Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CHAPTER 2
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1
large in
transportation,
energy and
22
Stir Casting
This process involves incorporation of ceramic particulate into
liquid aluminium melt and allowing the mixture to solidify. The crucial thing
is to create good wetting between the particulate reinforcement and the liquid
aluminium alloy melt. The simplest and most commercially used technique is
known as vortex technique or stir casting technique. In this method the matrix
material is melt and stirred vigorously to form a vortex at the surface of the
melt. The vortex technique involves the introduction of pre-treated ceramic
particles into the vortex of molten alloy created by the rotating impeller.
23
Stirring is continued for few minutes before the slurry is cast (Hai Zhi Ye and
Xing Yang Liu 2004). Stirring helps in two ways: (a) transferring particles
into the liquid metal and (b) maintaining the particles in a state of suspension.
It is then poured into the die and allowed to solidify. Mechanical stirring in
the furnace is a key element of this process. The resultant molten alloy, with
ceramic particles, can then be used for die casting, permanent mold casting, or
sand casting.
A homogeneous distribution of secondary particles in the
composite matrix is critical for achieving a high strengthening effect because
an uneven distribution can lead to premature failures in both reinforcementfree and reinforcement-rich areas. The reinforcement-free areas tend to be
weaker than the other areas. Under an applied stress, slip of dislocations and
initiation of microcracks can occur in these areas relatively easily, eventually
resulting in failure of the material. Microstructural inhomogeneties can cause
notably particle agglomeration and sedimentation in the melt and
subsequently during solidification. In the areas of signi cant segregation or
agglomeration of normally highly brittle hard particles, weak bonds are
formed in the material which can lead to the reduced mechanical properties. A
major concern associated with the stir casting process is the segregation of
reinforcing particles caused by surfacing or settling of the reinforcement
particles during the melting and casting processes.
Inhomogeneity in reinforcement distribution in these cast
composites could also be a problem as a result of interaction between
suspended ceramic particles and moving solid-liquid interface during
solidification. The nal distribution of the particles in the solid depends on
material properties and process parameters such as the wetting condition of
the particles with the melt, strength of mixing, relative density, and rate of
solidi cation. The distribution of the particles in the molten matrix also
24
25
stirring. The major merit of stir casting is its applicability to large quantity
production. Among all the well-established metal matrix composite
fabrication methods, stir casting is the most economical (Compared to other
methods, stir casting costs as little as one third to one tenth for mass
production. For that reason, stir mixing and casting is now used for largescale production of Metal Matrix Particulate Composites. Various metals such
as Al, Mg, Ni, and Cu have been used as the matrix and a wide variety of
reinforcements like SiC, graphite, SiO2, Al2O3 Si3N4, and ZrSiO4, have been
used as reinforcements. Processing of metal matrix composites by stir mixing
and casting requires special precautions including temperature control and
design of pouring and gating systems (Pradeep Rohatgi 2001).
2.3
RULE OF MIXTURES
Most studies concerned with the evaluation of mechanical
26
27
SiC particles and the matrix causes reduced fatigue strength. The mechanical
behaviour of these composites was related to the particle geometry (shape),
distribution and size of reinforcement particles in the matrix.
Chennakesava Reddy and Essa Zitoun (2010) reported that the
yield strength, ultimate strength, and ductility of Al/SiC metal matrix
composites are in the descending order of Al 6061, Al6063 and Al 7072
matrix alloys. The contents of alloying elements such as Si, Fe, Mg and Cu
play a vital role in the mechanical properties Al/SIC composites. Mg
improved the wettability between Al and SiC particles by reducing the SiO2
layer on the surface of the SiC. The fracture modes of composites are ductile
in nature.
Hamouda et al (2007) reported that the tensile strength and youngs
modulus of silicon dioxide particulate reinforced LM6 aluminium alloy
composites decreased gradually with increase in silicon dioxide. This was due
to the dominating nature of the compressive strength of quartz particulate
reinforced in LM6 alloy matrix.
Tensile strength, impact strength and fatigue properties of
aluminium composites reinforced with longitudinal steel fibers are higher
compared to composites reinforced with transverse fibers (Agbanigo and
Alowode 2008). This was due to the fact that transverse fibers created areas of
stress concentration which aids initiation and propagation of cracks resulting
in early commencement of deformation and fiber matrix debonding.
