Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Min urem
Pro
istr ent
c
y o Pro
SP’s
f H ce
• Affa bora
om ss e
iaʼs lem •
TH ela • tsʼ
IS n ID Re
ED d S S fe
ITIO ec He ren
N - urity adq ce -
& uarte Spe
rsʼ cial
role Inse
ONE OF THE KEY SPONSORS OF 3rd INTERNATIONAL ARTILLERY
in rt
AN SP GUIDE P U B L I C AT I O N
LandForces
TECHNOLOGY SEMINAR ORGANISED BY INDIAN ARMY & CII
2008
Coming
2009
�������������������
...shortly
�������������������
2009
2009-2010
2008
edition
ROUNDUP
���������������
���������������
WWW.SPSLANDFORCES.NET
4/20/09 3:20:57 PM
In This Issue T h e O N LY j o u r n a l i n A s i a d e d i c a t e d t o L a n d F o r c e s
Director General The pace of modernisation Real-time imagery is
Artillery Lt General of our infantry has been crucial to our national
K.R. Rao spoke to pathetic. Redtape, lack of security. The initiative
SP’s Land Forces on funds, lack of decisions, perforce will have to be
the modernisation lengthy procurement taken up by the MoD,
efforts of the artillery procedures, barriers MHA and Ministry of
and the conceptual of DRDO and at times Science and Technology
changes being conflicting in-service in conjunction with the
visualised by him in views are contributing military, RAW and IB.
the artillery doctrine. to this.
LT GENERAL (RETD) LT GENERAL (RETD)
2 4 11 P.C. KATOCH
SP’s TEAM P.C. KATOCH
E d i tor ial F ir s t E x c l u s i v e
Lately there has been
a fair amount of dis-
course in the media
and among the army
officers, serving and
retired, regarding the
somewhat unwarranted
media onslaught on
the senior hierarchy of
the army despite the
fact that it was the army itself which had
ordered the Sukna probe. Be that as it may,
now that the matter has been put into the
grinding judicial process it can be unequivo-
cally stated that while no one has gained,
the image of an excellent institution, the
Indian Army, has taken an undeserved beat-
ing. It is in this background that the new
Chief of the Army Staff, General V.K. Singh
has taken over this onerous responsibility.
He faces daunting tasks and challenges.
Foremost among them is the slow pace
of modernisation of the army. The budget
for the army is reducing every year in real
terms and meagre allotments of capital
Challenging
funds followed by surrenders at the end
of each year due to endemic delays in
procurement has a cascading effect which
is affecting the operational effectiveness
of the army. The saga of artillery guns, air
defence guns and missiles, and night fight-
Times Ahead
ing equipment are the cases in point.
The new Chief has an impeccable
professional record and it seems that
Photograph: PIB
A
sonnel, given their expertise, should staff ssumption of command by a These perceptions, coupled with the ing various insurgencies and a proxy war.
the Defence Ministry positions and posi-
new Army Chief is an important prevailing security environment, bring The combat potential of the army is at an
tions in the National Security Council. The
appointment of a one-point advisor in the
event, both for the army and with them overwhelming responsibilities. all-time low of nearly 50 per cent and there
person of a Chief of Defence Staff remains the nation. It is no different for All Army Chiefs have no doubt assumed has hardly been any modernisation in recent
to be done.” It is high time that our politi- General V.K. Singh, the 24th Army Chief command with varying challenges and dis- years. The budget for the army gets reduced
cal leadership become more conscious of of independent India. The importance of tinguished themselves during their tenures. every year in real term; the government con-
these vital issues. commanding the Indian Army is not just Some have done so with panache, while oth- tinues to keep the military out of the policy
because of its size, but more importantly ers could at best be termed as also-ran. formulation loop; the deteriorating civil-mili-
it is the only organisation that has full tary relations do not bode well for the safety
faith in our polity, on account of its profes- Situation and security of the nation; there have been
sional ethos and the alacrity with which it The ground reality is not encouraging. several recent incidents that have tarnished
responds to evolving situations. Nearly half the army is committed to fight- the image of the army and could have been
Lt General (Retd) V.K. Kapoor
Continued on page 3
‘Modernisation
both video and other digital means would
flow for analysis.
is progressing’
nised as force-multipliers in the modern
battlefield and have become important
part of the weapons inventory of many
advanced armies of the world. What are
the plans regarding their induction and
employment and would it become an all
Director General Artillery arms responsibility or will these be held by
the artillery only?
Lt General K.R. Rao spoke Rao: UAVs have already been introduced
into service and we have gained sufficient
to Editor-in-Chief Jayant experience in handling them. Serious
thought is also being given to weaponising
Baranwal and Lt General the existing UAVs, introduction of UCAVs
Photographs: SP Guide Pubns
(Retd) V. K. Kapoor, Editor, SP’s and aerostats in arty to augment the exist-
ing surveillance sensors. There is also a
Land Forces on the modernisation parallel plan to synergise sensors and shoot-
ers. The feasibility of allocation of a different
efforts of the artillery class of UAV to arms other than artillery is
under consideration.
Rao: Based on the directives issued by the rocket and gun ammunition. rately but integrated at formation HQs levels Rao: The ACCCS Shakti equipment is
Chief of the Army Staff, the modernisation by provision of seamless data and voice under induction into field formations in a
programme for Indian Artillery has been put SP’s: The modernisation plan with respect communication network. In this architec- phased manner. At present, some forma-
into motion. Modernisation is an all-round, to battlefield surveillance and target acqui- ture, each artillery weapon platform would tions have been equipped with these equip-
all-encompassing holistic process. It involves sition is progressing well. What are the also become a distributor and a recipient of ment. With the operationalisation of the
improving surveillance and battlefield capabilities that we are trying to acquire? the latest information and in that sense it ACCCS, the command & control of artillery
transparency capability through aerial and Rao: The modern battlefield requires acqui- would be a “Situationally Aware Platform”. has become automated and faster. The
ground-based sensors. It involves develop- sition of targets at longer ranges so that our The weapon platforms link to the observer time required for working out the technical
ment of rockets and missile systems, besides weapon systems can destroy them before at the battlefront, is now added by an auto- data and passage of orders will be reduced.
the guns which are under acquisition. It also they inflict any damage on us. Towards mated architecture. However, on a selective ACCCS will ensure optimisation of resourc-
involves modernising command and control achieving this, we have taken great strides basis, the Fire Control Centre (FCC) at the es and getting the biggest bang for the buck
systems. Some indicators in this direction are with the introduction of state-of-the-art sur- Artillery Brigade Headquarters and above in the shortest time-frame. SP
A Brief Profile of General V.K. Singh avoided; and the regional security environ- Essence of being the Chief
ment is also a cause of concern. Before I offer some unsolicited advice, some
General Vijay Singh has been seen in action in 2001 terror attack on Parliament. There are other negatives points too. home truths have to be stated. The first is the
the liberation War of Bangladesh in 1971 and Singh commanded 2 Corps (Strike Corps)
The media tends to sensationalise events unmatched prestige of the position he holds.
was awarded the Yudh Seva Medal in 1987 in Western Sector, before taking over the
for his distinguished service during ‘Operation command of the Eastern Army in March relating to the army. The pressure built up He must, therefore, concentrate on the good
Pawan’ against the LTTE in Sri Lanka. Singh 2008. He has been the Chief Instructor at by human rights advocates and other do- that he can do for this highly professional
has sizeable operational experience in coun- JLW (Commando Wing) at Belgaum and has gooders to scrap or modify the Armed Forces organisation and not be distracted by both
ter-insurgency operations, LC, LAC and in high also served as an Instructor at the Indian (Special Powers) Act continues. The status the mundane and the motivated.
altitude warfare. Military Training Team (IMTRAT) headquarters of army personnel continues to be on a Exemplary leadership and reaching
While in command of a counter-insurgency in Bhutan. downward spiral, adversely affecting morale. out to his command, to ameliorate their
force in Jammu & Kashmir, Singh was awarded The General was awarded the Param
the Ati Vishisht Seva Medal for his distinguished Vishisht Seva Medal by the President of India
Shortage of officers continues at high levels. concerns, are of essence. He must not get
service as General Officer Commanding. on the eve of Republic Day 2009 in recognition The resentment of veterans is palpable on bogged down in matters of detail and thus
Singh also served in the Military Operations of his exceptional and distinguished services. account of the attitude of the government to miss the woods for the trees. The Chief ’s
Directorate at the Army Headquarters and Singh is a graduate of the Defence Services their long-pending demand of one rank one appointment is matchless in the affection it
was Brigadier General Staff of a Corps dur- Staff College, Wellington, besides that of the pension (OROP). Even war-disabled veterans, generates from his vast command as well as
ing ‘Operation Parakram’ when troops were US Army Rangers Course at Fort Benning, and now increasingly referred to as the ”living from the other two services, the entire vet-
mobilised on the border in the wake of the the US Army War College, Carlisle.
dead,” are resentful of being neglected. eran fraternity and civil society.
Modernisation
The real test of any army lies in its
potency and not in sheer numbers.
The numbers are important in some
situations, but it is technology that
wins the day when two conventional
forces fight a war. The Indian Army
needs extensive modernisation at
a fast pace. The reasons are well
known, but two major ones are
tight-fisted budgetary support, and
archaic and cumbersome procure-
ment procedures. Even the little that
the army gets as its modernisation
budget remains unspent on account
of procedural blocks by the bureau-
cracy and is unspent every year.
Lack of modernisation has
resulted in a continuous drop in the
combat potential of the army and
steady loss of ground to our poten-
tial adversaries. The Chief now
needs to step in and push for mod-
ernisation. Bureaucracy may have
to be bypassed and the political
leadership urged to understand the
importance of rapid modernisation.
Transformation
Although the army has been tinker-
ing with its structures periodically,
no major transformation has taken
place. It has remained static, both
structurally and in doctrinal terms,
ignoring the changing face of war
and the advent of non-state actors
even in state-to-state conflicts. For
plains and desert sectors, we contin-
ue to field huge and ponderous corps-
size formations and plan to employ
our mechanised formations in clas-
sical tank battles, notwithstanding
our past experiences and the changes
in terrain. In the mountains, we are
content to be in a largely defensive
mode, with little mobility. Of the two
decisive entities for future conflicts,
we still have no special forces and
have only para-commandos. Army
aviation continues to stagnate.
Transformation requires vision,
sufficient resources, and moving
away from the status quo mentality.
