Professional Documents
Culture Documents
NPRCETNPRCETNPRCETNPRCET
NPRCETNPRCETNPRCETNPRCET
NPRCETNPRCETNPRCETNPRCET
NPRCETNPRCETNPRCETNPRCET
NPRCETNPRCETNPRCETNPRCET
MARKETING MANAGEMENT
NPRCETNPRCETNPRCETNPRCET
BA7203
NPRCETNPRCETNPRCETNPRCET
2013 REGULATION
NPRCETNPRCETNPRCETNPRCET
DEPARTMENT OF MANAGEMENT STUDIES
NPRCETNPRCETNPRCETNPRCET
NPRCETNPRCETNPRCETNPRCET
NPRCETNPRCETNPRCETNPRCET
NPRCETNPRCETNPRCETNPRCET
NPRCETNPRCETNPRCETNPRCET
NPRCETNPRCETNPRCETNPRCET
NPRCETNPRCETNPRCETNPRCET
NPRCETNPRCETNPRCETNPRCET
BA7203
MARKETING MANAGEMENT
LT P C 4 0 0 4
COURSE OBJECTIVE:
To understand the changing business environment
To identify the indicators of management thoughts and practices
to understand fundamental premise underlying market driven strategies
COURSE OUT COME:
knowledge of analytical skills in solving marketing related problems
awareness of marketing management process
UNIT I INTRODUCTION 12
Marketing Definitions - Conceptual frame work Marketing environment :
Internal and External - Marketing interface with other functional areas
Production, Finance, Human Relations Management, Information System.
Marketing in global environment Prospects and Challenges.
UNIT II MARKETING STRATEGY 12
Marketing strategy formulations Key Drivers of Marketing Strategies Strategies for Industrial Marketing Consumer Marketing Services marketing
Competitor analysis - Analysis of consumer and industrial markets Strategic
Marketing Mix components.
UNIT III MARKETING MIX DECISIONS 12
Product planning and development Product life cycle New product
Development and
Management Market Segmentation Targeting and Positioning Channel
Management
Advertising and sales promotions Pricing Objectives, Policies and methods.
UNIT IV BUYER BEHAVIOUR 12
Understanding industrial and individual buyer behavior - Influencing factors
Buyer Behaviour Models Online buyer behaviour - Building and measuring
customer satisfaction Customer relationships management Customer
acquisition, Retaining, Defection.
UNIT V MARKETING RESEARCH & TRENDS IN MARKETING 12
Marketing Information System Research Process Concepts and applications :
Product
Advertising Promotion Consumer Behaviour Retail research Customer
driven
organizations - Cause related marketing - Ethics in marketing Online marketing
trends.
TOTAL: 60 PERIODS
TEXT BOOKS
1. Philip Kortler and Kevin Lane Keller, Marketing Management, PHI 14th Edition,
2012
2. KS Chandrasekar, Marketing management-Text and Cases, Tata
McGrawHill-Vijaynicole, First edition,2010
3. Paul Baines, Chris Fill and Kelly Page, Marketing, Oxford University Press,
2nd Edition,2011.
REFERENCES
1. Micheal R.Czinkota & Masaaki Kotabe, Marketing Management, Vikas
Thomson Learning, 2000.
2. Duglas,J.Darymple, Marketing Management, John Wiley & Sons, 2008.
3. NAG, Marketing successfully- A Professional Perspective, Macmillan 2008.
4. Boyd Walker, Marketing Management, McGraw Hill, 2002.
5 Paul Baines, Chriss Fill Kelly Pagb, Marketing, II edition, Asian edition.
1. INTRODUCTION:
The apex body in United States of America for the Marketing functions,
American Marketing Association (AMA) defines marketing as Marketing consists of
those activities involved in the flow of goods and services from the point of production to
the point of consumption". The AMA has since amended its definition to read as:
Marketing is an organizational function and a set of processes for creating,
communicating, and delivering value to customers and for managing customer
relationships in ways that benefit the organization and its stakeholders."
Hence it can be surmised that marketing is basically meeting unmet needs for
target markets, identifying those unmet needs and planning how to meet them through
products, services, and ideas. Communicating the value to them along with pricing
which is affordable and profitable and also distributing the products so that customers
have appropriate accessibility and have quick and easy delivery. Marketing is thus the
process of planning and executing the conception, pricing, promotion, and distribution
of ideas, goods and services to create exchanges (with customers) that satisfy individual
and organizational objectives.
2. LEARNING OBJECTIVES:
After reading the unit, you will understand how:
3. MARKETING MANAGEMENT:
Marketing has evolved into a very important functional area in management
basically due to the increasing supply and lower demand over the years. This is primarily
through the competitive intensity in every sphere of the market. When competition
increases, as you know, every firm wants to be heard in the market. This will make the
firms to be different than the competitors. Hence marketing becomes a very important
functional area for every firm where the competition is very high.
In a business firm, marketing generates the revenues that are managed by financial people
and used by the productions people in creating products or services. The challenge of
marketing is to generate that revenue by satisfying consumers wants at a profit and in a
socially responsible manner. Marketing is not limited to business. Whenever you try to
persuade somebody to do something you are engaging in marketing. Thus marketing has
a broad societal meaning. In fact, the societal view is more truly descriptive of marketing
today. Moreover, modern business marketing activities are to a large extent, a
consequence of the societal view of marketing.
The essence of marketing is a transaction, an exchange intended to satisfy human needs
or wants. Consequently, marketing occurs any time on societal limit strive to exchange
something of value with another social unit. Marketing consists of all the activities to
facilitate the exchange.
Within this societal perspective, then (1) the makers (2) what they are marketing and (3)
their potential markets all assume broad dimensions. The category of marketers might
include, in addition to business firms, such diverse social units as (a) a political party
trying to market its candidate to the public (b) the director of an art museum providing
new exhibits to generate greater attendance and financial support (c) a labor union
marketing its idea to members and to company management; and (d) professors trying to
make their courses interesting for students.
In addition to the range of items normally considered as products and services, what is
being marketed might include (a) ideas such as reducing air pollution or contributing to
the red cross (b) people, such as new football coach or a political candidate and (c)
places, such as industrial plant sites or a place to for a vocation.
In a broad sense markets include more than the direct consumers of products services and
ideas. Thus a state universitys market includes the legislators who provide funds, the
citizens living near the university who may be affected by university activities and the
alumni. A business firms market may include government regulatory agencies,
environmentalists, and local tax assessors.
Definition of Marketing
As you already know there are many definitions for marketing. Some definitions focus on
marketing as the process involved in satisfying the needs of a particular market, while
other definitions lean more toward defining marketing in terms of its most visible
functional areas, such as advertising and product development. There probably is no one
best way to define marketing, though whatever definition is used should have an
orientation that focuses on satisfying customers. Therefore, we will define marketing as
follows:
Marketing consists of the strategies and tactics used to identify, create and maintain
satisfying relationships with customers that result in value for both the customer and the
marketer.
Let's examine this definition in a little more detail by focusing on a few of the key terms.
Strategies and Tactics - Strategies are best explained as the direction the marketing effort
will take over some period of time, while tactics are actionable steps or decisions made in
order to follow the strategies established. For instance, if a strategy is to enter a new
market, the tactics may involve the marketing decisions made to carry this out.
Performing strategic and tactical planning activities in advance of taking action is
considered critical for long-term marketing success.
Identify - Arguably the most important marketing function involves efforts needed to
gain knowledge of customers, competitors, and markets. We will see throughout this
course material how marketing research is utilized in all decision areas.
Create - Competition forces marketers to be creative people. When marketers begin new
ventures, such as building a new company, it is often based around something that is new
(e.g., new product, new way to distribute a product, new advertising approach, etc.). But
once the new venture is launched innovation does not end. Competitive pressure is
continually felt by the marketer, who must respond by devising new strategies and tactics
that help the organization remain successful.
Maintain - Today's marketers work hard to insure their customers return to purchase from
them again. Long gone (see History below) are the days when success for a marketer was
measured simply in how many sales they made each day. Now, in most marketing
situations, marketing success is evaluated not only in terms of sales figures but also by
how long a marketer can retain good customers. Consequently, marketers' efforts to
attract customers does not end when a customer makes a purchase. It continues in various
ways for, hopefully, a long time after the initial purchase.
Satisfying Relationships - A key objective of marketing is to provide products and
services that customers really want AND to make customers feel their contact with the
marketer is helping to build a good relationship between the two. In this way the
customer is made to feel as if she/he is a partner in the transaction not just a source of
revenue for the marketer. In recent years this has lead to the concept of Customer
Relationship Management (CRM), which has emerged as a strategic approach that
insures that everyone in an organization, not just the marketer, understands the
importance of customers. Maintaining close and consistent relationships with customers
through all points of customer contact is crucial but difficult to do well. We'll see in later
sections technology plays a key role in carrying out CRM, so that nearly anyone in a
organization that comes into contact with a customer (e.g., sales force, service force,
customer service representatives, accounts receivable, etc.) has the necessary information
and is well prepared to deal with the customer.
Value for Both Customer and Marketer - Value refers to the perception of benefits
received for what someone must give up. For customers value is most often measured by
how much they feel they are getting for their money, though the value one customer feels
she/he obtains may differ from the perception of value from another customer even
though they purchase the same product. On the other side of the transaction, the marketer
may measure value in terms of how much profit they are making for the marketing efforts
and resources expended. For a successful marketing effort to take place both the customer
and the marketer must feel they are receiving something worth while in return for the
efforts. Without a strong perception of value it is unlikely a strong relationship can be
built. Throughout this tutorial we will emphasize value and show ways in which the
marketer builds value into the solutions they offer.
Other definitions for marketing include:
Each option within the marketers set is tightly integrated with all other options so that a
decision in one area could and often does impact decisions in other areas. For instance, a
change in the price of a product (e.g., lowering the price) could impact the distribution
area (e.g., increases shipments, generates higher traffic).
5
Additionally, options within the toolkit are affected by factors that are not controlled by
the marketer. These factors include economic conditions, legal issues, technological
developments, social/cultural changes, and many more. While not controllable, these
external factors must be monitored and dealt with since these can potentially cause
considerable harm to the organization. Ignoring outside elements also can lead to missed
opportunities in the market especially if competitors are the first to take advantage of the
opportunities. As part of the strategic and tactical planning process discussed above it
would be wise for marketers to pay close attention to the environment outside the
organization.
3.1. EVOLUTION OF MARKETING MANAGEMENT:
The evolution of marketing is composed of a series of responses to major external
challenges. Pre industrial marketing, based around craft production and personal
relationships with local customers, was challenged by the urbanization and
mechanization of the industrial revolution. The industrial era created expanding markets
which required an emphasis on production, logistics and selling to get the goods to the
customer. In the late 1950s, the challenge of increasingly saturated and competitive
markets led to the birth of an explicit marketing philosophy. Marketing is a relatively
latest discipline having emerged in the early 1900s. Prior to this time most issues that are
now commonly associated with marketing were either assumed to fall within basic
concepts of economics (e.g., price setting was viewed as a simple supply/demand issue),
advertising (well developed by 1900), or in most cases were simply not yet explored
(e.g., customer purchase behavior, importance of distribution partners). Lead by
marketing scholars from several major universities, the development of marketing was in
large part motivated by the need to dissect in greater detail relationships and behaviors
that existed between sellers and buyers. In particular, the study of marketing lead sellers
to recognize that adopting certain strategies and tactics could significantly benefit the
seller/buyer relationship. In the old days of marketing (before the 1950s) this often meant
identifying strategies and tactics for simply selling more products and services with little
regard for what customers really wanted. Often this lead companies to embrace a sell-asmuch-as-we-can philosophy with little concern for building relationships for the long
term.
But starting in the 1950s, companies began to see that old ways of selling were
wearing thin with customers. As competition grew stiffer across most industries,
organizations looked to the buyer side of the transaction for ways to improve. What they
found was an emerging philosophy suggesting that the key factor in successful marketing
is to understanding the needs of customers. This now famous marketing concept
suggests marketing decisions should flow from first knowing the customer and what they
want. Only then should an organization initiate the process of developing and marketing
products and services. The marketing concept continues to be at the root of most
marketing efforts, though the concept does have its own problems (e.g., doesnt help
much with marketing new technologies) a discussion of which is beyond the scope of this
tutorial. But overall marketers have learned they can no longer limit their marketing
effort to just getting customers to purchase more. They must have an in-depth
understanding of who their customers are and what they want.
Today most firms have adopted the marketing concept, but this has not always been the
case. In 1776 in The Wealth of Nations, Adam Smith wrote that the needs of producers
should be considered only with regard to meeting the needs of consumers. While this
philosophy is consistent with the marketing concept, it would not be adopted widely until
nearly 200 years later. To better understand the marketing concept, it is worthwhile to put
it in perspective by reviewing other philosophies that once were predominant. While
these alternative concepts prevailed during different historical time frames, they are not
restricted to those periods and are still practiced by some firms today.
The Production Concept
The production concept prevailed from the time of the industrial revolution until the early
1920's. The production concept was the idea that a firm should focus on those products
that it could produce most efficiently and that the creation of a supply of low-cost
products would in and of itself creates the demand for the products. The key questions
that a firm would ask before producing a product were:
Can we produce the product?
Can we produce enough of it?
At the time, the production concept worked fairly well because the goods that were
produced were largely those of basic necessity and there was a relatively high level of
unfulfilled demand. Virtually everything that could be produced was sold easily by a
sales team whose job it was simply to execute transactions at a price determined by the
cost of production. The production concept prevailed into the late 1920's.
The Sales Concept
By the early 1930's however, mass production had become commonplace, competition
had increased, and there was little unfulfilled demand. Around this time, firms began to
practice the sales concept (or selling concept), under which companies not only would
produce the products, but also would try to convince customers to buy them through
advertising and personal selling. Before producing a product, the key questions were:
Can we sell the product?
Can we charge enough for it?
The sales concept paid little attention to whether the product actually was needed; the
goal simply was to beat the competition to the sale with little regard to customer
satisfaction. Marketing was a function that was performed after the product was
developed and produced, and many people came to associate marketing with hard selling.
Even today, many people use the word "marketing" when they really mean sales.
The Marketing Concept
After World War II, the variety of products increased and hard selling no longer could be
relied upon to generate sales. With increased discretionary income, customers could
afford to be selective and buy only those products that precisely met their changing
needs, and these needs were not immediately obvious. The key questions became:
8
Product
Price
Place (distribution)
Promotion
Price
Target
Market
Place
Promotion
These four P's are the parameters that the marketing manager can control, subject to the
internal and external constraints of the marketing environment. The goal is to make
decisions that center the four P's on the customers in the target market in order to create
perceived value and generate a positive response.
Product/Service
What does the customer want from the product/service? What needs does it
satisfy?
What features does it have to meet these needs?
Are there any features youve missed out?
Are you including costly features that the customer wont actually use?
How and where will the customer use it?
What does it look like? How will customers experience it?
What size(s), color(s), and so on, should it be?
What is it to be called?
How is it branded?
How is it differentiated versus your competitors?
What is the most it can cost to provide, and still be sold sufficiently profitably?
(See also Price, below).
Place
Price
10
Promotion
Where and when can you get across your marketing messages to your target
market?
Will you reach your audience by advertising in the press, or on TV, or radio, or on
billboards? By using direct marketing mailshot? Through PR? On the Internet?
When is the best time to promote? Is there seasonality in the market? Are there
any wider environmental issues that suggest or dictate the timing of your market
launch, or the timing of subsequent promotions?
How do your competitors do their promotions? And how does that influence your
choice of promotional activity?
SOCIAL
RESPONSIBILITY
(CSR)
AND
ETHICS
IN
11
A socially responsible firm will care about customers, employees, suppliers, the local
community, society, and the environment. CSR can be described as an approach by
which a company:(a) Recognizes that its activities have a wide impact on the society and that development
in society in turn supports the company to pursue its business successfully .
(b) Actively manages the economic, social, environmental and human rights.
This approach is derived from the principles of sustainable development and good
corporate governance. Marketing managers within different firms will see some social
issues as more relevant than others. The relevance of a given social issue is determined
by the companys products, promotional efforts, and pricing and distribution policies but
also by its philosophy of social responsibility.
Ethical Conflict faced by the Marketers
Marketers must be aware of ethical standards and acceptable behavior. This awareness
means that marketers must recognize the viewpoints of three key players: the company,
the industry, and society. Since these three groups almost always have different needs
and wants, ethical conflicts are likely to arise. Ethical conflicts in marketing arise in two
contexts :
First, when there is a difference between the needs of the three aforementioned groups (
the company, the industry, and society) a conflict may arise.
Second and ethical conflict may arise when ones personal values conflict with the
organization. In either case, a conflict of interest is a possible outcome.
An example of the first type of conflict is the tobacco industry. Cigarettes have for many
decades been a lucrative business. So, cigarette and tobacco marketing have been for
companies and good for the tobacco industry. Many thousands of people around the
world are employed in the tobacco industry. So, the world economy has been somewhat
dependent on cigarettes and tobacco. However, cigarettes are harmful to society. There is
documented proof that cigarette smoking is harmful to health. This is an ethical conflict
for cigarette marketers.
An example of the second type of conflict, when ones personal values conflict with the
organizations occurs when a leader in the company seeks personal gain (usually financial
profit) from false advertising. Cures for fatal diseases are one type of product that falls
into this category of ethical conflict: In their greed to make a profit, a marketer convinces
those who may be dying from an incurable disease to buy a product that may not be a
cure, but which a desperately ill person (or members of his or her family) may choose to
purchase in an effort to save the dying family member suffering. Promoting and
marketing such products violates rules of marketing ethics. Ethical dilemmas facing
marketing professionals today fall into one of three categories: tobacco and alcohol
promoting, consumer privacy, and green marketing. Standards for ethical marketing
guide business in efforts to do the right thing. Such standards have four functions:
12
To help identify acceptable practices, foster internal control, avoids confusion, and
facilitates a basis for discussion.
Consumerism
Consumerism is concerned with broadening the rights of consumers. The concepts of
social responsibility and consumerism go hand-in-hand. If every organization practiced a
high level of social responsibility the consumer movement might never have begun.
Consumerism is a struggle for power between buyers and sellers; specifically, it is a
social movement seeking to increase the rights and powers of buyers in relation to sellers.
Sellers rights and powers are presented in the following list:
To introduce any product in any size and style they wish into the marketplace, so
long as it is
not hazardous to personal health or safety or if it is hazardous, to introduce it with
the proper
warnings and controls
To price the product at any level they wish, provided there is no discrimination
among similar
classes of buyers
To spend any amount of money they wish to promote the product, so long as the
promotion is
not defined as unfair competition
To formulate any message they wish about the product provided that it is
misleading or
dishonest in content or execution
To introduce any buying incentive schemes they wish
In contrast, here are buyers rights and power:
To refuse to buy a product that is offered to them
To except the product to be safe
To expect the product to essentially match how the seller represented it
To receive adequate information about the product
It is in the best interest of marketers to understand the level of consumer standards and
the nature
of consumer perceptions, as well as what is required to foster realism and accuracy
among consumers.
Marketing and the Natural Environment
Another significant area of social concern is the environment. Marketing is ultimately
dependent on the use of scarce resources to fulfill human needs, without harming or
unnecessarily using care resources.
13
Marketing managers should help to determine which products are produced, and which
products are indirectly affecting the environment:
The natural resources and materials used
The amount of energy required in the production process
The residuals (e.g., waste water) that result from production
The consumption of resources and energy that is required to use products (cars,
air conditioners)
The generation of pollutants (e.g., exhaust fumes) in using products
The amount of packaging material that may have to be discarded. (packaging
comprises less than 14 percent of collectible solid waste, but consumers often
estimate its share of that waste at 40 to 80 percent)
Relationship Marketing and Ethics
Nowadays, most ethicists believe that Relationship Marketing is a reasonable practice
leading to positive relationships between buyers and sellers. Relationship marketing
requires that rules are not necessarily contractual. Relationship marketing allows buyers
and sellers to work together. However, there are disadvantages to this approach that
means relationship marketing requires time to develop a list of expected conduct or rules
of behavior.
Green Marketing and Ethical Issues
The next important area the marketer need to know about what is the relevance of Social
Marketing in order to protect the environment and to improve the quality of life and are
concerned with issues that include conservation of natural resources, reducing
environmental pollution, protecting endangered species, and control of land use. Many
companies are finding that consumers are willing to pay more for a green product. The
last three decades have seen a progressive increase in worldwide environmental
consciousness. This has been driven by a number of factors from increased media
coverage to rising evidence of environmental problems such as the depletion of the ozone
layer, acidification of rivers and forest degradation, global warming, the rise of pressure
group activity, tougher legislation and major industrial disasters. Concern has moved
from the local scale to a national and increasingly global scale.
The rate of environmental degradation has intensified. The nineteenth century brought
the first large scale pollution as companies geared themselves to produce goods as fast as
possible, with virtual disregard for human or environmental well-being. Nations battled
for industrial supremacy using raw materials and creating pollution at a staggering rate.
As countries became economically stronger, competition also grew. More efficient
production methods were employed, and few companies, if any, gave a thought to the
impact they were having on their surroundings. With the increase in water pollution from
the chemical works, and air pollution from the iron and steel industry, towns and cities
began to pay the price for high industrial productivity.
14
The seventies saw a resurgence of environmental concern. In 1972 the historic United
Nations Conference on the Human Environment took place in Stockholm, leading to the
creation of the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP). In 1972 the Limits to
Growth Report of the Club of Rome projected a catastrophic future if growth continued
at the same rate, and many groups called for zero growth. The reaction of companies,
governments and academics to such gloomy environmental prophecies varied widely.
In 1987 the United Nations World Commission on Environment and Development
recognized that zero growth was no longer a viable option if the needs and aspirations of
the industrializing nations were to be fulfilled. As a result, 1987 saw the publication of
Our Common Future (The Brundtland Report) which concluded that economic growth
had a role to play in improving the standards in the less industrialized world and also in
reducing environmental destruction. It suggested that growth had to be of a different
order, and had to move the world away from viewing the environment as an unlimited
resource to be exploited by each incumbent generation.
Ass the 1980s progressed, it became increasingly clear that, although the starkest
predictions of resource depletion and population explosion had failed to materialize, all
was far from well with the planet. A number of published analyses of the environment
showed that according to a wide range of indicators, the environment was coming under
increasing stress. Concern among consumers and the electorate began to mount, with the
inevitable consequence being that environmental issues moved from the fringes to the
center of the business and political agenda.
The environments role in business is profoundly obvious, but easy to overlook. It
provides every business with its inputs, and a destination for all its outputs. It also
provides the business with the physical space within which its operations occur. For
businesses dealing directly with environmental resources, such as agriculture, tourism or
oil, the importance of the physical environment has always been apparent. Society in its
present form and on its current trajectory of development, however, cannot be sustained
indefinitely. The physical environment has limited resources and limited capacity to
absorb pollution and waste. The underlying cause of societys current unsustainability
relates to the way in which economics and technology have come to dominate our
thinking about business and the environment. Conventional marketing within industry is
very much a product of this techno-economic perspective. This has created a grey
culture which is not sustainable and is therefore terminal. To transform this into a green
sustainable culture, there is a need to balance consideration of the economic and technical
impacts and aspects of businesses with understanding of their social and physical
implications.
It is now widely accepted that societies, economies, and the businesses within them need
to find a more sustainable path to for future development. In the business world the
vocabulary of management was suddenly expanded by the discussion of green
consumers, green markets and green products and the practice of environmental or
green marketing. For majority of the companies improving environmental performance
has, until recently, been a question of legislative compliance and occasional reactions to
15
external events and pressures. It has only been companies in the front-line sectors such as
oil, chemicals, power and cars that have gone beyond a reactive and tactical approach to
green issues. However, by early 1990s a shift away from a technical-compliance oriented
approach towards a more proactive green strategy orientation was noticed. Companies
were increasingly pursuing competitive advantage and product differentiation by
increasing investment in environmental marketing, green design and improving overall
corporate eco-performance. In addition to these externally motivated changes, the
realization is dawning within industry that sustainability will not be reached simply by
demand-pull from the market and compliance-push from the regulators. The changes that
are needed to safeguard the future of the environment and the economy must partly be
driven from the business community, which means they must proactively integrate ecoperformance into the strategies, systems and cultures of the organization.
Eg: Toyota has become quite successful with their hybrid cars.
The three R s of environmentalism are:
Reduce
Reuse and
Recycle.
Green marketing refers to the development and distribution of ecologically-safe products.
It refers to products and packages that have one or more of the following characteristics:
(1) Are less toxic
(2) Are more durable
(3) Contain reusable materials
(4) Are made of recyclable material. In short, these are products considered
environmentally responsible.
Research based studies on green marketing are very scanty. Whatever studies available
are those carried out in the West. Zinkhan & Carlson (1995) in a study titled Green
Advertising and the Reluctant Consumer analyses the advertisers dilemma from
different perspectives of consumers having negative attitudes about business and negative
impressions of the advertising industry. The nature of green marketing is clarified by
Kilbourne (1995) in Green Advertising: Salvation or Oxymoron, demonstrating that the
concept is far more complex than the existing marketing literature suggests. Green is
characterized in this study as a two dimensional concept with political and human
dimensions. Banerjee et al (1995) in a study on multi dimensional analysis of
environmental advertising suggests that environmental appeals are becoming increasingly
common in advertising. The results of a content analysis designed to uncover the
underlying structure of green advertising are presented. A majority of advertisers in the
sample attempted to project a green corporate image rather than focusing on the
environmental benefits of their product or service. Most of the studies focus on the
communication aspect of green marketing and studies that cover the entire gamut of
green marketing are woefully lacking and more so studies conducted in an Indian context.
16
In the early to mid 1960s created concern about the social responsibility of businesses
and their impact on the natural environment and the health and welfare of the planet. This
concern was heightened during the early 1970s in response to Limits to Growth and
resulted in the emergence of both the societal marketing concept and the ecological
marketing concept. In response to the new green challenge that emerged during the early
1980s, these early concepts have amalgamated to create an environmental marketing
concept. Green marketing is thus a form of socio-ecological marketing whereby the
goods and services sold, and the marketing practices involved in their sale take into
account the environmental ramifications of society as a whole. The marketing process
essentially involves matching the controllable internal variables of the marketing mix
with the demands of the marketing environment. Environmental marketing is no
different, in principle, although the internal variables and external demands that must be
reconciled are a little different.
Green marketing takes account of the wider relationship of the organization and its
products to the surroundings. It is about a more aware, open, targeted and sensitive
approach that integrates the strategic link between the company, the environment, and
marketing, rather than being primarily concerned with tactical communications
opportunities. The prime emphasis is on, developing relationships and satisfying separate
Stakeholders needs in an environmentally and socially responsible manner. The key
stakeholders are customers, investors, parent company, directors, employees, the
community, legislators, pressure groups, suppliers, and the media
Green marketing differs from its societal and ecological predecessors in its intertwining
of ecological and social concerns, in the breadth of the ecological agenda that it tackles,
and in its potential application across all types and sectors of business. Green marketing
goes beyond societal marketing in four key ways:
It is an open-ended rather than a long-term perspective.
It focuses more strongly on the natural environment.
It treats the environment as something which has an intrinsic value over and
above its usefulness to society.
It focuses on global concerns rather than those of particular societies.
The key elements of green marketing can be summarised as under:
marketing concept?
A. We have organised our business to make certain that we satisfy customer needs
B. We believe that the marketing department must organise to sell what we produce.
C. We try to produce only high quality, technically efficient products
D. We try to encourage company growth.
4. Which of the following is an example of a problem that may arise in the
implementation of the marketing concept?
A. By satisfying one segment in society, a firm contributes to the dissatisfaction of
other segments.
B. Consumers do not understand what the marketing concept is.
C. Dealers do not support the marketing concept.
D. A product may fit the needs of too many segments.
5. The marketing concept is a philosophy that states that an organisation should try to
satisfy customers' needs and at the same time:
A.
B.
C.
D.
5. Summary
In the current context, there is very high competition among the marketers in India and
that has been necessitated due to the fact that consumerism is on the high and the
importance of marketing is known to people. An interaction between business and
industry in a global perspective has become imperative because of the need to upgrade
regional technologies and maintain the competitive edge in the international markets.
Today's consumer is more demanding than yester-years'. He is not content with the
second best in technology and is reluctant to pay for a product or a service just because it
comes from a particular region or a country. This, understandably, has led to business and
industry across the world to make use of technologies and resources worldwide to
upgrade their products and services. In this Liberalisation-Privatisation-Globalisation era
to become an integral part of the global system, nations are opening up their economies at
a rapid rate, which were hitherto protected from world markets. The removal of artificial
barriers to trade has and should made it possible for innovative companies to go in search
of new markets across borders with improved efficiency and greater competitive strength.
This has forced the Indian companies to be competitive on the marketing front.
6. Exercises
1. Today we have an unmanageable surplus of food grains, but regrettably, no
integrated approach to agriculture, procurement & food processing, to take
advantage of such bounty or capabilities. More worrying is the fact that public
investment in Agriculture has been declining in real terms through the 1980s &
19
Marketing environment
1. Introduction:
The Business environment surrounds and impacts upon the organization. There
are three key perspectives on the environment, namely the 'macro-environment,' the
'micro-environment' and the 'internal environment'. Micro environment influences the
20
organization directly. It includes suppliers that deal directly or indirectly, consumers and
customers, and other local stakeholders. Micro tends to suggest small, but this can be
misleading. In this context, micro describes the relationship between firms and the
driving forces that control this relationship. It is a more local relationship, and the firm
may exercise a degree of influence. Macro environment includes all factors that can
influence and organization, but that are out of their direct control. A company does not
generally influence any laws (although it is accepted that they could lobby or be part of a
trade organization). It is continuously changing, and the company needs to be flexible to
adapt. There may be aggressive competition and rivalry in a market. Globalization means
that there is always the threat of substitute products and new entrants. The wider
environment is also ever changing, and the marketer needs to compensate for changes in
culture, politics, economics and technology. Keeping this in mind the environmental
influences needs to be studied and you will have the inputs in all the forces that influence
the organization in its quest for effective marketing.
2. Learning objectives:
After reading the unit, you will understand how:
has to be
proactive
3. MARKETING ENVIRONMENT:
Environmental scanning helps in assessing the impact the environment could
create the business. Observation played a minor, but non-negligible role. Visits to the
premises, including the factory plants in some cases, meals in the canteens of some of the
organizations, attention paid to the way-of-doing-things in the several companies - how
visitors were announced, how meetings were scheduled and cancelled, absence or
frequency and type of interruptions in the course of the interviews, degree of formality or
informality in interpersonal relations - contributed to consolidate impressions or confirm
information based on documentary evidence or on the interviews. The grounded theory
proposed comprises three main components: the categories (the core category and the
subsidiary categories), the principal relationships among them, and the contextual factors
that shape the categories and relationships. From an internal perspective, these factors
include corporate history and culture. From an external perspective, these contextual
factors include the overall economic, social, cultural and political conditions that
characerize modern India and shape, at least to a certain extent, the organizations
operating in that reality. The core category identified was that of environmental scanning,
to which a set of subsidiary categories was related. According to Aguilar,environmental
scanning refers to the exposure to and acquisition of "information about events and
relationships in a company's outside environment, the knowledge of which would assist
21
top-management in its task of charting the company's future course of action." This
interrelated set of categories contributes to understanding how contextual factors external and internal to the organization, influence the scanning activity, and also how
perceived environmental change affects strategic change. The task of explaining variance
among companies resides with a few key relationships among those categories. Now let
us see each environment in detail.
3.1. SOCIAL ENVIRONMENT:
Indian society is multifaceted to an extent perhaps unknown in any other of the
world's great civilizations. Virtually no generalization made about Indian society is valid
for all of the nation's multifarious groups. Comprehending the complexities of Indian
social structure has challenged scholars and other observers over many decades. The
ethnic and linguistic diversity of Indian civilization is more like the diversity of an area as
variable as Europe than like that of any other single nation-state. Living within the
embrace of the Indian nation are vast numbers of different regional, social, and economic
groups, each with different cultural practices. Particularly noteworthy are differences
between social structures in the north and the south, especially in the realm of kinship
systems. Throughout the country, religious differences can be significant, especially
between the Hindu majority and the large Muslim minority; and other Indian groups-Buddhists, Christians, Jains, Jews, Parsis, Sikhs, and practitioners of tribal religions--all
pride themselves on being unlike members of other faiths.
Urban-rural differences can be immense in the Indian Society. Nearly 74 percent
of India's population dwells in villages, with agriculture providing support for most of
these rural residents. In villages, mud-plastered walls ornamented with traditional
designs, dusty lanes, herds of grazing cattle, and the songs of birds at sunset provide
typical settings for the social lives of most Indians. In India's great cities, however,
millions of people live amidst cacophony--roaring vehicles, surging crowds, jammed
apartment buildings, busy commercial establishments, loudspeakers blaring movie tunes-while breathing the poisons of industrial and automotive pollution.
Indian caste system:
Members of the highest priestly castes, the Brahmans, are generally vegetarians (although
some Bengali and Maharashtrian Brahmans eat fish) and avoid eating meat, the product
of violence and death. High-ranking Warrior castes (Kshatriyas), however, typically
consume nonvegetarian diets, considered appropriate for their traditions of valor and
physical strength. A Brahman born of proper Brahman parents retains his inherent purity
if he bathes and dresses himself properly, adheres to a vegetarian diet, eats meals
prepared only by persons of appropriate rank, and keeps his person away from the bodily
exuviae of others (except for necessary contact with the secretions of family infants and
small children).
If a Brahman happens to come into bodily contact with a polluting substance, he can
remove this pollution by bathing and changing his clothing. However, if he were to eat
22
meat or commit other transgressions of the rigid dietary codes of his particular caste, he
would be considered more deeply polluted and would have to undergo various purifying
rites and payment of fines imposed by his caste council in order to restore his inherent
purity.
In sharp contrast to the purity of a Brahman, a Sweeper born of Sweeper parents is
considered to be born inherently polluted. The touch of his body is polluting to those
higher on the caste hierarchy than he, and they will shrink from his touch, whether or not
he has bathed recently. Sweepers are associated with the traditional occupation of
cleaning human feces from latrines and sweeping public lanes of all kinds of dirt.
Traditionally, Sweepers remove these polluting materials in baskets carried atop the head
and dumped out in a garbage pile at the edge of the village or neighborhood. The
involvement of Sweepers with such filth accords with their low-status position at the
bottom of the Hindu caste hierarchy, even as their services allow high-status people, such
as Brahmans, to maintain their ritual purity.
Members of the Leatherworker (Chamar) caste are ascribed a very low status consonant
with their association with the caste occupation of skinning dead animals and tanning the
leather. Butchers (Khatiks, in Hindi), who kill and cut up the bodies of animals, also rank
low on the caste hierarchy because of their association with violence and death.
However, castes associated with ruling and warfare--and the killing and deaths of human
beings--are typically accorded high rank on the caste hierarchy. In these instances,
political power and wealth outrank association with violence as the key determinant of
caste rank.
Status of Women in Indian society:
According to ancient Hindu scriptures no religious rite can be performed with perfection
by a man without the participation of his wife. Wife's participation is essential to any
religious rite. Married men along with their wives are allowed to perform sacred rites on
the occasion of various important festivals. Wives are thus befittingly called 'Ardhangani'
(betterhalf). They are given not only important but equal position with men.
But in the later period the position of women went on deteriorating due to Muslim
influence. During the Muslim period of history they were deprived of their rights of
equality with men. They were compelled to keep themselves within the four walls of their
houses with a long veil on their faces. This was definitely due to Islamic influence. Even
today in some Islamic countries women are not allowed to go out freely. The
conservative regimes of Iran and Pakistan, for example, have withdrawn the liberties
given to women folk by the previous liberal governments. Even in India the Muslim
women are far more backward than their Hindu, Christian and Sikh counterparts. The
sight of Muslim women walking with long 'Burkas' (veils) on their person is not very
rare. The women are, as a matter of fact, regarded as captive and saleable commodities in
Muslim families. One man is allowed to have so many wives with the easiest provision of
divorce. The husband can divorce a wife just by saying 'I divorce you' under the
23
provision of Muslim laws. This is what the emperors did hundred years back and the men
are doing it even now in almost all Islamic countries. Even in this last phase of the
twentieth century rich and prosperous men of Islamic countries keep scores of wives in
their harems. It was natural outcome of the Muslim subjugation of India that woman was
relegated to a plaything of man, an ornament to decorate the drawing room. Serving,
knitting, painting and music were her pastimes and cooking and cleaning her business.
In the wake of Raja Ram Mohan Roy's movement against women's subjugation to men
and British influence on Indian culture and civilization the position of women had once
again undergone a change. However, it was only under the enlightened leadership of
Mahatma Gandhi that they re-asserted their equality with men. In response to the call of
Gandhi they discarded their veil and came out of the four walls of their houses to fight
the battle of freedom shoulder to shoulder with their brothers. The result is that the Indian
Constitution today has given to women the equal status with men. There is no
discrimination between men and women. All professions are open to both of them with
merit as the only criterion of selection.
As a result of their newly gained freedom Indian woman have distinguished themselves
in various spheres of life as politicians, orators, lawyers, doctors, administrators and
diplomats. They are not only entrusted with work of responsibility but also they perform
their duties very honestly and sincerely. There is hardly any sphere of life in which Indian
women have not taken part and shown their worth. Women exercise their right to vote,
contest for Parliament and Assembly, seek appointment in public office and compete in
other spheres of life with men. This shows that women in India enjoy today more liberty
and equality than before. They have acquired more liberty to participate in the affairs of
the country. They have been given equality with men in shaping their future and sharing
responsibilities for themselves, their family and their country.
It is a fact that women are intelligent, hard-working and efficient in work. They put heart
and soul together in whatever they undertake. As typists and clerks they are now
competing successfully with men. There are many women working in the Central
Secretariat. They are striving very hard to reach highest efficiency and perfection in the
administrative work. Their integrity of character is probably better than men. Generally it
was found that women are less susceptible to corruption in form of bribery and
favouritism. They are not only sweet tongued but also honest, efficient and punctual in
their jobs as receptionists, air-hostesses and booking clerks at railway reservation
counters. As a matter of fact they are gradually monopolising the jobs of receptionists
and air-hostesses.
Another job in which Indian women are doing so well is that of teachers. In country like
India where millions are groping in the darkness of illiteracy and ignorance efficient
teaching to the children is most urgently needed. By virtue of their love and affection for
the children the women have proved the best teachers in the primary and kindergarten
schools. They can better understand the psychology of a child than the male teachers.
Small children in the kindergarten schools get motherly affection from the lady teachers.
24
cases families have been running in deficit due to the extravagance of the housewives in
maintaining a high standard of living. The result is that the earning male members of the
family are forced to fill up the gap in the budget by corrupt practices. Corruption has
been so far the greatest impediment in way to India's progress. Minus corruption India
would have been one of the most developed nations of the world.
There is no denying the fact that women in India have made a considerable progress in
the last fifty years but yet they have to struggle against many handicaps and social evils
in the male dominated society. The Hindu Code Bill has given the daughter and the son
equal share of the property. The Marriage Act no longer regards woman as the property
of man. Marriage is now considered to be a personal affair and if a partner feels
dissatisfied she or he has the right of divorce. But passing of law is one thing and its
absorption in the collective thinking of society is quite a different matter. In order to
prove themselves equal to the dignity and status given to them in the Indian Constitution
they have to shake off the shackles of slavery and superstitions. They should help the
government and the society in eradicating the evils of dowry, illiteracy and ignorance
among the eves. The dowry problem has assumed a dangerous form in this country. The
parents of the girls have to pay thousands and lacs to the bridegrooms and their greedy
fathers and mothers. If promised articles are not given by the parents of brides, the cruel
and greedy members of the bridegrooms' family take recourse to afflicting tortures on the
married women. Some women are murdered in such cases. The dowry deaths are really
heinous and barbarous crimes committed by the cruel and inhumane persons. The young
girls should be bold enough in not marrying the boys who demand dowry through their
parents. The boys should also refuse to marry if their parents demand dowry. But
unfortunately the number of such bold and conscientious boys is very few. Even the
doctors, engineers, teachers and the administrative officers do not hesitate in allowing
themselves to be sold to the wealthy fathers of shy and timid girls. Such persons have
really brought disgrace to their cadres in particular and society in general.
3.2. Cultural Environment:
A society's culture includes its values, its ethics and the material objects produced by
its people. It is the accumulation of shared meanings and traditions among members of a
society. A culture can be described in terms of its ecology (the way people adapt to their
habitat), its social structure and its ideology (including people's moral and aesthetic
principles). Culture refers to the set of values, ideas and attitudes that are accepted by a
homogeneous group of people and transmitted to the next generation. Subculture refers to
the norms and values of subgroups within the larger or national culture. African
American, Hispanics, and Asians represent sizable subcultures. It is inappropriate to think
in terms of stereotypes when marketing to these subcultures. African Americans represent
the largest racial/ethnic subculture in the united states. While price-conscious, they are
motivated by product quality and choice. Indian consists of people who are either Aryans
and Dravidians to a large extent. Current research indicates that stereotypes are
misleading. Christians are the subculture in India where as in United States, it is the
culture by itself. Asians are the fastest growing subculture in the United States. The
growth of this subculture is due primarily to immigration. Like Hispanics, Asians
26
27
from Rajasthan. One will find a Marwari business man settled in eastern states of North
Bengal, Assam, Orissa. Non-aggressive and soft spoken by nature, Marwaris are
peaceful.
The Punjabi Subculture
Punjabis are distinct in terms of their lavish lifestyle, whether it is in terms of food
habits, dressing, purchse of consumer durables and nondurables. Hardworking by nature,
the most distinct trait of a Punjabi is his adaptability in the new environment. The author
had chance to visit a Punjabi household in Delhi, the family for years of staying in
Calcutta enjoyed eating fish and sweet curd, one of their daughters being married to a
Keralite, the family was equally at ease with Keralite dishes like Appam and coconut
chicken. Trying new things is very common with Punjabis and they like to spend a lot,
with an occation or without it. Typical Punjabis food like their lifestyle is also very rich
consisting of rajma chawal, shahi paneer, butter chicken, patiala chicken, etc.
diwali is their main festival where besides the puja of godess of wealth Laxmi, people
exahange gifts. A typical Punjabi will be hardworking. Aggressive, and ambitious.
Being cosmopolitan and lively are some other traits of a Punjabi. Some is true with their,
music, dance or their language, it is full of life.
The Oriya Subculture
Quite similar to Bengali subculture is oriya subculture. Oriya people, by nature, are
extremely artistic. Oriya craftsmanship is known all over the country whether it is in
fabric, philigri work, stone work. Oddissi dance is as famous as the Jagannath Temple in
Konark. Extremely fond of sweets, Oriya people eat lot of pan and pakal; during
lunch hours one will find office goers standing on the road side and eating pakal. Rath
Yatra of lord Jagannath is their main festival during which Oriyas eat vegetarian food
and generally wear new cloths, take leave from the office to have a darshan of Jagannath
and touch him as it is the only time common man can touch the lord.
The Tamil subculture
Tamilians are known both their intelligence and hard work. They shine in
engineering field, scientific research and governmental jobs. Traditional by nature, a
Tamilian professor will not mind going to college wearing his traditional dress of a white
shirt and dhoti wrapped around. A Tamilian women will not mind going to her work
place with flower in her hair; such is their attachment to their culture. A Tamil household
ia an example of hygienic living. Tamil households are spic and span and decorated with
traditional handicrafts, especially brassware. Although Tamil Nadu is a hot place, people
are very fond of wearing rich silk sarees in deep colours, so are they fond of wearing
heavy gold and diamond ornaments. Tamil Nadu is known for its Kanjivaram silk and its
food whether is the ubiquitous dosa, idli or the tamrind rice, lemon rice, tomato rice.
They only eat rice and not difficult to find a renowned professor who is also expert in
Carnatic music or an engineer who is also a Bharatanatyam dancer. Tamilians love to
hold on to their rich traditional heritage. Pongal is their main festival which literally
30
means new cooked rich and held in the month of January and marks the incoming of the
new crop.
3.3. Economic Environment:
Business fortunes and strategies are influenced by the economic characteristics and
economic policy dimensions. The economic environment includes the structure and
nature of the economy, the stage of development of the economy, economic resources,
the level of income, the distribution of income and assets, global economic linkages,
economic policies etc. A widely used classification of economies is on the basis of per
capital income,ie.,the average annual income per person. Accordingly, countries are
broadly classified as low income, high income economies and the middle income
economies. Low income economies are those economies with very low per capital
income. All economies with per capita $755 or less in2000 are regarded as low income
economies. There are 63 low income economies in 2000. High income economies are
countries with very rich income per capital. Those with a per capital GNP of$ 9266 or
above in2000 fall in the category of high in come economies.
There are mainly two categories of high income economies, namely, industrial economies
and oil exporters. Middle income economies fall in between the low income and high
income economies. The middle income economies are subdivided in to lower middle
income and upper middle income economies. In 2000, there are 92 middle income
economies (54 lower middle incomes and 38 upper middle incomes. The low income
economies are sometimes referred to as third world (the high income and middle income
economies representing the first and second worlds.).Low income is just an indication of
deprivation people in developing countries. Low income prevents access to basic
necessities, not only better and modern amenities. The term recession is depression in an
economy which leads to stagnation and poor incomes. Within the category of low income
economies, for example, sometimes a special category name least developed economies
is identified. Most of the least developed economies suffer from one or more of the
following constraints: a very low GNP per capita, land locked remote insularity,
desertification and exposure to natural disasters. According to the Human Development
Report there are more than 40 least developed countries in 1999.There are on the other
hand developing economies such as the Asian countries. They are sometimes referred to
as newly industrialising economies. Now Peoples Republic of China is regarded as a
newly industrializing economy.
The most comprehensive indicator of the level of economic activity of an economy is its
aggregate output, i.e., the total annual output of finished goods and services, known as
gross national product (GNP), which is defined as the total market value of all final goods
and services produced in an economy during a given time period (usually a year). GNP is
a monetary measure of total output. It excludes transfer payments (like buying and selling
of bonds and securities, gifts taxes, or welfare payments) and secondhand sale of goods,
as these are a part of current production. In order to avoid double-counting. GNP
excludes the production contribution of housewives, the efforts of self-help in a
31
GNP Sum of the market value of all final goods and service3s in an
economy during a given time period;
GNI Sum of the money incomes derived from activities involving
current production in an economy during a given time period; and
GNE Sum of all that is spent of currently produced goods and services
by all types of buyers in an economy during a given period.
The national income data can also be quite helpful for business. In order to undertake
long-term investments and to formulate business policies it is quite essential for a
dynamic management to do a thorough analysis of changes occurring in the national
income. Since national income reveals, on the one hand, the structure of the economy
and, on the other, the possible directions of change in the future economic policy of the
government, national income data in the hands of an expert managerial economist can
prove a life-line for business. It is quite vital for a firm aspiring to capture or retain
leadership in business, as it is perhaps one of the most essential ingredients for any
business forecasting exercise. The national income data can also be successfully used for
determining the product diversification programme and undertaking technological
innovations. National income statistics is, thus, a wealth of information, but its usefulness
depends on keenness to observe and probe as well as patience to analyse.
BUSINESS CYCLES:
The effect of upswings and downswings in economic activity is felt quite
intensely because of the ever increasing business activity and the strong inter-relations
between different sectors of an economy and between various economies. The ill effects
of the wide swings in business activity were almost ravaging during the Great Depression
of 1930s. it was also noticed that after depression there was no natural recovery of the
economic activity. Artificial measures to be adopted for this purpose needed a scientific
understanding of the swings in the activity. Business cycle or trade cycle refers to the
fluctuations in economic activity occurring regularly in the capitalist societies. In a
32
business cycle there are wave-like fluctuations in four inter-linked economic variables:
aggregate employment, income, output and price level. When the values of these
economic variables over time are plotted on a graph, we get a wave-like figure, which is
given the name of a cycle. According to Keynes, A trade cycle is composed of periods
of good trade characterized by rising prices and low unemployment percentages.
Alternating with periods of bad trade characterized by falling prices and high
unemployment percentages. Mitchell gives even a more explicit idea of what a business
cycle is when he says, Business cycles are a type of fluctuations found in the aggregate
economic activity of nations that organize their work mainly in business enterprises. A
cycle consists of expansions, and revivals which merge into the expansion phase of the
next cycle: this sequence of change is recurrent but not periodic in short one can
observe that:
(1) Business cycles are the wave-like fluctuations in economic activity as reflected in
the basic economic variables like employment, income, output and price level.
(2) These fluctuations are cyclical in nature. One must distinguish between secular
trend, random fluctuations, seasonal changes and cyclical fluctuations. The
secular trend represents long run changes in business activity which occur slowly
and are spread over a number of years. Such long-run changes are the results of
factors like improvement in production techniques, change in population, etc,
which occur suddenly and are unpredictable. Effect of these events on the
economy is limited to the period of occurrence of the event, as there is no
regularity in their occurrence. Thus, neither the secular trend nor the random
variations in economic activity can form the part of business cycle. The seasonal
changes, which are short-run oscillations with regularity, can be confused with the
cyclical fluctuations. But the basic difference between the two is that seasonal
variations repeat themselves each year (e.g., demand for heavy woolen clothes,
light woolen clothes and cotton clothes, and so on, depending on the season each
year), while the cyclical fluctuations have a longer life span. The seasonal
fluctuations, therefore, have easier predictability and adjustability in business than
the cyclical fluctuations.
(3) The sequence of changes in business cycle (i.e., recovery, prosperity, depression
and recession) recurs frequently and in a fairly similar pattern.
(4) The rhythm or the periodicity between the cycles need not be similar.
(5) Business cycles are a type of fluctuations found in the aggregate economic
activity and not in any single firm or industry. In fact, it connotes the cyclical
changes in overall economic environment affecting all the business entities.
Business cycles, the periodic booms and slumps in economic activities, are generally
compared to ebb and flow. The ups and downs in the economy are reflected by the
fluctuation in aggregate economic magnitudes, including production, investment, prices,
wages, bank credits, etc. The upward and downward movement in these magnitudes
show different phases of business cycles. Basically, there are only two phases in cycle,
viz., prosperity and depression. However, considering the intermediate stages between
prosperity and depression, the various phases of trade cycle may be enumerated as
follows:
33
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
In a stagnated economy, depression begins when growth rate turns negative i.e. total
output, employment, prices, bank advances, etc., decline during the subsequent periods.
The span of depression spreads over a period during which growth rate stays below the
secular growth rate or below the zero growth rate in a stagnated economy. Trough is the
phase during which the down-trend in the economy slows down and eventually stops, and
the economic activities once again register an upward movement with a lapse of time.
Though is the period of most sever strain on the economy. When the economy registers a
continuous and rapid upward trend in output, employment, etc., it enters the phase of
recovery though the growth rate may still remain below the steady growth rate. And
when the growth rate crosses the line of steady growth rate, the economy once again
enters the phase of expansion and prosperity,. If economic fluctuations are not controlled
by the government, business cycles continues to recur.
Recovery
This is the phase of revival of demand for goods and services. The economic activity as a
whole increases slowly, although the general prices start rising. The upward movement of
business activity is slow, production picks up, construction activity is revived and there is
a gradual rise in employment. This is a period when the industrialists and the
businessmen repay the loans taken by them from the banks earlier and the frozen stocks
held by the banks are released. Stocks of goods remain below the normal with the
shopkeepers. Once the recovery starts, it results in a snowballing process for investment.
The result is that demand orders pour in and the producers get stimulus and
encouragement to produce more. The sellers stop their conservative period in general
favoring expansion in business activity. The capital equipment is replaced. Banks are
liberal in the matter of advances. The prices recover and tend to reach the normal. The
speed, with which the expansion of business activity takes place in response to a given
initial increase in investment, would depend upon the multiplier effect.
Prosperity
During this phase there is a rapid cumulative movement of prices, employment, income
and production. The prices and general business activity is above the normal. Total
output starts growing at a rapid pace due to higher investment and employment. Prices of
finished products rise faster than the increase in wage-rate, raw material prices and
interest rate. Consequently, producers stand to gain. Prices of all the commodities do not
rise to the same extent. The sequence of general price rise generally begins with increase
in security prices, which then passes on to raw material prices, wholesale prices, wages of
unskilled labour, retail prices and finally the interest rates.
34
Recession :
When the business cycle takes a downward turn from the state of prosperity, the state of
recession is said to have set in. during the phase of prosperity, production increases with
every increase in commodity prices. As more and more of unemployed labour, capital
and raw material are employed, interest rate, wages and other costs rise with increasing
rapidity. Simultaneously, the banks suddenly discover that they have expanded their
deposits a little too far. The ratio of cash reserves to total deposits falls. The banks
become reluctant to advance loans in the interest of their safety and statutory
requirements. In order to meet their obligations, the sellers would, therefore, have to
unload their stocks in the market. Due to unloading of stocks by many firms, the prices
start declining. Profit margins decline further because costs start overtaking prices.
Business psychology becomes depressed and the boom bursts. There is a struggle for
solvency among the businessmen. Some firms close down while others reduce
production, leading to reduction in investment, employment, income and demand. This
process is cumulative. This phase of business cycle is characterized by fall in prices,
commercial panic, restriction and calling back loans by banks, a sharp increase in interest
rate and fall in investment. Soon the production falls, unemployment increases and
inventory stocks get accumulated. There is a collapse of confidence. If not controlled in
the beginning by timely monetary and fiscal measurers by government which can sustain
investment at a high level, recession may give way to even a more grave situation, called
depression .
Depression:
If unchecked, depression is a natural consequence of the recessionary crisis. Gradually,
the process of falling prices, demand and employment gather momentum. Decrease in
price follows the same sequence as does the price increase in case of the state of boom. In
this phase, general demand for goods and services falls faster than the production of
goods, though this is more in case of capital goods than consumer goods. Producers find
selling prices falling faster than their costs. Producers suffer losses because by the time
the goods are ready for sale the prices are found to have fallen further, with the result that
producers are not able to recover their full cost. Businessmen get panicky, and start
releasing their stocks, which hastens the decline in prices. The phenomenon of overproduction appears and workers in large numbers are thrown out of work. There are
accumulated reserves with banks. Demand for credit is at its lowest, resulting in idle
funds with the banks. In general, the bottom of depression is reached when liquidation of
accumulated stocks is completed. Depression is, thus, characterized by low prices, idle
funds with banks, mass unemployment and slack trade.
Levels of the economy:
Two types of policies are pursued by State to combat the inflationary and deflationary
tendencies in the economy. These are called stabilization policies, which mainly include :
(i) Monetary policy and (ii) Fiscal policy.
