You are on page 1of 11

HAYDARIA 4xGE Fr.

9E GPP / CANTEEN BUILDING ARCHITECTURAL COMMENTS REVIEW

Aux Transmittal No. 010


MOE review
INSURE THAT ALL WALLS AND ROOF HAVE U=0.25W/M2K
ACCORDING TO ITEM (10.4.1) FROM CONTRACT)

Apply skirting 10 cm height at below edge for all brick walls.

transmittal NO.
11

enka response
NO

MOE response

STATUS
OPEN

TBC Remarks (25 Apr 2013)


This comment should be closed. Please refer
to the approved thermal conductance
calculation document no. HPP-TBC-M-02-GEN2891 (submittal no. 414.)

138

OK. This will be considered in Typical Architectural


Drawings.

O.K.

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

Show RC lintels below windows to work as a cap for double leaf


wall in architectural sections.

138

OK. This will be considered in Typical Architectural


Drawings.

O.K.

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

Show RC lintels above doors in and windows architectural


sections.

138

OK. This will be considered in Typical Architectural


Drawings.

O.K.

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

All vertical edges of cavity walls (double leaf wall) at doors,


windows and RC columns should be closed with brick units.

138

OK. This will be considered in Typical Architectural


Drawings.

O.K.

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

For long cavity walls (double leaf wall), add diaphragm brick
units between two brick layers.

138

OK. This will be considered in Typical Architectural


Drawings.

O.K.

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

Specify type of false ceiling, specifications and details of


supporting metal frame.

138

This was not mentioned in design meeting in Bagdad.A


dedicated data sheet of false ceiling shall be prepared by
TBC and submitted to client and if required, details of
false ceiling shall be shown in Typical Architectural
Drawings.

O.K., wait for TBC submital

OPEN

False ceiling specification will be defined by


TBC and submitted to MOE for approval.
Please close this comment.

All interior partitions should have thickness of 240 mm instead of


115 mm because of its large height and length and to provide
sufficient support for doors and windows.

138

There is no any statement about this request in Tender


Documents. This was also not mentioned in design
meeting in Bagdad. Bricks of 115 mm width are used in
this building. We do not see any technical reason to
increase the width of walls.

OPEN

Internal partition walls shall be made 14 cm


thick including plaster. We do not see any
technical reason for further increase on wall
thickness.

Apply damp proofing concrete layer DPC 20 cm thick under all


brick walls and partitions.

138

OK. This will be considered in Typical Architectural


Drawings.

O.K.

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

Use teak wood instead of hardwood for doors.

138

This was not mentioned in design meeting in Bagdad. At


10.5.3 of specification of project, material of doors is
described as hardwood. So in drawings indicated as it is.

O.K.

CLOSED

CLOSED

Specify type of interior plastering (cement or gypsum).

138

This was not mentioned in design meeting in Bagdad.


There is no any statement about interior plaster type in
Tender Documents. This should be decided by TBC. if
required, type of interior plastering shall be shown in
Typical Architectural Drawings.

O.K., wait for TBC submital

OPEN

TBC confirms that internal plaster will consist


of following layers: cement plaster + 2 mm
gypsum plaster + painting.

External cut ladder is needed.

138

External steel ladder is already shown in related


drawings. Required details are also given in Standard
Details for Steel Structures

CLOSED

CLOSED

Give table for doors and windows including all details.

138

This was not mentioned in design meeting in Bagdad.


Table of doors and windows that includes material and
dimensions of frames is already given in related
drawings.

It is needed to show doors and windows


DIMENSIONS in this table

open

This comment should be closed. Door and


window schedules are already provided in
building's architectural drawings (see dwg.
No. HPP-TBC-C-71-CNT-2062.)

Add protection steel grid layer for all exterior windows.

138

This was not mentioned in design meeting in Bagdad.


There is no any statement about this request in Tender
Documents.

It is needed to fix protection steel grid to


external windows for safety.

CLOSED

CLOSED

Show enlarge details for exterior wall.

138

OK. This will be considered in Typical Architectural


Drawings.

