Professional Documents
Culture Documents
a = log2(b)
Solution.
(a). It is clear that a point (a, b) is on the graph of a function f
if and only if the point (b, a) is on the graph of its inverse
function g. What we need to clearly see is that (a, b) and (b,
a) reflect into one another through the line y = x. My favorite
way to see that is to draw the coordinate box for each point.
Its clear that each box reflects into the other (because horizontal line segments reflect into vertical line segments of the
same length) and so the two points have to follow.
exp&log graphs
10/6/2007
(c) As we reduce the base below 2 (trying plots for base 1.9,
1.8, 1.7, etc.) we see the two curves getting closer together
and we get an intersection for 1.4. Thus the graphs
y = 1.4x and y = log1.4(x)
intersect twice, at x close to 2 and just above 4. Of course
they intersect on the line y = x.
exp&log graphs
10/6/2007
Example 2. Below, find two boxes, each containing the graph of a function. The graph on the left belongs
to the function y = 2x on the interval [0, 5]. The graph on the right is defined on the interval [5, 30] but it
follows exactly the same curve in the sense that if one box was laid precisely over the other the curves
would coincide. Find the equation of the graph in the right-hand box.
Students find this problem hard, or at least perplexing, but it does not have to be if it is approached in a
careful, organized manner. The graphs are the same but the axes are altered. This alteration is of two flavours: a stretch (or compression) and a shift. A good idea is to do one of these at a time, and the one to
start with is the stretch. The width has gone from 5 to 25, a factor of 5, and the height has gone from 40
to 4, a factor of 1/10. So a good first step (to cut our teeth, so to speak) would be to find the equation of
the graph which simply multiplies the axes by 5 and 1/10. Thats the graph at the right below.
The x-axis is expanded by a factor of 5. That requires a multiplication of x by some factor k. Should k be 5
or 1/5? The answer is that k should be 1/5. The best way to see this is to be a bit abstract and call the
function on the left f(x). Then f, as an abstract function, is defined only on [0, 5], so when you write a formula for the graph on the right, do you want to have f(5x) or f(x/5)? The answer is clearly f(x/5) so that as
x runs from 0 to 25, x/5 runs from 0 to 5 and we can legitimately apply f. If we have used 5x, wed be in
trouble. Thus to expand the axis by a factor of 5, we have to multiply x by 1/5.
The same argument works for the y-axis. Here we have a dilation of the axis by a factor of so we multi x
x
ply y by 4. The new equation is 4 y = f which in this case is 4 y = 2 5 .
5
It remains to do the shift and this works in the same opposite way. We need to now add 5 to all the values on the x-axis and we do this by subtracting 5 from x. And we need to add 1 to all the values on the yaxis and we do this by subtracting 1 from y. We get the equation:
4( y 1) =
x 5
2 5 .
exp&log graphs
10/6/2007
(a) Some of these curves are increasing and some are decreasing. What r-values belong to each set and
why?
(b) There is a significant symmetry in the above diagram. Describe this as precisely as you can and explain why it works.
(c) Discuss the nature of the solution set of the equation
rx = x
For any fixed r > 0. That is, for any particular r, how many solutions, x, are there and where are they located? Im not asking you to find the solutions for any particular r, but to describe how they change as r
changes.
Note to the teacher on part (c). Some students might not have
handled a request quite like this before and will wonder
whats required. I expect the students to draw the graph y = x,
and ask how many intersections it has with the r-curve for
each r. A good answer will say that for any r < 1, there is a
unique solution, positive, less than 1, and increasing with r.
For r = 1, there is a unique solution x=1. For r > 1, there are
two solutions if r is not too big. As r increases, the smaller
solution increases and the larger solution decreases, until at
some transitional value r*, they fuse together in a burst of
flame and then die, so that for r > r*, there are no solutions.
Some students will use a graphing calculator to show that r* is
close to 1.45. In fact, as reported in Example 1 it turns out
that r* = e1/e. Thats a good problem for the calculus course.
exp&log graphs
10/6/2007
Problems
1. At the right is the graph
y = (4/3)x.
Using a construction on this graph make as good an estimate
as you can of:
(a) (4/3)3
(b) log4/3(3)
(c) A solution to the equation (4/3)x = log4/3(x) .
Work as carefully and neatly as you can. Use a sharp pencil
or pen and a ruler.
(a)
exp&log graphs
(b)
(c)
10/6/2007
6. Since 30 is halfway between 20 and 40, wouldnt you expect log30 to be halfway between log20 and log40? If not,
should it be bigger or smaller? I want you to make this argument graphically, but instead of using the graph y = log(x), I
want you to do it with the graph y=10x, a copy of which is
drawn at the right. Work carefully and neatly on the graph
(use a ruler!) and write full explanations.
exp&log graphs
10/6/2007