Professional Documents
Culture Documents
THE HILLSDALE
To Celebrate a feast
personhood and gender
The future doesn't exist
Humane environmentalism
Leon Bridges' Heartening vision
VOLUME III, ISSUE 13 | April 2016
Ta b l e o f C o n t e n t s
Cover Art: Pretending Nothing is Out There 1
Forester McClatchey
Chris McCaffery
13
Emily Lehman
satire
15
Noah Weinrich
M i s s i o n S tat e m e n t
T h e H i l l s d a l e F o r u m April 2016
Letter
from the
A P R I L
EDITORS-IN-CHIEF
Madeline Johnson
Sarah Reinsel
MANAGING EDITOR
Emily Lehman
EDITOR-AT-LARGE
Chris McCaffery
COPY EDITOR
Andrew Egger
STAFF WRITERS
Timothy Troutner
Noah Weinrich
Mark Naida
ESSAYISTS
Stacey Egger
JoAnna Kroeker
Colin Wilson
DESIGN, ARTWORK,
& PHOTOGRAPHY
Sarah Reinsel
Forester McClatchey
FACULTY ADVISOR
Dr. John Somerville
Editors
2 0 1 6
Right as I was sitting down to write our final Letter from the Editors today,
a Facebook notification bleeped onto my laptop screenand since I was
supposed to be writing this letter, naturally I logged onto Facebook to check
the notification instead. It turned out to be quite a pleasant surpriseYou
Wont, a small-time, two-man band that happens to have quite a following at
Hillsdale, had allowed a website to stream their new album, Revolutionaries,
four days before the actual day of the album drop.
This Facebook notification just made Hell Week possible for a lot of
Hillsdale students.
As Stacey Egger explains with so much care in her article on taste
and community, small communities [bind] their members together in
a discourse that has the ease and depth that shared imagery and artistic
associations bring." This early album drop by You Wont furnishes a perfect
example: the new album will likely provide both the quietly humming
background music and the celebratory blasting-from-the-speakers music
that goes along with all of the camaraderie of all-nighters and hastily written
papers.This little-known band, well-loved by an even littler community,
has become a part of Hillsdales mythos, a recommendation passed down
and listened to and played at gatherings from birthday parties to weddings
for five or six years now, if not more. The albums appearance provokes
reflection on the richness of the Hillsdale student community's cultural
fabric: the communitys contemporary tastes are cultivated by its studious
appreciation of the liberal arts, and its general enthusiasm for beauty turns
outward to love for one another.
This issue of The Forum demonstrates the Hillsdale students love of
beauty in art particularly well. Chris McCaffery opens the issue with the
final installment of his essays on irony, urging us to learn to see not only
art and beauty, but reality itself, with new eyes. Stacey Egger follows up
her previous article on taste and community, explaining thoroughly what
I have only addressed briefly in this letter. Jo Kroeker and Colin Wilson
discuss better ways to approach gender with relation to personhood, and
Emily Lehman explores and contrasts our modern perspective on time
with that of the ancients. Providing another contrast of perspective, satirist
Noah Weinrich directs our attention to some of the non-art factors that can
forcibly shape a community. Finally, Mark Naida shares his thoughts on the
ways contemporary singer Leon Bridges has succeeded in becoming a part
of pop culture without cheapening his Christian vision, and Tim Troutner
explores the humane environmentalism of Hayao Miyazakis movies. On
the cover and throughout the issue, Forester McClatchey comes in clutch
with his delightful pen and ink illustrations.
As this is our final issue of the year, we would like to especially thank
the Intercollegiate Studies Institute and the Collegiate Network for their
continued support, our advisor Dr. Somerville, and our senior editors Chris
McCaffery and Minte Irmer. And to everyone who has contributed to The
Forum this yearthank you for sharing your thoughts and contributing to
the conversation on campus. F
Sarah Reinsel is a junior studying English. Madeline Johnson is a junior
studying philosophy.
To Celebrate a Feast
I R O N Y
P art T hree of T hree :
Learning to See and
Learning in Order to See
by Chris McCaffery
He has the repose of a mind which lives in itself, while it lives
in the world, and which has resources for its happiness at
home when it cannot go abroad. He has a gift which serves
him in public, and supports him in retirement, without
which good fortune is but vulgar, and with which failure and
disappointment have a charm.
John Henry Cardinal Newman,
The Idea of a University.
T h e H i l l s d a l e F o r u m April 2016
T h e H i l l s d a l e F o r u m April 2016
&Community
Taste
Part 2
Stacey Egger
T h e H i l l s d a l e F o r u m April 2016
Human Beings,
Being Gendered
Understanding personhood in light of stereotypes
by JoAnna Kroeker and Colin Wilson
ol
lowing a botched cir
cum
cision at seven
months, David Reimer, born Bruce Reimer,
underwent two sex reas
signment surgeries.
The first occurred at 22 months, when Bruce
became Brenda because doctors thought he
would be more likely to succeed as a woman
than as a man with a dis
figured penis. The
second reassignment took place at 15 years old,
when Brenda became David after the shocking
revelation that his female identity had been cul
tivated by psychologists, hormones, and dresses.
Throughout his life, doctors and psy
chol
ogists cut David Reimer to fit their definitions
of both masculinity and femininity. Our society
upholds these categories as mutually exclusive,
unconditional truths, and uses the manifest
differences in behavior, attributes, and roles to
obscure our universal personhood.
But what happens when these gender
constructions break down in the face of an
individual, like David, who does not fit the mold?
A proper understanding of the biological facts
of gender, sex, and of cultural path dependency
demand that we reevaluate the arbitrary,
behaviorist lines drawn around differing
expressions of personhood.
Gender sits at the crossroads of nature and
nurturea girl is identified as much by her
Our behavioral
categories cut the
human psyche even
more deeply than the
surgical tools cut the
human body because
they cut universally
and indiscriminately,
harming society in
the process.
10
T h e H i l l s d a l e F o r u m April 2016
11
Emily Lehman
12
T h e H i l l s d a l e F o r u m April 2016
13
14
T h e H i l l s d a l e F o r u m April 2016
SATIRE
THE BONE
TO TIGHTEN
FOOD SECURITY
by
Noah Weinrich
15
A Heartening
Mark Naida
16
T h e H i l l s d a l e F o r u m April 2016
17
Finding a Home
in the
enchanted
Hayao Miyazakis Humane
Environmentalism
by
18
T h e H i l l s d a l e F o r u m April 2016
Timothy Troutner
forest
W
and
environmental
destruction
perpetrated by Western modernity.
In particular, the two films Princess
Mononoke (1997) and Nausicaa of the
Valley of the Wind (1984) point the way
toward a humane environmentalism
in which human beings must relearn
the ability to see nature as enchanted,
assuming the responsibility to speak
for her. However, his vision, while
not a Baconian dualism, is ultimately
tragic, and must be supplemented by
a Christian eschatology where nature
and man can take their places as coworkers in a cosmic liturgy of praise
to Godlooking forward to a new
heavens and new earth.
Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind
19
T h e H i l l s d a l e F o r u m April 2016
T h e H i l l s d a l e F o r u m April 2016
23