See

discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at:

http://www.researchgate.net/publication/266963364

Social representations of HIV/AIDS

in mass media: Some important
lessons for caregivers
ARTICLE in INTERNATIONAL SOCIAL WORK FEBRUARY 2015
Impact Factor: 0.48 DOI: 10.1177/0020872813497380

1 AUTHOR:
Oscar Labra
Universit du Qubec en Abitibi-
11 PUBLICATIONS 0 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE

Available from: Oscar Labra

Retrieved on: 20 August 2015

International
Social Work
http://isw.sagepub.com/

Social representations of HIV/AIDS in mass media: Some important lessons for

caregivers
Oscar Labra
International Social Work published online 30 October 2013
DOI: 10.1177/0020872813497380
The online version of this article can be found at:
http://isw.sagepub.com/content/early/2013/10/30/0020872813497380

Published by:
http://www.sagepublications.com

On behalf of:
International Association of Schools of Social Work
International Council of Social Welfare
International Federation of Social Workers

Additional services and information for International Social Work can be found at:
Email Alerts: http://isw.sagepub.com/cgi/alerts
Subscriptions: http://isw.sagepub.com/subscriptions
Reprints: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsReprints.nav
Permissions: http://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav

>> OnlineFirst Version of Record - Oct 30, 2013

What is This?

Downloaded from isw.sagepub.com at Universite Abittibi-Temiscamingue on October 16, 2014

497380

2013

ISW0010.1177/0020872813497380International Social WorkLabra

i s w

Article

Social representations of HIV/AIDS

in mass media: Some important
lessons for caregivers

International Social Work

0(0) 111
The Author(s) 2013
Reprints and permissions:
sagepub.co.uk/journalsPermissions.nav
DOI: 10.1177/0020872813497380
isw.sagepub.com

Oscar Labra
Universit du Qubec en Abitibi-Tmiscamingue, Canada

Abstract
This article provides an overview of published studies on social representations of HIV/AIDS. It
argues that, despite changes over time in the peripheral elements of negative social representations,
such representations remain present within the health care field and continue to affect populations
across various cultures. This underlines the importance of health care that accounts for cultural
needs in interventions with people living with HIV/AIDS. A review of the relevant literature suggests
that it is necessary to assist caregivers (including social workers) in understanding both the social
significance associated with the illness and the concept of cultural competence.
Keywords
Cultural competence, health care, HIV/AIDS, social representation, social workers

Introduction
The present literature review discusses research into social representations of HIV/AIDS published
since 1986. The aim of the review is to provide a historical outline of social representations of HIV/
AIDS, beginning with the mass outbreak of the disease during the 1980s, through the decade of the
1990s, and to the present day. The works and authors cited reflect a range of representations of
HIV/AIDS across various world regions (e.g. Latin America, North America, Africa, Europe,
Oceania, Asia). A number of studies have argued persuasively for the importance of social representation theory in the overall body of research on HIV/AIDS, including works on such themes as
social representations of health and illness (Jodelet, 1989), media representations (Nengeh, 2003;
Scalvini, 2010), and various affected populations (Albert, 1986; Brasileiro and Freitas, 2006; Joffe,
1994, 1995, 1996a, 1996b; Labra, 2011; Pez etal., 1991; Weeks, 1989).
It is of primary importance to understand the development of social representations over time,
since they have had, and continue to have, a determinant influence on the quality of care that HIV/
AIDS patients receive today. The review of literature presented in this article will argue for the
necessity of developing cultural competencies among social workers who deliver care to people
Corresponding author:
Oscar Labra, Department of Human and Social Development, Universit du Qubec en Abitibi-Tmiscamingue, 445,
boulevard de lUniversit, Rouyn-Noranda, Qubec, Canada J9X 5E4.
Email: oscar.labra@uqat.ca

Downloaded from isw.sagepub.com at Universite Abittibi-Temiscamingue on October 16, 2014

International Social Work 0(0)

infected with HIV/AIDS. Published research into social representations of HIV/AIDS will be
examined in chronological order of publication, within three major periods that have marked the
development of social representations, largely corresponding to the three decades of the 1980s,
1990s and 2000s. During that time, representations of the pandemic have undergone many variations and changes. Beginning as perceptions of a stigmatized infection, following the first diagnosis of the disease (Herek and Glunt, 1988) , social representations of HIV/AIDS have become those
of a fundamentally social problem (Labra, 2010).

