Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ll'OSiti 3m
Sccd ol l
25
23
I rand
31.
48el:ual Attrtbutco or e
32
Lw
to
A Consc!ou Fo==IIulation
3.Generality
C. thOrttauve
Enforcclnent
a41 0'ED O
ll
A. lail.41annc Brand
B Vl nna
177
LECALP03m3
ffiir
dm%R
h,...r
1dlttW
t
l=
orI
on the
callFornla,produced
Sden" t tte un:"
M3t perepect
analytlcal or p
Ju
rk
Posrllrst
LE iAI Pllltns('t'tlY
l?8
3t.
o,'ult
Corcurr
Q!;lLw xor nressiuurv A Monrrt'
The ldca of the telcologlsts that thc norms of moral
of lhe
as tried by the. tcet of uulrty or by ony
ol
oplnlons
the
dlvlde
ch
test3 wl
varlous
mankttrd lt has no
hmedlst' concem'r
It
kcm thi
179
wlth thc
h:nst,t:r'rtvc
lr
to.
SptcuL,rno s
;;[JEi;a
temr,
lllvlcr'
U41MMmL
frt4l
L,
28. HOBBEII.AUATIN
CONCEPT
juat and unjust carr lake place, there urrtsl t:c $cine
i*rctye
powff lo
.ompd
'.
/
none beforc the creatlon o[ thc comlnonwenllh.'
Hobbcs, then, postted the ldea that lt ls lmprobable for
any statutc io be unjust. lle explalned that'law$ are
icputed
thi rules of Juat arld trluust' notlllng bcillg'lhtrs,
for
unjust that ie ttot contrary lo somc law.'E
Thlmas Hobbca, the'Edrerelg,n . . ts not subJect to
the taws for havlng thc power to make and repeal laws'
hc may. when hc pleases. free hhself from thelr
subjcclon.{ Stresslng '.he poht furthcr. Thomas
Hobbce stated that'to the carc olthe loverclr,n bclong!
the rrlaklng of good lanr6.'lo By 'good' laws Hobbcs
mcant not llust' laws for laws cannot bG unJult alnce
tlrcyarc rnatie by tlre tiortrclgn power. Hobbca concluded
thai 'au that lJ done by such power ls warranted and
TLnt rul, H^rr^x'cl^tAEr.87. P,f. colltsr
cDa. tae.
eDu., tso.
lood.. lgt.
&
llisrnvtsr l'r.t{sPu(
rtvE
sonr, NaPYorh.
Edlllon.
l_B
.P.Putnem a Son3.New Y rk
2:' b
a8
l,r.r i^t.
t,32
Illtlirsr r.try
27, LDOI&
POSITIYTSM
r*,acro?Jui!.trrlgDrlrlt.iro.
11au'.ztt.
l6Du.. szt.
26.
lLrl
Thus.
,E,
3Arrrr,,.r,, th"
183
ltrrdsr,D(1rvr
Posntyrr
l-lriltt- Ptlltrrstll'llY
l.(.1
i:l
ffiil;;;ii; '"
H"fi *Hi:i;.;lh,m:m*t,:.#.ff"fxllHi
law.
Professo--r
Orrr srrch,UUrn,",r",'t,rrrtt l)twcen
o' w'
Gethard
,o"rJ#li v."i ,,tr"''ttr and l"(li'ssor
ili'"ii"t ,t,it " rit*i's or thc ' '('rrnrrrt"'J,f#rgffiS
lffii:[':Fr;l,,&
H:'t,'ii!l:fli.,riifi
Prolcalrrtelv-' r'roli"ssor lutcornacir'
i;ilR;;r.'6i;"il;l,;i*u1,fi :8.:;#,'#ils'iltr*5J1x
Revi6r,.
made to ttorl6lt
Tlltlt . cer[^tlr sltldles lvrve been
o[ the lav' rhc
trature
rhc
tl-iu.i';;tcepi oftorm
posltlvc lar'
'pure
thc
of
taken'ure
thclrY.
