Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Pravin K. Trivedi
Pravin K. Trivedi
Indiana University. - Bloomington
Prepared for 2010 Mexican Stata Users Group meeting,
based on
A. Colin Cameron and Pravin K. Trivedi (2005),
Microeconometrics: Methods and Applications (MMA), C.U.P.
MMA, chapters 21-23
and
A. Colin Cameron and Pravin K. Trivedi (2010),
Microeconometrics using Stata Revised edition (MUSR), Stata Press.
MUSR, chapters 8;18.
Introduction
0. Dedication
Pravin K. Trivedi
Introduction
1. Introduction
Pravin K. Trivedi
Introduction
Background (1)
Panel data are repeated measures on individuals (i ) over time (t ):
data are (yit , xit ) for i = 1, ..., N and t = 1, ..., T , and yit are
nonnegative integer-valued outcomes.
Conditional on xit , the yit are likely to be serially correlated for a
given i, partly because of state dependence and partly because of
cserial correlation in shocks.
Hence each additional year of data is not independent of previous
years.
Cross-sectional dependence between observations is also to be
expected given emphasis on stratied clustered sampling designs.
(1) Pervasive unobserved heterogeneity, (2) a typically high
proportion of zeros, (3) inherent discreteness and heteroskedasticity
generate complications that are hard to handle simultaneously
Finally, the researchers interest often goes beyond the conditional
mean.
How well does available software (Stata) handle these issues?
Pravin K. Trivedi
Introduction
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
Introduction
Overview
Complications
I
I
I
Pravin K. Trivedi
Overview
1
2
f (y )
Poisson
NB1
NB2
Hurdle
ZI
FMM
Pravin K. Trivedi
f (y ) = Pr[Y = y ]
e y /y !
As in NB2 below with 1 replaced by 1
1
y
( 1 + y )
1
1
1
1
( ) (y + 1 ) +
+
8
f1 (0 )
if y = 0,
<
1 f1 (0 )
f2 (y )
if y
1.
:
1 f2 (0 )
f1 (0) + (1 f1 (0))f2 (0)
if y = 0,
(1 f1 (0))f2 (y )
if y
1.
m
j =1
j fj (y jj )
Mean; Variance
(x); (x) = exp(x0 )
(x); (1 + ) (x)
(x) ; (1 + (x)) (x)
(1
f1 (0))
Overview
or nonseparable heterogeneity
(7)
g (xit0 ).
(8)
or multiplicative eects
E[yit ji , xit ] = i
Pravin K. Trivedi
Overview
Pravin K. Trivedi
Overview
G-2 models
G-3 models
Period
1974-1990
1991-2000
Post-2000
Function
Mainly parametric
Flexible parametric
Parametric / SP
CS models
Poisson, Negbin
Hurdles, nite
Quantile reg;
mixtures, ZIP
Selection models
Panel models
Poisson, Negbin
Poisson, Negbin, EM
EM; QR;
Unobs. hetero.
Multiplicative
Separable or nonsep.
Flexible; non-sep
Modeling
Mainly RE or PA
RE, PA and
RE/PA/FE/
xed eects
Correlated RE; DV
Robust
Robust
Robust or Cl-Rob
wrt overdispersion
wrt OD
wrt OD/SC
Dynamics
Lagged xs
Exponential feedback
Linear or exponential
Endogeneity
Largely ignored
Allowed in RE models
Allowed in RE and FE
Estimators
Mainly MLE
Variance est.
Pravin K. Trivedi
QR; QRIV
Overview
Pravin K. Trivedi
Pravin K. Trivedi
,
,
)
g (i j)d i .
t =1 it it i
(9)
Analytical solution:
I
I
I
No analytical solution:
I
I
I
I
I
Pravin K. Trivedi
C 1
j =1
(10)
Pravin K. Trivedi
Pravin K. Trivedi
Q ( q ) =
i :yi xit
I
q jyit
xit0 q j +
(1
i :yi <xit
q )jyit
xit0 q j,
0<q<1
Pravin K. Trivedi
Implementation
Post-estimation transformation of the z-quantiles back to y -quantiles
uses the ceiling function, with
Qq (y jx) = dQq (z jx)
1e
Pravin K. Trivedi
Pravin K. Trivedi
Pravin K. Trivedi
Pravin K. Trivedi
Pravin K. Trivedi
Stata commands
I
I
Pravin K. Trivedi
where it = exp(xit0 ).
