Professional Documents
Culture Documents
I-2
I-3
I-5
I-7
I-9
I-10
I-17
I-21
2.5
2.6
2.7
Introduction
Observations at Site
Sea and Seabed conditions
Master Plan in Phases
2.4.1. Design Principles
2.4.2. Supply Base Layout
2.4.3 EPC Phase 1 Schedule (Summary)
List of Facilities
2.5.1 Phase 1 Suai Supply Base for Oil and Gas Industry
2.5.1.1 Land Facilities
2.5.1.2 Marine Facilities
2.5.2 Phase 2 Suai Supply Base for Energy and
Resources Industry
2.5.3 Phase 3 Suai Supply Base for Energy, Resources
and General Cargo
EPC Capex Cost
Maintenance Cost Estimate
2.7.1 Maintenance of Infrastructure
2.7.2 Maintenance of Operating Assets
II-2
II-4
II-6
II-7
II-7
II-8
II-13
II-14
II-14
II-14
II-21
II-23
II-25
II-26
II-29
II-29
II-32
TOC - 1
2.8
II-33
II-33
II-34
II-34
Introduction
User Survey and Infrastructure Review
3.2.1 User Survey (Oil and Gas)
3.2.1.1 Approach to Interview Sessions
3.2.1.2 Current Activity (from user surveys)
3.2.1.3 Forecast of O&G Programs from User Survey
3.2.1.4 Feedback from PSCs
3.2.1.5 Service Companies
3.2.2 Survey for Potential Non Oil and Gas Cargo
3.2.2.1 Movement of goods and supplies
3.2.2.2 Liquid Cargo
3.2.2.3 Local Industries
3.2.2.4 Southern Petrochemical Corridor
(Suai-Betano-Beaco)
3.2.2.5 Increased Industrial Activity and
Manufacturing
3.2.3 Facilities / Services required
3.2.3.1 Role of Supply Base
3.2.3.2 Facilities and Services
3.2.3.3 Port Configuration and Capacity
3.2.4 Recommendation of Infrastructure Improvements
3.2.4.1 Observations
3.2.4.1.1 Road Network
3.2.4.1.2 Airfield
3.2.4.1.3 General Commercial Port
3.2.4.1.4 Industrial Estate
3.2.4.1.5 Medical Facilities
3.2.4.1.6 Electricity / Power and Utilities
3.2.4.1.7 Telecommunications Voice / Date
3.2.4.1.8 Bulk Fuel Storage
III-2
III-3
III-4
III-4
III-5
III-6
III-7
III-9
III-10
III-11
III-11
III-11
III-12
III-12
III-13
III-13
III-14
III-18
III-19
III-20
III-20
III-21
III-23
III-23
III-23
III-26
III-26
III-26
TOC - 2
3.3.
3.4
3.5
III-27
III-27
III-28
III-29
III-30
III-30
III-31
III-31
III-32
III-33
III-33
III-33
III-36
III-37
III-38
III-38
III-39
III-39
III-39
III-45
III-54
III-54
III-55
III-55
III-56
III-58
III-58
III-58
III-60
III-61
III-62
III-63
III-65
TOC - 3
3.5.8
3.5.9
3.5.10
3.5.11
3.5.12
3.5.13
III-68
III-69
III-75
III-83
III-84
III-85
4.4
4.5
Background
Main Activities
Social Programs
4.3.1 Create a Community Office (in Suai)
4.3.2 Establish a regular Liner Service
4.3.3 Fuel Supply
4.3.4 Create a Timor-Leste East Java Business Forum
4.3.5 Encourage a Suai Darwin Line
Socioeconomic Impact
4.4.1 Population, Skills Development and Employment
4.4.1.1 Employment Summary
4.4.1.2 Human Capital Development
4.4.2 Economic Contribution
4.4.2.1 Direct Expenditure
4.4.2.2 Value Creation
4.4.3 Business Opportunities
4.4.3.1 Construction Industry
4.4.3.2 Hospitality and Food & Beverage,
General Trading and Supplies
4.4.3.3 Foreign Investment
4.4.4 Social Conditions
4.4.4.1 During Construction
4.4.4.2 During Operations
4.4.4.3 Transmigration of workers
4.4.5 Environment
Recommendations
IV-2
IV-3
IV-5
IV-5
IV-6
IV-8
IV-8
IV-9
IV-9
IV-9
IV-9
IV-12
IV-13
IV-13
IV-14
IV-15
IV-15
IV-15
IV-16
IV-17
IV-17
IV-18
IV-19
IV-19
IV-20
TOC - 4
Part V : Appendices
A.
B.
C.
General
1)
Study Team Organisation Chart
2)
Interim Reports and Memos
a.
Timor-Leste Kickoff Presentation (15 September 2010)
b.
Memo 1 Recommendation to include alternative site
into study
c.
Memo 2 Role of Service Companies (21 October 2010)
d.
Memo 3 Recommend postponement of introduction
event
e.
Interim Report Presentation to SERN 9 February 2011
3)
List of Source Documents from SERN
Technical
1)
Technical Site Survey Report
2)
Breakwater Design Study (ITS)
3)
FEED Drawings (In Separate Book)
4)
EPC Schedule Phase 1
Commercial
1)
Report on Shorebase Orientation Course
2)
List of Typical Facilities and Services (Powerpoint Slides)
3)
From Seismic to Well Shutdown (Powerpoint Slides)
4)
Report on Darwin Marine Supply Base
TOC - 5
List of Figures
Figure I 1 : Study Methodology
I-6
Figure I 2 : Photos at Lamongan Shorebase orientation and training program I-10
Figure I 3 : Photos during the Shore Base Orientation Course at Lamongan
Shorebase
I-22
Figure II 1 : Suai Supply Base Site
II-3
Figure II 2 : Photos of Suai Supply Base Site Vegetation and Site Condition II-4
Figure II 3 : Riverbed at river Karau-ulun
II-5
Figure II 4 : Chart of historical cyclone tracks
II-6
Figure II 5 : Suai Supply Base Land Allocation
II-8
Figure II 6 : Layout for Main Office block and Main Post Block
II-9
Figure II 7 : Suai Supply Base Master Plan Layout Phase 1
II-10
Figure II 8 : Suai Supply Base Master Plan Layout Phase 1 and Phase 2
II-11
Figure II 9 : Suai Supply Base Master Plan Layout Phase 1, Phase 2 and
Phase 3
II-12
Figure III - 1 : TLEA and JPDA Acreage
III-5
Figure III - 2 : Suai Supply Base Site Allocation
III-12
Figure III - 3 : Multipurpose Jetty Configuration
III-18
Figure III - 4 : Photos of Road Condition with potholes (Dili to Suai)
III-20
Figure III - 5 : Photos of road water damage(Dili to Suai)
III-21
Figure III - 6 : Photos of abandoned Suai Airport (cattle and children in
background)
III-22
Figure III - 7 : Photos of abandoned Suai Airport (nearby buildings) and
Helipad
III-23
Figure III - 8 : Clinics in Suai area
III-24
Figure III - 9 : Suai Hospital and facilities
III-25
Figure III - 10 : Fuel Tanker and fuel stop enroute to Suai
III-27
Figure III - 11 : Suai Supply Base Organisation Structure
III-40
Figure III 12 : Suai Supply Base Operations Team
III-41
Figure III 13 : Suai Supply Base Support Teams
III-41
Figure III 14 : Suai Supply Base Business Support Services Team
III-42
Figure III 15 : Suai Supply Base Sales, Finance and Admin teams
III-43
Figure III - 16 : Photos of Vocational Training Institute
III-54
Figure III 17 : Suai Supply Base Land Allocation
III-83
Figure IV 1 : Suai Supply Base Site Allocation
IV-14
TOC - 6
TOC - 7
Part I
Executive Summary
I-1
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This report has been prepared pursuant to a Memorandum of Understanding dated
12 August 2010 between the Government of the Democratic Republic of Timor-Leste
and Eastlog Holding Pte Ltd, and a subsequent Agreement between the same parties
dated the 17 December 2010. Pursuant to these documents a joint study team
consisting of representatives of Eastlog and SERN was constituted.
1.1.
Background
The Government of Timor-Leste intends to build and operate a logistics supply base
to support all offshore oil and gas activities in the Timor-Leste Exclusive Area (TLEA)
and Joint Petroleum Development Area (JPDA). To this end, they have designated an
area south of Suai city for this purpose (919'S, 12515'E).
The Northern Territories Government in Australia has similarly initiated the process
to build and operate a new Marine Supply Base to supplement their general
commercial port which currently substantially supports all offshore oil and gas
activity in Australian Sovereign waters, the JPDA and TLEA. The new Darwin MSB is
scheduled to come online in mid 2014. There is therefore a high level of urgency
required in this Suai Supply Base in order to be operational before the Darwin MSB
as it would be difficult if not impossible to move PSCs if they have already setup their
operations at the new Darwin MSB.
A supply base built on Timor-Leste shores to support the oil and gas industry will
generate much value both to the oil and gas activities in Timor-Leste as well as its
supporting industries. This can be seen in the following areas:
- Establish an oil and gas industry in Timor-Leste itself and build the
necessary skillsets to sustain these activities in the long term. This will
allow the PSCs to use Timor-Leste as a base for all future oil and gas
activities in the TLEA and JPDA.
- Stimulate the use of Timor-Leste as a base for pipeline operations for
projects such as Greater Sunrise (in the future) and Kitan (scheduled
production in 2011)
I-2
1.2.
At the onset of the project, the joint study team agreed on the following objectives
during the kick-off meeting:
- Determine the scope of facilities and services to be developed
- Recommend a masterplan layout
- Provide a framework for EPC award, including estimate construction
schedule
- Determine Commercial Feasibility
I-3
I-4
1.3.
The Team was given a period of six months to conduct the study and to report its
findings. Material used to guide the team include technical material in the
possession of Secreataria de Estado dos Recursos Naturais (SERN), survey data
gathered over a 3 week site visit, interviews with Autoridade Nacional do Petroleo
(ANP), oil companies and service companies, as well as with local vendors and
contractors. Various consultants were appointed by Eastlog, including PMC Oilfield
Services Pte Ltd, Cybermax Pte Ltd and Institut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember,
Indonesia (ITS).
I-5
Throughout the duration of the study, the State Secretary of Natural Resources, His
Excellency Alfredo Pires, provided guidance to the team and we gratefully
acknowledge this guidance.
The team utilised a systematic information tracking system to give accountability to
source of information developed, and created a web based project management tool
to guide the team. (http://www.suaisupplybase.com/)
The following methodology was used to ensure the team stayed on track with
proper management guidance.
I-6
1.4.
I-7
2.
In light of these factors, Eastlog CEO then directed the team to carry out the
following:
1. Technical Team
a. Develop a masterplan within the breakwater basin to encompass all possible
port activities for the next 50 years.
b. Propose a multi purpose jetty for the first phase, able to accommodate the
oil and gas industry and be used for other general port activities.
c. Notwithstanding the lack of local large scale contractors, to develop two EPC
costs and time estimates, namely:i.
ii.
I-8
1.5.
The technical team conducted 2 site visits and technical site surveys during the
course of the project. A full report can be found in the appendix B1.
From the Eastlog CEO directions, the technical team reported as follows:
1.
2.
3.
I-9
Domestic
Price
International
Domestic Price
International
Domestic Price
Note:
Commencement Completion
June 2011
June 2014
EPC
US$346,962,500
June 2011
US$273,162,500
December
2012
September 2011 December
2013
US$318,000,000
1.6.
I - 10
The commercial team made 3 visits to Dili and Suai. During the course of these visit,
they conducted surveys with ANP, the PSC holders, service companies and other
vendors. They also did a survey of infrastructure conditions and economic activity in
and around the Suai area.
The commercial team also did a social impact study, to have a better understanding
of the socioeconomic consequences of building the Suai Supply Base. This study
should form one of the key components to planning and decision making for policy
makers and agency planners in the Government of Timor-Leste with respect to the
Suai Supply Base project. A full report can be found in the Part IV of this report.
From Eastlog CEO directions, the commercial team reported as follows:
1.
Considered the following potential additional activities:a. onshore oil and gas development;
b. import of clean petroleum products ( diesel, gasolene, and aviation
gas);
c. dry bulk cargo-both import and export ( eg import of cement, export
of mineral ore);
d. general palletised or break bulk cargo;
e. container cargo;
f. heavy lifts, and tracked vehicles;
g. lifestock;
h. fishery activities.
Inpex Masela in Indonesian waters requires a supply base to support the
proposed floating LNG development. At the present time, ENI (the operator
of Kitan field) is conducting seismic activities in West Timor, and has a
commitment to the Government of Indonesia to drill 1 exploration well. The
executive agency in Indonesia to manage and control the Production Sharing
Contracts for upstream oil and gas industry is BPMIGAS. The Eastlog CEO
approached BPMIGAS in an effort to explore the possibility of these 2
activities using Suai as its supply base. The response from BPMIGAS was that
this was against the Government of Indonesias policy.
I - 11
In developing these potential additional activities, the team did survey visits
in the Suai district and found that there was potential demand for trade and
direct importation of goods between Surabaya and the Suai / southern region
provided there is a regular liner service vessel sailing between these two
districts to facilitate trade
As a result, the commercial team recommended:
i.
ii. During operation, continue to run a liner service LCT from Lamongan
to Suai to facilitate what the team anticipates to be growing trade.
The Commercial team highlighted that anticipated cargo will be initially one
way, that is, the importation of goods into the Suai area. It will take some
time to develop export cargo from the Southern region. It is important to
commence development of an industrial estate adjacent to the Suai Supply
Base early to stimulate economic growth and two way commercial cargo and
take advantage of the benefits of the port facilities.
2.
b.
Offshore oil and gas and onshore oil and gas activities;
c.
Offshore oil and gas, onshore oil and gas, and liquid storage terminal;
d.
Offshore oil and gas, onshore oil and gas, liquid storage terminal and
general port cargo.
I - 12
3.
4.
The Commercial team highlighted that it is very much within the ability of the
Government of Timor-Leste to generate port activities for the Project by
carrying out the following:a.
b.
c.
d.
e.
f.
g.
b.
c.
The first scenario is provided to demonstrate the negative effect of the cost
of the breakwater and land improvements on the project viability. It is not
common for commercial projects to bear the cost of breakwaters.
I - 13
The second and third scenarios would be more commonly used in a publicsector / private sector partnership.
The second scenario is envisaged because this location requires the
construction of a breakwater to make the site a viable site. Under such cases,
it is normal for the Government in question to undertake the necessary
works to make the location viable. An example of this can be seen in the
12.9Ha dredging to provide access to the channel that will be undertaken by
the Australian government in the Darwin Marine Supply Base project.
The last scenario is called terminal operatorship. One example of this is
Tanjong Priok in Indonesia. The Government builds the terminal and retains
ownership and control of the facilities as a strategic national asset. The
operator brings the operating capital assets and manages the facilities, with a
revenue sharing model.
5.
NPV
(US$)
IRR
Remarks
NA
-4.1%
NA
-7.4%
7.8%
28.1%
Table I 2 : Summary of NPV and IRR results for the different scenarios
I - 14
6.
I - 15
O&G (Offshore)
O&G (Total)
O&G (Total) + Liquid Storage
Supply Base Plus - All Available Cargo
2013
(1,795,634)
(1,795,634)
(1,306,754)
(1,306,754)
2014
1,475,206
1,475,206
2,290,006
6,014,806
2015
2,484,394
2,484,394
3,543,634
7,501,234
2016
4,604,814
5,906,166
6,965,406
11,039,406
2017
3,282,510
4,583,862
5,643,102
10,337,902
2018
841,602
1,743,120
2,802,360
9,359,560
2019
841,602
1,743,120
2,802,360
9,359,560
2020
462,914
1,364,432
2,423,672
8,980,872
2021
462,914
1,364,432
2,423,672
8,980,872
I - 16
2022
1,432,914
2,334,432
3,393,672
9,950,872
1.7.
Conclusions
The key findings and recommendations of the team are set out in summary herein :
Findings
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Phase 1, which is essentially oil and gas supply base with multi
purpose berths will require at least 18-24 months, provided the
Project starts breakwater construction by June 2011. We will be able
to have limited berth operations by December 2012 if we start in June
2011.
6.
7.
8.
All port requirements for the Southern regions of Timor-Leste over the
next 50 years of sustained development can be accommodated within
the extended breakwater basin. This can be developed in 3 or more
phases as demand justifies.
I - 17
9.
10.
11.
12.
The oil and gas companies operate to high international standards and
hold their contractors to the same standards. They have stringent
requirements in the areas of HSE and require high track records of
safety. They require that management has at least 5 to 10 years
experience in the oil and gas industry. In contrast, the available
skillsets in Timor-Leste for the management and vocational positions
is not currently available.
Recommendations:
1. Due to the high cost of breakwater construction, we recommend that all
future port activities be developed within the breakwater basin.
2. Develop the Suai Supply Base and leverage the port facilities as the de facto
port in the south. This will allow the Suai Supply Base to generate revenue
that is stable. Moreover, this will cater for the port needs of the southern
region for at least 50 years.
I - 18
3. Acquire the land required (all phases including future expansion) up front and
before any construction commences. The land value will appreciate
significantly with the presence of the port facilities. The subsequent industrial
development and real estate sales will finance the cost of building the port
infrastructure.
4. To promote intermodal connectivity and to encourage development of
economic activity in the Southern Region, authorize the operation of a
monthly liner service LCT between Lamongan Shorebase and Suai Supply
Base commencing during construction. This will continue after
commencement of operations.
5. Plan and build offices in and around the Suai City. Build an industrial estate
adjacent to the Suai Supply Base to benefit from port access and
infrastructure upgrades. This industrial estate will then provide two way
commercial cargo. Promote industrial activity in the zone to build the future
SMEs that will eventually be the pillars of economic growth as the
infrastructure projects and petrochemical development move ahead over the
next 10 to 15 years.
6. Allow the Suai Supply Base operator to establish bonded zones within the
supply base as the need arises to facilitate construction and subsequently
operations with the oil and gas activities. Setup a Customs, Immigrations and
Quarantine office at the Suai Supply Base.
7. Provide tax incentives and duty exemptions for the Project as well as for
external contractors who setup at the Suai Supply Base and the adjacent
industrial complex.
8. Mandate the use of the Suai Supply Base for all oil and gas activities in the
JPDA and TLEA.
9. Consider whether it is in the interest of the Republic of Timor-Leste to initiate
discussions on a Government to Government basis to request that the
Republic of Indonesia authorizes the use of Suai Supply Base for oil and gas
activities so that Inpex Masela and ENI West Timor will contribute
significantly to the revenue of the Suai Supply Base.
I - 19
10. Appoint a suitable Company with experience running a multi user integrated
supply base and an operating template that is similar to the intended Suai
Supply Base to develop and deliver a complete skills development program so
as to meet international certifications and operating standards from day one.
11. Appoint a suitable Company with experience running a multi user integrated
supply base and established in the oil and gas industry to provide ongoing
management guidance, audits, reviews and consulting support to the Suai
Supply Base. The presence of this management support would allow the oil
and gas industry players to accept the Suai Supply Base from the onset of
operations.
12. Award the EPC contract to an international EPC contractor with experience in
the oil and gas industry.
13. If the Government of Timor-Leste wishes to have a Public-sector / Privatesector partnership, it should be based on the terminal operatorship model.
The Government will retain ownership and control of this strategic asset and
all its future expansion whilst still having the full benefit of a professional port
operator.
14. It is very important for projects of this nature to have demonstrable strong
Government support. Both for the success of the project itself and to be able
to attract other foreign investment and business.
o In Government communications
o Committed skills development program
o Infrastructure support (power, roads, etc)
o Policies and laws to facilitate and attract foreign investment
o Tax and duty incentives
I - 20
Acknowledgements:
We gratefully acknowledge the presence and inspiration of his Excellency Kay Rala Xanana
Gusmao at Lamongan Shorebase during the Shorebase Orientation Course.
We gratefully acknowledge the guidance provided by His Excellency Alfredo Pires, State
Secretary for Natural Resources.
