Professional Documents
Culture Documents
in northern Kosovo:
towards a new balance?
www.cepolicy.org
Executive summary
The m unic ip a l ele c tio ns in Ko so vo o n
3 No ve m b e r w ill b e a litm us te st fo r
the Brussels Ag re e m ent a nd fo r the
no rm a lisa tio n o f rela tio ns b e tw ee n
Se rb ia a nd Ko so vo , b ut a lso a n o m e n
fo r the EU s a b ility to im p o se sta b ility
in its b a c kya rd . This p a p e r a im s to
a ssist a ll sta ke hold e rs to the Brussels
Ag re e m e nt
to
w o rk effe c tively
to w a rd a p o sitive o utc o m e in
no rthe rn Ko so vo (a s d iffe re ntly a s this
o utc o m e m a y b e a sse sse d b y e a c h
o f the m ), b ut a lso to p re p a re fo r
c o nting e nc ie s.
The vo te r turno ut in the fo ur Se rb m a jo rity no rthe rn m unic ip a litie s is a s
im p o rta nt a s the ir rela tio ns w ith
Prishtina a fte rw a rd s.
1 Filip Ejd us is Assista nt Professo r a t the Fa c ulty o f Politic a l Sc ie nc e s/ Unive rsity o f Belg ra d e a nd m em b e r o f the Ma na g em ent
Bo a rd of the Belg ra d e Ce ntre o f Sec urity Polic y. Leo n Ma la zog u is Direc to r o f the Dem oc ra c y fo r De velop m e nt Institute in
Prishtina . Mila n Ni is Se nio r Fellow a t the Ce ntra l Euro p ea n Polic y Institute , a re g io na l think ta nk b a sed in Bra tisla va . This p a p e r
is the first in a se ries o f re se a rc h p a p e rs p ub lishe d w ithin the p rojec t Vise g ra d Sup p o rt fo r Dia log ue b etwee n Se rb ia a nd
Ko so vo , a nd is sup p o rte d b y the Inte rna tio na l Viseg ra d Fund .
Less likely
More likely
Introduction
On 19 Ap ril 2013, Se rb ia a nd Ko so vo
sig ne d a n a g re e me nt whic h ha s the
p o te ntia l to
be
histo ric , if
fully
2
im p le m ente d . Me d ia te d b y the EU, it
w a s d e sig ne d to d efuse the la st c o nflic t
in the We ste rn Ba lka ns, a nd re m o ve one
o f the m a in log ja m s o n the p a ths o f
Se rb ia
a nd
Ko so vo
tow a rd s EU
m e m b e rship . The Brusse ls Ag re e m e nt, the
m o nike r it q uic kly a c q uire d , c o uld thus
b e a ha rb ing e r o f a ne w e ra in the
re la tio nship b e twe en Belg ra d e a nd
Prishtina , a s w e ll a s fo r the ir Euro p e a n
tra nsfo rm a tio n.
The a g re e ment p ro vid e d fo r the inc lusio n
o f the fo ur no rthe rnmo st Se rb -m a jo rity
m unic ip a litie s into Ko so vo 's le g a l syste m .
The
e sta b lishm e nt
of
an
Asso c ia tio n/ Co m m unity o f Se rb -m a jo rity
m unic ip a litie s is to furthe r g ra nt the m
sig nific a nt se lf-g o ve rna nc e (so m e sa y
a uto no m y). The p ro c e ss is to b e se t in
m o tio n a fte r m unic ip a l e le c tio ns w hic h
a re sc he d ule d to ta ke p la c e o n 3
No ve m b e r. As o nly le g a l a nd le g itim a te
m unic ip a l a utho ritie s m a y e sta b lish the
Asso c ia tio n (thro ug h the d ele g a tio n o f
c o unc illo rs up w a rd s), the p a rtic ip a tio n o f
Se rb s in the up c o m ing ele c tio ns is
c ruc ia l. The ele c tio ns w ill b e a litm us te st
fo r the Brusse ls Ag re e m e nt, b ut a lso a
p o rte nt fo r the EU s a b ility to im p o se
sta b ility in its b a c kya rd .