35
1. Monetary policy. It refers to the credit control measures adopted by the central bank
of an economy (in India, the Reserve Bank of India). These are of two kinds :
Quantitative or selective controls. Quantitative or general controls include bank rate
variations, open market operations and varying reserve ratios. They aim at regulating the
overall level of credit in the economy through the commercial banks. Bank rate is the
minimum lending rate at which the central bank discounts bills and securities held by
commercial banks borrow less from the Central bank. On the other hand, commercial
banks raise their lending rate. This reduces the money supply in the economy. Reduction
in money supply reduces demand for goods and services in the economy, resulting in the
check on price rise. Open market operations refer to the sale and purchase of securities by
the central bank. When the central bank aims to control inflation it sells securities in the
open market, thereby reducing reserves of commercial banks. When the central bank
aims to control inflation it sells securities in the open market, thereby reducing reserves
of commercial banks. This reduces credit in the market. The reduction in money supply
helps in checking price rise. Changes in reserve ratio can help combat inflation. The
portion of deposits which a commercial bank has statutorily to keep with the central bank
as deposit is called the reserve funds. In order to reduce credit by the commercial banks,
many a time the central bank increases the percentage of such deposits. Increase in
reserve ratio reduces the bank advances, thereby reducing demand for goods and services,
and checks price rise. Selective credit controls are used to encourage or discourage
specific types of credit for particular purposes. In order to check the speculative activity
in the economy, the central bank changes the margin requirements to be charged by the
commercial banks on those activities.
In recessionary conditions, the State should use monetary policies in the opposite
direction to control recessionary forces. The central bank should lower the bank rate,
thus, making borrowing by commercial banks cheaper. Commercial banks in turn would
lower their lending rate, resulting in greater demand for credit. This would encourage
investment, output, employment, income and demand. Consequently, prices would start
rising. Similarly, while operating in the open market, the central bank should buy
securities, thereby raising money supply in the economy, whose impact would also be an
increase in investment, output, employment, income and prices. The central bank can also
use the instrument of reserve ratio to combat encourage greater lending, thus reviving
economic activity. Lastly, when recession is in some specific sectors of economy the
central bank can use some selective credit control measures, particularly lowering margin
requirements, which would help in encouraging greater business activity.
2. Fiscal policy. Fiscal policy refers to the deliberate changing of taxes and government
spending for the purpose of keeping the actual GNP close to the potential full
employment GNP. If the potential GNP is exceeded it causes inflation, while if the actual
GNP falls short of the potential it causes recessionary conditions.
When inflation is due to excess purchasing power in relation to the amount of
goods and services available in the economy, the basic remedy for controlling
inflationary conditions is to drain away excess purchasing power. In such a case, fiscal
policy should aim at taking rupees out of the income-expenditure stream. As a result of
36
this policy the aggregate demand will reduce, leading to control of price rise. There are
two approaches for accomplishing this : (1) To restrain or reduce government spending
and create a surplus budget (where tax revenue exceeds government expenditure). The
cutback on government expenditures would reduce aggregate demand originating in the
public sector; and its spillover effect I rest of the economy would also dampen aggregate
demand. (2) To increase taxes on business and consumers without increasing government
expenditure. Obviously, its impact would also be to create surplus budget and dampen the
aggregate demand. Depending on which of the approaches are used, there will be
differential impact on public and private sectors. However, both these approaches can
also be used simultaneously.
To combat recessionary conditions, just the opposite kind of fiscal policy
measures need to be adopted. The government should aim to generate fiscal deficit by
either increasing government expenditure (keeping tax revenues constant) or decreasing
taxes (keeping government expenditure constant) or both. We know that in recession the
economy suffers from unemployment as well as low level of output and aggregate
demand. To give boost to aggregate demand, there is a need to pump purchasing power in
the economy. By increasing aggregate demand, the unused capacity and unemployed
labour can be employed. Again, the impact of the increase in government expenditure
will be felt through resurgence of demand in the public sector and that of the cutback on
taxes through the private sector.
Indicators of Economic Development:
Inflation:
Inflation has attracted sufficient attention of economists and policy makers. India
is pursuing a policy of planned economic development. One of the prime considerations
in the strategy of growth has been to ensure that growth takes place in an environment of
price stability, which was considered crucial for both-steady growth and even distribution
of the gains of growth. Any increase in prices was likely to affect investment planning
and income distribution in the economy. Hence, efforts to contain and or avoid the same
were an integral part of the planning process. The transmission of inflation-ary impulses
in the economy is affected by various factors e.g. the differences in sectoral relations in
the economy, nature of markets, both of products and services, the extent of linkages
between these markets, the pattern of income and asset distribution, levels of
concentration of corporate and trade-union's power and the effectiveness of the
intermediation of financial institutions, rate of growth in nominal wages and labour
productivity, structure of capital formation and, finally, the rate of development, etc.
Inflation is defined as the persistent rise in the general price level. The question arises as
to what should constitute the appropriate measure to reflect the general price level. In
order to analyse the general price level, percentage annual changes in (i) Wholesale Price
Index (WPI), (ii) Gross Domestic Product (GDP) at market prices, deflator, (iii) GDP (at
factor cost) deflator and (iv) cost of living index (CLI) for industrial workers are usually
considered. Because of wide coverage, the GDP deflator (both at market prices and factor
cost) should be considered as the most appropriate index of inflation because the deflator
37
covers commodities as well as services, whereas the other two indices reflect movement
only in commodity prices with different 'Baskets'. Inflation rate has dropped from being
among 10% during 1991 to 5.91% during 2004.
Emergence of Consuming class:
The Indian middle class has been an enigma to most marketers who have tried to
assess its buying patterns. Although this market has not proved to be the made-to-order
goldmine that the global players originally viewed it as, it is fast shedding the
conservative tag. Increased disposable income levels, as well as the shaking out of the
taboo associated with consumer loans has resulted in middle class families paying more
and opting for CTVs. As the number of channels increases, so does the strife amongst
family members on which programme to watch. TV manufacturers can convince them to
go in for a second TV set. Two colour TVs may seem too much of a luxury to bank
balance-conscious middle-class families, but a new B&W TV may do just fine. This
could be another market for the B&W makers to address. B&W manufacturers should
look at increasing production and cost efficiencies to sustain in the market. A very lowpriced B&W TV is sure to find a substantial market among the poorer classes. With
increased impetus on cost cutting, faster rotating models and a little help from the
Government on the duties front, the B&W industry can protect itself from blackening out.
The governements reform policies have already started to pay off. $1.6 billion in U.S
investment projects has been approved since the introduction of economic reform twice
the amount of investment in India during the preceding 40 years. This beginning of
liberalization although so very recent, has already meant an impetus and growth in the
rise of the standard of living among the middle class. By the year 2000, India is projected
to have a population of one billion, and while Indias per capita income average income
is quite low ($330USD), India has a growing middle class. An estimate 200 million
Indians have an annual incomes comparable to those in the United States and Canada.
Globally except for China nowhere will the new middle-class be larger than in India.
Amounting to hundreds of million of people, this new middle-class (with a major
political base and buying ability) while modern in many respect, being entrepreneurial
and professional, will also have the traditional caution of their past generation towards
the 21st century. The growth in the earning ability and thus a rise in the standard of living
amongst middle-class will also mean an end to the "Brain Drain" phenomena happening
in most developing countries. Brain Drain being a phenomena when some of the best
students and technicians in a developing country after being subsidized in their education
by their own government migrate to a developed country, to seek a better standard of
living. A quick survey amongst numerous American Engineering and Technical
Universities would probably illustrate this "Brain Drain" both amongst faculties as well
as students.
With the birth of the new middle-class, their buying power and their technical saviness
and an almost virtual end to the "Brain Drain" phenomena, the third world will be the
place for the growth of new technology. Bleeding technologies once mainly a factor of
the developed world, will be happening in this so called once called third world, as the
third world will be where consumerism will abound. In this newfound consumer land will
38
be the rise of telecommunication. Since 1990s, India's $1.1 billion computer equipment
market has been growing at the rate of 31 percent annually more than any other
information technology sector. India already is the worlds leading exporter in software.
There will also be a major trend (already existing) in the rise of programming farms,
where Indian programmers would write the backend and the front end developed
elsewhere. This philosophy of outsourcing work would not only exist in programming
but amongst numerous technical and scientific endeavors. The scale of economic
expansion in India (as well as in China) cannot be underestimated. By the year 2025 India
could be in the top five, with an economy as large, or almost as large, as that of Japan and
Germany. Moreover it is estimated that across the third world two to three billion will
emerge from poverty to enjoy middle-class affluence in coming years. As we stand today
at the threshold of a new century, we stand at the beginning of a new industrial
revolution. An industrial revolution that will take place in the third world countries with
the help of developed countries by way of monetary investment, transfer of technology,
implementation of management and marketing strategies. As the dynamics of global
economics continue to change, so will major companies that will be at its core be an
agent of that change or be its very victim. Those that see and seize the opportunities will
win; those that fail to recognize the intensity of global competition will lose.
Foreign Direct Investment:
Foreign direct investment is a key ingredient in economic growth. It can impact the host
economy through a variety of channels: by adding to investable resources and capital
formation; by transferring technology, skills, innovative capacity, and organizational and
managerial practices between countries; and by accessing international marketing
networks. FDI contributes to a significant share of the domestic investment, employment
generation, exports etc. FDI inflow into India touched $4.26 billion in 2003 as compared
to $3.44 billion in 2002. With a 24% increase in FDI inflow, India has become one of the
top 10 FDI destinations among the developing countries while it is fourth among the
Asian economies. FDI inflow into the country would further increase with the recovery of
the global economy.
Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) is permited as under the following forms of investments.
1. Through financial collaborations.
2. Through joint ventures and technical collaborations.
3. Through capital markets via Euro issues.
4. Through private placements or preferential allotments.
5. Through GDRs( Global Depository Receipt) is treated as Foreign Direct
Investment (EURO issues).
FDI is not permitted in the following industrial sectors:
1. Arms and ammunition.
2. Atomic Energy.
3. Railway Transport.
4. Coal and lignite.
5. Mining of iron, manganese, chrome, gypsum, sulphur, gold, diamonds, copper,
39
zinc.
3.4. Politico-legal environment:
India suffered political instability for a few years due to the failure of any party to win an
absolute majority in Parliament. However, political stability has returned since the
previous general elections in 1999. However, political instability did not change India's
economic course though it delayed certain decisions relating to the economy. The
political divide in India is not one of policy, but essentially of personalities. Economic
liberalisation (which is what foreign investors are interested in) has been accepted as a
necessity by all parties including the Communist Party of India (Marxist). Thus, political
instability in India, in practical terms, posed no risk to foreign direct investors because no
policy framed by a past government has been reversed by any successive government so
far. You can find a comparison in Italy which has had some 45 governments in 50 years,
yet overall economic policy remains unchanged. Even if political instability is to return in
the future, chances of a reversal in economic policy are next to nil.
As for terrorism, no terrorist outfit is strong enough to disturb the state. Except for
Kashmir in the north and parts of the north-east, terrorist activity is either non-existent or
too weak to be of any significance. It would take an extreme stretching of the imagination
to visualise a Bangladesh-type state-disrupting revolution in India or a Kuwait-type
annexation of India by a foreign power. Hence, political risk in India is practically nonexistent..
A country's economic policy environment must be conducive for firms to achieve
efficiencies that will enable them to be globally competitive. It is also widely accepted
that taxation policy can have strong incentive effects on corporate decisions. CII interacts
closely with different levels of government to put forward industry's viewpoint. CII's
large membership enables us to be the most impartial and representative industry body,
with a high level of credibility with the government and key regulatory bodies. In order to
achieve our objective of influencing government policy, we undertake extensive research,
interact with key government officials and disseminate information through publications,
seminars and events. With a large network of offices across the country, we are able to
track policy issues in detail at the regional level. CII also interacts closely with the
Members of Parliament - the policy makers - across political parties to raise awareness
about the need for reforms, the need for change to keep up with in an extremely
competitive global economy. This has helped to keep up the flow of economic legislation
passing through Parliament.
Among the critical contingencies faced by every business firm is the need to
manage its social and political environment. Both the social and the economic
performance of the firm can be affected in significant ways by managerial strategies and
tactics; firms and their managers can be active players in efforts to improve their social
and economic bottom lines. Thus, this course will examine the public affairs environment
of the firm and the methods used by managers to navigate within it. The corporate social
40
performance of a firm and its economic results are characteristically intertwined: Both in
the short and the long run, failures to attend to social performance issues can produce less
than optimal economic results. Sometimes these issues present themselves in crises that
demand swift, effective managerial intervention. These very practical concerns
accompany the manager's role as a moral citizen who must successfully manage a
complex
set
of
ethical
issues.
The private corporation is only one of the means by which economic activity and
social endeavor in general may be organized. Private managers are likely to have
significant interaction with their public counterparts, not only in the context of public
regulation, as in the United States, but also in the contexts of a variety of public
enterprises. Such enterprises are far more common in the global economy than in our
domestic one. We shall therefore examine the characteristic behaviors of public and of
private enterprises. The corporation is a relatively recent invention. Ever since it evolved
in the last century, it has made active use of the benefits that only government can
provide. Far from being seen purely as a history of conflict, the tradition of businessgovernment relations should be understood more often as a history of mutual benefit. An
important focus in this course will be on the management of the business-government
interface. We shall look at the functioning of legislatures and the decision making
processes of regulatory agencies from the perspective of participation by business.
Participants in public policymaking typically include a constellation of actors, including
legislative committees, regulatory agencies and other government bodies, public and
private interest groups, courts, and so on. We shall examine the processes by which
influence is exerted in this system, including a look at the behaviors and strategies/tactics
of interest groups and the means by which firms make strategic use of the opportunities
presented to them in this system.
Government in this country is often characterized by rigid hierarchies, red-tapism,
complicated procedures, sluggish decision-making and lack of accountability. Little
wonder then, interaction with Government usually turns out to be cumbersome,
perplexing and pathetically slow. Public access to Government services is usually clumsy
and complicated. In a paper-based system, locating a correspondence or file in a
Government department can be a truly frustrating experience. The problem gets further
compounded in case of multiplicity of agencies. The advent of Information Technology
(IT) as a tool leveraging the delivery of services is universally acknowledged now. In
today's world, e-governance has actually given an opportunity of a paradigm shift in the
process of delivery of government services to the public.
Sweeping transformations have taken place in IT with the convergence of computing and
communication technologies. The advent of the Internet has thrown open numerous
possibilities. Groupware technology can also offer dramatic improvements in the intragovernment synchronization, optimisation of government resources, and decision support
systems to boost the efficiency and efficacy of the public policy. The major contributions
of groupware in improving organisational performance include on-line collaborative
work, electronic community development, knowledge management and workflow
41
applications. In such a scenario, information will be more directly accessible to decisionmakers and flow smoothly across departments through a common database and
compatible systems inter-linked under a secure high-speed networked environment. In
addition to a tangible improvement in the functioning of the administration, the
government-public interface shall undergo a radical change for the better.
The near absence of IT in a large number of government departments today offers both a
massive challenge and an outstanding opportunity to use state-of-the-art technologies to
shape the country's future. Developments around the globe are taking place at a
breathtaking pace, and unless we urgently take steps to plan for this new world of
technology in this millennium, the government itself may shortly face the peril of
becoming lesser relevant. Wrapped in a mystic enigma, government processes at present
give enormous discretion and power to the administration, with ample scope of its
misuse. In such a scenario, a properly conceived, developed and deployed model of egovernance will provide a rare opportunity to the government to reinvent itself and
evolve on an on-going basis. It will redefine the public-government relationship and the
business-government interface. By enabling improved connectivity and communication
between all stakeholders, e-governance truly has the potential to propel the country on the
path of overall advancement. Such a thriving model of e-governance shall also reinforce
India's emergent status of a global IT superpower.
With the rapid pace of change in the IT industry, there has been a shift in focus from the
traditional inputs of a production process to the processes involved in the creation,
storage, dissemination and use of information. An IT-driven system of s-Governance
works better, costs less, and is capable of servicing citizens' needs as never before.
Analogous to e-commerce, which allows businesses to transact with each other more
efficiently (B2B) and brings customers closer to businesses (B2C), s-Governance aims to
make the interaction between government and citizens (G2C), government and business
enterprises (G2B), and inter-agency relationships (G2G) more friendly, convenient,
transparent and inexpensive. The resulting benefits are a higher revenue growth and
reduced costs. With the advent of the Internet, the 'citizen as a shareholder' can now
provide several inputs to the government's policy-making process, while the 'citizen as a
customer' can demand better services from his government. Governments across the
globe are trying to make this a reality through implementation of information technology
initiatives. However, undertaking such initiatives without focusing on long-term goals
will result in 'islands of excellence' and render a myopic vision of e-governance.
Public policy and its implications:
Developing an appropriate public policy towards the industrial sector has been an
important task for Indian policy makers for a long time. When India moved away from an
inward looking industrialisation strategy to a more open economy in 1991, industrial
firms needed to restructure themselves to retain competitiveness. Much of these
restructuring is needed to correct the inefficiencies created by operating in a protected
market. The Automobile sector has been a major candidate in the industrialisation
42
process since the beginning of planned development. Automobile industry in India has
been subjected to substantial policy changes over the last two decades. The policy
changes were in two doses and took the form of partial de regulations introduced in 1985
and liberalisation measures launched since 1991. The pre 1985 regime could be described
as an era of strict controls and regulations. The initial changes, introduced in 1985, eased
the licensing requirements, broad-based the classification of vehicles for issue of licenses,
allowed selective expansion of capacity and partially relaxed controls with regard to
foreign collaborations, imports of capital goods, raw materials and spares. Though these
measures represented a "domestic liberalisation", the policy environment continued being
geared towards imposing trade and investment regulations, constraining the growth of big
business houses and regulating exchange rates. It was only after 1991 that notable broadbased changes in policy that had far reaching implications actually came into being.
These changes dispensed with the bulk of controls and regulations and for the first time
since independence assigned a central role to market forces. To list some of these
changes more explicitly - approval for foreign investment up to 51% equity holdings
came to be given automatically, most of the industries that comprise the manufacturing
sector were removed from the licensing network, the monopolies [MRTP] act was
amended - allowing big business houses to expand at will, domestic currency was made
convertible in the trade account, the exchange rate was allowed to be influenced by the
market and quantitative controls on imports of capital goods and components were
removed. In addition to these measures aimed specifically at the industrial sector, the
Government of India also adopted certain structural adjustment and macro stabilisation
policy measures during the post 1991 period. A growing body of literature has examined
the impact of liberalisation in industrial and trade policies on manufacturing sector
performance in different countries. While most of the studies focused on making inter
country comparisons, a few studies analyse the impact of trade liberalisation on
manufacturing productivity .It focuses on variables such as concentration, ownership,
size distribution, spatial distribution and total factor productivity growth, and their results
suggest that liberalisation does not have a major impact on the industrial structure under
examination explores changes in some key corporate strategies in response to economic
reforms introduced in India since 1991 and points out significant changes with respect to
mergers and acquisition activities of multinationals, foreign technology purchase, R & D
and manufacturing capabilities. Most of the earlier studies that attempted to analyse the
differential behaviour of firms in terms of conduct and performance variables have
brought out the differences between multinationals and local enterprises. Automobile
firms in India over the period 1987-88 to 1989-90, found that even within the
multinationals, Japanese affiliates differ from those of Western Countries.
For India to become a major player in world trade, an all encompassing, and
comprehensive view needs to be taken for the overall development of the countrys
foreign trade. While increase in exports is of vital importance, we have also to facilitate
those imports which are required to stimulate our economy. Coherence and consistency
among trade and other economic policies is important for maximizing the contribution of
such policies to development. It was felt that the Exim Policy with its limited focus may
not be able to meet our objectives. Thus, while incorporating the existing practice of
enunciating an annual Exim Policy, it is necessary to go much beyond and take an
43
44
freely and rapidly but which actually restrict and hamper its growth. We may highlight
here some of the problems of the private sector.
Procedural delays. In all developing countries --India is no exception-there are too many
regulations imposed by the Government on the private sector and too many procedural
delays. It is estimated on an average, it takes 7 years "from the conceptual stage to the
production stage for any significant investment to take place in India." Decisions which
used to be taken at one time at a low level of government bureaucracy are concentrated in
the hands of the top bureaucracy, or with the ministers and in some cases even with the
cabinet. There is no delegation of decision-making and in fact, even the smallest
decisions are taken at the top level, resulting in avoidable delay, cost escalation, and
higher burden on the consumers.
Unrealistic controls. The Government is influenced by contradictory motives, as for
instance, the protection of the consumers (price controls) and the prevention of
concentration of wealth and income (capacity restraint). The price controls imposed by
the government on many of the goods do not give proper incentive for additional
production. Actually, the Government should encourage competition among the rival
firms and increased production would automatically bring down the prices. On the other
hand, price controls under conditions of shortage tend to perpetuate shortage, rise of
black markets and possible shifting of investment from controlled items to the production
of non-controlled items. In this Connection, the system of dual pricing has been found to
be much better than unrealistic price controls. At one time, licensing of capacity was
meant to bring about organised growth and prevent monopolistic tendencies, hi
practice, however, it has emerged as something unique in the whole world. While attempt
is made to increase capacity to create more employment and produce more, India is the
only country in the world which penalizes increase in production. Capacity restraint is
indeed anti-investor and anti-consumer. Since 1980, and more recently after the
resumption of power by Mr. Rajiv Gandhi there has been a welcome trend of regularising
excess capacity in scheduled industries, removal of restrictions on creation of new
capacities, abolition of unnecessary controls and liberalization of controls wherever they
cannot be abolished.
Reservation for the small sector. The Government has generally worked on the
assumption that small industries are in conflict with large ones which always stifle the
growth of the small and cottage sector. Accordingly, the Government has attempted to
help the small sector in many ways. One method is to provide excise exemption or
impose, a lower rate of excise duties for goods produced in the small sector. Another
method is to reserve certain products in the small sector and prevent the large sector from
producing such goods. As a result of such measures, the complementarity of the two
sectors in the process of growth has been lost. While it may not be desirable to continue
reservations or differential excise duties for all Government. Unfortunately, considerable
controversy has been created in the definition of the joint sector and the industries that
should be brought under this sector. Part of this blame goes to the Dutt Committee Report
which used the term "joint sector" for the first time and gave not one but three concepts
of joint sector :
45
(a) Existing private enterprises belonging to the large industrial houses should be brought
under the joint sector by public financial institutions converting their loans into equity.
"In that case we would like to emphasise that they should be clearly treated as belonging
to the joint sector and not to the private sector."
(b) The joint sector would include those industrial units in which both public and private
investment had already taken place and where the State has already been taking an active
part in direction and control.
(c) A large sized industrial unit in Schedule B and C categories, necessitated on account
of technical and economic advantages of large scale, should necessarily be in the joint
sector to prevent concentration of economic power. In this case, the joint sector should be
treated as belonging to the public sector, for a large portion of the cost would be provided
by the Government and public financial institutions though, of course, private parties too
would be permitted to have equity participation.
3.5. Lessons for marketers:
The most striking feature of contemporary India is the rise of a confident new
middle class. It is full of energy and drive and it is making things to happen. In terms of
political power, it is erstwhile middle class that has climbed to the top in the social
hierarchy of modern societies. It has transformed itself into the ruling class by acquiring
control over the levels of state power. Property no more rules, even indirectly, these days.
Nor does labour in the peasant and workers states. It is the knowledge group
comprising not only politicians and bureaucrats but also business executives, company
directors, factory mangers, scientists engineers, technocrats, bankers, journalists,
intellectuals lawyers, doctors, teachers and many other belonging to liberal profession
and services sector, that does so. That group or class constitutes the political class and a
section of it the ruling elite. The two key attributes distinguishing the class from other
social classes are its possession of education or knowledge in the broad sense of the term
and leadership qualities that help to put the class at the top in all walks of social life.
The social climb that this class has experience has gone coincided
with
metamorphical change that the society in Western countries has undergone in socioeconomic political and ideological fields. The concept of democracy secularism, human
rights, social security, social justice and welfare state all parts of middle class philosophy
and ideology. Since the thought and ideology of the middle class has come to acquire
universal appeal, this has help to put the class in commanding position vis--vis the rest
of society. It has cast that class in the leadership role and vested it with decision making
regulation coordination and controlling power in terms various types of social activity
and relations. This class has come to constitute the elite in the modern societies. A part of
it forms the governing elite, the rest becoming non-governing elite. The governing elite
by virtue of its control over the livers of power in the state machinery an exercise of all
political powers on behalf of the state is bale to influence production and distribution of
income and wealth class relation, social change, and the political and economic
development of the society it governs. This makes it and instrument of history, an arbiter
of destiny of nation. They are historical forces which are set into motion by the action of
46
the elite itself, there are others that are autonomous in character which the elite it self as
to content with. The elite itself, of course, does not have absolute freedom of action. It
exercise of power is moderated by the consideration of its continuing to be in possession
of power against the challenge that the non governing elite poses to it in the matter. The
struggle for power between the governing and non-governing elites is a constant feature
of the modern state and the society. The struggle is intra-class and not inter class. The
masses do not compete for power with the elite. It is the difference sections of the elite
who do so among themselves. The battles are fought and struggles waged in the name of
ideology, national interest and welfare of the masses. Professions about promoting these
interest no all masks worn by the elites contenting for political power; a degree of
genuineness is always there. That degree differs from one society to another depending
upon the level of consciousness reached among the masses. The mote developed that
consciousness is and more enlighten the masses are the more difficult it would be for the
elite to mislead them by catch phrases, empty slogan and ideological swearing. In
advanced society the class as well as self-interest of the elite will coalesce with those of
the society as a whole. The elite circulation will still be there and may even be more
pronounced than in a comparatively less developed society but it will waste on the
account that the governing elite gives of it self when in power that on the relative
manipulative abilities of the contenting elites. The competition for power among the elite
will thus become a of social instrument had material advancement. That gives the
democratic system of the government an edge over dictatorship and absolute monarchy in
which cases power is monopolised by a single individual assisted by his coterie or
collectively by a cohesive oligarchy. This will augur well for the marketers in the Indian
context.
Modern technology has made the job of the marketer easier. Here a few tools that are in
use today for improving marketing processes,and building brand value:
SMS
One can locate the nearest pizza outlet or log on to a Web site to check out the
specifications of the new car you plan to buy.
i-Seminars
Seminars on the internet instead of physical seminars is better for the customer-no travel
time and expense.
E-marketing
No snail mailing,only e-mails;interactive Web information (no printing of brouchers)and
Web banners.
e-Surveys
Online market surveys of customers help in deciding product strategies,which result in a
greater possibility of acceptance of the final product or service,adding to the the brand
value of the organization.
Online billboards
Online billboards made of super-large plasma displays allow for time-sharing and instant
message revision.
Superior design tools
Better tools like Photoshop and illustrator allow a designer to do things that would have
required very expensive design workstations a decade or two ago.
47
Touch-screen kiosks
Touch sreen kiosks used to market and showcase brands at shopping mails
have changed the way a consumer can feel and experience a product on the shop floor.
Analysis tools
Better data mining technologies coupled with cheaper storage has accelerated the pace of
research,so that one can narrow down on ones target and focus better.At every point of
influence,
not
just
marketingawareness,acquisition,education,conversion,sale,service,support-role of technology has
changed our processes and efficiencies.
The Indian electronics and hardware industry has been lagging behind the impressive
performance of the software sector. Most of the hardware requirements of the burgeoning
software and telecom sectors are met by imports. The Indian government has recognised
the need to increase domestic output and formulated the Electronic Hardware Technology
Park (EHTP) scheme that offers various concessions for companies that manufacture
either electronic goods or components.
4. Have you understood type questions:
1. The marketing environment is BEST described as being:
A. Composed of controllable variables.
B. Composed of variables independent of one another.
C. An Indirect influence on marketing activity.
D. Dynamic and Changing
2. If the Kellogg Company decides to build a new cereal plant because it anticipates the
next five years will bring low unemployment and increases in buying power, it is
forecasting a period of:
A. Depression
B. Prosperity
C. Recovery
D. Austerity
E. Recession
3. Coca Cola markets its soft drink to members of Generation Y who love extreme sports
and are risk-takers. If Coca cola Dew began lobbying politicians and engaging in
advocacy advertising to support continued use of high fructose corn syrup and caffeine in
products targeted toward young people, the company would be engaging in:
A. Mass Marketing
B. Environmental Management
C. Target Marketing
D. Market Segmentation.
4. Ramji Systems have developed Movie Mask, a system that acts as a video censor by
interfering with the playback process so that supposedly offensive material never appears
48
on the television screen. For movie production companies, the Movie Mask is a(n)
________ factor in their external environment.
A.
B.
C.
D.
Technical
Economic
Social
Political
5. Summary:
There is a perceptible change in the mind set of the consuming class in India as is
evident from the social, cultural, political, technological and economic environments as
discussed in this unit. However, one change which is fast sweeping the country is the
advent of Internet. The medium of the Internet and the development of e-commerce are
progressing extremely fast on a global. However, while the Internet acts as a faster and
less costly platform for consumers and businesses it has inadvertently increased the
importance of customer satisfaction. By making transactions faster and easier it had
enabled the customer to switch just as quickly between e-businesses, causing the element
of competition to take on a new diversion. It is very important to achieve customer
satisfaction to get good financial performance in services in the physical world, and the
same can be said of e-commerce where a customer can be lost if unable to access a
Website or if the experience proves unsatisfactory.
6. Exercises
1. A marketing manager for a small computer manufacturer is analysing the potential
effects of political, legal, social, and economic forces on the firm's operations.
Develop an environmental analysis for him.
2. To effectively monitor changes in the marketing environment, marketers must engage
in what activities?
3. Conduct an evaluation of the consumption pattern of the Indian middle class.
4. Do you think all these MNCs rushing to India is based on the growing economic
clout of India? Justify your answer.
7. References
1. A.E.A., Readings in Business Cycle Theories, American Economic Association.
CLARK,J.J.AND CHEN, M.(EDS.), Business Fluctuations, Growth and
Economic Stabilization, Random House, N.Y.,1963.
2. Dauten, C.A., Business Cycles and Forecasting, South-Western Publishing Co.
Cinciantti, 1961,2nd Edn., Cchs.3-7.
3. Gordon, R.A., Business Fluctuations, Harper and Brothers Publishers,
NewYork,1952,Chs.8-12.
4. Haberler,G., Prosperity and Depression, United Nations, New York, 1952, 3rd
Edn., Parts I and II.
49
50
3. MARKETING MANAGEMENT
Marketing management is an important to operative function (as distinct from managerial
function) of management. It performs all managerial functions in the field of marketing.
It is responsible for planning, organizing, directing and controlling the marketing
activities. It is required to build up appropriate marketing-mix to achieve the objectives
of the business.
According to E.W. Cundiff and R.R still, Marketing management is concerned with the
direction of purposeful activities towards the attainment of marketing goals. The basic
goals of marketing are satisfaction of needs of customers and generation of revenue for
the business. Most of the big business enterprises organize the marketing activities
separately under the charge of a marketing manager. The marketing manager looks after
various aspects of marketing to achieve the objectives of marketing, viz; creation of
customers and satisfaction of their wants and earning of profits.
Marketing management attempts to contribute to the organizational objectives. It deals
with planning, organizing, directing and controlling the activities related to the marketing
of goods, ideas and services to satisfy the customers needs and contribute to
organizational objectives. The nature of marketing management is illustrated in the
following points.
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
(v)
3.1.NATURE OF MARKETING
1. Marketing is Customer-focused. Marketing intends to satisfy and delight the
customer. The activities of marketing must be directed and focused at the customer.
Marketers can remain in customer mind if they are provided value for what they spend.
Customer focus can optimize costs for the customer while allowing the organization to
focus on its core competencies. Todays customer makes constant trade-offs between
quality, price, and benefits. Thus, marketers must allow customers to dictate product
specifications and quality standards. Marketing efforts must be directed at meeting
customer needs, not market shares. For this, marketers must track customer needs on a
continuous basis.
2. Marketing must Deliver Value. Marketer have to track customer needs and
deliver the product as per their requirements. This is not an end in itself. The company
must satisfy the following equation with resultant value above 1 as seen in fig.1:
The corporate strategy must be aimed at delivering greater customer value than
competitors. The corporate planning, processes, and people must be re-configured
around the customer.
3. Marketing is Business. When customer is the focus of all activities marketer has
not to search customers to seek response to his products. Customer group is decided for
whom the product is prepared and presented.
4. Marketing is surrounded by Customer Needs. Marketing starts with the
identification of customer needs and requirements. These are turned into probable
features that might satisfy the basic needs. The portable form of product is made out and
presented before the customer for approval. The customer suggests changes or
improvements in the portable product and the final product is brought before the
customer. Fig .1.illustrates the point.
Identification of
Customer Needs (by
Marketing Deptt.)
Probable Features of
Product (Suggested
by Marketing Deptt.)
Final Product
(Presented Marketing Deptt.)
Portable
Product
(Assisted by
Marketing
Deptt.
Customer Suggests
Changes/Modifications
52
(Through Marketing Deptt.)
Financial
Institutions
Educational
Govt. Agencies
Ecological
Technical System
Marketing Organisation
R & D System
International
Financial system
Suppliers
Customers
Economic
Personnel System
Competitors
Labour Organisations
Socio-cultural
Politico-Legal
Marketing research
Product planning and development
Buying and assembling
Selling
Standardisation, grading and branding
Packaging
Storage
Transportation
54
(ix)
(x)
(xi)
(xii)
(xiii)
Salesmanship
Advertising
Pricing
Financing
Insurance
Functions of Marketing
(A)
Functions of
Research
(B)
Functions of
Exchange
1. Marketing
Research
1. Buying and
Assembling
2. Product
Planning and
Development
2. Selling
(C)
Functions of
Physical
Treatment
1. Standardisation
Grading and
Branding
2. Packaging
3. Storage
4. Transportation
(D)
Functions
Facilitating
Exchange
1. Salesmanship
2. Advertising
3. Pricing
4. Financing
5. Insurance
The functions of marketing may be classified into four categories as shown in the above
Fig.6
A. FUNCTIONS OF RESEACH
A1. Marketing Research
It means the intelligence service of the organization. Marketing research helps in
analyzing the buyers habits, relative popularity of a product, effectiveness of
advertisement media, etc. its major task is to provide the marketing manager with
timely and accurate information so that better decisions can be made. The scope of
marketing research is very wide. It may cover all the areas of business which have
bearing on the marketing function. In the words of W.J.Stanton, Marketing research
is the systematic search for and analysis of facts related to a marketing problem. Its
emphasis is shifting from fact finding, information gathering activity to a problem
solving and action recommending function.
A2. Product Planning and Development
A product is something which is offered by a business firm to customers to satisfy
their needs. It has great importance in all other areas of marketing management. For
instance, marketing research is mainly directed towards knowing the needs of the
customers and increasing the sale of the product; and storage and transportation
activities depend upon the nature of the product. Therefore, it is necessary to plan
and develop products which meet the specifications of then customers. Products are
the foundation of any marketing programme. The success of marketing department
55
depends upon the nature of the product offered to the customers. The product must
be so designed and developed that it meets the requirements of the customers.
Product planning and development involves a number of decisions, namely, what
to manufacture or buy? How to have its packaging? How to fix its price and how to
sell it? The design, quality, colours, size and other features of the product can be
determined by conducting marketing research. The product department will be
guided by the requirement of the users.
B. FUNCTIONS OF EXCHANGE
B1. Buying and Assembling
Procurement of raw materials, semi-finished or finished products has gained great
importance for the modern industrial and commercial enterprises. Raw materials are
purchased for production by the industrial enterprises and finished goods are
purchased for resale by the commercial enterprises. Whatever may be the case, the
marketing department plays an important role. It is the marketing department which
will supply the information regarding the needs and tastes of the customers.
Coordination between purchasing officials and the marketing officials will help in
purchasing right types of materials or goods at right time and in right quantities.
Purchasing is different from assembling. Purchasing involves determination of
requirements, finding the sources of supply, placing the order and receiving the
goods. But assembling means collection of goods already purchased from different
sources at a common point. It is also used in another sense. Raw materials are
purchased and assembled in order to produce goods and services.
B2. Selling
This is an important aspect of marketing under which ownership of goods is
transferred from the seller to the buyer. Sale may take the form of : (i) a negotiated
sale, and (ii) an auction sale. In case of negotiated sale, the terms and conditions
between the buyer and the seller are arrived at by bargaining or haggling. But in case
of an auction sale, there is no scope for negotiation between the seller and the buyer.
The buyers assemble at the place of auction and bid against one another for the goods
on sale. The goods are sold to the highest bidder.
Negotiated sale may take the following forms, namely, (a) sale by inspection ,(b) sale
by sample, (c) sale by description, (d) sale by grade, and (e) sale by brand.
C. FUNCTIONS OF PHYSICAL TREATMENT
C1. Standardisation, Grading and Branding.
Standardisation means setting up of specifications of a product. Grades of
agricultural products are based on these specifications and standards. Industrial
goods are given brand names by their manufactures to convey to the customers that
their goods conform to certain well-defined standards. These activities promote the
sale of products.
56
C2. Packaging
Packaging is traditionally done to protect the goods from damage in transit and to
facilitate easy transfer of goods to customers. But now it is also used by the
manufacturer to establish his branded products as distinct from those of his rivals.
Author activity connected with packaging is labeling. Labeling means putting
identification marks on the package. The label is an important feature of a product. It
is that part of a product which contains information about the producer and the
product. A label may be a part of a package or may be a tag attached directly to the
product. The label is sued to communicate brand, grade and other information about
the product.
Packaging has become one of the essential services f modern marketing. It acts as
a multi-purpose arrangement. It gives protection to goods on its route from
manufacturer to consumer. It even protects the goods during its life with the user.
Packaged goods are generally more convenient to handle. Packaging also gives
individuality to a product. It makes easier for the consumer to identify a product by
looking at its package.
Packaging facilitates the sale of a product. It acts as a silent salesman of the
manufacturer, particularly at a place where there is widespread use of self-services,
automatic vending and other self-selection methods of retail selling. Sometimes,
packages are duly sealed to ensure products of right quality to the consumers. In the
absence of sealing, duplicate products may be distributed to the consumers by
unscrupulous dealers.
C3. Storage
Goods are generally produced in anticipation of the demand. They have to be
stored properly in warehouses to protect them from any damage which may be caused
by ants, rats, moisture, sun, theft, etc.
Storage of goods in warehouses has become an indispensable service these days.
Producers, manufacturers, traders, mercantile agents, importers and exporters
engaged in business have to store their goods in warehouses. Goods are produced or
procured well in advance of the demand. They are stored in warehouses till they are
actually sold in the market. Thus, warehousing creates time utility. In addition,
modern warehouses perform certain marketing services also such as grading,
packaging, labeling, etc.
C4. Transportation
Modern organizations produce on a large scale to cater to the requirements of
customers scattered throughout the country. This calls for transportation of goods
from the place of production to the place of consumption. Transportation provides
the physical means which facilitate the movement of persons, goods and services
from one place to another.
57
58
59
As a result of women venturing out of home, there is expanded need for Day Care
Centres, Maids/Robots, Telephone, Steel Grills, Alarm System, Personal Security
Device, TV, VCR Video games, Personal Computers, etc., Table 3 helps to gauge as
to how marketing affects our lives.
Table 2. Effect of Marketing on Our Lives.
Reasons
Promoting Need
1. Division of
Joint Family
2. Greater
Complexity of
Products offered
Need
Product/Servce Required
Separation
Lawler, Documentation, Officers to
Nuclear Family Administer separation, TV, Radio,
set-up
conveyance, Coolers, Gas stove, Gas
cylinder refill, Chair, Table, Bed, Almirah
etc.
(Separate-sized product for each)
Specialists
Special Institutions to provide maintenance
for Air conditioners, cars, scooters,
computers, etc.
60
3.
4.
5.
6.
The person dealing with financial aspects is known as Finance Manager. The task
of the marketing management is to coordinate with other departments and expect
reciprocal coordination from other departments. Thus, if sales people feel that the
product is not up to the mark, the marketing management should order a probe by the
marketing research department which invariably should include representation from
production department. Otherwise, it would mean that sales persons were unable to
sell the product and therefore put blame on the defects in the product. In essence,
there should be proper coordination between the marketing and other departments.
Achieving Coordination
Marketing concept forces business firms to use an integrated approach in their
operations. Each firm should coordinate the activities of purchase, production,
finance, personnel and marketing departments to satisfy the needs and expectations of
customers. Thus, marketing should not be considered merely as a fragmented
assortment of marketing functions. Each and every department bas to contribute for
the satisfaction of customers and this needs proper coordination between the
functioning of all departments.
Coordination with Purchase and Production Departments
Marketing department is responsible for sales forecasts which are communicated
to all the departments of the firm. It has to prepare the time schedules for the
production and the purchase departments to inform them the dates by which goods
are to be manufactured and made ready for delivery. It informs the purchase and
production departments of the introduction of new substitutes and any change in the
prices of competitive goods. It also communicates about the quality of goods
committed by it to the customers. Information is also to be given in case of urgent
orders so that the purchase department is able to proceed immediately for the
purchase of materials required to execute the urgent orders.
Since marketing department is in touch with the present and prospective
customers, it should gather information about the change in taste or needs of the
people and pass it on to the purchase and production departments. This will enable
the purchase department to purchase right types of materials. The purchase
department should inform the marketing department about the changes in the cost of
raw materials to facilitate the latter in fixing competitive prices. There should always
be harmonious relations between the purchasing and marketing departments. The
marketing department must take assistance from the purchase department in
calculation of pricing of job contracts and in submitting bids or quotations so that
adequate profit margin is assured of such proposals.
Coordination with Finance Department
Every enterprise maintains a separate department known as Finance Department
which is responsible for managing the funds of the enterprise. There should be
harmony of relationship between the marketing and finance departments because
64
marketing department cant extend unlimited credit to the customers and credit
collections are to be made by the finance department. The finance department should
help the marketing department to determine pricing, cash discount and credit policies
under different conditions. So far as revenues are concerned, finance is dependent on
the marketing policies and revenues are concerned, finance is dependent on the
marketing policies and programmes, and their administration. Total sales revenues as
well as their timing significantly affect the cash flow of the business. Product pricing,
customer credit policies, terms and conditions of sales including trade, cash and
quantity discount, all have a vital bearing on the finances of the company. On the
other hand, availability of funds plays a crucial role in the planning and operation of
marketing programmes. All promotional activities including advertising, sales
promotion, etc., are dependent on the size of the budget. Customer credit and sales
administration policies are also closely related to the firms financial policies.
Coordination with Human Resource/Personnel Department
Coordination between marketing and human resource departments is important
for matching the total organization effort with market opportunity. The effectiveness
of marketing, as of any other function, depends on the quality of its personnel..
Marketing needs sincere, aggressive and innovative kinds of people. Its personnel
should also be adept in interpersonal and communication skills. The personnel
specialist can be of great assistance to the marketing manger in the recruitment,
selection, training, development and maintenance of a high quality of sales force and
other marketing personal. A suitable incentive scheme is also important to motivate
the sales-force. The personnel manager can provide expert advice to the marketing
manager in designing an effective incentive scheme.
4. Have you understood type questions:
1. All of the following are marketing management tasks EXCEPT:
A. marketing planning.
B. organising marketing activities.
C. co-ordinating marketing activities.
D. project development and analysis
2. Which one of the following is an example of a customer in an organisational
market?
A. a homemaker who buys detergent
B. a consumer who hires a solicitor
C. a shop owner who buys pencils for use in his shop
D. a plant manager who buys petrol for her personal car
3. An aggregate of people who, as individuals, have needs for products in a product
class and have the ability, willingness and authority to purchase such products is
called a:
A. market segment
B. target market
65
C. customer group
D. market
5. Summary
To sum up, an attempt should be made to develop integrated marketing in the firm
to serve the customers better. The marketing department cant achieve the marketing
goals independently; it has to seek the cooperation of all other departments, namely,
purchase, production, finance, legal, personnel, etc. All these departments must focus
on the customer to achieve integrated marketing.
6. Exercises
1. What according to you is the problem area between marketing and finance
department? Comment.
2. Explain the relevance of marketing concept to a monopoly organization?
Comment.
3. Discuss the provisions in the organizations policy which could prove to be a
benefit for an organization.
4. A company which is foraying into the states of Orissa, Bihar and Jharkhand for
marketing its toothpaste, what support the entire organization should give?
Explain.
7. References
1. Cundiff , E.W.Etol , Fundamentals of modern marketing, Prentice Hall of India
Pvt. Ltd. New Delhi.
2. De Bruicker , Stewart F., and Summe, Gregory., make sure your customers keep
coming back , Harward Business review, 1985.
3. Neelamegham, S., Marketing management and the Indian Economic, Vikas
Publishing (P) Ltd., New Delhi 1987.
4. Neelamegham, S., Marketing in India, cases and Reading , Vikas (P) Pvt. Ltd.
New Delhi 1992.
Market segmentation
1.Introduction:
Market segmentation is based on the generally true concept that the market for a
product is not homogenous as to its needs and wants. The opposite of market
segmentation is market aggregation, which is looking into one mass market. CocaCola practiced mass marketing when it sold only one kind of coke in a 6.5 ounce
bottle. The arguments for mass marketing is that it creates the largest potential
66
market, which leads to the lowest costs, which in turn can lead to lower prices or
higher margins. Long run production runs are more economical than short runs.
However, many critics point to the increasing splintering of the market, which makes
mass marketing more difficult. The more that market may be aggregated, the lower
the cost per thousand in buying advertising to reach that mass market, at least within
the range of certain promotional budgets. However in order to attract more local and
specialised markets, it becomes necessary that the companies need to segment the
market. Thus segmentation involves substantial use of advertising and promotion.
This is to inform market segments of the availability of goods or services produced
for or presented as meeting their needs with precision.
Market segmentation is the process of disaggregating the total market for a given
product into a number of sub-markets. The heterogeneous market is broken up in the
process into a number of relatively homogenous units. The process is based on the
recognition that (a) any given market or consumer group is made up of a number of
subgroups distinguished by varying needs and buying behaviour; and (b) it is feasible
to disaggregate the consumers into suitable segments in such a manner that the
characteristics of the segmented groups would vary significantly AMONG segment
but would almost be identical WITHIN segments.
Segmentation may also be practised through specialisation in sales force in one
market or the greater diversification of distribution channels. Segmentation is based
upon developments on the demand side of the market and represents a rational and
more precise adjustment of product and marketing effort to consumer or user
requirements. According to Wendell Smith, market segmentation consists of
heterogeneous market (one characterised by divergent demand) as a number of
smaller homogenous markets in response to differing product preferences among
important market segments.
2. Learning Objectives:
When you finish this unit, you should be able to:
Understand the need for segmenting the markets.
Understand the importance of micro marketing.
Understand the steps and process of market segmentation.
Understand the market segmentation in different industries and
Learn the difference between consumer and industrial segmentation.
3. Market Segmentation:
A company can segment its market in many different ways. And the bases for
segmentation vary from one product to another. However, the first step is to divide a
potential market into two broad categories; ultimate consumers and business users. The
sole criterion for this first cut at segmenting a market is the customers reason for buying.
67
Ultimate consumer buy goods or services for their own personal or household use
and are satisfying strictly non-business wants. Business users are business, industrial, or
institutional organizations that buy goods or services to use in their own organizations, to
resell, or to make other products.
3.1 Micromarketing:
segments or by defining a group seeking a distinctive mix of benefits. For example, the
segment of heavy smokers includes those who are trying to stop smoking and those who
dont care.
An attractive niche is characterized as follows: the customers in the niche have a
distinct set of needs: they will pay premium to the firm that best satisfies their needs; the
niche is not likely to attract other companies (competitors); the niche gains certain
economics through specialization; and the niche has size, profit and growth potential.
Both small and large companies can practice niche marketing.
C. Local Marketing
Target marketing is leading to marketing programmes being tailored to the needs
and wants of local customers groups (trading areas, neighbourhoods, even individual
stores). Citibank provides different mixes of banking service in its branches depending on
neighbourhood demographics. Those favouring localizing a companys marketing see
national advertising as wasteful because it fails to address local needs.
D. Individual Marketing
The ultimate level of segmentation leads to segments of one, customized
marketing, or one-to-one marketing. For centuries, consumers were served as
individuals. The tailor made the suit and the cobbler designed shoes for the individual.
Much business-to-business marketing today is customized, in that a manufacturer will
customize the offer, logistics, communication, and financial terms for each major
account.
3.2.Steps involved in segmentation process:
According to Philip Kotler, the main steps involved in the segmentation process are as
follows.
1.
Asses the differences between one customer group and the other in terms of their
needs and their likely responses to the product and other marketing inputs of the firm.
2.
Find out by what descriptive characteristics can consumers of a particular
disposition be tagged on to a specified segment.
3.
Based on the above, disaggregate the consumers into suitable segments.
4.
Analyse and establish whether it is desirable and possible to formulate separate
marketing programs and marketing mixes for the different segments.
5.
Find out which segments would be happy with the offerings of the firm and could
therefore be considered as the natural targets of the firm.
6.
Select those segment which offer high potential and which would be amenable to
the offerings of the firm.
Three stages are there for identifying market segments
a. Survey
b. Analysis
69
c. Profiling
a. Survey stage: The researcher conducts exploratory interviews and focus groups to
gain insight into consumer motivations, attitudes, and behaviour. Then the researcher
prepares a questionnaire and collects data on attributes and their importance ratings;
brand awareness and brand ratings; product usage patterns; attitudes towards the products
category; and demographics, geo graphics, psychographics and media graphics of the
respondents.
b. Analysis stage: The researcher applies factor analysis to the data to remove highly
correlated variables then applies cluster analysis to create a specified number of
maximally different segments.
c. Profiling stage: Each cluster is profiled in terms of its distinguishing attitudes,
behaviour, demographics, psychographics, and media patterns. Each segment is given a
name based on its dominant characteristics. One way to discover new segments is to
investigate the hierarchy of attributes that consumers examine in choosing a brand. 1)
Brand-dominant hierarchy, 2) Nation-dominant hierarchy, 3) Price dominant, and 4)
Type dominant.
3.3. Bases for segmenting consumer markets:
Two broad groups of variables are used to segment consumer markets. Some researchers
try to form segments by working at consumer characteristics: geographic, demographic
and psycho graphic. Then they examine whether these customer segments exhibit
different needs or product responses. Other researchers try to form segments by looking
at consumer responses to benefits sought, use occasions, or brands. Once the segments
are formed, the researcher sees whether different characteristics are associated with each
consumer- response segment.
3.3.1.Geographic Segmentation:
Geographic segmentation calls for dividing the market into different geographical units
such as nations, states, regions, counties, cities or neighbourhoods. The company can
operate in one or few geographic areas or operate in all but pay attention to local
variations.
For example, Godrej Sara Lee identified two different geographical
segments, the south India and the other regions for its mosquito repellant products. For
South India, the brand Jet was popular and throughout India the Good Knight brand
was the popular brand. So Good Knight was made the national brand while Jet was
made a regional brand.
3.3.2.Demographic Segmentation:
70
Segmentation based on age of the customer group, sex, family size, race, religion,
community, language, occupation, educational level, social level, family life cycle,
nationality and income level comes under demographic segmentation. To consider an
example, the market for consumer goods in India has been segmented by marketers
broadly into three segments; the high-income group, the middle class and the lower
income group.
3.3.3.Psychographic Segmentation:
In psychographics segmentation, buyers are divided into different groups on the basis of
life style or personality and values. People within the same demographic group can
exhibit very different psychographic profiles.
3.3.4.Behavioural Segmentation:
In behavioural segmentation, buyers are divided into groups on the basis of their
knowledge of, attitude toward, use of, or response to a product. Many marketers believe
that behavioural variables-occasions, benefits, user status, usage rate, loyalty status,
buyer-readiness stage, and attitude-are the best starting points for consulting market
segments.
3.3.5.Multi-Attribute Segmentation (Geo-clustering):
Several variables are combined to identify smaller, better-defined target groups. Thus a
bank may not only identify a group of wealthy retired adults, but also within that group
distinguish several segments depending on current income, assets, savings, and risk
preferences. One of the most promising developments in multi attribute segmentation is
called geoclustering. Geo clustering yields richer descriptions of consumers and
neighbourhoods than traditional demographics. The groupings take into consideration 39
factors in 5 broad categories. (1) Education and affluence, (2) family life cycle, (3)
urbanization, (4) race and ethnicity and (5) mobility.
3.4. Bases for segmenting buisiness markets:
Some of the bases for segmenting the consumer markets are also useful bases for
segmenting business markets. For example, business markets can be segmented on the
geographic basis. Some industries are geographically concentrated. For example, firms
that process natural resources locate close to the source to minimize shipping costs. Also,
businesses can be segmented on the basis of demographics. For example, the size of the
firm, the firms type of business, firms method of buying, etc. Sellers also can segment
on the benefits desired by the buyer and on product usage rates. To get a feel for business
market segmentation, lets look at segmenting by
71
1. Type of customer
2. Size of customer
3. Type of buying situation
For segmentation to be useful, the segments must be Relevant, Accessible, Sizeable,
Measurable, and Profitable.
3.5. Benefits of market segmentation:
1. One customer group can be distinguished from another with in a given market and
enables to decide which segment of the market should form as target market.
2. Facilitates in-depth study of the characteristics of the buyers.
3. Help marketing man to develop marketing programme on a predictable and reliable
base.
4. More suitable marketing offers for a particular segment can be easily developed.
5. Suitable marketing mix can be achieved.
6. Due to concentrated efforts most productive and profitable segments of markets can
be achieved.
7. It helps to assess competitors stand in the market.
8. Customers and companies can choose each other for mutual benefit and satisfaction.
3.6.Market segmentation in various industries:
3.6.1.Soap industry:
Laundry soap: very expensive detergents to wash things. General application, broad
distribution, low cost and medium advertising. Examples: Nirma. OK, Rin
Special laundry soap: To wash fancy things with stress cleaning effect, and will do not
harm the expensive garments as selling points. Distribution only to high-income
customers and retailers. High priced much advertising. Examples: Surf Excel, Tide
Low-grade toilet soap: For washing the body. Broad application, low price, low quality,
medium advertising and wide distribution. Examples: Nima, Lifebuoy
Premium toilet soap: For the luxury customer group, particularly women and high
bracket income-groups. Stress beauty as a selling point. Distribution only to highincome customers and retailers. High price, high quality and heavy advertising.
Examples: Dove, Aramusk, Lux international
Toilet soap for stores, offices and restaurants: For customers and employees to wash
their hands. Sell direct to the businesses. Packaged in large numbers per box, no
individual wrapping, no advertising and low priced.
72
Industrial soap: For washing hands after very dirty work. Higher cleansing power than
commercial soap. Sold directly to industry. Packaged in large numbers per
3.6.2.Watch industry:
The Titan Company segments its market on the basis of
1. Geographic location of customers. Quite common is the rural and urban divide in the
consumer market. Sonata range is segmented for smaller towns and rural areas where the
company is looking at brand switches.
2. Life style pattern: Digital fastrack is designed especially for the trendy and sporty.
So far digital watches have always had a stereotyped image either around specification of
sports. With 22 variants in four series, Titans new collection aims to provide a wide
choice for the fashion conscious 15-24 age group.
3. Based on age: Titan produces watches for children in the brand Dash and youth.
4. Based on sex: Company produces variety of products aiming and beefing its presence
in the women market titan has launched variety of products like sonata, regalia, for, men
and has new range of fast track watches for woman aged 18-30 a fashion branch to match
the aspirations of woman.
5. Based on income: Titan launches variety of products based on the purchasing power
of people the titan sold it products for the range from 450/- on wards to 30,000.
3.6.3. Indian car industry:
Indian car industry can be classified based on the price of the car, into the small car or the
economy segment, mid-sized segment, luxury car segment and super luxury car segment.