Methods
The bulk of the documentary research underpinning the present review was carried out in digital
databases, including Sociological Abstracts, Social Work Abstracts, Current Contents, Medline,
Cinahl and Scielo. I will discuss the research presented in some 40 publications the earliest published in 1986, the most recent in January 2011 in order to examine their individual and collective
contributions to our understanding of social representations of HIV/AIDS. Among the retrieved
articles, the present study retained only those that directly examined the theme of social representations of HIV/AIDS.
The scope of this study was limited by time constraints and restrained access to resources,
which tilted the focus towards scholarly journals and away from book-length studies. It is possible that this research strategy resulted in the omission of relevant book chapters in edited volumes. Additionally, the relative paucity of published research on the subject available through
the major digital databases imposed limitations on the development of a potential analysis of
representations of HIV/AIDS from the perspective of cultural differences. The inclusion of publications in English, French and Spanish widened the scope of the study to include a broader
variety of perspectives. Nevertheless, the bibliography neither claims to be an exhaustive catalog
of all publications on the subject nor, ultimately, is it necessarily representative of the complete
body of literature on social representations. The nature of research in electronic databases meant
also that potentially relevant information contained in documents that did not match the key
words used was omitted, as were, possibly, other existing documents not indexed in the databases consulted. Given the limitations, it is important to add that the present study does not
attempt to generalize its findings to populations, jurisdictions or geographic regions not covered
by the reviewed literature. Its main contribution is to trace the historical development of social
representations of HIV/AIDS and identify their continuing influence on the care delivered to
those carrying the disease today.
In terms of approaches noted throughout the literature, the overwhelming majority of the examined publications rely on qualitative analysis methods. Most provide a portrait of social representations since the beginning of the pandemic without attempting to draw comparisons between
specific persons or groups affected by HIV/AIDS. Indeed, throughout the examined literature,
results and conclusions do not tend towards comparative considerations of individuals or specific
groups affected by HIV/AIDS. Rather, based on the available research, they describe social representations as they have emerged since the beginning of the pandemic.

Cultural competence
An overview of social representations shows that HIV/AIDS has principally affected social and
racial/ethnic groups that had previously suffered from discrimination and socioeconomic disparities. As they interact with health care providers, negative representations of these populations can

Downloaded from isw.sagepub.com at Universite Abittibi-Temiscamingue on October 16, 2014

Labra

significantly affect patientprovider relationships. Consequently, cultural competence among

health care professionals is of the utmost importance.
First, it is important to stress that the cultural competence evolves within broader cultural concepts and realities. The definition of culture I will adopt for the purposes of this study is that of a
complex and interdependent structure of models regulating behavior, knowledge, representations,
codes, formal and informal rules, interests, values, aspirations, beliefs and myths (Gratton, 2009:
33). For many authors, cultural competence is intimately connected with an awareness of cultural
differences. To talk of cultural competence is to talk of the ability to avoid stereotyping members
of a group while still appreciating the importance of culture. The National Association Social of
Workers, based in Washington, DC, defines cultural competence as a set of congruent behaviors,
attitudes, and policies that come together in a system or agency or among professionals and enable
the system, agency, or professionals to work effectively in cross-cultural situations (NASW, 2000:
61). Giger etal. (2007) , on the other hand, argue that cultural competence is an ongoing process
that involves accepting and respecting differences, while not allowing ones personal beliefs to
have an undue influence on those whose worldview is different from ones own. Thus, cultural
competence requires that AIDS health care providers (including social workers) display a certain
level of cultural awareness and sensitivity.
One of the purposes of the present article is to draw attention to the history of social representations of HIV/AIDS in order to insist on the urgency of improving health and social workers intervention practices, with a focus on cultural competence relevant to working with people living with
HIV/AIDS.
Therefore, before moving further, it is crucial to define clearly the concept of social representation. The definition used throughout this study was elaborated by Serge Moscovici (1961), founder
of social representation theory. Moscovici described social representation as:
a system of values, ideas and practices with a twofold function, first to establish an order which will enable
individuals to orient themselves in their material and social world and to master it; and second to enable
communication to take place among the members of a community by providing them with a code for social
exchange and a code for naming and classifying unambiguously the various aspects of their world and
their individual and group history. (Moscovici, in Herzlich, 1972: 11)

In short, thus, for Moscovici (1961), social representations exert great influence on individuals
understanding of the world around them.

The 1980s
Since the emergence of HIV/AIDS in the early 1980s, numerous studies have examined the social
representations of people infected with the virus, as well as the dissemination of those representations by mass media in the Western world (see, for example, Albert, 1986; Echebarra and R. Pez,
1989; Watney, 1989). In the history of research on social representations of HIV/AIDS, the work
of Weeks (1989) marks a major landmark. Weeks argued that HIV/AIDS had come to be seen as
the defining disease of the 1980s and, in the consciousness of the general public, was the 20th
centurys answer to the plague. And one of the most important factors driving the development of
representations during the 1980s was a generalized perception of HIV/AIDS as being closely
linked with marginalized populations (Gilman, 1987; Weeks, 1989).
Weeks (1989) referred to three stages, which he saw as fundamental in the shaping of social
representations during the period. The first stage was that of the illness as a dawning

Downloaded from isw.sagepub.com at Universite Abittibi-Temiscamingue on October 16, 2014

