Professional Documents
Culture Documents
doi:10.1111/jpc.12164
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Aim: Overweight and obesity affects approximately 20% of Australian pre-schoolers. The general practice nurse (PN) workforce has increased
in recent years; however, little is known of PN capacity and potential to provide routine advice for the prevention of child obesity. This mixed
methods pilot study aims to explore the current practices, attitudes, condence and training needs of Australian PNs surrounding child obesity
prevention in the general practice setting.
Methods: PNs from three Divisions of General Practice in New South Wales were invited to complete a questionnaire investigating PN roles,
attitudes and practices in preventive care with a focus on child obesity. A total of 59 questionnaires were returned (response rate 22%).
Semi-structured qualitative interviews were also conducted with a subsample of PNs (n = 10).
Results: Questionnaire respondent demographics were similar to that of national PN data. PNs described preventive work as enjoyable
despite some perceived barriers including lack of condence. Number of years working in general practice did not appear to strongly inuence
nurses perceived barriers. Seventy per cent of PNs were interested in being more involved in conducting child health checks in practice, and 85%
expressed an interest in taking part in child obesity prevention training.
Conclusions: Findings from this pilot study suggest that PNs are interested in prevention of child obesity despite barriers to practice and low
condence levels. More research is needed to determine the effect of training on PN condence and behaviours in providing routine healthy
life-style messages for the prevention of child obesity.
Key words:
1 The primary health care setting plays an important role in providing care to families and children.
2 The general practice nurse (PN) workforce has more than
doubled over the past decade, enhancing the capacity of the
primary health-care team to offer preventive care.
3 The Medicare-supported Healthy Kids Check provides PNs with
the opportunity to assess pre-schoolers health and development and discuss life-style habits with parents.
Overweight and obesity affects approximately 20% of Australian pre-school children1 and is a condition with serious health,
social and psychological consequences. Overweight children are
at increased risk of carrying excess weight into adulthood2 and
of developing some chronic diseases early in life.3 Hence, the
prevention of overweight and obesity is critical, especially in the
E294
A Robinson et al.
Semi-structured interviews
A purposeful subsample of the questionnaire respondents was
invited to participate in a semi-structured interview. Interviews were conducted either by telephone or face-to-face
depending on nurse preference, and lasted approximately
20 min. Informed consent was gained by participating nurses
for the recording, transcribing and qualitative analysis of interview data. Interview questions were designed to expand upon
questionnaire topics to gain a richer understanding of PN
experiences.
Analysis
Quantitative analysis was conducted using SPSS version 17.0
(IBM Corporation, Armonk, NY, USA) by two members of the
research team to investigate associations between PN demographics, workload and barriers and confidence levels relating to
child health checks. Qualitative data analysis was performed by
two members of the research team reading each transcript independently and then meeting to agree upon codes and themes.
Ethics
Participants
PNs from three Divisions of General Practice (DGP) (two metropolitan and one rural division with whom the authors have
previously conducted research) in New South Wales were
invited to take part in the study by responding to a questionnaire. Completion and return of the questionnaire was assumed
as consent for PNs undertaking this part of the study.
Questionnaire
The questionnaire was constructed by the research team and
included questions on nurse demographics, responsibilities,
confidence in and barriers to preventive care practices and interest in further education and training on child obesity prevention. The questionnaire was administered via nurses local DGP,
either electronically or in paper form. The sampling frame was
based on the list of PNs kept by the local DGP. A reply paid
Table 1
Results
Demographic data
A total of 59 questionnaires were returned (response rate
~22%), and most surveyed nurses (n = 34, 58%) expressed
interest in participating in an interview. Semi-structured interviews were conducted until data saturation was considered to be
reached (n = 10 interviews). Table 1 shows questionnaire
response rate by division characteristics.
Seven of the nurses interviewed were from a metro-classified
DGP, seven were aged over 40 years and seven had worked in
general practice for less than 5 years.
Division
Rurality
Number of nurses
Response rate
1
2
3
Metro
Metro
Rural
107
65
~120
21.5%
32.3%
~12.5
Classication of rurality determined using Rural Remote Metropolitan Area classication guide13.
Response rate approximate for Division as exact number of PNs unknown at time of questionnaire administration.
E295
A Robinson et al.
