIPTION

MAE @NTU

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Course Objectives & Outcomes

Breakdown of Lectures

Objectives

This course aims to provide the students with the knowledge on


design aspects of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAV) in terms of
consideration of UAV subsystems, such as Aerodynamics,
Payloads, Sensors, Flight control systems, and Propulsion. The
whole UAV system integration issues will also be covered

1.
2.
3.

4.

Outcomes
Understand the components building up to a UAV system
Understand functionalities of various UAV subsystems
Appreciate UAV design considerations based on mission
requirements
Appreciate integration challenges of various UAV subsystems

Dr. Rajkumar Pant


11th Jan to 22nd Feb
TITLE

Capsule-1

Dr. Lou Kok Yong


7th Mar to 18th Apr
HRS

TITLE

HRS

Introduction

Flight Modeling & Simulations

Overview of UAV Systems

Flight Control Systems.

Aerodynamics Considerations

Payload and Sensors

Propulsion

Other UAV Types

Performance

TOTAL
MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

13

TOTAL

13
Capsule-1

1/7/2016

Introduction

Five Capsules

Evaluation Scheme

(1)

Definition of UAV Systems. Historical overview. Scope and coverage

Overview of UAV Systems

(3)

Continuous Assessment: 50%

Aerial vehicles. Mission planning. Launch and recovery. Payloads and sensors.
Data links. Ground support equipment. Classes of UAV systems.

Aerodynamics Considerations

Dr. Rajkumar Pant 25%

(4)

o Project based submissions

Review of aerodynamics. Aerodynamic considerations for various UAV types.


Determination of aerodynamic parameters for analysis

Propulsion

Final Examination: 50%


Closed Book examination
Duration 2 hours

Dr. Lou Kok Yong 25%

(2)

Propulsion Systems for UAV. IC engines. Gas turbines. Other propulsive


techniques: e.g. flapping wings.

Performance

(3)

Performance measures for various UAV. Flight performance considerations:


speed, range, endurance, maneuverability. Launch and recovery performance.
Unconventional maneuvers
MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Course Policies

Course and Reference Books

Textbook
P. Fahlstrom, T. Gleason,
Introduction to UAV Systems,
2nd edition, UAV Systems
Inc., Columbia, MD, USA,
2005.

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

References
P. Castillo et al., Modelling
and Control of Mini-Flying
Machines, Springer-Verlag,
2005.
T. Mueller et al., Introduction
to the Design of Fixed-Wing
Micro Air Vehicles, AIAA
Education Series, 2007.

Capsule-1

Course Material on NTU Learn


Most communication by e-mail

Hand Phones to be switched off (not mute)


Or else I get to answer !

Questions and Interruptions Welcome !

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

1/7/2016

My Contact Details

rspant@pmail.ntu.edu.sg

Office : N3.2-02-45

Phone: 67906891

Meetings mostly by prior appointments

Who am I ??

MY BACKGROUND

Open Door policy for quick doubts

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Academic

Work Experience
Five years industrial experience

Three degrees in Aeronautical Engineering

Hindustan Aeronautics Limited, Kanpur (1984-88)

Bachelors

o Punjab Engineering College Chandigarh, India, 1979-83


Masters

o Indian Institute of Technology Madras, India, 1984-86


o Sponsored by Hindustan Aeronautics Limited
Doctoral

o College of Aeronautics, Cranfield University, UK, 1993-97


o Commonwealth Scholarship Commission in UK
MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

Capsule-1

oDo-228 and HS-748 structural modifications


Hindustan Aeronautics Limited, Nashik (1988-89)

oMiG 27-M and -21 Aerodynamics & Flight Testing

~25 years teaching & research @ IIT Bombay


Lecturer

(1989-90)

Asst. Prof.

(1990-01)

Associate Prof.

(2001-12)

Prof.