Fracture behaviour of two MMC materials Al6061/Al2O3 and Al-Si
alloy SiC were studied by Perez Ipina et al (2000). Annealing heat treatments
promoted an increase in fracture toughness and observed formation of fatigue
precracking after heat treatment.
28
29
30
2.5
31
expansion of castings decreased with increase in fly ash content. The hardness
and wear resistance increased as the fly ash content increased. Tensile
strength of heat treated composites (T6) containing less than 8 vol% fly ash
was similar to that of the aluminium alloy.
LI Yue-ying et al (2007) investigated the mechanical behaviours of
Al/fly ash particles synthesized by squeeze casting method. The hardness of
the composites was higher than that of the Al matrix and increased with
increase in volume fraction of fly ash particles. The tensile strengths and
elongation of composites are lower than that of the Al matrix and decreased
with increase in volume fraction of fly ash particles.
Rohatgi et al (2005) observed that the presence of fly ash
cenospheres in pure Al matrix decreased the coefficient of thermal expansion.
Increase in applied pressure and infiltration time decreased the coefficient of
thermal expansion. Increase in infiltration pressure and temperature improved
the infiltration and decreased the entrapment of air voids.
Differential thermal analysis study by Guo et al(1998) indicated
that pressure infiltrated aluminium with 40 vol.% fly ash composite was
chemically stable after holding for 10 hrs at 850C enhancing the chemical
stability of aluminium-fly ash composites during synthesis and reheating.
Yadong Li et al (1998) combined polyethylene terephthalate plastic
waste with fly ash and observed that fly ash served as a filler element. Fly ash
particles served as a heat conductor, decomposition inhibitor and as
lubricating agent. Fly ash improved the compressive strength, melting and
mixing processes. Sobczak et al (2003) observed oxy-redox reactions between
Al and fly ash constituents such as SiO2, Fe2O3, Fe3O4 and mullite resulting in
the formation of a thick reaction product region.
32
33
THEORY OF WEAR
Wear behaviour is the surface damage or removal of material from
one or both of the two solid surfaces in sliding, rolling or impact motions
relative to one another. Wear is usually a progressive loss of weight and
alteration of dimensions over a period of time. Wear is an undesirable product
in almost all machine applications such as bearing seals, gears and cams etc.
Wear of components ranges from mild polishing type attrition to rapid and
severe removal of material.
34
2.6.1
Types of Wear
In most basic wear studies dry friction was investigated to avoid the
Abrasive Wear
Abrasive wear occurs when asperities of rough, hard surface or
hard particles slides on a softer surface and damage the interface by plastic
deformation or fracture. In ductile materials with high fracture toughness the
hard asperities or hard particles results in plastic flow of the softer material.
Abrasion can be generally classified into two body or three body abrasions.
2.6.1.2
Adhesive Wear
Adhesive wear occurs when two smooth flat bodies are in sliding
35
2.6.1.3
Corrosive Wear
Most of the metals are thermodynamically unstable in air and reacts
with oxygen to form oxide developing oxide layers on the surface of metal
when their interfacial bonds are poor. Corrosion wear is the gradual eating
away or deterioration of unprotected metal surfaces by the effects of the
atmosphere, acids, gases, alkalis, etc. This type of wear creates pits and
perforations and may eventually dissolve the metal parts.
2.61.4
Erosive Wear
Erosive wear is caused by the impact of particles of solid or liquid
Fatigue Wear
Surface fatigue is a process by which the surface of a material is
36
layer on the wearing surface and the formation of fine equiaxial wear debris.
The influence of applied load, sliding speed, surface hardness, reinforcement
fracture toughness and morphology were critical parameters for adhesive
wear in relation to the wear regime encountered by the matrix material.
Sannino and Rack (1995) in their review on discontinuously
reinforced aluminium composites proposed that metals undergoing dry sliding
can be independently optimized through investigation of (i) third body
behaviour: the rate of third body ejection depends on sliding velocity, load,
geometry of contact and the reinforcement characteristics (ii) Surface
behaviour where adhesion is the principal debris generation mechanism (iii)
Subsurface behaviour when delamination is the principal debris generation
mechanism.
2.7.1.
