Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Frequencies
as Ratios
Or rno unNy characteristics of a musical tone the most important for
musical scienceis the number of pulsations it creates, in a given length of
time, in the air in which it is heard. We call thesepulsationsvibrations,and
u'hen we use the sixtieth part of a minute as our measureof time, it is now
customary to call them cycles. The number of cycles-per second-determinesthe pitch of the tone.r
A systemof music is an organization of relationships of pitches, or tones,
to one another, and these relationships are inevitably the relationship of
numbers. Tone is number, and since a tone in music is always heard in relation to one or severalother tones-actually heard or implied-we have
at leastt o numbers to deal with: the number of the tone under consideration and the number of the tone heard or implied in relation to the first
tone. Hence, the ratio.2
It is u'ell to plunge at once into ratio nomenclatureand to disregardthe
more familiar "A-B-C " terminologv by which the ratios in our conventional scalesare expressed.The advantagesof doing so, in opening new
tonal vistas, in getting to the analyzable root of music and the core of the
universe of tone, are inestimable. If time is taken out to translate each ratio
into what is assumed to be a synonymous word value, these vistas are
dimmed or lost altogether, and the values, u'hich are not synonyms, are
nevertheless convicted of fraud by alleged synonyms. After hearing a
"major third" on-the organ or piano or some other instrument with tempered intonation, this interval becomesfixed in the mind as a pretty poor
consonance,at leastby some comparisons,A certain modern composer,one
Ifhe use ofthe word cycles prevents any confusion as between vibrations in whole and
halves of vibrations, thc latter being the French manncr of indicating frcquencies.
parts numcrical, whcn compared togethr,
'1In Euclid's words, "all things which consist of
arc subject to the ratios ofnumber; so that musical sounds or notes [tones] compared together,
must consequently be in some numerical ratio to each othcr." Da\\, L.lk$,2t265.
76
of numerous possibl
is, of not being exac
just intervals and te
If ratios seem a
languageso old that
of musical sound car
results are more imn
um surrounds and p,
ing and tedious th;
any case.
Before proceedin
instrumentswill be c
tonestested.For the
this precisearticlefacile thinking it is n
and functions.
The handling an
exact
mathcmati
an
tave") above it mak
This additional 200
since 200 cyclesadd
cycles.To get the 2/
the 2/1 below 400 w
constitute a ratio, al
with the sameratiofor example, both I
relationships.
This2tolrelati,
why they cannot adc
result,just as they a
"octave" at the piar
and its doubling (2[
samequality of relat
(200 to 600, for exar
3Hindemith, crul
d ,
4W i th c ents ,ex pl ai nc c
which represcnt ratios.
77
GENESISOF A MUSIC
The2tolrelationship,basedonthefactorof2'appliesonlytopromuch more to the calculation
gr*ri"" L'pi,.tt by 2/1's.^ihere is of course
But if the factor of 2 applies to the
of musical intervals than successive2/1's'
of 2 must apply to intervals
2/1. then certain decrements of the factor
starting
fro* u 2/1, or-increments of the factor of 2
;;.;;;;;;";u.J
each
since
simple'
v^ery
are
i; a;ust Intonation the comPutations
;;i.
The
2'
of
factor
ratio is itself a patticular measure of the
,*ff-nrr-U.i
interval
or 312 fit'si "perfect fifth")' for examPle' an
i"[*"i]oolzoo,
of the factor of 2' and the
,ru..o*e. than a 2/1, representsa certain measure
even smaller measure'
ZSotzOo, or 5/4-(just "major third'')' an
,"i
frequencies by some constantOb.riorrrly, then, if it is impossible to add
get a seriesof 2/1's'
fo, .*ample' which was suggestedabove-to
ZOO
in"u.t..,
f'equencies by constants togtt any seriesof
to
t;;ilil;..tbi.
^aa
is determined by
.t ri- than 2/1. Positively, if a sequenceof 2/1's
i.*Jt
narrower
intervals
sequenceof
ii. i"",- .f 2, by multiplication, then any
the factor of 2-by
i. a.t".-ined by their respectiveproPortions of
ir,""i/r
to be
Therefore, when any two ratios-two intervals-are
-,-ri,lii"u,io.t.
addei, muttiPlYtheir ratios'
-the intervals to
frc ttt"afi"g of small-number ratios, representing
more than simple multi*frl.tr it. ea, i, irost responsive,involves nothing
olicationanddivisionofimProPerfractions.onlywhentheexpedientof
complicated'
;i.,trod.,..d ao tt't computations hcome at all
H;ia.'i;
irrational
chosen
deliberately
*i.'" i.g"ti,ttt". are employed to produce.
of the factor of 2 (see page 101)'
oercentJees
*^;;;:i;.
pitch'
of d"e intJrvals, somewhat at random in
;i; ,.1*r,..
