You are on page 1of 37

Getting

Personal
Go-Founders
Eli Broad College of Business,
Michigan State University, 2013

Eli Broad College of Business,


Michigan State Universi$, 2013

Gollege of Engineering,
Michigan State University, 2014

College of Engineering,
Michigan State University, 2014

Dialogue

with

$srclh $ s:r*'i*::-i 1*{ "} t ; s*\. i ts \,"

MY FAVORITE SMARTPHONE
APP
Snapchat

BEST ADVICE I'VE RECEIVED


ilnn't pmstp*me joy"
MY ADVICE FOR NEW
ENTREPRENEURS
Take y*ur tinre. Many entrepreilsur$ just wan? tc g*t th*ir pr*du*t
*ut as $ssrt as p*sslhlo. Sut 3r*u
n*ed tin:* tm test, n*t *nly y*ur
idem, hx"rt y*ur tsam"

MY BIGGEST SURPRISE
AS AN ENTREPRENEUR
Th* Iove ant5 supp*rt y** g*t fr*r*
mth*r *r*tr*pn*t:surs.

BEST PART OF BEING

A STUDENT
ffimscug'cg$, f,'*s#Err"ss$, i'tr$*t!,'**$.

WHAT I DO WHEN I'M NOT


WORKING
$ tmvs t# rur"r, ['aike, afi# *effip"

18r

'uotltleduoc oql pozJelcErEqc Joprel 'ouruurnn dn pepue pue 'pleruBH pue ptoluelg 6ur
-pnlcu! '&1unoc oql ssoJce sor1s;onrun uor,t sdn-ye1s Llcol lsue6e Ourleduoc otonn Aeql
'du1eq1 popunl elels ue6rqcryl 'spxol'urlsnv ur ocueJeluoC Blpol/\ pue otsny! +somqlnos
Aq qlnos oql lB slcelord pilOlp e6el;oc lo1 uorllleduoc L,lcud e 'sseupeyl dnyelg
luopnls ur ungoduJef perolue {eq1 grcz {pee ur losselord e }o uol}se66ns oq} }v
'suoJ+e
1e6e1 pue Durlerypu s,ungodruol uo peIJoM pue o6o; e peu6rs
-ep oqn suJelut sp tlcns ')ron loN drqsrneuaiderlu3 s,nSlA q6notql olqeltene socJnoseJ
ouoq old peztltln osp ,{eql '(Cff) {ueduroc r{ltttqell pa}llull p o}EoJc pue 'eepl r!or{} lrerrr
-oppll 'slelnduoc {nq o} uor}Brcosse sossoursnq sndurec e uol} }uel6 B pue 000'9$
eql pasn sreuyed oq1'IJoA ley drqsrneuerderlu:l s,nSN qlrnn dlqsleuued ul JoleJolocce
ssoutsnq }uapnls E 'tlclpH eLll o] ssocce pue ezud ISJIJ OOO'gg B pepnlcul utl eql 'uotl
-tledutoc otll uo^ {eq1 [lqtpoJcul 'eop! sseursnq rleLl] Jo] uotssed lraql A or.ls o] Ued ur
'sotllolc Outuunl ur peqcyd {eq1 'err1}E ssoursnq Ouueen }o peo}sul 'ssoutsnq Jo e6e;;oc
eql u! pleL.l sEA r..lclLlM 'uorlrleduoC Llclld pBoJg lsJI oq] peJe]ue 'elOZ ]o loquocoo ut
'pue ungoduel lo; ueld ssoursnq e eloln ,{eql 'acuorcs.relndr.uo3 ut oJeA uez}ee pue
)eLlcsoJd Lllog 'ssoutsng fir;elrdsoH +o looLlcs eL{} u! }uapn}s e sEA so^ez-ueq3 allL,l/v\
'sseutsng 1o e6elloC ppolg llf aL{} ur roleur scr.uouoca pue 6ul1e>1leur B sen Joptol
'elels ue6tqctyll Jo socJnoser oLll ozrlrln sr teslno eL{} ruol} plp sJouued eq1 6urq1eu6
'L{}oq ro1 ungoduol oueu oL,l} 6ursn 'dde eq1 pllnq pue ssoutsnq B uJo} o} poplcop
JnoJ Jo dnor6 aql 'lueudopnep pue Ourpoc 1e poo6 olan oL.lA ruozlee
'srolsonur
l!r",ld puE )er,lcsotd ulepv 'sluepnls o/vu qilA dn ueql polooL{ luoru
1e11ue1od o1 ue;d ssoutsnq
e lueserd fi;enrlcege o] Mor.l ure;dx3 .g
-yedep eLl+ u!.rosse1o.rd e pup 'Oulpuepe oJoA [eql firslentun oL]]'o]E]S
'ue;d sseutsnq B lo outllno
ue6rqcryll lB lueuuedep ecuotcs tepduro3 oL,ll polceluoc sonez-Uoq;3
pe1se66ns p oqucsop pue grluepl .V
pue eH 'peacold ol A oq lo esuos e peL{ pup seop! ssoutsnq pJanes uo
'ueld sseulsnq ontlcoJJo uE
peIJoA ppq Jeptel 'odue1 o1 Ourp.roccp ctsnu pezuo6elec let4l dde uB
olrJ^^ ol /v\olloJ ol soutloprn6 eq1 ssncsto .
t
sEAA L.fcrr.,ll 'pouorsrnuo soABZ-yeqJ pue Jeptel lpr.1/!\ {;1cexe plp }eq}
'to1 6u;>1oo; e.r,Ieq1 +Brl/\A
ouou pq 'seOueqc eced s,JeuunJ B sB sodruel 6uos lsnlpe leL{} }oryeu
pue ue;d ssoursnq B speoJ oL.lll oqtJcso6 .Z
oLll uo sddB oJe^ oJor.,ll leql puno;.rred oql toqunl lt onstnd o1 pep;c
'ue;d sseursnq B
esodlnd eq1 ureldx3 .
1o
f
-op uel,ll lo oA l oql pup 'Eep! eL,lI po^ol so^ez-uoqf teuunJ snoues p
:o7 tlpeet
e'sone7-Uoqf Auuag L,llt^ Bept aql percqs laptel
'uloq servr 'dde euoqdpeus p 'ungoduel
oq Hnoqs noi rcpdeqe sf# 6ut/tpn7s rcUV

SXAITCXIgO CNINUETT

{S$i

&*r

pup srq Jo puor;l

Jo Eopr eq1 'ecueH ..actsnu lnoA 1o

oduel eql ol

unJ s{ean;e no{

l,upc r{r.,|^^,, '1q6noq1 eH '}lnsel e sB unJ s,Jeplol l}o ouranolql '1uele;


-1rp {lerr1uo spM odure} eL{J- 'pouels 6uos loq}ouE puB pepuo ,,llosJno^ osol,, uor.ll
'A;1ce;red eced Outuunr slLl poqcleur 6uos eL{}
}o odue} aL{f 'euoL4dl slt.l uo tuoul.u3
oH 'unJ E uo se/v\ Japtol L{son ZrcZ;o lsn6ny u

[q

,J;esrno^ osol,, o1 Ouruelsll

sel

was' uruodwal'mmm :eafig

ueld sseutsng 6utuul^ e lo qloueJls eqt uo 6ulpeeco.r6


STIJOUd CNINSdO

LrBId ssautsntI e FuIlIryK


9urrdvHo

182

PART

2 I

DEVELOPING SUCGESSFUL BUSINESS IDEAS

and in parlicular the judging, as Shark Tank times 10. The judges were executives and
well-known entrepreneurs from companies like Google, Square, and TechStars. Leider
summed up the experience by saying that "We went into the competition thinking we

int

knew everything but found that we knew very little." This was actually a positive comment
on Leider's paft. He was referring to the learning that took place as a result of the rigor
of the judges' questions and their feedback. The South by Southwest win also netted
TempoRun $5,000 in Google Cloud Platform credit and acquainted the entrepreneurs with
people they would have had no way of coming into contact with othenryise. The nearby
photo was taken just after the win at the South by Southwest competition. The team, from

T]

left to right, included Phil Gatzen, Benny Eberl-Zavos, Adam Proschek, and Josh Leider.

ger

AS

Ch
of

Iti

sul
YCI

To gain visibility and prepare for launch, the TempoRun team sponsored a charity
5K at Michigan state in April of 2013. The proceeds went to support breast cancer
research. The company formally launched in the Apple App Store in May 2013. The
way the app works is that it helps users run at their preferred pace by categorizing the
music on their iphone from Level 1 (walking) to Level 10 (sprinting). lt also incorporates
music from a streaming lnternet music station. The user selects a level, which can be
changed with arrows on a simple interface. The app also keeps track of basic running
analytics, such as distance run, pace, and calories burned. TempoRun, which charged
a one-time download fee of $2.99 when it first launched, had 2,000 downloads its first

sh,

day of launch. The company has experienced a steady pace of downloads since.
Looking back, Leider credits the time his team spent in The Hatch, the Michigan
State student accelerator, and the business plan and pitch competitions in which they
participated as pivotal to their success. Leider says that the value of a business plan
or pitch competition is that it "gets your ideas down on paper and causes you to ask
questions of yourself that you would have never thought of before-questions about
your business, your revenue streams, and more." Another ingredient to TempoRun's
success is that Leider and Elbert-Zavos are very involved in the running community.
Because they are consumers of their own product, they are able to make tweaks to

te:

the product based on their own observations and listen to suggestions from runners
whom they know and who are also TempoRun users.
TempoRun is not yet a full-time job for the four founders, but they hope this will

soon be the case. They envision extending TempoRun's basic approach to other
sports, such as cycling and swimming.

an
pe

fat

cel

wi
Th

wl
rh
for
p|

a
n(

\[

el

E
o

his chapter discusses the importance of writing a business plan. Although


some new ventures simpty "wing it" and start doing business without
the benefit of formal planning, it is hard to find an expert who doesn't
recommend preparing a business plan. A business plan is a written nurative, typically 25to 35 pages long, that describes what a newbusiness intends
to accomplish and how it intends to accomplish it. For most new ventures,
the busin."s plan is a dual-purpose document that is used both inside and
outside the flrm. Inside the firm, the plan helps the company develop a "road
map" to follow to execute its strategies and plans. Outside the firm, it introduces potential investors and other stakeholders to the business opportunity
the firm is pursuing and how it plans to pursue it.1
To begin this chapter, we discuss issues \Mith which entrepreneurs often
grapple *h.r, facing the challenge of writing a business plan. Topics included
i1 ffr. chapter's flrst section are reasons for writing a business plan, a description of who reads the business plan and what they're looking for, and guidelines
to follow when preparing a written business plan. In the chapter's second section, we presenl un oufline of a business plan with a description of the material

t(

uEld

ajnlua^ A eu
slr Io pedsP
fuana qBnorql lulLlt
,{1;errleurapls o} uPal
Surpunol eql sa)rol

lBIJ
-ce

s3II

-dr:
pe
ue1

ssoutsng e 6u;1;rp1lo1
suoseag &eulu6 onnl
ffi

-ffi ffiffiffiffiffi#

fi1
-oJ

.slcnpord eql Fqdole ep eroJaq alqlssod


e16 .slsdlerre rv\ou qsec B uarn prre

sE

qcreoser qcnru s op ol pelrre.&\


plp e \ Fqqf lsJg eI{L 'sn

ueld sser4snq a(D

se/y\

roJ eu41lr1plr arll ser\ . ]I prre 'ldacuoc s1n lnoqe Fup1p1 eren\ e \.seepl ]noqB pe{IBl
sde^*r1e e11 .uedder{ ol Fr.qo! se \ I aerDl elf\ -retf}eFo} ssarqsnq r4 eq o} pa}ueru' s.(errr
-IB ptIB raqleFol fleuroC ]e sepxe] polpn]s pue aFaloc o] ]uerv\ I pue despt4l :uam1

:srnauerde.qua apure;;o slueurqqldurocce aq1 slqEgqlq 1et[+ sllsqe^r E 'qJrmz I


oqt!\ s3lpe-I or e,tea ,(e.{+ ltelArart4 ut uro4 s3nroJ auarfrn FrqrnoloJ eq1 :sr11a?o1
ssorrr.snq E usls ol poplJap 4ed aq1 Bupenpef raXB prre 'sc1rqel Fqdpnp e1q,,t
dltsrerrnrn fleuJoc lE latu Jeqs.IA\ pue Funqm'slcnpord arec cIJqEJ r3rtr+o prrE
quaBrelap rftpunel palelnrurol fle.rceds sllss ltq frreduroc E 'sseJprmE I eql
Jo s.EpunoJ-oc aql 'reqepY\,tespuq pue FupplA uatnS ,,(q papyrord sI 'splo.;rm
ssal4snq rYreu peu[rEld-11elYr e rcq prre 'peqo^t4 serlgaluos sI {Jo'r$' qc II aoq Jo
aldtrrexe uy 'polred srr{+ Furmp uqd erp uo 4rortr o1 i(1re1nFar leeur flJensn 1g,n
srapunoJ er{+ prre-rre1d ssar4snq pedolaaap-1a,t e aplduroc o1 srlaa'u ro Mep p:a
-rres sar1r1 flpnsn 1I-1JoJ3 IEI lII B lou q sr-ql q'errquarr llau rlarp;o pedse qcea
r{8norq+ {rrn{r ,(lpcpeurelMs ol srepunoJ s,urrf e see-ro; uqd sser4snq e Eupgrn
3111
ernFl{ rq ueld sset4snq e ollra 01 suoseer 'treurrrd oq eql
^rcqs

pB(

pu
'se
sp,
_o'
1,

1n
q

JO
il!,

o
'

lsrg 'I'9

ueld sseulsn8 e 6u;1.t1y1lol suoseou

.{auour prre eu1q s.rnauards4ua ue yo lusu4sa,rr4 pooF .,{1aure4xa rre

s1

rreld sseu

+snq e Suptl,u 1er+ uopou aq1 sgoddns ecu3plla aldure 'paapul 'uqd sset4snq e
p1p luecred
Fupgn uro4 rnauarde4ue rre rapp lou pFoqs scgsgs+s aserll
'1ou1eruJoJ E ual
Og Jo 1elol y 'sagreduroc rptn patprmEl daql aro;eq ueld sset4snq
-1grn peq ,{aql rarpeqz* rea,( lerg gg9 'au1 arp dn aleur 1etp surrg erp Jo srsprrnoJ
eq+ pa{se etrye?ew'au1 't(prqs ZOOZ e q 'i{g4u15 ,'uqd ssau.snq e a'req faql
leq+ p1es s.rarr..ro arll Jo luacred 99 dluo 'sratrto ssat4snq 999'6 pafa,ms qc1ryrr
'dpnls s$ccns ssorqsn51 IIEuTS IIOZ s.pro:FrEH aql ot Bqproccv 'proJIBH ar[L
,tq ,{a.tms IIOU eJo sllnssr et[+ 01 JPIFrrI.s q raqunu ler'f,L 6'uqd ssaqsnq e qlpl
pq-r4s lr.recrad Oe lnoq" fIIIo '(uuu Jaqlout ol aIEs Jo Okfl ue "e'I) s+p FUSsac
-cns pEq letIt ssot1l Jo letn ptmo; smauarda4ue 699 1o r{pqs ZIOZ-OIOZ e '1cr.J
Lq .sam+ue^ ryrsu rprp rol srreld esaur.snq aIIJA lorr op srnarrarde.rlua 1o aFeluearad
e8rq r(pageler e 'os op ol peeu aln FrrgsaBFns urops.rru puopualuoc 3o alds rq
'erqu3^ ryreu [eBu31od e ;o slgau atr+ ftrneBBsaatq Jo eBels slsi(prre
dlgtqlseeJ 3q+ r4 palel uncce sI p.e]3p sEn Jo qrnl tr 'goddns allscar plnoqs
pue
sI sser4snq l,ri.orr aW letll rapter aq] acrrlluoc ol r3pJo u! eJnlu3l
ftrr+pxe
aql Jo s}1rar[ aql ]noqE slls]3p luapgns aABq pue q8noua aaglualsqns
^{au
eq
lsruu rreld sser4snq aq1 't(1rea ool rrEld ssar4snq B elp\\ 01 a{s}slur E st tI
'ueld
ssaulsnq
sseulsng IryssacJns 8u1do1aaaq. pa11p ssaaord legnaua:de4ua arp;o
.'seepl
p p esodJnd oql uleldE 'r
dals
aq+ t4 pelelduroc fll^pce lsEI atll sI rreld ssaulsnq e Funun '1 reldeq3
u,.rdoqs ssacord pgnauardarlua etll Jo I3poul clsEq eql uI palBr+snflI sV

g LtcaIEo ctEi[ErJtrI t4

uPId sseulsng oq,f,


.sJerilo
o] 1l\or{ JoJ se-rF
eq]
rrBld
sser4snq
o]
prrB
sJolse^ul
]uaseJd
lBlluelod
-elB4s InI/\,\ slBep reldBqc elp Jo uoBces pJIq] aqJ 'ueld
Jo uonces I{cBe uI

"qt

e8r

N\fld SS]N/SNgV ENltlUM

9 U]J.dVHC

184

pART

2 I

DEVELopTNG succESSFUL BUSTNESS TDEAS

This group of young


entrepreneurs plans to

launch a website that


features educational
toys for children. Here,
they are discussing how
to integrate the results
of their feasibility analysis into their business
plan. A business plan
is more compelling if it
contains primary research
conducted by the entrepreneurs launching the
business.

'7

c
L!

.E
G
U

c
E

Lindseg; We spent Memoriat Day weekend (2003) doing our business plan. We
spent the Fourth of July weekend doing our cash flow. After we had our ideas
on paper, we went back to Cornell, met with a professor there, and had a crash
course in chemistry. She worked \vith us on the formulation of the products.
Gwen: I found a manufacturer on Columbus Day. Every piece of free time we had,
we dedicated to the business. We weren't at the beach with our friends an5rmore.6

The payoff for this level of dedication and hard work, which involved the
preparation of a formal business plan, is that Whiting and Wieber have now
had a successful business for lO-plus years. Their products are sold through
their website and in many stores.
Consistent with Whiting and Wieber's experience, writing a business plan
forces a firm's founders to intently study every aspect of their business, a
process that's hard to replicate in any other way. Imagine the following. Two
friends are thinking about opening a seafood restaurant. They spend the next
two months meeting four nights a week to hash out every detail of the business. They study the restaurant industry, identi$r their target market, develop
a marketing p1an, settle on a hiring schedule, identi$r the type of people they
want to employ, plan their facility, determine what their start-up expenses will
be, and put together five years of pro forma (projected) financial statements.
After 32 meetings and several drafts, tJrey produce a So-page business plan
that explains every aspect of their business. Regardless of how conscientious
the founders of a business are, it's difficult to discipline oneself to cover this
level of detail absent writing a business plan. As stated earlier, writing a business plan forces a business's founders to systematically think through every
aspect of their business and develop a concrete blueprint to follow.
The second reason to write a business plan is to create a selling document
for a company. It provides a mechanism for a young company to present itself to
potential investors, suppliers, business partners, key job candidates, and othlrs. Imagine that yo, h"rr. enough money to invest in one new business.T You
chat informally with several entrepreneurs at a conference for start-ups and
decide that there are two new ventures that you would like to know more about.

E=-E!I

==

'ro10u;1001 er,{aq1

lur.ln pue ue;d sseursnq


e spEor 0r.l^ 0qu3s00

'z

g^r,f,cx[ao cNrNuIrgT

suJnleJ IEIcuEug sJolsalul Iellualod s-rego prre elqel sI BepI sseulsnq eql ]Er{}
olerlsuoruep d1-ree1c ]snru rreld arn 'au4] erues oq] ]V 'uaq] epnlJul o] qs[ooJ
sI ]I os 'dlryq1perc s.ue1d sseulsnq e orrlrrrJepun suollcsfo-rd ro s]ueue]E]s
cllslrupdo d1-re.rr.6 'UBd s.ruJIJ er{} uo eJueplJuoJrelo Jo a^I}JeUer }ou pue cnsl
-IBaJ eq ]snru ueld sseulsnq aq1 'dnorF s1q1 o1 padde oJ 'ue1d ssoursnq B JoJ
ecualpnB puocas aq] ere 'seedoldue l(e4 prre 's:euped ssoulsnq ppualod 's-ro1
-selur sB qcns 'urJIJ e ulof ol pellruce-r Fuleq ere oqr\ sreploqe>Iels [BuJe]xg

sraploqalBls IEuJalxS Jaql0 puB srolsa^ul

'ln(
pu
noJ

-ql(

olJ
lue
.&re

-Ist

sI

'urIJ eril
Jo uo11cerlp prre sueld IIBJO^o aq] qll/y\ ]uelslsuoc sI Fulop er,nod ]Eqre ]Er{} erns
e{Bru nod dlaq uec sfeoF pue seIFe}E4s eJnlnJ s.sseulsnq or{} pue ssaulsnq
eql Jo slcadse IIB ]noqe $IIB] ]Er{} rrBld sser4snq IBruroJ e Jo &tlrqelge^e er{J
'dn-1re1s Fupo.o-rF dlplder B roJ suralsds uoIlEruJoJuI ]uerueFeueur JoJ ]ueplse:d
ecl poJlq ,finau eq] eJE nod 1eq1 auIFBuI 'eldurexa Jod 'ruJIJ Funod E Jo speaq
]uarugedep puoncunJ eql roJ InJesn d1:elncpred s1 ueld ssoulsnq B Jo oouelstxe
er{J 'Jarrrreru InJesod;nd pue }ue}slsuoc E 14 pJBly\JoJ aloru pue cuds u1 elerado
y
seedoldrua
oIIJ-prrB->IrrEJ
s,ruJIJ
e
sdlaq
osp
ueld
sseulsnq
uenlr
a
dlreelc
JIOSII ueld
er{} sE aIqenIE^ sE eq deru ueld aqt Funrrff\ Jo ssecord eq} 'dlplder eFueqc op
ueuo prre uec seceldle>IJeru ]Bq] eru] s,11 qFnor{}M 'po}Bp}no z{p1cpb eruoceq
m/y\ rreld due 1eq1 dlplder os seFueqc eceldle{reru eq} esneceq ueld sseulsnq
B elp\\ o] erun Jo alse/y\ B s.1I ]Bq] anF:e slradxa eruos 'saadoldrue elIJ-puB
-{trBJ or{} pue ruee} luerueFeueru eq} q}oq JoJ }rrBpodrul sI 'ruJIJ E Jo sueld
eJnlnJ prre UoISI aq] seIEInJIUB ]Bq] euo 'ue1d sseulsnq ue]]Urn d1-ree1c y

Sn
ITB

'sl
rur
da

do
-IS

}x
o/r

ut
q
/Y\(

af,

saefioldurl srluJIJ V
r{JEe }B >IooI s,}e.l 'ue1d sseulsnq s,rrrJIJ B JoJ secuelpne ztrerugd

olq

'ulerl] Jo
eJB eJOr{J

LroIEuIrIooT ,terlfi ery lrqfl\ pue


ssoulsnE eql speeu orl/h

-lrBld

xq)
0)

',{1epg4 1see1 1e 'ssor4snq ,reu JoJ


" eq
eepl -rnof o1 .ua1s11. o1 eurg dn o3{ IIIr!( srolsearrl 'due I ',ra; d.ren .lcEer rrEO
/s qclt{a ol ?qq}euos rolselr4 rre saa$ osp ueld sser4snq E Bupreg 'rre1d aq1
aredard o1 iCressacau d8:aua puB aurn oLIl +sa uI trl ern1rraa
arp o1 qBnoue
^[au seq .rnauerd
p3lllrrruroc q prre
ssor4snq
qcee qFnorql tq?nor11
aq+
lueur3la
Jo
-o4ue erp
s1se33ns
osle
atnlua
erfl lnoqe uoneruroJul pa1r-e]ep t1]1,tl
1zq1
lnq
nod
sappro:d
fluo
rreld
ssar4snq
e
seq rnauerderlua puooas ar1+ l"t1l lceJ
1ou
q ra.&srre eql ,pnba Ft4aq s8trpll .rsq1o

=.
0)

1'

lil

ilI:l
lii{r

=
o

,14
r!il1

E'

i.lii

iii

A)

