1/21/2015

ReservationsinthePrivateSectorGroupDiscussion

Like

Share

search...

ArithmeticAptitudeDataInterpretation
LogicalReasoningVerbalReasoningNonVerbalReasoning
GeneralKnowledge
SudokuNumberpuzzlesMissingletterspuzzlesLogicalpuzzlesPlayingcardspuzzlesClockpuzzles
CProgrammingC++ProgrammingC#ProgrammingJavaProgramming
MicrobiologyBiochemistry
BiotechnologyBiochemical
Engineering
Electronicsand
CommunicationEngineering
CivilEngineeringMechanical
EngineeringChemical
EngineeringNetworking
DatabaseQuestions
ComputerScienceBasic
ElectronicsDigitalElectronics
ElectronicDevicesCircuit
SimulationElectrical
EnigneeringEngineering
MechanicsTechnical
Drawing
PlacementPapersGroupDisucssionHRInterviewTechnicalInterviewBodyLanguage
AptitudeTestVerbalAbilityTestVerbalReasoningTestLogicalReasoningTestCProgrammingTestJavaProgrammingTestDataInterpretationTest
GeneralKnowledgeTest
DataStructuresOperatingSystemsNetworkingDATABASEDatabaseBasicsSQLServerBasicsSQLServerAdvancedSQLServer2008JAVACore
JavaJavaBasicsAdvancedJavaUNIXUnixFileManagementUnixMemoryManagementUnixProcessManagemntCInterviewQuestionsTheC
LanguageBasics.NETInterviewQuestions.NETFrameworkADO.NETASP.NETSoftwareTesting
Home
Aptitude
LogicalReasoning
VerbalAbility
GK
Puzzles
Engineering
Interview
OnlineTest

ReservationsinthePrivateSector
@:Home>GroupDiscussion>PoliticsDiscussionRoom

DellInspiron3542Laptop(Silver
NewDealsEveryDay
Rs.32,982

Pointstorememberbeforeyouparticipateinthisdiscussion:
Assume,youoneofthememberofarealgroupdiscussion.
Taketheinitiativetoparticipateandcontributeyourthoughts.
Expressyourpositiveattitudetowardsprovidingthesolution.

Akshatsaid:(Wed,Jan21,201501:57:55PM)

Guystodayreservationisdonenotonlyinprivatesectorsbutingovernmentandtertiarysectorsaswell.Whether
itbeintheformofjob,promotions,severalquotasorsomeotherofitskind.Thisreservationschemeplayan
impartialroleinourlives.Ononehandifithelpsapersoninachievingsomethingthenontheotherhanditstakes
somethingfromhandsofsomeotherperson.Iamtakingaboutthevariouskindofquotasinvolvedinreservation
foradmissionorjobsinprivatesectorslikeforexampleinanyprivateinstitutionsanyprivatecompanyetc.

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/reservationsintheprivatesector/

1/21

1/21/2015

ReservationsinthePrivateSectorGroupDiscussion

Duetopsuchthingsthepersonwhoactuallydeservetobeonthetopisactuallybelowtothepersonwhodonot
deserveit.Likeinmanycasesofjobsandeducation.Butthisisnottheonlythingreservationifdoessomething
badthenitdoesgoodtomanyofus.Reservationhelpsonetorepresentoneselfanditfulfillstherequirementof
manybackwardclassespeople.Itpromotessomeclassofpeopleandtheircommunities.
AsaconclusionIwouldliketosayifreservationsaredoneitshouldbedonekeepinginmindtheotherpeopleof
thesocietytooandifitpromotessomeclassofpeoplethenheshouldalsokeepinmindtheotherdeservingclass
ofcandidatestoo.Heshouldmaintainanequalbalancebetweenthetwogroups.
Ratethis:+0

Babansaid:(Fri,Jan16,201508:38:44PM)

Accordingtome,thereshouldnotbereservationinprivatesector.Ifthegovernmentwillallowthereservationin
privatesectorthenlotofcompanyorinvestorwillnotinvestinIndiabecausenoonewantaweakoraverage
employee.AndalsothisdecisionmaybeharmIndianeconomy.AndalsoIdonotsupportcastbasedsystem
becausetherearelotofpersonarepoorwhobelongtouppercast.AndalsoIwouldliketomentionthatcastis
goodbutnotoncastbasedbutonincomebased.
Ratethis:+1

G.Ramulusaid:(Thu,Jan15,201511:56:50PM)

IsawVenky'scommenton"reservationinprivatesector"(on15115).Economicfactorisoneofthereasons,but
itisnotthewholething.Casteisdeterminingalltheissues.Invariousaspects,wecanseethecastefactor.
Casteislinkedwithbirth,schooladmission,relatives,marriages.Andeveninburialgroundstoo.Didanybody
observethis?
Whythebigindustrialists,landlords,supreme&highcourtchefjustices,chiefeditorsoftheprint&electricmedia,
arefromuppercastesonly.Whatisthereason?Manyofthepeopledon'tknowthateducationandpropertyrights
weredeniedtoSc,StandBc'scenturiestogether.
Thepoor,fromtheuppercaste,canbeconsideredastheywerevictimizedbyeconomicalbasis.Buttheyhavenot
beenvictimizedbyothernoneconomicalissues.ManyofOurIndianintellectualsarenotinapositionto
understandallthefactors,duetotheircasteleanings.
Ratethis:+0

Danishsaid:(Thu,Jan15,201511:50:59PM)

