T.M.a. Pai Foundation and Ors. Etc. V State of Karnataka and Ors. Etc.

14/03/2016
Delivery | Westlaw India
Westlaw India Delivery Summary

Request made by :
NOVUS
IP USER
Request made on:
Monday, 14 March, 2016 at 23:44 IST
Client ID:
innlsbang-1
Content Type:
Cases > Supreme Court Judgments
Title :
T.M.A. Pai Foundation and others v State of

Karnataka and Others
Delivery selection:
Current Document
Number of documents delivered:
2016 Thomson Reuters South Asia Private Limited
14/03/2016
Page 2
T.M.A. Pai Foundation and others v State of Karnataka and

Others
Supreme Court of India
31 October 2002
Case Analysis
Bench
B.N. Kirpal, G.B. Pattanaik, S. Rajendra Babu, V.N. Khare,

S.S.M. Quadri
Where Reported
2002 Indlaw SC 1375; (2002) 8 SCC 481; AIR 2003 SC

355; AIR 2002 SCW 4957; 2002 (4) AWC 3297; JT 2002
(9) SC 1; 2002(8) SCALE 1; 2002 (6) SLR 627; 2002 (6)
SLT 313; [2002] Supp3 S.C.R. 587; 2002 (3) UPLBEC 2817
Case Digest
Subject: Constitution; Practice & Procedure; Trusts &

Associations
Summary: Constitution of India, arts. 29(2) and 30(1) Education - Minority - (A) Is there a fundamental right to
set up educational institutions and if so, under which
provision? - Held, the right to establish and administer
educational institutions is guaranteed under the
Constitution to all citizens under arts. 19(1)(g) and 26, and
to minorities specifically under art. 30 - (B) Does
Unnikrishnan's case require reconsideration? - Held, the
scheme framed by the Supreme Court in Unni Krishnan's
case and the direction to impose the same, except where it
holds that primary education is a fundamental right, is
unconstitutional However, the principle that there should
not be capitation fee or profiteering is correct -(C) In case
of private institutions, can there be Govt. regulations and, if
so, to what extent? - Held, unaided professional institutions
are entitled to autonomy in their administration while, at
the same time, they do not forgo or discard the principle of
merit Aided institutions, however, cannot obtain that extent
of autonomy in relation to management and administration,
but at the same time, it cannot also be treated as an
educational institution departmentally run by Govt. or as a
wholly owned and controlled Govt. institution and interfere
14/03/2016
Page 3
with Constitution of the governing bodies or thrusting the

staff without reference to Management - (D) In order to
determine the existence of a religious or linguistic minority
in relation to article 30, what is to be the unit - State or the
country as a whole? - Held, since reorganization of the
States in India has been on linguistic lines, therefore for the
purpose of determining the minority, the unit will be the
State and not the whole of India - (E) To what extent can
the rights of aided private minority institutions to
administer be regulated? - Held, any law or rule or
regulation that would put the educational institutions run by
the minorities at a disadvantage when compared to the
institutions run by the others will have to be struck down At the same time, there also cannot be any reverse
discrimination - Referred questions answered.
All Cases Cited
Relied On
Sodan Singh Etc. v New Delhi Municipal Committee And
Anr. Etc.1989 Indlaw SC 213, (1989) 4 SCC 155, AIR 1989
SC 1988, 1989 ALJ 1097, JT 1989 (3) SC 553, 1989(2)
SCALE 430, [1989] 3 S.C.R. 1038, 1990 (1) UJ 187
Kumari Chitra Ghosh and Another v Union of India and
Others1969 Indlaw SC 525, (1969) 2 SCC 228, AIR 1970
SC 35, [1970] 1 S.C.R. 413
Minor P. Rajendran v State of Madras and Others1968
Indlaw SC 341, AIR 1968 SC 1012, 1968 (2) MLJ(SC) 121,
1968 (2) SCJ 801, [1968] 2 S.C.R. 786, 1968 (2) SLJ 801
R. Chitralekha and Another v State of Mysore and
Others1964 Indlaw SC 103, AIR 1964 SC 1823, [1964] 6
S.C.R. 368
Affirmed
St. Stephen'S College v University Of Delhi 1991 Indlaw
SC 295, (1992) 1 SCC 558, AIR 1992 SC 1630, AIR 1992
SCW 1792, JT 1991 (4) SC 548, 1991(2) SCALE 1217,
1991 (6) SLR 1, [1991] Supp3 S.C.R. 121
Stephen's College vs. University of Delhi1992 (1) SC 558
Overruled
Unni Krishnan, J.P. And Ors. Etc. Etc v State Of Andhra
Pradesh And Ors. Etc. Etc.1993 Indlaw SC 1056, (1993) 1
SCC 645, AIR 1993 SC 2178, AIR 1993 SCW 863, JT 1993
(1) SC 474, 1993(1) SCALE 290, [1993] 1 S.C.R. 594,
1993 (1) SLR 743, 1993 (1) UJ 721
Distinguished
14/03/2016
Page 4
Rev. Father W. Proost and Others v State of Bihar and

Others1968 Indlaw SC 368, AIR 1969 SC 465, 1969 (1)
SCJ 700, [1969] 2 S.C.R. 73
Referred
Society of St. Joseph's College v Union of India and
others2001 Indlaw SC 205, (2002) 1 SCC 273, AIR 2002
SC 195, 2002 (1) ALD(SC) 60, 2002 (46) ALR 240, 2002
(5) ESC 227, JT 2001 (9) SC 538, 2002 (1) KLT 438,
2001(8) SCALE 206, 2001 (5) SCJ 303, 2001 (8) SLT 119,
[2001] Supp5 S.C.R. 273, 2001 (8) Supreme 211
P.V. Narasimha Rao v State(Cbi/SPE)1998 Indlaw SC 690,
(1998) 4 SCC 626, (1998) SCC (Cr) 1108, AIR 1998 SC
2120, 1998 (2) CCR 138, 1998 (2) Crimes 124, 1998 CRLJ
2930, JT 1998 (3) SC 318, 1998 (4) RCR(Criminal) 260,
1998(3) SCALE 53, [1998] 2 S.C.R. 870, 1998 (4) SLT 400,
1998 (4) Supreme 1
Mohini Jain (Miss) v State of Karnataka and Others1992
Indlaw SC 527, (1992) 3 SCC 666, AIR 1992 SC 1858, AIR
1992 SCW 2100, JT 1992 (4) SC 292, 1992(2) SCALE 90,
[1992] 3 S.C.R. 658, 1992 (5) SLR 1, 1992 (2) UJ 331,
1992 (2) UPLBEC 1198
Indra Sawhney v Union of India and Others1991 Indlaw
SC 280, (1992) Supp3 SCC 215, (1992) SCC (L&S) 482,
1992 (22) ATC 384
Christian Medical College Hospital Employees Union Andanr.
v Christian Medical College Vellore Association And
Ors.1987 Indlaw SC 28443, (1987) 4 SCC 691, (1988) SCC
(L&S) 53, AIR 1988 SC 37, 1988 (2) CCC 309, JT 1987 (4)
SC 129, 1988 LabIC 225, 1988 (1) LLJ 263, 1988 (1) LLN
9, 1987(2) SCALE 798, [1988] 1 S.C.R. 546, 1989 (1) SLJ
130, 1988 (1) SLR 259
Frank Anthony Public School Employees' Association v
Union of India and Others1986 Indlaw SC 734, (1986) 4
SCC 707, AIR 1987 SC 311, 1987 (2) ATC 35, 1987 (54)
FLR 353, JT 1986 SC 861, 1987 LabIC 427, 1987 (1) LLN
53, 1986(2) SCALE 805, [1987] 1 S.C.R. 238, 1987 (1) SLR
133
R. S. Nayak v A. R. Antulay1984 Indlaw SC 338, (1984)
SCC (Cr) 172, (1984) 2 SCC 183, AIR 1984 SC 684, 1984
(86) BomLR 365, 1984 (3) Crimes 568, 1984 CRLJ 613,
1984 CrLR(SC) 163, 1984(3) SCALE 198, [1984] 2 S.C.R.
495, 1984 (1) SLJ 347, 1984 (1) SLR 619
Sanjeev Coke Manufacturing Company v Bharat Coking
Coal Ltd. And Another1982 Indlaw SC 134, (1983) 1 SCC
14/03/2016
Page 5
147, AIR 1983 SC 239, 1982(2) SCALE 1193, [1983] 1

S.C.R. 1000, 1983 UJ 81
K. P. Varghese v Income Tax Officer, Ernakulam and
Another1981 Indlaw SC 334, (1981) 4 SCC 173, (1981)
SCC (Tax) 293, AIR 1981 SC 1922, 1981 (24) CTR 358,
[1981] 131 ITR 597, 1981(3) SCALE 1315, [1982] 1 S.C.R.
629, 1981 TAXLR 1448, [1981] 7 TAXMAN 13
All Saints High School, Hyderabad Etc v Government of
Andhra Pradesh and Others Etc1980 Indlaw SC 328, (1980)
2 SCC 478, AIR 1980 SC 1042, [1980] 2 S.C.R. 924, 1980
(1) SLR 716
Lilly Kurian v Sr. Lewina And Ors1978 Indlaw SC 85,
(1979) 2 SCC 124, (1979) SCC (L&S) 134, AIR 1979 SC 52,
1978 LabIC 1644, [1979] 1 S.C.R. 820, 1979 (1) SLR 26
Rt. Rev. Magr. Mark Netto v Govt. Of Kerala & Ors.1978
Indlaw SC 496, (1979) 1 SCC 23, AIR 1979 SC 83, [1979]
1 S.C.R. 609
Bangalore Water Supply and Sewerage Board and others
v A. Rajappa and Others1978 Indlaw SC 260, (1978) 2 SCC
213, (1978) SCC (L&S) 215, AIR 1978 SC 969, 1978 (36)
FLR 266, 1978 LabIC 467, 1978 (1) LLJ 349, [1978] 3
S.C.R. 207
Gandhi Faizeam College Shahajahanpur v University Of
Agra And Another1975 Indlaw SC 116, (1975) 2 SCC 283,
AIR 1975 SC 1821, [1975] 3 S.C.R. 810
The Ahmedabad St. Xaviers College Society & Anr. Etc. v
State Of Gujarat & Anr.1974 Indlaw SC 268, (1974) 1 SCC
717, AIR 1974 SC 1389, [1975] 1 S.C.R. 173
His Holiness Kesavananda Bharati Sripadgalvaru and
Others v State of Kerala and Another1973 Indlaw SC 537,
(1973) 4 SCC 225, AIR 1973 SC 1461, [1973] Supp S.C.R.
1
Seshammal and Others v State of Tamil Nadu1972 Indlaw
SC 607, (1972) 2 SCC 11, AIR 1972 SC 1586, 1973 (1) MLJ
58, 1973 (1) MLJ(SC) 58, [1972] 3 S.C.R. 815
D. A. V. College Etc. v State Of Punjab & Ors1971
Indlaw SC 638, (1971) 2 SCC 269, AIR 1971 SC 1737,
[1971] S.C.R. 688, [1971] Supp S.C.R. 688
State Of Kerala, Etc v Very Rev. Mother Provincial,
Etc1970 Indlaw SC 318, (1970) 2 SCC 417, AIR 1970 SC
2079, 1970 KLT 630, [1971] 1 S.C.R. 734
Rt. Rev. Bishop S. K. Patro and Others v State of Bihar
and Others1969 Indlaw SC 161, (1969) 1 SCC 863, AIR
14/03/2016
Page 6
1970 SC 259, 1969 KLT 312, [1970] 1 S.C.R. 172

Tilkayat Shri Govindlalji Maharaj v State of Rajasthan
and Others1963 Indlaw SC 305, AIR 1963 SC 1638, 1964
(2) SCJ 1715, [1964] 1 S.C.R. 561
Rev. Sidhajbhai Sabhai and Others V v State of Bombay
and Another1962 Indlaw SC 259, AIR 1963 SC 540, 1962
KerLJ 135, [1963] 3 S.C.R. 837
The Durgah Committee, Ajmer Andanother v Syed
Hussain Ali And Others1961 Indlaw SC 126, AIR 1961 SC
1402, [1962] 1 S.C.R. 383
Bhinka and Others v Charan Singh1959 Indlaw SC 76, AIR
1959 SC 960, 1959 CRLJ 1223, 1960 SCJ 892, [1959] 2
S.C.R. 798
Pandit M. S. M. Sharma v Shri Sri Krishna Sinha and
MLJ(SC) 125, [1959] 1 S.C.R. 806, [1959] Supp1 S.C.R.
806
In Re The Kerala Education Bill, 19571958 Indlaw SC
182, AIR 1958 SC 956, 1958 ILR(Ker) 1167, 1959 SCJ 321,
[1959] 1 S.C.R. 995
Mohd. Hanif Quareshi and Others v State of Bihar1958
Indlaw SC 48, AIR 1958 SC 731, 1958 SCJ 975, [1959] 1
S.C.R. 629
Sri Venkataramana Devaru and Others v State of
Mysore and Others (with connected petition)1957 Indlaw
SC 120, AIR 1958 SC 255, 1988 (34) E.L.T. 521, 1958 (1)
MLJ(SC) 109, 1958 SCJ 382, [1958] 1 S.C.R. 895
State of Bombay v R. M. D. Chamarbaugwala1957
Indlaw SC 153, AIR 1957 SC 699, 1957 SCJ 607, [1957] 1
S.C.R. 874
State of Bombay v Bombay Education Society and
BomLR 1211, 1954 (2) MLJ(SC) 359, 1954 SCJ 678, [1955]
1 S.C.R. 568
Kidangazhi Manakkal Narayanan Nambudiripad and Others
v State of Madras, Represented By Secretary, Firka
Development and Another1953 Indlaw MAD 106, AIR 1954
MAD 385, 1953 (2) MLJ 699
The State Of Madras v Srimathi Champakam Dorairajan
and another1951 Indlaw SC 44, AIR 1951 SC 226, 1951 (1)
MLJ(SC) 621, [1951] S.C.R. 525
Chiranjit Lal Chowdhuri v Union of India and Others1950
Indlaw SC 55, AIR 1951 SC 41, 1951 (53) BomLR 499,
14/03/2016
Page 7
[1951] 21 Comp Cas 33, 1951 SCJ 29, [1950] 1 S.C.R.