Transformation includes optimisation
of doctrine and concepts, restructur-
Continued on page 6
Photograph: www.natick.army.mil
I
nfantry has traditionally been the anti-terrorism (both rural and urban),
Queen of Battle. While the impor- internal security (IS), disaster manage-
tance of the man behind the machine ment and in contending with new forms
or weapon requires no debating, of unconventional warfare besides regular
conflict situations like terrorism, asym- deployment in varied terrain along our
metric and fourth generation wars, as borders and in UN missions. Future Soldier programme of the US Army Natick Soldier Centre
prevailing in Iraq and Afghanistan, have At present, the IA lacks an integrated
heightened their importance even more. system at the cutting edge; an integration
At the same time, rapid advances in infor- tool supporting individual soldier to bat- with the legacy communication equipment, 4B had to be shared with the RR battalions
mation technology are revolutionising talion group/combat group Commander retrofitted into combat platforms and scal- that needed the same urgently because of
methods of fighting. Situational aware- in the Tactical Battle Area (TBA) that can able to ensure its availability to all elements their permanent deployments in J&K but
ness, information dominance, jointness, provide in near real time an appropriate, ranging from man-portable to fit in combat were not authorised such equipment and
net-centricity, standoff precision weapons common and comprehensive tactical pic- vehicles. The technology being sought is weapons till end 2009; a typical example of
are the buzzwords, requiring a transformed ture by integrating inputs from all elements. mostly available in the world market and extreme bureaucratic intransigence. There
infantryman capable of dealing with hi- Situational awareness is ad-hoc and so is the indigenous industry has the competence have been improvements in the Mechanised
technology war that will be short and the common operating picture (COP). To to meet system requirements. However, Infantry. The BMP-2 ICV and the 81 mm
intense besides contending with fleeting bridge this gap, the IA has planned field- the project would involve customisation, Carrier Mortar Tracked Vehicle (CMTV) are
opportunities provided by terrorists/non- ing of the BMS at Battalion Group/Combat integration and testing (laboratory and field getting fielded but complete equipping of all
state actors/state sponsored non-state Group level and below as part of capability conditions), validation, fielding and eventual Mechanised Infantry units will take many
actors, who are becoming more and more building. This would enable a faster decision equipping. In Phase 1, integration of the years.
sophisticated. Today’s infantryman has process by commanders at all echelons, bet- system, establishment of the test bed lab and The F-INSAS programme, which is to
to be a man-machine-technology mix, a ter the decision due to reliable operational field trials at test bed location (one combat ensure a dramatic increase in lethality, sur-
weapon platform with adequate firepower, information provided in real time and ability group and three infantry battalion groups) vivability and mobility while making the
self-protection, night fighting capability to quickly close the sensor to shooter loop. originally planned by 2012 is delayed by infantry soldier “a self-contained fighting
and mobility. He should have the ability to The BMS is to be integrated with other com- more than nine months due to indecision machine”, is based on the Land Warrior
“see” the enemy or adversary much before ponents of the Tactical Command, Control, on delimitation between the BMS and the system of the US Army and Future Soldier
he himself gets spotted and be networked Communications and Information (Tac C3I) F-INSAS. This self-inflicted delay will have programmes of other nations. This is to
to the required level, enabling him to effec- System through the Command Information cascading effect on subsequent phases of the be developed in three phases: Phase 1 (by
tively respond to any situation in real/near and Decision Support System (CIDSS) . BMS project; Phase II under which equip- 2012) comprising weapons, body armour,
real time. Through the BMS, the IA wants to pro- ping was to be undertaken by 2017 and clothing and individual equipment, Phase
The pace of modernisation of our infan- vide a command and control system span- Phase III comprising change management II comprising the target acquisition system
try has actually been pathetic. Red tape, ning the TBA spreading across individuals, and upgradation of the system originally and Phase III comprising the computer
lack of funds, lack of decisions, lengthy pro- detachments, combat platforms, sensors, sub planned for completion by 2022. sub system, radio sub system, software
curement procedures, barriers of Defence units, units to the Battalion Commander/ and software integration. F-INSAS will
Research & Development Organisation Regiment Commander; achieve faster reac- Infantry Modernisation provide the infantryman with latest weap-
(DRDO) and at times conflicting in-service tion capability and flexibility in command It was very evident to the IA deployed as onry, communication network and instant
views are all contributing to this. Lack and control by providing information auto- part of the Indian Peace Keeping Force access to information on the battlefield. It
of proper equipping and modernisation matically in the right place at the right time, (IPKF) in Sri Lanka that the Sri Lankan will include a fully networked all-terrain,
implies not only depleted combat efficiency thereby compressing the OODA loop; provide infantry soldier was far better equipped all-weather personal-equipment platform,
but also avoidable casualties to our soldiers. a strong foundation for making decisions in comparison to its Indian counterpart enhanced firepower and mobility for the
There is an urgent need for speedy and based on near real time, consistent and well in every aspect from head to toe, be it the digitalised battlefield of the future. The
“packaged equipping” of the infantry, not- structured information, thereby enhancing helmet, combat dress, web equipment, belt, infantryman will be equipped with mis-
withstanding the media blitz concerning the information handling capability of com- boots, raincoat/poncho, personnel weapon, sion-oriented equipment integrated with
the Futuristic Infantry Soldier As a System manders at all levels; strengthening informa- quality of maps, etc. Had the LTTE not been his buddy soldier team, the sub-unit, as
(F-INSAS) and Battlefield Management tion exchange by having a strong messaging fighting with the AK-47/ AK-56, perhaps also the overall command, control, com-
System (BMS) which still are a couple of and replication mechanism; improving and our infantry would have even continued munications computers, information and
years away and appear to be getting unduly modernising presentation of information in with the 7.62 mm SLR. The situation has Intelligence (C4I2) system. Complete field-
delayed further. near real time; integrating with other com- improved somewhat since then but only ing in all infantry and RR units is likely to
mand and control system. slightly. Modification 4B to the war estab- be completed by 2020 or so.
Battlefield Management The BMS is to be a highly mobile inte- lishment (WE) of a Standard Infantry
System BMS-FINSAS Impasse
WWW.SPSLANDFORCES.NET
grated system with a high data rate, com- Battalion was approved in 1998, but is yet
The success in future military opera- prising a Tactical Hand Held Computer with to be implemented in all infantry battalions. The BMS and F-INSAS programmes are
tions will require a telescoped decision- individual soldiers and Tactical Computers This programme is to give more firepower to be developed concurrently; BMS under
action cycle and the ability to conduct at Battle Group Headquarters and combat and night capability to the Infantry includ- information systems and F-INSAS under
operations simultaneously within an all vehicles employing application and database ing improved anti-tank guided missiles the infantry. BMS was conceived at bat-
arms group. This is very pertinent at the servers connected on a data enabled com- (ATGMs) with night capability, battlefield talion/regiment level pan army (includ-
“Cutting Edge”; in the 400 odd Infantry munication network, enabling a COP by surveillance radars (BFSRs), hand held ing for the infantry) and comprises of
and Rashtriya Rifles (RR) battalions of the integrating inputs from all relevant sources thermal imaging (HHTIs) devices, individu- communication, non-communication
Indian Army (IA), not counting the Assam within a battle group by integrated use of al night sights, disposable rocket launchers, hardware and software. The lowest level
Rifles (AR) and Infantry Territorial Army GIS and GPS. The communications are to anti-material rifles (AMRs), under-barrel to which the system will be connected
(TA) battalions deployed in counter insur- optimally utilise the bandwidth available grenade launchers (UBGLs), sniper rifles, is the individual soldier / weapon plat-
gency (CI), low intensity conflict (LIC), for military communications, not interfere etc. The procurements under Modification form and highest level with Battalion/
Continued on page 13
ing of the field force, efficient management of even after over six decades of loyal, patriotic
sub-conventional conflicts, upgrading human and dedicated service to the nation, in both war ‘Army must heal itself’
resources, streamlining logistics and modernis- and peace, it is obvious that it is still not trusted.
ing the training methodology of the army. For Nothing else explains the reasons for its exclu- India’s new Army Chief General Vijay Kumar
obtaining resources, the army has to convince sion from policy formulations, but the inability Singh is straight off the blocks with a call to his
1.13-million-strong force to restore its “internal
the political leadership, as well as the people, of to evolve a viable and comprehensive structure
health”. In first exclusive with SP’s Consulting
the legitimacy of its needs. Defence allocations for higher defence, the pending appointment of Editor Vishal Thapar, General Singh indicated a
needs to be increased. Our slow decision making a CDS, accepted nearly a decade back, and the key redline—the army’s unwillingness to
system and processes also needs to change. non-integration of the Ministry of Defence. function in disturbed areas without the
Soon after Independence, the hierarchy of Armed Forces Special Powers Act.
Internal Issues the army had deliberately decided that it would
Let me now shift from policy issues to in-house be scrupulously apolitical. It has remained SP Guide Publications (SP’s): Congratulations on
issues of the army. My first suggestion is to shift so all these years, despite democracies falling taking over command of the world’s second largest
to the ”directive style of command” from the like nine pins all around us. The army has not Army. You have indicated that your first priority
prevailing “detailed orders command,” which only upheld democracy, it has also contributed is to attend to the internal health of the Army. What has gone wrong, and
curbs the initiative and loads successive leader- greatly to the stability of the nation and its what needs to be mended?
ship levels with too much work and unnecessary democratic norms. It has fought the enemies of Chief of Army Staff (COAS): Nothing has gone wrong. All that I want to do is
responsibility. This will entail radical reforms of the nation loyally, and won for itself the affec- boost our core values. We have our own procedures. We have our own traditions. I
our training systems and regimental upbringing, tion of all countrymen. It is thus difficult to want to strengthen them. That’s what constitutes the internal health of the Army.
as also reduced stress on minor issues of detail. understand why it is not trusted by our leaders. This will ensure that we provide the required dignity to the soldiers and we can
For success, the army will have to shed its antipa- A related issue is that our political leaders improve our own image.
thy to change, hesitancy to take risks, status quo either do not understand the true meaning of
mentality, and doubts about the ability of their “civil control” or find it easier not to understand SP’s: We have been told for quite some time now that the situation in Jammu
subordinates to execute the assigned tasks. it. Civil control implies the supremacy of the polit- and Kashmir and the Northeast is militarily stable. This has invigorated the
Senior officers are custodians of our value ical leadership over the military. It has nothing to political and public demand in these areas for a re-look at the Armed Forces
systems. All ranks look up to them for setting do with the civil bureaucracy as both military and (Special Powers) Act. Is the Army ready for a re-look?
an example. Lately, there have been too many civil officials are equally under civil control. The COAS: The Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act has been created to provide certain
cases of misdemeanours by senior officers. political leadership must deal with the military legal safeguards to people who are operating in these areas. The day you do not
Urgent actions need to be taken to ensure that directly, just as they do with the bureaucracy and want the Army to be operating out there, it can be taken out. But till that time, we
these do not reoccur. The army does have strin- not through the latter, which is the case now. The are operating, we feel, and that’s been our stand, that we need those safeguards.
gent norms for promotions and only the best Army Chief with the support of the other Chiefs
get through successfully. However, to weed out must endeavour to convince the political leader- SP’s: The Delhi High Court has recently ordered permanent commission for
the few whose motivational levels may have ship to bury this shibboleth for good. women officers in the armed forces. Is the Army ready for this, or will it have to
changed, there needs to be greater emphasis on wait till cultural and organisational changes are brought about to enable it?
character qualities in standards of selection for Conclusion COAS: Induction of women has been a very gradual process. There are lots of
higher leadership. Qualities such as integrity, While there is both affection and pride for the things that have to be taken into consideration whereever women are inducted. In
moral strength, intellectual ability and honesty, new Army Chief, there are also great expecta- the same breath, I would like to say that whatever our women officers have done,
self-discipline, and social as well as domestic tions from him by both the army and the nation. they have done a very good job so far. This case is under detailed examination.
probity or rectitude needs to be looked at in He will undoubtedly deliver, but he will also
detail along with professional competence. need all our support over the next two years. SP’s: Does this mean that it’s going to take some time?