This p a p e r a im s to a na lyse the
c ha lle ng e s a he a d a nd to a ssist a ll
sta ke hold e rs to the Brussels Ag re e m e nt
to wo rk effe c tive ly to w a rd a p o sitive
The First Ag re em ent of Princ ip les Go ve rning the
No rm a lisa tion o f Rela tio ns, full text a va ila b le he re:
http :/ / w ww .rts.rs/ up lo a d / sto ryBo xFile Da ta / 2013/ 04/ 20/
3224154/ Orig ina lni%20te kst%20sp o ra zum a .p d f
2
1. Preparations for
the elections
As
w ith
the
Ag re e m e nt
itse lf,
p re p a ra tio ns fo r the ele c tio ns ha ve b ee n
fra ug ht w ith te nsio ns a nd a m b ig uitie s.
Belg ra d e a nd Prishtina ha ve m a inta ine d
the ir d e c la ra to ry c o m m itm e nt, b ut ha ve
no t d one a ll the y c o uld to sm o o th
tra nsitio n o n the g ro und . The m a yo rs a nd
m o st p olitic a l re p re se nta tive s o f the
no rthe rn Ko so vo Se rb s ha ve m o unte d a
b o yc o tt a g a inst ele c tio ns, w hile re c e nt
vio lenc e in the no rth ra ise s se rio us
se c urity c o nc e rns tha t c o uld p o te ntia lly
und e rm ine the entire p ro c e ss.
The Brussels Ag re e m e nt fo re se e s tha t
m unic ip a l e le c tio ns sha ll b e o rg a nise d
in the no rthe rn m unic ip a litie s in 2013 w ith
the
fa c ilita tio n
of
the
OSCE in
a c c o rd a nc e w ith Ko so vo la w a nd
inte rna tio na l sta nd a rd s . 3 The OSCE w ill
p ra c tic a lly o rg a nise the ele c tio ns in
3
no rthe rn Ko so vo , o n b e ha lf o f Ko so vo s
Ce ntra l Ele c tio n Co m m issio n (CEC ). The
OSCE is to p la c e tw o o b se rve rs in e a c h
p o lling sta tio n a nd p o te ntia lly in site s in
Se rb ia .
The unc e rta inty ste m s no t only fro m the
c o m p le xitie s o n the g ro und , b ut a lso
fro m the 15 va g uely d e fine d p o ints o f the
a g re e me nt itse lf, w hic h le a ve a m p le
w ig g le ro o m fo r d iffe rent inte rp re ta tio ns.
Fo r Prishtina , the Ag re e m ent is a n
im p o rta nt ste p tow a rd s full no rm a lisa tio n
b e tw ee n tw o so ve re ig n c o untrie s a nd
w ill
eventua lly
le a d
to
Se rb ia s
re c o g nitio n
of
Ko so vo
as
an
ind e p e nd e nt sta te . Be lg ra d e insists tha t
the Ag re e m ent is sta tus-ne utra l a nd tha t
ele c tio ns a re inte nd e d to b ring m o re o f
Se rb ia
into
Ko so vo .
During
the
ne g o tia tio ns, the a m b ig uity o f the te xt
se rve d
c o nstruc tive ly
to
re a c h
a g re e me nt a nd m a sk the re m a ining
d isa g re e m ents.
Ho w e ve r,
if
suc h
ne b ulo us w o rd ing w a s the m a xim um
c o m p ro m ise tha t c o uld b e re a c he d ,
d iffe re nc e s we re ultim a tely b o und to
c la sh on the g ro und .
One of the p o ints o f d isa g re e me nt w a s
the a p p e a ra nc e o f Re p ub lic o f Ko so va
o n the b a llo t p a p e r. Fro m Se rb ia s p o int
o f vie w , no sym b ols o f Ko so vo s
sta te ho o d w e re a c c e p ta b le on the
b a llo t g ive n tha t the Brusse ls Ag re e m e nt
is sta tus-ne utra l. At the sa m e tim e ,
Ko so vo refe rs to the wo rd ing tha t
ele c tio ns a re o rg a nise d in a c c o rd a nc e
w ith Ko so vo la w (p o int 11), he nc e its
insiste nc e
to
m a inta in
the
sa m e
a p p e a ra nc e a s in p re vio us e le c tio ns. The
issue w a s fina lly re solve d in e a rly
Se p te m b e r when Ko so vo s CEC d e c id e d
to re mo ve the re fe re nc e to the re p ub lic
a nd le a ve the na m e a nd lo g o of the
CEC, und e r c le a r p re ssure fro m the
p o litic a l to p b ra ss.