We like to also acknowledge the following persons for their assistance and time during the
period of this study:
I - 21
We would like to congratulate the following for having completed the Shorebase Orientation
course and obtaining international certification for Oilfield Sea Survival.
Vicente Lacerda
Joao Camara
Francisco Ferreira
Josefa Nuning da Silva
Joaquim Amaral
Johny Leite
Helder Freitas
Bambang Gunawan
Figure I 3 : Photos during the Shore Base Orientation Course at Lamongan Shorebase
I - 22
Part II
Technical Study
II - 1
2.1.
Introduction
The Government of Timor-Leste has the intention to build a world class Logistics
Supply Base for offshore Oil and Gas activities on the southern coast of Timor-Leste
around the Suai area. When the Project team first studied the southern coast around
Suai, a site at Suai Loro with a preliminary natural breakwater was identified and
recommended to the Government of Timor-Leste for the construction of the Suai
Supply Base. However, we were given the direction to continue the study at the
allocated site as the Suai Loro location has been reserved for a commercial port
project.
At the start of the study, we were allocated a primary site of 395 Ha for the Suai
Supply Base, with a secondary site of 250 Ha that can be secured for future
expansion.
Primary Site: (Perimeter 8.24km, 395.4 Ha)
C1 (91915.5689 S, 1251809.5170 E)
C2 (91823.6756 S, 1251747.3084 E)
C3 (91741.4466 S, 1251848.6465 E)
C4 (91832.6071 S, 1251916.6662 E)
Additional Land to be secured for Future Expansion [if necessary]
(Perimeter 7.76km, 250.6 Ha)
D1 (91741.4026 S, 1251927.2402 E)
D2 (91743.8446 S, 1252028.6256 E)
D3 (91745.7733 S, 1252034.6811 E)
D4 (91752.4747 S, 1252022.6516 E)
D5 (91801.5272 S, 1252014.4735 E)
D6 (91803.5107 S, 1252001.7970 E)
D7 (91813.4372 S, 1251943.6232 E)
C4 (91832.6071 S, 1251916.6662 E)
C3 (91741.4466 S, 1251848.6465 E)
II - 2
II - 3
2.2.
The primary site is level, with a gentle slope towards the sea. Vegetation is thick and
forested. Drainage is good and there is no ponding of water. The current usage
appears to be cattle pasture and small agricultural plots of cornfield. There are
clusters of housing just outside the north boundary, along both sides of the road.
Figure II 2 : Photos of Suai Supply Base Site Vegetation and Site Condition
II - 4
The river Karau Ulun runs along the western boundary of proposed site. This river is
shallow and wide, and will require flood control improvement before we can use the
Site. We have identified this river as source of breakwater material. At the same
time, this will also have the purpose of flood control improvement by deepening the
river bed.
II - 5
2.3.
The site consists of gradual sloping land towards a sandy beach. The seabed consists
of fine sand, with gradual sloping of 500m to achieve -5 LAT. (borelog sample data).
Based on three borelog samples provided to us by SERN, we can conclude that the
seabed consists of a mixture of fine sand, silt, sandy gravel, clay and shell sediment.
The deepest borelog reaching to 60m from the seabed disclosed no hard bedrock.
Most persistent sea swells at the site will arrive from the southwest with typical
heights of between 1m and 2m.
Tropical cyclones in the Timor Sea can developed between November and April
resulting in short lived, sever storm events often with strong but variable winds. The
figure below shows the tropical cyclone tracks logged over a 36 year period off the
southern coast of Timor-Leste.
II - 6
Eastlog retained the services of Institut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember, Indonesia (ITS)
to conduct a study on the sea and sea swell at the proposed Suai Supply Base
location and recommend an orientation for the breakwater. A copy of the report can
be found in Appendix B2.
2.4.
II - 7
Zone C
Zone B
Zone A
II - 8
Figure II 6 : Layout for Main Office block and Main Post Block
II - 9
II - 10
Phase 2:
-
Figure II 8 : Suai Supply Base Master Plan Layout Phase 1 and Phase 2
II - 11
Phase 3:
-
Figure II 9 : Suai Supply Base Master Plan Layout Phase 1, Phase 2 and Phase 3
II - 12
Start of Preparatories
Engineering
Start of Construction
REV.1-20 MAR. 2011
No.
Description
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
Apr-11
May-11
Jun-11
Jul-11
Aug-11
Sep-11
Oct-11
Nov-11
Dec-11
Jan-12
Feb-12
Mar-12
Apr-12
May-12
Jun-12
Jul-12
Aug-12
Sep-12
Oct-12
Nov-12
Dec-12
Remarks
SSB Phase 1
Preliminary Works
1
1.3
1.4
1.4.1
Construction
Package 1-Earthworks
1.4.2
1.4.3
1.4.4
1.4.5
1.4.6
1.4.7
Package 6a - Electrical
1.4.8
1.4.9
1.4.9.1
1.4.9.2
1.4.10
1.6
1.6.1
1.6.2
1.7
Security
1.9
1.10
Start of Operation
thru Jun 13
Start of Operations
II - 13
2.5.
List of Facilities
2.5.1.
2.5.1.1.
Land Facilities
a. Office block
The office block is a 2-storey composite concrete and steel building
that will serve as base operations office. Inside the office block will be
the port operations office, several support department such as
Business Support Services (BSS), Security, Sales and Marketing, HR
and Admin, Purchasing and Finance, HSE, IT, Radio Room and General
Managers Office. The remaining offices shall be occupied by Customs,
Port Personnel, Shipping Agent, etc. Additional offices will be available
for rental to customers such as Service Companies, PSCs, and
transportation provider.
II - 14
The office will be equipped with telephone and fax facility, internet,
and computer local area network.
b. Crew Change Building
A one storey concrete building will be constructed and used as a crew
change building. The building will be equipped with air conditioning,
toilet, wash basin, refreshment counter and AV equipment. It will be
used as waiting and induction area for incoming and outgoing crew
from offshore production platforms, drilling rigs, FPSO and FSO.
c. Common Warehouses
Two common warehouses will be built, each will be divided into two,
forming 4 warehouses of distinct usage as follows;
1,800 m2 warehouse (General Cargo) with cool room,
1,800 m2 warehouse (Chemical and Dangerous Goods),
1,800 m2 maintenance workshop (with 5MT overhead crane)
1,800 m2 fabrication workshop and inspection area (with 10MT
overhead crane)
The above warehouses come complete with oil catchment area,
drainage, eye wash, emergency showers, smoke detectors, fire alarm
system and 2 way access (steel door, 8mwide 4m high). The floor is
capable of resisting 15MT/m2 forklift load.
d. 4 X Mini Shorebase (MSB)
Mini Shorebase is a compact facility that a single PSC would utilize for
their operations. The facility is composed of 20,000m2 open yard, a
500m2 office, a 1,000m2 closed warehouse and a mini staging and
parking area. The area is enclosed with chain link or BRC fencing
complete with perimeter lighting and street lighting. Internal drainage
is provided to connect to main drain on the main street.
e. Temporary Explosive Storage
The explosive store is a facility design to store explosive materials to
support oil and gas exploration. The facility is designed as a temporary
structure which is composed of 6X20 foot containers. Each container
will be provided with additional zinc roofing and will be installed with
earthing and lightning protection. The facility will be provided with 3
II - 15
II - 16
g. Open Yard
The open yard is an unpaved ground that will be used to store
tubulars. The yard will be compacted to 90% compaction and built to
15 tons/m2 load bearing capacity. The ground surface will be sloped
gently by 1% to ensure good drainage and to avoid water ponding.
The yard will be enclosed with interlink wire mesh or BRC fence and
will be provided with work lighting. Pipe sleepers or base blocks of 45
cm high and each 4 meters long will be provided to support the
tubulars and to avoid contact with the ground.
h. Transit and Staging area
The transit area is a one hectare open area in close proximity to the
main gate to accommodate equipment, cargo and passenger vehicles
while waiting for pass, security checks or jetty berth. The facility
includes security post, driver rest area and toilet facilities.
i. Reverse Osmosis Plant and Water Storage Tanks
The Reverse Osmosis (RO) plant will have a capacity to produce 15 kl
per hour and 2 X 400kl storage tanks. The source of raw water shall be
from the sea or from a deep well. The facility shall be connected with
6 diameter pipeline to the jetty berths. A pumping station will pump
the processed water from storage tanks with a discharge capacity of
120kl/hr (required for O&G supply ship). Each discharge point will be
fitted with water meter and clip lock connection.
j. Fire Fighting Systems
The fire fighting system will be composed of the following;
Fire hydrants spaced every 50m complete with fire hose
cabinet and 2 X 35m fire fighting hose and nozzle,
Electric fire pumps backed up by diesel fire pump with
operating pressure of 8 bars,
Jockey pump to maintain stand by pressure of 10 bars,
Sea water pump back up,
Foam systems,
Firewater pond with 2 hours of reserve capacity,
Deep well and well water tank.
II - 17
k. Substation
The substation is an 8mx25m concrete building to accommodate the
following:
3 X 500kVA generators ,
II - 18
n. Telecommunications Facilities
The telecom system is composed of the following;
Telephone system capable of data and voice capabilities
including tele and video conferences,
High speed internet access capable of voice and data
transmission,
VHF communication systems,
And as backup, there will be satellite system in place
o. Oil Spill Response Equipment
The facility will be provided with oil spill response services and
equipment, (i.e. sufficient boom length, skimmers and dispersants,
together with ISO tanks) for lease when required. Special clothing for
handling oil spill will be provided for each of the team members.
Vessels however are not necessary as the feedback from the oil
companies is that they maintain sufficient vessel capacity for first
responder.
The slipway will be used for launching the spill boom using tug or
work boat with sufficient power to tow it.
p. Waste Management
There are two types of waste that need to be managed at the Suai
Supply Base, namely domestic and industrial waste. For the domestic
waste, a waste segregation area will be provided. Segregated waste
will be disposed of at the local waste dumping area. For industrial
waste (including storage of hazardous waste as well as location for
transfers of hazardous liquids), a Waste Management Company who
specializes in handling, processing and disposing industrial waste will
be employed to handle it. During the construction phase, we will
work with the nominated Waste Management company to design and
build a suitable facility.
II - 19
II - 20
t. Recreation Centre
There will be a recreation centre built near the Supply Base entrance
for base personnel use as well as for the general community. Below
are the facilities to be constructed;
Football field with spectator facilities and night lighting,
Community centre with internet room, library, mini-mart,
Outdoor badminton / basketball courts
Training and conference facilities,
Parking spaces
u. Helipad
During construction, a helipad for visual landing only will be provided
to facilitate inspections and visits by VIPs, dignitaries, customers, etc.
A permanent helipad with navigation aids and fuel storage will not be
constructed if the SUAI airport provides for it.
v. Medical Clinic
The medical clinic will be housed in a 40 foot container and will be
located near the main office block. The facility will come complete
with an emergency room, a treatment room and examination table. It
will be stocked with first aid equipment and medicine. An ambulance
will be available on standby near the clinic for emergency cases that
need transfer to Suai hospital.
2.5.1.2.
Marine Facilities
a. Barging Jetty
The barging jetty will be constructed first and will be used to unload
materials such as concrete piles and pre-cast concrete to be used for
the construction of the main jetty. The jetty will also be used for
unloading construction materials such as steel structures, steel barges
and fuel tanks plates as well as to support operations using heavy lifts.
The operation requires that a barge to be berthed alongside while the
crane is on the land. After the construction phase, the barging jetty
could also be used as an alternative jetty for unloading fuel from a
II - 21
II - 22
The main jetty will be 50 meter wide and 150 meter long and capable
of 4x75m and 1x50m berth. The main jetty is designed to be wide
enough to accommodate the installation of bulk plants in the middle
for mixing and loading cement, barite, bentonite and brine to support
drilling. The jetty is complete with 50 ton bollards and rubber fenders.
Each berth is provided with one RO water, well water, firewater and
fuel outlet each.
d. Navigation Aids
To support safe navigation of ships in and out of the channel and
harbour, navigation aids and equipment such channel marker buoys,
boundary buoys, pile leading beacons, vhf communications, radar
reflectors and mooring buoys will be installed.
e. Breakwater
To ensure a 365/24 operations of the Suai Supply Base, a breakwater
will be constructed on west, south and east of the harbour.
It will be constructed from local materials quarried from nearby rivers
and from the nearest hill where good quality rocks are available. The
initial length of the breakwater is 1,850 meters. This is the minimum
length designed to protect the phase 1 facilities from the waves
brought by south west monsoon. It will protect the barging jetty, the
LCT ramps and the main jetty from the south west waves.
As new facilities and structures are built, extension on the main
breakwater will be built. East breakwater will be built simultaneous
with the construction of future facilities eastside of the basin.
2.5.2.
II - 23
a. Commercial Area
Commercial area is a compact facility designed to cater for oil and gas
service companies. The facility is composed of 1,400 m2 open yard, a
250-m2 commercial space, parking area and roads.
Each facility will be enclosed with interlink or BRC fencing, fence
lighting and drainage, oily water catchment facility and other
industrial waste management.
Telephone, fax, internet and other communication medium will be
provided in this facility.
b. Extension of Supply Base Jetty
The main jetty will be extended if there is a need for it. The proposed
expansion is 50m wide and 150 m long. The extension will be able to
berth 2x75 meter, 5,000 DWT supply boat on the shallow side and a
10,000 DWT drill ship on the deeper side or 2x10,000 DWT dry bulk
barge on the shallow side and 10,000 DWT general cargo ship on the
deeper side.
c. Breakwater
The main breakwater shall be extended to protect the Main Jetty
extension and the New Dry Bulk Terminal. The design is similar to the
Phase 1 Breakwater
d. Bulk Terminal
i. Bulk Port Jetty
The main dry bulk terminal is a 2x400m berth with draft of -9
M. LAT. The terminal will be provided with two conveyor
system that is capable of loading 2 x 20,000 ton per day of
mineral ore.
ii. Closed Dry Bulk Storage
Bulk closed storage is composed of steel structured warehouse
complete with a concrete floor and high enough to
accommodate heavy equipment such as shovel, backhoe and
dump trucks. The warehouse wall shall be reinforced concrete
and capable of retaining high pile of bulk materials. The roof
Suai Supply Base Feasibility Study and Front End
Engineering Design (FEED) Technical Study
II - 24
II - 25
b. Container Port
The container port is a 4-berth port capable of berthing up to 500 TEU
container ship or a maximum capacity of 600,000 TEUs per year. This
port is supported by an 80 hectare container yard for the processing
of incoming and outgoing containers.
The jetty and container yard will be provided with container cranes
and other equipment required for processing of containers through
the port.
c. Passenger/Cargo Terminal
The passenger terminal is capable of berthing 2 LCT vessels and 2 fast
crafts at the same time. It is supported by a Terminal Building, a
parking area, a transit area for waiting passenger buses, cars and
cargo trucks. The facility will be provided with fuel and freshwater
bunkering facility.
d. Fishery Port and Complex
The fishery port is a 4-berth port capable of handling medium-sized
fishing vessels. The facility is supported with refrigerated fish storage,
a fish canning factory, a fish auction market, an ice making machine
and parking area for trucks and car. The complex will be provided by
fresh water and fuel bunkering facilities for fishing boat.
2.6.
On top of the site Topographical and Bathymetric surveys, the technical team also
conducted surveys of the vendors and contractors in Timor-Leste to understand the
availability and costs of material, labour and equipment for the construction of the
Suai Supply Base. The conclusions from the surveys (a detailed site survey report can
be found in Appendix B1) are as follows:
1) Not all required materials and equipment can be found in Timor-Leste
2) The prices for materials and equipment available in Timor-Leste are generally
very high as compared to Indonesia. Materials are on the average 1.5 times
higher and equipment rental is at least 2 times that in Surabaya, Indonesia.
3) Most of the vendors and contractors are in or around Dili. There is very
limited availability in the Suai area. This will add additional mobilisation and
demobilisation costs.
II - 26
4) The route from Dili to Suai is unreliable. This increases the risk if all the
materials and equipment were to come from Dili.
5) During construction, there will be a need to bring personnel, equipment,
supplies and fuel from Lamongan to Suai on a regular basis. This can be
achieved by using an LCT (2kMT DWT) and a Tug and Barge set (5kMT DWT)
to run back and forth from Lamongan to Suai.
The project team however is mindful of the fact that one of the objectives of this
project is initiate economic activity in the Suai and southern regions. As such, the
Government of Timor-Leste has the desire to use as much as possible materials,
equipment and contractors from the local industry. With this in mind, the project
team has developed 2 separate cost scenarios.
1) International Domestic cost (commencement April 2011). This scenario
takes the best available cost for all the materials and equipment based on the
landed cost at Suai.
2) Domestic cost (commencement April 2011). This scenario takes as much as
possible material and equipment from local Timor-Leste vendors. The cost is
similarly landed cost at Suai.
The tables below shows a summary of the two scenarios.
Scenario 1
No
Description
Cost (US$)
1
2
Breakwater
Earthworks
3
4
11,500,000
31,000,000
5
6
Landbased Structures
Consultants fee
36,000,000
6,662,500
TOTAL
176,000,000
12,000,000
273,162,500
II - 27
Scenario 2
No
Description
Cost (US$)
Breakwater
225,000,000
2
3
Earthworks
Royalties (for Timor-Leste quarried materials)
15,000,000
11,500,000
4
5
40,000,000
47,000,000
Consultants fee
TOTAL
8,462,500
346,962,500
II - 28
there are withholding taxes, the EPC estimate will need to be grossed up to
factor this in.
i.
All prices are based on prices as of 15 February 2011. The actual EPC awarded
price may be affected by the general inflation in fuel prices and its knock-on
effect on other materials required for the construction of the Suai Supply Base.
j.
k. For the Domestic pricing, because of the limited availability of material and
equipment in Timor-Leste, there will also be a significant impact to the schedule.
Local suppliers and vendors will need to mobilise or purchase materials and
assets from overseas in order to fulfil their commitments. It is estimated that the
schedule for this scenario will be delayed between 12 to 24 months.
2.7.
To understand the type of maintenance costs required at the Suai Supply Base, the
team studied historical data from a similar facility, which is Lamongan Shorebase in
East Java.
2.7.1. Maintenance of Infrastructure
Based on the historical maintenance costs incurred in Lamongan Shorebase which
operates to a high standard of preventive maintenance, we recommend a provision
of 1% of the Infrastructure Capital Expenditure for the Marine and Land structures as
an annual budget for maintenance and repairs.
This provision of 1% is in line with industry practice for Marine based assets as these
assets are exposed to harsh operating environment. The harsh operating
environment caused by waves, salt water and strong winds requires constant and
II - 29
II - 30
and
and
and
and
II - 31
II - 32
Recertification such as load test and other test on lifting gear such as boom
limiter switch, emergency cut off switch, overload switch etc
Lifting gear certification such as sling wire, shackles, etc
Emission test
2.8.
2.8.1. Electricity
The electrical grid in the Suai area is still being developed. The current power
capacity inSuai city is 1MW. This comes from diesel generators. The power project to
establish a power plant in Betano, capacity 120MW, is scheduled to go online by 3Q
2012. It is unclear when the power grid will link to Suai, however the project caters
for a sub-station at the Suai area with 10MW.
As there will be a need for power at the Suai Supply Base site from the onset of
construction, the EPC contractor should be self sufficient and provide for its own
power generators and fuel supply. The timeframe for completion of the power grid
to Suai city is too near the planned commissioning date of the Suai Supply Base and
any delay in that project will have grave impact to the Suai Supply Base operational
capability. Moreover, it is unclear if provision of power to the Suai Supply Base has
been catered for in the power grid project. As such, we recommend that the
generators used for construction be taken over by the Suai Supply Base during
operations. When power from the grid is connected to the Suai Supply Base, these
II - 33
generators will then transition over to be the backup power supply. As such, the EPC
should provision for power generation of at least 2 X 500KW generators or similar
configuration.
