Professional Documents
Culture Documents
t
r
3
fi*'i$iii,r,#:ii";;;ti"
n{
-.'\. ; "* *.tu*iftf;f r:-,. Efu
rt,€l:!1,-Ai."t,t9
*4.- ... ;;.ili,ffii:,l:
t,\;s^j-,1d !:,er, !_ !!.!
t5/
coN'ftN ls
IATA Dange.ous
Coods
CJrSo
Possible
Causes
ofrheFne
t Jl b
REPOR'T ON
TIIi:FIRD,{,\D EXPLOS ION ASPECTS
. RgLATINCTO TIIE LOSSOF
r O \ 1 8 1,
T H Es O I T H \ F R I c a I I i R w A Y S7 1 7 = 2 0 0 8
REG.ZS.SA5, ON28THNOVENII]ER T'8?
NEAR II{AURITTUS
C,Nl, SOIITIILqRD
8SSr/CrIS
-_ "'
b",.,er,,r1\1xJ,,Jl)1,JV-ytooa,a1i2odJ,.,
J . ) r h J . n eI o 8 4 ., n " o . b . , \
^^.,r,,; ;,.,:;;,i;"
:,i l,l,"":::l:.l_,".".o_,.',,,r,"
i:*:T:,::::T::::: o"*'"
::*"""u." ",,,,"
*,,,:;; ;:ff; i::l
argc eeJ f-d b.. I
d . !o r B \ . I 0 .
'ri*xfi,ffilw
-;:r:1';:'.T*h:'.:
:;:
;#+,.,*'.r :;I j :ffi
0. r oirhe.e. pre..u.o
e r j t ' r , j .-r : -B: sr 12 _
l ol o' ,,.pt " .nr h
", -+ o i ' ' J b e e r r e P or r o
- |rrhe(oapd.rner|
co.firedro dererhinine
wxcme.
ofiioh..^r^
",,,.." _;;,;;,;":,.;:i
,..,.
Il,fij:"1:::*::'::.:::
li",l.:.il"l:,1,:*" -- :l:l;:;:l:.:;:
i;
rnerewasany
_....,,."i!,J,J,Jresulor,rerona.o,
"'..'."^'"""
;,;1"1",11;'1.,-;;'1;'"
--1"*- -" *+!!!re!!_!!:ls!-9l
.,. i"il,l,l',ll
, ,.. ., . Lilffifi'i, liii
.":-++'*#Jr9!1_!!8"!:_j!t:!:!
",",'iea,rcr,trandJhrnar"ty.!e+rr"id.1r,eorrner.re
:J
r a , r i n . ' r e. c r g o . o m o , . r n r e f t .
I n o r . e . r o B d r g e. 1 e t . l e r
0o0
I:,:,::,_'.o 1 b e t , esl , r r 1 , - o r r n e , e f D e r a , u , e \
e , p e . . e n c e d . n ,Jn,". -
o'.,"0,"."*,.;;;;;;.'
::ih
;:::i,::.:i':"I:t*::'t :;i;:;;"ll;;:;;"
*, ^ *ir.,"",r,",."r.ing.i"j,_;;;
;il:::;::,,ff:
;:_*:i:i ].:j:_, "*,""". ";;;t;.
ilJ"j"::i"f.::,
e!:!_r
!3qEelred in' r!!_.']1!.
rbi
;;;;":-;ltl^;illl:..:
. Nletringhu oc.r(.d. "";",
" ,.
;:11:'l,.:"'i:1,:: ''jo .", '" o"-,'. ","- ,".1^
::l* ",J;.,,;.."'";,;.,:J::;T; ;i ;..;,::;:jj;
:l::
I,_:.,:,JJ
::l'::.: ;:.:fi:If
In addirioqt|ere wasnetrine
ir
rl
,
(ft ro the coppercondlcrorsof wiing roured
loMa.d tiie ratr $ppon over
beao.-someof rhisnelringcourdhavebeen
causedby
$ 068
r
qposedw^ g'!e! b' conducrjvity
measuremenrs ,!ken on rtE skinbv Dr C F.\fler.
rrde re$rrs@nrirned
rhatrre higr,esr
renperarures
weree[*i.i."a bfIJJin
berqeenBS 1800,1820
andsringeA t5R-i4R. In addirrodtr wasnoledrhal the patnr
"r tn"."',t,,""r tl,
riJ:,rm
rt _
nad iallenonro so,ic ilems. ir padicutarrhe
r "'r. l N
.rlbGriter,r nrFenoorrphotogi,..hL
9C carso.e! wasnor hc,t airecred
3.1 The Cr.so on (hc Ca.soLkr, is prodlcedby lhe DCA ro. tlain c.reo Dock
Compartnent
3 2 iATA D!nge.ons
CcodsRegutrtio.j
t
I
ata
tu tra6porr k rhe InrcrnrlonJi
f
"il:',i':.;1,..l:,-'"":"
,l-1":. .;r"J; :;l:::::i:;;li
?Ur TrrnsDd( /
;;;::;::;:;:";::"#.","::
. , . , , i r e c x , q , , o. -"s" . .