(2012 )

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

1/7/2016

Aircraft I have mainly worked on

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

Other aircraft I worked on

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

Aircraft I have flown (in the cockpit !)

My Research Portfolio

UNMANNED AERIAL VEHICLES

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

1/7/2016

Overview

Technical vetting of Vihang Netra Mk-I

Design of a Snow UAV

Multicriteria Optimization of Snow UAV

Conceptual Design of Vihang Netra Mk-II

Conceptual Design of Hand Launched UAV

Aerodynamic Analysis of Flapping Wing UAV

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

VIHANG Netra Mk-1 UAV for SASE

TECHNICAL VETTING OF DESIGN

Capsule-1

VIHANG NETRA Mk-I

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

Vihang Netra-Mk-1

Short Range Unmanned Surveillance System


Key Specifications

Range 30 Km

Endurance 2 hours

Payload 25 Kg

Max Altitude 15000 feet (above MSL)

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

1/7/2016

Trials at Gliding Center, Pune

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

emonstration Flight

Trials at Bhuntar Airfield in Kulu


MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

1/7/2016

Landing at Helipad

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

VIHANGA NETRA HIGH ALTITUDE TRIALS

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

1/7/2016

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

Trials with standing snow

High Altitude Trials at Sissu

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

1/7/2016

Specified Requirements

Case Study-II

DESIGN OF UAV FOR SASE

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Critical Requirements

Tools used

Take off and Landing within 100m @ 12000ft

Maximum altitude of 18000 ft

Sustaining cross winds of 28 kmph

Wide temperature range of operation i.e.

RDS-Professional

from -300C to 500C

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

Capsule-1

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Advanced Aircraft
Analysis

Capsule-1

1/7/2016

CONFIGURATIONS INVESTIGATED

DRAGONFLY

VULTURE

SPARROW

SENTRY

Snow UAV

SHADOW-600

BLUE HORIZON

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

Aim and Scope


Aim
Conceptual sizing of a UAV
For snow studies in lower Himalayas

Multicriteria Optimization of
SNOWUAV

To set up a multi-objective optimization problem


Scope
Development of a methodology for UAV sizing

Dinesh Kumar
M. Tech. Project: 2009-10

Optimize and compare results from different optimizers


Multi-objective optimization
Identification of conflicting objectives

Dineshkumar, M. and Pant, R. S., Conceptual Sizing and Multicriteria


Optimization of UAV for Snow Studies, Journal of Aerospace Sciences and
Technologies, Aeronautical Society of India, August 2013.
MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

Obtain Pareto front for the conflicting objectives

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

10

1/7/2016

Assumptions

Mission Specification

Baseline Configuration of VN-Mk II

CRUISE
ALTITUDE = 3000m
DISTANCE = 92.6km
MACH NUMBER = 0.6

LOITER
ALTITUDE = 3000m
DURATION = 30 min
MACH NUMBER = 0.5

DASH
ALTITUDE = 3000m
DURATION = 5 min
MACH NUMBER = 0.8

CLIMB
INITIAL ALTITUDE=100m
FINAL ALTITUDE = 3000m
MACH NO. = 0.5
MANEUVER
ALTITUDE = 2000m
NO. OF TURNS = 2
MACH NUMBER = 0.5

CRUISE
ALTITUDE = 2000m
DISTANCE = 92.6km
MACH NUMBER = 0.6

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

Sharma, S.C., Feasibility Study for the design and Development of an Unmanned Aerial Vehicle
for the Evaluation of Snow Cover, Punjab Engineering College, Chandigarh, 2007
MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles
Capsule-1

Optimization
GENETIC ALGORITHM

Inputs

UAV DESIGN ALGORITHM

..Continued

Design Variables
READ
POPULATION SIZE
= NP
NUMBRE OF GENERATION = NG
STRING LENGTH
= LS
CROSSOVER PROBABILITY=PC
MUTATION PROBABILITY = PM
INITIAL SEED
= IS
GEN=1
INITIALIZE
POPULATION
FITNESS EVALUATION
REPRODUCTION

