Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Professor Nozawa
Introduction to Language and Culture
Wednesday the 8th of May 2013
We Interrupted a Variety Show and Are Receiving Death Threats:
Meditations on the Language and Culture of the Dartmouth Nation
Picture: the College on the Hill, surrounded by charming New
Hampshire woods with trees just budding, swarming with hoards of
prospective students deciding whether to matriculate next year, and
buzzing with an undercurrent of discontent. This is Dimensions of
Dartmouth weekend 2013, Dartmouth Colleges chance to convince
admitted students as of yet undecided on attendance that Dartmouth
is where they want to spend their next four or five years, and
potentially hundreds of thousands of dollars. Let us not forget that
Dartmouth is a business, indeed, the first official corporation in
America (Trustees of Dartmouth College v. Woodward). The key
components of business include product, consumer, shareholder (in
some cases this may be owner), and sale. In the specific case of
Dartmouth College, a non-profit organisation, though not a nonrevenue one, these components are tricky to identify. Is the product an
education for consumer-students provided by the owner-trustees? Or is
the product a degree, a coupon-to-the-good-life, a fast-track to Wall
Street? Are students the consumers of education or the products?
What is Wall Street, with its significant recruiting investments, and the
U.S. government, with its significant financial aid investments,
hold truth, that we assess language on its truth-value, and that this in
some way indicates the value of the speaker.
Furthermore, the hashtag at the beginning of the name places
the movement into a context of grouped thoughts. The hashtag, as
defined by Twitter, is used to mark keywords or topics in a Tweet. It
was created organically by Twitter users as a way to categorize
messages. In computer science languages, hashtags can have an
array of different purposes, but the current social use is highly related
to the Twitter definition. Hashtags group thoughts and track trends.
Thus, the hashtag in #Realtalk groups #Realtalk into some larger
movement; a contemporary, internet-age movement; a tweet-worthy,
real-time, grassroots movement. This kind of a-spatial, internetinspired grouping allows the formation of an imagined community
divergent from space but thoroughly rooted in time; this is an internet
update on Benedict Andersons nationalist newspapers. In fact, even
within the #Realtalk movement at Dartmouth, the diffusion implicated
in the hashtag, in fact ironically due to its grouping function, intimates
that many kinds of people can be involved. This hashtag implies that
one can be from any space, but only from this time; this is a movement
of college students in the second decade of the twenty-first century.
Throughout the week leading up to the disruption, #Realtalk
posted flyers and chalk across campus advertising for a poetry and
discussion event that would take place on Friday before the dimensions
show. This poetry and discussion event was to be the site of real talk,
itself already a disruption of the rewarded message: love for
Dartmouth and overall happiness. Throughout the week, these posters
and this chalk were removed from public spaces: advertising disrupting
the Dartmouth advertising was removed. While the poetry and
discussion event went ahead, it did not cause the significant
(socio)economic disruption the #Realtalk movement had been hoping
for: it didnt threaten Dartmouths prestige.
However, disrupting the main site of advertisement offered the
opportunity to threaten this prestige. Entering the Class of 53
Commons chanting Dartmouth has a problem as well as statistics
surrounding sexual assault as well as bias incident reports, a group of
protestors confronted a group of performers, at which point performers
and prospective students began chanting we love Dartmouth. The
clashing of these two phrases indicates the economic interest each
furthers. Upholding the image of a beloved Dartmouth directly leads to
greater revenue on the part of Dartmouth College, the trustees, and
often graduates. Criticising the supposed perfection of Dartmouth
disrupts all of these avenues, endangering federal funding (especially
for research) as well as the value and marketability of a Dartmouth
degree. The face-off of these phrases demonstrates linguistic ideology
at play: the performers show an adherence to the idea of language as
truth-statements if they can assert that it is true that they love
Appendix I
door, in the process tripping over the leg of the frat guy,
according to an anonymous protestor, who also emphasises that
the student who had been stuck in the door is very physically
small. A different protestor says that this administrator tripped
over his own leg, detailing, people have been saying we
assaulted but that's not true at all.
The next layer of security includes Tim Duggan, a tall
college employee, who stood in a football stance like ready to
tackle, according to one protestor, thinking this was a joke until
when another protestor walks up, he literally wrestles her I
cant believe he just leaped on her! Not having expected
physical violence, the students are shocked and intimidated.
The third layer of security includes the participants in the
Dimensions Show, some of whom are crying and begging the
protestors not to disrupt the show on the basis that it will ruin
their life, asking why are you doing this to me? One student
mentions that she was holding a sign saying I was called a fag
in my freshman floor as well as notes that the performers saw
through the glass doors these protestors being subjected to
physical violence.
As performers try to chant protestors out, the protestors
begin chanting from their script. Performers then attempt to sing
over the chants of the protestors, meaning that the original plan
of chanting from the back between songs is no longer viable. The
protestors are forced to go in front in order to convey their
message instead of being silenced yet again. After physical
harassment and a forced change of plans, protestors are
bewildered and find it difficult to remain calm.
One activists comments, people keep saying they should
have been more organised; they should have been these
different things. But honestly, the people who were part of that
protest are some of the most eloquent, brilliant, well-spoken
people I know ______ is a fucking actor. He is prepared for this,
and he is so freaked out that he couldnt finish Why would we
have been able to be completely calm?
Students are screaming at us, This is not a dialogue!
Youre doing it wrong! Youre doing it wrong! All previous
attempts at dialogue had been silenced.
After creating this disturbance of the theatre that is
Dartmouth, the protestors decide to walk out, having
accomplished all that they think they can given the situation.
Dimensions performers, as they walk out, in a monotone begin
chanting, We love Dartmouth. Protestors trying to draw
attention to their own personal experiences of being silenced and
oppressed on the basis of race, gender, sex, sexuality, and