The m o st im p o rta nt e le c tio n-rela te d
d e a d line w a s 4 Se p tem b e r fo r the
re g istra tio n o f p olitic a l e ntitie s a nd the
c e rtific a tio n o f c a nd id a te lists. While
ne g o tia tio ns c o ntinue d until d a ys b e fo re
the d e a d line , Ko so vo Se rb s sub m itte d 18
lists, c o m p e ting in 24 (o ut o f 38)
m unic ip a litie s inc lud ing the fo ur no rthe rn
o ne s. Tw o lists (o ne o f the m o p e nly
sup p o rte d b y Se rb ia s G o ve rnm ent)
w e re instruc te d b y the CEC to re mo ve
the w o rd Se rb ia fro m the na me . 4 The
d e a d line fo r the re g istra tio n o f vo te rs
living o utsid e o f Ko sovo w a s first
sc he d ule d fo r 11 Se p te m b e r b ut w a s
then e xtend e d to 17 Se p te m b e r.
Belg ra d e ha stily sub m itte d to the OSCE
a ro und 40,000 a p p lic a tio ns o f d isp la c e d
Ko so vo Se rb s w ho w a nte d to re g iste r to
vo te in Ko so vo s m unic ip a l ele c tio ns.
So m e 6,600 a p p lic a tio ns w e re a c c e p te d
w hile a ll o the rs we re re je c te d a s
inc o m p le te m a inly d ue to the a b se nc e
o f a p re se nt o r fo rme r a d d re ss in Ko so vo
o r o the r p ro o f of re sid e nc e . An
a d d itio na l num b e r of a ro und 12,000
Se rb s w e re a d d e d to the Vo te rs List
d uring ne g o tia tio ns in Brusse ls. 5 Prishtina
ha s, in the me a ntim e , p re p a re d fo r
ele c tio ns, a nd it ha s g o ne o ut o f its w a y
4 The Go ve rnm e nt of Se rb ia w hic h p rop osed the list
Civil Initia tive Se rb ia c ha ng e d the na m e into Se rb ia n
Civic Initia tive (Se r. Gra a nska inic ija tiva srp ska ). The
othe r p rob lem a tic list w a s initia lly entitled Se rb ia ,
Dem oc ra c y, Justic e Olive r Iva novi . It c ha ng e d its
na m e into SDJ-Olive r Iva no vi (Se r. Gra a nska
inic ija tiva SDP Olive r Iva no vi ).
5 Ta njug . 1 Oc to b e r 2013. Jo s 12.000 c e up isa ti za
izb o re .
http :/ / w ww .b 92.net/ info / vesti/ ind e x.p hp ?yyyy=2013&
mm =10&d d =01&na v_id =760235&utm _sourc e =tw itterfe
e d &utm _m ed ium =tw itte r
to
a c c o m m o d a te
Se rb
re q ue sts.
Co nsid e ring the stra te g ic im p o rta nc e o f
no rthe rn p a rtic ip a tio n, se nio r p o litic a l
le a d e rship ha s w e ig he d in to g e t the
CEC to vio la te its rule s a nd e xte nd the
d e a d line fo r vo te r re g istra tio n in Se rb ia ,
d ro p m e ntio n o f the Re p ub lic , a nd
a c c e p t the re c ruitm e nt in its se nio r
e c helons o f a Se rb fro m the no rth.
2. Serbias storylines
and strategies
Belg ra d e ha s m a inta ine d a thre e p ro ng e d
d isc o urse
re g a rd ing
the
Ag re e m e nt in g ene ra l a nd ele c tio ns in
p a rtic ula r. The first sto ryline is a im e d a t
Brusse ls a nd c a n b e sum m a rise d a s
Se rb ia is g iving up e ffe c tive c ontrol o ve r
the no rth o f Ko so vo , b ut w ill no t, a t le a st
fo r the tim e b e ing , re c o g nise Ko so vo .
