ZAKfNAGlB

by

It

is

possible

to

J. J. G.

discern

Mahmd,

who

1968.

The

metaphysical,

in

first,

1946.

In

this

Sin",

published

argues

that

everyone

the

optimism,

sometimes

difficult

Zaki's

to

later

the

mind",

which

he

first

printed

March

book,

in

mle,
Much

to

his

stating

ty.

(CAbbs
Dr.

Dr.
19th

ism,

In

his

theory,
genstein

etc.)

ZakI

visible

to

a youthful

if its

purport

is

to

to

Dr.
from

about
1958,

amply
implicitly

XX.

come

(Muhammad
Cairo

a\-Bahiyy

discussing
tries

Deutscher

A/a/iw

stresses
the
to

that

answer

Orientalistentag

Beimt

of
the

any

this

other

of

verifiabUi-

p. 411

-19).

violent

Egypt.
and

In

1953

about

this

It is a transcription
to

world

, Al-Fikr

is

of

bureaucrat,
in

vol

neopositivism

1966,

attempts
that

disqualify
created

al-Islmt

Zaki's
colonial

al-Hadtth

wa-

268-78).
Falsafa

^Ilmiyya

neopositivism

genesis

of

principle

doubts..

same

two

consideration.

a Superstition)

Al-Bahiyy

neopositivism,
ZakI

the

like

and

University

negative

p.

of

edition

a review

weakness
verify

in

first

is a rule
respect

neopositivism

the

essentially
change

the

wrote

our

Azhar

*1975,

was

a book

of

wa-n-Ns,

it "stimulates

they

al-Gharbi,

to

(Metaphysics:

materialism."

was

verifiability

propagate

at the
touched

"enormous

preface

could

well-known

Zaki's

present

positivism

al-'-Aqqd

al-Kutub

attempt

that

one

was

'^Abd

of

electricity"

this

a fundamental

how

Imm

found

work.

The

of

be

ZakI
if by

neopositivism

claims

al-Mttftztq

atheism.

in

his

special

Bayn

1946,
"as

Mahmd

points

the

of

by

can

as logical

principle

no

see

in

as Self-Determi-

translation

mentions

Logic).

the

make

to

and

he

faith

"-Abbs

that

can

that

by

Zaki's

famous

writtes

book

Ibn

essay

out

even

traces

suddenly,

course

(Positivist

second

Cairo
and

of

Western

third

was

in the

Al-Bahiyy,

bi-l-Istfmr

PhUosophy),

Zaki

explaining

orientalism

Silat"h

known

his

al-^ Aqqd,

Al-Bahiyy

by

then

Khurfat

century

theories

he

no

When,

thesis

is difficult

Zaki's

published

this

published

Arabic

1973)

to

argued

Muhammad

book

Cairo

undergone

Mahmd

In

is "brUliantly

Zaki,

tiU

"^Ayniyyat

259.

breathes

1946;

pp.;

views.

Al-'-Aqqd

it

College,
178

doctrine

mle

credit,

that

attacked

Zaki

King's

the

The

this

envy

Zaki

Cairo

Neopositivism,

e.g.

p.

essay

to

of

to

wrote

eye,

The

Ayer,

result

he

that

by

of

had

1951.

human

ought

1949,

ad-Dhtt,

al-Wad^t

which

and

perhaps

Cairo

introduction

Al-Mantiq

dated

ly

the

1957,

Alfred

that

In

The

one

(London,

of

conviction

he

Cairo

of

University

conversion

metaphysics

the

development

the

ZakT's

intellect".

anti-metaphysical

lecture

correct.

umes,

for

in

with

to

his

philosophical

grasp.

Al-Gabr

neopositivist

inaugural

ends

invisible
with

Press,

Imm,

the

wa-Lubb,

it

dissertation

Government

al-Fatth

by

for

in

1905)

Philosophy

speculative

although

seeks

metaphysical

In

of

QusMr

his

(Niederlande)

of

phase

in

Groningen

phases

Professor

period

soul,

who

nation.

was

(b.

Jansen,

three

Na^b

MAHMD

is

neopositivism
charges

1977

made

In Erlangen

(To
not

(Wiener
by

Dr.

a Scientific
19th
Kreis,

Al-Bahiyy.

century
Witt
It is

Zaki

somewhat

ironic

couragement
1975,

p.