ReservationisnotgoodwaytosecuretheseatsofSC,STinprivatesectorjustlikeinpublicsector,andwhythey
want.Imeanttosaythatweareallequalandnoneedtoputcastreservationinprivatesectoronthebasisthat
theyarepoorandbelongtolowercast.Ithinklowercastepeoplearetakingthisasa+point.
Andifthelawwillpassforreservationthansomanydeservedpersonwillnotabletogetthejobbecause
reservedpersonsalreadyacquiretheircertainseats.Andtheyarealreadyreservedtheirseatsinpublicsector.
Secondly,itwillbewellandgoodtoreservetheseatsforhandicaprathertoreserveforlowercaste.Because
somehow,practicallyhandicapsarenotasmuchphysicallyfitascomparetocommonman.
Ratethis:+7

Venkysaid:(Thu,Jan15,201512:50:32PM)

I'magainstforreservationsystembecausegovernmentisreservationgivingbasisof"cast".That'snotgood.All
sc,stcandidatesarenotpoorpersonsandalloccandidatesarenotrichpersons.Somepoorpersonsistherein
occastandsomerichpersonsarethereinsccandidatessoit'snotgoodpointofmyway.Ifyouwantgive
reservationyoucangivebasisoftalentandyoucangivehandicaps.Thisismyopinion.IfitfollowstheIndiawill
developdefinitely.WecanseetheIndiaintoppositionwithoutcorruption.
Ratethis:+6

Sonusaid:(Tue,Jan13,201510:55:29PM)

Reservationisnecessaryforpoorpeoplesandmajoritybelongstolowercast.Afterthe60yearoffreedomall
peoplearepoorwhoarebelongtolowercast.Castisrelatedtobirthsoanypersonmaybeinlowercastorin
uppercastbutweneedtothinkabouthumanity.Therearemanyresourcesofmoneyinuppercastfamilybut
lowercastdependsonlyhaveajob.Somelowercastfamiliesalsorichandsomeupperalsopoorbuttheseare
few.
Inthepastorinhistorylowercastpeoplesweregoodservantsthanwhysomepeoplesareinopposeintheir
reservation.Reservationmustbeinbothprivateandgovernmentsector.Andifanypersonisinopposeof
reservationandhethinksthatheisrightthanhemustallowlovemarriagesofhisrelativestolovercastperson
andthanifhethinksaboutnochanceofmarrywithlowercastthanhemustthinkaboutreservationifhelovesto
hiscountryorcountrygrowth.
Ratethis:+3

Srinivassaid:(Sun,Jan11,201506:14:49PM)

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/reservationsintheprivatesector/

2/21

1/21/2015

ReservationsinthePrivateSectorGroupDiscussion

Dearfriends!asaboveallyousaidtakeoutthecastesystembothintheprivateandpublicsector.
Actuallywehavetoknowwellabout,whyreservations,asthepoorpeoplearenotabletostudyandeatandto
getwelltrainedtomeetthepresentchallengesintheinterview,therearesomanyreasonswhypoorisstill
becomingpoorandrichisrich.Reservationshouldbecontinueuntilandunlessallgetminimumneeds.
Ratethis:+1

G.Ramulusaid:(Tue,Jan6,201510:18:40PM)

Whichhastogo?Eithercastesystem?orreservations?Thecastesystembenefitsuppercastes,
whereasthepresentreservationsbenefit,someofthethesuppressedcastes.
Ratethis:+0

Shrishai.Nsaid:(Tue,Jan6,201509:12:14PM)

Hiall,accordingtomethereshouldbereservationonlylimitedtoEDUCATIONbutwhencometoJobeitherPublic
orthePrivatethereshouldnotbeanyreservation.IfyouhaveSKILLS&theKnowledgeyouwillgettheJobany
whereyouwant.
AsIobservedintheabovedebateitdoesnotmeanthatthosewhocanreadandwritearefromuppercasteand
thosewhodon'tarefromthelowercaste.
AccordingtomeeventheReservationPatternshastochangeIcannotsayhowtochangebecauseifIsay
anythingtheneither(upperorlower)castepeoplewillblameme,sotheGov.Hastotakesomecorrective
Measures.
Ratethis:+6

Md.RagibAlamsaid:(Tue,Jan6,201504:14:42PM)

AfterlisteningallofyouIgottolearnmanythingsaboutReservationinprivatesectorbutaccordingtome
reservationshouldnotbethereinprivatesectorbecauseitcreatesdiscriminationbetweenuppercastesand
lowercastesandthosebelongstoschedulecastes,scheduletribeandotherbackwardcastesalsobelongstorich
familyandhavingaenoughresourcestosurvivetheirlife.Andthosewhoarehavingcapabilitiesultimatelyhewill
getthejobandthereisnoneedtohavingreservations.
Thankyou.
Ratethis:+0

Namansaid:(Mon,Jan5,201512:22:49PM)

FirstofallreservationiscreatinginequalityinIndiansociety.
AnotherthingisthatGovernmentfailedtoprovideexactbenefitofitinlast50years.Nowitisjustlikeacustom.
Thepeoplewhoisgettingbenefitofreservationisbecomingmoreidle.Theyfeelthattheycancrackexamorget
jobwithaverylesseffortthenwhytoworryaboutexamination.
Theyarealreadygettingbenefitforcrackingexamlikelowpassingscoreandlowexaminationfees.Theyalsoget
thescholarshipfortheirstudy.Sonowitstheirtimetoprovetheirmettletogetjobwithoutreservation.
ThecriteriaofdefiningreservedcasteinIndiaisnotpropermeasure.Highercastepopulationisalsopoor.They
arealsoloweducated.
Governmentneedtopreparereportonreducingreservationevery5yearsbasedonsomecriteriaandalso
removesomepeoplefromthebenefitofreservation.
Ratethis:+9

SurajChauhansaid:(Fri,Jan2,201502:54:49PM)