OPEN

This comment should be closed. Exterior wall


detail is already provided in typical
architectural drawings (see dwg. No. HPP-TBCC-51-GEN-2087.)

Submitt static and stability calculations for


115mm partitions taking into considerartion
reduction in thickness due to embedding
electrical and plumbing conduits.

O.K.

O.K.

MOE review
please clarify & INSURE THAT ALL WALLS AND ROOF
HAVE U=0.25W/M2K ACCORDING TO ITEM (10.4.1) FROM
CONTRACT.

HAYDARIA 4xGE Fr.9E GPP / SINGLE ROOMS BUILDING ARCHITECTURAL COMMENTS REVIEW
transmittal NO.
enka response
MOE response
11
NO

STATUS
OPEN

TBC Remarks (24 Apr 2013)


This comment should be closed. Please refer
to the approved thermal conductance
calculation document no. HPP-TBC-M-02-GEN2891 (submittal no. 414.)

Apply skirting 10 cm height at below edge for all brick


walls.

131

OK. This will be considered in Typical Architectural


Drawings.

O.K.

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

Show RC lintels below windows to work as a cap for


double leaf wall in architectural sections.

131

OK. This will be considered in Typical Architectural


Drawings.

O.K.

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

Show RC lintels above doors in and windows architectural


sections.

131

OK. This will be considered in Typical Architectural


Drawings.

O.K.

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

All vertical edges of cavity walls (double leaf wall) at


doors, windows and RC columns should be closed with
brick units.

131

OK. This will be considered in Typical Architectural


Drawings.

O.K.

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

Specify type of false ceiling, specifications and details of


supporting metal frame.

131

This was not mentioned in design meeting in Bagdad.A


dedicated data sheet of false ceiling shall be prepared by
TBC and submitted to client and if required, details of
false ceiling shall be shown in Typical Architectural
Drawings.

O.K., wait for TBC submital

OPEN

False ceiling specification will be defined by


TBC and submitted to MOE for approval.
Please close this comment.

All interior partitions should have thickness of 240 mm


instead of 115 mm because of its large height and length
and to provide sufficient support for doors and windows.

131

There is no any statement about this request in Tender


Documents. This was also not mentioned in design
meeting in Bagdad. Bricks of 115 mm width are used in
this building. We do not see any technical reason to
increase the width of walls.

Submitt static and stability calculations for


115mm partitions taking into
considerartion reduction in thickness due
to embedding electrical and plumbing
conduits.

OPEN

Internal partition walls shall be made 14 cm


thick including plaster. We do not see any
technical reason for further increase on wall
thickness.

Apply damp proofing concrete layer DPC 20 cm thick


under all brick walls and partitions.

131

OK. This will be considered in Typical Architectural


Drawings.

O.K.

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

Use teak wood instead of hardwood for doors.

131

This was not mentioned in design meeting in Bagdad. At


10.5.3 of specification of project, material of doors is
described as hardwood. So in drawings indicated as it is.

O.K.

Specify type of interior plastering (cement or gypsum).

131

This was not mentioned in design meeting in Bagdad.


There is no any statement about interior plaster type in
Tender Documents. This should be decided by TBC. if
required, type of interior plastering shall be shown in
Typical Architectural Drawings.

O.K., wait for TBC submital

OPEN

TBC confirms that internal plaster will consist


of following layers: cement plaster + 2 mm
gypsum plaster + painting.

Show details of spiral stair and connection details with the


building.

131

This was not mentioned in design meeting in Bagdad.


Separate drawing will be prepared to show all details of
spiral stair.

O.K.

OPEN

OK. A new drawing will be prepared and


submitted. Please close this comment.

Give enlarge details for stair case and handrails.

131

All dimensions of stair and landing are already given.


Required details are also given in Standard Details for
Steel Structures

O.K.

Give table for doors and windows including all details.

131

This was not mentioned in design meeting in Bagdad.


Table of doors and windows that includes material and
dimensions of frames is already given in related
drawings.

It is needed to show doors and windows


DIMENSIONS in this table

Add protection steel grid layer for all exterior windows.