The Chief must command with three aims— COAS: Overall, the process does take time because lots of things have to be
Civil-Military Relations making the army a powerful organisation in all taken into consideration. It is not as if you press the switch and say, tomorrow, I
In democracies the world over, the political lead- respects; alleviating the concerns of all personnel want A, B & C. It is a long process because it also has to take into account what
ership makes national policy and the national of the army and the veterans, and bringing the the A.V. Singh Committee said. SP
security strategy. This is done with the active par- fun back into the army, keeping in mind the old
ticipation of civil and military officials. However, adage “a happy army is a powerful army.” SP An exhaustive interview with COAS will
in our country, the military has been deliberately follow in the successive editions of SP’s Land Forces
kept out of the policy formulation loop and The writer is a former Vice Chief of the Indian Army.
www.spslandforces.net
�
�����
SP’s
���
� ���
����� �
�
�����
��
�
�����
�
����������
���������������
Procureme
Ministry nt Process
�������������
of Home elaborated
• Indiaʼs Elements
���������������
Affairs
IN THIS
��
����
Homeland• IDS Reference
��������������
EDITIONSecurity
�
���
• Eventsʼ
� �����
������
-
�� ����
��
LandForces.net
Headquart - Special
&
��
�����������
���������� ���������
���
��� �
ersʼ role Insert
���
SP's
MYB ��������� ���
0809
����
������������
���
CVR01.indd
��
in
����������
������
1
���
������
�����
������� ������ � ��
��������
��� ���
����
������
��� ���
2009
��
������200
������ �
������8
��
������
��
��
�
20 ��
���
200
��
������08
�������� ��
����
���������� ��
����
�� �����
9
����
���� ���� ��
��
��� ���
��� ��
�� �����
�� ��� ��������� � ���
��� ��� ����� ����
��� ��� ����
��� ��
��� ��� �����
���
���
�� ���� ��� �����
� ����� ����� ����
�� ����� ���� ���
��
��� ��� ������ ���
��� �� ���� ���� ������
������ ����
�� ��������� �� �� 4/20/09
�� ���� �����
��
3:20:57
�� ������ ���
���� �����������
��������� ������� �� �� ��
�� ������������� ����� ��� ���� ���
�����
������ �� ������ ������ ��
��� ������
����
����� ������������ ������
��� ���
��
������ ����� ����������� � ���
��� ��������� ���� ��� ��
� ��� ������ � ��
��� ���
������ ����� ���
��
��� �� � ��� ��
�� ������ ������
��
�� ���
��� ��� ������ �����
���
�� ��� ������ �������� ��� ��� ��
��� ��� ��
�� ��
�� �
��� ������ ��������
��������� ��� ���������� ��
��� ��
��� ��� ���
��
���
����� �� ��� ����������� �� ��
����� �������������������� ��
��� ������ ��� ����������� ��
�� ��
�� ����� ��������
�
���
������ ������ � ����� �
��� ������ ������
���
����
��� ���� ������ �����
��� ������
���
��� ���
��� ���
������ ��� ������
������ ����
��� � �� ���
��������� ������������� ���� ��
�� � �� ���� ����� ������ ��� ������
������ ������� ������ �� ��
�� �� �� �� ��� ���������� �������
��� ������ ������ ��
��� �� � �� ����� ��������������� ��
�� ����� ������ ������������ ���
���
���� ������ ��� ����� ��� ����� �
T h e O N LY j o u r n a l i n A s i a d e d i c a t e d t o L a n d F o r c e s
���
���
������� ���
��� ��� ����� ����� ����� ��� ����� ����
��� ������ ������ ������ ������ ������������� ������ ����� ����� ��� ��� ��
��� ���
������ ������ ���� ����� ����� ���
��� ������ �� ����� ������ �������
������� ����� ����� ������ �������� ������ ��
������������� ������ ����� �������� �
��� ���� ��� �����������
���
��� ��� ��� ��� ���� �����
�� ��� ��� ��� ��� �� ���
���
������ ������ ������� ������� ���
��� ���� ���������
��� ��� ��� ��� � ����
���� �� ��� ������ ������ ������ �
������ ������� ������ ��
��� �������� ������ ������ �
��� ������ ������ ���
��� ������ �������� ��
��� ���
����� ����������� ��� ���
���
�������
��� ���
��� ������ ������ ������ ������ ������ ��
��
����� ������������ ������ ������ ������ ����
��� ���
������ ������ ������������ ������ ������ ��
���
����� ����� ������ ������ ������ ������� ���
��
��� �
����� ��� ������ �����
��� ������
��� ������� ������ ������� ������� ����������
���
����� ������ ������ ������ ������ �
��� ������
���
��� ��� ������
������ ����� ������ ������ ���� ������
��� ��� ���
����� ������ ������ ����� ������� ����� ���
����� ����� ������� ������ ������� �����
��� �� �
site highlights
����� ����� ������������ ������� ������
�������� ����� ����� �� ������ ������
�� ��� ��� �� ���
������ ����� ������� ������ �������� ����
•��Read
������ �����
�� ��� �����
��
����� ����� �
�����
���
����� ������� ������ ����� ����� ��� �
�� ���
����
���
������ ������ ����� ����� ����� ������� ����
����
���
����� ������ ������ ������ ������ �������� �
�� ��
������ ���� ���� ����� ����� ����� ����
���� ���
����� ������ ������ �������� ������ ����� ��
���� ��� ����� ����� ��
��
��� ��� ���
���� ��� ���� ��� ���
������ ���������������� ����� ������ ������
���� ���
������ ����� ������ ����
������������ ������ ������ ����� ������
���
���
���
����� ���� ���
��� ������ ���
��� ����� ��� ��� �����
• Download ebook
��� ��� ���
������ ������ ������ ������ ������� �����
��
����� ������� ����
��� �� ��� �� ��
��� ��� �� ����
������ ����� ����� ������ ��������� ����� ����
�
��
��� ����� ��������
������ ���
��� �� ��� ��
�� ��� ���
��� ��� ��� ��� ����
��� �� ��� �� ��
��� ������ ������
������ ������ ������ ����� ������ �����
��� ������
�� ��
����� ���� ��� ��� ���
�� ���
����� ����� ����� �
��� ���
���� �� ��
��� ����� ����� ������ �����
��� ����� ���� �� �� ��
��� ���� ������
��� ����� ��� ���� � �����
��
��
���
�� � �
��� ������ ����� ������ �����
�� �� ��� ��� �� ��� ��
�� ��� ������ ������ ������ ��� ������ ������
�����
����
��� ���
���������� ����� ������� ������ ����� �
��
����
�� ��� ����� ���� ���
���� ����� ������ ������� ������ ����� ������ ��� � ��
�� ��� ������ �����
� ���� ������� � ��
����
����� ������� ������ ����� �������� ����� ����� ������
�� ����
���
���� ������ �
���
���� ������ ����� ������������ ������ ����� ������ �� ����� ������� ������
��� ��� ��
��� ����� ����� ����� ����� ����� ����� � � ����� ����� ������ ������
� � � � � � � � � ���� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ���� � ��
��� ���
SP'
����� ������ ������ ������ ����� ��������� � � ��������� ������� ����� ������ �� ���������������������������������
Minist ement
s Lan
Procur
������� �� �� ������
��
of
����
dFo
Home s
��
• Affairs ated
��� ��
Indiaʼs Eleme
IN Home nts Events
rces
����� ������ �� ������ ��
THIS land • ʼ
02-
���
N - ty
����� �������� ����� ������ ���� ������ ����� ����� ���� �������������������������������������������������������
in
������������ � � � � � � � �� � � �
����� �����
����������
�� ����� ���� ��������������� ������ ����� ��� ����������� ��������
�������������������������������������������������
������ ����� ������ �������
� �����
������
������ ������ � ��� ������ ����� ������ ���
��� ���
������ ������ ��� ��� ��� ������ ������� �������������� �����
� �������
������2008
�������
�����
������ ������ �������� ������ ������ ����� ����
2009
�������������������
���������� ��� ����
�������������������
� ������
2008
��
SP's MYB 0809 CVR01.indd 1 � ��
�� � � ��� ���� � 4/20/09 3:20:57 PM
�� �
� � � � � � � ��
����
�������������� �� ����
�� � � � ����
� ����
��������������������������������������
��
��
�
����������������� �� �������������������������� ���������������������
��������������������� ������������������������� ������������������������
������������������������ ��������������������������� �������������������������
������������������� �������������������������� �������������������������
���������������������� �������������������� ���������������������
4/21
������������������������� /10 ��������������������� ��������������������
������������������� 5:49 ���������������������
:38
PM
�����������������������
������������������������ ����������������������� ������������������������
�������������������������� ������������������������ ���������������������
��������
������������������� �������������������
� ��������� � �� �����������
������������
Community ���������
����������������������
���������������������
��������������������
�������������������
����������������������
������ ���������
�����������������������
���������������������
�������������������
������������������������
���������������������
�������������������������������������������
��������������������������������������������
������������������������������������������
���������������������������������������������
�������������������������������������������
�������������������������������������������
������������������������������������������
�������������������������������������������
Join us on Facebook
��������������������������������������������
��������������������������������������������
����������������������������������������
�������������������������������������
�����������������������������������������
��������������������������������������������
���������������������������������������
������������
����������������������������������������
��������������������������������������
�����������������������������������������
�������������������������������������������
���������������������������������������������
�������������������������������������������
�����������
��������������������������������������
��������������������������������
��������������������������������������
���������������
�����������������������������������������
������������������������������������������
������������������������������������������
������������������������������������������
����������������������������������������
���������������������������������������������
��������������������������������������������������
Join us on Linkedin
�����������������������������������������
�����������������������������������������
�����������������������������������������������������������
��������������������������������������
������������������������������������������
���������������������������������������������������������
���������������������������������������� �������������������������������������������������������
�������������������������������������������
�������������������������������������������� ���������������������������������
�����������������������������������������������
����������������������������������������
������������������������������������������� ������������������������������
���������������������������������������������
�
�������������������������������������������� ������������ �������������� ������������������������������������ ������������������������������������������
����������������������������������������
�������������� ����������������� ��������������������������������������� ����������������������� �������������������
��������������������������������������������
������������������������������������������
����������������������������� ����������������������������������������� ��������������� ������������������������������
������������������������������������������� ����������������������������������� �������������������������������������� ��������������������������������������������
The Chief must aim at making the army a powerful organisation in all
��������������������������������������������� ��������������������������������������� � ���������������������������������������� ��������������������������������������������
���������������������������������������� �� ������������������������������������� � �������������������������������������������� ��������������������������������������������
�������������������� ��������������������������������������� ������������������������������������������ ���������������������������������� ������������
���������� �������������������������������� ����������������������������������������� �����������������������������������������������
������������������������������������������ �����������������������������������������������
���������������������������������� ������������ ��������� ��������������� �����������������������������
Follow us on Twitter respects; alleviating the concerns of all personnel of the army and veterans;
�������������������������������������������� ��������������������������������������� ���������������������������������������������
��������������������������������� ����������� �������������������������������� ������������ ������������������������������
�����������������������������
� �������������������
� � �� � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �� ��
and bringing the fun back into the army, keeping in mind the old adage ‘a
WWW.SPSLANDFORCES.NET
Over 16000
ow
o AS MY
Channel views in
• N TO AR
a month
en
P
N
m
es EER IA
64 Videos
D
co
CA E IN
&
Fresh videos
ll
TH
po
•Y R
additions every day ITT opens office in New Delhi Exclusive April Calendar
6
IS
www.harris.com
RF Communications • Government Communications Systems • Broadcast Communications
A n al ysis functionaries must be held accountable by Notwithstanding, the requirements of the
the Parliamentary Committees. services are vast and wide ranging. Some of
T
budget stood at Rs 1,14,600 crore, scaled just Rs 17 crore. In the case of the Indian Air them within the country. Another area of
he security threats and challenges upward by Rs 9,000 crore (8.52 per cent). Force, its allocation of Rs 15,210.73 crore is inadequacy is the air defence (AD) of field for-
facing India have increased enor- Compared to the RE figure, the increase in Rs 992 crore higher than the Rs14,318.83 mations. Nearly, all equipment in the army’s
mously. While the old adversarial the budget was 23.65 per cent. For the year crore allocated for the previous fiscal, which air defence inventory needs replacement.
