Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Original article
Scand J Work Environ Health 1993;19(2):115-120
doi:10.5271/sjweh.1498
Pulmonary function one and four years after a deep saturation
dive.
by Thorsen E, Segadal K, Kambestad BK, Gulsvik A
Print ISSN: 0355-3140 Electronic ISSN: 1795-990X Copyright (c) Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment & Health
Table 1. Base-line anthropom etric data and diving experience of the deep divers and referents at the t ime of entry into the
study.
Age
(years)
Group
Weight
(kg)
Height
(cm)
--Mean SD
30.3
31.1
Deep divers
Reference divers
MeanSD
4.5
4.5
180
178
MeanSD
78
77
7
6
Diving
Smokers experience
(years)
(%)
8
6
8.3
7.8
Maximum depth
(rn)
Median Range
Mean SD
21
25
Time in
saturation
(days)
4.5
3.9
192
214
27-360
5-700
142
134
85-500
50-185
Table 2. Base-line pulmonary funct ion of the deep divers and the reference group at the time of entry into the study. (FVC = forced
vital capacity, FEV1.0 = forced exp iratory volume in 1 s, FEF = for ced expiratory flow rate at a certain per~entage (figures in subscr ipt) of the forced vital capac ity , PEF = peak expiratory flow, Tlco = trans fer fac tor for carbon monoxlde, Kco = t ransfer taclor for carbon mono xide per un it alveolar volume)
Grou p
Oeep dive rs
Referen ce divers
FVC
(% predie ted)
FEV,n
(% predi eted)
Mean
SO
Mean
SO
106
104
10
10
101
97
10
11
FEF 25 _ 75
(% predieted )
FEF,5_ 85
(% predi eted )
FEF so
(% prediet ed)
FEF, 5
(% predieted )
Mean SO
Mean SO
Mean SO
Mean SO
85'
82 '
17
19
116
80'
75'
15
19
84 '
ar -
16
17
76'
72'
18
21
PEF
(% predieted)
Tl co
(% prediet ed)
Kco
(% pre di eted)
Mean
SO
Mean
SO
Mean
SO
102
14
17
107
104
12
13
100
97
13
15
99
Results
The mean annual reduction in FEVl,o in all divers
(N = 52) over the whole observation period was 82
(SO 61) mi year", which was significantly higher
than the predicted annual loss of 34 ml - year I
(P<O .OOI ) (13). There were no significant changes
in FVC over the observation period. The control
divers had a mean annual reduction in FEVl,o of 35
(SO 80) ml . year" which was not different from the
predicted value. The deep divers, on the other hand ,
showed a reduction of 210 (SO 84) ml (P < O.OOI)
in FEVl.o in the first year after the deep dive. Thereafter the annual reduction in FEVl,o was 28 (SO 62)
ml . year I , which was not significantly different from
the corresponding reduction of the reference divers
or from the predicted value (figure 1). The forced
expiratory flow rates at given fractions of the FVC
expired showed changes similar to those of the
FEVl.O' with a significant reduction in the first year
after the deep dive (table 3). In the referents the rate
of change in FEF 75 was larger than predicted
(P < 0.02), whereas in the deep divers one year after
the deep dive and thereafter the rates of change in
the maximal expiratory flow rates did not differ from
those of the reference divers or the predicted values.
The PEF did not show any significant changes.
The deep divers had a reduction of 0.34 (SO 0.71)
mmol . min-I . kPa-! in TieDin the first year after the
deep dive, and thereafter the annual reduction in Tim
was 0.19 (SO 0.87) mmol mini . kPa- ' . year" ,
which was not significantly different from the 0.10
(SO 0.78) mmol . min-I. kPa- 1 year! of the reference divers or the predicted annual loss of 0.06
mmol . min" . kPa-1 year-'. There was no significant
change in VA in the referents or the deep divers, the
changes in Kco therefore being similar to the changes
in Tl co (table 3). There was a small increase in CV
(P< 0.01) one year after the deep dive. TLC, FRC,
RV, and L\-N z did not show any significant changes
(table 4).
117
--
100
Discussion
The results showed that in the first year after the deep
dive, there were significa nt reductions in FEVl.o and
forced expiratory flow rates that did not recover over
the following three years of observation. There were
no signifi cant differences between the deep divers
and reference divers at the time of entr y into the
study, and there were no obvious respiratory infections or other exception al activities dur ing the observation period that could explain the differences
between the two group s of divers. Except for the
deep dive, there were no significant differenc es in
the diving exposure of the two groups during the observation period s.
t.J
.5
GI
~ --------
ell
c -100 f-
III
.c
t.J
-200
-300
I
-400
4
Years
------------1
2
Years
Figure 1. Change in forced vital capacity (FVC ) and forced
expiratory volume in 1 s (FEV, ) in the deep divers (- ) one
and four yea rs aft er a deep saiuration dive and in refer ence
divers (-- - ). The mean reduct ions in FVC and FEV, 0 and
their standard dev iation s are shown.
.