International Social Work 0(0)

crisis (19811982) and it was at this early stage that perceived links with the 4Hs (heroin addicts,
homosexuals, Haitians and hemophiliacs) first took shape. During this period, mass media often
reported on the disease under such headlines as Mysterious new ill infects homosexual men and
drug addicts or The gay plague (Markova and Wilkie, 1987) and using such terms as GayRelated Immune Disease and its acronym GRID (Nengeh, 2003).
The second stage in the development of representations during the 1980s was that of moral
panic. The apparent marginality of those infected with AIDS and the diseases identification as a
gay plague were major influences in the period 19821985, which was especially characterized
by a rapid escalation of fear in media reports, as well as palpable public hysteria. In some sources,
HIV/AIDS was portrayed as a consequence of acts bringing about the judgment of God upon an
immoral world (Hussein and Miah, 1998; Silverman, 1989; Taylor-Brown and Garcia, 1995). In
many instances during this period, as noted by Joffe (1996a, 1996b), AIDS was seen as inextricably linked with death, stigma, immoral conduct and deserved punishment. Ultimately, however,
this context elicited strong reactions from the most affected groups, particularly the gay and lesbian
communities, and gave rise to widespread calls for the humanization of care.
The third stage identified by Weeks (1989) was that of crisis management (19851989). The
onset of this stage was, in part, the result of factors such as the widely publicized illness and death
of actor Rock Hudson, which added a new, dramatic dimension to representations of HIV/AIDS in
the mass media. This period saw a deepening of the health crisis, as HIV infection and the various
dimensions of AIDS, as well as its costs to society, became more widely understood.
Social representations of HIV/AIDS during the 1980s tended to portray the disease as being
endemic to the 4Hs and, according to Moatti etal. (1988), to construct heterosexual practices as
secure from risk by virtue of being the norm. This line of development of social representations
reflects a tendency reported by Echebarra and Pez (1989), whose study participants exhibited a
tendency to prefer information that was congruent with pre-existing representations and to distort
newly memorized information to conform with previously held representations. In the case of
HIV/AIDS, in the 1980s, moralizing representations associating the disease with the sinful world
of sexuality emerged early on and took root quickly (Velimirovic, 1987; Watney, 1989; Weeks,
1989). These moralizing representations, as Patton (1994) argued early on, understood the disease
within a queer paradigm in which HIV/AIDS became a mark of marginality and sexual perversion. In addition, in the United States and elsewhere, religious convictions played an important role
in driving the development of social representations of HIV/AIDS towards those of a disease
linked with sexual perversion.
Social representations observed in Europe sometimes attributed strong negative significance to
women, going so far as to identify them as responsible for the disease. Women were consequently
demonized through the negative significance attached to their sexuality (Gilman, 1987) and were
represented as diseased and contagious. In this respect, a parallel can be drawn with representations of HIV/AIDS on the African continent (Brijnath, 2007: 384), where, for many groups, representational dynamics hinge on elements such as contagion, weightloss, poisoning (slow poison,
nighttime poison), witchcraft (evil spells), the evil eye and death. These types of representations provide incitement to categorize the sick as different and separate, thereby at once facilitating
and justifying discriminatory behavior.
Representations similar to those popularized during the moral panic described by Weeks (1989)
were also present in Asia, particularly in Thailand, where three types of negative representation
were projected onto AIDS. The first described the disease as the result of moral laxity and was
propagated through representations filtering into public opinion that portrayed infected homosexual men as transmitting the virus to intravenous drug users and sex workers. The second, that of

Downloaded from isw.sagepub.com at Universite Abittibi-Temiscamingue on October 16, 2014

Labra

the HIV-positive as the dangerous other, implied that the pandemic was an infectious disease
transmitted through the blood of an infected person. The third was based on beliefs that the infection was the problem of individuals and risk groups that deviate from the social norm (UNESCO,
1999: 8).
In a study of reactions to AIDS in Europe, Pez etal. (1991) identified two distinct and largely
opposite belief structures, each based in different social and ideological convictions. One saw
AIDS both as a disease and as a moral and social crisis, reflecting the adherance of certain sectors
of society to a conservative and reproving ideology. By contrast, the second belief structure, which
may be identified with relatively liberal sectors of society, did not seek the origins of the disease
either in moral causes or among marginalized groups. The emerging representations, thus, were
strongly rooted in the pre-existing social contexts in which they took shape.