Inmypointofviewthereservationiscorrectinhisplacebutifthisexistingovernmentsectorisgoodnotinall
place.Cananyonetellmewhypeopleareagainstthereservationfromlongtimestheuppercasteaheadin
moneyandupperpostbecausetheyareingoodpositiontoachievethatpost.Whoaretalkingagainst
reservationcangivetheirmoneytopoorpeopletoachievetheirdream.Poorpeoplehavenotenoughmoneyto
gaininghighereducationbuttheytryandgovernmentalsowantthateveryonetorighttoachievegoodeducation,
respectinsociety.Ifeveryrichmanreadytodistributetheirmoneyamongpeopletheneveryoneisequalthen
competitionistookplace.
Ratethis:+5

G.Ramulusaid:(Fri,Dec26,201410:52:39PM)

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/reservationsintheprivatesector/

3/21

1/21/2015

ReservationsinthePrivateSectorGroupDiscussion

Hifriends,
Duetothecastesystem,ourcountryisnotgettingforwarded.
Centuriestogether,90%ofthepeople,whoweretheworkforceofthenation,werebarredfromtheeducation&
theliteracy.Atthesametime,thelazysectionofthepopulationwereeducatedbutdidnotparticipateinanykind
ofproduction.
Thiskindofsituationdidnotexistedintheworld.Thismightbethemajorreasontoourbackwardness.Ifthis
castesystemdoesremaininfuturetoo,thereservationhastofallow.Ifthecastesystemiseradicated,
automaticallythethereservationissuewillwitheraway.
Howtoeradicatethecastesystemistherealissue.Thecastehascomeintoexistenceonlyaftermarriagesystem
cameintobeing.Duetothe"Samecastemarriage",itiscontinuing.Thecastesystemwasexistedsofar,is
continuingandgoingtoremainonlythroughthesamecastemarriagesonly.
Ifthetwogenerationsareawaytothesamecastemarriages,thecastewillbenomore.Onlyonesolutionto
eradicatethecastesystemisboycottingthethemarriagesinthesamecaste.Areanyantireservation
participantsinthediscussions,areinapositiontomarryothercaste,ratherthansamecastetoyouoryourfamily
members?
Ratethis:+4

G.Ramulusaid:(Sat,Dec20,201408:59:55PM)

Hifriends,
Youobserveonething,Thecasteisbasisforthereservation.Ifcasteiseradicated,thereisnoquestionof
reservationeitherinprivateorpublicsector.Thosepeoplewhoareopposinganykindofreservation,areina
positiontoopposethecastealso?casteisalsoareservation.
Thefatherscastesarearebeingreservedfortheirkids.Shouldthisreservationcontinue?Respectsarereserved
foruppercastes,whereashumiliationsarereservedforSC,ST,andOBC.Howtocorrectit?Cananybodyina
positiontoleavetheircaste?Whyallthemarriagesarebeingtakenplaceinthesamecasteonly,Why?Please
explain.
Ratethis:+12

G.Ramulusaid:(Tue,Dec16,201411:00:59PM)

Hifriends,
Manyfriends,whoparticipatedinthediscussionsareproposingthateitherthegovernmentortheprivate
managementsshouldtaketheresponsibilitytoprovidespecialfacilitiestheneededpeople.Ifthisisnotdoneby
thegovtorprivatemanagement,whatshouldbethealternative?
Ratethis:+2

B.Subbaraosaid:(Sun,Dec14,201410:34:56AM)

Subbarao,
Hifriends,
Atpresentglobalcompetitiontime,skillfullpersonsareneededtothesocietyforupliftingthecountryandastobe
placedinthebettermarkintheworld.Iperceivedthatthereservationinprivatesectorindicatesnegative
economicgrowthbecauseofthoserealtalentedpersonsmaynotbeplacedintheproductbasedorganisations.At
thetimeofindependence,situationwasverydifferentthatwaswhyourleaderscreatedreservationstothe
backwardpeople.Butnow70%ofthepeoplearelivinginbetterway.
Ifpoliticalpartiesarefollowingthepatriotismandworkingforthecountrydevelopment,theyshouldchangetheir
mindsetregardingtothereservation.Theymaychoosealternatefacilitiestothebackwardpeople.Thereisaway
tosupportthebackwardstudentsthattoprovideenoughprivilegestothosewhoreallyeconomicallybackward
andphysicallyhandicappedwithoutnaminganycasteandreligionbecauseofall"ALLAREEQUAL"asperour
fundamentalright.
Finallymyconclusionisthatthevoiceofreservationinsistingintheprivatesectoristobeavoidedforbetterfuture
ofourcountry.
"TALENTSMAKEMEMORABLEWONDERS".
Ratethis:+21

G.Ramulusaid:(Mon,Dec8,201411:25:11PM)

Reservationscanbedividedintotwocategories.
1)Uppercastereservations&2)Lowercastereservations.

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/reservationsintheprivatesector/

4/21

1/21/2015

ReservationsinthePrivateSectorGroupDiscussion

Reservationsarealsocanbedividedintwotypes.
1)Positivereservations&2)Negativereservations.
(Positivereservationforgainandnegativereservationforloss.).
Thepositivereservationshavebeencontinuingcenturiestogethertouppercastes.
Andnegativereservationsforlowercastes,
Whereasthelowercaste(positive)reservationshavebeenstartednearly100yearsbackonly.
Nobodyismentioningabouttheuppercastepositivereservation,whatisthereason?
Buttheuppercasteintellectualsarenotrealizingthisfactor.Howtomakethemrealize?
Ifallthemeansofproduction(land,factoriesetc)arenationalized,thequestionofreservationwouldnotrise.
Ifthereisnoprivatesector,whatisthenecessityofdiscussingthisissue?
Letusfightfornationalizationandagainstprivatization.Areanybodytakethischallenge?
Ratethis:+3

