Professional Documents
Culture Documents
WHITE PAPER
Abstract
Oil and gas fields seem like a perfect market for wireless networksand a potentially lucrative
one. Yet operators are reluctant to use wireless, because of concerns about reliability and
security in an industry where downtime can cost millions and the product is literally explosive.
However, recent advances in technology are finally providing reliable, secure wireless systems
that systems integrators can offer to the energy industry with confidence.
Introduction
Modern oil and natural gas wells typically operate unattended for extended periods. Downtime
means lost profitswhich could be thousands or even tens of thousands of dollars per hour for
a new wellso oil companies are willing to pay a premium for an industrial grade system that
can maximize their wellhead uptime. With modern sensor technologies, centralized wellhead
monitoring alerts operators to device failures, so they can take immediate action to bypass,
replace or repair faulty equipment before it affects production. There are several ways to
collect the monitoring databut wireless technologies offer the lowest cost and the fastest
deployment.
System integrators would love to use wireless, but their energy industry customers have
serious doubts about it, particularly in the most critical areas of production. In this whitepaper,
we will discuss the two most common objections you will hear when upgrading an oil or gas
field with industrial wireless technologies: (1) Wireless communication is unreliable, and (2)
Wireless communication is insecure.
1-714-528-6777
1-714-528-6778
WHITE PAPER
WHITE PAPER
will start to speak louder, too. (In fact, for wireless, speaking louder usually cannot be very
effective because there are legal limits on transmitter power levels).
Fortunately, there are many techniques that can improve communications quality in these socalled multiple access (MA) situations. For example, using different frequencies (FDMA
Frequency Division Multiple Access), or using different time slots (TDMATime Division
Multiple Access).
WiFi (based on the IEEE 802.11 standard) uses a dynamic version of TDMA: Carrier Sense
Multiple Access with Collision Avoidance, CSMA-CA. To explain this briefly: Every WiFi device
listens briefly to the airwaves before transmitting, to detect if the frequency is free to use
(Carrier Sense). If no other device is transmitting nearby, then the device sends some data,
otherwise it waits until the frequency band is availablethe devices try to share the time. This
is like waiting for a break in conversation before speaking. However, this method suffers from
several potential problems that make it unreliable. Here we discuss these problems:
1. The frequency channel is overloaded. As we have mentioned, CSMA-CA devices share the
transmission time with others by checking whether the frequency is available. So if the
frequency is fully and continually
occupied, the transceiver will just keep
waiting. When installing any new
wireless devices, or moving existing
equipment, it is standard practice to
check which frequency channels are
least crowded, and use those
frequencies. As wireless devices
proliferate, finding space becomes increasingly difficult.
2. There is co-channel interference. Some people consider this part of the issue of overloaded
channels, but there is a difference
between a legitimate signal and
interference. The definition of co-channel
interference is: Transmitting while
another radio is transmitting. Such
interference is usually caused by
wireless radios that do not follow the
CSMA-CA protocolintentionally or
unintentionally. Intentional interference
could even be a malicious attack in
which someone is trying to hack or jam
your communications. An example of
unintentional interference is the hiddennode issue that is commonly seen in
badly set-up wireless networks and
requires enabling CTS/RTS. This can
easily cause co-channel interference that
makes your wireless network unstable.
3. There is adjacent-channel interference. The public wireless frequency range is divided into
a small number of channels. Each is so narrow that some of a signals energy will spill over
WHITE PAPER
into neighboring channels. Sometimes this prevents CSMA-CA from reliably detecting
whether a frequency is already being used. As a result, even if we appear to have a
channel available for our devices data, the signals transmitted on closely adjacent
channels can collide with each other and become unintelligible at the receiving end. This
problem is most commonly seen in 2.4 GHz channels (802.11b/g/n) as the available
frequency range is narrower, compared to 5 GHz (802.11a).
4. There is non-WiFi interference. Many other devices produce radio frequencies that interfere
with WiFi communications. For example, consumer
microwave ovens emit energy around the 2.45 GHz
frequency, with far more power than a WiFi device.
Some of this energy leaks out. So, if you are using an
802.11b/g/n device close to a microwave, your data
transmission can be severely disrupted.
5. A moving obstacle blocks the line-of-sight. In an office, it is not necessary to have a lineof-sight to your access point, because, over short distances, radio signals can bypass
obstacles by bouncing off walls and passing through some materials. However, for long
distance communication, line-of-sight is the best way to ensure wireless connection quality
and throughput. But if that line-of-sight is blocked by some large object, like a truck or
crane, you will usually experience a loss of connection or, at least, a drop in available
bandwidth.
WHITE PAPER
they can instantly switch to the other stream of data, and the network will continue
working without interruption or data loss.
