Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Presented by
SIDXXXXX
Marketing Management
SID: 0922010
5 May 2012
Page 2 of 24
Marketing Management
SID: 0922010
This paper focuses on Anglia Ruskin University, and the author has interpreted the
term customeras representing a full-time UK undergraduate student studying at one
of the institutions main East of England campuses.
Using suitable models identify the customer perceived value for the
customers for a product/division/company of your choice
Holbrook (1999, p.5) defines consumer value as an interactive relativistic
preference experience and explains that the notion of consumption experience
is central to the creation of customer value because customers desire in that
regard affects their relationships with products relative to their personal tastes,
the preference judgments they make, and the circumstances in which they find
themselves (Holbrook, 1999, p.9).
This definition suggests that what people desire is not the product or service with
which they interact, but the experience which that product or service will deliver
for them; this anticipated experience is therefore the perceived value. In the
context of a prospective Anglia Ruskin student, one can identify their perceived
value as being the desire to enhance their career prospects, maybe to develop
practical life skills and independence, or perhaps simply for the sense of
academic achievement that obtaining a qualification would provide.
Holbrook (1999, p.12) proposes a Typology of Consumer Value where eight
types of value are determined by analysing three given dimensions of the value
experience (see Appendix 1).Using Holbrooks model to assess the customer
perceived values of the prospective student discussed above, it is evident that
the perceived values of obtaining enhanced career prospects and developing
independence and practical life skills are classified as Efficiency types of values;
a means-to-an-end (extrinsic) value is derived from the (active) use of the
qualification or skills obtained, to progress along a desired (self-oriented) career
and/or life path.
Meanwhile, the categorisation of the desire to acquire a sense of academic
achievement depends on whether the desired experience is for ones own
Page 3 of 24
Marketing Management
SID: 0922010
perceived
value
can
be
categorised
underExcellence,
otherwise
underEsteem.
Zeithaml (1988) and Monroe (1990, p.46 cited in Woodruff, 1997) suggest that
consumer perceived value is determined by consumers, through a subjective
judgment made in consideration of all that they give and receive - the benefits
and sacrifices - associated with a product.
Considering this approach in relation to the aforementioned prospective student
of Anglia Ruskin, a comprehensive analysis of the likely customer perceived
benefits and sacrifices can be undertaken to understand the organisations value
offering:
Benefits
A customer looking to undertake a full-time higher education course would
expect to receive:
High quality tuition, with support and guidance available from approachable,
knowledgeable and enthusiastic academic staff
Page 4 of 24
Marketing Management
SID: 0922010
Sacrifices
In return for what the customer expects to receive, they are prepared to give up:
The money necessary to pay for - in most cases this will entail a long term
student loan debt tuition fees, and also the cost of study resources such as
stationery, books and perhaps IT equipment
The opportunity of full-time employment and the fiscal benefits that entails.
Woodruff (1997) observes that the way different definitions of customer value are
constructed make them difficult to compare, and attempts to consolidate the vast
body of concepts on the subject into a hierarchical means-end focussed model
(Appendix 2). Customer perceived value is derived from an assessment of the
product involved, through the use of that product, and ultimately in the
achievement of the customers end objective through product use.
Page 5 of 24
Marketing Management
SID: 0922010
Figure 1 applies this model in the context of the student customers of Anglia
Ruskin University.
Beginning at the bottom of the hierarchy, the student customer evaluates the
overall higher education product, then measures the experiences they
encounter through the use of the product (in this case, it is assumed that
studying represents use of the product) against what is desired in that regard.
At the top of the hierarchy, the ultimate goal of career development is
considered.
Page 6 of 24
Marketing Management
Critically
evaluate
SID: 0922010
the
existing
value
proposition
of
the
Page 7 of 24
Marketing Management
SID: 0922010
and, for the last three years have had the highest rise in UCAS
applications of all East and West Midlands universities.
(BCU, 2012a)
Importantly, there is also a link to learn more about us and this takes the visitor
to further relevant information about the universitys value proposition. There are
statements explaining that the institutions focus on practice-based learning
provides students with access to cutting-edge facilities and real-world
experience and that students gain the skills employers tell us they need (BCU,
2012b).
Mission, Vision, Value Analysis
On its website, Anglia Ruskin presents its values, its vision and a summary of its
corporate objectives - these are shown in figure 2 and the institutions full
corporate plan with all of its 15 objectives is available to download from the
website (ARU, 2012d).
Innovation. We are purposeful, challenging and curious about our world. We are
prepared to do things differently. We are creative, entrepreneurial and bring
enthusiasm to everything we do.
Values
Supporting each other. We are friendly and inclusive, and celebrate individuality
and diversity. We support and encourage everyone, and strive hard to anticipate
and meet needs and aspirations.
Honesty and openness. We operate with integrity, trust and respect for each
other and we deliver on our promises. We share ideas, information and
challenges and we seek out views and opinions.
Vision
Page 8 of 24
Marketing Management
SID: 0922010
internationally as exceptional.
wellbeing.
Nine out of ten students would recommend us to a friend.
