O/TAXAP/1182/2007

JUDGMENT

IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD

TAX APPEAL NO. 1182 of 2007

FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:

HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE KS JHAVERI

Sd/-

and
HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE G.R.UDHWANI

Sd/-

================================================================






 




















 







!

!"



 

#



$





================================================================

AVI POLYMERS LIMITED....Appellant(s)

Versus
THE ASST. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, CIRCLE 1....Opponent(s)
================================================================

Appearance:
MR BD KARIA with MR DARSHAN PATEL for MR RK PATEL, ADVOCATE for
the Appellant(s) No. 1
MRS MAUNA M BHATT, ADVOCATE for the Opponent(s) No. 1
================================================================

#%&'(

 


 



 


Date : 14/07/2016

Page
of 
HC-NIC

Page 1 of 6

Created On Thu Jul 21 15:53:28 IST 2016

O/TAXAP/1182/2007

JUDGMENT

ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER : HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE KS JHAVERI)



 
 

   

            

    

      !      "    
#$%
&'()'*++%*,**++- 
.  / "  
  0 
*

  

 1  

  23

 


 

  


 


  
 
  
 

 

 




 !"#$

 

 



%




%





&& 

 
 



 
 


' %

&


& 
 
( 


)*
%

4)5    .      



        .       6    

 .
    /  

 "              

  0     1
       6
        (            
   
  
.
    . 
 
  6  (  
      .  
/ 

 "23
7

0    .              

    .

Page  of 
HC-NIC

Page 2 of 6

Created On Thu Jul 21 15:53:28 IST 2016

O/TAXAP/1182/2007

JUDGMENT

   . 8

 



     

  
  0   
  
     
  
                   


     

    6


 
               8 


  . 

8   8
             
    6
      6              
   9 $$*:%%7'3 8  
       
       1           

.

 
    .    
     6  
                 
    
0 9 $$*:%%7'3 

%

45  .. 

    1  .             /

   

# 
-    **:   *++
  

*7'

'*++$
$

0. 



 6   0


             .          

  1. 

Page  of 
HC-NIC

Page 3 of 6

Created On Thu Jul 21 15:53:28 IST 2016

O/TAXAP/1182/2007

JUDGMENT

 / " 8   

   
           6    
4 6  

            3
   
   
6
 
1. 6 9 
&::*,+  

6 #.;)<= 

6  &$$++
 
6 
*$%,+6  
$::,+  6  .    9 %- 
  6    6    
9 
&::*,+  >              
    
          /  "      
?  
  
   .  6
       

            

  
 . 6    
.    .6
    0     1      
      

 


7

>.  

 >.

 

8
>. 
 8

    .      

  >    



 # 
-    **:   *++
    /     .   

23

+ 

 
( 
&& 


& 


 



 
( 



&& 
 

 




( 






, 


 


 

        

Page  of 
HC-NIC

Page 4 of 6

Created On Thu Jul 21 15:53:28 IST 2016

O/TAXAP/1182/2007

JUDGMENT

    !  "## 

 

&  

& $

 

 

 -


. 

, 
 

(


 
 



 

/

  




,& 
.
01


 2




3
 2
.
4
  
 



 



& 



 



& 


 


 


#







& (



50


.
( 


%


( 

& (


50
.


.



 

/

62

7.



%


 





 & 

 

(


62
.
& 



& 
8  
""

9
""

 

 



62
(
.
 
 


62
9& 


 
 



%


%
 
2
 
&


%




 
  






 
 :
2&



 & 





( 

 

3



 





  
 





 
 
 



 %
 


& &

( 

 

 
 


 

 

 
&& 




 


%



%





 
 


 %

 
3


& &



 

; 


 %
& 

 
 

 


%
 
 

 

( 


%

 %

 
   

2&  



& &

( 




; 



 

  


 



  
0

 
( 
&& 


&




&

&

 
3
 
(


  





&
 

&& 
 (





;

 

 (




 


(

 
&



 2
.&& 
& 



3
 2
.&& 
  

; 




'

&& 

*


-

   
       
   .         

     1  .                 /

Page  of 
HC-NIC

Page 5 of 6

Created On Thu Jul 21 15:53:28 IST 2016

O/TAXAP/1182/2007

JUDGMENT



# 
-**: *++
1 

 
              .          
 .  

     9 
&::*,+'3       

 6 6   


   

6
 
 . 

 

 
Sd/(K.S.JHAVERI, J.)

Sd/(G.R.UDHWANI, J.)
*malek

Page  of 
HC-NIC

Page 6 of 6

Created On Thu Jul 21 15:53:28 IST 2016