Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: Ivan Malagoli Lanzoni, Rocco Di Michele & Franco Merni (2014) A notational analysis of
shot characteristics in top-level table tennis players, European Journal of Sport Science, 14:4, 309-317, DOI:
10.1080/17461391.2013.819382
To link to this article: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/17461391.2013.819382
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Abstract
This study aimed to analyse selected shot characteristics in top-level table tennis matches, with a special focus on comparing
the playing style of Asian and European players. Ten mens matches played by 20 top-ranked players (14 Asians and 6
Europeans) were analysed. The indicators examined were the area of ball bouncing for serves (n 918), and the stroke type,
footwork type and shot outcome for other shots (n 3692). The interrelationships between variables were analysed using
chi-squared tests, log-linear modelling and multiple correspondence analysis. A strong association was found between
strokes and footwork types, with most stroke types executed each after specific footwork types. Furthermore, a clear
tendency to have a positive, negative or neutral outcome was observed for each stroke type. When compared to Europeans,
Asians used more frequently the most aggressive strokes and footwork types, confirming anecdotal claims on their
particularly offensive playing style. Asians showed also a better serving effectiveness, often sending the ball in those areas of
the table from which a counterattack is difficult to make. In summary, this study gives a systematic description of highly
relevant technical and tactical characteristics in top-level table tennis, thus providing valuable information for coaches and
performance analysts.
Introduction
Table tennis is a popular racket sport, practiced
worldwide and included in the Olympic programme
since 1988. In a singles table tennis match, two
players stand at the opposite sides of a rectangular
table and are engaged in hitting a lightweight ball
with the goal of sending it over a net to the
opponents side of the table, in a way that makes it
difficult for the opponent to return it. Playing a table
tennis match involves a significant physical effort
(Zagatto, Morel, & Gobatto, 2010), and having good
fitness seems essential for a high-level player. However, the most crucial determinants of performance
in table tennis are undoubtedly technical and tactical
skills, and understanding how such skills are mastered by top-level players would be of great interest
to both coaches and performance analysts.
Correspondence: R. Di Michele, Department of Biomedical and Neuromotor Sciences, University of Bologna, via del Pilastro 8, 40127
Bologna, Italy. E-mail: rocco.dimichele@unibo.it
# 2013 European College of Sport Science
310
Methods
Match sample
Ten top-level mens table tennis matches were
randomly selected among matches played in the
20082010 period in International events by the
top 30 players in the world. The considered ranking
was that published monthly by the International
Table Tennis Federation (ITTF), available at the
website www.ittf.com. The 10 selected matches were
played in the Olympic games (n 2), team world
championship (n 4), mens world cup (n 3) and
Pro Tour grand final (n 1). Six of the matches were
between an European and an Asian player, while the
other four were between two Asian players. European players won two matches out of six. All the 6
European players used a shake-hand grip, while 4
out of the 14 Asian players used a pen-hold grip.
Two major variations exist of the pen-hold grip,
namely the traditional style (Japanese or Korean) in
which forehand shots are definitely predominant,
and a modern style (Chinese) in which, similar to
what happens in the shake-hand grip, both forehand
Figure 1. Six-area subdivision of each table side used to individuate the area of ball bouncing in serve analysis. The thick line
represents the net.
311
Reliability
For one of the matches, data relative to serves
(n 89), to outcomes of rally-ending shots (n 89)
and to stroke and footwork types (n 85, taken from
one set of that match) were recorded by three
national table tennis coaches. Furthermore, those
data were recorded three times throughout a fourmonth period by the same coach who collected the
entire data-set of this study. Krippendorffs alpha
(Krippendorff, 2004) was calculated to assess interand intra-operator reliability. Alpha can range between 1 and 1, where 1 indicates perfect agreement. For serve bouncing area, stroke type, footwork
type and shot outcome, alpha, respectively, equalled
0.94, 0.89, 0.96 and 0.98 concerning the interoperator reliability, and 0.99, 0.99, 0.99 and 1.00
concerning the intra-operator reliability.
Statistical analyses
Bivariate associations were assessed for pairs of
variables with Pearsons chi-squared tests. Statistical
significance was set at P B0.05. To determine which
particular combinations of the variables categories
were the most responsible for the association when
the null hypothesis of independence was rejected,
two-way contingency tables were graphically displayed using mosaic plots. In that kind of plot,
each cell of the table is represented with a rectangle
whose area is proportional to cell frequency, thus
allowing to visually assess the structure of the
association between variables (Hartigan & Kleiner,
1981).