2.8.2. Water Supply
Water in the Suai area comes from mountain sources and the river. Limited water
piping is available and the condition of the water is inconsistent. Technical reports
provided by SERN also indicate that water supply from the existing sources are of
inconsistent quality. It is unclear when the Government of Timor-Leste has
scheduled to pipe fresh water supply to the Suai Supply Base site or even if this
project has been provisioned for.
As such, the Supply Base will provide for a reverse osmosis system that will provide a
stable and good supply of fresh water. This reverse osmosis system coupled with 2 X
400MT storage tanks will be able to provide the fresh water needs of the Suai Supply
Base. This system can also serve as emergency fresh water system for the district.
2.8.3. Telecommunications
The telecommunication infrastructure available in Suai is limited to land lines.
Mobile network is available with a Timor Telecoms tower in place in Suai city. There
is very limited connectivity for internet connections and when available, stability and
bandwidth are issues. It is unclear when telephone lines will be pulled into the Suai
Supply Base site.
We have explored the possibility of broadband satellite connection for voice and
data. Although expensive, this option is available in Timor-Leste and will be setup to
support the base in the event that such national infrastructure is not completed
before the commissioning of the Suai Supply Base.
II - 34
Part III
Commercial Study
III - 1
3.1. Introduction
The commercial study has the following objectives:
1. Identify the potential users of Suai Shorebase, and assess their needs over a
10 year period.
2. Identify the facilities and services required by the users, and the dates of
intended use.
3. Recommend a selling price for each item of service for the purposes of our
own forecasting, as well as for Government of Timor-Leste to negotiate and
agree with the users, a commitment for domestic expenditure.
4. Provide Manning Chart and a skills development programme.
5. Provide an estimate of operating expenses for purposes of financial modeling.
6. Identify the Source of funding and cost of funding.
7. Identify and/recommend fiscal issues ranging from handling of bonded or
duty free exemptions for project equipment, and for PSCs during operations.
8. Identify and recommend suitable tax and fiscal exemptions to improve
returns.
9. Identify and recommend required improvements to infrastructure (eg airport,
hotel, roads etc).
At the kick-off meeting, the following approach to the study was agreed:
1. Identify each PSC and obtain summary of their commitment (seismic,
exploration), and whether they are at exploration, development or
production stage
2. Prepare a Detailed Questionnaire as the basis to focus discussion.
3. Conduct a Presentation and discuss the questionnaire to all PSCs and Service
Companies Major Event , need to fix date in advance and to send out
invitations and to ensure attendance. Government of Timor-Leste Ministers
to attend.
4. Send out and obtain reply to Questionnaire to PSC and Service Companies.
5. Follow Up one to one interviews with Logistics decision maker of PSC.
III - 2
III - 3
With the user interviews, the team set out with the following objectives:
1) Establish a forecast of drilling activities in the next 5-10 years.
2) Validate the size and range of facilities and services at the Suai Supply base.
3) Gather general feedback on their views on the Suai Supply Base/
The team had an interview session with ANP and there was very strong level of
support and open sharing of information. The team also interviewed the following
PSCs to gather their feedback on the range of facilities and services required at the
base as well as other general feedback if they were to use the Suai Supply Base:
- Reliance
- ENI
- Conoco Phillips
- Oilex
During the interview, the team carried out the following:
-
Briefed the PSCs that the Government of Timor-Leste had appointed EastLog
Holdings Pte Ltd to conduct a technical and commercial feasibility study on
the establishment of a Supply Base at Suai.
Presented proposed scope of facilities and services at Suai Supply Base. (refer
to Project kick-off presentation) and engaged each PSC in an in depth
discussion on the technical aspects.
Asked each PSC their plan of activities from 2011 through 2015.
Asked each PSC for their views on using the Suai Supply Base.
Over and above discussions with the PSCs, and for completeness of scope, the
project team also engaged the potential service companies in discussion to solicit
their requirements as well as the level of support for the project.
III - 4
3.2.1.2.
Contractor
ENI
TLEA C
TLEA K
JPDA 06-101A
(Chuditch)
JPDA 06-102
ENI
Reliance
Minza
JPDA 06-103
JPDA 06-105 (Kitan)
Oilex
ENI
Conoco
Philips
Woodside
Petronas
Activities
Initial work program indicates 1 well to be drilled in each
towards the end of the exploration license.
2 wells back to back to be drilled in 1Q 2011
1 well, Dec 2010 to Jan 2011
Plan to drill in 2011
Contractor to exit and return block to Government of
Timor-Leste.
2 well drilling program. 1st well in 1Q 2011
Preparation for production in 3Q 2011. Currently 4
development wells. Preparations for 4 more exploration
wells in the south side, to start mid 2011.
No new drilling program planned. Currently 11 wells in
production.
Pending agreement on gas processing approach
III - 5
3.2.1.3.
None of the parties currently operating in Timor-Leste waters are able to provide any
reliable information on drilling activities beyond 2012. As a result the commercial
team has had to develop their own projections based assumptions of a certain level
of activity.
Due to uncertain nature of exploratory drilling, these projections are purely
estimates based on the best information available at the time of this report. As with
all projections, there is no assurance that the activities forecasted will be at that
level or at all.
However, several key conclusions can be drawn from the discussions with the
current PSCs:
1) Only 50% of acreage has been tendered out. No new exploratory drilling
expected before 2015.
Only 6 out of 11 lots for TLEA have been tendered out previously. More than
50% of the JPDA remains open acreage. The Government of Timor-Leste will
likely conduct a round of acreage release in 4Q 2011. If we assume 12 months
for additional seismic activites together with 12 18 months subsequently
for planning, submission and approval, that means no new exploratory
drilling expected before 2014.
2) As at 2011, only 2 fields will be in production, notably Kitan and Bayu-Udan.
ENI has plans to bring Kitan into production in 3Q 2011 but potentially has a
life cycle of only 8 10 years. Bayu-Udan is in production with 11 wells and
no plans for any additional drilling.
3) The current exploration drilling programs for Reliance and ENI have
completed with no success and no further activities planned.
III - 6
III - 7
5) The PSCs generally accept our proposed list of facilities and services. They
reviewed the proposed design and standards from EastLog and were satisfied.
6) The PSCs stressed that the facilities and services must be complete for them
to use the Suai Supply Base and not have to rely on Darwin for some services.
7) None of the PSCs were able to provide any forecast of activities beyond 2012.
8) The PSCs requirements for using the Suai Supply Base:
a. Must be built to international Oil and Gas standards.
b. Should be completed before the new Darwin offshore supply base is
scheduled to be completed, as they do not wish to move twice (from
existing Darwin to New Darwin Offshore Supply Base and then Suai
Supply Base).
c. Must offer full range of facilities and services they do not want to
have to use both Suai and Darwin.
d. Operator must have a proven track record of managing a multi-user
integrated supply base.
e. The project must demonstrate high level of HSE awareness and
compliance, from the onset of design, construction and through to
operations.
f. There must be skilled workforce available in Suai.
9) The PSCs expressed interest in the skills development program as this would
also establish a pool of skilled resources that they eventually can tap on. The
Government of Timor-Leste is already moving forward in this area with a
request to EastLog for a comprehensive program to train at all levels and
during the construction phase in preparation for operations.
10) The PSCs were concerned about the general state of the surrounding
infrastructure in Suai (i.e. road transport, telecommunications, small industry,
airport and helipad, etc)
III - 8
The project team recommends that several steps be taken to keep the industry
engaged and updated as well as build confidence in the Suai Supply Base project.
a. Regular project status communication to the general industry with
invitations to visit the project site.
b. Use only contractors that have experience working for the Oil and Gas
industry and understand their high standards.
c. High standard of project management and execution rigour throughout
the project timeline.
d. A focus on HSE at all levels. The eyes of our future customers are on us
and monitoring our commitment to HSE, starting at the construction
phase.
3.2.1.5.
Service Companies
It is envisioned that some of the services provided at the Suai Supply Base will be
provided by external service providers.
-
Cementing/Fluid/Formation Evaluation/Wireline
Logistics Provider/Forwarder
Waste Management
Catering
Oil Spill
Explosives
Medical
Drilling Company
General Fabricator
General Stockist
III - 9
The project team canvassed the different service providers and has the following
conclusions:
- Service companies will go where there is a business need and the facilities are
available.
- Decision on permanent presence or ad-hoc mob and demob will be purely
based on the level of activity anticipated. With current projections, the
activity at Suai is unlikely to attract permanent presence of these service
providers. This might change if onshore development takes place.
- They are generally happy with the base masterplan and have confidence in
EastLogs ability to provide them with the necessary support and
infrastructure as well as retain the Oil and Gas customers. They have an
existing relationship with EastLog and most have a hub in or around
Lamongan.
- General concerns:
o Availability of infrastructure and facilities (power, water, warehouse,
yard, heavy equipment, etc) and if there are safety standards.
o Availability of skilled labour.
o Commercial pricing of facilities. (Note: Pricing structure can be
tailored for service companies if necessary and a 2 tiered pricing
structure established.)
o Will the base operator understand their needs?
III - 10
3.2.2.1.
Once the Suai Supply Base is operational, the same facilities built for the Oil and Gas
industry now becomes available to use as a springboard for many other industries.
The port facilities will open the south to direct shipping of goods and supplies. All
manner of goods, from basic food and supplies, to electronics and home appliances
and even bulk cargo and livestock can now find their way easily to the Suai area and
on to the rest of the South.
The immediate trade links with Lamongan in East Java and Darwin in Australia will
open up import of general supplies and foodstuff. The multi purpose jetty as well as
the LCT ramp will allow break bulk, containerized cargo, tracked vehicles, etc and
open up many opportunities for the local industries. This will also be the point of
entry for construction equipment and materials for Government infrastructure
projects.
3.2.2.2.
Liquid Cargo
The port will also allow the importation of diesel, gasoline and aviation fuel directly
to the south without having to go through Dili and the overland route over the
mountains.
3.2.2.3.
Local Industries
The waters to the south of Timor-Leste are generally considered to be attractive for
commercial fishing activities. The existence of a sheltered port will enable the
Government of Timor-Leste to develop the commercial fishing and seafood
processing activities.
Lumber and agriculture industries will also be benefit from access to port facilities
for export.
The port facilities will also open up the channel for export of minerals. This will allow
the Government of Timor-Leste to commence development of the mining industry.
III - 11
3.2.2.4.
Once the Port facilities are in place, the Airport is operational, road infrastructure
connecting Dili and Suai are available for container traffic as well as scheduled
passenger (bus) routes and the infrastructure around Suai is established, Suai then
becomes an important hub in the south for intermodal integration of transport both
goods and passenger. Using the Oil and Gas industry as an enabler, and with the
Suai Supply Base as a catalyst, the economic development of the southern regions
can be steady and sustainable.
The next step would then be to build an industrial estate adjacent to the Suai Supply
Base (Zone C). This industrial estate will be sowing the seeds of future local small and
medium enterprises that can flourish as the larger investments move into the Suai Betano Beaco corridor. With the improved infrastructure and access to
international port facilities for shipment of cargo, industries around Suai can blossom.
Zone C
Zone B
Zone A
III - 12
This industrial estate will benefit from the port facilities and infrastructure upgrades
and will contribute to two way cargo volumes at the port. This industrial estate can
be built in phases as demand increases. It will serve as the platform for industrial
growth for the southern region. The industrial estate will also allow the Government
of Timor-Leste to recover some or all of its capital expenditure in building the port
facilities.
The Suai Supply Base has for primary role the support of offshore oil and gas activity
in the Timor Sea and potentially onshore drilling activity in Timor-Leste. The current
logistics support for offshore oil and gas activity in this area is done out of Darwin,
with only Reliance managing this out of Dili. Reliance was able to do so because they
had a single drilling program where much of the supplies were loaded on the rig at
source and brought together with it.
To be able to justify the Oil and Gas customers using Suai as their supply base and to
retain this customer base, a full suite of the standard services and facilities need to
be made available at Suai. Moreover, these facilities and services need to meet
International standards for the Oil and Gas industry. The customers in the Oil and
Gas industry will not compromise on standards of quality and safety as any errors
can have potentially catastrophic effects. It will also not make economic sense for
them to have to use Suai for half their needs and another supply base for the
remaining services. Thus, Suai needs to be able to provide for all of their basic needs.
This multi-user integrated logistics supply base will be similar to the facility currently
managed by Eastern Logistics at Lamongan in East Java.
III - 13
3.2.3.2.
Core to the Suai base design is a next generation concept for Multi-User Integrated
Supply Base called MiniShoreBase (MSB). Each PSC in residence will be required to
lease 1 X MSB. Each MSB will come with a 2 Hectare open yard, 1,000 m2 Warehouse
(General Cargo), Office space. This allows the PSC to operate efficiently within the
shorebase as all his facilities will be in close proximity, within a single fenced area.
The MSB will also come with a yard and warehouse crew (trained and administered
by the Suai Supply Base team) to manage his facilities. For all PSCs, the Suai Base will
also make available 1 set of OilSpill equipment which can be leased on an ad-hoc
basis.
The commercial team used the proposed list of facilities and services presented at
the Project kick-off to engage the PSCs in discussions to finalise their requirements.
The following is the revised list based on their feedback. This has been furnished to
the technical team as input for their design of the base layout and buildings that
need to be available from the start of operations.
a. * Berths
4X75 and 1X50 multi purpose berths (150mX50m), able to
accommodate 2X75m berths (crew change) at 7m LAT and 2X75m
berths at 9m LAT and 1X50m berth at 7m LAT.
Berths have sufficient area for bulk tanks, as well as safe working
zone for handling OCTG
All weather 365 days capabilities, with lighting for 24 hours work.
Radar Navigation aids, channel markers, VHF communication
equipment, 4 X mooring buoys.
b. * RORO jetty with LCT Ramp
2 X ramp for LCT at 4m LAT are needed to support construction. These
will then subsequently be used in operations.
Ramp provided with 3 X 50MT bollard
c. Crew Change Building.
Small building with air conditioning, AV equipment, toilets and rest
area.
d. Port Operations Office (within main office building)
For port base operations, with a radio room.
III - 14
e. * 2 X Warehouses buildings
2 X 3,600 sq m each managed by Suai Supply Base team, complete
with oil catchment areas, proper drainage, eye wash, emergency
showers, smoke detectors, alarm system, 2 way access (steel door,
8mwide 4m high). Floor capacity of 15MT/m2. Each building will be
divided into 2 units to provide the following:
- Warehouse (General Cargo) of 1800 m2 with cool room
- Warehouse (Chemical and Dangerous Goods) of 1800m2
- Maintenance and Fleet Workshop (with 5MT overhead crane)
- Fabrication Workshop and Inspection area (with 10MT
overhead crane)
f. * 4 X Minishorebase (MSB)
Each MSB will come with a 2 Hectare open yard, 1,000 m2 Warehouse
(General Cargo) and a 500 m2 Office space.
g. Open Yards 10 ha.
Compacted or filled to allow 15MT per sq m of load, divided into 1 ha
plots, 100m x 100m fenced to 2 m high, with drainage. Ground will be
sloped to 1% for good drainage and reduce ponding. Provision of light
for night work, as well as provision of power to support a porta cabin
office.
h. ** Transit and Staging area
1 hectare open area in close proximity to the jetty for vehicle and
equipment staging. This area will also include driver rest area and
toilet facilities.
i.
j.
III - 15
l.
m. Sub Station
25mX8m building to accommodate the following:
Step down transformer
Low voltage panels
3 X 500kVA generators + storage tank (outside) 3,000l
n. Telecommunications Facilities
Connect to the existing Timor Telecom infrastructure for high speed
internet access, data and voice capabilities, VHF. As a backup, there
will be satellite system in place.
o. Security System
Main guard post, Control room (in main office), 6 X guard towers, 33 X
cctvs, guard ready room (main accom block), and guard quarters
(main accommodation block). Security vehicles (patrol jeeps, motor
cycles, etc)
p. Offices
2 storey building (13m X 50m) with Offices for rental as well as for use
by the Operator.
q. Oil Spill Response Equipment
Maintain common user oil spill response services and equipment, (ie
sufficient booms, skimmers and dispersants, together with ISO tanks)
for lease when required. Vessels however are not necessary as the
feedback from the oil companies is that they maintain sufficient vessel
capacity for first responder.
r. * Explosive Storage
There is no justification for a permanent explosive bunker. We will
build temporary porta cabins with earthworks/bundwall and
adequate Public Traffic Route (PTR) zone.
s. Waste Management Area (including storage of hazardous waste as
well as location for transfers of hazardous liquids)
To be designed in consultation with waste management specialist
III - 16
III - 17
z. * Helipad
During construction, a Helipad for visual landing only will be provided
to facilitate inspections and visits by VIPs, dignitaries, customers, etc.
Will provide space for a permanent helipad with navigation aids and
fuel storage however, this will not be constructed if the SUAI airport
provides for it.
Footnotes for Facilities and Services
1) Refer to the technical section for more detailed description of each facility /
structure.
2) * indicates facilities that have changed from the kick-off meeting due to needs
of the base.
3) ** indicates new facilities not included in the kick-off meeting
3.2.3.3.
Phase 1 of the masterplan from the technical study has been designed to support 2-4
PSCs in residence and 2 exploration drilling programs at any one time. The port and
berthing facilities have are multipurpose facilities designed for optimum flexibility.
a) 4 multipurpose berths (Shorebase berths).
This is the most flexible configuration. This is demonstrated in the diagram
below.
III - 18
The jetty will also contain bulk plant facilities to deliver cement and muds to
the supply vessels.
b) 2 X LCT ramps.
This is required during construction and is of fairly low cost. However, it will
continue to be operational for commercial use. It allows the import of
tracked and heavy vehicles as well as bulk and heavy cargo using comato
vehicles. It will continue to support the development of industry in and
around Suai and the southern regions.
With these facilities, the base has the flexibility to handle all PSC activity and
commercial cargo, dry bulk import and export and liquid storage cargo. The
theoretical maximum capacity for phase one is:
a) 3 PSCs (2 Production support and 1 Drilling support) in residence and
b) 200,000MT dry bulk cargo and
c) commercial and liquid storage cargo for all the Suai area.
Road Network
Airfield / Helipad
Industrial Estate
Medical facilities
Utilities
Telecommunications
III - 19
3.2.4.1. Observations
The project team made several visits to the Suai district, travelling by road from Dili
to Suai. The general observations are as follows:
3.2.4.1.1. Road Network
1. Dili to Suai
The road from Dili to Suai is hazardous and poorly maintained. The main types of
road available are asphalt, gravel and mud tracks, however the asphalt and gravel
roads are in bad condition with many potholes and uneven surfaces. The passage
through the mountainous regions is especially dangerous and many potential
impasses exist. The roads are barely wide enough for 2 way traffic. Bad weather and
landslides aggravate the situation. Along the plains and coastal regions the road
conditions improve, however, there are still many potholes and the roads are narrow.
The vehicles plying these routes are generally trucks (max 3-5MT) and 4X4 vehicles.
The road is unacceptable by Oil and Gas industry standards. It will not be used for
crew change.
III - 20
III - 21
3.2.4.1.2. Airfield
The team has surveyed the existing old airfield in the Suai area. The access to the site
is poor and the roads in bad condition. The airfield is not fenced off and no buildings
remain. In the immediate vicinity of the airfield there is some local habitation. The
airstrip is currently used as a playground for the children living around that area.
There is an old helipad within the airport.
We were unable to ascertain the strength of the runway and helipad or their ability
to support flight activities.
No other facilities were observed at the airfield.
The airport is currently not operational.
Figure III-6 : Photos of abandoned Suai Airport (cattle and children in background)
III - 22
Figure III-7 : Photos of abandoned Suai Airport (nearby buildings) and Helipad
3.2.4.1.3. General Commercial Port
There is currently no general commercial port available although the Government
has plans to develop one in the Suai Loro vicinity.
3.2.4.1.4. Industrial Estate
There is currently no industrial activities in or around Suai.
3.2.4.1.5. Medical Facilities
1. Clinics
The team has surveyed the medical facilities in and around the Suai area. There are
several clinics around the Suai area, either operated by the Ministry of Health or by
Private NGOs. These clinics generally do not have a doctor in attendance. They have
nurses and a dispensary and cater to minor ailments and injuries. The NGO operated
III - 23
clinics also offer immunization and anti-natal care. Ambulances are used to transfer
any patients that need a doctors attention to the hospital in Suai.