The 1990s
Social representations of HIV/AIDS that had emerged during the 1980s and the set of groups most
affected by the resulting stigma changed little over the course of the 1990s. But an increasing number of researchers began publishing studies examining the negative representations of people
infected by HIV as marginal and deviant (Mannetti and Pierro, 1994; Sacks, 1996). Within certain
affected groups (gay community, sex workers, intravenous drug users), negative representations of
HIV/AIDS were internalized and, subsequently, led to strained interactions with HIV-positive individuals within those groups.
In the middle years of the 1990s, three archetypal representations of people afflicted with HIV/
AIDS were predominant. The most common archetype in the Western world was that of guilty
homosexual men who were deserving of the condition, which represented punishment (be it even
unto death) for their deviant sexual practices. The antithesis of this archetype was the image, most
frequently attached to white, married, middle-class men, of innocent people who happened to
have contracted HIV/AIDS. Heterosexual women infected with the virus were, for their part, frequently described during this period as having been infected by male sexual partners who had not
disclosed their own infection (Lupton, 1994; Sacks, 1996). In this context of representation, those
seen as most innocent were children, who were considered exempt from reproach, shame, or guilt
for their serological status. This representation was prominent in the case of hemophiliac children
infected with HIV through blood products (Kitzinger, 1993; Lupton, 1994). The distinction between
those guilty and those innocent of being HIV-positive has been maintained, to some extent, by
public health discourse on AIDS in later years, some of which has placed heavy stress on lifestyle
choices. Mannetti and Pierro (1994) pointed to mass media as having precipitated the construction
of HIV/AIDS as a social problem by fueling hysterical reactions among the general public.
As stated earlier, the homosexual population became the first target to be saddled with responsibility for HIV/AIDS during the 1980s. Sacks (1996), however, also identified a persistent tendency in public health discourse in the United States to attribute a part of responsibility for
transmission to infected sex workers. This discourse reproduced and perpetuated representations of
deviance, which were closely linked to notions of women as a polluting force. Another theme,
that of self-control and physical self-discipline, was particularly potent in the American context
and emerged as an implicit component of representations of sex workers, and HIV-positive mothers in particular. According to this representation, HIV/AIDS could be avoided through discipline
and those who had become infected had only themselves to blame.
Analyses of the social representations disseminated by various media in Australia, on the other
hand, pointed to three major archetypes built around a dominance relationship between HIV/AIDS

Downloaded from isw.sagepub.com at Universite Abittibi-Temiscamingue on October 16, 2014

International Social Work 0(0)

and those infected: the AIDS victim, the AIDS survivor and the AIDS carrier (Lupton, 1999). The
victim archetype had negative significance for many people infected with the virus in the mid1990s. The predominating representations were of HIV/AIDS patients as ravaged, disfigured and
debilitated by the syndrome, as well as alone, desperate and condemned to inevitable death
(Crimp, 1992b: 118, in Lupton, 1999). The archetype of the AIDS survivor portrayed people fighting against despair and sickness, as epitomized by portrayals of Earvin Magic Johnson, the HIVpositive American basketball superstar (Lupton, 1999). A third, alternative archetype, discernible
in media portrayals during the 1990s, was that of the HIV/AIDS carrier. With the development of
antiretroviral drugs in early 1994, it became possible to live with HIV increasingly longer before
developing full-blown AIDS. People infected with HIV were encouraged to live by distancing
themselves from the virus, which now began to be portrayed as having been tamed by medicine.

The 2000s
Recent research shows that the first decade of the 21st century, in comparison with the two preceding decades, has been a time of evolution in social representations of HIV/AIDS. As discussed by
Joffe and Bettega (2003), HIV/AIDS was a focal point of social representation research during the
1980s and 1990s, when the virus and its effects were a new phenomenon (see Echebarra and Pez,
1989; Joffe, 1995, 1996a, 1996b; Markova and Wilkie, 1987; Pez etal., 1991; Sacks, 1996). The
development of knowledge during that period led to the identification of a range of social representations of HIV/AIDS, in particular those informed by the conservative and religious attitudes that
initially dominated reactions to the human immunodeficiency virus.
During the 2000s, a number of researchers further developed the study of representations of
HIV/AIDS and pinpointed some of their most salient elements. Before discussing these, however,
let us recall that during the two preceding decades information on the pandemic was generally
scarce, while its social representations were overwhelmingly negative and attached to marginalized groups. Moreover, the deadly consequences of HIV/AIDS for those infected gave rise to perceptions of the disease as a death sentence. In many cases, mass media portrayed the virus as a
plague, an impurity, a polluting element and a contaminant. The construction of HIV/AIDS as a
symbol of fear, in large part fueled by media representations, has had a direct impact on health care
practices (Labra, 2011; Labra and Bustinza, 2009). The rapid development of fear towards HIV/
AIDS drove caregivers to adopt extreme measures in efforts to avoid physical contact or even
proximity with infected individuals (Chapman, 2002).
In sub-Saharan Africa, mass media representations remain based on perpetuated colonialist
views, in which Africa is a sick and feminized dark continent (Brijnath, 2007; Watts and Boal,
1995, in Bleiker, 2007). Thus, social representations of HIV/AIDS in Africa correspond to a representational model that has its origins elsewhere. Research has shown that beliefs prevalent in
Africa about the causes of conventional diseases are also reflected in social representations of HIV/
AIDS. To cite just one example, traditional views of disease have led Zambias Tonga rural ethnic
group to ascribe the spread of the pandemic to imported Western sexual practices (Mogensen,
1995, in Joffe and Bettega, 2003). Tonga beliefs associate HIV/AIDS with kahungo, an illness
traditionally believed to spread through contact (not necessarily sexual) with women who have
miscarried. Thus, earlier mistaken beliefs about the spread of disease have been transposed onto
representations of HIV/AIDS, which then become an extension of pre-existing concepts of disease
as a punishment (Joffe and Bettega, 2003).
In the case of Asia, a study carried out by Ming (2007) shows that the discourse on HIV/AIDS
prevailing in Hong Kong is closely linked to the historical trajectory of other culturally grounded
discourses of danger, deviance, and desire. Perceptions of HIV/AIDS as being deadly constitute
Downloaded from isw.sagepub.com at Universite Abittibi-Temiscamingue on October 16, 2014