FOC with respect to i yields b
i = t yit / t it (a su cient
statistic for i )
Substituting this yields the concentrated likelihood function.
Dropping terms not involving ,
h
i
ln Lconc ( ) _ i t yit ln it yit ln s is .
Pravin K. Trivedi
t ln yit(1!
(12)
Interpretation
Here is no incidental parameters problem.
Consistent estimates of for xed T and N ! can be obtained by
maximization of ln Lconc ( )
FOC with respect to yields rst-order conditions
h
h
i h
ii
y
x
y
x
/
= 0,
it
it
it
is
is
is
s
s
i t
that can be re-expressed as
Pravin K. Trivedi
xit
i =1 t =1
yit
it
yi
i
= 0,
(13)
Are we making too much of the xed eects and the associated
incidental paramnetr problem?
The dummy variables solution; Allison (2009); Greene (2004).
Pravin K. Trivedi
Count data
poisson; nbreg
qcount
q(%), rep(#)
fmm components(#) mixtureof(poisson)
FMM
fmm components(#) mixtureof(nbreg)
GEE (PA)
xtgee,family(poisson)
xtgee,family(nbinomial)
RE
xtpoisson, re
xtnbreg, fe
Random slopes xtmepoisson
FE
xtpoisson, fe
xtnbreg, fe
FMM is not part of o cial Stata but is in the public domain and can
be added
Pravin K. Trivedi
Data example
Pravin K. Trivedi
storage
type
float
float
float
float
float
float
float
float
float
display
format
%9.0g
%9.0g
%9.0g
%9.0g
%9.0g
%9.0g
%9.0g
%9.0g
%9.0g
value
label
variable label
number face-to-fact md visits
log(coinsurance+1)
count of chronic diseases -- ba
female
age that year
log of family size
child
person id, leading digit is sit
study year
Data example
b [y ] = 4.502 ' 7
Dependent variable mdu is very overdispersed: V
y .
Obs
Mean
mdu
lcoins
ndisease
female
age
20186
20186
20186
20186
20186
2.860696
2.383588
11.2445
.5169424
25.71844
lfam
child
id
year
20186
20186
20186
20186
1.248404
.4014168
357971.2
2.420044
Pravin K. Trivedi
Std. Dev.
Min
Max
4.504765
2.041713
6.741647
.4997252
16.76759
0
0
0
0
0
77
4.564348
58.6
1
64.27515
.5390681
.4901972
180885.6
1.217237
0
0
125024
1
2.639057
1
632167
5
Data example
Distribution of T_i:
Pravin K. Trivedi
min
1
5%
2
25%
3
50%
3
n =
T =
75%
5
5908
5
95%
5
max
5
Data example
Mean
overall
between
within
2.860696
Std. Dev.
4.504765
3.785971
2.575881
Min
Max
Observations
0
0
-34.47264
77
63.33333
40.0607
N =
20186
n =
5908
T-bar = 3.41672
Pravin K. Trivedi
Pravin K. Trivedi
is a
MLE Estimation
Model
Moment spec.
Estimating equations
Pooled
T
it ) = 0
N
i =1 t =1 xit (yit
where it = exp(xit0 )
ts = Cor[(yit exp(xit0 ))(yis exp
yi + /T
T
it
N
i =1 t =1 xit yit
i + /T
i = T 1 t exp(xit0 ); = var(i )
yi
T
it
= 0,
N
i =1 t =1 xit yit
i
Poisson
PA
RE
E[y it ji , x it ]
Poisson
= i exp (x it0 )
FE Pois
E[y it ji , x it ] = i exp (x it )
Pravin K. Trivedi
Pooled Poisson
Specify
yit jxit ,
Poisson[exp(xit0 )]
Pravin K. Trivedi
Pooled Poisson
Poisson regression
Number of obs
Wald chi2(6)
Prob > chi2
Pseudo R2
=
=
=
=
20186
476.93
0.0000
0.0609
Coef.
lcoins
ndisease
female
age
lfam
child
_cons
-.0808023
.0339334
.1717862
.0040585
-.1481981
.1030453
.748789
Robust
Std. Err.