III - 24
III - 25
III - 26
III - 27
3.2.4.2.2. Airfield
For the Oil and Gas industry, the availability of air transportation is extremely vital
in maintaining the link between the remote drilling rig and their onshore base for
crew change and all emergency evacuation.
The airport needs to upgraded to Oil and Gas standards. There is a need for basic
airport management buildings and services. This includes 2 or 3 small hangars for
helicopters and any small aircraft that will stay overnight and a small airport terminal
for the administrative services. The airfield needs to be fenced up and contained to
prevent locals and livestock from wandering onto the tarmac. The necessary safety
distances for habitation from the runway need to be implemented and the villagers
relocated if necessary. The access road should be improved to connect to Suai town
and the Suai Supply base. Electrical substation and utilities need to be constructed
for the Air terminal. The necessary fire and safety facilities (water holding tank, fire
engine/station, etc) also need to be established.
The following are the basic requirements for an airport to support the Oil and Gas
industry. This would be able to service the Oil and Gas industry needs for crew
change. However, since the airfield is to be upgraded, it should be upgraded directly
to a regional airport, able to service regional destinations for commercial cargo and
passenger traffic.
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
Aerodrome Reference
Code Number : 2 and Code Letter : C
Aircraft type
DHC 8-300, 50 seater with option to be upgraded
Runway
1.6km X 30m, CAN-PCN determination Code : R, to be extended in
future to 2,500m if required.
Runway Strip
75m left side and 75m right side from the centre line
III - 28
v.
vi.
vii.
Navigation System
Instrument landing system and precision approach path indicator as a
visual aid.
Night Landing
Runway and apron lights
Others
Fire fighting truck and facilities on site.
Once this airfield is available, it will be able to support the transfer of personnel to
and from the PSC facilities both at the Suai supply base and offshore. Crew change
will be by helicopter from the rig to the Suai airport, and then onwards to Dili or
Darwin by helicopter/plane/road.
The development of the airfield will also attract more investment opportunities into
the Southern regions of Timor-Leste. It will drastically reduce the commute time
between Dili and Suai, from 6-8 hours by vehicle down to 40 minutes by air transport.
The Oil and Gas industry will be the enabler, however all subsequent economic
activity will benefit. It will improve the accessibility of the south and open up this
area for more trade and tourism.
3.2.4.2.3. Helipad
It is a critical requirement for offshore drilling to have access to medivac facilities. To
this end, the helipad at the Suai airport also needs to be repaired. The main routes
for helicopter transport are from Dili to Suai and also from Suai to the offshore rigs.
This would likely be based out of the Suai airport.
There is an immediate need for a helipad at Suai. During construction, a helipad will
be built at the Suai supply base. This will be a helipad for visual landing and have day
capability only. There will be no facilities for maintenance or refueling. This helipad is
intended only to serve as air transport from Dili to Suai for officials, VIPs, customers
and management visits.
III - 29
III - 30
III - 31
The Suai supply base will thus only have a small clinic onsite for minor ailments and
patient stabilization in case of an emergency. This clinic can be manned by a Suai
supply base staff or by staff from the Suai hospital. It is recommended that the
hospital in Suai be able to provide the necessary manpower to staff the clinic at Suai.
This will be more efficient and economical as they are best able to find, train and
retain medical personnel.
Timor-Leste does not at the current moment have a decompression chamber at any
of its facilities. It is the opinion of this team that the purchase and installation of a
decompression chamber would be premature at this stage. It is best to review this
situation in 3 to 5 years.
3.2.4.2.8. Utilities
The Suai Supply Base as well as the Airstrip will need electrical substations to provide
their electrical supply. Both will also need backup power supply through generators
as they are required to have 24/7 availability. The electrical consumption for the
Supply Base is estimated at 120,000 kWh/mnth. During the construction of the Suai
Supply Base, generators will be brought in to provide the power required by the
project team and equipment. These generators will then transition into operations
and provide the electrical needs of the base when the base is commissioned. Once
power from the grid is made available to the Supply Base, the generators will then be
used as backup power supply. The current schedule for the power project in TimorLeste will provide for a 10MW sub-station in Suai to supply the Suai area.
In the short term there is no reliable source that can provide stable and good quality
fresh water to the Suai Supply Base. As such, the Supply Base will provide for a
reverse osmosis system that will provide a stable and good supply of fresh water.
The consumption of water at the Suai Supply Base is estimated at 100m3 per day.
III - 32
3.2.4.2.9. Telecommunications
A key component of modern day operational efficiency is the ability to communicate
both voice and data quickly and reliably. For the Suai supply base to be able to
operate and deliver a globally accepted standard of service and quality, the
telecommunications infrastructure must be available both for the base use as well as
for its customers. If at the time of commissioning of the base, the
telecommunications infrastructure from Timor telecoms is available, then this will be
used. If not, the Suai Supply Base will fall back on emmersat technology to provide
satellite broadband link for voice / data.
3.2.4.2.10. Bulk Fuel Storage
There is no existing bulk storage of fuels in Timor-Leste South. The Suai Supply Base
will need to provide for adequate storage to ensure self sufficiency of fuel for the
base as well as in support of its customers. The liquid storage facilities at the Suai
supply base can then also be used to support the southern region as the region
develops and grows. Fuel will no longer need to be trucked long distances over
hazardous routes. The ease of access to a stable supply of good quality fuel will
attract more businesses to establish reputable petrol distribution networks and also
facilitate the growth of industry in the area. The liquid storage at the Suai supply
base should also cater for aviation fuel. It will then also be able to support the
establishment of the airport and heliport. These services from the supply base
should be established as early as is possible to facilitate the development of the
region as well as any other projects in the area.
III - 33
III - 34
7) Suai is poised to play a key role in the development of the Southern region of
Timor-Leste. It will be a key hub for intermodal connectivity of passenger and
goods transport. Key to this success is:
o Road connectivity to Dili
o Air connectivity to Dili and regional for passengers and goods.
o Sea connectivity to an international hub with a regular LCT run to
Lamongan in the short term.
8) The Government of Timor-Leste should develop an industrial estate adjacent
to the Suai Supply Base. Secure the land for the port expansion and industrial
estate early. The port facilities at the Suai Supply Base will attract business to
setup to take advantage of the benefits from the reduced logistics costs and
improved infrastructure. The industrial activity at the industrial estate will
generate increased cargo volumes for the Suai Supply Base.
III - 35
III - 39
exchange programs between the two bases to enhance the operational readiness of
the newly setup Suai team. The Suai team will be staffed with a combination of
expatriates and locals. As far as possible, where the skills are available locally, the
positions will be filled with Timor-Leste locals. If adequate skill levels are not
available in Timor-Leste, then the positions will be filled with workers from Indonesia,
Philipines, Singapore or any ASEAN nation. If the right person cannot be found within
the ASEAN region, then it will be filled with an international expatriate.
III - 40
III - 41
The base will need several support functions to be filled to ensure its continuous
operational readiness. The QHSE team will be responsible for all Health, Safety and
Quality matters on the base. The maintenance team will keep the base and all
equipment serviceable and operational. Finally, the security team will provide base
security round the clock. Like the Port and Yard crews, these crews will also operate
24/7.
III - 42
Figure III 15 : Suai Supply Base Sales, Finance and Admin teams
The sales team is responsible for maintaining communications with the customer
and ensuring the base facilities and services are always one step ahead of the
customers needs. Finally, the base will need its Finance and HR departments. All
these 3 departments will operate during normal office hours.
III - 43
3
4
3
30
78
18
28
7
45
49
10 13 31
6
3
5
TOTAL 210
4
4
2
TOTAL
1
30
Grade 8
Grade 5
13
9
2
3
3
1
Grade 7
2
2
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
Grade 6
Management
Operations
Maintenance
Quality, Health, Safety and Environment
Security
Business Support Services
Finance
Human Resources
Sales
Grade 4
Department
Grade 3
The table below shows a breakdown by department and grade level for the staff at
the base.
Table III 2 : Breakdown of Suai Supply Base employees by Department and Grade
Level
III - 44
Position
Base General
Manager (BGM)
Requirements
Master degree or Bachelors Degree in Industrial Engineering (with
experiences) or Oil&Gas engineering (with experience) (experience in
either one)
At least 10 years experience in logistics, project explorationproduction and development (preferably in the oil and gas industry)
Offshore experience is mandatory
Good supervisory and interpersonal skills
Base Assistant
General Manager
BGM secretary
Diploma degree
Advanced level knowledge of word processing office, electronic mail
& calendar software application
Considerable knowledge of office procedures & practice of correct
punctuation, spelling & grammatical usage
Experience in filing, indexing & cross referencing
Multi tasking & work process effectively under pressure with
frequent interruption
Establish and maintain cooperative and effective relationships with
other departments & those contacted in the course of work
Excellent command of both spoken and written English
III - 45
No
Position
Operation Manager
Requirements
Bachelors Degree in Industrial Engineering or Oil&Gas Engineering
Between 10 and 15 years experience in logistics, port activities,
project exploration-production and development (preferably in oil and
gas industry), Mining
Good supervisory and interpersonal skills
Good command of both spoken and written English
Logistics supervisor
Yard Supervisor
Vocational certificate
5 years experience in transport handling / coordination related to
the shipping industry
On/Offshore experience is preferable
Computer basic knowledge (office suite : word/Excell/powerpoint)
Good command of both spoken and written English
Warehouse
assistant /
Fuel Storage
Technician
III - 46
No
Position
Resources assistant
Requirements
Senior High School or Diploma degree
Good knowledge of heavy equipment and overall maintenance
Good knowledge of both spoken and written English
Good knowledge and operating computer (Microsoft Office)
Good command of both spoken and written English
Port master
10
Assistant Port
Master
III - 47
No
11
Position
Radio Operator
Requirements
Minimum Senior High School Degree
Holding the Radio certificate minimum SOU
Good knowledge of Radio Regulation and technical principle
Minimum knowledge of technical radio equipment ( VHF & HF)
Have knowledge of computer
Good command of both spoken and written English
12
Port Admin
13
Stevedore
Vocational certificate
2 years experience in transport handling / coordination related to
the shipping industry
Offshore experience is preferable
Good command of both spoken and written English
14
Yard Crew
Vocational certificate
Dependable & organized
Good command of both spoken and written English
15
Foreman
Vocational certificate
2 years experience in transport handling / coordination related to
the shipping industry
Offshore experience is preferable
Good command of both spoken and written English
III - 48
No
Position
16
Maintenance
Manager
Requirements
Master degree or Bachelors Degree in Industrial Engineering
Between 10 and 15 years experience in maintenance and
construction site
Good supervisory and interpersonal skills
Good command of both spoken and written English
HSE awareness
Good command of both spoken and written English
17
Maintenance
Supervisor
18
Electrical engineer
19
Mechanical
Engineer
20
Carpenter
Vocational certificate
Able to work independently or part as a team
21
IT officer
III - 49
No
Position
22
Requirements
Diploma or Bachelor degree in Chemical / Engineering
5 years of experience in RO operations
HSE awareness
Basic computer knowledge (Office suite)
Good command of both spoken and written English
23
24
25
Maint. General
Workers /
Elect & Mech
Teams
Team player
QHSE manager
26
QHSE Officer
III - 50
No
27
Position
Medic
Requirements
Diploma in Health, Safety & Environmental
Hold license in first aid & artificial resuscitation
Good communication skill
Good command of both spoken and written English
28
Security Manager
29
Security Supervisor
30
Security Officer
31
Finance Manager
32
Tax officer
III - 51
No
33
Position
Invoice Officer
Requirements
Minimum Bachelors degree in Accounting
Minimum 3 years in accounting and Account Receivable Section
Accounting/finance skills, specially in account receivable section
Good interpersonal and communication skill
Able to work under pressure generated from deadline
Good command of both spoken and written English
34
GL Assistant /
AR/AP Assistant
35
36
HR Manager
HR assistant /
Training Officer
37
BSS Manager
III - 52
No
Position
38
Base Boss /
Customer
Liaison Spec /
Requirements
Minimum diploma
Computer literate (e.g. MS Word, MS Excel, Microsoft Outlook)
Conversant in both spoken and written English
Ability to work in an effective and timely manner
Good interpersonal and communication skill
good relationship with the person (staff / customer) interrelation
skill
Good command of both spoken and written English
39
Storekeeper /
Janitor /
Office boy /
Drivers
40
Catering
Supervisor /
Catering
Assistant
Note: It is expected that most positions will be filled by Timor-Leste nationals, who
are able to communicate in Tetum, Portuguese and Indonesian. For not Timor-Leste
nationals, the ability to speak Tetum, Portuguese and/or Indonesian will be a plus.
III - 53
Survey in Timor-Leste
The project team visited the University in Dili and a Vocational centre to assess the
availability of skilled manpower for the staffing of the Suai Supply base. Although
the vocational manpower with the relevant skillsets is not readily available in TimorLeste today, the vocational centre has the capability to conduct vocational training in
the specific areas required by the Suai Supply Base. These areas include rigging,
welding, equipment maintenance, etc. This approach, in conjunction with an on-thejob training (OJT) program and supervisory attachment program between the
Lamongan Shorebase and the Suai Supply Base would be the best strategy to ensure
the Suai Supply Base has the necessary skillsets from day one of operations.
III - 54
3.4.4.2.
Government Programs
For the Suai Supply Base to be operationally ready to international standards from
day 1, it requires more than just the construction of the facilities and structures. The
right manpower needs to be trained and in place as well as the operating procedures
need to be setup. This softer side of the project should not be underestimated.
Whilst the necessary staff can be trained, all Oil and Gas companies require senior
positions to be filled by people with at least 5 to 10 years oil and gas relevant
experience. This will not be available in Timor-Leste. To meet these requirements,
the Government of Timor-Leste needs to enter into a Management Agreement with
a company experienced in managing multi-user supply base such at Eastlog Holding
Pte Ltd to provide the necessary credibility and management team in the initial years
to allow the Suai Supply Base personnel to acquire experience.
There is significant advantage to Eastlog taking on this project. Apart from the
obvious experience and capabilities advantages, there are also benefits on the softer
side of setting up the Suai Supply Base. Both bases will be multi-user integrated
III - 55
supply bases and their operational templates will be very similar. The Lamongan
Shorebase has an established quality program and has already achieved ISO 9001,
ISO 14001-2004, OHSAS 18001-1999 and ISPS Code. They are an approved supply
base for many International O&G companies. With the similarities in the operational
templates, the Standard Operation Procedures from Lamongan Shorebase can be
ported across with relative ease. This will significantly reduce the time and effort
required to develop the documentation and operating procedure at the Suai Supply
Base. The experience and credibility in Lamongan Shorebase will also greatly assist
the Suai Supply Base in quickly establishing its credibility and obtaining the necessary
certifications.
The other major advantage is in the manpower and skills development for the Suai
Supply Base team. The Lamongan Shorebase is an operational multi-user integrated
supply base. There are many synergies that can be tapped on to assist Suai Supply
Base in their skills development. Most importantly, there exists a pool of skilled and
trained resources available at Lamongan for exchange programs and attachments.
There is also an operational base with standard operating procedures in place
available for any on-the-job training. Finally, the pool of resources available at
Lamongan also mitigates the risk of the shortage of such manpower or skills in Suai
at the onset of operations.
3.4.4.4.
III - 56
independent 3rd party evaluators. The candidates are required to pass this
evaluation to continue on to the second 12 months of On-The-Job training. At
the end of the training program, there will be further grading by the
independent 3rd party evaluators. The best candidate will assume the
managerial role with the others taking roles as assistant managers or
supervisors.
2) Trade Program
There will be a large number of personnel that would need vocational
training (i.e. riggers, welders, crane and forklift operators, mechanics,
electricians, etc). It is recommended that skills development program
incorporate working with local vocational institutes to establish a syllabus for
such training. The vocational training can thus be completed locally in TimorLeste, with skilled staff thus being made available to other industries or Oil
and Gas players. Selected graduates will then be provided additional training
to prepare them for the Oil and Gas industry standards (process
documentation, HSE as well as operating to established standards). In the 6
months prior to commencement of operations, they will attend training at
the suai Training centre by the Eastlog team.
3) Outsourced
Some skills are specialized and need dedicated external training. For example,
HSE manager, the relevant management trainee needs to be sent to
universities outside Timor-Leste to attend the relevant undergraduate course.
Once complete, they can then attend OJT at Suai. In the meantime, such roles
need to be filled by expatriates or as part of the Management agreement.
Additionally, select members from the management trainee program or trade
program will be sent for specialized training and certifications (oil spill
response, hazardous goods management, specific equipment maintenance
courses by vendors, sea survival, HUET, etc).
4) Suai training centre
Six months before commencement of operations, the EastLog team can set
up a small training centre at the Suai Supply Base for locals to train them on
general skills or certification. This approach has several advantages:
- Commissioning and handover from equipment vendors
- On the job experience in a controlled environment
- Bring the team together for the first time
III - 57
III - 58
For infrastructure Capex, we first did a calculation using the optimal pricing for all
equipment, materials and services (best price available in Indonesia or Timor-Leste).
No
Description
1
2
Breakwater
Earthworks
3
4
5
6
Cost (US$)
Depreciation (Yrs)
176,000,000
12,000,000
20
20
11,500,000
31,000,000
20
20
Landbased Structures
Consultants fee
36,000,000
6,662,500
20
20
TOTAL
273,162,500
Description
Breakwater
2
3
Cost (US$)
Depreciation (Yrs)
225,000,000
20
Earthworks
Royalties (for Timor-Leste quarried materials)
15,000,000
11,500,000
20
20
4
5
40,000,000
47,000,000
20
20
Consultants fee
8,462,500
20
TOTAL
346,962,500
III - 59
The Suai Supply Base will also need the acquisition of all the equipment for use at
the base. The following is summary of the cost of Operating assets Capex.
No
Description
Unit
Cost/Unit
(US$)
Total Cost
(US$)
Depreciation
(Yr)
Crane 150 MT
1,700,000
1,700,000
10
2
3
Crane 50 MT
Slings and lifting gear
1
1
800,000
500,000
800,000
500,000
10
2
4
5
Primemover + Trailer
Forklift 5 MT
2
2
150,000
50,000
300,000
100,000
5
10
6
7
Forklift 3 MT
Forklift Maniscopic
2
1
40,000
100,000
80,000
100,000
10
10
8
9
Vehicle (4WD/Passenger/Security)
Security Equipment (CCTV, etc)
10
1
50,000
75,000
500,000
75,000
5
5
1 set
1
200,000
200,000
200,000
200,000
10
2
10
11
12
13
Oilspill Eqt
Maint & Fabrication eqt
1
1
1,000,000
800,000
1,000,000
800,000
10
10
14
15
Communications
Harbour Tug
1
1
500,000
2,500,000
500,000
2,500,000
2
10
16
17
1
1
2,000,000
1,500,000
2,000,000
1,500,000
10
5
TOTAL
12,855,000
III - 60
Mnthly
Yearly
Remarks
Personnel Expense
US$270,438
US$3,242,250
Operating Expense
US$268,768
US$3,225,214
Business Expense
US$106,688
US$1,280,250
TOTAL Opex
US$645,893
US$7,750,714
III - 61
c. Helipad at airport is upgraded and helicraft based out of the Suai airport for
crew change and helivac.
d. Intermodal connectivity of the Suai Supply Base with the Suai Airport and
Suai City.
e. LCT / Ship line with regular run between Suai and Lamongan.
f. New acreage release in 4Q 2011 for the remaining lots in TLEA and JPDA.
g. Mandate the usage of Suai Supply Base for all Oil and Gas activities in TLEA
and JPDA as well as future onshore activities. From the onset of operations,
the contracts for support in Bayu-Udan and Kitan must be awarded to Suai
Supply Base.
h. There are no costs associated with obtaining all relevant consents,
authorizations and approvals for ownership, construction, maintenance and
operations of the Suai Supply Base.
i.