ratios being: 2400/1200'
rr".,ine a lo*et consiant of 1200 cycles, the five
number is exactlY
numbcr is lessthan
than a 2/1; and or
such as 3/2, rePrest
sequentlY,when an
halved or the lorve
16/5 is brought r'r'it
nithin a 211 by' t'
expressedin the les
A system of mu
cated in everl' othe
s,vmbols-ratiosin
211, and the symt
Nlusicians are acct
given "A" is still "-r
any given 9/8 is sti
cians will find this c
should be exPresse
But such a Proced
seven2/1's of the t
its own, and when
the number of tote
two or more 2/1's,
up and down from
2,i1," "Higher 211
It is common tr
built up*'ards (wi
and this Practicei:
is specificallYindic
ities,and is a matt
cation is synonym(
reversewill be ind
ItonochordProce
SupPosewe ha
a mark on the wc
rhat indicatesa th
;!)
number is exactly half the upper number, any ratio in which the lower
number is lessthan half the upper, suchas 5/2, representsan interval wider
than a 217; and one in which the lou,er number exceedshalf the upper,
such as 3/2, representsan interval smaller,or narrower, than a 2/1. Consequently, when an interval is wider than a 2f 1, the upper number may be
halved or the lower number doubled to bring it within a 2/7. The ratio
16/5 is brought within a 2/1by rvriting it 8.,/5,and the ratio 5,/2 is brought
lithin a 2/1 by rvriting it 514. Nearly all ratios in this exposition are
cxpressedin the lessthan 2/l form.
A s)stemof music is determined for one 2/1; the systemis then duplicated in every other 2/1, aboveor below, that is cmploycd. Consequently,
svmbols-ratios in this exposition-are used to denote the degreesof one
2 1, and the symbols are repeated in every 2/1 of the musical gamut.
\lusicians are accustomedto this idea; the "octave" above or below a
given "A" is still "A." The situationhere is identical; a 2/1 aboveor below
any given 9/8 is still 9/8. Only the physicistswho are not practising musicians will find this objectionable, since,acoustically, a 2/1 below a given 9/8
should be expressed9/16, and,a 2fl above 9/8 should be expressed9/4.
But such a procedure would mean that every one of the approximately
seven 2/1's of the common musical gamut would have a set of symbols of
its own, and when forty-three degrees-ratios-in a single 2/1 are involved
the number of total symbols would be unwieldy. The relative positions of
tuo or more 2/1's, when tables or diagrams or examples involve ratios both
up and down from a given 1/1, are indicated in this expositionby "Lower
2,'1," "Higher 2/1," "Third 2/1," and."Fourth 2/1," etc.
It is common practice musically to consider ratios (intervals) as being
built upwards (with the larger numbers above) from a lower constant,
and this practice is followed throughout this book except when the reverse
is specifically indicated. Such ratio symbolism isjust one of several possibilities, and is a matter of arbitrary choice; the reverseform in practical application is synonymous, and in order that this fact may not be obscured the
reversewill be indicated from time to time.
MonochordProcedures
Supposewe have a metal string stretched acrosstwo bridges, and make
a mark on the wood beneath that divides the string in half, then a mark
rhat indicates a third ofthe string, and finally a mark that divides the third
80
GENESISOF A MUSIC
513
441
543
The scaleof fo
rhe upper scale as
asccndsonly if rea
rhe same lilcies i
r aiucs,thc lorver :
"Tttinking"in R
Upon further i
rts comPrementv
numbers its comp
In the ratio 3/
ar rhc upper limit
l:cnce the interva
:ntcrval from 3 tt
*ithin the 2,r1; t)
nrs or Srnrr'to
rr 3/2. Each of these
lween two tones.The
ne of that relationto 2, or 3f2. For lack
ratio thinking" from
epresenting the cons of parts of a string
the string represents
)e-third of the string
:presents2 parts and
2f3, via the agent 3,
presentsthe interval
We thus see that the
e string lengths (see
rn). And the mental
ly, rather than as vitwnuard ratio think-
BI
54
43
54
"Thinking" in Ratios
Upon further investigation of the nature of ratios we find that each has
its complement within the 2/1, and if the ratio is composed of small
numbers its complementary ratio is also composed of small numbers.
In the ratio 3/2, 2 represents1/1, the lower limit of the 2/1. The tone
at tlre upper limit of the 2/1 may be representedby 4 (a doubling of 2);
hcnce the interval from the 3 of 3/2 to this upper limit of the 2/1 is the
interval from 3 to 4, or 4/3, which is therefore the complement of 3/2
*itlrin the 2/1i the two intervals might be expressedthus: 2:3:4. In the
GENESIS OF A MUSIC
ratio 5/4,4 represents 1/l; the 2/1 above 4 is 8; the complement of 5/4,
therefore, is the interval from 5 to 8, or 8/5, and the two intervals might be
expressed,4:5:8. In the ratio 6/5, 5 represents1/1; the 2/l above 5 is 10,
and the complement of 6/5 is therefore the interval from 6 to 10, or 70/6,
or, in its lowest terms, 5/3; the two intervals might be shown in this form,
5:6:10.
