Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
KEYWORDS
Abstract
Background: Remifentanil may attenuate maternal hemodynamic response during
cesarean section under general anesthesia, but could cause transient but signicant
neonatal depression. We investigated the effect of low-dose remifentanil on maternal
neuroendocrine response and fetal wellbeing.
Methods: Forty-two ASA I-II parturients undergoing cesarean section at term under
general anesthesia were randomized to receive either fentanyl after delivery (n = 21,
group C) or remifentanil bolus 0.5 lg/kg before induction followed by a continuous
infusion at 0.15 lgkg 1min 1 until peritoneal incision, then restarted after delivery
(n = 21, group R). Maternal heart rate and blood pressure, and epinephrine, norepinephrine, adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH), and growth hormone levels were measured at baseline, uterine incision, and the end of surgery. Remifentanil was measured in
maternal and umbilical arterial and venous blood. One- and 5-minute Apgar scores and
umbilical arterial and venous pH were recorded.
Results: ACTH was signicantly higher in group C at uterine incision (P < 0.01). No
signicant differences were observed in hemodynamics, catecholamines or growth hormone. Apgar scores at 1 (P < 0.05) and 5 min (P <0.01) were signicantly higher in
group C. Mean umbilical pH values were within normal range but signicantly higher
in group C. Three neonates in group R required intubation but recovered at 5 min without naloxone. Mean SD maternal remifentanil concentration was 1.67 1.04 ng/mL.
Conclusions: Remifentanil administration before peritoneal incision partially reduced
the hormonal stress response. Maternal benets must be weighed against transitory
but signicant neonatal respiratory depression. Neonatal resuscitation facilities are
mandatory when remifentanil is used.
c 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Analgesics; Opioid;
Anesthesia; Obstetrical;
Cesarean section;
Hormones; Piperidines/
adverse effects;
Anesthesia; General;
Infant/Newborn
Accepted 1 October 2007
G. Draisci, A. Valente, E. Suppa, L. Frassanito, R. Pinto, F. Meo, B. A. Zanni, Universita` Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Dipartimento di
Emergenza e Accettazione, Istituto di Anestesiologia e Rianimazione, P. De Sole, Universita` Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Istituto di Chimica
Clinica, E. Bossu`, Istituto Superiore di Sanita`, Rome, Italy.
* Correspondence to: G. Draisci, Largo A. Gemelli 8, 00168 Rome, Italy. Tel.: +39 06 30154507.
E-mail address: gdraisci@inwind.it
0959-289X/$ - see front matter c 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.ijoa.2008.01.002
Introduction
Regional anesthesia is preferred for cesarean section
because of reduced maternal mortality.1 However,
general anesthesia may be indicated if regional anesthesia fails or is contraindicated, or for emergency
delivery. In a recent meta-analysis, general anesthesia
was shown to be associated with transient neonatal
sedation and essentially benign effects on neonatal
acid-base balance.2
The neuroendocrine stress response to surgery appears less well controlled with general than with regional anesthesia.3 The use of systemic opioids obtunds
the hormonal stress response during lower abdominal
procedures under general anesthesia.4 However, during cesarean section opioid administration is usually
avoided until after delivery to reduce the risk of neonatal depression.5,6 If opioid administration before
delivery is thought to be advantageous, remifentanil
with its fast onset and rapid metabolism appears to
be a suitable agent. It provides hemodynamic stability
in patients undergoing cesarean section under general
anesthesia,7 and has been successfully used in cases of
maternal cardiac disease,8,9 neurological conditions,
preeclampsia and liver disease.1012 However, previous studies showed that the use of remifentanil to
control the hemodynamic response to intubation
and surgery is associated with transitory but signicant neonatal depression.7,13 Since this effect could
be dose-dependent,14 the aim of our study was to
investigate whether administration of low-dose remifentanil could control the neuroendocrine response at
cesarean section under general anesthesia without
adverse effect on the neonate.
Methods
The study was designed as a randomized, controlled,
single-blind trial. Anesthetists and pediatricians were
not blinded to anesthetic technique. Approval from
the local research ethics committee was obtained
and written informed consent was given by all patients who participated in the study.
Forty-two ASA I-II women with singleton term
pregnancy scheduled for elective cesarean section
were enrolled. All patients had absolute or relative
contraindications to regional anesthesia. Exclusion
criteria were active labor, preeclampsia, neurological
disease, substance abuse, predicted difcult airway
management, known congenital abnormalities or
signs of fetal compromise.