131

This was not mentioned in design meeting in Bagdad.


There is no any statement about this request in Tender
Documents.

It is needed to fix protection steel grid to


external windows for safety.

Give enlarge details for exterior wall.

131

OK. This will be considered in Typical Architectural


Drawings.

O.K.

CLOSED CLOSED

CLOSED CLOSED

OPEN

This comment should be closed. Door and


window schedules are already provided in
building's architectural drawings (see dwg.
No. HPP-TBC-C-71-SNB-2067 & 2068.)

CLOSED CLOSED

OPEN

This comment should be closed. Exterior wall


detail is already provided in typical
architectural drawings (see dwg. No. HPP-TBCC-51-GEN-2087.)

MOE review
Add penthouse for the building at roof with external cut
ladder.

Give details for external cut ladder..

HAYDARIA 4xGE Fr.9E GPP / SINGLE ROOMS BUILDING ARCHITECTURAL COMMENTS REVIEW
transmittal NO.
enka response
MOE response
This was not mentioned in design meeting in Bagdad.
It is needed to add penthouse, because
131
There is no any statement about this request in Tender
the building consist of 2 stories.
Documents. A steel ladder already shown in related
drawings to access roof of building. There is no need to
extend stair up to roof level and add a penthouse.
131

Required details are also given in Standard Details for


Steel Structures

O.K.

STATUS
OPEN

TBC Remarks (24 Apr 2013)


Access to roof level is already provided with a
ladder. We do not see any necessity to add a
penthouse.

CLOSED CLOSED

MOE review -transmittal 161


1. Apply skirting l0cm height at below edge for all brick walls.

enka response
NO

HAYDARIA 4xGE Fr.9E GPP / ELECTRICAL CONTROL BUILDING ARCHITECTURAL COMMENTS REVIEW
MOE review -transmittal 263
enka response
MOE review -transmittal 362
1. Apply skirting l0cm height at below edge for all brick
NO
1. Apply skirting l0cm height at below edge for all brick walls.
walls.

enka response
NO

STATUS
OPEN

TBC Remarks (24 Apr 2013)


OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will
be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

2. Specify type of painting for walls of each floor.

NO

2. Specify type of painting for walls of each floor.

NO

2. Specify type of painting for walls of each floor.

NO

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

3. Show RC lintels below windows to work as a cap for double leaf wall in
ARCH.Sections.

NO

3. Show RC lintels below windows to work as a cap for


double leaf wall in ARCH.Sections.

NO

3. Show RC lintels below windows to work as a cap for double


leaf wall in ARCH.Sections.

NO

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

4. Show RC lintels above doors in ARCH. Sections.

NO

4. Show RC lintels above doors in ARCH. Sections.

NO

4. Show RC lintels above doors in ARCH. Sections.

NO

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

5. All vertical edges of cavity walls (double leaf wall) at doors, windows
and RC columns should be closed with brick units.

NO

5. All vertical edges of cavity walls (double leaf wall) at


doors, windows and RC columns should be closed with
brick units.

NO

5. All vertical edges of cavity walls (double leaf wall) at doors,


windows and RC columns should be closed with brick units.

NO

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

6. For long cavity walls (double leaf wall),add diaphragm brick units
between two brick leafs.

NO

6. For long cavity walls (double leaf wall),add diaphragm


brick units between two brick leafs.

NO

6. For long cavity walls (double leaf wall),add diaphragm brick


units between two brick leafs.

NO

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

7. Specify type of false ceiling,specifications and de tails of supporting


metal frame.

NO

7. Specify type of false ceiling,specifications and de tails


of supporting metal frame.

NO

7. Specify type of false ceiling,specifications and de tails of


supporting metal frame.

NO

OPEN

False ceiling specification will be defined by


TBC and submitted to MOE for approval.
Please close this comment.

8. All interior partitions should have thickness of 240mm instead of


llSmm because of its large height and length and to provide sufficient
support for doors and windows.

NO

8. All interior partitions should have thickness of 240mm


instead of llSmm because of its large height and length
and to provide sufficient support for doors and windows.