2.4 GHz
5 GHz
WHITE PAPER
3. Device Failover: A critical wireless network should never be disabled by a single-pointof-failure. AeroLink Protection continually monitors each devices status. If the active
node is disabled by a local power failure or hardware fault, the backup nodes will
automatically take over to keep the data moving.
WHITE PAPER
However, despite this protection, data is still at risk when it passes through the public Internet.
For example, when you use cellular to collect data locally, you might assume your data is
safely contained onsite. In fact, your data probably goes from the mobile service provider out
onto the public Internet, before returning through your corporate router and firewall and finally
to your monitoring center. How do you secure your data even though it passes through the
public domain?
Its now an increasingly common industry practice for data to be encrypted whenever it passes
over the Internetfor example, companies such as Google encrypt all their users searches,
email, and so on. All organizations can greatly improve their security with end-to-end
encryption of data to keep data safe as it passes through the Internet or other less-secure
channels.
WHITE PAPER
3. In particular, the ability to perform deep packet inspection of specialized industrial and
automation protocols, such as Modbus/TCP, is important for seamlessly filtering out
unwanted or harmful data.
4. Tough, industrial-grade physical design helps protect devices and keeps them running
reliably. This is important in oil and gas applications, as maintenance can be difficult due to
hazardous environments or long distances.
5. A well-designed web interface allows faster setup and easier firewall rule maintenance. This
saves staff time and energy, making it easier to create and maintain a secure network,
with no security loopholes overlooked.
6. Denial of Service protection is important to keep the network available. A broadcast storm
can easily crash an unprotected network.
In view of these issues, a stronger, more secure oil field network can maximize system uptime,
keep data and equipment safe, and greatly reduce maintenance work.
Summary
Recent innovations are making low-cost wireless networks as reliable as old-fashioned
communications technologies, such as wired networks. While this makes switching to wireless
an attractive proposition for industrial users, the energy industry faces some special challenges,
particularly in the oil and gas production and processing sectors:
Reliability: For the energy industry, 100 percent uptime is critical for safety, and to avoid
costly interruptions in output.
Security: Control systems and production data must be protected from attackers. Even
after this is achieved, the network itself is also a critical asset which must be protected
against denial of service attacks.
Safety: Network hardware must be safe for use in environments where flammable or
explosive gas and vapor are present.
As we have learned in this white paper, solutions now exist for these challenges, and suitable
products are available today:
Reliability: Robust wireless networks monitor their own performance. They handle a wide
range of problems by instantly opening alternate communications links to maintain
seamless connectivity.
Security: Multiple layers of strong encryption keep out attackers. Sophisticated firewall
filtering techniques guard against denial of service attacks.
WHITE PAPER
large oil and gas companies are beginning to use wireless to collect and transmit missioncritical data, reliability and security are the two major concerns delaying full adoption.
Addressing these concerns, Moxas AWK-3131A series Wireless Access Point supports features
such as AeroLink Protection, which creates a reliable wireless bridge between two networks
and provides network-level redundancy.
When acting as access points for data aggregation on oil well pads, the devices might be
located close to the wellhead. For safety reasons, this requires Class I Division II / ATEX Zone
2 compliance. The AWK-3131A series is undergoing compliance testing with an independent
organization, and is targeted to achieve this certification by the end of 2015.
As oil and gas fields are often located in deserts, oceans, and other harsh environments, large
oil and gas companies require network hardware that can endure extreme operating
temperatures and has ingress protection. The AWK-6232 series Wireless Access Point has an
IP68-rated metal casing, preventing internal damage from dust, rain, moisture and extreme
temperatures, and enabling it to deliver continuous wireless transmission for data aggregation
on pads. Moreover, the AWK-6232 series supports Dual RF Wireless Redundancy, which
guarantees a reliable wireless connection with zero packet loss.
In addition to a reliable wireless network, oil and gas companies require a comprehensive
range of cybersecurity options when transmitting information between oil well pads and a
remote control center. The EDR-810 series secure router provides stringent cybersecurity
protection, including a VPN, firewall, packet checking and support for specialized industrial and
automation protocols, to ensure a high level of protection for mission-critical assets. It also has
Class I Division II / ATEX Zone 2 certification to meet safety and regulatory standards.
More information about these products is available on Moxas website at:
Visit Moxas Wireless Solutions for Digital Oil Fields site for more information:
http://www.moxa.com/Event/Vertical_markets/OG_WirelessSolutions/index.htm
Disclaimer
This document is provided for information purposes only, and the contents hereof are subject
to change without notice. This document is not warranted to be error-free, nor subject to any
other warranties or conditions, whether expressed orally or implied by law, including implied
warranties and conditions of merchantability, or fitness for a particular purpose. We specifically
disclaim any liability with respect to this document and no contractual obligations are formed
either directly or indirectly by this document.