Bishtsaid:(Sun,Dec7,201405:30:22PM)

Disagree,reservationgiveonlyforbasisofincomeinlowercastesomepeoplearesorichascomparetoupper
castandtheygrabreservationeventheydon'tneedthis.Governmentsayweshouldnotcreatelinebetween
uppercastandlowercastbutinrealgovernment.
Createlineb/wuppercastandlowercastbygivingreservationtolowercast.SoconclusionisReservationisgood
forourcountryinPublicsectorOrprivatesector.
Ratethis:+4

G.Ramulu(Hyd)said:(Sat,Dec6,201411:29:36PM)

Hifriends,
Wherethereisinequality,thereneedsthereservation.Inequalitystemsfromexploitation.Generallyexploited
needsthereservation,butinIndia,exploitersavailedthereservationcenturiestogether.Ifwecanimpartially
observe,allthewealth&knowledgeisforciblyreservedtouppercastesonly.
Inothercountrieswhocouldafford,cangettheeducation,everyonehadtherighttohavetheproperty.InIndia
theserightswererejectedtotothemajoritypeople,onlyduetothecastesystem.Thisfactorisnotunderstood
bythemajorityoftheparticipantsofthisdebate.
Aslongascasteremains,discriminationwillcontinue.Ifdiscriminationcontinue,thereservationdemandwillinbe
inlive.Ifanybody,whoreallyopposethereservation,hastofightagainstthecastesystem.Ifcastesystemis
disappeared,whereisthequestionofreservations?
Ratethis:+7

Deepaksaid:(Wed,Dec3,201404:25:54PM)

Hellofriends,
Letmeputmypointstraightaway,thereshouldbenoreservationforanybodyinanysector,whetheritspublicor
private.Notalluppercastepeopleareintelligentandrich,inthesamewaynotalllowercastepeopleare
backward.
Whenitcomestoworkinprivatesectoritsjustpurelybasedontheskilloftheindividualandthereisnocaste
columnanywhereinprivatesector,Meaningthatifyouhaveskillthenyouaremostwelcome,nomatterwhich
casteyoubelongto.Evenintheworkplacethereisnodiscriminationdoneeitherintermsofcasteofintermsof
gendertoo.UltimatelyTalentandskillshouldbethewinner,andnotthecaste.
Ratethis:+28

G.Rramulusaid:(Fri,Nov28,201412:16:47AM)

Reservationinprivatesectorisneededtolowercastes.Lowercastesnaturallyinvitesthisdemand.Whereas
uppercastesopposeit.Uppercastesgenerallyclaimthattheyaremeritandefficient,&Lowercastesarequality
less,meritlessandinefficientpeople.Thisisabsolutelywrongunderstanding.Ifuppercastesareonlythepatent
tomerit,howcantheyjustifyit?majorityofthecollectorsarefromtheuppercaste(merit)people.
Whydidthedistrictswhichwerecontrolledbythemarenotdeveloped?manySP'sarefrommerit(uppercastes)
thenwhylaw&ordernotcontrolledthere?Manychefministersarefromuppercastes,thenwhythis
backwardnessinthestates?allmostallthesupreme&highcourtjudgesarefrommeritpeople(fromuppercaste)

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/reservationsintheprivatesector/

5/21

1/21/2015

ReservationsinthePrivateSectorGroupDiscussion

then,whythelakhsofcasesarependinginthecourts?alltheprimeministersarefromuppercastesonly.No
bodywereeitherSTorST.WhyIndiaissobackwardtillnow?whatcantheysay?.
Accordingtothemthattheyarenotavailinganyreservations.Itisnotright.Cananybodytellthereason,how
could15%uppercastepeopleareowning94%oflandsinthecountry?.Howthe97%ofbusiness&industryarein
thehandsof15%uppercastes,68%politicalrepresentationwith15%population.
Reasonisverysimple,exceptlasttwo/threegenerationseducation&propertiesaredeniedtolowercastes.
Education,properties&honourswerereservedtouppercastes&poverty,illiteracyandhumiliationswere
reservedtomajority(lower)castes.
Realityisthattheuppercastesareavailingthereservationssince3000years,wherethesc,st&bc'sareonly
from1930onwards.Thattooveryrecently.Tocontinuetheircenturiestogetherreservations,theuppercaste
"castiests"areattackingthelowercastesreservations.WithoutunderstandingthisIndianreality,noonewould
beaintellectualinthecountry.
Ratethis:+6

12

G.Ramulusaid:(Wed,Nov26,201402:57:43PM)

Hifriends,above90%participantsinthediscussionareagainstthereservationinprivatesector.Majorityofthem
definitelymightbefromuppercaste.Theirpopulationinthesocietyisnotmorethan15%.Buttheyareina
positiontowriteinEnglish.
85%arenottrainedupinEnglish.Whatisthereason?Whoareresponsibleforit?Anyspeakingorwritingperson
cananswerit?Ifyouareameritman,giveexplanation.
Ratethis:+15

SurabhiSharmasaid:(Sat,Nov22,201403:19:58PM)

Helloeveryone.Frommy(astudent)pointofviewreservationisdangerousproblemofourcountrybecausethere
ispreferencebytheircastnotbyability.InIndiaeveryonesayscorruption,blackmoney,etc.arethebiggest
problembuttheydon'tknowthatreservationworklikeabarrierinprogressofourcountry.Apersonwhoisnot
ableforclericalpostgetahighpositionbyreservation.
Sothisproblemshouldbeshortoutassoonaspossible.
Ratethis:+22

Jordansaid:(Thu,Nov20,201410:03:03PM)