The various models in the segments of the car market can be classified as:
Economy segment
Mid-sized segment
Luxury segment
:
Maruti Omni, Maruti 800, Maruti Alto, Chevy Spark
:
Ambassador Nova, Fiat Palio, Maruti Zen Estilo, Hyundai
Santro,
Tata Indica, Maruti Swift, Maruti Wagon R, Chevy Aveo
UVA,
Hyundai Getz
:
Maruti SX4, Tata Estate, Tata Sierra, Chevy Aveo
Honda City, Mitsubishi Lancer, Ford Fiesta, Huyndai
Accent,
Hyundai Verna
Super Luxury segments:
a. Demographic
b. Psychographic
c. Geographic
d. Family life cycle
5. By offering Colgate for Kids (attractive taste for children), Regular Colgate,
Colgate Total and Colgate Herbal toothpastes, it is segmenting the market based
on:
a. benefits
b. psychographics
c. lifestyle
d. demographics
5.Summary
Segmentation emphasizes the importance of knowing and targeting current
customers. Most companies do not have a proper balance of targeting current
customers for retention and prospective customers for acquisition. Because of the
traditional emphasis on transactions rather than relationships and acquiring new
customers rather than retaining and growing current ones, many marketing programs
have not been as cost-efficient as they could be.
6. Exercises
1. Develop a market segmentation for the following:
a. Dish washers
b. Microwave ovens
c. Laptop computers
2. What are the factors that influence the development of a market segment?
Explain.
3. Develop a strategy for segmenting industrial markets. Cite examples.
4. Classify the lifestyles in India and break down the same for the benefit of
manufacturers of consumer durables.
7. References
1. Frank.E.Ronald, Massy.F.William, Yoram Wind, Market Segmentation, Prentice
Hall of India, 1972, pp.113-114.
2. Davar.S.Rustom, Modern Marketing Management, Universal Bookstall, 7th
edition, pp.147-149.
3. Stanton.J.William, Etzel.J.Michael, Walker.J.Brue, Fundamentals of Marketing, Mc
GrawHill Inc., 10th edition pp. 123-126.
75
The product can be positioned for an exclusive well to do segment of the market,
it can be positioned for men, for children, for fun loving youth, for health conscious
market, it can be a claim on luxury, a claim on distinctiveness, a claim of convenience,
economy, novelty, usage. The marketer cannot invent a positioning theme when he is
ready to enter the market with his product. He should have already decided what his cash
on point should be where he should introduce his product for whom and on what
distinctive claim he should go around and promote his product.
Thus as a comprehensive definition positioning can be viewed as
The position of a brand is the perception it brings about in the mind of the
target customer.
This perception reflects the essence of the brand in terms of functional and
non-functional benefits in the judgement of that consumer.
All products can be differentiated to some extent. But not all brand differences
worthwhile or meaningful. A difference is worth establishing to the extent that it satisfies
any of the following criteria.
Important- the difference delivers a highly valued benefit to a sufficient
number of buyers.
Distinctive- the difference is delivered in a distinctive way.
Superior the difference is superior to other ways of obtaining the benefit.
Preemptive- the difference cannot be easily copied by competitors.
Affordable- the buyer can afford to pay for the difference.
Profitable the company will find it profitable to introduce he difference.
3.1.Some of the principles of positioning are:
1. It is better to be the first than to be late. The selectivity of the mind is such that the
pioneer will always have a presence in the mind-set of the consumers. Hence
companies like Thums up, Amul, Xerox etc., are still in the minds of the
consumers.
2. In case not the first, then the company should be able to create a new category by
making even a small change in the marketing mix elements. AIWA and AKAI
created a pricing strategy through replacement market and got into the minds of
the consumers. Maruti created a small car market through product innovation.
3. It is important to understand the position and strategies of the competitors. It is
clear that the competitors strengths and weaknesses should be known to the
company. Britannia did the repositioning exercise to overcome the competition
and similarly Tata Indica gave a scare to Maruti when they introduced their small
car in the market. Certain strategies usually adopted by competitors for
positioning
Strengthen its own current position in the customers mind.
77
The famous advertising line from Avis acknowledged its position in the car
rental business and claimed We are number two. We try harder.
Grab an unoccupied position.
Complan is advertised as the complete food for the growing children.
Deposition or reposition the competition
Exclusive club strategy which is the Three Big idea and implies that those in
the club are the best.
4. Positioning using an easy name is very important in this context. Names like LG
is easy to pronounce as compared to the earlier name, Goldstar. Similarly, Bata
is found to be recalled better than LeeCooper.
3.2. Positioning errors:
As companies increase, the number of claims for their brand, they risk disbelief and a
loss of clear positioning. In general, a company must avoid four major positioning errors.
1. Under positioning: Some companies discover that buyers have only a vague idea of
the brand. The brand is seen as just another entry in crowed market place.
2. Over positioning: Buyers may have too narrow an image of the brand. Thus a
consumer might think that diamond rings at Tiffany start at $5000 when in fact
Tiffany now offers affordable diamond rings starting at $1000.
3. Confused positioning: Buyers might have a confused image of the brand resulting
from the companys making too many claims or changing the brands positioning too
frequently.
4. Doubtful positioning: Buyers may find it hard to believe the brand claims in view of
the products features, price, or manufacturer.
78
3. Use or application Positioning: Positioning the product as best for some use or
application. The Suzuki Samurai no problem bike is a classic example in this
category. DCold was positioned as a vapourub for adults.
4. User positioning: Focussing the product as best for some user group. Business today
position itself as a business magazine used by the top managers.
5. Competitor based positioning: The product claims to be better in some way than a
named competitor. For example, Pepsodent position itself as being able to reduce the
number of germs in the teeth of the users when compared to the other brands of
toothpaste. Pepsi used nothing official about it to counter the official drink status of
Coca-Cola during the Cricket World Cup in 1996.
6. Product category positioning: The product is positioned, as the leader in a certain
product category. Aquafresh position its dental paste not as toothpaste but rather a
mouth paste.
7. Quality or Price positioning: The product is positioned as offering the best value.
Bajaj scooters position itself as a product that offers value to the customers money.
In the automotive field, positioning by price and quality is common. In recent years,
luxury cars that accentuate quality and carry comparatively high prices have
proliferated; Infiniti and Lexus are the latest noteworthy entries. However, the makers
of luxury cars are having trouble differentiating themselves from each other with
respect to important attributes such as performance, comfort, and safety. As a result,
consumers are confused.
8. Positioning in relation to a target market: Regardless of which positioning strategy
is used, the needs of the target market always must be considered. This positioning
strategy doesnt suggest that the other ones ignore target markets. Rather, with this
strategy, the target market rather than another factor such as competition is the
focal point in positioning product. Nestle offers different products using this strategy
those address different consumers desires regarding taste, calories and price.
79
(4) How do the competitors brand favour in the ideal product map. Here the
customers are asked to assess competitor brands and specify how close or far they
are on each attribute to the ideal product.
(5) Based on the assessment of competitor brands on the ideal product map, product
managers identify vacant slots and then build the positioning strategy by filling
these up. It is important to note here that if an attribute sought by a customer is
not high on his/her priority and the firm feels it has the strength in it and should
be considered by the customers, the firm can adopt a strategy to help change this
perception. But the customer perceptions should be continued for, changing
customer perceptions in a long drawn out strategy involving substantial resources.
After this perceptual mapping is done, the marketer uses statistical techniques to
arrive at a position.
3.5.Most common positioning strategies in the consumer durable sector:
1. Benefit/use positioning:
The positioning strategies adopted by consumer durable depend a lot on usage,
economy and corporate identity of which a well established brand surely projects
the identity of the product in terms of which corporate house the product is from.
Benefit or usage is the next positioning strategy used. For e.g.: - BPL Converti
projects out the multi usage of the product. This strategy is based on identifying the
possible uses to which the firms brand can be put to. In a way it may appear same as
use situations but differs from it because this talks on all the possible uses of a
product or brand. For e.g.: - since video cassette recorders (VCRs) could be used in
playing, recording and regulating the pace at which the different scenes can be
watched (like pause, forward etc) most customers saw it as a distinct development
over the video cassette player and the demand for VCR boomed.
2. Competitor related positioning:
This is the strategy of placing a firms brand next to the leader in the market and
trying to uproot it on a specific tangible variable. . To fend off rival makers of
microprocessors, Intel corp. launched a campaign to convince buyers that its product
is superior to competitors. The company even paid computer makers to include the
slogan, Intel inside, in their ads. Coca-Cola and Pepsi-Cola compete directly with
each other in virtually every element of the marketing mix (even celebrity endorsers).
For e.g.: - Onida was positioned against the giants in television industry through this
strategy. For Onida colour TV was launched on the message that all others were
clones and only Onida was the leader and the message said the boss wasnt late; it
was others who arrived in a hurry and later followed it with the envy concept. Today
Onida has been able to uproot all the yesteryears leaders in the TV market.
3. Lifestyle positioning:
A firm may even position the brand as a lifestyle contemporary or futuristic. Many of
todays new kitchen appliances like microwave ovens are positioned accordingly.
80
81
makes the most sense is for the company to improve its service and promote this
improvement.
(1)
Competitive
advantage
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
Company
standing
Competitor
standing
Importance
of
improving
standing
Affordability
and speed
Competitors
ability to
improve
standing
Recomme
nded
action
H-M-L
H-M-L
H-M-L
Technology
Hold
Cost
Monitor
Quality
Monitor
Service
Invest
3.8.Disadvantages of positioning:
It is not possible to offer a product wholly for a specific type of customers.
The wrong positioning has affected a number of products.
3.9.Examples of positioning in the Indian context:
The Positioning of Great shake
-Health drink,
-Against milk
-Soya milk was positioned against a universal product; milk, appealing to a
health conscious market. However unpalatability to Indian tastes made the
product a failure.
The Positioning of Complan:
82
3.10.Perceptual mapping:
Perception is the meaning added by an individual to the information that has been
obtained from the environment. This forces a consumer to create his own ideas or say,
perception about a brand/product. If consumer feels that branded footwear are costly,
he/she will always try to buy from unorganised market. Similarly, a customer might feel
that Raymonds products are of high quality without even having an experience of the
product. When a brand creates a proposition, it chooses a position, which will enable it to
differentiate itself from other brands. As consumers get used to this position, a close
association develops between the brand and the proposition. Subsequently, this
association defines what the brand stands for and it is important for a brand to continue
and nurture that proposition or develop on it. This can be done through mapping the
perceptual thinking of the prospective customers. This method is known as perceptual
mapping.
In order to construct a perceptual map for say readymade garments; it is necessary
first to identify the features that are more widely expected by the customer. Based on the
market research and from the inputs of the experts/executives, following ten dominant
features have been identified:
Wrinkle free
Fashion
Perfect fit
Quality fabric
Good looks
Attractiveness
Color options
Popularity
Stitching and
Economical
With the above features, the perceptual map can be constructed by taking the two
outstanding features in the two axes as in the following figure. Those features can be
Quality and Price.
83
From the perceptual map, it is clear that the brands bearing foreign impressions are
falling in the first quadrant where the features like Wrinkle free, fashion, quality fabric
etc., are found. Color plus, Provouge brands are lying in the second quadrant which
denotes the features like perfect fit, colour options, popularity etc. This quadrant gives
less consideration to quality. The features like economical is taken in fourth quadrant
where the brands like Excalibur and Parx are plotted. This plotting of the perceptual map
gives a direction for any new entrant in the readymade garments about the consumer
psyche. Features must essentially translate into benefits in the consumers mind, and be
offered at a price where the price-value equation meets, is the lesson for the new entrant
in this sector.
High Price
Perfect fit
Colour options
popularity
Stitching
Colour plus .
Provouge .
Wrinkle free
Fashion
Quality fabric
. Arrow
. Louis Phillipe
. Zodiac
. Van Huesen
Attractiveness
Good looks
. Peter England
High Quality
Low quality
. Parx
. Cambridge
.Excalibur
. Kumar
Economical
Low price
Many products can be differentiated in form, the size, shape or physical structure of a
product. Consider the many possible forms taken by products such as aspirin. Although
aspirin is essentially a commodity, it can be differntiated by dosage size, shape, coating,
action time and so on. The UPS as is being used in Personal Computers and other
electronic devices have undergone such changes in size that from a vary bulky
equipment, one cannot even see an UPS now. To that extent miniaturisation has taken
place in this sector.
Features:
Most product can be offered with varying features, characteristics that supplement the
products basic function. Being the first to introduce valued new features is one of the
mose effective ways to compete. Companies must also think in terms of feature bundles
or packages. During 1992-93, when Kinetic Honda conducted market research, it showed
that most of the existing two-wheelers were not user friendly. Starting was the problem to
the user. Kinetic Honda brought in a scooter which had an electronic ignition dispensed
away with the boring kick-start routine as a stand-by. In addition the new model
contained a whole new range oof features including automatic gear shifting, choke, builtin indicators and a stream lined aerodynamic design.
The major differentiation through features as evident from Colour Television industry
are:
Screens are modified into super flat ones from the ususal tinted screens.
Interactive picture set modes
Bass, treble, 3D Surround effects, Dolby noise reduction, pitch adjustments
Number of channels nearing 210 in AIWA and 200 in Konka.
High Definition Televisions, Plasma televisions
Performance Quality:
Performance quality refers to the level at which the products primary characteristics
operate. This is to be focussed only when the company is certain that offering higher
product performance produce higher profitability. Quality link to profitability does not
mean that the firm should design the highest performance level possible. There are
diminishing returns to ever-increasing performance. The manufacturer must design a
performance level appropriate to the target market and competitors performance levels.
Conformance Quality:
Conformance quality is the degree to which all the produced units are identical and meet
the promised specifications. The problem with low conformance quality is that the
product will disappoint some buyers. Maruti for instance offers specific technological
product differentiations based on the model bought by the customers. Multi point fuel
injections, All Aluminium Combustion Engine are only available with specific models.
85
IFB washing machines are still famous mainly because of the fact that their front loading
machines have been performing without any defects.
Durability:
It is the measure of the productss expected operating life under natural or streeful
conditions, is a valued attribute for certain products. Buyers will generally pay more for
vehicles and kitchen appliances that have a long-lasting reputation. Tinting machines are
being introduced by Asian Paints to differentiate their shades since actual handling is not
possible to show the durability of the paints. This has also helped solve the logistics
problem as the dealers can now stock only the base material and thus save almost 20-25%
in the working capital cycle.
Reliability:
Reliability is a measure of the probability that a product will not malfunction or fail,
within a specified time period. Buyers normally will pay a premium for more reliable
products. Dunlop car tyres showed their reliability by advertising the special kind of
tyres for each brand. For a Maruti, a tyre was specially desinged for its front wheel drive.
An extra wide tyre was desinged for Premier Padmini because it goes through a lot of
wear and tear on city roads and for the Ambassador, the tyre walls with extra rubbe to
take the extra weight.
Repairability:
Repairability is a measure of the ease of fixing a product when it malfunctions or fails.
Buyers prefer products that are easy to repair. An automobile made with standard parts
that are easily replaced has high repairability. Channel differentiation in terms of number
of Maruti service centres made Maruti a successful one.
Style:
Style describes the products look and feel to the buyer. Buyers are normally willing to
pay a premium for products that are attractively styled. Car buyers pay a premium for
Weekender models because of their extraordinary look. We must include packaging as a
styling weapon, especially in food products, cosmetics, toiletries, and small consumer
appliances. The package is the buyers first encounter with the product and is capable of
turning the buyer on or off.
Design:
As competition intensifies, design offers a potent way to differentiate and position a
companys products and services. Design is the factor that will often give a company its
competitive edge. Design is the totality of features that affect how a product looks and
functions in terms of customer requirements. Design is particularly important in making
and marketing durable equipment, apparel, retail services, and packaged goods. Some
86
companies confuse design with styling and think that design is a matter of enclosing an
average product in a stylish casting. Or they think that reliability is something to catch
during inspections rather than designing it into the manufacturing process.
For example, for many people, brushing is a ritual to which they pay relatively little
attention. As a consequence, many brushes are used well past the point when their
bristles are worn and are no longer effective. Toothbrush maker Oral B discovered a
way to capitalize on this widespread habit. The company, by introducing a patented blue
dye in the center bristles of its toothbrushes found a way to have the brush itself
communicate to the customer. As the brush is used, the dye gradually fades. When the
dye is gone, the brush is no longer effective and should be replaced
Similarly, John Scully marketing team at Pepsi cola used packaging as a way to
differentiate Pepsi from Coke. They created a distinct, if temporary advantage for Pepsi
by designing plastic bottles that where lighter and thus easier for customers to carry, than
the heavy glass bottles of the time. They called it the beauty on the move and that it not
only made carrying soda easier, but it also reduced the advantage of Cokes well known
contoured bottle. At the time ,it was difficult to produce plastic bottles in that shape.
3.12.Characteristics of differentiation strategies
There are a variety of ways to differentiate. Whatever the route, the successful
differentiation strategy should have three characteristics.
Generate customer value
Provide perceived value
Be difficult to copy
Differentiation strategy needs to add value for the customer. A distinction is
needed between apparent value and actual value. Too often a point of difference with
apparent value is not valued by the customer. The one stop financial service vision was
not valued by customers they wanted excellence and competence from investment
managers, and aspirin products had much less value in the market than was hoped. The
value of the Bayer name did not transfer to new product classes. One key to a successful
differentiation strategy is to develop the point of differentiation from the customers
perspective rather than from the perspective of the business operation. How does the
point of differentiation affect the customers experience of buying and using the product?
Does it serve to reduce cost, add performance, or increase satisfaction?
Another method for differentiating a product is to employ market research to
systematically understand the customer and to test ideas and assumptions. One role of
market research is to insure that the value added will justify the price premium involved.
A differentiation strategy is often associated with higher price, because it usually makes
87
price less critical to the customer and because differentiation usually costs something.
The question is whether that price premium works in the marketplace.
The perceived value problem is particularly acute when the customer is not
capable of evaluating the added value. Consider the airline safety or the skill of a dentist.
The customer is unable to evaluate them without investing a significant time and effort.
Rather than expand such effect, the customer will look for the signals such as the
appearance of the aircraft or the professionalism of the dentists front office. The task is
then to manage the signals or the cues of value added. User association and endorsements
can help. Oral B is the toothbrush recommended by the dentists and Air jordan is
endorsed by Michel jordan.
The point of differentiation needs to be sustainable. A value added such as 24hour support is relatively easy to copy if it proves successful. The challenge is to create
differentiation strategies that are difficult to copy. One reason to identify two strategic
thrusts synergy from the previous chapter and first mover advantage in the next is that
when they are combined with a differentiation thrust, sustainability is more likely. When
the point of differentiation involves a total organisational effort with a complex set of
assets and skills, it will be difficult and costly to copy, especially if there is a dynamic
constantly evolving quality to it. A creative organisation with heavy R&D investment,
such as that of Microsoft, will inhibit duplication. The quality option and building strong
brands can also require a total organisational effort.
c. attribute
d. image
5. Summary
Many kinds of efforts that were given to produce differentiation in the product
being offered have failed. For example Westin Stamford hotel in Singapore advertises
that it is the worlds tallest hotel. But the tourists were least bothered about the height of
the hotel. Hence each firm needs to develop a distinctive positioning for its market
offering which is very much relevant in the benefit being provided by the product. Take
the case of an excellent positioning strategy being used by Volvo (station wagon). They
are aiming at the safety conscious upscale families and the positioning strategy is very
much related with the benefits being offered which are durability and safety. They
position the product as the safest, most durable wagon in which your family can ride.
Differentiation is the act of designing a set of meaningful difference to distinguish the
companys offering from competitors offerings. Most profitable strategies are built on
differentiation; offering customers something they value that competitors dont have. But
most companies in seeking to differentiate them, focus their energy only on their products
or services. In fact, a company has the opportunity to differentiate itself at every point
where it comes in contact with its customers from the moment customers realize that
they need a product or service to the time when they no longer want it and decide to
dispose of it. It is believed that if companies open up their creative thinking to their
customers entire experience with a product or service what the company call
consumption chain they can uncover opportunities to position their offerings in ways
that they, and their competitors, would never have thought possible. Physical products
vary in their potential for differentiation. Product differentiation has a close linkage with
product positioning. It is in a way a prelude to product positioning. At one extreme we
find products that allow little variation: salt, steel, paracetamol. Yet even here, some
differentiation is possible. HLL makes several brands of laundry detergent, each with a
separate brand identity. At the other extreme are products capable of high differentiation,
such as automobiles, commercial buildings, and furniture. Duplication by competitors
requires not only ability but will. Increasing the investment or risk involved will
discourage competitors. If, for example, multiple points of differentiation are involved,
duplication will be more expensive. Duplicating only one aspect of this differentiation
strategy would be inadequate. Over investment in a value added activity may pay off in
the long run by discouraging competitors from duplicating a strategy. For example , the
development of a superior service back up system might discourage competitors. The
same logic can apply to a broad product line. Some elements of that line might be
unprofitable, but if they plug holes that competitors could use to provide value, then the
analysis looks different.
6. Exercises
1. Develop a perceptual map for automobiles (cars) in the Indian context.
2. What is positioning errors? Can you identify during the last one year in selected
industries.
89
3. What is the role of advertising agency in making positioning statements? Identify the
same from two agencies (national) of your choice.
4. Explain the positioning of Surf Excel and Tide and justify your answer.
5. What is the difference between product positioning and brand positioning? Explain
with examples.
7. References
1. Adrian Slywotzky and Benson Shapiro, Leveraing to beat the odds: The new
marketing mindset, Harvard Business Review, September- October 1993, pp.100107.
2. Claudio Romano, Identifying factors which influence product innovation: a case
study approach, Journal of Management Studies, January 1990, pp.78-92.
3. Devine Hugh and John Morton, How does the market really see your product?,
Business Marketing, July 1984, pp.70-77.
4. Ian C. MacMillan and Rita Gunther McGrath, Discovering New Points of
Differentiation, Harward Business Review, July-August 1997, pp133-145.
5. J.Karel, Brand strategy positions products worldwide, Journal of Business Strategy,
May-June 1991, pp.16-19.
6. John Rockwell and Marc Particelli, New product strategy: How does the pros do
it?, Industrial marketing, May 1982, pp.49-60.
Product management
1. Introduction:
Dominiquez conceives product management as a hexagon and found to have the
following as the important aspects:
Product
Forecasting
Planning
Market
Profit and
Coordination
According to Philip Kotler, there are five levels of a product. Marketing managers need
to think their way around five different levels of product when working through the
essentials of the offer which is going to be made to the customers. They are:
The core benefit: The basic benefit which is what the customer really wants when
deciding on a particular product. For example, a toothpaste which is able to clean the
teeth.
The generic product: This is the basic version of the actual physical product, for example,
an electric cooker.
90
The expected product: A set of attributes and conditions that buyers normally agree to
when they purchase a product. For example, a soap is expected to last long and at the
same time does not wear away due to water.
The augmented product: The product includes additional services and benefits which help
to distinguish it from competitive offerings, for example, a manufacturer of television
might extend the normal warranty period from one year to say three years. In fact,
SHARP television offered seven years warranty.
The potential product: At the final level stands the product of the future, namely all the
transformations and augmentations that a particular product might undergo in the future.
This is where the companies search for new ways to satisfy their customers and
differentiate their products. The emergence of Hyper markets is one example.
It is hence imperative that you are given a indepth information on what is product, why
product management is important to organizations, the ways of new product development
and its entry into the market etc. Let us learn them in detail.
2. Learning Objectives:
When you finish this unit, you should be able to:
Understand the various product levels and their importance .
Understand the different aspects of product life cycle
Understand the product management issues and problems .
Understand the ways of new product management and their steps .
3. Product management:
Product is any thing that can be offered to a market to satisfy a want or need. Products
that are marketed include physical goods, services, experiences, events, persons, places,
properties, organizations, information, and ideas. A product mix (also called product
assortment) is the set of all products and items that a particular seller offers for sale. For
example, Kodaks product mix consists of two strong product lines: information products
and image products. A companys product mix has a certain width, length, depth, and
consistency. These concepts are illustrated below.
Width:
The width of the product mix refers to how many different product lines the
company carries. Hindustan Unilever Limited (HUL) has different product lines. It offers
different products for the consumers. The product lines offered by HUL are Home and
Personal care, Food and Beverages and Industrial, Agricultural and others.
Length:
91
The length of a product mix refers to the total number of items in the mix. This is
obtained by dividing the total length by the number lines. Procter and Gamble offers
different product line width. It offers different brands under detergents like Tide, Ariel.
Depth:
The depth of a product mix refers to how many variants are offered of each
product in the line. Hindustan Unilever Limited offers tooth paste named Close Up at
different sizes like 20 grams, 50 grams, 150 grams etc. In this case HTL had a product
depth of three.
Consistency:
The consistency of the product mix refers to how closely related the various
product lines are in terms of the end use, production requirements, distribution channels,
or some other way. P&Gs product lines are consistent insofar as they are consumer
goods that go through the same distribution channels. The lines are less consistent insofar
as they perform different functions for the buyers.
These four product mix dimensions permit the company to expand its business in
four ways. It can add new product lines, thus widening its product mix. It can lengthen
each product line. It can add more product variants to each product and deepen its
product mix. Finally, a company can pursue more product-line consistency.
COMPANIES
PRODUCT MIX
WIPRO
RELIANCE
UB
MODI
TTK
92
Godrej offers different brands of refrigerators, soaps and other things to its
consumers. Did this diverse assortment of products developed by accident? No --- it
reflects a planned strategy by the company. To be successful in marketing, producers and
middlemen need carefully planned strategies for managing their product mixes.
Product-mix expansion
Product-mix expansion is accomplished by increasing the depth within a
particular line and/or the number of lines a firm offers to consumers. Lets look at these
options. When a company adds a similar item to an existing product line with the same
brand name, this termed a line extension. For illustrations, pull the coupons insert out of
your Sunday newspaper. For example Pepsi-cola company introduced many new flavors
for its drink like Diet Pepsi, Lehar Team etc. Like wise Coca-Cola Company introduced
news flavors like sprite, diet coke etc. The line extension strategy is also used by
organizations in service fields. For example, universities now offer programs to appeal to
prospective older students, and the Roman Catholic Church broadened its line of
religious services by adding Saturday and Sunday evening masses. There are many
reasons for line extensions. The main one is that the firm wants to appeal to more market
segments by offering a wider range of choices for a particular product. Line extensions
might be the most pronounced trend in marketing during the early 1990s. As discussed in
the nearby box, line extensions have become so common as to raise questions about their
effectiveness. Another way to expand the product mix, referred to as mix extension, is to
add a new product line to the companys present assortment. To illustrate, when Johnson
& Johnson introduced a line of Acuvue disposable contact lenses, that was mix extension
because it added another product to the companys product mix. In contrast, line
extension adds more items within the same product line. When J&J adds new version of
baby soaps, thats line extension. Under a mix-extension strategy, the new line may be
related or unrelated to current products. Furthermore, it may carry one of the companys
existing brand names or may be given an entirely new name. Here are examples of these
four alternatives. Most often, the new line is related to the existing product mix because
the company wants to capitalize in its expertise and experience.
Related product, same brand:
94
litre bottle). The vast majority of new product introductions consists of line extensions.
Bacardi white rum which entered India, soon realising the need for black rum, added the
brand into their line. In a study undertaken by Holak and Bhatt revealed the following
about line extensions:
Line extension of strong brands are more successful than weak brands
Line extension of symbolic brands enjoy greater market success than those of less
symbolic brands
Line extensions that receive strong advertising and promotional support are more
successful than those that receive less promotional support
Firm size and marketing competence plays a part in an extension success
Earlier line extensions have helped in the market expansion of the parentbrand
Incremental sales generated by line extension may more than compensate for the
loss in sales due to cannibalisation.
96
of Dettol. This has been done mainly due to the threat of Savlon. All these products will
be positioned along Dettols core values trust and protection.
2.Godrej:
Apart from their growing portfolio of soap brands, Godrej bought Key, Ezee and
Trilo from Cussons International. IT has since added many brands in the soap category
including Godrej Fairglow, Godrej Sandal, Fairever vanishing cream etc. Godrej also
added Cooklite, edible oil and later on added a small variant Chota Cooklite. In the
FMCG sector, Godrej is trying to augment their portfolio with new brands from
competitors.
3.DS Groups:
During 1999, DS group conducted a study through McKinsey and decided to increase
their product mix by adding food and beverages, Salt and spices branded Catch, Tea and
edible oils in the same brand name and also mothfreshners. This is done apart from their
major brands Baba Zarda and Rajniganda paan masalas.
97
Once the product manager has summarized the issues, he or she must decide on
the plans financial and marketing objectives.
5) Marketing Strategy:
The product manager is responsible for the broad marketing strategy or game
plan to accomplish the plans objectives. In developing the strategy, the coordination of
product manager, production manager and buyers are needed. The product manager also
needs to talk to the sales manager to obtain sufficient sales force support and to the
financial officer to obtain sufficient funds for advertising and promotion.
6) Action Programs:
The marketing plans should specify the broad marketing programs for
achieving the business objectives. Each marketing strategy should be focussed in such a
way that the action to be done, when and how it is to be done should be planned.
7) Projected Profit and Loss statement:
Action plans allow the product manager to build a supporting budget. On the
revenue side, this budget shows the forecasted sales volumes in units and the average
price. On the expense side, it shows the cost of production, physical distribution, and
marketing, broken into finer categories. The difference between revenue and sales is
projected profit. Once approved, the budget is the basis for developing plans and
schedules for material procurement, production schedule, employee recruitment, and
marketing operations.
(viii) Control:
The last section of the market plan outlines the controls for monitoring the plan.
Typically the goals and budget are spelled out for each month or quarter. Senior
management can review the results each period. Some control sections include
Contingency plans. A Contingency plan outlines the steps management would take in
response to specific adverse developments, such as price war or strikes.
3.4.Product Life Cycle
Product life cycle as a concept has been an indicator by which companies decide the fate
of the products and the brands they posses or introduce as new products. It is only a toll
which can be used for taking marketing decisions based on the position of the
brand/product in the life cycle. Some of the important aspects of the life cycle strategies
are mentioned below:
Stages
Main strategy
Price
98
Introduction
Growth
Maturity
Decline
Generate awareness;
Reinforce success;
1.Revamp
2.Promotion
Reduce price
3.Substitution
Do nothing
99
Evidence suggests that where companies have tried to use the PLC as a planning tool,
opportunities have been missed and costly mistakes made.
The product life cycle of Maruti:
The passenger cars in the low end models are passing through a maturity stage. The
profits associated with a car follow the S curve of its life cycle , and decline as the
product nears the end of the maturity phase. Maruti Udyogs decision to drop prices
during December 1998 of all versions of the Maruti 800 came at this stage. The
respite that the price-cut is expected to provide is aimed at extending the maturity
phase of Maruti as seen from the following figure:
Every product comes to the market has to pass through a series of stages (i.e.) which is
studied under the head product life cycle. It may be a shorter (or) longer life cycle
depending upon the performance of the product. To say that a product has a life cycle is
to assert four things :
Products have a limited life.
Product sales pass through distinct stages, each posing different challenges, and
problems to the seller.
Profits rise and fall at different stages of the product life cycle.
Products require different marketing, financial, manufacturing, purchasing, and
human resource strategic in each stage of their life cycle.
Stages In Product Life Cycle :
The shape of the product life cycle curve are portrayed as bell-shaped. This curve
is typically divided into 4 stages:
Introduction
Growth
Majority
Decline
100
Sales
Maturi
ty
Decli
e
Growt
h
Introductio
n
TIME
Introduction :
During the market introductory stage, there may not be ready market for the product.
Sales are low; the product undergoes teething troubles, profits seem a remote possibility ;
demand has to be created and developed ; and the customers have to be prompted to try
out the product. this stage posses several problems for the marketer. This stage poses
several problems for the marketer. The complexity of the problems and the duration of
the stage depend upon the nature of the product, its price, its technological newness and
the consumers view of the product. One of the crucial decision to be taken in this stage
is the pricing decision so, the management can pursue one of the four strategies.
I. Rapid skimming :
Launching the new product at a high price and a high promotion level. It will take
advantage of early entry and the realitive novelty of the product in the market
introduction stage. Those who became aware of the product are eager to have it and can
pay the asking price and the firm faces potential competition and wants to build brand
preferences.
2. Slow skimming :
Launching the new product at a high and low promotion. This strategy make
sense when the market is limited sense, when the market is limited in size ; most of the
market is aware of the product, buyers are willing to pay a high price, and potential
competition is not imminent.
3.Rapid Penetration :
101
Launching the product at a low price and spending heavily on promotion. This strategy
make sense when the market is large, the market is unaware of the product, most buyers
are price sensitive, there is strong potential competition, and the unit manufacturing costs
fall with the companys scale of production and accumulated manufacturing experience.
4. Slow penetration :
Launching the product at a low price and low level of promotion. This strategy
make sense when the market is large, is highly aware of the product, is price sensitive,
and there is some potential competition. Another crucial area demanding attention at this
stage is market development and promotion. In this stage, demand has to be created and
developed. The firm has to invest heavily in promotion and visit for the reward.
Several examples of this introductory phase illustrates the different core strategies
available. Consumer electronics and industrial product companies almost always pursue a
skimming strategy. When Washing machines, Refrigerators, Camcorders, digital tape
players were first introduced, they were priced heavily intitally and then fell in price over
time. At the same time, penetration pricing is done usually in the Fast Moving Consumer
Goods (FMCG) because market share is very important for retaining the Space Keeping
Units in the retail outlets.
II. Growth Stage :
During this stage, the demand for the product increases and the size of the market
grows. There is a rapid increase in sales. Early adopters like the product, and additional
consumers start buying it. Now competitors enter, attacked by the opportunities. They
introduce new product features and expand distribution. Prices remain where they are or
fall slightly, depending on how fast demand increases. Sales rise much faster than
promotional expenditures, causing a welcome decline in sales promotion ratio. Profits
increase during this stage as promotion costs are spread over a large volume and unit
manufacturing costs fall faster than price declines owing to the producer learning effect.
During this stage, the firm uses several strategies to sustain rapid market growth
as long as possible.
It improves product quality and adds new features and improved styling.
It adds new models and flanker products (i.e. products of different sizes,
flavours, etc.)
It enters new market segments.
It increases its distribution coverage and enters new distribution channels.
It shifts from product awareness advertising to product preference advertising.
It lowers price to attract the next layer of price sensitive buyers.
Marketing and distribution efficiency becomes the decisive factor at this stage. The
pioneer sales and profits keep increasing at this stage.
III Maturity Stage :
102
In the maturity stage, the demand for the product reach a saturation point. Price
competition become intense and the pioneer tries to distinguish his brand by subtle
product differentiation and exploits the brand loyalty built by the company. Maturity
divides into 3 phases :
i) Growth phase :
This is the first phase where the sales growth rate starts to decline.
ii) Stable phase :
In the second phase, sales flatten on a per capita basis because of market
saturation. Most potential consumers have tried the product, and the future sales ar
governed by population growth and replacement demand.
iii) Decaying maturity :
In the third phase, the absolute level of sales starts to decline, and customers begin
switching to other products and substitutes.
Market Modification :
The company might try to expand the market for its mature brand by working
with the two factors that makeup sales volume.
Volume = number of brand users x usage rate per user.
The company can try to expand the number of brand users in three ways.
Convert non-users.
Enter new market segments.
Win competitors customers.
Volume can be used adopting the following three strategies.
The company can try to get customers to use the product more frequently.
The company can try to interest users in using more of the product on each
occasion.
The company can try to discover new product uses and convince people to
use the product in more varied ways.
Product modification:
Managers also try to stimulate sales by modifying the products characteristics
through quality improvement, feature improvement, or style improvement. This strategy
has several advantages. New features build the companys image as innovator and win
the loyalty of market segments that value these features. They provide a opportunity for
free publicity and they generate sales and distributor enthusiasm. The chief disadvantage
103
is that feature improvements are early imitated ; unless there is a permanent gain from
being first, the feature improvement might not pay off in the long run.
Marketing Mix Modification :
Product managers might also try to stimulate sales by modifying other marketing
mix elements.
i) Price :
Regarding the price, the decisions should be made in a way to attract buyers or the
price should be lowered (or) sometimes it is highered to signal higher quality.
ii) Distribution :
In the distribution element, the outlets where the products to be displayed
increased or not ; about the introduction of new distribution channels, the number of
outlets are to be decided.
iii) Advertising :
The factors to be considered in advertising is, the expenditures made, the message
of the present advertisement to be modified, and about the frequency, size of
advertisements.
iv) Sales Promotion :
Should the company set up sales promotion trade deals, cents off coupons,
rebates, warranties, gifts and contests are to be decided.
v) Personal selling:
In this, the number of quality of sales people to be increased, basis for sales force
specialisation, sale territories revision, sales force incentives, sales call planning are to
be properly planned.
vi) Services :
The technical assistance given by the company to the customers, credit facilities,
their delivery node are to be enhanced. So, the marketing mix modifications should be
done efficiently. The major problem is especially price reductions and additional
services is that they are early imitated.
IV Decline Stage :
In this stage, sales begin to fall. The demand for the product shrinks probably due
to new and functionally advanced products becoming available in the market / market
being more saturated to the product. In any case, prices and margins get depressed ; total
sales and profits diminish. Firms do perceive the impounding total decline and prepare
for the gradual phasing out of the product. Successful firms quite often keep new
products ready in the queue to fill the vacum created by the decline of existing products.
104
Some firms will use several strategies to over come this decline stage like that is
to link up the sale of these products with some other premium products they have
developed and thus try to sketch the life of declining product. In a study of company
strategies in declining induction, five decline strategies available to the firm :
Increasing the firms investment (to dominate the market / strengthen its competitive
position).
Maintaining the firms investment level until the uncertainties about the industries are
resolved.
Decreasing the firms investment level selectively, by dropping unprofitable customer
groups, while simultaneously strengthening the firms investment in lucrative riches.
Harvesting (milking) the firms investment to recover cash quickly.
Divesting the business quickly by disposing its assets as advantageously as possible.
Managing the product mix throughout the product life cycle
Effects and
Responses
Competition
Profits
Profits are
negligible
because of
high
production
and
marketing
costs
Selective, as
distribution
is slowly
built up
Distribution
Advertising
strategy
Aim at the
needs of
early
adopters
Overall
Strategy
Market
establishme
nt; persuade
Profits reach
peak levels as a
result of high
prices and
growing
demand
Intensive;
employ small
trade discounts
since dealers
are eager to
store
Make the mass
market aware of
brand benefits
Market
penetration;
persuade mass
Maturity
Many rivals
competing for a
small piece of
pie
Increasing
competition
cuts into profit
margins and
ultimately into
total profits
Decline
Few in number with a
rapid shakeout of
weak members
Intensive; use
heavy trade
allowances to
retain shelf
space
Selective; slowly
phase out
unprofitable outlets
Use advertising
as a vehicle for
differentiation
among
otherwise
similar brands
Defence of
brand position;
check the
Declining volumes
pushes costs up to
levels that eliminate
profits entirely
Preparations for
removal; milk the
brand dry of all
105
early
adopters to
try the
product
market to prefer
the brand
inroads of
competition
possible benefits
106
Entry as innovators
Entry as early followers
Entry as segmenters
Entry as Me-toos
5) Effective tool in managing customers :
Customers experience with the company changes as the product passes through
the PLC stages. As the experience level of customer changes, the benefits they seek from
the company also keep changing. The seller of the product has to understand when and
how a transition is taking place in the experience level of the customer, as his product
moves along its life cycle. The changing expectations and demands of the customers can
be handles through different strategy routes strengthening the company customer
relationship, augmenting the product, improving service support or modifying the pricing
approaches.
6) As a control tool :
PLC concept also helps the company as a control tool by measuring the
performance of the products of their company to the competitors product launched in the
past. A detailed comparison can be made at each stages of PLC and an effective strategy
can be implemented.
3. Brand level :
At the brand level ; HCL, Wipro and Siva brands are having their own paths.
107
So, when a company wants to project its life cycle (i.e.) Wipro wants to project
the life cycle of its PC, it cannot make a realistic analysis unless it studies the life cycle of
a product sub-category personal computers as a whole. Wipros life cycle at the brand
level cannot evolve totally independent of other PCs in the market. So, when the life
cycle of brand is assessed, it is essential to study the life cycle of the product category
and the product sub category as well. However, an idea of the likely life cycle of the
main product category of computers is helpful in understanding the course of the sub
category personal computers. In concluding that, a meaningful picture of the path the
brand is taking, it has to be studied in the context of the life cycle of the product sub
category and product category.
PLC strategies of Nylon:
Nylon was a product that was primarily used for the military purposes to make
parachutes, threads, and ropes. Then it was extended to circular knit market that is
womens hosiery. At that stage, the necessity for the growth of nylon was found. Then
there are steps taken to vitalise nylon.
Steps Taken To Vitalise Nylon:
Frequent usage:
Then steps were taken to vitalise nylon. The usage of nylon was increased and the
convenience that nylon had created a market for itself. Frequent usage of nylon was
promoted the bare laggardness of the users were used. The stockings were promoted
using that.
Varied usage:
Nylon was promoted as a fashion product. This product is perceived as a hosiery
functional product. The clothing function of it was to promote as a large extent. There the
varied usage of the nylon was stressed to the users and was promoted in the market.
New users:
The users of the nylon products were first the military, the it was targeted at
hosiery function and fashion users, and younger teenagers and substitutes were using
those products.
New uses:
New uses were created for the nylon, it was stretched and socks, rugs, tires and
bearings there uses of the nylon which was created to promote it warp knits were
invented in 1945 and nylon tire cord was invented in 1948. Nylon textured yarns were
invented in 1955 and carpet yarns were invented in 1958. As a result of this in 1962 the
sales went up of to 500 million pounds which was previously 50 million pounds.
108
Portfolio planning is best advised for diversified companies than a more product
coherent ones. Portfolio planning hence recognises that diversified companies are a
collection of businesses, each of which makes a distinct contribution to the overall
corporate performance and which should be managed accordingly. Such companies are
expected to redefine businesses for strategic business units (SBU), which may or may not
differ from operating units. They then classify these SBUs on a portfolio grid according
to the competitive position and attractiveness of a particular product market. Based on
109
these, they use this framework to assign each a strategic mission with respect to its
growth and financial objectives and allocate resources accordingly. Companies can thus
theoretically assess the strategic position of each of their enterprises and compare these
positions using cash flow as the common variable. The four components of strategy can
be seen as influences on the firm's effectiveness and efficiency. The firm's effectiveness
is determined by the combined influence of scope, distinctive competence and
competitive advantages.
Objective of Resource Development:
Implementing Corporate Level Strategy
Resource development is very helpful implement corporate level strategy.
Corporate level strategy is to determine what business to go into and relative allocation of
resource and management of synergies among them.
Direct Interaction with Scope and Resources Deployment
They should there fore be considered at the corporate level and should not be
treated as functional area policy decisions to be decided at lower levels. Business level
strategy focuses on how to compete in a particular product / market segment or industry.
Competitive advent ages and distinctive competencies thus become dominant strategic
concerns at this level. At functional level, the primary focus of strategy is efficiency.
Types of portfolio planning:
Following are the possibilities of various types of portfolio planning undertaken by
companies:
Types
Explanations
Analytic planning
Process planning
110
Since the road to portfolio planning is a long one, companies often get stuck trying to
implement it and cannot realise the full potential of the approach. In implementing
portfolio planning, companies often write in biases that block its usefulness, including the
tendency to focus on capital investment rather than resource allocation. In spite of such
limitations, portfolio planning is offering the following benefits to companies if
implemented properly:
1. It promotes substantial improvement in the quality of strategies developed at both the
business and the corporate level.
2. It provides a guideline for adopting their overall management process to the needs of
each business.
3. It provides selective resource allocation to the various SBUs.
4. It furnishes companies with a greatly improved capacity for strategic control when
portfolio planning is applied intelligently and with attention to its limitations and
problems.
Peter Drucker on portfolio planning:
Peter Drucker suggests a mechanism of portfolio analysis of products within the
company. He suggests that all products can be classified into five groups as follows:
Tomorrows breadwinners:
These are either modifications or improved versions of what one company has got
as their major products or new products.
Todays breadwinners:
These may exist today but they really are the innovations of yesterday.
Yesterdays breadwinners:
These are old hat but eat up all that they earn.
Problem children:
Difficult to live with perhaps but better parental control should make the
difference between a healthy child and a potential deviant child.
Also-rans:
These are otherwise known as me-too products in the market whose existence
itself is a question mark.
Boston Consulting Group Matrix:
The business policy portfolio models are most popular useful to understand the
firms strategic concerns and choices. They defined the firm's scope or domain by
highlighting the inter - relatedness of diverse factors such as
1.
Market growth
2.
Market share
3.
Cash and Cash flow patterns
4.
Capital intensity
5.
Product maturity etc.
111
Market
growth
High
Low
Star
Question mark
Cash cow
Dog
High
Low
BCG Growth/Share Matrix
Star
Star are high growth - High market share business which may or may not be self
sufficient in term of cash flow. This cell corresponds closely to the growth phase or
product life cycle
Cash cows
As the term indicates, cash cows are business which generate large amounts of cash but
their rate of growth is slow In terms of PLC, these are generally mature business which
are reaping the benefits of experience curve. The cash generation exceeds the
reinvestment that could profitably be made into 'cash cows'.
Question Marks
Business with high industry growth but low market share for companies are question
marks or problem children. They required large amount of cash to maintain or gain
market share. Question mark is usually new products or services, which have a good
commercial potential
Dogs
Those businesses, which are related to slow growth industries and where a
company has a low relative market share, are termed as 'dogs'. They neither generate nor
require large amounts of cash. In terms of PLC, the 'dogs' are usually products in the late
maturity or declining stage.
The firm should hold its dominant market position by reducing prices and thus
keeping away the high cost competitors. Cash flows are likely to be negative during the
growth phase in a dominant market since the firm will have to keep in investing to
maintain its competitive edge. Dominant position generates positive cash flows, during
the mentioned stage of life cycle. The BCG matrix makes it very clear that a firm for its
ultimate success needs a balanced portfolio of products or businesses. The individual
businesses are analyzed to form a corporate portfolio, which should act as a guide to
112
commit the firms resource. Portfolio should be balanced in terms of profit, cash flows,
and overall corporate risk.
GE Nine Cell Matrix:
Another corporate portfolio analysis technique is based on the pioneering effort of
general electric (GE) company of the united state supported by the consulting firm of
Mckinsey & Company.
The vertical axis represents industry attractiveness, which is a weighted composite rating
based on eight different factors. These factors are: 1.
Market size and growth rate
2.
Industry profit margins
3.
Competitive intensity
4.
Seasonably
5.
Cyclically
6.
Economics of Scale
7.
Technology and
8.
Social, environmental, legal and human impacts.
The horizontal axis represents business strength competitive position, which is again; a
weighted composite rating based on seven factors. These factors are
1.
Relative market share
2.
Profit margins
3.
Ability to compete on price and quality
4.
Knowledge of customer & market
5.
Competitive strength and weakness
6.
Technological capability and
7.
Caliber of management
Industry attractiveness
High
High
Investment
Medium
Low
Selective
growth
Selectivity
Selectivity
Harvest
Growth
Business
Strengths
Medium
Selective
growth
113
Low
Selectivity
Harvest
Harvest
114
The cell labels represent possible strategic choices or types of resource deployments
most appropriate for the firm, given its score on each of the two axes. More specifically
these cell labels have the following implications:
Disinvest (1,1): Likely already losing money; net cash flow negative over time.
Losses may be minimized by divestiture or even liquidation.
Phased Withdrawal (1,2) and (2,1): Probably not generating sufficient cash to justify
continuation; assets can be redeployed.
Cash Generator (3,1): Equivalent to a "cash cow" in the GE planning grid. A firm or
product would occupy this cell in later stages of the life cycle that does not warrant
heavy investment, but can be "milked" of cash due to its strong competitive position.
Proceed with Care (2,2): Similar to a "question mark;" firms falling in this sector may
require some investment support but heavy investment would be extremely risky.
Growth (upper - 3.2) and (lower - 2.2): Similar to a GE planning grid "green-light"
strategy. A firm, product, or SBU in these sectors would call for investment support
to allow growth with the market. It should generate sufficient cash on its own.
Double or Quit (1,3): Units in this sector should become "high fliers" in the not too
distant future. Consequently those in the upper rightmost corner of cell (1,3) should
be singled out for full support. Others should be abandoned.
Try Harder (2,3): External financing may be justified to push a unit in this sector to a
leadership position. However, such a move will require judicious application of
funds.
Leader (3,3) (lower - 3,2): The strategy for this segment is to protect this position by
external investment (funds beyond those generated by the unit itself - occasionally);
earnings should be quite strong and a major focus may be maintaining sufficient
capacity to capitalize on strong demand.
Companys
Competitive
Capabilities
Average
Attractive
Weak
Disinvest
Phased
Withdrawal
Double or
Quit
Average
Phased
Withdrawal
Custodial
Try harder
Growth
Growth
Leader
Strong
Cash
generation
Leader
115
The DPM can thus be used to identify strategies for single businesses as well as for
plotting combinations of units in multi business or multi product firms. Locating
competitors on the DPM can provide useful insights into the nature of corporate-level
strategic configurations. However, there is room for error in the positioning of a firm or
product on the two axes, and thus DPM location should be interpreted with an open mind
and not in isolation. The Directional Policy Matrix (DPM) developed by Shell
Chemicals; U.K. uses the two parameters of business sector prospects and companys
competitive abilities.
A number of factors such as market growth, market quality, market supply, etc. are
used to rate the business sector prospects as unattractive, attractive or average. A
companys competitive abilities are similarly judged as weak, average, or strong on the
basis of several factors. The 3 x 3 matrix when plotted form the basis for recommending
baseline strategies. One advantage on DPM is that one of its extension; risk matrix
provides alternative way to analyse environmental risk. In a risk matrix, environmental
risk is taken as the third dimension and is divided into four categories from low risk to
very high risk. Each risk position is determined on the basis of environmental threats and
the probability of their occurrence.
Business Profile matrix:
This matrix is more flexible than the growth/share matrix and uses competitive
position and industry maturity as the two dimensions. It uses twenty cells for clarity of
resource allocation. Empirical determination of the correlates of the two dimensions is
superior to the growth/share matrix.
Growth
Maturity
Aging
Dominant
Strong
Competitive Favourable
Tenable
Position
Weak
Designing a portfolio:
116
In order to design a portfolio, the following guidelines are suggested by Yoram Wind
and Vijay Mahajan:
Establishing the level and unit of analysis and determining what links connect them
Identifying the relevant dimensions, including single-variable and composite
Determining the relative importance of the dimensions
To the extent that two or more dimensions are viewed as dominant, constructing a
matrix based on them
Locating the products or businesses on the relevant portfolio dimensions
Projecting the likely position of each product or business on the dimensions if (a) no
changes are expected in environmental conditions, competitive activities, or the
companys strategies and if (b) changes are expected
Selecting the desired position for each existing and new product and developing how
resources might best be allocated among these products.
In order to establish a matrix out of the available information from both the company
and the market, the GE matrix can be constructed using the following steps:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
Weight
(%)
Market attractiveness
.20
.20
.15
.15
.15
.05
.10
must be
acceptable
Overall size
Annual growth
Competitive intensity
Technological requirements
Inflationary pressures
Energy need
Historical margins
Social/Legal/Economic/
Political/Technological impact
1.00
Measurement
4.00
5.00
4.00
2.00
3.00
2.00
1.00
Value
0.80
1.00
0.60
0.30
0.45
0.10
0.10
3.35
117
Business Strength
0.10
0.15
0.10
0.10
0.05
0.05
0.15
0.15
0.10
0.05
Market share
Share growth
Product quality
Brand reputation
Distribution strength
Promotional effectiveness
Production capability
Unit costs
R & D strength
Management effectiveness
2.00
4.00
4.00
5.00
3.00
2.00
3.00
5.00
4.00
4.00
0.20
0.60
0.40
0.50
0.15
0.10
0.45
0.75
0.40
0.60
1.00
4.15
:
:
Attractiveness factors
Importance scale
Market size
Information
available
Yes
Current coverage
No
Competition
Current systems
Social aspects
Legal aspects
Yes
Yes
No
No
3
4
5
6
Five-point
measure
2
4
5
5
2
Weightage Value
5
15
10
15
10
10
60
50
75
20
118
Costs
Managerial personnel
3
2
5
15
10
20
70
250
Possible total: 350
Market
attractiveness
factors
Market size
Five-point
measure
Weightage
15
Coverage
Competition
Current systems
Social aspects
Legal aspects
4
2
4
2
2
15
5
10
5
5
60
Value
75
60
10
40
10
10
205
Possible total
Industry attractiveness
300
200
High
350
100
Medium
Low
High
+
233
Business
Strengths
117
Medium
Low
119
The next stage was to use the matrix to compare the present markets with Mumbai
as a potential investment by using the same basis. Hence the + in the matrix clearly gives
evidence for investment in the market concerned.
New products provide new life for otherwise aging organizations and propel
entrepreneurs to the top of new industries. The rate of new product introductions varies
across industries, but new and better ways to serve needs and wants are ultimately
introduced in all industries. Introducing a product can mean moving into an industry
leadership position. Thus, few decisions in an organization are fundamental, pervasive,
and long lasting as those concerning products. Still, the number of new products each
year is striking. Just in the food industry, it is common to see over 2,000 new product
introductions in a year and such that in pharmaceutical industry also. The risks,
opportunities and strategies associated with a product will partly depend on the type of
newness in question. At one extreme, newness could simply involve a new pack size or
colour, while at the other extreme, the product could represent a break through
innovation. Hence it is pertinent to note the type of newness as follows:
1. New to the company; new to the market:
Technological developments often provide the basis for such radical new products.
Those products like CD player, Personal computer, Internet, which have made a huge
impact on the life style of people, are examples. At the first instance, many customers
will not obtain the product for the want of reason to use the product. Hence it was
only appropriate to target the right audience who are not price-sensitive. Companies
will get lot of time to convince the customers since competition is less. Ponds black
head remover is a new product for HLL and also new to the market.
2. New to the company; a significant innovation for the market:
Customers may be aware of the core concept but an improvement in the product
creates a market. Hence the companies need to only communicate the nature of
innovation and the added benefits it provides to the product. Consumers can compare
the new product with the old from their own experience and reach an opinion as to the
value of the innovation. Stain-free clothes, wrinkle free ready-made garments and
first car fitted with a catalytic converter are some examples.
3. New to the company; a minor innovation for the market:
A minor innovation for the market is always required to stay tuned to the vagaries of
the markets and hence many companies in the consumer durable, automobiles always
try to opt for minor innovations. AKAI introduced TV with VCR as combined
equipment but however due to the risk involved in the product, customers were not
120
interested and was withdrawn. Products like FMCG where the risk is less, minor
innovations can work out.
4. New to the company; no innovation for the market:
Me-too products come under this category. For small companies with limited
resources, it makes sense to let the big competitors spend the time, effort and money
developing the radical new concepts. When the market is established and known, it
can launch a slightly cheaper imitation and get a foothold in the lower end of the
market. Walkman now has as many as 100 brands of imitations. There are plethoras
of soap brands, which are me-too in the market.