Once all the relevant standards are in place, grant an international public port
license to the operator of the Suai Supply Base. Consolidate all port activities
for the southern regions into the Suai Supply Base.
j.
k. All goods, materials and equipment for the construction, maintenance and
operations at the Suai Supply Base shall not be subject to any import duty,
excise duty or value added tax of any form.
Breakwater is built to shelter the port during inclement weather and give the
Suai Supply Base year round (365/24) operating capability.
The project is given the go ahead by May 2011. This will give the project team
time to complete construction of the breakwater and jetty during the calmer
III - 62
months. The Suai Supply Base is operational by December 2012, with some
construction continuing for a further 6 months.
-
In 2015, additional exploration of the Greater Sunrise field with 6 wells and 3
supply boats to support the drill ship. This program goes on for 6 months.
Sunrise then goes into production in 2018.
The PSCs agree to the rates for the facilities and services at Suai Supply Base
as forecasted.
For simplicity of presentation, the revenue and financial modeling does not
take into account any inflation in the revenue (i.e. rates of services) or
operating cost. This allows us to better demonstrate volume growth or
decline over a period of 10 years. In reality, it would be possible to increase
rates periodically to cover rising costs and operating expenditure due to
inflation.
The revenue scenarios are only forecasted and beyond the control of the
operator to make happen.
III - 63
Qty
UOM
MiniShorebase
Maintenance Cost
Fuel storage
Yard Labour
W/H Labour
1
10%
3,000
14
4
each
Unit Price
(US$)
36,000
MT
Pax
Pax
12
1,500
3,000
Oilspill Equipment
Set
5,000
TOTAL
Per month
(US$)
36,000
3,600
36,000
21,000
12,000
5,000
113,600
1,363,200
Remarks
UOM
Unit Price
(US$)
150
100
MT
MT
10
8
200
MT
15
TOTAL
Revenue
(US$)
1,500
800
1,000
3,000
6,350
25,400
304,800
Remarks
Purely stevedoring /
cargodoring cost (5 + 5)
Min per call = 50MT
Min 3hrs at $1,000
Min per call = 200MT
per boat call
per month assuming 4 boat
calls a month
per year
UOM
Fuel
Water
300
300
MT
MT
330
600
Hrs
MT
MT
Unit Price
(US$)
Revenue
(US$)
10
8
3,000
2,400
15
2
TOTAL
2,500
4,950
1,200
14,050
281,000
Remarks
Purely stevedoring /
cargodoring cost (5 + 5)
Min per call = 50MT
3 hrs min + 3hrs at $500 per
hour after
Min per call = 200MT
per boat call
for 20 boat calls a month
III - 64
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,363,200
304,800
304,800
304,800
304,800
304,800
304,800
304,800
Maintenance ^^
50,800
50,800
50,800
50,800
50,800
50,800
50,800
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,363,200
304,800
304,800
304,800
304,800
304,800
304,800
304,800
50,800
50,800
50,800
50,800
50,800
50,800
50,800
Sunrise MSB
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,363,200
Sunrise (Development)
^^^
1,686,000
500,000
500,000
304,800
304,800
50,800
50,800
5,156,400
5,156,400
Production ^
Maintenance ^^
3,437,600
3,437,600
6,486,800
5,300,800
5,300,800
Table III 10 : Revenue from oil and gas activities in Kitan, Bayu Udan and Sunrise
III - 65
It is clear from the table above that Oil and Gas activities from the existing fields will
be unable to even cover operating expenses. We anticipate the Government of
Timor-Leste will release new acreage in Dec 2011 and have projected the exploration
drilling programs for this new acreage as follows:
-
Each PSC will lease a MSB for 2 years. The 2 PSCs in TLEA will commence in
2013 and the 2 in JPDA will commence in 2015.
Each PSC will engage in 2 drilling programs on the 2nd year. Each drilling
program is for 2 months with 20 boatcalls per month.
1 each in TLEA and JPDA will be successful in their 2nd exploration well. Each
will then drill 2 additional appraisal wells, similarly each drilling program will
be for 2 months with 20 boat calls a month.
The team considered business prospects from the Inpex Masela and the ENI West
Timor activities in an attempt to increase revenue. The SUAI Supply Base would be
the closest facility to these locations. Inpex Masela requires a Supply Base to support
the proposed floating LNG development. At the present time, ENI (the operator of
Kitan field) is conducting seismic activities in West Timor, and has a commitment to
the Government of Indonesia to drill 1 exploration well. The CEO Eastlog approached
BPMIGAS in an effort to explore the possibility of these 2 activities using Suai as its
Supply Base. The response from BPMIGAS was that this was against the Government
of Indonesias policy.
III - 66
Based on the above assumptions, the table below shows the EBITDA (US$) expected
from offshore Oil and Gas activities.
Description
2013
3,437,600
1,363,200
Exploration Boatcalls ^
New Acreage PSC B MSB
2014
3,437,600
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
6,486,800
5,300,800
5,300,800
5,156,400
5,156,400
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,363,200
500,000
500,000
1,363,200
1,363,200
500,000
500,000
1,363,200
1,124,000
1,363,200
1,363,200
Exploration Boatcalls ^
1,124,000
Appraisal Boatcalls ^^
1,124,000
Development
1,686,000
Project work
Production
New Acreage PSC C MSB
1,363,200
Exploration Boatcalls ^
1,363,200
1,124,000
1,363,200
1,363,200
Exploration Boatcalls ^
1,124,000
Appraisal Boatcalls ^^
1,124,000
Development
1,363,200
1,686,000
Project work
Production
TOTAL O&G Offshore
Operating Expenses
Management Fee ^^^
EBITDA
^
^^
^^^
6,164,000
9,536,000
10,576,400
12,762,400
11,399,200
8,882,800
8,882,800
(7,750,714)
(7,750,714)
(7,750,714)
(7,750,714)
(7,750,714)
(7,750,714)
(7,750,714)
(208,920)
(310,080)
(341,292)
(406,872)
(365,976)
(290,484)
(290,484)
(1,795,634)
1,475,206
2,484,394
4,604,814
3,282,510
841,602
841,602
III - 67
3.5.8. Profit and Loss (All Oil and Gas revenue, Offshore + Onshore)
To complete the Oil and Gas picture, we went ahead to model revenue that can be
expected from onshore Oil and Gas activities. This is assumed to commence in 2016
as follows:
- 1 onshore PSC in residence.
- The PSC will lease a MiniShoreBase (2 Hectare yard, 1,000m2 Warehouse and
office space).
- During exploration, there will be 4 boat calls per month with 2,000MT of
cargo per month. Exploration takes 24 months.
- During production, only 1 boat call per month and cargo services down to
200MT per month.
Onshore Drilling Exploration (Boat calls)
Qty
Fuel
Water
Port and Berthing
Cargo services
100
50
3
500
UOM
Unit Price
(US$)
MT
MT
Hrs
MT
10
8
350
15
TOTAL
Revenue
(US$)
1,000
400
1,050
7,500
9,950
39,800
477,600
Remarks
Purely stevedoring /
cargodoring cost (5 + 5)
Min per call = 50MT
Min per call = 200MT
per boat call
per month assuming 4
boat calls a month
per year
100
50
3
200
UOM
Unit Price
(US$)
MT
MT
Hrs
MT
10
8
350
15
TOTAL
Revenue
(US$)
1,000
400
1,050
3,000
5,450
5,450
65,400
Remarks
Purely stevedoring /
cargodoring cost (5 + 5)
Min per call = 50MT
Min per call = 200MT
per boat call
per month assuming 1
boat call a month
per year
III - 68
UOM
Unit Price
(US$)
0.1
500
Yard Labour
W/H Labour
Oilspill Equipment
12
Per month
(US$)
30,000
3,000
6,000
14
4
pax
pax
1,500
3,000
21,000
12,000
set
5,000
TOTAL
72,000
864,000
Remarks
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
3,437,600
3,437,600
6,486,800
5,300,800
5,300,800
5,156,400
5,156,400
2,726,400
6,098,400
4,089,600
7,461,600
6,098,400
3,726,400
3,726,400
1,341,600
1,341,600
929,400
929,400
6,164,000
9,536,000
10,576,400
14,104,000
12,740,800
9,812,200
9,812,200
(7,750,714)
(7,750,714)
(7,750,714)
(7,750,714)
(7,750,714)
(7,750,714)
(7,750,714)
(208,920)
(310,080)
(341,292)
(447,120)
(406,224)
(318,366)
(318,366)
(1,795,634)
1,475,206
2,848,,394
5,906,116
4,583,862
1,743,120
1,743,120
Table III 15 : Summary of revenue from oil and gas activities (offshore and onshore)
III - 69
In order to demonstrate the effect of such revenue sources, we have made the
following assumptions on revenue opportunities:
i)
The Suai Supply Base can generate revenue from liquid storage
activities. This is modeled as follows:
a. 50% of tank capacity at Suai Supply Base will be leased out for a
fuel trader/distributor to use. (i.e. 1 X 3,000kl tank and 1 X 500kl
tank)
b. Storage cost is charged at US$10/kl for the first turn, US$6/kl for
the 2nd turn and US$4/kl for the 3rd turn per month. One turn is
defined as storage of one full capacity tank. For example, if the
operator stores 5,000kl for that month (i.e. initial 3,000kl + 1 top
up of 2,000kl), he will be charged 3,000klXSU$10 for the first turn
and 2,000klXUS$6 for a portion of the 2nd turn.
c. Port charges are US$2 per kl.
d. Volume assumption are that the fuel sales will cover 1 turn a
month for the 1st year, 2 turns a month for the 2nd year and 3
turns a month for the 3rd year. Subsequent years will stay constant
at 3 turns a month.
e. Volume growth is based on anticipated growth of economic
activity stimulated by the availability of the port for cargo
shipment and intermodal connectivity.
1st yr
3,000
36,000
432,000
3,000kl Tank
2nd yr
6,000
60,000
720,000
3rd yr
9,000
78,000
936,000
1st yr
500
6,000
72,000
500kl Tank
2nd yr
1,000
10,000
120,000
3rd yr
1,500
13,000
156,000
Non oil and gas cargo, commencing in 2015. This revenue is estimated
based on our experience at Lamongan Shore Base, that within 2 years
from operations, entrepreneurs will identify and capitalize on
opportunities created by the availability of a port for non oil and gas
cargo and a regular liner service to import and export goods and
materials.
III - 70
iii)
Commercial dry bulk cargo from 2014 onwards. This commercial dry
bulk can be from mining activities (export) or from other potential
bulk cargo (limestone, coal, trass/cement, fertilizer, etc). Commercial
dry bulk customers would lease a stockpile yard at Suai Supply Base.
Material is trucked in/out of the Suai Supply Base continuously. For
export, the material is loaded onto barges (10,000MT barge) via
purpose built conveyor system. For import, the dry bulk is transferred
to the stockpile at the yard. Trucks will then pick the material up from
the yard.
The financial model below assumes there is no capex associated with
setting up a conveyor system. In reality, the throughput charges will
be higher than the US$2 in the table, with the additional charges
being used to finance the construction of such a conveyor system.
During period of higher Oil and Gas activity, the throughput of
commercial dry bulk is estimated at only 100,000MT. From 2018
onwards, when Oil and Gas drilling activities is expected to taper off,
the volume of dry bulk is then estimated to grow and increase to
150,000MT.
Yard Rental
Throughput of material
Vessel berthing
Qty
UOM
50,000
100,000
10
m2
m3
call
Unit Price
(US$)
2
2
2,000
TOTAL
Per month
(US$)
100,000
200,000
20,000
320,000
3,840,000
Remarks
Per month
Per year
III - 71
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
O&G Activities
Description
6,164,000
9,536,000
10,576,400
14,104,000
12,740,800
9,812,200
9,812,200
Liquid Storage
Revenue
504,000
840,000
1,092,000
1,092,000
1,092,000
1,092,000
1,092,000
6,668,000
10,376,000
11,668,400
15,196,000
13,832,800
10,904,200
10,904,200
Operating Expenses
Management Fee
(7,750,714)
(224,040)
(7,750,714)
(335,280)
(7,750,714)
(374,052)
(7,750,714)
(479,880)
(7,750,714)
(438,984)
(7,750,714)
(351,126)
(7,750,714)
(351,126)
EBITDA
(1,306,754)
2,290,006
3,543,634
6,965,406
5,643,102
2,802,360
2,802,360
Table III 18 : Summary of revenue from oil and gas + liquid storage activities
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
O&G Activities
Description
6,164,000
9,536,000
10,576,400
14,104,000
12,740,800
9,812,200
9,812,200
Liquid Storage
Revenue
504,000
840,000
1,092,000
1,092,000
1,092,000
1,092,000
1,092,000
240,000
360,000
1,000,000
1,000,000
1,000,000
3,840,000
3,840,000
3,840,000
3,840,000
5,760,000
5,760,000
6,668,000
14,216,000
15,748,400
19,396,000
18,672,800
17,664,200
17,664,200
Operating Expenses
Management Fee
(7,750,714)
(224,040)
(7,750,714)
(450,480)
(7,750,714)
(496,452)
(7,750,714)
(605,880)
(7,750,714)
(584,184)
(7,750,714)
(553,926)
(7,750,714)
(553,926)
EBITDA
(1,306,754)
6,014,806
7,501,234
11,039,406
10,337,902
9,539,560
9,539,560
Table III 19 : Summary of revenue from all available cargo Supply Base Plus
III - 72
Description
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
Kitan MSB
Production Boatcalls
Maintenance Boatcalls
Well shutdown
1,363,200
304,800
50,800
1,363,200
304,800
50,800
1,363,200
304,800
50,800
1,363,200
304,800
50,800
1,363,200
304,800
50,800
1,363,200
304,800
50,800
1,363,200
304,800
50,800
1,363,200
304,800
50,800
1,363,200
304,800
50,800
1,363,200
304,800
50,800
1,000,000
1,363,200
304,800
50,800
1,363,200
304,800
50,800
1,363,200
304,800
50,800
1,363,200
304,800
50,800
1,363,200
304,800
50,800
1,363,200
304,800
50,800
1,363,200
304,800
50,800
1,363,200
304,800
50,800
1,363,200
304,800
50,800
1,363,200
304,800
50,800
1,363,200
1,686,000
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,363,200
500,000
500,000
304,800
50,800
304,800
50,800
304,800
50,800
304,800
50,800
304,800
50,800
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,363,200
500,000
500,000
304,800
304,800
304,800
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,363,200
Sunrise MSB
Sunrise (Development)
Sunrise (Project work)
Sunrise (Production)
Maintenance
New Acreage PSC A MSB
Exploration Boatcalls
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,124,000
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,124,000
1,124,000
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,686,000
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,124,000
1,363,200
1,363,200
1,124,000
1,124,000
504,000
1,363,200
1,363,200
500,000
500,000
304,800
304,800
304,800
1,341,600
1,341,600
929,400
929,400
929,400
929,400
929,400
1,092,000
1,092,000
1,092,000
1,092,000
1,092,000
1,092,000
1,092,000
840,000
1,092,000
240,000
360,000
1,000,000
1,000,000
1,000,000
1,000,000
1,000,000
1,000,000
3,840,000
3,840,000
3,840,000
3,840,000
5,760,000
5,760,000
5,760,000
5,760,000
5,760,000
9,536,000
9,536,000
10,376,000
14,216,000
10,576,400
10,576,400
11,668,400
15,748,400
12,762,400
14,104,000
15,196,000
19,396,000
11,399,200
12,740,800
13,832,800
18,672,800
8,882,800
9,812,200
10,904,200
17,664,200
8,882,800
9,812,200
10,904,200
17,664,200
8,492,400
9,421,800
10,513,800
17,273,800
8,492,400
9,421,800
10,513,800
17,273,800
9,492,400
10,421,800
11,513,800
18,273,800
Commercial cargo
1,363,200
1,686,000
Onshore drilling
Liquid Storage Revenue
1,363,200
Table III 20 : Revenue Forecast (2013 to 2022) from all available cargo Supply Base Plus
III - 73
O&G (Offshore)
O&G (Total)
O&G (Total) + Liquid Storage
Supply Base Plus - All Cargo
2013
(1,795,634)
(1,795,634)
(1,306,754)
(1,306,754)
2014
1,475,206
1,475,206
2,290,006
6,014,806
2015
2,484,394
2,484,394
3,543,634
7,501,234
2016
4,604,814
5,906,166
6,965,406
11,039,406
2017
3,282,510
4,583,862
5,643,102
10,337,902
2018
841,602
1,743,120
2,802,360
9,359,560
2019
841,602
1,743,120
2,802,360
9,359,560
2020
462,914
1,364,432
2,423,672
8,980,872
2021
462,914
1,364,432
2,423,672
8,980,872
2022
1,432,914
2,334,432
3,393,672
9,950,872
III - 74
3.5.10.
To understand the commercial viability of the Suai Supply Base, the final step is to
calculate the Net Present Value and Internal Rate of Return over 20 years for the
Project. We also identified 2 cases from the revenue models above to fun this
analysis. To do this, we took the revenue models from 2 cases above, namely 2)
Revenue from Oil and Gas (Total) and 4) Supply Base Plus All Available Cargo.
The Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) of a project is the minimum return
that the project must earn to satisfy its creditors, owners and other providers of
capital, or they will invest elsewhere. For the purposes of the Suai Supply Base, we
will use a WACC of 8%. This is lower than what is typical in Indonesia (15%), however
a large part of this project is expected to be funded by the Government as a strategic
infrastructure project and thus a lower yield is not unreasonable.
The Net Present Value (NPV) of a project over a defined period is a sum of all
discounted cash flow over that period (i.e. the cash flow is discounted by the WACC
over time to reflect its present value). This is a standard method for using the time
value of money to appraise long term projects. For our calculation of Net Present
Value, the initial capex is excluded from the year 0 cashflow. A measure of the
profitability of a project is thus the comparison of the NPV against the initial outflow
of capital (i.e. Capex outlay). For our analysis, we have calculated the NPV of the
project over a period of 20 years, which is typical for an infrastructure project. As our
revenue model extends only out to 10 years, the subsequent 10 years (2023 to 2032)
are assumed the same as 2022 which is not an unreasonable assumption. This is
purely for the purposes of modeling the financial viability. Forecasts of revenue
beyond 10 years are unreliable at best, and have very limited value.
The Internal Rate of Return (IRR) is a rate of return used in capital budgeting to
measure and compare the profitability of investments. The free cash flow year on
year is compared against the initial capex outlay to give a rate of return on the
investment (i.e. Capex cost). The IRR calculation used in our analysis is a simple rate
of return and does not take into consideration any cost of capital. Another way of
looking at the IRR of an investment is the interest rate at which the net present value
of costs (negative cash flows) equals the net present value of benefits (positive cash
flows). In theory, all projects with an IRR that exceed the cost of capital (WACC) is a
commercially viable one. As with the NPV, the IRR has been calculated over 20 years.
III - 75
Three scenarios were run for each of the 2 cases to calculate the NPV and IRR. The 3
scenarios are described below:
Scenario 1: Full Capex Model. In this scenario, the full cost of the infrastructure
(Breakwater, Jetty/Dock, Building and facilities) as well as the operating
assets are borne by the business venture and return on investment
needs to fully compensate all of this.
Scenario 2: Build, Own and Operate Model. In this scenario, the cost of the
breakwater and earthworks has been removed from the cost of project
setup for the Suai venture. Return on investment needs to only
compensate the Buildings & Facilities and all operating assets.
Scenario 3: Terminal Operatorship Model. In this scenario, it is assumed that the
cost of infrastructure is purely borne by the Government of Timor-Leste
as a project of national interest. Operating assets are the only
investment of the joint venture. The Government of Timor-Leste then
enters into a revenue sharing agreement with the Supply Base operator
for 20% of total revenue off the topline.
The first scenario is provided to demonstrate the negative effect of the cost of the
breakwater and land improvements on the project viability. It is not common for
commercial projects to bear the cost of breakwaters.
The second and third scenarios would be more commonly used in a public-sector /
private sector partnership.