Labra

another salient element identified in studies of representations during the 2000s (Goodwin etal.,
2004; Schoeneman etal., 2010) and similar observations have been made in a study by Brasileiro
and Freitas (2006) as well as, more recently, by the present author (Labra, 2011). However, a study
by Da Silva and Takahashi (2008), carried out in Brazil, has shown that people infected with HIV/
AIDS assign meanings to the virus that do not evoke images of death. Their more positive relationship with the disease, according to the study, encourages sufferers to take better care of themselves
and allows them to maintain their anonymity as AIDS carriers.
In Eastern and Central Europe, social representations of groups at risk of infection exhibit both
remarkable similarities and intriguing differences throughout the region (Goodwin etal., 2003).
Studies have identified a number of negative associations related to the HIV/AIDS epidemic, echoing the findings of studies carried out elsewhere. One survey showed that media representations of
the disease varied widely across the region and that prevalent conservative religious opinion had
been a factor in the spread of prejudices about the disease and people living with HIV/AIDS.
However, a study by Campbell and Gibbs (2008) also showed that media representations in the
region reflect a narrow definition of HIV/AIDS as a primarily medical problem.
In Brazil, on the other hand, social representations have tended to establish links and draw comparisons between AIDS and other diseases, such as cancer. There is evidence to suggest that sufferers may use such comparisons to relativize HIV/AIDS in reaction to fears of being discovered and
ones sexual orientation being revealed (Brasileiro and Freitas, 2006). It appears that, although
previous portrayals of HIV/AIDS as a gay cancer are no longer current, sexual prejudice continues to play a role in the Brazilian context, as indeed it does elsewhere, too, as is evident from the
substantial literature on the subject (see for example, Andrinopoulos etal., 2011; Mizuno etal.,
2011). In a similar vein, a recent study by Riley and Baah-Odoom (2010) has identified social
representations that link HIV/AIDS to frequent sexual relations. One likely reaction to the moral
stigma associated with sexually transmitted diseases is to dissimulate the causes of disease and ill
health, and this is indeed a well-documented facet of the development of representations of incurable illnesses (Markova and Wilkie, 1987).

Discussion
A review of the history of social representations of HIV/AIDS shows that the pandemic became
associated with an already marginalized homosexual population in nearly all affected regions; a second pattern, common in places where large numbers of women had contracted the disease, associated
HIV/AIDS with female sex workers. Interpretations of the modes of infection framed in terms of
morality were assimilated and then disseminated by Western print media and became the prevalent
social representations of people infected by HIV/AIDS. Social representations were at first broadly
attached to marginalized populations in general and only later became more distinctly identified with
the 4Hs (heroin addicts, homosexuals, Haitians and hemophiliacs). In terms of research into social
representations of HIV/AIDS, studies following this period focused increasingly on populations that
had been neglected during the first decade of the diseases spread (Juhasz, 1995).
In tracing the development of social representations of HIV/AIDS since the 1980s in various
world regions, it becomes apparent that Africa represents a distinct context. There, representations
took on a specific form in which the disease was frequently not perceived as a syndrome acquired
through infection. Rather, among some African communities, the disease was given magical representations, such as poisoning (slow poison, nighttime poison), witchcraft (sorcery), kahungo
or evil eye. In fact, in stark contrast to the situation commonly found in Europe, North America,
Latin America and Asia, the present review did not identify any studies of African representations
linking the disease to marginalized groups.
Downloaded from isw.sagepub.com at Universite Abittibi-Temiscamingue on October 16, 2014

International Social Work 0(0)

