Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DUS2022
INTRODUCTION
TOSTRATEG
IC
STUDIES
LECTURE;
The CausesOf WarAnd The Condition
Of Peace
V
o INTRODUCTION
o THE STUDYOFWAR
v
o HUMAN NATUREEXPLANATIONSOF WAR
-
4. the structureof internationalsystem.
z aims:
RelatecontemDorarvscholarshipacrossa ranse of
disciplines-biology,'political science,-philosobhy&
history (problem& causationof war)
Identify different kinds of 'cause'.E.g..underlying,
immediate,consciousness & unconsciousness motives.
"a The cure of war relatesto its cause.Different causes
leadto differentpolicy recommendations.E.g.arms
race- policv of dsarmament or arms controlare
appryfriate solutions. E.g.Non Proliferation Treaty
(NPT)
Or the way to peacelie in the spreadof democracy
If causesof war deemedto'international anarchv'-
then attempt to get {d of war will geartoward
promotrng'systemchange.
E.g..strengthen IL or a systemof collectivesecurityor
worlcl government
2
- -t!
1t2112010
- causes war
istinctions
O.INSTINCTIVE'VS. LEARNEDBEHAVIOR
O.IMMEDIAIE, VS.'UNDERLANG'CAUSES
O.EFFICIENT'VS. PERMISSIVE'CAUSES
O.CONSCIOUS' VS.'UNCONSCIOUS'
MOTIVESOF WAR
O.NECESSARY' VS. .SUFFICIENT'CAUSES
E
1t21t2010
THESTUDYOFWAR
o War regardedas human disaster,sourceof misery
on a calastrophicscale,& in nuclearage-threatto
entirehuman race.
. rgtncentury- G.W.F.Hegel-war preservedthe
eihical hea'lthof nationsl
. H.Von Treitschke-condition of progress,preventa
country from going to sleep.
o E.H.Carr- war as 'the midwifeof change,
strengthenedgroupconsciousness & economic
development.
(
o War as purposive,functionalBUTabnormal,
pathologicalcondition- threatus all.
STUDYOF
r rs stepto abolishwar is to find the causes.
o War is causedby human behaviornot human nature-
modify it by reward,posiry threat by education
programmesor propaganca.
\t/ . Civilizedsocieties-makingpeoplebehavedespitetheir
nature.
o E.H.Police,Law,Schools,Mosque& Churches-
modifying human behaviorin domesticenvironment.
. Modifying statebehavior-widely recognize.E.g.
diplomac!, force,threat, aid & piopaginda -
instrument usedby leadersto effeit t-hebehaviorof
states.
4
F
1t21t2010
ESTUDYOFWAR
o Deterrencestrategies(DS)- if human nature
is fatally flawed, statescan still be deterred
from act of aggressionby threat of
unacceptablepunishment.
o E.g.Robbers-threat of imprisonment.
5
1t21t201
IN STUD
CULTIES
o Human being do not fieht becausethey haveweapon
but thev acqiire weapo"nto fieht. Not all arms rac'e
leadto war. E.e.ColdWar arrilsracebtwn US & USSR-
led to a deterrEdstalemate-most prolongedperiod of
peacein Europeanhistory
o Historian - origins rather than causes
r Bestway to describehow they comeabout in term of
social contefi & eventthey spring.
. E.g.WWII- Treatyof Versailles,the world depression,
the rise of Hitler, Germanrearmament, Foreign
policies of Britain & France.
IMMEDIATE& UNDERLYINGCAUSES
7
1t21t2010
8
-- Ir
1t21t2010
HUMANNATURE
EXPLANATIONS
OFWAR
Frustration
o SocialPsychologisthavearguedthat aggressionis
\> the result of frustration.
o Somebelievefeelingsof aggression can be
channeledinto harmlessactivitieslike sport.
o Emphasizethe connectionbtwn violenceand the
failure of human beingsto achievetheir objectives.
o Canchannelthe aggressionto harmlessactivities-
socialengineering
9
1t21t2010
HUMAN NATUREEXPLANATIONS
OFWAR
Misperception
o Warsthat resultfrom misperceptions,
misunderstandinss & mistalculationsbv
statesmenmight 6e preuentedby belter'
communicatiSns& riroreaccurafeinformation.
r Hatred& suspicioncan be reducedif understand
better- but the morethev understandmore thev
will hateoneanother- Sir EvelynBaring(Britisti
Governorin Egypt r883-r9o7)
. FalklandWar
HUMANNATURE
EXPLANATIONS
OFWAR
Conscious& unconsciousmotivesfor war
o Psychologisttrying to look behind statesmen's
I decision,tend to seewar asa resultof
unconsciousness drives& weaknessesin the
human psyche.Practitionersareunlikely to agree.
. Official (statesmen)believethat war resultsfrom a
calculated,purposive,consciousdecision.
e Philosopher- war asa resultof unconsciousdrives
& weaknesses in human psyche.
10
1t21t2010
HUMAN NATUREEXPLANATIONS
OFWAR
I Somebelievethat there is something about human
collectivesthat encouragesviolencb.
o Crowd psychology-Lessresponsibility on individual but
diffused in crowds* lessweight on individual.
o There is someevidence,howeverthat though democratic
statesfight as frequently as other states,they do not fight
eachother.
o E.g.Democracy& Peacedemocratictheory
,WITHIN' 'BEYOND'
& STA
o As interstatewar haswaned,intra stateconflict
hasbecomemore frequent.
o E.g.identity conflict, protractedconflict, ethnic
9. conflict.
-v
o Ethnic conflicts do not easilyfit the Clausewitzian
model.
o Theyare particularlyviolent & peopleareoften
killed becauseof they areratherthan becauseof
their behavior& politics.In the future,some
writers suggest,wars may be between'civilizations'
rather than betweenstatesor ethnicsgroups.
11
1t21t2010
a CureforWAR:
l. Changeof human nature/behavior
2. To reconstruct the system
12