'l ;;."-',J "" .,.","r..";,;.'-,,"'.'
,.,"*, ,
*
2 i::1,
i1;;; ":
*
::::il';':'j,;"::iiIll11.;i;,i;.;:I
"" I r"ril.
:"',i!";t ;
f " ;"::.',:;
:::"-,.,". :"i-:"i:l:""i"
;llil::"
E
6 n l r u f e . l Ue e o . L j 5 l : h : :
r h J n j u _ar s e n e r JItn l c
E-
I ",1l;:,:,,"tj;l;.; .1..'' e,.J Ji,:.
;,:1,';: :,i]::
s
-
I edb) - ,. " "r. "*-," ,.,",,i""1
_e I
F ",'lll ::::l";'"'
r " ! , i n c u w n $ r n t j K r k \ L h ec i r s
.,.,:.".,,"t.
":'"; ;';:';':ii';i:;,j,;::
J i t l U n a i o nr n t r )u
";".,:l:
,
tre, .. i, , (eorroi.iry .onFoJi,,..., i
* , - - , ' d * . q . i : . ; ; ; : : : ; " 1 " i l ; " [p; .J( ,: -; d
i ,.( g
,o. ._n.poir 01 ",, ,;:",1,'.'*-
';:li:i,";
l " : " i i ' ; " : : " :I : : : r ' ^,;';;:;. , ' b!,o ,b u 1 . r , p p e
: : r h ' ' ' ' p o;r;;
"'.'::,:.;i"iT' ' or , , . o i
.,:;:t :l:, : ;.::* ;;:
* " .,^';;";;;;.:'.ii','
,l;;;X;'" jii :ll
-ii1"..1'",'i1.,
';.1.^11,1i1,,"
*.*r**
' - 6 . - n u 5 lconcernjns
IA'A" u c e r r f g r,he Gtrpor!
h. a t u p o n ot 'DaigcroLs
'n',"'"'.",;
^^.-,.,
.r. -"1,"""i1",""
o'"d;;;';; ;::iil",.:il i"
AIponrr. ...nd \r,n-..,*rr!n{,/e5reconhendadons
- '"b" '",u,_8. ro"d.nE
coodt,
as ro
serk_,^, .. a r d securineiand tor
ncomrrDk,uur_ne. w.1,1 w I r r,.*.,o
rhe
so;d:;"jlo'
C o o d rh - ., ., . ,
, q , c , o a rg e r u u t J* i t h
e g u t dr,o
o r,,"
' e larer, soDe {langero!s
o n pa l u r t _ e",n o r l e r e t o . e
ouflng transitrheyftus
471
.
be physically
separared,
sometimes in djffererrholds. hshing and securi,rg
amngcnentsmuslbecai.jcdourin ..cordancewilhrheoperarots innrucrions.
Noneof$esubslaiceslistedonthecarlo list
, , ashaury becdnow.d
urd have,D ny opiruon.reactedw h one
,helord,rions
or lovr8e in rne4rc,rfr. s,miia,I,
:1::-:,t 1..*"1
n o r nn gn q e J{ h r c h w o u ' d
h a r eb e eI p r o n er o l e t f h e a r i u B u u innoCr a S e .
at2
.1. CALCULATIONS
li
0/3
i. Dtsc!SsloNs
(ii) 'Ile.e $as no fne damage aroundthe windowtraneson lhe riahrsideoi palter
PR *hich indicarcd that no firc had burnron |he irgrrtlde to\verrhanlbour
stringerr9R. il ike had dctetopedar lbis point or if debris
bad iallen doqn,
flahesqould haveburntrhrougbfi€ polycrrbonare ,pulrdo\vn,shade
ovc! rhe
Mndow wrrhrelariveeaseand aho d4ftoyed $e plastc
windows,producing
tracesotrhatbuningon llie windowfranes.No sucht.lcess.ere
ioutrd,
(in) In ny opitrioqif rhefirc laj staded
rowa.dsrhelert sideoathe pxttcrn qould
haveinvolvedPanerpLat a fanlyearlysta8eandir is likdy rhar
debrisfrom !he
e d g eo. . f e r f _ , ' e bv o , . | 1 , . 1 cr J i e r a o q . " L sI heal
C damagelo $e itoor
i
(rv) The inrenseleat whichu6 l
expedencedby the skiobehveen
levelof slringer15Rindicatedlnar a locatised
BS l80l]_t82l]ar i I
fire nad buht adjacentro rhis
area. If a firc h.d sla.redlowerdoM towaldsrheccnrre
of lhe palterI solld
lave expededit to hrve spreadlpwardsard olrwards
rowardsrhe top ot rhe
pall.r, horder ro fiavecals€drhctocalised
dmag€ seeno€Neentss r30l]-lS2O
1i
'iii
al4 ri
it trouldhlve beenoece$aryro havearriliciatty
channelted
rhe iire ros.rds thlr
(r) A normaldirfusion
flamctke invollingontyrbenlleriah Inrenon t|c ca.g. l$r
w|ich had becr burningrnd producjngsmokctor sornetin., bur lor
some
..rson hadnotbecr dct.clci
(ii) A prornord or a(.tenrcd lire which w."rd h.v. d::.l.i.j ,.r, ,.1piLltv rn<,
r. i n i r i . t i o n . n di o r L d h a r e p , r C u . e di n t c n s eh e a tI n F " d i ^ r e l ,
i . U o * i n di S r i r i . .