threats due to unresolved borders 2010-11, defence has been allocated Rs 1, was later raised to Rs 14,681 crore at the RE Most of the equipment is 30-40 years old.
remain, new threats and challenges have 47,344 crore, a marginal increase of 3.98 stage. The ordnance factories have been allo- Simultaneously, there is a need for equipping
also added to the old inventory. Terrorism per cent over the BE of 2009-2010 and 8.13 cated only Rs 24,619 crore which is because our infantry and Special Forces with new
in all its varieties and forms is a palpable per cent from the RE. The outlay for Defence at the RE stage they were given Rs 2,187.32 assault rifles, carbines and modern surveil-
threat as India also faces insurgencies comprises of Rs 87,344 for revenue expendi- crore against a planned allotment of only Rs lance devices and software driven (SDR)
generated both externally and internally. ture and Rs 60,000 crore for capital expendi- 8,32.94 crore at the beginning of the fiscal communications equipment. Tactical com-
Likewise, proxy war in Jammu & Kashmir ture as declared by the Defence Minister. The year 2009-2010. The Defence Research and munications need to be upgraded for field
fostered and supported in all respects by details of comparison at the BE stage, are as Development Organisation (DRDO) has got formations as that will form the backbone
Pakistan, continues unabated. explained below: a hike of Rs 881 crore to Rs 5,230.42 crore structure for the C4ISR system when it is
It is a well-known fact that building mili- from its revised allocation (RE) of Rs 4,349 established. Hence, there is no dearth of proj-
tary capability is a long-term exercise which Capital Budget crore in the previous fiscal. Compared to the ects in the army which needs to be funded.
depends not only on the level of expenditure, The Capital budget has been increased by Rs Budget allocation of Rs 4757.67 crore, the Cruise and ballistic missile capability also
but on a holistic plan which presents stage- 12,176 crore over the RE figure of Rs 47,824 increase is Rs 472.75 crore, 9.9 per cent over needs enhancement all of which will require
wise milestones of capability development. crore allotted in 2009-2010 which in per- the previous fiscal. additional funding.
Thus, defence expenditure is linked to long centage terms works out to 25.4 per cent, as The IAF is in dire need of multi-role combat
term planned expenditure, based on the Rs 7,000 crore was returned from the origi- Modernisation Plans of the aircraft to fill the vacuum that already exists.
emerging challenges and threats, trends in nal allotment of Rs 54,824 crore. Had the Armed Forces They have been reduced to the strength of
warfare, induction of new technologies and entire amount been allocated/ spent then the Modernisation of the armed forces is not about 30 squadrons from its earlier strength
new methods of warfighting, depending on current increase amounts to only Rs 5,176 keeping pace with the changing security of 39 and half squadrons. IAF is also in the
the nature of future conflicts. Hence, military crore which is a meagre 9.44 per cent over environment of India’s immediate and stra- urgent need of radars to cover the gaps exist-
expenditure for capability building is associ- the BE allocation of 2009-2010. The rev- tegic neighbourhood. New challenges have ing in our western and northern borders
ated with a wide range of issues. The other enue allocation has increased only by 0.5 per already emerged while the old threats from and air defence missiles. They also require
factors which impinge on building a military cent. Thus with the return/non-allocation of traditional adversaries remain. Hence, India replacing the surface- to-air-missiles to pro-
capability include the voids in the inventory Rs 7,000 at the RE stage, the statement by needs to prepare itself for the full spectrum of vide satisfactory air defence in vulnerable
of equipment and munitions of each service, the Finance Minister, “Needless to say, any warfare ranging from low intensity conflict areas and vulnerable points. The percentage
the revenue to capital ratios, indigenous additional requirement for the security of the involving counter-insurgency and counter- of precision munitions is also inadequate for
research and development and manufactur- nation will be provided for” seems meaning- terrorist operations to conventional conflicts anticipated conflicts in the future.
ing capabilities, import content, the technol- less. Merely allocating the budgetary resourc- under the nuclear shadow. The dilemma is The Indian Navy requires long range air
ogy and performance of acquired weapon es will not make any difference so long as regarding the extent of emphasis that should defence and anti-missile defence (AMD)
systems, their lifetime support, interoperabil- we continue with our archaic bureaucratic be laid to acquiring each type of capability. capability; long range anti-surface warfare
ity with other systems in use within the three procedures which are neither transparent
services, and the efficiency of the equipment nor efficient. Given the size of Indian Armed
in local geographical environment, etc. Forces, no country in the world can provide 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11
Considering the challenges confronting India’s requirements at a short notice, while
India, the defence budget announced by our indigenous production agencies and • Defence budget (BE Stage) 1,05,600 1,41,703 1,47,344
the Finance Minister in the Parliament on our Defence Research and Development • Growth of defence budget (%) 10.00 34.19 3.98
February 26, 2010, seems too modest to Organisation (DRDO) cannot cater to our • Revenue expenditure (Rs in crores) 57,593 86,879 87,344
ensure either modernisation or indulge in the needs currently, despite their rhetorical skills. • Share of revenue expenditure (%) 54.54 61.31 59.23
long-term capability building exercise. The At the time when the IAF does not have • Growth of Revenue expenditure (%) 6.50 50.85 0.5
defence budget over the last three decades adequate number of fighter aircraft, the IN
• Capital expenditure (Rs in crores) 48,007 54,824 60,000
has varied between 2-3 per cent of the GDP, does not have a credible carrier borne task
• Share of capital expenditure (%) 45.46 38.69 40.77
which corresponds to 13-17 per cent of the force or an effective submarine force, and
central government expenditure. The annual the IA does not even have adequate artillery, • Growth of capital expenditure (%) 14.51 14.20 9.44
increase has varied from as low as 3 per cent assurances of this nature are merely concilia- Note: All figures are in rupees.
to a high of 34 per cent as witnessed last tory noises. No one seems to be impressed by
year. This time, it has been pegged at 2.12 India’s claims of being a rising military power
per cent of the GDP. Historically, the resource anymore and hence Indian adversaries are Defence budget (Comparision)
allocation strategy of the government has getting bolder by the day. Asymmetric wars
appeared to be incrementally driven by the waged against the nation are a result of lack
147,344
need to replace the obsolescent equipment of suitable military deterrence against such
141,703
es for all central government employees in If we assume that nearly 80 per cent of the 120000
accordance with the Sixth Pay Commission capital budget is meant for capital acquisi-
87,344
86,879
report. As far as building a military capability tions, with 60 per cent of committed liabili-
is concerned, despite all the rhetoric of the ties and 40 per cent for new schemes, then 90000
WWW.SPSLANDFORCES.NET
need for capability based defence budgeting the main sub-divisions of the capital budget
60,000
54,824
still employing the same old methods with an • Total capital budget : Rs 60,000 crore
48,007
60000
element of superficial sophistication brought • Capital acquisition : Rs 48,000 crore
in by the integrated defence staff. • Committed liabilities : Rs 28,800 crore
• New schemes : Rs 19,200 crore
Budget Details and its Impact In view of the above, while the money 30000
Last year, the defence budget stood at 2.35 may not be enough, the expenditure of even
per cent of the GDP, an increase by 34.19 per this meager amount may be difficult unless
cent over the previous year’s budget estimate we radically improve our methodology 0
(BE) of Rs 1, 05,600 crore. However, at the and hold our officials and political leaders Total (At BE stage) Revenue Expenditure Capital Expenditure
revised estimate (RE) stage of 2008-09, the responsible for lapse of funds. The senior
Continued on page 12
It’s not just Britain that trusts us to deliver. Our major international
partnerships are delivering tailored Battle Management Systems for
our customers worldwide.
www.generaldynamics.uk.com
P r o cur ement
T
he L1 or “lowest bid” factor has fact that our economic prosperity hinges on equipment for the defence services. An
ruled the roost in defence pro- Stagnation of defence national security. example is the hand-held light weight
curements in India since times modernisation over the Laser Target Designators for our Special
immemorial. It is but natural that Defence Procurements Forces, the RFP for which was floated
countries, especially the cash-strapped past successive years has The responses to challenges facing us needs some 8-9years back, but the critical
developing ones, take the L1 factor into serious ramifications for to be addressed in a focused and credible equipment is still not provisioned since
account in order to optimise defence acqui- manner, but how does one decide on defence the L1 vendor had failed to deliver in the
sitions and modernise their armed forces. national security procurements? The bureaucrats would say first instance.
At the same time, should we let the L1 fac- that the defence services have their own long
tor continue to be a major decisive factor term integrated procurement plans (LTIPP). What is Required?
for defence procurements for the Indian unsettled relationships with its neighbours, Fair enough, but from where has this We urgently need the following:
defence forces when globally it is acknowl- fractious nature of its polity, nuclear pro- LTIPP emanated. Should this not be from a • Formulation and issue of a National
edged that technological advances have liferation, jihadist terrorism, comparatively National Security Strategy? Logic would say Security Strategy (NSS).
revolutionised warfare and technological low levels of human security, technology yes but we do not have a National Security • A LTIPP based on the NSS.
superiority will be a major battle winning and poverty index. Obama’s Af-Pak policy Strategy despite having a National Security • Allocation of adequate defence budget
factor in future? Should we blindly submit is arming Pakistan to the hilt and the Advisor (NSA), the Cabinet Committee on in accordance with the NSS and the
to the British legacy of L1 bids, deluding unethical China-Pak collusion as also the Security (CCS), the Cabinet Committee on LTIPP.
ourselves under the pretext of being “cash- aggressiveness of China is ominous. Political Affairs (CCPA) and the National • Appointment of a Chief of Defence
strapped” when annually thousands of Security Council (NSC), notwithstanding the Staff to ensure implementation and
crores of the defence budget is being sur- Military Modernisation ongoing turf war between the NSA and the monitoring of the NSS and LTIPP in the
rendered coupled with the increasingly wid- Our Ministry of Defence is the only Home Ministry. The reason for not having defence services.
ening gap in RMA (Revolution in Military Ministry that regularly surrenders part of a National Security Strategy is simple, for it • Decentralisation (in stages) of defence
Affairs) led combat capabilities between the defence budget annually, advertently or will usher in accountability by the govern- expenditure to the services from exist-
India and China, the requirement to be pre- inadvertently to permit diversion of funds ment and the bureaucracy. ing bureaucratic controls.
pared for a two-front/two and a half front elsewhere. The government needs to realise Our archaic and labyrinthine bureau- • Prohibit surrender of funds for defence
war and the continuing retrograde defence that this practice is at the cost of national cratic procedures further add to the woes modernisation, usher in bureaucratic
modernisation trends in India over the last security and that lack of modernisation of the defence forces. The tortoise will accountability and permit carry forward
decade? Prudence demands that not only results in avoidable loss of life albeit lives consider itself a speedster compared to of unexpended funds to next financial
should we review the significance of the L1 may have little value to some in India. Last movement of defence procurement case year.
factor but perhaps replace it with the “best year, Rs 7,000 crore from the defence bud- files. When annually a part of the defence • Institute standing Empowered
technology bid” factor. get was surrendered. As always, this sur- funds get surrendered, the critics smirk Committees for procurement of critical
rendered portion of the defence budget was and say, “Why do you need more alloca- equipment in a time bound manner.