37
38
at sliding speeds ranging from 0.6 to 1.25 m/s and under loads ranging from
3.98 to 6.37MPa for pin specimens of Al-5083 matrices composites
reinforced with 5 and 10 wt.% B4C particles. Two stages in the pin length
reduction curves while reinforcing B4C in aluminium alloy was observed. The
low length reduction rate in the first stage corresponded to a flat stage with
low coefficient of friction. The transition from the first stage to the second
stage attributed to the change in wear mechanism from abrasive wear to
adhesive wear.
Jha et al (1989) studied the dry sliding wear of 6061 aluminium
alloy and composites containing graphite particle dispersions developed by
power metallurgy route. The wear rate of composites increased with
increasing amount of graphite due to the increased porosity (interconnected
and interfacial) in the composites. Most of the wear debris was flaky in
nature.
performance of the Al/4Cu alloy. The wear resistance increased with increase
in amount of TiB2. The improvement in wear resistance of both alloy and
composites was mainly due to the formation of finer debris.
Pritt Kulu et al (2005) reported the behaviour of powder materials
and coatings under different abrasive wear conditions was dependent on the
type, composition of materials and conditions of abrasive wear (abrasive
particle size and velocity, media of abrasive wear etc). Under high-energy
impact wear TiC based cermets with optimal composition were almost as
39
40
in an alumina based ceramic cutting tool material was studied by Hong Xiao
et al (1991). The surface parallel to hot pressing direction was found to have
more wear resistant than the surface perpendicular to hot pressing direction.
Oxidation of Sic whiskers occurred in the wear process which accelerates the
wear rate. The oxidation of whiskers is less on the surface parallel to hot
pressing direction.
The friction and wear behaviour of aluminium/graphite fiber
composites was examined by Nayeb Hasbemi (1991) as a function of
interfacial reaction. The wear fibers parallel to the sliding direction were
dominated by three wear mechanisms: (1) matrix removal by delamination (2)
wear due to ploughing and (3) fiber pull-out. Whenever fiber pull-out was a
contributing mechanism in the wear, the wear rate is an exponential function
of the normal load. In contrast, the wear rate of composites was proportional
to the normal load in the absence of fiber pull-out. When the fibers were
41
normal to the sliding plane and direction, fiber pull-out was minimal. When
the fibers were parallel to the sliding plane and perpendicular to the sliding
direction, fiber roll-out was significant. When the fibers were parallel to the
sliding plane and direction, fiber pull-out was significant.
Nannaji Saks and Nelson K. Szeto (1992) compared the wear
behaviour of three composites namely graphite /aluminium, stainless steel
/aluminium and Al2O3/Al/Li and reported that graphite/Al is a low-friction,
low-wear composite. Stainless steel/Al is a high-friction, high-wear and
highly anisotropic composite. The low friction was due to spreading of
graphite at the sliding interface. Fiber pull-out was the dominant mechanism
of wear, especially in the Gr/Al and SS/Al composites. Poor bonding and
fiber clusters lead to high wear and high friction.
The wear and frictional behaviour of LM 13 alloys containing up
to 30 vol % of Al2O3 fiber were investigated by Akbulut (1998) in sliding
against a hard steel counter face (63 HRC) under dry conditions at room
temperature in the transverse section of composites. Increased fiber volume in
the composites decreased the wear rate and coefficient of friction. Reinforcing
AI-Si (LM 13) alloy with alumina short fibers reduced the wear rate of the
matrix alloy by a factor from 1.2 to 4.o and the coefficient of friction by 525% , depending on the fiber volume. Excessive plastic deformation occurred
during the wear and the amount of the plastic deformation decreased with
increasing fiber volume.
Iwai et al (2000) reinforced Al2O3 fibers ranging from 0.03 to 0.26
volume fractions and rubbed against a pin of nitrided stainless steel with a
load of 10 N at a sliding velocity of 0.1 m/s in aluminium alloy. Improvement
in dry sliding wear resistance of composites was observed. Reinforcements
inhibited plastic flow and restricted propagation of wear cracks. Duration of
severe wear regime and severe wear rate decreased with increase in fiber
42
volume fraction. Wear rate of the counter face (steel pin) increased
moderately with increase in volume fraction of alumina fibers.