,q
o

..:|:

ffi

6',

at11 'rnauards4ue puocas aql----6nol qo

rvesseulsnqrau'""*T^l.::iff

#I#,:;"'ffiH,o",'"HHJ::ti*i3"1?H-u

sseulsnq arp 'rtep lxau aql"rtlpmgoaao


srn8ua4s sq1 Bqnrgpno
"=..4".rq ",p 1o
3o qof 1ua11acxa ue op prre 1r4od arp o] pue dqrc ere qcp{ryl,sepqs erp q6no.rq1
{ool no 'Ftr.n:rour prou aq} a 1rrB IIIAI rrEld ssaursnq eq1 lerp alou B r[+I.lr\ xoq-r4
peur-a -rnod 14 s1 uopuluasard 1t4odJa.ercd er{l talel o q ro rnoq uy .ueld ertr1 1o
rllallre o rre seppord lEtB uons+ueserd 1r4o6rano4 apIIs-OI E qlpr Fuop ,uqd
ssar46nq a?ed-gg e go ,{doc e nod pren:o; o1 pep aq plno^\ eqs lerp sdzs rnau
-arde:1us etp 'er4q slur 'lsenbar errres aql e{Errr prrz rnerrardarlua puocos erg
fcsluoc no 'sEapl sFI ssncslp ()1 nort rppn raq1a3o1 laE o1 e^ol plno !. 1nq rreld
ssarlsnq purJoJ e psredard 1.useq aq lerp si(es prrE lICl E sa1u11seq rnauardarlue
aq1 'rre1d ss3r4snq s1q go ddoc E JoJ {sE prre rnauardarlua 16Jg ar.n lceluoc no

9l

N\fld ssfMsns v 9NutuM

I srrdvHc

1Bo

pART

2 I

DEVELopTNG succESSFUL BUSTNESS TDEAS

greater than lower-risk investment alternatives. The same is true for potential
business partners, customers, and key recruits. Unless the new business can
show that it has impressive potential, investors have little reason to become
involved with it.
Investors vary in terms of the reliance they place on formal business
plans.s Initially, many investors ask for a PowerPoint deck or the executive
of a business plan. A PowerPoint deck is a short set of PowerPoint
"rm*ary
slides that describe a business idea, and an executive summary is a one- to
two-page overview of the full plan. If their interest is sufficiently peaked, in
some cases investors will ask for a full business plan, and in other cases they
won't. It's still necessarJr to have a business plan, however. If an investor commits, in most cases a business plan will be required during the due diligence
phase. Due diligence refers to the_ process investors go through after they tenlatively commit to an investment.e The commitment is based on a thorough investigation of the merits of the venture, whether any legal complications exist,
and whether the claims made in the business plan are accurate and realistic.
A firm must validate the feasibility of its business idea and have a good
understanding of its competitive environment prior to presenting its business plan to others. Sophisticated investors, potential business partners, and
key recruits will base their assessment of a proposed firm's future prospects
on facts, not guesswork or platitudes, as emphasized in Chapter 3. The most
compelling facts a company can provide in its business plan are the results of
its own feasibility analysis and the articulation of a distinctive and competitive business model. A business plan rings hollow if it is based strictly on an
entrepreneur's predictions of a business's future prospects. Modi$z Watches, a
retailer of custornizable watches, is an example of a business that laid a firm
foundation for its business plan via the feasibility analysis that it conducted
very early on. Modi[z Watches is the focus of Case 3.1.
In addition to the previously mentioned attributes, a business plan should
disclose all resource limitations that the business must address before it is
ready to start earning revenues. For example, a firm may need to hire service
people before it can honor the warranties for the products it sells. It is foolhardy for a new venture to try to downplay or hide its resource needs. One
of the main reasons new ventures seek out investors is to obtain the capital
needed to hire key personnel, further develop their products or services, lease
office space, or fill some other gap in their operations. Investors understand
this, and experienced investors are typically willing to help the firms they fund
plug resource or competency gaps.

Guidelines forWriting a Business Plan


oBJEGTIVE There are several important guidelines that should inlluence the writing of a
3. Discuss the guidelines t0 business plan. It ts important to remember that a firm's business plan is typifottow to write an effective cally the ffrst aspect of a proposed venture that an irrvestor will see. If the plan
business plan.
is incomplete or Iooks sloppy, it is easy for an investor to infer that the venture
itself is incomplete and sloppy.lo It is important to be sensitive to the structure, content, and style of a business plan before sending it to an investor or
anyone else who may be involved with the new lirm. Table 6.1 lists some of the
"red flags" that are raised when certain aspects of a business plan are insufficient or miss the mark.

LEARNING

Structure of the Business Plan


To make the best impression, a buslness plan should follow a conventional
structure, such as the oufllne shown in the next secflon. Although some entrepreneurs want to demonstrate creauvity in everything they do, departing

T
I

].uprp ]ErIl ueld ssaulsnq E pe^Iecer ecuo erl ]Eq] {ooq slq} Jo sroq}nB eq} plo}
ue.\J JolSsArr! euo 'pesn eq o1 Fu1o3 sB1\4. dsuoru 3q]
Jo 'p3p3eu duedruoc
^{oq
qcns 'uollerrrroJul ]ue1
arlr iauoru qcnru
'spue4 ,ft1snpur ]rrecgTuFls se
^\oq
sJo}salul o} }ues sueld ssar.4snq }noqe selJo}s snoJarunu
-rodnl lno ]JeI ]Br{}
arB srerll'pe]]Fuo ueaq sBr{ uonBruJoJr4 IBJBIJJ ou ]Br{} erns e{Bru o} prrB 'JBr.u
-uerF 'Fuqleds roJ poly\al aJ eq ppor{s 11 'palaldruoc s1 ueld sseulsnq B Ja}JV
'xlpuedde LrB u1 -readde uec
'sJneueJde4ue Fulpuno; er{} Jo sgrrrnsgJ erp se qcns 'uoI}BruJoJuI .Funroddng
'lualrlJJns ere (saFed gt ueq] gG ol resolr {1ec1d,Q pue) seFed gt o} 96 'sue1d
]sotu Jod ']seJelul JepEaJ ulelu;eur o] qFnoua Uor{s 1ad 'uolleruJoJul }uoIO.rJJns

Fur
-ue
IBIIoI

-Jns

eql
JO J

ueld
-Idr(

uEld ssaulsng sql lo luoluo3

eJn

appo-rd o1 q8noua Fuol eq ]snru ]I 'eJnlue,\ rrorr pasodo-rd


slcedse ]uE]
--rodrul eq] IIE uo uorleruJoJul eslcuoc prrE JEaIc anIF ppoqs "qt;o
ueld sseulsnq dql

-Jr

EJO

8r'ss^Iesrrrsq] sselr
-ISnq eql Jo sJoleeJc eq] dq paqslldruocce lsaq {sE} B-ern}uel
B punorrns
^4.eu
]Eq] sep{Iqlssod eq1 }noqe }uerue}Icxe prre uopedlcpue Jo esuos e lcafo-rd o1
speau ueld sseulsnq e 'se-rnFIJ pue slrEJ r{rpr Fuoly 'ue1d eq} Jo ror{}ne dleru
-IJd ern eq ],uplnor{s rosl pB epls}no Jo }rre}fnsuoJ B 'eIqISSod se puolssa;o-rd
sB s>Iool ueld E lern eJns Fuqeu Jo ocl pE Fug1aF qlyy\ Fuorzn Fulqlou sI eJeql
{Fnoq11y 'sue1d ssoulsnq JIeq} e}1l o} sJosI.\pE epls}no Jo s}ue}Insuoc eJIq
sessoulsnq aruos 'ssarrlsnq IEnpI lpu1^. er1] ot perol.re] eq [-r]s ppoqs uBId eq] uI
uolleruroJul eq]
'arul] Fuyres prre arnlrrl-us Fqpno:d u1 pgdleq aq deu aFe
]nq
-qced aJEAlJos er{J 'ocJnos
E ruo-g errreJ
sB s{ool }Br{} uEId
}I
.,peulrec,,
eFnoql
e1e1d-ra11oq B pIoAE plnoqs s:neuerdeJlua 'Je.\err.oH
.,'InJdlaq d.ren e:e surerF
-o:d eseql Jo eruos 'ue1d sseulsnq e go FuRua erfl rrl ]slsse o] qceoJdde uezlgp
-nrroru 'el-rlceJelul uE doldrue ]Bq] eIqE[.rB^e are saFe4ced ere^qJos due6

l.t"fliH"t:

aryF drdruls lq;su er{s ro er{ 'orer, }.usr }snf !.T:1,fil"t=T'"? H


-aq Fulqleruos JoJ ]unq o] seq rolsolrrr ue JI 'uo11eurtoJul IBoIIIJc puIJ d11sea uec
d"qt eJeqa rrBld E ]ue{y\ pue eldoed dsnq.{ra.r ere sro}selur 'd1pc1dd1 'e>IB}sIru
e dlpnsn sI ]eru-ro; ueld sseulsnq IBuoIlueALroJ erp Jo eJnlcrurls cISEq erfl ruo{

pur
puE
esB

IE}I

3u(
-Io(
ac!,

SI:
PI

pe
tu

e''
IIB

-rl
Jo
fir;rqrperc s,rneuelderluo arll UnL{ pue
llelop ol uotluopeut se uoos oJE solelsr.u 1o sedfi osor.,l1'Bere {ue ur sseurddols io 'ecuplpq
l,uop leql sloot-,ls ocuplpq 'sod{1 q6norql open ropeal e e}Eu o} popt poo6 E Janau st }l
'{;>1ctnb {ltltqtperc ute6 lueur6pnl pue qcJeosol punos {q pe>1ceq s}uauo}E}s
pouoseol-11enn leqos '1ser1uoc u1 {y;rqrperc osol crlsrr-r-rr1do [1;ecrlsrlee.run Jo peuoseol
suotlcelo.r6 'ueld orll ]o uoryod slilt o] [;lcetrp dr>1s stolsenur Aueyl

[lrood ote

]EL,ll

&lsnput otll utt-lltnn


ctltceds
e
ro
e
oJnluen
/v\au
eq1 '{;snornq6
lolJetu
lueu6es
1e6;e1
llrn
'poutlop lolloq oq oI spoou firunpoddo lolrptu eq1 ';n1d;aq +,usl {.r1snpur
;ecrpeceut.reqd
;eqo16 eul] le6rB+ llt^ oJnluon eu e leL.ll 6ur{es 'e;dulexe JoJ 'po4t}uepr Aprealc uooq }ou
^ sA oLls Ilpeo.rq ool
seLl loltetu le6lel onJl otll leq]
oJnluon A ou e lo1 IaIJEtu orll 6ururle6

eere fiue u; sseurddo;g

slercueuU enrsser66e

ezrs

lolretu

{;leng

{lpeolq oo1
eq1 6urur1e6

'ps+lc aq plnoL,ls

6e1g peg

uorleue;dx3

ISU le {euour unno


rlotll Jo ouou qlr^ siopunol

},ueJB srepuno} aL4} ll

tlcJPosor fuepuoces pue fuetuud ||e JoJ socrnos oql'ueddeq llt/v\ ,,sIU[-11,, rneueldal]uo
ro IJoA SSen6 1ou 'qcreeser punos pue ocuoprno plel-,; uo +ltnq oq plnoLls ueld y

ue;d peyc {pood

uE +eqm

eoslo euo[ue plnoqs {qan

'>1su 1e

{euour ul o ltor.l} md o}

6u11;lrvr

supld ssaulsng q s6e1g


L8t

N\fld SS]N/SNSV ENU-IUM

pog I'S HTgIftr

U]IdVHC

1g8

pART

2 I

DEVELopTNG succESSFUL BUSTNESS IDEAS

include any contact information for the entrepreneur. Apparently, the entrepreneur was so focused on the content of the plan that he or she simply forgot
to provide contact information on the business plan itself. This was a shame,
because the investor was interested in learning more about the business idea.la
mw ffimwwem* w# &fum ffiwmw*meww ffiffimme The plan's appeara.nce must be
carefully thought out. It should look sharp but not give the impression that a lot
of money was spent to produce it. Those who read business plans know that entrepreneurs have limited resources and expect them to act accordingly. A plastic
spiral binder including a transparent cover sheet and a back sheet to support
the plan is a good choice. When writing the plan, avoid getting carried away with
the design elements included in word-processing programs, such as boldfaced
t54re, italics, different font sizes and colors, clip art, and so forth. Overuse of
these tools makes a business plan look amateurish rather than professional.15
One of the most common questions that the writers of business plans ask is,
"How tong and detailed should it be?" The answer to this question depends on
the type of business plan that is being written. There are three types of business
plans, each of which has a different rule of thumb regarding length and level of
detail. Presented in Figure 6.2, the three types of business plans are as follows:
ffi&grKm

ffi Summary plan: A summary business plan is 10 to 15 pages and works


best for companies that are very early in their development and are not
prepared to write a full plan. The authors may be asking for funding to
conduct the analysis needed to write a full plan. Ironically, summary
business plans are also used by very experienced entrepreneurs who may
be thinking about a new venture but don't want to take the time to write
a full business plan. For example, if someone such as Drew Houston, the
co-founder of Dropbox, was thinking about starting a new business, he
might write a summary business plan and send it out to selected investors to get feedback on his idea. Most investors know about Houston's
success l,^rith Dropbox and don't need detailed information. Dropbox, the
subject of Case 2.1, is a free file hosting service that was founded in 2OO7
and is now being used by more than 2OO million people across the world.
ffi Full business plan: A fult business plan is typically 25 to 35 pages long.
This type of plan spells out a company's operations and plans in much
more detail than a summary business plan, and it is the format that is
usually used to prepare a business plan for an investor.
ffi Operational business plan: Some established businesses \ rill write an
operationd business plan, which is intended primarily for an internal
audience. An operational business plan is a blueprint for a company's operations. Commonly running between 4O and 100 pages in length, these
plans can obviously feature a great amount of detail that provides guidance to operational managers.

ffiffiffiwffiffi ffi-ffi
Types of Business Plans
l0-15

pages

Works best for


new ventures in the earlyi
stages of development I

that want to "test

the

waters" to see if
investors are interested
in their idea

25-55 pages

40-100 pages

Works best for


new ventures that are at

ls meant primarily for


an jnternal audience;
works best as a tool for
creating a blueprint for
a new venture's
operations and providingi
guidance to operational
managers

the point where they


need funding or
financing; serves as a
"blueprint" for the
company's operations

:
-

p3cnpo4rll
'ueld ssaulsnq 'sseuelsldruoc Jo ssodmd aq] roJ sJaq ulaql spnlJr4 3'Ix. :Z'9 eIqEJ t4
polso66ns sluerrl3le eql IIe epnlcr4 lou oP sueld sseulsnq lsotr I 'srneuords4ue FuIBmoJ

p lo ourmo

e iqucsJp pue

inuapt

''

eql Jo

aql pu ss3rfi.snq atn Jo aJnlzu aq] uo Fr4puadap

=lrnrrJ"o'=rrd
rurcxlao cl{rNErrxl "oria "g'I""ag 'Z'9 eIqEJ r4 srEadde ueld sset4snq 11ry etpJo aqnno

'(eur
y

"{re'r
pelsaFFns

ueld ssoulsnE arll Jo oulllno

'eJrrleal -tu{d lelJneue-rda-r1ug dLrte5,, eW ut peJapIS


-uoc eJE seuo pelEIeJ pue sensq aseILL ',{+snpr4 JIaq} Jo dlllnelol pue sseu/Y\au
eq] puB slsdleue d11gq1see3 IBIIIuI r-ratl.+ 3o dlppnb eID uo paseq 'sJeqlo ueq] erolu
.Fo"q, [Iry\ sesseulsnq eluos .{cBqpeeJ IEuoBlppe uo pesBq 'peqcun,el s.}I Ja}JP
sselrlsnq aqt ]ErB paledlcpue osIE s.]I sr'ua11gznFu1
eFueqc pu"
"lerell ruA\JIaslI
-3q s.l,I se aFueqc o1 ueld eq] esnEc ILr,r, aldoad de4 asaql ruo4 peulBlqo {rBqpaeJ
eq] ]eql pIIB 'sJeqlo plIB 'sraulred ssat4snq 's:aqddns 'SJeulolsnc p11ua1od qlII&
eceld 1gm 's1sd1eue ,(fmqtsea; Fulpacard eq] pIrB 'ue1d
qcno] uI srepu.ol
"qf
'>ISep e }B
aq1 elalduroc o] pelcnpuoc I{3JBOS3J eID }EIil paledlcpge sI }I 'pge}sul
uogElosl uI u3nu1Y\ lueurncop cnBls B eq o] pepuel4 ]ou q ]I ]ErD prrelsrspun
ppor{s LrBId sseulsnq e Fuldolalep esoq} 'Jsrres sr-q} uI 'sesofund p;asn dueur
se res prrE eJnlue^ l\,\au B JoJ 1u1Od Fuprels ltrepodrul ue sluesa-rdar 'slsdlerre d11
jIqISEeJ e dq pepeerord 'ue1d ssel4snq E IEII1 FqrnFre 'uoplsod ellsoddo eq] e{B}
e^, '{ooq SIID q 'BepI eq} uo e}ncexe o} Iepou ssel4snq pIIE BspI sseulsnq E uo
F.ryni"= o1 -rogd srerrrolsnc e4lcedso-rd uro{ dpca4p >IceqpeeJ Fqlpqos Jo eare
ern-r4 dpelncp-red 'seap1 luaIIOJxe dueru sasnodse ']ueruelorrr dq;e1g uB3'-I 3rD
qlyy\ pelelcosse sI qcII!!\ 'qceordde sr-t1l r,'Fu.nrueld purro; JeAo {ceqpesJ Jaluo}
-*n, qFno-rq1 pauealF Fulureal Jorre-puB-IeFI pue uollBlueurpadxe selecolpe
q e Fupgn Jo EepI aIII sasoddo 1eq1 1r{Fnoq1 Jo Iooqcs Fulfireue
pue ueld
"..,r1"t
'uengrY\ Fuleq aF+Y\ aFrreqc dgensn sueld sseulsnq esnceg
rre sI oJOID
'seepl pue slqFlsu1
B Jo
A4.eu o1 uedo pug UoIB rrlBrrreJ 01 sJnauarderlua selooqeq ]I pu 'duedtuoc
aJII eq] lrroqfit orrp sanunuoc ssecord sItL 'sraqlo ruo4 >IceqpeeJ FuntaF Ue1s
p,re o=14 aq1 Fuplrzn uI sellasueql esJeruul srneue:darlua ueq/Y\ eFretua dlqe
rlraN 'seAIoAe sseulsnq eq] sB pIIE ue]]1rm Fuleq sI ]I se afiueqc
-rrrrt l
grrn ueld aql ]BID ezluFoceJ o1 s1 rreld sseulsnq e Fullgzvr roJ euII
dlpnsn"fqflisul
-eplnF IBuIJ v *ffiwmxwp swffi xetrd 3rI1 Io sllral-aIffi ffis&s ffiuxgmgwffi##@w
'alBplpuBc rolse^ul aIqEI e Fulaq Jo sISEq etfl uo p3]reles d1n;erec eq pFoqs
rrBld ,,ilio ddoc B selleceJ oq/K uosred qcea 'pEo]sul '1s11 eq] uo euod.rele o] uBId
.qi p,r"" d1pqlq pIIB sro}selul Jo }s11 E LrIE]qo o] q ,{Fe1e4s rood e 'FuIpunJ roJ
']I Fulzrlacer [BnpI IpuI
Fup4ool sI eJnluel /\\eu B JI 'oI raldeq3 rr.r passncslp sv
eq] o] t r." Fulaq s1 ueld sseulsnq aq1 dryn elels d1-ree1c puB rneuerde-que eq1
acnpo4t4 dualrq plnoqs ra]13l re^oc atf,l 'LrBlu aq1 qFnorIS srsploqe{B}s ral{}o
Jo Jolse1r.4 rrp o] ]ues rreld sser.4snq e drredruocc ppoqs Janol JeAoc Y
sE 4. I sseulsnq eII] Jo FupuelsJepun Je]laq qcnu e Fupreq
er'eJeeJc of Fulrtq
'sue1d
eru uI pellnseJ lnq IFoIJJIp pue 'Frr.nrrnsuoc etun 'snolpel sdemle lsoIuIE s.11
sseulsnq snoJerunu FugUm uI pellolu-r sery\ I 'tneueldeJlue tre sV 'lnJesn dlqlperc
-uI sI IIBId ssoulsnq e FupgzvrJo eslrraxa eql 'roop eq] u1 ]eF o1 IEcIlUc ssel sI ueld
sseulsnq IBIuroJ B ellqr\A. 'r(epoa '(sCrf pue sleFue) secrnos Fupun; lsoru qlPA uols
-sncslp -ro;1u1od,(r1ue rre se..v\ 1I 1u-rod euo lV 'pJBr{ s1 ueld sseulsnq pooF e FuPu &

:aloJr\. oqlvr'opEJoIoC Jeplnog t4 paseq 1sge11dec eJnluelB 'ple.t[ pBJg dq peurrg


-JB sI ]uelupuas gII{J 'dl1pn1ul 3uo roJ >ISB },IIop deql JI uele '1ue1rodur1 s1 ueld
sseulsnq IInJ B FunUzn Jo ssaco:d aq1 e el1eq sJo]selur ]soMuol]BruJo]4 eroru
JoJ {sB II.I ,r aqs Jo eq 'panbld sI }SeJeI4 s,Jo}selul aLI} JI 'ecuexncco uouruoc
e q s-II{L 'pet1rJele eq }.uop 'ue1d aleldruoc eq} ueq} Jeq}eJ uEId ssaulsnq rnod
w JI
;o ltreururns ell]ncexe eII[ Jo {cep }t4odJe \od e JoJ nod slse Jo}Se^uI

68t

N\fld ssSN/sngv eNU-luM

it:

rlt
:
:
rl
..

'I

-p
ese

-do
[B

'Fuol
.PIJ(
LOO

eql
-S

eq]
elI
deu

s{
:Sr

JO I

ssel

uo
.SI

9I

Jor
psc

LI}!

uo
cnl
-u

]oI
eq
VT

'e

1o

-e

I I Ull-dVHc
I

1go

pARr

W,F&ffiffi.ffi

2 I

DEVELoptNG succESSFUL BUSTNESS TDEAS

ffi"ffi Business Plan Outline

Cover Page
Table of Gontents

l.
ll.

Executive Summary
lndustry Analysis
lndustry Size, GroMh Rate,
and Sales Projections

VIl.

lndustry Structure

lll.

Nature of Participants
Key Success Factors
lndustry Trends
Long-Term Prospects
Company Description
Company History

Product, Price, Promotions, and Distribution


Sales Process (or Cycle)
Sales Tactics
Design and Development Plan
Development Status and Tasks
Challenges and Risks
Projected Development Costs
Proprietary lssues (Patents, Trademarks,
Copyrights, Licenses, Brand Names)

Vlll. Operations Plan

Mission Statement
Products and Services
Current Status
Legal Status and Ownership
Key Partnerships (if any)
lV. Market Analysis
Market Segmentation and Target Market Selection
Buyer Behavior
Competitor Analysis
Estimates of Annual Sales and Market Share
V. The Economics of the Business
Revenue Drivers and Profit Margins
Fixed and Variable Costs
Operating Leverage and lts lmplications

Start-up Costs
Break-Even Chart and Calculation

Vl. Marketing Plan


Overall Marketing Strategy

IX.