A further analysis was performed using log-linear
modelling (Agresti, 2002). This approach allows to
simultaneously evaluate the relationships between all
the examined variables by selecting a log-linear
model that best represents the effects of variables
and their interactions. The best model was individuated through a forward stepwise procedure, with
312
313
Figure 2. Mosaic plots of the school of training/area of ball bouncing contingency table (A), and of two-way contingency tables of shot data
(BG). For each cell, the range of values including the standardised Pearson residual of that cell is indicated using different cell shadings
and edges. Positive and negative residuals, respectively, indicate that the observed cell frequency is lower or higher than the frequency
expected under independence. These residuals are asymptotically distributed as a standard normal; thus, a residual lower than 2 and
higher than 2 indicate lack of fit of the null hypothesis of independence in the respective cell; topctop top-counter-top.
314
Table I. Goodness-of-fit measures of log-linear models evaluated in the forward stepwise selection process for serve (upper part) and shot
(lower part) data
Step
Serve data
Shot data
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
6
G2
df
P-value
AIC
113.66
49.35
9.24
2.77
0
1110.71
319.41
241.66
180.28
151.29
150.88
16
11
6
5
0
342
297
288
270
265
263
B0.001
B0.001
0.16
0.73
1
B0.001
0.177
0.978
0.999
0.999
1
129.66
75.35
45.25
40.77
48.00
1146.71
445.41
385.66
360.28
341.29
344.88
Note: The selected models are indicated in bold. AT, AH, HT, FS, FT, OS, OT and ST indicate two-way associations between the
respective variables; AHT indicates the three-way association. G2: likelihood ratio test statistic; df: degrees of freedom; A: area of ball
bouncing; F: footwork type; H: handedness of opponent; O: shot outcome; S: stroke type; T: school of training.
Figure 3. Map obtained by the multiple correspondence analysis performed on the four-way contingency table formed by shot type,
footwork type, school of training and shot outcome. The map displays the coordinates of categories of all variables in the two dimensions
that capture the highest fraction of total variance; topctop top-counter-top.
315
316
References
Agresti, A. (2002). Categorical data analysis. Hoboken: Wiley.
Djokic, Z. (2002). Structure of competitors activities of top table
tennis players. In N. Yuza, S. Hiruta, Y. Iimoto, Y. Shibata, & J.
R. Harrison (Eds.), Table tennis sciences (pp. 7490). Lausanne:
International Table Tennis Federation.
Drianovski, Y., & Otcheva, G. (2002). Survey of the game style of
the best Asian players at the 12th World University Table
Tennis Championships (Sofia, 1998). In N. Yuza, S. Hiruta, Y.
Iimoto, Y. Shibata, & J. R. Harrison (Eds.), Table tennis sciences
(pp. 39). Lausanne: International Table Tennis Federation.
Greenacre, M. J., & Blasius, J. (2006). Multiple correspondence
analysis and related methods. Boca Raton, FL: Chapman & Hall/
CRC.
Greenacre, M. J., & Nenadic, O. (2010). ca: Simple, multiple and
joint correspondence analysis. R package version 0.33. Retrieved from http://CRAN.R-project.org/packageca
Hartigan, J. A., & Kleiner, B. (1981). Mosaics for contingency
tables. In W. F. Eddy (Ed.), Computer science and statistics:
Proceedings of the 13th symposium on the interface (pp. 268273).
New York, NY: Springer-Verlag.
Hohmann, A., Zhang, H., & Koth, A. (2004). Performance
diagnosis through mathematical simulation in table tennis in
left and right handed shakehand and penholder players. In A.
Lees, J. F. Kahn, & I. W. Maynard (Eds.), Science and racket
sports III (pp. 220226). London: Routledge.
Hughes, M. (1998). The application of notational analysis to
racket sports. In A. Lees, I. Maynard, M. Hughes, & T. Reilly
(Eds.), Science and racket sports II (pp. 211220). London: E &
FN Spon.
Hughes, M. D., & Bartlett, R. M. (2002). The use of performance
indicators in performance analysis. Journal of Sports Sciences,
20, 739754. doi:10.1080/026404102320675602
Krippendorff, K. (2004). Contents analysis: An introduction to its
methodology. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Laborde, S., You, M., Dosseville, F., & Salinas, A. (2012).
Culture, individual differences and situation: Influence on
coping in French and Chinese table tennis players. European
Journal of Sport Science, 12, 255261. doi:10.1080/17461391.
2011.566367
317