The second scenario is envisaged because this location requires the construction of a
breakwater to make the site a viable site. Under such cases, it is normal for the
Government in question to undertake the necessary works to make the location
viable. An example of this can be seen in the 12.9Ha dredging to provide access to
the channel that will be undertaken by the Australian government in the Darwin
Supply Base project.
The last scenario is called terminal operatorship. One example of this is Tanjong
Priok in Indonesia. The Government builds the terminal and retains ownership and
control of the facilities as a strategic national asset. The operator brings the
operating capital assets and manages the facilities, with a revenue sharing model.
The following tables show the results of the 6 different scenarios.
III - 76
Scenario 1:
Full Capex Model
Revenue: Oil and Gas (Total)
Year 0
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
Revenue
6,164,000
9,536,000
10,576,400
14,104,000
12,740,800
9,812,200
9,812,200
9,421,800
9,421,800
10,421,800
Operating Expenses
Outsourced Variable Management Fee
(7,750,714)
(208,920)
(7,750,714)
(310,080)
(7,750,714)
(341,292)
(7,750,714)
(406,872)
(7,750,714)
(365,976)
(7,750,714)
(290,484)
(7,750,714)
(290,484)
(7,750,714)
(278,772)
(7,750,714)
(278,772)
(7,750,714)
(308,772)
EBITDA
(1,795,634)
1,475,206
2,484,394
5,946,414
4,624,110
1,771,002
1,771,002
1,392,314
1,392,314
2,362,314
Depreciation:
- Infrastructure
- Operating Assets
(13,658,125)
(2,003,000)
(13,658,125)
(2,003,000)
(13,658,125)
(1,403,000)
(13,658,125)
(1,403,000)
(13,658,125)
(1,403,000)
(13,658,125)
(928,000)
(13,658,125)
(928,000)
(13,658,125)
(928,000)
(13,658,125)
(928,000)
(13,658,125)
(928,000)
EBIT
(17,456,759)
(14,185,919)
(12,576,731)
(9,114,711)
(10,437,015)
(12,815,123)
(12,815,123)
(13,193,811)
(13,193,811)
(12,223,811)
(17,456,759)
0%
(17,456,759)
15,661,125
(14,185,919)
0%
(14,185,919)
15,661,125
(12,576,731)
0%
(12,576,731)
15,061,125
(9,114,711)
0%
(9,114,711)
15,061,125
(10,437,015)
0%
(10,437,015)
15,061,125
(12,815,123)
0%
(12,815,123)
14,586,125
(12,815,123)
0%
(12,815,123)
14,586,125
(13,193,811)
0%
(13,193,811)
14,586,125
(13,193,811)
0%
(13,193,811)
14,586,125
(12,223,811)
0%
(12,223,811)
14,586,125
(1,795,634)
8%
1.08
(1,662,624)
1,475,206
8%
1.17
1,264,751
2,484,394
8%
1.26
1,972,192
5,946,414
8%
1.36
4,370,792
4,624,110
8%
1.47
3,147,092
1,771,002
8%
1.59
1,116,032
1,771,002
8%
1.71
1,033,363
1,392,314
8%
1.85
752,224
1,392,314
8%
2.00
696,504
2,362,314
8%
2.16
1,094,208
Free Cash Flow = EBIT x (1-T) + Depreciation - Changes in Working Capital - Capex
EBIT
Tax Rate
After-tax EBIT
Depreciation
Capex
Free Cash Flow
WACC (%)
Discounting factor
Discounted value of FCFs
NPV
IRR
(286,017,500)
(286,017,500)
1.00
18,111,936.91
#DIV/0!
This scenario is for a pure Oil and Gas revenue model, with the full infrastructure Capex taken into consideration.
NPV for this scenario falls very far short of the initial Capex outlay. This structure is not commercially viable.
III - 77
Scenario 2:
Full Capex Model
Revenue: Oil and Gas + Commercial cargo
Year 0
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
Revenue
6,668,000
14,216,000
15,748,400
19,396,000
18,672,800
17,664,200
17,664,200
17,273,800
17,273,800
18,273,800
Operating Expenses
Outsourced Variable Management Fee
(7,750,714)
(208,920)
(7,750,714)
(310,080)
(7,750,714)
(341,292)
(7,750,714)
(406,872)
(7,750,714)
(365,976)
(7,750,714)
(290,484)
(7,750,714)
(290,484)
(7,750,714)
(278,772)
(7,750,714)
(278,772)
(7,750,714)
(308,772)
EBITDA
(1,291,634)
6,155,206
7,656,394
11,238,414
10,556,110
9,623,002
9,623,002
9,244,314
9,244,314
10,214,314
Depreciation:
- Infrastructure
- Operating Assets
(13,658,125)
(2,003,000)
(13,658,125)
(2,003,000)
(13,658,125)
(1,403,000)
(13,658,125)
(1,403,000)
(13,658,125)
(1,403,000)
(13,658,125)
(928,000)
(13,658,125)
(928,000)
(13,658,125)
(928,000)
(13,658,125)
(928,000)
(13,658,125)
(928,000)
EBIT
(16,952,759)
(9,505,919)
(7,404,731)
(3,822,711)
(4,505,015)
(4,963,123)
(4,963,123)
(5,341,811)
(5,341,811)
(4,371,811)
(16,952,759)
0%
(16,952,759)
15,661,125
(9,505,919)
0%
(9,505,919)
15,661,125
(7,404,731)
0%
(7,404,731)
15,061,125
(3,822,711)
0%
(3,822,711)
15,061,125
(4,505,015)
0%
(4,505,015)
15,061,125
(4,963,123)
0%
(4,963,123)
14,586,125
(4,963,123)
0%
(4,963,123)
14,586,125
(5,341,811)
0%
(5,341,811)
14,586,125
(5,341,811)
0%
(5,341,811)
14,586,125
(4,371,811)
0%
(4,371,811)
14,586,125
(1,291,634)
8%
1.08
(1,195,957)
6,155,206
8%
1.17
5,277,097
7,656,394
8%
1.26
6,077,892
11,238,414
8%
1.36
8,260,570
10,556,110
8%
1.47
7,184,311
9,623,002
8%
1.59
6,064,124
9,623,002
8%
1.71
5,614,929
9,244,314
8%
1.85
4,994,415
9,244,314
8%
2.00
4,624,459
10,214,314
8%
2.16
4,731,204
Free Cash Flow = EBIT x (1-T) + Depreciation - Changes in Working Capital - Capex
EBIT
Tax Rate
After-tax EBIT
Depreciation
Capex
Free Cash Flow
WACC (%)
Discounting factor
Discounted value of FCFs
NPV
IRR
(286,017,500)
(286,017,500)
1.00
80,364,981.34
-4.1%
In this scenario, the revenue model is that for a Supply Base Plus All Available Cargo. It assumes the Supply Base is the de facto port
facility in the south for all cargo. The full infrastructure capex is applied to the project.
Even with the full revenue of all available cargo, the NPV in this scenario falls far short of the Capex investment. The IRR is negative.
Undertaking the project with this structure is not commercially viable.
III - 78
Scenario 3:
Build, Own and Operate Model
Revenue: Oil and Gas (Total)
Year 0
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
Revenue
6,164,000
9,536,000
10,576,400
14,104,000
12,740,800
9,812,200
9,812,200
9,421,800
9,421,800
10,421,800
Operating Expenses
Outsourced Variable Management Fee
(7,750,714)
(208,920)
(7,750,714)
(310,080)
(7,750,714)
(341,292)
(7,750,714)
(406,872)
(7,750,714)
(365,976)
(7,750,714)
(290,484)
(7,750,714)
(290,484)
(7,750,714)
(278,772)
(7,750,714)
(278,772)
(7,750,714)
(308,772)
EBITDA
(1,795,634)
1,475,206
2,484,394
5,946,414
4,624,110
1,771,002
1,771,002
1,392,314
1,392,314
2,362,314
Depreciation:
- Infrastructure
- Operating Assets
(3,431,707)
(2,003,000)
(3,431,707)
(2,003,000)
(3,431,707)
(1,403,000)
(3,431,707)
(1,403,000)
(3,431,707)
(1,403,000)
(3,431,707)
(928,000)
(3,431,707)
(928,000)
(3,431,707)
(928,000)
(3,431,707)
(928,000)
(3,431,707)
(928,000)
EBIT
(7,230,341)
(3,959,501)
(2,350,313)
1,111,707
(210,597)
(2,588,705)
(2,588,705)
(2,967,393)
(2,967,393)
(1,997,393)
(7,230,341)
0%
(7,230,341)
5,434,707
(3,959,501)
0%
(3,959,501)
5,434,707
(2,350,313)
0%
(2,350,313)
4,834,707
1,111,707
0%
1,111,707
4,834,707
(210,597)
0%
(210,597)
4,834,707
(2,588,705)
0%
(2,588,705)
4,359,707
(2,588,705)
0%
(2,588,705)
4,359,707
(2,967,393)
0%
(2,967,393)
4,359,707
(2,967,393)
0%
(2,967,393)
4,359,707
(1,997,393)
0%
(1,997,393)
4,359,707
(1,795,634)
8%
1.08
(1,662,624)
1,475,206
8%
1.17
1,264,751
2,484,394
8%
1.26
1,972,192
5,946,414
8%
1.36
4,370,792
4,624,110
8%
1.47
3,147,092
1,771,002
8%
1.59
1,116,032
1,771,002
8%
1.71
1,033,363
1,392,314
8%
1.85
752,224
1,392,314
8%
2.00
696,504
2,362,314
8%
2.16
1,094,208
Free Cash Flow = EBIT x (1-T) + Depreciation - Changes in Working Capital - Capex
EBIT
Tax Rate
After-tax EBIT
Depreciation
Capex
Free Cash Flow
WACC (%)
Discounting factor
Discounted value of FCFs
NPV
IRR
(81,530,000)
(81,530,000)
1.00
18,111,936.91
-7.4%
This scenario is for a pure Oil and Gas revenue model, with the infrastructure Capex (less breakwater and earthworks) taken into
consideration.
NPV for this scenario still falls short of the initial Capex outlay. This structure is not commercially viable.
III - 79
Scenario 4:
Build, Own and Operate Model
Revenue: Oil and Gas + Commercial cargo
Year 0
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
Revenue
6,668,000
14,216,000
15,748,400
19,396,000
18,672,800
17,664,200
17,664,200
17,273,800
17,273,800
18,273,800
Operating Expenses
Outsourced Variable Management Fee
(7,750,714)
(208,920)
(7,750,714)
(310,080)
(7,750,714)
(341,292)
(7,750,714)
(406,872)
(7,750,714)
(365,976)
(7,750,714)
(290,484)
(7,750,714)
(290,484)
(7,750,714)
(278,772)
(7,750,714)
(278,772)
(7,750,714)
(308,772)
EBITDA
(1,291,634)
6,155,206
7,656,394
11,238,414
10,556,110
9,623,002
9,623,002
9,244,314
9,244,314
10,214,314
Depreciation:
- Infrastructure
- Operating Assets
(3,431,707)
(2,003,000)
(3,431,707)
(2,003,000)
(3,431,707)
(1,403,000)
(3,431,707)
(1,403,000)
(3,431,707)
(1,403,000)
(3,431,707)
(928,000)
(3,431,707)
(928,000)
(3,431,707)
(928,000)
(3,431,707)
(928,000)
(3,431,707)
(928,000)
EBIT
(6,726,341)
720,499
2,821,687
6,403,707
5,721,403
5,263,295
5,263,295
4,884,607
4,884,607
5,854,607
(6,726,341)
0%
(6,726,341)
5,434,707
720,499
0%
720,499
5,434,707
2,821,687
0%
2,821,687
4,834,707
6,403,707
0%
6,403,707
4,834,707
5,721,403
0%
5,721,403
4,834,707
5,263,295
0%
5,263,295
4,359,707
5,263,295
0%
5,263,295
4,359,707
4,884,607
0%
4,884,607
4,359,707
4,884,607
0%
4,884,607
4,359,707
5,854,607
0%
5,854,607
4,359,707
(1,291,634)
8%
1.08
(1,195,957)
6,155,206
8%
1.17
5,277,097
7,656,394
8%
1.26
6,077,892
11,238,414
8%
1.36
8,260,570
10,556,110
8%
1.47
7,184,311
9,623,002
8%
1.59
6,064,124
9,623,002
8%
1.71
5,614,929
9,244,314
8%
1.85
4,994,415
9,244,314
8%
2.00
4,624,459
10,214,314
8%
2.16
4,731,204
Free Cash Flow = EBIT x (1-T) + Depreciation - Changes in Working Capital - Capex
EBIT
Tax Rate
After-tax EBIT
Depreciation
Capex
Free Cash Flow
WACC (%)
Discounting factor
Discounted value of FCFs
NPV
IRR
(81,530,000)
(81,530,000)
1.00
80,364,981.34
7.8%
In this scenario, the revenue model is that for a Supply Base Plus All Available Cargo. It assumes the Supply Base is the de facto port
facility in the south for all cargo. Only the infrastructure Capex (less breakwater and earthworks) is taken into consideration.
NPV for this scenario barely allows the project to break even after 20 years. The IRR is 7.8%, just slightly lower than the WACC of 8%.
III - 80
Scenario 5:
Terminal Ownership Model
Revenue: Oil and Gas (Total)
Year 0
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
Revenue
6,164,000
9,536,000
10,576,400
14,104,000
12,740,800
9,812,200
9,812,200
9,421,800
9,421,800
10,421,800
Operating Expenses
Outsourced Variable Management Fee
SiteLease
(7,750,714)
(208,920)
(1,232,800)
(7,750,714)
(310,080)
(1,907,200)
(7,750,714)
(341,292)
(2,115,280)
(7,750,714)
(406,872)
(2,820,800)
(7,750,714)
(365,976)
(2,548,160)
(7,750,714)
(290,484)
(1,962,440)
(7,750,714)
(290,484)
(1,962,440)
(7,750,714)
(278,772)
(1,884,360)
(7,750,714)
(278,772)
(1,884,360)
(7,750,714)
(308,772)
(2,084,360)
EBITDA
(3,028,434)
(431,994)
369,114
3,125,614
2,075,950
(191,438)
(191,438)
(492,046)
(492,046)
277,954
Depreciation:
- Infrastructure
- Operating Assets
(2,003,000)
(2,003,000)
(1,403,000)
(1,403,000)
(1,403,000)
(928,000)
(928,000)
(928,000)
(928,000)
(928,000)
EBIT
(5,031,434)
(2,434,994)
(1,033,886)
1,722,614
672,950
(1,119,438)
(1,119,438)
(1,420,046)
(1,420,046)
(650,046)
Free Cash Flow = EBIT x (1-T) + Depreciation - Changes in Working Capital - Capex
EBIT
Tax Rate
After-tax EBIT
Depreciation
Capex
Free Cash Flow
WACC (%)
Discounting factor
Discounted value of FCFs
NPV
IRR
(12,855,000)
(12,855,000)
1.00
(5,031,434)
0%
(5,031,434)
2,003,000
(2,434,994)
0%
(2,434,994)
2,003,000
(1,033,886)
0%
(1,033,886)
1,403,000
1,722,614
0%
1,722,614
1,403,000
672,950
0%
672,950
1,403,000
(1,119,438)
0%
(1,119,438)
928,000
(1,119,438)
0%
(1,119,438)
928,000
(1,420,046)
0%
(1,420,046)
928,000
(1,420,046)
0%
(1,420,046)
928,000
(650,046)
0%
(650,046)
928,000
(3,028,434)
8%
1.08
(2,804,106)
(431,994)
8%
1.17
(370,365)
369,114
8%
1.26
293,015
3,125,614
8%
1.36
2,297,420
2,075,950
8%
1.47
1,412,857
(191,438)
8%
1.59
(120,638)
(191,438)
8%
1.71
(111,702)
(492,046)
8%
1.85
(265,837)
(492,046)
8%
2.00
(246,146)
277,954
8%
2.16
128,746
(1,316,068.16)
#DIV/0!
This scenario is for a pure Oil and Gas revenue model, with no infrastructure Capex and only Capex on operating assets. The facilities
are leased to the operator.
With only Oil and Gas revenue, the Suai Supply Base is unable to cover the cost of the lease. This scenario is not commercially viable.
III - 81
Scenario 6:
Terminal Ownership Model
Revenue: Oil and Gas + Commercial cargo
Year 0
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
Revenue
6,668,000
14,216,000
15,748,400
19,396,000
18,672,800
17,664,200
17,664,200
17,273,800
17,273,800
18,273,800
Operating Expenses
Outsourced Variable Management Fee
SiteLease
(7,750,714)
(208,920)
(1,333,600)
(7,750,714)
(310,080)
(2,843,200)
(7,750,714)
(341,292)
(3,149,680)
(7,750,714)
(406,872)
(3,879,200)
(7,750,714)
(365,976)
(3,734,560)
(7,750,714)
(290,484)
(3,532,840)
(7,750,714)
(290,484)
(3,532,840)
(7,750,714)
(278,772)
(3,454,760)
(7,750,714)
(278,772)
(3,454,760)
(7,750,714)
(308,772)
(3,654,760)
EBITDA
(2,625,234)
3,312,006
4,506,714
7,359,214
6,821,550
6,090,162
6,090,162
5,789,554
5,789,554
6,559,554
Depreciation:
- Infrastructure
- Operating Assets
(2,003,000)
(2,003,000)
(1,403,000)
(1,403,000)
(1,403,000)
(928,000)
(928,000)
EBIT
(4,628,234)
1,309,006
3,103,714
5,956,214
5,418,550
5,162,162
5,162,162
4,861,554
4,861,554
5,631,554
(928,000)
(928,000)
(928,000)
Free Cash Flow = EBIT x (1-T) + Depreciation - Changes in Working Capital - Capex
EBIT
Tax Rate
After-tax EBIT
Depreciation
Capex
Free Cash Flow
WACC (%)
Discounting factor
Discounted value of FCFs
NPV
IRR
(12,855,000)
(12,855,000)
1.00
(4,628,234)
0%
(4,628,234)
2,003,000
1,309,006
0%
1,309,006
2,003,000
3,103,714
0%
3,103,714
1,403,000
5,956,214
0%
5,956,214
1,403,000
5,418,550
0%
5,418,550
1,403,000
5,162,162
0%
5,162,162
928,000
5,162,162
0%
5,162,162
928,000
4,861,554
0%
4,861,554
928,000
4,861,554
0%
4,861,554
928,000
5,631,554
0%
5,631,554
928,000
(2,625,234)
8%
1.08
(2,430,772)
3,312,006
8%
1.17
2,839,511
4,506,714
8%
1.26
3,577,575
7,359,214
8%
1.36
5,409,242
6,821,550
8%
1.47
4,642,632
6,090,162
8%
1.59
3,837,835
6,090,162
8%
1.71
3,553,551
5,789,554
8%
1.85
3,127,916
5,789,554
8%
2.00
2,896,218
6,559,554
8%
2.16
3,038,343
48,486,367.39
28.1%
In this scenario, the revenue model is that for a Supply Base Plus All Available Cargo. It assumes the Supply Base is the de facto port
facility in the south for all cargo. There is no infrastructure Capex and only Capex on operating assets. The facilities are leased to the
operator.
The NPV for this scenario is very healthy and the Project shows a robust 28.1% IRR. This is a commercially viable structure.
III - 82
3.5.11.
Zone C
Zone B
Zone A
The 250Ha in Zone C allocated for the industrial complex can be developed in phases
as demand dictates.
The following key numbers demonstrate the tremendous increase in value of land
adjacent to the port.
-
Revenue from sale of industrial land: 250 X 10,000 X 0.8 X US$150 = US$300Million
Cost of sales: (US$5 + US$20) X 10,000 X 250 = US$62.5Million
Profit before tax: US$237.5Million
III - 83
3.5.12.
NPV (US$)
IRR
NA
-7.4%
NA
-4.1%
7.8%
28.1%
Remarks
Not viable. NPV falls far short of
Capex. Negative IRR.
Not viable. NPV falls short of
Capex. Negative IRR.
Unable to cover site lease. Project
loses money, negative NPV.
