You are on page 1of 20

Volume 47, Number 5, 2008 www.ventana.sierraclub.

org

MAGAZINE OF THE VENTANA CHAPTER OF THE SIERRA CLUB

Vote the environment


Clip this handy election guide

November 4
and take it to the polls

Z National
Barack Obama, President
Anna Eshoo, House of Reps.
Sam Farr, House of Reps.
OCT - DEC State
OUTINGS Joe Simitian, State Senate
Bill Monning, State Assembly
YES on Proposition 1A
YES on Proposition 2
NO on Proposition 4
NO on Proposition 7
NO on Proposition 10
Monterey County
NO on Measure Z
Marina
Frank O’Connell, City Council
Bruce Delgado, City Council
David Burnett, City Council
Marina Water District
Quinn Gardner
Santa Cruz County
John Leopold,
Santa Cruz Co. Supervisor
Mark Stone,
Santa Cruz Co. Supervisor
City of Santa Cruz
Tim Fitzmaurice, City Council
Katherine Beiers City Council
Scotts Valley
Frank Kertai, City Council
“Sam Farr has been a Caryn Machado, City Council

true environmental hero


Chuck Walker, City Council
Capitola
for protecting our wild Dennis Norton, City Council
public lands.” Michael Termini, City Council
—Vicky Hoover Soquel Creek Water Dist.
Tom LaHue
Randy Tunnell

Bruce Daniels

Explore, enjoy and protect the planet


W hile it is the intent of The Ventana
to print articles that reflect the po-
CHAPTER CHAIR

T
sition of the Ventana Chapter, ideas
expressed in The Ventana are those of the au- General Plan to come before trolled Board. We expect these pro devel- fully in the County process, pouring over
thors and do not necessarily reflect the position opment interests to put heavy pressure on documents and spending thousands of
of the Sierra Club. Articles, graphics, and pho-
their Supervisors to further weaken the hours at hearings and meetings. Now we
Supervisors
tographs are copyrighted by the authors and he blueprint for the future for
plan. need your help.
artists and may be reprinted only with their per- Monterey County will be submit-
mission. Environmentally-sensitive Supervisor- Please write, telephone, and fax or
ted to the Board of Supervisors in a
DEADLINES FOR SUBMISSIONS elect, Jane Parker, will likely be denied an email each Supervisor now and let them
few months. As presented, it will not
opportunity to represent the voters when know that you want Monterey County
All materials for publication must be received meet the Sierra Club’s goals of defending
GPU-5 is brought before the Board. To farms, open space and valuable resources
by the deadlines listed below. No exceptions. valuable farmland, scenic easements,
SUBMISSIONS FORMAT prevent her from doing so, the Supervi- protected from developer sprawl. Your
water resources and wetlands, wildlife
sors have limited the review period for the prompt communication will help to pro-
Please limit articles to 800 words; letters to 300. habitat, and coastal protections.
1000-page plan and the Draft Environ- tect Monterey County for future genera-
All submissions may be edited for clarity and The Ventana Chapter has strong con-
length. Email to dfbulger@cruzio.com. Mail ment Impact Report (DEIR) to just 45 tions.
cerns about hillside and steep slope ordi-
hard copy to editor, address below. days, so that they can vote on the plan be- Email the Clerk to the Board before
nances that will encourage projects in
PHOTOS fore Parker takes her supervisorial seat. October 28 at: CTTB@co.monterey.ca.us
Monterey County’s scenic foothills. The
Your Ventana Chapter has been work- or each individual supervisor at
Photos submitted to The Ventana must meet the Chapter also seeks stronger protections
following requirements: No laser copies or ing nearly nine years to bring Monterey district1@co.monterey.ca.us, district2, etc
for oak woodlands—that otherwise might
inkjet outputs. Electronic photos should be no County a general plan that balances the up to 5. Call 755-5066. A sample letter is
be sacrificed for sprawl and leapfrog de-
smaller than 1200 x 1100 pixels or 300 dpi. needs of its residents and protection of on the Chapter website: www.ventana.
Cover photos must be 3000 x 2000 pixels. Film velopment—and the few remaining stands
natural resources. We have participated sierraclub.org.
photos, slides, or negatives are fine. Please call of rare Monterey Pine Forest, which need
—Rita Dalessio
the editor if you have any questions. an overlay district with strong conserva-
WHERE TO SEND SUBMISSIONS tion guidelines.
Send submissions to Debbie Bulger, Editor, 1603 Moreover, the Draft General Plan
King Street, Santa Cruz, CA 95060. Email: (GPU-5) will be subject to further review

D
dfbulger@cruzio.com. and possible amendment by a devel- FROM THE EDITOR
CHANGE OF ADDRESS oper/agribusiness/tourist industry-con-
Do not call editor! Send address changes to: ad- washing. Just because a ballot proposition
dress.changes@sierraclub.org or use the mail in sounds green, doesn’t make it green.
Beware of greenwashing
coupon in each issue. uring the famous Lincoln-Douglas
Statement of ownership, management, presidential debates, Abraham I am speaking of Proposition 7 and
POSTAL NOTICE
and circulation Lincoln said, Proposition 10 on the November ballot.
The Ventana (015057) is published 6 times a year,
“If you call a tail a leg, how many legs Both of these propositions are opposed by
(Feb., Apr., Jun., Aug., Oct., Dec.) paid by sub-
not only the Sierra Club, but also by
1) Publication title: The Ventana. 2) Publication number:
scription included in membership fee, by The
015-057. 3) Filing date: 9-24-2008. 4) Issue frequency: bi-
has a dog? Five? No; calling a tail a leg
Ventana Chapter of the Sierra Club, 1001 Cen-
monthly. 5) Number of issues published annually: 6. 6)
don’t make it a leg.” other environmental organizations. While
this column does not go into the details,
Annual subscription price: included with membership. 7)
ter Street, Santa Cruz, CA 95060. Periodical Complete mailing address of known office of publication:
The same philosophy can be taken to-
postage paid Santa Cruz, CA and at additional Sierra Club, P.O. Box 604, Santa Cruz, CA 95061-0604.
ward two propositions on the ballot for we urge you to read the articles on page 4
of this issue and check out various other
Contact person: D. Bulger, phone number: 831-457-1036.
mailing offices.
Postmaster: Send address changes to Sierra Club,
8) Complete mailing address of headquarters or general
this coming election. Beware of green-
The Ventana, P.O. Box 604, Santa Cruz, CA
business office of Publisher: P.O. Box 604, Santa Cruz,
independent references.
Greenwashing is the same technique
CA 95061-0604. 9) Full names and complete mailing ad-
95061-0604. dresses for Publisher, Editor and Managing Editor: The

Thank you!!
Editors:
address for the Publisher: Ventana Chapter Sierra Club,
used by the Bush administration for such
destructive legislation as the “Healthy
c/o P.O. Box 604, Santa Cruz, CA 95061-0604. Publisher:
Debbie Bulger, dfbulger@cruzio.com, Ventana Chapter. Editor/Managing Editor: Deborah F.
Virginia Draper, assistant editor Bulger, Address: 1603 King Street, Santa Cruz, CA 95060.
Forests Initiative” which was pro-logging
Production:
forest-exploitation and the “Clear Skies
10) Owner: Ventana Chapter Sierra Club, P. O. Box 604,

This issue of The Ventana has


Santa Cruz, CA 95061-0604. 11) Known bondholders,
Debbie Bulger, Vivian Larkins, mortgagees, and other security holders owning or holding
Initiative” which sought to weaken air
been expanded to 20 pages to
Dale Nutley
pollution laws. As being green becomes
1 percent or more of total amount of bonds, mortgages
Writers:
include all the political endorse-
or other securities: none. 12) Tax status: has not changed.
Rita Dalessio, Debbie Bulger, 13) Publication title: The Ventana. 14) Issue date for circu-
more important to voters, we can expect
ments for the coming election to see more special interest bills being
lation data below: Vol. 47, No.4.
Paul Mason, Stuart Cohen
Jim Metropulos, Denyse Frischmuth
dressed in green in the future.
November 4. We have endorse-
Extent and nature of Average # of # of copies
Photographers:
circulation copies each issue of issue pub-
As always, the bottom line rests with
ments on every level: National,
during preceed- lished nearest
Steve Zmak, Nancy Huguenard, Ventana staff
you, the voter, who must study the facts
ing 12 months: to filing date:
Proofreaders
Jim Danaher, Wolfgang Rosenberg, State, County, City, and Water and try not to be carried away by the
Robin Drury, Jeff Alford, Eloise Graham a) Total number of Districts. emotional claims and slick advertising. I
A big thank you goes out to all
Distribution:
Keith Wood, Esperanza Hernandez,
copies 7500 7500
always find it useful to see which organi-
zations are for or against a particular bill.
the members who participated
b) Paid and/or requested
Beth Lilienthal, Debbie Bulger circulation
If you are for some reason not regis-
in the endorsement process.
Advertising Sales:
1) Outside County mail

tered to vote, or if you have moved since


subscriptions 2400 2780
Debbie Bulger
Political endorsements take a
2) In-County subscrip-
Carpentry & Software: tions 3500 3144
you voted last, the last day to register is
lot of work including develop-
Anonymous
October 20. If you will be unable to get
3) Sales thru dealers, etc. 0 0
Chapter website:
4) Other mailed 0 0

ment of questionnaires, inter- to your assigned polling place on No-


c) Total paid/requested
http://ventana.sierraclub.org
vember 4, the last day to request a vote-
viewing of candidates,
circulation 5900 5924
d) Free distribution by
by-mail ballot is October 28.
documentation, endless meet-
mail

To learn more about your voting sta-


1) Outside County 0 0

ings and phone conversations,


2) In-County 0 0
3) Other mailed 0 0
tus, polling place or other election infor-
not to mention facilitation of mation contact:
e) Free distribution out-
side the mail 1100 1200

the entire process. Thank you. Monterey County:


f) Total free distribution 1200 1200
2008
http://montereycountyelections.us/
Be sure to vote for the
g) Total distribution 7100 7124
Ventana Publication Schedule h) Copies not distributed 400 376
Issue Deadline Mailing Date 796-1499
environment on November 4.
i) Total 7500 7500
#6 Dec. 1 Dec. 17 Santa Cruz County:
j) Percent paid/requested
circulation 83% 83%
http://www.votescount.com/
Articles received after deadline may —The Ventana Chapter and
16) Will be printed in Vol. 47, No. 5
17) Signature of editor, 9/24/08
454-2060.
not be published the Santa Cruz Group —Debbie Bulger
Deborah F. Bulger, Editor

2 The Sierra Club/Ventana Chapter, Volume 47, Number 5, 2008 Printed on recycled paper
Prop. 2 would reduce pollution Club supports Proposition 1A to
from chicken factories build high-speed rail