Elsewhere, the 1990s marked a generalized change in representations of high-risk groups. When
HIV/AIDS was first identified, male homosexuals and intravenous drug users were seen as the
main targets of infection. But, during the 1990s, groups such as prostitutes, bisexuals and heterosexuals also became identified with high risk of infection (Kitzinger, 1993; Lupton, 1994). In the
case of the female population, despite the growing numbers of women infected with HIV/AIDS,
the majority of the literature on social representations tends to gloss over their condition. In general, however, research and public opinion have undergone considerable change: Western public
opinion no longer accepts the notion that HIV/AIDS is an infection limited to the deviant and
anonymous; it must now be approached as potentially affecting the whole population (Nengeh,
2003: 81). This view reflects a new element in the public understanding of the pandemic, since, as
we saw in the case of developments during the 1980s and 1990s, social representations mirror the
changes of their constituent peripheral elements.
During the 2000s, a new archetype of those infected with HIV/AIDS began to assert itself
throughout the literature: that of people living with HIV/AIDS, also known by the acronym PLHIV/
AIDS (Lance etal., 2007; Reynolds etal., 2009). This representation arguably reflects a more
humane vision of the life conditions of HIV-positive individuals and suggests an empathetic
approach towards the suffering of those whose infection carries the stigma of social exclusion
(Formozo and de Oliveira, 2010). The image is no longer one of carriers or victims or even survivors: the present archetype carries the public message that it is possible to live as a person with HIV.
This new outlook has come as a result of medical advances, already underway during the 1990s,
which have transformed the HIV/AIDS health care landscape. Previously, an HIV-positive diagnosis was considered by many to be effectively a death sentence. Now, however, HIV/AIDS is more
likely to be seen as a chronic disease (Roberts, 2002). This change in the representation of HIV/
AIDS from deadly to chronic has not been universal, however. For those infected, HIV/AIDS is
still frequently synonymous with deadly disease (see Brasileiro and Freitas, 2006; Labra, 2011).
Despite changes at the level of the peripheral elements of representation of HIV-infected populations, prejudices, stereotypes and stigma remain present. It is therefore essential to acknowledge
that the irruption of AIDS into individuals lives cannot be disconnected from local conceptions of
the individual, culture, strength and vulnerability. It is therefore important that the care delivered
to an infected population take into account the totality of that populations needs. In order to
accomplish this, it will be necessary to elaborate new conceptions and discover new methods of
responding to those needs. Since negative social representations of various populations still affect
the delivery of care, an essential element in the process will be to assist caregivers (including social
workers) in understanding both the social significance associated with the illness and the concept
of cultural competence.
Medical advances during the 1990s transformed the landscape of health care approaches to
HIV/AIDS. In the eye of the public, an HIV-positive diagnosis was once widely considered a death
sentence. And although today HIV/AIDS is increasingly seen as a chronic disease (Roberts, 2002),
current trends in the spread of the disease and its social representations highlight the need for better
preparation of health workers in terms of cultural knowledge, so that they are able to respond effectively to the needs of PLHIV/AIDS. Cultural competence must be developed within an approach
that takes into account the worldviews of both health professionals and sick individuals, in order to
produce intervention strategies that are better adapted and more responsive to the needs of the
infected individuals to whom care is addressed.
The analyzed studies show that discriminatory attitudes towards sexual activity, sexually transmitted diseases, homosexuality and hard drug use all affect access to care for PLHIV/AIDS.
Caregivers do not always demonstrate attentive or considerate attitudes towards the infected,
largely because of prejudices and plainly erroneous beliefs about the pandemic. Developing
Downloaded from isw.sagepub.com at Universite Abittibi-Temiscamingue on October 16, 2014

Labra

intercultural competence places many challenges before social workers, including those linked
with attitudes of openness, acknowledgement and understanding towards a clientele saddled with
negative representations built up over long periods of time.

Conclusion
The aim of this literature review was to provide an overview of social representations of HIV/
AIDS since its mass outbreak during the 1980s, through the decade of the 1990s, and to the present
day. The review shows that, within specific national contexts, changes have begun to take place in
the attitudes of HIV/AIDS care personnel towards infected individuals. The majority of studies
concerned with infected populations, across a range of cultures, demonstrate the presence of negative representations within the health field. Stigma and prejudice remain present in the lives of
people infected with HIV/AIDS and it is care personnel (including social workers) who must
counteract the deleterious consequences. In order to be able to improve the efficiency of their
work, we must continue to improve our understanding of social and cultural factors and, thus, more
accurately view the experience of infected individuals within specific contexts.
PLHIV/AIDS feel a deep need to be heard. The socio-epidemiological history of the disease
they carry is unique. It is therefore necessary to assist health care professionals and social workers
in understanding the social significance attached to the disease and to explore the concept of cultural competence within the scope of interventions addressed to PLHIV/AIDS a highly vulnerable population whose self-esteem has long suffered because of the representations projected onto
the disease. This review of the literature has provided an account of the historical development of
social representations of HIV/AIDS and their continuing influence on the care delivered to those
carrying the disease today.
Funding
This research received no specific grant from any funding agency in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit
sectors.

References
Albert, E. (1986) Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome: The Victim and the Press, Studies in Communication 3: 13558.
Andrinopoulos, K., P. Figueroa, D. Kerrigan and E. Ellen (2011) Homophobia, Stigma and HIV in Jamaican
Prisons, Culture, Health & Sexuality 13(2): 187200.
Bleiker, R. (2007) Representing HIV/AIDS in Africa: Pluralist Photography and Local Empowerment,
International Studies Quarterly 51: 13963.
Brasileiro, M. and M. Freitas (2006) Social Representations about Aids in People over 50, Infected by HIV,
Revista latino-americana de Enfermagem 14(5): 78995.
Brijnath, B. (2007) Its about TIME1: Engendering AIDS in Africa, Culture, Health & Sexuality 9(4):
37186.
Campbell, C. and A. Gibbs (2008) Representations of HIV/AIDS Management in South African Newspapers, African Journal of AIDS Research 7(2): 195208.
Chapman, E. (2002) Patient Impact of Negative Representations of HIV, AIDS Patient Care and STDs
16(4): 1737.
Da Silva, G. and R. Takahashi (2008) The Search for Health Care: Lowering the Vulnerability for Illness
among HIV Carriers, Revista de Ateno Primria Sade 11(1): 29.
Echebarra, A. and R. Pez (1989) Social Representations and Memory: The Case of AIDS, European Journal of Social Psychology 19: 54351.