Future Warfare from the capital budget of the MoD meant tions?” Despite the annual fanfare of a new • Replace the Best Bid/L1 Factor with the
There is a paradigm shift in the nature of for fresh acquisitions and modernisation. Defence Procurement Procedure (DPP) and Best Technology Bid.
conflict. Modern-day conflicts have expanded So how does it affect the military? Existing reduction of procurement time, we still take • Permit automatic procurement through
to include sub-nationalities, terrorists, insur- states of our poorly equipped infantry and recourse to about 40-month span for infor- L2 vendor without any loss of time
gents, religious fanatics and ethnic interests. antiquated air defence weaponry by them- mation system and communication projects should the L1 vendor fail to deliver.
South Asia is in the centre stage of sub-con- selves indicate the criminality of surrender despite rapidly changing the technologies. • Have a separate DPP for Information
ventional conflict and instability. The entry of defence modernisation funds. It is for Under such circumstances, our military Systems and Communications with
of non-state actors has added a new dimen- such reasons the erstwhile Chairman Chiefs modernisation will continue to regress. telescoped gestation period of not more
sion to low intensity conflicts. Responses to of Staff Committee had said that we are in than 12 to 14 months.
such challenges need to be addressed in a no position to take on China. The hollow- The L1Factor
focused and credible manner. The conven- ness of being prepared for a two front / two The response of vendors to the request Conclusion
tional armed forces need to maintain edge and a half front war is thus obvious. for proposal (RFP) is of two types; “best Stagnation of defence modernisation over
by upgrading technologies. Intelligence and Defence budget allocations are dismally price” and/or “best quality”. Invariably, the past successive years has serious rami-
security agencies need to coordinate nation- low. There was a time when the French weightage of the former is more and fications for national security. The issue is
ally and internationally and cooperative Defence Forces were in similar state until “best quality” becomes a casualty. Given all the more significant with the aggres-
security as strategy needs to be enforced at President Charles De Gaulle took the stra- the state of corruption in the country, siveness of a rising China, the US arming
regional and international levels. tegic decision of allocating 8-10 per cent at times, the price being quoted by other Pakistan, and Pakistan’s recourse to ter-
It is said that RMA cannot be limited of the GDP towards defence for a continu- vendor(s) gets leaked out or shall we say rorism. Failure to take note and rectify can
only to systems since recent technological ous decade and France emerged as a global obtained through “economic espionage”. lead to situations far worse than 1962. We
advancements actually require revolution- force. In India, the services have been ask- The enterprising vendor then bids a much have no option but to crystallise the larger
ary changes in the manner in which we ing for increase in the defence budget, to lower price to obtain the contract though vision through a national security strat-
conduct our military business since RMA at least 3-4 per cent of the GDP but their the quality of his product may be qualita- egy and speedily equip our defence forces,
encompasses the entire military organisa- demands have gone unheeded. Insufficient tively inferior. The focus on quality is over- streamlining the defence procurement pro-
tion and the technologically advantaged funds are available for military moderni- shadowed by the lower price being offered. cedure, to meet the future challenges. SP
combatant may often face an enemy net- sation and these too are not fully utilised. The Defence Research & Development
work that is quite elusive. However, tech- Of the Rs 147,344 crore Defence Budget Organisation (DRDO) wanting to attempt
nology does have an immensely important allocated this year, only Rs 60,000 crore is each and every requirement of the ser- See you at
role in future wars. Military transformation capital expenditure. How much of this will vices, many a times does not have the
includes network centricity as an essential get surrendered is not difficult to guess; Rs competence to do so, but reluctantly
Eurosatory 2010
WWW.SPSLANDFORCES.NET
ingredient plus miniaturisation of technol- 7000-8000 crore on the average. The claim admits this after lapse of considerable
ogy, enabling single platforms to do multiple that defence budget has been increased months/ years. At times, the General Staff
tasks, particularly in the sub conventional by four per cent needs to be viewed in the Qualitative Requirements (GSQR) are Hall No.: 6
and irregular environment. Cyber and backdrop of eight per cent inflation and that therefore forced to lower. Stand No.: A310
space are the new frontiers besides Network the latter will only keep rising. The money To compound the above problem the
Centric Warfare. allocated for modernisation and re-equip- existing procurement procedure does not
Date: June 14-18, 2010
ping has actually reduced from the previous permit contracting through the L2 ven- Venue: Paris, France
Threats year. Compared to China’s seven per cent dor should the L1 vendor fail to deliver
India faces a number of security threats in and Pakistan’s five per cent, India’s defence for some reason. In case the L1 vendor
the form of militancy in Jammu & Kashmir, budget in proportion to its GDP continues to fails, the procurement procedure requires
the Northeast, left-wing extremism, rising be low. The government appears to be oblivi- the entire process of RFP to be repeated
unemployment and economic disparities, ous to the long-term consequences and the involving critical delays in procuring vital
T
he Indian populace got its first taste ery is critical to defence, besides the many mission-critical surveillance applications which includes Resourcesat-1 and other
of real-time communication links benefits it provides for civilian applications. since it enables imaging through atmospher- cartographic satellites. Masking is obviously
and the advent of aggressive media A successful military must have access to ic obscurants like fog, haze, dust and smoke. incorporated in order to shield strategic
coverage when they were able to real-time imagery, automatically filtering and The 3D maps and geographical infor- assets/important locations. The potential of
view the Kargil War from their bedrooms. sharing it at required levels. This is vital in mation system (GIS) are the need at every Bhuvan would actually be optimised once
Today, everyone from the man on the battle- modern era wars where weapons can deliver level to fight future wars successfully. This is the National Spatial Data Infrastructure
field to the entire chain of command and thousands of tonnes of ordnance with possible with panoramic image fusion (PIF) (NSDI) is fully integrated with the relevant
control right up to the chief political execu- precision and mostly in standoff mode over creating a 3D environment; making periph- ministries/departments like forest, water
tive and the populace are on the same real enormous distances in very short time and eral vision just as clear as seen in front of the resources, surface, etc. At the moment,
time grid. Battlefield Transparency (BFT) is the need for the military to be capable of net- eye. Research is on to combine light intensity Defence Image Processing and Analysis
the buzzword. If you can see the adversary centric warfare. direction and ranging (LIDAR) sensors with Centre (DIPAC) is providing satellite imag-
before he sees you and if you can monitor his The threats to a nation are more var- thermal imaging and X-ray backscatter tech- ery to the military. However, the military
moves throughout, the victory scales would ied and complicated than ever before and niques to create near-real-time 3D pictures requires imagery of very high resolution to
axiomatically tilt in your favour. Application detailed imagery analysis is needed in addi- of buildings and streets. With the addition of meet future requirements. The army is in
of real-time imagery has tremendous mili- tion to the naked eye watching the moni- radar, the system could even detect objects the process of establishing an enterprise GIS
tary potential, in that, it not only ushers BFT, tors. Surveillance of military targets, border and people inside the buildings. Troops using that should have come a decade ago. This
it helps compress the observe, orient, decide areas and for homeland security requires 3D maps for urban operations will be able will be a prelude to setting up a Defence
and act (OODA) cycle also. Implication of Spatial Data Infrastructure (DSDI) duly inte-
present day technology for the military is grated with the NSDI.
that decisions have to be taken with great UAVs and a host of surveillance devices
swiftness and efficacy—and the entire, con- are in use with the army, navy and air force,
sultation—decision-making process has to be but interoperability within the services is still
radically reviewed. a distant dream. The strategic highway to be
provided by the Defence Communications
Real Time Imagery Network (DCN) is still a few years away. The
Real time imagery at times gets accredited Army Strategic Operational Information
to only satellite imagery of the Google Earth Dissemination System (ASTROIDS) of the
variety that is web-based. Not only are satel- army is under development. Significantly, the
lites part of the product base, web-based ASTROIDS and its compatriots Sangharsh
imagery may well be dated and not “real of the navy and TADIDS of the air force have
time” in actual sense. Today, unmanned aer- different protocols and standards and hence
ial vehicles (UAVs) relay live coverage of the have no interoperability. Hence, even when
area of operations, playing the role of “eyes the DCN (which is only a highway) does
in the sky”. A Special Forces operative using come through, interoperability will continue
a hand held digital device streams video cov- to be a casualty in absence of common soft-
erage of the target/target area directly to the ware. This issue needs urgent attention. The
pilot of the en route attack aircraft. Imageries present-day UAVs are designed for real-time
captured by Hand Held Thermal Imagers imagery intelligence, artillery adjustment,
Illustration: SP Guide Pubns
(HHTIs) are being streamed up the chain battle damage assessment, reconnaissance
of command to show terrorist movements. and surveillance, target acquisition and
Ground, air and sea based surveillance battlefield observation. Similarly, other sur-
devices, in addition to satellites, provide day veillance devices of the three services need to
and night satellite imagery of the battle area be integrated at lower/every possible level in
or areas where disaster has struck, order to provide a seamless common opera-
Satellite imagery providers offer a com- much more than several monitors. Today, to identify targets, determine best routes to tional picture (COP) and for maximising
prehensive compilation of satellite products a variety of tools are available for surveil- approach terrorist sites and “virtually walk potential of all available weapons.