Categories of new products:
Booz, Allen & Hamilton, Inc., an international management and technologyconsulting firm with extensive experience in new product development conducted a
major study manufacturing companies. It identified six categories of new products in
terms of their newness both to the company and to the customers in the market place.
1. Additions to the existing product lines: Products that supplement a companys
established lines (26% of total). Lakme Lever ltd. Unveiled a new brand identity. It
launched a range of premium skin care products, reconstituted its existing range, and
got itself a new logo and a new positioning statement: The source of radiant beauty.
Margo Natural Moisturizer was launched in November 2000,apart from Margo
original Neem. The variant is pale green, translucent soap retaining the Neem, but
with glycerin and the scent of lime. Research had revealed that Margo tended to dry
skin in the winter and the variant sought to redress this complaint well.
2. Improvement in/revisions to existing products: Products that provide improved
performance or greater perceived value and replace existing products (26% of total). )
New upgraded version of Pentium 4 from Intel inside. HLL considered most Indians
tend to oil their hair before they shampoo and tried to tap this trend by introducing a
Ceramides based oil brand called Ceramics Sunsilk hot oil treatment.
3. New product lines: Products that allow a company to enter an established market for
the first time (20% of total). Bal Pharma is all set to launched 'Ketovate' a novel anti
dandruff and seborrhoeic dermatitis of the scalp. The product is expected stand out in
the crowded anti-dandruff market with its unique formulation and competitive
pricing. Initially, the product will be introduced through the dermatologists. But the
company will slowly bring it to the OTC segment, considering the consumer
awareness on the anti-dandruff shampoo market.
4. Cost reductions: New products that provide similar performance at lower cost (11%
of total). Usha group launched a fan which will save 50 per cent electricity (the
company already has a model-Windsor-which consumes 25 per cent less energy); a
shank-less fan, where the blades wrapped around a triangular shaped motor; a fan
with propeller-like blades, each revolving at 360-degree, giving a two-way breeze;
121
5. New to the world products: Products that create an entirely new market (10% of
total). MinerWa ,a miniature mineral water machine launched by Softel was
commercially launched almost three years after the concept stage
Repositioning: Existing products that are targeted to new markets or market segments
(7% of total). The mid- market CTV brand of LG, Sampoorna, directed at rural and
semi urban consumers, was repositioned to appeal to middle and lower middle income
urban consumers too. HLLs lime soap Rainfresh does not highlight any natural
ingredient. It was basically a perfumistic soap, which smells fresh. Rainfresh does not
connote lime freshness; hence it was decided to change to blue colour a new
repositioning.
No Company can survive on new products alone. It will also need to upgrade its
existing products on a continuous basis making incremental improvements. Sometimes
there are accident grades like microwave oven but without a good process in place it
cannot work. The above mentioned stages are sequential in nature and in each stage,
management should be gathering additional information to reduce uncertainty about
demand, product-company fit, or even cannibalization of its own products. The concept
of stage-gate process involves the maintenance of control over the expenditures
involved in new product development by balancing the companys investment against the
value of additional information. That is, by assessing each idea after each stage based on
the information acquired, management can reevaluate the ideas prospects for success. In
this stage-gate system, managers can open the gate to the next stage in the process or can
kill the new product at that point, thus avoiding the further expenditure of time and
money if the demand or profit prospects for the new product seem unfavorable.
Stage 1: Exploration
This stage is the one, which decides the fate of a company in the process of its
commitment to new product development. Hence, companies need to first determine the
product fields of primary interest to the company. Here the question of new products inhouse or using acquisitions as a route to new product development needs to be addressed.
122
Companies have to analyse the major problems confronting them. They have to evaluate
the companys principal resources. At this stage, it is necessary that external growth
opportunities like expanding markets, technological breakthroughs, rising profit margins
be identified. If found acceptable, such a route needs to be planned. In order to do so,
companies have to establish a planned programme for idea generation. The sources of
new product ideas are many and varied. Following is the table of new product idea
generation possibilities:
Table 11.1.Sources of new product ideas
INTERNAL SOURCES
EXTERNAL SOURCES
Companies have to identify the idea generating groups and give them a clear
concept of the companys interest fields. It is important that the creative personnel are
exposed to idea generating facts. These people are kept away from the distractions from
the current problems the company might face. Some companies designate an idea
collection point. Many companies in India in the manufacturing sector have a suggestion
box or idea box in the factory/office premises. Some companies even provide incentives/
bonuses for the employees whose suggestions have been carried forward to the next
stage.
To find and nurture REALLY BIG ideas, organizations should
Start with a clear strategic imperative
Add a culture conducive to cross-functional creativity
Feed in forecasting from trends, technology mapping, and outside learning
Invite customer wisdom, intuition, understanding and input
In addition, a companys scientists and technicians often make discoveries that lead to
new products. Mahindra & Mahindra uses the nomenclature of sandpit projects where
the R&D staff is encouraged to act freely around with new concepts. This is the way they
had made Bijlee. At Titan, ideas can originate with the marketing brief on the shop floor
123
as a spin off from a new material or process, in a lab, as an R&D idea no matter where it
comes from. Blow Plast, in the first week of the month begins with a meeting headed by
the CEO and attended by the functional heads of manufacturing, sales, R&D and
marketing purely for the purpose of product development brain storming. They have the
policy of set the standards and the creativity will follow. The most common methods of
idea generation in companies are:
Brain storming:
This method developed by Alex Osborn uses the recognition that the really new
ideas often mix several ideas to produce something that is non-obvious and exciting.
Group discussions are held to generate as many new ideas as possible. The group
generally consists of six to ten people. The group members are encouraged to be as wild
as they want in suggesting solutions. No idea is criticised and hence no ideas are held
back. As ideas start to flow, one leads to another. Within a short time, hundreds of ideas
can be on the table. Only after ideas are generated freely, the group can then look forward
to critically evaluate later on for the purposes of practicability. A specific problem or goal
is set at the beginning of the meeting, which is known as synectics.
Market Research:
Companies have to identify the needs of the customers through the use of market
research. Most of the companies rely on this method since the customer analysis is the
best way of offering a product to their need. Nowadays, there are many consultants and
agencies that provide the necessary support to companies. The Persona toothpaste from
Amway uses accu pressure point was developed based on market research. The research
revealed that people tend to apply excessive pressure while brushing. This adversely
impacts teeth and gums. The accupressure point in Persona toothbrushes allows the brush
to bend, absorbing excess pressure. In addition to the USP of accue pressure point, the
Persona toothbrush has an angular design, and a slender neck, which allow easy access to
all regions of the mouth. The toothbrush also has rounded bristles, which prevent gums
from being grazed. A non-slip grip helps support the thumb, providing for better control.
Long range planning studies:
Often a long term forecasting by companies can yield the required results. The customer
life style changes over the years, the changing societal trend etc., can be forecasted and
products brought accordingly. Dishwashers, Microwave ovens are examples to this
category of research.
Market Gap Analysis:
Gap analysis is a technique which plans maps of the market and used to determine how
various products are perceived by how they are positioned on the market map. This
method helps in understanding the flaws in the existing products and the need for a new
product. The advent of Satellite television showed the need of nearly 100 channels and
host of other attributes which was immediately worked upon by companies like BPL,
124
Onida etc. Dabur developed Lemoneez lemon juice using market research to identify the
gaps felt most keenly by its target customer, as the lady in a house worked in the kitchen.
From this process the idea for Lemoneez, the lemon substitute converted into a product
by its laboratories.
Think Tank:
Companies are now employing the use of think tanks that assess the companys resources
and objectives and devise concepts. Some times, top managers of the companies often act
as the source of new product ideas by identifying the consumer needs and changing
society. They also act as the think tanks.
Activity Analysis:
This technique is used by companies in ascertaining the usage of a product. Maruti Omni
was intended as a cargo vehicle but however, the usage of the product showed that it was
more used as a passenger vehicle. Hence the positioning and the product itself was
changed to the requirement. P & G studied the washing habits of 3000 customers in the
target segment for its middle market laundry brand, Ariel Gain Super Soaker, to identify
the one critical need removing grease stains that the brand addresses.
Foreign Search:
Some times, many multi national companies translate their experience from another
country. Some Indian companies search the various products, which are not available in
India and offer this product after obtaining the necessary agreements. It is often found
that many products, which are successful in one country, may not succeed in another due
to the cultural and social differences. Soya bean milk was successful in USA but when in
India, it failed confirming the above reasons.
Morphological analysis:
This method analyses the structural dimensions of the product, which helps in getting to
the relationships between them. When a writing instrument is analysed, the extent of its
length, clarity and convenience become the relationship factors from where a new
product can be found out. Research on the old Ford Escort indicated that a three box
design found favour than a hatchback. Apart from more space for luggage, consumers felt
the boot also provided more safety than a hatch. Indian customers also told Ford that rear
seats used for 70 % of the time. In other markets, the rear seat is used less than 10% of
the time, whereas in India it is used extensively to cram in people. So, the Ikon was to
have a roomier rear seat with full roll down windows, reading lights and comfortable
centre seating as well. And the rear door openings were claimed to be the largest in the
industry while the height of the chassis was such that it will be easy to get in and out. The
new Ford Ikon cars design had also taken care of the poor road conditions during the
monsoons in India.
125
Stage 2: Screening:
Screening is the second stage in the new product development model. During the
screening process, a company evaluates the commercial potential of a new product. The
commercial potential of a product includes such criteria as profitability, marketability,
and costs of production. Screening also calls for the participation of other departments
within the company in the development of new ideas. The ideas and advice of people at
different levels of production will aid the product in areas such as its eventual
effectiveness, ease of production, and production costs. Allowing all levels of employees
to be involved in the process increases the empowerment within the company.
After the necessary ideas are generated, the next stage is to reduce the number to a
manageable size. It is important to expand each idea into a full product concept. New
product ideas should fit into the companys overall strategy. They should also build on
the companys resources and skills. They have to collect facts and opinions, which are
quickly available, bearing on the product ideas as business propositions. This stage
should translate the idea into business terms. At this stage it is important to identify the
best sources of facts and qualified opinions. Quick and inexpensive fact gathering
methods using the principle of diminishing returns is better to be resorted. The
checklist for the screening of new product ideas is depicted in the following table.
No.
Element
The idea represents high value-added products, not
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
Yes
No
commodity products
It requires consumer-oriented development and
presentation of products utilising existing marketing
capabilities
The idea has high advertising or promotional content
that allows for intensive communication of products
It is not a major capital investment for the consumer
There is opportunity for logical extensions to be
developed
The product offers a significant plus that is
discernible by a large majority of consumers
There is an opportunity to expand into many overseas
markets
The idea ties in with existing company functionstechnology, marketing, sales force
Labour will be of average or lower intensity relative
to national standards
Capital will be of average or lower intensity relative
to national standards
The product is compatible with companys physical
packaging capabilities
The product is preferably non-perishable
The idea is related to the area of operation of the
126
14
15
16
company
The product utilises existing distribution channels
There is an extended product life cycle
The product can be a building block for a multiproducts line or business
127
Based on these, once the concept has been developed, it has to be tested. Consumer
reactions are obtained by using a verbal description or a picture of the product and asking
for unbiased opinions. In the major manufacturing industry, the products are brought to
business or industrial consumers at a designated test sites, and developers work closely
with these consumers to spot the problems and refine the designs. After this, the company
has to project costs, profits, return on investment and cash flow if the product is placed on
the market. Projections of potential sales at various prices need to be made, as well as
detailed cost projections for different volumes of production. Start-up and continuing
costs, fixed and variable costs and the impact of economies of scale need to be
determined. Tentative marketing plans need to be set, along with the costs associated
with them. Lastly, a set of full-blown budgets is required to estimate the potential return
on the product. Thus business analysis must include an assessment of the amount of risk
the company will face if the new product is introduced. If the new product can be
produced using existing production and marketing capabilities, the risk is lower. Less
investment in new plant and equipment will be needed, and the marketer can benefit from
already acquired knowledge of the market. TVS Suzuki and Bajaj Auto use the technique
of target costing to determine the price of the product and working backwards to fix the
maximum acceptable cost to develop new products.
Stage 4: Development:
Once a company reaches prototype process development-the fourth stage of newproduct development-they are committing to spend a lot of money on the initial
production of a still unproven product. Product development aimed at better serving
through a disciplined process, with clearly defined targets for every stage, continuous
interaction with other functions and more than one eye on costs, delays and the extent of
manufacturablity. During this stage, many companies implement computer-aided
production programs. Not only do these reduce overall costs in production, but also
should a flaw be found with either the product or the production process, computer-aided
production systems can easily correct the problem. This saves valuable time in redesign
and production restructuring. By getting the product to the market more quickly, a
company can turn potential profit into realized profit. Production engineers and R&D
specialists construct a model; the marketing department develops a brand name to match
the idea or concept; packaging is designed; and the major elements of the marketing mix
are put together. The positioning strategy is also identified. At this stage, many different
functional areas of the company are called upon to cooperate in the creation of prototypes
and development of production or delivery processes, marketing plans and other elements
required to make the idea a reality.
After the laboratory tests on the basic performance against specifications are over,
the new product should be released. At this stage it is important to note the commercial
rather than scientific standards to determine the product release point. TI Cycles of
Chennai put the Hercules top gear in shops, a product that has fuelled 20-fold growth in
the segment in quick time as a new product to overcome the depressing cycle sales. When
this was identified as the lack of reliability of gears, TI cycles decided to use the best and
safest gears and design its product around its component. Managing cost was a critical
128
issue, because the gears were being imported. This was achieved by maintaining best
control on material cost and cheaper outsourcing. Both the decision taken as a part of
product development and not as a production process. At Bajaj Auto, product
development is about five parallel activities like product definition and design,
manufacturing process development, marketing, planning and tooling. Different
departments work on different application areas, industrial design on styling, engineering
design on structural and engine components, product engineering on machine tool design
and systems on system configuration. A potent technique for ensuring product quality at
the development stage is benchmarking. For instance M&M is benchmarking Scorpio
against Tata Sumo for passenger comfort against its own vehicle for fuel economy,
against the Maruti Gypsy for comfort and ease of driving, against Tata Sierra for
acceleration. Philips applies the fault-mode effect analysis technique to check the various
things that could go wrong with a specified product and chalk out an optimum solution.
Stage 5: Test Marketing:
Test marketing is a tool for new product launch and new product development.
The company can develop new product in own laboratories and independent researcher
develops a new product. Test Marketing has been defined as a research technique in
which the product under study is placed on sale in one are more selected localities or
areas, and its reception by customer and trade is observed, recorded and analysed. This
test market will allow managers to see how the product might perform when released to
the entire market. From this information, managers can also decide if they have the right
target market, the right price, and the right level of advertising.
In this stage the new product and relevant marketing programme is tried out for
the first time in well selected market segments under representative marketing
environments. Hence test marketing is the process of introducing a new product or
service to a small test market (i.e.) considered to be representative of the large target
market. Test marketing have many alternative forever like advertisement with coupon
and samples. Launching the new product in the market is risky one, Because the product
development are variable to changing customer needs and taste, New technology,
shortage product life cycle, and lastly the increased domestic and foreign competition.
Seventh aspect of product development is launching the market product.
Test marketing is done mainly to identify the following:
129
City selection
Select the sales representatives.
Duration of the test.
Select suitable data.
Implementation
recorded and then projected nation-wide. For example, if monthly volume in 2 per cent
of the country were Rs.4000, then the total volume projected would be Rs.4000/.
02=Rs.2, 00,000.
All available data should be carefully reviewed to make sure that the test-market is by
and large representative of the whole market in terms of social class, caste, age, and other
demographic variables. All available data should be reviewed also to make sure that the
test-market is representative in terms of consumption of similar or substitute products. It
is also advisable to be assured that competitive strength in the test-market is approximate
to those in the whole market. After having considered the above factors in test marketing,
it is also advisable to check up different components of the marketing-mix to be
employed in the test marketing and their probable future relationships. It is important
because distortion in any one component at the commercialization stage would bring
about distortion in the test results and the actual product performance. For example, if
testing is accompanied by an aggressive sales promotion campaign but not so in
commercialization stage then subsequent results would be different. Based on the
response in the test marketing, a company can follow any of the three options:
Abandonment of the product,
Additional testing, and
Commercialization.
The test marketing needs to incorporate the following as the tools:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
money and are invited in to a store where they may buy the product or any item of
product. Some weeks later, they are interviewed by phone to determined product
attribute, usage, satisfaction and repurchase frequently and are offered a opportunity for
repurchasing of the product, results are incorporated in forecasting to the sales levels.
Colgate Palmolive used a different marketing mix in each four cities like. Colgate
Palmolive after launching a new product in set of small lead corners and keeps rolling
it out if the proves successful, and general mills have launched new product area too large
for rivals to distribute.
An average amount of advertising coupled free samples.
Heavy advertising with free samples
Average amount of advertising linked with redeeming samples.
An average advertising with no the other special offers.
Stage 6: Commercialisation:
At this stage, complete final plans for production and marketing has to be done. The
product team if necessary needs to be expanded to cover all the departments of the
company. This is the stage where the right individuals are identified who would take over
the successful marketing of the product and who have the capacity to coordinate with
other departments of the company. A complete activity schedule has to be prepared. Feed
back mechanism has to be developed for effective control. The product has to be ready
for meeting any competitive pressures and changing internal problems. In terms of
launching or commercialising the product, there are two main alternatives.
Immediate national launch:
This is one way to overcome the competition and to save on the costs of launch. If
considerable promotions are carried out, it will be difficult for the competition to
overcome the company. The risk of national launch is that it leaves the company with
many problems, which were not countered during the test marketing. Production routines
that work well on the schedules may not scale up as expected. Early problems of supply
may show poorly on the launch.
Rolling launch:
This is an alternative to the full national launch. It involves building towards full national
coverage by starting with one or two recognised distribution areas, then gradually adding
new regions to those already served as experience and success of the product further
increases. This helps the company to concentrate on getting the logistics and production
schedules in tune with the requirements. Coca-Cola, Kelloggs and several other major
players including HLL use this strategy effectively.
NEW PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT IN THE INDIAN SCENARIO:
132
In April 1999, Mahindra & Mahindra unveiled the Bijlee, the first ever
commercially viable electrically operated 3 wheeler, a classic skunk work project,
worked on by a 14 member team, without a deadline, budget or even assurance of
success. The project took exactly 6 months. For example, at Titan industries which
develops between 70 and 100 new watches every year every new model flows from 3
central strategic considerations viz., boosting brand value, increasing market share and
profit maximisation. HUL considered most Indians tend to oil their hair before they
shampoo and tried to tap this trend by introducing a ceramides based hot oil brand called
Ceramides sunsilk hot oil treatment. Though the company had already stretched the
equity of its largest selling shampoo, Clinic into oils, in the case of Sunsilk it is the
ceramides based hot oil concept it was trying out on its customers. It was initially test
marketed in Calcutta and the product poised for a national launch at the end of 1999.The
product was in the form of a blister pack in which the contents were visible .The oil was
to be immersed in warm water before use. Stretching the equity of a shampoo brand into
hair oils was not looked upon favorably by analysts. HUL after realising its market share
in the shampoo market has slipped from 18% in 1996 to 16.75% in 1998, in a move to
regain its position, launched two new variants to the brand Sunsilk- Fruitamins and
Ceramides as standalone brands in 1998.
4. Have you understood type questions:
1. Raman called several airlines to compare rates and chose a flight on Jet airways as it
had a better reputation for service and competitive prices. The airline ticket is an example
of which type of product?
A. convenience
B. shopping
C. specialty
D. unsought
2. Industrial products are :
A. purchased for personal consumption.
B. frequently purchased for both their functional aspects and their psychological
rewards.
C. traditionally classified according to their characteristics and intended uses.
D. not purchased by nonbusiness organisations.
3. Products that are used directly in the production of a final product but are not easily
identifiable are categorised as
A. accessory products.
B. component parts.
C. consumable supplies.
D. assembly components.
4. Hindustan Unilever Ltd., markets a number of different brands of laundry detergents
including Surf Excelmatic, Surf Excel, Rin, Ariel and Surf. Each of these specific
versions of laundry detergents can be described as:
133
A. a product item
B. a product line
C. a core product
D. a mix item
5. A product item can be best described as a
A.
B.
C.
D.
5. Summary:
As the competition becomes more intensified in years to come, companies are gearing
to face them by becoming more specialised. Hence the marketing department
becomes more professionalised and in this context, product management gains
prominence. The expanding markets based on liberalisation, privatisation and
globalisation needs a professional approach coupled with the sophistication in
technology and consumers becoming more educated, this development in product
management is inevitable. A product manager has to be in the current competitive
environment competent to handle diverse functions like:
Strategy development: oversee the long-term strategy for the product category, like
specific competitive strategies for different market segments as well as develop
product line extensions and project demand.
Consumer understanding: maintain close contact with the consumer and develop an
intimate knowledge of consumer attitudes and behavior. champion the cause of the
consumer in the business.
Product innovation: awareness of consumer needs gaps and appreciation of
technological possibilities will impact the product development team and help bring
about innovations with tangible benefits to the consumer.
Brand equity management and communication: As a custodian of the brand, the
product manager will build the image and personality of the brand and communicate
it consistently through advertising over different media. He will be responsible for
optimising advertising spends and the selection of the right media mix to reach the
specific target audience.
Team leadership: An excellent team leader and team player, he will co-ordinate with
the sales and product development teams to facilitate and implement business
initiatives in these areas.
Hence it is imperative that he should have a clarity over the new product
management and development along with the knowledge of product life cycle.
6. Exercises
1. Prepare a product mix depth for fast moving consumer goods of any company.
134
2. Identify and explain strategies for the following products in different product life cycle
stages:
a. Ceiling fans
b. Scooters
c. Palm top computers
d. Starch for laundry
e. Digital diary
f. Mobile phones
3. For a product like Vacuum cleaner, you want to conduct test marketing. This product is
to be launched on a national basis. Explain how will you proceed?
4. Describe the new product development process in a pharmaceutical industry.
5. Evaluate the methodology for launching the following products on a national basis:
a. Incense sticks
b. Digital note books
c. Mouthwash
d. Anti septic lotion
7. References
1. Dhalla and Yuseph, Forget the Product Life Cycle, Harvard Business Review,
1976, pp.102-110.
2. John Smallwood, The product life cycle: a key to strategic marketing planning,
MSU business topics, winter 1973, pp.29-32.
3. Joseph Gullitinan, Gordon Paul and Thomas Madden, Marketing managementstrategies and programs, McGraw-Hill,1996, pp.182-85.
4. Glen Urban, Theresa Carter, Steven Gaskin and Zofia Mucha, Market share rewards
to pioneering brands: an empirical analysis and strategic implications, Management
Science, June 1986, pp.645-57.
5. Ian Wilson, Reforming the Strategic Planning Process: integration of social and
business needs, Long Range Planning, October 1974, p.3.
6. Michel Allen, Diagramming GEs planning for whats WATT in Robert Allio and
Malcolm Pennington, editors, Corporate planning Techniques and applications,
New York, 1979.
7. Philippe Haspeslagh, Portfolio planning: uses and limits, Harvard Business Review,
January-February 1982, pp.61-63.
8. Dhawan Radhika, How to develop the best new products , Business Today, June
22,1999,pp.74 85.
9. Dobhal Shailesh & Gupta Indrajit, David Vs Goliath ii: The soap opera, Business
Today, October 7 1999, pp.23-24.
10. Hubert Gatington, Eric Anderson and Kristiaan Helsen, Competitive reactions to
market entry: explaining interfirm differences, Journal of Marketing research,
February 1989, pp.44-55.
11. Albert Page, Assessing new product development practices and performances,
Journal of product innovation and management, Spetember 1993, pp.136-145.
135
12. Bhushan Ratna, Turning on the heat, Businessline, October 12, 2000.Tom Gorman,
What will our customers think of this product idea? Business Marketing, September
1987, pp.76-78.
13. Chakraborthy Alokananda, Donning the war paint, Business India, November 3
16, 1997, pp. 97-98.
14. Challapalli Sravanthi, "Margo dishes out a new avatar, Businessline, January 11,
2001
15. Robert Cooper, The new product system: the industry experience, Journal of
Product innovation and management, June 1992, pp.113-120.
16. Roger Calantone, Anthony Di Benendetto and Ted Haggblom, Principles of New
product Management: Exploring the beliefs of product practitioners, Journal of
product innovation and management, June 1995, pp.235-240.
17. Salton, Gary J., Organizational Engineering: A New Method of Creating High
Performance Human Structures. Ann Arbor: Professional Communications Inc.,
1966.
Brand management
1. Introduction:
Brand is a name term, sign, symbol, or design or a combination of them intended
to identify the goods or services of one seller or group of sellers and to differentiate them
from those of competitors. In essence the brand identifies the seller (or) maker. Brand is
considered to be a trademark or distinctive name identifying a product or manufacturer.
The brand must be a bridge between the customer and the owner of the brand. Both
functional and emotional satisfaction is attained through branding. A brand has the
power to create interest and command an immediate second look. The value of a business
is directly related to the strength of its brand. A strong brand will evoke a number of
images in the mind of the prospects.
Branding is a major issue in product strategy on the one hand, developing a
branded product requires a great deal of long term investment especially for promotion,
advertising and packaging. On the other hand manufacturers eventually learn market
power lies with building their own brands. Even when the companies can no longer
afford to manufacture their products in their homelands, the brand name continues to
command customer loyalty.
A brand is essentially a sellers promise to deliver a specific set of features;
benefits services consistently to the buyers. The best brand conveys warranty of quality.
Brands convey even more meanings up to six levels.
Attributes
Benefits to the customer
Producers values
Culture
136
Personality
User
2. Learning objectives:
After studying this unit, you will understand:
The traits of successful brands
The brand management aspects and strategies
The brand equity issues and why is it important etc..
3. Brand management:
Kevin Lane Keller, brand guru identified the following ten traits as the common aspect
behind the successful brands:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
137
3. Reduced or even eliminated the need for regular infusion of fresh capital investment
needs can be met out of internal accruals, and extensions of a successful brand can
give the benefits of a new product launch at reduced cost.
4. Created an entry barrier for would be rivals, who must now spend heavily to counter
the brand and
5. Insulated the brand from economic cycles, since a successful brand immediately
reduces the impact of price alone on demand.
3.1.Branding Decisions:
3.1.1.Brand name decisions:
The first decision is whether the company should develop a brand name for its
product. Branding is such a strong force that hardly anything goes unbranded. In some
cases however there has been no branding of certain staple consumer goods and
pharmaceuticals. generics are unbranded, plainly packaged, less expensive versions of
common products. They offer standard or low quality at a price that may be as much as
20 percent to 40 percent lower than nationally advertised brands and 10 percent to 20
percent lower than retailer private label brands. The lower price is made possible by
lower quality ingredients, lower cost labeling and packaging, minimal advertising. The
advantages of brand naming are:
Easier for the seller to process orders and track down problems
Provide legal protection against plagiarism
Gives the seller the opportunity to attract a loyal and profitable set of customers
Helps build corporate image
Qualities of a brand name are as follows
Should suggest something about products benefits like fairever or fair &lovely
Should suggest product qualities such as action or color like sunsilk, 'Head and
Shoulders
Should be easy to pronounce like Tide ,surf
Should be distinctive like Rin, Lux
Should not carry poor meanings in other countries and languages.
There are certain basic categories of brand (or corporate) name:
Descriptive name A name which describes the product or service for which it is
intended, e.g., MILMA brand of milk available in Kerala.
Associative name A name which alludes to an aspect or benefit of the product or
service, often by means of an original or striking image or idea, e.g., VISA.
Freestanding name A name which has no link to the product or service but
which might have meaning of its own, e.g., PENGUIN.
Abstract name A name which is entirely invented and has no meaning of its
own, e.g.,ONIDA. Abstract names are a sub-set of freestanding names because
they also have no link to the product of service.
138
Coined name Any name which is in some way invented. Coined names can be
descriptive (3M), associative (TANCEM Tamil nadu cements) and
freestanding/abstract (ELECTROLUX).
The brand name is the most important element in the branding mix. It identifies the
product or service, and allows the consumers to specify, reject or recommend brands.
Through time and use, a name can therefore become a valuable asset. Colgate- Palmolive
company has systematically tried to harmonise the naming of its products from country to
country. In general, it uses the Colgate name for oral care products, such as toothpaste,
and the Palmolive name for body care products, such as shampoos and conditioners.
When Nissan Motor Company introduced its cars into the United States, its management
did not have total confidence in the quality of its cars, so the name Datsun was used for
fear of losing face. However, after 20 years of promoting the Datsun name and building a
quality image, the company decided to phase out the Datsun name and substitute the
corporate name, Nissan. For a time, the companys cars carried both names, until the
Nissan name was firmly established in consumers minds.
Inter brand in the 1980s helped pioneer a shift in pharmaceutical naming trends
through the creation of the name Prozac for Eli Lillys anti-depressant. Prior to this,
pharmaceuticals names were scientific sounding with usually some reference to the
chemical compound. Prozac was coined from Pro for professional, pro-active and
Zac for the ability of the medication to target exactly the area needing treatment. It was
one of the first names to suggest a benefit in a way that was approachable to consumers.
Over 10 years later, Prozac still remains the worlds leading antidepressant with over $3
billion in annual sales. Hence naming a brand is very important. The various stages in
naming a brand are:
1. Decide what job the new name need to perform, now and in the future.
2. Isolate those naming themes that are relevant to the consumer and appropriate in
branding and positioning terms.
3. Use Delphi technique or focus groups, name development specialists, computers and
an existing name library to create names.
4. Once a vast list of names are identified, it needs to be pruned to manageable
proportions.
5. Names that have difficulty of pronounciation, legibility, memorability or meaning
need to be discarded.
6. Eliminate those names that are unregistrable as trade marks, that are too close to
existing competitive marks or that fail to meet other criteria like length of the name
etc.
7. Choose the name upon discussion with the top management, advertising agency and
the participants in the marketing system.
Initially, Mitsubishi sought to sell its four-wheel-drive utility wagon as the Pajero until
they learned it meant "straw man" in Spanish; it was renamed the Montero, "Mountain
Man." One firm tried to sell a de-icer in the U.S. by the name "Super-Piss." The Spanish
potato chip "Bum" did not do well for the same reason. Nissan also sought to sell a sports
139
car in the U.S. in the early '70s called the "Fair Lady." It later sold better as the 240Z. In
any naming process, hundreds of potential names are eliminated by some of the steps
already mentioned. In coming up with a name for the old Bell Labs division of AT&T,
San Francisco-based firm Landor Associates went through 700 different names before
they came up with "Lucent Technologies." Finally, it makes sense to eliminate names
that do not sound well or make sense in other languages. During Coca-Cola's first
entrance in China, great care was taken to get the phonetics correct in pronouncing CocaCola. However, the name manipulators forgot the meaning of the symbols they selected
only to learn they meant "kiss the wax tadpole."
Qualities of a brand name are as follows
Should suggest something about products benefits like fairever or fair &lovely
Should suggest product qualities such as action or color like sunsilk, 'Head and
Shoulders
Should be easy to pronounce like Tide ,surf
Should be distinctive like Rin, Lux
Should not carry poor meanings in other countries and languages.
3.1.2.Brand Sponsor Decision:
There are several options with respect to brand sponsorship. The products can be
launched as any of the following types of brands.
Manufacturer brand-called sometimes as a national brand like the Blowplast
Industries VIP.
Distributor brand-also called reseller, store, house (or) private brand.
Licensed brand name. Although manufacturer brands dominate, large retailers
have been developing their own brands by contracting production from willing
manufacturers.
In years past, customers viewed brands in a category arranged in a brand ladder with
their favorite brand at the top and remaining brands in descending order of preference.
Now the brand ladder concept is being replaced by brand parity that many brands are
equivalent.
3.1.3.Brand Strategy Decision:
A company has five choices with regards to brand strategy. They are,
1. Line extensions: existing brand name extended to new sizes or flavors in the existing
product category like Cinthol cologne, Cinthol lime. Extensions may lead to the
brand name losing in specific meaning. However there is a much higher chance of
survival than brand new products.
2. Brand extensions: where a company may use its existing brand name to launch new
products in other categories like the brand Rin being extended to both detergent
140
powders, detergent cakes. The new product may disappoint buyers and damage their
report for the companys other products. The brand name may be in appropriate to the
new product. The brand name may also lose its special positioning in consumers
mind trough over extension. Brand dilution occurs when consumers no longer
associate a brand with a specific product or highly similar products.
3. Multi-brands: a company will often introduce additional brands in the same product
category. Sometimes the company is trying to establish different features or appeal to
different buying motives. A multi-branding strategy also enables the company to lock
up more distributor shelf space and to protect its major brand by setting up flanker
brands. Hindustan lever limited produces three different brands of detergent
powders. Company inherits different brand name in the process of acquiring
competitors. SmithKline Beecham consumer health care owns the acquired brand
names like Viva, Malt ova. Hindustan Lever Ltd. Owns acquired brand names like
Brook Bond, Hamam Kissan. A major pitfall introducing multi-brand entries is that
each might obtain only a small market share and none may be particularly profitable.
The company will have dissipated its resources over several brands instead of
building a few highly profitable brands.
4. New Brands: New Brands are created when company launches products in a new
category it may find that none of its current brand names are appropriate. Yet, the
cost of establishing a new brand name in the market place is costly.
5. Co Brands: A co-brand is a combination of two or more well known brands in an
offer like the combination of SBI and GE Capital in the issue of SBI credit cards.
3.1.4.Brand Repositioning:However well a brand is currently positioned, the company
may have to reposition it later when facing new competitors or changing customer
preferences. The UB groups McDowells Mera no.1 brand was once positioned for
people with ecstatic moods but now it has been repositioned as a drink for socially
responsible individuals.
The branding strategies for readymade garments and general lighting segments are
depicted in the following figure :
Figure: Branding strategies some examples
Strategy/decision
Readymade Garments
General lighting
Always branding is
advantageous.
e.g. Arrow, Louis Phillipe,
Peter England, Cambridge
Licensed brand name is
most common
e.g. Arrow (Cluett Peabody,
USA)
Louis Phillipe ( Van
Heusen, UK)
Brand-sponsor decision
Manufacturers brand
e.g.. Philips, Bajaj
141
3.2.Brand meaning:
A brand can convey up to six levels of meaning. The challenge in branding is to develop
a deep set of these meanings for the brand. When the audience can visualise all the six
levels, then the brand can be deemed to be a success. The following are the six levels:
1. The key attributes based on its recognition, reputation, affinity and expertise needs to
be communicated to the customers. Hence if Maruti advertises on its MPFI engine or
Bajaj advertises on its resale value, then the attributes are put across to the customers.
2. The second level is that the attributes should be translated into functional and or
emotional benefits. Thus Maruti advertises that every 2 out of 3 buy a Maruti
translates their key attributes across the customers.
3. The third level of meaning is about the producers values. By advertising that even in
Himalayas, Maruti has a service centre, they show that they care for the customer and
their concern to have as many service centers across the country.
4. The fourth level is in its culture. Johnson and Johnson had always focussed on the
bondage between the mother and the child while advertising their child care products,
it represents their culture. Hyundai Santro focussed their Korean culture intitally and
then used a celebrity to drive home their product differentiations. When Dabur Amla
hair oil advertises, the non-chemical requirements of the Indian women got translated
in their culture.
5. The fifth level of meaning is on the brand personality. The brand is portraying the
personality of an individual who owns it. Hence if surf is to be related to God Shiva,
Nirma is related to Goddess Kali and their relationship will reflect the true identity of
the brands.
142
6. The last level is the kind of person who buys or uses the product. He/She does it
based on the products values, culture and personality. That is the reason why
Raymond advertises the complete man factor to get the premium-ness it expects
from the market. Three roses tea portrays what the totality of tea is all about. Vim
bar is also an example which shows the middle class womens thriftiness and quality
consciousness.
3.3.Brand Platform:
Interbrand's proprietary model for defining brands. The Brand Platform consists of
the following elements:
Brand Vision: The brand's guiding insight into its world.
Brand Mission: How the brand will act on its insight.
Brand Values: The code by which the brand lives. The brand values act as a
benchmark to measure behaviors and performance.
Brand Personality: The brand's personality traits
Brand Tone: That of voice. How the brand speaks to its audiences.
3.4.Brand Architecture:
Brand Architecture is the vehicle by which the brand team functions as a unit to create
synergy, clarity and leverage. How an organization structures and names the brands
within its portfolio is also known as the brand architecture. There are three main types of
brand architecture system:
monolithic, where the corporate name is used on all products and services
offered by the company;
endorsed, where all sub-brands are linked to the corporate brand by means of
either a verbal or visual endorsement; and
freestanding, where the corporate brand operates merely as a holding
company, and each product or service is individually branded for its target
market.
Brand architecture is an organizing structure of brand portfolio that specifies the
brand roles and relationship among the brands and different product market context. It is
mainly defined by the three major dimensions viz. Portfolio roles, Product market context
roles and the Portfolio structure.
Brand portfolio: Brand architecture involves the management of brand portfolio. Brand
portfolio includes all the types of brand viz. Brands and sub-brands as well as co-brands
with other firms. For example, the brand portfolio of HLL consisting of 110 brands with
950 of different types of packs which are operating under different market context like
healthcare, personal care, beverages, etc. During the annual year 2001-2002, HLL has
taken a decision to further prune down their 110 brands to 36 brands only over a three
year period. A brand portfolio can be strengthen by the addition of brand keeping in view
the portfolio perspective. Some international brands are being planned to be strengthened
in HLL.Similarly brands can be deleted by identifying the superfluous brands which are
143
contributing nothing to the brand portfolio. Some of the brands to be deleted by HLL
include Jai soap, Captain cook salt and Aim toothpaste.
Portfolio roles:
For building effective brand architecture it is necessary to identify the portfolio
roles of each brand. A strategic brand or a mega brand is a currently dominating brand
that represents a meaningful future level of sales and profit. For ex: Lux and Lifebuoy are
strategic brands for HLL, TATA consultancy services (TCS) is a strategic brand of TATA
group of cos. because the vision of the firm is to move beyond traditional steel and
automobile business. A linchpin brand unlike strategic brand does not necessarily
represent a meaningful future level of sales and profit but it is a leverage point of a major
business area. It indirectly influences a business by providing a basis for customer
loyalty. For ex. Premium, a brand extension of JK.It is a linchpin brand for JK because
it has extended the JKs credibility in different businesses from chemicals to mens
toiletaries. A silver bullet is a brand or sub-brand that positively influence the image of
another brand.it can be a powerful force in creating, changing and maintaining a brand
image. For example, when iMaC was launched it has provided a significant boast in
public perception of the Apple brand. Strategic, Linchpin and Silver bullet brands
involves investments and active management for fulfilling their strategic mission. The
cash cow brands on contrast does not require any investment because it has a significant
loyal customer base. The role of a cash cow brand is to generate marginal resources that
can be invested in other brands, which will help for future growth and vitality of brand
portfolio. For ex; Fair and Lovely fairness cream the core product of HLL, a brand that
has been extended to soaps. Similarly, Dettol as a cash cow brand has been extended in
order to gain the maximum out of the equity.
Product market context roles
There are four steps of product market context roles that work together to define a
specific offering:
a) Endorser and sub-brands roles: An endorser brand is an established brand that
provides credibility and substance to the offering. Endorser brands usually represents
organizations rather than products because organizational associations such as
innovation, leadership and trust are particularly relevant in endorsement context for
example, Tata has 80 different companies operating in seven business sectors, which are
endorsed under the mega brand TATA. The sub brands on the other hand stretches
endorser brands that add associations, a brand personality or any other quality which
creates brand identity of it for ex. Nestles Cerelac, Gillettes Mach 3 and Cadburys
Bournvita. The understanding and use of endorser brand and sub brands is a key in
achieving clarity, synergy and leverage in the brand portfolio.
b) Benefit brands: The benefit brand is a brand which offers either features, component
ingredients or services which becomes the unique selling proposition (USP) of offering.
144
For example, Johnson and Johnson brand Indicator toothbrush, has a branded feature
which shows the time to replace the toothbrush.
c) Co-Brands: Co- branding occurs when brands from different organizations combine to
create an offering in which each plays a driver role. The impact of co-branding can be
greater than expected when the associations of each brand are strong and complementary.
d) Driver role: Driver role is an extent to which a brand drives the purchase decision and
defines the use experience. Brand with a driver role will have some level of loyalty.
Nirma washing powder for Nirma Chemicals and Lifebuoy for HLL are driver brands.
Brand portfolio structure:
The brands in the portfolio have a relationship with each other. Brand
architecture also involves designing a structure of all the brands, which will provide
clarity to the customer rather than complexity and confusion. It must provide a sense of
order, purpose and direction to the organization. Three approaches can be utilized to
present the portfolio structure.
For any firm the objectives behind designing and maintaining an effective brand
architecture are:
Create effective and powerful brands.
Understand the portfolio roles of each brand (strategic, silver bullet, linchpin and
cash cow) and allocate the brand building resources in that manner.
Create synergy between brands by enhancing visibility, creating and reinforcing
associations and cost efficiencies.
Advance clarity of product offering to the customers and organization.
Leveraging the brand equity by proper brand and line extensions exercise.
Provide a platform for future growth option to the organisation.
3.5.Brand Extension:
In todays fiercely competitive marketplace, brand extensions have become a
standard strategy for new product introductions. Brand extensions have proliferated over
the past decade, and the rationale behind endowing a new product with a well-known
brand name is to provide consumers--and the trade--with a sense of familiarity and
security by leveraging positive brand characteristics in a new product category. Brand
extensions have become a standard strategy for new product introductions in todays
fiercely competitive marketplace. It is considered as a marketing strategy in which a
company uses one of its established brand names on a modified product i.e., a new line,
or on an entirely related new product. It is done so because the new products entering the
market place are well supported and well recognised. Core brands are being referred to
as assets with profit generating capabilities. A Company may decide not to position the
brand explicitly against any competitor. In implementing this strategy, the firm may
advertise the brand and its benefits on its own grounds rather than in a comparative
fashion. In this respect, brand-extension research has shown that the positive affect of a
brand may be transferred to the extension. Moreover, affect transfer is most likely to
145
occur when the brands old and the new categories are perceived to be similar. Finally,
brand-specific associations are another important factor to consider; they may dominate
the effects of brand affect and category similarity, especially when consumers are
knowledgeable about the brand.
Line extensions and brand extensions are different as such. Line extensions should
refer only to additions to an existing product like new sizes, styles or related products
to fill out the line. Thus, Fair Glow is an addition to the Godrej toilet soap line,
which already included Cinthol and Ganga. Wheel was a line extension to HLLs line
of detergent bars, which already contained Rin and Surf. By contrast, brand extension
refers to using an existing brand name to enter another product market category
altogether viz., Dettol antiseptic liquid and Dettol soap.
Product line extension: Adding related products to an already established brand.
Arrow After hours shirts being added to business shirts.
Product form extension: Providing the same product in another forms variant.
Ponds soap cake offered as a liquid soap is an example.
Product category extension: Launching a different product under an already
successful products brand name. BiC disposable razors under the same brand
name as BiC disposable ball pens. Shivaki watches after entering TV market as
Shivaki TV. Amul Ice creams after the success of Amul Butter.
The most common form of brand extension is family branding. A family brand is
assigned to an entire range or mix of all product items. Godrej makes soaps, locks,
furniture etc. In all these products, Godrej brand extensions are carried out. A
powerful name, however, is no guarantee that family branding will succeed. Xerox
tried to extend its powerful brand name to computers and printers but failed. Murphy
suggests that brand extensions constitute an estimated 95 per cent of the 16,000 new
products launched in the Untied States every year. Extensions are popular because
they can provide new products with a ready-made image while helping existing
products through increased brand exposure. However, extending a brand name to
inappropriate products may result in product failure and/or reduced brand value.
There are three key factors that a company must consider in the implementation of a
brand-extension strategy:
(1) competitive brands in the extension categories
(2) the attributes of the extension brand and
(3) The perceived fit between the brand and the extension.
3.6. Brand Stretching:
Brand stretching is applying an existing brand to a completely different business
area or a new product or service- such as Cadburys entry into cola market. The risk
attached to brand stretching is that failure in the new field may affect the core product.
NEPC is one such example. Its failure in the Television, aviation and agricultural
146
businesses affected the very credibility of NEPC brand. One aspect of brand stretching is
that, once a brand personality becomes strongly associated with a product category, it
becomes difficult to stretch the brand to another category like Hero Honda shampoo.
3.7. Brand equity:
Brand equity is a set of assets and liabilities linked to a brands name and symbol
that add to subtract from the value provided by a product or service to ad firm and / or
that firms customers. According to David A. Aaker, brand equity is "a set of brand assets
and liabilities linked to a brand, its name and symbol, that add to or subtract from the
value provided by a product or service to a firm and/or that firm's customers". Lance
Leuthesser, et al wrote that "Brand equity represents the value (to a consumer) of a
product, above that which would result for an otherwise identical product without the
brand's name. In other words, brand equity represents the degree to which a brand's name
alone contributes value to the offering (again, from the perspective of the consumer)". In
America, there is a now an influential body called the Coalition for Brand Equity
(founded 1991), which evangelists for the importance of building brand relationships and
brand loyalty. The Marketing Science Institute defines brand equity as, The set of
associations and behaviors on the part of the brand's customers, channel members, and
parent corporations that permit the brand to earn greater volume or greater margins than it
could without the brand name and that gives the brand a strong, sustainable, and
differentiated advantage over competitors. Joel Axelrod defines brand equity as the
incremental amount your customer will pay to obtain your brand rather than a physically
comparable product without your brand name.
The assets and liabilities on which brand equity is based differ from context to
context. They can be usefully grouped into four categories viz., Perceived quality, brand
awareness, brand identity, and brand loyalty. Brand equity refers to a set of assets and
liabilities linked to a brand, its name and symbol that add to or subtract from the value
provided by a product or service to a firm and or to that firms competitors. In other
words brand equity provides (or negatively subtract) value to a firm in the form of price
premium or trade leverage or competitive advantage. The most important assets of any
business are intangible: its company name, brand, symbols, and slogans, and their
underlying associations, perceived quality, name awareness, customer base, and
proprietary resources such as patents, trademarks, and channel relationships. These
assets, which comprise brand equity, are a primary source of competitive advantage and
future earnings. The overall description of Brand Equity incorporates the ability to
provide added value to a company's products and services. This added value can be used
to the company's advantage to charge price premiums, lower marketing costs and offer
greater opportunities for customer purchase. In FMCG products, brand equities are
relatively stronger as the consumer is reluctant to try unknown brands and even
unbranded products as most of these products are for personal use. It is often difficult to
differentiate a product on technical or functional grounds and therefore there is little
reason to switch from a known brand. A successful brand generates strong cash flow,
which enables the company brand to reinvest a part of it in the form of aggressive
advertisement or promotion in order to reinforce the perceived superiority of the brand.
147
they still face the task of making customers switch brands. Switching costs would be a
consideration for a software user, for example, when a substantial investment has already
been made in training employees to learn a particular software system. Another
development is Co-Branding. It is also called dual branding. Here two or more wellknown brands are combined in an offer. It is a form of cooperation between two or more
brands with significant customer recognition, in which all the participant brand names are
retained. Co-branding lies between the two extreme points of marketing alliances. It is of
medium to long term duration and its shared value potential is not as low as a temporary
nature nor it is as high as to justify the culmination into a joint venture. Each brand
sponsor expects that the other brand name will strengthen preference or purchase
intention. If the two brands are such that the brand values are difficult to be shared, the
success of a co-branding exercise between them is remote. In case of co-packaged
products, each brand hopes it might be reaching a new audience by associating with other
brand. If an organization has a strong brand, it can last for years. If it is not having a
brand and only physical infrastructure, it is destined to be in loss.
6. Exercises:
1. There are certain characteristics for a brand. Keeping these characteristics, find out
whether the following brands have them or not. Justify your answer
a. Kitply
b. Close-up
c. Dabur
d. Maltova
e. Pepsodent
f. Style-Spa
2. Explain the brand extensions done by companies in India.
3. Brand stretching will damage the companies in the long run- Explain with examples.
4. Do you think brand equity is needed for short run gains? Explain.
5. Brand dilution can lead to brand deletion- with examples explain.
7. References:
1. Balaji Prasad & M.Chandrasekhar, The power of brand, Indian management,
August 1998, pp.88-89.
2. Bruce Horovitz and Melanie Wells, Long after their sales stop sizzling, some brand
names linger in product purgatory, USA Today, May 2, 1995, p.1.
3. Chris Roush, At Timex, they are positively glowing, Business Week, July 12, 1993,
p.141.
4. deChatnatony and McDonald, Creating powerful brands, Oxford Butterworth,
1998.
5. John A.Quelch & David Harding, Brands versus private labels: fighting to win,
Harvard Business Review, Jan-Feb, 1996, pp.105-109.
149
6. Kevin Goldman, Old Spices familiar sailor is lost at sea, Wall Street journal,
September 10, 1993, p.2.
7. Kevin Lane Keller, Managing Brands for the long run: Brand reinforcement and
revitalisation strategies, California Management Review, spring 1999, pp.120-122.
8. Kevin Lane Keller, Susan Heckler and Michael Houston, The effects of brand name
suggestions on advertising recall, Journal of marketing, January 1998, pp.48-56.
9. Kotler, Philip; Marketing Management, Prentice Hall of India private limited, New
Delhi, 1999, pp. 414 417.
10. Kumar, .S. Ramesh , Importance of Techno-branding, Business Line Catalyst,
Thursday, March 16,2000.
11. Laura Bird, Tambrands plans global advertising campaign, Wall Street Journal,
June 22, 1993, p.8.
12. Mahaswetha Ghosh Roy, Second coming, Business World, 20 March-2April 1996,
pp.44-46.
13. Michael McCarthy, Pepsi is returning to younger generation, Wall Street journal,
January 22, 1994, p.2.
14. Mohan Ramamurthy, Sweet taste of victory, Business India, May 18-21, 1998.
15. Mukul Gupta, Tug of war, Indian management, September 1997, pp.37-39.
16. Nielson, Brand stretching can be fun- and dangerous, The Economist, 5 May, p.105.
17. Pratap Ravindran, Brands, The corporate trust mark, Business Line, January 9,
1999.
Pricing
1. Introduction:
Most people simply use the word price to indicate what it costs to acquire a product. The
pricing decision is a critical one for most marketers, yet the amount of attention given to
this key area is often much less than is given to other marketing decisions. One reason
for the lack of attention is that many believe price setting is a mechanical process
requiring the marketer to utilize financial tools, such as spreadsheets, to build their case
for setting price levels. While financial tools are widely used to assist in setting price,
marketers must consider many other factors when arriving at the price for which their
product will sell.
2. Learning Objectives:
150
3. Pricing:
Price is considered as a component of an exchange or transaction that takes place
between two parties and refers to what must be given up by one party (i.e., buyer) in
order to obtain something offered by another party (i.e., seller). Price means different
things to different participants in an exchange. One is the buyer. Their view for those
making a purchase, price refers to what must be given up to obtain benefits. In most
cases what is given up is financial consideration (e.g., money) in exchange for acquiring
access to a good or service. But financial consideration is not always what the buyer
gives up. Sometimes in a barter situation a buyer may acquire a product by giving up
their own product. For instance, two farmers may exchange chicken for crops. In the
case of the seller, price reflects the revenue generated for each product sold and, thus, is
an important factor in determining profit. For marketing organizations price also serves
as a marketing tool and is a key element in marketing promotions. For example, most
discount retailers highlight product pricing in their advertising campaigns. Price is what a
buyer pays to acquire products from a seller. Cost concerns the sellers investment (e.g.,
manufacturing expense) in the product being exchanged with a buyer. For marketing
organizations seeking to make a profit the hope is that price will exceed cost so the
organization can see financial gain from the transaction. While product pricing is a main
topic for discussion when a company is examining its overall profitability, pricing
decisions are not limited to for-profit companies. Not-for-profit organizations, such as
charities, educational institutions and industry trade groups, also set prices, though it is
often not as apparent.
3.1. Basic principles of pricing:
Before any discussion on pricing, it is important to know what really drives pricing.
Every organization is involved in a cost component before the ultimate product comes to
the market. Now we need to know how the cost is calculated. The components that are
considered in costing include cost of materials that you have issued for order, activity you
have performed in terms of labour hours that you entered while confirming the order (the
rates for the labour vary..) which is generally associated with a formula key and attached
to a work center that is linked to a cost center also and the overhead as applicable with
respect to that cost center based on a predetermined cost center planning and its rate.
A break-even analysis examines the interaction among fixed costs, variable costs,
prices, and unit volume to determine that combination of elements in which revenues and
total costs are equal. Fixed costs are those expenses necessary to keep the business open,
and are not impacted by sales volume. They will include such things as rent, basic
telephone expenses and utilities, wages for core employees, loan or lease payments, and
other necessary expenditures. An entrepreneur should also include a living wage for
himself/herself as a fixed cost. Variable costs include those expenses that change as a
result of sales volume. Variable costs can also be very complex; for example, higher sales
151
in one area of our business may increase long distance charges. Labor costs may be fixed
for full-time employees, then, as sales increase, some overtime is incurred until additional
personnel can be justified. Generally, an initial break-even analysis focuses on a
relatively narrow range of sales volume in which variable costs are simple to calculate. A
general term often used for the difference between selling price and variable cost is
"contribution margin," or the amount that the unit sale contributes to the margin available
to pay fixed costs, and generate profit. Selling price is determined based on all this above
considerations. The extent of contribution margin will decide the pricing of the product.
3.2.Importance of Pricing:
For a buyer, value of a product will change as perceived price paid and/or
perceived benefits received change. But the price paid in a transaction is not only
financial it can also involve other things that a buyer may be giving up. For example, in
addition to paying money a customer may have to spend time learning to use a product,
pay to have an old product removed, and close down current operations while a product is
installed or incur other expenses. Pricing decisions can have important consequences for
the marketing organization and the attention given by the marketer to pricing is just as
important as the attention given to more recognizable marketing activities. In most
companies, prices are tactically derived based on internal costs and gut reaction to
competitive moves.
This is often the only element the marketer can change quickly in response to demand
shifts and it is directly related to total revenue. Profits can be made only by knowing the
difference between total revenue and total cost. Organizations can use price symbolically,
emphasize quality or bargain. The importance of pricing depends on the image the
organization wants to portray, competitive activity in the market and the changing
behaviour of the customer. From a strategic aspect, pricing has more impact on
positioning and ultimate profitability than any other item in the overall marketing mix.
Depending on market sensitivities and current profit margins, a 1% increase in price
could increase profitability by up to 10%. The key to effective strategic pricing is to
leverage market based understanding of how customer's value new and existing offerings
in a competitive marketplace. Customers want the best value for their money, and thus
they will almost always do a quality comparison and make purchases based on the best
price for the best value. How customers view the product or service and what they are
willing to pay for it is based upon those perceptions. In the end, customers will tell
through their purchasing behavior whether or not the prices are too high, too low or right
on the money.
3.3.Factors Affecting Pricing Decision
There are both internal and external factors that affect pricing.