;;rfi;';;
".
A' L^us
BR t{D
'{t{r
lauaannc'
Ern8t Roeutn of ttE thlverslty o[
rr r{qllr
n , tlte Rr**rrr.olvdrc Jut:r!cn''
-1E""1.r,,.r,
ff]r*r
; J"mif if:r*lffi
}##iT
ffi?
jil
b- *- lry:
"r
"*-,t}'l.'',kffi H'#.H"'
18['
ir.*rrr.." if
B'
YlEtrr{. Bn
to
3lt(a at. H., ttr. O*or1lr a ler rrD ltnirt, !' Hlrtrtd
UnlvrfrltY PEr.. crnbn ltc'
2lt*earr, H.. q. cf.. rv.
tilt&L.n, H., on lrE Eorb t{a'lr '17 cdlhmb law Rlvtcw'
M,zla.
l'ostrrrrst Pt.tsltc
lvt:
l8Z
Jar.r'orr the
olher. 'ltlls
Is
hc poslts thc ldea that thc couc"pt of law lurs rro nroral
(t)
hl
188
PosrrMsr
hrRst+:rrrvE
l8S
Attct n,n,
fr4rar C atuP.r,r
PIfl,lfr,ri},,.271.
zth.sr.
H..
o. ct.
mttctcn, ff , f.yfra rr
rdlcrx. ,6e.
6.
fuF,t,rilwu {t
ourZ 3a
Tulan.l..v
\ 'sttivtst f't:tr:,tt:r
190
i.s,
to the
32Drt.
og.
2lo. Unl'
n'!:
l9l
en.H.
Re w.269270
:
`
nJrLa
34
ancc W
l f(;^l' [\tll,r)s('l'llY
192
oeoDlc Dav taxes on
*rrtarn"nitt
another should'sta(cnretrt (becnrlse thc
sol but by "a'ouse
ocoole shluld obey the tegal nornr)'34 There ls a
dtlTirent luettllcatlon for actlon, nantely. a corlsclenuous deslre to dtschargc an obllgatlon wlthotlt atry
lhouSht of Seitlng, away wtth anything'
Thus. tn thc normatlve legal order. theJusslveness
of a legal norm ts not only presewed but lts ftlnctlons
c'Ifomh law
Rtvlcrx'
Posmu$
Plxst+:(:tlvt
I03
p"rt
"t tir.
Ehoutd obs"rve
Obvlously, thl! concept of a hlerarchy of noncontradlctory norrns crcatc the condltlons ofp?acl nnd
ordcr. Bchavtor wtuch adverscly allcctc thcse condt'
ttoru ar e dealt wlth by the force ofa polltlcally organlzcd
socfety. lf lndlvlduab wcre ablc to do the very thlngs
that ere not prcacrtbcd. authorlzed. or prrnltted by the
ra
10
Jn
d ttIOS9h
194
l,ri(;Ar,
Il
xu
's(r'r
rY
Pr:srrrvrsr
[\:trsl,t](rtvt:
lg5
to e
/rs.
w14a
"I
"andAnal
: :Jt17Sp"
41
.".J.
DmiulNEO,91:
l"
196
}I)^r, [itlrrsr]lllY
one ft)r the rrztson tllal wllhln one natlon only one arld
not two comprlltng orders can be valld at thc same
nme.,)P
/n,
gIrPEBroR
11
thc
the uprooung type
tire f,iXts
llowevcr.the
rcvoluuonary
revolut`onary r Pon
response t" not eastly nrwoked, lt can cven be sUncd
dependtng on the people themselves., It artse$ ol yln
a itttratton of speclal dtfilculty for thc people whlch
too'close elther.
, 1
U.nllr.
-- '.lnc.,
lggttl,Itiotd
hw Thd!
.umtt R"
o/ taur.
