r

.'\~,"'\\\~[;~';~~"'''-f,'''~~~';'k~

,1?;;r;

. .:..

..

'i:~.';.iL'~

.,

.\~'~~:~~~i.(t.~~i~;~
.

. . i.i,

.. , ..

ifr!J.INrfuttf lft~im.fltir;/A Pr.1!f}Y A~/J'i!!Jf~Y:Ut:Jr.)JjM!'jj;rI;~lt!fJ)r~~~J~V

!J]iWh~ g4r:t!)'m'IJ!!,~r,j~~f!r
2flJE:::,:
..\ :
(JP,fJJ:ZICll! 16?)J/P 7!"~~1l.::JJ)N;tf;,:~}s!{)'mt}O/jl
:. .... ;:. ..
.}'~~4!!JIS~i(~jI
!1..A~lfl~f.?t~~'
f-nu tLI.I ff ,:t~
od.r:QJIfl1.IU11.rt:riti60_@JliJ.[dac. go 1/. n q

'

. Phone No: a:l.:291JZJ'!3

..'
"

~i
I

~~;\::">"..::t~::~~
..,,,.,",,,_,~,::.~~~:~~~1:.,;,,.~,,,,.,
.;"'u,,_.'.,,","'_'"~.'."""'.'''.,..~.'~'''~'''_''~' ,.".:..~"..

N _'.,.'"

''"'

_.~

_._.~.;_.~''.._.''';-"'r'-""'~"'~i"'"
.

~;f:
'JL'()l ::

v :
:

i :

Ii'ltONl[~

..

'.

sun.JJI'A::T: U'?:O.ATE 01''4' p. lL,O,][, STYJDY/SU.. VEY OJ!' f'O:VJtATO}S ~I~l:\EP'!~:

.
. n\!' ]GtlB.:'rAIt JP.'A~:;KS
('fI'~SAI~D.sA<C]'Hnlj'/rS) JJV1[~pIOJRrf):~J,? i
"
FJR01\1[CI JUTA,D:'STRUn;1UTJQJJDl
Ar~ID.SO]L,DlC~ LAGOS~ i. .,
_

I'I'_~

Ml_,.

.'_"".,III.>

IIIIII..
ljILIoJtolu'~"'\..,

JI\I .
,v,JIjoIlllo'jjj

I_I , )!.I)jl."

\'I\"I_.""tJlIl

I"I!I/fIII.IIOIiIIUoIIIIll'u"'~'J

..,uJ

""w ..
""'.f~

.IJI __

rtl,l;JHlIll.oooI"'I

.->II-.."._"'t"" ..., 'i'~"""'-''''\'''

'\.

Please, above subject

11 atter

refers ..
.nthe ql a ity of brar ded tomato naste in'retail

.~'o:UovvingFood Sa 'ety Concerns

packs imported from China and distributed and sold in Nigeria, an 8: Jprov8:I was
.
.
.
'.
given. to conduct a pilot survey/study of sucn Tomato paste prod Jets in ret;:{Uipack.s
".

(Tin/Sachet) .
.

iI i
I

11'SAN working together with P .",8 and 1,S, carne i.1P with data collectiontemplate,
. study design, sampling' pl'oc;e~l~i.re~\}.~.Pbratory
requirements etc. in order to Jdndltd:\
:'tt .'3tucly/s:lrve~.that will beyal~.dj:J~~~?:1181lY
and intematior ally, evidence ;)~i'3qd.a: n(\

an effective aid to regula.tory.d.ecup:or':li

.':.:. :i:.

"!','

" . . .'.

",.. '. ,!.

I.'

"'~-~

J.

.'1' ..

.,

."

,I
1 ,

Lagos w~s chosen ~s.the,.:~Orml1etda. center 0: ..ligeria vith ~1J.oretbantw~:i1.il.8;jOr

. seaports 111 A oa JGl, mea 1, etc.Laud borders (Seme, etc.), Au" cargo tel'mmp]!s

(l JA :-ICO,etc) and major markets serving not oDly 'Nigeria but West and Central
Africa Sub-region,
i I.
I.

'

.,,'~;

I i
I .1

'~. :'

\- - I

'. I.

:.;;1,.-,:1..-"

: i

'

::\i..I".::;...

,i .:

'i

~ I

, .

----------

\
I

....n. '.

..
i

.. ., /".

':..

.,..,..

-,," Iwenty s.ev.f?p.('1.7, mam markets

vvere

t\'l. Lagos

Senatorialzones

..

. ~f:~r::;..,::.:.' :

supern arkets from thG~:A.;:: .;'

.
visited mid samples purchased and s1.ibmitt~~tJ.(XJb?::~:.:.
Eottr (4)

f.;SK

1'.I)8J01'

:n!.{.

