Professional Documents
Culture Documents
to the contrary is adduced. It is incumbent upon the party alleging bad faith to
sufficiently prove such allegation. Absent enough proof thereof, the
presumption of good faith prevails. In the case under examination, the burden
of proving bad faith therefore lies with petitioners (plaintiffs below) but they
failed to discharge such onus probandi. Without a clear and persuasive
substantiation of bad faith, the presumption of good faith in favor of
respondents stands (Gregorio v. CA et al., G.R. No. 117609, December 29,
1998).
The following are instances when good faith is a valid defense:
1. Good faith is a valid defense to falsification of public documents by making
untruthful statements in a narration of facts [U.S. v. San Jose, 7 Phil. 604
(1907)]; G.R. No. L-3247. March 5, 1907
G.R. No. 6486, U.S. V. Catolico, 18 Phil. 504 US vs. Catolico
People vs. Pacan G.R. No. L-22642 December 19, 1924