3.3.1. Internal Factors :
These internal factors are controllable by the company and, if necessary, can be
altered. However, while the organization may have control over these factors making a
152
quick change is not always realistic. For instance, product pricing may depend heavily
on the productivity of a manufacturing facility. The marketer knows that increasing
productivity can reduce the cost of producing each product and thus allow the marketer to
potentially lower the products price. But increasing productivity may require major
changes at the manufacturing facility that will take time and will not translate into lower
price products for a considerable period of time. Corporate objectives can be wideranging and include different objectives for different functional areas (e.g., objectives for
production, human resources, etc). While pricing decisions are influenced by many types
of objectives set up for the marketing functional area, there are four key objectives in
which price plays a central role. In most situations only one of these objectives will be
followed, though the marketer may have different objectives for different products. The
four main marketing objectives affecting price include:
Return on Investment : A firm may set as a marketing objective the requirement
that all products attain a certain percentage return on the organizations spending on
marketing the product.
Cash Flow: Firms may seek to set prices at a level that will insure that sales
revenue will at least cover product production and marketing costs. This objective
allows the marketer to worry less about product profitability and instead directs
energies to building a market for the product. This is most likely to occur with new
products where the organizational objectives allow a new product to simply meet its
expenses while efforts are made to establish the product in the market.
Market Share: The pricing decision may be important when the firm has an
objective of gaining a hold in a new market or retaining a certain percent of an
existing market. For new products under this objective the price is set artificially
low in order to capture a sizeable portion of the market and will be increased as the
product becomes more accepted by the target market. For existing products, firms
may use price decisions to insure they retain market share in instances where there is
a high level of market competition and competitors who are willing to compete on
price.
Profit maximization: Older products that appeal to a market that is no longer
growing may have a company objective requiring the price be set at a level that
optimizes profits. This is often the case when the marketer has little incentive to
introduce improvements to the product and will continue to sell the same product at
a price premium for as long as some in the market is willing to buy.
Marketing strategy concerns the decisions marketers make to help the company satisfy its
target market and attain its business and marketing objectives. Price, of course, is one of
the key marketing mix decisions and since all marketing mix decisions must work
together, the final price will be impacted by how other marketing decisions are
made. For instance, marketers selling high quality products would be expected to price
their products in a range that will add to the perception of the product being at a highlevel.
Costing is yet another area of concern. While variable costs are often determined on a
per-unit basis, applying fixed costs to individual products is less straightforward. For
153
154
adjustments are made to reduce the list price in an effort to either stimulate interest in the
product or to indirectly pay channel partners for the services they offer when handling the
product. It should be noted that many companies do not make adjustments to their list
price, particularly those selling directly to final customers. There are two key reasons for
this. First, the product is in high demand and therefore the marketer sees little reason to
lower the price. Second, the marketer believes the product holds sufficient value for
customers at its current list price and the marketer feels reducing the price may actually
lead buyers to question the quality of the product.
For firms that do make standard price adjustments, the possibilities include:
Quantity Discounts
Trade Allowances
Geographic Pricing
Special Segment Discounts
Quantity Discounts
This adjustment offers buyers an incentive of lower per-unit pricing as more products are
purchased. Most quantity or volume discounts are triggered when a buyer reaches certain
purchase levels. For instance, a buyer may pay the list price when they purchase between
1-99 units but receive a 5% discount off the list price when the purchase exceeds 100
units. The most common quantity discounts exist when a buyer places an order that
exceeds a certain minimum level. While quantity discounts are used by marketers to
stimulate higher purchase levels, the rational for using these often rests in the cost of
product shipment. There can be discounts offered to the products. This method allows
the buyer to receive a discount as more products are purchased over time. For instance, if
a buyer regularly purchases from a supplier they may see a discount once the buyer has
reached predetermined monetary or quantity levels. The key reason to use this
adjustment is to create an incentive for buyers to remain loyal and purchase again.
Trade Discounts
Manufacturers who rely on channel partners to distribute their products (e.g., retailers,
wholesalers) offer trade discounts off of list price. Essentially the difference between the
trade discounted prices paid by the reseller and the price the reseller charges its customer
will be the resellers profit.
Special Segment Pricing
In some industries special classes of customers within a target market are offered pricing
that differs from the rest of the market. The main reasons for doing this include: building
future demand by appealing to new or younger customers; improving the brands image
as being sensitive to customers needs; and rewarding long time customers with price
breaks. For instance, many companies including railways, airways offer lower prices to
senior citizens. Some marketers offer non-profit customers lower prices compared to that
156
charged to for-profit firms. Other industries may offer lower prices to students or
children.
Geographic Pricing
Products requiring marketers to pay higher costs that are affected by geographic area in
which a product is sold may result in adjustments to compensate for the higher
expense. The most likely cause for charging a different price rests with the cost of
transporting a product from the suppliers distribution location to the buyers place of
business. Transportation expense is not the only cost that may raise a products
price. Special taxes or tariffs may be imposed on certain products by local, regional or
international governments which a seller passes along in the form of higher prices. Now
with the advent of VAT, these issues will be overcome.
The final price may be further adjusted through promotional pricing. Unlike standard
adjustments, which are often permanently part of a marketers pricing strategy and may
include either a decrease or increase in price, promotional pricing is a temporary
adjustment that only involves price reductions. They are:
Markdowns:
The most common method for stimulating customer interest using price is the
promotional markdown method, which offers the product at a price that is lower than the
products normal selling price. There are several types of markdowns including:
Temporary Markdown Possibly the most familiar pricing method marketers use
to generate sales is to offer a temporary markdown or sale pricing. These
markdowns are normally for a specified period of time the conclusion of which will
result in the product being raised back to the normal selling price.
Permanent Markdown Unlike the temporary markdown where the price will
eventually be raised back to a higher price, the permanent markdown is intended to
move the product out of inventory.
Seasonal Products that are primarily sold during a particular time of the year,
such as clothing, gardening products, sporting goods and holiday-specific items, may
see price reductions at the conclusion of its prime selling season.
Loss Leaders:
An important type of pricing program used primarily by retailers is the loss
leader. Under this method a product is intentionally sold at or below the cost the retailer
pays to acquire the product from suppliers. The idea is that offering such a low price will
entice a high level of customer traffic to visit a retailers store or website.
157
Sales Promotions:
Sales Promotion may offer several types of pricing promotions to simulate
demand. These include rebates, coupons, trade-in, and loyalty programs. There is a
separate unit on Sales promotions later on.
Bundle Pricing:
Another pricing adjustment designed to increase sales is to offer discounted pricing when
customers purchase several different products at the same time. Termed bundle pricing,
the technique is often used to sell products that are complementary to a main
product. For buyers, the overall cost of the purchase shows a savings compared to
purchasing each product individually. For example, a TV retailer may offer a discounted
price when customers purchase both 29 TV and DVD that is lower than if both items
were purchased separately.
With the price decided, the final step for the marketer is to determine in what form and in
what timeframe customers will make payment. As one would expect payment is most
often in a monetary form though in certain situations the payment may be part of a barter
arrangement in which products or services are exchanged.
Dynamic Pricing
The concept of dynamic pricing has received a great deal of attention in recent years due
to its prevalent use by Internet retailers. But the basic idea of dynamic pricing has been
around since the dawn commerce. Essentially dynamic pricing allows for the point-ofsale (i.e., at the time and place of purchase) price adjustments to take place for customers
meeting certain criteria established by the seller. The most common and oldest form of
dynamic pricing is haggling; the give-and-take that takes place between buyer and seller
as they settle on a price.
Finally marketers must decide in what form payments will be accepted. These options
include cash; check, money orders, credit card, online payment systems (e.g., PayPal) or,
for international purchases, bank drafts, letters of credit, and international reply coupons,
to name a few. They can also offer the following:
Ownership Options
Early Payment Incentives
Auction Pricing
Ownership Options:
An important decision faced by marketers as they are formulating their marketing
strategy deals with who will have ownership of the product (i.e., holds legal title) once an
exchange has taken place. The options available include:
158
Buyer Owns Product Outright The most common ownership option is for the
buyer to make payment and then obtain full ownership.
Buyer Has Right to Use but Does Not Have Ownership Many products,
especially those labeled as services, permit customers to make payment in exchange
for the right to use a product but not to own it.
159
far easier to use a markup pricing approach due to its simplicity than it would be to
determine what the market is willing to pay for each product.
Resellers differ in how they use markup pricing with some using the markup on cost
method and others using the markup on selling price method.
Markup on Cost Using this method price is determined by simply multiplying
the cost of each item by a predetermined percentage then adding the result to the
cost. A major general retailer, such as Bigbazzar, may apply a set percentage for
each product category (e.g., womens clothing, automotive, garden supplies, etc.)
making the pricing consistent for all like-products. Alternatively, the predetermined
percentage may be a number that is identified with the marketing objectives (e.g.,
required 20% ROI). The calculation for markup on cost is:
Item Cost
Rs.500
Item Cost
= Price
(1.00 Markup Percentage)
Rs.500
(1.00 .30)
= Rs. 714.3
The astute reader should recognize that the information in markup of selling price
contains the same information in markup of cost.
Cost-Plus Pricing
In the same way markup pricing arrives at price by adding a certain percentage to the
products cost, cost-plus pricing also adds to the cost by using a fixed monetary amount
rather than percentage. For instance, a contractor hired to renovate a homeowners
bathroom will estimate the cost of doing the job by adding their total labor cost to the
cost of the materials used in the renovation.
Breakeven Pricing
Breakeven pricing is associated with breakeven analysis, which is a forecasting tool used
by marketers to determine how many products must be sold before the company starts
realizing a profit. Like the markup method, breakeven pricing does not directly consider
market demand when determining price, however it does indicate the minimum level of
160
demand that is needed before a product will show a profit. From this the marketer can
then assess whether the product can realistically achieve these levels.
Market Pricing
Under the market pricing method cost is not the main factor driving price decisions;
rather initial price is based on analysis of market research in which customer expectations
are measured. The main goal is to learn what customers in an organizations target
market are likely to perceive as an acceptable price. Of course this price should also help
the organization meet its marketing objectives. Market pricing is one of the most
common methods for setting price, and the one that seems most logical given marketings
focus on satisfying customers. For those marketers who use market pricing, options
include:
Backward Pricing
Psychological Pricing
Price Lining
Backward Pricing
In situations where a price range is ingrained in the market, the marketer may need to use
this price as the starting point for many decisions and work backwards to develop
product, promotion and distribution plans.
Psychological Pricing
Certain pricing tactics may have a psychological effect since the results of some studies
have suggested otherwise.
Odd-Even Pricing - Many times a buyer will pass along the price as being lower
than it is either because they recall it being lower than the even number or they
want to impress others with their success in obtaining a good value. For instance,
in our example a buyer who pays Rs.299.95 may tell a friend they paid a little
more than Rs.200 for the product when in fact it was much closer to Rs.300.
161
on price alone. Price lining can also be effective as a method for increasing
profitability. In many cases the cost to the marketer for adding different features to create
different models or service options does not alone justify a big price difference. For
instance, an upgraded model may cost 10% more to produce than a base model but using
the price lining method the upgraded product price may be 20% higher and thus more
profitable than the base model. The increase in profitability offered by price lining is one
reason marketers introduce multiple models, since it allows the company to not only
satisfy the needs of different segments but also presents an option for a customer to buy
up to a higher priced and more profitable model.
Competitive Pricing
For some, competitors price serves as an important reference point from which they set
their price. In some industries, particularly those in which there are a few dominant
competitors and many small companies, the top companies are in the position of holding
price leadership roles where they are often the first in the industry to change
price. Smaller companies must then assume a price follower role and react once the big
companies adjust their price.
When basing pricing decisions on how competitors are setting their price, firms may
follow one of the following approaches:
162
competitor research, makes this type pricing one of the most challenging of all pricing
setting methods.
4. Have you understood type questions:
1. You've just invented an innovative new product and are ready to launch it into the
market. You will most likely price the product high. Your pricing strategy is probably
based on:
A. Distribution strategy
B. Promotion strategy
C. Lack of relevant competition
D. Quality image
2. One of the advantages of break-even analysis is the ease with which costs can be
verified to be fixed or variable
True/ False
3. If the formula for elasticity results in a measure of elasticity (E) equal to 1, an increase
in sales will exactly offset a decrease in price, and total revenue will remain the same
True/ False
4. When Indian oil reduces the price, immediately Essar group lowers the price of petrol
and diesel. This strategy is called:
A. Predatory pricing
B. Cost plus pricing
C. Market share pricing
D. Status quo pricing
5. Economies of scale will help in lowering pricing by:
A.
B.
C.
D.
5. Summary
Customers want the best value for their money, and thus they will almost always do a
quality comparison and make purchases based on the best price for the best value. While
the beat-the-competition pricing approach may work for some, there are many other
complexities involved in establishing a pricing strategy. Many players have started to use
multiple pricing methodology for getting across to variety of customers. Hence pricing is
a major aspect of decision to be made by organizations.
6. Exercises
163
1. Now a days, retailers are resorting to EDLP pricing. What is this pricing? Conduct a
study and explain the same.
2. Trace the role of Break even analysis in price fixation.
3. Do you think cost plus pricing will help organizations? Comment.
4. Elucidate the steps to be taken for pricing strategies for services in the current context
with examples.
7. References
1. Everett Rogers, Diffusion of innovations, Free Press, New York, 1996.
2. Geoffery Moore, Crossing the chasm, Harper Business, New York, 1991.
3. Laurence P. Feldman, Buy In and Get Well' as a Product Launch Strategy,
University of Illinois at Chicago, Journal of Product Development and Management,
1996.
4. Govindarajan, V. and Anthony, R. (1983), How Firms Use Cost Data in Price
Decisions, Management Accounting, July pp. 30-36.
5. Abrams, J. (1964). A New Method for Testing Pricing Decisions. Journal of
Marketing, 28(1).
6. Frderer, R., Hermann, A., and Wbker, G. (1999). In R. Frderer, A. Hermann, amd
G. Wbker (Eds.), Optimal Bundle Pricing: Marketing Strategies for Improving
Economic Performance, chapter Introduction to Price Bundling. Berlin, Heidelberg:
Springer Verlag.
CASE STUDIES
1. CATHOLIC SYRIAN BANK:
In a study of SWOT analysis conducted at some branches of CSB, the following was
found:
Strengths
Branches
Bank deliver products and services through a variety of channels ranging from extensive
branch network, extension counters, ATM centre, Internet banking and Mobile banking.
There are 344 branches all over India. Non performing assets of the bank is reduced. i.e,
Amount of Bad & doubtful debts reduced. Supreme customer services. Employees are
shareholders hence more commitment from employees. Technology Implementation
Weaknesses
A major part of banks branch network is concentrated in southern India. More than 90%
of the total branches are located in Southern India. Any disruption, disturbance or
breakdown in the economy of these areas could adversely affect the result of banks
business and operations. CSB does not have any trademark for the name The Catholic
Syrian Bank along with the logo and the tag line support all the way associated with
the Bank. Bank may not be able to prohibit persons from using the said trademark to their
164
advantage and any unfavorable use of such trademark may adversely affect banks
goodwill and business. Human resource profile is weak. Cost involved in adopting
technology. Reducing Spreads. CBS is not started yet
Opportunities
Bank may undertake mergers or acquisitions. Bank may make acquisitions and
investments to expand customer base, acquire new service or product offerings or to
enhance technical capabilities. The Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets
and Enforcement of Security Interest Act 2002 (The Securitisation Act). With the
enactment of The Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement
of Security Interest Act 2002 (The Securitisation Act), banks have been empowered to
attach assets of the defaulters without intervention of lengthy and time-consuming court
procedures. This has suddenly turned the tables in favour of banks. Till recently, debt
recovery was one of the most hopeless jobs in India due to archaic laws, which were
totally tilted towards borrowers. Banks were in fact at the mercy of borrowers'
willingness to pay. Thus in spite of the fact that most borrowing is against security, the
value of which is often higher than the loan, banks still could not do much except cajole
and tempt borrowers to pay up. Huge NPAs were burdening the entire banking sector.
Due to the fear of increasing NPAs, their willingness to lend and expand business was
also adversely affected. It is expected that over the next couple of years, banks will be
able to significantly clean up their NPA mess due to the Securitisation Act.
Threats
Delay in the rollout of banks core banking solutions. CSB is in the process of
implementing Core Banking Solution (CBS) and has already succeeded in bringing a
substantial number of branches under the CBS system. This technology initiative will
allow to increase interconnectivity among branches and to provide many of the products
and service. In the event of any delay in the roll-out of the CBS across entire branch
network, it may be difficult to expand products and services. Competition. Regulatory
System Cost.
Questions:
1. Do you think the SWOT gives an option for improvement by the bank? Justify.
2. Develop a SWOT for another bank and compare the same with CSB.
2.MARKS AND SPENCER
"There's no need to ask the price - it's a penny" was the proud claim of Marks and
Spencer a hundred years ago. From the start, it had developed a unique position in its
market - an emphasis on low price, wide range and good quality. Over time, the Marks
and Spencer position has been steadily developed, along with its profitability. By the
1990s it looked unstoppable as a retailer, as it progressively expanded its product range
from clothing to food, furnishings and financial services. The world seemed to be waiting
for M&S to exploit, and despite disappointing starts in the US and Canada, it developed
165
steadily throughout Europe and the Far East. Then, just like any star who has been put on
a pedestal, the media began to savage the company. After a sudden drop in profits and
sales during 1998, critics claimed that the company had lost its position in the market
place. It appeared to be like a super tanker, ploughing straight ahead with a management
that had become much less adaptable to change than its nimbler competitors. Many
observers had commented on the fact that the company did not have a marketing
department until 1998. Marketing, at least in terms of advertising the brand, had become
so important to its competitors, but had never been high on Marks & Spencer's agenda.
According to Media Monitoring Services, M&S's total media spending between Dec
1997-Nov 1998 was just 4.7 million, almost a drop in the ocean compared to the
spending of Sainsburys (42.1m); Tesco (27.5m); and Woolworths (21.5m). While
other retailers had worked hard on building a brand image, M&S has relied on the quality
of its stock to do the talking. The argument was that everyone knew what they were
getting with M&S underwear or shirts - good quality at fair, but not cheap, prices.
Similarly with food, M&S's offering was about quality rather than price. M&S believed
its customers knew what the brand stood for and advertising was much less important
than ensuring that it could obtain the right products at the right price.
In 1998, M&S looked to marketing to help turn around its performance, describing its
new marketing division for UK retail as "a significant development in our retailing
philosophy". Many suspected that M&S's conversion to marketing had been encouraged
by the example set by the star of modern retailing, Tesco. There are many similarities
between the problems facing M&S and those which Tesco faced a decade previously. In
the early 1990s Tesco was a brand which looked like it had seen better days. The
retailer's format was tired, its stores poorly laid out and the positioning of the company
was still based on its founder's principle of 'pile it high and sell it cheap'. Its arch-rival,
Sainsbury's, was regarded as the more upmarket store for the middle classes, who
shopped for quality food in a more pleasant environment. Since then, Tesco had
innovated with improved store designs, petrol stations, coffee shops, a new fascia, the
Tesco Clubcard and 24-hour store opening. The list of Tesco's marketing initiatives
seemed to be unstoppable, in an attempt to keep one step ahead of its competitors. In
contrast, M&S had failed to keep pace with customer service. In many issues of retail
development, such as out-of-town shopping centres, Sunday opening and loyalty cards, it
had lagged behind its main competitors. While it has stood still, the likes of Tesco and
Sainsbury's marched ahead until there was no longer much that felt exceptional about the
M&S shopping experience. Analysts argued that M&S had failed to make its store
layouts help shoppers bring clothing together to make outfits. In a typical M&S store, all
jackets would be located in one area and all cardigans in another, for example. Its
competitors had made much greater progress in bringing together co-ordinated sets of
clothing which would encourage shoppers to spend more. M&S has also been criticised
for making things difficult for customers by not accepting payment by major credit cards.
In response to its current troubles, the newly created marketing department of M&S
launched its first national campaign for retail towards the end of 1998. The ads followed
an initial attempt at regional TV advertising earlier in the year, which the company was
said to be very pleased with. The newly appointed Chief Executive claimed "It's not that
166
people don't like what we're selling, but that we haven't got the message across. There
are an awful lot of people who love us for our knickers, but they don't love our home
furnishings because they don't even know they are there." Many critics thought the
problems were much more deep-seated and blamed the store's problems on the fact that
its autumn fashions were seen as dull and uninspiring, and out of touch with consumers'
preferences. Greater authority was pledged to the marketing department when it came to
new product design.
In response to its pledge to listen to what its customers wanted, new designers were
brought in to try and give the company's ranges more sparkle. The company even thought
the previously unthinkable by proposing to stock manufacturers' own branded products,
instead of relying entirely on M&S's own label products. If customers wanted to obtain
variety at M&S, the new thinking was that the company must adapt and offer it. Another
area identified for development was direct marketing of fashion products - an area where
the company had begun to lag behind its rivals who had developed interactive web sites.
Serious questions remained about the company. How quickly could it change in response
to its changed environment? The company had not been known for speedy decision
making, so probably a major structural overhaul was essential before it could get down to
the serious business of adapting to customers' changing needs. Also, there was a great
danger of changing the company's position too far and too fast, thereby alienating its
traditional customers without gaining sufficient new ones. As a warning of how not to
change, M&S's rival Laura Ashley had repositioned itself so radically from its original
format that it now failed to gain the support of any major group. M&S had itself tried to
become more fashion conscious during the mid-1980s with similar effect, and had to
make a hasty retreat to its traditional, more staid image.
QUESTIONS
1. What do you understand by positioning, and what tools are available to Marks and
Spencer to give it a positioning advantage?
2. There has been a lot of debate bout whether the existence of a marketing department
can actually be harmful to services companies because it absolves everybody else of
marketing responsibilities. What then, do you make of M&S's decision to introduce a
marketing department.
main networks to choose from, dozens of tariffs and hundreds of handsets, it easy to see
why buyers sought means of simplifying their buying process. Throughout the 1990s,
Vodafone had positioned its UK network as superior technically to its competitors.
Advertising focused on high coverage rates and call reliability. Vodafone was the UK's
most popular mobile phone operator, with almost eight million customers, including 4.2
million Pay as you Talk customers. It had opened the UK's first cellular network on 1
January 1985and was the market leader since 1986. Vodafone's networks in the UK analogue and digital - between them carried over 100 million calls each week. It took
Vodafone more than 13 years to connect its first three million subscribers but only 12
months to connect the next three million. Vodafone had the largest share of the UK
cellular market with 33% and had more international roaming agreements than any other
UK mobile operator. It could offer its subscribers roaming with 220 networks in 104
countries.
Despite all of the above, Vodafone was aware that although it was recognised as an
extremely strong business in the corporate marketplace, it was not so strong in the market
for personal customers. Research indicated that personal buyers bought Vodafone for
essentially rational reasons rather than having any emotional attachment to the brand. The
success of the competing Orange network, which had developed a very strong image, was
a lesson to Vodafone that many people did not understand many of the product features
on offer, but instead identified with a brand whose values they could share. Vodafone
recognised that it needed to be perceived as adding value to a consumers lifestyle?.
Given the increasing complexity of product features, positioning on technical features
was likely to make life more confusing for personal customers. An alternative approach
was needed which focused on image and lifestyle benefits. The company decided to hire
Identica the consultancy that originally created the One 2 One brand to revamp its
brand communications and advertising strategy in an effort to make Vodafone more
appealing to personal customers. Identica created a new visual language for the
Vodafone brand. Vodafone became involved in the biggest ever TV, press, poster and
radio advertising campaign in its 15 year history. Employing a completely new style, the
new advertising centred around the theme: 'You are now truly mobile. Let the world
come to you' and featured a new end-line - Vodafone YOU ARE HERE. The campaign
demonstrated how Vodafone's products and services were designed to make life easier
for its customers.
The campaign, created by BMP DDB, was worth 20 million over two months alone and
ran for the whole year. Bringing meaning to the Vodafone brand and what it represented,
a series of advertisements, through a range of media, showed how Vodafone let the world
come to its customers, enabling them to be truly mobile. This portrayed how Vodafone
always pioneered to make things more possible for its customers in a wire-free world. In
press and poster executions, Vodafone used arrows photographed in various real life
situations to depict its flagship services, e.g. a weather vane was used to illustrate the
Vodafone Interactive weather service showing how weather information could be brought
to customers through their mobile. Each advertisement again had the Vodafone YOU
ARE HERE end-line. The arrows indicated the directional approach of Vodafone, letting
the world come to the customer. Other executions illustrated cinema listing information,
168
sports updates, share price information, international roaming and the Vodafone Personal
Roadwatch 1800 service.
The change in emphasis by Vodafone seemed to be timely. The mobile phone industry
was facing a new wave of confusing product features hitting consumers, with the
development of Wireless Access Protocol (WAP) phones and the newer Third
generation phones due to be launched in 2001. It seemed inevitable that all of the
competing networks would be offering confusing permutations of features with their
service, so Vodafone calculated that, given similar levels of reliability and sophistication
by all networks, a favourable image and lifestyle association would be an important
source of competitive advantage. Given the right image with existing technology, there
would be a strong probability that consumers would migrate with the brand to the new
technology when it arrived.
Source: adapted from
Vodafone Image Shift, Marketing, 4th May, 2000 and Vodafone Home Page,
http://www.vodafone.co.uk
1.Introduction:
Distribution decisions are taken by companies basically to allow customers to gain access
and purchase a marketers product. However, marketers may find that getting to the
point at which a customer can acquire a product is complicated, time consuming, and
expensive. Distribution decisions are relevant for nearly all types of products. In fact,
while the Internet is playing a major role in changing product distribution and is
perceived to offer more opportunities for reaching customers, online marketers still face
the same distribution issues and obstacles as those faced by offline marketers.
2. Learning Objectives:
3. Channels of Distribution:
169
For marketers the distribution decision is primarily concerned with the supply
chains front-end or channels of distribution that are designed to move the product (goods
or services) from the hands of the company to the hands of the customer. Obviously
when we talk about intangible services the use of the word hands is a figurative way to
describe the exchange that takes place. But the idea is the same as with tangible
goods. All activities and organizations helping with the exchange are part of the
marketers channels of distribution. Activities involved in the channel are wide and
varied though the basic activities revolve around these general tasks:
Ordering
Handling and shipping
Storage
Display
Promotion
Selling
Information feedback
3.1. Type of Channel Members:
Channel activities may be carried out by the marketer or the marketer may seek specialist
organizations to assist with certain functions. We can classify specialist organizations
into two broad categories: resellers and specialty service firms.
Resellers
These organizations, also known within some industries as intermediaries, distributors or
dealers, generally purchase or take ownership of products from the marketing company
with the intention of selling to others. If a marketer utilizes multiple resellers within its
distribution channel strategy the collection of resellers is termed a reseller
network. These organizations can be classified into several sub-categories including:
Retailers Organizations that sell products directly to final consumers.
Wholesalers Organizations that purchase products from suppliers, such as
manufacturers or other wholesalers, and in turn sell these to other resellers, such as
retailers or other wholesalers.
Industrial Distributors Firms that work mainly in the business-to-business
market selling products obtained from industrial suppliers.
170
Agents and Brokers Organizations that mainly work to bring suppliers and
buyers together in exchange for a fee.
Distribution Service Firms Offer services aiding in the movement of products
such as assistance with transportation, storage, and order processing.
Others This category includes firms that provide additional services to aid in the
distribution process such as insurance companies and firms offering transportation
routing assistance.
3.2.Importance of Distribution Channels
Distribution channels often require the assistance of others in order for the marketer to
reach its target market. While on the surface it may seem to make sense for a company
to operate its own distribution channel (i.e., handling all aspects of distribution) there are
many factors preventing companies from doing so. While companies can do without the
assistance of certain channel members, for many marketers some level of channel
partnership is needed. For example, marketers who are successful without utilizing
resellers to sell their product (e.g., Dell Computers sells mostly through the Internet and
not in retail stores) may still need assistance with certain parts of the distribution process
(e.g., Dell uses parcel post shippers such as FedEx and UPS). In Dells case creating
their own transportation system makes little sense given how large such a system would
need to be in order to service Dells customer base. Thus, by using shipping companies
Dell is taking advantage of the benefits these services offer to Dell and to Dells
customers.
When choosing a distribution strategy a marketer must determine what value a channel
member adds to the firms products. Several surrounding features can be directly
influenced by channel members, such as customer service, delivery, and
availability. Consequently, for the marketer selecting a channel partner involves a value
analysis in the same way customers make purchase decisions. That is, the marketer must
assess the benefits received from utilizing a channel partner versus the cost incurred for
using the services.
Benefits Offered by Channel Members
Cost Savings in Specialization Members of the distribution channel are
specialists in what they do and can often perform tasks better and at lower cost than
companies who do not have distribution experience. Marketers attempting to handle
too many aspects of distribution may end up exhausting company resources as they
learn how to distribute, resulting in the company being a jack of all trades but
master of none.
Reduce Exchange Time Not only are channel members able to reduce
distribution costs by being experienced at what they do, they often perform their job
more rapidly resulting in faster product delivery.
Customers Want to Conveniently Shop for Variety Marketers have to
understand what customers want in their shopping experience. Referring back to our
171
grocery store example, consider a world without grocery stores and instead each
marketer of grocery products sells through their own stores.
Resellers Sell Smaller Quantities Not only do resellers allow customers to
purchase products from a variety of suppliers, they also allow customers to purchase
in quantities that work for them. Suppliers though like to ship products they produce
in large quantities since this is more cost effective than shipping smaller amounts.
Create Sales Resellers are at the front line when it comes to creating demand for
the marketers product. In some cases resellers perform an active selling role using
persuasive techniques to encourage customers to purchase a marketers product.
Offer Financial Support Resellers often provide programs that enable customers
to more easily purchase products by offering financial programs that ease payment
requirements. These programs include allowing customers to: purchase on credit;
purchase using a payment plan; delay the start of payments; and allowing trade-in or
exchange options.
Provide Information Companies utilizing resellers for selling their products
depend on distributors to provide information that can help improve the
product. High-level intermediaries may offer their suppliers real-time access to sales
data including information showing how products are selling by such characteristics
as geographic location, type of customer, and product location (e.g., where located
within a store, where found on a website).
3.3. Channel Arrangements
The distribution channel consists of many parties each seeking to meet their own business
objectives. Clearly for the channel to work well, relationships between channel members
must be strong with each member understanding and trusting others on whom they
depend for product distribution to flow smoothly. For instance, a small sporting goods
retailer that purchases products from a wholesaler trusts the wholesaler to deliver
required items on-time in order to meet customer demand, while the wholesaler counts on
the retailer to place regular orders and to make on-time payments.
Relationships in a channel are in large part a function of the arrangement that occurs
between the members. These arrangements can be divided in two main categories:
independent and dependent.
Independent Channel Arrangement
Under this arrangement a channel member negotiates deals with others that do not result
in binding relationships. In other words, a channel member is free to make whatever
arrangements they feel is in their best interest. This so-called conventional distribution
arrangement often leads to significant conflict as individual members decide what is best
for them and not necessarily for the entire channel. On the other hand, an independent
channel arrangement is less restrictive than dependent arrangements and makes it easier
172
for a channel members to move away from relationships they feel are not working to their
benefit.
Dependent Channel Arrangement
Under this arrangement a channel member feels tied to one or more members of the
distribution channel. Sometimes referred to as vertical marketing systems this
approach makes it more difficult for an individual member to make changes to how
products are distributed. However, the dependent approach provides much more stability
and consistency since members are united in their goals. The dependent channel
arrangement can be broken down into three types:
Corporate Under this arrangement a supplier operates its own distribution
system in a manor that produces an integrated channel. This occurs most frequently
in the retail industry where a supplier operates a chain of retail stores. Starbucks is a
company that does this. They import and process coffee and then sell it under their
own brand name in their own stores. It should be mentioned that Starbucks also
distributes their products in other ways, such as through grocery stores and mail
order. As we will see in more detail later, Starbucks is using a multi-channel
structure to market their products.
Contractual Under this arrangement a legal document obligates members to
agree on how a product is distributed. Often times the agreement specifically spells
out which activities each member is permitted to perform or not perform. This type
of arrangement can occur in several formats including:
o
Wholesaler-sponsored where a wholesaler brings together and manages
many independent retailers including having the retailers use the same name
o
Retailer-sponsored this format also brings together retailers but the
retailers are responsible for managing the relationship
o
Franchised where a central organization controls nearly all activities of
other members
Administrative Arrangement In certain channel arrangements a single member
may dominate the decisions that occur within the channel. These situations occur
when one channel member has achieved a significant power position. This most
likely occurs if a manufacturer has significant power due to brands in strong demand
by target markets (e.g., Procter &Gamble) or if a retailer has significant power due
to size and market coverage (e.g., Shoppers-stop or Reliance Fresh). In most cases
the arrangement is understood to occur and is not bound by legal or financial
arrangements.
3.4. Factors involved in creating Distribution Channels
Like most marketing decisions, a great deal of research and thought must go into
determining how to carry out distribution activities in a way that meets a marketers
objectives. The marketer must consider many factors when establishing a distribution
system. Some factors are directly related to marketing decisions while others are affected
173
by relationships that exist with members of the channel. Let us examine the key factors to
consider when designing a distribution strategy.
Distribution strategy can be shaped by how decisions are made in other marketing areas.
Product Issues
The nature of the product often dictates the distribution options available especially if the
product requires special handling. For instance, companies selling delicate or fragile
products, such as flowers, look for shipping arrangements that are different than those
sought for companies selling extremely tough or durable products, such as steel beams.
Promotion Issues
Besides issues related to physical handling of products, distribution decisions are affected
by the type of promotional activities needed to sell the product to customers. For
products needing extensive salesperson-to-customer contact to (e.g., automobile
purchases) the distribution options are different than for products where customers
typically require no sales assistance (i.e., bread purchases).
Pricing Issues
The desired price at which a marketer seeks to sell their product can impact how they
choose to distribute. As previously mentioned, the inclusion of resellers in a marketers
distribution strategy may affect a products pricing since each member of the channel
seeks to make a profit for their contribution to the sale of the product. If too many
channel members are involved the eventual selling price may be too high to meet sales
targets in which case the marketer may explore other distribution options.
Target Market Issues
A distribution system is only effective if customers can obtain the
product. Consequently, a key decision in setting up a channel arrangement is for the
marketer to choose the approach that reaches customers in the most effective way
possible. The most important decision with regard to reaching the target market is to
determine the level of distribution coverage needed to effectively meet customers
needs. Distribution coverage is measured in terms of the intensity by which the product
is made available. For the most part, distribution coverage decisions are of most concern
to consumer products companies, though there are many industrial products that also
must decide how much coverage to give their products.
174
As we will see the marketer must take into consideration many factors when choosing the
right level of distribution coverage. However, all marketers should understand that
distribution creates costs to the organization. Some of these expenses can be passed
along to customers (e.g., shipping costs) but others cannot (e.g., need for additional
salespeople to handle more distributors). Thus, the process for determining the right
level of distribution coverage often comes down to an analysis of the benefits (e.g., more
sales) versus the cost associated with gain the benefits.
There are three main levels of distribution coverage - mass coverage, selective and
exclusive.
175
A good distribution strategy takes into account not only marketing decisions, but also
considers how relationships within the channel of distribution can impact the marketers
product. In this section we examine three such issues:
Channel Power
A channel can be made up of many parties each adding value to the product purchased by
customers. However, some parties within the channel may carry greater weight than
others. In marketing terms this is called channel power, which refers to the influence one
party within a channel has over other channel members. When power is exerted by a
channel member they are often in the position to make demands of others. For instance,
they may demand better financial terms (e.g., will only buy if prices are lowered, will
only sell if price is higher) or demand others members perform certain tasks (e.g., do
more marketing to customers, perform more product services). Channel power can be
seen in several ways:
Backend or Product Power Occurs when a product manufacturer or service
provider markets a brand that has a high level of customer demand. The marketer of
the brand is often in a power position since other channel members have little choice
but to carry the brand or risk losing customers.
Middle or Wholesale Power Occurs when an intermediary, such as a wholesaler,
services a large number of smaller retailers with products obtained from a large
number of manufacturers. In this situation the wholesaler can exert power since the
small retailers are often not in the position to purchase products cost-effectively and
in as much variety as what is offered by the wholesaler.
Front or Retailer Power As the name suggests, the power in this situation rests
with the retailer who can command major concessions from their suppliers. This
type of power is most prevalent when the retailer commands a significant percentage
of sales in the market they serve and others in the channel are dependent on the sales
generated by the retailer.
Channel Conflict
In an effort to increase product sales, marketers are often attracted by the notion that sales
can grow if the marketer expands distribution by adding additional resellers. Such
decisions must be handled carefully, however, so that existing dealers do not feel
threatened by the new distributors who they may feel are encroaching on their customers
and siphoning potential business. For marketers, channel strategy designed to expand
product distribution may in fact do the opposite if existing members feel there is a
conflict in the decisions made by the marketer. If existing members sense a conflict and
feel the marketer is not sensitive to their needs they may choose to stop handling the
marketers products.
Overall Distribution Design
176
Mindful of the factors affecting distribution decisions (i.e., marketing decision issues and
relationship issues), the marketer has several options to choose from when settling on a
design for their distribution network. We stress the word may since while in theory an
option would appear to be available, marketing decision factors (e.g., product, promotion,
pricing, target markets) or the nature of distribution channel relationships may not permit
the marketer to pursue a particular option. For example, selling through a desired retailer
may not be feasible if the retailer refuses to handle a product. For marketers the choice of
distribution design comes down to selecting between direct or indirect methods, or in
some case choosing both.
Direct Distribution System
With a direct distribution system the marketer reaches the intended final user of their
product by distributing the product directly to the customer. That is, there are no other
parties involved in the distribution process that take ownership of the product. The direct
system can be further divided by the method of communication that takes place when a
sale occurs. These methods are:
Direct Marketing Systems With this system the customer places the order either
through information gained from non-personal contact with the marketer, such as by
visiting the marketers website or ordering from the marketers catalog, or through
personal communication with a customer representative who is not a salesperson,
such as through toll-free telephone ordering.
Direct Retail Systems This type of system exists when a product marketer also
operates their own retail outlets. Arrow, Zodiac and others are examples in this
category.
Personal Selling Systems The key to this direct distribution system is that a
person whose main responsibility involves creating and managing sales (e.g.,
salesperson) is involved in the distribution process, generally by persuading the
buyer to place an order. While the order itself may not be handled by the
salesperson (e.g., buyer physically places the order online or by phone) the
salesperson plays a role in generating the sales.
Assisted Marketing Systems Under the assisted marketing system, the marketer
relies on others to help communicate the marketers products but handles
distribution directly to the customer. The classic example of assisted marketing
systems is eBay which helps bring buyers and sellers together for a fee. Other
agents and brokers would also fall into this category.
Indirect Distribution System
With an indirect distribution system the marketer reaches the intended final user with the
help of others. These resellers generally take ownership of the product, though in the
some cases they may sell products on a consignment basis (i.e., only pay the supplying
177
company if the product is sold). Under this system intermediaries may be expected to
assume many responsibilities to help sell the product. Indirect methods include:
Single-Party Selling System - Under this system the marketer engages another
party who then sells and distributes directly to the final customer. This is most likely
to occur when the product is sold through large store-based retail chains or through
online retailers, in which case it is often referred to as a trade selling system.
Multiple-Party Selling System This indirect distribution system has the product
passing through two or more distributors before reaching the final customer. The
most likely scenario is when a wholesaler purchases from the manufacturer and sells
the product to retailers.
Multi-channel or Hybrid System
In cases where a marketer utilizes more than one distribution design the marketer is
following a multi-channel or hybrid distribution system. The multi-channel approach
expands distribution and allows the marketer to reach a wider market, however, as we
discussed under Channel Relationships, the marketer must be careful with this approach
due to the potential for channel conflict. Since channel members must be convinced to
handle a marketers product it makes sense to consider channel partners needs in the
same way the marketer considers the final users needs. However, the needs of channel
members are much different than those of the final customer. They are:
Delivery Resellers want the product delivered on-time and in good condition in
order to meet customer demand and avoid inventory out-of-stocks.
Profit Margin Resellers are in business to make money so a key factor in their
decision to handle a product is how much money they will make on each product
sold. They expect that the difference (i.e., margin) between their cost for acquiring
the product from a supplier and the price they charge to sell the product to their
customers will be sufficient to meet their profit objectives.
Other Incentives Besides profit margin, resellers may want other incentives to
entice them especially if they are required to give extra effort selling the
product. These incentives may be in the form of additional free products or even
bonuses (e.g., bonus, free trips) for achieving sales goals.
Packaging Resellers want to handle products as easily as possible and want their
suppliers to ship and sell products in packages that fit within their system. For
example, products may need to be a certain size or design in order to fit on a stores
shelf, or the shipping package must fit within the resellers warehouse or receiving
dock space. Also, many resellers are now requiring marketers to consider adding
identification tags to products (e.g., RFID tags) to allow for easier inventory tracking
when the product is received and also when it is sold.
Training Some products require the reseller to have strong knowledge of the
product including demonstrating the product to customers. Marketers must consider
offering training to resellers to insure the reseller has the knowledge to present the
product accurately.
178
Promotional Help Resellers often seek additional help from the product supplier
to promote the product to customers. Such help may come in the form of funding
for advertisements, point-of-purchase product materials, or in-store demonstrations.
1. Introduction:
Retailing is defined as selling products to consumers for their personal use. A retailer is a
reseller (i.e., obtains product from one party in order to sell to another) from which a
consumer purchases products. In the majority of retail situations, the organization from
which a consumer makes purchases is a reseller of products obtained from others and not
the product manufacturer. While consumers are the retailers buyers, a consumer does
not always buy from retailers. For consumers the most important benefits relate to the
ability to purchase small quantities of a wide assortment of products at prices that are
180
considered reasonably affordable. For suppliers the most important benefits relate to
offering opportunities to reach their target market, build product demand through retail
promotions, and provide consumer feedback to the product marketer. Wholesaling is
defined as the activities involved in selling to organizational buyers who intend to either
resell or use for their own purposes. A wholesaler is an organization providing the
necessary means to: 1) allow suppliers (e.g., manufacturers) to reach organizational
buyers (e.g., retailers, business buyers), and 2) allow certain business buyers to purchase
products which they may not be able to otherwise purchase.
2. Learning objectives:
When you finish this unit, you should be able to:
Understand the need for retailing and whlesaling.
Understand the various types of retailing and wholesaling.
Understand the issues involved in both forms .
Understand the relevance to the channel management.
3. Retailing:
Currently, India does not possess a very high percentage of organized retail segments.
Even by the most optimistic estimates, the figure stands at less than 3%. But suddenly the
biggest business houses of India have woken up to the great potential of this Rs. 1 lakh
crore retail sector. Today the likes of Wal-Mart and Tesco are all set to debut in India.
The rising per capita income of middle and lower middle class has propelled the growth
of retail in India. They form a large chunk of people visiting the malls and food joints on
any day. The emergence of many Tier-2 and Tier-3 cities has given the fillip to the
development of organized retailing in India. The concepts of malls and super-stores have
now gripped the entire nation and the number is increasing. The organized retail sector is
expected to grow at 6% by 2010 and touch a retail business of $ 17 billion as against its
current growth level of 3% which at present is estimated to be $ 6 billion, according to
the study undertaken by The Associated Chambers of Commerce and Industry of India
(ASSOCHAM). It has emerged as one of the most dynamic and fast-paced industries
with several players entering the market. Retailing in India is gradually inching its way
toward becoming the next boom industry. The whole concept of shopping has altered in
terms of format and consumer buying behavior, ushering in a revolution in shopping in
India. Modern retail has entered India as seen in sprawling shopping centers, multistoried malls and huge complexes offering shopping, entertainment and food all under
one roof.
3.1. Retailers Types:
There are many ways retailers can be categorized depending on the characteristics being
evaluated. For our purposes we will separate retailers based on six factors directly
related to major marketing decisions:
181
ownership
Under this classification retailers are divided based on the width (i.e., number of different
product lines) and depth (i.e., number of different products within a product line) of the
products they carry.
General Merchandisers These retailers carry a wide range of product categories
though the number of different items within a particular product line is generally
limited (i.e., shallow depth).
182
3.1.4.Promotional Focus
Retailers generate customer interest using a variety of promotional technique, yet some
retailers rely on certain methods more than others as their principle promotional
approach.
183
Retailers sell in many different formats with some requiring consumers visit a physical
location while others sell to customers in a virtual space. It should be noted that many
retailers are not tied to a single distribution method but operate using multiple methods.
Store-Based Sellers By far the predominant method consumers use to obtain
products is to acquire these by physically visiting retail outlets (aka brick-andmortar). Store outlets can be further divided into several categories. One key
characteristic that distinguishes categories is whether retail outlets are physically
connected to one or more others stores:
o
Stand-Alone These are retail outlets that do not have other retail outlets
connected.
o
Strip-Shopping Center A retail arrangement with two or more outlets
physically connected or that share physical resources (e.g., share parking lot).
o
Shopping Area A local center of retail operations containing many retail
outlets that may or may not be physically connected but are in close proximity
to each other such as a city shopping district.
o
Regional Shopping Mall Consists of a large self-contained shopping area
with many connected outlets.
Non-Store Sellers A fast growing method used by retailers to sell products is
through methods that do not have customers physically visiting a retail outlet. In
fact, in many cases customers make their purchase from within their own homes.
o
Online Sellers The fastest growing retail distribution method allows
consumer to purchase products via the Internet. In most cases delivery is then
handled by a third-party shipping service.
o
Direct Marketers Retailers that are principally selling via direct methods
may have a primary location that receives orders but does not host shopping
visits. Rather, orders are received via mail or phone.
o
Vending While purchasing through vending machines does require the
consumer to physically visit a location, this type of retailing is considered as
184
non-store retailing as the vending operations are not located at the vending
companys place of business.
3.1.6. Service Level
Retailers attract customers not only with desirable products and affordable prices, but
also by offering services that enhance the purchase experience. There are at least three
levels of retail service:
Self-Service This service level allows consumers to perform most or all of the
services associated with retail purchasing. For some consumers self-service is
considered a benefit while others may view it as an inconvenience. Self-service can
be seen with: 1) self-selection services, such as online purchasing and vending
machine purchases, and 2) self-checkout services where the consumer may get help
selecting the product but they use self-checkout stations to process the purchase
including scanning and payment.
Assorted-Service The majority of retailers offer some level of service to
consumers. Service includes handling the point-of-purchase transaction; product
selection assistance; arrange payment plans; offer delivery; and many more.
Full-Service The full-service retailer attempts to handle nearly all aspects of the
purchase to the point where all the consumer does is select the item they wish to
purchase. Retailers that follow a full-price strategy often follow the full-service
approach as a way of adding value to a customers purchase.
Finally, we can categorize retailers based on the ownership structure of the business.
Individually Owned and Operated Under this ownership structure an individual
or corporate entity owns and operates one or a very small number of outlets. Single
ownership of retail outlets most frequently occurs with small retail stores, though
there are some cases, for instance in the automotive or furniture industries, where
single ownership involves very large outlets.
Corporate Chain A retail chain consists of multiple retail outlets owned and
operated by a single entity all performing similar retail activities. While the number
of retail outlets required to be classified as chain has never been specified, we will
assume that anyone owning more than five retail locations would be considered a
chain.
Corporate Structure This classification covers large retailers predominantly
operating in the non-store retail arena such as online, catalog and vending.
Contractually Licensed and Individually Operated The contractual channel
arrangement has lead to a retail ownership structure in which operators of the retail
outlet are not the out-right owners of the business. Instead, the arrangement often
involves a legal agreement in which the owner of the retail concept allows the
185
Even though India has well over 5 million retail outlets of all sizes and styles (or
non-styles), the country sorely lacks anything that can resemble a retailing
industry in the modern sense of the term. This presents international retailing
specialists with a great opportunity.
Retailing in India is thoroughly unorganised. There is no supply chain
management perspective. According to a survey by AT Kearney, an
overwhelming proportion of the Rs. 400,000 crore retail market is
UNORGANISED. In fact, only a Rs. 20,000 crore segment of the market is
organised. As much as 96 per cent of the 5 million-plus outlets are smaller than
500 square feet in area. This means that India per capita retailing space is about
2 square feet (compared to 16 square feet in the United States). India's per
capita retailing space is thus the lowest in the world.
Just over 8 per cent of India's population is engaged in retailing (compared to
20 per cent in the United States). There is no data on this sector's contribution to
the GDP. From a size of only Rs.20,000 crore, the ORGANISED retail industry
will grow to Rs. 160,000 crore by 2005. According to AT Kerney, the total
retail market, however, as indicated above will grow 20 per cent annually from
Rs. 400,000 crore in 2000 to Rs. 800,000 crore by 2005
Given the size, and the geographical, cultural and socio-economic diversity of
India, there is no role model for Indian suppliers and retailers to adapt or
expand in the Indian context. The first challenge facing the organised retail
industry in India is: competition from the unorganised sector. Traditional
retailing has established in India for some centuries. It is a low cost structure,
mostly owner-operated, has negligible real estate and labour costs and little or
no taxes to pay. Consumer familiarity that runs from generation to generation is
one big advantage for the traditional retailing sector.
In contrast, players in the organised sector have big expenses to meet, and yet
have to keep prices low enough to be able to compete with the traditional
sector. High costs for the organised sector arises from: higher labour costs,
social security to employees, high quality real estate, much bigger premises,
comfort facilities such as air-conditioning, back-up power supply, taxes etc.
Organised retailing also has to cope with the middle class psychology that the
bigger and brighter a sales outlet is, the more expensive it will be. The above
should not be seen as a gloomy foreboding from global retail operators.
International retail majors such as Benetton, Dairy Farm and Levis have already
entered the market. Lifestyles in India are changing and the concept of "value
for money" is picking up.
186
188
may match those of large retailers thus allowing them to obtain lower prices from
suppliers. Wholesalers can then pass these lower prices along to their buyers, which
can enable smaller retailers to remain competitive with larger rivals. In this way
transacting through wholesalers is often the only way certain retailers can stay in
business.
Provide Access to Markets Providing smaller retailers access to products they
cannot acquire without wholesaler help offers a benefit for suppliers as well since it
opens additional market opportunities for suppliers. Namely, suppliers can have
their products purchased and made available for sale across a wide number of retail
outlets. More importantly, for a company offering a new product, convincing a few
wholesalers to stock a new product may make it easier to gain traction in the market
as the wholesaler can yield power with the smaller retailers convincing them to stock
the new product. Considering a wholesaler can serve hundreds of small retail
customers, the marketing efforts persuading the wholesaler to adopt a new product
may be far more efficient compared to efforts needed to convince individual store
owners to stock the new product.
3.5. Categorize Wholesalers:
Similar to how retailers can be categorized, wholesalers can also be classified by the
width and depth of product lines they handle. The categories include:
General Merchandise Wholesalers carrying a very broad line of products fall
into the general merchandise wholesaler category. Like general merchandise
retailers, the product lines these wholesalers carry may not offer many options (i.e.,
shallow depth). These wholesalers tend to market to the smaller general
merchandise retailer such as smaller convenience or general stores.
Specialty Merchandise Wholesalers focusing on narrow product lines but
offering deep selection within the lines fall into the specialty merchandise
category. Most specialty merchandise wholesalers direct their marketing efforts to
specific industries. For example, specialty wholesalers supply such industries such
as electronics, seafood, and pharmaceuticals.
Wholesalers can be separated based on the importance promotion plays in generating
demand for products handled by the wholesaler. Two basic categories exist:
Extensive Promotion The main job of some wholesalers is to actively locate
buyers. This occurs most often where a wholesaler is hired to find buyers for a
suppliers products or where the wholesaler is very aggressive in finding new
customers for their business. Under these arrangements the most common
promotional activity is personal selling through a sales force, though advertising may
also be used.
Limited Promotion Nearly all wholesalers engage in some promotional
activities. Even in situations where a wholesaler dominates a channel and clients
have little choice but to acquire products from the wholesaler, some promotion will
189
still occur. For instance, at times a wholesaler may need to use their salespeople to
persuade buyers to purchase in larger volume than normal or to agree to stock a new
product the wholesaler is handling. In other cases, especially for wholesalers selling
products for business use, promotional activities may be more extensive and include
advertising and other promotional methods.
Wholesalers can be distinguished by the number and depth of services they provide to
their customers.
Full-Service Wholesalers in this category mainly sell to the retail industry, and
in most cases, require a strong, long-term retailer-wholesaler relationship be
established. In addition to basic distribution services, such as providing access to an
assortment of products and furnishing delivery, these wholesalers also offer
customers additional services that aid retail store operations including offering
assistance with: in-store merchandising; retail site location decisions (e.g., find best
geographic location for a new store); store design and construction; back-end
operations (e.g., payroll services); financial support; and many more.
Limited Service Compared to full-service wholesalers, buyers dealing with
limited service firms offer far fewer services. Most offer basic services, such as
shipping and allow credit purchasing, but few offer the number of service options
found with full-service wholesalers.
No Service Some wholesalers follow a business model whose only service is to
make products available for sale and only on a cash basis. In these instances, the
buyer handles their own transportation of the product.
4. Have you understood type questions:
1. State whether True/ False
Wholesaling activities must be performed during distribution of all goods,
whether or not a wholesaling institution is involved.
Wholesaling is an inefficient process that should be eliminated from the
marketing channel in India.
manufacturers prefer to deal direct with retailers in India.
2. By using a wholesaler, some firms have a distinct advantage because the specialised
services performed by the wholesaler allow the firm to:
A. focus on developing and manufacturing products that match consumers' needs
and wants.
B. focus on increasing production capacity and efficiency
C. reduce manufacturing costs to retailers and provide quality merchandise to
consumers.
3. A merchant wholesaler
A. takes title and assumes risk and is generally involved in buying and reselling
products.
B. takes title and possession of goods and sells only to retailers.
C. does not take title and possession of goods but may facilitate exchange
between any two parties.
190
superstore.
hypermarket.
department store.
general merchandise retailer
5. Summary
191
6. Exercises
1. Identify the issues wholesaling by visiting a nearby wholesaler and explain the future
of wholesalers.
2. Wholesalers will not perish in India- comment.
3. Explain the steps to be taken in making a wholesalers mover forward to a retailer
status.
4. Enumerate the functions done by a cash and carry outlet.
5. With suitable examples, explain the various retail formats in India.
6. Prakash has a group of farmers who provide him with a regular supply of fresh
vegetables. He picks up their produce and has a regular route of grocers and restaurants
who inspect and purchase quantities of the items he has on any given day. Prakashs
operation belongs to a specific type of wholesaler. Explain.
7. Compare and contrast Shoppers Stop with Big Bazzar.
7. References
1. Knapp Duane E. ( 2000 ) The Brand Mindset, McGraw Hill New York NY.
2. Christopher Knee (2002) Learning from experience: five challenges for retailers,
International Journal of Retail and Distribution Management, Vol.30 No. 11, pp.
519-29.
3. Whats eating Indian retailing? Business Standard , 10 July 2001.
4. Betancourt, R. & Gautschi, D. (1988) The economics of retail firms, Managerial and
Decision Economics, 9, June, 133142.
5. Macintosh, G. & Lockshin, L. S. (1997) Retail relationships and store loyalty: a
multilevel perspective, International Journal of Research in Marketing, 14, pp. 487
497.
