12/5/2015

WhyareSomeCountriesmoreSuccessfulTouristDestinationsthanOthers?

en fr

Subscribe to the Newsletter

LEADERSHIP

STRATEGY

INNOVATION

ECONOMY & FINANCE

BUSINESS & SOCIETY

ABOUT ESSEC

WHY ARE SOME COUNTRIES MORE SUCCESSFUL

TOURIST DESTINATIONS THAN OTHERS?

by Sarah Brown , 04.10.12

Follow

37
With Peter O'Connor and Vincenzo Esposito Vinzi

1
Google+

0
Reddit

3893

Tourism can be very important to a countrys economy, particularly in less developed regions,
where it can drive growth. Tourism also tends to have important impacts on the environment and
society at large.
Many researchers have examined the consequences of tourism, but fewer have looked at the
other side of the coin: the way economic, social and environmental factors can drive tourism or
hold it back. The few studies that have examined the issue have usually used the various factors
to arrive at a score reflecting a particular countrys attractiveness as a tourist destination.
We wanted to look at this topic more deeply not just how economic, social and environmental
factors affect tourism, but also how they affect each other, both positively and negatively. To do
this, we used a mathematical technique called structural equation modelling, which uses a set of
linear equations to analyse the relationships between a set of variables.

Choosing the variables

0

Comments

Building on the work of earlier researchers, we first developed a set of variables covering four
aspects of a tourist destination: its economy, its infrastructure, its natural environment and its
society.
To measure the economy, we used five variables: consumer price index, purchasing power parity,
trade volume, foreign direct investment and industry value added. These reflect the way lower
local prices or better exchange rates entice tourists to visit, and how a countrys tourism tends to
benefit when its businesses are doing well.
To assess environmental issues affecting tourism, we used three measures: population density,
carbon dioxide emissions and the number of environmental treaties ratified. The environment is
important because people obviously prefer to visit places with unspoilt natural surroundings.
To analyse infrastructure, we used seven variables reflecting a countrys road network, sanitation
standards, electricity supply, number of vehicles, Internet access, landline phone network and
mobile phone network coverage. All these factors improve the tourism experience by providing

http://knowledge.essec.edu/en/businesssociety/whatreallymakestourismsuccessful.html

1/4

12/5/2015

WhyareSomeCountriesmoreSuccessfulTouristDestinationsthanOthers?

easier travel, drinking water and better communication.

Finally, society in a tourist destination was reflected in variables covering education, life
expectancy, ownership of TVs and PCs and newspaper readership. Social issues are relevant
because local populations can react to tourism in different ways embracing it or rejecting it.

Causal relationships
Having determined our variables, we tried to predict the most likely causal relationships between
these four areas and tourism.
Forexample we thought that a strong economy could have both positive and negative effects:
higher local prices could discourage visitors, but growth would develop infrastructure and
improves society, both of which could help tourism indirectly. As infrastructure develops, tourism
should increase but the environment might suffer.
Similalrly social differences between tourists and their hosts could either help or hinder tourism,
depending on the local quality of life and peoples attitudes towards making sacrifices for the
tourist dollar. Social progress could also affect the environment the more advanced the society,
the more enlightened its attitudes towards sustainability. And the more pleasant the environment,
the more the tourist industry is likely to benefit.

Improving the model

We tested our hypotheses using data for 162 countries. First, we tested and refined the data, and
quickly discovered that there was too much overlap between our society and infrastructure
concepts , so we combined them both under infrastructure. We found that electricity coverage
was actually more relevant to the environment than to infrastructure, so we reassigned it. And
three variables (population density, foreign direct investment and industry value added) were not
significant, so we dropped them.
We ended up with a new, simpler model reflecting economy, infrastructure, environment and
tourism that worked much better. When we analysed our data using this model, we found that
some of our hypotheses were supported but some were not.

Surprising results
According to our results, a better economy has no direct influence on tourism. This challenges the
idea that lower local prices or favourable exchange rates encourage people to visit a destination.
However, the economy does have a direct, positive effect on both infrastructure and society and
these two factors, in turn, affect tourism. This is in line with the findings of earlier researchers,
who found that better infrastructure encourages tourism. In fact, our model shows that
infrastructure is the single most important factor more than either the environment or the
economy.
This finding challenges an earlier theory called social exchange, which argued that a more
deprived society would be more willing to suffer some inconvenience in order to gain tourists
business. In our model, the more developed the society, the more supportive it is of tourism.
We found that a well-developed infrastructure does indeed cause harm to the environment, as we
expected. But a more developed society does not necessarily result in environmental
improvements, and a better environment does not seem to drive more tourism either.