HiAll,
IwouldliketellonethinginPvtsectororGovtsector,thereshouldbenoreservation.ActuallyIdon'tunderstand
whyneedreservationisthatneededtilltoday?Askeveryoneyourselfbecauseeveryonestudyingthesame
subjectsbutcomingtothisreservationstudentsarebifurcated.InIndiathisistheworstthingIwillsay.Hopein
futurenoreservationshouldnotbethereandallareequalforallopportunities.
Ratethis:+14

PawansutYadavsaid:(Thu,Nov20,201411:55:09AM)

HelloMitro(friends),
Weknowthateverythinghavepositivepointbutitsmirrorimagealwayshavesomenegativepointweshouldtry
toneglectnegativethought(point)butalongtimeneglectionofthosepointthenthatpointbecomepoisonsfor
ussoimplementationismuchimportantforthatsituationeventuallyRESERVATIONisimportantbutmustimportant
thatreservationisprovidedforwhichtypeofcandidate.
Ratethis:+6

ShaliniSinghsaid:(Sun,Nov16,201412:02:40PM)

Soguys,thetopicisshouldreservationbethere.FirstofallItotallydisagreethestatementandreservation
shouldnotbethereinanysector.Everyoneworkhardtosucceedandthenwhythereispartialitywithsome
people.
Ithinkifour"India"isgroupofreligionsnbelievein"unityindiversity"thenwhyitisdividingpeopleonthebasis
ofcasteaswellasreligion.Insteaditshouldbeonthebasisofeconomicstatus.Thiswillalsohelpimprove
povertyandalsodirectourcountryinrightposition.
Reservationhasmanyotherdisadvantagessuchasitcreateshatredamongthepeopleofdifferentcommunity,
thedisappointedamongtheunreservedcandidateswhichshouldnotbeignored.
So,Ithinkitsenoughandweshouldfightorourrightsandmustchangetherules.

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/reservationsintheprivatesector/

6/21

1/21/2015
Ratethis:+21

ReservationsinthePrivateSectorGroupDiscussion

Suryasaid:(Thu,Nov13,201401:32:41PM)

Inmyviewreservationsystemshouldnotbeallowedinprivatesector,becausethepersonwhoisclaiming
reservationinprivatesectorisalreadybeinggivenallpossiblesupportandhelpforhiseducationfromthe
governmentfreeofcost,nowthathehasenoughskillandtalenttogetajoborstartasmallscaleunit,moreover
Ihavetoagreereservationsystemdohampertheprivatesectorsauthorityinrecruitingaspertheirwishandwill.
Ifatallareservationhavetobemade,ashumanityisconcernedIthinkhandicappeopledeservesitbecauseitis
afactthattheyarerationallylargeinnumberandfeweropportunityingovtsector.
Ratethis:+9

Suryasaid:(Thu,Nov13,201408:17:27AM)

Inmyviewreservationsystemshouldnotbeallowedinprivatesector,becausethepersonwhoisclaiming
reservationinprivatesectorisalreadybeinggivenallpossiblesupportandhelpforhiseducationfromthe
governmentfreeofcost,nowthathehasenoughskillandtalenttogetajoborstartasmallscaleunit,moreover
Ihavetoagreereservationsystemdohampertheprivatesectorsauthorityinrecruitingaspertheirwishandwill.
Ifatallareservationhavetobemade,ashumanityisconcernedIthinkhandicappeopledeservesitbecauseitis
afactthattheyarerationallylargeinnumberandfeweropportunityingovtsector.
Ratethis:+4

Praveensaid:(Wed,Nov12,201403:34:56PM)

Hi,
InmypointofviewGovtandPrivatesectorsShouldnotencourage'Reservation'.InsteadGovernmentshould
encouragethestudents/employeesbasedontheirfamilyIncomeortheirKnowledge.ThenOurIndiaWillbeWorld
No.1soon.
Ratethis:+12

G.Ramulusaid:(Mon,Nov10,201411:26:29PM)

Whohaveparticipatedinthisdiscussionaredefinitely,Ithink,arefromUppercastes.Theyarenotrealisingthat
therealbeneficiariesofthereservationareuppercastesonly.Thelands,factories,businesses,thepolitical
power,judiciary(completemeansofproductions)arewiththem.Lessthan15%arecontrollingtheentiresociety
inallfields.Thesefacilitiesareprovidedbywhom?Propertyrights&educationalrightswerereservedforupper
castesonly.
Illiteracy,poverty,humiliationswerereservedformajority(SC,ST&BCsections).Since3000years,these
reservationarebeingenjoyed.SC,ST,BCsectionsaregivenreservationsonlyrecently.Whichreservationhasto
stay?Whichreservationhastogo?
Ratethis:+8

14

Rattan.said:(Sat,Nov8,201410:38:42PM)

Castsystemwaslikeworkingclasssystemi.e.GroupA,B,C&Dlikenow.WhathappenifgroupAclasscaptureall
postsofGroupAandsimilarlyotherclassesuptoGroupCandonlyclassgroupDworkingclasshastodothe
workandtheirgenerationwillnotallowedtolearnandreadandeducationandtreatedasuntouchable.Thisis
exactlylikecasteism.
Respectismuchmoreimportantthanreservation.Sohinducastesystemwaslikeavariousclassesofworkingin
governmentandunfortunatelyitturnedintocastesystem.SofirstweshouldbeproudofbeingHindu.Everybody
whoisholdinggoodpositionisproudofhisbeingborninupperclassthenwhataboutthosewhoareborninso
calledlowerclasses.Theylosetheirconfidencebecauseoftheircastes.
Sountilcastesystemisthere,reservationmustbeforlowercastes.Aspermyopinion,EveryHindushouldwrite
hissirnameashinduinsteadofhisforefathersworkingclassstatus.Thiswillhelptohinduismtospreadallover
theworld.So,thequestionofreservationwillnotbethereaswellasconfidencelevelinsocalledlowerclasses
willbehighwhichagaincanhelpIndiatobesuperpowerinthework.
Ratethis:+8

Loveysaid:(Wed,Nov5,201412:23:48AM)

Hieveryone,
FirstofallIwouldsaythatthereservationsystemisalwaysbadinmypointofviewspeciallywhenitcomesto
studiesbecauseeveryonetriesthebestathisorherpart.Nowadaysifwetalkaboutthereservationprocess,
thenitisworstforthepeoplewhofallinthegeneralcategory.Theyarethepeoplewhofacesthemost.