869, 1950 SLR 659
In The Matter of The Central Provinces and Berar Sales of
Motor Spirit and Lubricants Taxation Act, 19381938 Indlaw
FDH 1
The State of Bombay v. Bombay Education Society and1955
(1) SCC 568
San Antonio Independent School District v. Demetrio P.
Rudriguez(411) US 1
Unni Krishnan J.P. vs. State of A.P.
D.A.V. College etc. vs. Punjab State &1971 (S) S.C.R. 68
v. United States',1878 (98) US 145
(1) His Holiness Kesavananda Bharati Sripadgalvaru and
Others; (2) Shri Raghunath Rao Ganpath Rao and N. H.
Nawab Mohammed Iftikhar Ali Khan; (3) Shethia Mining
and Mfg. Corpn. Ltd. Etc.; (4) the Oriental Coal Co. Ltd. v
(1) State of Kerala and Another; (2) Union of India; (3)
Union of India and Others; (4) Union of India and Another
Cases Citing this

Case
Alagaapuram R. Mohanraj and others v Tamil Nadu

Legislative Assembly, Represented by its Secretary and
another
2016 Indlaw SC 154
Bimla Lal v State of U. P. and others
2016 Indlaw ALL 78
C. B. S. E. v Mount Carmel School Society and others
2016 Indlaw DEL 58
Dr. Janet Jeyapaul v SRM University and others
2015 Indlaw SC 888, JT 2015 (12) SC 259, 2015 (4)
UPLBEC 3176
Archana Chugh and another v Ramjas School and others
2015 Indlaw DEL 5523
Hindu Front for Justice, Through Secretary and others v
State of Uttar Pradesh, Through Chief Secretary Uttar
Pradesh Government and others
2015 Indlaw ALL 1799
Nisha Kanwar and another v State of Himachal Pradesh and
others
2015 Indlaw HP 687
Shivom College of Education and others v National Council
14/03/2016
Page 8
Teacher Education and another

2015 Indlaw DEL 5505, 2015 (225) DLT 314
Mehdi Hasan v C/m. M. M. Inter College and others
2015 Indlaw ALL 1719, 2015 (4) UPLBEC 3380
Army Welfare Education Society and another v Manju
Nautiyal and others
Dr. Sandeep S/o Sadashivrao Kansurkar and others v Union
of India and others
2015 Indlaw SC 885, JT 2015 (11) SC 321, 2015(12)
SCALE 24
Vatsal Gupta, Through his Father v State of U.P., Through
Principal Secretary Secondary Education Government of
U.P. and others
2015 Indlaw ALL 917
Supreme Court Advocates on Record Association and
another v Union of India
2015 Indlaw SC 750, 2015(7) ALL MR 453, JT 2015 (10) SC
1, 2015(11) SCALE 1
Suraj Bhan v Dr. Madan Kumar Bansal and others
2015 Indlaw ALL 1007, 2015 (6) AWC 6312
Madala Venkata Akshay S/o M. Bala Venkateswarlu and
others v Comedk Uget, Represented by Its Secretary and
another
2015 Indlaw KAR 6730
Hakeem Harbans Singh New Era College of Education and
another v State of Haryana and others
2015 Indlaw PNH 194
K. M. College of Education and another v Union of India and
others
2015 Indlaw ALL 1836, 2015 (6) AWC 5783
K. M. College of Education Muriya Ghatampur Kanpur Nagar
and others v Union of India, Through Secretary Minority
Welfare and others
Kanailal Ghosh and others v State of West Bengal and
others
2015 Indlaw CAL 1114
Dau Dayal Mahila (PG) College UPSIDC Campus Through its
President v State of Uttar Pradesh Through its Principal
14/03/2016
Page 9
Secretary Higher Education Civil Sectt. and others

2015 Indlaw ALL 537, 2015 (6) ADJ 616, 2015 (5) AWC
5426
Frank v Delhi University and others
2015 Indlaw DEL 2997, 2015 (222) DLT 37
Shatrughan Thakur and others v Director of Education and
others
West Bengal Board of Secondary Education and others v
Bhagawandas Haralalka and others
2015 Indlaw CAL 433, AIR 2015 CAL 176
Basaveshwar Vidya Vardhak Sangha Represented by Its
Chairman Veeranna C. Charantimath S/o
Chandrashekharayya, Bagalkote and others v Medical
Council of India Through Its Secretary, New Delhi
Prof. I. Ilangovan v Government of Tamil Nadu,
Represented by its Secretary, Department of Higher
Education, Chennai and others
2015 Indlaw MAD 1200
Dr. Aparna Singh v Appellate Authority and District Judge,
Dehradun and others
2015 Indlaw UTT 112
CBCI Society For Medical Education, Represented by its
Secretary Rev. Dr. Lawrence D'souza, Bangalore and others
v State of Karnataka, Department of Health And Family
Welfare (Medical Education), Represented by its Principal
Secretary, Bangalore
T. N. Vidyanandan v Secretary to Government, Department
of School Education, Chennai and others
2015 Indlaw MAD 529, 2015 (4) MLJ 459
Dr. Rahul Bhartia and others v Dental Council of India and
others
2015 Indlaw MP 116, AIR 2015 MP 111
Defence Public School v N.C.T Government of Delhi and
another
2015 Indlaw DEL 996
Abdul Gofur Mondal S/o Late Nalu Mondal v State of Assam
and others, Represented by Commissioner and Secy. To
14/03/2016
Page 10
Government of Assam, Education (ELE) Deptt., Dispur

2015 Indlaw GUW 476, 2015 (2) GauLR 575
Managing Committee National Public School v Government
of (NCT of Delhi) and others
Aarav Goswami v State of Himachal Pradesh and another
2015 Indlaw HP 344, AIR 2015 HP 24
Pardeep Kapoor and others v Panjab University and another
2015 Indlaw PNH 46, 2015 (1) Law Herald (P&H) 334
Dr. Suhail Ahmed Khan, Aurangabad v State of Maharashtra
2014 Indlaw MUM 2155
Chandana Das and another v State of West Bengal and
others
2014 Indlaw SC 923, JT 2014 (14) SC 118, 2014(14)
SCALE 1
Dr. Ranjit Kumar and others v Union of India through
Health Secretary, Government of India, New Delhi and
others
2014 Indlaw PAT 652, AIR 2015 PAT 21
Directorate of Education and another v Action Committee
Unaided Recognized Private Schools and another
Susanta Kumar Sahoo and others v Union of India and
others
2014 Indlaw ORI 392
M. Aamira Fathima and another v Annamalai University
Represented by its Administrator, Cuddalore District and
others
Forum for Promotion of Quality Education and another v Lt.
Governor of Delhi and others
2014 Indlaw DEL 4117, 2015 (216) DLT 80
M. Ct. Muthiah Chettiar Boys Higher Secondary School
Represented by its Correspondent, Chennai v Government
of Tamil Nadu Represented by its Secretary Department of
School Education, Chennai and others
A. M. Abdul Gafoor S/o A. K. Muhammed and others v
Calicut University, Represented by its Reigstrar and others
2014 Indlaw KER 776
14/03/2016
Page 11
Siddarth Singh v Vice Chancellor, Delhi University and

others
Varun Saini and others v Guru Gobind Singh Indraprastha
University
2014 Indlaw SC 716, JT 2014 (12) SC 1, 2014 (8) MLJ 626,
2014(12) SCALE 184, 2014 (6) SLR 471
A. C. Grice v Uttar Pradesh Avas Evam Vikas Parishad and
others
2014 Indlaw ALL 3154, 2014 (10) ADJ 159
National Mahila Mahavidyalaya Balramur v State of Uttar
Pradesh Through Its Principal Secretary Basic Education,
Lucknow and others
Association of Management of Unaided Engineering Colleges
(Mah.) through its President Balasaheb Wagh, Maharashtra
and others v State of Maharashtra through Secretary,
Mumbai and others
2014 Indlaw MUM 2166, 2015(1) ALL MR 369, 2015 (2)
MahLJ 370
State of Uttar Pradesh and others v Pawan Kumar Divedi
and others
2014 Indlaw SC 573, (2014) 9 SCC 692, 2014 (106) ALR
805, 2014 (6) AWC 6276, JT 2014 (10) SC 190, 2014 (6)
MLJ 739, 2014(10) SCALE 27, 2014 (6) SLR 34, 2015 (2)
UPLBEC 890
Correspondent Rev. Fr. John Alexander Don Bosco
Matriculation Hr. Sec. School, Chennai v J. Lourduraj and
others
2014 Indlaw MAD 1689, 2014 (6) MLJ 647
Tadikela Subbaiah Trust Subbaiah Institute of Medical
Sciences, represented by Its Director (Admissions) C.
Mahesh Kumar v State of Karnataka, represented by its
Chief Secretary Department of Health And Family Welfare
(Medical Education), Bangalore and others
2014 Indlaw KAR 2223, 2015 (1) KarLJ 462
Sree Anjaneya Medical Trust, Kozhikode v CIT, Kozhikode
2014 Indlaw ITAT 1766, [2014] 66 SOT 272
Guru Nanak Ayurvedic Medical College and Hospital,
Muktsar, Through its Principal Dr. Nav Prabhat Lal S/o Bhika
Kali Charan Lal v Baba Farid University of Health Sciences,
14/03/2016
Page 12
Punjab Through its Registrar

2014 Indlaw PNH 1706
Teacher-in-Charge of Calcutta Airport English High School v
West Bengal Board of Secondary Education and others
2014 Indlaw CAL 636
Hindu Front For Justice through secretary others v Union of
India Through Secretary Ministry of Minority and another
H-Private Universities Management Association (H-PUMA)
and another v State of Himachal Pradesh and others
2014 Indlaw HP 419
Dr. A. K. B Sadbhavana Mission Trust, Represented by its
Manager Dr. Sanu John Kovoor S/o K. A. Elias v State of
Kerala and another
2014 Indlaw KER 452
Devamatha CMI Public School, Represented by Its Manager,
Thrissur v Employees' State Insurance Corporation and
another
2014 Indlaw KER 460
Mahadeo S/o Pandurang More and others v State of
Maharashtra and others
2014 Indlaw MUM 876, 2014(5) ALL MR 1, 2014 (5) MahLJ
877
Manager/Correspondent, V. K. P. Higher Secondary School,
Kanyakumari District v State of Tamil Nadu and others
Sanjeevan Gramin Vaidyakiya & Samajik Sahayata
Pratishthan v University of Mumbai and another
2014 Indlaw MUM 593, 2014(4) ALL MR 739, 2014 (4)
Bom.C.R. 58, 2014 (4) MahLJ 512
Committee of Management Adarsh College of Education
(Ideal Education Trust) and another v State of Uttar
Pradesh Through its Principal Secretary Department of
Basic Education, Lucknow and others
2014 Indlaw ALL 3088, 2014 (6) ADJ 162, AIR 2014 ALL
130
Manipal University and others v Union of India
2014 Indlaw KAR 645, 2014 (5) KarLJ 220
D. Bhoobalasamy and others v State of Tamil Nadu and
others
14/03/2016
Page 13
2014 Indlaw MAD 883