S S
By Paul Mason, Deputy Director, Sierra California’s enormous chicken facto- by Stuart Cohen, Executive Director,
Club California ries besides being cruel to animals seri- Transportation and Land Use Coalition
ierra Club supports Proposition 2, ously pollute the air and water in part due
the Standards for Confining Animals to the density of the confined animals. ierra Club supports Proposition 1A, the Grasslands Ecological Area, allowing
Initiative, formerly known as Prop. 2 would re- which would provide $9.95 billion bond funds to be spent on improvements
the Prevention of Farm Animal duce the density of dollars to begin the development of in the Altamont corridor connecting the
Cruelty Act. This Humane Soci- the animals, and the 800-mile High-Speed Rail system and Bay Area to Modesto and Stockton, and
ety-backed initiative would set therefore the in- to make improvements to existing rail strong financial accountability provisions.
minimum standards for the hu- tensity of the air networks. Building High-Speed Rail will At their September 2008 meeting, the Cal-
mane treatment of confined chick- and water pollu- promote sustainable land use, significantly ifornia High-Speed Rail Authority Board
ens. tion. reduce global warming pollution, and get approved a goal of using 100% renewable,
Prop. 2 requires that confined Many family commuters off congested roads and out of carbon-free electricity to run the sys-
chickens be able to stand up, turn farmers who raise crowded airports. While it is an extremely tem.One of the most daunting challenges
around and fully extend their limbs. Cur- animals humanely support Prop. 2, be- expensive project, adding the same capac- is the cost of the system— especially with
rently in California approximately 19 mil- cause the cruel (but profitable) practices ity by expanding highways and airports our state budget in crisis. Although the
lion egg-laying chickens are packed into of large factory farms make it difficult for would cost at least twice as much. price tag is very steep (over $30 billion to
tiny “battery cages” in factory farms and small farms to compete financially. Sierra The fully completed high-speed train connect San Francisco and Los Angeles
are unable to extend their wings. Club supports family farming, and this system would run between San Diego and through the Central Valley), it pales in
initiative helps level the playing field by Sacramento, with connections to the Bay comparison to the cost of new highway
requiring big agri-business to apply some Area. Trains would run at speeds of over and airport expansions. Caltrans esti-
220 miles per hour, zipping from San
“To get a chicken’s eye view of these basic standards to their treatment of ani-
Francisco’s Transbay Terminal to Los
mates, for example, that it would cost $6
mals. Vote YES on Prop. 2. billion to widen Highway 99 alone from
conditions, picture yourself standing Angeles’ Union Station in two and a half four lanes to six. Widening just this one
in a crowded elevator. The elevator hours. highway to eight lanes, now being dis-
is so crowded, in fact, that your body High-Speed Rail will help to achieve cussed, is estimated to cost at least $20 bil-
the State’s greenhouse gas reduction goals lion.
is in contact on all sides with other by replacing car and airplane trips with It is time to develop a zero-emission
bodies. . . . And one more thing to LETTERS rail trips. By 2030, when the whole sys- high-speed train system that propels Cali-
keep in mind—this is your life. . . . . The Ventana welcomes letters. tem is in place, rail travel is anticipated to fornia into the 21st century.
Your only release will be at the hands Send to: reduce California’s greenhouse gas emis-
of the executioner. LETTERS TO THE EDITOR sions by up to 12 billion pounds of CO2
“By the way, in your picture of the el- The Ventana, 1603 King Street per year. Vote YES on Prop. 1A.
Santa Cruz, CA 95060 Over the past four months, Sierra Club
evator, you may have imagined the or email to dfbulger@cruzio.com and other organizations have worked to
other people trapped with you as Please include a phone number with your put important safeguards into the original
doing the very best they can to hold letter. Anonymous letters are not accepted. Let- bond measure, including protections for
ters may be edited for length.
still, and not make things difficult for
you. But what if all the others do not Ask Supervisors to buy the
have the ability to understand what is CONTACT YOUR REPRESENTATIVES
The County of Santa Cruz is consider-
Roadhouse property
happening? What if they react to the President George W. Bush (831) 424-2229 (Salinas)
ing the purchase of the Roadhouse Prop- The White House (202) 225-6791 (FAX, Washington, DC)
terror of it all with raw instinct, with- erty on East Cliff Dr between 38th and 1600 Pennsylvania Ave. NW samfarr@mail.house.gov
out even a trace of a civilized ve- 41st Ave. This property is one of the last Washington, D.C. 20500
bits of open space along the Coastal Trail Comment Line: (202) 456-1111 U.S. Representative Anna Eshoo
neer? What if, like you, they have FAX: (202) 456-2461 698 Emerson Street
adjacent to the Monterey Bay Sanctuary. president@whitehouse.gov Palo Alto, CA 94301
powerful territorial needs, and the This property could contain a much- (408) 245-2339; FAX: (650) 323-3498
utter frustration of the situation has needed park with an interpretive center, Vice President Dick Cheney go to website to email
driven them literally insane, prone to public meeting spaces, and offices for non (202) 456-1414
profits and social services. vice.president@whitehouse.gov State Senator Abel Maldonado
erupt into violence with or without Though the $4-6 million purchase price 100 Paseo De San Antonia, Suite 206
Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger San Jose, CA 95113
provocation? may seem high, the environmental and so- State Capitol Building (408) 277-9461
“Now imagine further that the floor of cial benefits will reward the investment Sacramento, CA 95814 senator.maldonado@sen.ca.gov
many times over. (916) 445-2841
the elevator is slanted sharply, so Please contact the Santa Cruz County FAX: (916) 445-4633 State Senator Joe Simitian
gravity tends to push you all in one www.governor.ca.gov State Capitol, Sacramento, CA 95814
Supervisors and ask that they purchase the (916) 445-6747; FAX: (916) 323-4529
direction. The ceiling is so short that property. Purchase by the County is sup- Senator Dianne Feinstein Senator.Simitian@sen.ca.gov
you and the others can only stand ported by the Sierra Club and other local 331 Hart Office Building
groups. Washington, D.C. 20510 State Senator Jeff Denham
upright towards one side, and the (202) 224-3841; (415) 393-0707 369 Main Street, #208
You can reach the Supervisors at, 1 Post Street, Suite 2450 Salinas, CA 93901
floor is made of a wire mesh that is 454-2200, 454-3262 (FAX), email: San Francisco, CA 94104 (831) 769-8040
terribly uncomfortable to everyone’s neal.coonerty@co.santa-cruz.ca.us, go to website to email Senator.Denham@sen.ca.gov
mark.stone@co.santa-cruz.ca.us,
feet. And to complete this approxima- tony.campos@co.santa-cruz.ca.us, Senator Barbara Boxer Assembly Rep. Anna Caballero
112 Hart Office Building assemblymember.Caballero@assembly.ca.gov
tion of the living conditions in today’s jan.beautz@co.santa-cruz.ca.us, Washington, D.C. 20510
factory farms, what if some of the ellen.pirie@co.santa-cruz.ca.us. (202) 224-3553; (415) 403-0100 (voice) Assembly Representative John Laird
1700 Montgomery Street 701 Ocean Street, Room 318-B
others trapped with you in the eleva- Thank you for your help. San Francisco, CA 94111 Santa Cruz, CA 95060; (831) 425-1503
tor have, in their madness, become go to website to email 99 Pacific Street, Suite 555D
—Charles Paulden Monterey, CA 93940
cannibalistic?” Santa Cruz U. S. Representative Sam Farr (831) 649-2832; FAX: (831) 649-2935
People for the Preservation of 100 W. Alisal Street, Salinas, CA 93901 assemblymember.Laird@assembly.ca.gov
—John Robbins
Pleasure Point (831) 429-1976 (Santa Cruz)
Please recycle this paper again The Sierra Club/Ventana Chapter, Volume 47, Number 5, 2008 3
Statewide Propositions

Vote No on No on Prop. 7
Sounds good but would decrease environmental protection
Proposition 4
Maintain open access

N
to family planning
by Jim Metropulos, Senior Advocate, Sierra The lack of a sound, steady source of store is able to stock more grocery choices
Club California
services
funding represents one major flaw that’s because it has more buying power than a
ormally, Sierra Club volunteers sure to get in the way of a 50% renewables smaller store operated by one family. Sim-
and staff would eagerly line up be- goal. Instead of setting up such a funding ilarly, a community that bands together

F
hind a measure proposing that stream, Prop. 7 would force renewable could have more choice over what type of
by Paul Mason, Deputy Director, Sierra power generators to depend upon an un- energy it chooses to buy.
Club California half of California’s electricity come from
renewable sources by 2025. But Proposi- certain system of penalty monies. It also Prop. 7 would decrease environmental
or the third time in four years, Cal- tion 7, an initiative on the November bal- locks in energy rate raises to just 3% an- protections, in the guise of “streamlining”
ifornians face a proposed constitu- lot, doesn’t do enough to save our state nually, even though there are no limits for the permitting process for renewable
tional amendment that would create and our planet from fossil fuel depend- nonrenewable power sources. power. Local chapters wouldn’t be able to
new notification requirements for women ence. In fact, by cementing loopholes that Existing loopholes in enforcement and introduce new evidence of environmental
under 18 who are seeking an abortion. would hold back the growth of the re- archaic policies that tie the price of re- harm when appealing a proposed permit.
Sierra Club opposes Proposition 4. For newable energy industry, it actually could newable energy to the price of natural gas- Sierra Club isn’t standing alone against
nearly 40 years, the Club has supported worsen our current energy situation. generated energy would be locked in this potentially harmful law. The Union
open access to family planning services, Proposition 7: place. In fact, Prop. 7 even lowers some of Concerned Scientists, California
and Prop 4 creates a new obstacle to ac- • Contains serious flaws that could penalties. League of Conservation Voters, and Nat-
cess. Prop 4 would require women under get in the way of achieving its goal of 50% Prop. 7 also would obstruct Sierra ural Resources Defense Council, among
18 to wait 48 hours before obtaining an renewable fuels by 2025. Club’s efforts to establish community other groups, have taken a stand against
abortion and would require notification • Actually works against Sierra Club- choice for energy policy, since it removes Prop. 7. California’s Democratic and Re-
of parents or grandparents or permission backed energy policies that would allow local control over energy policy. Com- publican parties and major utilities also
from the court, before proceeding. communities to choose the source of their munity choice promises to increase the oppose Prop. 7.
This initiative attempts to create better energy. energy-buying power of local communi- Defeat Prop. 7 and clear the way for
family communication through a consti- • Decreases environmental review of ties, giving them more authority. real progress on renewable power.
tutional amendment. While legislating proposed power plants. Consider how a community co-op
better communication is unlikely to suc-
ceed, it is likely that young women caught
in abusive family situations will be put in
an impossible situation and will end up Vote NO on Proposition 10
pursuing black-market abortions.

The wrong road toward cleaner vehicles


Prop 4 is likely to end up sending
young women to seek dangerous amateur
abortions, which is why organizations

S
such as the California Medical Association
and California Nurses Association oppose by Jim Metropulos, Senior Advocate, Sierra The measure has several drawbacks. pound additional water. Defining dams as
the proposal. For more information visit Club California First, the initiative sets a low bar for “renewable” could also create confusion
www.noonprop4.org. ierra Club opposes Proposition 10, “clean alternative vehicles,” which it says in utilities’ attempts to comply with the
The California Renewable Energy must produce “no net material increase in California Renewable Portfolio Standard
and Clean Alternative Fuel Act, be- air pollution” relative to gasoline or diesel. law.
cause it would put California on the Vehicles that meet this standard would do Prop. 10’s promise of more clean alter-
wrong road to cleaner vehicles. little, if anything, to reduce air pollution native vehicles sounds good on its surface.
“One touch of nature Proposition 10 would provide $5 bil- or greenhouse gas emissions.
Second, the State already provides sig-
However, the initia-
tive would ac-
makes the whole
lion in general obligation bonds for four
main purposes: nificant incentives for natural gas and al- complish little
world kin.” 1. alternative fuel vehicles rebates and
research ($3.425 billion),
ternative-fuel vehicles, including a $200
million clean fuels program paid for by
to facilitate
real, sound al-
—Shakespeare fees. ternative energy
2. renewable energy ($1.25 billion),
3. renewable energy demonstration Third, we question the use of bond or technologies,
($200 million), and funds for rebates. Traditionally, bond and its reliance on
4. “clean tech” education and training funds pay for large public works projects long-term borrow-
($125 million). The primary funder of the that would normally be too expensive for NO ing for short-term
initiative is Clean Energy Fuels Corp., the state to afford. Proposition 10 does- benefits and potentially
Moving? which, according to its website, is the n’t set up a system to pay back the obsolete technology
largest provider of natural gas for trans- state’s big borrowing; instead it re- would put us on the
Please fill out and mail the change portation in North America and also lies on future state tax collections. wrong road.
of address form on p. 15 or email: builds and operates natural gas fueling sta- Fourth, we worry that Proposition 10 Joining Sierra Club in opposing Propo-
tions. could lead to the creation of environmen- sition 10 are the League of Women Vot-
The post office charges us 70¢ each Prop. 10’s backer would benefit finan- tally-harmful dams, as it includes all ers, California Nurses Association,
address.changes@sierraclub.org

cially from its passage, because the main classes of hydroelectric power as renew- California Federation of Teachers, Con-
if they handle the address change. able energy. This conflicts with existing sumer Federation of California, Con-
Please help the club by using the thrust of the measure is to provide close
to $3 billion dollars in bond funds to be state law that generally limits the “renew- sumer Watchdog, the Utility Reform
coupon on p. 15. distributed as rebates to buyers of “clean able” designation to smaller hydroelectric Network, and California Labor Federa-
Thank you! alternative fuel vehicles.” installations and to facilities that don’t im- tion, AFL-CIO.