!l This Ilpe oa tne coul,l hxur i.ecn .r!3e.1 !t .ither an inc€ndixr/
devi.c or br
!ome chetriicxlrc.cliotr\virhincrrgoDorlisredon lhe ca,gortrr.
r
The nomal niilusjonflame Ine, tuclled odt by lje qpe ., $bn.nces
li$eJ in
rhecareolisr an{trheasso.icredpackagi.s.canonlyreactrcc ain renrper!rures ao{l
.nir cedainlevehot cnergy.This h dtre to rhe fact lh.r theyarc
lestrj.ledbl 1|e
sfeed ar rvbich(he iuei can conbine wirh orrgen in th€ surouiding.ir
ie. rhe
corlbi.arioncanontyhke ptaceat the €dgesof rheflafre. ConsequearL),
rherareof
Dum'ngsoull be lessand rher€tore lhe enerSyemilredeoutd be sma er than if rtj.
oxrSenwas mi{edwirhrhefuetbeforeicnitjonie premiledllame. -:l
l::,i,i'ri '
;:i il .
;;,'t;ig_fti_::":l;
p, - ",,:: " """
"lJ:...|:ii'ii
.::iiii:.;::'il:;T ;;,'i1;
;::^"r.;,
;;'i;;,I;;
.;"* l*trj,I;]1+:HJ1 .*:::r**:i ::::
'.,1;: :#*fu#*t,;;ilr; i; i ;jl,ir:t,,
:;:Tlijl;
"1. xti: Ijil#} : tiir"r:r.
:.::;:
""; ; r:
;:":::::t :'*it''. """."..
;;";,;;:
."'.,1,,1J,,i..
ii,;';;;i
*;::;:;:;:;::'::: :ffHr;,j::*ll:,*j r',:
I an tr.refore of (he
ca.gosro$cdon pallerpR. 1fiecarseof tte fire was
somerhinc
in rhc
oelibeEtelyptanred nave.beenan incendjary devicewhichwar
in rhe courd haye been a cb€nical
whict was
a7/
'fhc h.in
dcckcrrtsoconrpldhen!wascquiptedwnh r 16 ttr {7.25Kg)IhLon
L.ll1 crrnrsuishdbut o$d !lalon erringlishe^nnd waterc{inguishenwere ako
rerrl,bleon boardlbe ahcrafr.Ellod 1t11(;CF) extinguishes namesby interf*ine
$irh rhechainroacdonin ilanes antl consltuedtlyliaton lould be €ffecriveon fics
n,volrnBnorn'alpackagnrg mare.irkin.!io:: !3nslbt. tiquid!. riHalon js uscdon
lrcs iuv"lvirgoxidisiDglgcrrs o! ircrlLsN rtrc iLrct,Ios..vcr, rhcr rtre IIrt(nr crn
..rct qrlh tlre burningFeral 4! oyirlijcr jnJ pic.lJ.. M .\-Jt$nic.eacriotr Lyhi.h
enn6 a raree quaniitt ol |eat. rhus pronod.g the iire insre3ri.!.r.inAui:tii3 ii.
rvrtcr *ould have a similar €ifect or metat lircs untesssuficienr spray could D.
appliedIo cool rhe area. This is u..likelyiron a iimired sourcesuchrs a p.rr.b!. fire
F al3
I
T
5 (i, coNctustoN
I
! Ti:e lire on boarddr SouthAlricanAiNlys 747,Regiskarion ZS SASlvhjch
T
I
(d'ed ofl i{auririuson28tbNovenber1987srartedin P.llet PR,\vhichwassilulred
r t t l r e l r o n t r i g h r s i d et o
h fe n a i n d e c k c a r g o c o m p l r l m e n i
I
t3 In iry opinioorhe lire na ed a a rlpidly devetopingnamingfire rowardsrte
rup righl sideof rhepaller,andnmes cxrended a(.$ lhe c.oNn.i the ahcdit and
ove.,1!et_oNdrdlileraftsuppoiib€amatBS1680-1720.'tl;cheatdamagede(easd
* .s th€distlncefromBS 1800!820increded-
E
E
Ii j; aljo rny opinion lhar tbe fi.e wascausedby sonelhins in rnc careoa.Fen
on Palle' PR whichpr.m.!.J a npidly devclopiig fire ar an early si!:.. Tl,i! .,-nt
hxeebeeneitheran in.endiarydeviceorahuardols substance wnhin nie.!rgo shi.tt
had appar€ndynot beer declared.Mant 5uchsub$nces havelhe abilily ro isdj|e anJ
promorcan n'tensetue ifspilled on ro suitablesubsrrates,
( q=a;\ss.*\