NO

8. All interior partitions should have thickness of 240mm


instead of llSmm because of its large height and length and to
provide sufficient support for doors and windows.

NO

OPEN

Internal partition walls shall be made 14 cm


thick including plaster. We do not see any
technical reason for further increase on wall
thickness.

9. Specify type of interior plastering (cement or gypsum).

NO

9. Specify type of interior plastering (cement or gypsum).

NO

9. Specify type of interior plastering (cement or gypsum).

NO

OPEN

TBC confirms that internal plaster will consist


of following layers: cement plaster + 2 mm
gypsum plaster + painting.

10. Give table for doors and windows including all details.
11. Add protection steel grid layer for all exterior windows.

NO
NO

11. Add protection steel grid layer for all exterior


windows.

NO

NO

CLOSED
CLOSED

CLOSED
CLOSED

12. Show enlarges details for exterior wall.

NO

12. Show enlarges details for exterior wall.

NO

12. Show enlarges details for exterior wall.

NO

OPEN

This comment should be closed. Exterior wall


detail is already provided in typical
architectural drawings (see dwg. No. HPP-TBCC-51-GEN-2087.)

13. Check the structuralsupporting frame of the main s'tair case.

NO

13. Check the structuralsupporting frame of the main


s'tair case.

NO

13. Check the structuralsupporting frame of the main s'tair


case.

NO

OPEN

This comment should be closed. A separate


drawing was issued for stairway support
frame structure (see dwg. No. HPP-TBC-C-90ECB-2890, submittal no. 407.)

14. Add water proof protection layers for RC basement w'all

NO

14. Add water proof protection layers for RC basement


w'all

NO

14. Add water proof protection layers for RC basement w'all

NO

OPEN

This comment should be closed. Two layers of


bitumen coating is already shown in related
architectural and structural drawings.

15. Add drain pit at basement level.

NO

15. Add drain pit at basement level.

NO

15. Add drain pit at basement level.

NO

OPEN

This comment should be closed. Drain pit is


already added to the related structural
drawings (see dwg. No. HPP-TBC-C-71-ECB2201 & C-90-ECB-2516.)

16.Give enlarge details for all stairs case.

NO

16.Give enlarge details for all stairs case.

NO

16.Give enlarge details for all stairs case.

NO

OPEN

This comment should be closed. Stairway


design, dimensions and reinforcement details
are already provided with following drawings:
HPP-TBC-C-90-ECB-2516, 2517, 2518, 2519,
2521, 2522 and 2539.

17. Increase thickness of ra ft foundation to be 50cm minimum.

NO

17. Increase thickness of ra ft foundation to be 50cm


minimum.

NO

DONE

CLOSED

CLOSED

18.Revise levels of typical section in drawing no. C-14606 and C-14607


according to basement level.

NO

18.Revise levels of typical section in drawing no. C-14606


and C-14607 according to basement level.

NO

DONE

CLOSED

CLOSED

19. Show details of steelgrid around out door spiral stair case.

NO

19. Show details of steelgrid around out door spiral stair


case.

NO

OPEN

OK. A new drawing will be prepared and


submitted. Please close this comment.

19. Show details of steelgrid around out door spiral stair case.

NO

MOE review
please clarify & INSURE THAT ALL WALLS AND ROOF
HAVE U=0.25W/M2K ACCORDING TO ITEM (10.4.1)
FROM CONTRACT.

HAYDARIA 4xGE Fr.9E GPP / MAIN GATE HOUSE ARCHITECTURAL COMMENTS REVIEW
transmittal NO.
enka response
STATUS
12
no
OPEN

TBC Remarks (24 Apr 2013)


This comment should be closed. Please refer
to the approved thermal conductance
calculation document no. HPP-TBC-M-02-GEN2891 (submittal no. 414.)

1. Apply skirting 10cm height at below edge for all brick


wa lls.

163

no

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

2. Show RC lintels below windows to work as a cap for


double leaf wall in ARCH. Sections.

163

no

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

3. Show RC lintels above doors in ARCH. Sections.

163

no

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

4. All vertical edges of cavity walls (double leaf wall) at


doors, windows and RC columns should be closed with
brick units.