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/reservationsintheprivatesector/

7/21

1/21/2015

ReservationsinthePrivateSectorGroupDiscussion

Itisalsotruethatpeoplewithbackwardclassalsoputtheirbestefforts.Butthepointisthatifeveryoneputtheir
besteffortsthenhowcanthereservationcriteriaeffectsomeone'sresult.Ireallyfeelbadwhensomeoneinthe
generalcategory,getsmuchbetterresultthenacandidatewithsomequotaandhe/shedoesn'tgetachancefor
theselectionprocess.
Reallyagainstthisreservationsystem.Atsomepointitisgood,whenitisaboutreservingacoachinthemetroor
trainforwomen.AndIwouldthankthegovernmentfordoingthis.

Ratethis:+19

Anusaid:(Tue,Nov4,201411:37:45AM)

TherearepeoplewhobelongtoSC/STandotherbackwardcategorieswhoareilliterate.Lotofthemdon'teven
haveproperbasicessentialsfortheirlivelihood.Reservationsprovetobeboontothesepeoplepromoting
importanceofeducationandupliftmentofthesebackwardclasses.
Thiswouldpromoteoverallgrowthofourcountry.
Ratethis:+18

12

Karthiksaid:(Fri,Oct31,201411:34:52PM)

Hieveryone.
MajorproblemthatthepeopleofIndiafacingistheReservationsystem.Reservationsystemsexistsin
GovernmentOrganisationsandnowadaysithasoccupieditsplaceinPrivatesectorsalso.
Reservationsystemforbackwardclassesshouldmemeantforthosewhoareintellectualandpoor.Backward
peoplewhohavehighfinancialabilityshouldnotbegivenreservation.Highclasspeoplewillhavethemoney
powerandlowclasspeoplehavereservationpower.
LetusaccepttheseinGovernmentsectors.IftheseOpportunitiesaregiveninprivatesectors.Whataboutthe
peoplewhodoesn'thaveneitherofthemoneypowerorreservationcategories?
Ratethis:+6

Jeevasaid:(Fri,Oct31,201407:39:32PM)

Hifriends.
ThereservationsystemisverybadofourIndia.BecauseSC/STpeoplearecheatingthissystem.So,already
failurecountryeconomy,futuretechnologyimprovementsandetc.Don'tcontinuethissystemequallygivetoall
thepeople.
Thankyou.
Ratethis:+5

18

HemantRaghavsaid:(Fri,Oct17,201408:24:23PM)

Thereshouldbenoreservationinprivatesectorbycastepointofview.Govtcangivereservationtothosewho
arefinanciallyweaker.Becauseithelphim/hertoshowabilitythattheyhavebutnotabletoperformjustbecause
ofmoney.Onlythancountrydevelopmentispossible.
Ratethis:+12

Subbaraosaid:(Sat,Oct11,201411:24:37PM)

Mypointofviewreservationiswastprocessbutitcanhelpfulforsomepeopleandthosearelikehandicapped
peopleandorphan.Whohasbackwardpeopleandthatpeoplegovernmentmustbeprovidedipresitationto
collegefreeorothersetc.Henceeithergovernmentorprivateonlyprovidereservationanyfeeverylesscompared
tohigherclasspeople.Iknowreservationwaste.Idon'tknownotonlygiventofeepurposebutalsogob
purpose.
Forsixtyyearsbackcouldbeprovidereservationithasbeencontinuingforwhenhadwegotindependenceday.
Althoughithastakenadvantages.Itishelpfulforelectiontime.Butanyoneofthemwillnevertodareremove
reservation.
Everyfiveyearsitwillbeincrease.WhatevermaybeprivatesectorsreservationisworstsoIsaythatwhohas
talentpeopleandthatonepeoplearesuitableforanyofthis.AswellasIndiawhenwillneverdevelopinfuture
forletusconsiderforeigncountriesarethoselikeJapan,UKandGermanythesecountriesdidalreadydeveloped
althoughthesehaveeitherpoorandrichpeopleshouldnotprovideanyreservationsothatcountries.
Ratethis:+12

10

SourabhYerawarsaid:(Mon,Oct6,201402:52:14PM)

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/reservationsintheprivatesector/

8/21

1/21/2015

ReservationsinthePrivateSectorGroupDiscussion

HelloEveryone,beforeIspeakaboutthistopicIshallputforwardafactwhichsays,"everyhumanbeinghasthe
brainwithsamecapacitywhichcanholdthedatainsomepetabytes."Buttheonlythingthatdifferentiatesthe
onefromanotheristheutilizationofit.
Sotoutilizethemostofit,weneedresourcesforwhichweneedmoney.Andpoorpeopledonothaveitsoif
governmentcouldprovidethefundtotheseneedypeople,everyonewillbeatsamepositionanditwouldbeafair
contention.
Sotherehastobereservationintermsoffinancialhelponlyforneedypeople.
Thankyou.
Ratethis:+45

10

ShadeedaShahinsaid:(Tue,Sep23,201410:18:34PM)