READ DESIGN VARIABLES


AND CONSTRAINTS

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

GEOMETRY

MASS
ESTIMATION

PACKAGING
CALCULATION

MISSION
PROFILE

Design Variable
Aspect Ratio
Wing Span (m)
Wing t/c
Wing Setting Angle (deg)
Flap Area Percent
Propeller Radius (m)
Fuel Mass (kg)
Vehicle Length (m)
Design Mass (kg)
Air Brake CD0

AERODYNAMICS

Three Engine options available

CROSSOVER
ENGINE
DATA
MUTATION

GEN=GEN+1

Engine
LIMBACH L 275 E
Simonini Flying MINI 2 PLUS
UAV Engines AR 741

PERFORMANCE
CALCULATION

GEN=
NG
STOP

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Lower Limit Upper Limit


6
10
4
10
10
20
0
5
0.0
0.25
0.2
0.8
1
8
3
6
70
120
0.5
1.98

OBJECTIVE FUNCTION
AND PENELTY
ESTIMATION

Capsule-1

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Power
(kW)
15
19
28

Mass
(kg)
7.8
18.3
16

Length Width
(m)
(m)
0.4
0.26
0.25
0.26
0.4
0.26

Height
(m)
0.26
0.45
0.26
Capsule-1

11

1/7/2016

Constraints
Computed Constraint
Type Reference
Mission fuel +reserve
= Fuel Mass
Total Mass Computed
= Total Mass
Takeoff Distance
< 100 m
Landing Distance
< 100 m
Wing Location + Wing Chord
< Fuselage Length
Propeller Tip Mach number
< 0.8
Stall Speed 1.5
< Design Speed

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

Multicriteria Optimization

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

Multi-objective Optimization
8.5

Pareto Front
7
6

Identification of Conflicting Objectives

8.0
Wing Span (m)

1
2
3
4
5
6
7

7.5
3

2
1

7.0

47
MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

6.5
6.0

6.5

7.0

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

7.5

8.0

Stall Speed (m/s)

8.5

9.0

9.548
Capsule-1

12

1/7/2016

Design Variables Pareto Front


Design Variables of Pareto Front
1
Aspect Ratio
Wing Span (m)
Wing t/c
Wing Setting Angle (deg)
Flap Area Fraction
Propeller Radius (m)
Fuel Mass (kg)
Vehicle Length (m)
Design Mass (kg)
AirBrake CD0
Engine
Objective Functions
Stall Speed (m/s)
Wing Span (m)

7.12
15.48
0.48

2
7.26
7.21
18.71
0.0
0.32
1.56
3
70
1.49

7.43
7.12

7.01
7.21

6.31
7.26
8.02
20
17.42
0.48
0.32
0.25
0.41
2.22
5.67
88.82
1.59
L 275E
6.92
7.26

6.76
8.02

1.13

6
6.0
8.35
17.42
0.32

1.19

0.34
2.11
3.29
95.1
0.89

1.98

6.55
8.06

6.5
8.35

6.46
8.39

8.06

7
8.39

1.0
0.8
1.89

0.6

7
6
5
4
3
2
1

0.4
0.2
0.0

50
MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Observations

Summary & Conclusions

Multi Objective Optimization

Dedicated methodology for conceptual

Seven non-dominating objectives obtained

sizing and optimization for one-class of

Minimum stall speed 6.46 m/s @ wing span of 8.39 m

UAVs developed

Minimum wing span 7.12 m @ stall speed of 7.43 m/s

LIMBACH 275 E powerplant is selected in all the cases

Multi-criteria Optimization

Maximum flap fraction of 0.25 is selected in all the cases

Evolutionary optimization Algorithm can find full Pareto front


Seven Pareto designs obtained offers various possibilities in the design

51
MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

Capsule-1

52
MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

13

1/7/2016

Team Members:
Jason Berti
Anish Bhatt
Donald Brooks
Michael Hazuda
David Rigotti
Sumeet Singh
Anthony Swago
Andrew Wang
Supervisor:
Prof. Rajkumar S. Pant