INTEGRATED MARKETING COMMUNICATION
192
1. Introduction:
Marketing communication has become the backbone of the effective functioning
of an organisation in the information technology era. Many companies are very much
dependent on the services provided by these players in the market. This is only in the
nascent stages and once the technology grows, it will also grow in the same proposition.
We are now talking about going global which means every such organisation should
start looking at the basic impediment of language problems. The complexities of business
increase to the maximum and hence top management of research organisations should
give more importance to cross cultural communication. What is considered okay in one
society may be a taboo in another one. This is where tourism products can be affected.
With the advent of sophisticated technologies, it becomes easier for a manager to
communicate. We are now living in the era of interactive communication. A person at
Venice can easily talk with a person in Baroda through a video terminal. Technology has
shaped the way communication is dealt.
2. Learning Objectives:
When you finish this unit, you should be able to:
Understand the need and scope of IMC.
Understand the past marketing communications.
Understand the future of marketing communication and the role of IMC.
3. Integrated Marketing Communications:
Today, communication goes beyond the specific promotion tools/marketing
communication mix. The products design, its price, the shape and colour of its package
and the stores sell it all communicate something to buyers. Hence, although the
promotion mix is the companys primary communication activity, the entire marketing
mix promotion and product, price and place must be coordinated for the greatest
communication impact. Each brand contact will deliver a message and their impact can
be positive, negative or neutral on the consumer. Therefore, the company needs to deliver
a consistent positive message at all contact points. This is possible when organizations
develop a total marketing communication strategy that requires how all of a firms
marketing activities not just promotion, communicate with its customers. Thus, the
practice of Integrated Marketing Communication (IMC) was encouraged.
Advocates of IMC argue that it is one of the easiest ways a company can maximize the
return on its investment in marketing and promotion. This is achieved by building longterm relationship with the customers. The media both deliver the messages and provide
ways for customers to send messages to the company. Customers respond to the brand
messages by buying its products, asking questions, placing complaints, having repairs
made and so on. Thus, brand experiences are created. Each brand experience either
strengthens or weakens the brand relationship. Strengthened relationships lead to
increased sales and profits, enhancing brand equity. Weakened relationships result in lost
193
sales and lost customers, undermining brand equity. All through the years, the clients
were leading the advertising agencies and the role of consumers was relatively
insignificant in designing the brand communication. Also the agencies are doing what
they feel comfortable to do. It is high time the agencies need to follow customers and
create competencies in the customers preferences. If the customer is more convinced
with the online information about the brand then the agency should focus on that media
and should take the lead to integrate all other brand communications.
Jagdish Seth and Rajendra Sisodia, in their Four As of Marketing, have emphasized on
the integration of the various aspects of marketing to get the desired results. They say,
Marketers cannot make a trade-off by building an acceptable product that is not
affordable; or a product that is affordable but of cheap quality; or a product that is
affordable and acceptable but cannot be accessed through appropriate distribution
channels. Today, the biggest fights are between marketing, sales and customer support,
not between marketing and engineering or sales and engineering. But having done with
the marketing mix will not ensure necessary integration, even though these are the
primary factors to be integrated. Even integrating the elements of marketing
communication mix and coordinating all the brand communication will move half-way
through. The companies have to go beyond these integrations. Identify the factors need to
be integrated by throwing light into the firms internal and external environments. Here
are a few Indian examplesBharti Airtel, seems to have integrated three factors viz., connectivity, affordability and
innovation, which reinforce each other in bringing the expected results. The brand
recognition, market share and the brand being in the top of consumers mind, point to the
effective integration of the marketing mix and communication mix variables, which
Airtel has already done. Their network coverage is wide and the service is offered at
affordable rates. They are catering to the needs of almost all customers from the
enterprise segment to the villagers. Life time prepaid is one way to make it affordable.
This, along with the song catcher is their innovative measures in the industry. Thus, these
three factors support each other to make Airtel in positioning it among the leaders in the
industry.
Kellogg India Ltd. was having their toughest time during their initial period. Through the
pricing and availability in premium retail stores, Kellogg tried to convey the product
quality to the target market. But there was lack of integration of the marketing variables
which resulted in rejection of the product because of bad taste, in spite of the managerial,
technical and financial support from the parent company. Their frantic media activity
proved to be a failure when the consumers referred to their wheat and rice varieties as
rice corn flakes and wheat corn flakes. Learning from these mistakes Kellogg
restructured their marketing activities by integrating all the marketing elements.
Indianised versions of the product were launched; different packs of varying quantities
were introduced; media advertising along with symposiums, community oriented
programmes, etc. were organized; sales inducers were identified as children and free gifts
for them were offered; price reduction without compromising on the quality but by
changing the packaging was made; products were made available in premium and small
194
retail stores; one-serving sample packs were distributed. All these resulted in converting
the experimenters to regular users and Kellogg made the India Cereal Breakfast market to
grow to almost tribled its size in five years.
3.1. The Need For Ingrated Marketing Communication:
Marketing Communication Process:
Communication is the process of influencing other's behaviour by sharing ideas,
information or feeling with them. The two major participants in the communication are
sender (marketer) and the receiver. The communication occurs :
(a) when sender transmits the message, and
(b) a receiver receives that message and
(c) the sender and the receiver have a shared meaning.
ENCODING
THE MESSAGE
Ad display or
Sales promotion
MESSAGE
CHANNEL
Advertising
media or sales
force
DECODING
THE MESSAGE
Compare to
frame of
reference,
memory &
experience
NOISE
Competing
advertisements, other
sales people
distractions
MESSAGE AS
INTENDED
Sales idea or
USP
MESSAGE AS
RECEIVED
Knowledge,
beliefs, or
feelings
Start
FEEDBACK
Sales reports,
attitude research
RESPONSE
Interest, desire,
or purchase
195
a big number of customers. Mass media advertising enjoyed a dominant role among the
promotion mixes of consumer product companies those times. And only companies
which were financially sound used expensive media to reach the market. This was
sufficient in producing satisfactory results to the companies those times. But almost all of
them faced the problem of the message getting lost because of the advertisement reaching
the non-targeted people also. In spite of this, many companies proved themselves to be
experts in mass marketing.
With the increase of competition and when the customers tend to gain more and more
importance, marketers felt the necessity of maintaining healthy customer relationship. To
enhance better relationship with their customers marketers advanced their objective from
customer satisfaction to customer delight. Researches on consumer behaviour show the
tendency of the consumer to stick on to the company which treats him individually. The
consumer, as he is a human being, needs to be cared personally by the marketer. There
are always prospects and customers who have question, complaints and suggestions
which must be heard and given a timely and satisfying response. If this is the trend in the
market, the marketers have to definitely tune their marketing activities accordingly. So, in
order to delight their customers through building closer relationships with them,
marketers are now moving away from mass markets and are focusing on more narrowly
defined micro markets. This trend in marketing is supported by the improvements in
information technology by providing more information about consumers at the individual
and house hold levels. Also new technologies provide new communication avenues for
reaching smaller customer segments with more tailored messages.
198
- Consumers may pay more attention to these messages, because they are not quickly
screened out as are many advertisements.
Demerits
- Publicity is not always possible because it is not in the hand of the seller.
- Limited repetition of publicity messages.
- Publicity can be negative and hurt sales as well as company product, and brand
images.
- Company cannot completely control the content of publicity messages.
Public Relations
It is a planned effort by an organization to influence the attitudes and opinions of
a specific group by developing a long term relationship. The target may be customers,
stock holders, a government agency or a special interest group.
Characteristics of Promotional Types
Factor
Advertising
Publicity
Personal selling
Sales promotion
Audience
Mass
Mass
Small (one-to-one)
Varies
Message
Cost
Uniform
Low per viewer or
reader
Specific
High per customer
Varies
Moderate per
customer
Sponsor
Flexibility
Control over
content and
placement
Credibility
Major goal
Company
Low
High
Uniform
None for media
space and time;
can be moderate
costs for press
releases and
promotional
materials but not
met by the
advertiser
No formal sponsor
Low
None (controlled
by media)
Company
High
High
Company
Moderate
High
High
To reach a mass
audience with an
independently
reported message
Moderate
To deal with
individual
consumers, to
resolve questions,
to close sales
Moderate
To stimulate
Short-run sales, to
increase impulse
purchases
Moderate
To appeal to a
mass audience at
a reasonable cost,
and create
awareness and
favourable
attitudes
In this new communication environment, marketers need to rethink the roles of various
media and promotion mix tools. They have to put in efforts to create a consistent and
coordinated communication programme. Today, although television, magazines, and
other mass media remain very important, their dominance is now declining. Many
companies recognize the value of being customer focused, of integrating their marketing
efforts, and of no longer depending on traditional advertising. Fragmentation of mass
200
markets has reflected in media fragmentation with the effect of more focused media that
better match todays targeting strategies.
Now, advertising appears to be giving way to other elements of the promotion mix.
Today, media advertising captures only 26% of total promotion spending. The rest goes
to other marketing communication mix elements, which focus on individual consumers
and trade segments. To quote Philip Kotler, companies are doing less broadcasting and
more narrowcasting. For most companies, the question is not whether to communicate
but rather what to say, to whom and how often. They have recognized that to achieve
their objectives they must ask not only how can we reach our customers? but also how
can our customers reach us?. Even the best practitioners of mass marketing noticed that
a single marketing communication tool rarely gives the maximum result. For promotion
to be effective, each element of the MC mix should reinforce the other through a well
planned communication programme. Marketers understood that a combination of tools
will give the desired output maximum sales. Now a days consumers are being exposed
to a greater variety of marketing communications from and about the company from a
variety of sources. But unlike the marketers, customers do not distinguish between the
message sources of a company. In the consumers mind, advertising messages from
different media such as TV, magazines or online sources blur into one. This again
necessitates the messages send by a company to be consistent and coordinated so that the
consumer is not confused.
3.2. Future of marketing communication:
Following are the possible ways of looking at how marketing communication is
going to be in the near future:
1. Earlier only one promotional tool was used but now integrated communication
strategy is being increasingly adopted which heavily relies on the use of information
technology with the advent of Internet.
2. Electronics has taken a major share of the business communication and it is expected
that communication possibilities, which are fast and cheap is, expected to help the
business sector.
3. Due to the increasing complexities in dealing with the trade unions and other workers
associations, it is now considered that informal communication is also to be given
importance. When we take into consideration the influence of domestic partners of
tourism and the local dialects as well as ecotourism participants it becomes more
important. Organisations in future will allow for this communication openly.
4. Every sales people will have to be fully conversant in the case of communication and
are expected to give feedback to the management. If we take the case of Kerala, of the
total number of tourists visiting per year, domestic tourists account for not less than
75%. At this juncture there is a need for a hardsell in this market. All those who are
part of the Travel and tourism wing have to get their act better. Hence they should
continuously upgrading or changing the report formats. Letter writing style to
overcome structuing and monotony and with the use of multimedia and laptop
computer, there is a possibility of changes happening in the basic mindset with which
they are going to be looked.
201
5. Since technology has pervaded every aspect of life, new technological devices will
help the sales people or Tailor-made devices for the sales people will be introduced
for effective communication. With the arrival of Internet, sales people are expected to
be conversant on the same as the tourists are becoming more Internet savvy.
6. More organisations will start to utilise the services of missionary sales people. This
will help in developing a good information base for the company with its clients.
7. Direct marketing will have to be strengthened in the years to come since the
competition is increasing. As most of the people as what happens in Dubai shopping
festivals the ultimate beneficiary is directly contacted for all the benefits offered. To
overcome competition, well-written communication sent by direct marketing can
have a positive result in the market.
8. We are entering an era where paperless or fileless offices are going to be in vogue.
This means that all correspondence will be undertaken via the networking of
computers. The employees of an organisation especially in the case of Tourism and
travel agencies and other related areas need to know about these aspects.
The Kerala State Government understanding the importance has sanctioned an
amount of Rs 18 lakh for the development of the Kerala Tourism Web site. According to
an official release, the amount will be spent on improving the site,
www.keralatourism.org. The Tourism Department's site, launched in 1998, has already
come in for recognition from several information technology magazines, the release adds.
The appearance of the Web site, which contains over 1.2GB of information on the State,
was recently revamped. In addition to pictures and video clips on Kerala, the site also
contains a gallery of audio clips that showcases sounds of Kerala including traditional
folk songs. With Hyderabad emerging as a major information technology destination, the
demand for rooms has been on the rise. Indian Hotels manages the operations of all the
three hotels under the Taj brand Taj Krishna, Taj Bandra and Taj Residency. Indian
Hotels is now focussing on becoming asset-light, owning less properties. This means that
some of its future undertakings would be owned by its subsidiaries or by way of joint
ventures. With more information technology being added, this will be a major attraction.
There is escalation in the cost of media and there is a clutter of competitive activity
all over the market. When more companies fight for the customers money, those who put
across the message alone stand in getting profitability. By constantly contacting the
customer and packaging the product, promoting differently each time, the actual cost of
promotion comes down. Constant communication creates a building up effect. The use of
a combination of marketing communication techniques with the use of information
technology gives more opportunity to increase the number of times the product/brands
are known to the customer. The build-ups effect of delivering the same message through
several media or techniques not only increases the efficiency of the transmission of
message but is the sum total of integrated marketing communication. For example, in the
tourism market, Singapore tourism has covered a place in the minds of the customer.
These communications spanning TV and cinema commercials, newspaper advertising
and magazine advertising, indoor promotion and many other techniques always delivers
202
the same core message. In integrating any campaign, proper positioning of the product in
the mind of the consumer, the personality and proposition need to clearly understood.
It is a commonplace argument now about the use of information technology in the
field of marketing. With the advent of Electronic Data Interchange (EDI), now even retail
outlets can target their customers without many problems. Developments in the area of
infrastructure and attraction will boost the consumer confidence in tourism. The Internet
is going to be a boon in the communication front. The use of digital technology as like
digital theatre systems have made people flock to the cinema halls which earlier were
considered to be a declining industry. As part of tourist attractions, now Ramoji film city
has got into the guides schedule. This gives more room for the marketer to effectively
target, differentiate and position his product and services in the market place. We have
already witnessed the evolution of virtual market places and it is expected that the ecommerce will provide fillip to industry to a large extent. People today are prosperous
and they want to spend on leisure. They are tired of visiting the same place and want to
explore new areas. Tourism sector should take note of this aspect. In India, middle class
tourists form a major component in the tourism circuit. If a person in Haryana wants to
explore the tourist destinations of Karnataka, he/she should be given adequate facilities.
He should be able to know all the aspects through the Internet. Infrastructure at the
destination should be good.
2.
According to DM Asia,LG Electronics has launched a new global integrated marketing campaign
focusing on the company's 'Full HD' 1080p flat-panel high-definition televisions (HDTVs). The
global campaign will be first seen in the United States and will roll out to more than 70 countries
worldwide over the next month. LG will invest approximately $25m in the US and more globally to
highlight the ultimate viewing experience delivered by LG's 1080p liquid crystal display (LCD) and
plasma HDTVs. Key elements of the campaign include a series of broadcast, print, outdoor and
online advertisements in three creative concepts all featuring an LG Red Couch, which serves as a
symbol of the consumers' all-encompassing high-definition viewing experience. The campaign also
incorporates LG's corporate sponsorship of the Cannes Film Festival and targeted public relations
activities highlighting LG's 1080p Full HD technology and stylish flat-panel designs.
Coca-cola India has launched the following campaign:
203
ADVERTISING
1. Introduction:
205
Advertising is one of the form of mass selling, employed when the use of direct,
person-to-person selling is not at all practical, impossible, or simply inefficient. It is to be
distinguished from other activities intended to persuade the public, such as propaganda,
publicity, and public relations. Advertising techniques range in complexity from the
publishing of simple, straightforward notices in the classified advertisement columns of
newspapers to the concerted use of newspapers, magazines, television, radio, direct mail,
and other communications media in the course of a single advertising campaign. From its
unsophisticated beginnings in ancient times, advertising has burgeoned into a worldwide
industry. Modern advertising is an integral segment of urban industrial civilization,
mirroring contemporary life in its best and worst aspects. Advertising is an indicator of
the growth of civilisation and a pointer of attempts at its betterment and perfection. It is a
part of our social, cultural and business environment. Not only advertising mirrors this
environment but also it affects and gets affected by our style of living. In today's
environment, not only are advertisers closely examined by the target audiences for whom
the advertisements are meant, but by society in general. Advertising is considered to be
costly but with its reach, it gives the return to the employer in a very short span of time.
2. Learning Objectives:
When you finish this unit, you should be able to:
3. Advertising management:
Advertising is the one of the major industries across the world. As long as media is there,
advertising, advertisers and advertising agencies will be there.
1. American Marketing Association proposed the following definition of advertising :
"Advertising is any paid form of non-personal presentation and promotion of ideas,
goods, and services by an identified sponsor."
1. John S Wright, Willis L Winter, and Sherilyn K Zeigler defined Advertising as :
"Advertising is controlled, identifiable information and persuasion by means of mass
communications media."
2. John J Burnett defined Advertising as :
"Advertising is the non-personal communication of marketing related information to
a target audience, usually paid for by the advertiser, and delivered through mass
media in order to reach the specific objectives of the sponsor."
These definitions have used certain words or phrases that need some elaboration.
"Any paid form": The paid aspect of the definition reflects the fact that the space or time
for an advertising message generally must be bought.
"Non-personal presentation and promotion": In case of personal selling, there is face-toface presentation and promotion of product or service by the salesperson. Advertising is
206
totally non-personal, offering no personal interaction, delivered through media and often
viewed as intrusion. Of course, advertising may help the salesperson in his/her selling
efforts.
"Ideas, goods, and services": Advertising, being a powerful mass communication tool, is
used not only to present and promote goods and services with the intent of selling them, it
is also increasingly used to further the goals of public interest and social causes.
"An identified sponsor": These words clarify the difference between advertising and
propaganda. Just like advertising, propaganda attempts to present certain opinions and
ideas, which may influence the attitudes and actions of people. However, the source of
propaganda mostly remains unknown and hence its authenticity is often doubtful. People
in general do not know who the originator of these opinions and ideas is. In case of
advertising, the sponsor of ideas or opinions is known.
"Controlled": The advertiser controls the content of advertising message, its time, and
direction. In case of publicity, it is not under the control of the advertiser. The story may
be presented in a manner not to the liking of the advertiser, or not at a time chosen by the
advertiser.
"Mass communications media": The broad group of audience can best be reached by
mass media such as newspapers, magazines, television, radio and outdoor displays. This
qualification separates advertising and personal selling. The multiple messages are
delivered to thousands of people simultaneously.
3.1. History of Advertising:
The development of technology and research has led to increased sophistication in
advertising in recent decades. Modern advertising is largely a product of the twentieth
century. During ancient and medieval times advertising was crude if measured by
present day standards. However, the basic reason for using advertising was the same then
as it is now. The recorded history of advertising covers a period of about 5000 years
including the modern satellite and Internet age. Our knowledge of advertising in ancient
times is in fragments. The urge to advertise has been a part of human nature since ancient
times. The diggings of archeologists in the countries rimming the Mediterranean sea have
unearthed a Babylonian clay tablet of about 3000 B C, bearing inscription for an ointment
dealer, a scribe and a shoemaker. Romans and their predecessors knew that "it pays to
advertise." Papyri found in the ruins of Thebes (Egypt) show announcements' offering
rewards for the return of runaway slaves (about 3000 B C). Before the invention of
printing, there were three forms of advertising :
i. Trademarks : Craftsmen in early times wanted to be identified for their skills and
placed their individual marks on goods they crafted.
Buyers learnt to look for the distinctive mark just as we look today for brand names and
trademarks on products.
ii. Signs : Phoenicians and other traders painted commercial messages on prominent
rocks along trade routes that they used. These messages highly praised the products that
were for sale. This is an example of ancient outdoor advertising.
iii. Town criers : The system of town criers was perhaps present in all developed
civilisations of ancient world. In Greece during the Golden Age, town criers were paid to
go around spreading news and making announcements in the streets of Athens. Epics and
207
history books about ancient India reveal that the system of town criers was used by the
rulers in India to inform the public of various public interest matters. In rural India, town
criers were used till 1950s.
The first known printed advertisement in the English language appeared nearly
forty years after the invention of the movable type writer. William Caxton of London
printed the first advertisement. The first ad in any language to be printed on a circulated
sheet appeared in German news pamphlet in about 1525. The ad praised the virtues of a
mysterious drug. It was from such beginnings that the printed newspaper emerged and the
first printed newspaper in English came out in 1622, the Weekly News of London. The
first advertisement appeared in an English newspaper in 1625. Advertising as we know it
really had its beginnings in mid 19th century. Volney B Palmer was the first advertising
agent who established an office in Philadelphia. For a fee, he worked as an agent of the
newspapers numbering about 1400. He sold space to advertisers throughout the country.
He did not provide any creative or planning services to clients, except the media
selection. During the 1920s, modern marketing research entered the world of advertising.
As a result of this new development, advertising of this period started stressing on the
outcome of consumer purchases such as health, happiness, status and love, etc.
Advertisements contained bold headline, artwork, photography and plenty of colour.
3.2. Benefits of advertising:
Advertising is multi-faceted. To be effective, advertising programmes need to be
specific in their goals, specific in their audiences and specific in their means.
Advertising can particularly help in the following areas:
To create awareness: it can help to make things known. On the whole, people do not
deal with things they have never heard of, or they prefer not to.
To create or develop favourable attitudes: it can help to foster a positive view of the
product or service.
To develop a brand identity: advertising can help introduce a product with a special
image or characteristic.
To position a product in a market: where a market is segmented, advertising can help
position a product with a particular segment and identify with it.
To sustain relationships: it is a force to build and strengthen producer-customer
relationships over time.
To persuade: advertising puts up a case for the customer to be interested in the product
on offer.
To create demand: Advertising makes the product seem desirable, worthwhile and
attainable.
To build up enquiries: often advertising is a bridge between the product and a sales call.
Its function is to obtain enquiries for a sales call, or for literature, or for a sample, or for a
price estimate.
To support distributors: where there is a distributive chain, the distributor may require
reinforcement in the local marketplace. Advertising is one of the forces that can supply
this.
208
A major portion of advertising effort is designed to increase the demand for a product or
service. There are two kinds of demand : Primary and selective. Primary demand refers to
the demand for the generic product such as milk, magazine, radio, television set.
Selective demand is designed to gain acceptability for a particular manufacturer's brand.
Primary Demand Advertising
When the product is in the introduction stage, the best promotional strategy may be to use
advertising that is designed to gain acceptability for a product group rather than a
particular brand. Frequently primary demand advertising is conducted by an industry,
group or trade association in order to promote a product.
Selective Demand Advertising
Most new product introductions today are accompanied by selective demand advertising,
which promotes a specific manufacturer's brand. Most advertising for various products
and services is concerned with stimulating selective demand and emphasizes reasons for
buying a particular brand. Advertisers generally assume that there is a favourable level of
primary demand for a product class and focus attention on increasing their market share.
ii. Advertising based on the audience to which it is directed
Consumer Advertising
209
Consumer advertising is that type of advertising that is directed towards the ultimate
consumers.
Industrial Advertising
It is directed toward the complete institution with the aim to increase the good will of the
institution rather than on a specific brand in the eyes of the customers, shareholders,
employees, suppliers etc. Institutional advertising is often closely related to the public
relation function of the enterprise.
Public Service Advertising
Public Service Advertising is designed to operate in the public interest and promote the
public welfare. Public service advertisements emanates from various commercial as well
as non-commercial organisations. It involves sponsoring public welfare activities such as
safe driving, good health, how to prevent epidemic etc.
Advocacy Advertising
It is also called as issue advertising. It is concerned with the propagation of ideas and the
classification of controversial social issues of public importance. In other words, it can be
said to be another form of public service advertising. It is done when a commercial or
non-commercial organisation present a point of view about economic or social problems
210
Advertising designed to obtain some immediate response from the target customer is
called direct action advertising. All sales promotion advertising and mail order
advertising is of this type. In mail order advertising, the seller attempts to induce the
reader to mail in his order for the goods advertised. An advertisement that attempts to get
the reader to send in a coupon for a sample of the merchandise would be the example of
direct action advertising.
Indirect Action Advertising
It is designed to influence the reader to have a favourable opinion or image of the brand
so that when the reader does decide to buy that product, he will buy the advertiser's brand
rather than the competing one.
iv. Advertising based on geographical coverage
National, Regional & Local Advertising
Advertising reaches people through media that are classified as national, regional or
local. National Advertising is done on nation-wide scale to stimulate the demand for the
product among ultimate buyers. If the advertising is confined to one region of the
country, it is called as regional advertising. Local advertising is confined to one trading
area or city. This type of advertising is done by local manufacturers.
3.4. Ethical and Social aspects of Advertising
The essence of a free marketplace and a free society is the freedom to make
decisions of various kinds or the freedom to select or not select a particular brand. There
are arguments that this freedom is circumscribed by the "power" of advertising.
Advertising is so effective that it can manipulate a buyer into making a decision against
his or her will or at least against his or her best interests in allocating his financial
resources. This argument takes several forms. First, there is concern with the use of
motivation research, the appeal to motives at the subconscious level. Second, there is the
use of indirect emotional appeals. Finally, there is the more general claim of the power of
scientific advertising to persuade- to make people believe things and behave in ways that
are not in their own or society's best interests. The communication of factual information
about a product's primary function is usually accepted as being of value to the consumer.
However, when advertising utilizes appeals or associations that go beyond such a basic
communication task, the charge of manipulation via "emotional appeals" is raised.
211
There exists a general feeling that advertisers have the raw power to manipulate
consumers. Many companies have the capacity to obtain large numbers of advertisement
exposures. Some believe that these companies can utilize highly sophisticated, scientific
techniques to make such advertising effective. Some critics feel that advertising is
objectionable because the creative effort behind it is not in good taste. Advertisements
may be annoying and offensive. Annoying advertisements are too loud, too long, too
repetitious, or involved unpleasant voices, music, or people and may be inappropriate for
children. To some people, advertising, especially television advertising, is often like a
visitor who has overstayed his welcome. It becomes an intrusion. Greyser postulates a
life cycle wherein an advertising campaign moves with repetition from a period of
effectiveness, and presumably audience acceptance, to a period of irritation. The cycle
contains the following stages :
i. Exposure to the message on several occasions prior to serious attention (given some
basic interest in the product)
ii. Interest in the advertisement on either substantive (informative) or stimulus
(enjoyment) grounds
iii. Continued but declining attention to the advertisement on such grounds
iv. Mental tune-out of the advertisement on grounds of familiarity
v. Increasing re-awareness of the advertisement, now as a negative stimulus (an irritant)
vi. Growing irritation.
The number of exposures between the start of a campaign and the stage of growing
irritation is obviously a key variable. Advertising by its very nature receives wide
exposure. Furthermore, it presumably has an effect on what people buy and thus on their
activities. Because of this exposure and because of its role as a persuasive vehicle, it is
argued that it has an impact on the values and life-styles of society and that this impact
has its negative as well as positive side. The key issues are what values and life-styles are
to be encouraged as healthy, which are to be avoided, and what relative impact or
influence advertising has on them. Three issues that have attracted particular attention are
the relationship of advertising to materialism, the role that advertising has played in
creating harmful stereotypes of women and ethnic minorities, and the possible
contribution of advertising in promoting harmful products. Materialism is defined as the
tendency to give undue importance to material interests. There is a corresponding
lessening of importance to non-material interests such as love, freedom, and intellectual
pursuits. Bauer and Greyser argue that although people do spend their resources on
material things, they do so in the pursuit of nonmaterial goals. The distinctive aspect of
our society is not the possession of material goods, but the extent to which material goods
are used to attain nonmaterial goals. Bauer and Greyser thus raise the issue of whether
material goods are a means to an end rather than an end in themselves. In making, such
an evaluation it is useful to consider how people in other cultures fulfill non-material
goals. The leader in a primitive culture may satisfy a need for status in a different away
from someone in our culture. Associating advertising with materialism does not
demonstrate a causal link. Such a link is impossible to prove or disprove. It is true that
advertising and the products advertised are a part of our culture and thus contribute to it
in some way. It is also true; however, that advertising does not have the power to
212
dominate other forces (family, literature, and so on) that contribute to the values of
society.
The accusation that advertising has contributed to the role stereotyping of women and
ethnic minorities has been supported by several studies. One such study found that the
advertisements reflected the stereotype that women do not do important things, are
dependent on men, are regarded by men primarily as sex objects, and should be in the
home. There is a national concern with the problems of alcohol and cigarettes. In India,
there are certain restrictions over the advertisements of alcohol and cigarettes.
Alcohol is unhealthy for the individual and is indirectly responsible for injuries and
deaths resulting from drunk drivers. There are a variety of counterarguments. First, there
is no evidence that advertising, which is geared toward brand choice rather than
increasing consumption, affects total alcohol consumption.
Other arguments are :
- A ban of advertising would prohibit product innovation that may be helpful.
- The real goal is to return to alcohol prohibition.
- Many other products could be criticized on similar grounds.
Although social and ethical criticisms of advertising are by no means new, the
nature & seriousness of the complaints made has in recent years increased significantly.
This trend has in turn been supported and reinforced by the attention paid by successive
governments to the role of advertising and the rise of consumerism. Followings are the
criticisms which are made most frequently and because they bear the direct relationship
to the ethics of advertising are most pertinent to such discussion. These criticisms are :
- Advertising is frequently false and misleading.
- Advertising concentrates on selling products to people who neither need nor want.
- Advertising exhibits bad taste.
- Advertising stresses small and insignificant differences between products and has
resulted in an unnecessary and wasteful proliferation of brands.
- Advertising is too persuasive.
- Advertising can be used, to take advantage of children (bad effect on children).
- Much advertising is irrelevant and unnecessary.
3.5. Five Ms of Advertising
Marketing managers must always start by identifying the target market and buyer
motives. They can make five major decisions in developing an advertising programme.
These are known as five Ms of Advertising. They are :
- Mission
- Money
- Message
- Media &
- Measurement.
3.5.1. Mission:
The objectives of the advertising programme includes :
213
- To increase support : Advertising increases the morale of the sales force and of
distributors, wholesalers and retailers. It thus contributes to enthusiasm and confidence
attitude in the organisation.
- To stimulate sales amongst present, former and future consumers. It involves
decision regarding the media.
- To retain the loyalty : To retain the loyalty of present and former consumers.
Advertising may be used to reassure buyers that they have made the best purchase,
thus building loyalty to the brand name or the firm.
- To project an image : Advertising is used to promote an overall image of respect and
trust for an organisation. This message is aimed not only at consumers but also at the
government, share holders and general public.
- To communicate with consumers : This involves decision regarding Copy.
DAGMAR was the study of Association of National Advertisers (ANA) that the
goal of advertising is to achieve specialized objectives and it recognized that different
advertisements can have a number of objectives.
"Advertising's job, purely and simply, is to communicate to a defined audience
information and a frame of mind that stimulates action. Advertising succeeds or fails,
depending on how well it communicates the desired information and attitudes to the right
people at the right time and at the right cost."
Russell H. Colley
DAGMAR Approach can be summerized as follows :
(i) Advertisine goals are virtually always communication goals : Colley pointed out that
advertising is only one part of the marketing mix for all companies. He assumed that
specific goal for advertising in virtually all situations would have to be represented in
terms of some communication objective.
214
(ii) Goals should be written down : The goals should be made very clear in form of
writing, so that every one understands what is being done.
(iii) Advertising should be measured in terms of effects, not exposures : Colley pointed
out that in reaching out a certain number of potential consumers, no matter how
astronomical that number seems to be, is meaningless unless there is some effect in terms
of communication goals.
(iv) Advertising operates through a hierarchy of communication effects : There is a series
of mental step through which a brand or objects must climb to gain acceptance. The
initial task of the brand is to gain awareness to advance one step up in the hierarchy. The
next step is brand comprehension, which involves the audience member learning
something about the brand. The next step is the attitude and conviction step and
intervenes between comprehension and final action. The action phase involves some
overt move on the part of the buyer like trying the brand for the first time, visiting a show
room or requesting information.
(v) Creative planning considerations should come before media decisions in the
advertising planning process : When media considerations come first, there is a tendency
to be concerned about the amount of reach an advertising campaign can develop rather
than the effects that are to be generated. The creative or message strategy decision is
always intimately related to the communication effects that are intended. Therefore, the
creative planning decision should occur first.
(vi) Benchmark measurements should be developed before the campaign is implemented :
Colley suggested a particular research procedure for measuring advertising effectiveness.
This involved developing a measurement of the level of an objective before the campaign
and then measuring deviations from the measurement as an indicator of communication
effect.
(vi) Specific criteria must be developed : It is impossible to develop benchmarks unless
the objectives are stated specifically in terms of some operational measurement. This
means that the advertising objective should state the specific target market segment, the
marketing goal in some percentage terms over sometime period and the advertising goals,
in terms of a percentage attainment in a particular time period.
Colley identified following advertising tasks or advertising objectives that a firm can
pursue :
- Perform the complete selling function (take the product through all the necessary steps
toward a sale).
- Announce a special reason for "buying now" (price, premium, etc.).
- Remind people to buy.
- Stimulate impulse sales.
- Tie in with some special buying event.
3.5.2. Money:
Advertising budgets fundamental purpose is to aid in securing control over
advertising and is accompanied by comparing actual attainments against the projected
allocation and using it as a yardstick in determining the effective use of advertising.
Advertising budget is an estimate of future advertising expenditure that will be used to
implement managerial decisions to maintain or improve profit results. In advertising
215
budget the money must be allocated to various promotional forms in such a manner as to
minimize the waste and maximize the utility of such budgets. Advertising allocation must
be considered as a capital investment rather than current expense. Investment is a capital
asset that brings benefits in the future. The usual starting place for management in setting
the advertising budget is to decide the overall objectives of the company. The objectives
can be e.g., the growth, profits, net return investments, attracting personnel etc.
Budgetary process
The advertising budgeting process involves the following steps :
- Step 1. Preparation of Budget : It is generally prepared by advertising manager in
consultation with marketing manager. The advertising budget made is based on inputs
provided by marketing research people. The budget is generally made on annual basis.
Primary input would depend upon type of product, new or established one, target market,
demographic composition, advertising copy and media selection etc.
- Step 2. Presentation and approval of Budget : After the budget is made, it is presented
to top management for the approval of the budget.
- Step 3. Execution of the Budget : After the budget is approved by the top management,
it is executed. Various channels and media for budget allocation are considered. The task
of preparing advertising messages and acquiring advertising time and space is given to
advertising agency.
- Step 4. Control of Budget: After the budget is executed, the results come out. Control
of budgets involves comparing the desired advertising objectives and actual advertising
objectives. The purpose is to know the effectiveness of advertising in terms of money
allocated to advertising. If it is found that the allocated budget is on the higher side or on
the lower side, the appropriate corrective action can be taken.
Factors influencing the advertising budget allocation:
Following factors should be taken into consideration while allocating the advertising
budget:
- Marketing mix of the company
- The sales forecast
- Affordability
- The product life cycle
- Quality of the campaign
- Level of competition
- The budgeting cycle
- Contingency planning
- Type of product
(i) Marketing mix of the company : The important factor influencing the amount to allocate to
advertising is the general marketing mix of the company for marketing the product (s)
involved.
(ii) The Sales forecast : While making the final budget, it is important to correlate the
amount needed to sales forecast. It is needed to know what may be expected to happen in
216
the light of past experience, present conditions and any changes in factors that were
influential in the past. This forecast is developed to provide the following data :
- Sales in units rather than Rupee volume : Used whenever possible in order to be more
specific in allocating the budget to various items.
- Sales by customer classes : Data for ascertaining the advertising cost in reaching various
customer groups.
- Sales by product lines : In order to determine how much advertising will be needed to
attain the volume projected.
- Sales by territories : Helpful in deciding what advertising expenditures should be made
in each area.
(iii) Affordability : The most important and the foremost factor while deciding the budget is
how much funds are available to the company.
(iv) The Product life cycle : When the product is introduced, high level of advertising is
required because the product is new and the market is to be informed and persuaded to
purchase the product. When the product reaches to the maturity stage, more advertising
expenditure is required to reduce the dropping of sales and to maintain the status quo.
(v) Quality of the campaign : If the advertising message is of high quality and a USP widely
recognized and established, even a small budget can be effective.
(vi) Level of competition : If the competitors advertising budget is immense and is
advertising heavily, the higher budget would be required to counter attack.
(vii) The budgeting cycle : Budget appropriation would also depend upon the time period for
which the budget is allocated. If the budget is made for six months, lesser money is
required than the budget for one year.
(viii) Contingency Planning : There are many external uncontrollable restraints that must be
taken into consideration while planning the budget.
(ix) Type of the Product: If the product is one for which a strong consumer demand can be
stimulated, so that the pull strategy of marketing can be used effectively, the budget for
advertising might constitute virtually the entire marketing budget. But for a standardised
basic industrial product, the use of advertising may play a negligible part of the
marketing strategy, and it might be advisable to use other promotional means, such as
direct sales efforts.
Methods of determining budget appropriation:
The total amount of the advertising appropriation is a major question to be
answered each year. There is no research technique that will provide an exact answer as
to what is the right amount. Logically, advertising expenditures should go up as long as
they are capable of increasing returns.
Methods of determining budget appropriation are :
- The Percentage of sales method
- Unit of sales method
- Competitive parity method
- Objective task method
- Arbitrary allocation method
- The affordable method
217
Here the functional benefits of a product are highlighted. Industrial buyers are most
responsive to rational appeals. Buying motives are normally considered rational under the
following circumstances :
- High quality appeal
- Low price appeal
- Long life appeal
- Performance minted appeal
- Ease to use oriented appeal
Emotional appeals
Emotional appeals are those appeals, which are not preceded by careful analysis of merits
and demerits of making a buying decision. Emotions are those mental agitations or
excited states of feeling, which prompt to make a purchase. Emotional appeals are
designed to stir up some negative or positive emotions, which will motivate product
220
Moral appeals are those appeals to the audience, which are directed to their sense of right
and wrong. These are often used in messages to arouse a favourable response to social
causes such as adult literacy, social forestry, anti smuggling, consumer protection, equal
rights for women, rural development etc.
Copy writing
Copy writing is a specialized form of communicating ideas that are meant to serve
the requirements of modern marketing. The purpose is to inform or persuade or remind or
collective. But before copy writing, the objective of the copy should to well defined. The
copywriter must be familiar with the marketing goals of the advertiser and specific
advertising objectives. Copy writing skill requires command over language.
Steps in Copy Writing
221
Headline
Sub head-line
Body Copy
Captions
Blurb
Boxes & Panels
Slogan, logotypes & signature
Head line : Presents the selling idea. Primary function is to catch the eye of the reader.
Head line need not always contain special message. Company or brand name could be
used as a head line.
Sub- head line : Important facts may be conveyed. It requires more space than the head
line. All advertisements do not require sub-head lines.
Body copy : Refers to the text in the advertisement. Contains details regarding the
functions of the product/service and its benefits. Body copy can be short or long.
Captions : Used with illustrations, coupons and special offers.
Blurb : Display arrangement where words appear from the mouth.
Boxes and panels : Special display positions to get greater attention.
Slogan, logotypes & signatures : Logotype - company name, seal or trade mark also refer
to signature. Logotype is an important aid in quick recognition.
Characteristics of effective Copy
222
In composing a script for television, the writer must include both audio and video
instructions. There is no layout, but there is a script, and ultimately, there is a storyboard.
In writing a script, the general practice is to use the right side of the sheet(s) for audio
instructions, which include the dialogue, narration, sound effects, and/ or music. The left
side is used for video instructions, which include scene and character descriptions,
movement and action instructions, camera movement, scene changes and other edits, and
any graphics. In both the audio and video instructions, there are a number of
abbreviations. These are common symbols recognized by everyone who will be working
on the commercials. The script is the equivalent of the rough layout of the print
advertisement. Its purpose is to allow the creative and account groups to discuss the
proposed commercial without investing a great deal of expense in artwork or production.
223
After the script has been agreed upon within the agency, a storyboard is
developed for presentation to the client and to serve as a blueprint for later production.
The storyboard is comparable to the comprehensive layout for the print advertisement. A
storyboard has three components: (1) pictures that show the main scenes and action, (2) a
written description of what occurs, and (3) the audio. The most common way to present a
storyboard is with all scenes mounted on a large poster board. Alternatives might include
(1) putting the scenes on slides and synchronizing these to an audio track or (2) creating
an animatic. An animatic is an animated form of the commercial that would show some
of the movements, camera work, and edits of the commercial, again including a rough
sound track. Of these formats, the straight storyboard is most common when working
with an existing client, while the other formats are more likely to be used during a
presentation to a prospective new client. Television, with sight, sound, and motion, is
hard to capture in a static storyboard, yet the storyboard must often be used because the
production alternatives are too expensive at this stage. One purpose of the storyboard is
to help the agency sell its creative work to the client.
After approval of the storyboard by the client, it goes through one more stage
similar to the mechanical layout. Here, the board is given as much specificity as the
agency would like the producer to have. Sets are designed and actors are cast on the basis
of this board. At this stage, more scenes may be added to the board to show more detail.
The final level of specificity must evolve between the creative department and the
production company. Because it is difficult to visualize the entire commercial on paper,
there should be some flexibility remaining for the production team, but too much
flexibility means that the director may miss the essence of the story. This is a fine line,
requiring a good storyboard as well as good communications between writer and director.
The writer, who has been involved throughout the development of the script, is usually
also around when the commercial is shot to ensure that the main issues are properly
portrayed.
Copy testing
Copy testing is an important part of advertising management. There are three
factors that have to be addressed in copy testing: (1) whether or not to test, (2) what and
when to test, and (3) what criteria or test to use. Every advertising manager must consider
these factors in the context of the overall advertising plan. Copy testing implies that funds
will be allocated to research on consumer reactions to the advertising before the final
campaign is launched. The first decision is really whether or not to spend more money on
research. Most local advertising is not tested, and there are many cases in national
advertising where copy is used without formal copy testing of any kind. Not only are
there money costs involved in testing, but there are time costs as well. Copy testing can
mean weeks or months of delay in launching a campaign.
3.5.4. Media:
224
The selection of media has become quite intricate because of the nature of media
themselves. The characteristics of each alternative must be considered carefully. For
example, TV can show action, combining both sight and sound, and can produce an
impact that simply is not possible in other media. Newspapers can carry ads containing
much more detailed information than TV or radio. Magazines can convey detailed
information, which remains available to a potential buyer for a longer time. The process
of choosing between alternatives becomes even more complicated considering the wide
range of alternatives within the same medium. New and evolving media have further
contributed to the difficulty of planning when, where, and how the advertising message
will be delivered. Media planning refers to a series of decisions required in delivering the
advertising message to the target audience. The plan specifies media objectives and
media strategies to accomplish the objectives. The basic goal of media plan is to
formulate a particular combination of media that would enable the advertiser to
communicate the message successfully and effectively to the maximum number of
potential and existing customers in the target market at the lowest cost. Any mistakes in
this function may result in wastage of substantial amounts of money.
Each medium offers its own distinct advantages. By carefully developing a suitable blend
of media, the advertiser can introduce versatility in media strategy to increase coverage,
reach and frequency levels. To effectively cover the target market, the media planner
determines the segments that should get the maximum media emphasis. This requires
matching the media and media vehicles most suitable to the target audience. A very
optimistic goal could be full coverage of the market. However, in real situations the
coverage of the media does not allow for this. Some potential customers are left without
exposure to the advertising message. Media coverage reaches some non-targeted
audiences who are not considered as potential customers and the advertiser is faced with
the problem of overexposure referred to as waste coverage. The media planner's objective
is to reach as many members of the target audience as possible and at the same time
minimise the extent of any waste coverage. This is something where perfection is almost
impossible.
There would be situations when there is less than desired media coverage and also some
situations when the most effective media would also reach people not at all intended. For
advertising mass consumption products, mass media are generally very effective in
reaching large numbers of target audience. In such situations there is bound to be some
waste coverage. However, the cost of wastage is negligible compared to the value gained
from their use.
Geographic Coverage : Geography is an important consideration for the media planning
process. The demand for certain types of products depends on the geographic locations of
the markets. There may be regional differences in consumption and media planners select
secondary localised media to supplement their national media schedule. Advertisers are
often interested in presenting a local advertising message in different markets.
Scheduling : It is neither necessary nor possible for companies to keep their advertising
always in front of the consumers to serve as a constant reminder of their products or
services. Media schedule is the calendar of advertising plan. Scheduling is concerned
225
with timing the insertion of advertisements in the selected media. Decisions in this area
are essentially based on certain assumptions regarding how the target audience will
respond to the presence or absence of the advertising messages with respect to the set
advertising objectives such as product recall or attitudes. There are three approaches to
scheduling
1.
2.
3.
continuity,
flighting,
pulsing.
Continuity refers to the length of time an advertising schedule continues such as every
day, every week, or every month. If the planners believe that product recall respond
easily to the exposure of advertising messages and also decay easily if there was no
advertising, then probably recall increasing advertising messages are needed
continuously, at a low frequency level. What is required is to develop a continuous
pattern of reminder advertising without any time gaps in which there is no advertising.
This strategy is suitable for those product categories that are regularly consumed on an
ongoing basis without any seasonal fluctuations such as washing powders, soaps,
toothpaste, and soft drinks, etc.
Flighting refers to a less regular schedule of advertising messages and is quite
popular. There are intermittent periods of advertising and no advertising. Because of the
possible S-shaped response function, initial advertising may require heavy expenditures
on media to bring about desired change in attitudes, and once formed, such attitudes resist
rapid decay. This suggests the need for flighting, if the advertising was intended to
achieve change of attitudes. Periods of heavy advertising would be followed with no
advertising believing that changed attitudes would not decay rapidly. In case of certain
consumer products, both durable and non-durable, flighting pattern is often used.
Examples are desert coolers, refrigerators, woolen jackets and sweaters and many other
products. Flighting offers the advantages of cost efficiency as advertising covers only
purchase cycles and may allow the use of more than one medium or vehicles with limited
budgets. It has the disadvantages of possible wear out, possible advantage to competitors
and decreased awareness, interest and retention of advertising messages during nonscheduled periods.
Pulsing is a combination of continuity and flighting. The continuity is maintained
as a base throughout, but during certain periods the level of advertising is stepped up.
During the period just before the last date of tax return submission, advertising for cars
increases to motivate customers to buy and get depreciation benefit. Pulsing offers the
combined advantages of both continuity and flighting. This method is not suitable for
seasonal products or for small budget companies.
Decisions about scheduling strategy are based on the advertising objectives (brand
awareness, or brand attitudes), buying cycles, competitive spending, advertising decay,
available budget, etc.
226
Media Reach and Frequency : Media planners face the essential tasks that concern the
optimal use of media budget while deciding about the reach, frequency, and the number
of advertising cycles affordable for the year. There is no known way to determine how
much reach is required to achieve desired levels of awareness, attitude change, or
purchase intentions. Also, there is no certainty that an advertisement placed in a
particular media vehicle will actually reach the target audience. For example, if an
advertiser buys 30 or 60 seconds of TV time during a certain programme, everyone who
is tuned to this programme will not necessarily see the commercial for a number of
reasons.
Frequency refers to the average number of times audience individuals or
households are exposed to a medium in an advertising cycle, not necessarily to the
advertisement itself. An advertisement may be placed in a media vehicle and the fact that
an individual has been exposed to it does not mean that the advertisement has been seen.
For this reason media buyers refer to the reach of media vehicle as opportunity to see
(OTS) an advertisement rather than actual exposure to it.
Total exposures
Frequency = ______________________
Reach
Media options:
An advertising medium is the vehicle used to carry the advertising message from the
sender to the intended receiver. Generally, no single medium will be sufficient in
reaching all potential customers and as a result, it is often necessary to use a combination
of several media in an advertising campaign.
Print Media
Print media includes newspapers and magazines
Newspapers
227
- They are one of the media in which great numbers of people look for information
about merchandise.
- They provide intensive coverage of the cities and surrounding areas.
- They are very flexible, and copy can be tied in with latest developments.
- They reach all economic classes.
- They await the convenience of the reader to read.
- They have relatively low cost in comparison with other media especially audiovisual.
- They can emphasize the local news appeal.
- They can be used, effectively for test campaigns and to check results.
- They can be tied in with the sales appeals in specific localities.
- They can be used even when the advertising budget is quite modest.
- They appeal to the entire family.
- They are the major local medium for which readers pay.
- They can be used on a daily basis.
Demerits
There are complex difficulties in selecting a satisfactory schedule of newspapers in a
national campaign and in deciding which newspaper to use in a specific market.
- For products purchased by a restricted class, there is considerable waste circulation.
- Many newspapers employ publishers, representatives to represent them nationally,
which results in the national advertiser having to place the advertising through an
intermediary.
- They are read hurriedly, and the impact of the advertisements may be relatively
small.
- The paper and printing techniques may make them unsatisfactory for products that
require special colour and other mechanical features to show qualities of the
product.
- There are so many advertisements in some newspapers that it is easy for an
advertisement to get buried.
- There is overlapping of newspaper circulations in many sections of the country.
- Newspapers are read hurriedly and have a very short life, although they reach to all
classes of people. An advertisement in the newspaper is usually read but once,
with the average reading times estimated to be less than 200 seconds. In this short
span of time, the appeal must stimulate the reader into action.
Magazine
Magazine is the other form of print media. The Newspaper appeals to all people
in a particular community; the magazine appeals to particular people in all kinds of
communities. The life of a daily newspaper is short-rarely more than a day. A magazine
advertisement continues to live and produce results. for a week, a month, or longer as the
periodical is read and re-read not only by those who buy it, but by others who come in
contact with it. Most magazines offer high quality paper and printing. The dead line for
newspaper insertions is usually two or three days in advance of publication, but such
228
flexibility is impossible with a magazine advertisement. The increased quality that goes
into magazine production slows down the insertion process. The newspaper is primarily
a local medium and the magazine is mainly national one. Different types of magazines
are published for different types of customers e.g., women magazines, professional
magazines, trade magazines general consumer magazines etc. Magazines are published in
English as well as in all Indian languages from different geographical areas for meeting
the needs of various sections of the society.
Magazines are unique in their service in that they communicate to a distinct group of
common interest, even if the member of this group are widely dispersed. For example,
Photography magazine reaches most camera enthusiasts, no matter where they are,
nationally or even internationally. Thus, the advertisement about a new and unique
camera would be observed and noticed by prospective customers, wherever they are.
Merits
- Due to the high quality paper and improved printing, magazines offer the
advertisers with the merits of quality printing, excellent pictorial reproduction and
colour display.
- Advertisements may be read more carefully and with greater depth of interest in
magazine than elsewhere, both because magazines tend to be kept longer and
some times read repeatedly and because of the specialized character of their
contents.
- Magazines usually have a well defined target market. They are considered largely a
class media rather than the mass media as newspapers.
- Magazines have a long life and the readers read it at leisure.
- Magazines has a secondary and further readership or pass along readership as
magazines are kept at home for the longer period than the newspaper.
- Magazines generally have an aura of prestige, expertise and credibility because of
the editorial support.
- Magazines buying families are normally above average prospect and they are loyal
to magazines to such an extent that they feel and identify themselves a distinct
class.
- Because of the high quality of paper in magazines, it is possible to use a variety of
colours and printing techniques.
Demerits
- There is a necessity of buying space and preparing copy well in advance of the date
on which it is to appear.
- Since there is no daily news nor any urgent sales of products advertised in
magazines people tend to read them at their leisure and thus reach tends to build
up slowly.
- For advertisers who do not have national distribution or wide differences in
distribution and sales strength in different markets of the country, magazine
advertising is a sheer waste.
229
Radio is widely used by people to listen news, music and other programmes and radio is
the medium, which reaches now to every nook and corner of the country. Main advantage
of the radio is that it can be carried every where. Because of its portable character, it is
possessed by more than 90% of the population approximately. Because of the nature of
broadcasting and the distances radio waves travel, there can be many radio stations in
different areas so that every owner of a radio has many signals available to him and
depending upon the technical features of the radio receiver equipment, the signals from
long distances can also be caught. The advertiser using radio must decide whether or not
to use a sponsored programme. However, in recent years, the number of sponsored
programmes on radio has declined drastically. Though a very large share of radio
listening is done outside the home, it is difficult to measure the actual amount of
listening. This audience can be measured by the use of personal interviews but it still
makes extremely difficult to accurately determine the size of the radio audience.
Merits
- Radio advertising is much less costly than most of the advertising media.
- Radio is flexible and timely. The advertiser can run as many commercials in an area
or during a time period and news events and special occurrences can be aired on
radio almost as soon as they happen.
- Radio is a selective medium in the sense that the advertiser can advertise in only
those markets he desires. He can vary his messages and the intensity of coverage
of different markets to meet local conditions.
- It permeates all economic and social strata, thereby reaching the masses.
- In country like India, where literacy rates are low and so newspapers have limited
significance, radio is popular both with advertisers and audience.
- Radio is a personal medium that gives human touch as human voice is the most
natural way for the people to communicate with each other which has warmth,
persuasiveness, liveliness and dramatisation.
Demerits
- Commercial time available is limited. Only 10 seconds time for the commercials is
too less to retain and understand the message in one time.
- Message is perishable. If the person is not listening to advertising message at the
time of the broadcast, the message is lost for ever.
- Radio advertisement is of little use to products that had to be seen and
demonstrated.
230
Television has exhibited the most rapid growth of any advertising medium. A major
portion of the promotion budget is spend to advertise on television as now it has become
a leading medium for national advertiser. Television is intense in nature, in the sense that
it commands undivided attention and programme dedication of viewers and an eye catching commercial is easily noticed thus creating product awareness among TV
viewers. Because of an inherent life-like quality, the advertiser has almost infinite
creative flexibility for this medium. That is one of the reasons why it is the medium of
national advertisers. TV appeals to both the senses - sound as well as sight. As a result, it
combines the two to produce high impact commercials. The fact that a product or service
is promoted on TV may build a prestigious image of the product and its sponsor. The
pleasure derived from watching TV is at least transferable to the advertising messages
delivered through the medium.
Merits
- Television has a broad reach. It has the power to reach a great number of people.
- Television has a deep impact. Television is a scientific synchronization of sound,
sight, motion and colour.
- It is the personal medium that tries to involve the viewer by direct person-to- person
selling.
- Like radio, television is becoming a vehicle of mass communication.
- Television has the unique characteristics of the ability to demonstrate the operations
and the utility of the product. This makes it the closest medium to personal
selling.
- Television has a great frequency. Unlike magazines, where the message cannot be
repeated until the next issue of the magazine comes out, there is no limit to
message repetition.
- Television has more prestige than its competitive media.
- Even though the TV media is very expensive media in terms of commercial
production and air time, the cost per thousand viewers can be very low given the
advantage of sight, sound, colour, and action. Thus, new products can be
introduced, corporate images can be built and brand names can be established at
the very low cost per viewer.
- Like radio and newspapers, television is highly flexible and selective medium. It can
be used locally, regionally and nationally.
Demerits
- Even though some demographic selection of TV coverage is possible, it is still
basically a mass media. The result is a lot of wasted coverage as the message
reaches people who are not the potential buyers.