Reservationistypicallyamajorproblemwhichdifferentiatespeople.Anysystemtoworkefficientlyneedstobe
absolutelyunbiased.Foracountrytodevelop,talentisthekeypointwhichshouldbekeptintoconsideration.
Conceptofreservationcameupduringtheearlytimesjusttogiveachanceforbackwardpeopletogetthrough.
But,sincethepurposehasbeenservedduetoequalrightsforall,timehascometogiveitaSTOP.Itiswitnessed
thatprivatesectorsaremuchefficientthangovernmentjustbecausetheydon'tcompromisewithtalents,thus
grabthebesthand.
Ratethis:+39

PratikshaGawandarsaid:(Sun,Sep21,201411:53:48AM)

Accordingtomypointofviewreservationispartofdirtypolitics.Privatesectorsuccessisdependshisservicesto
customersorthisthinkfulfilledbyemployeeifweshouldgetreservationinprivatesectorthechancesislessto
companygetefficientemployee.Reservationshouldonlythosepeoplewhoisfinancialbackwardsorhandicap.
Thisismyopinionaboutreservation.
Thankyou.
Ratethis:+16

AnkurSahasaid:(Sat,Sep20,201410:49:20PM)

Hellofriends,Ithinkthattheirshouldnotbeanyreservationinprivateandalsoingovernmentsectorstoo.Only
poorpeopleshouldgetfullhelpbutonlyinandthroughouttheireducationlife.ManyofmyfriendswhoareSCor
OBCenjoythosequotasandspendtheirquotamoneyinfunthoughtheybelongtomiddleclassfamilyandthey
donotneedanyhelp.Thesealsodevelopasenseinthemthattheywillgetagovtjobinfutureandtheydonot
studywell.Sothesequotasratherdestroyscountriesfuture.
Ratethis:+21

SuyashGuptasaid:(Sat,Sep20,201410:27:12PM)

Hellofriends,Doreservationreallyhelpthepoorpeopleorminorityorsomesimplymisusethem.
1.Welltohelptheneedythebestwayistogivethembooks,helpthemeconomicallyenlightenthewholesociety
withknowledge,technologysothattheycanstandwiththeirownlegsandwithproudtheycansayIreachthere
byfacingsamestrugglesthateveryonefaced.
2.ReservationPracticallyuptillnowithasprovedthatithelpmoretopoliticalleaderforgainingvotesby
thoughtslikethisleaderisfromourminorityorwillbringreservationforus.
3.Itwillmakecountrymorepronetointernalwarandwillraisetopiclikesecularism.
4.Asoneminoritywillrise,soontheotherminorityorit'sequivalentgroupwillrisedefinitelyforit'sreservation
andwillfinallyleadtorush.Inlastitisfactthatgeneralwillspittheirangerbysayingthisisunfairandagainthis
isharmfulforcountry'sunity.
5.Naturallyitwillweakenstherealeffortofminorityortalentofreservedpeoplebecausetheytheywillfeel
themselvesreservedandwillnottrytheirbestandsoinrealtermsitcanharmthem.
6.Thereshouldbesomeothermethodsandmeasurewhichshouldhelpminorityandcastsystemshouldbe
avoidedperhapssocietyparametershouldnotbemoneybutshouldbemoralvaluesandknowledge.Money
shouldbeequallydistributed,realhelpandrealfactisequality.
Ratethis:+16

Nagarjunasaid:(Wed,Sep17,201407:57:28PM)

ReservationinprivateSectorshouldnotbeallowed.Therearemanystatementsthatcansupportthisargument:

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/reservationsintheprivatesector/

9/21

1/21/2015

ReservationsinthePrivateSectorGroupDiscussion

ThesuccessofPrivatesectorfirmsmainlydependsontheQualityoftheServicestheyprovide,theycanofferbest
servicestoitscustomersifthatorganisationishavingTalentedEmployees.
Now,iftheprivatefirmsstartrecruitingcandidatesbasedonreservationthentheymaynotgettheBestTalentas
perindustrystandards.Thiscanaffecttheirbusinessinabigwayandmayresultinabiglosstotheirreputation.
Thereservationsmayresultinagreatdepressionamongeducatedpeopleofhighercastesincetheiremployment
opportunitieswillbebleakinbothGovtandprivatesector.
Ratethis:+12

Sagniksaid:(Wed,Sep17,201412:04:32PM)

HithisisSagnik.Iwouldliketospeak"against"thetopicgiven,i.e.Ithinkreservationinprivatesectorisnotatall
ajustoptionintoday'sworld.
Myreasons:
1.Asmostofmyfriendshavespoken,reservationgivenonthebasisofcasteorcreeddoesn'tensurethatthe
helpisgoingouttotheoneswhoreallyneedit.Ontheotherhand,manywhoareactuallysufferingarekept
awayfromitsbenefits.
2.Reservationbreedsmediocrity.Onceapersonknows,heisbeinggivenextraallowances,hewillnotgivehis
bestwhichaffectshisperformanceandtheinstitutionasawhole,speciallyifitsaprivatesectorjobrequiringhigh
efficiency.
3.Whenapersongetsinsideanorganizationonthebasisofreservation,evenifhecapableoftherolestillothers
sometimesfeelthathehasgotaneasywayoutwhicheventuallygivesbirthtojealousyandanunhealthy
environment.
Sothesolutionisformulatingaproper,errorfreesystemwhichcanfindtherealneedyandbackwardclassesof
oursocietybasedontheireconomicconditionsandthenprovidereservationstosomeextent.Onlythencanthis
systembemaderight.