Association of Self Financing Institutions and another v
Guru Govind Singh Indraprastha University and another
Indian Olympic Association v Union of India
2014 Indlaw DEL 1648, 2014 (212) DLT 389
Canossa Society, Canossa Convent MahakaliCaves Road,
Andheri and another v Commissioner, Social Welfare,
Directorate, Government of Maharashtra and others
2014 Indlaw MUM 527, 2015(3) ALL MR 575, 2014 (3)
Bom.C.R. 556
State of Karnataka and others v Associated
Management of (Government Recognised - Unaided English Medium) Primary and Secondary Schools and others
2014 Indlaw SC 330, (2014) 9 SCC 485, AIR 2014 SC
2094, 2014 (5) ALD(SC) 114, 2014 (105) ALR 723, 2014
(5) AWC 5243, 2014 (3) Bom.C.R. 521, JT 2014 (7) SC
326, 2014 (3) KarLJ 161, 2014 (2) KLT 578, 2015 (2)
MahLJ 10, 2014 (4) MLJ 362, 2014 (3) RLW 1958, 2014(7)
SCALE 53, [2014] 5 S.C.R. 1104, 2014 (3) UPLBEC 1752
Pramati Educational and Cultural Trust and others v
Union of India and others
2014 Indlaw SC 333, (2014) 8 SCC 1, AIR 2014 SC 2114,
2014 (5) AWC 5048, 2014 (3) Bom.C.R. 496, 2014 (3)
CLT(SC) 145, JT 2014 (7) SC 46, 2015 (2) KarLJ 70, 2014
(2) KLT 547, 2014 (4) MLJ 486, 2014 (3) RLW 2007,
2014(7) SCALE 306, 2014 (5) SLR 139, 2014 (3) UPLBEC
1775
D.A.V. College Managing Committee Through Regional
Director v Laxminarayan Mishra and others
2014 Indlaw SC 255, (2014) 14 SCC 69, 2014 (3)
Bom.C.R. 607, JT 2014 (7) SC 626, 2014 (2) OLR 122,
2014(5) SCALE 108, [2014] 8 S.C.R. 604
Bapuji Education Society and others v State of Karnataka
and another
NIIT Limited, Hyderabad v Deputy Commissioner (CT),
Abids Division, Hyderabad and others
2014 Indlaw AP 334, 2014 (4) ALD 571, [2014] 71 VST 481
Sukhmani Kaur Brar and others v State of Punjab and
others
2014 Indlaw PNH 605
14/03/2016
Page 14
Managing Committee, Contai Rahmania High Madrasah and

another v State of West Bengal and others
2014 Indlaw CAL 152, 2014 (2) CalLT 332
State of Madhya Pradesh and another v Suresh Narayan
Vijayvargiya and others
2014 Indlaw SC 127, (2014) 11 SCC 694, 2014 (2)
ALD(SC) 142, 2014 (104) ALR 265, 2014 (4) AWC 3808,
2014 (2) JabLJ 90, JT 2014 (3) SC 468, 2014 (3) RCR(Civil)
387, 2014 (3) RCR(Criminal) 251, 2014 (123) RD 804,
2014(3) SCALE 124, [2014] 3 S.C.R. 374, 2014 (6) SLR
335
P. A. Inamdar and others v State of Maharashtra and others
2014 Indlaw MUM 123, 2014(3) ALL MR 654
Action Committee Unaided Recognized Private Schools and
another v Lt. Governor of Delhi and others
2014 Indlaw DEL 107, 2014 (206) DLT 731, 2014 (2) SLR
734
Delhi College of Education v Guru Gobind Singh
Indraprastha University and others
Federation of the Catholic Faithful and another v
Government of Tamil Nadu, Represented by its Secretary,
Higher Education Department, Chennai and others
2014 Indlaw MAD 1725, 2014 (4) CTC 432, 2014 (5) MLJ
163
Dr. Subramanian Swamy and others v State of Tamil Nadu
and others
2015 (2) ALD(SC) 33, 2015(2) ALL MR 408, 2014 (1) MLJ
622, [2014] 1 S.C.R. 308
Aditya Educational Society, Represented by its Chairma, Dr.
M. M. Vilekar and others v Union of India Represented by
its Secretary, Ministry of Medical and Health, New Delhi and
others
2014 Indlaw AP 81
Management of S. D. Model Senior Secondary School and
another v District Judge -cum- Service Tribunal and another
2013 Indlaw PNH 3988, 2014 (1) Law Herald (P&H) 312,
2014 (174) PLR 89
Management Board of Ansal Institute of Technology of
Charanji Charitable Trust, Gurgaon v State of Haryana and
14/03/2016
Page 15
others
2013 Indlaw PNH 4868, 2014 (174) PLR 84
Saraswathi Educational Society and five others v
Government of Andhra Pradesh, Represented by its
Principal Secretary, Higher Education Department,
Hyderabad and others
2013 Indlaw AP 761, 2014 (1) ALD 580, 2014 (1) ALT 781
Sachin Mehta and others v State of Rajasthan and others
2013 Indlaw RAJ 1869, 2014 (3) SLR 776
H-Private Universities Management Association (H-PUMA) v
State of Himachal Pradesh and others
2013 Indlaw HP 915
Delhi High Court Bar Association and others v Govt. of (NCT
of Delhi) and another
2013 Indlaw DEL 2669, 2013 (203) DLT 129
Rita Mukherjee and others v State of West Bengal and
others
2013 Indlaw CAL 743, 2013 (4) CalLT 560
Thalappalam Ser. Co-op. Bank Limited and others v State of
Kerala and others
(Supp) 437, 2014(1) ALL MR 451, 2013 (6) AWC 6215,
2014 (1) CLT(SC) 187, 2014 (1) CompLJ 319, 2013 (6)
CTC 98, 2013 (4) KLT 232, 2014 (3) Law Herald (P&H)
1999, 2013 (7) MLJ 407, 2013 (4) RCR(Civil) 912,
2013(12) SCALE 527
Gujarat Minority Schools Association and others v State of
Gujarat and others
2013 Indlaw GUJ 1318, 2014 (2) G.L.R. 921
Tummuri Jalandhari v Government of Andhra Pradesh,
Represented by its Principal Secretary, Health Medical and
Family Welfare Department, Hyderabad and others
2013 Indlaw AP 193, 2013 (6) ALD 155, 2013 (5) ALT 749
Centurion University of Technology and Management,
Represented Through Pro-vice Chancellor, Ardhendu Mouli
Mohanty v State of Odisha and others
2013 Indlaw ORI 132
Bhojia Dental College and Hospital and another v State of
Himachal Pradesh through Principal Secretary and another
2013 Indlaw HP 865
14/03/2016
Page 16
Rohilkhand Medical College and Hospital, Bareilly v Medical

Council of India and Another
(Supp) 394, 2013 (4) CLT(SC) 133, JT 2013 (12) SC 199,
2013(11) SCALE 183, [2013] 9 S.C.R. 692, 2013 (6) SLR
585, 2014 (1) UPLBEC 611
West Bengal University of Health Services and others v
Indian Centre for Advancement of Research and Education,
Haldia and others
2013 Indlaw CAL 566, 2013 (4) CalLT 351
Sister Meera and another v State of Uttar Pradesh Thru.
Secy. and others
2013 Indlaw ALL 1832, 2013 (10) ADJ 310
Joseph Sriharsha and Mary Indraja Educational Society
(Regn No.662/1996), represented by its Secretary Rev. K.
V. K. Rao, Hyderabad and others v State of Andhra Pradesh,
represented by its Principal Secretary to Government,
Higher Education (EC.2) Department, Hyderabad
2013 Indlaw AP 43, AIR 2013 AP 168, 2014 (1) ALT 16
Adarsh Vidya Mandir Samiti, Bharatpur and another v Raju
Lal and others
2013 Indlaw RAJ 1556, 2014 (2) RLW 1753
Orissa Private Engineering College Association and others v
State of Odisha and others
2013 Indlaw ORI 101, 2014 (1) ILR(Cut) 72
Dau Dayal Mahila (P.G.) College and another v State of
Uttar Pradesh and others
Priti and others v Himachal Pradesh University and another
2013 Indlaw HP 842
Faculty Association of AIIMS v Union of India and others
2013 Indlaw SC 449, (2013) 11 SCC 246, 2013(5) ALL MR
952, 2013 (6) AWC 5640, 2013 (139) FLR 4, JT 2013 (10)
SC 526, 2013 (5) MLJ 833, 2013 (3) RLW 2484, 2013(9)
SCALE 198, 2013 (5) SLR 508
Christian Medical College Vellore and others v Union of
India and others
2013 Indlaw SC 452, (2014) 2 SCC 305, 2013(9) SCALE
226, [2013] 7 S.C.R. 908
Diamond Jubilee High School and another v State of
14/03/2016
Page 17
2013 Indlaw MUM 562, 2013(5) ALL MR 385, 2013 (5)

Bom.C.R. 530
Dr. Madan Kumar Bansal v Union of India and others
2013 Indlaw ALL 3932, 2014 (3) SLR 312
Dhrub Dev Sharma and others v State of Himachal Pradesh
and others
2013 Indlaw HP 760
Southern Railway Mazdoor Union and others v Mazdoor
Welfare Trust and others
Managing Committee and others v Chandigarh
Administration and another
Manoj Singh Tomar v State of Madhya Pradesh and others
2013 Indlaw MP 59, 2013(3) M.P.H.T. 541, 2013 (4) MPLJ
418
Manoj Singh Tomar v State of Madhya Pradesh and others
2013 Indlaw MPLJ 253
Anna University Represented by its Registrar, Chennai v
Council of Architecture, Represented by its Registrar India
Habitat Centre, New Delhi
Association of Management of Private colleges and another
v All India Council for Technical Education and others
2310, 2013 (4) AWC 3934, JT 2013 (6) SC 277, 2013 (5)
MLJ 76, 2013 (2) RLW 1677, 2013(6) SCALE 349, [2013] 6
S.C.R. 1054, 2013 (4) SLR 246
Rosary Matriculation Higher Secondary School, Represented
by its Correspondent Rev. Sr. Lily D'Souza, Chennai v
Government of Tamil Nadu and another
2013 Indlaw MAD 875, 2014 (1) CTC 626
Anti-Corruption and Crime Investigation Cell and others v
State of Punjab and others
2013 Indlaw PNH 3712, 2013 (2) Law Herald (P&H) 1207
Maharashtra University of Health Sciences, Nashik v
Kalicharan S/o Ramdas Tripathi and others
2013 Indlaw MUM 1514, 2013 (4) MahLJ 612
Karnataka Unaided Schools Management Association
(KUSMA) and others v State of Karnataka Department of
14/03/2016
Page 18
Education and another

2013 Indlaw KAR 1779, 2013 (6) KarLJ 59
Dayanand Anglo Vedic (Dav) College Trust And
Management Society v State Of Maharashtra & Anr.
2013 (3) AWC 2608, 2013 (2) CLT(SC) 103, JT 2013 (8) SC
102, 2013(4) SCALE 624, [2013] 4 S.C.R. 821, 2013 (4)
SLR 383
Essa @ Anjum Abdul Razak Memon (A-3) and others v
State Of Maharashtra Through Stf, Cbi Mumbai; (2)
Suleman Abdul Razak And Others
2013 Indlaw SC 169, JT 2013 (6) SC 1, 2013(4) SCALE 1
Karuna v Government Medical College and Hospital,
Chandigarh and others
2013 Indlaw PNH 463
Kharagpur Tribal B.Ed. Training College and another; (2)
Subhash Chandra Basu B.Ed. Training College and another
v Vidyasagar University and others
2013 Indlaw CAL 152
Kumari Udyan Balika Inter College, Kanpur and others v
D.I.O.S., Kanpur and others
2013 Indlaw ALL 3439, 2013 (97) ALR 839
Dr. Suresh Kumar Pandey v State of Uttar Pradesh Thru.
Prin. Secy. Deptt. of Higher Education
2013 Indlaw ALL 651, 2013 (3) ADJ 505
Gopal Mishra v Ravishankar Shukla University and others
2013 Indlaw CTH 44, AIR 2013 CHH 80, 2013 (2) CGLJ 374
Delhi Public School and another v Shalu Mahendroo and
others
2012 Indlaw DEL 2618, 2013 (196) DLT 147
Mohameed Sathak Dastagir Matriculation School, Run by
Mohamed Sathak Trust by its Chairman, Dr. S. M. Hamid
Abdul Quadir, Ramanathapuram District v State of Tamil
Nadu and another
Iftekar Ahmad v State of Uttar Pradesh and others
4158, 2013 (2) UPLBEC 1448
Deepa Yadav v State of Haryana and others
14/03/2016
Page 19
Lakshmi School and others v State of Tamil Nadu Secretary

to Government Education Department, Madurai and others
2012 Indlaw MAD 2648, 2012 (6) CTC 8
J. R. Memorial College of Education, Rewari and others v
State of Haryana and others
Ramesh Ahluwalia v State of Punjab and others
2012 Indlaw SCO 1409, (2012) 12 SCC 331, 2013 (96) ALR
819, 2013 (136) FLR 86, JT 2013 (7) SC 149, 2013 (4) SLR
63
Bhawna Garg and another v University Of Delhi & Ors
3299, 2012 (6) AWC 6321, JT 2012 (8) SC 618, 2012(8)
SCALE 504, [2012] 10 S.C.R. 512, 2012 (3) UPLBEC 2403
Rajan Purohit & Ors. v Rajasthan University Of Health
Science & Ors
2012 Indlaw SC 331, (2012) 10 SCC 770, 2012 (5) AWC
5331, JT 2012 (8) SC 265, 2012(8) SCALE 71, [2012] 11
S.C.R. 299
Velammal Matriculation Higher Secondary School
represented by its Correspondent, Chennai and others v
Private Schools Fee Determination Committee and others
Laxmibai Shantaram Doke Samajvikas Prathisthan and
another v State of Maharashtra, through its Secretary, the
Department of School Education and Sports, Bombay and
others
2012 Indlaw MUM 527, 2012(6) ALL MR 287, 2013 (1)
Bom.C.R. 568, 2013 (1) MahLJ 538, 2013 (4) RCR(Civil)
6136
State of Kerala, represetned By Secretary,
Thiruvananthapuram v Mythri Vidya Bhavan English Medium
School and another
2012 Indlaw KER 1580
St. Joseph's Hospital Trust, St. Joseph's College of
Pharmacy, Dharmagiri College Campus, Represented by
Provincial Superior v Kerala University of Health Sciences
and others
2012 Indlaw KER 551, 2012 (4) KLT 444
Rungta College of Engineering and Technology Bhilai and
others v State of Chhattisgarh and others
14/03/2016
Page 20
2012 Indlaw CTH 111, 2012 (5) M.P.H.T.(CG) 59