Table 3. Rate of change (~) in the lung function variables for the deep divers and the reference divers compared with the predicted
rates of change (4, 13, 14). (FVG = forced vital capacity , FEV1.O = fo rced expiratory volume in 1 s, FEF = forced expiratory flow
rate at a certa in percentage (fig ures in subscript) of the forced vital capacity, PEF = peak expiratory flow , Tlco = tran sfer factor
for carbon mono xide, Kco transfer factor for carbon monoxid e per unit of alveolar volum e)
Deep divers'
Rate of change
between base-line and
1-year examinat ions
Mean
~FVC (ml 'year')
~FEF50 (mls-1.year-')
~F E F75 (mls-1. year- 1)
~ P E F (mls- 1 year-')
~ Tlco (mmol min- 1kPa-1.year-')
~ Keo
- 56
-210
-323
-181
-346
- 223
-32
-0.34
- 0.028
SD
77
84
184
102
197
115
232
0.71
0.076
Rate of change
between 1-year and
4year examinations
Mean
SO
Mean
SO
-8
- 28
-87
-56
- 83
- 79
- 10
- 0.19
- 0.012
83
62
201
92
193
106
253
0.87
0.090
- 12
- 35
- 104
- 69
-1 16
-1 01
41
-0.10
- 0.009
102
80
226
106
192
112d
240
0.78
0.083
Number of d ivers was 24 in one-year exami nati on and 22 in four -year examinati on.
Number of divers was 28.
c P<0.001 ; significantly different from the predicted and referents ' value.
d P<0.02; signific ant ly diff erent fro m predicted.
11 8
Reference divers>
(rate of cha nge
between base-line and
3-year examinations)
Predicted
-29
- 34
-43
-40
-38
-47
- 20
- 0.06
- 0.008
(9 ) nor at the end of the follow-up period. The crosssectional study in which these divers were included
did not show any correlation between FVC and diving e xpos ure, and there were no differences in the
static lung volumes between the divers and a matched
reference group (4). The results are therefore consis tent with the development of airflow limitation in
divers, and the characteristics of their lung function
cannot be explained by adaptation or se lectio n. The
larger-than-predicted rate of change in FEF75 among
the reference divers and the increase in CV in the
deep di vers are al so in agreement with the development of airflow limitation.
In contrast to our previous cross-sectional study
of div ers' lun g fun ction (4) and the studies of pulmonary fun ction immediately after deep dives (9,
10), there wa s no significant reduction in Tl co in this
investigation. The mean reduction in Tl co immediately after the deep saturation dives wa s 10.6% or
1.24 (SD 0.87) mmol . min-I . kP a- 1 (P < O.OOI), and
0.39 (SD 0 .78 ) mmol min-I . kPa- ' (P < 0 .05) one
month later. There were, on the other hand, no changes in the FEV 1.0 or maximal expiratory flow rates
immediately after or one month after the deep di ves.
The changes in dynamic lung volumes and flow s
mu st therefore have taken place later than one month
after the deep div e and may therefore not be rel ated
to the deep dive at all. There was, however, a significant increase in TLC and FRC immed iate ly after the deep di ve s, and the increase could ha ve compensated for a real reduction in the maximal expiratory flow rates since these measurements are related to the fraction of FVC expired and not to ab so lute lung volume.
Several factors may be in vol ved in th e development of airflo w limitation in divers. In saturation
diving , the partial pressure of ox ygen is usually e levated to 40-60 kPa to en sure oxyg enation and facilitate inert gas elimination during decompression.
Oxygen ha s well-established acute to xic effects on
the lun gs ( 16) , and in an animal study by Ril ey e t al
(17) it wa s shown that four to six weeks afte r exposure to hyperoxia loss of pulmonary elastic tissue and
reduced pulmonary recoil pre ssure occur. Th ese findings are consistent with the development of an em physematou s lesion. Venous ga s mi croemboli generated during decompression are common, e ve n in
the absence of clinical de compression sickness (18),
and can induce pulmonary inflammatory lesion s and
gas exchange abno rmalities (19, 20). This effect ca n
be pot entiated by hyp eroxia since oxygen radi cals are
in vol ved in the inflammatory reaction s induced by
gas microembolism ( 19) . Th e exposure to fact ors
such as cumulative hyperoxic exposure, cumulative
hyperbaric exposure , time in saturatio n, and tim e in
de compression we re all inte rrelated and co rre lated
with the maximal pre ssure to which the deep divers
were e xpos ed during the ob servation period . We
we re therefore not abl e to ascribe the c hanges in the
IVC(I)
TLC (I)
FRC (I)
RV (I)
CV (% of VC)
~N2 (%)
" " P<0.01,
Mean
so
Mean
so
6.21
7.95
3.94
1.68
11.2
0.71
0.54
0.86
0.83
0.35
1.8
0.10
6.16
8.04
3.82
1.86
13.7* "
0.77
0.58
0.74
0.74
0.31
3.1
0.12
Acknowledgments
This work was suppo rted by Norsk Hydro A/S , Statoil, and the Ro yal N orwegian Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (NTNF) .
References
I. Crosbie WA, Reed JW, Clarke MC. Functional char-
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
120