From

1968
and

Zaki's

activities

as

the

Western

culture

The

can

Zaki

Put

of

techniques,
be

in

of

new

the

123-5;

State

En

Al-Gadid,!

A,

in the
sight

University

have

al-Fikr

of

little

to

Ku-

do

with

al-^Arabi(\971)

These

titles

"Rational

and

may

and

be

trans

Irrational

in

the

the

to

into

one

Zaki

such

How

the

Arabs

taken

to

what

how

system

have

they
can

that

accepted

we

amalgate

is both

Arab

and

finds

customs,

a collection
and

p.

in

and

as a whole.
in

written

"culture"

tools

fostered

17,

a passage

Read,

is a paraphrase

utensUs,

Only

daily

H.

the
for

and

what

life.

of

by

is a name

no

is useful

(The

quotation

Read,

The

Politics

p. 67).

suggests,

the

called

"Modern

recently

doubt:
added

to

actions,

problem

agglomeration

agglomeration

until

civilisation.

complicated:

according

preserved

1945,

that

and

coherent

problem

accept

be

writes

culture

century?

Read:

be

Zaki

to

should
more

20th

this

books,
Western

started

be

in Tagdid^,

the

called

had

opinions,

Zaki

two

becomes

that
"the

Arab

simpler

is called

Arab

heritage"

Culture"?

and

"Western
should

Zaki

we

then

easier

culture"
select

proceeds

to

and
to
to

man
which

constmct

discuss

this

in detaU.

The
known

second

book,

episodes

of

Al-Ghazli

that

book.

aim

The

analyse

and
here

the

ent

work

as

are
of

no

doubt

philosophy,

the

of

belittle

ideological
work

Tractatus,

as

Ayer,

make

4.112;

them

often

of

clear

quoted

the

and
by

"cloudy
give

Zakf,

them
e.g.

his

the

to
can

pres
to

constmc

propositions.

indistinct"

sharp

Khurfat

we

and

of
and

the

and

According

is not

clarification

remain

of

past

Perhaps

contents.

philosophy

weUfrom

reader
the

phUosopher
their

and

mottoes

of

thinking.

of

rather
to

and

sanctity

historical

aim

glorious

a traditionalist
the

cirtic

the

aUowed

many

quotations

a neopositivist

but

are

to

and

and

propositions",

phUosophers

Wittgenstein,

impress

to

and

thoughts

with

to

ideologies

Wittgenstein

discusses

is spiced

obviously,

Zakfs
of

Irrational",
and

calculated

Arab

between

"phUosophical

task

is,

examiner

Without

past,

book

current

like

and

Islamic

the

link
an

philosophers
of

"Rational
the

clarify

find

30

received
p.

at first

and

much

the

of

source

of

he

Herbert

should

way,

thing,

question

tion

54,

(1975).

with

might

to

bound

parts

these

culture

London

this

of

perhaps

solution
essayist

without

which

parts
a

the

and

Unpolitical,

age:

of
1959,

Tagdtd

Thought"

years

appropriate

ever

gives

that

al-Fikri

civihsation

last

Arab

a collection

the

age
July

of Philosophy

books

Arabic

problem

with

to

a coUection

such

the

philosopher:

first

and

real

time

poet

body

at

Professor
two

Turthn

and

West,

the

key

British

the

the

the

but

of

of
culture

continues,

same

was

wrote

a neopositivist

beginning

from

at the

Zaki,

Heritage".

identified
he

Zaki
he

of

'The

already,

in

1973,
years

Resurgence

as

Intellectual

much

book

xxxi,

ft

Arab

ever,

this

1959.

wa-l-L-Ma^ql

lated

In

till

in these

Al-M(fql

had

for

for

563

Mahmd

13-5).

wayt,

he

that

Price

Nagib

it is

boundaries.
al-M.,

(L.

p.

17,23,

etc.)
In

tivist

his

Westem
tion

early

years

years

Zaki

culture,
and

quoted
as subject

analysis"
by

Zaki)
of

his

Zaki

seems
and
(A.

in

his

sharp

have

discontent

attempted

third

Ayer,

taking
scrutiny.

felt

to

period

Language,
his

own

with
to

he

replace

its

own

his

"confines

Truth
culture,

his

culture,

own

in his

culture

hmiself

to

with
works

& Logic,

London

1967,

historical

thinking

and

neoposi
a form

of

clarifica

p. 51,
its

often

ideologies,

of