reproduced in graphical form. The service is lance users, such as infrared short-wave and through” buildings to rehearse operations. Situational awareness currently in the
provided on a 24x7 basis and the image files long-wave, image fusion, satellite links, and Since LIDAR provides dimensions of doors, army is ad hoc, whereas the requirement is
displayed are automatically refreshed with video streamed from UAVs. Technology can windows and alleys with millimetre accu- of an integrated network system, particularly
the latest, openly available data from the provide impressive detailed surveillance in racy, the technology could even be used for at the cutting edge; an integration tool sup-
satellites. In addition, the archive of dated many ways, but system integrators continue choosing appropriate weapons for a mission. porting individual soldier to Battalion Group/
images is also provided. The real-time images to look for better ways of interpreting the Combat Group Commander in the Tactical
service incorporates satellite image-data detailed night and day images these modern The Indian Scene Battle Area (TBA) that can provide in near
loops, visualised products derived from satel- tools provide. Video analytics, image fusion, Remote-sensing and satellite technologies real time an appropriate, common and com-
lite data and a selection of RGB composite and high-definition capability are just some have become an essential part of security prehensive tactical picture by integrating
images that provide multi-spectral informa- of the methods being developed. The soft- world wide, especially in the field of defence. inputs from all elements. Due to this void, the
tion content for optimum visualisation. ware must cater for filtering/analysing the Bhuvan, India’s own mapping service was common operating picture (COP) too is ad
While real-time imagery can be derived information from multi-intelligence sources launched in 2009 by the Indian Space hoc. To bridge this gap, the IA has planned
from multiple sources and surveillance within the video and be able to tag, sort, cat- Research Organisation (ISRO), though its fielding of the Battlefield Management
devices, what is critical is the software alogue and share digital footage in real time. coverage is restricted to the Indian conti- System (BMS) at Battalion Group/Combat
to analyse and more importantly share This has become all the more important, nent. It offers multi layer 10 metre resolu- Group level and below as part of capability
it simultaneously with users at various as a variety of increasingly sophisticated tion imagery as compared to 200 metre building. This would enable a faster decision
levels. ‘Interoperability’ and ‘Enterprise surveillance tools are being added periodi- single layer imagery by Google Earth. The process by commanders at all echelons, bet-
Architecture’ are vital issues, both for inter- cally. Eventual aim is to get more interactive update frequency is one year in comparison ter decision due to reliable operational infor-
service and intra-service functioning. through touch-screen capability where the to four years of Google Earth. The package mation provided in real time and the ability
operator can touch a piece of data in the offers information in regard to geographic to quickly close the sensor to shooter loop.
Military Applications stream to pull more detailed information. location, maps, imagery, etc. In addition to The BMS is to be integrated with other com-
The fact that battlefield transparency is Military users continue to demand more and satellite imagery, long-distance laser scan- ponents of the Tactical Command, Control,
vital to the military requires little empha- more digital capability and high definition ning technology and digital photography is Communications and Information (Tac C3I)
sis. Surveillance is critical to every facet of (HD) imagery. At the same time, short wave also used to provide geographical informa- System through the Command Information
national security and hence real-time imag- infrared (SWIR) technology is required for tion. Bhuvan uses data from seven satellites and Decision Support System (CIDSS).
capability using precision guided weapons posals submitted by the service HQ remain equipment may not be available in adequate equipment, 10 per cent on revenue works,
including those with a credible land attack pending with the government. There are no numbers. The time required to absorb tech- 4 per cent on transportation, and 5 per
capability; anti-submarine warfare (ASW) clear indications from the ministry about nology will also militate against mass pro- cent on miscellaneous charges. Ways and
capability to counter the potential subma- the final outcome of these proposals and the curement. There are a host of other reasons means will have to be found to curb the
rine threat both conventional and nuclear related cash out go in the current FY. Since for surrender of funds such as non pursuit revenue expenditure. A macro measure
through provision of a balanced mix of the requirement of funds for the ensuing FY of procurement cases with zeal, bad and half in this regard would be to synergise the
ASW capability both for deep waters as also also depends on the proposals cleared in the baked preparation of cases, bureaucratic strengths of the three services through
the more challenging littorals; amphibi- current FY, Service HQ are not in a position delays, delays in price negotiation committee integrated theatre commands and by
ous capability for provision of security to to project the BE accurately. Additionally, (PNC), single vendor situations, long trials, pruning the existing command headquar-
island territories as also for a possible power the government is also known to surprise no or late release of payments to vendors, etc. ters and other organisation of the three
projection role; and mine warfare through the services at the RE stage (around mid Surrender of funds has been hotly debated in services to cut out redundancy. Similarly,
augmentation of minesweeping and mine February) by withdrawing sizeable amount the Parliament, as well has been commented if the nation does not envisage full scale
hunting capability. of funds from the initial allocations. The adversely by successive defence committees state- to-state wars, why is capability cum
All the three services need to develop blame game between the services and the of the Parliament. threat based force structures in place?
Network Centric Warfare (NCW) capability. government continues. The services feel that The services need a clear strategic direc-
the government deliberately goes slow and Conclusion tion from the political leadership to review
The Budgeting Process and its withdraws funds from defence allocations The threats and challenges to the security and revise their organisational structures
Weaknesses
WWW.SPSLANDFORCES.NET
due to political considerations or in order to environment in and around India have in view of the changed nature of wars.
The budgeting process for the ensuing balance their books at the end of the FY. This resulted in an increased spectrum of war Our weakness in this regard is evident.
financial year (FY) starts with the forecast surrender of funds is a matter of serious con- requiring multifarious capabilities. The gov- The services are moving forward on their
estimates (FE), which are submitted to the cern, since these funds are from the capital ernment has no choice in this regard and own steam. Even the so called Defence
Ministry of Defence by each service head- account of the budget, needless to say, the has to provide more funds under the Capital Minister’s Operational Directive is drafted
quarter (HQ) in the month of November of modernisation programme of the services are budget for modernisation and transforma- by the services and comes back to them as
the previous year. FE is an indicative projec- delayed and the much needed equipment is tion of forces. Thus, the focus of reduction the Operational Directive. It is unfortunate
tion of requirement of funds by the services not available to the troops in actual combat. will inevitably be on the revenue budget. that the national security structure in
for the forthcoming FY. The FE is followed The cascading effect of this delay in procure- The revenue expenditure trend for the India is manned by diplomats, bureaucrats
by the BE in December. This is a finer tuned ment can never be made up, because of the last three years shows that about 46 per and officers from the intelligence commu-
estimate of requirement of funds for the sheer numbers and size of requirement. Thus cent of expenditure is incurred on pay nity and hence ignorance prevails at the
ensuing FY. Meanwhile, a number of pro- even if adequate funds are allocated, the and allowances, 35 per cent on stores and highest levels about military matters. SP
Regiment Commander. The system will super hype fielding of a particular piece of
be further integrated with the tactical Core System weapon or equipment to such an extent
command, control, communications and that it gives the false pretext of ‘total
information system (Tac C3I) through Warning Sensors modernisation’ having been effected. For
the Command Information Decision (A-, B-, C-, Radar-, Health-, Laser-, GPS example, while the Special Forces were
Support System (CIDSS). The Directorate IFF Device, Landmine Detection Sensor) equipped with the Tavor assault rifles some
General of Information System (DGIS) is time back with plenty fanfare, important
charged with facilitating transformation equipment like hand held light weight
Operator Unit
of the IA into a dynamic network-centric Group Radio laser target designators are yet to be provi-
force, achieving information superiority sioned. While Modification 4B is not fully
through effective management of infor- effected despite approval in 1998 and F-
mation technology. Quite logically, Phase INSAS is a few years away, the infantry is
III of F-INSAS (computer sub-system, woefully short of even items like compass-
radio sub-system, software and software es, GPS, bullet proof jackets (BPJs), bullet
Aux-Display
integration) should be part of the BMS. proof patkas (BPPs), cold weather clothing,
However, infantry has been adamant that rappelling ropes and even tents. The qual-
Phase III of F-INSAS should be developed ity of personal clothing and equipment
by Infantry and not be part of BMS. A leaves much to desire. Current plans to
separate project of software and com- provide Ghatak Platoons of infantry bat-
munication integration by infantry will Inertial Navigation Core Computer talions with anti-terrorist equipment and
be retrograde, delay overall net-centricity System training too are myopic. Considering the
pan army, incur additional avoidable costs speedy expansion of terror, asymmetric
and defeat the very purpose that DGIS and fourth generation wars, it should be
was created for, considerable work in the very apparent that the requirement is to
fields of geographical information system Battery Pack Cabling equip complete infantry battalions and
(GIS) and applications having already that too on emergent basis. How many
been done by the latter in addition to com- individuals of the Ghatak Platoon will be
pleting Phase 1 of CIDSS and Battlefield on leave, courses and temporary duties
Surveillance System (BSS). out of the unit when emergencies occur?
While the IA required the BMS ‘yester- When we acknowledge that terrorists can
day’, squabbling on delimitation between use radiological/dirty bombs and chemical
the BMS and F-INSAS has already cost attacks, why are we not giving even basic
a delay to Phase 1 of BMS by more than Clothing, Protection and Carrying System gas masks to every soldier? Logically, a gas
nine months. The infantry has been mask should be available to every citizen in
haggling that Phase III of F-INSAS be the market, as is available in Israel.
developed by them in full or at least till (FFW) programme being started. Land parate systems would be required and it
company/platoon level. If F-INSAS is to Warrior did not integrate with FBCB2. As would be difficult to achieve test bed of What needs to be done?
incorporate situational awareness and GIS a result, FBCB2 is being replaced by JBCS an integrated Combat Group or Infantry • While the F-INSAS and Modification
then it amounts to not only ‘re-inventing (Joint Battle Command System) which Battalion Group. It would be prudent for 4B are ongoing, there is a crying need
the wheel’ but will require yet another goes down to the soldier. Significantly, the Infantry to only develop Phases 1 and to boost the combat capability of the
project to integrate the F-INSAS with the FFW programme is looking only at the II of the F-INSAS, leaving development of infantry by provisioning 100 per cent
BMS implying infructuous and avoid- soldier ensemble to include weapon, Phase III as part of the BMS. night fighting capability, navigation
able additional expenditure and time. protection and integrated helmet. The equipment, fire power, BPJs, BPPs, and
Foreign armies have faced similar situ- future soldier programme will not have a Penny Wise Approach rappelling ropes, etc. In terms of BPJs,
ations and “we need to learn from their radio of its own but JTRS Cluster 5 Radio Some of the procurements have been fol- our infantry today (less deployments
mistakes rather than going through the (Soldier Radio), common to all the US lowing the “penny wise, pound foolish in J&K) is no better than what state
same mistakes”. In UK, Future Integrated soldiers and a common SA and computer approach”. When the hand held thermal of Mumbai police was during 26/11.
Soldier Technology (FIST) programme for from JBCS. Helmet will have a helmet imagers (HHTIs) were initially procured, The money spent on modernisation
infantry was thought of 10 years after mounted display and earphones as well only one charger per four HHTIs was provi- of infantry in past decades has been
the Bowman programme. In the latter, as microphone. System of systems are sioned. This caused considerable problems miniscule considering the expendi-
the C2 system went down to half squad. about integrating systems and empower- since widely dispersed infantry company ture on balance modernisation plans
The Platoon Commander carries both the ing the user. The soldier is only a part deployments in Jammu & Kashmir (J&K) especially considering the combined
Bowman and the FIST. In case the section of the network; he is not responsible for faced major problem in re-charging. The strength of the infantry, RR, Infantry
has to function independently, the Section the network. Separate F-INSAS and BMS result was locally manufactured impro- (TA) vis-a-vis the overall strength of
Commander carries both the Bowman programmes will lead to issues related vised chargers; not the best arrangement the IA. More significantly, the fiscal
and FIST. Separate FINSAS and BMS to interoperability and integration of for top level serviceability. Night sights requirement of modernising the com-
could lead us to similar situations which systems as the systems may be developed for rifles too were provisioned at the rate plete infantry is extremely small com-
should be unacceptable. by different agencies using different plat- of one per four rifles. Similarly, when the pared to weapon systems. It is only
FBCB2 was implemented in 1998 in forms. Development of different systems artillery procured laser target designators a question of taking a decision and
the US Army. Land Warrior was started for the same purpose will accrue avoidable for the Krasnopol ammunition, only one executing it speedily. A holistic mod-
late, prototyped in 2005 and foreclosed additional costs on account of yet another charger was procured for several designa- ernisation plan needs to be chalked
in 2007, leading to Future Force Warrior integration project. Maintenance of dis- tors. Then, we also have the tendency to out and implemented with alacrity.
www.selexgalileo.com
THREAT SIMULATION.