Abhimanyu Singh S/o Satinder Chauhan and others v State
of Himachal Pradesh and others
2012 Indlaw HP 708
Momin Education Society, Mohalla Sayadan, Nanded and
another v Education Officer (Primary), Zilla Parishad,
Nanded, Tq and others
2012 Indlaw MUM 1245, 2012 (6) MahLJ 539
Guru tegh bahadur khalsa post Graduate evening college v
M. Abimanyou and others v Government of India and others
2012 Indlaw MAD 749
Dr. Shyamal ku. Saha and others v State of Orissa and
others
Association of Self Financing Arts and Science and
Management Colleges of Tamil Nadu v State of Tamil Nadu,
Chennai and another
Committee of Management, National Inter College, Varanasi
and another v State of Uttar Pradesh and others
2012 Indlaw ALL 3952, 2012 (6) AWC 6489
Priya Gupta v State Of Chhatishgarh & Ors
2413, 2012 (6) AWC 6299, JT 2012 (5) SC 102, 2012(5)
SCALE 328, [2012] 5 S.C.R. 768
Charutar Arogya Mandal v Parents Association For The
Medical/Dental Students and others
2012 Indlaw GUJ 1451
Haryana Pradesh Chamar Sangharsh Samiti v State of
Haryana and others
2012 Indlaw PNH 5777, 2012 (167) PLR 686, 2013 (2) SLR
376
Society For Un-Aided Private Schools Of Rajasthan v U.O.I.
& Anr.
2012 Indlaw SC 607, (2012) 6 SCC 1, 2012 (4) AWC 4260,
2012 (6) Bom.C.R. 711, JT 2012 (4) SC 137, 2012 (2)
RCR(Civil) 775, [2012] 2 S.C.R. 715
Modern Dental College and Research Centre and others v
14/03/2016
Page 21
State of Madhya Pradesh and others

2012 Indlaw SC 585, (2012) 4 SCC 707, 2012 (4) AWC
3482, 2012 (2) JabLJ 181, JT 2012 (4) SC 69, [2012] 2
S.C.R. 685, 2012 (2) UPLBEC 873
Ashok Kumar Mishra v State of Orissa and others
2012 Indlaw ORI 43, AIR 2012 ORI 153, 2012 (2) ILR(Cut)
6, 2012 (2) OLR 171
President, Sind Educatonists' Association Jai Hind College
Building and another v Registrar, University of Mumbai, Fort
Campus, Mumbai and another
2012 Indlaw MUM 191, 2012(3) ALL MR 123, 2012 (3)
MahLJ 929
Dr. Pournamy Mohan D/o K. B. Mohandas and others v
State of Kerala and others
2012 Indlaw KER 2409
Bhartiya Kamgar Sena and others v State of Maharashtra
Through and others
2012 Indlaw MUM 1318, 2012 (3) MahLJ 872
Commissioner of Income-Tax, Vijayawada v Vijaya Vani
Educational Trust, Chowdepalle
2012 Indlaw AP 133, [2012] 349 ITR 280
Sowri Raj and others v Director of School Education,
Pondicherry and others
Neha D/o Vinod Kumar Jain v State of Madhya Pradesh and
others
President, Subbalakshmi Lakshmipathy Foundation, Madurai
v Union of India,Represented. by its Secretary,Ministry of
Petroleum & Natural Gas, New Delhi and others
Managing Committee, Arya Higher Secondary School,
Dhuri, District Sangrur and another v State of Punjab,
through the Secretary to Government, Punjab, Department
of Education, Chandigarh, and others
2011 Indlaw PNH 3211, 2012 (166) PLR 153
Xavier's Institute of Management v State of Orissa and
others
Queen Mary's School and another v Union of India and
14/03/2016
Page 22
others
2011 Indlaw DEL 3410, 2011 (185) DLT 168
Consortium of Engineering Colleges Managements
Association (CECMA) and others v Government of Andhra
Pradesh and others
2011 Indlaw AP 377, 2013 (3) ALD 572
V. Krishna Moorthy and others v State of Tamil Nadu
(Department of Education), Chennai and others
Dr. T. Varghese George v Kora K. George & Ors.
2011 (4) CLT(SC) 190, [2011] 12 S.C.R. 1070, 2012 (2)
UPLBEC 1325, 2012 (1) WLN(SC) 1
Colvin School Society and another v Anil Kumar Sharma
and another
2011 Indlaw SC 726, (2012) 1 SCC 200, 2012 (3) AWC
2755
Fee Regulatory Committee v Kalol Institute Of
Management, Etc
203, 2011 (5) ESC 756, [2011] 11 S.C.R. 829
Chhatrapalsinh Parakramsinh Jadeja Since Minor v Central
Board of Secondary Education
2011 Indlaw GUJ 1368
D. A. V. College Managing Committee v Laxminarayan
Mishra and others
Mount Abu Education Society v Anshu Sharma and another
2011 Indlaw DEL 3303, 2011 (183) DLT 184
Federation of Andhra Pradesh Minority Educational
Institution v Admission and Fee Regulatory Committee for
Matters relating To Fee Fixation in Private Unaided
Professional Colleges and others
2011 Indlaw SC 552, (2011) 12 SCC 358, 2012 (1)
ALD(SC) 50, JT 2011 (11) SC 159, 2011(9) SCALE 422
Dr. A. Christopher Asir, President, Governing Council of the
American College and another v State of Tamil Nadu and
others
2011 Indlaw MAD 766, 2012 (1) ESC 84
State Of Tamil Nadu & Ors. v K. Shyam Sunder & Ors.
14/03/2016
Page 23
2011 Indlaw SC 493, (2011) 8 SCC 737, 2011 (4) CTC 874,
JT 2011 (9) SC 166, 2011(8) SCALE 474, [2011] 11 S.C.R.
1094
Anmol Sandhu and another v Council for the Indian
Certificate of Secondary Education, through its Secretary,
New Delhi and others
2011 Indlaw UTT 1301
Management Board of Ansal Institute of Technology,
Gurgaon and others v State of Haryana and another
Committee of Management, Aditya Birla Intermediate
College, Renukoot, Sonebhadra v State of Uttar Pradesh
and others
2011 Indlaw ALL 637, 2011 (7) ADJ 348, 2011 (88) ALR
586, 2012 (1) AWC 840
Dr. A. Safiullah v Director of Collegiate Education and
others
2011 Indlaw MAD 412
Management of DAV Public School and others v State of
Orissa and another
Harsh Vardhan Mathur v State of Jharkhand and another
2011 Indlaw JHKD 433
Ajinder Kaur Lamba and others v Guru Harkrishan Public
School and others
NIMS University Rajasthan, Jaipur v State of Rajasthan and
others
2011 Indlaw RAJ 296
Humanity and others v State Of West Bengal And Others
2308, 2011 (88) ALR 261, 2011 (4) AWC 4286, 2011 (4)
CalLT 9, 2011 (3) CLT(SC) 403, JT 2011 (6) SC 334, 2011
(5) RCR(Civil) 439, 2011(6) SCALE 378, [2011] 8 S.C.R.
653
Haji Ismail Degree College v State of Uttar Pradesh and
others
2011 Indlaw ALL 542, 2011 (7) ADJ 23
Indian Medical Association and others v Union of India and
others
14/03/2016
Page 24
2365, JT 2011 (6) SC 505, 2011(6) SCALE 86, [2011] 6

S.C.R. 599
Salesian Province of Kolkata (Northern India), Represented
by Its Secretary, Father Mananchira Chacko Matthew v
State of West Bengal and others
2011 Indlaw CAL 374, 2011 (130) FLR 709, 2012 (1) LLJ
461
Mohammad Ateeque Siddiqui and others v State of Uttar
Pradesh and another
2011 Indlaw ALL 801, 2011 (7) ADJ 55, 2011 (88) ALR 80,
2011 (5) AWC 4537, 2011 (4) ESC 2783, 2011 (3) UPLBEC
2547
Medical Council of India v AL Karim Educational Trust and
another
2011 Indlaw DEL 1123, 2011 (180) DLT 268, 2011 (3) ESC
1840
Little Angels Educational Society, Tirupati, represented by
its Secretary and Correspondent and another v All India
Council for Technical Education, New Delhi, represented by
its Member Secretary and others
2011 Indlaw AP 315, 2011 (4) ALD 655, 2011 (4) ALT 90
Samarth Shiksha Samiti (Regd) v Directorate of Education
and another
2011 Indlaw DEL 3369, 2011 (180) DLT 93
Ratikanta Dutta and others v State of Orissa
2011 Indlaw ORI 72, 2012 (2) ESC 1226, 2011 (1)
ILR(Cut) 932
Association of National Board Accredited Institutions and
others v Union of India and another
2011 Indlaw DEL 594, 2011 (178) DLT 322
SRM University, Represented by its Registrar v Government
of India, Ministry of Human Resource Development, New
Delhi and another
2011 Indlaw MAD 357
Maharaja College of Arts and Science and others v State of
Tamil Nadu and others
2011 Indlaw MAD 347, 2011 (4) LLJ 271
Sacred Heart School and another v Union Territory,
Chandigarh and others
2011 Indlaw PNH 310
Principal, Delhi Public School, DPS Dhaband v Syed
14/03/2016
Page 25
Mohammad Sharfullah and others

2011 Indlaw JHKD 97
Secretary, St. Joseph's College (Autonomous) v State of
Tamil Nadu and others
2011 Indlaw MAD 131
Enakshi Pant and others v Union Territory, Chandigarh and
others
2011 Indlaw PNH 191
Sudha Tiwari v Union of India and others
374
Dr. Subrahmaniam Swamy v State of Kerala
2011 Indlaw KER 44, 2011 (1) KLT 807
Prafull Goradia v Union Of India
2011 Indlaw SCO 75, (2011) 2 SCC 568, 2011(2) ALL MR
453, 2011 (3) AWC 2376, 2011 (1) CTC 747, 2011 (2)
RCR(Civil) 232, 2011(1) SCALE 761, [2011] 1 S.C.R. 579
Principal, St. Anthony Convent Girls Intermediate College,
Allahabad v State of Uttar Pradesh and others
2011 Indlaw ALL 1583, 2012 (3) AWC 2337
Air Force School Parents Welfare Association, Bengaluru v
State of Karnataka and others
2011 Indlaw KAR 43, 2011 (2) KarLJ 363
Padanilam Welfare Trust v Deputy Commissioner of IncomeTax
2010 Indlaw ITAT 540, [2011] 10 ITR (Trib) 479
New Noble Educational Society v Chief Commissioner of
Income-Tax and another
2010 Indlaw AP 752, [2011] 334 ITR 303, [2011] 201
TAXMAN 33
Policy Planning Body and another v Silicon Institute of
Technology and others
Congregation of Regular Tertiary Franciscans Sisters Of Our
Lady of Bonsecours, Represented by its President, Rev. Sr.
Fatima Rani, Superior General v Government of Tamil Nadu
and others
Ramesh Chander Ladohia v Sanatan Dharam Sabha and
others
14/03/2016
Page 26
2010 Indlaw HP 384

Priya Ranjan Mohanty v State of Orissa and others
P. B. Prince Gajendra Babu, General Secretary, State
Platform for Common School System and others v
Federation of Association of Private Schools and others
2010 Indlaw MAD 1786, 2010 (5) CTC 721
Takreem Ahmad Khan and others v Vice Chancellor Aligarh
Muslim Universty Aligarh and others
1146, 2011 (2) ESC 915, 2010 (4) UPLBEC 3392
R.D. Gardi Medical College & Anr. Etc. v State Of M.P. & Ors.
(Supp) 35, 2011 (1) JabLJ 346, JT 2010 (11) SC 157,
2010(10) SCALE 371, [2010] 12 S.C.R. 692
St. Xavier's Sr. Sec. School, Chandigarh and others v
Municipal Corporation through its Commissioner,
Chandigarh and another
2010 Indlaw PNH 2779, 2010 (4) Law Herald (P&H) 3168,
2010 (4) RCR(Civil) 807
University of Delhi v Bombay Patel Welfare Society, Bharuch
Charutar Arogya Mandal v State of Gujarat and another
2010 Indlaw SC 1015, (2010) 13 SCC 420, 2010(12)
SCALE 103, [2010] 12 S.C.R. 916
Modern Dental College & Research Centre & Ors. v State Of
Madhya Pradesh & Ors
2010 Indlaw SC 1112, 2011 (3) ESC 446, 2010(13) SCALE
412
Association of International Schools and Principals
Foundation and another v State of Maharashtra and another
2010 Indlaw MUM 1487, 2010(6) ALL MR 21, 2010 (6)
Bom.C.R. 266, 2010 (6) MahLJ 816
Master Ankit Kumar and another v Summer Fields School
and another
2010 Indlaw DEL 2208, 2010 (173) DLT 478
Presiding Officer Delhi School Tribunal v Govt. of (NCT of
Delhi) through Its Chief Secretary
2010 Indlaw DEL 3481, 2011 (180) DLT 551
Sanwal Coal Carriers, through its Proprietor, Rajveersingh
14/03/2016
Page 27
Sanwal v Western Coalfields Limited and others