4 The Sierra Club/Ventana Chapter, Volume 47, Number 5, 2008 Printed on recycled paper
National and State Offices

R A A E
U.S. House of Representatives U.S. House of Representatives California State Senate, California State Assembly,
Sam Farr Anna Eshoo Joe Simitian Bill Monning

11th District 27th District


epresentative Sam Farr has earned nna Eshoo has earned the Sierra s a Mayor, County Supervisor, As- lect Bill Monning to the State As-
the endorsement of the Ventana Club endorsement for reelection semblymember and now running sembly. Bill has a long career as a
Chapter for his ninth bid for the to the House of Representatives for his second term in the State practicing environmental attorney
House of Representatives. A winner of for the 14th Congressional District. In Senate, Joe Simitian has been a stalwart and community organizer. As an attorney
the prestigious National Sierra Club’s Ed Washington Eshoo has exercised leader- advocate for the Sierra Club’s mission. with the United Farm Workers Union
Wayburn Award in 2003 for his strong ship in proposing increased fuel efficiency Senator Simitian chairs the Senate Envi- and later California Rural Legal Assis-
leadership in environmental legislation, standards for automakers resulting in the ronmental Quality committee and re- tance, he worked to protect farm workers
he remains one of the Sierra Club’s and Fuel Economy Reform Act which raises cently carried bills that would increase the and rural residents by handling cases re-
the environment’s most stalwart friends. fuel standards to 35 mpg by 2018. She has State's use of renewable energy and re- lated to toxic exposure.
Rep. Farr is best known by the chapter fought to end clearcutting, protect old quire the State to conduct additional stud- Bill’s efforts included holding EPA
as a staunch defender of coastal resources growth forests, and is an original sponsor ies before approving new liquefied natural hearings on the impacts to workers and
and a strong advocate for wilderness ac- of the Safe Climate Act to reduce green- gas terminals. the environment from exposure to toxic
quisition, two of our highest priorities. house gas emissions by 80% below 1990 Currently, Senator Simitian is carrying chemicals, fighting pesticide application
Most recently, he introduced HR 21 levels by 2050. legislation that would mandate climate companies that were dumping Class 1 tox-
(OCEANS 21) to broadly overhaul our Of particular interest to Santa Cruz change to be taught in public schools and ics into the Salinas River, and opposing
ocean management systems and stop the County residents, Eshoo worked tire- would require ocean rangers to monitor methyl bromide use.
degradation of our oceans. lessly with others to protect Sand Hill environmental compliance aboard cruise Bill opposes oil drilling off our coast
Farr’s long standing advocacy for Bluff from future development. The Cal- ships. Senator Simitian has received and in the Arctic National Wildlife
wilderness has won him fans locally and ifornia Congressional delegation led by awards for his work protecting open Refuge. He states, “The focus on offshore
made him a hero to Sierra Club’s Wilder- Eshoo and Senator Feinstein secured $2 space, reducing waste, and fighting to im- drilling distracts from a necessary com-
ness Committee. Vicky Hoover, Chair of million from NOAA toward the $9.6 mil- prove air quality. He has been recognized mitment to development of alternative en-
the Sierra Club California/Nevada lion purchase price. The 154-acre prop- by the Sierra Club for a lifetime of com- ergy, fuel-efficient vehicles, and
Wilderness Committee says, “Sam Farr erty immediately north of Coast Dairies mitment. investment in mass transit.”
has been a true environmental hero for was transferred to State Parks last year. We are proud to endorse his re-election Bill strongly supported Measure A in
protecting our wild public lands. While Eshoo also secured funding to purchase to California’s 11th Senate District. Monterey County, the citizens’ Commu-
his focus has, of course, centered on his Bair Island and thousands of acres of bay nity General Plan Initiative favored by
own congressional district, he has also wetlands in South San Francisco which the Chapter and worked with us to gather
been a cosponsor of the key visionary have been added to the Don Edwards San labor and community support. Bill is
wilderness bills the Club has promoted Francisco Bay National Wildlife Refuge. committed to work at the state level to see
over the years for places such as the Anna Eshoo has earned a 2007 League that General Plans are regularly updated
coastal plain of the Arctic National of Conservation Voters rating of 90%. as required by law and that they meet
Wildlife Refuge and America’s Redrock
Wilderness in Utah.”
To help with his campaign, contact
sam@friendsoffarr.org or call 373-4607.
Her lifetime LCV rating is 97%.
Re-elect Anna Eshoo on June 3. w standards for ensuring protection of farm-
land and sensitive habitat.
Monterey and Santa Cruz County res-
idents have serious concerns regarding
transportation. Bill shares the Chapter’s
opposition to widening Highway 1 and
supports Santa Cruz County’s imminent
purchase of the rail corridor to open up
short- and long-range possibilities for al-
Vote the Environment ternatives to auto transportation.
Bill Monning’s strong environmental

November 4 record and advocacy for the health and


well being of residents and wildlife have
earned the Ventana Chapter Sierra Club
endorsement. Visit www.billmonning.org
to contact Bill or to help with the cam-
paign.

Please recycle this paper again The Sierra Club/Ventana Chapter, Volume 47, Number 5, 2008 5
C A L E N D A R

Sierra Club Events


Friday, October 10 Tuesday, December 9

Join us for this informative slide show to


Potluck & Slides: Elephant Seals
Save the date. Our holiday lunch this year
Senior HOLIDAY LUNCH
learn about the elephant seals who visit will be either at Linwood’s at Chaminade
our coast from Nancy who is a volunteer or Severino’s. Leader is working out menu
naturalist at Año Nuevo State Reserve. options and prices. Flyers will be available
The potluck begins at 6:30 p.m. Bring at hikes for sign ups. But, it will be
food to share and your own washable great!!!!!!!!!! Leader: Pat Herzog, 458-9841.
plate, cup, utensils, and serving utensils.
We love home cooked meals or dessert,
but store-bought food (minimum value $5)
makes great contributions too. For direc-
tions call Nancy, 423-5509.
Nancy Huguenard

Alpha bull northern elephant seal, 2008 breeding season

Non-Sierra Club Events of Interest


The following activities are not sponsored or administered by the Sierra Club. The Club makes no representations or warranties about the
safety, supervision or management of such activities. They are published only as a reader service.

Saturday, October 18 Ph.D., Professor of Biology, Saint Mary’s Monterey CNPS


College of California will be the keynote
speaker. Symposium includes field trips.
For more information contact Bruce Del-
Volunteers are needed to pull trash from Volunteer to restore native habitat in
River & Road Clean Up Habitat restoration
gado, 394-8314, bdelgado@blm.gov.
the river and clean up the road. Trucks State Parks in Monterey Co. Wear layered
with winches appreciated. Clean-up bags, work clothes. Bring water & snacks.
refreshments, provided. Help protect the Tools & gloves provided. Carpools meet
San Lorenzo River and keep trash from
FREE Wormshops
at Rio Rd. Park and Ride. Rain or shine.
being carried to the Bay when the rains Contact Jan Shriner, jshriner@mbay.net,
come. For more info: 338-1728 or Learn how worms can eat your food 236-0905. Website: www.montereybay
www.vwcweb.org. Sponsored by the Val- scraps and make beautiful compost for cnps.org.
ley Women’s Club, County of Santa your garden. Master composters will teach
Cruz, and San Lorenzo Valley Water you everything you need to know. Pre- October 19, Garrapata State Park, 11:00
District. registration required. Free and below a.m. to 2:00 p.m.
wholesale worm bins for residents of unin-
October 24, Garrapata State Park, 9:00
corporated Santa Cruz Co. and Scotts Val-
Wilderness first aid a.m. to 5:00 p.m.; contact to participate re-
ley. $50 charge for residents of Capitola,
Thursday, October 30 quired by October 22
City of Santa Cruz, and Watsonville. Call
offered at UCSC
427-3452 to register. Sponsored by S.C. November 1, Pt. Lobos, 1:00-4:00 p.m.
Fast paced and hands-on, this 2-day Co. Board of Supervisors; produced by November 16, Garrapata State Park, 11:00
Learn about the economic value
Tree Forum
course (16 hours) covers a wide range County Public Works Recycling a.m. to 2:00 p.m.
of the Carmel urban forest. and Solid Waste Services.
of wilderness medicine topics for peo- 2-4:30 p.m. Sunset Cen- November 21, Garrapata State Park, 9:00
ple who travel in the outdoors. Whether ter’s Carpenter Hall, Sunday, October 19, 1- a.m. to 5:00 p.m.; contact to participate re-
spending time in the backcountry is Carmel. Sponsored by 3 p.m., Quail Hollow quired by November 19
your passion or your profession, you City of Carmel Forest Ranch County Park,
should never have to ask, “What do I and Beach Commis- 800 Quail Hollow
do now?” In this course, you’ll learn sion and Friends of Road, Felton Santa Cruz CNPS
how to prepare for the unexpected. Carmel Forest.
Keynote address by
Kelaine Vargas, Urban Saturdays Volunteer to restore native habitat in
Habitat restoration
Cost: $195.00 Ecologist, U.C. Davis.
State Parks in Santa Cruz Co. Wear lay-
Location: Stevenson College Room FREE.
ered work clothes. Bring water & gloves.
175, UC Santa Cruz The Monterey Peninsula Regional Tools provided. 10:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m.
Garland Ranch Hikes

Dates: Saturday and Sunday, October Park District docents lead hikes at Gar- We work rain or shine, but if things get
Friday, November 14 land Ranch every Saturday. An updated particularly unpleasant, we call it a day.
25-26, 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.
list of all hikes may be found on their Contact Linda Brodman, redwdrn@pac
Instructor: Wilderness Medicine In- website: www.mprpd.org. bell.net, 462-4041. Website: www.cruz
stitute of N.O.L.S. Staff The 10th annual California Invasive Weed
Weed Symposium
cnps.org.
Register online at Symposium will present “Evolution/Rev-
www.ucscrecreation.com olution—What’s New in the Invasive October 4, Sunset Beach State Park
Weed World” at CSUMB. Carla Bossard, October 25, Natural Bridges State Park
6 The Sierra Club/Ventana Chapter, Volume 47, Number 5, 2008 Printed on recycled paper
Monterey County

M
Vote NO on Measure Z County allowing only
45 days for review of

T
easure Z, on the Monterey • Measure Z does not include fair
General Plan Draft EIR
County November ballot is a share contributions from agriculture and
half-percent sales tax to raise $980 the hospitality industry even though they he Draft EIR (DEIR) for Monterey
million over 25 years. Called the Trans-
portation Investment Plan, it is part of a
could benefit from the measure.
• Measure Z may afford very little “What is the use County’s latest General Plan Up-
date is out and being reviewed by
$1.8 billion transportation funding pro-
gram, with another $470 million pro-
net improvement. TAMC admits some of a house if you Chapter members. A General Plan is

haven’t got a
roads will even be worse. It also does little often called a “land use bible.” This ver-
posed by Transportation Agency for to address the county road deferred main- sion of the General Plan Update has been
Monterey County (TAMC) in matching
state and federal money, and $320 million
tenance costs of $800 million.
• Measure Z offers no guarantee to tolerable planet ongoing for nearly nine years and has seen
many political and legal battles.
in regional impact fees paid by develop-
ers. It requires a 2/3 vote to pass. The
receive state or federal matching funds. to put it on? The Board of Supervisors acquiesced to
development interests by limiting public
Historically, the state has shown prefer- —Henry David
Ventana Chapter opposes Measure Z. ence to metropolitan areas. With state and Thoreau input to only 45 days for this approxi-
Sierra Club has a policy against widen- national budgets in crisis, where will mately 1000-page document. The public
ing highways. Transportation studies matching funds come from? has only until October 28 to comment.
show that building or widening highways • Measure Z is growth inducing. The issues will be the same as with previ-
induces more traffic. Shortly after widen- • Proponents claim that the highway ous versions:
ing, traffic will increase by 10 - 50% as projects will improve safety, yet almost • Can the county’s natural resources,
public transit or carpool riders switch to 40% of the funding for roads and high- its air and water and its infrastructure and
driving, or motorists take more or longer ways would be used to widen Highway services cope with the amount of growth
trips or switch routes. After about three 156 which is number 12 on the list of the the pro-development Board desires?
years, as the new roadway capacity stim- 16 most unsafe highways in Monterey • Can the side effects-the environ-
ulates more sprawl and motorists move County. mental impacts of the growth -be man-
farther from work and shopping, traffic • Since the Investment Plan can be aged appropriately?
increases 50 - 100%, clogging local streets amended by the TAMC Board of Direc- The Chapter is especially concerned
at both ends of the highway. tors, there are no safeguards for voters in- about the County’s attempts to greatly
This is TAMC’s 4th try on a tax to ex- cluding no penalties for misuse of funds weaken the existing ordinances that pro-
pand roads; the last one failed in June and no assurance that the priority for tect steep hillsides from development and
2006. projects will be followed or even funded. conversion to vineyards. These hills are
Other reasons the Club opposes Meas- home to an incredible array of special sta-
ure Z are: Vote NO on Measure Z. tus plants and animals as well as serving as
our vital watershed. Sierra Club has re-
peatedly called for a full evaluation of this
dangerous policy change, but to date that
Sustainability gaining ground in Monterey County has not occurred.

