Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A NEWSLETTER FOR WATER FOR ASIAN CITIES PROGRAMME IN MADHYA PRADESH (INDIA)
Despite Willingness to Pay, Why the Urban Poor do not have access
to WATSAN Services
Until recently water supply and sanitation, almost throughout the world utility. Often poor have a substantial willingness to pay for water supply
were provided by large, state owned monopolies. The poor institutional as shown by what they pay private water vendor, yet a large number of
structures, weak organizations, poor governance, illegal connections, such households lack access to decent water supplies. There has been
lack of effective metering, high unaccounted-for-water, and political pressure to improve the efficiency of delivery services and ensure uni-
interference in day to day working of these utilities, however, led to dis- versal coverage of these services. Since the urban poor usually do not
mal performance by most of these utilities in providing quality services in live in a specific cluster, they may be spread over a number of geo-
almost all the developing countries despite huge amounts of money graphically scattered settlements or may be living as pavement dwellers
having been spent by the Governments in these countries in provisioning on road side, it is difficult to provide them these services through tar-
of these services. Available research studies confirm that public spend- geted water supply schemes without the fear of subsidy allocated for
ing on social services does not always translate to outcomes because them being not getting diverted to non-poor.
the delivery of public services is often weak and highly inefficient. The Their supply needs to be integrated with the municipal systems. These
poor has suffered inexplicably in the process, despite huge amounts of compulsions combined with the greater consumer awareness, techno-
subsidies having been provided to these utilities to make the services logical change, regulatory innovations and pressures from international
available to the poor. Many of the poor, in city after city, are not even organizations have led many of the developing countries to initiate insti-
connected to the networks. While some cities have tried to introduce low tutional reforms, including seeking private sector participation in differ-
connection charges for the poor, in fact poorly developed tertiary net- ent formats, in building the infrastructure and running of these utilities.
works and the existence of corruption has meant that the costs of getting
connected prevent many poor people from becoming customers of the Source: R.P.S. Malik, "Water and Poverty", Background Paper prepared for the World Bank Report on India's
Water Economy: Bracing for a Turbulent Future, 2005.
Page 2
OCTOBER 2005 VOLUME 1 ISSUES 12
cities include (a) Collection of preliminary information and updating of base maps; (b) Collection and analysis
of metering/pumping records from utilities; (c) Mapping of the transmission and distribution network in digital
format; (d) Flow measurement, network analysis and water balance estimation; and (e) Study of the existing
tariff structure including billing, pricing, and recovery structure.
Assessment of the cities highlights that most of the information on operational aspects is either unavailable or
is available as a crude estimate. Similarly data for financial assessment is either inadequate or in improper
format. The maps available for the GIS work are also not to scale in most of the cases and some of them were
not updated. Absence of most of the data on leakages and reliability of the basic data has been a major con-
cern in the calculations on water balance audit. The audit is therefore based on the best information available,
which tends to be a mixture of assumptions that shall need formal vetting by the officials of Municipal Corpora-
tion in due course. Observations from the site visits and assessments reveal the following key issues:
Leakage from pipeline
1. Metering of water flow: None of the cities have adequate provisions for monitoring water flow either in
the transmission mains or distribution mains or at consumer end. Accordingly locations for installation of
bulk meters and district-metering areas (DMA) are being proposed for each of the cities.
2. Energy audit: Expenditure on energy consumption for operation of pumps and water treatment process
accounts for a high percentage of the overall expenditure. Realizing the huge potential to improve en-
ergy efficiency of the system, energy audit of the facilities is being proposed.
3. Planned maintenance: Financial assessments of the cities reveal that a very small percentage of total
expenditure is going towards maintenance activities. There is an urgent need to establish procedures for
planned maintenance with adequate resources allocated to this activity. Infrastructure replacement also
needs to be planned in advance.
4. Tariff and Revenue collection: It is not possible to realize the expenditure incurred on water supply
provisions at the current levels of water tariff and collection efficiency. Recommendation for revision in
tariff rate and improving revenue collection are being made which are expected to be discussed during A suitable locations for measuring flow
the stakeholder consultation process.
5. Institutional reforms: As expenses on establishment account for a very high percentage of the overall
expenditure, there is a need to utilize the manpower resources optimally.
6. Consumer awareness: It is necessary to build consumer awareness on water use and conservation
and build a consensus on reforms. An implementation action plan for this strategy is being formulated
accordingly.
7. Management Information Systems (MIS): The level of information available currently and its quality
calls for developing a comprehensive MIS that covers all aspects of water management.
Based on the assessment, WDM strategy and implementation plan are being developed and recommended
for individual cities. Time frame and activity plan for implementation of WDM strategies is being suggested. As
part of planned activities, feedback shall be obtained on the analyzed information and proposed implementa-
tion plan in each of the cities. Capacity building exercises shall also be undertaken for different functionaries of Flow monitoring at treatment plant in Bhopal
the Municipal Corporation on diverse subjects of WDM. Course content for capacity building of the decision
makers shall include introduction to principles of financial management; project formulation and appraisal; use
of latest tools for decision making such as GIS and water balance model; management control using MIS and
sharing of national and international best practices in efficient delivery of services.
Page 3
WATER FOR ASIAN CITIES PROGRAMME IN INDIA
Editorial Team
UN-HABITAT
Editorial Board Gopal Reddy, Secretary, UADD, State Govt. of M.P EP-16/17, Chandragupta Marg, Chanakyapuri
Savitur Prasad, Director, Govt. of India New Delhi - 110021 (India), Tel: +91-11-24104970 - 73
Fax: +91-11-24104961, Email: Wac.India@unhabitat.org
S.N. Mishra, Project Director, UWSEIP, Bhopal
Debashish Bhattacharjee, ADB, India Resident Mission
WAC Programme Project Office
Aniruddhe Mukerjee, CTA, UN-HABITAT, Bhopal E-1/191, Arera Colony, Bhopal - 462016
Tel: +91-755-2460836-37, Fax: +91-755-2460835
Editor Kulwant Singh, CTA, UN-HABITAT, New Delhi
Page 4