Ta ilo re d fo r the d o me stic a ud ie nc e , the
se c o nd sto ryline inte rp re ts the Brusse ls
Ag re e m e nt a s a vic to ry o ve r Prishtina
a nd the m a xim um Belg ra d e c o uld g e t
a t this p o int . Ac c o rd ing to this na rra tive ,
Ko so vo Se rb s w ill o b ta in le g itim a te
institutio ns, w hile Se rb ia ha s no t sw e rve d
fro m its p le d g e ne ve r to re c o g nise
Ko so vo s unila te ra l ind e p end e nc e . The
third sto ryline a im s to m o b ilise no rth
Ko so vo Se rb s, to who m the Ag re e m e nt
w a s p re se nte d a s a ve hic le to re ta in
Se rb ia s
p re se nc e
a nd
d isrup t
ind e p e nd e nt
Ko so vo
fro m
w ithin.
Prishtina is e sp e c ia lly c onc e rne d w ith this
na rra tive , fe a ring tha t the Asso c ia tio n o f
Se rb
Munic ip a litie s c o uld
bec ome
Belg ra d e s Tro ja n
Ho rse
w ithin
a
g ra d ua lly Da yto nise d a nd d ysfunc tio na l
Ko so vo .
the ne xt
Se rb ia .
p a rlia m e nta ry
ele c tio ns in
3. Northern Kosovo
Serbs: anxiety and
fragmentation
In sp ite o f the p olic y shift in Be lg ra d e ,
m a ny Se rb s in no rthe rn Ko so vo ha ve
re fuse d
to
ac c ept
the
Brusse ls
Ag re e m e nt, a ltho ug h
re sista nc e
is
g ra d ua lly w e a ring a w a y. Ove r the p a st
14 ye a rs, no rthe rn Se rb s we re mo b ilise d
p rim a rily b y the d e sire to re m a in p a rt o f
Se rb ia a nd ha ve often c onsc io usly
w ithd ra w n the m selve s fro m d e c isio nm a king , le a ving re sp o nsib ility sq ua re ly in
the ha nd s o f the Belg ra d e a utho ritie s.
The
situa tio n
bec omes
furthe r
c o m p lic a te d w he n so uthe rn Se rb s a re
fa c to re d into the e q ua tio n. While a ll Se rb
p a rtie s sho uld b e in p rinc ip le enthusia stic
a b o ut the Asso c ia tio n, the y m a y b e le ss
so g ive n Se rb ia s insiste nc e o f its full
c o ntrol. In the ir vie w , Se rb ia is no w
a d vo c a ting the sa m e p o lic y fo r w hic h it
ha d c ritic ise d the SLS in 2009 when it ha d
the c o ura g e to p a rtic ip a te in e le c tio ns,
then a g a inst Se rb ia s w ill. If the SLS w ins
se ve ra l m unic ip a litie s in the So uth, a s
e xp e c te d , it is unc le a r if it w ill jo in the
4. Four scenarios
G ive n the c o m p le xity a nd vola tility o f the
situa tio n in no rthe rn Ko so vo , it is c le a r
tha t the re is a w id e ra ng e o f p o ssib le
9
w ith
re p re se nta tio n
fro m
se ve ra l
g ro up ing s. The ele c to ra l p ro c e ss is se e n
a s la rg ely free , fa ir a nd tra nsp a re nt. The
o p p o nents und e rta ke a p a ssive b o yc o tt
o f the ele c tio ns, b ut d ue to the inte nsive
c a m p a ig n b y Belg ra d e , the ir c a m p a ig n
ring s hollo w . In this sc e na rio , the fe w
vio la tio ns o f the c o d e o f c o nd uc t a nd
p o lling p ro c e d ure s a re insuffic ie nt to risk
the integ rity o f the p ro c e ss. The lo c a l
a sse m b lie s o f the fo ur m unic ip a litie s
c o nvene a nd ele c t m a yo rs w ho a c c e p t
Prishtina a s the so urc e o f the ir le g a l
fra m e w o rk. G ive n the rela tively hig h
turno ut o f o the r g ro up ing s too , the
Belg ra d e-sp o nso re d jo int list is una b le to