General Approach to Operations


Business Location
Facilities and Equipment
Management Team and CompanY

Structure
Management Team (lncluding a Skills
Profile)
Board of Directors
Board of Advisors

Company Structure

X. Overall Schedule
Xl. Financial Projections
Sources and Uses of Funds Statement
Assumptions Sheet
Pro Forma lncome Statements
Pro Forma Balance Sheets
Pro Forma Cash Flows
Ratio Analysis

Appendices

Exploring Each $ection of the PIan


Pmgm mse# ffmfuffim m# #mss*ear*w The cover page should include the
company's name, address, and phone number; the date; the contact information for the lead entrepreneur; and the company's website address if it has
one. The company's Facebook page and TWitter name can also be included.
The contact information should include a land-based phone number, an e-mail
address, and a smartphone number. This information should be centered at
the top of the page. Because the cover letter and the business plan could get
separated, it is wise to include contact information in both places. The bottom
of the cover page should include information alerting the reader to the confidential nature of the plan. If the company already has a distinctive trademark,
it should be placed somewhere near the center of the page. A table of contents
should follow the cover letter. It should list the sections and page numbers of
the business plan and the appendices.
ffimwmw

The executive summarlr is a short overview of the


entire business plan; it provides a busy reader -itf, everything she needs to
know about the new venture's distinctive nature.l9 As mentioned earlier, in
ffixcmmxx*&ww Srmmc,ffimffi#$r

(penu4uoc)

;ueld ssoursnq

s1r

pe6ueqc l,uppr.,l lr

tr qnHqnr3 o1 peueddpL.l o^eLl plno^ IulLll no{ op


1,ue|d sseursnq leu;6;ro

}pr.l6 'Z

sll r]llM 1cq1s A1lnt

-ssoccns ol elqe uooq spLl Aueduuoc or.ll ),lulL.li no{ op


{qnn 'pepunol sEA^ lcryOuog uoql 'LOOZ ocurs }euJe}ul
or.ll r.lll/v\ peueddeq a^ELl leql se6ueqc oLl] lle eltdse6

't

...
'uollllq

sel

'ue.r6elsul

looqocel

)otZIOZ

ur

leq6

6ur>1se

onell

plnol pue 'sJorrolsnc

1eO plnonn

Outlstxe [uo;] sropro orotu

uorlrsod r-unrurerd e ur poceld sluernelsor all]

]eql sel Eopr ol{l 'oUSqoA sU uo uorlrsod unrure;d e ur


pecepd aq o] poluem lelll sluernplsor rol oo; uotlducs
-qns E Dur6reqc Aq Aeuou o)eu pue oorl ro1 sluernelsor
lsll plnon qnHqnJO 'loporu 6urcr.rd ,,ulnruleor1,, e uo

poseq senn uegd ssoursnq lelllul eL,l1 'sso;ppe oc41o Jo


oruol-l s,rosn relncryed e ol Jonllop IeL{} s}uerne}sor oL.l}
lle polsrl lprll oUSqoM e dn 1es o] sE^ Bopt oql 'oltsqon^
eldurrs e sE VOOZ ur ue6eq qnHqnJC
6ur1sr1 ]ueJnESoJ

L$

papoaN e6ueqg roupffi-qngqnrC

'tuor.l+ o]
pe;rnbce senn uer6plsul
^lolEultxo.ldde

^q'soeprn pue sernlcrd oxe] ol srosn


sJollg pilOlp Aldde pue
slr s^ ollE leql oorruos Ourlronnlou lercos pue '6ur.reL,ls-ooprn
'6uueqs-o1oqd eurluo rc1ndod {leprnn e ou sr ure;6e1su1
^ oxll pue '1ueur
'sery;rqedeo
Uol sen

-tuoo '6uueqs-opqd eq1 sEA lr '1no pau;nl I sV '+sou ell]


o] olnquluoc plnoc [eq1p1pue poIU Aeql e.rnleel ro dno.r6
auo all] o1 u^ op uqrng peddrils {eq1 'og ';;enn {leuol}xo }!
uo olncoxo pue oJnleo] e;6urs e lcrd o] sEA qceordde lseq
otll ]eLll popnlcuoc ,teql 'pojoprsuocoj pue IcEq peddels
Aeql og 'oreqs lolJeru rol EIlpMoC pue e.renbsrnol q1m
+no 1! 1q6!J o1 eneq plnonn {eq1 'po}srxo i{peer;e 'ellen
pue e.renbsrnol 'secrnros Jelr.urs oA 'ssouenglrleduroc

oe
s1r

]noqe pourol^ os;e {eq1 'so;n}Bo} r-,lirl uruJono pue palo}


-+nlc llol +l ruotll oI'I elll l,uplp.reOeuy pup tuorls{g-urel
-qord {1uo eq1 '6urpun; ul 000'009$ pp'l pup 'zznq po}e
-roue6 peLl 'ouop {le1elduroc sen y 'ree[ e rono Jo] uqrng
uo polron re6euy pue r.r.rorlsAg 'dde ol1l oprsur sernlcrd
o;eLls pue 'spueul iror..l] Lllr^ lno Our6ueq rol slurod uree
'suo11eco; o1 ul Icoqc plnoo srasn 'e.,lenbsrnoJ o] relr.urs
ocrruos posPq-uollBcol e se^ uqJng 'uqrn8 polpc ocrruos
-ur-Ioaqc E uo Ourlroan oro^ re6euy o),lly\ pue urorls{g
urnoy s;opunol-oo 'sr ll ]ErJl 1q 6uueqs-o1oqd oql ouecoq
ue;6e1su1oloJog 'lp lE uerOe1su1 l,usel ]soule urer6elsul
papaaN seEueqg ro [etrtr1-urer6e1su1
uo pece;d eq ol

'eusqo^ sll
sluernelsor ur oseorcur crletuplp

B MES qnHqnrC 'epetu senn e6ueqc oql JoUV 'peceld


r-,lcpo JoJ uorssr.utuoc e polcolloc {eql o;aqn

ropro

lopotu lpuorlcesur..l.l e o1 'ece1d ulnrure;d E JoI sluelne1


-ser pe6reqc [eq1 olel.l^ ']opou Durcud uorlducsqns e
luoJl por-1olrn S {ueduoc eq1 'ue1d ssoutsnq s}! oslnaJ
o] qnHqnrg peldurotd slqOrsut asol,1 :lopro ue peceld
Josn qnHqniC e uoq^ qnHqnle Aed oI peluenn {1uo
Aeql 1eq1 Jeolc olo^ sJor.uolsnc s1; 'ueddeq 1ou lq6lur
ro lqOru leL1t soles roJ +uoJI dn 6urfied L,l]r^ olqepo]r.uoc
] ueron^ lnq '6urop oJoA Aeql leqnn ponol sluetnelsel
leLl] pazrlBor qnHqnlc lo slopunoJ eq1 'uo ]uo^ orutl sv
'sreluolsnc A ou l{q ,,perenocsrp,, 6ureq ooueqc Jouaq e
ex*m*Segseige! ;Js##yrqg fexxmx#egsarg

'r.lluoru red sresn uorllnu


I rono seL.l A ou olrs ol.ll 'pe6ueqcun pouretuer seq ueld
ssoursnq s1r 'sreed oLll .rono s6uue;;o ocrnJos slr pacueq
-ua sEL,l 1cr16uog allqM 'o}!sqon sU uo s}olct} uocuoc
Ourgles

{q Aeuou seIELU 1ct16uog 'ede irotl} ur o}ep

Jno] B ocunouue sJelu;olod esoql

uoql

Uolp uocuoc

pozrleuosred e ureu{} pues 11rnn >1cr16uos pue 'e1t; Aeql ste


-ruro;red ol,ll IceJ] upc slosn 'uop;ee erenbg uostppy\ 1e
OurIeld qcuo[eg ot qnlc]qOlu lecol e ]e Outfegd pueq etp
-ur ue uror]-uorlecol fuene ur Outueddeq s,1eql uocuoc
fuene ]noqe MouI ol sr uorssttu sll 'olqpltene spocuoo
6urluocdn Jo oseqeiep onrsuor.,lorduroc ISot! otll ole
-oJc o] srededsanou lecol pue 'salrsqon enusn 'sropuen

lo)cl] lo roqunu e6rel e soxopur 1cry6uog 'ue;qord


srr.,ll o^los 01 'eos oi oxll p,r{eq} uocuoc E ssll.u },uo^
suEI orsnu ]eq+ ainsuo l,usoop pue sseco;d [sutn;c
p s! srqf 'sjoilols/v\ou uacuoc cueueo q6no.rq1 6ul;lns
pue 'selrsqoln pueq 6uulceqc 's1st; ;teu;-o onuon o1 6ut
s.reo6pecuo3
-qucsqns {q uuelqord srrl} pro^e ol
'ea)e
^r}esnecoq spueq
roL{}
ur orom Aeql r',roul },uplp {eq1
Jror.l+ Ourees uo lno Durssrtu sronol orsnu sr

oluonpl

so^los {uedr-uoc eq} Lr-rolqord eq1 'qpeOog upl pue 'no1


ollor.fcrt/\ 'Ll1lurs e1e6 Aq LOOZ ur popunol

se^

1cu16uog

papeeN sa6ueqg oN-{c;46uog


'souloolno snor;en osel,ll pecueuedxe onpq ]eq]
sossoursnq ]o suorlducsep ]ouq oJE 6urnnollo1 aLlf rono
uBls o] spaou ssaursnq oLll puE A opur^ oq} ]no uA orL.l]
oq o] spoeu ]r soseo JeL,llo lllls ul pue 'poleennl {;1uecr1ru
-6;s eq o] spoeu ueld e 'sosec roLllo u1 'ue1d oql ruoJ+
fuen sr op plnoo ropuno1 e 6ulrll lslol or.l+ pue uo-+ods
sr ueld ssaursnq p 'sosec ouos ul 'souen pouorsrnuo s;o
-puno] JraLl] se 1no ued sue;d sssursnq qclq/v\ o1 eer6ep
or.{} }ng 'ueld s,Lur4 oLl} o} oper.u oq o} paou 1lrnn se6ueqc
or.uos 'soseo lle lsotxle ul 'Iceqpool Jetuolsnc Durnrecet
Uels {eul} pue poqcunel sr sseursnq oq} ocuo UB;d -."".ssoursnq ror.,ll o] Iolls o1 A;esogc nnoq DuruluJrol
-ep sl a^Bq s;eumo ssoursnq se6uel;eqc oull ,ro au ir,_

qoaqacel

q$#dqfl',"$Sr& ;Js6S/qA fry*6gqruC

-ry*gryS***s& ;ie$"$#deg 3rycsry$uos

"'s*.sss.rx*#*Srysx,xryy;#g*ag

:E#/yt ;urex#m6sr."r1

qooqergr faxx**"rym*,yqrrxff"ffi##d ;q#** rryr?$dryf,frg


qaaqa*egr I*er*e"ry*p6#wos"r1fid?{i?! iry*d& ;ry*gry#uog

uroq,l pIoJ ol uor{]v\ /raoux 'uroq,l pIoH ol uoq/V\ /laoux

16r

N\fld SS]N/SNgV ONII-IUM

UfldVHC

192

PART

2 I

DEVELOPING SUCCESSFUL BUSINESS IDEAS

3. Why do you think some start-ups find it difficult to

change their business plan, even when presented with


evidence that their current business plan isn't working?
4, Look at the "You Be the VC" features at the end of
Chapter 3, which focus on August Smart Locks and
Blue Apron, and the "You Be the VC" features at the
end of this chapter, which focus on Buzzy and Flings
Bins. From the information in the features and on each
company's website, which company do you think will
have the easiest time sticking to its original business

plan? Which company do you think will have the hardest time? Explain your selections.
Sources; Songkick home page, www.songkick.com, accessed
February 28, 2014; GrubHub home page, www.grubhub.com, ac-

cessed February 28, 2014; lnstagram home page, http://instagram, accessed February 28,2014; B. Barringer and R. D. lreland,
Entrepreneurship: Successfully Launching New Ventures, 3rd edition, 2010; M. G. Siegler, "A Pivotal Point," Techcrunch, available at
http://techcrunch.com/201 0 / 1 1 /08/instagram-a-pivotal-point, accessed February 28, 201 4.

many instances an investor will first ask for a copy of a firm's PowerPoint
deck or executive summary and will request a copy of the full business plan
only if the PowerPoint deck or executive summary is sufficiently convincing.
Thus, certainly when requested, the executive s_ummary arguably becomes
the most important section of the business plan.2o The most critical point to
remember when writing an executive summary is that it is not an introduction or preface to the business plan; instead, it is meant to be a summary of
the plan itself.
An executive summary shouldn't exceed two single-spaced pages. The
cleanest format for an executive summary is to provide an overview of the
business plan on a section-by-section basis. The topics should be presented
in the same order as they are presented in the business plan. TWo identical
versions of the executive summary should be prepared-one that's part of
the business plan and one that's a stand-alone document. The stand-alone
document should be used to accommodate people who ask to see the executive
summary before they decide whether they want to see the full plan.
Even though the executive summary appears at the beginning of the
business plan, it should be written last. The plan itself will evolve as it's written, so not everything is known at the outset. In addition, if you write the
executive summary first, you run the risk of tryrng to write a plan that fits
the executive summary rather than thinking through each piece of the plan
independently.2l
ffimffiwmw*wp ffimemffipw&m The main body of the business plan begins by describing the industry in which the firm intends to compete. This description should
include data and information about various characteristics of the industry,
such as its size, growth rate, and sales projections. It is important to focus
strictly on the business's industry and not its industry and target market simultaneously. Before a business selects a target market, it should have a good
grasp of its industry-including where its industry's promising areas are and
where its points of vulnerability are located.
Industry structure refers to how concentrated or fragmented an industry
is.22 Fragmented industries are more receptive to new entrants than industries
that are dominated by a handful of large firms. You should also provide your
reader a feel for the nature of the participants in your industry. Issues such as
whether the major participants in the industry are innovative or conservative
and are quick or slow to react to environmental changes are the types of characteristics to convey. You want your reader to visualize how your firm will fit
in or see the gap that your firm will fill. The key success factors in an industry
are also important to know and convey. Most industries have 6 to 1O key factors in which all participants must establish competence as a foundation for
competing successfully against competitors. Most participants try to then differentiate themselves by excelling in two or three areas.

rc

'EepI cIlsEluEJ E sI ler{a- '{uFI} pue esned o1 euo osnec uele }HFtur }I 'e}BIeJ
s1 ztrols s.{Jo}S pue B}r{seJS
uBc euodue qclqrlt qlllll. euo sI pue
lIeJUEar{
'suoJJs JeIIsr relseslp;o ged
sB ]ues dluoruuoc sellddns eq] go ped e tqF11 pIVuIun'I eq] a{Brrr o} sI poF
s,dueduroc erIJ '1qFU Jo ecJnos elqe/v\eueJ 'oIqBUod E acnpo:d o1 pesn ueq \
setrBUuI prre '}EU paddqs eq uec lI ]Bq] u1 anbpn st IqFII relos pwuurn'I er{J
'ruelqo-rd slq] e^Ios o1 pIVuFun'I pepels {ro}S pue e}qsors '1qFU Jo {cEI sI
ruo.r; reJJns sruncp relseslp lsoru Fulrp euo 'suo1111ru Jo se^II aq1 1cedu1 d1ezr.r1
-eFeu uec relseslp E /!\oq puBInsJIJ pacuagedxe degJ 'OIOZ, q IIIEH u1 eceld
{oo} }BrI} e4enbqpee rofeu e dq pa}caJJe aldoad roJ urecuoc rler{} dq pe-r-rnds
sem IqFII or{} uFlsap o} uoI}BAIlou s,{ro}S prre B}r{sars 's}uopn}s d11s;errpn
EIqunIoC oryq '{Jo}S Burrv pue B}qsers Berprrv dq pepe}s se/v\ }Bq} dueduoc
lqFU JBIos B 'pr-Vultunl uo sesncog g raldeqC JoJ eJnlea; Fuluado eq1 'aldtuexa
Jo*f ']I 11e] ']IeJUBer{ sI ruo4 oruec dueduroc er{} JoJ EepI eq} eJer{.ly\;o ,iro1s aq1
g1 'uolldecul sll pupleq ecroJ Fuf,rUp eq] prrB ruo-r; eruec ,(ueduroc aql JoJ BepI
eq] arorry\ upldxe pFoqs ]nq Jolrq aq plnoqs uollcas d.ro1s1q duedruoc er{J
'sseulsnq E olul eepl rre elEISuB4 o] rv\oq zvrouq nod
]Eq] JepeeJ rno.r{ o} se}BJ}suoruep }I }ErD uI }uEuodrul dleue4xe sI }I 'sJal{}o
ueq] Iecngc ssal ruees detu uollces sFII acrrelF ts.rly 1e qFnoqlly 'dueduoc aI{}
yo uopdgcsap p-reueF E qllry\ sulFeq uonces sIr{J rxopdgmpffiffim Su*wffie"axwp

'd.rlsnpul eq] -ro; slcadso-rd ur:el-Fuol eql FupreFer sJeIIeq


:nod Jo luoruelels Jauq B r.IlIA epnlJuoc ppor{s slsrtleue drlsnpul eI{J 'tr/Kop Jo
dn FuloF orB slsoc 1ndu1 Jer{}aq/y\ pue Fuluqcep ro Fulseercul e-re .&rlsnpq eq}
uI sulF-reru lgoJd reqleqzn sB qcns senssl apnlcu1 spueJl sseulsng 'saFueqc
.,fto1e1nFe-r pue pc1111od pue 'seclrelpe [ec.rFolouqca] 'spueJ] IEIcos 'spueJl
c1ruouoce eJB spueJl IelueruuoJllue luelrodurl ]soru eqJ 'spueJ] ssoulsnq pIrB
IBluaruuorllue qloq epnlcq qc1tryrr 'pessncs1p eq ppor{s spue4 [r1snpu1

g
x

o
x
o
3
@

OJ
(o

o
o
o

o
a

'onorqce ol dn-ye1s
roi elqrssod {lecrlsrleor
],usr ler..ll pue e;qrssod

{1;ecrlsr;eer sr }eqn }no


sAe; fu1snpu! srtuJrl P
;o srsA;eue lnloJec V
'&1snpu1 or.l1 Jo ;er1ue1od

ornlnJ pue qllEoq oql

luouncop ol lueuodr.ur
s,1r 'fu1snpur ueple6 pue
fuesrnu oL,ll ul Iueduroc
E uels o1 ueld no{ 1;

e6t

N\fld ssfN/sns v

eN[luM

I usldvHc

:.:
=::'

--=

':i=

194

PART

2 I

DEVELOPING SUCCESSFUL BUSINESS IDEAS

That's just the type of solution that people recovering from a natural disaster
like an earthquake need."
A mission statement defines why a company exists and what it aspires
to become.23 If carefully written and used properly, a mission statement can
define the path a company takes and act as its financial and moral compass.
Some businesses also include a tagline in their business plan. A tagltine is a
phrase that a business plans to use to reinforce its position in the marketplace.
For example, Wello's tagline is "By., Bye G5rm Hello Convenience." Wello is an
online platform that allows participants to arrange workouts with trainers via
Slqrpe or another online means, which avoids having to make a trip to a grm'to
receive the same service.
The products and services section should include an explanation of your
product or service. Include a description of how your product or service is
unique and how you plan to position it in the marketplace. A product or service's position is how it is situated relative to its rivals. If you plan to open a
new type of smoothie shop, for example, you should explain how your smoothie
shop differs from others and how it will be positioned in the market in terms of
the products it offers and the clientele it attracts. This section is the ideal place
for you to start reporting the results of your feasibility analysis. If the concept
test, buying intentions survey, and library, Internet, and gumshoe research
produced meaningful results, they should be reported here.
The current status section should reveal how far along your company is
in its development. A good way to frame this discussion is to think in terms
of milestones. A milestone is a noteworthy or significant event. If you have
selected and registered your company's name, completed a feasibility analysis, developed a business model, and established a legal entity, you have aIready cleared several important milestones. The legal status and ownership
section should indicate who owns the business and how the ownership is
split up. You should also indicate what your current form of business ownership is (i.e., LLC, Subchapter S Corp., etc.) if that issue has been decided.
We provide a full discussion of the different forms of business ownership in
Chapter 7.
A final item a business should cover in this opening section is whether it
has any key partnerships that are integral to the business. Many business
plans rely on the establishment of partnerships to make them work. Examples
of the types of partnerships that are common in business plans are shown in
the "Partnering for Success" feature.
The market analysis is distinctly different from the industry analysis. Whereas the industry analysis focuses on the industry in which
a firm intends to compete (e.g.,toy industry, fitness center industry, men's
clothing industry), the market analysis breaks the industry into segments
arrd zeroes in on the specific segment (or target market) to which the firm will
try to appeal. As mentioned in Chapter 3, most start-ups focus on servicing a
specific target market within an industry.
The first task that's generally tackled in a market analysis is to segment
the industry the business will be entering and then identi$z the specific target
market on which it vrill focus. This is done through market segmentation,
which is the process of dividing the market into distinct segments. Markets
can be segmented in ma.ny ways, such as by geography (city, state, country),
demographic variables (age, gender, income), psychographic variables (personality, lifestyle, values), and so forth. Sometimes a firm segments its market
based on more than one dimension in order to drill down to a specific segment
that the firm thinks it is uniquely capable of serving. For example, in its market analysis, GreatCall, the cell phone serwice provided especially for older people, probably segmented the cell phone market by age and by benefits sought.
Some start-ups create value by finding a new way to segment an industry.
Wtmlrilrymt $&r*mtymf;ro

B eJoru er{J '}e{Jeur }aFJB} s.ruJIJ E uI sJerunsuoc eq} Jo JoI Er{eq eq} q}yr dpcer
-Ip spep ]Eq] sysdpue ]a{reru eq} u1 uonces B epnlcul o} }ue1rodu1 s.11

'plnq

prrB sprrBq JellBurs s.LrBr.uo/\. E elBpoulluoccE ]BrD

srellnF se{Eru }I }BrI} s1 aFelue^pe a^I}11aduroc s,rB}InC {cog ds1eq 'rapueF i(q
paluaruFes ueeq ]ou peq zt4snpur relpF eq] 'ueluo^{rr JoJ }snf sre}InF so{Bru
leq] dueduroc e 'JBlInC >IcoU dspq pegels oIoAEJIC qsIJ eJoJeq 'eldruexa rog

2,sercueleduoc o^rlcullslp slr uo snco] ol uleol


lueure6eueu dol slr olle pue sluoluertnbe; p1ldec sy
ro^ ol ol r.urol Azzng ^plnoc sdlqsreuyed 1o sed& +eqM
'loqs e Oulua6 Llllm pelelcosse Aletxe pue upd eq1
o^orlar sd;eq lEqI acrnep E poleoJc seq 1eull [ueduoc

e'rtzzng uo sosnco] einlps; ,, L'g Cn oLll oE no1,, oL4l 'n


'suosEor otll Jo

ouo sU] 1eq1d;qsreuued e 1o eldtrexo up sp!^ord 'turl1


ror1loup rllrm rouued plnonn uJll llelrs e fiqnn (etn1eel
slr.ll ul pouorluoru l(uoJe 1eq1) suoseor oA l oqucso6t 'e

