Professional Documents
Culture Documents
COMELEC
G.R. No. 179271
April 21, 2009
Carpio:
Facts:
June 27, 2007- BANAT files before the COMELEC acting as the National Board of
Canvassers (NBC) a Petition to Proclaim the Full Number of Party-List Representatives
Provided by the Constitution.
July 9, 2007- NBC promulgated Resolution No. 07-60 (Resolution 1) partially proclaiming 13
political parties as winners in the 2007 elections since they already reached the 2%
qualifying threshold under the Panganiban formula. Subsequently, NBC Resolution No. 0772 (Resolution 2) was promulgated, allocating additional seats for the appropriate parties.
July 9, 2007- Bayan Muna, Abono, and A Teacher asked the NBC to reconsider Resolution 1
because the Panganiban/ Veterans formula is violative of the Constitution and of RA 7941
(Party-List System Act). NBC denied reconsideration.
August 3, 2007- NBC promulgated Resolution No. 07-88 denying the BANAT petition as this
was rendered moot and academic by Resolution 1. BANAT did not file motion for
reconsideration.
BANAT and Bayan Muna, et al. raised their issues before the Court.
Issue
Ruling
Ratio
It is mere
ceiling.
Yes.
No (as far
as
the
computatio
n
of
additional
seats
is
concerned).
Section 11(b)
First clause: Guarantees a seat to parties which
garnered at least 2% of the total votes cast for
the party-list system.
Total votes garnered by
party
--------------------------------------This is constitutional as stated in the provisions
of RA 7941.
Second clause: prescribes the way in allotting
the additional seats after the guaranteed seats
(as discussed in the 1st clause) are allotted. In
5. Does
the
Constitution
prohibit the major political
parties from participating
in the party-list elections?
If not, can the major political
parties
be
barred
from
Yes.
participating
elections?
in
the
party-list
vehicle:
While any duly authorized party or org
may engage, the role of the Comelec is
to ensure that only those marginalized
and underrepresented become members
of Congress through the party-list
system.
2. Limiting the party-list system to the
marginalized is aligned with the
constitutional
mandate
to
reduce
inequalities by diffusing wealth and
political power.
Note: The ponencia discussed in the majority
opinion that neither the Constitution (based on
the records of the Constitutional Commission)
nor RA 7941 prohibits major political parties
from participating in the party-list elections.
The definition of party under RA 7941 includes
not just sectoral parties but also political
parties.