T
The more comments Supervisors re-
ceive about protecting the environment,
by Denyse Frischmuth the better. See the Chapter Chair column
he concept of sustainability is fi- ing ordinance will bring about a marked Big Sur: on p. 3 for addresses and more informa-
nally making deeper inroads into reduction in wasted energy and natural re- www.relocalize.net/groups/bigsur tion.
our awareness, and the acceptabil- sources. The purchase of electric and hy- Salinas:
ity of sustainability practices is increasing. brid vehicles for its fleet reduces CO2 sustainablesalinas@gmail.com
To hasten and broaden the process, Citi-
zens for a Sustainable Monterey County
emissions. Dual flush toilets, waterless uri-
nals, and a waterless truck cleaning station
Carmel Valley:
mibsmccarthy@sbcglobal.net “We won’t have a
is urging cities in Monterey County to will reduce water usage. Salinas has only Carmel: society if we destroy
the environment.”
adopt and implement two sustainability recently signed the sustainability agree- mlepage1@sbcglobal.net
agreements: the United Nations Urban ments and is considering measures to CSMC works to initiate an action
Environmental Accords and the U.S. adopt. group in every city of the county and to —Margaret Mead
Mayors Climate Protection Agreement. Citizens for a Sustainable Monterey have them adopt the Accords and Agree-
So far, three cities have signed: Pacific County acts as a catalyst for the creation ment. To get involved, contact denyse@
Grove, Monterey and Salinas. of sustainability action groups which ini- sustainablemontereycounty.org.
These agreements provide helpful tiate local projects, educate people on sus-
guidelines for better environmental stew- tainability issues, and partner with their
ardship, and several of their recommen- city government for the implementation
dations have been implemented. Pacific of the Accords and the Agreement. For Moving?
Grove has planted over 2,000 trees more information and to get involved in Please fill out and mail the change
through its “Trees for P.G.” reforestation your community, visit the following web-
project. Its ban on Styrofoam containers sites or use the email contact. of address form on p. 15 or email:
used in restaurants and for take-out food Pacific Grove:
The post office charges us 70¢ each
address.changes@sierraclub.org
will reduce the amount of toxic products www.sustainablepg.org To change address by email:
entering the environment. The use of Monterey: address.changes@sierraclub.org if they handle the address change.
biodegradable and organic cleaning prod- www.montereygreenaction.com Membership inquiries: Please help the club by using the
ucts for all its public buildings reduces Seaside: membership.services@sierraclub.org coupon on p. 15.
water pollution. Monterey’s green build- groups.google.com:80/group/sustain
able-seaside?hl=en
Thank you!

Please recycle this paper again The Sierra Club/Ventana Chapter, Volume 47, Number 5, 2008 7
Santa Cruz County

City of Santa Cruz

Santa Cruz County Supervisor, Santa Cruz County Supervisor,


Mark Stone John Leopold

S E
5th District 1st District
ierra Club endorses Mark Stone for lection of John Leopold to the
another term as County Supervisor Board of Supervisors presents a piv-
for District 5. otal opportunity to move forward
Stone has ably represented District 5, on many critical environmental issues fac-
providing leadership to protect its water- ing Santa Cruz County. On the critical
sheds, including negotiating a settlement issue of Highway 1 widening in our
of the proposed Lompico headwaters for- county, John supports the Sierra Club’s
est logging project. The Lompico water- opposition to this project, whereas his

S K
shed has since been permanently competitor supports the widening.
Santa Cruz City Council Santa Cruz City Council
Tim Fitzmaurice Katherine Beiers
protected through its acquisition by Sem- As a Cabrillo College Trustee, Leopold
pervirens Fund. Mark has consistently has been working to strengthen alterna-
supported Felton citizens’ efforts to buy tive transportation to campus and is a ierra Club endorses Tim Fitzmaurice atherine Beiers has earned the
their water distribution system and to strong supporter of having Cabrillo install because of his strong environmental Sierra Club endorsement for Santa
transfer its management to the San the largest solar array in the county. He record during his prior eight years on Cruz City Council not only be-
Lorenzo Water District. is committed to reducing greenhouse gas the City Council. He has committed to cause of her environmental record on the
While serving on the Regional Trans- emissions through green building, alter- continue working for the environment. Council from 1989-1999, but also for her
portation Commission, Supervisor Stone native transportation, sustainable urban While on the City Council, Tim voted to continuing advocacy for the environment.
has worked to improve regional trans- design, renewable energy, and sustainable hire an environmental coordinator for the For 35 years, Katherine has fought to
portation planning and options. He un- lifestyle choices. City, insisted on adoption of green build- maintain the beauty and environmental
derstands the relationships between John’s experience as a small business- ing standards, helped install recycling con- quality of Santa Cruz, helping to preserve
environmental issues, transportation in- man, his extensive work with local non- tainers downtown, and voted to place Lighthouse Field, establishing the Green-
frastructure, and our quality of life. His profits, and his established relationships solar panels on City Hall. belt, rebuilding a walkable downtown
fairness, vision, and accomplishments with other community leaders display the Tim has promised to take a strong after the earthquake, and promoting an al-
merit this endorsement and your vote on management skills needed by a Supervi- stand against developing water sources ternative route to the Broadway/Brom-
November 4. sor. through desalination that would result in mer bike path across Arana Gulch.
As a board member of the Rex Foun- increased growth. He is committed to If elected, Katherine has promised to
dation, Leopold has either initiated grant providing leadership in reaching tangible address global warming, to allow only re-
revenue or supported funding for a large results to address global warming as part sponsible and sustainable development, to
number of grassroots environmental of the City’s Climate Action Program. reduce the negative impacts of growth, to
groups including the Mattole Restoration While on the Transportation Commis- preserve the integrity of our neighbor-
Salmon Group, Sustainable Fishery Ad- sion, Tim opposed the widening of High- hoods, and to ensure that all of our citi-
vocates, the Environmental Protection In- way 1 and supported transit, bike, and zens have a meaningful opportunity to be
formation Center, and People Power. other alternative transportation. The rail heard in open, democratic government.
Sierra Club endorses John Leopold for trail has been a special project for Tim. Katherine intends to ensure that envi-
Supervisor for the 1st District, Santa Cruz For decades Tim has personally recy- ronmental reviews fully disclose and ex-
County. cled, used public transit, and volunteered amine proposed mitigations and
at beach, river, and graffiti cleanups. His alternatives. She will promote efforts and
election will further environmental goals projects that help people find alternatives
in Santa Cruz. to driving alone. She would support legis-
“I think that I shall never see lation to require that environmentally-
sound building practices be followed for
A billboard lovely as a tree. all new construction. She does not sup-
Perhaps, unless the billboards fall,
port building a parking garage at the
Farmers’ Market site downtown. Kather-
I’ll never see a tree at all.” 333 ine will discourage “spot-zoning” espe-
cially concerning large developers.
—Ogden Nash
Sierra Club believes Katherine will
bring great energy and valuable experi-
ence to the City Council.

8 The Sierra Club/Ventana Chapter, Volume 47, Number 5, 2008 Printed on recycled paper
Marina Coast City of Marina
Water District

F T D
Marina Coast Water District Marina City Council Mayor, Marina Marina City Council
Frank O’Connell Bruce Delgado David Burnett

Q
Quinn Gardner

Board of Directors rank O’Connell has earned the he Sierra Club is pleased to endorse avid Burnett, a Marina resident
uinn Gardner is endorsed by Sierra Club endorsement for the Bruce Delgado for Mayor of Ma- and homeowner since 1995, is en-
Sierra Club for the Marina Coast Marina City Council. Frank has rina in appreciation of his demon- dorsed by Sierra Club. He was ap-
Water District Board of Direc- been a member of the City Planning strated commitment to protecting the pointed to the Marina Planning
tors. Commission since February 2007; he has environment. As a botanist for the BLM, Commission in 2003 where he served for
Quinn’s three primary issues are: 1) worked as an attorney in Monterey since Bruce has introduced many urban resi- four years including one year as chair and
Making our water sustainable for the fu- 1978. As a member of the planning com- dents to the wonders of nature on the one year as vice-chair. During that time,
ture; 2) protecting our families and the mission, Frank had a strong voice in the Fort Ord Public Land. David influenced the city’s General Plan
public health; and 3) getting the people in- environmental aspects of the Marina Sta- As mayor, Bruce will continue his and insured the ongoing preservation of
volved again through greater government tion project on the Armstrong Ranch. prior efforts on City Council toward in- open space.
transparency and education. As a member Frank always reviews the City staff re- clusion of walkable community features Since leaving the Planning Commis-
of the Water Board, Quinn will best rep- ports and recommendations on proposed and renewable technologies in all new sion, David has been increasingly con-
resent the Sierra Club and the citizens of projects, but does not limit his decisions projects in the City. He supports incen- cerned about the approval of so many
Marina, and their interest in a continued to that information. He does independent tives for solar and thermal power installa- large projects in Marina without sufficient
safe, sustainable, cost effective and eco- research to determine the accuracy and tions, redeveloping the downtown instead public participation. David proposes a re-
nomical water supply. He is dedicated to conclusions of environmental impact re- of creating urban sprawl, and making the turn to a sense of fairness and balance in
insuring that the district require all new ports, traffic impacts, zoning, etc. and fol- downtown more exciting, beautiful, and all dealings with the public.
development projects perform an inten- lows that research up with more relevant university friendly. Once elected, David will encourage
sive water supply assessment while questions prior to making a decision and As mayor, Bruce would serve on the town hall meetings and promote environ-
tripling their efforts to seek out more sus- casting his vote. For example, he re- Fort Ord Reuse Authority and be in a po- mentally-sound policies in decision mak-
tainable water creation solutions and searched the feasibility, development, and sition to increase the sustainability of fu- ing. David has deep respect for the Coastal
water conservation methods. maintenance of rain gardens in Marina. ture reuse projects. His vision for the Act and understands the principles of
Water is by far the most crucial and This research included seeking and ob- Central Coast includes working with the CEQA. He values these guidelines in forg-
stressed natural resource on the Monterey taining independent data from govern- Regional Park District and the Big Sur ing a future for emerging cities like Ma-
Peninsula. With threats of seawater intru- mental agencies in other states. Land Trust to acquire coastal open space rina. He will focus on green building
sion and carbon tetrachloride left over Frank shares Sierra Club concerns as it becomes available. practices and the use of sustainable mate-
from Fort Ord, we need a steward who is about balanced growth, traffic congestion, Bruce’s seeks to increase the awareness rials.
not afraid to ask tough questions to pro- alternative energy, and fuel-efficient vehi- of the link between environmental issues To support David Burnett and get in-
tect this vital resource. Quinn’s first pri- cles. He is the proud owner of a hybrid and economic and social needs in cities volved with his campaign, call 384-2828.
ority will be to protect public health; he automobile. around Monterey Bay. To support his
will not wait until damage has been done Frank’s priority of an open and ac- campaign, contact Bruce at
to start looking for remedies. countable government assures us that the bdelgado@mbay.net or call 277-7690.
Both an inspiring community organ- Chapter’s priorities will be well served
izer and passionate environmentalist, with Frank on the Marina City Council.
Quinn has devoted his life to getting peo- To get involved with his campaign, call
ple involved in the issues plaguing Marina. 384-0415.
He believes in open, transparent, partici-
patory government and a water board
that reports directly to the citizens and
looks to them for guidance. To support
Quinn and get involved with his cam- Moving?
paign, call 916-606-3373.
Please fill out and mail the change
of address form on p. 15 or email:
Please patronize our
The post office charges us 70¢ each
address.changes@sierraclub.org
advertisers
if they handle the address change.
Let them know you have
Please help the club by using the
seen their ad in coupon on p. 15.
The Ventana Thank you!