Each Faculty's teaching receives public endorsement of its quality overall and is
recognised as a UK leader in one or more of its disciplines.
25% of our activity is at postgraduate level and we award at least 50 PhDs across
at least 10 disciplines each year.
Corporate
magnets for overseas students and 20% of our UK campus-based students are
Objectives
Every student may study entrepreneurship and 10% of our students choose selfemployment when they leave us.
We are recognised for successful innovation in the way in which services are
provided and for imaginative new learning environments.
We readily attract talented staff and prepare everyone to achieve our goals
through continuing staff development.
Through this material, there are elements of a market mission. However, there
are a couple of issues.
Issues
Firstly, it is not clear exactly who the university regards as its customer base
beyond a general classification of students.
Marketing Management
SID: 0922010
students fulfilling their potential, and of passion and enthusiasm, these appear
more as a list of philosophical high ideals rather than commitments of what the
university delivers to its customers. The corporate plan certainly demonstrates
that the university has identified levels of performance that it considers important
to achieve in order to succeed in the higher education sector, but the plan comes
across as a to do list that the organisation is working to achieve - it is not
obvious how this translates to benefits for the customer.
Competitors (Mission, Vision, Objective)
Birmingham Citys mission and vision statementsappear on their website and are
shown in figure 3.
Our
Mission*
Our Vision*
Corporate
Objectives**
To extend our research base and, through the application of the knowledge we
generate, create advantage for students, employers and other key partners.
To invest in and support our staff to achieve excellence in all aspects of teaching,
research, knowledge exchange, student support and service delivery.
However,
because their succinct statements are more direct and specific, they convey a
more coherent purpose and are easier for the customer to interpret and
Page 10 of 24
Marketing Management
SID: 0922010
graduates employable (BCU, 2012c, p.10) and its links to industry that provide
work experience and prepare graduates for the working world (BCU, 2012c,
p.14).
Anglia Ruskin also explains how the university places importance on preparing
graduates for work as part of their studies and explains how students are
supported, advised and coached through an Employer Mentoring Scheme (ARU,
2012b).
The inferred value proposition being conveyedby Anglia Ruskinis that it will
deliver to customers the knowledge and skills they need to succeed in work; that
the university will make them employable and that it is best placed to make these
things happen. This is all underpinned with the statistic that appears in the 2012
full-time undergraduate prospectus, explaining that 90% of students are in
employment or further study within six months of graduating (ARU, 2012c, p.2).
Furthermore, the prospectus discusses the experience students can expect with
regard to preparing for their post-study careers (ARU, 2012c, p.11), presented in
a this is what we will do for you format, and there is similar content within the
description of many of the courses that the university offers in terms of the
knowledge and practical skills a graduate can expect to obtain.
Page 11 of 24
Marketing Management
SID: 0922010
However, whilst the this is what we will do for you approach is an effective way
of delivering a value proposition, Birmingham City seems to be able to deliver its
message which in essence is similar to Anglia Ruskins - in a more accessible,
forceful and compelling way.
Chancellor mentions what a friendly place we are and explains that staff are
committed to making your time here happy and fulfilling (ARU, 2012c, p.2). On
the institutions website, there are statements likewe are friendly and inclusive
(ARU, 2012a) and we care about our students accompanied with a description
of welfare services that are provided to support students at a personal level
(ARU, 2012b).
Both universities try to differentiate themselves through the promotion of their
facilities. Birmingham City promotes its 180m investment in facilities (BCU,
2012g) and explains howits campus facilities provide an effective learning
environment (BCU, 2012c, p.56-63).
detailed account of all that is available to students in the way of facilities, from its
state-of-the-art
technology
and
learning
environments
to
the
Page 12 of 24
Marketing Management
SID: 0922010
2012b; ARU, 2012c; ARU, 2011), but Birmingham City also does this (BCU,
2012b; BCU, 2012c; BCU, 2012d).Perhaps what could be considered one of
Anglia Ruskins stronger marketing assets, and one which certainly differentiates
it from all but one of its competitors is itsCustomer Service Excellence (CSE)
accreditation, received in recognition of the high standard of customer service
that it provides (CSE, 2012). The university is one of only two institutions in the
UK to hold the accreditation on anorganisation-wide basis, but unfortunately, the
potentially reputation enhancing factor is not mentioned in any of the promotional
material that prospective students have access to, aside from the appearance of
the CSE accreditation logo in some places.
Other marketing assets such as the universitys Skillsmark accreditation, and its
status as the largest provider of undergraduate courses in subjects areas such
as Architecture, Building and Planning, and those allied to medicine, are
promoted on Anglia Ruskins website (ARU, 2012b).
Birmingham Citys most distinctive marketing assets is that as mentioned earlier,
the university is the highest ranked Million+ institution in the latest Complete
University Guide League Table (The Complete University Guide, 2012), and its
top-30 ranking for placing graduates in work. It also promotes the fact that it was
the most in demand university in terms of the number of UCAS applications, in
2009 (BCU, 2012a).