Not viable. NPV falls short of
Capex. Negative IRR.
Project breaks even over 20 years.
Healthy NPV and robust IRR.
Project commercially viable.
Table III 22 : Summary of NPV and IRR for the different scenarios
We can draw the following conclusions from the financial modeling done:
1) The revenue from existing fields cannot justify a Supply Base at Suai. The
assumptions on new acreage revenue model are essential for the Suai Supply
Base to have positive operating cashflow but will still not be able to provide
any return on the capital investment.
2) If the Suai Supply Base has only the Oil and Gas industry as its source of
revenue, the project is not commercially viable.
3) With no additional Capex or Opex investments, the addition of revenue
sources from outside the Oil and Gas industry significantly improves the
financials for the Suai Supply Base.
4) As much as the breakwater is essential for the base to be able to operate
365/24, the cost of the breakwater is a significant burden on the project.
With the cost of the breakwater, the Suai Supply Base is not a viable business
venture.
5) Operating as the de facto port facility for the southern region, the Suai Supply
Base is able to generate enough revenue to make it a viable business venture.
III - 84
3.5.13.
Recommendations
As a result of the financial analysis above, the commercial team have the following
recommendations:
-
III - 85
Part IV
Social Impact Study
IV - 1
4.1.
Background
The Government of Timor-Leste intends to build and operate a logistics supply base
to support all offshore Oil and Gas activities in the TLEA and JPDA. A Supply Base
built on Timor-Leste shores to support the Oil and Gas industry will generate much
value both to the Oil and Gas activities in Timor-Leste as well as its supporting
industries. The Suai Supply Base is set to be the catalyst that will launch the social
and economic development of the Southern Region of Timor-Leste. The availability
of port facilities for the movement of cargo will release the full potential the SuaiBetano-Beaco corridor.
As it now stands, Suai is yet to be developed and has very limited infrastructure
support and hence is a challenge to develop. During this phase of rapid change and
progress, there will be a need for better coordination between Government agencies,
development partners and contractors. There is a need also for the Government to
strengthen the regulatory framework within which the development partners,
contractors and local industry will operate. A study of the social impact of the Suai
Supply Base project will allow the Government of Timor-Leste to prioritise its efforts
to assist its citizens as well as local businesses in transitioning to the new economy.
This study will look at the socioeconomic impact of the Suai Supply Base project in
the Suai region. The Suai region is dominated by the Suai city and is the capital
district of Covalima. The entire Covalima district has less than 40,000 inhabitants.
Suai City has a population of less than 10,000. The main economic activity in the
region is small scale farming, mainly for subsistence. It is difficult under the
circumstances to assess the actual rate of employment, however it is low.
Infrastructure is weak compounded by difficulties of transport and communications
between Dili and Suai.
IV - 2
4.2.
Main Activities
The Suai Supply Base project will undergo 2 distinct phases. The first is the
construction phase, during which all the construction activities for the breakwater,
marine and land based facilities will be built.
During the construction phase, the following activities will take place:
-
Work at up to two quarry sites to blast and gather rocks as building material
for the breakwater.
Work at Karau-Ulun river bed to gather rocks and sand as building material
for the breakwater.
Construction of access road (gravel) from the quarry sites and river bed to the
Suai Supply base or LCT loading ramp.
Trucking of materials from the quarry sites and river bed on the access roads
by dump trucks.
Clearing of site for land based facilities, including a helipad (visual landing).
Construction of roads and land based facilities at the Suai Supply Base site in
accordance with the EPC plan.
The second phase will be the operations phase. During the operations phase, the
initial focus will be for the Supply Base to serve as the logistics base for offshore oil
and gas activities in the JPDA and TLEA. Since the port facilities can also serve other
cargo (commercial bulk and container cargo), and as businesses and projects in the
southern region get familiar with the port facilities, commercial cargo is expected to
grow. The port infrastructure and facilities will be available for use by other
businesses in the southern region (liquid fuel storage, commercial cargo, Ro-Ro LCT
ramp, etc) and this will act as a catalyst for general economic activity in the Suai area
and the Southern region as a whole.
IV - 3
IV - 4
4.3.
Social Programs
As part of the efforts to create economic alignment with the local community and
minimize negative social impacts, Eastlog will put in place the following programs:
4.3.1. Create a Community Office (in Suai)
This community office will be staffed by Timorese personnel and will play the
following roles:
i. Single point of contact with the community to provide information as to the
progress of the project, opportunities for jobs, contracts, etc. Help to identify
and promote activities for Timorese nationals in the Suai Supply Base project.
ii. Liaise with the community on all pre-condition surveys to be conducted
before the commencement of work in the vicinity of any buildings or
structures. This will help make sure that these structures are not damaged
during the course of works done as part of the Suai Supply Base project.
iii. Manage any potential environmental (noise and dust) impact or damage
during work and blasting at the quarries.
iv. Encourage the community to build accommodation and assist the community
in defining the requirements and specifications of such accommodation such
that they can be rented out in the future to personnel in the oil and gas
industry.
v. Track the economic development and impact to the community and produce
an annual report available to the public.
Once operations at the Suai Supply Base commences, this community office will be
absorbed into the Suai Supply Base organization structure as a Community Relations
Department.
IV - 5
This creates awareness in the local business community that there is a port
being built and thus cargo volumes start to develop. From our experience, it
takes time (about 5 years from first operation) for cargo volumes to grow to
their full potential. This early creation of the Liner Service will accelerate this
process.
IV - 6
This regular line will continue during operations to provide for global logistics
connectivity. Additional destinations like Darwin or even Singapore and the
Philippines should be explored.
Commercial Cargo development at Lamongan Shorebase in East Java
From experience at Lamongan Shorebase, it takes time (about 5 years from first
operation) for cargo volumes to grow to their full potential. This can be attributed to
the time taken for 1) businesses to realise the opportunities presented by the
availability of nearby port facilities, 2) germinate the idea and mobilise resources and
3) setup and establish full operational capability.
At the start of operations at Lamongan Shorebase, all the focus was on supporting the
Oil and Gas industry and commercial cargo was not promoted or marketed. In the first
year, 100% of business was for Oil and Gas support.
Now, 6 years into operations, the cargo volumes are 70 % commercial to only 30% for
the Oil and Gas industry. This growth came mainly in the 3rd to 5th years of operations,
as we realised this potential and started promoting commercial cargo business.
Since 2006, at least 10 businesses have commenced operations around the Shorebase
purely because of the access to port facilities. These include fertiliser factories, cement,
coal trading, fabrication and importation of tracked vehicles into Indonesia. The
pipeline of new businesses include a major Soya Bean and Soya Bean Meal hub for the
worlds largest Soya Bean producer as well as a seamless pipe manufacturer.
The customers for commercial cargo at Lamongan Shorebase are as far out as 100km
from the port.
The recommendation for the Suai Supply Base is therefore to establish this regular
connectivity as early as possible. This will bring forward the ramp up period for cargo
volumes. Increased cargo volumes mean increased economic activity and the knock-on
effect of job and wealth creation for the community.
IV - 7
IV - 8
4.4.
Socioeconomic Impact
The Suai Supply Base project will impact the lives of Timorese nationals in many ways.
We will look at the impact to the local community from different perspectives:
a) Population, skills development and employment
b) Economic contribution
c) Social conditions
d) Environment
Employment Summary
The construction of the Suai Supply Base at Suai will bring many employment
opportunities for Timor-Leste nationals.
-
IV - 9
o 200 persons will be employed at the Suai Supply Base site by the
contractors for general construction activities.
o 50 persons will be employed at the Suai Supply Base site for local
administration and security
Individuals trained in the various construction vocations (masonry,
electrician, carpentry, etc) will have job opportunities. This is however
only temporary. Once the construction of the Suai Supply Base is
completed, a large part of these positions will disappear and the
individuals will then need to seek continued employ at the other up and
coming projects or in general construction in the Suai area.
-
During Operations
o 200 to 250 locals working at the Suai Supply base. This will be staff of
all levels.
o 18 to 30 locals working at each MiniShoreBase leased by PSCs.
During the operations of the Suai Supply Base, the base will employ 200 220
Timor-Leste Nationals. These jobs will cover the full spectrum of a logistics
supply base operations, from security, logistics, port management and
maintenance through to finance, administration and human resources.
Moreover, each PSC in residence will employ an additional 18 warehouse and
port crew and 4 to 12 administration staff.
Indirect employment
We expect the indirect impact to be an additional 1,000 other support jobs
within the Suai area. This will be in the ancillary support industries for the
provision of accommodation, food and beverage, recreation, transportation
and other services to support the migrant workers to the Suai region.
IV - 10
Industrial estate
The largest job creator by far will come from the impact that port facilities at
Suai will have on industry in the south. If the Government of Timor-Leste
builds an industrial estate next to the Suai Supply Base as recommended, it is
this estate that will create the largest number of employment opportunities,
fueled by the business opportunities generated by the Suai Supply Base. A
typical mid-sized garment factory employs upwards of 3,000 people. An
industrial estate of 250Ha can create more than 10,000 jobs, assuming every
hectare of industrial space has 40 workers (this is a very low estimate).
450
PSC MiniShoreBase
Supply Base Operations
400
350
300
250
200
150
100
50
17
3Q
17
1Q
16
3Q
16
1Q
15
3Q
15
1Q
14
3Q
14
1Q
13
3Q
13
1Q
12
3Q
12
1Q
3Q
11
IV - 11
4.4.1.2.
During the course of their work in the construction of the Suai Supply Base, the
workers will be acquiring experience and skills that they would not otherwise be
exposed to (Quarry blasting works, breakwater and jetty construction, etc). These
experiences and skillsets will greatly improve their marketability for future roles.
The oil and gas industry has been identified by the Government of Timor-Leste as a
strategic enabler to jumpstart the economy in Timor-Leste and specifically in the
southern regions. The provision of 200 to 220 new jobs in the Suai region for the oil
and gas industry is a great benefit for the local economy. It will upgrade the skills of
the local manpower, increase the purchasing power of the Timorese nationals and
inject much needed cash into the local economy. This skilled workforce then also
becomes available to other industries and oil and gas players who currently
experience a shortage of manpower in these areas. A more skilled workforce helps
the community attract a higher level of business investment and target specific types
of industry investments.
This skills development plan for the Suai Supply Base itself will take 12 to 24 months
to complete. As these positions are likely to be highly sought after, the process of
selection should be a rigorous one to ensure the right individuals are identified, with
high levels of work ethics and commitment. However, it is also possible that not all
candidates are able to complete the training programs successfully. The competitive
nature of the selection process should be properly communicated to the candidates
and there should be provision for candidates who fall short of the mark during the
training to downgrade and still find a suitable position at a lower level. Local
vocational institutes will need to develop additional curriculum (or work with an
external party to do so) to train students in the areas required at the Supply Base
(e.g. riggers, welders, heavy equipment operators, mechanics, etc).
Three to six months prior to commissioning of the Suai Supply Base, a training centre
will be set up at the Suai site. The centre will focus on validating the vocational skills
of Suai employees and providing oil and gas standard supplementary training for
several trades such as crane and forklift operators, prime mover drivers, mechanics,
maintenance personnel, riggers, security staff, etc.
IV - 12
Direct Expenditure
The Suai Supply Base project will spend an estimated US$150M in Timor-Leste during
the construction phase and US$4.5M annually from their operating budget. This will
be a great stimulus to the local economy.
- An estimated 40% of the EPC contracts will be awarded to local contractors
for works and services to be performed in the construction of the breakwater
and Supply Base facilities as well as for purchase of local supplies and
materials.
- Over the 18 - 24 month skills development program, the project is expected
to spend US$2.2M in wages to hire and train the necessary employees who
will subsequently staff the Suai Supply Base.
-
An estimated US$4.6M of annual Opex spending will benefit the local TimorLeste economy. This includes wages and purchase of local supplies and
services. This is only the direct impact of the Suai Supply Base and does not
include indirect expenditure from expats and PSCs. Assuming an average
national savings rate of 10%, the economic multiplier effect on the economy
could be as much as 10 times this value.
Each PSC in residence at the Suai Supply Base will spend in excess of US$1M
per month in the local community on supplies and services to support their
production platform.
$50,000,000
$45,000,000
$40,000,000
Project Management
$35,000,000
$30,000,000
$25,000,000
$20,000,000
$15,000,000
$10,000,000
$5,000,000
$0
3Q 11
4Q 11
1Q 12
2Q 12
3Q 12
4Q 12
1Q 13
2Q 13
IV - 13
4.4.2.2.
Value creation
The expenditure by the operator of the Suai Supply Base, the PSCs and different
foreign investors will benefit the economy significantly. However, the single most
important factor that will benefit the Government and the people around Suai is that
the land value around the Suai Supply Base, the adjoining industrial estate and the
Suai city will appreciate tremendously in value.
Land Value around Lamongan Shorebase
The Government of East Java first acquired the land for Lamongan Shorebase in 2004 at
US$1.50 /m2.
Currently, land within the Shorebase is leased on a monthly rental of US$2.50 /m2 and
sold with 30 year leases at US$150 to US$200 /m2 (depending on the size of the plot).
This is a 100 times appreciation on original land value.
Land outside of the Lamongan Shorebase has also appreciated considerably in value.
Within 5km of the Shorebase, the value of the land is US$60 / m2 and within a radius of
20km, land has now been transacted at US$30 /m2, or 20 times its original value.
It is imperative that the Government of Timor-Leste acquire all the land identified at the
Suai site as early as possible, and before construction at Zone A.
Zone C
Zone B
Zone A
IV - 14
Construction Industry
Contracts given to local contractors for construction services will help them fund
their purchase of new equipment and expand their businesses. The availability of the
LCT run for import of this equipment will further help reduce the cost for the local
contractors. However, the contractors should be mindful of their capacity to absorb
such expansion once the Suai Supply Base project is complete.
The new gravel quarry access roads can be used even after the completion of
construction works. This will provide new roads in the area, linking to the main trunk
road. They also provide the means for others to continue to exploit the quarry
locations. These quarries should continue to be operated thus bringing new
capability to the construction industry in the region.
4.4.3.2.
Local businesses will need to grow to accommodate the migrant workers for lodging
and food. Access to the LCT run from Suai to Lamongan will allow local
entrepreneurs to have easy access to overseas supplies and export markets of East
Java.
Access to port capable of handling commercial cargo will significantly reduce the cost
of supplies and promote entrepreneurship. This same access will also make local
produce more competitive on the international market.
The regular run between East Java and Timor-Leste will also include a tanker ship.
This means diesel and gasoline will be available at lower prices. More importantly,
this will provide a stable supply of diesel to the region 365 days a year.
IV - 15
Foreign Investment
With more skilled labour and small businesses available, this will promote business
investment into the region and in turn further upgrade the workforce and grow the
local businesses. Improved infrastructure and access to telecommunications
backbone will attract small and medium based businesses to setup and respond to
the local business community needs. This, coupled with the access to a port and
regular lines to East Java and Darwin, will attract Australian and Indonesian investors,
especially in the industrial estate to be built.
The Suai Supply Base will launch Timor-Leste as a player in the Oil and Gas industry.
As such, the success of the project is of great national interest. Moreover, with the
success of such a public sector private sector partnership in Timor-Leste, other
investors will start looking at Timor-Leste more favourably and financial institutions
lower their risk profiles for projects in Timor-Leste. International infrastructure
investors will see more potential in Timor-Leste and wish to develop other public
sector private sector partnerships.
With all these developments, the oil and gas community will believe that the
Government of Timor-Leste is committed to growing the oil and gas industry and this
in turn will entice them to bid for the remaining open exploration blocks. The
IV - 16
availability of a supply base at Suai will make logistics for offshore exploration and
production activities less costly than operating from Dili or Darwin. Discoveries
previously considered too costly to exploit can be re-evaluated and found feasible as
a result of the shorter supply chain from the availability of the Suai Supply Base and
full integrated services.
With the existence of this south facing port and industrial estate development, Suai
and the Southern regions will continue to grow and attract investment opportunities.
Suai will become the centre for economic development in the south. In addition, a
large number of expatriates will live in Dili or Suai to provide skills transfer and
manage the foreign investments in Timor-Leste.
The port facilities and infrastructure improvements will open opportunities in other
industries, for example agriculture, fisheries, manufacturing, mining and
construction.
During Construction
The dedicated access roads to the quarries have also been selected to avoid
habitation in general however it is unavoidable that the route will go through some
habitation and/or agricultural plots. This needs to be properly communicated to the
affected parties and adequate compensation provided. Some agricultural plots may
need to be cut in two or removed altogether. Habitation along the way will get
access to the new road once the construction is complete. Because of the heavy
vehicles, it is not desirable to build the road through or alongside habitation.
During the full duration of the breakwater construction, dump trucks will be plying
the access roads, on many occasions 24 hours a day. Timorese nationals are not used
to such heavy traffic and such heavy vehicles. Local villagers that are affected and
especially children should be properly educated and warned.
Even with the highest of HSE standards, there is always the risk of a worksite or
construction accident. This will need to be managed swiftly, openly and in a fair
manner should such an eventuality arise.
IV - 17
4.4.4.2.
During Operations
The Suai Supply Base will be operated 24/7. This is a new concept to many of the
local businesses and population. Some of the mindset needs to change to
accommodate this. There basic services should be made available to the staff of
require them outside of standard office hours (i.e. transport, general supplies, etc).
Vehicular traffic will increase on the main access roads. As many of these are by the
side of local habitation, there is also an increased risk of accidents. In many areas,
with the current volume of traffic and size of the roads, there is still no need for
more sophisticated traffic management measures (i.e. traffic lights, pedestrian
crossings, roundabouts on approaches to villages/towns, etc). However, as traffic in
the major crossroads increase, there will come a time when this becomes necessary.
However, better access to health facilities, ease of travel to schools, etc all improve
the standard of living.
With the 24/7 operations of the Suai Supply Base, traffic will also be plying the main
routes 24 hours a day. On many of the roads, night time travel is not safe and this
needs to be addressed. Also, increased night traffic will bring noise pollution to
habitation in the vicinity of major trade routes. The amount of traffic will be
significantly affected by the extent and rate of development of the general industry
around Suai.
The new facilities available at the Suai Supply Base also bring many benefits to the
region. The availability of a sheltered basin and port will improve overall maritime
safety. The Reverse Osmosis system can be used in any emergency to provide fresh
water to the population. Access to a public internet facility, thus technology enabling
Timorese nationals, will also greatly benefit the community. In general, the Supply
Base infrastructure like liquid storage tanks and RO water system and LCT liner
connection can also provide support to the local community, either on a regular
basis or as an emergency backup.
The new community centre will provide improved recreational programming. The
local population will have the opportunity to integrate recreational activities at the
centre, thus allowing them to create new or reinforce existing community linkages.
Local rallies and events can be organized at the community centre or soccer pitch.
IV - 18
The availability of a heli-pad at the Suai supply Base location will facilitate the visit of
important visitors and officials. This will promote government communication as
well as investor access to the region.
In any rapidly changing environment like the one we are witnessing here, there will
be Timorese nationals who are set in the old ways and resistant to change. The
project needs to be communicated early to the local community, with clear
articulation of the impact to them, both negative and positive. Regular updates
should be provided.
4.4.4.3.
Transmigration of workers
As a result of increase economic activity in the Suai district, and the availability of
jobs and business opportunities, there will be migrant workers from other regions in
Timor-Leste who move to the Suai region.
-
Expand benefits from this project beyond the Cova Lima district
4.4.5. Environment
During the construction, there will be 2 quarries operating and 1 river bed
excavation site. This will involve blasting, generally during day time hours, several
times a day. This will generate noise and dust for any villages in the surrounding
areas. Even though the quarry sites have been selected to be far from habitation in
general, should there be any in the vicinity, they will need to be warned and
educated. Quarry sites should be adequately cordoned off with adequate safety
zones. There may be some damage to any nearby buildings from the blast
shockwaves.
At the river bed site, there will be new access roads to move the sand and gravel.
The excavation will muddy the waters downstream during the period of work.
However, this will reduce the risk in future of the river flooding during periods with
high water levels.
