Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Gingras
Jaburg
& Witk,P.c. dsg@jaburgwilk.com
Direct Line 602/248-1000
ATToRNEYS AT LAw
Direct Fax 6021297 -5049
May 28,2008
VIA FACSIMILE:
EMAIL:
3200 N. CentralAvc.,
Suite2000
& U.S.Merl
Ph o e n i x,A Z 8 5 0 1 2
Re: KobeBryant
www.TheDir4,.corn/
Gary J. Jaburg
Lawrence E. Wilk DearMr. Streisand:
Rogcr L. Cohen
RandyNussbaum
Mitchcll Rcichman
Bcth S. Cohn
Kraig J. Manon
As you know, this firm is intellectualpropertyand litigation counselto the
ScottJ. Richardson operatorsof the websitewww.TiicDirty.corn("The Dirfy"). This letteris in response
RonaldM. Horuitz
Kathi M. Sandwciss
to a letter from you datedMay 23, 2008 regardingyour client Kobe Bryant ("Mr.
Mcrvlm T. Braudc Bryant").
Laurcn L. Camcr
Maria Crimi Spcth
M i c hcl l cC . L o mb i n o First,on a technicalpoint,your lettercontainsa reference
to a websitecalled
Ncal H. Bookspan
GrcgoryP. Gillis
www.AZSportsllub.com. Pleasenote that The Dirty doesnot operatethis website
PctcrM. Gcnnrich andhasno relationshipof anykind with it. For thatreason,all otherissuesaside,The
JaDcssa E. Koenig
Mark D. Bogard
Dirty could not complywith your demandto removeany materialfrom that site even
.lonathanlbscn if it believedit wasobligatedto do so,whichit doesnot.
David N. Fancn
Valcrie L. Marciano
D a v i d L . A l l cn Turning to the merits of your letter, The Dirty and its founderNik Richie
Kclly Brown
Kcvin J. Rattay
understandthat Mr. Bryant disputesthe accurac'yof the story first reportedon
David S. Cingras www.TheDirly.comconcerningan affair betweenMr. Bryantand a formerLakerGirl
Adam S. Kunz
Danicl L. Hulsizcr
namedVanessaCurry. Nevertheless, Mr. Richieis informedthat the storyis accurate
J i l l M. H u l si zcr andhe thereforerespectfullydeclinesMr. Bryant'srequestfor removalof the report.
LaurenceB. Hirsch
Laum A. Rogal
ScottT. Ashby I understandfrom your letter that without addressingspecifics,Mr. Bryant
deniesthe allegationsand intendsto "seek all relief availableunder the laws of the
United Statesand the Stateof California ... ." Pleasenote that The Dirty and Mr.
Richie are well-awareof the laws of defamationgenerally,as well as other celeb-
specificstatutessuchas CaliforniaCivil Code $ 33aa(a). Of course,Civil Code $
3344(d) expresslyexcludesmattersof news, sporls,and "public affairs" from the
consentrequirementof$ 3344(a). All threeof thesecategoriesapply to the newsat
issuehereandthereforeMr. Bryanthasno claim whatsoeverunderthis section.
www.jaburgwilk.com
Officesalso in Scottsdale
14500N. NorthsightBlvd.,SuiteI 16 . Scottsdale. I . Fax480/609-0016
A285260. Tel 480i609-001
l/DSG/DSG1657
I 3788- 633_vl
AdamF. Streisand,
Esq.
Jaburg May 28,2008
^*XtlLis; Paee2
4.) As you are no doubt aware,in the eventthat Mr. Bryant were to pursue
litigation againstThe Dirty, the matter would be immediatelysubjectto an Anti-
SLAPPmotionunderC.C.P.$ 425.16.Facedwith sucha motion,Mr. Bryantwould
be requiredto establisha likelihoodof successon the merits. Again, due to his prior
historyof similarconduct,this may representan impossiblehurdle.
In closing,it shouldbe notedthat thereis no small irony in the fact that Mr.
Bryant's efforts to pursue claims againstwi,vw.TheDirU.comonly increasesthe
likelihood that this story will receive more attentionthan it already has. This
situationimplicatesthe "Streisandeffect" which shouldcertainlybe familiar to you:
"The Streisandeffect is a phenomenon on the Internetwherean attemptto censoror
removea pieceof informationbackfires,causingthe informationto be [more]widely
effect(visitedMay 28,2008). As
publicized."http://en.w.ikipedia.org/wikiiStreisand
you know, this phenomenon is namedfor your cousin,Barbra,basedon her famously
unsuccessfu I attackuponthe websitewww.califbrniacoastline.org.
6f3 vl
13788-l/DSG/DSG/657
Adam F. Streisand,
Esq.
Jaburg May 28, 2008
& Wilk, p.c. Pase3
For each of thesereasonsand with all due respectto Mr. Bryant, I cannot
adviseThe Dirfy to comply with your client's demands.As you may havenoticed,
www.The.Dirfy.com allows viewersto post commentsin responseto storiessuch as
this one,as severalfolks havealreadydone. If he would like to do so, Mr. Bryant is
welcome to post a commentin this sectionexplainingthat he is not pleasedwith the
Phoenix Office: story and he is welcometo expresshis opinion that The Dirty is not a websitehe finds
3200N. CentmlAve.,
Suite2000 worthy of his endorsement.
Phoenix,
AZ 85012
Tel 6021248-1000 If you have any questions,pleasefeel free to contactme at (602) 248-1000or
Fax 602/248-0522
via email a'
Tel 480/609-001I
Fax 480/609-0016
David S. Gingras
DSG:jas
13788-l/DSG/DSG/657633
vl