.0080013
.0026024
.0342551
.0016891
.0323434
.0506901
.0785738
z
-10.10
13.04
5.01
2.40
-4.58
2.03
9.53
P>|z|
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.016
0.000
0.042
0.000
-.0651199
.039034
.2389251
.0073691
-.0848062
.2023961
.9027907
Pravin K. Trivedi
V[yit jxit ] =
exp(xit0 ).
With no correlation
V[yi jXi ] = Hi ( ) =
Pravin K. Trivedi
Diag[exp(xit0 )].
Pravin K. Trivedi
GLM Estimation
mi0 ( )
1
Hi ( ) (yi
mi ()) = 0.
i =1
N
mi0 ( ) b 1
i (yi
mi ( )) = 0,
1b
b = [D
b 1 , ..., D
b G ]0 , u
b g = mg0 ( )/ b , D
where D
bg = yg
1/2
1/2
b ) R(
b) .
b g = Hg (
and now
b ) Hg (
I
Pravin K. Trivedi
b
D0
b ),
mg (
GLM Estimation
Number of obs
Number of groups
Obs per group: min
avg
max
Wald chi2(6)
Prob > chi2
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
20186
5908
1
3.4
5
508.61
0.0000
Coef.
lcoins
ndisease
female
age
lfam
child
_cons
-.0804454
.0346067
.1585075
.0030901
-.1406549
.1013677
.7764626
Semi-robust
Std. Err.
.0077782
.0024238
.0334407
.0015356
.0293672
.04301
.0717221
z
-10.34
14.28
4.74
2.01
-4.79
2.36
10.83
P>|z|
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.044
0.000
0.018
0.000
-.0652004
.0393573
.2240502
.0060999
-.0830962
.1856658
.9170354
GLM Estimation
The correlations Cor[yit , yis jxi ] for PA (unstructured) are not equal.
But they are not declining as fast as AR(1).
. matrix list e(R)
symmetric e(R)[5,5]
c1
c2
r1
1
r2 .53143297
1
r3 .40817495 .58547795
r4 .32357326 .35321716
r5 .34152288 .29803555
Pravin K. Trivedi
c3
c4
c5
1
.54321752
.43767583
1
.61948751
Poiss [i exp(xit0 )]
Pravin K. Trivedi
Number of obs
Number of groups
=
=
20186
5908
1
3.4
5
Log likelihood
Wald chi2(6)
Prob > chi2
= -43240.556
=
=
529.10
0.0000
Observed
Coef.
Bootstrap
Std. Err.
lcoins
ndisease
female
age
lfam
child
_cons
-.0878258
.0387629
.1667192
.0019159
-.1351786
.1082678
.7574177
.0086097
.0026904
.0379216
.0016242
.0308529
.0495487
.0754536
/lnalpha
.0251256
alpha
1.025444
z
-10.20
14.41
4.40
1.18
-4.38
2.19
10.04
P>|z|
-.1047004
.0334899
.0923942
-.0012675
-.1956492
.0111541
.6095314
-.0709511
.0440359
.2410442
.0050994
-.0747079
.2053816
.905304
.0270297
-.0278516
.0781029
.0277175
.9725326
1.081234
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.238
0.000
0.029
0.000
Normal-based
[95% Conf. Interval]
- Bloomington (Prepared
Panel counts
for 2010 Mexican
Statatimes
Users Group
April
meeting,
29, 2010
based on44A./ Colin
77
The defaultIndiana
(nonUniversity.
cluster-robust)
t-statistics
are 2.5
larger
Pravin K. Trivedi
. xtpoisson mdu lcoins ndisease female age lfam child, fe vce(boot, reps(100) seed(10
(running xtpoisson on estimation sample)
Bootstrap replications (100)
1
2
3
4
5
..................................................