MADE REAL.
Widely recognised as a best-in-class reusable threat
simulation system, the high performance Mirach 100/5
aerial target is in use in all major European Firing Ranges
and deployed by six Armed Forces worldwide and employed
to qualify over 30 guided weapons in the air, naval and land
Towards a safer world domains. Able to embark a wide range of target mission
payloads, Mirach replicates the most complex air threats
to present weapons and sensors with representative and
stressing engagement scenarios.
Make sure you know your threats before you meet them.
Tomorrow’s technology is here today.
J o i nt Exerci se
Strengthening Ties
The political and economic links between India and Singapore improved after the end of the Cold
War. In August 2008, both states entered into a bilateral defence agreement for joint training
exercises in India. The latest in the series codenamed Bold Kurukshetra was recently held in Babina.
LT GENERAL (RETD) V.K. KAPOOR
T
he current close relations milestone in bilateral defence relations. In
between Singapore and India are August 2008, both countries entered into
in sharp contrast to their distant another bilateral defence agreement that
relations during the Cold War. allowed their infantry forces to undertake
The end of the Cold War and collapse of joint training exercises in India. India’s
the Soviet Union caused the political lead- willingness to allow all three branches
ership to relook at India’s geopolitical and of the Singapore military to train on
strategic equations globally. The decision Indian soil is a strong indicator of this
to open up economically was complemen- rapidly developing bilateral relationship.
tary to the political and strategic moves. In less than 30 years, the non-existent
It is during this period that the political defence relations between Singapore and
and economic links between India and India are now characterised by close and
Singapore improved. Defence relations enduring cooperation.
between the two countries has also shown The latest in the series of armour
rapid improvements which demonstrate exercises codenamed Bold Kurukshetra
the strides made in bilateral ties. was held in Babina on March 26
Photograph: www.news.gov.sg
Singapore and India have a mutual and 27, 2010 under the aegis of the
interest in maintaining the security of the Indian Armoured division located
regional sea lanes, and therefore naval there. Singapore Minister of State for
cooperation was designed to be mutually Defence Koo Tsai Kee and Singapore’s
advantageous. The close naval collabora- High Commissioner to India Calvin Eu,
tion was therefore a confidence-building along with a delegation of ten dignitar-
mechanism that later became a model ies witnessed the bilateral exercise. The
for cooperation among other branches of and Ex Bold Kurukshetra and these were visit once again underscored the warm
their militaries. In 2003, the conclusion held at Deolali and Babina (near Jhansi) In 2004, Exercise SINDEX defence relations between both countries.
of the Defence Cooperation Agreement respectively. 04 was held in Central Major-General Neo Kian Hong of
again improved bilateral defence ties as The signing of the 2007 Joint Military Singapore Army said, “To what I have
it facilitated the ensuing establishment Exercises agreement allows the Singapore
India. In 2005, both seen today, I’m pleased to say that what
of the annual India-Singapore Defence Air Force to train at Indian military militaries conducted we have achieved here eventually is what
WWW.SPSLANDFORCES.NET
Policy Dialogue. The dialogue aimed to bases in Kalaikunda, West Bengal, for their first joint artillery we had asked for. For this, I extend my
provide a regular forum for both sides five years, in return for payment and the appreciation to Indian Army for allow-
to discuss defence cooperation as well understanding that the Singapore Air and armour exercises ing us to train in India.” Elements of the
as regional and defence issues. The first Force maintains and upgrades the Indian codenamed Ex Agni Singaporean Army had started their train-
such meeting was conducted in Singapore facilities provided. The significance of the ing on March 1 under the supervision of
in March 2004. These confidence-build- military agreement was that for the first Warrior and Ex Bold the Armoured Division of Indian Army
ing mechanisms led to further develop- time the Indian government allowed the Kurukshetra and these and the training also included profes-
ments in defence cooperation. In 2004,
Exercise SINDEX 04 was held in Central
stationing of foreign troops on its soil. In
November 2008, a three-week long joint
were held at Deolali sional exchange between the two armies
in the form of lectures, presentations,
India. In 2005, both militaries conducted air force training exercise was conducted, and Babina (near familiarisation with the other army’s
their first joint artillery and armour which Singapore’s Ministry of Defence Jhansi) respectively. equipment, tactical discussions, and sand-
exercises codenamed Ex Agni Warrior considered as yet another significant model exercises. SP
A Success STORY
Photographs: Abhishek / SP Guide Pubns
Defexpo India 2010 saw the largest congregation ever of products and companies from across
the world. The exhibition ground set the stage for many pacts and deals between global
industry giants.
SUCHETA DAS MOHAPATRA
T
he Indian defence market is increas- all aspects of defence technologies available
ing in size. This was evident at worldwide. But Defexpo 2010 had much
Defexpo 2010 which saw the largest more on display. Besides the products, the
ever conglomeration of companies exhibition ground set the stage for innu-
from across the world. The sixth edition of merable of pacts and agreements between
the biennial Land and Naval Defence System global industry giants.
Exhibition held at New Delhi had 650 exhibi- Israel’s Rafael Advanced Defence
tors with 200 new entrants from 33 coun- Systems Ltd declared its plans to start
tries. It witnessed an increase in industry a joint venture with Bharat Electronics
participation by about 45 per cent compared Limited to develop advanced missile sys-
to Defexpo 2008. tems. The proposed facility will be scaled
Inaugurating the show, Defence Minister up to develop new technologies in missile
A.K. Antony declared that India will very seekers depending on the projects it can
soon publish the ‘Technology Perspective and secure from India.
Capability Roadmap’. The roadmap high- Larsen & Toubro joined hands with
lighting the military requirements of India’s Raytheon on a JV to upgrade Indian Army
defence forces for the next 15 years shall be T-72 tanks. As a part of the proposal,
displayed on the Ministry of Defence website. Raytheon will provide infrared imaging
It will make the defence pocurement process sights and electronics to improve the target
transparent and speedy. accuracy and increase in overall system
The Defence Minister added that India’s lethality for the T-72, while L&T will pro-
defence expenditure will increase in pro- vide fire control system, sensors and the DG AAD Lt General Ram Pratap (centre) at SP’s stand
portion to the GDP growth of the country. final integration along with customer sup-
“India’s defence expenditure is about 2.5 port to the Indian Army which retains the
per cent of its GDP. The Indian economy is T-72 tanks.
expected to grow at 8-10 per cent for the Thales announced the launch of
next two decades. Expenditure on defence in Vigile LW, a new, lightweight, naval
absolute terms is bound to increase in equal Radar Electronic Support Measures sys-
proportion,” said Antony. tem set to redefine situational awareness
Speaking on the defence offsets policy, the for small vessels.
Union Minister informed that changes are Rockwell Collins was awarded a contract
being made to render the offsets policy more for Electronic Counter-Counter Measure
feasible. “Offset banking is now part of the radio modules by Electronic Corporation of
defence offsets policy and the licensing condi- India Ltd (ECIL). The component hardware
tions have also been rationalised. Necessary card sets will be integrated into ground-
administrative structures have been put in based ultra high frequency (UHF) radios for
place in the Ministry of Defence to facilitate use by the Indian Defence for Command and
offset banking,” he said. Control of ground-to-ground and ground-
to-air communications.
Announcements
Over the years, Defexpo India has grown as Products Unveiled
an important event in the global defence and The newly formed joint venture com-
aerospace exhibition calendar, showcasing pany of Mahindra & Mahindra Limited Senior Executives of Mahindra & Mahindra and BAE Systems
offerings in India, as well as meeting many Antony, Minister of States Dr. M.M. Pallam
potential customers. Raju, Member of Parliament and industrial-
Maxtech Networks (Maxtech), the Israel ist Naveen Jindal and many other dignitaries
based creator of voice optimised mobile mesh visited the stall during the Defexpo. Union
networking technology showcased its Savion Minister of State for Communication and IT
handheld radio. The Savion Radio technol- Sachin Pilot also visited the expo.
ogy is helpful in times of distress when any
traditional communication infrastructure Defexpo India 2012
collapses, especially in special situations such A biennial event, the seventh edition of
as earthquake, floods, etc. The technology is the Defexpo will be held from February
able to provide groups of users with unlim- 9 to February 12, 2012, as stated by the
Tata’s mine protected vehicle
ited mobility and coverage without the need Ministry of Defence. SP
the international opportunities being SP’s: Are you active in India and in which
programmes?
evaluated by the company Grasso: We are in India for more than
20 years. To mention the most important
programmes, Selex Communications
is the supplier of avionics systems like
Communications can offer scalable and mod- Doppler/GPS navigation systems and HF
Profile: Giancarlo Grasso ular solutions for communications and thus and V/UHF radios for many of the fixed
enable the modernisation of the army, being and rotary platforms manufactured in
Giancarlo Grasso graduated in Electronic Engineering at the University “La at the same time, the preferred interface of the country. Moreover, in partnership
Sapienza”, Rome. He has a formidable professional experience: he worked the customer. with HAL and BEL, we are supplying the
27 years at Selenia, six years as General Director of Elettronica; then, as Indian Navy with advanced HF communi-
Business Development Director in Alenia and as CEO of Alenia Difesa, SP’s: What is the trend of defence moderni- cation systems for most of the platforms
Avionics Division. He was the President of Alenia Marconi Systems, Oto sation in India? and ground stations. Today, we are col-
Melara and Galileo Avionica and later on was appointed as CEO of Selex Grasso: I believe that the effects of the so- laborating with BEL for the supply of tac-
S&AS and Chief Technical Officer and Senior Advisor for the President called globalisation are evident also in the tical deployable Tetra system (TETRATAC)
and CEO of Finmeccanica. Since 2009, Giancarlo Grasso is CEO of SELEX field of defence systems. In almost all coun- to the Army.
tries worldwide the basic concepts on which
Communications, a Finmeccanica company.
the armed forces modernisation plans SP’s: What kind of scope do you foresee
leverage on are quite similar. Generally or anticipate in India for your business
speaking, the differences depend on either expansion?
SP Guide Publications (SP’s): Can you provide robust and secure links to support the allocated budget or by the capability of Grasso: We aim at increasing our presence
briefly outline the history of Selex military identification processes and data the local industries. From both the point of in India in strong cooperation with the local
Communications? What has been the mar- transmission to centres on the ground. view, India seems to be very well positioned. industry, not only with HAL and BEL. Selex
ket share of Selex Communications in the Communications has a representative office
domestic and the export market? SP’s: With regard to Future Soldier SP’s: The Tactical Communication System in Delhi, to show our continuous attention to
Giancarlo Grasso (Grasso): Selex programme, what solutions are Selex (TCS) programme has been finalised. BEL the country’s industry developments and to
Communications, a Finmeccanica Communications providing? Are these has bagged it. What involvement does Selex catch possible partnership opportunities.