fo rm a m irro r-im a g e e xe c utive a utho rity
c o m p o se d o f Se rb ia n Pro g re ssive Pa rty
(SNS) a nd So c ia list Pa rty o f Se rb ia (SPS)
c a d re o nly. A p lura listic m a jo rity ha s to
ne g o tia te
a c ro ss
se ve ra l
p olitic a l
g ro up ing s, e na b ling
the ne c e ssa ry
sta rting p o int fo r d e m o c ra tic d e lib e ra tio n
a nd p lura lism tha t, o ve r tim e , re le g a te s
e thno -p olitic s to a m a tte r o f se c ond a ry
p rio rity. The Asso c ia tio n o f Se rb ia n
Munic ip a litie s is e sta b lishe d , c o m p o se d
o f o the r g ro up ing s a s w e ll a nd
c o o p e ra te s c lo sely w ith Prishtina . Le ft
w itho ut
fina nc ia l
re so urc e s
a nd
le g itim a c y, the Inte rim Asse m b ly fa d e s
into irre leva nc e to g e the r w ith othe r
sp o ile rs. Ord ina ry Se rb s se e k to se c ure
the ir p ro sp e rity in the ne w e nviro nm e nt
a nd suc c e ssful ele c tio ns e nc o ura g e a ll
the sta ke hold e rs to m o ve the a g end a
fo rw a rd . The EU g a ins e no ug h c re d ib ility
to c o nc lud e a n ove ra rc hing a g re e me nt
b e tw ee n Belg ra d e a nd Prishtina to
m e d ia te in p o st-c o nflic t situa tio ns furthe r
a fie ld .
12
Conclusions
Ne ithe r the EU no r the b ro a d e r
inte rna tio na l c o m m unity se e m to b e
p re p a re d fo r the p o ssib ility o f fa ile d
ele c tio ns in no rthe rn Ko so vo , o r fo r
uninte nd e d o utc o m e s in the ir a fte rm a th.
The
e xiste nc e o f a n o ve ra rc hing
inte rna tio na l c o nsensus m a y d e te r
re je c tio nist sp o ile rs, b ut the im p o te nc e o f
the inte rna tio na l sta kehold e rs vis- -vis
d e a d ly a tta c ks m a y te st w he the r the y
a re c a p a b le o f d isc ip lining w rong d oe rs.
Ind ee d , the see ming a b senc e o f a b a c kup p la n m a y furthe r e nc o ura g e sp o ile rs.
G ive n the c ha lle ng e s, it is vita l tha t the re
b e so m e se rio us c o nting e nc y p la nning
b y the EU in a d va nc e o f 3 No vem b e r o n
ho w to p ut thing s b a c k o n tra c k in c a se
o f d e ra ilm ent. As w e d e sc rib e a b o ve ,
so m e d e ra ilm ent is to b e a ntic ip a te d
a nd c a nno t b e p e rc e ive d a s a n
une xp e c te d o utc o me .
One o f the ind ic a to rs o f suc c e ssful
ele c tio ns is the d e ve lo p me nt of the
Asso c ia tion of Se rb ia n Munic ip a litie s. In
va ria tio ns o f o ur re a listic sc e na rio , a
p o w e rful Asso c ia tio n und e r Belg ra d e s
he a vy
c ontrol
may
sp ur
e thnic
m o b ilisa tio n a m o ng Ko so vo Alb a nia ns,
le a d ing to b ro a d c o a litio ns tha t le a ve
e thnic
Se rb s
a nd
na tio na list
Ve t ve nd o sje in the o p p o sitio n (in m ixe d
so uthe rn m unic ip a litie s a nd p o te ntia lly in
the ne xt na tio na l p a rlia m e nt). This c o uld
ha ve ha rmful effe c ts no t only o n inte re thnic re la tio ns a c ro ss Ko so vo , b ut a lso
o n the few c he c ks a nd b a la nc e s on the
Prishtina g o ve rnme nt a lre a d y in p la c e .
Central European Policy Institute - A think-tank by the Slovak Atlantic Commission - October 8, 2013
This report was published with the support of the International Visegrad Fund.