..................................................
Conditional fixed-effects Poisson regression
Group variable: id
Log likelihood
50
100
Number of obs
Number of groups
=
=
17791
4977
2
3.6
5
Wald chi2(3)
Prob > chi2
= -24173.211
=
=
4.64
0.2002
Observed
Coef.
age
lfam
child
-.0112009
.0877134
.1059867
Bootstrap
Std. Err.
.0095077
.1125783
.0738452
z
-1.18
0.78
1.44
P>|z|
0.239
0.436
0.151
Normal-based
[95% Conf. Interval]
-.0298356
-.132936
-.0387472
.0074339
.3083627
.2507206
Limitations:
I
I
I
Pravin K. Trivedi
Find that
I
I
Pravin K. Trivedi
POOLED
POPAVE
-0.0808
0.0080
0.0339
0.0026
0.1718
0.0343
0.0041
0.0017
-0.1482
0.0323
0.1030
0.0507
0.7488
0.0786
-0.0804
0.0078
0.0346
0.0024
0.1585
0.0334
0.0031
0.0015
-0.1407
0.0294
0.1014
0.0430
0.7765
0.0717
RE_GAMMA
RE_NOR~L
-0.0878
0.0086
0.0388
0.0027
0.1667
0.0379
0.0019
0.0016
-0.1352
0.0309
0.1083
0.0495
0.7574
0.0755
-0.1145
0.0073
0.0409
0.0023
0.2084
0.0305
0.0027
0.0012
-0.1443
0.0265
0.0737
0.0345
0.2873
0.0642
FIXED
#1
lcoins
ndisease
female
age
lfam
child
_cons
-0.0112
0.0095
0.0877
0.1126
0.1060
0.0738
lnalpha
_cons
0.0251
0.0270
lnsig2u
_cons
0.0550
0.0255
Statistics
Pravin K. Trivedi
20186 (Prepared
20186
20186Stata Users
17791
N Indiana 20186
University. - Bloomington
Panel
counts
for 2010 Mexican
Group April
meeting,
29, 2010
based on48A./ Colin
77
=
=
exp(xit0 )i wit
exp(xit0 )i + wit
Moment spec.
E[xit uit +j ] = 0, j
E[xit uit s ] 6= 0, s
GMM
Chamberlain
Wooldridge
GMM/endog
Pravin K. Trivedi
Wooldridge
Estimating equations
0
1
it 1
yit 1 jxti 1 ) = 0
it
yit
yit 1 t 1
E
jx ) = 0
it
it 1 i
yit
yit 1 t 2
E
jx ) = 0
it
it 1 i
E yit
Pravin K. Trivedi
Applications
For illustrating panel methods the RAND data set has limitations
. sum
Variable
Obs
Mean
Min
Max
officevis
T0officevis
educ
age
income
78888
78888
78888
78888
78888
1.387372
1.488084
12.32776
4.562129
27.60833
3.328148
3.334559
3.264869
1.742034
28.94855
0
0
0
1.8
-63.631
94
58
17
8.5
264.674
totchr
78888
.7881047
1.081315
Pravin K. Trivedi
Std. Dev.
Applications
MEPS Data
Quarterly data for 2005-06
. xtdes
dupersid: 30002019, 30004010, ..., 38505016
n =
timeindex: 1, 2, ..., 8
T =
Delta(timeindex) = 1 unit
Span(timeindex) = 8 periods
(dupersid*timeindex uniquely identifies each observation)
Distribution of T_i:
Freq.
min
8
Percent
Cum.
9861
100.00
100.00
9861
100.00
Pravin K. Trivedi
5%
8
25%
8
50%
8
75%
8
95%
8
9861
8
max
8
Pattern
11111111
XXXXXXXX
Applications
Pravin K. Trivedi
Applications
0:
1:
2:
3:
GMM
GMM
GMM
GMM
criterion
criterion
criterion
criterion
Q(b)
Q(b)
Q(b)
Q(b)
=
=
=
=
///
.00140916
1.487e-07
1.583e-14
1.843e-28
GMM estimation
Number of parameters =
4
Number of moments
=
4
Initial weight matrix: Unadjusted
Coef.