5l law Ouutrrly
s
L
`O COmmumy h
FhlrpfltPr, 32 *RA227.
lrsrnv,sr l't:t.st,E(
ltvr;
lg7
Itrt erccsscs ilr tllc cxcr( lsc l)y the Aoverntnenl ol lllc
lxrwers (l('lcg:rle(l to ll. ltul il)(. use of this tylx' ol
r(.sponsc is dcpelrdcnt rrlxIr tlrc trrt(|nslly oI tllc
governnrcntal clnllcnge lts.l[.
When the challenge ls mirrlm l tllcrc ls no
rcsponsc Jusl fls there catr be no response anyrr)ore
when thc govemmental challenge has reachcd tts
maxlmum tntenslty. ln the former $ltrratton, lhe
govcmrncnlirl chnllenge ls ncgllglble ns to nrake any
tlnFression on the ;rcoplc cnou(h Lo oxcllc or arorrg(
tlrclr collcctlve sensc of anllpathy. Tllcre ts. lnd.(d.
re$traint ln externallzlng the rractlon of lhe tx'ople. ln
the latter sltuallon. (hc cll llenge has :rsrsurned srrch
trclnendolls proportlons th t thecapacltyof tlre people
to rrxporrd has bcrn stlllu.l. In thls evctrt, only wltlr
oulslde asslstonce or IntcF/er,tlon miry thc .vtll rrc!
power to r6lst be regrlncd. But when tire govcrn.
mrrrtal chnllenge ls at lls {rpllmunl hltcnslly the pt'ople
mcy act elfcctlvely, unless they allow thc qovern.
mcntal challcngc to pru'eed unlnrpe(l('(l t(r lLs rnaxlmum tnlenslty.
Thc challenge of the govemrnent t8 deltbcratcly
amblgu0ue, that 18 to sey cqutvocal and euphemBuc.
There B o hard and fast nrlt that can be lald down wlth
wtrlch to mcaaure the tntenslty ol Ute challenge of the
govcrnme,nt, However, there are some gutdtng factoE.
Thc evaluatlon of the govtmmental challenge lo a
rrutter that addresges ltoelf to thc conaclalcc of the
people. The revolutlonary response depends, lh.n, on
thc combhatlon of thc condttlons produchg or promlslng to produce the bcst average recult of success for
lhe people.
The response to the challenge of the goverrrment
cannot be applled by a rntnortty. That would plalnly be
l,lr;Al.
:1)8
l)t tIr\q(tl'rtY
4.fu ,rlo,,r,,"
ri,kMur'Aitr.tn
I'osn Ntrir
h:x.sr,!x:tt|r
199
RAlr
,\
4l A^'u"nn'tur: lllrtrtlr< t:vt;wr
a.s a ild or tromt tracketl l)y lhe iluthorlty of the
(
2OO
'illc
firtrtre.
l,r
201
/Thts proccea has bcen crtuclzed as a very torrntdeblc task. But thts ls nelther a logtcal nor pcrsuaslve
reason for not dolng so. Aa a rnatter of fact. tt baa
un
6!P.j !,} .
!vn cr"w
. H"n
,B Pll:
/pl t 1
w.148.Ynle
CHAly ER
tv
Labcls
34.
BackgOund o
35
L gal
Theory
Recogrution o
he intorests or ttctcty
37.
38.
39.
Fttnction i Concept o
40
41.
42.
Lw
rests
A Fxm L I
Factor8
B.ncs oFinterestB
C.MCan3 0rSCCunng Prtvate lnterest8
D.Mearl oF Securlng Pubuc hter t3
tegones or sOclal:nterests
A Sodal hterest m the cenem: cuJty
B.Soctal interest in the Maintenance and
Protectlon o sOclallnsutuu
(1,Domeouc lnstltuuon
t21 Rdi"u Instttution
13)Poutlel:neututl
O Econon c lnsutuuon
"