;sdn-ye1s llpus L,ly^ Jauued [eq1 uoL1^ elel selued


-r.uoc e6re; op s)sp +etl111;setuedr-uoc Inlssoccns'e6re1
qlrm Ouueuued uor.l^ ecpl sr.uJ4 lleus op slslr leqM 'Z
leleduroc ol;euued ol stul+

e6Brnocue ]ueuuoJrnuo ssoursnq eql ur siolcel

lptl6 't

Eugulql IeclllrC Jo, suollsong


'sorlr^rlce aros Joqlo uo
snool o1[ueduoc p see;] pue (slcnpord e.lenngos sB qcns)
uoddns pue louuosred lueue6Bueut sscJnosoJ ueLunL{ ul
]uotulsonur s.url4 p ozr.ururru UBC sISEI osoL{} 6u1c;noslng
'sonssr polelor4cJnoser ueunq qldep-ur ojotu Joqlo puE
'ecuerldtuoc fuo1e1n6e;'6u1urer1'6ur.r;'6uulq qpn dn-uels

ro) rcrnlcplnueu pu;6;ro otll ol uo Joplo eq1 sessed 1l


rop;o up senrecer s6ege ueqn 'peolsul 'lles {eql OulqytuB
osnoLlsJen lou op 'sure11 Jpllulls pue 's1cpdlceq 'ebe66n;
slps lerj+ rollelil eurluo up sl tlc!L.l/v\ 's6ege e111 seddtqs
do.r6 '6u$dpqs dorp pegpc poqlotx e st 'slcnpo.td ,s;e;n1
-celnueru roLllo llos letll seluedutoc poseq-qe1111 pue 6o1
-BlEc.ro1 'qceordde srql Jo uolteppn V 'sluotue;tnbe; ;e1dec
lplllul slr socnpoJ pue slcnpo.ld 6u11e1rctl pue Outu6tsap
uo sncol o1 Auedtroc etue6 pJeoq oL.ll sooll luetue6ue.ue
srql 'ssecord eql ur dels &ene ]B ponlonut slsoc oJB oJotll
ollr.lM 're[nq oL.l] o] lcnpord eq1 sdrqs {ueduoc }uotullrylnJ
pue osnoLloJpl etlt (Ueu;le6 Jo olqoN B sou:Eg sP tlcns
iolrclor B Aq) peceld s! lepJo uE uotl^ pue 'selels po1un
or.ll ul fueduroc ]uouJlllgnJ pue asnoqolen P o] ButtlC

uorl peddlr.ls ll oneLl 'pultlC ut JoJnlcelnueru ]ceJluoc E


lq aperr eure6 oLlI enell Aeut eue6 pteoq lo ed& A ou E
sdopnep leql dn-Uels E 'llnsor B sV 'slcnpo.ld tleull dtt,ls
pup 'llrfinl 'ecnpo.rd llr^ sreuyed lBtlt uollou otll uo sueld
sseursnq Jlsql ernpruls 'o6-]e6 e,+ uo.tl 'sultl AAou Aueytl
slcnpord

rlaq,f, d;qS rolpup 'IUJInJ lecnpor6 o1 seguedurog


re6re.1 rIlIJra 6ugraupe6 saluedurog raileurs

lo{retrtr1 ol spnpord rlaqf 6qrg o1 seguedurog


ra6re'1 qly$ 6upeupe6 sepedrrrog roileurs

rogsrrrs

'IolJEtu ol slcnpoJd e.ll 6uuq ol seluedu.toc


leorlnecpulreqd re6rel qlli\A reuued ll,Aotll letll pue s6ntp
A eu luoled pue 'do;enep lenocstp ol sl uotssltu JtoL4l lBLl]
olels Alureld sueld ssoursnq ,sruJ4 qcolotq lsotu '1;nse; e
sV '1e poo6 er,{eq1 }eLl/\\ s,}l 'tuotl} }noqe slo}cop o} uol}
-Br.xlolul Ougp;nord ur pue s6nrp 6ur11es pue 6ut1e)Jptu ut
ezr;elceds 'rc244 pue XcJoy\ e1r1 'setuedtttoc 6nlp e6rel
eq1 ']sprluoc ul 'lolJeur ol slcnpo,td etll 6u1rq ol ecuelled
-xa aql;ou [euou.r or.l] roLl]rau oneq [eq1 lenennoq 'sosec
+soru ul 'lB poo6 e;,{eq1}eq/\r s,1t-s6n;p A ou Outdolenep
pue Oupenocsrp u! ez!lercads setuBdtuoc qoololg 'loryeu,l
o+ slcnpord rreql 6uuq o1 serueduloc ;ecrlneceur;eqd
e6.reg qlrn rouyed AluourLuoc seruBduroc qcelolq 'qOlul
ou e but6uuq Io lsoc eLll osnecog

suollcunl ]ueue6eueu oornosoJ uetunl1 roL4l lo e6uBr


lapporq e oornoslno sdn-yels Jeqlo '1eNUl ro xeqcAe6
se L,lcns sulrlJ 6urlunocce 11oiled L{}l/v\ reuyed suilU
osorlf 'uollerlsrulupe s]gouoq pue Ourssecoid ;;ofied
se L,lcns 's>1se1 onrleJlsrurupe {uo oornos}no sdn-Ue}s
otuos 'esryedxe pezrlerceds e;rnbe; pue onrsuolur Joqpl
orc lelll slsel lueue6euetu eclnosoJ ueurnq acJnoslno
ol sr sueld sseursnq ur arnleol uoruruoc ,tlOurseercur uV

e dleq upc s63d 'seop +oNUI pue xeqc{ed }eq} Oulqytene


Ourop qynn 6uoy 'rur4 ror.llo .ro dn-uels e JoI lueuryedep
ocJnosor ueunl,l oUs-JJo ue se lce pue (sO=a) suollezlu
-B6.ro reAo;dtue leuorsselo;d pe11ec e;e serueduoc osoql
'JJElsrunrJpV ro dOV se L,l3ns [ueduroc e Ll]l/v\ rcuped pue

s4setr luaure6eueyg sacrnos

-oll uprung 6ugcrnoslng saluedurog

'esrpueqcJoru poleplno qlh lq6nec OulUeb ]ou pue


secud olqepJoJlp le sreuolsnc ol slcnpo;d ]o uo!+colos

eplm e 6u;.re1rto 1o ueld ssoursnq s,s6ege o1;erOe1ul sl I ]nq


'Aeuour sOege slsoc ]ueu.ra6uere sr.ll 's6ege u;or1 {;1ce.r
-!p ourpc y q6noql sE slool lr os lsrl Ouplced s6ege ue L{}r^

xoq s6ege uE ur uouo lepro orll sll4lnl

qclL,Uv\

'(rolnqpptp

os s! lolrptu o1 6nrp

'sue1d ssoulsnq ur uotuuroc ore leL1l soupuecs

buueuped Jo sadAl oL.ll ]o seldurexe e.rB burnnollol oqt


'sAenn Aueu; ur dn-pe1s e dgeq uec Ouueuyed anrlcoJlo
'Iooq srql poqOnorql pole;lsnlll sy 'sueld ssoutsnq."""'

raq] Io yed ;erluesso up 6upeuyed olerr uogo AeUli.r,..


'peurellsuoc oclnosoJ oJB sossaursnq A ou osneco

sueld ssoursnE uI uoruruoc orv leqJl sdrqsrouued 1o sed[;,

96r

N\fld SS'N/SNgV CNIJ.IUM

9 U]I-dVHC

196

PART

2 I

DEVEL.PING SU.CESSFUL BUSINESS IDEAS

start-up knows about the consumers in its target market, the more it can gear
products or services to accommodate their needs. Many start-ups find it hard
to sell products to public schools, for example, because purchase decisions
are often made by committees (which draws out the decision-making process),
and the funding often has to go through several levels of administrators before
it can be approved. A competitor analysis, which is a detailed analysis of a
flrm's competitors, should be included. We provided a thorough explanation of
how to complete a competitor analysis in Chapter 5.
The final section of the market analysis estimates a firm's annual sales ,and
market share. There are four basic ways for a new firm to estimate its initial
sales. If possible, more than one method should be used to complete this task.
The most important outcome is to develop an estimate that is based on sound
assumptions and seems both realistic and attainable. We show the four methods entrepreneurs ca.n use to estimate sales in Table 6.3.
Wffism ffiwspmmmrruffimm qBff *ftae ffiExsf,mesm This section begins the financial analysis of a business, which is further fleshed out in the financial projections. It
addresses the basic logic of how profits are earned in the business and how
many units of a business's product or service must be sold for the business to
"break even" and then start earning a profit.
The major revenue drivers, which are the ways a business earns money,
should be identified. If a business sells a single product and nothing else, it
has one revenue driver. If it sells a product plus a service guarantee, it has two
revenue drivers, and so on. The size of the overall gross margin for each revenue driver should be determined. The gross margin for a revenue driver is the
selling price minus the cost of goods sold or variable costs. The costs of goods
sold are the materials and direct labor needed to produce the revenue driver.

TIIBLE

6"3

The Eour Methods for Estimating a New Firrn's Initial Sales

Method

Explanation

Utilize the Multiplication


Method

There are two approaches that fit this category. Start-ups that plan to sell a product on a
national basis normally use a top-down approach. This involves trying to estimate the total
number of users of the product, estimate the average price customers pay, and estimate what
percentage of the market your business will garner. Start-ups that plan to sell locally normally
use more of a bottom-up approach. This approach involves trying to determine how many
customers to expect and the average amount each customer will spend.

Find a Comparable Firm

Find a comparable firm and ask for an estimate of annual sales. For example, if you are
planning to open a women's clothing boutique, try to find a boutique that is similar to yours
(and is not in your trade area) and simply call the owner and ask for a chance to talk to him or
her about the business. Once a relationship has been established, you can ask for an estimate
of the business's annual sales.

Contact lndustry Trade


Associations

Contact the premier trade associations in your industry and ask if they track the sales numbers
for businesses that are similar to your business. lf the trade association doesn't track actual
sales numbers for comparable businesses, ask if there are other rules of thumb or metrics that
help new companies estimate sales. For example, many industries collect statistics such as
"average sales per square foot" or 'oaverage sales per employee" for firms in their industry.

Conduct lnternet Searches

lnternet searches often reveal magazine and newspaper articles as well as blog entries that
focus on firms in your industry. On occasion, these articles and blog entries will talk about the
sales experiences of a similar early-stage firm. lf you know of a firm that is comparable to your
firm, target that firm first in your search. You may get lucky and find an article or entry that says,
"XYZ firm earned gross revenues of $250,000 per year its first three years." lf the source of this
data is credible andXYZ firm is comparable to your firm, you've just found useful information.

L6t

3q o] pspuelul sdo] Jo ]as E p3]B3rc sEq z(uedruoc eq] 'Fulpgnq Jo lcE eI{} q}!Y\
uonceuuoc s.p1F Funod B esEaJcul ru/\{ Fullaytro}s }Eq} uo.qdurnssB eln q}yY\
FuluulFag 'ueuro.{y\ dq pleq are sa}E}S pe}un etI} u1 sqof FugeeulFua;o luacred
B sB
0I ]noqe dIuO 'FulraeulFue Jo pIeIJ ar{} o} sI:tF secnpo4ul }BtI} dueduoc 'srol
do1 eql 'xolgelPloC
JIeslI Fuluonlsod s1 '6 reldeqC q pecnpo4ul dueduroc
ptre }e>Ireru s}I q JIes}I suonlsod }I
lilrduro, ruorJ JIeslI selelluereJJlp ]I
qceordde ^\ot{
o} ulrop
IIEre^o s.rrr4J V 'socl ras pue slcnpord s11
"fioq,(1pc1dd1
^\or{
qceo-rdde
JoJ
Fulle4reru
IIeJeAo sll o1 sraJer IFele.4s iullerlreur s.ruJIJ V
'e1q1ssod se ]seq se's1u1od qFU
eq] }Iq pFoqs nod 1nq .uo.rlces Fulle{reul eI{.} ro3 rreld sseulsnq e uI pe}}grred
se-Fed e^U ol rnoJ eI{} uI ueld Fulle4relu u/roIq-IInJ B epnlcul o} elqlssod 1ou s.11
,dlsnoprqg .dFete-rts uor.1nqlJlslp pue 'ssecord sales prre x.rur Ieuolloruord 'acgd
dq pepoddns 3q IIpv\ ueld eql Jo slcadse IIEr3.\o aseq] /y\oq ]noqe {IE} ueq} pr.re
'uollelluereJJlp 1o s1r1od p.re 'fiu1uo111sod '.dFalerls Fu11a>1-reu sll Fu11e1nc.t1
--re ,(q UBls o1 sI ueld Fu11e>peur s..,(rleduroe E eqlJcsep o] delr lseq eqJ,
'1cnpo:d s11 fnq o1
ueq] epensJad pue sJeruolsnc puIJ o] seq ggs tI lnq 'sJo111eduroc puE sJeruo]
-"tt, sli Jo FulpuelsJepun poofi E pue ']aryEru laFre] peulJep-fleln e '1cnpo;d
learF B eABr{ deru 'sJesn JOpIo JoJ sauoqd lac Fulcnpo-rd urrg e 'IIeC]eaJC
.saIBS
,eldruexe
'ttoporrro:d 'acgd Jo sruJe] uI Fune{reru
pue
'uollnqlJlslp
Jod
'esr,Lres ro }cnpo-rd s11 fles puB ]e{rIII
Jo slloq pue slnu er{1 rplrr\ slesp }I
uo sesnco; ueld Frrgeqreur aqJ ffiffi*d ffiaxgpaxgxepg
[I/r sseulsnq eq]
^4.oq

's1sd1eue uo^a-{BeJq

e elnduoc o] /r,roq upldxe ern 'g raldeq3 uI 'rgo:d e Fuluree sUEls prrB ueAe
s>IEeJq ]I oJoJoq IIes ]snru sseulsnq e ]cnpoJd sU Jo slpn drreur /\{oq Yo s1s'fieue
uE sI l{clq/v\ 'srsdleue uels-{BeJq E IDIAI apnlJuoc ppol{s uonces sIqJ
pepnlcul eq lou plnotls sesuedxe Fulleredo puroS
.sesuedxa orull-auo JeIIuIS pue 'uFlsap oFol sset4snq 'uFIseP ellsqefi\ 'slIIII
-rad pue sesuacll sseulsnq JoJ seal 'sasuedxe fefiat epnlcu1 slsoc esaqJ 'aIqE]
uI 1nd prre pelelullse eq ppoqs slsoJ dn-lrels au4]-auo s,ssoulsnq eI{J
E

r ifl#:11##'fiJrj :iH}';

slr Jo eroru .peqc,sr sr ue^e-{Berq sruo -r


se{B} aFeralel Fu-r}e:ado q!1q e q}yr uug e 'aldnrexa rog 'pessncslp eq pFoqs
aFerazrsl Fune:edo pelceford s,ur:1; erp Jo sttoElef,ttdur-r aqJ, 's]soc aIqeUBA o] 3^I]
-BIoJ slsoc pexlJ Jo uolgodo:d A.oI e e^Er{ }Er{r safuedruoc uI }s3/Y\oI s1 aFe-rerral
Fu11eredo 'lse4uoc uI 'slsoc oIqBIJB^ J-rortrt o1 a REIoJ slsoc pexlJ Jo uolUodo-td
qftH B eABq ]Br{l seltredruoJ uI }saqEFI s-r aFanarrel Fune:edg 's}soc aIqBIJB^
snsJe1 pexlJ sll Jo slsdleue rre sr eluraaq tufpoao s,ruJIJ V ']xeu pessncslp
aq ppor{s afie-razle1 Fuperado s,.r{ueduroc erLL ]ou ro Frqq}eruos sllss }I JerDel+lt
sJncur dueduroc e slsoc eJE slsoc pexg sll alrq.$. 'safes dq ^ftezr slsoc oIqBIJBA
s.ruJIJ V 'slsoJ pexlJ s,sseulsnq eq] Jo rropm[o-rd e ppv 'dlsnopa-rd parnFg sBlY\
Je^IJp enueleJ qcee -ro; (p1os spooF Jo slsoJ ro) slsoc oIqBIJBA eqJ 'slsoc eIqE
-IJB^ pug pexg s,sser4snq eq];o slsdlerre rre apprord ppoqs uo.rlces lxeu er{J
'J3A[p enrre^eJ ]Eq] ruo4 eruoc o]
palcedxe seIES ;o efieluecrad orp uo peseq Ja^IJp anueleJ qcue Jo ulFreru uoE
-nqlJluoJ IBnpIAIpq eql FulqFtarn dq sra4rp arureleJ s,dueduroc eq] Jo tlcBe JoJ
ulFieu uonnqgluoc eFerere pe1qF1e,u aql atelnJ[Ec ueq] uBc no (..'sre1ugd.
JeAIJp enrreloJ eq] Jepun sJeluLrd :alnduroc ]ueJeJJIp IBJeAos eAEr{ deru nod
,eJols dlddns ecIJJo ue Fuluado ar.no.f,31 'alduexa rog) 'oFeJOAE rre e>IP] prrE ]cn
-po:d qcge roJ ulF-reru uonnqgluoJ artr+ elBInJlBc rrec nolt 'd.roFelec JeAUp anua
-rrer uerr-rfl B uI slcnpo:d a1d11pur e Bq nod 3tr 'rlcea ro; u-rFreu uollnqgluoc eq]
a-rnFIJ plnoqs nod 'lerrgp enu3ler erro rreql aJotu ser1 sseulsnq rnod g1 '1gord e
Fulcnpo-ld pue slsoc pexlJ s.ssor4snq eql Ftr.uaaoc o] *elnql4troc,, o] oIqEIIEAB sI
pug JeAo lJeI s.leq] oIBS Jo ]Iun rad lrrnorrre er11 sT sIt{J 'ulF.reru uoEnq!4uoc
eq] peIIEc osle sT Og$ eqJ']uacrad 09 ro 09$ sI ur.Freur sso.rF eq1 '(splrelelu
puB roqBD 07$ sI plos spooF Jo ]soc eql puB ool$ roJ slles lcnpord E JI 'oS
N\fld SSEN/SNSV ENIIIUM

U]IdVHC

198

PART

2 I

DEVELOPING SUCCESSFUL BUSINESS IDEAS

used to solve problems while reading about adventures. The ultimate goal is to
connect girls \Mith the art of building and encourage young women to pursue
careers in engineering. As we see with the example of GoldieBlox, the marketing strategr sets the tone and provides guidance for how the company should
reach its target market via its product, pricing, promotions, and distribution
tactics. For example, it will invariably promote and advertise its.products in
places that young women and their parents are most like1y to see. Similarly, it
will most likely sell its products through specialty toy stores and its owrl website, along \ rith mass merchandisers such as Toys"R'IJs.
The next section should deal with your company's approach to product,
price, promotion, and distribution. If your product has been adequately explained already, you can move directly to price. Price, promotion, and distribution should all be in s5mc with your positioning and points of differentiation, as
described previously. Price is a particularly important issue because it determines how much money a company can make. It also sends an important message to a firm's target market. If GoldieBlox advertised its toys as high-quality
toys that are both educationalty sound and environmentally friendly but also
charged a low price, people in its target market would be confused. They would
think, "This doesn't make sense. Are GoldieBlox toys high quality or aren't
they?" In addition, the lower price wouldn't generate the profits that GoldieBlox
needs to further develop its toys. You should also briefly discuss your plans regarding promotions and distribution.
The flnal section should describe the company's sales process or cycle and
specific sales tactics it will employ. It's surprising how many business plans
describe a business's overall marketing strategies, but never comment on how
a product or service will actually be sold.
Wwweffic&w* {xaw Senw&me} ffimm&grc mmd ffiewwf,rypmmema* ffiffimsm If you're developing a completely new product or service, you need to include a section in your
business plan that focuses on the status of your development efforts. Many
seemingly promising start-ups never get off the ground because their product
development efforts stall or the actual development of the product or senrice
turns out to be more difficult than expected.
The first issue to address is to describe the present stage of the development of your product or senrice. Most products follow a logical path of development that includes product conception, prototyping, initial production, and
fult production. You should describe specifically the point that your product or
service is at and provide a timeline that describes the remaining steps. If you
are in the very early stages of your business and only have an idea, you should
carefully explain how a prototype, which is the first physical depiction of a new
product or service, will be produced. A product protot54re is the first physical manifestation of a new product, often in a crude or preliminary form. The
idea is to solicit feedback and then iterate. For example, a prototype of a product, like one of GoldieBlox's toys, might consist of a preliminary version of the
product for users to test and then report their experiences. GoldieBlox would
then modi$r or tweak the toy based on the users' experiences. Similar1y, a prototype for a Web-based company might consist of a preliminary or beta version
of the site, with sufficient functionality built into the site for users to test it
and then provide feedback. In some instances a virtual prototype is sufficient.
A virtud protot54re is a computer-generated 3D image of a product or service
idea. It displays the idea as a 3D model that can be viewed from all sides and
rotated 36O degrees.
A section labeled "Challenges and Risks" should be included and disclose
any major anticipated design and development challenges and risks that will
be involved in bringing the product or service to market. While you want to
remain upbeat, the last thing you want to do is paint an overly rosy picture of
how quickly and effortlessly your design and development process will unfold.

66r

N\fld ssfN/sngv

'rrorleueldxa pellelep e eppord


o1 ztressaJeu ].usl ]I 'sJerurue-rFo-rd -ralndruoJ JoJ ecedsqrozlL cpreuaF E sE r{cns
'ldpcsepuorr ere seIlUIcEJ -rnor( JI 'peqslldurocce eq IIIr\ ]Er{} xeoq uo }ueurruoc
ppor{s nod 'uo.rlcnpord rnod acJnos}no ro }JB4uoJ IIII\\ prre }cnpord e Fulcnp
-o-rd eq ilyy\ nod;1 'sueeru Jer{}o eruos qFnorql pe:1nbce ro 'peseel 'pesqcrnd
eq ru1\l. d"q} Jaq}er{^\ Jo srrrre} uI 'pa-rrnbce (ueaq e^Bq :o) eq rulv\ deq}
^\oq
eqgcsep duepq pue luaudlnba pue seqIIIcBJ luelrodul ]soru rnod ]s{ p1nor{s
no 'lueudpba pue seIl[IcBJ s,ruJIJ E aqlrJsap osIE plnoqs uol]ces sIr{J
'ecueJeJJlp cllerrrerp E e{pur deur '}ee4s dsnq B Jo epIS
uIBUec e to '-raluec fiulddoqs Jo IIBru B r4rilIm uolleool c1;1cads eql 'sesseqsnq
IIEIoJ pue slrreJnelseJ roJ 'IaAOI peurBJF-euIJ aJoru E uO 'espy\Jerno per{ e^Br{
],uplno.{r,l' }I }Bq} eFelrrenpe }soc e padofue seq ruoc'uozBrrrv 'sor]IIIcEJ uol]nqlr]
-slp eseq] reau Fu11eco1 dg 's-reqsllqnd {ooq aFrel Ierales roJ qnq uoqnqrr1srp
-roferu e sl d]Ic sI{} }Bq} sI eInEeS u1 urolluozeurv e}Bcol o} poplcap sozog JJaI-,
suoseeJ eq] Jo euo 'eldruexe Jod '],usl 1I sacrrelsul Jeqlo uI prrB 'enssl ]uE]
-:odur1 dlerue:1xe uE sI uollecol seJuelsur eruos uI 'sseulsnq rnod Jo uollBcol
clqderFoeF eq1 eqprsep ppor{s ueld suoneredo aq1 Jo uonces }xeu er{J
'seuo IEcIlUc ]soru ar{+ ssaJppe prrB seI}BI}cB eFels-1uor;
pue aFels->IJBq {e>1 eq1 1no z(q uec nor{ }nq 'rreld suo11e-rado rnod JoJ eABq
nod seFed rno; o] eerrp ern u1 enssl r{cee rro }ueurruoJ }.rrec nod ifisnopqg

(sa;p;1cy sauacs-aql-pulqag) e6elg Iceg

luo4

I
I
I
I
I
I
I

I
I
I
I
I
I
I

repols^ eu {;q1uoy1
sdoqs>1ro11

sourrlcBtu ssouuj
sue.r6o.rd pue sosselc ssou1l
ocuPlsrssE JJPIS
sJnor.l

6u;leredg

srnol roqruar!
(eeg sreqtuehl eql teqn ) e6e1g

sue;d [cue6.rer.u3
6ururerl pup uorleluorJo eeAoldur3

spualeu 6urlelreur

1o

lueurdolo^oq

luoruuro^o6 [+rc qlrnn sdrqsuor]elou


srer;ddns qlrnn sdrqsuolleloU
lenuPU suorleredg
uorlcolos #els

:si!\oIIoJ sB rr \op ue{orq eq lqFpu senssl aFels-1uog erl} pue eFels-{ceq eril
'leluec sseulu lKeu e Fquado ar.nod31 'aldurexa Jod 'secuepadxe puE seas Jeruo]
-snc eq] IBrIlr Jo *'eFE1s JuoJJ,, prrB 'sanr^pJB seuacs-aq]-pr4qeq lo ,.'eFe1s >Iceq,,
Jo sruJel 14 UoISSnJSIp eql eruB4 uarn rrBc no 'erB ssnssl >[BeJq-Jo-e{eu er.n
]er{lll prre }rrepodrul }soru s.}er{ A.Jo srrre} r.4 srropeJado ol qceo;dde p-rauaF -rnod
elEInJnJB ]sJU o] sI urLr eq flI/!\ sser4snq rnod rnor{ o}E4snII1 o1 dem. InJasn V
'dsl-rc pue Uoqs uorlcas s1q1 daa4 o1 ]soq sI 1I ']InseJ E sV 'suollerreldxe
pellelep -roy Fup4ool aq lou III ,r. d1p;euaF deql }nq 'urLr eq IIIA sseulsnq eq}
^\or{
Jo esues IIBre^o r.rB ]LrB/v\ IIIff\ sJepBeJ JnoI 'Lrslep qcnu oo] Fuppo-rd pue c1do1
s1q1 Fulqlrcsep dlelenbepe uoe/vqeq ecrreleq InJeJEc B e{I4s o} eAEr{ no1 'pecnp
-ord oq IIII\{ ecrales Jo }Jnpord -rno,t lnor{ prrE uru eq IIIA sseulsnq rno,(
^\oq
seuqlno rreld sseulsnq er{} Jo uol}ces rreld suol}BJedo eqa wwgd ssil&E&&trad6