/insprv
/age
/income
/totchr
-.0080549
-.5125841
.001128
.2211125
Robust
Std. Err.
.5460749
13.1682
.0013911
.3354182
Number of obs
z
-0.01
-0.04
0.81
0.66
P>|z|
0.988
0.969
0.417
0.510
78888
1.062232
25.29662
.0038545
.8785201
Applications
0:
1:
2:
3:
log
log
log
log
likelihood
likelihood
likelihood
likelihood
= -84468.435
= -84154.68
= -84154.647
= -84154.647
Log likelihood
Coef.
insprv
age
income
totchr
-.0080549
-.5125841
.001128
.2211125
=
=
63688
7961
8
8.0
8
Wald chi2(4)
Prob > chi2
= -84154.647
officevis
Number of obs
Number of groups
Std. Err.
.027985
.0629145
.000258
.0091051
z
-0.29
-8.15
4.37
24.28
P>|z|
0.773
0.000
0.000
0.000
=
=
618.20
0.0000
.0467947
-.3892739
.0016336
.2389582
Indiana
- Bloomington (Prepared
Panel counts
for 2010
Mexican
Stata
Users Group
April
meeting,
29,
based
on55A./ Colin
77
No dierence
in University.
point estimates
because
MLE
and
GMM
solve
the2010
same
Pravin K. Trivedi
Applications
0:
1:
2:
3:
log
log
log
log
likelihood
likelihood
likelihood
likelihood
= -84468.435
= -84154.68
= -84154.647
= -84154.647
Log likelihood
Coef.
insprv
age
income
totchr
-.0080549
-.5125841
.001128
.2211125
=
=
63688
7961
8
8.0
8
Wald chi2(4)
Prob > chi2
= -84154.647
officevis
Number of obs
Number of groups
Std. Err.
.027985
.0629145
.000258
.0091051
z
-0.29
-8.15
4.37
24.28
P>|z|
0.773
0.000
0.000
0.000
=
=
618.20
0.0000
.0467947
-.3892739
.0016336
.2389582
Coef.
officevis
insprv
age
income
totchr
-.0080549
-.5125841
.001128
.2211125
Std. Err.
.0715881
.1804831
.0007661
.0250814
z
-0.11
-2.84
1.47
8.82
P>|z|
0.910
0.005
0.141
0.000
.1322552
-.1588438
.0026295
.2702712
Wald
chi2(4) = Indiana
80.59
ProbMexican
> chi2 Stata
=
0.0000
Pravin
K. Trivedi
University. - Bloomington (Prepared
Panel counts
for 2010
Users Group April
meeting,
29, 2010
based on56A./ Colin
77
1)
e.g. Many doctor visits last period lead to many this period.
Linear model:
yit = i + yi ,t
+ xit0 + uit .
Pravin K. Trivedi
= i it 1 = i exp(yi ,t
= min(c, yi ,t 1 ).
+ xit0 ),
1 , ..., yi 1 , xit,..., xi 1 ]
= i it
1.
(it
= 0.
So MM or GMM based on
E zit
where e.g. zit = (yit
yit
1 , xit )
it 1
yit
it
=0
in just-identied case.
0:
1:
2:
3:
4:
5:
6:
GMM
GMM
GMM
GMM
GMM
GMM
GMM
criterion
criterion
criterion
criterion
criterion
criterion
criterion
Q(b)
Q(b)
Q(b)
Q(b)
Q(b)
Q(b)
Q(b)
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
4.9539327
4.7296297
1.4832673
.01045573
6.508e-06
3.032e-12
7.264e-25
GMM estimation
Number of parameters =
7
Number of moments
=
7
Initial weight matrix: Unadjusted
Number of obs
69027
/xb_L_offi~s
.064072
.2152153
/xb_insprv
/xb_educ
.0404143
/xb_age
.1221278
-.0003585
/xb_income
/xb_totchr
.3027348
/b0
-1.447292
Pravin K. Trivedi
Indiana University. -
Robust
Std. Err.