2010 Indlaw MUM 941, 2011(3) ALL MR 716
Mount Carmel School Society and another v Government
(NCT of Delhi) and another
2010 Indlaw DEL 2987, 2010 (171) DLT 728
Association of Management of Private Colleges,
Represented by its President, Dr. M. Aruchami v
Government of Tamil Nadu, Represented by its Secretary,
Rural Development and Panchayat Raj Department
Sunita Bugga v Director of Education and others
Kaamadhenu Arts and Science College, represented by its
Correspondent, Komarapalayam Village Panchayat v State
of Tamil Nadu and others
Sindhi Education Society & Anr v The Chief Secretary, Govt.
Of Nct Of Delhi & Ors.
2010 Indlaw SC 540, (2010) 8 SCC 49, 2011 (2) Bom.C.R.
197, 2010 (4) ESC 483, JT 2010 (7) SC 98, 2010(6) SCALE
578, [2010] 8 S.C.R. 81
Rajasthan Pradesh V. S. Sardarshahar and others v Union of
India and others
2221, 2010(4) ALL MR 969, 2010 (4) AWC 3894, 2010 (3)
ESC 353, JT 2010 (6) SC 306, 2010(6) SCALE 107
St. John's Educational Development Society and others v
Government of Andhra Pradesh by its Principal Secretary
and others
2010 Indlaw AP 140, 2010 (5) ALD 499, 2010 (5) ALT 347
Apeejay School v Darbari Lal and others
2010 Indlaw DEL 1562, 2010 (170) DLT 608
Haseena Mansoor v State of Kerala
2010 Indlaw KER 288, 2010 (2) KLT 981
Institution of Technology and Management run by Samta
Lok Sansthan Trust v Government of Madhya Pradesh and
another
2010 Indlaw MP 225, 2010 (3) JabLJ 187, 2010(4) M.P.H.T.
111, 2010 (3) MPLJ 643
Institute of Technology and Management Run by Samta Lok
14/03/2016
Page 28
Sansthan Trust, Gwalior v Government of Madhya Pradesh

and another
Rama Educational Society and another v State of Uttar
Pradesh and others
2010 Indlaw ALL 462, 2010 (6) ADJ 509, 2010 (3) UPLBEC
2108
Krishnagiri District Private Schools' Association,
Represented by its Secretary, D. Soundara Raju @ Guruji
Pandian v State of Tamil Nadu and another
Sardar Patel Vidyalaya v G. P. Srivastava
Zameer Ahmed Latifur Rehman Sheikh v State of
Maharashtra and Others
2633, JT 2010 (4) SC 256, 2010(4) SCALE 276, [2010] 4
S.C.R. 1042
Governing Body, Christ Church College Kanpur v Vice
Chancellor and others
340, 2010 (4) UPLBEC 2800
Tamil Nadu Nursery Matriculation and Higher Secondary
Schools Association (Regd.) Represented by its General
Secretary and others v State of Tamil Nadu, Represented by
the Principal Secretary Department of School Education and
others
2010 Indlaw MAD 1443, AIR 2010 MAD 142, 2010 (4) CTC
353, 2010 (5) ESC 3194
Asha Seva Bhavi Sanstha, through its President, Pralhad
Baburao More and others v State of Maharashtra, through
its Secretary, School Education and Sports Department and
others
2010 Indlaw MUM 819, 2010(3) ALL MR 536, 2010 (3)
Bom.C.R. 429
Jamuna Devi Naresh Chandra Mahavidyalaya and others v
State of Uttar Pradesh and another
Valliammai Society v Director General of Income-tax and
another
2010 Indlaw MAD 1235, [2010] 327 ITR 337
14/03/2016
Page 29
Belsi v Corporate Management of Latin Catholic Schools

2010 Indlaw KER 57, 2010 (2) KLT 134
M. D. P. S. U.P. School v Paulose
2010 Indlaw KER 59, 2010 (2) KLT 29
Raunak s/o. Ajaykumar Gandhi v Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan's
Bhagwandas Purohit Vidya Mandir and others
2010 Indlaw MUM 1620, 2010(6) ALL MR 759, 2010 (6)
Bom.C.R. 198, 2010 (4) MahLJ 41
Shree Shree Lakhsmi Narain Trust and others v State of
Jharkhand and Others
2010 Indlaw JHKD 73
Maa Saraswati Educational Trust v Union of India
2010 Indlaw HP 95, [2013] 353 ITR 312, [2010] 194
TAXMAN 84
Centre for Policy Research and another v Brahma Chellaney
and Others
2010 Indlaw DEL 928
Hindu Balika Uchchattar Madhyamik Vidylaya, Mirzapur v
State of Uttar Pradesh and others
2010 Indlaw ALL 238
NG. Komon v State of Manipur and others
2010 Indlaw GUW 115, AIR 2010 GAU 102, 2010 (6) GauLR
179
Ram Dulari Bachcu Lal Jaiswal Mahavidyalaya Nawabganj
and another v State of Uttar Pradesh and others
2010 Indlaw ALL 924, 2010 (3) ADJ 521, 2010 (2) UPLBEC
1121
W. Queen Sheeba v Joint Director Directorate of School
Education and others
2010 Indlaw MAD 1353, 2010 (2) ESC 1574
N. Balasubramanian v Director of School Education-cumAppellate Authority (Private Schools) and others
Delhi Sikh Gurudwara Management Committee v Harvinder
Kaur Bajaj
2010 Indlaw DEL 613, 2010 (168) DLT 302
Anju Singh v Greenfields Public School and another
Rosetta Williams v Delhi Public School Society
14/03/2016
Page 30
2010 Indlaw DEL 594, 2010 (167) DLT 428

G. Vallikumari v Andhra Education Society and others
2010 (125) FLR 1048, JT 2010 (3) SC 75, 2010(2) SCALE 1
Pinegrove International Charitable Trust v Union of India
and Others
2010 Indlaw PNH 731, [2010] 327 ITR 73, [2010] 188
TAXMAN 402
Association of International Schools and Principals
Foundation and others v State of Maharashtra and others
2009 Indlaw MUM 1728, 2010 (2) Bom.C.R. 95,
2010(Supp) ALL MR 292
Laxmi Education Society and Others v State of Maharashtra
and Others
2009 Indlaw MUM 1794, 2010(1) ALL MR 680, 2010 (3)
Bom.C.R. 390, 2010 (2) MahLJ 837
G. Devakadashyam Bishop v (1) Secretary, Education
Department; (2) Director of Technical Education,
Department of Technical Education; (3) Regional Officer, All
India Council For Technical Education; (4) All India Council
For Technical Education, Member Secretary, New Delhi
Shikshan Prasarak Mandal v State of Maharashtra and
Others
2009 Indlaw MUM 1508, AIR 2010 BOM 39, 2009(6) ALL
MR 215, 2009 (6) Bom.C.R. 1, 2009 (5) MahLJ 969
(1) Director, Gitanjali Medical College; (2) Rajan Purohit
and Others; (3) Federation of Private Medical and Dental
Colleges, Rajasthan and Others; (4) Principal, Gitanjali
Medical College; (5) State and Others; (6) Sukhveer
Tanwar and Others v (1) State and Others; (2) Vibhor
Khandal and Others; (3) Abhishek Sain and Others; (4)
Piyush Kr. Agrawal and Others; (5) Hena and Others; (6)
Rakhi Soni and Others; (7) Geetika Chopra and Others
2009 Indlaw RAJ 236
Himachal Pradesh Institute of Management Studies v State
of Himachal Pradesh and another
2009 Indlaw HP 36, AIR 2010 HP 23
Francis Edward v (1) Government of Tamil Nadu, Secretary,
Higher Education Department; (2) Directorate of Secondary
Education; (3) Chief Educational Officer; (4) District
Educational Officer; (5) Correspondent, Punitha Susaipar
14/03/2016
Page 31
(St.Joseph's) High School

Sunil Kumar Saxena v Holy Cross Ashram Higher Secondary
School, Datia and others
2009 Indlaw MP 757, 2010 ILR(MP) 29, 2010 (1) JabLJ
221, 2009(5) M.P.H.T. 364, 2009 (4) MPLJ 641
Sunil Kumar Saxena v Holy Cross Ashram Higher Secondary
School, Datia (Madhya Pradesh) and others
Action Committee, Un-Aided Private Schools and v Director
of Education, Delhi and Others
2009 Indlaw SC 1107, (2009) 10 SCC 1, 2009 (162) DLT
50, 2009 (4) ESC 658, 2009(11) SCALE 77, [2009] 12
S.C.R. 631
(1) Subhash Chandra and Another; (2) Sarv Rural v (1)
Delhi Subordinate Services Selection Board
(Supp) 517, 2010 (166) DLT 659, 2010 (1) ESC 128, JT
2009 (10) SC 645, 2009(11) SCALE 278, [2009] 12 S.C.R.
978
Dr. S. J. Rajalakshmi v Secretary, Medical Education
Department, Government of Karnataka, Bangalore
2009 Indlaw KAR 328, 2010 (124) FLR 879, 2010 (1) KarLJ
676
L and T Case Equipment Private Limited v State of
Karnataka and Another
2009 Indlaw KAR 297, [2010] 27 VST 447
Hislop Education Society, Secretary, Anna, Nagpur v (1)
Presiding Officer, Dr. Ambedkar University Law College,
Nagpur; (2) Dr. Raja J. Singh, Hislop College, Nagpur; (3)
Dr. P. W. Bhelwa, Ex-Secretary, Hislop Education Society,
Nagpur; (4) Vilas Manohar Gujar, Hislop Education Society,
Nagpur; (5) Nagpur University, Vice Chancellor, Nagpur
2009 Indlaw MUM 939, 2009(5) ALL MR 776
Hislop Education Society, Nagpur v Presiding Officer,
University College Tribunal, Nagpur and others
2009 Indlaw MUM 2172, 2009 (6) MahLJ 419
C.B.S.E. School Management's Association v State of Kerala
2009 Indlaw KER 864, 2010 (125) FLR 1103, 2010 (2) LLJ
240
(1) Anjali Sood and Others; (2) Managing Committee,
14/03/2016
Page 32
Natoinal Public, School v Director of Education and Others

2009 Indlaw DEL 736, 2009 (161) DLT 214
Binalish M. Sangma v State of Meghalaya and others
2009 Indlaw GUW 160, 2010 (1) GauLR 437
Gurleen Kaur and others v State of Punjab and others
2009 Indlaw PNH 2702, 2009 (3) RCR(Civil) 324
Modern Dental College and Research Centre and others v
2432, 2009 (4) AWC 3459, 2010 (1) MPLJ 1, 2009(8)
SCALE 660, 2010(13) SCALE 412, [2009] 9 S.C.R. 845,
2009 (7) UJ 3360
Association of Private Dental and Medical Colleges v State
of Madhya Pradesh and others
2009 Indlaw MP 671, 2009 ILR(MP) 2269, 2009(3) M.P.H.T.
418
(1) Meerut Development Authority; (2) Pawan Kumar v (1)
Association of Management Studies and Another;
2009 Indlaw SC 527, (2009) 6 SCC 171, 2009 (5) ADJ 157,
AIR 2009 SC 2894, 2009 (5) ALJ 506, 2009 (3) AWC 2558,
2009 (2) BC 551, 2009(6) SCALE 49, [2009] 6 S.C.R. 663
Vice-Chancellor, Aligarh Muslim University, Aligarh and
others v Nishit Sharma (Minor)
898, 2009 (3) AWC 2533, 2009 (4) ESC 2208, 2009 (3)
UPLBEC 2221
Akhil Bhartiya Upbhokta Congress, Bhopal v State of
Madhya Pradesh and others
2009 Indlaw MP 658, 2009 ILR(MP) 2233, 2009(3) M.P.H.T.
41, 2009 (3) MPLJ 674
Akhil Bhartiya Upbhokta Congress, Bhopal v State of
Mgt. Hindu Educational Society Shri Kurukeshetra (Regd)
and Another v Government of N. C. T. of Delhi and Others
1237
Anirudh Dwivedi v State Chief Commissioner Bharat Scout
and Guide and Another
2009 Indlaw MP 310, 2009 (2) MPLJ 166
14/03/2016
Page 33
Anirudh Dwivedi v State Chief Commissioner Bharat Scout

and Guide and another
Albert B.Jerald v (1) Board of Directors, The Lawrence
School, Nilgiris; (2) Central Board of Secondary Education,
Chennai
2009 Indlaw MAD 305
(1) West Bengal University of Technology and Another; (2)
Arijit Adak and Others; (3) Nabanita Bagchi and Others; (4)
Debayan Mondal and Others v (1) Rishin Mitra and Others;
(2) Anirban Banerjee and Others; (3) Mala Mukherjee and
Others; (4) Asish Kumar Kundu and Others; (5) Shiladitya
Adhikary and Others; (6) State of West Bengal and Others
2008 Indlaw CAL 682, AIR 2009 CAL 67, 2009 (1) CHN 590
Committee of Management, Mumtaz Post Graduate Degree
College and Another v Vice-Chancellor, University of
Lucknow and Others
2008 Indlaw SC 2129, (2009) 1 SCC (L&S) 424, (2009) 2
SCC 630, AIR 2009 SC 1159, 2009(3) ALL MR 907, 2009
(1) AWC 437, JT 2009 (2) SC 305, 2008(16) SCALE 327,
[2008] 17 S.C.R. 774, 2009 (2) UPLBEC 1345
Parents Association Of Students v M. A. Khan And Another
(Supp) 1138, 2009 (2) AWC 1354, JT 2009 (1) SC 128,
2009 (1) RCR(Criminal) 512, 2008(16) SCALE 417, [2008]
17 S.C.R. 735
Dr. Manasvini M. Yogi v Chairman Governing Body I. P.
College and Others
Dr. Rajah Muthiah Chettiar Charitable and Educational
Trust and Others v State of Tamil Nadu, Government,
Health and Family Welfare Department and Others
(1) Krishna Adit Agarwal; (2) Indian Medical Association
and Another; (3) Abhishek Gupta and Others; (4) Kumar
Himanshu v (1) Guru Gobind Singh Indraprastha University
and Another; (2) Union of India and Others
3310
Dhrumit M. Patel and Others v C. U. Shah Medical College,
Surendranagar and Others
2008 Indlaw GUJ 135, AIR 2009 GUJ 1
14/03/2016
Page 34
(1) G. H. R. Education Foundation Society, Through Its