'61 raldeqC t4 passncsp sI dpedord IEnlreIIeluI 'seere


eseql u1 sueld rnof ssncslp 'runur.rrr.nrr B ]B 'r.rBJ nod os ecnpe pFel 1aF ppoqs
nod '1ad senssl ,Q-radord Ienlcefie]q Fr4preFer uol]ce ue{E} }ou e^Bq nod pue
seFels dpee eq] u1 ru]s sI dn-lrels rnod JI 'Futdole^ep are nod secllres ro slcn
-pord eq] o] e^IlEIeJ eJnJes o1 ueld Jo peJnJes eAEr{ nod 1eq} s}eJces apEJ}
Jo 's1qF1,rl(doc 's{Jeruape4 's1ue1ed due eqprcsap plnoqs uol}cas IEuIJ V
'Fugeygo rEInc.rUBd rnod qlp\ a1ed1c11ue nod s4sg pue saFuelleqc
aq] olu1 slqFlsul luE/K 11pn deq1 pue 'ssaco-rd FulFue11Br{c puB ddurnq d11ue
-raquI LrE sr lueurdolelep ecrares prre ]Jnpord 1eq1 .1\4.orDI sJepBeJ pacuegedxg

eN[tuM I

uft_dvHc

200

PART

2 I

DEVELOPING SUCCESSFUL BUSINESS IDEAS

Kmmwm mued ffimxw*pmrap ffi*wamw*xxwe Many investors and


others who read business plans look first at the executive summary and then
go directly to the management team section to assess the strength of the
people starting the firm. Investors read more business plans w"ith interesting
ideas and exciting markets than they are able to finance. As a result, it's often not the idea or market that wins funding among competing plans, but the
perception that one management team is better prepared to execute its idea
than the others.
The management team of a new firm typically consists of the founder
or founders and a handful of key management personnel. A brief profilb of
each member of the management team should be provided, starting with the
founder or founders of the firm. Each profile should include the following
information:

ffiffimmmmgmmmerxq*

ffi Title of the position


ffi Duties and responsibilities of the position
ffi Previous industry and related experience
ffi Previous successes
ffi Educational background

Although they should be kept brief, the profiles should illustrate why
each individual is qualified and will uniquely contribute to the flrm's success.
Certain attributes of a management team should be highlighted if they apply
in your case. For example, investors and others tend to prefer team members
whoVe worked together before. The thinking here is that if people have worked
together before and have decided to partner to start a new firm, it usually
means that they get along personally and trust one another.za You should also
identiflr the gaps that exist in the management team and your plans and timetable for filling them. The complete resumds of key mzrnagement team personnel can be placed in an appendix to the business plan.
If a start-up has a board of directors and /or a board of advisors, their
qualifications and the roles they play should be explained and they should be
included as part of your management team. A board of directors is a panel of
individuals elected by a corporation's shareholders to oversee the management
of the firm, as explained in more detail in Chapter 9. A board of advisors is a
panel of experts asked by a firm's management to provide counsel and advice
on an ongoing basis. Unlike a board of directors, a board of advisors possesses
no legal r."por"ibility for the firm and gives nonbinding advice.2s Many startups ask people who have specific skills or expertise to serve on their board of
advisors to help plug competency gaps until the firm can afford to hire additional personnel. For example, if a firm is started by two Web designers and
doesn't have anyone on staff vrith marketing expertise, the firm might place
one or two people on its board of advisors with marketing expertise to provide
guidance and advice.
The final portion of this section of your business plan focuses on how your
companywill be structured. Even if you are a start-up, you should outline how
the company is currently structured and how it will be structured as it grows.
It's important that the internal structure of a company makes sense and that
the lines of communication and accountability are clear. Including a description of your company's structure also reassures the people who read the plan
that you know how to translate your business idea into a functioning firm.
The most effective way to illustrate how a company will be structured and
the lines of authority and accountability that will be in place is to include an
organizational chart in the plan. An organizationd chart is a graphic representation of how authority and responsibility are distributed within the company.
The organizational chart should be presented in graphical format if possible.

llTry

=.=
:a
==

rca

'8 JeldeqC uI sISdIEue oIIBJ puB slueruolBls


IBIcueuIJ BruJoJ ord eleldruoc o] /y\oq Jo uolleueldxa alelduroc E ]ueserd a16
'sseulsnq or{} Jo IBI}uo1od eq1 o1 p-reFer uI Fu1uBeru
rBIncIUEd e seq oller qreg 'uaq] qllr\ sollEr Fuluuo; pue slueurelels IBIcuBu
-IJ Jo ]no sJequrnu Fup14 ,tq pelnduroc eJE 'soIBS r.ro uJnleJ pue s]ossB uo
uJnleJ sB r{cns 'sol}Eu 'sls.fpuu oIIBJ qFno:q1 s}ueue}e}s IBIcuBuIJ eruJoJ
ord ro IBcIJolsIq s,ruJIJ B Jo esues e{Bru :o 1arfue}ul sJe}Iry\ ueld sseulsnq
lsontr 'slueruolels IEIcUuIJ Ieclrolslq ;o sreed eeJq] epnlcul osIE plnoqs nod
'slslxe dpee-rp ro; ueld -rnod Funuzn er.no.,{ ,(treduroc eq} 31 'sluerire}B}s EruJoJ
o-td;o sree.[ e^IJ o] earq] puaruruocer spadxa ]sol tr ']xeu eq] o] auo ruo{ dlpc
-IFo1 s.{KoU uol}eruroJul esneceq Jepro slq} q perede-rd dlpnsn e-re deqg '}uarrr
-elels rviog r{sec BruJoJ ord aq1 pue '}eeqs ecr.releq eruJo; o-rd eq} '}uarug}}s
eruocul BruJoJ ord eq1 apnlcu1 slueruelels [BIcuBuIJ BruJoJ oJd '1sed eq] {cEJl
ueq] Jer{}BJ pJE/\ JoJ >IooI dr,.{t ldecxe 'serede:d urrl; poqsllqe}se u s}ueru
-elels IEcIJolsIq eq] o] JEIIrurs eJB sluarualels IEIoUBUIJ BrrrJo; o-rd s,ruJIJ V
'1no urnl deqt aor.I
ees o] Fullsarelul s.1I ']InsoJ B sV 'rreld eJpue er{} Jo aIeuIJ er{} }uese-rder osp
sluerualels IBIcrrEr4J ar{J 'qFnoroql are rreld :nod Jo suopcas Fulpaca-rd aq} JI
sseco:d pJely\JoJlqFfe+s dlrpg E s,]I 'eslcJaxa snolpa] B eq o1 s-readde sluaurelels
IBIrrrBug Fugederd ecuelF ]srIJ 1e qFnorptv 'rreld sseulsnq B Jo uonces [BIcrrErrJ
er{l Jo Ueer{ or{} eJE slueurelcls IBIcrrBuU (pefcefo.rd .ro) uru.rol o.rd eqa
']cerrocul eq o] ]no peuJn] uo
peseq se/vr sseulsnq leql suogdunsse de4 erp Jo lereles esneceq .fiaFrel FIIBJ
'eJnlBaJ er{} Jo sncoJ erfl sI }Br.I} dueduroc ar{+ 'an1}uelg 'eJn}BaJ .,fiuoq6 }uel\
]BrUK,, erp uI pele4snl11 q suopdurnssB aq1 FUttarr ,(lqFnoroq] pue uo paseq sI
sseulsnq e leql suopdurnsse 1ecngc lsoru et1+ FuLg$uepl Jo ecuepodul eqa
'uoIlEruJoJuI sll Jo secJnos 3[n ellc
ppoqs ]I ueq] 'read dlarr.a seIES sll eseercr4 uec 1I ]Br.I] JeIIeq sll uI a1o: eF-re1 e
sdeld ernFg s1tll puB 'ernlnJ elqeeesaroJ eq] ro; read qcee eFeluacrad uplrac
e 1e ,r.orF o1 pelcedxe s1 ,t4snpq do1 s.ua:plrqc erI] Jo lueuFes IEuollecnpe eql
]Bq] Fupnoqs BlEp elqlperc seq xolge1plog a,1 'aldurexe rod 'suopdunsse rnod
JoJ ecJnos eql elIJ plnoqs nod pue 'uoRErrrJoIrI clglceds drarr uo paseq eq rultr
suolldrunsse Jer{}O ('ae-rFeslp -ro eerFe o} Jeper -rnod o1 dn ueq} s.11) 'zrrayr. sns
-uesuoc e FullceuoJ eJ.nod-ec;nos crJ:rceds e ellc ].uplnol\ nod 'ecuelsu1 s1r{}
u1 'uolldrunsse ]Bq] elels pFor{s nod uaql 'suo11ca[o:d saps rnod Fupgp uo11
-drunsse Fu1d1-repun rre s.]Brp pue 'sJead eag o] eeJrn ]xeu er{} JeAo r{}Fuer}s
upF gplr durouoce 'S'n eq] ]Br{} e^elloq nod 31 'eldruexa rod 'uondurnsse sq1
elelluelsqns o] pellc eq rurr secJnos cgrcads ou pue 'rrollruJoJul IBJeuaF uo
paseq eq ilpy\ suopdurnsse eruos 'paseq eJB slueruelels IBIcuBuIJ eql qc1r1zy\ uo
suolldurnsse IBcIIIJc ]soru eq] Jo uollerreldxe rre sI qcg#vi 'leeqs suogldurnssu
uB sI epnlcq o] ruell ]xau er{J 'pasn eq gpn dauou eq}
pLrB 'ruo4 eruoc
^roq uol}ue}ul aq}
deuou eq] eJer{llr 'ldeuoru as[BJ o] sI rrBld sseulsnq er{}
Jo
JI)
speeu rrulJ e dauour qcnru /y\oq dlpclRcads 1no sdel 1eq1 ]ueruncop E sI qc1r1lv\
pzvr

'lueureluls spunl fo sesn pu? secJnos e sI epnlcq o1 Fu1q1 ]sJIJ ar{J


'sruJe] IEIcueuIJ uI rueq] ssardxe pue pedola^ep en,nod sueld eq] e{B} daql '}sEI
eruoc suopceford plcrreulJ er{} dr{ ees o} dsea s.11 'ue1d eq} Jo suonces snorl
-e-rd eq] palelduoc Fupeg 'suo11caford plcuer4J (pe]caford ro) eur-roy o-rd s.ru-r1y
B slrreserd ueld sseulsnq E Jo uorlces 1eug er{J s6x#SpflF@$crxd gffifffrs$#ffiexgJ
'orer{} }eF o} eceld u1 ueld B sr{ puB eJn}ual er{} qcunel o1 aceld e>IB} o}
speeu ]Br{ \ Jo aJB.lvrB sI rueo} }uaruaFerreru eq} }Er{} sJo}salul IEI}ua}od Fulcuyr
-uoc q elqenprr dleurerlxe eq uec elnpeqcs peluoseJd pue pereda-rd d1azr11ce;ga
rrv 'qUoJ os pue 'oIBS ]srIJ eq1 Fu.nr.relqo 'suope-redo Jo uoncnpo:d eq1 Fulpels
'FulcueulJ IBcIlUc Fup1elqo 'soIlIIIcEJ Jo le]ual 'sedd1o1o-rd;o uopalduroc 'eJn]
-uel eril Fuperofuocul sB r{cns 'sseccns s,ssar4snq eq} o} pcI}IJc seuo}sagru Jo
]BruroJ or{} u1 eq ppor{s eppeqcs er{J 'sseulsnq eq} qcunel o1 pe4nber s}uelo
-roferu eq] s \oqs ]Br{} pereda:d oq plnoqs elnpaqcs V egrft,p*q##S *Xffitr#e43
N\rId SS3N/SNgV ENU-IUM

U]IdVHC

202

PART

2 I

DEVELOPING SUCCESSFUL BUSINESS IDEAS

What EventVue Learned the HardWay About Making Assumptions


ilventVue was a product that was intended to

im-

fu* prove the experience of people who attend conferL*ences. lt started as a private social network that
helped conference attendees network more effectively. lt
pivoted twice, once to rollout a widget that would bring
more people to specific conferences, and then to an
app that promised to be the best way for conference attendees to disscuss what was taking place in real time.
EventVue launched with promise but failed in early 2010.
What went wrong?
Several things, all of which have to do with incorrect
assumptions. The first assumption was that conference
organizers would see EventVue as an invaluable asset.
They didn't. While EventVue saw itself as essential, conference organizers saw it more as "a vitamin rather than
a pain pill." lt was something that event organizers said
they liked, but none of them saw it as essential. lt didn't
make their lives easier, make them more money, reduce
their costs, or boost the profile of an event. lt was simply
nice to have. Although EventVue's platform made it easier
for conference attendees to network with one another, it
wasn't clear what was in it for the organizers, who were
the ones being asked to pay for it. What the founders of
EventVue found was that conference organizers care first

they were less likely to register themselves. Therefore,


rather than making conference organizers money, the
EventVue widget actually cost them money. EventVue
tried out several other ideas, but eventually ran out of
ideas, persistence, and money.
There are two key takeaways from the EventVue story
for business plan writers. First, a business should test its
assumptions prior to launching. This lesson illustrates
the need to complete a comprehesive feasibility analysis
prior to writing a business plan and moving forward with

a business idea, as illustrated in Chapter 3. Second,

it's essential that a business understand its customers'


needs. EventVue never found a way to help conference
organizers sell more tickets. lt found a way to help conference attendees better network with others, but conference attendees were not EventVue's customers.
ffimmm&ffi#ffiffi ffmr ffiw$*$mmff Ykerruffic$mg

1.

and foremost about one thing-selling tickets. Anthing


that doesn't sell tickets is a secondary consideration.
After disappointing initial results, EventVue pivoted
to offer a widget that would help bring more people to
conferences. This, the company founders assumed,
would get the attention of conference organizers. The
widget would let people know who was registered for
an event. The idea was that if a prospective attendee
saw that a friend or someone they admired was registered for a conference, they would be more likely to
register for the event conference as well. lncredibly, the
widget had the opposite effect. A rule of thumb for conferences is that the majority of sales come in the last
two weeks before the conference is scheduled to take
place. As a result, when people looked at the registration list-particularly if they looked at it more than two
weeks out from the event-and saw that none of their

friends

or people that they admired were registered,

2.
3.

4,

Briefly map out the feasibility analysis that EventVue's


founders should have conducted prior to launching
the company. Of the four forms of feasibility analysis
described in Chapter 3, which of the forms should
have been emphasized the most? Explain your
answer.
lf EventVue had conducted a comprehensive

feasibility analysis prior to launch, what do you think


the company would have looked like?
Do some lnternet research to see if there are companies
that are providing social networks for conference attendees. lf so, what are they doing differently than what
EventVue tried to do? Try to discern why they have been
able to stay in business while EventVue failed.
The "You Be the VC 3.1" feature focuses on August
Smart Locks, a company that will enable users to
controlthe locks on their homes or apartments via a
smartphone. What are some of the main assumptions
that August's business plan is based on?

Source: J. Fraser, "A Few Words About EventVue," Online Aspect,


available at wwMonlineaspect.c om/201 0/1 0/26/ a-tew -words-abouteventvue, accessed February 28,

201 4.

ffippema#$re Any material that does not easily fit into the body of a business
plan should appear in an appendix-resumes of the top management team,
photos or diagrams of product or product prototypes, certain financial data,
and market research projections. The appendix should not be bulky and add
significant length to the business plan. It should include only the additional
information vital to the plan but not appropriate for the body of the plan itself.
ffi*x**&mg ffi* ffi&H Wm6w&kew In evaluating and reviewing the completed business plan, the writers should put themselves in the reader's shoes to determine if the most important questions about the viability of their business

1o s1u;od

aur[

or.l]

rol orn]nl

lL46Uq E

]co[ord {eq1 op pue '{;lceroc pelelduoc suot}ce[ord lPtcueu4 otl]

oiv

'O]

ectlstleor uo suorlco[ord lelcueul] s]l Ourseq sr ur4 aqt ]Etl] suotlduunsse aLll oJV '6

apunos pue eleudoldde ue;d suotleledo s,ssoulsnq oq+ sl '8


ituJ4

^Aou

eq1 Ourqcunel Jo

)sel

eLl] ol dn pup 'pallrls 'pecueuedxe rueol lueule6eueu oq+ sl .L


a,ue1d

6urla4teur punos p o^Etl sseulsnq oqt sooo '9

aolqeuPlsns uo;1e;luoroJ+rp
oseql oJV astoltleduroc sU r.uot1 11 eleredes A;n.r11eq1uollerlueio$lp ]o slugod o^eLl ssoutsnq oL4l seo6 '9

elalrptu le6re1 peu[op-llon e o^eL] ssoutsnq

oL,l]

soo6 ,n

4,fu1snput
ult1ly\A

eql

uorlrsod ont]oelilp up polllluopl ruJll or.ll seLl pue ,{.r}snpu; 6u;nnor6 '6ur1tcxe ue Ouueluo ssoulsnq oql

ueeq srs[;eue I1r;rqrseo] B sEH eJoruolsnc

oL.l]

sl 'e

as1nsor otll ore lpup\ 'os ll apole;dutoc


ol onlen luecrlru6rs ppe il soo6 aolqprn

1,p;1ue1od leoJ quM

'{lrunyoddo

octrues to lcnpold oql sl 'Z


sl 't

ue u sr ro 'eepr ue 1sn[ ssoulsnq eq]

ra^ suy plnoqs ueld sseulsng t suollsen$ luelrodurl lsolltr 0t orl,f, &'$ HTSHJ.
dn-pe1g 'uoFrel lecluqce] pIo^E plnoqs prre {Is} tareld Jo }slsuoc ppoqs uon
'Fullaaur eq] o1 roprd eperu aq plnoqs slueureFueJJe eseqJ
-BluaseJd
']I e^Br{ "qJ ro}selur eq}
arf} dlddns o1 pe-rede-rd eq p1not{s
lueurdlnbe
},useop
J}
rneuardeJlue eq] 'pepeeu sI
]ueudlnba
[BnsI olpne due ;1 'perederd lem
eq] ]E o:lrrB plnoqs rneuardaJlua ar{J
eq pue erup uo
luorululodde
'1elraleur rtrl1,rr parapnlc ]ou pue fueqs eq ppoqs
sepqs er{J 'pesJBaqeJ-IIa \ pue rpoorus aq ppotls uo.r}E}uaserd eqJ 'sa}nupu
OZ uErD eroru ]sBI ],up1noqs uolleluasa:d ar11 'poged Je^\sue-pue-uonsanb
olnu1ru-O7 e pue uolleluasard alnr.r.rur-O7 e lo ]slsuoc [I1\4. Jnoq eq] ]Bq] pr.re
Jnor{ euo ser{ eqs Jo eq }Bq} rnauarder}ua rre sIIe} Jo}seAuI ue JI 'suopcru}sul
rv\oIIoJ o1 sI uollelueserd IEJo uE Fq4eu uI eIru IsJIJ eqJ 'suoplladruoc rreld
sseulsnq ]soru o1 seqdde lBruJoJ eures erla 'FuRaaru er{} Jo uop;od uol}B}uose-rd
eq] roJ pe/y\oIIB ]ols erun eq] IIIJ IIIl\r ler{r sapfls ]r4odreaod Jo ]es B erede-rd
pFoqs eJnllrs^ 1!(\eu E Jo sJepunoJ arI} 'Jo}ser\rr! rrB I{}y(\ }eau o} pe{sE usIl!\

uBld sssulsng e lo uollEluosoJd lBro

aql

'uollelueserd qFnoroq] eJoru


e errnbal IIIIv\ pue reFuol lsBI .,(1pc1d,! 111,u, Funeeru sIqJ 'srauped Jar{ Jo slq
pue Jolselur eq] qlpa ]eeru o] Funaeru puoJes B roJ {ceq pe{se oq IIIr\ sJe}ues
-ard eql 'eJnluel ern ]noqe eJoru rLrEeI o] slrrea, prre passa-rdur1 sI Jolselul eq]
JI 'suo$sanb >ISE o1 erun er{} Jo }soJ or{t osn pue sep[s ]ulodJorv\o4 Fulsn uop
-ElueseJd alnulur -OZ, ol -g I E a{Bru o} rrrJg ern {sE d1pc1dd1 11!y\ Jo]se^q er{J
Jnor{ euo }noqe 'Uor{s d.ren d1p-rauaF sI Jo}se.\u-r rrB q}I { Fupearu }sJIJ eI{J
9z

'sJolsonul

sBO>rerup*or{sru,Irl\4.eurr""Jg;H";:#t3ffi

lepualod

l;anrlcege o]

orl

;Y;:r:'ffi :'$XllrT,it'ff ',X

srolselur esneceg 'sJepunoJ s.ruJg erp q]1irl. ]aaru o] ]rrB/K,(1pc1dd1 illy\ Jolsel
-uI eqJ 'uos-red u1 rreld eq] ]uesa:d pue Jolsalr4 eq] q]1.rr,r' ]eeru o1 sI dals ]xeu
erII 'Jolselul ppualod B Jo ]sarolt4 et1l slIrIIa ,tgrgssaccns rreld ssaulsnq eq] JI

ol ueld ssoursnq e lueserd


^

upld6 'g

EAI,f,CXISO CNINUEXT

srolso^ul ol ueld ssoulsng eql 6qluosord


'Jel1.r \ uBId sseursnq due roy ]sIt{ceqc pooF E s.}I 're^rsue plnoqs uBId sseulsnq
E suollsenb luepodrul ]soru 0I aq] sls{ t'g aIqEJ'paJe^.\.sue ueoq a^Bq ern}rrel

aoz

N\fld SSSN/SNSV ENIIIUM

UfldVHC

204
'ART

2 I

DEVEL.'TNG succESSFUL BUSTNESS TDEAS

entrepreneurs may mistakenly spend too much time talking about the technologr that will go into a new product or service and not enough time talking
about the business itself. The most important issues to cover in the presentation and how to present them are shown in Table 6.5. This presentation
format calls for the use of 12 slides. A common mistake entrepreneurs make
is to prepare too many slides and then try to rush through them during a
2o-minute presentation.

fABeE 6.5 Twelve PowerPoint Slides to Include in an Investor


Presentation
Topic

Explanation

1. Title slide

lntroduce the presentation with your company's name, the


names of the founders, and the company logo if available.

2. Problem

Briefly state the problem to be solved or the need to be filled.

3. Solution

Explain how your firm will solve the problem or how it will
satisfy the need to be filled.

4. Opportunity and target

Articulate your specific target market. Talk about business


and environmental trends that are providing your target
market momentum.

market
5. Technology

This slide is optional but is normally included. Talk about


your technology or any unusual aspects of your product or
service. Don't talk in an overly technical manner. Make your
descriptions easy to understand and interesting.

6. Competition

Explain specifically the firm's competitive advantage in the


marketplace and how it will compete against more established
competitors.

7. Marketing and sales

Describe your overall marketing strategy. Talk about your sales


process. lf you've conducted primary research regarding how

people feel about your product, report the results here.


8. Management team

Describe your existing management team. Explain how the


team came together and how their backgrounds and expertise
are keys to the success of your firm. lf you have a board of advisors or board of directors, briefly mention the key individuals
involved. lf you have gaps in your team, explain how and when
they will be filled.

9. Financial projections

Briefly discuss the financials. Stress when the firm will achieve
profitability, how much capital it will take to get there, and when
its cash flow will break even. Use additional slides if needed to
properly display your information, but don't go overboard.

10. Current status

Describe the current status of your firm in the context of the


milestones you've achieved to date. Don't diminish the value
of your accomplishments.

11. Financing sought

Lay out specifically how much financing you're seeking and


how you'll use the money.

12. Summary

Bring the presentation to a close. Summarize the strongest


points of your venture and your team. Solicit feedback from
your audience.