163

no

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

5. For long cavity walls (double leaf wall),add


diaphragm brick units between two brick leafs.

163

no

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

6. Specify type of false ceiling,specifications and details


of supporting metal frame.

163

no

OPEN

False ceiling specification will be defined by


TBC and submitted to MOE for approval.
Please close this comment.

7. All interior partitions should ha ve thickness of


240mm instead of 115mm to provide sufficient support
for doors and windows.

163

no

OPEN

Internal partition walls shall be made 14 cm


thick including plaster. We do not see any
technical reason for further increase on wall
thickness.

8. Apply damp proofing concrete layer DPC 20cm thick


under all brick walls and partitions.

163

no

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

9. Use teak wood instead of hard wood for doors.

163

no

OPEN

This comment should be removed same as


the other buildings.

10. Specify type of interior plastering (cement or


gypsum).

163

no

OPEN

TBC confirms that internal plaster will consist


of following layers: cement plaster + 2 mm
gypsum plaster + painting.

11. Give table for doors and windows including all


details.

163

no

OPEN

This comment should be closed. Door and


window schedules are already provided in
building's architectural drawings (see dwg.
No. HPP-TBC-C-71-GTH-2075.)

12. Add protection steelgrid layer for all exterior


windows.

163

no

OPEN

This comment should be removed same as


the other buildings.

13. Show enlarges details for exterior wall and cut


ladder.

163

no

OPEN

This comment should be closed. Exterior wall


and cat ladder details are already provided in
typical detail drawings (see dwg. No. HPP-TBCC-51-GEN-2085 & 2087.)

HAYDARIA 4xGE Fr.9E GPP / FUEL UNLOADING GATE HOUSE ARCHITECTURAL COMMENTS REVIEW
MOE review
transmittal NO.
enka response
STATUS
TBC Remarks (24 Apr 2013)
1. Apply skirting 10cm height at below edge for all brick
164
no
OPEN
OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will
wa lls.
be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.
2. Show RC lintels below windows to work as a cap for
double leaf wall in ARCH. Sections.

164

no

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

3. Show RC lintels above doors in ARCH. Sections.

164

no

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

4. All vertical edges of cavity walls (double leaf wall) at


doors, windows and RC columns should be closed with
brick units.

164

no

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

5. For long cavity walls (double leaf wall),add diaphragm


brick units between two brick leafs.

164

no

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

6. Specify type of false ceiling,specifications and details


of supporting metal frame.

164

no

OPEN

False ceiling specification will be defined by


TBC and submitted to MOE for approval.
Please close this comment.

164

no

OPEN

Internal partition walls shall be made 14 cm


thick including plaster. We do not see any
technical reason for further increase on wall
thickness.

8. Apply damp proofing concrete layer DPC 20cm thick


under all brick walls and partitions.

164

no

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

9. Use teak wood instead of hard wood for doors.

164

no

OPEN

This comment should be removed same as


the other buildings.

10. Specify type of interior plastering (cement or


gypsum).

164

no

OPEN

TBC confirms that internal plaster will consist


of following layers: cement plaster + 2 mm
gypsum plaster + painting.

11. Give table for doors and windows including all details.

164

no

OPEN

This comment should be closed. Door and


window schedules are already provided in
building's architectural drawings (see dwg.
No. HPP-TBC-C-71-GTH-2393.)

12. Add protection steelgrid layer for all exterior windows.

164

no

OPEN

This comment should be removed same as


the other buildings.

7. All interior partitions should ha ve thickness of


240mm instead of 115mm to provide sufficient support
for doors and windows.

HAYDARIA 4xGE Fr.9E GPP / FUEL UNLOADING GATE HOUSE ARCHITECTURAL COMMENTS REVIEW
MOE review
transmittal NO.
enka response
STATUS
TBC Remarks (24 Apr 2013)
13. Show enlarges details for exterior wall and cut ladder.
164
no
OPEN
This comment should be closed. Exterior wall
and cat ladder details are already provided in
typical detail drawings (see dwg. No. HPP-TBCC-51-GEN-2085 & 2087.)