Secretary, Nagpur; (2) G. H. R. Education Foundation
Society's, G. H. Raisoni Institute of Engineering and
Management, Through Its Principal, Jalgaon v (1) State of
Maharashtra, Through Secretary, Department of Higher and
Technical Education, Mumbai; (2) Director, of Technical
Education, Government of Maharashtra; (3) North
Maharashtra University, Through Its Registrar, Jalgaon
2008 Indlaw MUM 685, 2009(1) ALL MR 707, 2009 (1)
Bom.C.R. 837, 2009 (3) MahLJ 356
Vivekanandha Educational Society, Represented By
Secretary, S. Selvaganapathy, Pondicherry v (1)
Pondicherry University, Represented, By Registrar, R.
Venkataraman Nagar; (2) Deputy Registrar, Pondicherry
University, R. Venkataraman Nagar; (3) Regional Director,
National Council For Teacher Education, Bangalore
Francisco D. Luis v (1) Director, Board of Secondary and
Higher Secondary Education, Maharashtra; (2) State of
Maharashtra
2008 Indlaw MUM 440, 2008 (5) Bom.C.R. 569
Mahatma Gandhi Missions Institute, Aurangabad and others
v State of Maharashtra,and others
2008 Indlaw MUM 656, 2008(5) ALL MR 878
Mahatma Gandhi Missions Institute, Aurangabad v State of
2008 Indlaw MUM 1916, 2008 (5) Bom.C.R. 545, 2008 (5)
MahLJ 913
St. Stephen's College represented by Its Supreme Council v
University of Delhi and Another
2008 Indlaw DEL 796, 2008 (152) DLT 228
State of Tamil Nadu, Represented By District Collector v (1)
K. Selvaraj; (2) R. Krishnamurthy
(1) V. Subramaniam; (2) M. Yesudoss v (1) State of Tamil
Nadu, represented By Its Secretary To Government,
Department of Education, Chennai; (2) Collector, Erode; (3)
M. Yesudoss; (4) District Elementary Educational Officer,
Erode
2008 Indlaw MAD 1669, 2010 ACJ 1861, 2009 (1) CTC 434
Sonica Jaggi v Lt. Governor and Others
2008 Indlaw DEL 994, 2008 (152) DLT 601
14/03/2016
Page 35
State of West Bengal and Others v Bahar Alam and Others

2008 Indlaw CAL 167
Commissioner of Income-Tax (International Taxation) and
Another v Illinois Institute of Technology India Private
Limited
2008 Indlaw KAR 566, [2010] 321 ITR 49
State Of West Bengal And Others v Brahmo Samaj
Education Society And Others
2008 Indlaw SC 2579, 2008(14) SCALE 83
Josegiri Hospital v Government of Kerala
2008 Indlaw KER 205, AIR 2008 KER 209, 2008 (3) KLT
627
St. Vincent Palloti College and another v State of
Chhattisgarh and others
2008 Indlaw CTH 128, 2008 (4) M.P.H.T.(CG) 89
C.S.I.Kanyakumari Diocese, Nagercoil, represented By Its
Chairman and Bishop, Rt.Rev.G.Devakadacham
Kanyakumari v (1) Government of Tamil Nadu, reprented
By Its Secretary To Government, Higher Education
Department, Chennai; (2) Director of Collegiate Education,
Chennai; (3) Joint Director of Collegiate Education,
Tirunelveli
Cochin University of Science and Technology and Another v
Thomas P. John and Others
2008(6) ALL MR 964, 2008 (3) ESC 445, JT 2008 (7) SC
76, 2008 (2) KLT 718, 2008(9) SCALE 21, [2008] 7 S.C.R.
887, 2009 (Supp) Bom.C.R. 477
Viswa Bharathi Institute and Another v State of
Chhattisgarh and Another
2008 Indlaw CTH 36, AIR 2008 CHH 68, 2008 (4) M.P.H.T.
(CG) 25
Ashoka Kumar Thakur v Union Of India & Ors
2008 Indlaw SC 596, (2008) 6 SCC 1, AIR 2008 SC (Supp)
1, 2008 (4) Bom.C.R. 80, 2008 (3) CTC 97, JT 2008 (5) SC
1, 2008(5) SCALE 1, [2008] 4 S.C.R. 1
State of Kerala v Nirmala Public School
2008 Indlaw KER 145, 2008 (3) KLT 47
State of Kerala v Manager, Nimala Public School,
Karimannoor and Another
14/03/2016
Page 36
2008 Indlaw KER 538, AIR 2008 KER 197

Subha Mishra and others v State of Madhya Pradesh and
others
2008 Indlaw MPLJ 93
Tuples Educational Society and another v State of Uttar
Pradesh and others
2008 Indlaw ALL 1763, 2008 (3) AWC 2499
P.S.James Arulraj and Another v Government of Tamil Nadu
and Others
2008 Indlaw MAD 544
(1) Vile Parle Kelavani Mandal, Mumbai; (2) Dr. Shrihari, I/c
Principal, Svkm's Dwarkadas J. Sanghvi College of
Engineering, Mumbai; (3) Dr. N.D. Grampurohit, Svkm's Dr.
Bhanuben Nanavati College of Pharmacy, Mumbai v (1)
State of Maharashtra, Through The Government Pleader,
Mumbai; (2) Pravesh Niyantran Samiti, Mumbai; (3)
Director of Technical Education, Maharashtra State,
Mumbai; (4) University of Bombay, Mumbai
2008 Indlaw MUM 131, 2008(3) ALL MR 397, 2008 (4)
Bom.C.R. 363, 2008 (4) MahLJ 413
Meera Bhagwat Jadhavar and Others v State of
Maharashtra and Others
2008 Indlaw MUM 106, 2008(3) ALL MR 55, 2009 (Supp)
Bom.C.R. 191
Zade Manisha Gunderaoji and others v State of
2008 Indlaw MUM 1828, 2008 (3) MahLJ 788, 2008 (Supp)
Bom.C.R. 726
Social Jurist, A Civil Rights Group v Gnct and Others
1274
Shashi Kant v State of Haryana and others
2008 Indlaw PNH 1253, 2008 (149) PLR 742
Maharaja Jiwaji Rao Education Society and another v State
of M.P. and others
2008 Indlaw MP 415, 2008 (1) JabLJ 379, 2008 (2) MPLJ
99
Maharaja Jiwajirao Education Society, Vidisha and another v
Secretary, Kamaraj College, Thoothukudi and others v
14/03/2016
Page 37
D.S.Arulmani, Reader and Head of Department of Tamil,

Kamaraj College, Thoothukudi and others
2008 Indlaw MAD 102
Ebenezer Teacher Training Institute, Women Run By
Ebenezer Educational Trust, Represented By Its Cor,
R.Emerson Udai Singh, Tuticorin v (1) State of Tamil Nadu,
Represented By Its Secretary, School Education
Department, Chennai; (2) Director of Teacher Education
Research and Training, Chennai; (3) Regional Director,
National Council For Teacher Education, Bangalore
2008 Indlaw MAD 303
Self Financing Private Teacher, Training Institutes
Association, (Regd.) v State of Tamil Nadu and Others
2008 Indlaw MAD 311
Sahil Mittal v State of Punjab and Others
2007 Indlaw PNH 95, 2008 (1) RCR(Civil) 373
Suyog v State of Maharashtra and Others
2007 Indlaw MUM 1203, 2008(1) ALL MR 773, 2008 (2)
MahLJ 274
Bhagwat Saran and Others v State of Uttar Pradesh and
Others
2007 Indlaw ALL 459
Committee of Management, Begum Khair Girls Inter
College, Basti and another v State of Uttar Pradesdh and
others
4587
Malankara Orthodox S.C.M. College v Fee Regulatory
Committee
2007 Indlaw KER 440, 2007 (4) KLT 530
(1) Tamil Nadu Self Financing Colleges of Education
Management Association (Regd.); (2) St. Charles College of
Education (Women; (3) Tamil Nadu Self Finance B.Ed. and
Teacher Training Institutes Society; (4) Stella Mary's B.Ed.
College v (1) State of Tamil Nadu; (2) Director of Collegiate
Education, Government of Tamil Nadu, Chennai; (3)
National Council For Teacher Education; (4) Regional
Director, National Council For Teacher Education, Southern
Regional Committee, Bangalore
Abhishek Kodian v State of Uttar Pradesh and Others
14/03/2016
Page 38
2007 Indlaw ALL 2073, 2007 (7) ADJ 429, AIR 2007 ALL
204, 2007 (4) AWC 3607, 2007 (4) ESC 2580, 2007 (3)
UPLBEC 2187
Vishnu Dayal Sharma v State of Uttar Pradesh and Others
2007 Indlaw ALL 687
Madha Engineering College Kundrathur, Chennai and Others
v State of Tamil Nadu and Others
2007 Indlaw MAD 1337, 2007 (4) CTC 13
D. Aravinth and Others Etc v State of Tamil Nadu and
Others
2007 Indlaw MAD 2268, AIR 2007 MAD 300
Committee of Management, L.P. Inter College, Kanpur and
Another v State of Uttar Pradesh and Others
2007 Indlaw ALL 834, 2007 (6) ADJ 621
Orissa Management Colleges Association and Etc v State of
Orissa and Etc
2007 Indlaw ORI 53, AIR 2007 ORI 120
R.V.P.R.T., Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Akola v Assistant
Provident Fund Commissioner, Nagpur and Others
2007 Indlaw MUM 400, 2007(4) ALL MR 584
R. V. P. R. T. Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Akola v Assistant
Provident Fund Commissioner and others
2007 Indlaw MUM 1551, 2007 (3) LLJ 561, 2007 (4) MahLJ
273
B. Narasimha Reddy, Chairman, Nalgonda-Ranga Reddy
Milk Producers Co-Operative (District) Union Limited and
Others v State of Andhra Pradesh, Represented By Its
Secretary, Legislative Affairs and Justice, Law Department
and Others
2007 Indlaw AP 657, 2007 (6) ALT 681
S. Aswin Kumar and Others v State of Tamil Nadu and
Others
2007 Indlaw MAD 973, 2007 (2) CTC 677
Priyanka and Others Etc v State of Madhya Pradesh and
Others
2007 Indlaw MP 122, AIR 2007 MP 182, 2007(2) M.P.H.T.
536, 2007 (3) MPLJ 325
Priyanka D/o Chandra Prakash and others v State of
14/03/2016
Page 39
Ameet Navinchandra Patel and Others v President, Arya

Vidya Mandir Society and Others
2007 Indlaw MUM 1331, 2008 (Supp) Bom.C.R. 868
Committee of Management D.N. (P.G.) College, Meerut and
others v State of U. P. and others
5607
Kumari Surya Shukla and another v State of U. P. and
others
2007 Indlaw ALL 2895, 2007 (4) AWC 3618
Dr. Mehandi Hasan and another v State of Uttar Pradesh
and others
3066, 2007 (3) ESC 2153, 2007 (3) UPLBEC 2229
Social Jurists, A Lawyers Group v Government of Nct of
Delhi and Others
2007 Indlaw DEL 1241, 2007 (140) DLT 698
Anshul Singhal and Others v State of Karnataka and Others
2007 Indlaw KAR 45, 2007 (3) KarLJ 572
Preston College and Another v State of Madhya Pradesh
and Others
2007 Indlaw MP 87, AIR 2008 MP 99, 2009 (1) ESC 138
Nair Service Society v State of Kerala
2007 (6) AWC 5758, JT 2007 (6) SC 103, 2007 (2) KLT 77,
2007(4) SCALE 106, 2007 (5) SCJ 657, [2007] 3 S.C.R.
149, 2007 (3) UPLBEC 2120
Appejay Education Society v Government of NCT of Delhi
and Others
2007 Indlaw DEL 85
K.Sumathi v (1) Eka Ratchagar Sabai Higher Secondary
School; (2) Chief Educational Officer, Tuticorin.; (3)
D.Sumathi Mispa Maharani
2007 Indlaw MAD 8
S. K. C. Charan v Ashwin M. Singh and others
4531
Ashoka Smokeless Coal Ind. Private Limited and others v
2006 Indlaw SC 1470, (2007) 2 SCC 640, 2007 (5) AWC
14/03/2016
Page 40
5156, JT 2007 (1) SC 125, 2006(13) SCALE 102, [2006]

