Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Professor Manley
EN 102
27 March 2015
The Unleveled Playing Field: Females in Collegiate Sports
Imagine being one of thirty eight females. Now of those thirty eight females, imagine you
are only one of ten that participate in sports. Welcome to my reality. To be a female at Valley
Forge meant joining a miniscule, under-recognized group of people. But there wasnt really any
sense of how underrepresented we would be as student athletes. Upon my arrival, as I walked to
meet and join the remainder of my classmates, I noticed something was extremely peculiar. The
amount of male collegiate athletes was overwhelming; the disproportion minding-blowing. To
make matters even worse, out of the approximate one hundred ten males placed in H Company
(the athletic company for the residential students at VFMC), about 85% of them (if not more)
financed their education through athletic scholarships after being recruited. In complete contrast,
out of the ten females at VFMC for athletics, only six of them financed their education through
athletic scholarship upon recruitment. Noting these major differences, I decided to compare the
athletics offered at VFMC side by side.
At the conclusion of volleyball season, which initiates the beginning of female and male
basketball season, several large differences sent up immediate red flags. For one, the mens
bench barely had any room. The bench, at any given time, held fifteen members, which meant
there were approximately twenty members on the mens team. However, in great contrast, the
womens team struggled with five members. The players would have to take on forty minutes of
playing time and were expected to play through exhaustion and injury. This also became a
problem when two females (my roommate and I) were requested to play basketball or at least sit
on and fill the bench by both our Head Coach of Womens Volleyball and the Head Coach of
Womens Basketball. Along with being well aware that I had a serious injury at the time and was
not cleared and that we didnt possess the qualifications to play this sport, my roommate and I
were uninterested in playing as we had come to play softball and volleyball, respectively.
Another large issue is that the sports offered are uneven for the men and women. The mens
teams include football, basketball, lacrosse and baseball, while womens teams include only
volleyball and basketball. While the VFMC website advertises the school offers that there are
soccer and softball programs, neither program exists. (vfmac.edu)
Unfortunately, incidents such as this are not just exclusive to Valley Forge Military
College; they happen in colleges and universities all across the United States. The acts
introduced above are all illegal under the Title IX law. Enacted in June of 1972, the main
objectives were not only surrounding the basis of athletics, but for the gender equity in all things
education, healthcare, job availability, etc. Though edited to meet the growing demand and
issues of the public, the fundamentals of Title IX are particularly straight forward. Through
athletic Title IX and female equity are seen something that has been solved already through the
passing of the Title IX law, it is evident in my case and similar cases nationwide that this is still a
relevant problem that needs to be improved.
Senator Birch Bayh of Indiana, who was the chief Senate sponsor and the author
of Title IX, first introduced the law to Congress. Bayh was also attempting to rework various
constitutional issues in regards to womens rights at the time of Title IXs introduction. One
major amendment he incorporated was the Equal Rights Amendment, built to abolish
discriminatory differential treatment based on sex. The Higher Education Act of 1965, reworked
and eventually reauthorized, was finally introduced as an amendment on February 28, 1972.
When making some remarks on the Senate floor, Bayh stated, "We are all familiar with
the stereotype of women as pretty things who go to college to find a husband, go on to graduate
school because they want a more interesting husband, and finally marry, have children, and never
work again. But the facts absolutely contradict these myths about the 'weaker sex' and it is time
to change our operating assumptions. While the impact of this amendment would be farreaching", Bayh concluded, "it is not a panacea. It is, however, an important first step in the
effort to provide for the women of America something that is rightfully theirsan equal chance
to attend the schools of their choice, to develop the skills they want, and to apply those skills
with the knowledge that they will have a fair chance to secure the jobs of their choice with equal
pay for equal work". Title IX became law on June 23, 1972. When President Nixon signed the
bill, he spoke mostly about desegregation busing, which was also a focus of the signed bill, but
did not mention the expansion of educational access for women he had enacted.
Title IX in its entirety is quite brief and therefore requires specific language, phrases and
clarifications when understanding the implemented regulations. President Nixon delegated the
Department of Health, Education and Welfare (HEW) with belief that they could handle the task.
There was growing concerns about how exactly Title IX would affect mens athletic programs
and there were several notions looking for ways to limit Title IXs overall influence. Senator
Bayh spent the following three years watching the HEW formulate regulations that would end
discrimination, based on sex, in higher education. When the regulations were issued in the
summer of 1975, they were contested. The House Subcommittee on Equal Opportunities held
hearings about the discrepancies between the regulations and the actual law. Also to be
monitored were colleges and universities, to ensure that implementation of the law took place.