Please recycle this paper again The Sierra Club/Ventana Chapter, Volume 47, Number 5, 2008 9
“The oil age, including combustion processes, which threaten the
very stability of life on earth, is ending, not because we are running
out of oil, but because we have a better idea. The Stone Age never
ran out of stones either.”
—Paul Hawken

10 The Sierra Club/Ventana Chapter, Volume 47, Number 5, 2008 Printed on recycled paper
Please recycle this paper again The Sierra Club/Ventana Chapter, Volume 47, Number 5, 2008 11
Scotts Valley

“The fog comes


on little cat feet.
It sits looking
over the harbor and city
on silent haunches
and then, moves on.”
—Carl Sandburg

S S C
Scotts Valley City Council Scotts Valley City Council Scotts Valley City Council
Frank Kertai Caryn Machado Chuck Walker

ierra Club has endorsed Frank Kertai ierra Club endorses Caryn Machado, huck Walker is endorsed by Sierra
for Scotts Valley City Council. a political newcomer, because of her Club for election to the Scotts Val-
passion for the conservation of ley City Council. His experience as
Frank has not only stated his concern wildlife, her understanding of the intense a former mayor of the City has given him
about City water resource problems, he pressure that human society places on the an excellent understanding of the devel-
ATTENTION: has attended Scotts Valley Water Board natural world, and her understanding opment pressures facing Scotts
District meetings and made specific sug- of the environmental issues fac- Valley. Walker under-
Potential gestions on measures that agency might ing Scotts Valley. stands the principle of
Advertisers! take to conserve water. He practices what Caryn’s knowledge of build-out and how
he preaches and has installed a drip irriga- city government, the 1994 this is directly re-
tion system to cut down on his personal General Plan, the Scotts lated to planning
water use. Valley Water District and zoning.
Kertai has expressed concern about the Chuck ex-
Sierra Club Member
Groundwater Manage-
endangered and threatened native species ment Program, and pressed his sup-
Profile
Advertising in this newsletter packs present in the city including the Ohlone other key documents port for green
more clout into your advertising dol- tiger beetle, red-legged frog and Scotts Val- will enable her to hit the building princi-
lars. Sierra Club members are one of the ley spineflower. Frank supports manda- ground running. She be- ples and a commu-
most valuable audiences in America. tory green building practices in the City. lieves water is the most im- nity where people
They are “opinion leaders” and “influ- He notes that green building is often no portant issue facing the City. could enjoy walking
entials;” by any name they are some of more expensive than conventional build- Caryn supports priority and riding bikes rather
America’s most sought-after advertising ing. placement of local businesses in the than simply being stuck in
targets. Their own purchasing activity is Frank has been active on public issues. new Town Center, adoption of LEED traffic. He is a strong supporter of
substantial. But, more important, they His opposition to the proposed Target building standards, inclusion of bike lanes local small businesses.
influence others—in everything from store is well known, and he submitted 32 and bike parking in the Town Center As Mayor, Walker supported the
opinion and outlook to choice of prod- pages of comments on the Draft EIR for plan, and follows environmental practices wastewater recycling plant which supplies
ucts. They are not only consumers, but the project. His grasp of the environmen- in her personal life. She will work to in- recycled water for landscape use. He be-
also doers and leaders. tal problems facing the city, his impres- corporate sustainability into the Town lieves an adequate and clean water supply
sive analytical skills, and his commitment Center rather than its being optional as it and traffic congestion are the most im-
Club Members are among the most to the future of Scotts Valley have earned is at present. portant environmental issues facing the
active, affluent audiences of adventure the Club endorsement. City. He advocates recharge projects and
travelers and year-round outdoor responsible planning as solutions.

Vote the environment


sports enthusiasts your advertising dol-
lars can buy. It’s an unduplicated audi- Please patronize our
advertisers
November 4
ence with the power to buy your prod-

Let them know you have


ucts and services.

seen their ad in
Median Age: 41
Sierra Club Members are Great Prospects
Male/Female: 63% / 37%
The Ventana
Median Household Income: $56,227
Attended/Graduated College: 81%
Professional/Technical/Managerial: 36%
Moving?
Please fill out and mail the change
Outdoor Sports Enthusiasts
Backpacking/Hiking 4 times more active
than the average adult
of address form on p. 15 or email:
Mountain Biking 5 times more active
Cross-Country Skiing 5 times more active The post office charges us 70¢ each
address.changes@sierraclub.org
Whitewater Rafting 5.5 times more active
if they handle the address change.
Please help the club by using the
Source: 1996 MRI Doublebase

For Rate Information, Contact: coupon on p. 15.


Debbie Bulger - 457-1036 Thank you!

12 The Sierra Club/Ventana Chapter, Volume 47, Number 5, 2008 Printed on recycled paper
Capitola

Task Force and Capitola’s Commission took bold steps to ban its use for take-out
on the Environment. food. Capitola had the first such ordi-
Sierra Club urges you to vote for Den- nance in the nation.
nis Norton for Capitola City Council. Termini has also taken the lead in per-
suading restaurants to separate food waste
from other trash. This is a vital first step
to addressing the problem of fugitive
methane in landfills. Methane is a far

I
more dangerous greenhouse gas than CO2
Capitola City Council
Dennis Norton
and is generated from organic material
such as decomposing food waste
n his previous terms on the Capitola in landfills. Eliminating
City Council from 1999 to 2006, Den- this source of a greenhouse
nis Norton was a strong advocate for gas is a very important
the environment. As the Capitola repre- measure that cities can im-
sentative to the Regional Transportation plement to fight global
Commission, Dennis was an outspoken warming.
advocate for alternative transportation The City of Capitola is for-
and purchase of the Union Pacific rail cor- tunate to have a leader of Michael Ter-
ridor. He championed sensible trans- mini’s quality. Vote for Michael Termini
portation and opposed widening for City Council.

S
Highway 1.
Capitola City Council
Michael Termini
Dennis employs green building prac-
tices in his design business and is working
to incorporate green building into the ierra Club enthusiastically endorses
City Code. He supports housing above re-
tail businesses, preservation of historic
Michael Termini for reelection to the
Capitola City Council. Coun- Vote the environment
neighborhoods, and public open space.
Dennis supported the polystyrene ban
cilmember Termini is knowledgeable,
committed to the environment and effec- November 4
in the City and is working to preserve the tive in turning ideas into action.
Golino property along Soquel Creek. He Michael Termini’s leadership in ban-
is an advocate for creeks protection and ning Styrofoam containers in Capitola has
advocates the use of permeable surfaces to made the City a model for the rest of the
decrease storm water runoff. As mayor, nation. He saw the blight that polystyrene
Dennis founded the first Soquel Creek caused on beaches and in the ocean and

“Peace begins
Soquel Creek Water District Well Within”

the founding Chair of the Santa Cruz


County Chapter of Surfrider Foundation.
Many local defenders of our natural re-
sources have joined the Sierra Club in en-
dorsing this slate, including Assembly
member John Laird, Fred Keeley, The
P R I V A T E SP A S & S A U N A S O V E R L O O K I N G
People’s Democratic Club of Santa Cruz A JA P A N E S E G A R D E N
County, and hydrologist, Dr. Bob Curry.
Bruce and Tom will continue to ad-
dress customer needs while dealing with
the issues of clean water, salt-water intru-
sion, environmental protection and con- u Massage Therapy
servation. They will base solutions to
problems on expert science. They are
Tom LaHue
working to protect both the water qual-
u Skin & Body Care
Soquel Creek Water District
Bruce Daniels
ity and resident wildlife of Soquel Creek

T
Board and the Monterey Bay. u All Natural Skin Care
Bruce and Tom also believe that water
conservation with financial incentives can
Products
he Sierra Club endorses Bruce reduce our current water deficit and they
Daniels and Dr. Tom LaHue for re- are dedicated to carbon-neutral solutions.
election to the Soquel Creek Water For more information and to support
District (SCWD) Board of Directors. Bruce and Tom, visit
Bruce Daniels (current SCWD President) www.ProtectWater.info.
was the founding Chair of the Sierra
Club’s local Water Resources Committee. 4 1 7 C e d a r St . , S a n ta C r u z 8 31- 4 58 - W E L L .
Tom (current SCWD Vice-President) was Visit our web site at www.wellwithinspa.com

Please recycle this paper again The Sierra Club/Ventana Chapter, Volume 47, Number 5, 2008 13
Sierra Club organizer, Marily Woodhouse, NEWSCLIPS
is mobilizing volunteers against clearcutting American way of dying
National Geographic reports that we
bury more than bodies after people die.
Each year in the United State we also
bury 30 million board feet of wood com-
prising caskets, 90,000 tons of steel (more
than in the Golden Gate Bridge), and use
1.6 million tons of concrete in burial
vaults.

Drying tip
If Americans would dry just half their
laundry loads on a clothes rack or clothes-
line instead of using a dryer, the collective
reduction in CO2 would be almost 9 mil-
lion tons. It saves money too. Such a deal.

Carbon Sink
An article in the September 11 issue of
the journal Nature provides more evi-
dence that old growth forests sequester
carbon for centuries. Conventional teach-
ing, based on one study from the 1960s,
assumed that old growth was carbon neu-
tral. Many of these old growth forests are
unprotected at present.

Fish killers
Even with careful use, the pesticides
chlorpyrifos, diazinon, and malathion