Supp9 S.C.R. 954
Jesus and Mary College, Delhi v University of Delhi and
Another
2006 Indlaw DEL 1396, 2007 (137) DLT 138
Association of Management of Hindu Educational
Institution, Tamil Nadu and Others v State of Tamil Nadu
and Others
2006 Indlaw MAD 1907, 2007 (1) CTC 30
The Secretary,Malankara Syrian Catholic College v T. Jose
and Others
2007 (3) Bom.C.R. 199, 2006(13) SCALE 1, 2007 (3) SCJ
700, [2006] Supp9 S.C.R. 644
Association of Managements of Nursery, Primary and
Matriculation Schools, Peelamedu, Coimbatore v
Government of Tamil Nadu and Another
(1) Darus Salam Educational Trust Represented By Its
Trustee Syed Shah Akbar Nizamuddin Hussaini; (2) Non
Minority Engineering and Professional Colleges
Managements Association, Somajiguda, Hyderabad
Represented By Its General Secretary, A.Maheshwar Reddy
and Another v Government of Andhra Pradesh, Represented
By Its Principal Secretary, Higher Education, Hyderabad and
Others
2006 Indlaw AP 518, 2007 (4) ALD 73
Shresth Shiksha Sanstha v State of Uttar Pradesh and
another
2006 Indlaw ALL 576, 2006 (65) ALR 857, 2006 (7) AWC
7343
Maria Grace Rural Middle School, Venkatarayapuram v
Government of Tamil Nadu and Others
Sanjay Kumar v Managing Committee, Seth Jai Parkash,
Mukand Lal Institute Ofengineering and Technology, Radaur
and Others
Hena Farheen v State of U. P. and others
7705
14/03/2016
Page 41
Ruchi Choudhari and another v Judges Committee and

others
2006 Indlaw MPLJ 56
Association of Management of Private Colleges, Coimbatore
v Secretary, University Grants Commission, New Delhi and
others
M. Ajmal Khan v Election Commission of India Represented
By Its Chief Election Commissioner, New Delhi-l and Others
2006 Indlaw MAD 1445, 2006 (5) CTC 121
J.Gracelin Vinil v (1) Christian Medical College Vellore,
Represented By The Registrar, Tamil Nadu; (2) Tamil Nadu
Dr.Mgr Medical University, Represented By The Registrar;
(3) State of Tamil Nadu Represented By The Secretary To
Government Education Department, Chennai
Self Financing Private Teacher Training Institutes
Association (Regd.), Chennai and Others v Tamil Nadu Self
Finance Colleges of Education Management Association
(Regd.), Chennai and Others
Dr. Hari Bansh Dwivedi v Vice-Chancellor, Mahatma Gandhi
Kashi Vidyapith, Varanasi and others
2006 Indlaw ALL 1376, 2006 (4) AWC 3877, 2006 (4) ESC
2722
(1) State of Tamil Nadu Represented By Secretary Higher
Education Secretariat Chennai; (2) Director of Technical
Education Chennai v (1) V.S.B.Educational Trust
Represented By Chairman V S. Balasamy; (2) The Anna
University Represented By Registrar S.P. Road Chennai; (3)
Secretary Tamilnadu Engineering Admissions, Anna
University, Chennai; (4) Centre For Engineering
Partnership, Represented By Director Anna University
Chennai
2006 Indlaw MAD 971
Mohammadiya Education Society, Ahmednagar and others v
State of Maharashtra and another
2006 Indlaw MUM 1084, 2006 (6) MahLJ 54
R.S. Garg v State of Uttar Pradesh and Others
2006 Indlaw SC 801, (2006) 7 SCC 405, (2006) 6 SCC 430,
(2006) SCC (L&S) 1388, AIR 2006 SC 2912, 2006 (6) AWC
6186, JT 2006 (7) SC 1, 2007 (2) MLJ 315, 2006 (7) SCJ
14/03/2016
Page 42
193, 2006 (5) SLR 348, [2006] Supp4 S.C.R. 120

Dr. K.S.R. Prasad and Another v Karnataka Religious and
Linguistic Minority Professional Colleges Association,
Bangalore and Others
2006 Indlaw KAR 334, 2007 (1) KarLJ 263
Association of Educational Institutes For Hotel Management
and Catering Technology, Represented By President M. P.
Purushothaman v (1) Government of Tamil Nadu
Represented By Secretary Higher Education Department,
Chennai; (2) Director of Technical Education Chennai
2006 Indlaw MAD 778
Cor, Avila Convent Matriculation Higher Secondary School,
Coimbatore v (1) State of Tamil Nadu, Represented By Its
Director of School Education, Chennai; (2) Inspector of
Matriculation Schools, Ramanathapuram, Coimbatore; (3)
N. Radhakrishnan
2006 Indlaw MAD 979
Committee of Management, Mohd. Hasan Inter College
Jaunpur and another v State of Uttar Pradesh and others
5729
(1) Shyam Lal College; (2) Shyam Lal Charitable Trust v
Vice Chancellor, Delhi University
2006 Indlaw DEL 357
C. Manonmony v State of Tamil Nadu and others
2006 Indlaw MAD 710
Hussain Khan v Shah Babu Education Society, Patur and
others
2006 Indlaw MUM 1212, 2006 (4) MahLJ 553
Committee of Management, Shri Kund Kund Jain Inter
College, Khatauli Muzaffarnagar v State of Uttar Pradesh
and others
7202
Harish Tandon v State of U. P. and another
358, 2006 (3) AWC 2829
N.N. Seth and Others v Renu Gupta and Others
2006 Indlaw DEL 35, 2006 (128) DLT 626
Aligarh Muslim University, Aligarh v Malay Shukla and
others
14/03/2016
Page 43
147, 2006 (1) UPLBEC 268
Lisie Medical and Educational Institutions v State of Kerala
2006 Indlaw KER 115, 2007 (1) KLT 409
Abhishek v State of Uttaranchal and Others
2006 Indlaw UTT 12, AIR 2006 UTT 64, 2006 (2) UC 1011
Smt. G. Bharati Tarak Rao v Director of Education and
Others
2006 Indlaw DEL 25, 2006 (127) DLT 50
Committed of Management, National Inter College, Lal
Kurti, Meerut and another v Joint Director of Education,
Region-I, Meerut and others
740
Gopal Ji Trivedi v State of U. P. and others
2005 Indlaw ALL 1455, 2006 (6) AWC 6126
M.I. Hussain v N. Singh and Others
2005 Indlaw DEL 1120, 2005 (8) AD(Del) 499, AIR 2006
DEL 86, 2005 (125) DLT 223, 2005 (85) DRJ 282
Dr. Naresh Agarwal v Union of India and others
2489, 2005 (3) UPLBEC 2246
Lalita Rajpal v Director of Education and Others
2005 Indlaw DEL 1152, 2005 (125) DLT 581
Hon'Ble Justice R. J. Shah (Retd.) Fee Admission Committee
v G. S. E. Medical and Paramedical Association and Others
2005 Indlaw GUJ 250, AIR 2006 GUJ 40
Welfare Association of Self-Financed Institutions and others
v State of U. P. and others
2005 Indlaw ALL 1477, 2005 (6) AWC 6199
P.A. Inamdar and Others v State of Maharashtra and
Others
3226, 2005 (4) AWC 3864B, 2005 (5) Bom.C.R. 859, 2005
(3) ESC 373, JT 2005 (7) SC 313, 2005 (2) LCD 1358,
2005(6) SCALE 471, 2005 (5) SLR 409, [2005] Supp2
S.C.R. 603, 2005 (5) Supreme 544, 2005 (3) UPLBEC 2295
Bal Patil and Another v Union of India and Others
3172, 2005 (5) ALD(SC) 123, 2005 (3) AWC 2796, 2005
14/03/2016
Page 44
(6) Bom.C.R. 769, JT 2005 (7) SC 185, 2005 (3) RCR(Civil)

735, 2005(6) SCALE 374, [2005] Supp2 S.C.R. 459
Kathuria Public School v Director of Education and Another
2005 Indlaw DEL 1095, 2005 (6) AD(Del) 893, 2005 (123)
DLT 89, 2005 (83) DRJ 541
Shri P.A. Inamdar and Others v State of Maharashtra and
Others
2005 Indlaw MUM 95, 2005 (5) Bom.C.R. 52, 2005 (3)
MahLJ 1067
N. Priyadarshini v (1) Secretary To Government, Education
Department; (2) Secretary, Selection Committee (M.B.B.S),
Kilpauk, Chennai - 10
2005 Indlaw MAD 226
Royal Society of Educational Academy, Kanpur Nagar and
another v State of Uttar Pradesh and another
2005 Indlaw ALL 1060, 2005 (6) AWC 5812
Karunesh Kumar Singh v State of Uttar Pradesh and others
2005 Indlaw ALL 1629, 2005 (4) AWC 3410, 2005 (3)
UPLBEC 2361
St. Anthony's Girls Senior Sec. School and Others v
Government of Nct of Delhi and Others
2005 Indlaw DEL 1020, 2005 (6) AD(Del) 181, 2005 (121)
DLT 230
Parents' Association of Medical Students, Maharashtra v
Pravesh Niyantran Samiti and others
2005 Indlaw MUM 687, 2005 (4) MahLJ 75, 2006 (Supp)
Bom.C.R. 349
S. Sesham Raju S/o Mattam Raju v State of Andhra
Pradesh and others
2005 Indlaw AP 453, 2005 (3) ALD 264, 2005 (3) ALT 596
Government of Andhra Pradesh and Another v J.B.
Educational Society and Another, Etc
2014, 2005 (2) ALD(SC) 69, 2005 (2) ESC 184, JT 2005 (2)
SC 521, 2005 (2) KLT 154, 2005(2) SCALE 337, [2005] 2
S.C.R. 302, 2005 (2) SLR 823, 2005 (2) Supreme 210,
2005 (2) UPLBEC 1647
Christian Inter College, Mainpuri v State of U. P. and others
4287
Messrs Zee Telefilms Limited and Another v Union of
14/03/2016
Page 45
India and Others

2005 (4) CompLJ 283, JT 2005 (2) SC 8, 2005(1) SCALE
666B, [2005] 1 S.C.R. 913
I. Saraswathi and others v State of Tamil Nadu and others
2005 Indlaw MAD 21
Robin Tuli v Jawaharlal Medical College, Belgaum and
Others
2004 Indlaw KAR 266, AIR 2005 KAR 276, 2005 (4) KarLJ
122
National Institute of Dental Technology, Hyderabad v Dental
Council and Others
2004 Indlaw AP 301, AIR 2005 AP 175
Ramakrishna Vivekananda Mission v State of West Bengal
and Others
2004 Indlaw SC 1032, (2005) 9 SCC 53, JT 2004 (10) SC
196, 2004(10) SCALE 16, [2004] Supp6 S.C.R. 423, 2005
(1) UPLBEC 632
K. Srinivasan v (1) State of Tamil Nadu; (2) Bharathidasan
Institute of Management(School of Excellence of
Bharathidasan University); (3) All India Council For
Technical Education; (4) Regional Office, All India Council
For Technical Education, Bangalore; (5) Vasanth.P
2004 Indlaw MAD 692
Maharaja Agrasen Institute of Technology v Guru Govind
Singh Indraprastha University
2004 Indlaw DEL 1324, 2005 (3) AD(Del) 14, 2005 (116)
DLT 290
Committee of Management of Bhagwati Adarsh Vidyalaya
Inter College, Balrampur and another v State of U. P. and
others
2004 Indlaw ALL 1564, 2005 (5) AWC 4041
Academy of Medical Sciences v Regina. M
2004 Indlaw KER 199, 2004 (3) KLT 628
Vile Parle Kelvani Mandal and another v State of
Maharashtra and another
2004 Indlaw SC 1986, (2004) 13 SCC 56
State of Rajasthan and another v Senior Higher Secondary
School, Lachhmangarh and others
2004 Indlaw SC 1756, (2005) 10 SCC 346
14/03/2016
Page 46
All India Medical and Engineering Colleges Association v (1)

State of Tamil Nadu; (2) Director of Technical Education
2004 Indlaw MAD 451
Yagya Dutt Mishra and others v State of U. P. and others
2004 Indlaw ALL 1611, 2005 (5) AWC 4404, 2005 (1)
UPLBEC 138, 2005 (2) UPLBEC 1097
Tuples Educational Society v State of U. P. and others
2004 Indlaw ALL 1728, 2005 (2) AWC 1443
(1) Association of Management of Private Colleges; (2)
Jansons School v (1) Government of Tamil Nadu; (2)
Director of Collegiate Education; (3) All India Council For
Technical Education ; (4) State of Tamil Nadu
2004 Indlaw MAD 377
Educate India Society v State of Haryana and others
2004 Indlaw SC 2055, (2004) 13 SCC 701
Rajaram Vidyavihar v State of Gujarat
2004 Indlaw GUJ 73
Dr. Diwakar Singh v State of U. P. and others
533
M. Kumarasamy College of Engineering v (1) The
Government of Tamil Nadu; (2) All India Council For
Technical Education
2004 Indlaw MAD 339
N. K. P. Salve Institute of Medical Science and Research
Centre and Etc v State of Maharashtra and Others
2004 Indlaw MUM 437, AIR 2005 BOM 18, 2005 (1)
Bom.C.R. 659
Modern Dental College and Research Institute and others v
State of Madhya Pradesh and another
2004 Indlaw SC 1947, (2004) 8 SCC 213, 2005 (1) UPLBEC
251
Islamic Academy of Education and another v State of
Karnataka and others
573
Messrs Pushpagiri Medical Society v State of Kerala and
Others
2004 Indlaw SC 544, (2004) 8 SCC 135, 2005 (2)
Bom.C.R. 337, 2004(6) SCALE 481
14/03/2016
Page 47
Balpatil and another v Union of India and others

2004 Indlaw SC 1866, (2005) 9 SCC 352
Himalayan Institute Hospital Trust and others v State of
Uttaranchal and another
2004 Indlaw UTT 118, 2004 (2) UC 1291
Harold James v Union of India and others
2004 Indlaw ALL 1252, 2004 (5) AWC 5025, 2004 (2) LCD
1649
P.A. Inamdar and Others v State of Maharashtra and Others
245
Consortium of Professional Arts and Science Colleges, Tamil
Nadu and others v Permanent Committee For The Conduct
of Common Entrance Test and others
2004 Indlaw MAD 222
Har Dev Singh v Committee of Management D. B. Santokh
Singh Khalsa Inter College, Partab Pura, Agra and another
2004 Indlaw ALL 806, 2004 (3) AWC 2770
Martha S. Khan, Officiating Principal Emma Thompson
School, Lalbagh, Lucknow v Lalbagh Christian Educational
Society, Lalbagh, Lucknow and others
2004 Indlaw ALL 1185, 2004 (5) AWC 4802
U. P., B.Ed. Prashikshan Sangh Sathian, Azamgarh v High
Court of Judicature at Allahabad
2779, 2004 (5) ESC 621
Saurabh Choudhary and Others v Union of India and
Others
2212, 2004 (55) ALR 769, 2004 (3) AWC 2637, 2004 (3)
ESC 407, JT 2004 (Supp1) SC 578, 2004(5) SCALE 432,
[2004] Supp2 S.C.R. 611, 2004 (4) Supreme 292, 2004 (2)
UPLBEC 1655
Brahmo Samaj Education Society and Others v State of
West Bengal and Others
3358, 2004 (3) AWC 2377, 2004 (2) CLR 821, 2004 (98)
CutLT 65, JT 2004 (Supp2) SC 569, 2004 (2) KLT 742,
2004 (3) LLN 61, 2004(5) SCALE 794, 2004 (4) SLR 612,
[2004] Supp2 S.C.R. 214
Usha Mehta & Ors. v State Of Maharashtra & Ors.
14/03/2016
Page 48
2004 Indlaw SC 385, (2004) 6 SCC 264, 2004 (5) ALD(SC)