Company since 2005, has over 100 years under operation with the domestic Communications have in the programme?
of experience as a global supplier of (Italian) army and at any other army Do you have something more to offer as SP’s: Is 26 per cent Foreign Direct
advanced communications, navigation across the globe? compared to what is available in India? Investment (FDI) fixed by the Indian gov-
and identification solutions to protect Grasso: Selex Communications is the refer- Grasso: The Indian Tactical Communication ernment sufficient?
communities and critical national infra- ence company for the architectural design, System is one of the most prominent defence Grasso: More than 25 per cent is the
structure. We entered the business at integration of both the hardware and the programme available worldwide, therefore minimum to get a good role in order to
the turn of the 20th century, when the software components and implementation Selex Communications is paying special be really responsible of what goes on. Of
Defence Chiefs of Staff understood the of the Italian Future Soldier programme attention to it. We are already partner of BEL course, a lot depends on the local indus-
importance that radio communications (named as “Soldato Futuro” programme), for other important Indian Army and Indian try, but we look forward to an increase
would have played in future military oper- leading an industrial team of Finmeccanica Navy’ programmes and we are also currently of our role with the per cent fixed by the
ations. Throughout the years, the Italian companies and other partners. The company dealing with BEL for some of the main com- Indian government.
company diversified its activities—to also has specific implementation tasks in ponents of the TCS.
include professional mobile radio, space, the Command & Control, Communications, SP’s: A debate has been going on in our
avionics, command and control systems, Computers, Information/Intelligence, SP’s: What kind of potential you antici- country whether the FDI should be 26
networks for terrestrial and naval applica- Surveillance, Targeting Acquisition and pate in India for communication centric per cent or 49 per cent. What do you have
tions and more—and expanded globally Reconnaissance (C4ISTAR) area. A first pre- solutions? to say about it?
to become a multinational company, that series batch of “Soldato Futuro” systems has Grasso: Establishing industrial relationships
generates roughly half of its revenues in been provided to the Italian Army for trials with the local industry is one of the most
the international market. With regard and the programme will be fully operational effective tool in order to meet the customer’s
to India, Selex Communications started by the end of 2011. needs. In this context, it is important to
its activities in the country’s military At an international level, Selex set up a percentage which guarantees the
market since the eighties, operating Communications’ UK branch supplies dis- minorities in terms of rights an respect of the
through many of the companies (as Elmer, mounted troop communications to UK armed roles. In some countries this percentage is 25
Marconi, etc) which constitute the “roots” forces, designing and delivering the Vehicle per cent, in some others 53 per cent. I think
of Selex Communications today. Integrated Personal Role Radio (VIPRR) sys- that increasing this limit in India would prob-
tem for installation in British Army Warrior, ably be more effective.
SP’s: Give us a brief idea about the vari- CVR (T), Saxon and other armoured vehicles.
ous solutions offered to army, navy and Moreover, international opportunities for SP’s: You spoke about the Tactical
air force. soldier modernisation programmes are cur- Communication System (TCS) programme.
Grasso: Selex Communications’ offer rently being evaluated by the company. We How is the programme moving?
ranges from solutions for the improve- are in talks with five foreign countries. Grasso: Selex Communications is working
ment of the soldiers’ capabilities on the at the TCS programme for many years and
battlefield to secure communications SP’s: Compared to others in the global today we look forward to entering into the
systems for the naval sector, which competition, what are the benefits of Selex real contractual phase. We believe that,
include both the voice communications Communications’ Future Soldier pro- within the TCS, our radio, switches, radio
component in HF and V/UHF frequen- gramme? links and wide band communication for
cies and the data and messaging compo- Grasso: Started in the US and a few other military security can really meet the armed
nent. Moreover, our offer includes also western countries in the late Nineties with forces needs. We are the first in the world to
advanced Communications, Navigation the goal of improving the soldiers’ capabili- provide these solutions.
and Identification (CNI) solutions for both ties, soldier modernisation programmes have
Photograph: www.selexgalileo.com
fixed and rotary wing platforms. Applying demonstrated that only firepower proves SP’s: I believe you have support from your
its proven and extensive expertise in the insufficient to achieve the mission. It has to government for programmes in India?
avionic field, Selex Communications has be complemented with communications, Grasso: Yes, we have. Our armed forces are
developed a family of state-of-the-art situational awareness and targeting tools, really in a very good relationship with their
next-generation Identification Friend-or- that are the pillars of the battlefield intel- Indian counterpart and there are many
Foe (IFF) systems, which are currently ligence and the enabling technologies for the agreements, initiatives and operational
operational and NATO certified, able to so-called “information superiority”. Selex The Italian Future Soldier needs in common to both the countries. SP
Photograph: Rolls-Royce
tion, following Ministry of Defence (MoD) Special Correspondent
approval to extend the upgrade to 22 air- Ruchika Chawla
craft. British Army Aviation School training Assistant Correspondent
The US Army will test an improved version regiment commanding officer Lieutenant Abhay Singh Thapa
of the M-24 sniper rifle when the candidate Colonel David Meyer said there had been a Sub-Editor
Bipasha Roy
weapons for the programme are unveiled Larsen & Toubro Limited (L&T) and Rolls- recent endorsement for all 22 AH9s to be
Assistant Photo Editor
later this month. Soldier Weapons project Royce have signed a Memorandum of upgraded, and for the out-of-service date Abhishek Singh
manager Colonel Douglas A, Tamilio said Understanding to address the projected to be extended to 2016. AgustaWestland Contributors
that the industry was challenged to improve need for light water reactors (LWR) in said the AH9A follow-on contract was India
the M-24 sniper rifle to make it more accu- India and internationally. LWR technol- likely to be signed this month, according General (Retd) V.P. Malik, Lt General (Retd)
Vijay Oberoi, Lt General (Retd) R.S. Nagra,
rate and more adjustable to the soldiers’ ogy is in use in over sixty per cent of civil to flightglobal.com. Equipped with more Lt General (Retd) S.R.R. Aiyengar, Air Marshal
needs. Four industry competitors are expect- nuclear power plants operating world- powerful Honeywel/Rolls-Royce engines, (Retd) Vinod Patney, Major General (Retd)
ed to supply their improved M-24 candidates wide. The two companies have agreed to hybrid analogue/digital cockpits and secure Ashok Mehta, Major General (Retd) G.K.
Nischol, Brigadier (Retd) Gurmeet Kanwal,
by March 11. The improved version of the collaborate on areas including nuclear communications equipment, the upgraded Brigadier (Retd) S. Mishra, Rohit Sharma
rifle will have an adjustable stock, adjustable instrumentation and controls, engineered model will be capable of operating in high Europe
cheek welds as well as 5-10 round external products and systems, reactor compo- temperatures expected when the fleet is Andrew Brookes (UK)
magazines. Following the tests, the army will nents, engineering services, in-service deployed to Afghanistan. USA & Canada
choose a producer in mid 2010, with a view reactor support and waste management. Lon Nordeen (USA)
to deploy the improved M-24 to army snipers The cooperation with L&T for instrumen- ■ Anil R. Pustam (West Indies)
South Africa
later in the year. tation and controls will form the first Helmoed R. Heitman
operational phase of this relationship New Lakota helicopter to be Chairman & Managing Director
■ to bridge the gap in the existing supply sent to Germany Jayant Baranwal
chain in support of India’s ambitious new Admin & Coordination
build programme. Bharti Sharma, Survi Massey
S h o w Calendar Senior Art Director
26 April – 28 April
■ Anoop Kamath
Photograph: www.eads.com
Design
Military Helicopter 2010 Layout Designs: Vimlesh Kumar Yadav,
MineWolf mine-clearance Sonu Singh Bisht
The Waldorf Hilton Hotel, London, UK machine Sales & Marketing
www.helicopter-conference.com Director Sales & Marketing: Neetu Dhulia
27 April – 28 April Head Vertical Sales: Rajeev Chugh
Sales Manager: Rajiv Ranjan
Military Satellites Summit 2010
SP’s Website
Sheraton Premiere at Tysons Corner, The US Army has received a UH-72A Sr. Web Developer: Shailendra P. Ashish
Vienna, VA Lakota light utility helicopter from EADS Web Developer: Ugrashen Vishwakarma
www.militarysatellitessummit.com North America at American Eurocopter’s Published bimonthly by Jayant Baranwal
Photograph: www.minewolf.com
18 May – 21 May missile the outgoing COAS, General Deepak Representative Offices
BANGALORE, INDIA
The Indian Army will induct the indige- Kapoor on March 31, 2010.
Soldier Technology 2010 Air Marshal (Retd) B.K. Pandey
Olympia Conference Centre, London nously developed Nag missile in May after • General Vijay Kumar Singh took over 534, Jal Vayu Vihar, Kammanhalli Main Rd,
completing the final round of trials in as the Chief of the Army Staff with Bangalore 560043, India.
www.wbresearch.com/soldiertechnologyeurope Tel: +91 (80) 23682534
Rajasthan. The Nag, an anti-tank guided effect from March 31, 2010. He suc-
26 May – 29 May MOSCOW, RUSSIA
missile (ATGM) developed by the Defence ceeds General Deepak Kapoor as the LAGUK Co., Ltd, Yuri Laskin
HEMUS 2010: International R&D Laboratory (DRDL), Hyderabad, will 24th Chief of the Indian Army. Krasnokholmskaya, Nab.,
Defense Equipment Exhibition be deployed in the army’s reconnaissance • Lt Gen Bikram Singh has assumed the 11/15, app. 132, Moscow 115172, Russia.
Plovdiv/Bulgaria Tel: +7 (495) 911 2762,
and support battalions, mechanised units appointment of GOC-in-C of Eastern Fax: +7 (495) 912 1260
www.hemusbg.org that locate and destroy enemy tanks, Command with effect from March 31, www.spguidepublications.com
8 June-13 June according to business-standard.com. 2010. www.spslandforces.net
ILA Berlin Air Show 2010 The Indian Army has spent Rs 335 crore • Inderjit Sial has been appointed as RNI Number: DELENG/2008/25818
Berlin-Schoenefeld Airport ($73.8m) on 443 Nag missiles, which the Country Head of Saab International
www.ila-berlin.com will be manufactured at the public sector India AB. Sial takes on this position
Bharat Dynamics Limited. During the test from Jan Widerstrom, who will be mov-
14 June – 18 June
trials conducted last year, six Nag missiles ing on to the role of Head-Asia Pacific
EUROSATORY 2010
were fired at tanks 3km-4km away and Region, Saab AB. Inderjit has been with
Paris Saab since 2007.
each of them hit their target accurately.
www.eurosatory.com
The Nag is scheduled to undergo another
Today’s battlefields demand more than an ultra-rugged computer. That’s why the DRS JV-5 is ultra-rugged and
joint-ready when you are. With 65,000 systems currently fielded across the joint force, the JV-5 has proven
its mission-critical reliability in one grueling situation after another. For 3,233 days in the field and counting.
Delivering exceptional performance whenever and wherever it’s needed. In the air and on the ground.