Real-world applications
Previous studies have looked at the way these areas affect tourism, without considering how they
interact. Our study has taken a first step towards uncovering the causal relationships between the
key factors affecting the tourism sector, and showing how they actually affect tourism. By using
real-world data and subjecting it to rigorous analysis and refinement, we have shown how tourism
can be investigated in a more scientific, empirical way.
Our study has many potential applications. Policymakers who are aiming to promote tourism in
their respective countries can use it to make more informed decisions about allocating resources
to different areas of development. For example, while higher local prices might be seen as
http://knowledge.essec.edu/en/businesssociety/whatreallymakestourismsuccessful.html

2/4

12/5/2015

WhyareSomeCountriesmoreSuccessfulTouristDestinationsthanOthers?

negative, its important to realise that a stronger economy drives infrastructural and social
improvements that indirectly encourage tourism.
Similarly external trade is important, because it helps drive economic growth and infrastructure
improvements. Electronic communications are key they must keep pace with developing road
networks in order to attract tourists. Finally, the levels of computer use, car ownership and
newspaper readership are important, because they help society to develop, in the process
becoming more welcoming and attractive to visitors from overseas.

Further Reading:
"Structural Equation Modeling in Tourism Demand Forecasting:A Critical Review", published
inJournal of Travel and Tourism Research.
TAGS:
hospitality, top research, center of excellence hospitality, ids department, food & travel, travel

RELATED ARTICLES

Strategy

Business & Society

Leadership

Economy & Finance

Do Unusual Hotels Have Lower

CSR: Will all the sustainability

Can managers build social ties

Why arent hotel chains more

Market Value?

talk have a real impact on the

between employees?

worried about AirBnB?

Read More

Read More

Read More

environment?

Read More

ESSEC KNOWLEDGE ON TWITTER

Tweets by @ESSECKnowledge

FEATURED INDUSTRIES

ESSEC RECOMMENDS

ENERGY
The Biofuel Bad Rap

Blog - Micro-Positioning and the end of

traditional positioning in a social world

AGRICULTURE
9 challenges facing French agricultural coops

Blog - The Power of Writing in Organizations

MOBILE BUSINESS
ESSEC Knowledge Hangout: What Drives
Organizational Innovation?

ESSEC Executive Education

Blog - Flirting with Finance

DEFENSE
Mali Aftermath: Soft Power Raises Hard
Questions
RESEARCH
How Alliances Impact your R&D Capacity

http://knowledge.essec.edu/en/businesssociety/whatreallymakestourismsuccessful.html

3/4

12/5/2015

WhyareSomeCountriesmoreSuccessfulTouristDestinationsthanOthers?

0Comments
Recommend

essec

Share

Login

SortbyBest

Startthediscussion

Bethefirsttocomment.

WHAT'STHIS?

ALSOONESSEC

NetflixpourratilsimposerenFrance?

Alimentation:lducationmneauxbonnespratiques

1comment10monthsago

1commentayearago

VincentNallatambyIntressant.Anoterquelastratgie

NefertitiM.Jesuisentirementd'accord,uneinformationn'apas

cataloguedeNetflixsemblevoluerversdesfilmsindpendantset
pluspointusquisontintrouvablessuruneplateformecomme

d'effetdslorsqu'ellevoudraits'imposercommeunecontrainte
pournous.Acemomentl,ilestfaciledetrouverdes

CanApplekeepwinningthegamewithalatemoverstrategy?
1commentayearago

MarkSteveThisoneisagreattechnologywhichApple

Regulation?PrivateActorsStillhaveUnrivaledPowerover
theirownSystem
1commentayearago

introduced.Theyalreadylaunchedmanyapplicationswhichis
demandinginthemarket.Therearelotsofappdevelopment

Subscribe

AddDisqustoyoursite

AbiatharBarakNormallythroughthegrowthofmoneyinanyway

wegettolearn,thethingistoexperienceeverythingwellwhichcan
provideusthemaximumoutcomenomatterwhatthethingisso

Privacy

FOLLOW US ON SOCIAL MEDIA

GROUP ESSEC 2015

ESSEC'S PARTNERS

Terms and conditions - Contact - Accessibility

http://knowledge.essec.edu/en/businesssociety/whatreallymakestourismsuccessful.html

4/4