33, 2005 (1) Bom.C.R. 464, 2004 (2) KLT 696, 2004(5)
SCALE 800, 2004 (5) SLR 16, [2004] Supp2 S.C.R. 226
Modern School, Mahavir Senior Model School, Mater v
Union of India and Others, Government of Nct of
2236, 2004 (4) ALD(SC) 50, 2004 (111) DLT 317, JT 2004
(Supp1) SC 362, 2004(5) SCALE 170, 2004 (3) SLR 693,
[2004] Supp1 S.C.R. 668, 2004 (2) UPLBEC 2012
Shri Omar Vaishya Vidyalaya Committee and another v
Kanti Pandey
2004 Indlaw ALL 1171, 2004 (2) AllCJ 1013, 2004 (5) AWC
4698
P. Dhanapakkiam v Secretary Holy Angel High School,
Madurai
2004 Indlaw MAD 545
State Of Tamil Nadu And Anr v S.V. Bratheep (Minor) And
Ors.
1861, 2004 (3) AWC 2473, 2004 (3) ESC 359, JT 2004 (3)
SC 416, 2004(3) SCALE 330, [2004] 2 S.C.R. 1218, 2004
(2) SLT 575, 2004 (2) UPLBEC 1306
Bharati Vidyapeeth (Deemed University) and Others v State
of Maharashtra and Another
1943, JT 2004 (3) SC 451, 2004(3) SCALE 488, [2004] 2
S.C.R. 775, 2004 (3) SLR 291, 2004 (2) UPLBEC 1090
Kerala Student Union v Sojan Francis
2004 Indlaw KER 163, 2004 (2) KLT 378
Maa Sharda Maha Vidyalaya, Shambhoopur, Gahji,
Azamgarh v State of U. P. and others
2004 Indlaw ALL 1155, 2004 (5) AWC 4525, 2004 (1)
UPLBEC 784
Agarwal Pharmacy College and Another v State of
Rajasthan and Others
2004 Indlaw RAJ 186, AIR 2004 RAJ 177
Biju Pattnaik University of Technology, Rourkela and Etc. v
Government of Orissa and Others.
2004 Indlaw ORI 62, AIR 2004 ORI 101
GSF Medical & Paramedical Association v Association of
Management of Self Financing Technical Institutes and
14/03/2016
Page 49
Another
1177, 2004 (54) ALR 172, 2003(10) SCALE 947, 2004 (1)
SLT 950, 2003 (8) Supreme 813
Keraleeya Samajam and others v State of Maharashtra and
others
2003 Indlaw MUM 808, 2004 (3) Bom.C.R. 723, 2004 (2)
MahLJ 171
Manager, Nirmala Senior Secondary School, Port v N.I.
Khan and Others
2003 Indlaw SC 1068, (2003) 12 SCC 84, (2004) SCC
(L&S) 1002, AIR 2004 SC 499, 2004 (1) CLR 644, 2004
(100) FLR 494, JT 2003 (9) SC 472, 2004 (1) LLN 43,
2003(10) SCALE 121, 2003 (1) SCW 6549, 2004 (1) SLR
397, 2003 (7) SLT 351, [2003] Supp6 S.C.R. 75, 2003 (8)
Supreme 437, 2004 (1) UPLBEC 997
State Of Punjab And Another v M/S. Devans Modern
Brewaries And Another
2003 Indlaw SC 1507, (2004) 11 SCC 26, JT 2003 (10) SC
485, 2003(10) SCALE 202, [2003] Supp5 S.C.R. 930
Government of Andhra Pradesh and another v Medwin
Educational Society and Others
2004 (1) ESC 90, JT 2003 (8) SC 567, 2003(9) SCALE 500,
2003 (1) SCW 6162, 2003 (8) SLR 500, 2004 (1) SLT 12,
[2003] Supp5 S.C.R. 408, 2004 (1) Supreme 412, 2004 (1)
UPLBEC 372
Christian Medical College and Hospital, Vellore v Inspector
of Labour, Vellore and Another
2003 Indlaw MAD 99
Saurabh Chaudri and Others v Union of India and Others
361, JT 2003 (8) SC 296, 2003(9) SCALE 272, 2003 (1)
SCW 6392, 2004 (1) SLR 287, 2003 (6) SLT 724, [2003]
Supp5 S.C.R. 152, 2004 (1) Supreme 26, 2004 (1) UPLBEC
279
P.V.Suter Paul v Manager and Others
2003 Indlaw KER 261, 2003 (3) KLT 1019
Educate India Society v All India Council For Technical
Education
2003 Indlaw DEL 820, 2003 (8) AD(Del) 91, 2003 (108)
DLT 274
14/03/2016
Page 50
Indian Handicrafts Emporium and Others v Union of India

and Others
3240, 2003 (6) ALD(SC) 39, 2003 (5) AWC 4251, 2003
(106) DLT 350, JT 2003 (7) SC 446, 2003(6) SCALE 831,
2003 (5) SLT 289, [2003] Supp3 S.C.R. 43, 2003 (6)
Supreme 439
Governing Body of the registered Society designated as St.
Andrew's College Association and another v State of U. P.
and others
5059
S.K. Puri and Others v Lt. Governor, Nct of Delhi and Others
2003 Indlaw DEL 895, 2004 (1) AD(Del) 261, 2004 (109)
DLT 71, 2004 RLR 112
Chaudhary Charan Singh University, Meerut v Astron
Educational Samiti and others
2003 Indlaw ALL 1210, 2003 (6) AWC 4927
Islamic Academy of Education and Another v State of
Karnataka and Others
3724, AIR 2003 SCW 4240, 2003 (5) ALD(SC) 1, 2003 (4)
AWC 3119, 2004 (1) Bom.C.R. 593, 2003 (4) ESC 509, JT
2003 (7) SC 1, 2003(6) SCALE 325, 2003 (5) SLR 1,
[2003] Supp2 S.C.R. 474, 2003 (6) Supreme 303, 2003 (3)
UPLBEC 2424
I.I.T.T. College of Engineering v State of Himachal Pradesh
and Others
2003 (3) AllCJ 2557, 2003 (5) AWC 3634, 2003 (4) ESC
587, JT 2003 (7) SC 86, 2003(6) SCALE 237, 2003 (5) SLR
72, 2003 (6) SLT 129, [2003] Supp2 S.C.R. 348, 2003 (5)
Supreme 534, 2003 (3) UPLBEC 2400
Christian Medical College v State of Tamil Nadu and another
206
Sojan Francis v M.G. University and Others
2003 Indlaw KER 317, AIR 2003 KER 290
Fatima Society and another v Government of India, Ministry
of Defence and another
2003 Indlaw ALL 1383, 2003 (6) AWC 5580, 2003 (4)
UPLBEC 2965
14/03/2016
Page 51
Kapila Hingorani v State Of Bihar

2003 Indlaw SC 483, (2003) 6 SCC 1, 2003 (3) AWC 2344,
[2003] 116 Comp Cas 133, 2003 (5) ESC 203, 2003 (98)
FLR 329, JT 2003 (5) SC 1, 2003 (3) LLJ 31, 2003(4)
SCALE 712, 2003 (4) SLR 541, 2003 (3) SLT 673, [2003]
Supp1 S.C.R. 175, 2003 (4) Supreme 1
State of Karnataka v Dr. T. M. A. Pai Foundation and Others
2003 Indlaw SC 1435, (2003) 6 SCC 790
State of Kerala and Others v Pushpagiri and Another
2003 Indlaw KER 5, 2003 (1) KLT 923
Sierra International Shipping Corpn. v M. V. Umka and
Others
2003 Indlaw MUM 197, AIR 2003 BOM 265, 2003 (6)
Bom.C.R. 723
Serbjeet Bhatia v Goc-In-C, Hq Central Command, Lucknow
(UP) and others
2003 Indlaw MP 31318, 2004 (2) MPLJ 125
Serbjeet Bhatia v Goc-In-C, Hq Central Command, Lucknow
(UP) and others
Legislation Cited
Bihar Universities Act

Bihar Universities Act 48-B
Constitution (Forty-Second Amendment) Act, 1976
Constitution (Seventh Amendment) Act, 1956
Constitution of India, 1950
Constitution of India, 1950 art 14
Constitution of India, 1950 art 15(1)
Constitution of India, 1950 art 16(4A)
14/03/2016
Constitution of India, 1950 art 19(1)(f)

Constitution of India, 1950 art 19(1)(g)
Constitution of India, 1950 art 23(3)(a)
Constitution of India, 1950 art 23A
Constitution of India, 1950 art 26(1)(a)
Constitution of India, 1950 art 26(a)
Constitution of India, 1950 art 26(b)
Constitution of India, 1950 art 26(c)
Constitution of India, 1950 art 26(d)
Page 52
14/03/2016
Page 53

Constitution of India, 1950 art 290(A)
Constitution of India, 1950 art 350A
Constitution of India, 1950 art 350B
Constitution of India, 1950 art 371(H)
Gujarat University Act, 1949
Guru Nanak University (Amritsar) Act (21 of 1969)
Guru Nanak University (Amritsar) Act (21 of 1969) 4(2)
Guru Nanak University (Amritsar) Act (21 of 1969) 5
Guru Nanak University (Amritsar) Act (21 of 1969) 33A(1)
(a)
Guru Nanak University (Amritsar) Act (21 of 1969) 41
Guru Nanak University (Amritsar) Act (21 of 1969) 41(1)
Guru Nanak University Act
Kerala Education Bill, 1957
Kerala University Act, 1969
Kerala University Act, 1969 19
Societies Registration Act, 1860
2015 Thomson Reuters South Asia Private Limited
This database contains editorial enhancements that are not a part of the original material. The database may also have mistakes or omissions. Users are requested to verify the
contents with the relevant original text(s) such as, the certified copy of the judgment, Government Gazettes, etc. Thomson Reuters bears no liability whatsoever for the adequacy,
accuracy, satisfactory quality or suitability of the content.

T.M.a. Pai Foundation and Ors. Etc. V State of Karnataka and Ors. Etc.

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

T.M.a. Pai Foundation and Ors. Etc. V State of Karnataka and Ors. Etc.

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

14/03/2016

Delivery | Westlaw India

Westlaw India Delivery Summary

Request made on:

Monday, 14 March, 2016 at 23:44 IST

Cases > Supreme Court Judgments

T.M.A. Pai Foundation and others v State of

Number of documents delivered:

2016 Thomson Reuters South Asia Private Limited

Delivery | Westlaw India

T.M.A. Pai Foundation and others v State of Karnataka and

B.N. Kirpal, G.B. Pattanaik, S. Rajendra Babu, V.N. Khare,

2002 Indlaw SC 1375; (2002) 8 SCC 481; AIR 2003 SC

Subject: Constitution; Practice & Procedure; Trusts &

Delivery | Westlaw India

with Constitution of the governing bodies or thrusting the

All Cases Cited

Delivery | Westlaw India

Rev. Father W. Proost and Others v State of Bihar and

Delivery | Westlaw India

147, AIR 1983 SC 239, 1982(2) SCALE 1193, [1983] 1

Delivery | Westlaw India

1970 SC 259, 1969 KLT 312, [1970] 1 S.C.R. 172

Delivery | Westlaw India

[1951] 21 Comp Cas 33, 1951 SCJ 29, [1950] 1 S.C.R.

Cases Citing this

Alagaapuram R. Mohanraj and others v Tamil Nadu

Delivery | Westlaw India

Teacher Education and another

Delivery | Westlaw India

Secretary Higher Education Civil Sectt. and others

Delivery | Westlaw India

Government of Assam, Education (ELE) Deptt., Dispur

Delivery | Westlaw India

Siddarth Singh v Vice Chancellor, Delhi University and

Delivery | Westlaw India

Punjab Through its Registrar

Delivery | Westlaw India

2014 Indlaw MAD 883

Delivery | Westlaw India

Managing Committee, Contai Rahmania High Madrasah and

Delivery | Westlaw India

Delivery | Westlaw India

Rohilkhand Medical College and Hospital, Bareilly v Medical

Delivery | Westlaw India

2013 Indlaw MUM 562, 2013(5) ALL MR 385, 2013 (5)

Delivery | Westlaw India

Education and another

Delivery | Westlaw India

Lakshmi School and others v State of Tamil Nadu Secretary

Delivery | Westlaw India

2012 Indlaw CTH 111, 2012 (5) M.P.H.T.(CG) 59

Delivery | Westlaw India

State of Madhya Pradesh and others

Delivery | Westlaw India

Delivery | Westlaw India

Delivery | Westlaw India

2365, JT 2011 (6) SC 505, 2011(6) SCALE 86, [2011] 6

Delivery | Westlaw India

Mohammad Sharfullah and others

Delivery | Westlaw India

2010 Indlaw HP 384

Delivery | Westlaw India