Source: B. Barringer, Preparing Effective Busrness Plans: An Entrepreneurial Approach, 1st Edition, O 2009,
pp.242-253. Adapted by permission of Pearson Education, lnc., Upper Saddle River, NJ.

EE:t

:':
:-:
:':

==

e qllra ]u3]sIsuoc eq ppoqs lI

:arramoq

lpelenple d1p;arec eq ppor{s ecr.rureedde


s,ue1d eqJ 'paurer; sI auqeppF prlril eq}
qcll#a punoJE senssr eql eJB ]EruJoJ prrB
aldls s.ue1d ertrl 'pepnlcq ]ceJ uI sI uolleru
-roJr4 IEII ItB }Eril r$.uen o] pue 's3{B}slru
fir411eds 'sJorre retuurerl ro; pe{car1J eq
ppor{s rreld eq} 'ueBUA\ ecuo 'ueld eq} uI
pepnlcul eq pForIS eJnluel pasodo-rd eq1
;o slcedse lrregodurl 11V 1ueurdolarrap s11
uI JBaIO prrB eslcuoc oq plnoqs uBId sseu
-ISnq B 'puocas 'ssoJoJd Ftr.DIBrrr-uoISIcop
rler.I] ol tBcp1:c ere lern rrBld B Jo sged aql
uo sncoJ ol sJolse^ul sser4snq s/nollB srril
FqoC 'ueld sseursnq e dolanap ol pesn
eq plnorls aJnlcru]s lBuo[]ue^uoc B ]Er.n sI
aJaq aJI pe er{J roplsuoc o} er.4leplnF lsrg
eql s1 ueld arp Jo eJnlcruls ar{J 'ueld sseu
-ISnq a IlceJJe ue dolazr.ep rufi\ rneuarde4ue
rrB 1ertr1 drylqeqo:d aqtr sesBarcul saqlepp8
eseql o1 Fu.ueqpv 'lKoIIoJ o1 rrBld sseulsnq
e Fupgzn esoq] JoJ oIqEI[BAE ere ssr.4leppC .##ry
'suorleJado s.fueduroc E JoJ

lupdanlq E sopl ord pue Fuol ssFed 961


o] 07 sI 1l 'acualpne leurelr.4 ue roJ pared
-e-rd dlpnsn s1 ueld ss3r4snq puolleredo
uV -rolselur u JoJ paredard rreld sseu
-Isnq E roJ ]BruroJ lBnsn sq] sI pue ueld

sseulsnq d.reururns B retl1 IIElap oJoru


qcnu u1 srreld puB suoperedo s..(rreduroc
e ]no s11ads 'seFed gg o] 96 d1pc1dd1 'ue1d
ssaulsnq IInJ v 'EapI JIer{} uI pe}sere}r4 3rE
srolsolul Iellualod I aas o1 ueld sseulsnq
d,reununs E :aq1aFo1 ]nd {eru }nq LrEId
sseulsnq IInJ E roJ pepaeu uoIlBruJoJuI 3rfl
eABr{ },uop sagueduroc eserlJ 'lueurdolelep
go seFels dlrea ar.I] u1 salueduroc roJ ]seq
s{Jo/K pue saFed gf o} OI s1 ueld ssaulsnq
rtreuurns B 'aldurexe Jod 'sue1d sseu
-ISnq Jo spupl ]usreJJlp erB ereqJ 'sreploq
-e{e}s IBuJeJxs J3r{}o puB sJo}se^ul rBl}ue}
-od pue saadoldrue sll are ueld sseulsnq
E JOJ SsJUeIpne ,trerrrpd o.{Y\+ srIJ 'ffiffi?
s.ruJIJ

'dlnrngoddo 1eq1 ans:nd gpo.


sseulsnq er{} uvroq saqlJcsep prre Fulns:nd
sI r.urlJ er{} d}funpoddo sseulsnq eq} q}yr
sJeploqe{B}s Jar$o prre sJo}setul ppuelod
slupnbce 11 '1nJS aq] apISlnO 'salFale.lls
slI Fupncexo uI /\r.oIIoJ o1 deur pBoJ e dolal
-ap duedruoc eq1 sdlaH 1I 'ru.rlJ eql epISuI
',11-rIJ er{} spls}no prrE eplsul q}oq pesn sI
]Eq] ]ueruncop asofund-Fnp e s1 ueld sseu
-ISnq erII 'sasseu-rsnqly\3u }soru rog 'spoF
sll e e1t{oe o} sueld lI lrror{ prre r{s{dtuocce
ol spualul ss3r.4snq
E }erry\ saqgcsep
ueld sseulsnq V
^/Y\3u

IBLI1 eARErrBu uap1:,rl

s1

.
H

#=

,fuen:u:ng Je?dEqJ

lsnreffr-srerrs,,"r,,,^oi""::11"J,L',:r:]#$:',#$::1ft'":pfr

TI"l""#Hil

:de,r. slql lI 1nd 'sqe1 AV 1B s.rrrepv qou


raulred B 'reulou IaBqJIIN 'eJnluel
Jo
sseulsnq aln lnoqe are deql alqeeFpel \oLDI
pue ]eeJ JIar{} uo {ugn srneu
^roq
-arda:1ua IIad\
-ro; Fuprlool d1pc1dd1 eJE sro}selrq ereH '1uepodu1 dlauer}xa
^\ot{
s1 poped re^tstte-pue-uonsanb
eqJ 'eJnlrrel u/Ko rlaq] u1 lueplJuoc dlqllq ere
sraFerretu erp Jerneqltr\ esues o} ,ft} osIE IIIr\ Jo}sa^r4 eqJ 'eJn}ual eril 13o lnd
o] s[pIS ptre ocuagadxe eq] seq ruee] luauaFerrerrr er{} Jerileqra prre s}sp(a
dllunpoddo par B raqleq^4. uo sncoJ {1ec1dd1 sro}selul ,Fupaaru lsrlJ er{} uI
'uollelueserd aq1 ro/prre ueld sseulsnq eq1 errord
-tul ol lI esn prrB UBerI o] {ceqpeeJ s.Jo}selu-r eq} e{B} uec Jneue-rderlua eq1
esneceq sI sIqJ 'rnaua:deJlua eql JoJ JoAEJ B seop uollElueserd :o ueld sseu
-Isnq E ur sessau{Be/r\ rtnuapl o} alqe sI oq/y\ Jo}seAuI r.rB '}cEJ uI 'suonlladuroc
uBId sserlsnq uI suolleluaserd troIIoJ ]Br11 suorsses Je{\slre-prre-uonsanb eq1
seglddl clureudp etues er{L 'uEId ssaulsnq eq} yo lcadse .[reur.a u1 seloq Fuprlod
eq o] sruees Jolselul eql JI dlrelncpred 'peFe:nocslp eruocaq o] Jneuerde4ue
rrE JoJ dsea sI 1I zz'IBcRUc ltran Fuleq sB ssoJce eruoc uelJo sJolsalr.rr esneceg
'sagenb eseq] JoJ perBdard sI pIrB lcedxa 01 ler{ln Jo epl pqos B ser{ rneue;d
-eJlue lrBrus srIJ 'srolse^ul ppuelod dq suollsanb Jo lsoq B pe{sB 3q IIIIY\
:naua-rde4ue rre 'suolsecco luanbesqns uo :o Fu1leeur IEIIIuI eql uI Jer{leqr!\

srCIlsaAul uiol$ *3adx3 ol xsEqpaal pue suollsane


902

N\fid SSSN/SNgVEN|I|HM

H]IdVHC

2oo

pART

2 I

DEVELoPING succESSFUL BUSINESS IDEAS

conventional structure (as noted earlier)


and should not suggest to the potential investor that a great deal of money was spent
to prepare the plan itself.
F.#,4. A business plan has multiple parts, the
first of which is the executive summary.
The executive summary is a quick overview of the entire business plan and provides busy readers with everythin$ they
need to know about the distinctive nature
of the new venture. In many instances, an
investor will ask for a copy of a firm's executive summary and will request a copy
of the full business plan only when the
executive summary is sufficiently convincing. The industry analysis, which is another part of the business plan, describes
the industry a business will enter. The
market analysis part of the plan breaks
the industry analysis into segments and
zeros in on the speciflc segments (or target markets) to which the firm will seek
to appeal. The management team and
company structure section of a business

plan is critical. Many investors and others


who read business plans look first at the
executive summary and then go directly
to the management team section to assess
the strength of the people starting the
firm. The sources and uses of funds statement is a document that lays out specifically how much money a firm needs (if it
is raising money), where the money will
come from, and what it \Mill be used for.
An assumptions sheet is an explanation of
the most critical assumptions that a business's financial analysis is based on.
E*#S. After writing the business plan, the entrepreneur must prepare to present it effectively to potential investors and possibly
others as well. The oral presentation of a
business plan typically consists of 20 minutes of formal remarks, accompanied by
approximately 12 PowerPoint slides, and
40 minutes of questions and answers. The
presentation should be smooth and wellrehearsed. The slides should be sharp and
not cluttered with material.

Key Terms
assumptions sheet, 2Ol
board of advisors, 2OO
board of directors, 2OO
business plan, 182
competitor analysis, 196
contribution margin, 197
costs of goods sold, f 96
executive summary, l9O
fixed costs, 1,97
full business plan, f 8a
market analysis, 194

market segmentation, f 94
marketing strategr, 1v-7
milestone, 194
mission statement, 194
operating leverage, 197
operational business
plan, f8a
or garizational chart, 2OO
position, 194
pro forma (or projected)
financial statements, 2Ol

product prototype, 198


ratio analysis, 2Ol
sources and uses of funds

statement,2Ol
summary business
plan, fa8
tagline, f94
variable costs, 197
virtual prototype, 198

Review guestions
1. What is a business Plan?
6-2. What are the advantages of preparing a
business plan for a new venture?
6-3. When is the appropriate time to write a
business plan?
6-4. What are the two primary reasons for
those starting a new venture to write a
6-

business plan?

6-5. It is often argued that the process of writ-

ing a business plan is as important as the


plan itself, particularly for the top management team of a youn$ firm. 'vVhy is this so?
6-6. Who reads the business plan and what are
they looking for when doing so?
6-7. How will investors typically react if
they think a business plan is based on

a{cBqpeeJ

JoJ lsenbor s.puel-g Jnod o] puodseJ nod


plnoff\ /y\oH -FurpunJ leF o1 ]ue^,l. dlper 1
']s3uoq ag esItf} op I eroJeq elu roJ 3cI
-pE JO SpJO,'!s.,itre arreq nod oq '{ea/v\ }xeu
Fu.ruq8aq srolselr.rl o1 ueld du pues o1
puatt4 t 'BuoI saFed 6 sI Jlesl1 ,treuurns
alpnlaxa artr; 'qfFuel uI seFed OOI Je^o
]Iq E lsn[ pue ellsuaqardruor sI ueld aqa

'uaullrt eA.I ]ErryI\Jo pnord ltrarr ur.I 'eJn]


-Lrer\'rrerr dur ro; rreld sseulsnq eq1 Fu11pzu.
peqslql ]sn[ I ]Bq] /Korr{ nod 1e1 o} }rrely\,,

:spBeJ aFesseur ar{J 'puegJ E ruo4 aFes

-seru IIBru-e uB pellece-r

lsnf nort auIFeuI

'VZ,-g

2,uop.qadruoc

rreld sseulsnq s,d11sren1un aq] uI Funed


-1cp:ed ,(q upF uerey prrB ul ey ]r{Flur
saFeluerrpe ]ErL!\ 'pJBr\ JoJ eloru o1 etug
sI ]I puB slelduroc s1 ueld ssaulsnq s.OZH
eladuro3 }Bq} FuFFre 'EepI eql o1 pesoddo
sI ueJey 'uo111aduroc arn Fugalua Jo JoA
-EJ uI sI u1ney 'uo1111edruoc rreld sseulsnq
lEnuue ue slsoq pue]]B ueJEy prrE ul ey
]Eq],[11sra.tr1un eqJ 'sJo]uec ssau]IJ uI
p3]Bcol s{osr{ IIBurs BI plos aq rulr\ oz,H
aleduro3 ]BrD u1 enblun eq 11l/vr dn-Ue]s
ar{J 'OZH aleduro3 perueu dn-pe1s re}e.{Y\
rre FUI
eploq peJo^BU-]IruJ 'peueles
^.sun
-qcunel Jo ssecord eq1 u1 a-r,daqa 'sJorues
eFelloc eJE nEId uerey ptte s/v\aJpuv upey

o1 esuodser tq r\arprrv., n?:t#;;itftT


]er{r!t.2,Fr411es pue Fwr{c11d ro; eroru lr3}
-]1.rlra 1I sI Jo Frr.uarrocslp prre Fulureel ro3
eJoru uepgrrr ueld sseulsnq e sI 'pesnJ
-uoc ]Iq B IIIIs rue I qoIrIV\ ]noqe ]ulod e
sI eJeq] prre 'rreld ssaulsnq B elIJlY\ ol /Y\oq
lnoqe seIcIFE puB s{ooq IBJeAes pBeJ eA.L
:nod o] Fu1lvrolloJ ern sdes pue eJnluel
slq] roJ uBId ssaulsnq e raqleFol Fu.rpnd
sI eH 'gr.rlJ Fu11lnsuoc (uopez1u41do euIF
-ue r{cJees) OgS elenprd B r{cunel o} JepJo
u1 qo[ elerod-roc s1t{ aABaI o} peplcep seq
'sJelBd\ freJprrv'slno.r( Jo pueuJ pooF v'2,7'-9
ldqzlt pue
esodord nod plnon ueld sseursnq e Fungal
o] sel{ceordde eAI}BuJe}IE }BqA\.2des no,'(
plnoa }Er{/I\ 'sJspunoJ-oc S.SI.ABJIJo euo
eJe/v\ nodg *asuollce[qo duy'Lreld sseu
-ISnq Jno ]no >Icou{ pue sdep;o aldnoc e
JoJ esnoq s,puel{ dur o1 do1de1 dur a>p1 11,1
iaerFe nodSo eerq] er{} JI 'Iooqcs o} FuloF
eJB e \ eJeq r JBatt e{EI E tIO ASnOq e sBq
eugu Jo puepJ y 'ue1d sseursnq Jno oILUV\
o] Jeelunlol o] e{11 p,I os '^[snq dlper 1e
'ples sIAEJJ 'Funaaur

e
L
-

eJ.e.&t ]Eq1 A4.orr{ L,

]uaceJ e

Fugnq 'eJnlrrel JIeq] ro3 Fulpun;

u-rElqo o1 ueld sseulsnq E 3]IJ1Y\ o] poplcep


e^Br{ sJapunoJoc eqJ 'drredruoc pJeoqe}B{s

'tz-g

e Jo sJapunoJoJ JnoJ Jo euo s1

uedg sI eJJ 'IZ,-9

suolls3ns uollEcllddy
auolleluasa-rd Jolselul tte
Fup4eur uI elru euo-Jeqrunu eq] sI ]BI{r!\ 'oz-9
asluerus]Bls IBIc,rBu-rJ
BruJoJ ord pue slueruslels IBIcTTBUIJ Iec
-uolsll{ u3e^\}eq secuereJJlp eql erB ]Er{]Y\ '6r-9
a]3er{s

suopdurnssB rre Jo asofund eql sI ]ErL!\ '8r-9


alualuelEls spunJ Jo .LT-g
sesn pue secJnos E go asofund eq1 sI ]Br{r!\
asuo.rloes luepodurl
]sour er{} Jo arro sB pe}no} ue}Jo ueld sseu
-ISnq e Jo uollces .eJnlcnJls duedruo3
puB rueeJ ]ueueFeue141,, eql sI dqfvf '9r -9
uonces *rreld
arrBld ssoulsnq

B Jo

suoEleJedo,, eql;o esod-rnd eq1 sI ]er{r!\ '9I-9


asuoJJs luelu
-dolarr.ep eql Jo snlels eq1 FupreFar uBId
sseursnq rnod u1 epnlcul nod ppor{s uo-r}
lcnpord
-BruJoJul go eddl ]BrUy\ 'ec1tt:es ro

^\err

dlelalduroc B Fuldolerrap ar.nor{;1 'vr-9

N\fld ssfN/sngv 9NlrlHM

1,ue1d

sseursnq e Jo uo-rlces ..sseulsng er{} Jo


sc1ruouoJg er{J,, yo esodrnd eq1 sI }er{r!\ 'tI-9
2,[4snpu1 PeluaurFe4 B PUB Po]Br1
-uecuoc B ue3.&qeq ecuereJJlp 3q] sI lBr{/!\.zl-9
aueld sseulsnq B Jo uo.rlces sIS
-d1erre 1e{reru aq} pue uopces slsdleue dr1
-snpu} eq] ueelvqeq ecuereJJlp eq} sI }er{^rYUI I-9
A}SEI

uenurK aq 'rre1d sseulsnq e u1 sreedde


]ErD sFu1q1 lsrlJ arp Jo euo sI qclq/\{
'-,(leununs alllncaxe eq] ppoqs dq11 'OI-9
arrBld ssaulsnq [Errol]BJado ue pue
'rre1d sseulsnq IInJ e 'rre1d ssaulsnq -&reur
-runs e Fuoure secrraJaJJlp eq] eJB ler{ \ '6-9
aol.rleeJc prre elnelorrul dgFU eq ueq]
JaTDEJ eJnlcru]s lBuollus^uoc e aoIIoJ o]
rreld sseulsnq E roJ luepodrul ]I sI dq f 'g-g
aslceJ pue slsdlerre InJarBc
uo ueril JeqlBJ suonclperd pue selerr4]sa

I I UlrdvHc
I

,ART

L=u=.oprNG succESSFUL

BUSTNESS IDEAS

6-25. The entrepreneurship class you are taking meets for four hours once per week.
A break of 10 minutes or so takes place
after the first two hours of each class.
During a recent break, you overhead one
of your classmates say to another person
that in her opinion, the teacher is overselling the importance to potential investors of a start-up's management team.
"After all," the classmate says, "A good
product outweighs any deficiency a firm
may have in terms of managers and their
abilities." Given what you have learned
about business plans, what would you
say to your classmate to convince her
that she needs to rethink her view about
potential investors' views about the
quality of a proposed venture's management team?
6-26. d. light, which operates as a for-profit social enterprise, is the focus of Case 6.2.
What, if any, special factors should be
kept in mind when writing a business plan
for a for-profit social enterprise?
6-27. Michael Graves and Jill Simpson just
left their jobs with Microsoft to launch a
business that will sell a new type of fax
machine. They wrote a full business plan
that they've asked you to review. When
reading the plan, you noticed that several
key sections begin with the phrase "We believe...." Is any knowledgable person who
reads this business plan going to know
what "We believe..." really means? What is
the problem with including the phiase "We

believe...." to introduce key sections of a


business plan?
6-28. Recently, Megan, Jennifer, and Mark, the
cofounders of a medical products company, presented their business plan to a
group of investors in the hopes of receiving funding for their venture. One of the
investors asked the three, "How much of
your personal money do each of you have
invested in this firm?" Is this a legitimate
question for the potential investor to ask?
'vVhy would an investor want to know how
much of their own money each cofounder
has committed to the ProPosed new
venture?
6-29. Patty Carroll is thinking about opening a
high-end fashion boutique in an affluent
suburb of Minneapolis. She contacts an
angel investor she knows has previously
invested in this type of firm and asked if
he would read her business plan. She received the following response from the angel investor: "I would be glad to read your
plan. But you should know that when
examining business plans for high-end
fashion boutiques, the section I concentrate on with great intensity is called "The
Economics of the Business." Why do you
think the angel investor concentrates on
this particular section of a business plan
when studying proposals to launch a highend fashion boutique? What specifically do
you think the angel investor is interested
in understanding when concentrating on
this section?

s,Jee^ A oN e Jol suoolleq puB lltoluoc lo 'enboq)eq e


rol ruer.l6ur6 olttl^ pup poJ {UBd [;np 1o qunol B lo]
sJoloc crlo;r1ed se Llcns 'sule11ed pue sloloc luere#lp
Aueur ur elqelrene de rteql 'slouteluoc t,lsetl lsotu L4ltn
osec eL{} sl se 'eroso{e ue e}Eotc uetl} Jsq}BJ }uono lo
[Ued e dn sserp osle [eq1 '{sseut fpelnctped l,usenn

oplsu! r1serl oL1l Il u;e6e posn pue pe;1duo eq o1 q6noue


[prn1s oJe ]nq 'e;qepelOopolq ]uecled 0O L pue e;qesod
-slp orB r{erll'{qreeu uPc qsel} ou s! eleq} oloLlAA setyed
Oulte6llet pue 'seysduec 'scluctd ol sJooplno lq6nolq
oq uec pup olqeuod ere ,teql '{uBd ot,l} lo olpplLu otl} u!

rlspJl 1no Ouryel +noqe [;toan o] oneq ]ou pue esnoL1 otl]
punoJe s;oureluoc s6u;13 letenos dn 1es upc no1'ouo ul
Oeq qserl pue routeluoc dn-dod 6u;puelsooJl e s1 s6u;13

'surelqord eseql sserppe

ol

poleoJc

ool uouo or, sroureluoc orrr",trXlt


mN :**&&ifsl& e sr"rlffi

elon surg s6ut13

ru"#:'JSJ[r?;

ploLlesnoq 'euoq unno lno{ ur Ayed e Ougnnolql e;,no{ 1t


uo^f '/y\olpo^o oI suec e0eqle6lol pue dn e11d ol soluoq
reeq pue suec Epos tol [see s,]l 'tl]Uv\ rclllue+ 1ou el,no,{
+pr.ll Ailllcel e lo 'L{ceoq e '>1;ed B }e [ued e Outmolql
eu;6er.u1 'ls6ue eldoed lueu esnec suotlecllduoc Jo
sed& osaql 'sseutsnq lo otuotl s,uosted e ruoJ; [enne
pleq o.re leLll sluone pup se;ped lP llnc4ltp oq uec

Durlcrtcer pue Llserl Ou;lpueLl puv {11q61sun puB [Ulp


]oO Aplcrnb uec sJouteluoc 6u;pc[ceg .'tl]l/\ leep o]
pJeL{ pue ,tstI111 ueuo ele s6eq qsB[ '[enn lteql ul 1e6
selcelsqo pq '6u11c{cel pue Llset} Ou1lpueq o} soLuoc
1! Ueq/v\ *ltl6u,, s! Ieq/v\ op ol luEA eldoed lsoy\l :t{c}!d
'unl eJou pue reueelc
le;durgs 'se;celdecel 6u;1c[cer pue e6eqrcO Aepfuene
ruorl Aer*p ppq arc lel,ll sluono pue setped 1e Apelnclued
'qser1 6ur1celloc pue OutlclcoJ lo ssecold oL1l soletu letl]
ulq qsBJl elqesodstp 'dn-dod e eleelC :Bopl sseulsng

ualllJfvl se/n osPc slql aull aL{} a"B }un*s*ffi J*$}tj1qL


r{$*& pum surlcA*og d1-dc6 s$ur13 :IooqaseJ r ulo3'sulqmsull$'sruffirvt :Qeffi o

;1ou Aqnn ro Aq6 a,fueduoc s1q1 punl nof


plno^ 'olrsqo^ ot,ll uo pue qcld otll ul pep;notd uo;1
-Bturolur eq1 1sn[ uo uotstcop rnoA oleu ol pPL1 no{ 11 'te-g
a,noA Alstles

plno^ srs^ sue leLlM euolslcop

6u;pun1 inor{ 6u11eu

oroloq sJepuno1 s,tuJl,t oLll ISe no{ p;nonn suotlsenb


leq/\A 'reldeqc slr.ll ul poronoc leuolptu oql uo poseg'ge-g
'elqesnoi s! oct^ep Azzng oL,lI'poledlcllue
sr loqs P JoJ poou eql uoLl^ eclJlo s,Jolcop aql ol uelEl eq
ro 'erur6or eJBc L1lpotl otuotl pesgruedns-uetclslqd e

uBc

1o

yed
se
so^lesureLll
tcelul oqnn e;doed [q posn oq uec
eLll '96'6e$ le pecud st pue osn ouoLl lo;

uorsJon or.uorl

elqelrene osle s! uorsren luegldruoc-V6l ,tttnl V 'sclullc


pue 'spelrdsoq 'socuJo ,sroloop ol plos s; fizzng 'uo!]lpuoc
cluorl1c p lo llnsor or.,ll sp stoL,ls rc;n6er ontecel lsnu oLlA
eldoed Jol lelclloueq Apelnc;ped s; Azzng 'lol-,ls leuolsec
-co up le6 oqnn eldoed 6u;d1eq q1;rn 6uoy 'l-,lcJeosoJ pue
pollpon ueeq seq Icectge s,fzzng
Ourlsel luepuedepul