2.7.5
43
aluminium alloy and decreased with increase in SiC content. With an increase
in load (0 to 60 N) , cracking of SiC particles occurred and a combination of
abrasion, delamination and adhesive wear was observed (Basavarajappa et al
2006). Mild wear was observed for a small applied load, but as the load
increased up to 20 N, the wear rate of the unreinforced alloy and composite
increased. At the load of 20 N, the wear pattern changed for the unreinforced
alloy, while the composite followed the same trend up to 50 N (the
unreinforced alloy seizes at this load). At a 60 N load, the SiCp reinforced
composites showed a change in the wear rate pattern to severe wear.
Mehmet Acilar and Ferhat Gul (2004) carried sliding wear tests
under normal loads of 12, 24 and 36 N at a sliding speed of 1.0 m/ s and
sliding distances of 2.2, 3.6 and 5.0 km against a steel disk using a pin-on-disc
type apparatus. The surface damage of Al/10Si/SiCp (10 and 30-vol% )
composites produced by vacuum infiltration technique increased with
increasing load since matrix materials have wear low resistance. Delamination
type of wear mechanism was observed under higher loads. Oxidation was the
wear mechanism under the low load, since oxide layer with high Fe content
formed on the steel disc surface served as a lubricant and reduced the wear.
The damage to the surface of the composites increased with increasing load.
Shorowordi
et
al
(2006)
investigated
the
tribo
surface
44
distances (90-540 m) resulted in higher volumetric wear loss but lowered the
wear coefficient of Al6061/ TiO2 composites. At larger sliding distances, rise
in temperature of the sliding surfaces resulted in softening of both the matrix
alloy and the composite pin surfaces, leading to heavy deformation at higher
sliding distances contributing to higher wear losses. The volumetric wear loss
of the composites were much lower when compared with the matrix alloy and
reduced with increased content of TiO2 in the composites at all sliding
distances studied. This is due to enhancement in hardness of the composites
resulting in improvement of wear and seizure resistance of materials.
Wear loss was found to increase more or less linearly with sliding
distance (125-500 m) for A6061 matrix alloy as well as composites
containing 7 vol.% graphite particles. The rate of increase in wear rate with
increase in sliding distance corresponding to the 6061 matrix alloy was less
than that of the graphite containing composite.
Wear rates and friction coefficients were measured by Martin
(1996) in 2618 Al alloy reinforced with 15 vol % SiC and the corresponding
unreinforced alloy in the temperature range 20- 200oC. Both materials
presented a transition from mild to severe wear as the temperature increased
with increase in sliding distance. The transition temperature was between 100
45
and 150oC in the unreinforced alloy and between 150 and 200oC in the
composite.
2.7.8
46
adhesion, twisting and rolling of small wear particles during the wear process
resulted in the formation of long needle like debris.
2.7.9
aluminium alloys reinforced with SiC (20 vol. % SiC) particulates against
automobile friction linings (brake pads). They revealed that if the structure
and composition of friction linings are arranged correctly, the wear resistance
and frictional properties of aluminium MMC brake rotors are superior to
those of cast iron brake rotors. At high loads and sliding velocities,
cohesiveness of materials within the pad was poor and the wear rate of the
MMC was extremely high.
Natarajan et al (2006) studied the wear behaviour of aluminium
metal matrix composite (A356/25SiCp) sliding against brake shoe lining
material and compared it with the conventional brake drum made of grey cast
iron. MMCs have considerable higher wear resistance than conventional grey
cast iron while sliding against automobile friction material under identical
sliding speed and load conditions.
Kok and Ozdin (2007) reinforced Al2O3 (16m and 32m) in 2024
Al matrix alloy and observed significant improvement in abrasive wear
resistance of composites tested against different abrasives (600,320,240 grit).
Wear resistance increased with increasing Al2O3 particles content and
abrasive size and decreased with increasing the sliding distance, applied load
and abrasive grit size.
Straffelini et al (2004) studied the friction and wear behaviour of
aluminium based composites reinforced with SiC. The friction and wear
behaviour was connected with the characteristics of the transfer layer formed
47
on the disc surface. External heating favoured the transfer phenomena and
decreased the wear of Al-MMCs (which is negative) but decreased the
friction and increased the wear of counter face friction material.
2.7.10
48
m/s). For unreinforced 6061 Al and A356 A1 alloys a transition from mild to
severe wear occurred in ranges of 175-190 oC and 225-230 oC respectively.