MOE review
INSURE THAT ALL WALLS AND ROOF HAVE U=0.25W/M2K
ACCORDING TO contract

HAYDARIA 4xGE Fr.9E GPP / FIRE BRIGADE BUILDING ARCHITECTURAL COMMENTS REVIEW
transmittal NO.
enka response
MOE review transmittal 160
19
no

status
open

TBC Remarks (24 Apr 2013)


This comment should be closed. Please refer
to the approved thermal conductance
calculation document no. HPP-TBC-M-02-GEN2891 (submittal no. 414.)

1. Apply skirting lOcm height at below edge for all brick walls.

141

no

1. Apply skirting lOcm height at below edge for all


brick walls.

open

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

2. Show RC lintels below windows to work as a cap for double leaf


wall in ARCH. Sections.

141

no

2. Show RC lintels below windows to work as a cap for


double leaf wall in ARCH. Sections.

open

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

3. Show RC lintels above doors in ARCH. Sections.

141

no

3. Show RC lintels above doors in ARCH. Sections.

open

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

4. All vertical edges of cavity walls (double leaf wall) at doors,


windows and RC columns should be closed with brick units.

141

no

4. All vertical edges of cavity walls (double leaf wall) at


doors, windows and RC columns should be closed with
brick units.

open

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

5. For long cavity walls (double leaf wall),add diaphragm brick


units between two brick leafs.

141

no

5. For long cavity walls (double leaf wall),add


diaphragm brick units between two brick leafs.

open

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

6. Specify type of false ceiling,specifications and details of


supporting metal frame.

141

no

6. Specify type of false ceiling,specifications and


details of supporting metal frame.

open

False ceiling specification will be defined by


TBC and submitted to MOE for approval.
Please close this comment.

7. All interior partitions should have thickness of 240mm


instead of llSmm because of its large height and length and to
provide sufficient support for doors and windows.

141

no

7. All interior partitions should have thickness of


240mm instead of llSmm because of its large height
and length and to provide sufficient support for doors
and windows.

open

Internal partition walls shall be made 14 cm


thick including plaster. We do not see any
technical reason for further increase on wall
thickness.

8. Apply damp proofing concrete layer DPC 20cm thick under all
brick walls and partitions.

141

no

8. Apply damp proofing concrete layer DPC 20cm thick


under all brick walls and partitions.

open

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

9. Specify type of interior plastering (cement or gypsum).

141

no

9. Specify type of interior plastering (cement or


gypsum).

open

TBC confirms that internal plaster will consist


of following layers: cement plaster + 2 mm
gypsum plaster + painting.

10. Give table for doors and windows including all details.

141

no

10. Give table for doors and windows including all


details.

open

This comment should be closed. Door and


window schedules are already provided in
building's architectural drawings (see dwg.
No. HPP-TBC-C-71-FBB-2082.)

11. Add protection steelgrid layer for all exterior windows.

141

no

11. Add protection steelgrid layer for all exterior


windows.

open

This comment should be removed same as


the other buildings.

12. Show enlarges details for exterior wall.

141

no

12. Show enlarges details for exterior wall.

open

This comment should be closed. Exterior wall


detail is already provided in typical
architectural drawings (see dwg. No. HPP-TBCC-51-GEN-2087.)

13. Section D, F:It is suggested to extend roof of the building on


the left side to the right side (make an interaction between the
two buildings) to avoid rain water entrance through the gap
between two buildings.

141

no

14. Show in plan how fire truck entrance connection with the site.

141

no

closed

14. Show in plan how fire truck entrance connection


with the site.

open

CLOSED

This comment should be closed. Requested


connection is shown in plot plan (dwg. No.
HPP-TBC-G-55-GEN-2001) and internal road
plan (dwg. No. HPP-TBC-C-58-PIR-2159.)

MOE review
15. It suggested increasing the distances between axes (4 and 5)
and (5 and 6) in truck building (to contain and cover fire truck)
from 4.3m to 5.0m.