IV - 19
At the sea, the area designated for the breakwater will have restricted access for
vessels. The waters around the breakwater construction will look muddy due to the
dumping of sand and gravel. There will however be no permanent impact on the
water quality nor will it affect marine life once completed.
The general construction of new gravel roads will provide better access to habitation
and agricultural land along the route of the roads once the construction of the
breakwater is complete. This will also increase the value of such land.
4.5.
Recommendations
The study team has the following recommendations to mitigate any risk of negative
socioeconomic impact from the Suai Supply Base and to maximize the benefits.
Construction
-
Ensure the quarry sites are adequately surveyed and cordoned off prior to
commencement of blasting works. Once the construction phase is complete,
the Government of Timor-Leste should explore the possibility of continuing
operations at these sites as permanent quarries. This will help alleviate the
risk of employment losses but also provide additional capability and capacity
for the construction industry in the southern regions in preparations for
upcoming projects.
IV - 20
All buildings and assets that may be affected by the blasting or construction
activities should be subject to a pre condition survey. Any damages as a result
of works by the project should be repaired.
The project team should work together with the local contractors to assess
what the local economy can reasonably absorb when awarding contracts that
require substantial asset capitalization. If this exceeds their capacity to retain
after the project, then such equipment should be brought and re-exported
after the project.
Have first aid station available throughout the construction and ensure the
relevant supervisors on the ground are familiar with access to medical
facilities in Suai and the Suai hospital. Work with the Suai hospital to ensure
the right medical expertise is available for the nature of industrial activities
being developed in the region.
The project team should promote the transfer of skills for specialty
construction works during the course of the construction (i.e. operating of
boring equipment during quarry blasting, construction of breakwater, etc).
IV - 21
Operations
-
The main trunk roads between Dili and Suai, around the Suai region and
along the Suai-Betano-Beaco corridor should be upgraded and provided with
24hr capability. Wherever possible, main trunk road where volumes of traffic
are expected to grow should bypass urban centres. Alternatively, any
habitation should be setback from the road and adequate traffic
management measure put in place.
The operator of the Suai Supply Base should consider setting up their own
programs for community development in the Suai district to build their
corporate image with Timorese nationals.
Explore what measures the Government can put in place to help the services
industry in and around Suai to develop in the short term. (specifically in
business accommodation, food and beverage and sundry supplies)
IV - 22
IV - 23
Acknowledgements:
We gratefully acknowledge the presence and inspiration of his Excellency Kay Rala Xanana
Gusmao at Lamongan Shorebase during the Shorebase Orientation Course.
We gratefully acknowledge the guidance provided by His Excellency Alfredo Pires, State
Secretary for Natural Resources.
We like to also acknowledge the following persons for their assistance and time during the
period of this study:
I - 21
We would like to congratulate the following for having completed the Shorebase Orientation
course and obtaining international certification for Oilfield Sea Survival.
Vicente Lacerda
Joao Camara
Francisco Ferreira
Josefa Nuning da Silva
Joaquim Amaral
Johny Leite
Helder Freitas
Bambang Gunawan
Figure I 3 : Photos during the Shore Base Orientation Course at Lamongan Shorebase
I - 22
5/5/2011
General Admin
Offices and Admin B uilding
- General Cargo
Procurement
- Cold Room
Telecommunications
- Explosive
Cleaning Area
Fabrication workshop
Freight forwarding
Customs
Security
Slide No.: 2
5/5/2011
Office Building
Objectives :
This will provide a central location for all offices, both for
the base staff as well as for all customers. The offices can
be leased by PSCs or any service providers and will facilitate
overall management and communication with
suppliers/customers.
Services provided:
All offices will come with basic office amenities, utilities. As
an option, administrative services can be provided,
depending on customer demand.
SUAI Approach:
Office space will be built for the base team as well as for
rental to PSCs and any service providers and suppliers that
need it. One third will be occupied by the SUAI Supply Base
team and two thirds allocated for rental.
Building / Infrastructure :
Office building with 2 or 3 floors.
Slide No.: 3
Warehousing
Warehousing
Objectives :
There will be a crucial need for warehouse facilities within
the SUAI supply base to support the O&G operations. The
following warehousing needs have been identified.
General Cargo
Chemicals
Cold Storage
Reefer / chiller
Explosives storage (optional)
As the requirements and approach for each of these cargo
types are different, we will cover each one seperately.
-
Slide No.: 4
5/5/2011
Warehousing
(General Cargo)
Objectives :
To provide warehouse facilities for O&G operations onsite at the
supply base.
Services :
Warehouse management (from base team)
Warehouse space (per warehouse of 1000m2)
SUAI Approach:
The buildings can be phased in based on volume projections.
However, land space should be allocated to for future expansion.
Central warehousing will also be provided for the base
requirements and also for service providers/suppliers (that
require smaller storage capacity).
Building / Infrastructure:
Covered warehouses
Slide No.: 5
Warehousing
(Chemicals)
Objectives :
It is desirable to centralise the storage of all chemicals and dangerous goods. This will
allow better control of these items and reduce the risk of any accidents.
Services :
Warehouse services and management as required by international standards for
Dangerous Goods storage.
Appropriate safety procedures and facilities in place (i.e. HSE equipment, medical and
accident abatement facilities, administration of MSDS and GHS marking, etc)
SUAI Approach :
Customers can request for dedicated areas inside the chemicals warehouse (available
for rental)
To be operated and managed by the SUAI Supply Base team. Security also to be
provided by the SUAI base security.
Building / Infrastructure:
Chemicals Warehouse with a good ventilation system, spill control, fire protection, etc)
The building should also be protected from heavy rain or flooding.
Regulation:
The GTL needs to advise on all relevant laws and policies regarding handling and
storage of chemicals and hazardous goods.
Slide No.: 6
5/5/2011
Warehousing
(Cold Storage)
Objectives :
To be able to store at SUAI supply base all necessary items
that also require air-conditioned or temperature controlled
storage (i.e. rubber seals, electronic spare parts, etc)
Services:
The facility, like the DG warehouse, be managed by the SUAI
Supply base as one of the base facilities.
SUAI Approach:
A section of the Centralised General Warehouse can be
allocated for this purpose. This will be managed by the SUAI
warehouse team. This section can be further subdivided for
differing storage temperature requirements, or based on
customer demand for dedicated space or item segregation.
Building / Infrastructure
It is envisaged that this room will be between 100 to 150m2
and be located within the General Warehouse facility.
Slide No.: 7
Warehousing
(Reefer & Chillers)
Objectives:
To provide an area for storage/placement of reefer and chiller
containers to facilitate the provision of fresh and/or frozen food for all
offshore operations. This is intended to allow the customers/service
provider to administer their supply chain of such products to support
up to 7 days of drilling activities.
SUAI Approach:
This will be managed in conjunction with the catering service provider.
Example of supplier :
Indocater, Sodexo
Building / Infrastructure:
Concrete slab (able to support loading/unloading by crane for cargo up
to 20 tons)
Plots for 10 and 20 containers (against corrosion)
Adequate electrical supply (with backup)
Slide No.: 8
5/5/2011
Warehousing
(Explosives)
Explosive Bunker (Optional)
Objectives :
To provide a secure and safe storage area for all explosives used
during the drilling campaign (and for mining activities)
Services :
Transportation, storage and loading/unloading of explosives.
Security and control of all explosive items.
Example of supplier :
Dahana in Indonesia (Explosive management)
SUAI Approach:
Space will be set aside for this purpose. However, the construction
will depend on user/customer requirement.
Building / Infrastructure:
- 2 small warehouses (10m distance between each warehouse)
- Protective wall / structure (earth/sand)
- Barbed wire, CCTV and security
Regulation:
The GTL needs to advise on all relevant laws and policies regarding
handling and storage of explosives.
Suai Supply Base Feasibility Study and Front End
Engineering Design (FEED) Appendix C2
Slide No.: 9
Slide No.: 10
5/5/2011
Slide No.: 11
Slide No.: 12
5/5/2011
Slide No.: 13
Waste Management
Services
Objectives :
To create a waste management treatment center, which can then be
used for all Timor Leste (South) industrial activities (O&G, Refinery,
LNG plant, Mining, hospital, public waste, etc)
Only B3 waste which can not be treated at this plant, will be
forwarded on to Indonesia PPLI treatment plant.
Example of supplier : PPLI WMI
SUAI Approach:
The infrastructure will be provided on site and leased to a 3rd party
service provider who will manage the facility and provide the services
to the PSCs. We will work closely with the service provider during the
construction phase to jointly develop this.
Building / Infrastructure:
warehouse with dedicated drainage system
open cover area
yard with concrete slab or asphalt and fence
Offices near the warehouse
Area with drum cleaner and crusher
incinerator
Regulation:
The GTL needs to advise on all relevant laws and policies regarding
waste management and associated services.
Suai Supply Base Feasibility Study and Front End
Engineering Design (FEED) Appendix C2
Slide No.: 14
5/5/2011
Slide No.: 15
Inspection/Certification
Services
Objectives :
To provide the necessary 3rd party inspection and certification services
required by the Supply base operations as well as to support the
customers Offshore drilling programme.
Services proposed :
all NDT (MPI, RT, UT, Xray, Eddy Currant, etc)
lifting gear inspection
heavy equipments inspection
pipes (casing, tubing, drill pipe,...)
HSE equipment (extinguisher, alarm, life boat, life raft, etc)
Infrared thermographic inspection
Pressure testing (valves)
SUAI Approach:
A 3rd party service provider will be engaged to provide these services at
the base. He will be provided with the necessary infrastructure to.
Building / Infrastructure :
Small Office
Dedicated Pipes inspection area (with special drainage system)
High pressure test room (30-50m2, reinforced walls and roof)
Suai Supply Base Feasibility Study and Front End
Engineering Design (FEED) Appendix C2
Slide No.: 16
5/5/2011
Slide No.: 17
Slide No.: 18
5/5/2011
Sling fabrication
and testing
Objectives :
To be able to provide all the necessary slings to the SUAI
Supply base customer without delay and maintaining all
International safety standards.
Services :
Fabrication of wire slings and webbing slings.
Testing and certification for offshore usage.
Example of supplier :
This can be provided by the SUAI workshop team
Building / Infrastructure :
- 100m2 Workshop with gantry crane (5 tons)
- Protected area for pull testing unit
- Small office
- Warehouse for raw materials and finished products
Slide No.: 19
Fabrication Workshop
Objectives :
To provide fabrication services needed by the O&G
customer directly onsite at SUAI supply base.
Scope of services :
Baskets, racks, mini containers, drill cutting boxes, tanks,
custom work, etc
SUAI Approach:
Option 1: Find and develop a local engineering company to
provide this service.
Option 2: Build a team as part of the SUAI Supply Base team
to provide this service.
Building / Infrastructure:
Small office + 1 cool room for tools
Workshop with gantry crane (10 MT) and one small
warehouse
Yard with concrete or asphalt flooring (for forklift or crane)
and fencing.
Slide No.: 20
10
5/5/2011
Slide No.: 21
Slide No.: 22
11
5/5/2011
Freight Forwarding
Objectives :
To provide SUAI supply base and the Airport with professional and global freight
forwarding services.
Services :
- Multimodal transport
- Custom and Regulatory compliance
- Projects
Example of operators : SDV (worldwide O&G involved)
SUAI Approach: Outsource to 3rd party service provider
Building required :
Inside SUAI base, an office, yard & warehouse
At the Airport : 1 office
Slide No.: 23
Sourcing/Procurement
Services
Due to the remote location of the SUAI supply base, it could be
difficult for the Oil&Gas operators to purchase supplies in the
timeframe that their operations needs require.
The SUAI supply base can provide onsite stock of the more
frequently used supplies to facilitate replenishment for their
customers. For more specialised items, the SUAI team can assist
their customers in the sourcing, procurement and logistics.
Some more typical items to be stocked onsite:
HSE: helmets, safety shoes, gloves, goggles, extinguishers, life raft,
mask, gas detector, etc
IT & Telecom equipment: computer, printer, cartridge, VHF
handset, radar, etc
Fabrication and piping : welding rods, etc
Lifting gear : shackles, etc
Engine Oil : stock at SUAI from a major supplier (e.g. Total, Shell)
Chemicals : stock at SUAI (after customer needs survey) from a
major supplier (e.g. Nalco)
Slide No.: 24
12
5/5/2011
Training / Conference
Centre
Objectives :
Provide the facilities for SUAI base team to provide
internal training. This will ensure the team is able to
provide world class service to their customers. These
facilities can also be used by their customers for
conference/training activities.
Services :
The training center could be composed of 2 parts:
Technical training / Office training
Technical training:
Firefighting, Basic sea survival, H2S, NDT certification,
lifting operations, Welding
Office training :
ISO 9001, 14001, OHSAS 18001, ISPS, Nebosh,
Computer, English, Accounting, warehousing (SAP,
Maximo,..)
Slide No.: 25
Slide No.: 26
13
5/5/2011
Casing/Tubing
Maint Services
Objectives :
To provide SUAI supply base customers with the
capability to perform casing/tubing maintenance
onsite.
SUAI Approach :
Can be done by the inspection company as part of
their services.
Building / Infrastructure :
- Inspection area 200m2
- 24/7 availability
Slide No.: 27
14
5/5/2011
PMC Oilfield
copyright
Slide No. 1
Examples of PSC
Slide No. 2
5/5/2011
Drilling companies
Slide No. 3
Wireline
Chemical
Wellhead equipment
5/5/2011
5/5/2011
Slide No. 7
Slide No. 8
5/5/2011
5/5/2011
Slide No. 12
5/5/2011
Drilling
w############################
Slide No. 13
Slide No. 14
5/5/2011
Slide No. 15
Drill Ship
Slide No. 16
5/5/2011
Slide No. 17
Well Testing
When the rig drilling depth is within reach of the fault / potential reservoir
within the underground formation layers, a well testing operation could
be triggered. Also known as Well service Down hole equipment (well
testing, completion, well clean up, wire line )
5/5/2011
Rig move
Once the testing is completed, the well will be plugged / sealed and a
corrosion cap will be put on the sea bed covering the drilled hole (abandoned
well).
The rig will be moved out of the location (supply vessels AHTS) and
contractually demobilised.
Slide No. 19
Rig move
Slide No. 20
10
5/5/2011
Slide No. 21
Slide No. 22
11
5/5/2011
Slide No. 23
Drilling Appraisal
In the event of the well drilled is successful (positive hydrocarbons discovery),
the second step is to drill more wells to define the potential of the whole
block / concession (field).
This step is known as appraisal well
Logistics interface:
Operation personnel flow and material requirement are similar to an
Exploration well.
Slide No. 24
12
5/5/2011
Slide No. 25
Slide No. 26
13
5/5/2011
Slide No. 27
14
5/5/2011
Slide No. 29
Slide No. 30
15
5/5/2011
Production
Wellhead platforms (various small platforms) are spread out onto the field
gathering all the productions / development wells drilled) connected with
each other through submarine flow line, and finally linked to the main
production platform
For safety and comfort, all the personnel working on various production
platform are accommodated onto a separate module called Living quarter
platform.
Slide No. 31
Production
Slide No. 32
16
5/5/2011
Production
Once the production is up and runnings,
PSCs need to insure the hydrocarbon
production flow accordingly from the
reservoir, as numerous problems can
occur. The range of operations to solve
these issues is quite wide, and come under
what is called Work over :
- Scrapper
- Coiled tubing,
- well stimulation
- gas lift
- water injection
Slide No. 33
Production
Other main operations taking place to be aware of , are related to the
maintenance facilities (platforms shut downs, revamping). They are
significant and carried with caution due to the environment, and they
called for a temporary stoppage of production.
For all these operations either rigs, specialized vessels, work barges or
others supports are especially contracted.
As for everything else, a well / reservoir has a life expectancy (10, 20 or
30 years).
Therefore production technician along with reservoir engineers will
decided when and how to abandon a well.
On a production platform there are device to isolate the underground
reservoir from the surface.
Slide No. 34
17
5/5/2011
PRODUCTION
The export main pipeline can be connected to various storage
terminals, which are either onshore
(depot tank terminal), or offshore permanently
Anchor storage tanker (FSU, FPU, FPSU, FSO,
FPSO, FDPSO, FSG, FGSO).
Onshore terminals either have an export jetty or a pipeline going
offshore conencted to an SBM,
Slide No. 35
Production
Where tankers come and connect to load the production (like
vehicle service station).
For offshore terminals, tankers come nearby (various way to
technically approach storage facilities) to pick up production load
up.
The next step is the production delivery to process plants. It can
either go straight to onshore refinery / liquefied gas plant
through a submarine pipeline, or delivered by tanker.
Slide No. 36
18
5/5/2011
PRODUCTION
FPSO
Slide No. 37
19
5/5/2011
Slide No. 39
20
5/5/2011
Slide No. 41
Refinery
Slide No. 42
21
5/5/2011
Slide No. 43
Slide No. 44
22
5/5/2011
Annexe
In addtion to this presentation, we have included a section
dedicated to Drilling detailed explanations. There are 3
sketches:
- Anatomy of a basic rig
- Casing well design
- Rig design
Along with these sketches we shall address to all attendees a
basic introduction on the drilling activities and tools, as well as to
answer any queries
Slide No. 45
Onshore
Rig
Slide No. 46
23
5/5/2011
Directional Drilling
Slide No. 47
Slide No. 48
24
5/5/2011
Drill Bit
Slide No. 49
Mud Flow
Slide No. 50
25
5/5/2011
Slide No. 51
26
C4 - 1
Dedicated multi-user marine berths, berth pockets, staging areas and channel
connections to service rig tender vessels, which supply offshore gas rigs with
all their supplies,
Undercover, open and bonded storage areas to service critical cargoes being
transferred to/from rig tender vessels,
Connections to all utilities and easy supply of fuel, water and other supplies
to enable quick turn-around times for rig tender vessels.
C4 - 2
Expressions of Interest were called and submissions by various parties were done by
27 October 2010.
On 10 December 2010, three bidders were shortlised:
Toll Holdings, a major international transport and logistics firm who operates
supply bases in both Singapore and Australia
The successful consortium will receive revenue from Marine Supply Base (MSB)
activities to cover the costs and earn a commercial return on their capital over a 30year concession.
The Government of Northern Territory recognizes the challenges of operating and
getting a reasonable return for this Marine Supply Base. They are transferring the
existing oil and gas business from the present Darwin Harbour to the Marine Supply
Base to kick start business once operational. The government will absorb the cost of
dredging and maintaining an access to the channel for the Darwin Marine Supply
Base. They have also indicated that the proposed MSB will handle the rock export for
the Ichthys project. Also, they are prepared to look at other forms of assistance if
necessary to make the Public Sector Private Sector Partnership (PPP) a success.
The Financial close is expected in December 2011, with construction starting in early
2012. The supply base is expected to be operational by December 2013, and the
project commissioned and the transfer of activities to East Arm Wharf completed by
mid 2014.
C4 - 3
C4 - 4
C4 - 5
C4 - 6
C4 - 7
3) Given the factors above, the Darwin MSB project will be able to obtain bank
financing.
4) Two of the three candidates are established oil and gas shorebase operators,
namely Toll (operates Singapore Offshore Petroleum Services, a multi user
integrated hub) and ASCO (operates several single user facilities for BP in the
north sea and a multi user facility in Scotland).
5) The Suai location has the advantage of being significantly nearer for all
activity within the JPDA and TLEA. For example, it is 110nm from the Sunrise
field whereas the Darwin MSB is 240nm. The consequence of this is
additional fuel cost if the PSCs operate from Darwin as well as cost of
additional supply vessels to maintain the necessary supply chain.
6) Suai has a potentially shorter material supply chain if Suai is able to utilise
Lamongan Shorebase as a materials hub and operates a regular liner service.
7) Based on their own timetable, the Darwin MSB project will have a financial
close 31 Dec 2011 and estimated to be operational mid 2014. Based on our
EPC masterplan, the Suai Supply Base will be operational end 2012, giving it a
18month first mover advantage. This is critical as the oil companies will not
move once they are settled in.
C4 - 8