With the addition of 20 vol. % Al203 to 6061 Al, the mild wear transformed to
severe wear transition was raised to a range between 310-350 C. Likewise,
an addition of 20 vol. % of SiC to the A356 Al increased this transition to
440-450C. A hybrid A356 AI composite containing 20 vol. % SiC and 10
vol.% graphite remained in a mild wear regime at the highest test temperature
of 460oC. All the reinforced alloys were able to withstand considerable
thermal softening effects while remaining in a mild sliding we at regime. The
elevated temperature sliding wear of the particulate reinforced alloys was
accompanied by extensive thermal softening of their bulk matrix
microstructures. The formation of transfer layers of comminuted particulates
and steel inclusions delayed the onset of severe wear.
2.8
WEAR
BEHAVIOUR
OF
ALUMINIUM/FLY
ASH
COMPOSITES
Rohatgi and Guo (1997) observed that abrasive wear resistance of
aluminium alloy containing 5vol% fly ash was superior to that of the base
A356 alloy below a load of 8 N at a sliding velocity of 1 m/s. The decrease in
specific wear rate with increase in load was due to an accumulation of wear
debris in the interstices between the abrading particles and observed sub
surfaces below the rubbing surfaces of composites and the base alloy.
Samrat Mohanty and Chugh (2007) incorporated fly ash particles in
automotive brake lining friction composites. Ingredients such as phenolic
resin, aramid pulp, glass fiber, potassium titanate, graphite, aluminium fiber
and copper powder were used in the composite development phase in addition
to fly ash. The developed brake lining composites have exhibited consistent
coefficient of friction and wear rates.
49
50
51
2.10
52
abrasive grains being rubbed. The compact which had 13 m SiC particles
exhibited higher wear rate than the compact with 3 7m SiC particles.
Sudarshan and Surappa (2008) fabricated aluminium alloy (A356)
composites with
(0.5400 m) fly ash particles. Composites reinforced with narrow size range
fly ash particle exhibited superior mechanical properties compared to
composites with wide size range particles. At higher loads wear resistance of
composites reinforced with narrow size range fly ash particles was superior to
that of composites with wide fly ash particles.
2.11
REGRESSION ANALYSIS
Regression analysis is a statistical tool for the investigation of
1x
(2.1)
0
is Y intercept,
slope of the regression line, x is the independent variable, and is the random
53
linear is used because the Equation (2.1) is a linear function of the unknown
parameters
and
1.
1x1............
pxp+
0,
(2.2)
1,
2.......
x1, x2.xp are independent variables in the model. In the classical regression
setting it is usually assumed that the error term
The multiple linear regressions involve more issues than the simple
linear regression such as collinearity, variance inflation, graphical display of
regression diagnosis, and detection of regression outlier and influential
observation. A linear regression model may also be written as shown in
Equation (2.3).
Y=
1x1+
2x2+
12x1
x2 +
(2.3)
54
1x1+
2x1
3x3
(2.4)
55
56
test (NDT) to determine the influence of grain size and carbon. Fadare et al
(2009) developed an ANN model to predict the tool life and wear rate while
machining Ti/6Al/4V alloy by varying the cutting parameters (cutting speed,
feed rate, depth of cut, coolant pressure, and tool type) using a three layered,
feed forward, back propagation artificial neural networks.
The machining forces-tool wear relationship of an aluminium metal
matrix composite was studied using multiple regression analysis (MRA) and
Generalised Radial Basis Function (GRBF) neural network by Lin et al
(2003). The use of a neural network analysis improved the accuracy of tool
wear prediction particularly when the functional dependency is non linear.
Hulya Kacar Durmus et al (2006) studied the effects of wear loss and surface
roughness at various ageing temperatures, load, sliding speed and abrasive
grit diameter of aluminium alloy against SiC water proof emery using
artificial neural networks and observed that the experimental results coincide
with ANN results.
Mustafa Taskin et al (2008) used ANN approach to predict the
diffusion bonding behaviour of Ni/Ti alloys manufactured by powder
metallurgy process using back propagation neural network. In neural
networks training, different temperatures and welding periods were used as
input for predicting the shear strength. Rajendraboopathy et al (2008) was
successful in generating a feed forward back propagation neural network
model to predict the failure of fiber reinforced composite materials by
acoustic emission influenced by parameters like amplitude, duration, counts
and energy.
2.13
57
reinforcements
in
aluminium
metal
matrix
58