P>|z|
.0041069
15.60
0.000
.0560228
.0721213
.0331676
6.49
0.000
.1502079
.2802227
.0065808
6.14
0.000
.0275162
.0533124
.0134542
9.08
0.000
.0957581
.1484976
.0004981
-0.72
0.472
-.0013347
.0006178
.0141805
21.35
0.000
.2749415
.330528
.0952543
-15.19
0.000
-1.633987
-1.260597
Bloomington (Prepared
Panel counts
for 2010 Mexican Stata Users Group April
meeting,
29, 2010
based on59A./ Colin
77
0:
1:
2:
3:
4:
5:
6:
GMM
GMM
GMM
GMM
GMM
GMM
GMM
criterion
criterion
criterion
criterion
criterion
criterion
criterion
Q(b)
Q(b)
Q(b)
Q(b)
Q(b)
Q(b)
Q(b)
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
4.9696148
3.7545442
.86353039
.25844389
.07248002
.07235453
.07235443
GMM estimation
Number of parameters =
7
Number of moments
= 11
Initial weight matrix: Unadjusted
Number of obs
69027
.0631186
.0468067
.0422612
.1208516
.0004412
.2988192
-1.361726
Robust
Std. Err.
.0042901
.1154105
.0074362
.0136986
.0007107
.0144326
.0972536
z
14.71
0.41
5.68
8.82
0.62
20.70
-14.00
P>|z|
0.000
0.685
0.000
0.000
0.535
0.000
0.000
.071527
.273007
.0568359
.1477003
.0018341
.3271066
-1.171113
Instruments
for
equation
L.officevis
educcounts
age
income
totchr
female
marrie
Pravin
K. Trivedi
Indiana
University.1:- Bloomington
(Prepared
Panel
for
2010
Mexican
Stata Users
Groupwhite
April
meeting,
29,hispanic
2010
based on60
A./ Colin
77
yi ,t
f (yi ,t jit ) =
it
it yit
it
yit !
= it it = E[yit jyi ,t
1 , xit , i ]
= g (yi ,t
1 , xit , i )
Alternative specications
1 , i ]
= h(yit , xit , i )
Pravin K. Trivedi
Initial conditions
Dynamic panel model requires additional assumptions about the
relationship between the initial observations ("initial conditions") y0
and the i .
Eect of initial value on the future events is important in a short
panel. The initial-value eect might be a part of individual-specic
eect
Wooldridges method requires a specication of the conditional
distribution of i given y0 and zi , with the latter entering separably.
Under the assumption that the initial conditions are nonrandom, the
standard random eects conditional maximum likelihood approach
identies the parameters of interest.
For a class of nonlinear dynamic panel models, including the Poisson
model, Wooldridge (2005) analyzes this model which conditions the
joint distribution on the initial conditions.
Pravin K. Trivedi
Pravin K. Trivedi
Pravin K. Trivedi
0:
1:
2:
3:
4:
5:
6:
GMM
GMM
GMM
GMM
GMM
GMM
GMM
criterion
criterion
criterion
criterion
criterion
criterion
criterion
Q(b)
Q(b)
Q(b)
Q(b)
Q(b)
Q(b)
Q(b)
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
4.9539327
4.7296297
1.4832673
.01045573
6.508e-06
3.032e-12
7.264e-25
GMM estimation
Number of parameters =
7
Number of moments
=
7
Initial weight matrix: Unadjusted
Number of obs
69027
Robust
Std. Err.