HAYDARIA 4xGE Fr.9E GPP / FIRE BRIGADE BUILDING ARCHITECTURAL COMMENTS REVIEW
transmittal NO.
enka response
MOE review transmittal 160
141
no

16. Add 2 steel beams connect each set of Bumpers,more details


are needed.

141

no

17. Add cut ladder to the truck building.

141

no

18. Increase height of truck building from5.0 m to 5.5 m.


19. Use teak wood instead of hard wood for doors.

141
141

no
no

16. Add 2 steel beams connect each set of


Bumpers,more details are needed.

status
closed

open

TBC Remarks (24 Apr 2013)


CLOSED

Related drawing will be revised to include


reinforced concrete barrier blocks.
This comment should be closed. Cat ladder is
already included with dwg. No. HPP-TBC-C-71FBB-2082 & 2084.

19. Use teak wood instead of hard wood for doors.

closed
open

CLOSED
This comment should be removed same as
the other buildings.

13.The interaction between should be revised and


unified for other elevations and sections.

open

This comment is already incorporated. Please


refer to the latest revisions of related
architectural and structural drawings.

16. Unify levels of the 2 buildings for all section and


eleva tions according to Left and Right

open

This comment is already incorporated. Please


refer to the latest revisions of related
architectural and structural drawings. Please
close this comment.

MOE review
please clarify & INSURE THAT ALL WALLS AND ROOF HAVE U=0.25W/M2K
ACCORDING TO ITEM (10.4.1) FROM CONTRACT.(TRANSMITTAL NO.10)

HAYDARIA 4xGE Fr.9E GPP / ADMINISTRATION BUILDING ARCHITECTURAL COMMENTS REVIEW


enka response
MOE response
NO

Apply skirting 10 cm height at below edge for all brick walls (TRANSMITTALOK. This will be considered in Typical Architectural
Drawings.

status
OPEN

TBC Remarks (24 Apr 2013)


This comment should be closed. Please refer
to the approved thermal conductance
calculation document no. HPP-TBC-M-02-GEN2891 (submittal no. 414.)

O.K.

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

Show RC lintels below windows to work as a cap for double leaf wall in
architectural sections (TRANSMITTAL NO.143).

OK. This will be considered in Typical Architectural


Drawings.

O.K.

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

Show RC lintels above doors in and windows architectural sections


(TRANSMITTAL NO.143).

OK. This will be considered in Typical Architectural


Drawings.

O.K.

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

All vertical edges of cavity walls (double leaf wall) at doors, windows and
RC columns should be closed with brick units (TRANSMITTAL NO.143).

OK. This will be considered in Typical Architectural


Drawings.

O.K.

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

O.K., wait for TBC submital

OPEN

False ceiling specification will be defined by


TBC and submitted to MOE for approval.
Please close this comment.

OPEN

Internal partition walls shall be made 14 cm


thick including plaster. We do not see any
technical reason for further increase on wall
thickness.

OPEN

OK. Typical Architectural Details drawings will


be revised accordingly. Please close this
comment.

Specify type of false ceiling, specifications and details of supporting metal This was not mentioned in design meeting in
frame (TRANSMITTAL NO.143).
Bagdad.A dedicated data sheet of false ceiling
shall be prepared by TBC and submitted to client
and if required, details of false ceiling shall be
shown in Typical Architectural Drawings.
All interior partitions should have thickness of 240 mm instead of 115 mm There is no any statement about this request in
because of its large height and length and to provide sufficient support for Tender Documents. This was also not mentioned
doors and windows (TRANSMITTAL NO.143).
in design meeting in Bagdad. Bricks of 115 mm
width are used in this building. We do not see any
technical reason to increase the width of walls.

Submitt static and stability calculations for 115mm


partitions taking into considerartion reduction in
thickness due to embedding electrical and plumbing
conduits.

Apply damp proofing concrete layer DPC 20 cm thick under all brick walls
and partitions (TRANSMITTAL NO.143).

OK. This will be considered in Typical Architectural


Drawings.

O.K.