M
find their way into streams and harm
Sierra Pacific Industries is in the process of clearcutting 1.7 million acres of their holdings in the Sierra Nevada.
salmon. These chemicals are used on
a campaign aimed at building sufficient fruits, vegetables, livestock, and fence-
arily Woodhouse knows first dustries (SPI) clearcuts. She told us, “What
public outrage at this logging practice that posts among other uses. Under a settle-
hand the destruction of clearcut- is being done a few miles from where I
demand will build for wood products that ment of a lawsuit, NOAA Fisheries has
ting. Living in the foothills of Mt. live is a microcosm of what is being done
are not produced by destroying our until October 31 to work with the EPA
Lassen, her quiet, little-used road suddenly all over the northern part of the state. It is
forests. to find new ways to safely use these chem-
became a logging truck superhighway deforestation as surely as what has been
Our partnership with ForestEthics will icals. Are there any safe ways? To learn
with truckload after truckload of trees done to rainforests in other parts of the
be a marriage of strengths. While we have more visit www.earthjustice.org/news/
being hauled away from Sierra Pacific In- world. The difference is that it is right
many members to call upon to help de- index.html for the August 13 press release.
here in our state instead of thousands of
miles away. These archaic and unsustain- fend the Sierra, we will be taking advan-
able logging practices must be stopped. tage of the tried and true approaches that
Cities can help with solar
AB811, signed by Governor Schwarz-
The only way to do that is for ‘we the ForestEthics developed which stopped the
enegger this summer, allows cities and
people’ to act to make it so.” production of Victoria’s Secret catalogs
counties to offer low-interest financing to
Marily has been hired with contribu- from Canada’s boreal forests and con-
residents and business owners who want
tions of five California Sierra Club chap- vinced Staples that it was not in their eco-
to install solar panels or make other en-
ters, including the Ventana Chapter, to nomic interests to market products made
ergy improvements.
enlist and coordinate volunteers in a cam- from old-growth forests.
paign to end clearcutting in the Sierra Ne- The key to this campaign will be to
vada. draw the public’s attention to the horrific
College pledge
Ripon College, a 1000 student college
Many people are not aware that al- effects of clearcutting, including the loss
in Wisconsin, is offering incoming fresh-
though clearcutting on National Forests of beauty and wildlife habitat, the erosion
men a new mountain bike, helmet, and
in the Sierra has mostly been abandoned, and the sedimentation, and the poisoning
lock if they pledge not to bring a car to
on vast private forestlands it is still the of soil and streams with toxic herbicides.
campus. Sixty percent of incoming fresh-
dominant timber harvesting method. SPI Healthy forests provide 60% of Califor-
men have signed up.
is by far the worst offender. The company nia’s water supply and sequester carbon to
is in the process of clearcutting and turn- help combat global warming. Public pres-
ing into tree plantations over 1.7 million sure can force Sierra Pacific Industries to
acres of their holdings in the Sierra Ne- change their timber harvesting practices.
vada. To stop the onslaught, the Sierra For this ambitious effort to succeed, we
Club has partnered with ForestEthics in need many volunteers, members who
truly care enough about the Sierra to step
up and take action. If you would like to
To change address by email: learn more, or to sign up to help, Marily
address.changes@sierraclub.org can be reached at 530-474-5803 or
marily.woodhouse@mlc.sierraclub.org.
Membership inquiries:
More about ForestEthics and the Save the
membership.services@sierraclub.org Sierra Campaign can be found at:
www.savethesierra.org.
14 The Sierra Club/Ventana Chapter, Volume 47, Number 5, 2008 Printed on recycled paper
O U T I N G S
Sunday, October 12
In the interest of facilitating the logistics of some outings, it is customary that HIKE: MARIN HEADLANDS
participants make carpooling arrangements. The Sierra Club does not have in-
OUTINGS RATINGS
surance for carpooling arrangements and assumes no liability for them. Car- We’ll carpool to the south end of the Golden
GENERAL INFORMATION:
pooling, ridesharing, or anything similar is strictly a private arrangement Gate Bridge where we’ll take the bus over the
All outings begin and end at the trailhead. bridge to the Point Bonita Lighthouse. From
among the participants. Participants assume the risks associated with this travel. there we’ll hike back along the Marin Head-
Carpooling to and from the trailhead is strictly CST 2087766-40. Registration as a seller of travel does not constitute approval lands and over the bridge to San Francisco.
a private arrangement between the driver and by the State of California. We’ll experience coastal views, the fall migra-
the riders. Carpool drivers are not agents or Participants will be required to sign a liability waiver. To read it before choos- tion of raptors as they prepare to cross the
employees of the Sierra Club. ing to participate on an outing go to Golden Gate, and one of the most unique ex-
www.sierraclub.org/outings/chapter/forms/. periences of all, walking the bridge. Space lim-
EXPLANATION OF RATINGS: ited, call for details. Leader: John Howerton,
The outings described vary in difficulty 476-4253.
OCTOBER
We’ll ride along paved streets for about 15
from leisurely walks to strenuous hikes. The miles, enjoying ocean scenery and stopping at
following explanation is a general guideline. Tuesday, October 14
viewpoints. About 2 hours. Helmets manda- SENIOR HIKE: JACKS PEAK
(For more information about the difficulty of a Saturday, October 4 tory. Bring a lunch to eat at the end of the ride
particular outing, call the leader). in the leaders’ back garden. Hosts will provide We’ll hike in a Monterey Pine forest stopping
HIKE: EL CORTE DE MADERA PRESERVE at the highest point of the Monterey Peninsula.
Walk: Between 2-5 miles, leisurely pace. cups of English tea. Leaders: Cath Farrant and
Easy: No more than 5 miles; slight elevation A 9-mile loop starting from the entrance park- Mary Dainton, 372 7427. - Great views. Some hills but not too steep. Meet
gain; easy pace. ing area on Star Hill Road. We’ll hike the El BEFORE 10:00 a.m. at Sears 41st Ave. To go
Corte De Madera Creek Trail 3.6 miles to the Saturday, October 11 direct, take Hwy. 1 then 68 east. Park entrance
Moderate: 5-10 miles; up to 2000' gain; main entrance near Skegg’s Point on Skyline is across from airport entrance. Restrooms
HIKE: BIG BASIN
boots; better than average fitness required. Blvd. Then the Tafoni, Fir, and Methusela available. Bring lunch, water, $5 carpool, and
Strenuous: May involve off-trail hiking; Trails back to our start. Along the Tafoni Trail The East Branch of Waddell Creek is the lesser
known tributary flowing into Last Chance. share of entrance fee. Leader: Pat Herzog,
demanding pace; for experienced hikers in good we’ll take a side trip to a large sandstone for- 458-9841.
condition only. mation with shallow caves and honeycomb de- We’ll go farther than last time, to the edge of
pressions reminiscent of outcroppings at Castle the park. 9 miles with 1500' elevation gain. Tuesday, October 14,
Rock State Park, though it seems to be made of Meet at 9:30 a.m. at the Santa Cruz County HIKE: NISENE MARKS
softer and more fragile material. Spectacular Government Center to carpool. Call Nick for
This 6-1/2 mile loop on the Bridge Creek Trail
MEETING PLACES
views to the sea along the ridge top and near additional information. Leader: Nick Wyckoff,
462-3101. with 900' elevation gain takes us through a
DIRECTIONS: the creek headwaters. The canyons are filled lovely redwood forest and along beautiful
Rio Road Park & Ride: This parking lot is with second-growth redwoods and Douglas fir.
on Rio Road in Carmel. Meet at the Santa Cruz County Government
Center at 8:30 a.m. Bring water, lunch, and $8
Save-Mart / Bagel Bakery: (formerly Al- carpool. Leader: Ed Gilbert, 685-8389.
bertson’s) South of Monterey on Hwy. 1. One
mile past Ocean Ave., turn L on Carmel Valley Saturday, October 4
Rd. Almost immediately, turn R at the light. HIKE: SOQUEL DEMO FOREST
Save-Mart/ Bagel Bakery on the R. This large forest is situated north and above
Santa Cruz County Government Center: Nisene Marks. Strenuous 10-mile loop with
The large grey building at the corner of Ocean 1500' elevation gain on forest roads and trails,
& Water in Santa Cruz. We meet at the corner mostly shaded, shared with mountain bikers.
of the parking lot nearest to the intersection. Bring water and lunch, snacks for breaks. Meet
Felton Faire: The shopping center at the in Seaside at Home Depot at 8:30 a.m. or at the
junction of Graham Hill and Mt. Hermon Rds Corralitos Meat Market at 9:15 a.m. Definitely
in Felton. We meet at the edge of the Safeway call before. Leader: Anneliese Suter, 624-1467.
parking lot nearest Graham Hill Rd.
Sunday, October 5
41st Avenue / Sears: From Hwy. 1 in Capi- HIKE: LOS PADRES NATIONAL FOREST
tola take the 41st Ave. exit. Go toward the
ocean on 41st Ave. Pass the main Mall entrance Depending on the extent of the recent forest
and turn right into the next entrance near fires in our National Forest, we’ll hike some-
where in the northern sections of Los Padres.
Sears. We meet behind the bank located at 41st Either Devil’s Peak, Danish Creek, Big Pines,
and Capitola Road. or Bluff Camp. Expect 8-12 miles and 2000' el-
MPC Parking lot: Monterey Peninsula evation gain. Please call within a week of this
College Parking Lot. From Hwy. 1 take the hike to confirm the location, meeting time &
Fisherman’s Wharf exit, go straight one block, place, etc. Leader: Larry Parrish, 622-7455.
turn L and L again into the first parking lot—
A. This is the site of the Thurs. Farmers Mkt. Tuesday, October 7
Plenty of parking with no fee on weekends. HIKE: MITTELDORF PRESERVE
6-mile hike with little elevation gain along
Williams Creek through a serene redwood for-
est. We’ll see a nice variety of ferns and flowers.
Bring water & lunch. Arrive early, we leave at
9:30 a.m. sharp from Rio Road Park & Ride.
Call for reservation. Leader: Lynn Bomberger,
375-7777.
Friday, October 10
BIKE RIDE: PEBBLE BEACH
Meet at 10:00 a.m. outside the Fishwife restau-
rant in Pacific Grove (Hwy. 68 and Asilomar
Blvd.) Please arrive with your bicycle in work-
ing condition with the tires properly inflated.
Home Depot Seaside

Please recycle this paper again The Sierra Club/Ventana Chapter, Volume 47, Number 5, 2008 15
O U T I N G S
creeks with several crossings. Moderate pace Carmel River Beach at the lagoon (south end turn-off to Portola Rd. Right on Portola for a
with stops to enjoy flora & fauna. Bring water of Carmelo Street in Carmel) at 9:00 a.m. short distance to a 10:10 a.m. start. To carpool NOVEMBER
& lunch. Arrive early, leave at 8:45 a.m. sharp Leader: Martha Saylor, 372-9215. ($5) meet at 9:00 a.m. at Sears 41st Ave. Leader:
from Shell station by Home Depot in Seaside Diane Cornell, 423-5925. Saturday, November 1
or from parking lot behind Aptos Station at Monday, October 20
HIKE: BIG CREEK/CANOGAS FALLS
9:30 a.m. sharp. Call for a reservation. Leader: HIKE: PINNACLES Thursday, October 23
Lynn Bomberger, 375-7777. This is the perfect time to hike the North WALK: PG & MONTEREY TRAILS The UCSC Reserve at Big Creek was very
Wilderness Trail. Plan to spend all day. Call We’ll check out two short trails recently in the lucky: the big fire this summer stopped right at
Wednesday, October 15 leader one week ahead for meeting place and news: PG/Asilomar & Veterans Memorial their borders. And we’re lucky to have a reser-
HIKE: WATSONVILLE WETLANDS time, or call will not be returned. Leader: Es- Park areas. Both have been long used by the vation to hike up to the High Camp where
One of only two major systems of coastal fresh peranza Hernandez, 678-1968. public, and now their use is being challenged. 5 we’ll leave our lunches. From here, just with
water sloughs remaining in California. Spend miles of easy walking. Call for meeting loca- water, we’ll hike down 1,000' to the Canogas
the morning with the environmental/educa- Tuesday, October 21 tion, time and reservation. Leader: Lynn Falls, the largest waterfall deep inside Big Sur.
tional nonprofit Watsonville Wetlands Watch. SENIOR HIKE: NISENE MARKS Bomberger, 375-7777. After a late lunch, eventually back down over
Begin at its educational resource center where the meadows with the ocean always shimmer-
4-mile shady hike of the Hoffman Loop start- ing beneath us. Wonderful! A strenuous day
you will learn about its programs in restora- ing at Porter Picnic area. Narrow trails with Sunday, October 26
tion, education and conservation, then take a HIKE: SALINAS RIVER STATE BEACH with 14 miles and 3000’ elevation gain. Bring a
some uphill to Hoffman Site. Meet before 9:30 hearty lunch and lots of water, hiking poles and
guided tour through environmentally-sensitive a.m. at Sears 41st Ave. or the dirt parking lot We’ll hike 4 miles south along the pristine
habitat areas including Dept. of Fish & Game a hat. Please call before. Meet at Rio Road Park
before the Park entrance. Bring lunch, water, beach to the mouth of the river in the Salinas and Ride at 7:45 a.m. Leader: Anneliese Suter,
properties. Picnic on a knoll overlooking sit upon, repellent, $2 carpool and share of en- River National Wildlife Refuge. After a short
Struve Slough. After lunch walk 6 miles skirt- 624-1467.
trance fee. Restrooms. Leader: Beverly Meschi, break, we’ll return for an optional lunch at
ing the sloughs. Rich in birds; bring binoculars, 475-4185. Phil’s seafood restaurant in Moss Landing. Ex- Saturday, November 1
water, and lunch. Meet at Sears 41st Ave. at cellent opportunities to view shorebirds and HIKE: BUZZARDS ROOST
9:00 a.m. or call leader for a Watsonville meet- Wednesday, October 22 marine mammals. From Hwy. 1, take Moss & SEMPERVIRENS FALLS
ing place. Leader: Diane Cornell, 423-5925. HIKE: WINDY HILL Landing Rd. to Sandholdt Rd. Meet at 9:00 a.m. A 9-mile loop hike, with 1200’ elevation gain,
This trail traverses an area of high grassy slopes in the parking lot on the left after crossing the beginning and ending at the Big Basin head-
Saturday, October 18 bridge. (Do not take Potrero Rd.) 8 miles with
WALK: CARMEL RIVER BEACH that can be seen from most of the Bay Area. quarters. We’ll follow the Pine Mountain Trail
From the top, views over the ocean give the no elevation gain. Rain cancels. Leader: Eugene to Buzzards Roost at 2200' where we’ll visit the
How about an early morning walk from trail its name as currents of wind wash over the Sobka, 449-0873. satellite tracking station at the rocky butte be-
Carmel River Beach to Monastery Beach via ridge. Don’t let this scare you off, because the fore returning to the Blooms Creek Trail. We’ll
the hill and back via the bluff trail. Enjoy views protected Hamms Gulch Trail descends Sunday, October 26
follow this trail, the East Ridge Trail and the
of Point Lobos and listen to the surf. About 3 through a Doug fir forest with rays of sunlight HIKE: PALO CORONA TO ROCKY RIDGE
Shadowbrook Trail to Sempervirens Falls then
miles. Wear comfortable shoes; dress for shining between massive trees. 8 miles. Bring Let’s get in a good hike before Daylight Savings back. Meet at the Santa Cruz County Govern-
weather; windbreaker recommended. Bring lunch and water. From Hwy. 280 take Alpine ends. We’ll begin this 12 mile jaunt at the Palo ment Center parking lot at 9:00 a.m., or at Fel-
water and snack. Meet at the parking lot of Corona trailhead, hike up and down 3000' of ton Fair at 9:20 a.m. Bring water, lunch and $5
ranch roads to the south, eventually crossing carpool. Leader: Ed Gilbert, 685-8389.
Mal Paso Creek, then exit via the Rocky Ridge
Trail of Garrapata State Park. Bring food and Sunday, November 2
water. Space is limited; call for reservation. HIKE: PESCADERO CREEK
Leader: Larry Parrish, 622-7455. A meandering hike through mixed woodlands
Tuesday, October 28
in this county park. Lunch on the deck of the
SENIOR HIKE: MT. MADONNA
Sierra Club hiker hut. 10 miles and 1000' ele-
vation gain. Meet at the Santa Cruz County
Located off Hwy. 152, this is a moderate 3-1/2 Government Center at 8:00 a.m. Remember to
mile hike. We’ll return via Gizdich Farms for set your clock back! Call for details. Leader:
dessert. Meet before 9:30 a.m. at Sears 41st Av- John Howerton, 476-4253.
enue. To go direct, meet by 10:00 a.m. just be-
yond park’s kiosk entrance by restrooms or Wednesday, November 5
Built by Sierra Club members in 1934, this rustic, hostel-style lodge
call leader. Bring lunch, water, $4 carpool and HIKE: HAKONE GARDENS & MONTALVO
stands atop historic Donner Pass, just an hour and a half from
share of entrance fee. Leader: Joan Brohmer, We’ll start in Hakone Gardens, an 18-acre
462-3803.
Sacramento.
Japanese garden started by the Stine family in
1915. Japanese gardeners were hired to bring
from Japan a tea house and reconstruct it in the
Clair Tappaan Lodge is the perfect autumn base camp for anyone
center of a garden which was designed to be
who enjoys the wide variety of activities offered by the Tahoe area.
like Fuji-Hakone National Park in Japan. After
lunch, we’ll walk the hillsides and formal gar-
Autumn is the secret season in the Sierra when the summer crowds

dens of Montalvo Arts Center, a Mediterranean


go home, temperatures cool off, and the fall colors come out. Short
hikes to secluded mountain lakes are perfect for introducing the
family to the mountains. The nearby Pacific Crest Trail offers
expansive views for both novice and advanced hikers. Donner Lake
offers great kayaking and fishing while Donner Summit has long
been a destination for rock climbers and mountain bikers.