Iaborutory-for analysis: '

11\1',\1'

.~.

'.

ur:l;if'I:,' 'i', -,

i'\

The focus of the study andlaboratory analysis was the Tomato content! ,'Jh6';Codex
!' '. "
.:'!.t:-:;;\i(;:S~andards and the Nigerian Industrial Stander ds C\r].S) has specified that I C>.?fXto ,
.<'~::;;,;{,~::'.c(Atten:t 31.ould be 28% minin .1JJD. "
. '
:: ,:
'
''''::';~''.:'. 'I'
. .
k i
~'.l.;..
..
... -.
", "
"
f ..~
:\\:::,;:~;.:'i;~.,JY.{:;IJOJ:'hy;:5ftJ:v~ brands 'of Tomato paste sampled 'were registered brands, 'l;')?:~.'
resultshave also been forwarded to D (PRS) for Data Evaluation.
. i.
.:

"

t-:

"...

:'

'.

\.

.'

"..

'\ri"u]~:Ilrl)~l"\'\iJ((~j";-'

:..~:_.:~~.~~,.;!.c..~,~,,~_:2,_.~~.

('J
J'. "II"
.. O':a.

'.

\ -; -.

'.

1
d anc.s'J.Jrn.rce
.
. . t ..t.O "1e
t']
aboratory=S
purc,Jc1.se
"C

no. ,(.,'0:1:sanlp.es

r-

.C"

_.

-'_

::' "
v;;
'.:1. :

2. Total no. samples released=S lA .

3. "~ot~.llio. found unsatisfactory

. !.

due to l'omato conten.t=286.

,t.t. Total no. with satisfactory Tomato content=zs

5. NQ of samplesawaiting releasef ..om Laboratory

16

,
I

I I~

= 9 J. .I%

6. .)ercent,age (%) unsatisfactory

. ..

,
'I,

7. Percentage (%) satisfactory ~ 8.9%

"(.

I"

:;,
.":
;.,

,.'

','h',r:

~.

'j

,'"

.:

Chart below represents S1.11U~nary'of findings tomato survey (see attached. Lab

reports).

.'.

'.

,/

o'

j'

..

;,:

!ll

Percentage (%)

Unsatisfactory
[111

PerCel1'tage (%)

Satlsfactoiv

I
\

! .

'~-.

--..,-.-....--.---r..-----,..~._.

-'-:.":"-.-

...-;o--:-,,~ ......
~r-_'_ .. ~
','

, ,i.

.t

.__ ._-----:- __

'

:.

~!<> .AJL:th~.Ji':llsatisfactory.
tOl1j.~I;Opas-te' products hac the same red .Go}oJ'ia$~;tre
\')'" .

\. :.',

satisfactoi'Y paste.

. ,,:'

'"

'I

.i,'
i

I
I

I '

:.

:'

'..

'I

.....'

1-'Je' Food.l.UCL.L'Safety
.

,,>,.
~.'

1 j
11
r"1'tO')
attendant
J ... < lJ .C.,,:.I
... ,.. cand
.. Lc.,_
... ,._LI"C
Y

,_ ."J..'L
'

..'

"-..:\1'(-"8

1.1.

"" ... ,; ....

are.verv",J t:.."I'i a'lr::n.illg ':jfts

'-eS11""S
1Jl(~1C<11'e'
.l I J....
_.1.,\ _..
.._ ,e ._ '1"1"'\'L cornt
~
....~,........;1"8
, .

C'J. . _':\.

I.{,: .

_.

I.

(:

/L,

ofrecistered
.;J.l,.,.
-

,,-

"I

,.

:iOln~lr\
C."" I

,-f'

I . . SllC)::>"1',.
:1.- - 1
...
: l I'..C'1.8
'" t.0 '1_~le
" - LL.'JU"'JJCC
n~ '~1 .. ", ...._;..r.lg. 1\(1)'
.i '1 f',-,o.].,.,t~;ne.:,'-'"
1 q .,.. I ~ir.'.
(mnp
..dJ;lC.dXCt.
PlOC
.t, ,.beJ. ..8L
.
-0-

'-.

0'(
bal vJ "11-)(' rlc.~ ("I' of (' isou
ssi 01'1" 0'(.' 'L1IJW to ~..,ck
("[" me are I.,v ein
'e'r'.L
t:>'.
.,Jt,.~.
A;I.
~ . Ai::> cl';r,(""ll~'
,. W:.,
. .";~;: ".
".
.
. .
. . 7"'~"'\" ,--. \\..,,~r.,
'''''';-'(-''1
1,',' t..O()C0~t
., C"'1~'.cty ("_.OJ,l.Li-:Je
.r.'"._ 'r
-, '}'/f> J".
,,rlc. .... over . t1'",Ie WOJ,.':(.;.
';-:1,"
c1.\. LOO""
.....lI~
..e::s,.\.,(:,C
mgs E,.V.....
Uf: .