Patients were randomly assigned to receive remifentanil infusion (group R) before and after delivery,
or fentanyl bolus (group C) only after delivery. Sub-
131
132
Statistical analysis
A mean increase of 20% stress hormone concentration at uterine incision was dened as the primary
outcome of the study, with a study power of 90%
(b = 0.10) and a sensitivity of 95% (a = 0.05). Based
on past data on patient variation at baseline level
from our central laboratory, given the expected variability (r) of 20%, the sample size required was 21 per
group.17 Statistical analysis was performed with the
SPSS program package. Demographic and blood
gas analysis were compared using the unpaired t test.
Apgar score and maternal hormone data were compared using Wilcoxon and Students t test. Signicant
differences were conrmed using non-parametric
tests. P values <0.05 were considered signicant.
Table 1
Control
(n = 21)
Age (years)
Weight (kg)
Height (cm)
Gestation (weeks)
Birth weight (g)
Indication for general anesthesia
refusal of regional anesthesia
thrombocytopenia
previous spinal surgery
11 (52.4%)
6 (28.6%)
4 (19%)
SAP Control
SAP Remifentanil
MAP Control
MAP Remifentanil
200
160
120
80
40
0
Baseline Induction
Results
Remifentanil
(n = 21)
Maternal venous blood samples were taken for assay of norepinephrine and epinephrine, adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH), and growth hormone
30 min before surgery (baseline), just before uterine
incision, and at the end of surgery. Umbilical venous
and arterial blood samples were collected from a
segment of cord just after clamping to measure pH,
base excess, and remifentanil concentration. Remifentanil concentration was measured in maternal
blood taken at baseline and uterine incision. To
determine remifentanil concentration, blood samples
were collected in heparinized tubes containing 50%
(w/w) citric acid solution (10 lL/mL of blood), then
immediately placed on ice and centrifuged at 4C
for 15 min at 2000 rpm. Plasma was separated and
stored at 70C (catecholamines and remifentanil)
and at 20C (ACTH, growth hormone). Norepinephrine and epinephrine were measured by high
performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) and
quantied by an electrochemical-coulombmetric
method (HPLC-EG-ESA 5100 A, Coulochem, Bedford, MA, USA). Concentrations of ACTH and
growth hormone were measured by commercially
available radioimmunoassay kits. Umbilical blood
acid-base balance was analyzed on a Critical Care
Express Nova Biomedical blood gas analyzer. Remifentanil plasma concentrations were determined by a
validated HPLC-MS method after solid phase extraction.16 The quantitation range of the assay was 0.5 to
48.0 ng/mL; the estimated limit of detection was 0.18
ng/mL, and the limit of quantitation was 0.5 ng/mL.
G. Draisci et al.
After
Skin
Intubation Incision
Uterine
Incision
End
Surgery
Figure 1 Maternal arterial pressure. SAP Control: systolic arterial pressure of control group; SAP Remifentanil:
systolic arterial pressure of remifentanil group; MAP
control: mean arterial pressure of control group; MAP
remifentanil: mean arterial pressure of remifentanil group.
Table 3
Remifentanil
133
Apgar scores and umbilical blood gas analysis
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
Baseline Induction After IOT
Figure 2
Table 2
Skin
Incision
Uterine
Incision
End
Surgery
Control
(n = 21)
Remifentanil
(n = 21)
Norepinephrine (pg/mL)
Baseline
Uterine incision
End of surgery
408 155
602 227
617 147
386 182
716 272
516 241
Epinephrine (pg/mL)
Baseline
Uterine incision
End of surgery
91.6 84.3
333 415
96 103
96.7 80.3
231 208
61 56
ACTH (pg/mL)
Baseline
Uterine incision
End of surgery
29 13
138 94
64 36
39 15
53 39*
44 25
0.22 0.14
0.32 0.19
0.42 0.6
0.21 0.20
0.33 0.32
0.37 0.4
Induction-to-delivery time (I-D time), uterine incision-to-delivery time (U-D time), and peritoneal incision-to-uterine incision time (P-U time) were similar
in the two groups. Apgar scores were signicantly
lower in group R at 1 min (P <0.05) and at 5 min
(P <0.01) (Table 3). Three neonates in the remifentanil group required tracheal intubation (Apgar score 2
at 1 min). Naloxone was not administered in any
case. At 5 min, Apgar scores were 8 or more in all
newborns and no further intervention was required.