Condence
Nurses reported greater confidence in providing healthy lifestyle advice to overweight adult patients compared with providing advice to parents of overweight children (Table 2). Less
than half of PNs (43.1%) surveyed reported moderate or high
confidence in conducting child health checks, assessing BMI
and providing suggestions to parents about healthy eating,
physical activity and limiting screen time. PNs spending more
than 10% of their time on child health checks reported greater
confidence providing healthy eating (P = 0.01) and physical
activity (P = 0.05) suggestions to parents than PNs spending
<10% of their time on child health checks. PNs with <5 years
experience in general practice indicated lesser confidence than
those with >5 years experience in assessing dietary intake as
part of child health checks (P = 0.003), providing advice to
parents of overweight children (P = 0.001) and providing
suggestions to parents regarding setting limits on screenbased activities for children (P = 0.01). Education, training,
resources, life experiences and employment history were
also key factors influencing confidence levels in providing
advice for child obesity prevention of the ten PNs who were
interviewed.
The [DGP] came through and gave us support to set it [HKC]
up. We have a template from them. . .and also training at the
Division so Im fairly confident in what Im doing (Nurse 3,
metro).
A Robinson et al.
Table 2
Questionnaire data
Gender
Female
Age
2039 years
4049 years
50+ years
Years in general practice nursing
05 years
610 years
11+ years
Responsibilities in practice nursing
030%
3150%
Time spent conducting adult health checks
32 (58.2%)
11 (20.0%)
Time spent conducting child health checks
47 (88.7%)
4 (7.5%)
Time spent in other preventive activities
30 (58.8%)
9 (17.6%)
Condence in practice
Conducting adult health checks
Providing advice to overweight adult patients about healthy eating and activity
Assessing body mass index as part of child health checks
Providing suggestions to parents regarding healthy eating for children
Assessing growth as part of child health checks
Providing suggestions to parents regarding physical activity recommendations for children
Providing suggestions to parents regarding setting limits on TV and other screen-based activities for children
Conducting child health checks
Assessing physical activity levels as part of child health checks
Providing advice to parents of overweight children regarding healthy eating and activity
Assessing dietary intake as part of child health checks
Potential barriers
Socio-economic factors affecting the ability of families to make a change (e.g. cost of health food/referral to
exercise programs)
Patients lack of interest in making life-style changes
A lack of referral pathways to provide additional/ongoing care for patients if required
A lack of support for me to undertake this work in my role
My own lack of time
Lack of appropriate education materials for patients available at my general practice
A lack of relevance to the patients presenting issue
My lack of condence in counselling skills regarding child obesity prevention
My concerns patients/parents will not be receptive to healthy eating and physical activity advice
My insufcient knowledge about preventive care for child obesity (including healthy eating and physical activity
recommendations)
Advice regarding healthy eating and physical activity is not effective in preventing child obesity
Communication difculties with patients
Lack of relevance to my job role
Cultural differences between nurses and patients
My lack of interest in addressing child obesity preventive measures
My own life-style habits
Interest in further education and training
Participating in further training in chronic disease prevention in general practice
Being more involved in conducting adult health checks in my practice
Being more involved in providing child obesity prevention services in general practice
Being more involved in conducting child health checks (e.g. 4-year-old health check) in my practice
Participating in further training in child obesity prevention in general practice
Training preference for those interested in participating in further training in child obesity prevention
Half-day workshop
Full-day workshop
Self-directed online tutorial
Online module with tutor
Unit of study within graduate diploma
57 (96.6%)
15 (25.4%)
28 (47.5%)
16 (27.1%)
33 (55.9%)
11 (18.6%)
15 (25.4%)
>50%
12 (21.8%)
2 (3.8%)
12 (23.5%)
Moderately or very condent
51 (87.9%)
44 (75.9%)
28 (49.1%)
28 (48.3%)
27 (46.6%)
26 (44.8%)
26 (44.8%)
25 (43.1%)
24 (41.4%)
22 (37.9%)
21 (36.2%)
Moderately or very important
41 (73.2%)
38 (69.1%)
37 (66.1%)
35 (64.8%)
36 (62.1%)
34 (61.8%)
33 (60.0%)
33 (58.9%)
32 (57.1%)
29 (51.8%)
28 (50.9%)
28 (49.1%)
24 (46.2%)
21 (38.9%)
20 (37.0%)
19 (33.3%)
Moderately or very interested
48 (84.2%)
44 (78.6%)
44 (77.2%)
39 (70.9%)
Interested
50 (87.7%)
Indicated some interest (more
than one response allowed)
38 (65.5%)
37 (63.8%)
26 (44.8%)
23 (39.7%)
12 (20.7%)
E297
A Robinson et al.
Discussion
This mixed methods pilot study investigated roles, attitudes and
preventive care practices for child obesity among a small sample
of PNs in New South Wales, Australia.