G.

\.

,.I...'...

'.

~.I;J

IJ.

.:')

....
_.

1.1.\....1. .or

)'q

'".,.,/.

'f

C ..

I)'

:"

,I.I~)

.,

1 ..',Hl [1'
. ,.. t e,.~aCC)J
1 rt
icl1 .',..
,:, T - f'
_lC~\.
1.0.f.1..0.,'/.'
..C,0 lr'
.. D.I.- W .\...l.1.,.)
.to::. .'I10 trp I"'V'
_,...n "I..Iitt,CC,\ c'IT'
....L':\.
el.1 ,~0_lJ.-'.

't.1 't..\.lt~
_, I~",
'
eC. (e'O
0

;>01"

r
"J'"
(;1 e 1
....
~
s:
v s.
r'ov:rtltOt)(-"

C..'0'IOJ'8"
..
.

1>~+

l.:h.:,...Il,

Carcinozenic
<...
.'
l:-,J

.I

....

VJ01;IC!
ILT''''11t11
c''''CJ:nl)'J'Y
V
l.,l ...
c.. ..J i' ~i.)
.... , ',
.J...I .

I,...J.

"W'hat
are t' ese
C..
. ,.I.

GI.A.

..

\..")

'C:rr.\[LIA)
notec the increase
'V ..'1:.
1

Diseases (.J. TeDs),. Diabetes,

."""""

..

,}....

1(.'.:.1,)\..1

--.

.I.

,Ca leer, Cardio vascular diseases, etc. ineJud5:ng

measures need to
J(, L,

.A,

L::.I .~

J.

of organ f~i Vl'CS e.g. :~(i(ney etc

'~~1>Strinaent
~., - o..! .

J ...,

1'111\)'OJ1 CO"Y'lTI'PJ'
J~.
T ....', ... icable
c..

incidences

1,i\'\"1
C
.'_ ........

001..
11)111(""
..l.).
"'o"
... ..).' !"l
.;

"-.,

be taken

",'

';"11

,_,,::,::.".::

protect
- . "" :\:'O'P;ri~;H'
,b'""_ ..v..... cOll~mme'ji.!TO'II

"0 x'
1\.. .......

l.

.,

'"

";~,

' ,...

"

";

.,.'~:

'

consuming....'this array of sr bstanc ..ard

products,
.
~

'i,t

Taking all the above into consideration.

"

1. Imported Tomato Pas1:6 brands it retail pac

(8

( ..Iigh 'Risk Countries) should be suspended

_

?, .

'I,;S'
.u.,.1

(""

. '-

~L

V8:!:iOUS

C'}i1'1""
.l.~ .. (.,. ~"]--)I)O"f'("(
",'"''
..

C _ " "

'."

;"

'

of tomato paste in retail :P~~/,:~;..'.,'i'"

.)):8.H:;S

(tins/sac .iet),
. ",.

until further notice .. :';.''.. :.:.:.:,

.'.:.

for loca man rfacto ...e.of

".'.'

(tins or sachets) fromC'iina

doesu ..not affect t} eI."tomato

concentrate
in
.\.
.,I...
"'..... c,
_... _ .,.l
., ....]''YlS
c.".., froro
..' '"
L

.,::.. ,....

I wis ),to recomn or c~_C.S fol ows:':"

.. .:.,'.

. .

..

':;!.. :..

',.;i''""

':':

"j":"""'\I::.

FSA. \ PVG/PNiS, ._& E Directorates should star I: a nationwidelrecall and

. mop

1J.9

".

'

, .
:

1..1. r- here would be need.toinfon

.I.
lJJ
'J

!.

of these brands of Tomato paste in retail packs D'-OIl)Ch.1J10;fl.l.'feadY

i circulation,
_.

;,..

\.. ..

'

."

...

J .

-~...\.YIf;,
11_relevant
d.'
c~1. _Fede
.. .0..'"
__
oJ

Cl;i~fo:t.1,~,SService,' Po icy makcrsetc. of this measures, in ord.ero

..\ .\

Fed.~i~j;~:
Gover.nm.eitt .: o: icy
.'

'. ~.!

OIl

I ' .

EWe!. rec uce the import hL..S.

. !

istr:_,.e8,, Nl'lO'f"";:

. "0;;,...10(.1-1

.J.';'

I
!~,

~j:J"

"id(;~
.~.

.ooking inwards to encourage .o(~aj industries

' I;

" I,'

;1..."""