^q

'peJalsrulr.upe

sr loL{s e roue osnec suol}Pclpol,u otuos }eLll uol}Bsuos


Oururnq oql sloolq osle ll 'uollcefu! eqt uorl uled eq1

)tcolq ol ulerq eql pue oils uollceful eq1 uoe^ leq peceld
uorll sr oc!^op eq1 's6uuv\ o)4ll lool IBL{} slced oc! ulq}
ol soL.lceue eoq Oullerqln eL[ ']or.,ls B no[ 6u;nl6 elo]oq
IcoL4c rnoA 6ur166rt 1s;1uep ol,ll ro rolen ploc Jopun Inc p
6u;qqnr olll lo pupl s,ll 'u;ed eLll Aq pecnpo.td ere ueLll
sfiennqled erueu oL]] dn suor]Bsuos etnlercduel pue

uorlotu re6uo.r1s Oulpuas I;;ere1g; Aq loqs e ,tq posnec


upd eql lno sp/y\oJc uolleJqtn eql pue ploc oL1l'uolleJqln
peeds-q6lL4 tlll^ etnleladuol ploc Io uolleulquoc E uo
peluos relxB8 'Jo 'suollPlnulls lo spu!) luelo#lp qUAA
Ourlueugedxe JaUV 'uleJq eL{} Llceol Aeql eloleq 'p.toc
leu;ds erl+ dn 6u;1ane.r1 spubgs urcd 1drute1ut [;;en1ce
plnoc uorlelnurs fuosues ]o spull snouen teql pelced
-sns 6uol e^pq sJeqcJposeu 'loJluoc 1;eO pellec fuoeq]
lueue6eueu ured e uo seleledo Azzng'oclnep pozls
-urged 'padeqs-eeq e '/.zzng peluenut lelxeg )C '(HlN)
qlpeH Jo solnlrlsul puolleN eql uorl tuer6 uo1lg1tu ;g e

[q

pepre pue 'uorlelueugredxo pue L]cleose; eruos loUV


'sluotulporl eleudotdde enlecet

pue Jolcop eL{} o} oO o} pteJ}e eq le6uog ou

os Oultlleulos op ol

pBLl

plnol

otls leql [ennB 1q6u

N\fId SSSN/SNSV ENIIIUM

uos

JeLl

rrneu),1 oL]S

'clqoqd elpeeu eueceq pue ocueuedxe loqs peq {;1eel e


peLl uos reH 'uotlenps stql qlt/r^ puetllsr;1 6u;Jeop JlosJoLl
punol leqc.reesa u;ed pue uerc;s{qd uool Acue6leue ue
lelxeg Aury rcpuno1 Azng'elec L{}poL4 rc;n6el Outntece.t
pue 'slor.ls nU elll suolleztunuu; Ourge6 'poo;q Outleuop
ruorl uaql sdeel il leLll lot,ls E 6ulue6 lo Inpeol os oJE
eldoed clqoqd elpeeN 'c;qoqd olpeou Aglelelp erc {eq} }eq}
ecuepedxo orlt lo ptpJle os ote egdoed ouos '1cltd le0u;1
ro loqs e Outpe6 ol pJB/v\Jol s)ool ouo ou ellL,l6 :tlclld
's>1clrd

rc6ug pue 's/v\Blp poolq 'spe1s Al elll slctls olpoeu


[letxue pue u;ed

Jor1lo pue loLls e Ourpe6 L{}lA po}Plcosse

oLlI enerlor

sdpq lpL{l oclnep B o}eolC :eepl ssoulsng

sloqsp$xxilffi& :Jal1ldql * fizzng:Iooqaoel * L$*s.fiexnq"nr*nn$e ;q*ffi

602

9 H3J-dVHC

z1o

pARr

2 I

DEVELoptNG succESSFUL BUSTNESS IDEAS

Eve party. While people don't normally think of impress-

ing their guests with their trash or garbage containers,


Flings Bins are quite stylish. Flings Bins are also available that are completely covered in the recycle symbol
and are labeled "Please Recycle Here." There are boxes
that can be checked with a marker or sharpie that say
"cans," "plastics," "glass," and so on, so a host can opt
to set up recycling bins for different purposes.
Flings containers come flat and pop up for use. As a result,
they are easy to transpott and store. As the company says,

"Pop lt! Fill lt!Toss lt! Or Recycle and Reuse!" Each bin has
a 13-gallon capacity (which holds about 60 cans or bottles),
and a drawstring that makes them easy to close and carry.
6-32. Based on the material covered in this chapter, what
questions would you ask the firm's founders before
making your funding decision? What answers would
satisfy you?
6-33. lf you had to make your decision on just the information provided in the pitch and on the company's website, would you fund this company? Why or why'not?

GASE 6.1

Birchhox: teveraging the Coltege Experience to lllrite


a Business Plan and lraunch a1ftIinning Start-up
.

Web: www.birchbox.com

. Facebaok:

Birchbox'Twitter: @birchbox

Oklahoma State University


R. Duane Ireland, Texas A&M University
Bruce R. Barring

er,

*rstnmdu*t&sn

The GCIllege Hxperience

Katie Beauchamp and Hayley Barna met on their first


day at Harvard Business School. They volunteered to
co-coordinate a spring holiday for themselves and 50 of
their classmates. Through the experience they realized
that they worrked well together as a team, but at that
time, they had no thought of co-founding a business.
That all changed just over ayear later, when Beauchamp
and Barna launched Birchbox, a beauty samples subscription service that now has over 400,000 monthly

Beauchamp and Barna quickly became friends. They


were also in the same MBA cohort and took many of their
classes together. The idea for Birchbox emerged gradually. One class was pafticularly instrumental. lt was a class
on disruptive innovation taught by Harvard professor
Clayton Christensen. The class challenged the students
to think of a big idea that's an industry game changer.
Beauchamp and Barna's first idea concerned the beauty
industry, which hadn't experienced significant innovation
for many years. A personal dynamic also nudged them

subscribers.

Birchbox Co-founders
Hayley Barna and Katie
Beauchamp

(penwyoc)

o
=
=.
a
!o

=
o
I
!)_
U)

J
c
o
a
o
x

'olaL,l uA

otls

seuo ot{} ol lPllLuls


are sa;dutes lcnPo.ld
eq1 'se;drues lcnPo.td
elr{fse1l pue'Outtuoo.t6
'Alneeq [ttlenb-qOlq

lo uollcolloc lleus

t,
iil

Sr

s
$

sapnlsul uol,uoM JoJ


xoqL.lcrlg {lq1uout qcel

'sjoqucsqns ooo'oL peq xoqL.lcJ!8'ol0z lo puo oLll


Ag 'sen;esuotll ooptn oql ul poJlels pue dn pesserp 'see

-{oldtre {pee;o eldnoc e q}l/v\ 6uop 'Aeql os lee1un;on o1


sreryo1 mep {snq }eD o} e;q;ssodttt! s,}l }eL{} punol uoos
,teql'(ueuequey\ u! Pole rclndod e) ercnbg uolun ul sleol

-unlo^ ltnrcal o] peu] {eql oeprn lcnpo.td }sJ!} lloLl} epeu


[er.,l] ueqnrr'e;duexe log 'Aean 'unl seuttleuos pue 'p;e[.;
'o;nllu
or.,ll suosse; Aueu pourcel euleg pue duteqcneog
-,rnt Vfyl peq pue snotluololdun senn ocqJo lsll; llotlf 'sle
-rlddns JloL1l ol rosolc oq ol u[11oolg o] xoqL{cllg ponotu
purpg pue dueqcneog 'uotlenpelO rcgy'e;A1se1t; s,luop
-n1s e6elloc e polcollol pue ueel pouleruoJ l! 'loslno eLll
]V 'O LgZ requeldes ut paLlcunel {p1cu}o xoqLlcrlg
'upol xoqL,lcltg deel ol lsoq oq plno^ tl 6ul>lultlt
'sroJlo oL4l uo pessed AeqI'[euou lted eq1 polo$o
lo leJe^os pue 'slstleltdec oJnluon Aq pebpnf senn
uror.ll

uorlrleduroc

eql 's;olueu pue s;oslnpe eueceq

oqiv\

epdoed letl [eq1 's;neue;dol]ue ]uocseu sE PUJeE pue


dureqcneog loJ pue xoqLlcrtg ro1 elnsodxe snopuoueJ+
peprnotd uolllleduoc otll 'ocuop4uoc llotll perelsloq
roLlUnJ L{cltl/v\ 'ece;d puocos uonn

Aeql 'uotltleduoc

ue;d sseulsnq SEH otl] olu! xoqqsllg poleluo euJeg


pue dureqcneeg 'sde1s eseql Oullelduloc JoUV
'elep pue 'sllnse; 'sJotttolsnc lelluolod lo lstl
fueulurr;erd e 'slep;ddns peq ,{eql'Eept ue ueLlt erou peLl
eurcE pue dr"ueqcneeg '1utod slLll lV'seole {e1 ;etenes ut
xoqqcrg pu1Or.ro eql enoldul! ol slesn oLlt Llloll lceqpeo1
posn ,{etll'}decuoc lloq} }so} o} tl}uotu e OZ$ tueq} Aed
o1sroqucsqns 002 poluecu! puB ollsqom JleL1l lo uolsJo^

ploq B poleoJc Aeql'puocos 'uo peuOls s,lqley pue 'sJeN

'sl4euog Ourpn;cut 'setuedtuoo eql lo lerenos {qtpelcul


'(sessegc ltoL1l ut trl6p le4eu le6.le1 rleL{} }o ecuolpne
epeuApee; e ppq ,{eqt)e6eluenpe ue se 1 peuerl Aeql
'peelsul 'e6egloc ul lllls olon [eqt leqt ]ce] eq] pltl reneu
Aeqj'setueduloc sctleusoc pue [1neeq,,pellec-ploc,,
Ieql 'u1-Anq 1eO oI 'ops rol slcnpoJd eqt Jo suolsrol pezls
-llnl reJJo uel,l] plnonn [eq1 'Luot,l] ]noqe eroLu ureol plnoo
rourolsnc eql os '1cnpold Llcee lnoqe leuuetic oqnlno1
pup olrsqal JtoLll uo pd eq plno^ uolleturolu; 'seldtles
lcnpord ftneeq eAU uteluoc plnol xoq eLll'tlluoLu qce:l
'sseursnq oql Io lsor otll q6norql lq6noql ueql {eq1 'xoq
oL1l ul pelueserd oq plnol se;dutes oLll A oL4 peululelop
pue se;dutes filq1uotu eq] pues plnol [eq1 qctqnn u! xoq
Ieql '1st13 'socrnos oL,ll o11q6te4s
or.ll Io edAlolold e illnq

llz

N\fld sssN/sn8 v eNU-luM

oO ol spl suotlsenb osoLll lol SUe o1 'peln6tl Aeql [enn


[;uo eq1 asoseL]ilnd pazrs-;;n] onup se;dues plnon 'pllql
puy aseldulPs ]o sexoq polelnc rol Aed uouo^ plno/\^
'puocos a,se;dues outpno.rd ol pleoet ul 'LUoLll tlll/v\
IJoA spuelq &neeq plnon 'lsJll 'suotlsenb leluotuepunl
ealll] Jalv\sue o] peq eule8 pue dueqcneo8 'IloA o]
xoqqcllg JoJ 'sleuolsnc pue sle;lddns qlnn loop ot,l] u!
lool ltol,ll 6u;pe01o Aenn e sE snlels luopnls lleLl] pesn
osp Aeql'xoqqoJtg oq plnon sselc qoeo ut lcelord ;eut1
rrotll os srosse;o.td llot,ll L4lln pelerlo6eu Aeql'snlels
e6elloc rteql e6elenol oI plnoc Aeqt Dutqtfuone plp eulBg
pue drueqcneeg 'xoqqc;lg L{cunel o} fu} ueq} pue ecuo
-pedxe e6elpoc Jtotl1 uo ]no unl )1colc oL4l lol uel,ll lot,lleu

xsqLisJl$

l0l

punoJry ffiutlsag V-pJBniPp{ }e Jt}sstalog }se'I


'xoqLlcll8 ssoulsnq lloL,ll llBc ol poplcop BUIeE

pue dtueqcneeg 'so;ols ul lno pepueLl Aeql teql seld


-ues 6ut1eu Apeerle orenA spueJq lo[eu oL,lf 'oles loJ
ollsqon lloul uo seldules oLl+ lo suolslen pozls-lln; ro#o

uorl] plnonn [eq1 '1no &1 plnoc srotuo]snc po4llenb leq+


se;dues lcnpotd [1neeq ]o xoq lletus P ]o pe]slsuoc
lerll oclntes uotldltcsqns flq1uout oulluo ue sBA Pepl
s,eurpg pue dureqcneeg 'lsl4 uelll 6u;ees pue 6ut
-qcnol InoL4ltn slcnpold fineeq 6ul[nq lol oAPL1 eldoed
leLll uotlellseLl ol1l punole 1eO pue 'eut;uo slcnpo.td
{}neeq 6u;11es 1o firunpoddo otl} uo ez;;e1;dec oI 'tuotlt
o] luotuole looJ pue '4.t1 'tlcnol P e^eq Aeql esneceq oull
-uo lles ol r.,l6nol ole slcnpord Alneeg 'slsnpold [1neeq
lou ]nq 'uotllspl Outpn;cut 'eut;uo slcnpord Aueu lles
o1 sAenn leerb ulllnn dn euoc peq solueduto3 'pelllt eq
o1 edu eceldlelreu ol,l+ ul plon e BS r{er{I leq1e6o1
^
sseursnq e Outuels Inoqe 6u11urq1 eron {eq1 'eult} }sll}
oL1l roJ 'tuerOo.td VEy\ teeA-onnl lleql Jo JelsoLuos ]sel
eLl] ul pocseleoc slqOnoql s,euleg pue dtleqcneeg

,,aLuorl] ol slcnpoJd Ilneeq pueuuocer plnoc pue lollpo


{1neeq p se^ }el,l} puaut }soq e oneq o} o)1ll ueuon fuene
'uloql
l,uplnol ,, 6u;lurql PUlPg pue dureqcneog ]o0 il
popuotutuocoJ peq (,roUpe {}neeq eq1) ueq3 }eq} Aes sAenn
-p plnon eqs 'uotll1oO eqs o;otll pelse uoqn pue 's1cn
-pord fineeq lsoq oLll peq sAennle BUJEE leLll ocllou plnol
dureqcneog loltpo {}neeq P seAA'uotlC olllol4 'puop} }soq
s,euJeg fu+snpul ftneeq oql ul eopl sseulsnq B spremo+

I I UlrdvHC
I

212

pARr

2 I

DEVELopTNG succESSFUL BUSTNESS TDEAS

ffifrrchbmx Ymdmy

Birchbox today is operating on all cylinders. The company has 400,000 monthly subscribers. lts monthly
subscription service for women, which costs $10 per
month, is much the same as it was when the company
originally launched, except that subscribers now fill out
a beauty profile and several versions of the monthly box
are sent out. ln 2012, the company launched Birchbox
Man, a $20 box filled with men's grooming supplies and
lifestyle products. It also started testing a limited edition
"home box" for $58 a month that will include home d6cor products and items such as seasonal napkins and
decorations. ln September 2012, Birchbox acquired
JolieBox, a Paris-based competitor. The acquisition
will allow Birchbox to more effectively enter European
markets. Along the way the company has grown to 140
employees and raised almost $12 million in funding.
The company's performance metrics are also
strong. The number of monthly subscribers in all of
its categories continues to grow. More than half of its
monthly subscribers make purchases from the firm's
e-commerce store, and the e-commerce store now represents a quarter of its revenue. Birchbox's online store
even attracts business from nonsubscribers. About '15
percent of the company's orders come from customers
who don't get the monthly box of sample products.
Birchbox's model is also working out for its suppliers. Traditionally, beauty suppliers have tried to acquire
customers by handing out samples at their counters and
in other parts of stores and malls. Birchbox's customers,
in stark contrast, actually pay to be acquired through
the monthly subscription service. They in effect opt-in
and explicitly want to be sampled. When Birchbox sells
a full-sized version of something that was sampled
through its subscription service, it shares the revenue
with the supplier.
Sha$fengem A*remd
Despite its success, Birchbox has significant challenges.
It may at some point plateau in terms of subscribers for

its staple women's subscription service. New markets


may be more difficult to grow. For example, the number of products and product samples made for men's
grooming and lifestyle supplies is much lower than
those made for women. lt may also be difficult to find
as large a following for products like home d6cor as for
women's beauty suppliers

Another challenge Birchbox faces is growing


competition. A number of start-ups have replicated
Birchbox's monthly subscription service for beauty
product samples for women. While Birchbox remains
the clear leader in this space, the number of competitors it is attracting is somewhat worrisome. lnterestingly,
while it doesn't directly impact Birchbox's business, the
company has also inspired a wave of companies selling
monthly boxed products in almost every conceivable
area, including fishing, food, crafts, kids' toys, products
for dogs, and wine.

Discussion Questions
6-34. How effectively do you think Katie Beauchamp and
Hayley Barna used their time in college to advance
their business idea?
6-35. ln what ways is Birchbox's business approach a
win-win for both its suppliers and its customers?
6-36. How was writing a business plan and preparing
for a business plan competition helpful to Katie
Beauchamp and Hayley Barna while Birchbox was
still in the planning, testing, and prototyping stage?
6-37. Going forward, what are the most serious challenges
facing Birchbox? Which of these challenges do you
believe is the most threatening to the firm's success? Why?
Sources; Birchbox home page, www.birchbox.com, accessed
March 1,2014; A. Groth, "Exclusive Q&A: Birchbox Co-Founder on
HSB and the Advice They Got from lnvestors," Business lnsider,
www.businessinsider.com, acessed March 1, 2014; A. Dizik,
"MBA Enrepreneurs Think Outside the Box for Beauty Business,"
Financial Times, March 3, 2013; T. Baldwin, "Entrepreneur's
Corner: Birchbox," The Wharton Journal, February 28,2014.

GASE 6.2

d.light: How Bringing lts Business Plan to Life Helped


a Social Enterprise Get Off to a $trong Start
* Web: dlightdesrgn.corr, * Facebook: D.lightDesign

Thitter: @dlightdesign

Bruce R. Barringer, Oklahoma State University


R. Duane lreland, Texas A&M University

lntnoduction
lmagine the following. You're in the audience of a business plan competition. The next team up to present is
d.light, a for-profit social enterprise that plans to bring

light to people without access to reliable electricity.


Two young men introduce themselves as the founders
of d.light, and say they're going to start their presentation with a demonstration. The lights go out. ln a few

(penu4uoc)

pue odel,ls oIEl [uedtuoc eq1 Ourdleq u; peIeld ueld


ssoursnq s,{ueduloc or.l} }BLl} alol le}ueunl}su! oL,l} st

lLl6ll'p ]noqe

sllel 6uunp sossolls ueulploe

6urq1

eug

$uolleluasajd
Jslsanuf pue suo!1*gedu.rag usld s$aulsng
'euezuet puP 'Eurtlc 'erpu; ur
sec4lo leuorleurolur ISrU s1r peuedo pue 6uruun;-pue-dn
ou sen lll6ll'p '6urnurluoc nM pue 'uezo1 'ueulplog
flree ur euos pouutr.l] tupo] oL1f 'L1cJposol
A

L1lU\\ '8OOZ

6u;op rcuueAyl Io elppr.u eL{} ul sBA uetllp;og '[;rue;


slr.l oos ol oruol,l Our;enerl lo peolsul '1eelq setulspr.lC
6uun6 'edAlolord rleL.ll +noqe lcpqpeel 6u;u1e1qo Jo
esodrnd ol,ll JoI spoJp olotlel o1 Our;eneJl ponutluoc
sJepuno]-oc srrl pup ueuploe 'g0OZ {pee ll}un /O0Z

]o rouruns oql porenoc Llclqm 'polled srql 6uun6


'1e11dec luotu
'suo#e OgU

-ISeAUr Jolcos-olenud etrnbe.l

leuorlrppe pue qsec

plnon

L{clq/v\

olel plnon suotltque {yo; Jtorl}

}Er.l}

A oul ueol slL1 pup ueuploe 'eldoed Jo suotllLu lo spoJp


-unq lcedur! ot 1nq eldoed uor;;rtu e .ro eldoed OOO'OO L

lcedu; ol lou senn ;eo6 s,[uBdruoc oL1I 'Aueduroc 11o;d


4ole oq plno^ lL{6ll'p }pr.,l} uo [pee operu sEM uols
-!cop or.['elqegord oq o] ]116ll'p.rol sur6leu ]uetct#ns
peplerfi 1eq1{enn p ut pecnpold 6ureq 1o elqedec 1e[ 1r
pJo#e plnoc sre6el;ln 1eq1 q6noue deeqc eq ol peq osle
]l 'ssol Ourqlou pue eJoru Ourqlou-popoou sre6ell;n
[;1cexe se^ ]EL1l ]L{6ll Cll elqeyod perennod
IEJnJ leL1l^

-Jelos e ecnpord ol sE^ 1eo6 eq1 '+ce[ord eq1 qlrnn dleq


o1 'srseq ouoq o;d;eeu E uo polJon oqn 'syedxe uorl
-nqulsrp pue sJoou;6ue peluolel poltnJcol 'pUoAA eLll

lnoq6nolql sa^tl s,e;doed lo suo!llLu Illele1g 6u;6ueqc


firlrqrssod orll
roL.l1ou +Br.,ll

[eql ereqn
EUIqC

u1

1o

uonup 'uree1 slr.l pue ueuploe oS

'olqeurelsns SEAA slepou osoql Io


^q
uetuploe ol reolc spm Il '{pood peutoyed

'oJot.ln oslo pue EoU]V o] uer-1] 6u;yodxe pue


s1q6rl enrsuedxeul {1euet1xe Ourlnq sesr.rdlelue

lercleutrJoc.ro 'uelolq +t Jo dn pesn ueql ece;del o1


proJJE ],uplnoc [eq1 qcrqm'A1tcu1ce1e o] ssecce ]noq]tm
eldoed o1 s1q611 enlsuedxe {prel ,,6utA16,, slueurutenoO
puP socN uo Jequo pollol slepoul snot^eJd 'uollnq
-Ulslp pue u6rsep Io uotleutqruoc p spl 'uorleurrlse
s,r.ueo+ srrl pue ueulploe ur 'ue;qo.ld eu{J_ 'sorut} Iuetu
porJl uoeq peL{ l! '}cEJ ul 'A ou },usen seoJe lelnt lood
ur slq6r; elqeyod e6leqcel ol tennod Jelos 6ursn 1o ldec
-uoc oL.ll 'ldecuoc ssoutsnq Jtorl+ uo IJoA o] onutluoc
ol peururolep (poyunel [eq1 'lle] oLl] ul rotuulns eqt
rol suorlcollp oleJedes lteql popeeLl soleultueo] oL1]
'esrnoc u6;se6 ;euneueldoJluf eq1 Dullelduoc roltv
*.rCItlnqil&s[ffi

puu ufigsag

'lrl6lu le ]q6ll popoou 'oo1 '{eq1 'sed[1o1oid el]l


polpcs4uoc ecr;od lecol or.l] e6ellrn ouo ut 'dr.r1s,uee1eq1
lo lunocce ouo o1 Ourploccy'1denn [;;en1ce ueu]ol ouo
leL{} ue)B} os eron steOe;;rn oLl} 'sotuor1 Jloq} uo sleued
Jelos lleus DurAoldep {q {durrs {ep eq1 6uunp pe6teqcet
oq pup lrlOlu 1e lq6ll eprnotd plnoc edAlolord opnrc Jter.l1
A OL4 uA Or.lS UOIJM 'oUOSOJOI uO OrUOCul

ew

N\fld ssfN/sn8 v

eN[tuM I I

rloql1O lUeoled

0t

o+

dn lueds {eq1 ueq} plo} sre6eg;r1 'ocr^ep rloll}

ocnporlur o1{lrculcelo o} ssoccp oneq },up!p leql se6e;