Umbilical blood gas analysis was in the normal range
in both groups although umbilical vein pH was significantly lower in group R (P <0.01). There were no
episodes of desaturation, respiratory depression,
hypoglycemia or hypothermia in neonates from
either group after initial resuscitation.
Data from 16/21 patients who received remifentanil were analyzed to determine plasma remifentanil
Apgar at 1 min
<5
6-8
9-10
mean
Apgar a 5 min
<5
6-8
9-10
mean
Umbilical vein
pH
BE (mEq/L)
Umbilical Artery
pH
BE (mEq/L)
I-D time (min)
U-D time (min)
P-U time (min)
Control
(n = 21)
Remifentanil
(n = 21)
0
13 (61.9%)
8 (38.1%)
8.4 ( 0.96)
3 (14.3%)
18 (85.7%)
0
6.84 ( 2.44)*
0
0
21 (100%)
9.4 ( 0.51)
0
4 (19.%)
17 (81.%)
8.73 ( 0.45)*
7.40 0.05
0.03 3.46
7.36 0.04**
0.53 2.46
7.34 0.04
0.47 3.28
6.7 1.8
1.4 0.7
1.5 0.3
7.36 0.03
0.08 2.66
6.77 2.97
1.85 0.8
1.4 0.4
P < 0.05.
P < 0.01.
Discussion
Remifentanil, administered as a 0.5-lg/kg bolus before induction followed by an infusion of 0.15
134
lgkg 1min 1 until peritoneal incision, partially
obtunded the neuroendocrine response to surgery
with a decrease in ACTH rise. However, this was at
the expense of transient neonatal depression, with
Apgar scores signicantly lower in babies whose
mothers had received remifentanil, although all
scores improved to P8 within 5 min. Neonatal respiratory depression has previously been reported
following maternal remifentanil administration with
more than 10% of babies requiring intubation.7,13,18
Fortunately, respiratory depression was transient,
and umbilical cord pH values did not suggest fetal
asphyxia.
When cesarean section is performed under general
anesthesia, it is benecial to minimize both maternal
surgical stress and neonatal depression. As signicant
amounts of drugs used for general anesthesia cross
the placenta,19 opioids are usually administered after
umbilical cord clamping. Consequently, the maternal
neuroendocrine response is more pronounced during
induction of anesthesia and surgical incision.5,6 This
is undesirable when the mother has concomitant systemic disease and haemodynamic stability is required.
We administered remifentanil as a bolus and continuous infusion to blunt the maternal stress response. The infusion was stopped at peritoneal
incision to allow partial metabolism before uterine
incision and hopefully minimize effects on the baby.
The dose of remifentanil was derived from previous
studies in both obstetric and non-obstetric patients,
and was based on clinical safety and the ability to
limit secondary effects.712
In previous studies, both Ngan Kee and colleagues
and Van de Velde and colleagues showed transient
neonatal respiratory compromise lasting up to 5
min with remifentanil bolus in cesarean section under
general anesthesia7,13 We also observed a signicant
reduction in Apgar scores in the remifentanil group
at 1 and 5 min, with a concomitant difference in
umbilical vein pH values, even though these remained
in the normal range. These data indicate that, even at
low doses, remifentanil has the potential to cause
respiratory depression.7 However, all Apgar scores
were P8 at 5 min without naloxone administration,
indicating rapid resolution of respiratory depression
when present. No other adverse neonatal effects were
observed during the rst 24 h of life. We chose not to
blind anesthetists and pediatricians to the anesthetic
technique. As remifentanil is not part of our standard
technique we considered that it was safer for both
mother and baby if staff were aware of treatment
allocation.
Remifentanil transfer across the placenta has
been described.7,18 In our study, the mean remifentanil concentration in maternal venous blood was
1.67 1.04 ng/mL, a level similar to that reported
G. Draisci et al.
by Kan et al (1.32 0.80 ng/mL).18 Unfortunately,
we were unable to calculate UV/MV and UA/MV
ratios. No correlation between umbilical or maternal
remifentanil concentration and Apgar scores or pH
could be established. Babies of remifentanil-treated
mothers had a greater need for medical assistance
in the rst minutes after birth, but in no case
showed evidence of prolonged neurological insult
or damage.