Downloaded from isw.sagepub.com at Universite Abittibi-Temiscamingue on October 16, 2014

10

International Social Work 0(0)

Formozo, G. and D. de Oliveira (2010) Social Representations of the Care Provided to HIV Seropositive
Patients, Revista Brasileira de Enfermagem 63(2): 2307.
Giger, J., Davidhizar, R., Purnell, L., Harden, J., Phillips, J., & Strickland, O. (2007) American Academy
of Nursing Expert Panel Report: Developing cultural competence to eliminate health disparities in ethnic
minorities and other vulnerable populations. Journal of Transcultural Nursing, 18(2): 95102.
Gilman, S. (1987) Setting the AIDS Patient in Disease and Representation: Images of Illness from Madness
to AIDS. London: Cornell University Press.
Goodwin, R., A. Kwiatkowska, A. Kozlova, L. Nguen Luu, G. Nizharadze, A. Rarolf, A.K. Ulvetf and A.R.
Ammer (2003) Social Representations of HIV/AIDS in Central and Eastern Europe, Social Science &
Medicine 56(7): 137384.
Goodwin, R., A. Kwiatkowska, A. Realo, A. Kozlova, L. Nguyen Luu and G. Nizharadze (2004) Social
Representations of HIV/AIDS in Five Central European and Eastern European Countries: A Multidimensional Analysis, AIDE Care 16(6): 66980.
Gratton, D. (2009) Linterculturel pour tous. Qubec: ditions Saint-Martin.
Herek, G-M. and Glunt, E. K. (1988) An epidemic of stigma. Public reactions to AIDS, The American
Psychologist 43, 886891.
Herzlich, C. (1972) La reprsentation sociale, in S. Moscovici (ed.) Introduction la psychologie sociale.
Paris: Larousse.
Hussein, H.S. and M.R. Miah (1998) A Cross-cultural Study of Social Work Students Attitudes toward
AIDS Policy: Implications for Social Work Education, International Social Work 41: 3952.
Jodelet, D. (1989) Folies et reprsentations sociales. Paris: Presses universitaires de France.
Joffe, H. (1994) Not Me, Not My Group: Cross-cultural Social Representations of AIDS, in P. Guareschi and S. Jovchelovitch (eds) Textos em Representaes Socias, pp. 297322. Petropolis-RJ: Vozes.
Joffe, H. (1995) Social Representations of AIDS: Towards Encompassing Issues of Power, Papers on Social
Representations 4(1): 2940.
Joffe, H. (1996a) Social Representation and the AIDS Field, Psychology in Society 24: 2139.
Joffe, H. (1996b) AIDS Research and Prevention: A Social Representational Approach, British Journal of
Medical Psychology 69(3): 16990.
Joffe, H. and N. Bettega (2003) Social Representation of AIDS among Zambian Adolescents, Journal of
Health Psychology 8(5): 61631.
Juhasz, A. (1990) The Contained Threat: Women in Mainstream AIDS Documentary, Journal of Sex
Research 27(1): 2546.
Juhasz, A. (1995) AIDS TV: indentity, community, and alternative video. Videographye by Catherine Saalfield. London: Duke University Press.
Kitzinger, J. (1993) Understanding AIDS: Researching Audience Perceptions of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome, in J. Eldridge (ed.) Getting the Message: News, Truth and Power. London: Routledge.
Labra, O. (2010) Travail social et VIH/sida. Une analyse des pratiques dintervention. Revue de Travail
social, Un espace critique pour la rflexion en travail social, Universit Centrale, Santiago, Chili, septembre, Chili.
Labra, O. (2011) Reprsentations sociales du VIH-sida dans lenvironnement des services sociaux et de sant
de la rgion du Maule au Chili, Thse de doctorat. Universit Laval, Canada.
Labra, O. and R. Bustinza (2009) Aspects socioculturels de la sant au Chili, Facult des sciences de
ladministration, Universit de Talca, Centre de gestion des institutions de sant, an 5, N 10, septembre,
pp. 321. Available online at: http://www.cegisutalca.cl/publicaciones.html.
Lance, S., A. Scott, K. Kosneko and R. Vjensen (2007) Male Patient Perceptions of HIV Stigma in Health
Care Contexts, AIDS Patient Care and STDs 21(12): 95669.
Lupton, D. (1994) Moral Threats and Dangerous Desires: AIDS in the News Media. London: Taylor and
Francis.
Lupton, D. (1999) Archetypes of Infection: People with HIV/AIDS in the Australian Press in the Mid 1990s,
Sociology of Health & Illness 21(1): 3753.
Mannetti, L. and A. Pierro (1994) Social Representations of AIDS among Italian Health Care Workers
[Representaciones sociales del SIDA entre trabajadores de la salud en Italia], Revista de Psicologa Social
9(1): 3142.
Downloaded from isw.sagepub.com at Universite Abittibi-Temiscamingue on October 16, 2014