Visiting Faculty @ Dept. of AOE, Virginia Tech, 2010-11

HAUSS PROJECT

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

Capsule-1

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

Introducing

The NEW

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

14

1/7/2016

Desired Features

Conceptual Design Study of a


Hand Launched UAV

Light weight, hand launched and belly landing


Undetectable, low observability
Loiter optimization
Portability
No special piloting skills

M. Naveesh Reddy
Undergraduate Project
2011-12

Reliable

Reddy, N., Pant, R., Conceptual Design Study of a Hand Launch UAV,
Paper AIAA-2013-4423, Proceedings of AVIATION 2013, Los Angeles,
USA, 12-14 August 2013
MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Existing HaL-UAVs

Specific Requirements
Specifications

All up Weight 7 kg

UAV

Endurance : 3 hours
Loiter speed :

Capsule-1

AeroVironment Pointer

12 m/s - 25 m/s

AeroVironment Raven

Range: 30 km

Wing

Length

Gross

Range

Endurance Velocity

Operational

span

(m)

Weight

(km)

(min)

(km/h)

Altitude

60

80

(kg)

(m)
2.74

1.4

1.83

0.9

4.5

1.9

(m)

10

6090

Upto 300

(max)

AGL

32-81

152 AGL

AeroVironment PUMA

2.8

1.4

5.9

15

120

37-83

152 AGL

AeroVironment Dragon Eye

1.1

0.9

2.7

45-60

35-65

300 AGL

Skylark 1 LE

2.9

2.2

6.1

15

180

37-74

-273 to 914
from take off

METU Guventurk

2.2

1.35

4.5

10

90

33-85

Bayraktar

1.6

1.2

15

60

95 (max)

300 AGL
Upto 900
AGL

Desert Hawk
MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

1.37

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

0.91

15

90

30 -80

150 AGL
Capsule-1

15

1/7/2016

Baseline UAV

Propulsion System

Skylark 1 LE

Battery pack, propeller, motor and speed controller

Type

Advantage

Disadvantage

NiCd

Cheapest, Fast charging, not very Heavy,


sensitive to overcharging,
problem,
capacity,

Voltage Energy Density


(W-hr/kg)

Belly landing with inflated


cushion
Composite Structure
STAMP
Stabilized Miniature Payload
Daylight, night, uncooled
thermal and HD

memory 1.2
low

NiMH No memory problems, Medium Heavy, sensitive to 1.2


cost,
overcharging
LiPo

Light weight, Highest capacity Expensive,


needs 3.7
and no memory problems, 3.7 special charger, Risk
volts/cell
of explosion

Li ion No memory effect, high energy Risk of explosion


density
MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

3.6

40-80

60-100
130 +

100-160

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

Comparison :S1223 v/s FX 63137

Airfoil Selection

Fx 63137

S1223
MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

16

1/7/2016

Constraint Analysis

Design Point (Hp/W , W/S) = (0.013 hp/N, 58.32 N/m2)

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Refined sizing

Capsule-1

6
6

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Design Layout

Capsule-1

Sensitivity to Weight
Range
7

Gross Weight (kgs)

Gross Weight (kgs)

Endurance
7
6.5
6
5.5
5
150

160

170

180

190

200

210

6.5
6
5.5
5
27

28

Endurance (minutes)

29

30

31

32

33

Range (kms)

Gross Weight (kg)

Max. Velocity
8
7
6
5
4
16

17

18

19

20

Velocity (m/s)
MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

17

1/7/2016

Thanks for your attention !


Open for queries

MA-4878 Unmanned Aerial Vehicles

Capsule-1

18

You might also like