However, there were cases in which some did not want to comply with the law. Senator John
Tower was one of these cases, in 1974. He introduced the Tower Amendment, which would have
exempted revenue-producing sports from complying with Title IX. In that same year, the Tower
Amendment was rejected and in its place came the Javits Amendment. Senator Jacob Javits
proposed that the HEW must include reasonable provisions considering the nature of particular
sports.
In June of 1975, HEW published the final regulations about Title IX and how it would be
enforced. It was not until then that the general public fully understood the entirety of Title IX and
its application to collegiate sports. Three years was the time frame in which the government gave
universities that received federal assistance to comply with Title IX regulations. However, the
NCAA claimed that Title IX and its implications were illegal. This is when the Tower
Amendment was brought back into debates, with revisions. However in the end, Title IX stood,
untouched.
males when it comes to these five factors: program support, financial support, sports offerings,
scheduling, and changes in the past two to three years. (aauw.org)
order to be able to expand the team, according to Title IX, there must be an equal amount of
female athletes and athletic programs available at the school. Without the aforementioned
requirements being fulfilled, football coaches would have to cut down their team sizes. On
average, a team in this day and age is about 111 men strong as opposed to previous years, were
the team was made up of approximately 96 men.
The total unduplicated number of student athletes at Chadron State College in 2013-2014 was
348. There were 252 men and 96 women who participated in intercollegiate athletics. 69.2% of
the participants were men and 30.8% were women. The breakdown by individual sport is below:
List all sports and number of participants by gender as below.
Mens:
Women:
Basketball
16
Basketball
12
Cross Country
15
Cross Country
15
Football
156
Golf
Indoor Track
59
Softball
21
Outdoor Track
60
Indoor Track
38
Wrestling
29
Outdoor Track
39
Volleyball
17
Total*
335
149
*Participant totals may be duplicated due to athlete participation in more than one
List all sports and dollar amount of financial aid by gender as below
Mens:
Women:
Basketball
$88,307
Basketball
$67,409
Football
$273,987
Golf
$13,844
Track Combined
$131,118
Softball
$55,633
Wrestling
$574,589
Track, Combined
$85660
Volleyball
$68,181
Total
$568,001
$290,727
Women:
Basketball
$77,667
Basketball
$57,874
Football
$215,479
Golf
$19,029
Track Combined
$104,728
Softball
$75,893
Wrestling
$57,535
Track, Combined
$72,742
Volleyball
$47,471
Total
$455,409
$273,009
10
Recruiting Expenses
The total recruiting expenditures for athletics in 2013-2014 were $38,561, with the mens
program spending $26,715, the womens program spending $11,846. 69.3% of the recruiting
dollars were for men and 30.7% for women. A breakdown by individual sport is below:
List all sports and dollars spent by gender as below.
Mens:
Women:
Basketball
$6,046
Basketball
$4,735
Football
$18,099
Golf
$98
Track Combined
$1,528
Softball
$3,810
Wrestling
$1,042
Track, Combined
$1,075
Volleyball
$2,128
Total
$26,715
$11,846
11
Now, imagine your mother, sister, wife, daughter. Imagine them having to deal with what
thousands of women have to face on a yearly basis. The amount of hours they put into the sport
of their choice, perfecting their skill just to find out that they arent being properly represented or
are being pushed to do things that they arent interested in to make their school look better.
Everything that they had wanted is put on the line for things that seem to be beyond their control.
Being able to understand and possibly solve the issues would be the best way to fix this problem
of Title IX infractions and the inequity seen in collegiate sports, By budgeting money fairly
between the scholarship funds and the actual team funds for each sport, the equity issue could be
more easily avoided. It would also make sense to be sure that if there arent many female teams
with an abundance of male teams, several of the male teams that arent as popular would ideally
be cut to better accommodate both men and women. There are things that everyone can do to
ensure that these things are more fairly run.
Through Title IX, women have been given rights that they should have always had. While
this law was enacted approximately 50 years ago, the ability to treat females as though they are
equal to men remains a challenge. Everyone aspires to be great. So to limit the greatness of
females is a definite injustice. To live this reality firsthand and to have experience several athletic
Title IX offenses in my first year of college, I would hate for other women with goals, hopes and
dreams to have to experience this as well.