The HKC provides an ideal opportunity to assess a childs
weight and provide healthy life-style advice to promote healthy
weight gain as part of routine care. However, the overall percentage of time respondents spent conducting child health
checks was low, compared to that for adult health checks.
Although the number of HKCs performed by PNs increased by
15% between the periods July 2008 to June 2009 and July 2009
to June 2010,14 low awareness and reluctance of parents to
attend the child health check suggests the need for greater
promotion of the value of the checks to parents, perhaps as part
of the school enrolment process.
Qualitative findings in this pilot study indicated that GPs and
employers largely determined PN roles, with priority given to
the provision of acute care. This suggests organisational and
structural barriers to PNs providing preventive care that are
likely to require solutions at the system level such as greater
reimbursement and funding models to support PNs role in providing preventive care. The theory of planned behaviour,15,16
which has been previously applied to preventive care delivery in
general practice in a predominantly GP cohort,17 would suggest
that in this context, social pressure is focused away from PNs
performing preventive activities and directed rather at tasks
such as wound care and immunisations. Combined with a low
level of autonomy in determining workload, PNs may feel
expected to comply with this pressure and therefore less likely
to perform preventive care tasks.
Common problems to addressing child obesity prevention as
described by PNs surrounded parental barriers, including
E298
Acknowledgements
This study was funded by a UNSW Faculty of Medicine, Early
Career Research Grant to E Denney-Wilson and a PHCRED
A Robinson et al.
14
References
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
http://www.phcris.org.au/fastfacts/fact.php?id=4801 [accessed 31
January 2011].
Medicare Australia. Medicare Item Reports. 2011. Available from:
http://www.medicareaustralia.gov.au/statistics/mbs_item.shtml
[accessed 4 May 2011].
Nutbeam D, Harris E. Theory in a Nutshell: A Guide to Health
Promotion Theory. Roseville, CA: McGraw-Hill Book Company
Australia, 1999.
Francis JJ, Eccles MP, Johnston M et al. Constructing questionnaires
based on the theory of planned behaviour: a manual for health
services researches. Quality of Life and Management of Living
Resources; 2004.
Ampt AJ, Amoroso C, Harris MF, McKenzie SH, Rose VK, Taggart JR.
Attitudes, norms and controls inuencing lifestyle risk factor
management in general practice. BMC Fam. Pract. 2009; 10: 59.
Mildestvedt T, Meland E. Examining the Matthew Effect on the
motivation and ability to make lifestyle changes in 217 heart
rehabilitation patients. Scand. J. Public Health 2007; 35: 1407.
Govil SR, Weidner G, Merritt-Worden T, Ornish D. Socioeconomic
status and improvements in lifestyle, coronary risk factors, and quality
of life: the Multisite Cardiac Lifestyle Intervention Program. Am. J.
Public Health 2009; 99: 126370.
McKee MD, Maher S, Deen D, Blank AE. Counseling to prevent obesity
among preschool children: acceptability of a pilot urban primary care
intervention. Ann. Fam. Med. 2010; 8: 24955.
Gaume J, Gmel G, Faouzi M, Daeppen J-B. Counsellor behaviours and
patient language during brief motivational interventions: a sequential
analysis of speech. Addiction 2008; 103: 1793800.
Francis N, Rollnick S, McCambridge J, Butler C, Lane C, Hood K. When
smokers are resistant to change: experimental analysis of the effect
of patient resistance on practitioner behaviour. Addiction 2005; 100:
117582.
Burke BL, Arkowitz H, Menchola M. The efcacy of motivational
interviewing: a meta-analysis of controlled clinical trials. J. Consult.
Clin. Psychol. 2003; 71: 84361.
Rubak S, Sandbaek A, Lauritzen T, Christensen B. Motivational
interviewing: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Br. J. Gen. Pract.
2005; 55: 30512.
Laws R, Kemp L, Harris M, Powell Davies G, Williams A, Eames-Brown
R. An exploration of how clinician attitudes and beliefs inuence the
implementation of lifestyle risk factor management in primary
healthcare: a grounded theory study. Implement. Sci. 2009;
4: 66.
Yeazel MW, Lindstrom Bremer KM, Center BA. A validated tool for
gaining insight into clinicians preventive medicine behaviors and
beliefs: the preventive medicine attitudes and activities questionnaire
(PMAAQ). Prev. Med. 2006; 43: 8691.
E299
Copyright of Journal of Paediatrics & Child Health is the property of Wiley-Blackwell and its content may not
be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written
permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.