So the value propositions that have been identified for the universities are in
essence similar. Both partner with industry to deliver relevant, practical courses
that prepare students for their chosen career by equipping them not only with the
knowledge that they need, but also the skills and work experience. Teaching
takes place in a well-developed, comfortable, modern and well-equipped
environment that will make the learning experience positive for the customer.
In terms of distinction between the two, whilst Anglia Ruskin emphasises that the
customer is supported academically and personally to make sure they are happy
and able to achieve their full potential, Birmingham City can show that more
Page 13 of 24
Marketing Management
SID: 0922010
students want to study with them. Where Birmingham City can boast over its
league table ranking position and its track record of placing graduates in work,
Anglia Ruskin can demonstrate it delivers excellent customer service that is
recognised and accredited by Government.
It is reasonable to suggest that both universities value propositions match the
customer perceived value that was identified earlier.
correctly
identified,
and
demonstrate
their
understanding
that
for
This in itself is
Page 14 of 24
Marketing Management
SID: 0922010
Page 15 of 24
Marketing Management
SID: 0922010
In light of your analysis of your existing value proposition and what you
have learnt in this module produce
a. Anew value proposition that will match the value criteria of
your customers
As identified in section two, the weakness of Anglia Ruskins current value
proposition is that it is obscure and inaccessible to customers, and because
the identification of it relies on customers own interpretations of the
information they find across the wide body of promotional material that
exists, the message can be missed or misconstrued.
The following proposed value proposition statement draws upon the wide
body of promotional material that already exists within the university, to
present a concise, compelling statement that aligns the apparent values and
vision of the institution to customer perceived values.
Through our collaborative links with industry, and exceptional
teaching in a modern state-of-the-art learning environment, we
deliver engaging, stimulating and relevant courses that make
our students highly employable by equipping them with the
knowledge and practical skills they need to pursue successful
careers.
Our
outstanding
customer
service
positively
Page 16 of 24
Marketing Management
SID: 0922010
Page 17 of 24
Marketing Management
SID: 0922010
External Marketing
Page 18 of 24
Marketing Management
SID: 0922010
The
Page 19 of 24
Marketing Management
SID: 0922010
APPENDICES
Appendix 1
Holbrooks Typology of Consumer Value
Self-oriented
Active
Reactive
Extrinsic
Intrinsic
EFFICIENCY
PLAY
(O/I,
Convenience)
(Fun)
EXCELLENCE
(Quality)
Other-oriented
Active
STATUS
(Success,
Impression
Management)
Reactive
ESTEEM
(Reputation,
Materialism,
Possessions)
AESTHETICS
(Beauty)
ETHICS
(Virtue,
Justice,
Morality)
SPIRITUALITY
(Faith,
Ecstasy,
Sacredness,
Magic)
Page 20 of 24
Marketing Management
SID: 0922010
Appendix 2
Woodruffs Customer Value Hierarchy Model
Page 21 of 24
Marketing Management
SID: 0922010
REFERENCES
Ahmed, P. Rafiq, M., 2002.Internal Marketing - Tools and concepts for customerfocused management. Oxford, UK: Butterworth-Heinemann
ARU, 2011.Annual Review 2010/11. [pdf] Chelmsford: Anglia Ruskin University.
Available at:
<http://www.anglia.ac.uk/ruskin/en/home/your_university/about_anglia_ruskin/ann
ual_review.Maincontent.0002.file.tmp/annual-review-2011.pdf> [Accessed 30 April
2012]
ARU, 2012a.About Anglia Ruskin [online] Available at:
<http://www.anglia.ac.uk/ruskin/en/home/your_university/about_anglia_ruskin.html
> [Accessed 28 April 2012]
ARU, 2012b.Why choose Anglia Ruskin? [online] Available at:
<http://www.anglia.ac.uk/ruskin/en/home/your_university/reasons.html> [Accessed
27 April 2012]
ARU, 2012c.2012 Full-time Undergraduate Prospectus [online] Chelmsford: Anglia
Ruskin University. Available at:
<http://issuu.com/pubsadses/docs/anglia_ruskin_ftug-12> [Accessed 28 April
2012]
ARU, 2012d.Corporate Plan 2012-2014. [pdf] Chelmsford: Anglia Ruskin University.
Available at:
<http://www.anglia.ac.uk/ruskin/en/home/your_university/about_anglia_ruskin/corp
orate-plan.Maincontent.0001.file.tmp/corporate_plan_2012-14.pdf> [Accessed 3
May 2011]
Barnes, C. Blake, H. Pinder, D., 2009. Creating & Delivering Your Value Proposition
- Managing customer experience for profit. [e-book] London: Kogan Page.
Available through: Anglia Ruskin University Library website
<www.libweb.anglia.ac.uk> [Accessed 29 April 2012]
BCU, 2012a.Welcome. [online] Available at: <http://www.bcu.ac.uk/> [Accessed 30
April 2012]
Page 22 of 24
Marketing Management
SID: 0922010
Page 23 of 24
Marketing Management
SID: 0922010
Page 24 of 24