231
232
i. Reach : Outdoor advertising maximises both reach and frequency. It is estimated that
with proper placement, a moderate outdoor campaign reaches 75 per cent adults in a
market at a minimum of 15 times in a 30-day period. This level of exposure is beyond
any other medium.
ii. Geographic Flexibility : Outdoor advertising is highly flexible and can be placed almost
anywhere the law permits. It can be placed near stores, on buildings, along city roads, on
mobile billboards, highways, etc. Outdoor advertising can conveniently cover local,
regional, or national markets.
iii. Continuity : Outdoor advertising provides 24-hour coverage and cannot be turned off
or ignored like any other media. Exposure to outdoor media is not dependent on audience
habits, it cannot be put aside or left unopened. The outdoor advertisement message is
always working for the advertiser.
iv. Efficiency : From the cost point of view, outdoor advertising is the most efficient of all
mass media.
v. Creativity : By combining colour, art and short copy, outdoor advertising can quickly
generate an association with a particular brand. If a billboard is placed at a busy point,
audiences see the advertisement again and again. The more frequently the idea is
repeated, the more likely it is to be retained.
Demerits
i. Limited Message Capabilities : Outdoor copy must be brief since it is perceived while the
audience is mobile and the exposure time is short. The messages are limited to just a few
words. Lengthy appeals are unlikely to be registered to have any impact.
ii. Waste Coverage : Generally the purchase of outdoor ad space results in high levels of
waste coverage, because not everyone driving or walking past a billboard is part of the
intended target audience.
iii. Limited Effectiveness : A number of uncontrollable factors may lessen the effectiveness
of outdoor ads such as trees, structures and traffic signals which may distract the
audience.
iv. Public Criticism : Various public interest and environmental groups criticise outdoor
billboards, posters, etc. claiming that they are an eyesore, nuisance, and often a cause of
road accidents.
Outdoor advertising has become a useful medium with the increase in the number
of automobiles and improved road network. Roadside and market area billboards are
increasingly in demand by advertisers, particularly, on prime locations.
Transit advertising
233
keeps the message in front of the air passenger for as long as the ticket is retained. There
is an extensive public transport system in India because most people cannot afford private
transportation. A very large number of commuters travel every day to their place of work
and back home. A large number of people, including those who come to see off
passengers, visit railway stations, bus terminals, and airports every day and are exposed
to a variety of ad messages on posters, neon signs, electronic boards, etc. Posters also
appear on the sides and backs of buses, commuter trains, trams and delivery vans.
Merits
i. Exposure Duration : A major advantage of indoor forms of transit advertising is that the
duration of exposure is long.
ii. Exposure Frequency : Millions who commute to their place of work and back home
every day are exposed to advertisements repeatedly.
iii. Geographic Selectivity : Advertisers can choose geographic areas to reach a select
segment of population. This is particularly useful to local advertisers who can buy
locations in certain neighbourhoods.
iv. Low Cost : Transit advertising is among the least expensive media and can be
purchased for a very reasonable price.
Demerits
i. Waste Coverage : A significant number of exposed audiences to transit advertising do
not fall under the category of potential customers. In the absence of specific geographic
segments for products, this form of advertising leads to considerable waste coverage.
ii. Creative Limitations : The message on the outside of vehicles is fleeting and only short
copy points are appropriate. This does not allow for any colourful and attractive
advertisements and limits any creativity.
iii. Audience Mood : Sitting or standing on a commuter train, station, or bus stand may not
really be helpful to reading advertisements. The audience is likely to be engaged in other
thoughts and may not be in the right mood to pay attention to advertising. Hurrying
through a station or airport often causes anxiety and advertisements are unlikely to attract
attention.
Cinema and videos
Cinema halls and videotapes are also used to communicate advertising messages.
Commercials are shown before the film and previews, carrying messages from both local
as well as national advertisers. Many local advertisers use this medium to advertise their
products. Advertisers, mostly local businesses or retailers, use prepared slides for
projection. National advertisers generally use 35 mm advertisement films based on a
script. These are produced by professionals or the advertising agency and are expensive.
Cinema is a popular source of entertainment in India. A large proportion of cinema
audience is young and comes from almost all classes of society and socio-economic
groups. Like TV, cinema also combines sight, sound, colour and movement. People come
to see a movie of their choice and hence are more involved. The screen size is large,
234
picture clarity is superb, and the sound quality is superior compared to television. The
combined total effect of these features creates a powerful impact on the audience. The
audience also knows that the movie will not be interrupted by the commercials and for
this reason they are unlikely to be irritated when the commercials are shown in the
beginning or during intermission.
Merits
i. Exposure : As a source of entertainment, cinema is quite popular both in urban and rural
areas and the number of people attending cinema halls is substantial. Similarly,
households owning VCRs or DVD players are increasing and a large number of video
films remain in circulation every day carrying a variety of ad messages to captive
audiences.
ii. Audience Mood : People deliberately plan to go to movie theatres. Their pre-movie
mood is positive and this mood may lead to carry over effect to the advertised product.
iii. Selectivity : In case of movies shown in cinema halls, advertisers can be selective in
terms of region, towns and cinema halls.
iv. Recall : According to Betsy Baurer, research shows that nearly 87 per cent viewers can
recall the advertisements that they saw in a movie next day.
v. Lack of Clutter : Most theatres limit the number of advertisements and competing
brands are not screened one after the other. This eliminates the chances of clutter.
Demerit
i. Audience Irritation : Most people perhaps do not like to see advertisements in these
media. This is particularly the case with videotapes and DVDs and for this reason zipping
is a very common occurrence. Audience irritation can lead to the development of
negative feelings towards the film as well as the advertised product.
3.5.5. Measurement:
In recent years the investment in all forms of advertising has increased
dramatically and advertisers have found advertising a powerful selling tool. But, in many
cases, advertisements failed to produce the expected results. Some advertisements, and
some advertising campaigns turn out to be flops. Hence, advertisers want to weed out the
poor advertisements and pick the good ones. For this, evaluation of advertising
effectiveness needs to be done. Advertisers have actively and continuously sought new
methods, which would help them to better evaluate the effectiveness of their advertising
with the aim to eliminate waste and to increase the effectiveness of their advertising.
Measurement of advertising effectiveness help management to maximize the contribution
that advertising can make. For most advertising, the eventual measure of effectiveness is
frequently tied to sales per rupee spent. However, before advertising can make its
contribution, certain communication objectives must be met. The eventual buyer must
have been exposed to advertising, it must have communicated a message, and it must
have motivated or conditioned the buyer, either consciously or unconsciously to want to
purchase. The effectiveness of the advertising in achieving these communication
235
more important factors which are directly related to advertising stimulus. Such factors or
elements create awareness, comprehension, liking, preference, conviction, purchase
action, development of strong USP, brand image, brand personality and changing
attitudes which indirectly support the sales effort.
Advertising campaigns are launched with certain objectives such as creating
awareness, increasing brand image, trial rate to change consumer attitudes or increasing
market share etc. The advertising should achieve: the targets, fulfil the marketing and
advertising objectives within a specified period of time. Advertisers spend huge amount
of money to convert the prospects into active consumers, but they would be dismayed to
what extent their advertisements achieved the results. Since Cable and satellite television
advertisements are very expensive business, it is almost necessary for the advertisers to
know the actual result of their advertisements. Hence, the measurement of effectiveness
of advertising on television and Cable TV network is quite essential. Lack of feedback,
interference, and translation of advertiser's language into consumer language are
important problems in advertising, but they do not alter the basic requirements for
successful advertising. For any idea to be transmitted effectively from the source to the
receiver, whether the source is personal or non-personal, the message must meet these
three qualifications :
i. It must be so designed and delivered as to gain the attention of the receiver.
ii. It must use signals that are understood in the same way by both the source and
the receiver.
iii. It must arouse needs in the receiver and suggest some ways of satisfying these
needs that are appropriate to the receivers' group situation when moved to
make the desired response.
In order to accomplish the communication task advertising goals are set to achieve the
cognitive, affective and behavioural responses from the prospects or consumers, or
viewers. Almost in all cases the above three aspects are essential for measuring the
effectiveness of advertising. These aspects are also dealt in various models of advertising
communication such as AIDA, DAGMAR etc. The AIDA acronym stands for Attention,
Interest, Desire and Action.
3.6. Advertising agencies:
An advertising agency is an independent company set up to render specialised
services in advertising in particular and marketing in general. When a firm has decided
upon advertising programme as part of its over all promotion mix, it needs to have a
system and an organisation to implement it for the attainment of the desired objective.
Firms do have an advertising department to manage the advertising function. In some
small firms, there may not be a separate department in the name of advertising, but the
marketing manager or the chief executive looks after the function. The company's
advertising department usually relies on out side experts who prepares the advertisement
messages, selects appropriate media, and arranges to release them. The advertising
department of a company has only a limited creative function, primarily a liaison point in
237
the company for the agency, though it is responsible for the advertisement budget and
supervises the performance of the agency. An advertising manager has to co-ordinate
with the marketing and sales function, so that the advertising efforts may be fully
integrated with the firm's marketing and sales strategy. He has also to perform the
managerial task of formulating advertising strategy and planning an advertising
programme. The execution of such programme is managed by this department through
the advertising agency. The agency often assists the advertising manager in programme
formulation.
Advertising agencies can range in size from one or two person operation to large
organisations with over 1,000 employees. Accordingly, the services offered and functions
performed will vary. There can be following types of advertising agencies :
- Full service agency
- In house agency
- A creative Boutique
- Media buying services
- A La-carte agency
- Special service agency
Full service agency : Full service agency offers its clients a full range of marketing,
organisation may decide to establish its own operation for all services of an advertising
agency within its own structure. The in-house agency as its name implies is owned by
and operated under the direct supervision of the advertiser. It performs all the creative
and media services provided by the traditional full- service agency. A major goal in
adopting this approach is to reduce the total cost of the advertising.
Creative Boutique : It is an agency that provides only creative services. The client may
seek outside creative talent because it believes that an extra creative effort is required or
because its own employees do not have sufficient skill in this regard. Full-service agency
often subcontract work to creative boutiques when they are very busy or want to avoid
adding full time employees to their payroll. Creative boutiques are usually founded by
members of the creative departments of full service agencies who leave the firm and take
with them clients who want to retain their creative talent.
Media Buying Services: There are independent companies specialize in the buying of
media, particularly radio and TV time. Media buying is a niche service and these
agencies are specialized in the analysis and purchase of advertising time & space. Both
238
agencies and clients utilize their services for developing their own media strategies and
using the buying service to execute them. Because media buying services purchase such
large amounts of time and space, they receive large discounts and can save the small
agency or client money on media purchases. Media buying services are paid a fee or
commission for their work.
A La Carte Agency: Some advertisers prefer to order a la carte rather than using all of an
agency's services. Services can be purchased from a full service agency or from an
individual firm that specializes only in creative work, media, production, research, or new
product development. The two requirements most frequently obtained by a la carte are
creative and media services.
Special Service Agency (Group): Some agencies focus their efforts only in some selected
areas and then become specialists in those areas. There is great multiplicity of firms
whose objective is to provide advertisers, advertising agencies and the advertising media
with a host of specialized services. These firms collectively are called special service
groups and they are the least known component of the advertising industry.
4. Have you understood type questions
1. What was the growth rate of advertising during 2005?
a. 11.1%
b. 12.1%
c. 14.1%
d. 15.1%
2. Which media according to NRS is showing higher growth rate?
a. Newspaper
b. Magazines
c. Transit
d. Outdoor
3. Which of the following is the advertising appropriation method that is most effective?
a. Affordable method
b. Percentage of sales
c. Percentage of turnover
d. Objective and task method
4. What is the expansion of LINTAS?
5. Media scheduling has become cumbersome due to advent of satellite channels. Yes/No
6. Portfolio method is one of a advertising measurement method. Yes/ No
5. Summary
The advertising industry has a 15.1% growth, clocking Rs.11,915 crore in 2005.
Both the leading media, Television and the Print, have grown by 15 percent each.
Together they account for 90 percent of the advertisement pie. While Television and Print
media have cornered Rs 5,003 crore and Rs 5,700 crore worth of advertising,
239
respectively, the third largest media category Outdoor, has grown moderately at 8.7
percent netting Rs 870 crore. While the advertisement revenue growth of the Print media
can be attributed to the significant jump in advertising spends by educational institutions,
real estate developers, independent retailers, durables marketers, and automobile
companies among others, the revenue growth of Television has been largely powered by
the FMCG sector, which has recovered sharply in 2005 clocking a double-digit growth,
on back of some heavily advertising categories like toilet soaps, hair oil, etc. Two media
genres that have seen scorching growth rates are Radio and the Internet, which have
grown by 33 percent and 57 percent to touch Rs 200 crore and Rs 110 crore, respectively.
While for the Radio this growth has been led by a number of factors, such as vigorous
activities following the liberalised regulatory regime and the faster expansion of the
circles, the humungous growth of the Internet has been driven by the faster growth in the
Net user-base that has touched 50.6 million. This augurs well for the industry as well the
marketing function as such.
6. Exercises
1. It is said that advertising helps meet competitors and match competitors, by
persuading the customer or providing a counter-claim. In an increasingly
competitive world, suppliers must advertise to protect themselves against primary
competition, and sometimes against other categories of product too. With suitable
examples, explain this aspect.
2. One such study found that the advertisements reflected the stereotype that women
do not do important things, are dependent on men, are regarded by men primarily
as sex objects, and should be in the home. Identify such campaigns in the Indian
context where stereotyping is done.
3. Conduct a study to find the styles of any three leading advertising agencies in
India.
4. What are the conflicting issues advertiser have with agencies? With suitable
examples, explain how it can be overcome.
5. Prepare a story board for a campaign on quit smoking.
7. References
SALES PROMOTION
240
1. Introduction:
Every marketer has to think about sales promotion at one stage or the other of the
product life cycle. In modern business world, sales promotion is considered as an
important instrument to lubricate the marketing efforts. The marketers have realised that
it is not expenditure but it is an investment because it will pay rich dividends. This does
not compete with advertising or personal selling. Sales promotion activities are
complementary to them. Advertising is frequently used to make sales promotion
activities, such as sweepstakes, coupons, premiums etc., known to consumers. Sales
people often use sales promotion to help sell their product lines to intermediaries.
2. Learning Objectives:
When you finish this unit, you should be able to:
3. Sales Promotions:
According to the American Marketing Association, sales promotion includes all
marketing activities, other than personal selling, advertising and publicity, that stimulate
consumer purchasing and dealer effectiveness such as displays shown and expositions,
demonstrations and various non-recurrent selling efforts not I the ordinary routine. Sales
promotional activities are impersonal and usually non-recurring and are directed to
ultimate consumer, industrial consumer and middlemen. These activities tend to
supplement the advertising and personal selling efforts. Examples of sales promotion are
free product samples, premiums and trade shows. For many organisations, including the
marketers of foods, toys and clothing, store displays are important sales tolls. All
prospective buyers must be attracted and even persuaded to buy the product. Sales
promotion is a vital link between advertising and field selling. It aims at stimulating
consumer purchasing at the point of sale and dealers effectiveness at the retail channel of
distribution especially because of the competitiveness of retailing.
3.1. Objectives of sales promotion:
The goals of sales promotion must confirm to the overall objectives of promotion efforts.
There are five broad sales promotional objectives. They are:
Exposure:
241
pressure on the demand for sales promotion. As the number of brands increases, for
example, the competitive pressure for display space in retailer store or Stock keeping unit
(SKU) intensifies. These forces increase retailers demand for more sales promotional
efforts from their suppliers.
A good sales promotional programme could alleviate consumer dissatisfaction
with respect to retail selling. The trend is away from the use of retail sales people and
towards self service also points up the need for sales promotion. Sales promotional
devices are often the only promotional materials available in the point of purchase.
Advertising media reach potential consumers at their homes and at their places of
business. When the time for buying arises, the impact of the advertisements may have
worn off (or the prospect may not even have seen the advertisement). However, the sales
promotional devices at the point of purchase inform, remind and persuade the buyer.
People who comprehend the promotional devices are excellent prospects. They are
usually in the buying frame of mind, or they would not be there at the purchase point.
The importance of sales promotion to manufacturers, middlemen and consumers are
explained below:
Sales promotion to consumers:
With the help of promotional efforts, the consumers get latest information
regarding the new goods or services to be initiated or sold in the market.
Consumers get effective incentives in the shape of off-season discount , gifts,
samples etc.,
Consumers get the opportunity to participate in contests
Upgrade the standard of living of the consumers
Reduction in prices make certain products affordable
243
Weaknesses
Clutter
Can set false retail price
Can undercut brand name
Cost can be prohibitive if continued
244
245
In-pack premiums which are inserted into the package by the manufacturers
On-pack premiums which are placed on the outside of the package at the
factory
246
Dealer Loaders:
To help encourage the retailer to put up a special display or POP display for a
promotion, the marketer will sometimes design a display to include an attractive item of
value to the retailer.
Trade shows:
Manufacturers, suppliers and vendors in a particular industry gather to display and
review new product developments at trade shows. Manufacturers have exhibits or booths
where they can demonstrate the product, provide informations, answer questions and
write orders.
3.6.Developing the sales promotion schemes:
After deciding the objectives and tools of sales promotion, the marketer has to make a
few more decisions to ensure effective results. The following are a few such aspects:
1.Size of incentive:
The marketer has to determine how much incentive should be offered. A certain
minimum incentive is necessary if the promotion is to succeed. A higher incentive level
will produce more sales response but at a diminishing rate. The marketers may usually
decide the quantum of incentives on the basis of effectiveness of part promotion plans.
2.Conditions for participation:
Incentive should not be disturbed to all the prospective buyers indiscrimenably. It should
be offered only who have the innate desire and attitude to purchase products offered by
the company.
3.Distribution Pattern:
The marketer must also decide the mode and media of distribution of incentives. The cost
of distribution should not be more than the results that are expected from the promotional
efforts.
4.Duration of the promotion:
If the sales promotion period is too short, many prospects will not be able to take
advantage, since they may not be repurchasing at that time. With the promotion trends
too long, a scheme will lose some of its effects.
5.Timing of the promotion:
The promotion managers have to develop a time schedule for the promotions. The dates
must be useful to production, sales and distribution managers. Some unplanned
promotions may become necessary. At that time, co-operation of people concerned must
be enlisted.
6.Sales promotion budget:
247
The marketer can choose the promotional tools, the method of implementation in
advance. On the basis of such a plan, he can estimate the cost of sales promotion
activities. The more popular way is to take a conventional percent age of the total budget
to use for sales promotion.
7.Pretesting:
Sales promotion scheme should be pre-tested if possible. The purpose is to determine
whether the scheme is appropriate or not. It is also helpful to test the suitability of the size
of the incentive in the context of a particular target group.
8.Implementing the promotional schemes:
Companies should establish implementation plans for each promotion covering leadtime and sell off time.
Lead-time is the time required to prepare the programme before launching it.
Sell off time begins with the launch and ends when the deal closes.
3.7. Evaluation of the sales promotion schemes:
Manufacturers can use various methods to measure the effectiveness of sales promotion
schemes. Some of them are:
The most common method is to compare sales before, during and after a promotion.
Suppose a company has 6% market share, in the pre-promotion period, which jumps
to 10% during the promotion, falls to 5% immediately after and rises to 7% after
some time. The promotion evidently attracted new buyers as well as more purchasing
by existing customers. After the promotion, the sales fell as consumers worked down
their inventories. The long run rise to 7% indicates that the company gained some
new users.
Consumer panel data would reveal the kind of people who responded with the
promotion and what they did after the promotion. If more information is needed, the
consumer surveys can be conducted to learn how many recall the promotions, what
they think about it, how many took advantage of it, how it affected their subsequent
branded choice behaviour.
Sales promotion can also be evaluated through experiments that differ such attributes
as incentive value, duration and distribution media.
3.8. Sales promotions in India:
1. Baron International, the marketers of AIWA TV promised the money back if India
succeeds in the World Cricket Cup 1999. If the team wins, one gets some Rs.6, 000
back on a TV priced at around Rs.12, 500. Apart from this, the company has
promised each team player a Mercedes if India wins the cup. This is by far the best
sales promotion and had given the company the dividends.
248
2. Britannia invested Rs.10 Crore on its Britannia khao, World Cup jao promotion and
it created waves in the market. Every product comes with a number of runs (printed
on the pack). By collecting 100 runs, one gets a booklet from the retailer. This
represents a potential trove for the buyer ranging from complementary packs to
match tickers. The company kicks off this sales promotion scheme in February that
year well ahead of the programme.
3. Samsung and Sansui gave away Cup related freebies with every product.
4. Asian Paints asked the customers to walk into any of their showrooms and pick out
the shade of blue that the Indian team wears in the World cup. Winners flew to
England to watch the Indian games.
5. Re.1 off on a Surf carry bag
6. 50 gm. Cake of Ponds soap was at one time given free with every purchase of HLL
shampoos.
7. Britannia Quiz Contest
8. Coke offered a cap on the purchase of 5 Coke bottles
9. Vicks, Ariel using sampling technique
10. Tamil magazines providing in pack premiums like Amrutanjan cream, Shampoos,
Saffrons and soaps
11. For every three Peter England shirts bought, one white Peter England was given free
12. Pepsi by keeping three digit numbers in the crown offered the following prizes based
on weekly draws:
13. Rupees One lakh if all the three numbers match
14. Rupees Ten thousand if two numbers match
15. One Pepsi free if one number matches
16. TVS-Suzuki offering to provide the vehicle at Rs.3000 and later on in instalment
schemes
17. LML allowing trade ins of any make
18. Akai spearheading the exchange market where the old TV was valued at Rs.10,000
for a new Akai TV
19. Nike tying up with Advertising and Marketing for the subscription drive
20. Castrol and Servo giving away caps, T-shirts etc as freebies
21. Parle cashing on the Sakthimann serial success with Sakthimann sub-brand products
with sales promotional efforts
22. Kurl-on mattress offered pillows free in the 5 category
23. Maruti lowering the prices of its 800, Zen Estilo by Rs.25, 000.
4. Have you understood type questions
1. To convince supermarkets to stock a large display of HUL products (containing eight
cases of the company's bar soap and body wash products), the company's sales force had
to engage in ________, especially when dealing with chain stores.
A.
B.
C.
D.
Advertising
Personal selling
Sales promotion
Publicity
249
2. Do you agree that sales promotion is a below the line promotion? Yes/ No
3. State whether True or False. Sales promotion aimed at the sales promotion normally
do not provide the results intended and discourages the entire field force
4. Which sales promotion is quite often used by the retailers?
A. Premiums
B. Couponing
C. Tie-ins
D. Discounts
5. State whether True or false. Sales intended across the traders necessarily need to be
discounts either as cash or in quantity.
5. Summary
Marketers who employ sales promotion as a key component in their promotional
strategy should be aware of how the climate for these types of promotions is changing.
The onslaught of sales promotion activity over the last several decades has eroded the
value of the short-term requirement to act on sales promotions. Many customers are
conditioned to expect a promotion at the time of purchase otherwise they may withhold
or even alter their purchase if a promotion is not present. For instance, food shoppers are
inundated on a weekly basis with such a wide variety of sales promotions that their
loyalty to certain products has been replaced by their loyalty to current value items (i.e.,
products with a sales promotion). For marketers the challenge is to balance the
advantages short-term promotions offer versus the potential to erode loyalty to the
product. Sales promotions are delivered to customers in many ways such as by mail, inperson or within print media. However, the Internet and mobile technologies, such as
cell-phones, present marketers with a number of new delivery options. For example, the
combination of mobile devices and geographic positioning technology will soon permit
marketers to target promotions to a customers physical location. This will allow retailers
and other businesses to issue sales promotions, such as electronic coupons, to a
customers mobile device when they are near the location where the coupon can be used.
Tracking customers response to marketers promotional activity is critical for
measuring success of an advertisement. In sales promotion, tracking is also used. For
instance, grocery retailers, whose customers are in possession of loyalty cards, have the
ability to match customer sales data to coupon use. This information can then be sold to
coupon marketers who may use the information to get a better picture of the buying
patterns of those responding to the coupon. For many years consumers typically became
aware of sales promotions in passive ways. That is, most customers obtained promotions
not through an active search but by being a recipient of a marketers promotion activity
(e.g., received coupons in the mail). The Internet is changing how customers obtain
promotions. In addition to websites that offer access to coupons, there are a large number
of community forum sites where members share details about how to obtain good deals
which often include information on how or where to find a sales promotion. Monitoring
these sites may offer marketers insight into how customers feel about certain promotions
and may even suggest ideas for future sales promotions. Sales promotions do the same
way, an advertisement competes with other advertisements for customers attention. This
250
is particularly an issue with inserted coupon promotions that may be included in mailing
or printed media along with numerous other offerings. The challenge faced by marketers
is to find creative ways to separate their promotions from those offered by their
competitors.
6. Exercises
1. There are number of products designed for consumption by children but the purchases
are made by mothers. Such products must appeal to children and have the mother's
approval too. In what way sales promotion by these companies be effective? Give
examples.
2. Manufacturers, suppliers and vendors in a particular industry gather to display and
review new product developments at trade shows. Manufacturers have exhibits or
booths where they can demonstrate the product, provide informations, answer
questions and write orders. Explain how you will conduct these exhibitions as an
event manager.
3. An offer of merchandise, either frees or at a reduced price, for responding in same
way is called a premium. Many companies also use premiums to encourage
consumers to switch brands or to reward customer loyalty. Conduct a study to find
the latest measures in the Indian market.
4. Advertising is a must to show cause the sales promotion efforts Discuss with
recent examples.
7. References
1. Julian Cummins, Sales Promotion, Universal Book Stall, New Delhi
PERSONAL SELLING
1. Introduction:
Sales management is considered crucial in those industries where personal selling
is given the most important part in the promotional mix. Sales management needs to be
carried out with conviction otherwise there will be lot of manpower turnover from
companies. There are a lot of differences sales management has as compared to other
promotional mix elements. Personal selling is a two-way flow of communication between
a potential buyer and a sales person that is designed to identify the customers needs,
match those needs to one of the companys products and convince the customer to buy
the product. Hence it is very comprehensive in nature.
2. Learning Objectives:
When you finish this unit, you should be able to:
251
3. Personal selling:
Personal sellings greatest strength is its personal touch. Of all the marketing
communication functions, personal selling involves the most human contact and
interaction, qualities that are indispensable to building lasting relationship between
buyers and sellers. A related strength is the flexibility of personal sales thereby making
necessary changes in the specific needs of each potential customer, highlighting the
characteristics of a product that are most likely to meet those needs. Personal selling is
most likely to persuade some one to buy a product than other promotional tools. The oneto-one situation facilitates instant feedback with the result that the sales person can
address customers objections. Salespeople are part of the corporate team, and their
relationships with other areas and functions within their own company are important
factors affecting the companys image and ultimately the sales. A weakness of personal
selling is that one person can sometimes spoil a relationship between a company and one
or more of its customers. Because the salesperson is the companys main representative
to customers, anything this person does that is out of line will reflect negatively on the
entire company. Another weakness is that if a salesperson leaves the company to work
for a competitor, he or she takes along all the companys selling strategies, important
accounts and also other inside information. Personal selling is very costly due to the
labour intensiveness. A highly qualified professional sales person calling on corporate
headquarters and selling high-tech products or large volume products can make only a
few calls a day because customers are rarely geographically close. Consumers often
complain about high pressure and dishonesty among sales people, an image that
competent sales people are continually trying to dispel.
3.1. Relevance of selling to the modern marketer:
In todays highly competitive market place, customers expect more from
companies. That can be offered only directly through the use of sales management. Since
the customers expect more information and expertise, there needs to be a one-to-one
interaction. Through selling, all the questions and other problems which the customer
have can be answered with full satisfaction. This makes selling an unique tool as
compared to advertising, sales promotion etc. Another aspect is that the customers require
a honest and just answer. The value for money (VFM) can be provided only through the
use of personal selling with effectiveness.
The broad strategy for the marketer is organising the firm to meet consumer
needs. The sales force is one of the practical weapons that the chief marketing executive,
who can be the managing director can use to achieve the objectives. In most firms the
bulk of the presentation effort is carried out by the sales force, and thus it is often by far
the most important tactical weapon. In a situation where products and prices are
252
becoming sincreasingly similar and the sales force is the weapon, its efficiency is
absolutely critical to the success of the whole enterprise. In fact, in many markets it can
be said that the differenece between competitors lies in relative quality of their sales
forces. The company with the best planned, selected, trained, motivated and controlled
sales force will inevitably gain dominance in the market. To a large extent, once the sales
person has been recruited and given basic training his success will depend on the field
sales manager who controls that sales person.
3.2. Selling steps:
Prospecting
Prospecting refers to identifying and developing a list of potential clients. Salespeople
can seek the names of prospects from a variety of sources including trade shows,
commercially-available databases or mail lists, company sales records and in-house
databases, public records, referrals, directories, and a wide variety of other sources.
Prospecting activities should be clearly structured so that they identify only potential
clients who fit the profile and are able, willing, and authorized to buy the product or
service. Once prospecting is underway, it then is up to the sales professional to qualify
those prospects to further identify likely customers and screen out poor leads.
Pre-approach
Before engaging in the actual personal selling process, sales professionals first analyze all
the information they have available to them about a prospect to understand as much about
the prospect as possible. During the Pre-approach phase of the personal selling process,
sales professionals try to understand the prospect's current needs, current use of brands
and feelings about all available brands, as well as identify key decision makers, review
account histories (if any), assess product needs, plan/create a sales presentation to address
the identified and likely concerns of the prospect, and set call objectives. The sales
professional also develops a preliminary overall strategy for the sales process during this
phase, keeping in mind that the strategy may have to be refined as he or she learns more
about the prospect.
Approach
The approach is the actual contact the sales professional has with the prospect. This is the
point of the selling process where the sales professional meets and greets the prospect,
provides an introduction, establishes rapport that sets the foundation of the relationship,
and asks open-ended questions to learn more about the prospect and his or her needs.
Making the Presentation
During the presentation portion of the selling process, the sales professional tells that
product "story" in a way that speaks directly to the identified needs and wants of the
253
prospect. A highly customized presentation is the key component of this step. At this
point in the process, prospects are often allowed to hold and/or inspect the product and
the sales professional may also actually demonstrate the product. Audio visual
presentations may be incorporated such as slide presentations or product videos and this
is usually when sales brochures or booklets are presented to the prospect. Sales
professionals should strive to let the prospect do most of the talking during the
presentation and address the needs of the prospect as fully as possible by showing that he
or she truly understands and cares about the needs of the prospect.
Overcoming Objections
Professional salespeople seek out prospect objections in order to try to address and
overcome them. When prospects offers objections, it often signals that they need and
want to hear more in order to make a fully-informed decision. If objections are not
uncovered and identified, then sales professionals cannot effectively manage them.
Uncovering objections, asking clarifying questions, and overcoming objections is a
critical part of training for professional sellers and is a skill area that must be continually
developed because there will always be objections. Trust me when I tell you that as soon
as a sales professional finds a way to successfully handle "all" his or her prospects'
objections, some prospect will find a new, unanticipated objection-- if for no other reason
than to test the mettle of the salesperson.
Closing the Sale
Although technically "closing" a sale happens when products or services are delivered to
the customer's satisfaction and payment is received, for the purposes of our discussion I
will define closing as asking for the order and adequately addressing any final objections
or obstacles. There are many closing techniques as well as many ways to ask trial closing
questions. A trail question might take the form of, "Now that I've addressed your
concerns, what other questions do you have that might impact your decision to
purchase?" Closing does not always mean that the sales professional literally asks for the
order, it could be asking the prospect how many they would like, what color they would
prefer, when they would like to take delivery, etc. Too many sales professions are either
weak or too aggressive when it comes to closing. If you are closing a sale, be sure to ask
for the order. If the prospect gives an answer other than "yes", it may be a good
opportunity to identify new objections and continue selling.
Follow-up
Follow-up is an often overlooked but important part of the selling process. After an order
is received, it is in the best interest of everyone involved for the salesperson to follow-up
with the prospect to make sure the product was received in the proper condition, at the
right time, installed properly, proper training delivered, and that the entire process was
acceptable to the customer. This is a critical step in creating customer satisfaction and
building long-term relationships with customers. If the customer experienced any
problems whatsoever, the sales professional can intervene and become a customer
254
advocate to ensure 100% satisfaction. Diligent follow-up can also lead to uncovering new
needs, additional purchases, and also referrals and testimonials which can be used as
sales tools.
3.3. Sales force objectives:
Sales objectives must be based on the character of the companys target markets and the
companys desired position in these markets. Companies typically set objectives for their
sales force. For example, a computer sales person is responsible for selling, installing and
upgrading customer computer equipments. Sales representatives perform one or more of
the following tasks for their companies:
Prospecting
Targeting
Communication
Selling
Administration
Information gathering and
Allocating
Considering these, sales representatives work with customers in several ways:
Sales representatives to buyer: A sales representative discusses issues with a prospect or
customer in person or over the phone.
Conference selling: Sales representative brings company resource people to discuss a
major problem.
Seminar selling: A company team conducts an educational seminar for the customer
company.
Once the company decides on a desirable selling approach, it can use either a
direct or contractual sales force.
Direct: It consists of full-time or part-time paid employees who work exclusively for the
company. This includes inside sales personnel who conduct business from their office
using the telephone and receiving visits from prospects and field sales personnel, who
travel and visit customers.
Contractual: This consists of manufacturers sales agents or brokers, who are paid a
commission based on their sales.
3.4. Sales force structures:
The sales force strategy will have implications for structuring the sales force. If
the company sells many products to many types of customers, it might need a product or
market sales force structure. If the company sells one product line to one end- using
industry with customers in many locations, the company would use a territorial sales
force structure.
Territorial structure:
255
257
The rationale for exclusive territories is that all prospects can be covered in an orderly
and efficient manner. The risk of duplication of effort is virtually eliminated. The
customer may be better served because each sales person will be responsible and reap the
rewards of happy customers and all that means in terms of repeat business. This type
generally thought to encourage more loyalty from the sales person toward the company.
3.Territory planning:
Everyone involved must understand the plan and thus aid in its implementation. By the
same token the plan should provide direction and reduce the tendency to drift without
working toward a desirable objective. To be useful, it must be written in simple plain
language. Such issues as market penetration, geographic concentration, sales blitzes, new
account emphasis, and product strategy, among other factors, will affect how the territory
is divided.
5.Sales forecast:
Once the area to be served is defined the next step is relatively easy. From the sales
forecast for the following year and the estimates projected for future years, the sales
manager should be able to determine how many sales people will be required to attain the
projections. This involves analysing the sales forecast in terms of the number of sales
persons needed to make the predicted sales. One of the considerations is the commission
level expected for each sales person. The sales manager should also decide how many
territories will be required. Again it is a function of the forecast. In fact, a complete and
scientific forecast, in-depth and well documented, will be the best spring board from
which the sales manger can build the territory design for profitable sales.
3.6. Sales force management:
3.6.1. Recruitment:
258
259
260
261
Provident fund , gratuity and employee insurance schemes where the employee
needs to contribute.
Straight commission:
The commission schemes are followed only in those industries which are very old. There
are lot of individuals who are experienced who can understand the riguors of the industry
and would be able to provide the company what they expect. The following are the
methods followed in this straight commission:
Simple Percentage
Company pays its salespeople 10 per cent of whatever they sell.
The details of this method are provided in the next lesson.
Salary and Commission:
This method allows for the improved performance by the sales people. In an effort
to achieve above their targets, this method helps the companies. The sales people will
work more than what they do when they are earning only a simple salary. If the
organisation is old and the industry is growing, this method is found to be useful.
Incentives:
Incentives are motivators. Over and above the salary, these incentives play a vital
role in the overall growth of the company as well the sales personnel. Incentives provide
the extra money for the employee and motivates him to perform better. A study by Ralph
& Affliates among the companies and sales people revealed that, incentives are used to
Increase or maintain sales (84%)
Build morale (65%)
Build customer loyalty / trust (51%)
Increase market share (51%)
Build employee loyalty / trust (49%)
Improve customer service (49%)
Create new markets (44%)
Foster teamwork (42%)
Develop contracts (40%)
262
ESOP:
Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP): An ESOP is a defined contribution
employee benefit plan that allows employees to become owners of stock in the company they
work for.
ESOP works as under:
1. The ESOP operates through a trust, setup by the company, that accepts tax deductible
contributions from the company to purchase company stock.
2. The contributions made by the company are distributed to individual employee accounts
within the trust.
3. The amount of stock each individual receives may vary according to pre-established
formulas based on salary, service, or position.
4. The employees may cash out after vesting in the program or when they leave the
company. The amount they may cash out may depend on the vesting requirements.
4. Have you understood type questions:
1. Personal selling plays a vital role in industrial markets. True/ False
2. The stage in the personal selling steps where the sales force actually meets the
prospect is at:
A. Prospecting
B. Pre approach
C. Approach
D. Demonstration
3. The emergence of specialised trade journals and magazines like Express Pharma
pulse, IT magazine, PC quest, Hotelier& Caterer, Auto India, Retailing magazine etc.,
has helped the recruiter to zoom down to the right candidates. State True /False.
4. Simulation is a method of sales force.:
A. Recruitment
B. Selection
C. Training
D. Performance appraisal
5. ..is the best method in industries which are old.
A. Salary only
B. Commission only
C. ESOP
D. None of these
5. Summary
Personal selling is different for different industries. The sales people require to have
certain unique skills and traits that force them to face the harsh realities of the market. The
most important personality traits for sales people are empathy and focus, ego-drive, optimism
and attitude toward responsibility. There is a need to have personal introspection before
venturing into selling. An introvert can hardly be able to sell anything. It is hence important
that the individual is outgoing, gregarious and also an extrovert, talkative person. Apart from
selling, the sales person has to perform many other tasks, such that the percentage of calling
263
time is only about 33 per cent. The potential customers have to be first identified from
databases/company sources/primary information available. The sales person has to plan on
which prospect needs to be called with what priority. Then, the sales person has to decide
how to approach a customer. Thus the selling techniques have to be constantly followed up.
In addition, the sales persons company will request administrative work such as providing all
kinds of data on customers, reporting activities, participating in sales meetings and
conferences and visiting trade shows as seen earlier. In order to constantly improve the
competence, the sales person has to take part in product as well as sales training.
Marketing of services
1. Introduction:
Services permeate every aspect of our lives; consequently the need for services
marketing knowledge is greater than ever before. The distinction between goods and services
is often unclear. In general goods are defined as objects, devices or things, where as services
are defined as deeds, efforts, or performances. Very few products can be classified as pure
products or pure services. When a customer purchases a service, he or she purchases an
experience. The four components of the servicing system create the experience for the
customer-the inanimate environment, service providers/contact personnel, other customers,
and the invisible organization and systems. In turn, the service experience that is created
delivers a bundle of benefits to the consumer. This service sector which is now a major
component of the Indian economy will thrive for years to come and the marketers should
know how to make the most of this sector.
2. Learning Objectives:
When you finish this unit, you should be able to:
264
the language which the world speaks. Being a developing nation rearing to make a mark
globally our services have the leverage of wage differential. This phenomenon makes Indian
professionals much sought after in the world market. For domestic economy too, opening of
the services sector is advantageous as it absorbs the teaming millions reducing the possibility
of educated unemployed stuck with limited options in agriculture and manufacturing sectors
of the economy. Sixteen service sectors in the country achieved growth of more than 20 per
cent in 2004-05 compared to 2003-04, according to an analysis of 42 service sectors carried
out by the FICCI. Another 18 sectors clocked 10-20 per cent growth during the same period.
Based on the feedback received from representatives of various service-related industry
associations and private and public sector companies, the analysis found that the sectors that
recorded more than 20 per cent growth in 2004-05 included organised retail trade (30 per
cent), road transport service (20 per cent), domestic air passenger traffic (24 per cent), total
air cargo handled (20 per cent), mobile subscriber (55 per cent), Internet subscriber (22 per
cent), and live entertainment (40 per cent). The sectors that have achieved 10-20 per cent
growth included international air passenger traffic (17.1 per cent), international air cargo (19
per cent), courier services (15 per cent), car finance (16 per cent), and film industry (17 per
cent).
3.1. Characteristics of Services:
Service is an intangible product; any product offering that is essentially intangible. The
features of services that distinguish them from tangible products; these are intangibility,
variability, inseparability and perishability.
People often try to overcome some of these difficulties by ensuring that the physical
manifestations of the service (the people running it, the library building, printed search
results, airline tags, hotel material, web pages etc) indicate the quality of the service. The
people running the service are more likely to inspire confidence in the service if they are
responsive, reliable, courteous, and competent. If the hotel lobby looks shabby and
disorganised, or if the website is difficult to navigate with broken links, then users may
assume that the services provided by the respective hotel or provider is bad.
3.2. Segmentation, Positioning and Differentiation:
265
Market segmentation is used as a strategic marketing tool for defining markets and thereby
allocating resources. Market segmentation is the act of dividing a market into distinct groups
who might be attracted to different products or services. This technique is widely accepted as
one of the requirements for successful marketing. By dividing the market into relatively
homogenous subgroups or target markets, both strategy formulation and tactical decision
making can be more effective. Market segmentation is concerned with individual or group
differences in response to specific market variables (e.g. preferences, lifestyles, media habits,
etc.). The strategic presumption is that if these response differences exist, can be identified,
and are reasonably stable over time, and if the segments can be efficiently reached, the
company may increase its market share beyond that obtained by assuming market
homogeneity. Apart from the normal market segmentation possibilities that are mentioned
earlier in this study material, one major segmentation that is needed in services is customer
segmentation. Customer segmentation is a good thing. It helps to recognize how customers
are different and it should draw the attention to needs of different segments, prompting you to
better meet those needs. Segment by need rather than profit or revenue. A low-profit
customer today could be high-profit tomorrow if you offer products and services that fill
her/his needs. Look for ways some customer segments can effectively be more "selfservice," which cuts costs for the company while meeting customer service needs. Build in
ways to create exceptions in automated customer service processes, so as not to alienate those
with special situations. If offering promotions, rewards, or other incentives to some segments
but not others, "spell it out" for customer service representatives and structure your Web site
and promotional mailings accordingly. By taking steps to assure customers receive consistent
information across all channels of communication, you avoid customers being exposed to
offers for which they do not qualify. There are ways to segment customers without lowering
customer service.
Positioning applies to all products and services. Positioning is about making products
available at the right time, to the right people, and at the right place. Thus, it is in the hands of
marketers how well they play with positioning by adopting innovative methods. It is
imperative for an organization to clearly differentiate its product or service from that of its
competitors. This enables the firm to gain sustainable competitive advantage in the market.
Positioning is the strategy by which the firm does the aforesaid endeavor. Some of the
methods include getting into the mind of consumers, avoiding overload of information to
customers, and sustaining the leadership position. There are perceptual mapping that can be
done so that the desired service can be offered to the customers. It has been used as a strategic
management tool for about thirty years now. Perceptual mapping helps to communicate the
relationship between competitors and the criteria used by your consumers while making
purchase decisions. Perceptual maps, being simple graphic figures, can pave the path for all
types of organizations.to think in strategic terms.
A study conducted by Nargundkar brings out the perceptual map of the Indian airline sector
where the respondents were A)Jet airways, B)Indian Airlines, C)Air Deccan and D)
Kingfisher in this order. The study was based on perceived service quality. This study shows
that customers of Jet Airways rate it as an airline that provides very good service quality
across the fourteen service variables. Kingfisher ranks second and its customers have
reported that usually the airline provides good service quality. Indian Airlines was rated as
266
providing good in-flight food, waiting time for baggage, good ground service,
accommodation on delay and a few other elements such as price, online booking and benefits
for frequent fliers. Indian Airlines was rated as average or below average on the rest of the
service variables. Baggage loss has been reported as a problem faced by some of the Indian
Airlines customers. Air Deccan has been rated by its customers as providing good service
quality in informing customer about delay. Air Deccan customers are happy with its
provision for online booking, discounted fare and real benefits for frequent fliers.
The
travelers of Air Deccan seem to rate it to be a bad service provider even though they were
flying on low fares. Differentiation can occur only by adding new service elements along
with providing better quality in delivering quality service which now Kingfisher and Jet
airways have started to do so.
267
268
in terms of performance with respect to position and growth with reference to total personal
deposits.
o A High performance
o B Medium Performance
o C Low performance
A set of three branches was selected at random from each groups and a sample size of nine
branches were obtained, three each from the above categories. A set of thirty customers was
interviewed at each branch by performing a systematic random sampling from these
branches. After knowing the average total number of customers per day from the branch
manager. Analysis was done by comparing the data obtained from different branches based
on the preference and opinion of the customers. A ChiSquare test for independence of
attributes was done in order to test whether the customers opinion on the rating given to the
banks is dependent on the basis of performance by the branches. The SERVQUAL scores
were determined from the responses of the customers on their perceived value against their
expectations on the various dimensions of service quality.
The findings of the study revealed three factors that make the customer continue with the
bank. They are:
o Service dependent
o Bank dependent &
o Customer dependent
More than 38% of the respondents do business with SBT due to its service quality. Here it is
found that the scores for service dependent factors are more for higher performance branches
in comparison with others. Factors that make the customers start account with other bank
includes reasons like dissatisfaction with the current services provided by SBT, and some of
the mostly told causes for this are:
o Waiting time for counter service delivery
o Confusions at the counter
o Lack of coordination between employees
o Technical difficulties in availing funds through ATMs
o Unavailability of right information due to employees lack of knowledge
The best SERVQUAL scores are attained for the dimensions of quality by branches like
Kowdiar, Medical College and Nanthencode while others are far back in the race.
Performance of the branch is dependant on its attitude towards the performance in various
dimensions of service quality. The banks have got good feedback on higher reliability while
on responsiveness, assurance, empathy as well as tangibles are not convincing to customers.
At Kowdiar, Medical College and Nanthencode the expected and personal service quality are
almost comparable while in other branches it has got much difference. The introduction of
Grahak Mitra has proved to be the right move to help the customers who are unaware about
the information regarding their transaction with the bank. In the outskirts of the district the
customers face difficulties due to the lack of knowledge and understanding of the banks
operations; Dissatisfaction level in service is higher in case of private sector employees when
compared to that of the public sectors. Public sector employees have rated the service of SBT
to be excellent and good while most of the private sector marked it to be average and
suggested for betterment. Dissatisfaction level is higher in case of youth and middle-aged
while the senior people are very well satisfied with the present service.
269
SERVQUAL in KTDC:
Understanding the changes in customer preferences and expectations of services, to deliver
service according to that is important in hotel service industry. This will help to anticipate the
competition and stay ahead in the competition. Keeping in mind these aspects, the following
objectives were set:
To understand the customer perception and expectation of service quality in
hotels of KTDC
To find out the present service quality prevailing in hotels of KTDC
To find out customer satisfaction in service rendered by the hotels of KTDC
This study is based on primary and secondary data. The primary data is collected from
100 members of the management staff of the KTDC Ltd and secondary data is collected from
the published annual reports and from other documents and from the website of the company.
The study is mainly carried out in Trivandrum (dist) and KTDC hotels at Trivandrum, Hotel
Mascot, Hotel Samudra, and Hotel Chaitram. For the study mainly primary and secondary
data were used. The Primary data was collected through questionnaire and interview method
and secondary data was collected from annual reports, brochures, and websites. In the
findings it was found that majority of respondents were professionals and businessmen. The
purpose of visit by most of the respondents in the hotel was for leisure. A good majority of
the respondents visit not only Trivandrum but other places in Kerala as well. Most of the
respondents plan to visit Kerala yearly. Majority of the respondents prefer premium hotel for
their stay. A high level of satisfaction exists among the respondents regarding the level of
services offered. The respondent rated the information availability and thanking provided as
excellent at the reception. The respondents rated the welcome, verbal introduction, nonverbal introduction and other conversations at the reception as very good. The respondents
have rated room service as excellent, food and beverages, cleanliness, overall atmosphere as
very good and room facilities as good. The respondents rated the transportation and guiding
as excellent, ticket booking, foreign exchange as very good. The majority of the respondents
are not aware whether their suggestions have been implemented or not. More than 90% of the
respondents are loyal as they would use the same hotel on their next visit and would also
recommend it to others.
Some of the suggestions put forward include provision for few separate rooms with
all the facilities, which the businessmen/professional might need to stay connected with his
business. Examples may the personal computer with broadband connection, printer, tax etc.
this is because there is a growing number of businessmen and professionals who visit Kerala.
Setup help desk at each hotel, which would provide assistance and guidance to the tourists in
planning their trip in Kerala. This could be done in co-ordination with the events organized
and places highlighted by Kerala tourism department. The main aim would be to promote the
packages of hotels of KTDC. Set up a data bank consisting of information regarding
preferences of regular customers. This would help them in providing better service to the
customers and building brand loyalty. This would translate in repeat usage of the hotel and it
getting recommended by way of word of mouth communication. The hotels should keep up
270
regular communication with the clients and keep them up to date with the new packages
being offered to sending greetings on the special occasions in the clients country, so that
KTDC remains in their minds long after their visit, with the minimum effort on the part of
KTDC in terms of cost. The front desk and the hotel staff should be provided with training
regarding customer relationship and they should be kept up to date wit the changing global
preferences trends in service since most of the clients are foreigners. Implement the changes
and show it in the service provided to the customer so that the customer feels that his
suggestions have been implemented. Provide compliments to the customers who had taken
interest in providing those suggestions. A roof top hotel could be constructed at hotel
Chaitram as was mentioned by many of the customers.
3.4. Marketing mix strategies for services:
The service marketing mix has 7Ps consists of Product, Price, Promotion, Place, People,
Physical evidence and Process. There are 3Ps in addition to the 4Ps of product keeping in
mind the characteristics of services. Let us now look at the three additional Ps:
Physical evidence is the material part of a service. Strictly speaking there are no physical
attributes to a service, so a consumer tends to rely on material cues. They are:
Building
Catalougues
Brochures
Furnishings
Signages
Pacakging
Internet web presentation
Uniforms
Process is another element of the extended marketing mix, or 7P's.There are a number of
perceptions of the concept of process within the business and marketing literature. Some see
processes as a means to achieve an outcome, for example - to achieve a 30% market share a
company implements a marketing planning process. Another view is that marketing has a
number of processes that integrate together to create an overall marketing process, for
example - telemarketing and Internet marketing can be integrated. A further view is that
marketing processes are used to control the marketing mix, i.e. processes that measure the
achievement marketing objectives. All views are understandable, but not particularly
customer focused. process is an element of service that sees the customer experiencing an
organisation's offering. It's best viewed as something that your customer participates in at
different points in time. Here are some examples to help your build a picture of marketing
process, from the customer's point of view. Going on a flight trip - from the moment that you
arrive at the airport, you are greeted; your baggage is taken to the screening. Accessibility
given to the person from restaurants and inflight shopping. Finally, at the end of the journey
the baggage is delivered to you. Here many airlines want to differentiate their offerings to
make the process successful.
People are the most important element of any service or experience. Services tend to be
produced and consumed at the same moment, and aspects of the customer experience are
altered to meet the 'individual needs' of the person consuming it. Remember, people buy
from people that they like, so the attitude, skills and appearance of all staff need to be first
271
class. Here are some ways in which people add value to an experience, as part of the
marketing mix - training, personal selling and customer service. All customer facing
personnel need to be trained and developed to maintain a high quality of personal service.
Training should begin as soon as the individual starts working for an organization during an
induction. The induction will involve the person in the organization's culture for the first
time, as well as briefing him or her on day-to-day policies and procedures. At this very early
stage the training needs of the individual are identified. A training and development plan is
constructed for the individual which sets out personal goals that can be linked into future
appraisals. In practice most training is either 'on-the-job' or 'off-the-job.' On-the-job training
involves training whilst the job is being performed e.g. training of bar staff. Off-the-job
training sees learning taking place at a college, training centre or conference facility. There
are different kinds of salesperson. There is the product delivery salesperson. His or her main
task is to deliver the product, and selling is of less importance e.g. fast food, or mail. The
second type is the order taker, and these may be either 'internal' or 'external.' The internal
sales person would take an order by telephone, e-mail or over a counter. The external sales
person would be working in the field. In both cases little selling is done. The next sort of
sales person is the missionary. Here, as with those missionaries that promote faith, the
salesperson builds goodwill with customers with the longer-term aim of generating orders.
Again, actually closing the sale is not of great importance at this early stage. The forth type is
the technical salesperson, e.g. a technical sales engineer. Their in-depth knowledge supports
them as they advise customers on the best purchase for their needs. Finally, there are creative
sellers. Creative sellers work to persuade buyers to give them an order. This is tough selling,
and tends to o ffer the biggest incentives. The skill is identifying the needs of a customer and
persuading them that they need to satisfy their previously unidentified need by giving an
order. Many products, services and experiences are supported by customer services teams.
Customer services provided expertise (e.g. on the selection of financial services), technical
support(e.g. offering advice on IT and software) and coordinate the customer interface (e.g.
controlling service engineers, or communicating with a salesman). The disposition and
attitude of such people is vitally important to a company. The way in which a complaint is
handled can mean the difference between retaining or losing a customer, or improving or
ruining a company's reputation. Today, customer service can be face-to-face, over the
telephone or using the Internet. People tend to buy from people that they like, and so effective
customer service is vital. Customer services can add value by offering customers technical
support and expertise and advice.
4. Have you understood type questions?
1. Classification of products into goods, services, and ideas is determined by the:
A.
B.
C.
D.
272
3. The appearance of the production facilities and the interpersonal skills of actual service
providers are critical in __________ services.
A. low-contact
B. equipment-based
C. industrial
D. high-contact
4. Marketers for the airline industry sometimes find it difficult to promote their product
because unused aeroplane seats cannot be stored. This problem illustrates which one of the
following unique features of services?
A. Intangibility
B. Inseparability
C. Perishability
D. Heterogeneity
5.
Summary
In the present CRM era where the customer is the decision maker, the increase in competition
has made the differentiation in product range and services of an organization more important
in any industry. Considering the fact that services are growing and are expected to be 75% of
the Indian GDP, the importance can be seen. The growth in IT and software are one of the
primary indicators. Hence organisations entering the service sector need to be competitive
and updated.
6.
Exercises
Brand D
Shares many attributes
with Brand F
More Classy
More Sporty
Is conservative
More Practical
Less Sporty
Less Classy
Is Sporty
Less Conservative
Brand E
Brand F
Brand G
Your Brand
More Conservative
More Classy
Exclusive
Less Classy
Less Practical
Less Practical
Unique
2. Explain the service quality that is needed from a retail store. Visit the nearest retailer and
explain the same.
3. Describe the need for people in services with examples from Hotel and Hospital sector.
4. Explain the relevance of marketing mix in the following aspects:
a. Courier services
273
b. Software services
c. Consultancy services
Rural marketing
1. Introduction:
Marketing of products has taken precedence over the process of production itself.
This can be attributed to the fact that the new-age consumer equipped with the potent tool of
information seeks more knowledge about the product, its features and its uses. Customer
today indeed is the "King". He can make or break the company. And when this information is
presented in a creative and effective manner, it creates an everlasting impression on the
consumer's mind and may even alter his perception of what he needs. The urban consumer
has always been pampered with the most dazzling array of goods and services from every
industry. But the urban market is fast shrinking due to saturation caused by the competition,
and the growth rate over the past few years has consistently shown a declining trend. Hence
the only option before the marketer is to tap the rural sector which can provide a large
volume for economies of scale.