','

I
I

.:~

.i'I;':':"''};

"'"

sub~jt"ectcd
"J. to
_

~J ..

-,

,>
'':1,

I.... , ( .. ,1~J

',I

'

~'

,.J...

facil if1,.~~' 'I')['''/~-)'I'~'

t~ any
..t..
.

.-'1

comprehensive
. _.:J}~ ),. .'1.1;.1.

I.

.J}VI.."

I,

~I

ec 'tSl(VI'l'~w

.r
'1,....

I.

.I

"

(.:v~v.'_
l NP...

'.

'

their

;0'"'.
f)

t'(~-~r.,'I'0,(;'I~t)1'''''1]1
""', .{~"""~I~''''''_\'.,:; ....... '

of.L

-':'~'"

' ..

~I)(.>I]
,.\rl~nv
d'cll"'\'>
'.,,1,:...
,.,.
~. _\~,_
.......
'\;' . L. n'H'I/)'
..__ ... ",:;J
,'r

';'O'I.]'Cf'
(;IT!~?
PI
0"
'''J'/ ".~"
h(''''1'''\)\/I'/('~
\... " .~I ('0(') ",t,"
.;. ~. _1....
J .. :,"
...,J
. JI.
I\,
.J
1_,)

".J.. .....

13.

0.-1

r_

'~ "

/'(II,

other

"C:'1['18""';'
o:
, '_'0." '/'0 . C\h"I'J'l()'~'
1.:::,'" Mar
... ;1....... I f'\';',~C'I'I"J':'/"
<;t" "_', .. 1,_,1.,;:,

All.. .I). ,_!"'l.. .'~ j'X""""O,'t('I'"

... ,.1-.\) 1.. " .. ,~ VV")ll'CI"
.
\.,
.. t .. U"

(.1 ..

-.J ....
'lI ...

j
q.,.).
;'.':
.
l':':;,"l"/
I.:,~ t!l'l
...
,C,
1,_ .....,I.

measures are tcllcen to minimize dumping of su~x;ta!J_anlq:eo(tu cts J:h~':l!

'.

',\"

~.

'7. Ii'SAN St::\f~'havebeer ..encouraged tc study

1'\
O!'
.. ]:"0")"\
..
'- 'L... ]:;""";111,:1
< <.:. .",1. .;
.....'.

order
V. ,-1.1_'.1.. to

.,.
,C"h,,"
,--I '"
.~I.
O'

the
...." ';n)
.I..'.~ ...men
_

h....

J'.:'

itl

"'"
.,,",, 'j'"
1 ,;./-,).
'I
., 17, 'Ie, 1, ..
d.,.'clOt.;.Id.,CC
VI/.l .0. ~I
IJlLloJ.)\.cll(~.aJ.OdJ.c"
.. :. d .t.". 000

G.O.liD.!:)

CertiticetionP :'o'g':n.mnJes

S'''' l't'C'IOr.:1r. ('

"11:'(-''/"
I,]' c.
_ ,. c) r _-).n,",l).!
. __ , (':..
_ I.J..",~\'
<. :'
\."

:, I)".l.1O('l1.,
:1' rJ..,..:,,

8. Food Evaluation Division staff oLf:,'SAN should be commended

.

'.wel

'\....

'.

"\,,J

"'JOD',~ as

I.

(.

...".

1.,~ .,

....

1.

.,..'

,'\

:k)~"(:li
:
.

. .

this was
...l~_
;'(i;1AI\T workplan
c.., part
c~.. t. ofthe
J..
.J..
.":.J.~I:1

\.,.1. ~, ..

': ,..',

CI"'~l

"'n~ ',]'
ore
_.
,_
.

C:~
......
lt

job

1~'ncIJ' studies
'l.,: c:.S

IY'
't,".',
~~'.,.,.;'.;..

;!;

1.,1.,

axe planned in future with industry support and coEc\borEti:.i.on.!

';
,'"

.:

Thank you.

)\l,JI!r"'ll'l[~'1"""'"''''''
.O/.Iil.j(.u ,Ut~tI!31d.\~
It

1',

i i.:':! \ ,

. I '~;t : ,:

0 N, 11'11 AfU"C'1-"'''/."
. l"l

1(1",

\_.Y.L

\.:,, ~r. ~";

"'1
,.1

;:.; .

'I

. .!

" _
..

,.,

'j'"

;..', }llj.

."

.. ~~

I .,

:i. : ~ I.

!
;

.:

I'

.: ~'I. \ \ \:11

I'

I
I

..

, i
!

"'''',1,

: i
)

,
I

.t

I ,"

_~~--==-=======--~~~_~l

!\ ",

1'~\:;,