P>|z|
.0041069
15.60
0.000
.0560228
.0721213
.0331676
6.49
0.000
.1502079
.2802227
.0065808
6.14
0.000
.0275162
.0533124
.0134542
9.08
0.000
.0957581
.1484976
.0004981
-0.72
0.472
-.0013347
.0006178
.0141805
21.35
0.000
.2749415
.330528
.0952543
-15.19
0.000
-1.633987
-1.260597
Bloomington (Prepared
Panel counts
for 2010 Mexican Stata Users Group April
meeting,
29, 2010
based on66A./ Colin
77
0:
1:
2:
3:
4:
5:
6:
GMM
GMM
GMM
GMM
GMM
GMM
GMM
criterion
criterion
criterion
criterion
criterion
criterion
criterion
Q(b)
Q(b)
Q(b)
Q(b)
Q(b)
Q(b)
Q(b)
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
4.9696148
3.7545442
.86353039
.25844389
.07248002
.07235453
.07235443
GMM estimation
Number of parameters =
7
Number of moments
= 11
Initial weight matrix: Unadjusted
Number of obs
69027
Pravin K. Trivedi
.0631186
.0468067
.0422612
.1208516
.0004412
.2988192
Robust
Std. Err.
.0042901
.1154105
.0074362
.0136986
.0007107
.0144326
z
14.71
0.41
5.68
8.82
0.62
20.70
P>|z|
0.000
0.685
0.000
0.000
0.535
0.000
.071527
.273007
.0568359
.1477003
.0018341
.3271066
6.30e-26
GMM estimation
Number of parameters =
8
Number of moments
=
8
Initial weight matrix: Unadjusted
Number of obs
69027
.0495929
.0311947
.2153361
.0382539
.1303702
-.0003019
.2847798
-1.484486
Robust
Std. Err.
.0044248
.0043446
.0351702
.0056386
.0095834
.0004701
.010334
.0605323
z
11.21
7.18
6.12
6.78
13.60
-0.64
27.56
-24.52
P>|z|
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.521
0.000
0.000
.0582654
.0397099
.2842684
.0493054
.1491534
.0006194
.3050341
-1.365845
Instruments for equation 1: L.officevis T0officevis insprv educ age income totchr _c
Pravin K. Trivedi
.0685762
GMM estimation
Number of parameters =
8
Number of moments
= 12
Initial weight matrix: Unadjusted
Number of obs
69027
.0490201
.0305356
.0565968
.0402952
.1299791
.0004368
.2805608
-1.408679
Robust
Std. Err.
.0046062
.0044538
.1135886
.0059253
.0098075
.000703
.0101571
.0607941
z
10.64
6.86
0.50
6.80
13.25
0.62
27.62
-23.17
P>|z|
0.000
0.000
0.618
0.000
0.000
0.534
0.000
0.000
.0580481
.0392648
.2792264
.0519085
.1492014
.0018148
.3004684
-1.289525
Instruments for equation 1: L.officevis T0officevis educ age income totchr female wh
married employed _cons
Pravin K. Trivedi
1 , i ]
= yit
+ exp(xit0 + i )
Pravin K. Trivedi
= yit
= yit
0
0
+ exp(x1it
1 + + x2it
2 + 1 yi 0 + zi0 2 + wi )
0
0
0
1 + exp(wi ) exp(x1it 1 + + x2it 2 + 1 yi 0 + zi 2 + wi )
1
(yit
it )2
7.35e-23
GMM estimation
Number of parameters =
8
Number of moments
=
8
Initial weight matrix: Unadjusted
Number of obs
69027
.5366234
.0672159
.1509578
.0375916
.1234875
-.0002804
.3270725
-2.187085
Robust
Std. Err.
.0248079
.0038061
.0408185
.0062318
.0119579
.0006164
.0154421
.096687
z
21.63
17.66
3.70
6.03
10.33
-0.45
21.18
-22.62
P>|z|
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.649
0.000
0.000
.585246
.0746758
.2309606
.0498058
.1469245
.0009277
.3573383
-1.997582
Instruments for equation 1: L.officevis T0officevis insprv educ age income totchr _c
Pravin K. Trivedi
Pravin K. Trivedi
Concluding Remarks
Pravin K. Trivedi
References
Pravin K. Trivedi
References
use
instead!
References
Pravin K. Trivedi
References
Pravin K. Trivedi
References
Pravin K. Trivedi