Blood pressure and heart rate were not signicantly different between the remifentanil and control
groups although surgical stimulation resulted in a
similar increase in heart rate in both groups. Other
investigators have observed that remifentanil provided greater hemodynamic stability at induction of
anesthesia.7 This disparity could result from a lower
remifentanil dose in our study or alternatively lighter
anesthesia in control patients in previous studies.
Also it could be that we did not measure maternal
hemodynamic parameters sufciently frequently to
observe a difference. We did, however, record blood
pressure and heart rate at times to coincide with the
most noxious stimulation. Adequately deep hypnosis
seemed to have been assured by general anesthesia
with or without remifentanil, as evidenced by BIS
monitoring and by the absence of recall of intraoperative events.
Hemodynamic changes alone are less sensitive
indicators of surgical stress than are biochemical
markers.20 Reduced hormone secretion would indicate better control of surgical stress and potentially
of its adverse metabolic consequences, such as glucose tolerance reduction, catabolism enhancement,
and depressed immune function.3,21 Reduction in
stress hormone response with the present dosages of
remifentanil was limited to ACTH secretion. ACTH
is a sensitive index of stress, and correlates with the
severity of surgical trauma.22 It is partly inhibited
by the afferent neural blockade obtained with epidural or spinal anesthesia.23 ACTH is known to cause
increased muscle catabolism, and to affect immune
function. The transient immunosuppression induced
by surgical stress may be partially explained by activation of the ACTH-cortisol axis.24
In our study, signicant differences in ACTH concentration just before uterine incision may reect opioid-mediated suppression of CRH secretion,25 or a
combination of central and peripheral mechanisms.
The metabolic effect of growth hormone is in some
ways similar to that of ACTH-cortisol (glyconeogenic, anti-insulin effect), and in part the opposite
(anabolic effect with stimulation of protein synthesis
in non-muscle tissues). We were unable to identify
any differences between the groups suggesting that,
at the current dosages, remifentanil does not affect
growth hormone release.
References
1. Cooper G M. Maternal death from anesthesia. An extract from
Why mothers die 2000-2002, the Condential Enquiries into
Maternal Deaths in the United Kingdom: Chapter 9: Anesthesia. Br J Anaesth 2005; 94: 41723.
135
136
22. Traynor C, Hall G M. Endocrine and metabolic changes
during surgery. Anaesthetic implications. Br J Anaesth 1981;
53: 15360.
23. Kehlet H. Modication of responses to surgery by neural
blockade: clinical implications. In: Cousins M J, Bridenbaugh
P O, eds. Neural blockade in clinical anesthesia and management of pain. Philadelphia: Lippincott, 1998: 12975.
24. Scarborough D E. Cytokine modulation of pituitary hormone
secretion. Ann NY Acad Sci 1990; 594: 16987.
25. Rittmaster R S, Cutler Jr G B, Sobel D O et al. Morphine
inhibits the pituitary-adrenal response to ovine corticotropinreleasing hormone in normal subjects. J Clin Endocrinol Metab
1985; 60: 8915.
26. Schricker T, Carli F, Schreiber M, et al. Propofol/Sufentanil
anesthesia suppresses the metabolic and endocrine response
during, not after, lower abdominal surgery. Anesth Analg 2000;
90: 4505.
G. Draisci et al.
27. Giesecke K, Hamberger B, Jarnberg P O, et al. High- and lowdose fentanyl anesthesia: hormonal and metabolic responses
during cholecystectomy. Br J Anaesth 1988; 61: 57582.
28. Raeder J C, Hole A. Alfentanil anesthesia in gall-bladder
surgery. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 1986; 30: 3540.
29. Gin T, Ngan-kee W D, Siu Y K, et al. Alfentanil given
immediately before the induction of anesthesia for elective
cesarean delivery. Anesth Analg 2000; 90: 116772.
30. Myre K, Raeder J, Rostrup M, et al. Catecholamine release
during laparoscopic funduplication with high and low dose of
remifentanil. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 2003; 47: 26773.
31. Halter J B, Pug A E, Porte D. Mechanism of plasma
catecholamine increases during surgical stress in man. J Clin
Endocrinol Metab 1977; 45: 93644.
32. Esler M, Jennings G, Lambert G, et al. Overow of catecholamine neurotransmitters to the circulation. Source, Fate,
Functions. Physiol Rev 1990; 70: 96385.