Use teak wood instead of hardwood for doors (TRANSMITTAL NO.143).

This was not mentioned in design meeting in


Bagdad. At 10.5.3 of specification of project,
material of doors is described as hardwood. So in
drawings indicated as it is.

O.K.

Specify type of interior plastering (cement or gypsum) (TRANSMITTAL NO.14This was not mentioned in design meeting in
Bagdad. There is no any statement about interior
plaster type in Tender Documents. This should be
decided by TBC. if required, type of interior
plastering shall be shown in Typical Architectural
Drawings.
Give enlarge details for stair case and handrails (TRANSMITTAL NO.143).

All dimensions of stair and landing are already


given. Required details are also given in Standard
Details for Steel Structures

O.K., wait for TBC submital

O.K.

This was not mentioned in design meeting in


It is needed to show doors and windows DIMENSIONS in
Give table for doors and windows including all details (TRANSMITTAL NO.143
Bagdad. Table of doors and windows that includes this table
material and dimensions of frames is already
given in related drawings.
Add protection steel grid layer for all exterior windows (TRANSMITTAL NO.14This was not mentioned in design meeting in
Bagdad. There is no any statement about this
request in Tender Documents.
Give enlarge details for exterior wall (TRANSMITTAL NO.143).

OK. This will be considered in Typical Architectural


Drawings.

It is needed to fix protection steel grid to external


windows for safety.
O.K.

CLOSED CLOSED

OPEN

TBC confirms that internal plaster will consist


of following layers: cement plaster + 2 mm
gypsum plaster + painting.

CLOSED CLOSED

OPEN

This comment should be closed. Door and


window schedules are already provided in
building's architectural drawings (see dwg.
No. HPP-TBC-C-71-ADB-2054, 2055 & 2056.)

CLOSED CLOSED

OPEN

This comment should be closed. Exterior wall


detail is already provided in typical
architectural drawings (see dwg. No. HPP-TBCC-51-GEN-2087.)

MOE review
Add cut ladder to the penthouse with details (TRANSMITTAL NO.143).

HAYDARIA 4xGE Fr.9E GPP / ADMINISTRATION BUILDING ARCHITECTURAL COMMENTS REVIEW


enka response
MOE response
OK. This will be considered in next issue.
O.K.

Give details for external cut ladder (TRANSMITTAL NO.143)


Partition lie on expansion joint at ground and first floors should be shifted
to the edge of column (TRANSMITTAL NO.143).

Required details are also given in Standard Details


O.K.
This was not mentioned in design meeting in
It is needed to shift brick partion to the edge of column
Bagdad. This will be considered in next issue.
to avoide expansion joint.

Check relation between external stair and adjacent window on axis M.


(TRANSMITTAL NO.143)

Unfortunately external stair of building intersects


and blinds this window partially. This window may
be cancelled completely or keep as it is.

Extend area of upper land of external stair to the end of column on axis 7. OK. This will be revised as requested.
(TRANSMITTAL NO.143)

Show details of expansion joint at roof and at edge of penthouse on axis 6- Please clarify.
6. (TRANSMITTAL NO.143)

Add window to penthouse. (TRANSMITTAL NO.143)

OK. This will be revised as requested.

status
OPEN

TBC Remarks (24 Apr 2013)


Roof access is already provided with a
stairway and penthouse. There is no need for
a cat ladder. Please remove this comment.

CLOSED CLOSED
OPEN
This comment is already incorporated. Please
refer to the latest revisions of related
architectural and structural drawings. Please
close this comment.

O.K.

OPEN

This comment should be closed with our


previous response and your agreement.

O.K.

OPEN

This comment is already incorporated. Please


refer to the latest revisions of related
architectural and structural drawings. Please
close this comment.

OPEN

This detail is already provided in latest


revisions of related drawings (see dwg. No.
HPP-TBC-C-90-ADB-2578, 2581 & 2586.)
Please close this comment.

OPEN

This comment is already incorporated. Please


refer to the latest revisions of related
architectural drawings. Please close this
comment.

Show expansion joint at penthouse in sections on axis


6-6'

O.K.

You might also like