-lrn olur 6ugo0 1o esodrnd eqt Jol ptulng o] poloneJl rueol
eq1 '6ulrds leq1'reanod rplos ern pe6teqcal eq plnoo

ler.l] lrl6ll O3l slqpuod e 1o ed{}olold q6nor e pedo;en


-op pue [1rcrr1ce;e elqerlor ol ssocce ]noq]tl eldoed
ro11q6rl lo ruolqoJd e..,1+ pollcel tueo] oql'nM uErX pue
operlsf ecrJf 'sluepnls OuueeurOue oA + pue 'eleussplc

ssoulsnq e'unzo1- peN L,llliv\ dn peureel sen ueruploe


'pUoM burdolenep oLll u! onssl luecrlru6rs B ssolp,pe o+
peOuelleqc sEA rupo+ Llceo pue 'sureol olut peptntp sBAA
sselc oqf 'esrnoc u6rse6 ;euneueldorluf LOOZ-qOOZ
s,llloled r!r[. sem sselc ;elonrd y 'es;rdle]ue letcos ut
uerOord e Oulyels sEA LlcrL1A 'proluels +p popuel oH
ftrculce;e olqello.r o] ssocce lnoL1lrl^ eldoed ol lrl6ll elet
o] ssoursnq e 6urleerc lnoqe 6ur>lurql UEls ol firunyod
-do eq1 urL{ eprnord plnoan 1eq1 urerOoid elenpet5 e
po lq6nos ueuploC 'ocuouodxe srql Iq pelcedurl
'seprnord 6u;1q6r; olqerloJ suleuoq
oLll Inoquan elqeur6purun oJo^ teull1,l6lu 1e s6urql op pue
'pee; '>1ooc A ou plnoc oH 'olll s,uosred E ur e)euJ uec
]L{6!u }p }r.1611 Ourneq Aldru;s }Brl} ecuoJegp c!}ptuerp ell} Iq
Icnrls sel pue 'due;peeq Cfl poJonnod-fuepeq e uenr6
sBAA uetuplog 'eOe;1!A oL1+ u! our!] s;q 6upnp lurod euo lV
'ueuploe pepedur Aldeep ler.,ll tuono ue 'e;rl ouosoJol
B ur poujnq ,{lpeq senn Aoq roqqoreu y'firculcolo ou pErl
1eq1e6egl;A uEcUlV +soM B ur s;ee[ rno] Jo] ponrl oL1 'sd.ro3
oceod oL1l rol 6ur>1tonn ellLl/v\ 'llnpp 6unoA p sV 'soplunoc
lelpul 'nro6 'uelsrled ut pentl
JoL1lo lEJeAes pue 'EpeuEC
ueruploe 'eqo16 oL1+ ssotce sorJlunoc ut ocuelstsse uptJpi
-ruEUnLl pue clurouoco soprnord teql Acue6e lueuruleno6
B '(ClVSn)1ueudolo^eg lpuorlpurolul ro+ Acue6y solels
po]lun eL{} Jol polrom s1uercd s.uer.uploe 'dn Durnnotg
'poorlunpe fipee pue qpoA s,uptuploe ulES o] pecptl eq
uBc Ouruur6eq s1; 'I1stanru61 prolupls le sselc p ut pouels
{llecruqce} }qOll'p qOnoqly [ycr4ce1e olqe!lor o] ssecce
eAeL{ },uop oLlA sror.unsuoc ,,prure;Ad oL,l} }o oseq,, Ouprues
Aueduoc slcnpo.rd Jounsuoc lpuotleulelut up sl lq6ll'p
'srolsonur peqclrd Ieql ueqnn pue suot1leduoc ueld sseu
-!snq 1e {ueduoc eLl} pecnpoJ}ul '}Ll6!l'p Jo slepunoJ-oc

eL{} 'unzof poN pue upuploC ueg Aenn eq} s,}l 'sotul}
lerenes-eceld 1oo1A11en1ce oJotl peqtJcsop ouocs eqf

lq6!l'p;o sul6pl0 aql pLrH r"re*Irplcg

LupS

'sror.lto Jo] suorleo;dr,uoc L,llleorj ssol

-lunoc osnec pue leef ted e;doed uor;;rr.r.l g'L lll) soun]
euesoJol +Bq] seleulllso suotlBN pellun oLll'+cEl ul 'lElpj
uens 'Aqi;eequn [;euetlxe ele sotun] ouosoley ']L{6lu
lB sorloL,l lleql tq6rl o] euasolsl ssn eldoed oseql,o
oreqs e6re; y'{lddns }uoplr.u;olur ro elqe!loJun uE eneq
oror.u uollllq B ]noqe pue 'Alrcr.rlcolo o] ssaccp ou enpL.l
'uor1e;ndod s,p1;onn oL,l+ Jo qlJU ouo uer-l+ olotu ;o 'e;doed
uollllq g'L puno;y '1urod E oleJlsnllr o1 peOels sB^ uotl
-Bllsuoruop oL1l {es 1nq 'e)ou.ls oL,l} pue }Ll6ll Jo Icel eL{}
rol ezrOo;ode ueur 6unoA eqf 'sleolc alouls oLl+ pue uo
lcpq Llclr^ s slq6ll orlf 'eqleelq ol olqeyoltrJocun {11qOr;s
seuroceq +l pue Jelel o1UEls se{e tnofi 'spuoces 0e
lnoqe JoUV 'ouosolol bururnq pue olouls lleus pue
eql ]o luoJ+ eLll ]E ]116ll ullp e oos no{ 'spuoces
'LUooJ

UfldVHC

214

pART

2 I

DEVELoptNG succESSFUL BUSTNESS TDEAS

updated frequently. These numbers reflect the impact


of the availability of light, produced by d.light solar
lanterns, for people who didn't previously have access to reliable electricity and light. The numbers are
remarkable, particularly in terms of lives empowered,
school-aged children reached with solar lighting, and
savings in energy-related expenses. The numbers reflect the good that a well-managed social enterprise
can create.

in raising investment capital. Early on, d.light entered


several business plan competitions. lt the spring
of 2007, it took second place in the University of
California, Berkley's Social Venture Competition and
won first prize at Stanford's Social E-Challenge. A big
breakthrough happened in May 2007, when the team
claimed the $250,000 first prize in the prestigious
Draper Fisher Jurvetson Venture Challenge competition. This money provided seed funding for much of
the work that was completed during the summer and
fall of 2007.
What's particularly interesting is Goldman's reflections about why d.light was so successful in business
plan competitions and eventually with investor presentations. These reflections are instructive for entrepreneurs as they think about how to design and then successfully launch their ventures. As shown in the nearby
table, there are six reasons that account for d.light's
success, specifically with business plan competitions.
Collectively, the attributes shown in the table present
d.tight as an organization with a compelling idea, a
strong management team, large markets to serve, an
intense product focus, and a coherent, resolute, and
extremely admirable vision for the future.

d.light's $ocial lmpact Dashhoard

Number

Category

28,785,844

Lives empowered

7,196,461

School-aged children reached with


solar lighting

$905,549,027

Saved in energy-related expenses

9,276,143,334

Productive hours created for working


and studying

2,125,754

Tons of CO2, offset

37,590,326

kWh generated from renewable energy


source

d.light Today
Today, d.light is having the impact that its founders

envisioned it could. The nearby chart shows the numbers on d.light's social impact dashboard, which is

o
o
o
o)

z=

d.light sells its product through a number of channels in more than 30 countries. One strategy that has
worked well is to employ "rural entrepreneurs" to sell
the product. d.light likes to employ indigenous personnel, who know the local customs, people, and
language, to sell its product on a commission basis.
It also has partnerships with NGOs, microfinance organizations, and social enterprise start-ups that are
producing solar lanterns to achieve the same goals it
is striving towards. ln 2013, d.light entered into a major
partnership with Total, a French oil and gas company
that sells d.light's products as part of the "Access to
Energy Program" throughout Africa. As a result of the
Total partnership, and its initiatives across the world,
d.light now makes more than 500,000 of its solar lanterns per month. The first few years of its existence,
d.light's production was more in the neighborhood of
20,000 to 30,000 units per month. d.light has funded
its operations and growth through both investment
capital and earnings. d.light is also continualty updating its products. For example, its newest design incorporates a smartphone charger, knowing smartphones
are the lifeline of many small business owners and others in developing countries.

o)

o
E
o)

U)

o
o

-c
(L

o
.E

E(E

o.

o
-c

lndian mother of three with her d.light solar-powered lamp.

Ohallenges Ahead
As it continues to grow, d.light faces a host of challenges. The problem it is trying to solve, to provide
a reliable source of light to people without access to
electricity, is as large as ever. The United Nations now
estimates that over 2 billion people in the world do not
have access to reliable electricity. lncredibly, that number is higher than when d.light was founded in 2007.
Its for-profit status is also periodically challenged. A

'600Z'B roquoldos'lr.ulLl'gezfl rplop


/sAAOq5/6rO'lroA lousuorlEsJo^uoc' cts//:duLl' $ec pod s u o |]es'/ aAuoc
uoyeAouul ppos,,'luouldoganoq cLuouoca o1 [ep1 eq1 6ul1qDq,,
'ueurploe 'S pue uBruetnqlos 'S :OLOZ 're AeW!'aurre1eyy
ssau/sngr pJoluels,,'Elpul ul sebue;;eqC lecttcetd 1eeyr1 sleog Ago-'1
s,lLl6|I'p,, leuerpl 'I:VIOZ 'L LIcJE1A possocce 'uroc'lo1ruousc'Ml A
'JOJ|UOW aCuaps ue!$utlc aql ,,esocloJ ulor luEle llo uB puE
esudrelu3 prcos p uoLlM sueddeg leq1 ,, 'peu[ean7 'V :VIOZ'I
oJE 17\ possocce' uroc'1sod uo$u rgnq'anarran';so6r u o76 u ryn g eq1
r.,f

,,

[do;q1ue1rqd

]o pUoM eq16ur1dnlsr6 AlelelduoC sJnouoJde.rlu3

lelcos oql loey\,, lesanog


possoccE'

'f!

r-uoc' uOrsoplq

61

d pue sre663 'M:VLOZ '97 &enrqe3


p'rvrman'ebed euoq lq 6l l' p .'sac./nos

eI! Oulseqcrnd qpnn pelercosse sgrouoq oL,l+ pue lcnpord


Jno^ lnoqe ppo^ aL{} Jo seore e}ouol ut oldood 6u;1ec
-npo +noqe oO noI plno^
aoq I6elBrls 6urle4retu
^AoH
.rno{ p;noan }BqM 'sJapunol
s,}q6tl'p }o ouo oJoA no^ il
asUoJJo rlounel sil ul tq6ll'p podlor.l ssoutsnq
psleoJc {;snolncrleul B 6ur^ELl),lulrlt no{ op s{Bnn IELIA^
u| 6ueld ssoursnq s,+r{6!l'p lo ocuBuoduu; eq1}noqE
ueurp;oe LUES soop r{qnn

IlEl ol Aenn srq

+o +no oO

esdlllr.ld ro (crr1ce13 pleueg)


1ou

{}!cu}colo olqerloJ o} ssacce

oqnn e;doed o11q6r; 6u;6upq 1o

fe

'tr-g

'6e-g

sE Llcns

onpL4

'lEoO oL{} Dulnorqce o1[enn


sU uo lle/n aq o1 sreedde il'OZOZ {q eldoed uotlltul OO L
lsPel lE jo so^rl or.ll lcPdrul ol s! leo6 polpls s,1q6r1'p
'uorlcelloc

roqunu }coho sl '0gZS orl} 'ure}uel crseq


'spelqo OO L ul pUoM oql lo fuo1sgg s(runosnl4

eL{} ul 00 L

s,1r.l6!l'p

r.lsllyg etll ul eceld sll s! uo!]cullslp ecru [pelnoyed eug


'peqsrldtrogce seLl ll ]BL,l/v\ ozruoocer o] spre^ P snorounu
pa^Bcar seLl LU.rU aq1 'eldoed 1o suorlllru ]o sonrl or.ll
Lu

aoLlelaJ#p e opetu {pee1c oneq sUoJJo s,}Ll6ll'p

'suroluel crseq sll Jo


lurod ao!.id aLlI remol ol 6ur&l [;;enurluoc osle sl ]116ll'p
'lrns ,$olloJ o+ sreqio rol urolupl lrl6ll'p e OurAnq e6elltn

e ur uos.led fer]uanl]ur up soIE] uogo ]l 'sontl ,sle6e;1rn


Aueur Jo Ued pr6elur up sr ]r 'slcege oprs Inlureq [ueu
sBL{ aLraso.lal q6noqly'[6o1our.lco] Jerlrle]un u! lsonut
ol ou.rocu{ e.Uxa al111l e Ll}rA s;otuo}snc }ue}srsoq 6urcurn
ocp} o} senur}uoc osle }q6ll'p
aoerl Jo]

-uoc ]o e6ualpqc

'Ofg

afircrr1ce1e olqellor o] sseccE

lcel oq^ ppo^ orll ul eldoed lo suollllq eq1o11q6r1


Outptno.rd 1o uelqord oql o^los uroq+ dleq 1lrnrr 1eq1
o^pr1 ueol slrl pup ueuploC ues op se;ylenb lpqM
'fiueduroc 6ul+t,l6rle6;e; e {q {ean lnlOurueeul B ut pol

-IcE] 6u;eq

},uop

ulelqold oql sl ,(qnn 'gg-g

suollsono uolssncsro

oL{}

Aervre ular.il+ 6urnr6 sl OCN [qleeu e 1; slq6lg relos 6ul11es


6urnr1 e ayeu 'sen6re {uBdr.uoc or..l}'EAuoy ur rneuerd
-eJluo ue LrsJ /y\oH rolces elenud eq1 qonolql ftlnrlce
ssaursnq alplnurls ol sr 6ur1q6r; elqerlel 1o eDepoqs
eprAAppor$i aL11aHcB+ A;enrlcege o1{enn Aluo eq1 }eq} s!
]uaunfue slLli o] Jelunoc s,+tl6ll'p '{enne suJolupl Jroq}
enr6 pue slgo.rduou oq plnoL,ls lrl6ll'p o)rl serueduroc 1eq1

a^orleq sleA.,rsqo

eldoed ,{ueu }o

ue 'srellop 'S'n

euos 'soulunoc pedo;eneplopun

L{ceo.r eq1

ut

puo[eq surerlor ]Brl] ]unotue


eq1 slsoc ureluel ]q6ll'p

0t lo luolenrnbe

'uotlezrue6ro
peleeured
oql
uorsrn pue asodlnd 1o esuos srql
'pelcedult
{;entltsod
solllr.rp}
ioqrunu
eq}
ssoccns sU pornsBotu o6[p ]rj6ll'p '1e1ldec
ll
Jo
rolcos-olenud etn peqst;dutocce oq Aluo p;noc^q
olecs o1 Ourge6 leql apilosa"r seir\ ureal aqf
'o;nluo^ 1;lord-tol e sp lloslr pelueserd Ilpeureqseun U 'esr.rdrelue letcos E s8,,,\ 1'r.{6ll'p q6noqlly
'ece;d lool suorleJolt erou os 'q6rq ool lltls sern acud aLl+ Ipql pelectpu!
Icpqpeol {pe3 'gzg punore }o }uole^tnbe 'g'1-1 p ro} plos E^oN oqf 'E^oN er.,l} pl{pc '}qOll Cfl
elqeyod perennod-relos
pa+erail fruedruoc eq1
slr uo 6ur;pes
eJoleq
sourl
e;dr1;nul
octnop
sll
lsr4
'go,ted prluelod eq1

se^ os '1eer6 senn eoualleqc oLl+ ollrlM'slrun ]o suorllrru llos pup ssoursnq aL{+ ellEcs ot o^eq plno^
ueel oLll 'IloA slEtcuEUU loql oletu ol_ 'o)!l srolsenur qclql '1e1leur e6rel e 6ut;1ce1 servr 1q6rl'p
'ocr^ep Jrolll lnoqe )le1 o1 se6e;;rn olotuoJ o1 Our;enell lnoqe su.rorpqlrjut ou ppq
{eq1 1eq1 po}BJ}suoulep perl sJoqruotu ueol JoL,l}O 'up}sr}ed pue Etpul a4l1 saceld u! 'oJll slr.l }o
{ltlofeuu otl} sposro^o ponrl ppq ueuploe 'e^r}erlrur leqo;6 e Ourqcunel rol puns-llem sem ruee}
eqf 'oslliodxe Ouueeut6ue pue ssoursnq Jo ocueleq e qll/\A 'l.ueo1 6uo.t1s e.r,eq1a6o1 pd 1q6rl'p
'suorleluoserd ueld ssoutsnq eL{} alo+aq, sL!.,rec sdul eq11o
otuos 'l! plp puP +no luo^ lsnl {eq1 'ecrnep Joql }so} o1 se6e;1rn o}ouJar o} pAtsr} o1 peuueld Aeql
leql 6utAes lo peolsul ,,'Ilpn orll pollen ,, oslE Ieql ,,'>1;e1 eql 6ur1|el,, r.{}lA\ 6uo[V 'ar.u!} lln} }L{6ll'p
uo posnsol pue sqolelelodloc uo pessed ,{etll'}rl6ll'p o} popr..rluloc ,{1;n1a"laAr srapuno} eql
'uorlpluose;d s,1q6r;'p poJoquouloJ {eq11uepr}uoc serfi eq 'frep e Ouunp pJeoq
sJolsonut to se6pnl;o dnot6 e seqclrd io sue;d [ueur A or.,l Joueul ou ]eq] paXJeuJeJ uetuplog
'metrue1ut ouo ul 'sletuoturlsal Jrorll porqlls pue 'ecrnep rleql 6ursn sle6eglm lerru ]o sqdelboloqd
po^Aol".ls sjopuno] s,{ueduuoc ot,['sernlcrd ouranoqs puE seuo]s 6ur11a1 uo pasncoi ]Ll6ll'p 'slurod
lollnq pue soptls lutodJolno6 entsserdull qllm suorlrleduuoc ue;d ssautsnq ra1lo surpel r{ueu ollr.,l7171

uo!sn 6uor1g

sncoJ lcnpojd

1e1rcy1 6;9

rueof

tr.46lU

UI IIV

sornlcrd po^ orls


puP sorrols plol

suolilIsdruos ueld ssoulsng u! Inlssa3cns servl rq6!l'p suoseaH {ay xls

glz

N\fld ssfN/sns v eNU-ruM

ull-dvHc

21o

pART

2I

DEVELopTNG succESSFUL BUSTNESS TDEAS

Exrds:*tes
1. S. A. Alvarez and J. B. Barney, "Entrepreneurial
Opportunities and Poverty Alleviation,"
Entrepreneurshtp Theory and Practtce 38, no. 1
QOr\: 159-184.
2. A. Tjan, R. Harrington, and Tsun-Yan Hsieh,
Heart, Smarts, Guts and Lttck (Boston, MA:
Harvard Business Review Press, 2Ol2).
3. The Hartford SmallBus[ness Success Shtdg,
20 L L Available at http : / /newsroom. thehartford.
com, (accessed March l,2Ol4).
4. S. Barlett, "Seat of t]:e Pants," fnc., October 2OO2.
5. J. Brinckmann, D. Grichnik, and D. Kapsa,
"should Entrepreneurs Plan or Just Storm the
Castle? A Meta-analysis on Contextual Factors
Impacting the Business Planning-Performance
Relationship in Small Firms," Entrepreneurshtp
Theory andPractice25, no. I (2010): 2+4O.
6. "Meet Lindsey Wieber and Gwen Whiting," [,adies
Who Launch, www.ladieswholaunch.com, (accessed July 20, 2OO7), originally posted January

t6, 2007.
7. A. Parhankangas and M. Ehrlich, "How
Entrepreneurs Seduce Business Angels: An
Impression Management Approach ," Journal oJ
Bustness Venturirg, 20 | 4, in press.
8. R. Zachary and C. S. Mishra, "Research
on Angel Investments: The Intersection of
Equity Investments and Entrepreneurship, "
Entrepreneurship Research Journal 3, no. 2
(2013): 160-170.

9. H. Scarbrough, J. Swart, K. Amaeshi, and T.


Briggs, "Exploring the Role of Trust in the DealMaking Process for Early-Stage Technologr
Ventures ," Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice

37, rto. 5 (2013): 1203-1228.


10. G. Sutton, WrttingWinning Bustness Plans: How
to Prepare c-Business Plan Tho;tlnuestors W1LL
Want to Read-and Inuest In (Scottsdale, AZ: BZK

Press LLC, 2012).


11. W. Drover, M. S. Wood, and G. T. Payne,'"The
Effects of Perceived Control on Venture Capitalist
Investment Decisions : A Conligurational
Perspectiv e," Entrepreneur ship Theory and"
Practice, 2014, in press.

12. M. W. Lawless, "Entrepreneurial Risk:


Jordan Baltimore and Oyster Digital Media,"
Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice 37, no. 5
(2013): r229-L245.
13. P. M. Getty, The 12 Magic Sttdes (NewYork, NY:
APress, 2Ol4).
14. Personal conversation \Mith Michael Heller,

January 20,2OO2.

15. L. Essig, "Ownership, Failure, and Experience:


Goals and Evaluation Metrics of University-Based
Arts Venture Incubators," Entrepreneurshtp
ResearchJournal 4, no. | (2Oru): 11'7-135.
16. B. Feld, "should You Hire Someone to Write Your
Business Plan?" Ask the VC, http://www.askthevc. com / wp / archives / 2OO 7 / 02 / should-youhire-someone-to-write -your -business-plan. html,
accessed February 27, 2OL4.
17. S. Blank, "Why the Lean Start-up Changes
Everythin$," HctruordBusiness Reuleru 91, no. 5
(2013): 110-112.
1

8. G. Clydesdale, Entrepreneuriat Opportunifu

(New

York, NY: Routledge, 2010).


19. M. J. Bliemel, "Getting Entrepreneurship
Education Out of the Classroom and Into
Students' Heads, " Entrepreneur shtp Re seqrch
Journal, 2014, in press.
20. U.S. Small Business Administration, "Executive
SummarSr," www.sba.gov, (accessed March 10,
2Or4).

2I.

M. Jenkin, "Smal1 Business Tips: How to Write


a Business Plan Executive Summary," Ttae
Guardian, www.theguardian. com, February 22,

2014.
22. C. A. Bartel and B. M. Wiesenfeld, 'The Social
Negotiaflon of Group Prototype Ambiguity in
Dyeamic Organlzational Contexts," Academg oJ
ManagementReuiew 38, no. 4 (2013): 5O3-524.
23. D. L. King, C. J. Case, and M. Kathleen, "2OL2
Mission Statements: A Ten Country Global
Analysis," Academg oJ Strategtc Management
Journal,12, no. 1 (2013): 77-93.
24. E. R. Crawford and J. A. LePine, 'A Configural
Theory of Team Processes: Accounting for the
Structure of Taskwork and Teamwork," Academg
oJManagementReuiew 38, no. I (2013): 32-48.
25. J. J. Chrisman, P. Sharma, L. P. Steier, and
J. H. Chua, '"The Influence of Family Goals,
Governance, and Resources on Firm Outcomes,"
Entrepreneurshtp Theory and Practice 37, no. 6
(2013): L249-r261.
26. T. Vanacker, S. Maingart, and M. Meuleman,
"Path-Dependent Evolution Versus Intentional
Management of Investment Ties in Science-Based
Entrepreneurial Firms, " Entreprerwurshtp Tlrcory
andPractice 38, 2014, in press.
27. M. Renko, "Early Challenges of Nascent Social
Entrepreneurs, " Entrepreneur shtp Tlrcory and
Practtce 37, rto. 5 (2013): 1045-1069.
28. R. Adams, A Good Hard Kick in ttrc Ass (New York,
NY: Crown Books, 2OO2), L5O.

fr

:::
=:
:- =:
-.::
=.f
::--=

You might also like