To find the sum of two intervals multiply the two ratios. The sum of
which, reducedto its lowest
5/4 and 6/5, for example, 5/4x6/5:30/20,
terms, is 3/2 (a "major third" and a "minor third" make a "perfect fifth").
To find the interval between t\ /o tones invert the smaller or narrower
ratio and multiply. For example, to find the interval between 3/2 and 4/3
invert the smaller,4/3, and use it as a multiplier: 3/2X3/4:9/8,which
is therefore the interval representing the tonal distance between the 4 of 4/3
and the ! of 3/2. (The difference between a "perfect fourth" and a "perfect
.fifth" is a "major second.")
To find a given interval above a given tone is of course simply a matter
multiplying
the two ratios involved; to frnd the same interval distance
of
downward from the same tone, the procedure is inversion and multiplication. Forexample,a6f5 above3/2 is arrived at r}Lvs 3/2X6 /5:9/5; and
a 6/5 below 3/2 thrs: 3/2X5/6:5/4.
ward, to put it ch
vals "C-F*F-C :
In resorting tc
adopt the negative
would say that 16
tone flat in the "l
think of the piano
and the more fruit
tion and indispen
rtould say that "I
equal semitone.Il
the pursuit of the J
recommcnded. Ft
crepancieswith tl
Ellis' MeasureoJ
*'ard, to put it charitably, than the idea that the ascendingmusical intervals "C-F *F-C : C-C" can accuratelyrepresent4/ 3 X3 / Z : 2/ 1,
In resorting to the piano two procedures are possible. First, one can
adopt the negative procedure of regarding ratios as altered piano tones.One
would say that 16/9, for example, is "F" one tu'enty-fifth of an equal semitone flat in the "key of G." On the other hand, it is quite as possibleto
think of the piano tonesas alteredratios.This is the constructiveapproach,
and the more fruitful one, since it predicates an understanding of the function and indispensabilityof ratios. In accordanceu'ith this procedureone
rlould say that "F" in the "key of G" is 1679 plus one t$'enty-fifth of an
equal semitone.If translation into conventionalvalues seemsdesirablein
the pursuit of the Monophonic theory, the secondis certainly the procedure
recommended. Follorting the explanation of cents a table of piano discrepancieswith the nearestsmall-numberratios will be given.
Ellis' Measure
of Cents
One mori step in the simple mechanicsof dealing with ratios must be
prcsentedin preparationfor the expositionof the Monophonic conceptsand
principles, namely, the measure of musical intervals established by AlexanderJ. Ellis in an appendix to his translationof Helmholtz's On theSensatiansoJ Tone.6This measureis the cent, the hundredth part of an equal
semitone-1200 to rhe 2/1. Cents provide a logarithmic device which enablesthe theorist to add and subtract numbersrepresentingthe respective
magnitudesof the variousratios, which he cannot do with the ratios themselves.They give the adventurerhis longitude and latitude and thus establish his u'hereaboutsin that vast. barely explored sea which lies from the
number 1 to the farawayshoresof the number 2. The ratioson previousand
subscquentpages,then, are the familiar or exotic islandsthat lie within the
boundariesof this little-knoransea.
If "G" is the starting point, the intcrvalsof the piano keyboardcontain
centsas shownin Diagram 2. The tempered"major third," "G to B," conrains400 cents.The true "major third," 57'4,containsonly a triflc over 386
cents.The diference, nearly 14 cents,is approximatelyone-seventhof 100.
Thcrefore "B" in the "key of G," which is 14 centssharPerthan 5/4. may
be cxpressedas 5/4 plus 14 cents,or approximatelyone-seventhof a semitone.
sPaces446-451.
B4
GENESIS OF A MUSIC
Drncnalr 2.-Celrrs
of G," which is 16 cents flatter than 6/5, may be stated as 6/5 minus 16
cents, or approximately one-sixth of a semitone.
Below are translations of all so-called diatonic intervals to the nearest
small-number ratios, the discrepanciesbeing expressedin approximate plus
or minus number of cents:
INTERVAL
RATIO
"G"
"G to Ab"
,,G to Bb',
INTERVAL
RATIO
"G to C*"
"G to Eb"
"G to F*"
This table represents,of course, the falsities that are found not only in
the "key of G" but in any "key" of Equal Temperament. If the "key of C"
is chosen,(!C to Dt"-the smallestinterval-is 16/15 minus 12 cents,etc.
For finding the number of cents in a given ratio Ellis provides a simple
arithmetical method-not adequate for investigation of a many-toned
scale-and alsome
placcs.For prescn
suflicient.All the l
lrc-.ides,
are givcn i
rable of Appendix
( nlv to that advcn
r oncl the ratios cxl
pl:rcelogarithms.c
r i Llclrnholtz'sOrr
lllis cxplainshis p
OA R D