2. Learning Objectives:
When you finish this unit, you should be able to:
3. Rural marketing:
The rural market comprises of 74 per cent of the country's population, 41 per cent of its
middle class, 58 per cent of its disposable income and a large consuming class. Today, real
growth is taking place in the rural-urban markets or in the 13,113 villages with a population
of more than 5,000. Of these, 9,988 villages are in seven states -- Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, West
Bengal, Maharashtra, Andhra Pradesh, Kerala and Tamil Nadu. According to the National
Council for Applied Economic Research, the millennium belongs to the Class III and IV
rural-urban towns. In order to efficiently and cost-effectively target the rural markets, the
companies will have to cover many independent retailers since in these areas, the retailer
influences purchase decisions and stock a single brand in a product category. Most of the
companies have started tinkering with pack sizes and creating new price points in order to
reach out to rural consumers since a significant portion of the rural population are daily wage
workers. Hence it becomes important to have a deeper insight into this emerging market.
274
275
agriculture revolution. This calls for strong bias in favour of raising the rural demand as
against the urban demand.
The hurdles in the rural marketing are:
1. High distribution costs
2. High initial market development expenditure
3. Inability of the small retailer to carry stock without adequate credit facility
4. Generating effective demand for manufactured foods
5. Wholesale and dealer network problems
6. Mass communication and promotion problems
7. Banking and credit problems
8. Management and sales managing problems
9. Market research problems
10. Inadequate infrastructure facilities (lack of physical distribution, roads warehouses
and media availability)
11. Highly dispersed and thinly populated markets
12. Low per capita and poor standards of living, social, economic and cultural
backwardness of the rural masses
13. Low level of exposure to different product categories and product brands
14. Cultural gap between urban-based marketers and rural consumers
In a nutshell the rural market profile is large and scattered in the sense that it consists of over
63 Crore consumers from 5, 70,000 villages spread throughout the country.
Nearly 60 % of the rural income is from agriculture. Hence rural prosperity is tied with
agricultural prosperity. Consumer in the village area do have a low standard of living because
of low literacy, low per capita income, social backwardness, low savings, etc.
The rural consumer values old customs and tradition. They do not prefer changes. Rural
consumers have diverse socio-economic backwardness. This is different in different parts of
the country. The Infrastructure Facilities like roads, warehouses, communication system, and
financial facilities are inadequate in rural areas. Hence physical distribution becomes costly
due to inadequate Infrastructure facilities.
276
much advertising support. Chik shampoo, second largest shampoo brand. Ghadi detergent,
third largest brand. Both of them have had concerted effort in the north Indian rural market
and have benefited. The gap between the urban and rural spend is huge. Though there is no
authenticated figure, it is found that rural marketing currently must be accounting for only Rs.
5 billion out of a total estimated advertising budget of over Rs. 100 billion a year. There is a
vast difference in the lifestyles of the people. The kind of choices of brands that an urban
customer enjoys is different from the choices available to the rural customer. The rural
customer usually has 2 or 3 brands to choose from whereas the urban one has multiple
choices. The difference is also in the way of thinking. The rural customer has a fairly simple
thinking as compared to the urban counterpart. With low disposable incomes, products need
to be affordable to the rural consumer, most of whom are on daily wages.
Some companies have addressed the affordability problem by introducing small unit packs.
Godrej introduced three brands of Cinthol, Fair Glow and Godrej in 50-gm packs, priced at
Rs 4-5 meant specifically for Madhya Pradesh, Bihar and Uttar Pradesh - the so-called
`Bimaru' States. Hindustan Lever, among the first MNCs to realise the potential of India's
rural market, has launched a variant of its largest selling soap brand, Lifebuoy at Rs 2 for 50
gm. The move is mainly targeted at the rural market. Coca-Cola has addressed the
affordability issue by introducing the returnable 200-ml glass bottle priced at Rs 5. The
initiative has paid off: Eighty per cent of new drinkers now come from the rural markets.
Coca-Cola has also introduced Sunfill, a powdered soft-drink concentrate. The instant and
ready-to-mix Sunfill is available in a single-serve sachet of 25 gm priced at Rs 2 and
multiserve sachet of 200 gm priced at Rs 15. The rural consumer is more of price oriented
and also has high level of patronage motive.
3.3. Strategies for Rural Marketing
Traditional methods of rural marketing make an interesting study and they ought to be
analyzed carefully to draw relevant conclusions. Conventionally, marketers have used the
following tools to make rural inroads:
Use of few select rural distributors and retailers to stock their goods but no direct
interaction with prospective consumer.
Use of print media or radio but no alternate form of advertising for promoting their
brands.
More focus on price of product but less attention devoted to quality or durability.
Same product features for urban and rural setting with no customization for rural
areas despite differences in the market environment.
Low frequency of marketing campaigns.
Little uses of village congregations like haats and melas to sell the products.
More focus on men as decision makers and buyers.
The past practices of treating rural markets as appendages of the urban market is not correct,
since rural markets have their own independent existence, and if cultivated well could turn
into a generator of profit for the marketers. But the rural markets can be exploited by
realizing them, rather than treating them as convenient extensions of the urban market.
Considering the magnitude of the task at hand with the companies, it makes sense for noncompetitive companies like HLL and LG to make a joint effort to penetrate the market. They
277
can use each other's distribution channels to leverage their brands. Also considering the poor
awareness levels of the people, competitors like HLL and P&G should join hands to avoid the
product proliferation, which results in confusing the consumer. Rural consumers have a very
high level of ethos so all the care should be taken not to hurt them in any form of advertising.
Moreover, every effort should be made by the companies to promote the "my brand" feel in
the minds of consumers. This can be achieved by connecting the local industries of that place
and, if possible, use it in packaging or graphics of the product.
Marketers need to understand the psyche of the rural consumers and then act accordingly.
Rural marketing involves more intensive personal selling efforts compared to urban
marketing. Firms should refrain from designing goods for the urban markets and
subsequently pushing them in the rural areas. To effectively tap the rural market, a brand
must associate it with the same things the rural folks do. This can be done by utilizing the
various rural folk media to reach them in their own language and in large numbers so that the
brand can be associated with the myriad rituals, celebrations, festivals, "melas", and other
activities where they assemble. One of the ways could be using company delivery van which
can serve two purposes - it can take the products to the customers in every nook and corner of
the market, and it also enables the firm to establish direct contact with them, and thereby
facilitate sales promotion. However, only the bigwigs can adopt this channel. The companies
with relatively fewer resources can go in for syndicated distribution where a tie-up between
non-competitive marketers can be established to facilitate distribution. Annual "melas"
organized are quite popular and provide a very good platform for distribution because people
visit them to make several purchases. According to the Indian Market Research Bureau,
around 8000 such melas are held in rural India every year. Rural markets have the practice of
fixing specific days in a week as Market Days (often called "Haats') when exchange of goods
and services are carried out. This is another potential low cost distribution channel available
to the marketers. Also, every region consisting of several villages is generally served by one
satellite town (termed as "Mandis" or Agri-markets) where people prefer to go to buy their
durable commodities. If marketing managers use these feeder towns, they will easily be able
to cover a large section of the rural population. Firms must be very careful in choosing the
vehicle to be used for communication. Only 16% of the rural population has access to a
vernacular newspaper. So, the audio visuals must be planned to convey a right message to the
rural folk. The rich, traditional media forms like folk dances, puppet shows, etc., with which
the rural consumers are familiar and comfortable, can be used for high impact product
campaigns.
3.4. Rural retailing:
The Indian rural market with its vast size and demand base offers a huge opportunity that
MNCs cannot afford to ignore. With 128 million households, the rural population is nearly
three times the urban. The rural market accounts for half the total market for TV sets, fans,
pressure cookers, bicycles, washing soap, blades, tea, salt and toothpowder, What is more, the
rural market for FMCG products is growing much faster than the urban counterpart. This is
where rural retailing really takes off. Study on buying behaviour of rural consumer indicates
that the rural retailers influences 35% of purchase decisions. Therefore sheer product
availability can affect decision of brand choice, volumes and market share. India offers a
huge, sustainable and growing rural market which can be tapped effectively through
innovative distribution channels with retailing being the most critical element of this strategy
278
as it is the final touch point and the actual touch point with the customer which can be the
most critical influence in the buying process. From the time HLL's new distribution model,
named Project Shakti, was piloted in Nalgonda district in 2001, it has been scaled up and
extended to over 5,000 villages in 52 districts in AP, Karnataka, Gujarat and Madhya Pradesh
with around 1,000 women entrepreneurs in its fold. The vision is ambitious: to create by 2010
about 11,000 Shakti entrepreneurs covering one lakh villages and touching the lives of 100
million rural consumers. HLL has operated Project Shakti through these self-help groups; AP
was chosen for the pilot project as its has the most number and better established SHGs there are about 4.36 lakh SHGs in AP covering nearly 58.29 lakh rural women. The Shakti
model trains women from SHGs to distribute HLL products of daily consumption such as
detergents, toilet soaps and shampoos - the latter's penetration being only 30 per cent in rural
areas. The women avail of micro-credit through banks. Mr Sehgal explained that some of the
established Shakti dealers are now selling Rs 10,000-Rs15,000 worth of products a month
and making a gross profit of Rs 700-Rs1,000 a month. Each Shakti dealer covers 6-10
villages which have a population of less 2,000. The company is creating demand for its
products by having its Shakti dealers educating consumers on aspects like health and hygiene.
Similarly ITC has already set up over 700 choupals covering 3,800 villages in four States
which include Madhya Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh, Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh dealing
with products ranging from soya bean, coffee, aquaculture and wheat.
Now there is re-emergence of mandis in the form of portals or virtual bazaars like that EID
Parry, Amul and ITC e-choupals etc. After all, the concept of mandis cannot be written off
that easily. They have evolved over a period of time and have lasted for several centuries.
They lost their prominence temporarily due to the brand marketing strategies adopted by
companies. The basic problem with brand marketing is its high cost. Mandis offer a costeffective method of marketing. With the virtual mandis the cost saving is still better. Consider
for example the case of marketing farm inputs like fertilisers, seeds and pesticides. In the
brand marketing approach, the same information is provided by several marketers through
different media and methods. In the virtual mandis, several people can join hands and provide
best possible information in a most cost effective manner to the farmers.
3.5. Rural marketing initiatives:
1. Escorts did not rely on TV or press advertisements, but rather concentrated on focused
approach depending on geographical and market parameters like fares, melas, etc.
Looking at the 'kuchha' roads of village, they positioned their bike as tough vehicle. Their
advertisements showed Dharmendra riding Escort with the punch line 'Jandar Sawari,
Shandar Sawari'. Thus, they achieved whopping sales of 95000 vehicles annually.
2. HLL started 'Operation Bharat' to tap the rural markets. Under this operation, it passed
out low-priced sample packets of its toothpaste, fairness cream, Clinic plus shampoo, and
Ponds cream to twenty million households.
3. ITC is setting up e-Choupals, which offers the farmers all the information, products and
services they need to enhance farm productivity, improve farm-gate price realization and
cut transaction costs. Farmers can access latest local and global information on weather,
scientific farming practices as well as market prices at the village itself through this web
portal - all in Hindi. It also facilitates supply of high quality farm inputs as well as
purchase of commodities at their doorstep.
279
4. BPCL introduced Rural Marketing Vehicle (RMV) as their strategy for rural marketing. It
moves from village to village and fills cylinders on the spot for the rural customers.
BPCL considered low-income of rural population, and therefore introduced a smaller size
cylinder to reduce both the initial deposit cost as well as the recurring refill cost.
4.
Summary
According to the United Nations, the richest 20 percent in the world accounted for about 70
percent of total income in 1960. In 2000, that figure reached 85 percent. Over the same
period, the fraction of income accruing to the poorest 20 percent in the world fell from 2.3
percent to 1.1 percent. According to CK Prahlad, contrary to popular assumptions, the poor
can be a very profitable market especially if MNCs change their business models.
Specifically, Tier 4 is not a market that allows for the traditional pursuit of high margins;
instead, profits are driven by volume and capital efficiency. Margins are likely to be low (by
current norms), but unit sales can be extremely high. Managers who focus on gross margins
will miss the opportunity at the bottom of the pyramid; managers who innovate and focus on
economic profit will be rewarded. Considering the discussions mentioned above, it is
imperative that marketers start realizing the need for giving attention to the rural markets.
Thus, looking at the challenges and the opportunities, which rural markets offer to the
marketers, it can be said that the future is very promising for those who can understand the
dynamics of rural markets and exploit them to their best advantage. A radical change in
attitudes of marketers towards the vibrant and burgeoning rural markets is called for, so they
280
can successfully impress on the 230 million rural consumers spread over approximately six
hundred thousand villages in rural India.
6
Marketing Research
1. Introduction:
Managers need to exceed the expectations of the various stake holders in business
such as shareholders, suppliers, employees, customers, government, general public etc.. And
it is very evident that these different groups of stake holders possess conflicting interests. So
the ability to build and maintain mutually beneficial long term relationship with customers
and suppliers, the skill to adhere to government rules and regulations, the capacity to the
uphold the shareholders expectation, and the task of securing appreciation from the general
public, all are the performance indicators of the present day business. The turbulent
environment forces further makes it a tough sail. The ability to get adapted to the complex
and every changing environment is crucial in this Darwinian economy, which ensure the
survival of only the fittest. The much demanding system never allows a manager to consider
information as a bureaucratic nuisance like in the yesteryears. Today, managers, irrespective
of their position consider information as a strategic weapon. The major aim of applied
research is to find out a solution for a practical problem where as basic research is aimed at
contributing towards the organized body of scientific knowledge. Descriptive or Ex post facts
research is characterised by the fact that the research can only report what has happened or
what is happening. In analytical research, the researcher has to use facts or information
already available and analyse these to make logical conclusions. Quantitative research is
concerned with the measurement of quantity or amount. It involves the generation of data in
quantitative form and various analysis using mathematical tools. Qualitative research is
important in behavioural sciences. Conceptual research is related to theory. It is used by
thinkers to develop new concepts or reinterpret existing ones. Empirical research relies on
experience or observation. It is also called experimental type of research. In marketing the
following are normally taken up for research:
a.
Consumer behaviour, loyalty
b.
Product positioning, product development, product life cycle
c.
Branding, brand equity
d.
Market segmentation & targeting
e.
Advertising, sales promotion
f.
Sales and distribution etc.
2. Learning Objectives:
When you finish this unit, you should be able to:
281
3. Marketing research
The Oxford Encyclopedia English Dictionary gives the meaning of research as the
systematic investigation into the study of materials, sources etc., in order to establish facts
and reach new conclusion. In other words, research is simply the process of finding solutions
to a problem after a detailed study and analysis of the situational factors. So it is about
finding the truth with the help of study, observation, comparison and experiment.
3.1. Marketing research process:
The research process consists of a series of activities. The activities in the research process
are closely related and they overlap continuously rather than following the sequence
presented. A problem well defined is half solved. Research also is not an exception to this
dictum from the dateless past. Problem identification and formulation is a crucial part in the
research process. A research problem is one which requires a researcher to find out the best
possible solution from among to find out a best possible solution from among the alternatives
available. In order to select the best alternative, researcher has to find out and evaluate the
alternatives available. Also he as to identify the various environmental factors which have a
bearing on the problem at hand. For example, company X is worried about the high sales
force turn over they experience and you are assigned to undertake a research on that. Here
you have to identify the reasons for the high attrition rate. Also you need to identify various
alternative courses of action to deal with the problem at hand which may be like increasing
the perks, ensuring better working environment, imparting proper Training and Development
programmes etc. Then you have to evaluate these alternatives and suggest the appropriate one
or may be a combination of these. Also inorder to reach a decision, the researcher has to
consider the environment to which the problem pertains ie., the general industry environment,
competitors strategy etc. The research problem for the study must be carefully selected and is
not an easy task Defining a research problem properly and clearly is a herculean task. It is a
task that must be accomplished intelligently, not hurriedly. Identification of the broad
problem area through developing an intimacy with the general situation and the problem at
hand is the starting point. Then the problem is stated in a general way. The best way to
understand the problem is to discuss it with people having some expertise in the subject. A
preliminary literature review concerned with the conceptual as well as empirical aspects of
the issue is also useful. This helps the researcher to refine and rephrase the problem. So
essentially there are the following steps involved in defining the research problem. At this
stage, the researcher makes an attempt to state the problem in a loose, general way. In no way
it may be holistic as the researcher address only some of the concerns at this stage. A relook
at the aspects covered in the general statement of the problem is done after seeking the
opinion of the experienced people. Also it is required to keep in view the environment within
which the problem is to be studied. A preliminary literature review is recommended at this
stage. This enable the researcher to get a better understanding of the conceptual and empirical
aspect of the problem. This also sheds some light on the data and the materials available for
the study as well as the techniques that might be used. Referring the studies done on the
similar or related topics will also be useful. When doing primary research, there are three
282
basic avenues you can apply. First is using direct mails. The tactics include brief and direct
questions, direct addressee of the respondents, limited pages of questionnaires, attached
professional cover letter explaining the survey, and enclosed reminder to respond. The
drawback can be lower mail responses from the respondents. The second is using phone
surveys. This is more cost-effective compared to direct mails in terms of response rates.
Phone interviews also allow a wider geographical range. It is also relatively inexpensive by
using the cheaper rates at specified hours. The tactics include direct respondents confirmation
upon contacts, constant flow of conversation, follow-up calls, and direct relay of information.
The third is personal interviews. It can either be a group survey or a depth interview. Group
survey is mostly used by big businesses as a brainstorming tool to obtain information on new
products and product modifications. Depth interviews are done with a ready made checklist.
The secondary sources can be: Public sources such as public libraries, business departments,
and governmental departments. This is the most cost-effective way of finding information. It
can be sometimes provided as free with lots of better information to offer. Commercial
sources such as trade and research associations, financial institutions, corporations being
traded publicly, and banks. This can be costly since association fees and subscription fees are
involved. However, it will cost less if you hired a team to research and collect the information
for you. Educational sources is sometimes overlooked. However, more research is conducted
in polytechnic institutes, colleges, and universities compared to a business sector in the
community.
A hypothesis is a predictive statement capable of being tested by scientific methods.
Development of working hypothesis plays an important role in research because it help the
researcher to limit the area of research on the relevant variables. It sharpens the thinking of
the researcher and help to focus attention on the important aspects of the problem. Also it
sheds light on the type of the data required as well as the method of data analysis to be used.
A detailed thinking about the subject, a fruitful literature review and consultation with
experts, all result in the formulation of working hypothesis. The hypothesis must posses the
following characteristics.
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
v.
vi.
vii.
viii.
Eg:
Sales force who have training show greater productivity than the employees who do
not receive training.
A null hypothesis (H0) is the hypothesis we are trying to reject. Alternative hypothesis
(Ha) represents all other possibilities. For example, if we are comparing two employees A
and B about their productivity and if we make the assumption that both are equally good, it is
called as null hypothesis. All the other possibilities ie, A is better them B or B is better than
A, are termed as alternatives hypothesis. A decision rules is made for the acceptance or
rejection a hypothesis. For example, if you have to take a decision on the acceptance or
283
rejection of a lot of goods. The null hypothesis (H0) is that the lot is good and the alternative
hypothesis is that it is not good. Here the decision rule is that we might test 10 items from the
lot and if there are none or only one defective item, we will accept H0, otherwise we will
reject H0 ie, accept Ha.
A research design is the structures with which the research is conducted. It deals with
the collection, measurement and analysis of the data. It is the decision regarding what, where,
when and how much concerning the research. A research design consists of the following
parts
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
The sampling design which deals with the method of selecting items.
The observation design which deals with the conditions under which
observations are made.
The statistical design concerned with the methods of data analysis, and
The operational design which deals with the techniques by the procedures
specified for the above can be carried out.
So a research design contains (a) Statement of the research problem; (b) Procedure and
techniques to be used for data collection. (c) The population to be studied and (d) Methods to
be used for processing and analyzing data. The entire group of study is called the population.
These may be people, organisations, geographical areas, products etc. If the entire population
is investigated, it is a census. Normally, it is not possible to study the entire population. So
the researcher, quite often, select only a few items from the universe for the study. The items
so selected are called a sample. The problem of sampling is to ensure that the sample is fair
representation of the underlying population. So the researcher has to select an appropriate
sampling method which answers two questions:
(a)
(b)
So we can say that a sample design is a definite plan determined before the data are
actually collected. Sampling can be either probability sampling or non-probability sampling.
With probability sampling, each element of the population has a known probability of being
included in the sample whereas the non-probability samples, do not provide equal probability
for all the elements to be studied. For example, researcher undertake a study to evaluate the
effectiveness of the sales training programme undertaken by a company. If the number of
participants of the programme are 500 that constitute the population. For practical reasons,
the researcher decides to study only 50 participants and then to generalise the results. So in
this study 50 is the sample size. If all the 500 participants have equal chance of being studied,
it is probability sampling and if it is otherwise, it is a non-probability sampling method.
Raw data does not make any sense and only when it is analysed, we get information, which is
meaningful. Before anlaysis, the raw data is processed to ensure that we have all the relevant
data. Processing implies four activities:
Editing
Coding
Classification and
284
Tabulation
The process of examining the raw data to detect errors and omissions and to correct
these when possible is called Editing. Coding is the process of assigning numerals or other
symbols to the data in order to put them in limited number of categories. Putting larger
volume of data into homogenous groups is termed as classification. The tabulation deals with
the process of summarising raw data and displaying the same in correct form for further
analysis. Analysis work after tabulation is based on the computation of various percentages,
coefficiencies, etc. by applying appropriate statistical tools and techniques. The data analysis
provides the researcher some logical insights into the problem at hand and enable him arrive
at generalisation, i.e., to built a theory. The effort undertaken by the researcher to explain his
findings is known as interpretation. The process of interpretation quite often trigger off new
questions and thus saw the seeds for further researches. It is important that the results of the
study are properly presented and communicated. Otherwise, all the efforts hitherto
undertaken by the researcher would be in vain. So writing a report and making an oral
presentation on the same is of extreme importance.
3.2. Marketing research Analysis:
There are many analytical tools used in marketing research. SPSS is the software which is
used effectively for analysing the tabulated data. Apart from SPSS, there are few other
packages like SSP are used for the analysis. Multivariate techniques are those that involve
more than variables at the same time. They can be categorised into essentially three broad
areas which depend on the nature of the variables examined and their relationship with each
other. The categories are based on certain questions being posed when designing surveys for
primary data and analysing primary and secondary data. In Marketing Analysis multivariate
techniques are employed for a variety of reasons i.e. establishing relationships between
variables in order to explain and/or predict examination and analyses of differences in groups
or populations. The various approaches are:
Multiple Regression Analysis which examines the relationship between at least two interval
scaled independent variables and one interval scaled dependent variable. It differs from
regression analysis, which is bivariate (involving one dependent and one independent
variable). Multivariate Correlation which is an extension of simple correlation analysis, to the
situations involving two or more independent variables and their degrees of assocation with
the independent variable. There are two coefficients used: The coefficient of multiple
correlation, R which indicates the strength of relationship between two or more independent
variables and the dependent variable. Also the coefficient of multiple determination, R 2. This
is similar to the coefficient of determination, it indicates the proportion of variance in the
dependent variable which is statistically accounted for by knowledge of the two (or more)
independent variables. Conjoint analysis is a commonly used tool in market research. It
enables manufacturers, for example, to find which features of a product will have most appeal
to potential customers, or conversely, which features are regarded as least important. One
consequence of this is that it is possible to trade-off factors against each other, to keep costs
within acceptable limits, and also to position a product within the market place.
Cluster Analysis can help us to identify groups of people. The idea is quite simple, and is
based upon the idea of drawing a graph of particular peoples scores, known as factor scores,
285
looking at them, and noticing where there are clusters of people, that is, a lot of people with
similar scores on the factors. Computer packages allow us a variety of options in this
procedure, in a later case example we will concentrate on trying to find easily identifiable
groups. We can actually record peoples group membership allocation in the data file, too, so
you can observe this, and see how useful it becomes. The key piece of output, however, is the
dendogram, which helps us to identify the number of groups that may be useful to us.
Perceptual mapping is concerned with describing the consumers perceptions of objects on
one or a series of spatial maps, in order that the relationship(s) between objects can be easily
seen. These methods can:
identify the number of dimensions that consumers use to distinguish objects;
determine a preferred location of an object on each of the dimensions;
provide information on the nature and characteristics of these dimensions.
These approaches require respondents or observers to evaluate a set of objects on a large
number of attributes. This usually requires ranking the objects on scales such as Likert or
semantic differential. The following describes three of these approaches:
There may be few or many linked variables in a data set as a result of these marketing
analysts try to group responses from tests into basic clusters. This technique is known as
factor analysis and can be used in conjunction with other techniques, such as cluster analysis.
The analysis is usually undertaken on responses to a questionnaire. It is used to reduce the
questionnaire to those questions that are really measuring different attitudes or traits of the
respondent. The starting point of the analysis is to obtain a matrix of the correlations between
variables, gained from answers to questions. The analysis identifies patterns from
correlations. It does not indicate variable dependence directly but offer guidance for the
analyst in what patterns predominate. Discriminant analysis seeks to generate
dimensions
that will separate objects as much as possible. The procedure for this is analogous to factor
analysis. Like multiple regression analysis, this
technique has one dependent variable
and a set of independent variables. Based on measurements for the independent variables,
discriminant analysis can be used to classify people or objects into one of two or more
groups. Both factor and discriminant analysis require that attribute evaluations be interval
data. Correspondence analysis allows the creation of visual perceptual maps using categorical
data as well as mixed data sets (nominal, ordinal, and/or interval).
3.3. Marketing research methods:
3.3.1. Demand measurement research:
The major concepts in demand measurement are:
Market demand
Company demand
Market demand for a product is the total volume that would be bought by a defined customer
group in a defined geographical area in a defined period of time in a defined marketing
environment under a defined marketing programme. Company demand is the companys
estimated share of market demand at alternative levels of company marketing effort. One
major reason for undertaking marketing research is to identify market opportunities. Once the
286
research is complete, the company must measure and forecast the size, growth, and profit
potential of each market opportunity. Sales forecasts are used by finance to raise the needed
cash for investment and operations; by the manufacturing department to establish capacity
and output levels; by purchasing to acquire the right amount of supplies; and by human
resources to hire the needed number of workers. Marketing is responsible for preparing the
sales forecasts. If its forecast is far off the mark, the company will be saddled with excess
inventory or have inadequate inventory. Sales forecasts are based on estimates of demand.
Managers need to define what they mean by market demand. Companies can prepare as many
as 90 different types of demand estimates. Demand can be measured for six different product
levels, five different space levels, and three different time levels. Each demand measure
serves a specific purpose. A company might forecast short run demand for a particular
product for the purpose of ordering raw materials, planning production, and borrowing cash.
It might forecast regional demand for its major product line to decide whether to set up
regional distribution.
The growth of the market for consumer electronics might be more predictable.
Consider colour TVs (CTVs). These sold 4.4 million units in 1999-2000. The market should
sell some 10.5 million CTV sets in 2004-05 (with a 500,000 units margin of error). Prices
have been descending in the past five years, even as the entertainment arena bustles with the
launch of more and more satellite-TV channels. Now, with import barriers set to fall further,
the action could get even more breathtaking. Unlike PCs, however, the market is closer to
maturity amongst the middle class. The competition in this market is likely to be immense,
and its still not obvious whether todays market leaders will remain so five years ahead (the
1980s, remember, had a completely different set of leaders than the 1990s). As
commodification grows, price will become a major selling point. Meanwhile, the replacement
market is likely to grow further - even as the low-end booms. In fact, some analysts feel that
top-end and low-end brands will coexist. The drop in excise duty on picture tubes has helped
the lower-end perk up.
Using Delphi technique, some analysts expect the TV to become an Internet-access
device, thus setting the screen for convergence. But will the TV merge with the PC?
Unlikely, given that most people remain in different mental frames while surfing the Web
and watching the idiot box. Actually, this market, like with PCs, has too many
imponderables. Lots might depend on what happens to software content (will it converge?).
Meanwhile, the Indian market for washing machines is expected to grow at 15 per cent
CAGR to reach 3.5 million units. Most of the growth is expected to come from the semiautomatic segment, though fully automatic machines could account for most of the value
growth. The markets for microwave ovens and dishwashers might also start selling in
reasonable volumes, given the requisite marketing efforts, of course.
The market for refrigerators, is now expected to reach 7.5 million by 2004-05, at a CAGR of
12 per cent. Excise structures, if rationalized, could raise growth in the entry-level segment.
Meanwhile, this category is ripe for a wave of replacement, for which marketers are already
geared. Refrigerators with 300-litre capacity and above are likely to grow faster than the rest
of the market. If Indian food habits start to change, demand for greater freezer capacity might
also grow. The market for air-conditioners (ACs) is also prominent among those that have
failed to reach the expected figure for 1999-2000. A likely reason could be excise duties. The
fact is that this product is still treated as a luxury by the Government, and ACs are
287
outrageously priced in India (because of high duties). Assembled ACs, put together by corner
shops that pay no duties, are thriving - much to the dismay of the organized sector.
Wristwatches are a market that is not growing quite as well as it should - formally.
The market was pegged at 38 million units in 1999-2000, less than half the expected figure.
At a CAGR of just under 12 per cent, the market could touch the 50-million-units mark by
2004-05. Of late, the market has seen a sudden rush of top-end activity. At the lower end,
assembled and smuggled watches thrive. The prize for the most thrilling performance over
the past five years goes to the market for personal computers (PCs), which has been booming
all through this period (CAGR: 36 per cent), regardless of the ups and downs of other
markets. This is heartening news, for this product is an input for future economic growth. The
Indian PC market in 1999-2000 stood at just over 1.2 million units (missing expectations by
nearly 200,000 units). At an expected CAGR of 25 per cent, the market should hit 4.0 million
units in 2004-05. But then, the prices have been falling sharply over the years. If duties are
reduced to nothing - as an incentive - the current rate could hold up. Also, Internet
penetration is projected to take a hockey-curve upwards - and PCs might just remain the
primary access device (other gizmos are still to catch on). Yet, sustaining a 36-per cent rate
might not be possible. Since the PC is part of the convergence sector, projections are hard to
make. Demand for consumer electronic products is highly seasonal and cyclical. The demand
for such products reaches a high during the festive season and when the national economy is
enjoying a boom. Thus, 2000 AD is expected to witness a boom in TV sales, as it is an
Olympic year. Manufacture of CTVs registered a growth of 42% during the first quarter of
FY2000 while audio products registered an increase of 26%. However, supply continues to
outstrip demand as a result of which prices continue to fall. In terms of volume, buyers
upgrading from B&W sets represent 65% of the TV market. The upcoming rural market
represents 19% of CTV sales and 39% of B&W TV sales.
Price range for consumer electronics products has increased many times over the
years. This enables manufacturers to focus on niche markets or specific market segments.
India imports a relatively higher proportion of video and audio equipment.
The current market trends in consumer electronics industry include:
Fierce competition resulting in price wars;
An array of modern designs and updated technology;
Players focusing on product differentiation, value addition and
exchange offers; and
Manufacturers emphasising on altering consumer psyche, sub-branding
products.
The main demand drivers for consumer electronics products in the future include the
following:
Growth in per capita income, disposable income of households and
growth in entertainment sector;
Increasing consumerism, changing aspirations and higher affordability
will drive demand further; and
Product penetration currently low - immense potential exists in smaller
towns and rural markets.
288
289
special attention in failure prevention. What went wrong with product X? Was there
something that the manufacturer/designer should have foreseen that would have avoided the
failure? Should the manufacturer have discovered that failure was inevitable and abandoned
the product, not spending any more money on it?
3.3.3. Advertising research:
Every year companies spend huge sums of money creating advertisements and buying
media time and space. They hope that these marketing communication efforts and
expenditures would benefit their businesses by influencing consumer choices. Too much of
money is at risk unless advertisers have very good information about who their customers
are, what they want and where they spend their media time. Research is needed to furnish the
information that drives marketing and advertising decision making. Without reliable
information, in today's highly competitive market conditions, use of guesswork or intuition
alone may prove to be failure. Advertising research is a subset of marketing research. It
systematically gathers and analyses information to help develop or evaluate advertising
strategies, individual advertisements, or whole advertising campaigns. Advertiser needs to
know how consumers perceive its products or services, what their views about the
competition are and what image of the brand or the company would be most appropriate to
build.
Advertising research is required to serve a number of purposes, which can be grouped into
four categories :
- Advertising strategy research is used to determine product positioning to assist in
the selection of the target markets, advertising messages, or media vehicles.
- Creative concept research is used to assess the extent of target audience's
acceptance of different creative ideas at the concept development stage
- Pre-testing of advertisement is done to diagnose any possible communication
problems before beginning an advertising campaign.
- Post-testing of advertisements helps advertisers to evaluate the campaign results.
3.3.3.1.Advertising Strategy Research
290
customers can be classified as primary users of the product category and carefully study the
geographic, demographic, psychographic and behavioural characteristics. The research may
reveal which are the most potential market segments and target those to achieve advertising
objectives. This is particularly true while introducing a new product. Companies may have
budget constraints and may prefer to launch the product in a phased manner instead of
attacking all geographic areas at the same time.
Communications Media Research helps develop media strategies and select media
vehicles from among different media class and type (TV, newspapers, magazines, radio
outdoor, etc.). Advertising agencies subscribe to syndicated research services that monitor
and publish information on the reach, audience profiles and effectiveness of different media
vehicles. Advertisers undertake research to study and identify what consumers' likes and
dislikes are with respect to brands and products and hope to find the big idea and develop
promising advertising messages. Researchers use concept testing to determine which
message-element options are most likely to prove successful.
3.3.3.2. Creative Concept Research
Creative specialists prepare several tentative advertising concepts in the form of rough
copy platform or the storyboard. Researchers conduct focus group discussions in the agency's
developmental lab which combines intensive qualitative interviews with quantitative
techniques. A discussion leader moderates the conversation and each group views the roughs
(copy platform, Storyboard or animatic). The reactions of these groups are measured,
videotaped and observed by researchers behind a one-way mirror. This helps in identifying
the most promising creative concept among the ones that have been seen and discussed by the
focus groups.
3.3.3.3. Pre-testing and Post-testing
Advertisers use pre-tests and post-tests to ensure that the advertising money is used wisely to
achieve predetermined objectives. Testing can help in judging the effectiveness of advertising
strategy or medium. Pre-testing is used to increase the likelihood of creating the most
effective advertising messages. This helps in spotting any communication gaps or flaws in the
message content before the account executive recommends it to the client. Advertisers are
often interested in concurrent testing to assess the audience response while the advertisement
campaign is under way. Post-testing (also called advertisement tracking) is important to
evaluate the success or otherwise of an individual advertisement or the whole campaign after
it has run.
3.3.4. Customer satisfaction research:
Market researchers, ad agencies and many others have been trying to figure out what
consumers want since the opening of the first store. Valuable as traditional qualitative
techniques such as focus groups and in-depth interviews are, there is another way to study
consumer Behaviour that can get at otherwise unobtainable truths. On-site observation, or
research by watching people, gives researchers the chance to observe and learn about
consumer purchasing decisions as they are being made. This is most effective if done in a
supermarket situation where consumers can walk around and decide on their purchases. The
best approach is for the researcher or manager or whoever, to be in, say, a supermarket at that
moment and present himself or herself as a shopper who needs advice for making a decision.
291
The consumer identifies the researcher as someone who deserves assistance, and no long
introductions are required. If the trained researcher asks the right questions about the product,
the answers will come naturally. Shoppers tell about prices, taste, quality, health, ingredients,
packaging and so on just what researchers want to know. Moreover, unlike focus groups,
consumers will tell spontaneously without feeling that they must give an acceptable response
because they are being paid or because they like to show off. Nor will there be any problems
with their recall about a product or how often they have really used it. Finally, if an interview
is unproductive, moving on is easy. Just take your shopping cart and approach someone else.
A skilled researcher can do about 35 interviews a day in several supermarkets with
minimal overhead costs, an excellent yield for qualitative work. Of course, when it comes to
testing a new product, exploring certain concepts in depth and having members of a group
bounce ideas off each other, there is no substitute for focus groups. But on-site observation
has many benefits and should be used far more often. Doing so, however, is not that easy.
This type of research requires intensive training in interviewing and observational techniques.
The researcher only has about three seconds in which to make eye contact, introduce him and
pop the question that will determine receptiveness. He must know, by sizing up the shopper
according to dress, demeanor, contents of their cart, the neighborhood the store is in, age,
gender etc. The marketing scenario has changed today with an increasing emphasis on
customer delight rather than just customer satisfaction. Today, companies need to put in
additional effort to learn the likes/dislikes of their customers. In an age where product
differentiation is tending to zero and brand promiscuity is a marketer's recurring nightmare, it
is the customer's relationship with the brand that is becoming increasingly important.
Companies are looking at ways and means of entering into a regular dialogue with their
customers, to build this ever-so-important relationship. An effective customer satisfaction
survey program should focus on measuring customer perceptions of how well the company
delivers on the critical success factors and dimensions of the business. These usually include
factors like service promptness, staff responsiveness, and understanding of the customer's
problem.
The American Association for Advertising Agencies has suggested that the advertiser ask
the following questions when considering a magazine buy:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
Does the magazine reach the type of reader to whom expected to reach?
How does distribution of circulation compare with the product distribution?
What is the cost of reaching the thousand prospects?
How do readers regard the magazine?
Will the advertisement be in acceptable association?
How co-operative is the publisher in giving good position?
How important are merchandising aids, availability of aids?
How do other magazines compare with the said one on the above comparing
points?
292
employers, and individual Canadians to improve workplace safety and health.[1] CCOHS
fulfils this mandate through a portfolio of free and priced products and services that draw
upon a core collection of occupational safety and health information and the application of
information management technologies. The key products and services offered by the Centre
are the free Inquiries Service and web site and information products and services for which it
charges.
CCOHS wished to conduct a customer satisfaction survey of users of its Inquiries service,
and subscribers to and users of its other products and services. The survey was designed to:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
In addition, CCOHS also wished to conduct a survey of visitors to their extensive web site.
The use of a web-based survey provided a self-completion mode with added flexibility of
delivery: skip patterns are opaque to the respondent, as they are in a computerized telephone
survey. In addition, a web survey is considered ideal for business users in that it provides for
swift response and any-time-anywhere completion
Two surveys were conducted as part of this assignment.
Web-site visitor survey: A pop-up survey of 603 visitors to the CCOHS/CCHST web site.
The survey was available from February 13 to March 9, 2004. It should be kept in mind that
this is a self-selecting sample.
Customer survey: An invitation to participate in an online survey was mailed to 3,736
customers from the CCOHS database. The invitation was mailed and not e-mailed due to the
need to comply with federal privacy legislation, and because valid e-mail addresses were not
available for some customers. The survey was available online from February 19 to March
26, 2004. A reminder card was mailed on March 8. Cards were returned from only 42
addresses.
CCOHS provided two Access data files for the survey. One file contained contact
information for individuals who had used the Inquiries Service. The second file contained
coded information of purchasers of products and other services (such as subscriptions).
Records with incomplete mailing addresses were removed. The files were checked for
duplicates, cleaned and a sample selected of Canadian and US clients. A language preference
(English/French) was available in CCOHSs sample file.
The sample file identified four product/service types:
1.
2.
3.
4.
Inquiries
Web Services
CD/DVD
Publications
293
Clients who purchased more than one type of product had more than one entry in the sample
file. Our sampling department randomly selected a product for individuals with more than
one. The product names in the data file were used as provided, so there was a possibility that,
in some instances, a French respondent could get an English product name, or vice versa.
Product names were occasionally abbreviated and always capitalized in the original file, and
thus appeared as such in the survey and the letter.
Web-site visitor survey: 603 visitors to the CCOHS/CCHST web site completed the survey
over the course of the field period.
Customer survey: Completions were achieved with 549 respondents for a response rate pf
15%, which is quite typical for a customer survey in a self-completion mode but less than
was anticipated given the level of involvement many customers have with CCOHS.
Number of challenges arose during the design of the customer survey methodology. CCOHS
did not have previous opt-in consent to e-mail their customers or Inquiries users for the
purposes of conducting research. As well, a significant number of records did not have e-mail
addresses. To comply with Privacy legislation and to attempt to reach customers without email addresses, a personalized letter was sent to a selected sample of potential respondents to
the customer survey. This mixed mode methodology resulted in a somewhat lower
completion rate than might have been expected with an all-electronic delivery, partially due
to the extra effort required to turn from the written word to the computer and manually enter
the web address for the survey. As well, it required a longer field period. However, our firm
notes that many surveys involving client-supplied customer lists result in a response rate of
between 10 and 15% regardless of mode.
The CCOHS web site is unique in many ways, as it provides a great deal of technical
information to a wide audience of varying levels of knowledge, much of it free or at low cost.
Although predominantly designed for the needs of Canadian business and individuals, it is
used by a worldwide audience to answer an astonishing variety of occupational health and
safety queries. Visitors mainly learn about the site via a search engine and, for half of
respondents, it was their first visit to the site. Two-thirds of these first-time visitors indicate
they are satisfied with the site, and satisfaction increases with more frequent visits. The
majority indicates that they found the information they came to the site to seek, even though
the site is structurally quite complex.
Visitors express a rather high level of satisfaction with how the site performed in all areas,
however, areas where there is the most gap between satisfaction and importance are ease of
finding information and scope of information. Visitors would also like to see more free
information provided. Overall, more than three-quarters of visitors express satisfaction with
the site. Very few suggested improvements were offered. CCOHS customers represent a mix
of organization types and sizes, but a typical customer would be someone in a safety role of a
manufacturing company of medium to large size. Despite the sizes of the organizations, most
indicate that from 1 to 10 people will use or benefit from a specific CCOHS product or
service. Close of half (43%) of customers have used the free web services, such as OSH
Answers and INCHEM, in the past year. There is room for expansion in awareness and use of
the HS Canada internet mailing list and the Health and Safety Report newsletter. A quarter of
customers indicate the product or service is used once a month, although pay for use services
294
are used more frequently. There is a growing preference for electronic media for provision of
products. In product attributes, reliability and clarity are the most valued qualities, and
coverage/comprehensiveness and currency (being up-to-date) are the qualities customers
would most like to see improved. While the majority of customers are either satisfied or very
satisfied with all rated attributes of the product or service they received, they are most
satisfied with usefulness and relevance, and least with cost and assistance provided for
solving a problem. Gaps between perceived importance and performance for CCOHS product
and service attributes are small (0.5 or less) and show that CCOHS is very close to meeting
customer expectations for most of its offerings, including the important measure of time
required to receive products and services. CCOHS meets its customers expectations
regarding the number of service staff and contacts required to obtain products and services.
Gaps in service attribute importance and performance are also small and there is a high level
of customer satisfaction with the service provided by CCOHS staff on all measures. Very few
errors are being made in provision of products and/or services. Close to three-quarters of
customer report that, in the end, they got what they needed, and over 80% indicate they
would purchase the product or service again.
3.3.5. Retail stores image research:
Researchers have studied a multitude of retailer attributes that influence overall image, e.g.,
the variety and quality of products, services, and brands sold; the physical store appearance;
the appearance, behavior and service quality of employees; the price levels, depth and
frequency of promotions; and so on. According to Kevin Lane Keller, it can be further
categorized into a smaller set of location, merchandise, service, and store atmosphere related
dimensions. The five dimensions we use to review past research are: 1) access, 2) in-store
atmosphere, and 3) price & promotion, 4) cross-category product/service assortment, and 5)
within-category brand/item assortment. A detailed presentation on this is available in the unit
Retailing.
3.3.6. Distribution research:
The study has been now divided into supply chain research and also on logistics research. In
the case of supply chain, following are included for research:
1 - Alignment of markets with supply
2 - Linking Demand Chain and Firm performance
3 - Outsourcing
4 - Reverse Logistics
5 - RFID
6 - Supply Chain Agility
7 - Supply Chain Collaboration
8 - Supply Chain Costing
9 - Supply Chain Information Systems
10 - Supply Chain Risk & Resilience
11 - Supply Chain Strategy
12 - Service Supply Chains
13 - Stock loss
Logistics plays a crucial role in business as it is involved in the entire supply chain starting
from purchase of materials to supply of finished products. Logistics costs account for 15-
295
25% of the cost of the final product in India, which is much higher than 7-9% in developed
countries. Logistics contributes 13-14% of GDP in India, when compared with 10% in US.
The relative inefficiencies in logistics in India can be attributed to inadequate logistics
infrastructure (both physical infrastructure and technological), laborious paper --based and
manual processes and fragmented supply chains.. Currently logistics in India does not have
an industry status. The absence of a uniform tax structure and procedures in all the states
often leaves the transporters to face delays at check posts, creating bottlenecks in
transportation. These frequent delays also result in enormous increase in transportation costs,
which go up to 40 % of the total logistics costs. Hence it becomes important that logistics
research is undertaken also.
Case study of Home Grown Cereals Authority:
This research is a collaboration between Cranfield School of Management and Cardiff
Business School, supported by the Food Chain Centre and the Home Grown Cereals
Authority (HGCA). The project started in February 2005 and has a duration of three years.
During this period eight case studies will be conducted focusing on different sub-sectors
within the cereals industry, including malting and brewing, bread making, animal feed and
bio-fuels. Some of the main industrial partners include Coors Brewers, Bernard
Matthews, Frontier and United Biscuits. The overall aim of the project is to transform the UK
cereals supply chain by fulfilling two main objectives.
To conduct improvement programmes within the representative cereals supply chains and to
give confidential recommendations to the companies involved in each chain
To disseminate general lessons from these programmes in order to give guidance and
encouragement to the wider industry
A multiple case study methodology is being used for the research, in which each of the
studies has its own specific objectives:
1. To analyse collaboration across the Supply Chain
Producing a Supply Chain Collaboration Index (SCCI)
Conducting collaboration interviews for specific relationships
2. To analyse the current supply chain
Creating a process map of the supply chain
3. To improve the current situation
Identifying opportunities to eliminate waste
Creating a Future State vision agreed by the companies
Producing recommendations as to achieve that vision
Defining an agreed action plan
The project covers two essential aspects of supply chain management, one refers to the hard
elements of the process (i.e. activities, times and inventories), the other to the soft elements,
this is, the personal and organisational relationships in the chain. These two aspects were
analysed using different tools:
Process Mapping: It is a pencil and paper tool that helps to visualise and understand the flow
of material and information as a product makes its way through the supply chain. Some of the
296
main benefits of this tool are that it helps to identify waste in the process, supporting the
analysis of the linkages between information and material flows and serving as a basis for the
implementation plan.
Supply Chain Collaboration Index: the purpose of this tool is to capture quantitative and
qualitative data to reveal the dynamics of long-term collaborative business relationships. The
method has been proven in a large number of multi-million pound, bilateral relationships in
the public and private sectors, and subjected to rigorous testing. Measurements from both
sides of a collaborative relationship are taken in order to assess five key dimensions of the
relationship (creativity, stability, communication, reliability and value) and seven additional
characteristics (long term orientation, interdependence, C3 behaviour, trust, commitment,
adaption and personal relationships). Three case studies have already been completed giving
some indication of the overall results of the project. It has been found that the commodity
nature of the products in question promotes relationships that are transactional, where parties
are not interested on establishing a close, long-term supply chain relationship. However, the
project has also shown that in parts of the industry, other factors such as quality, delivery and
reliability have gained importance. Taking these factors into consideration requires more
complex relationships which are not necessarily served by a transactional approach. As a
result, some of the organisations that contributed to this study are already moving towards
more collaborative, long-term approaches. The research has also revealed a number of
opportunities for improvement in areas such as haulage, information flow, inventory
management, vulnerability, communication, personal relationships and trust. This was the
case during 2006.
3.3.7. Competitor analysis Research:
There are number of possibilities of conducting competitive analysis. Competitive
Intelligence is the legal and ethical process of collecting and analysing information,
converting it into intelligence and then using it to determine the capabilities, vulnerabilities,
and intentions of the competition. There are three levels at which the research is undertaken:
1.
2.
3.
Feature level - Find out how your product stacks up against the competition, featureby-feature. Learn what features customers think are important, how much they are
worth, and how to focus your efforts on getting the most from your product
development efforts.
Solution level - We can help you understand the overall solution characteristics that
create competitive advantage. Go beyond features to leverage options including
delivery, support, and complementary services that differentiate your offering from
the competition.
Hidden competition - Your customers' perceptions determine who your competitors
are, and it might not be who you think. Sometimes the competition comes from the
customers themselves: internal departments, legacy techniques, or lack of awareness.
We can help you identify what your marketing efforts are really competing with.
297
Literature search
Company annual reports (see library)
Business directories
Observation - mystery shopper visits to competitors
Media - advertising
Trade fairs, exhibitions, etc
Trade press
Collateral material (corporate brochures, Internet sites)
Exclusive reliance on online sources is to be discouraged
298
three steps: understanding, organising and writing. The general guidelines that should be
followed for any report or research paper are as follows:
Consider the audience: The information resulting from the study is ultimately of importance
to marketing managers, who will use the results to make decisions. Thus, the report has to be
understood by them; the report should not be too technical and not too much jargon should be
used. This is a particular difficulty when reporting the results of statistical analysis where
there is a high probability that few, if any, of the target audience have a grasp of statistical
concepts. Hence, for example, there is a need to translate such terms as standard deviation,
significance level, confidence interval etc. into everyday language. This is sometimes not an
easy task but it may be the case that researchers who find it impossible do not themselves
have a sufficiently good grasp of the statistical methods they have been using.
Be concise, but precise: On the one hand, a written report should be complete in the sense
that it stands by itself and that no additional clarification is needed. On the other hand, the
report must be concise and must focus on the critical elements of the project and must
exclude unimportant issues. There is a great temptation, on the part of inexperienced
researchers, to seek to convey all that they did in order to obtain information and to complete
the research. This is done almost as if the researcher is afraid that the audience will not other
wise appreciate the time, effort and intellectual difficulties involved. What the researcher has
to come to realise is that he/she will be judged by the contribution towards solving the
marketing problem and not by the elegance or effort involved in the research methodology.
Understand the results and drawing conclusions: The managers who read the report are
expecting to see interpretive conclusions in the report. The researcher must therefore
understand the results and be able to interpret these. Simply reiterating facts will not do, and
the researcher must ask him/herself all the time "So what?"; what are the implications. If the
researcher is comparing the client's product with that of a competitor, for example, and
reports that 60 percent of respondents preferred brand A to brand B, then this is a description
of the results and not an interpretation of them. Such a statement does not answer the 'So
what?' question.
The following outline is the suggested format for writing the research report:
Title page
Summary of findings
Table of contents
List of tables
List of figures
Introduction
Background to the research problem
Objectives
Hypotheses
Methodology-Data collection
Sample and sampling method
Statistical or qualitative methods used for data analysis
Sample description
299
Findings
Results, interpretation and conclusions.
The summary of findings is perhaps the most important component of the written report,
since many of the management team who are to receive a copy of the report will only read
this section. The summary of findings is usually put right after the title page, or is bound
separately and presented together with the report. The introduction should describe the
background of the study and the details of the research problem. Following that,
automatically the broad aim of the research can be specified, which is then translated into a
number of specific objectives. Furthermore, the hypotheses that are to be tested in the
research are stated in this section. In the methodology chapter the sampling methods and
procedures are described, as well as the different statistical methods that are used for data
analysis. Finally, the sample is described, giving the overall statistics, usually consisting of
frequency counts for the various sample characteristics. Once the sample has been described,
the main findings are to be presented in such a way that all objectives of the study are
achieved and the hypotheses are tested. As mentioned before, it is essential that the main
findings are well interpreted and conclusions are drawn wherever possible. Easy-tounderstand tables and graphics will greatly enhance the readability of the written research
report. As a general rule, all tables and figures should contain:
1. Identification number corresponding to the list of tables and the list of figures
2. A title that conveys the content of the table or figure, also corresponding to the list of
tables and the list of figures, and
3. Appropriate column labels and row labels for tables, and figure legends defining specific
elements in the figure.
4.
2. Subhiksha wants to learn about consumer attitudes toward mail order purchases and
conducts a study to acquire this information, this study would best be classified as collecting
_________data.
A. casual
B. experimental
C. primary
D. secondary
3. Marketing researchers at Rohan Lathes Ltd. repeated an experiment several times and
discovered that the results produced each time were identical. This would suggest that the
results were:
A. reliable
300
B. valid
C. predictable
D. compatible
4. The first step in planning a marketing research project is:
A. conducting a cost/benefit analysis
B. defining and locating problems
C. assessing organisation resources
D. defining goals and objectives
5. State whether true or false: The need for marketing research is basically from the lacuna in
framing wrong marketing strategies.
5.
Summary
Marketing is a restless, changing, and dynamic business activity. The role of marketing itself
has changed dramatically due to various crisesmaterial and energy shortages, inflation,
economic recessions, high unemployment, dying industries, dying companies, terrorism and
war, and effects due to rapid technological changes in certain industries. Such changes,
including the Internet, have forced todays marketing executive to becoming more market
driven in their strategic decision-making, requiring a formalized means of acquiring accurate
and timely information about customers, products and the marketplace and the overall
environment. The means to help them do this is marketing research. Marketing research
assists in the overall management of the marketing function. A marketing manager must
prioritize the more important and pressing problems selected for solution, reach the best
possible solution based on the information available, implement the solution, modify the
solution when additional information so dictates, and establish policy to act as a ready-made
solution for any recurrence of the problem. Marketing research often focuses on
understanding the Customer (purchasers, consumers, influencers), the Company (product
design, promotion, pricing, placement, service, sales), and can also be expanded toward the
environment to include Competitors (and how their market offerings interact in the market
environment).
6.
Exercises
1. The shoe market in India can be divided into two major segments, namely the formal
leather shoes and the casual wear shoes. There has been a rapid change in the casual
shoes market in the past few years in India. It is no more a distinctive possession of the
elite only. It has now become a ubiquitous, all purpose shoe as the outlook of people
towards casual shoes has also changed. The market is now set for a boom. This is also
owing to the launch of many new range of casual shoes by Bata and Carona in technical
collaboration with the world famous leading manufactures of shoes like Adidas and Puma
respectively. In a study of casual shoes we found that top of the mind awareness for
various brands were North Star (33%), Nike (38%), Puma (17%) and Adidas (15%).
Although Bata and Carona have been existing in the market for a long time, there have
been scores of new entrants such as Liberty, Dawood etc. and even some foreign brands.
This has led to an increased competition. It would be worthwhile to do an exploratory
study of the casual shoe market with the aim of understanding consumer behaviour,
301
buying criterion, awareness and preference and brands, attitudes of consumers etc.
Conduct a research study to see the demand for shoes in South India.
2. Assume a situation where there is a retail mart which want to understand the potential in a
town, outline the advice you would give to your client on:
a. How to plan the research
b. Which literature to search first
3. The problem definition stage is more critical in research process than the problem
solution stage. Discuss.
4. If Proctor and Gamble, the makers of Ariel, need to know what percentage of customers
examine product labels before making a product selection in the supermarket, what is the
best methodology to do so?
QUESTION BANK
302
303
304
305