Guests enjoy excellent family style meals, a friendly staff and a


casual and communal atmosphere. See you on Donner Summit...

For more information about the Lodge or to


receive a full schedule and description of Clair
Tappaan programs please visit our website at
www.ctl.sierraclub.org or call (800) 679-6775.

16 The Sierra Club/Ventana Chapter, Volume 47, Number 5, 2008 Printed on recycled paper
O U T I N G S
Monday, November 17 Sunday, November 23 Tuesday, November 25
style villa nestled in the foothills above HIKE: PINNACLES HIKE: GARLAND RANCH HIKE: JACK’S PEAK
Saratoga. This center, the former home of
James Phelan, a California Senator, is devoted This is a very strenuous hike of the South Need to work up an appetite for Turkey Day? Jack’s Peak offers quiet, forested trails with
to the development of art, architecture, music, Wilderness Loop, not for the weak! Cool Let’s hope for a clear day and puff up and down spectacular views of Monterey, the Bay and
and literature. Concerts and shows are held weather will help us on this breathtaking chal- a few hills somewhere around Garland Ranch. Carmel Valley. 5-1/2 miles with 700' elevation
here each year. Bring lunch and water for this lenge. Reserve all day; it will be worth every Slow pace; under 5 miles. Dress in layers; bring gain. Moderate pace with stops to enjoy flora &
moderate hike with some uphill to lookout minute of it. Call me one week ahead for time lunch, water, and optional hiking stick to help fauna. Bring water & lunch. Arrive early, leave
points with great views of Santa Clara Valley. and meeting place or call will not be returned. on tricky trail spots. Meet at 10:00 a.m. in the
Meet at 9:00 a.m. at Sears 41st Avenue to car- Bring food and water. Leader: Esperanza Her- main parking lot (not up on the shoulder of CV
pool ($6 including parking) or at 21000 Big nandez, 678-1968. road!) or if coming from town, check (no
Basin Way, Saratoga and park inside the gate leader) for carpoolers at the Rio Road Park and
for a 10:00 a.m. start. Leader: Diane Cornell, Tuesday, November 18 Ride at 9:40 a.m. Real rain cancels! Leader:
423-5925. HIKE: PEBBLE BEACH Mary Gale, 626-3565.
We’ll hike a figure 8 through serene pine forests
Tuesday, November 11 and open meadows of Pebble Beach. Lunch Sunday, November 23
SENIOR WALK: LEVEE TO HARBOR gives us the option of a sandwich at Poppy HIKE: PINNACLES
Casual walk along River Street levee to mu- Hills. 6-1/2 miles, 850' elevation gain, moderate Rising out of the chaparral-covered Gabilan
seum on East Cliff for a short stopover then pace with flora & fauna stops. Arrive early, Mountains, east of Central California’s Salinas
onto the yacht harbor for lunch. Bring lunch leave at 9:30 a.m. sharp from the Safeway park- Valley, are the spectacular remains of an an-
or visit a restaurant. 5 miles. Meet before 9:30 ing lot recycle shed on Hwy. 68 in P.G. Call cient volcano. Massive monoliths, spires, sheer-
a.m. at Sears 41st Ave. or Gateway Plaza on for a reservation. Leader: Lynn Bomberger, walled canyons and talus passages define
River Street by Ross at 9:50 a.m. Leader: Pat 375-7777. millions of years of erosion, faulting and tec-
Herzog, 458-9841. tonic plate movement. Within the monument’s
Wednesday, November 19 boundaries lie 24,000 acres of diverse wildlands.
Wednesday, November 12 HIKE: WADDELL CREEK TO BERRY FALLS We’ll hike about 10 miles, 1500' elevation gain.
HIKE: PURISIMA CREEK One of our favorite hikes is on this trail that Bring food and plenty of water. Call for car-
starts at Rancho Del Oso by the coast and fol- pool details by Friday. Leader: John Hower-
See breathtaking ocean views, towering red- ton, 476-4253.
woods and firs, a picturesque creek, and plenti- lows Waddell Creek up to the Berry Creek wa-
ful wildlife and ferns. “Purisima” means terfall for lunch. The trail passes between
pristine, and it surely is the best 9-mile hike private lands with organic gardens and red-
that I have taken recently. We’ll start from the wood groves. After crossing the creek, the trail
coast entrance along the flat creek trail where winds uphill and narrows. Boots recommended
every part of the creek could be a stunning cal- for this 9-mile hike with 800' elevation gain.
endar picture. We’ll go up Soda Gulch Trail We’ll pass the site of Herbert Hoover Jr’s camp
and along the ridge for ocean views, then down when he was a boy building fences on the
the steep Whittemore Gulch Trail. Bring lunch ranch. Bring lunch, water and $5 carpool. Meet
and water. Meet at Sears 41st Ave. at 9:00 a.m. at Sears 41st Avenue at 9:00 a.m. or at the trail-
to carpool ($6) or at the trailhead off Hwy. 1 head on Hwy. 1 across from the bus stop at
north to Verde Road for 1/4 mile, and then Waddell Beach at 10:00 a.m. Leader: Diane
continue onto Purisima Creek Rd 3.7 miles. Cornell, 423-5925.
Leader: Diane Cornell, 423-5925.
Wednesday, November 19
Saturday, November 15 SENIOR HIKE: MANZANITA PARK
WALK: PEBBLE BEACH/ASILOMAR NOTE: THIS HIKE IS ON WEDNESDAY.
4-mile loop hike, starting on neighborhood A moderate, hilly 3-mile hike in North Mon-
streets and then thru dunes between fairways, terey County. On a clean day, see the ocean
out to Point Joe and back along the beach and Fremont Peak. Lunch at picnic tables.
boardwalk. Quiet neighborhood, beach wild- Restrooms available. Meet before 9:30 a.m. at
flowers, possible wildlife to be seen. Meet Sears 41st Ave or at Manzanita. Call leader for
across from the Fishwife Restaurant on Sunset directions. Bring lunch, water, $5 carpool.
Drive and Asilomar Blvd., Pacific Grove at 9:00 Leader: Bev Meschi, 475-4185.
a.m. Back about noon; bring snack and water.
Leader: Martha Saylor, 372-9215. Saturday, November 22
HIKE: FORT ORD PUBLIC LANDS
Saturday, November 15 There are so many places to visit in this federal
HIKE: WUNDERLICH COUNTY PARK open space; we’ll come up with something dif-
An 8-mile loop starting at the parking area off ferent to see. Estimate 8 miles with 1000' ele-
Woodside Rd. west of I-280. The hike will be in vation gain. Meet at 9:30 a.m. at the Mar Monte
the mountains behind the horse stables on the exit off Hwy. 1 on the way to Watsonville to
old Folger Coffee family estate. We’ll hike on carpool. Call Nick for more information.
the Bear Gulch, Alambique, Meadow, Red- Leader: Nick Wyckoff, 462-3101.
wood, and Madrone Trails in this 942-acre park
with a 1,000' elevation gain. This is one of the
most ecologically-diverse and beautiful parks
east of Skyline Boulevard, with cool groves of
2nd-growth redwoods, open grassy meadows
and nearly pure stands of Douglas fir. Along
the trail we’ll pass the “Lonely Redwood Giant
of the Alambique” and the “Salamander Flat,”
with its emerald reservoir—a popular hangout
for newts. Meet at the Santa Cruz County Gov-
ernment Center parking lot at 8:30 a.m., or at
Felton Fair at 8:50 a.m. Bring water, lunch and
$7 carpool. Leader: Ed Gilbert, 685-8389.
Please recycle this paper again The Sierra Club/Ventana Chapter, Volume 47, Number 5, 2008 17
O U T I N G S
at 9:30 a.m. sharp from the northwest corner from Rio Road Park & Ride. Call for a reser- Wednesday, December 10 to see Mother Nature’s fire management meth-
of Whole Foods parking lot in Monterey. Call vation. Leader: Lynn Bomberger, 375-7777. HIKE: CAPITOLA / APTOS BEACHES ods in this fire-prone area. 6 miles with 800' el-
for a reservation. Leader: Lynn Bomberger, Our beaches are beautiful and uncrowded in evation gain. If it’s closed, we’ll do something
375-7777. Wednesday, December 3 the winter. Starting at New Brighton Beach else, probably in the Bonny Doon area. Meet
HIKE: QUAIL HOLLOW RANCH will allow us to go both ways into Capitola at 9:30 a.m. at the Santa Cruz County Govern-
Saturday, November 29 This county park, once an Ohlone Indian along the bluffs past the butterfly trees and ment Center to carpool. Rain cancels. Call
HIKE: OLD COACH ROAD camp, was homesteaded by Joseph Kenville along the railroad track though Seacliff to the Nick for additional information. Leader: Nick
We’ll start on Crazy Horse Road, drive for a who sold his produce to the booming logging Esplanade in Aptos. We’ll walk back along the Wyckoff, 462-3101.
while on the Old Coast Road, and finally hike towns in the San Lorenzo Valley. We’ll start sand for about 1-1/2 miles if the tide permits,
or we can hike along the bluff. Bring lunch and Sunday, December 14
all the way over the hills and down to San Juan our 6-mile hike at the park center home that
water. 7 miles. To carpool ($1) meet at Sears HIKE: MOSS LANDING
Bautista. After lunch and exploring the Mission was built by the family that developed Sunset
and old town, back the same way. 12 miles and Magazine. The home has been preserved with 41st Ave. at 9:00 a.m. or at the parking lot at Fish Fry anyone? Let’s hike over to Phil’s at
1000' elevation gain. Bring hat, water, and '50s furnishings. The pond is habitat for frogs, the beach inside the park at 9:20 a.m. Leader: Moss Landing and back again. We’ll walk
lunch, or $ for a sit down in a cafe. Wear good and the sandhills home for rare plants. The Ital- Diane Cornell, 423-5925. north from the lot off Potrero Road along the
shoes; bring your hiking poles. Meet at Home ian Trail takes us up through chaparral. The beach to the “island,” and return by an inland
Depot in Seaside near the gas station at 8:30 Sunset Trail goes uphill to the Vista Point. Thursday, December 11 route. Meet at Home Depot in Seaside (near the
a.m. Heavy rain cancels. Leader: Anneliese Meet at Sears 41st Ave. at 9:00 a.m. to carpool HIKE: CARMEL TO PEBBLE BEACH gas station) at 10:00 a.m. Wear layers, bring
Suter, 624-1467. ($3) or at the park at 9:35 a.m. Bring water and This nice lollypop loop begins in Carmel and water, optional binoculars, and $$ for gas and
lunch. Leader: Diane Cornell, 423-5925. leads into the quiet forest of Pebble Beach. chow (or you could bring PB&J to eat on the
Saturday, November 29 Lunch gives us the option of a sandwich at beach). If coming from further north, meet us
HIKE: ELKHORN SLOUGH Saturday, December 6 Poppy Hills. 6-1/2 miles, 750' elevation gain, at the end of Potrero Road in Moss Landing by
A 5-1/2 mile hike, with minimal elevation HIKE: GARLAND PARK moderate pace with flora & fauna stops. Arrive 10:30 a.m. Leader: Mary Gale, 626-3565.
change, through California’s first National Es- We’ll hike up to the Mesa via Buckeye and Wa- early, leave at 10:00 a.m. sharp from the Rio
Road Park & Ride. Call for a reservation. Sunday, December 21
tuarine Research Reserve. We’ll venture to sev- terfall Trails on this 4-mile+ hike. We’ll come
Leader: Lynn Bomberger, 375-7777. HIKE: WADDELL CREEK, BIG BASIN
eral slough overlooks, the old dairy site, back via Fern, Mesa, and Lupine Loop trails.
Hummingbird Island, a eucalyptus grove, and Nice valley views; trails may be muddy. Meet Starting at Hwy. 1 we’ll hike the Skyline to the
oak woodlands. Along the way, we may see at Save Mart to carpool at 9:00 a.m., or if at Saturday, December 13 Sea trail and McCrary ridge to the Mt McAbee
Peregrine Falcons, Brown Pelicans, Red-tailed Garland Park, please call leader. Bring food and HIKE: GROVER GULCH / BATES CREEK overlook returning via the Howard King and
Hawks, Great and Snowy Egrets, and other water. Heavy rain cancels. Leader: Martha Say- A 6-mile loop beginning from the Land of the Skyline to the Sea Trails with a short side trip
wetland inhabitants. Meet at Sears 41st Avenue lor, 372-9215. Medicine Buddha. We’ll hike up through beau- to Berry Creek Falls. 12 miles; 1700' elevation
at 9:30 a.m. or at the reserve’s parking lot at tiful Grover Gulch, into the southwest corner gain. Dress in layers, bring lunch and plenty of
1700 Elkhorn Road. Bring water, lunch, $2.50 Saturday - Sunday, December 6 - 7 of Nisene Marks, and return along the ridge water. Meet at the Santa Cruz County Gov-
day-use fee, and $4 carpool. Leader: Ed Gilbert, CARRIZO PLAIN WORK PARTY/CARCAMP above Bates Creek. This moderate hike, with a ernment Center at 8:30 a.m. to carpool. Leader:
685-8389. Fencing built for ranches in what is now the 500' elevation gain, passes through second- John Howerton, 476-4253.
Carrizo Plain National Monument are deadly growth redwoods and allows views of many of
Sunday, November 30 the features of the Land of the Medicine Bud- Monday-Saturday, December 29 - January 3
to the beautiful pronghorn antelope that live
HIKE: SOBERANES CREEK/ROCKY RIDGE dha. Meet at Sears 41st Ave. at 9:30 a.m. Bring CARRIZO PLAIN WORK PARTY
there. Much progress has been made removing
5-mile loop with 1700' elevation gain. We’ll fol- this fencing, and it is making a difference. Join water, lunch, and $2 carpool. Leader: Ed Celebrate the end of one year and the begin-
low the Soberanes Creek Trail into a verdant us for the weekend as we remove more fencing Gilbert, 685-8389. ning of the next in one of our new national
redwood grove, then climb steeply to grassy to assist the pronghorn. Camp at Selby Camp- monuments. The Carrizo Plain near San Luis
knolls for great views at lunch. We’ll descend ground. Bring food, all your water, heavy Saturday, December 13 Obispo, is a vast grassland, home to pronghorn
Rocky Ridge with more fine views. Boots rec- leather work gloves, and camping gear for the HIKE: OLD COAST RD. TO BIG SUR antelope, tule elk, kit fox, and a wide variety of
ommended; hiking poles helpful. Bring water weekend. Potluck Sat. night. Rain cancels. For This unpaved road in Big Sur makes a lovely birds. A welcome hike Dec. 29, 3-1/2 days of
and lunch. Meet at Rio Road Park & Ride at more information, contact Leaders: Cal and long hike. It’s 11 miles up and down through service modifying barbed wire fencing, and a
9:00 a.m. to carpool. Call for reservation. Letty French, (e-mail preferred) lettyfrench@ fern-lined redwood canyons with views out to full day for hiking and exploring are planned.
Leader: DJ Goehring, 277-9908. gmail.com or cal.french@gmail.com, or 14140 the coast and inland to Pico Blanco. Car shut- Accommodations at Goodwin Ranch included.
Chimney Rock Road, Paso Robles, CA 93446, tle. Expect moderate to strenuous hills at a Limited to 12 participants, $30 covers five din-
DECEMBER (805-239-7338). leisurely pace. Bring lunch and water; meet at ners. For more information, contact leader:
Craig Deutsche, deutsche@earthlink.net, (310-
the Rio Road Park and Ride at 9:00 a.m. Bring
477-6670), or co-leader Melinda Goodwater,
Tuesday, December 2
HIKE: MITTELDORF/NATURE TRAIL
Our hike winds along Williams Creek through
Tuesday, December 9
HOLIDAY LUNCH
Our holiday lunch this year will
be either at Linwood’s at Cham-
R water and lunch. Rain cancels. Leaders: Cath
Farrant and Mary Dainton, 372 7427.
Saturday, December 13
mgoodwater@sbcglobal.net, (408-774-1257).

