Professional Documents
Culture Documents
t o FactsbeU
Ethical issuesin A-Level Biology
This Factsheetwill refer to spiritual, morel, ethical,and socialissuesrelevantto the following topics:
.
o
.
2. Who owns the genesand the other piecesof DNA? Is it the scientist
or company that obtained the information, or the individual who has
that genome?This has implications for:
.
3. How reliable and useful is fetal genetic testing at present and will
healthcare personnel counsel parents correctly, and sympathetically,
about the risks and limitations arising from genetic technology? Before
individuals can give consentfor proceduresto be carried out they must
be adequatelyinformed about complex and conffoversial procedures,
about how to assessgenetic information for reproductive decisionsand
about the reproductive rights of parents and children. For example,
parents may be told that the baby they are expecting is carrying the
allele for cystic fibrosis. Should the pregnancybe terminated or should
they allow the baby to be born? The fact that gene therapy is being
developed as a ffeatment for cystic fibrosis may help the parents to
decide to let the pregnancycontinue,even though the baby will develop
cyctic fibrosis. So that correct decisionscan be made, it is important
that genetic testing is evaluatedand regulated for accuracy,reliability
and usefulness.Genetic tests must be reliable and interpretableby the
medical professions.At present there is little quality control of such
procedures.Doctors, other health service personnel and patients must
be educated about the new genetic capabilities, their scientific
limitations and social risks. Quality control measures and the
implementation of standardsmust be developedproperly.
greenhouse effect,
global warming.
4. Should parentshave the right to let their children be testedfor adultonset diseases?Should testing be performed in cases where no
treatment is yet available? Uncertainties exist about gene tests for
susceptibilitiesto diseaseand for complex conditions such as 'heart
disease',especially when the conditions are linked to multiple gene
interactionsand to gene-environmentinteractions.
5. Do people'sgenesmake them behavein particularways or can people
genesconsidered
always control their behaviour?Are disease-causing
acceptable genetic diversity? Knowledge of the human genome
imposes conceptual and philosophical implications on humans,
including human responsibiliry free-will versus genetic determination,
it also may modiff conceptsof health and acceptabledisease.
Genetic engineering and its uses in agriculture.
Genetic engineeringin agricultureis used to produce geneticallymodified
crops (GM crops), geneticallymodified animalsand growth hormones.
.
Bio Factsbeet
'
'
In the Book of Genesisin the Bible, God gave man the instruction
'go forth
and multiply'. Similar statementsoccur in the Koran and
other religious books. The United Nations'Declaration of Human
Rights, article 16 states'men and women have the right to man-y
and found a family'. Many considerthat it would be immoral and
unethical to prevent any family to have a child.
'
Abortion
' Some people think that abortion is wrong in all circumstances
becauseit doesnot recognisethe rights of the fetusand it challenges
the idea of the sanctityof all human life. Those who considerthat
an embryo, from the moment of conception,is a human being with
full moral status,think that abortion is the same as murder. people
with this view will not acceptthat it shouldbe possiblefor women
to legally obtain abortion, no matter how difficult the rives of those
women and families are made as a result.
'
'
Bio Factsbeet
centres
There is great cost incurred by health servicesand rehabilitation
habit'
the
of
users
to treat drugisolvent related diseasesand to cure
services
There is considerablecost incurred by the police and prison
in dealing with drug usersand suppliers'
fromdiseaseswhichcouldbepreventedbymassvaccination
upsets,
in many '
There are personalcostsinvolved due to loss of work, family
programmes.Mass vaccinationprogrammesare not in place
abuse
drug/solvent
to
due
bereavements
and quite frequently,
countriesbecauseof:
economicPoverty.
l.
Smoking and disease/cancer.
the failure of more affluent countries to fund programmes.
2.
is now inefutable evidencethat smoking, including passivesmoking'
There
wars.
3.
and to
is linked to the development of cancers (particularly lung cancer)
should
heart
disease.
and
emphysema
adult
There is a moral dilemma with somevaccinations.Individuals
bronchitis,
example,
for
'herd effect' which protects the other illnesses,
'smoke or not to smoke' is a matter of choice for the individual and any
be vaccinated to build up the
To
For
to
individuals.
threat
pose
a
vaccines
to be selfsome
However,
population.
personal damage it may causeto the smoker can be considered
in a
smoker.
passive
a
be
to
but
.*u-pl., the MMR triple vaccine (measles'mumps' rubella)'
choice
no
has
person
inflicted, unlessthe
effects
small number of casesis thought to have causedcatastrophic
becomes Smoking-relateddiseasestake approximately one third of the National
in the recipient, such as severe autism (when the child
'tie up' innumerable
severely withdrawn, divorced from realiry unable to communicate Health Service budget per year, and continually
of the staff, beds,and operatingtheaffes.Becausemost smoking-relateddisease
and subjectto severerages)and Crohn's disease(inflammation
triple
the
that
fact
the
totally unethical, because it reduces the
with
lie
to
is self-inflicted this ,..-,
ileum). Part of the problem seems
three capability of the NHS to ffeat non-smoking patients'
with
system
immune
developing
buby't
ih.
vaccine challenges
the possible
different viral pathogens at the same time. Becauseof
- eutrophication, greenhouse effect, global
r i s k s o m e p a r e n t s a n d d o c t o r s p r e f e r t o g i v e t h e t h r e e p a t h o g e n s a sEffects of pollution
This
injections)'
nine
(a
of
total
time
over
single vaccinations spread
warming.
proteins nine
becauseof the
means however, thai the baby is exposed to foreign
Somep.opt. would arguethat pollution is a necessaryevil
reactionsto
However'
output'
industrial
and
production
food
world
times as frequently and thus has a gteaterrisk of adverse
need to increase
all nine
it or to reduce
the proteinr. AtrL the baby is not fully protected until
wherever pollution occurs, efforts should be made to stop
a year.
injections have been given, a programmewhich takes about
it as far as possible.
causes
Measles in a non-immunised individual is a killer disease,
infectious.
extremely
is
and
serious long-term effects in survivors
suffering
Thus measlesepidemics should be avoided the risks of
In conclusion
of the spiritual,
This factsheet has tried to give a balanced view of some
It should be
biology.
modern
in
involved
isiues
social, ethical and moral
discussion'
stimulate
to
basis
used as a
restrictedto asking
Exam questionson thesetopics,to date,have always been
to what has
relating
issues
ethicaVmoral
two
the candidateto state one or
recentyears
in
example.
For
question.
the
part
of
previous
the
been askedin
cloning'
animal
questionshave been frequently asked aboutthe techniqueof
Acknowledgements
This Factsheet was written bv Martin Grffin'
Steet' Birmingham Bl8 6NF
Curriculum Press.Unit 3058, The Big Peg, 120 Vyse
staff or students, provided that their
Bio Factsheetsmay be copiedfree of .t oi*, bv-teaching
Factsheets may be reproduced, stored in a
school is a registe)ed sub'scriber. Ni porti.lth"t,
b1, any other means' without the prior
retrieval $)stem, or transmitted, in any other form or
1351-5i,36
ISSN
publisher
ofthe
permission