11

Labra

Markova, I. and P. Wilkie (1987) Representations, Concepts and Social Change: The Phenomenon of AIDS,
Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour 17(4): 389409.
Ming, K. (2007) Cross-border Traffic: Stories of Dangerous Victims, Pure Whores and HIV/AIDS in the
Experiences of Mainland Female Sex Workers in Hong Kong, Asia Pacific Viewpoint 46(1): 3548.
Mizuno, Y., C. Borkowf, G. Millett, T. Bingham, G. Ayala and A. Stueve (2011) Homophobia and Racism
Experienced by Latino Men Who Have Sex with Men in the United States: Correlates of Exposure and
Associations with HIV Risk Behaviors, AIDS and Behavior, pp. 112.
Moatti, J.P., L. Manesse, C. Le Gals, J.P. Pages and F. Fagnanil (1988) Social Perception of AIDS in the
General Public: A French Study, Health Policy 9(1): 18.
Moscovici, S. (1961) La Psychanalyse, son image et son public: tude sur la reprsentation sociale de la
psychanalyse. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France.
National Association of Social Workers. (2000b) Cultural competence in the social work profession. In:
Social work speaks: NASW policy statements. Washington, DC: NASW Press, pp. 5962.
Nengeh, M. (2003) Ni vues ni connues? Femmes, VIH, Mdias. Montral: Les ditions du remue-mnage.
Pez, D., A. Echebarra, J. Valencia, I. Romo, C. San Juan and A. Vergara (1991) AIDS Social Representations: Contents and Processes, Journal of Community and Applied Social Psychology 1: 89104.
Patton, C. (1994) Heterosexual AIDS, A Panic: A Queer Paradigm, Gay Community News.
Reynolds, L., E. Sanzero, P.K. Nichiolas, I.B. Corless, K. Kirkser, M.J. Hamilton, J.K. Kempppainen, E.
Bunch, P. Dole, D. Wantand, E. Sefcik, K.M. Nokes, C.L. Colemen, M. Rivero, G.E. Canval, Y.F. Tsai
and W.L. Holzemer (2009) HIV Illness Representation as a Predictor of Self-care Management and
Health Outcomes: A Multi-site, Cross-cultural Study, AIDS Behaviors 13(2): 25867.
Riley, G. and D. Baah-Odoom (2010) Do Stigma, Blame and Stereotyping Contribute to Unsafe Sexual
Behaviour? A Test of Claims about the Spread of HIV/AIDS Arising from Social Representation Theory
and the AIDS Risk Reduction Model, Social Science & Medicine 71(3): 6007.
Roberts, K. (2002) Physician-Patient Relationships, Patient Satisfaction, and Antiretroviral Medication
Adherence among HIV-infected Adults Attending a Public Health Clinic, AIDS Patient Care and STDs
16(1): 4350.
Sacks, V. (1996) Women and AIDS: An Analysis of Media Misrepresentations, Social Science & Medicine
42(1): 5973.
Scalvini, M. (2010) Glamorizing Sick Bodies: How Commercial Advertising Has Changed the Representations of HIV/AIDS, Social Semiotics 20(3): 21931.
Schoeneman, T., K. Schoeneman-Morris, J. Obradovic and L. Beecher-Flad (2010) Social Representations
of AIDS: Pictures in Abnormal Psychology Textbooks, 19842005, Journal of Applied Social Psychology 40(1): 1335.
Silverman, D. (1989) Making Sense of a Precipice: Constituting Identity in an HIV Clinic, in AIDS: Social
Representation, Social Practices. New York: Falmer Press.
Taylor-Brown, S. and A. Garcia (1995) Social Workers and HIV Affected Families: Is the Profession Prepared?, Social Work 40(1): 1415.
UNESCO (1999) A Cultural Approach to HIV/AIDS Prevention and Care: Thailands Experience. Paris:
UNESCO.
Velimirovic, B. (1987) AIDS as a Social Phenomenon, Social Science & Medicine 25(6): 54152.
Watney, S. (1989) Policing Desire: AIDS, Pornography, and the Media. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Weeks, J. (1989) AIDS: The Intellectual Agenda, in AIDS: Social Representation, Social Practices. Lewes,
England: Falmer Press.

Author biography
Oscar Labra, Ph.D., Professor in social work, Department of Human Development and Social, Universit
du Qubec en Abitibi-Tmiscamingue, QC, Canada.

Downloaded from isw.sagepub.com at Universite Abittibi-Temiscamingue on October 16, 2014