a lovely redwood forest where we’ll see what inade or Severino’s. Leader is working out HIKE: BONNY DOON PRESERVE
is said to be the County’s largest redwood. 6 menu options and prices. Flyers will be avail- This Fish and Game Preserve burned in a very
miles with little elevation gain. Bring water & able at hikes for sign ups. But, it will be big way this summer. Although now closed, I Happy
lunch. Arrive early, leave at 9:30 a.m. sharp great!!!!!!!!!! Leader: Pat Herzog, 458-9841. have been told by a F&G ranger that it will be
re-opened by December. It will be interesting New
Year!!
CLASSIFIEDS
Rates: $5 per line for Sierra Club members. Pay-
ment must accompany all ads. Make checks
payable to: Sierra Club. Approx. 35 characters
per line. Spaces and punctuation count as char-
acters. Typewritten or computer generated copy
only.
WHAT DO YOU HAUL IN A BIKE
TRAILER other than kids? Email the editor,
dfbulger@cruzio.com, and relate your experi-
ence. Include your city and telephone number.

18 The Sierra Club/Ventana Chapter, Volume 47, Number 5, 2008 Printed on recycled paper
Ventana Chapter
Mailing Address—The Ventana Chapter, P.O. Box 5667, Carmel, CA, 93921
Phone: 624-8032 (Santa Cruz Group Phone: 426-4453) Website: www.ventana.sierraclub.org

Chapter Executive Committee


Chapter Chair Rita Dalessio 16 Via Las Encinas Carmel Valley, CA 93924 659-7046
Treasurer Joel Weinstein 140 Carmel Riviera Dr. Carmel, CA 93923 625-5586
Other Members Julie Engell 15040 Charter Oak Blvd. Prunedale, CA 93907 633-8709
George Jammal 601 Manzanita Ave. Felton, CA 95018 706-4233
Beverly Bean 39 Calera Cyn Rd. Salinas, CA 93908 484-2451
Steve Zmak 3200 Crescent Ave. Marina, CA 93933 883-4459
Heather Zissler 615 Lobos Ave. #B Pac. Grove, CA 93950 541-337-7511
Nicole Charles 2936 Yorktown Court, Marina, CA 93933 (915) 381-1982
Admin Chair/Sec Mary Gale 25430 Telarana Way Carmel, CA 93923 626-3565
Coastal Chair
Conservation Committee
Co-chairs Gudrun Beck 23765 Spectacular Bid Monterey, CA 93940 655-8586
Gillian Taylor 52 La Rancheria Carmel Valley, CA 93924 659-0298
Local Wilderness Committee
Chair Mike Splain P.O. Box 66882, Scotts Valley, CA 95067 359-2489
Computer Database
Stephanie Kearns 740 30th Ave. #67 Santa Cruz, CA 95062 475-1308
NC/NRCC Reps George Jammal 601 Manzanita Ave. Felton, CA 95018 706-4233
Patricia Matejcek P.O. Box 2067 Santa Cruz, CA 95063 768-8187
Population Committee
Chair Harriet Mitteldorf 942 Coral Dr. Pebble Beach, CA 93953 373-3694
Political Chair Terry Hallock P.O. Box 22993 Carmel, CA 93922 915-0266
Sierra Club Council
Delegate George Jammal 601 Manzanita Ave. Felton, CA 95018 706-4233
Alternate Rita Dalessio 16 Via Las Encinas Carmel Valley, CA 93924 659-7046
Transportation Committee
Chair Neil Agron 26122 Carmel Knolls Dr. Carmel, CA 93923 624-3038
Outings Chair Anneliese Suter 9500 Center St. #53 Carmel, CA 93923 624-1467
Membership Chair Judy Karas, 60 Boronda Lane #7, Monterey, CA 93940, 372-5762
Ventana Editor Debbie Bulger 1603 King St. Santa Cruz, CA 95060 457-1036
Pajaro River Committee
Co-chairs Lois Robin 4701 Nova Dr. Santa Cruz, CA 95062 464-1184
JoAnn Baumgartner P.O. Box 1766 Watsonville, CA 95077 722-5556
Forestry Chair Jodi Frediani 1015 Smith Grade Santa Cruz, CA 95060 426-1697

Santa Cruz County Group of the Ventana Chapter


Group Office: 1001 Center St., Santa Cruz, next to Actorsʼ Theatre Website: www.ventana.sierraclub.org
Mailing Address: Sierra Club, Santa Cruz Group, P.O. Box 604, Santa Cruz, CA 95061-0604
Phone: 831-426-HIKE (426-4453), Fax: 831-426-LEAD (426-5323), email: scscrg@cruzio.com

Executive Committee
Chair Aldo Giacchino 1005 Pelton Ave. Santa Cruz, CA 95060 460-1538
VEGAN SHOES
Vice Chair Kevin Collins P.O. Box 722 Felton, CA 95018 335-4196
Secretary
Other members Kristen Raugust 454 Swanton Road Davenport, CA 95017 423-8566
Charles Paulden 415 Palisades Ave. Santa Cruz, CA 95062 462-3423
Paul Elerick 1960 Jennifer Dr. Aptos, CA 95003 688-2304
Dennis Davie P.O. Box 651 Capitola, CA 95010 427-2626
David Kossack P.O. Box 268 Davenport, CA 95017 427-3733
Patricia Matejcek P.O. Box 2067 Santa Cruz, CA 95063 768-8187
Treasurer Aldo Giacchino 1005 Pelton Ave. Santa Cruz, CA 95060 460-1538
Conservation Chair Patricia Matejcek P.O. Box 2067 Santa Cruz, CA 95063 761-3263
Forestry Chair Jodi Frediani 1015 Smith Grade Santa Cruz, CA 95060 426-1697
Outings Chair George Jammal 601 Manzanita Ave. Felton, CA 95018 706-4233
Transportation Chair
Paul Elerick 1960 Jennifer Dr. Aptos, CA 95003 688-2304
Political Chair Gary Lasky 2350 Felt Street Santa Cruz, CA 95062 476-5702
Coastal Chair Patricia Matejcek P.O. Box 2067 Santa Cruz, CA 95063 768-8187
Water Chair Ken Reiller 990 Hecker Pass Rd. Watsonville, CA 95076 728-4046

Please patronize our


advertisers
Let them know you have
Lynnelle Wing

seen their ad in MEETING SCHEDULE


Ventana Chaper (Monterey Co.) Santa Cruz Regional Group
The Ventana

Information: 624-8032 Information: 426-4453


Meeting Place: Sierra Club Office, 1001
Executive Committee: Center St., Santa Cruz, Suite 11.
Last Thursday of the month; Call for
meeting place & time. Executive Committee:
Wednesday, October 8 at 7:00 p.m.
Conservation Committee: Wednesday, November 12 at 7:00 p.m.
As needed. Wednesday, December 10 at 7:00 p.m.
For dates and times call 655-8586
Conservation Committee:
Call Conservation Chair for meeting
times and dates: 768-8187

Please recycle this paper again The Sierra Club/Ventana Chapter, Volume 47, Number 5, 2008 19
MAGAZINE OF THE VENTANA CHAPTER OF THE SIERRA CLUB

“We’re borrowing money


from China to buy oil from
the Persian Gulf to burn it
in ways that destroy the
planet. Every bit of that
has to change.”
—Al Gore
Ventana staff photo

Maturing sugar pine cones oozing a sugary resin, considered a delicacy to the native Americans. John Muir liked it better than maple syrup.

Explore, enjoy and protect the planet


www.ventana.sierraclub.org

Periodical Postage
Harbor seal

and at additional
Post Offices
Santa Cruz
Election

Paid at
inside
MAGAZINE OF THE VENTANA CHAPTER OF THE SIERRA CLUB

picks

Explore, enjoy and protect the planet


AUG - OCT
OUTINGS
Volume 47, Number 5, 2008

Santa Cruz, CA 95061-0604


P.O. Box 604
Sierra Club

Steve Zmak

You might also like