Ratethis:+12

AnkushKulshreshthasaid:(Tue,Sep16,201407:17:42PM)

Accordingtomypointofview,Indiangovernmentneedsomeethicalchangesinthecurrentreservationsystem.
Thereissomeflawsincurrentreservationspolicies.Ontheotherhand,reservationinprivatesectoriscompletely
ridiculousbecauseofthesomereasons.
1.Privatesectorknownfortheirqualitiesnotquantity.
2.Eligiblecandidatemustbeselected.
3.Theequalitybetweenhighclassandlowclassiscomeundertotheoccurrencewhenthereisnosuchthingslike
reservation.
Thankyou!
Ratethis:+7

AffanAhmedsaid:(Mon,Sep15,201401:58:17PM)

Hellofriend,IamAffan,frommypointofview,reservationisgoodthing,butthesystemshouldchangetheir
policy.Thereservationshouldbebasedontheireconomyconditionnotonthecastesystem.Castsystemisthe
worstthinginoursociety.Ifthecastsystembeabolishedfromthecountrythenallpeopleunitethereisno
partialityforanyone.Reservationislikeaparasiteinourcountry.Reservationshouldbereplacedbyscholarship
bywhichpeoplefromlowerbackgroundgetscholarshipfortheireducation.
Ratethis:+5

OBCCaste
SCST
Reservation

NishiGuptasaid:(Sun,Sep14,201405:27:19PM)

Aspermyopinion,reservationisnotgoodforsocietyitisaverybigreasonofbackwardnessinoursocietyand
country.Aswealwayssaythateverybodyisequalrightnowafter63yearsofindependence.Butitisnotthetrue
factaboutsocietylowcastepeoplealwaysdiscriminateandcriticized.Buttogivehimequalityreservationisnot
anoptionbecauseduetoreservationtalentmaybehidden,manyofthetalentedcandidatenottogetequal
opportunitybecauseofreservation.Ingovtjobstherearealotreservedseatsforbackwardandlowercaste
people.Andiftherewillbereservationalsoinpvtsectorthentheremaybechoicesofhidingthetalents.But
privatesectoralwaysrequiredonlyskillsandtalent.Sothereisnorequirementofreservationinpvtsector.

Ratethis:+15

ShruthiKsaid:(Sun,Sep14,201412:30:46PM)

Hellofriends,

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/reservationsintheprivatesector/

10/21

1/21/2015

ReservationsinthePrivateSectorGroupDiscussion

Ialwaysvoteagainstthereservation,becauseitnotonlycreatediscriminationbetweenthelowclassandhigh
classpeoplesbutalsoincreasestheevilcastesiminthemindsofyounggeneration.Insteadofreservation,
provideenoughscholarshiptotheeconomicallypoorstudentsfortheireducationandprovideallthefacilitiesfor
themtoreadbutdon'tmaketheirwayeasybythesereservationsandall.Ifnoreservationsaretherethenthey
willautomaticallyworkhardandearnsomeknowledgeandthentheyfittogetgoodjobsinbothprivateand
publicsectorswithoutanyreservations.
Ratethis:+10

Rahulsaid:(Sat,Sep13,201406:27:53PM)

Hieveryone,
A/ctomypointofviewreservationshouldnotgivetoprivatesectororevengovernmentsector.Atthetimeof
independencematterwasdifferentbuttodayit'sdifferent.
Onthebasisofcasteorreligiontogivereservationistotallywrongbecausetodaymanyofthetalentedpersons
evendon'tgetthechanceinothersidemanyoftherichpersongetthechanceandusereservationcategory.If
wegivethereservationinprivatesectorthenitwon'tbegoodforcompanybecausemanyofthetalentedperson
evendon'tenterincompany.Soreservationinanysectorisnotagoodpolicy.
Thankyou.
Ratethis:+10

VikasSonawanesaid:(Wed,Sep10,201404:19:46PM)

HelloGuys,
IwanttosharemyfewwordsonGanesan'sstatement.Ganesanistotallywrong.SorryIamnotagreewithhim.
BeacauseIneverygovtsectorSC,NTgetsconessionandalsogetthefreeexamguidence.Inthissenariopvt
sectoriscorrect.IfSC/NTcandidatesgettingmoreandmoreconcessionandtheirallseatsarereservedforthem,
sowhyshouldtheyapplyinpvtsector.PleaseusetheirtalentingovtsectandnotinPvtsector.BecauseallOBC
andOpencandidatesarenotgettinganyconcession.
Thisismysuggestion.
Ratethis:+2

Ganesansaid:(Tue,Sep9,201401:58:03AM)

Swathiwhatyousaidiscorrect,oneofmyfriendisveryintelligentandtalentedpersonbuthebelongstoSC.He
isworkinginprivatecompanyandsearchingjobchangebutprivatesectorisnotacceptinghimbecausehe
belongstoSC.Thisiswhathappeninprivatesector.So,casteshouldnotcomeincertificate.
Ifthereisnoreservationinprivate,whyprivatesectorisaskingcaste?Theyshouldseehistallenandknowledge
notcaste.Whoaskingreservationinprivatesector?whoaffectedbyprivatesectorthosepeopleonlyasking.Why
privatesectorbehavinglikethis.BecausesomeprivatesectorisnotacceptingSCpeopleforhigherpositioneven
thoughheistallenandintelligent.Theonlywayiscasteshouldnotcomeincertificate.

Ratethis:+23

UltaChashmahsaid:(Mon,Sep8,201408:49:49PM)

HiGuys!
Iwouldliketoaddthat,reservationsucceedsinkeepingtheproblematbayandnotcuringit!Ratherthanfussing
overonhowtodetermineacorrectreservationsystem,itwouldbebetterifweallcanwipeouttheneedforit.
Thisimpliesequitablegrowthwhichwouldcomefromgreatereducationlevelsandthusdemolishcasteprejudices
andageoldbias,therebyputtinganendtoinequalitywhichgivesrisetoreservationinthefirstplace.
Ratethis:+4

Srikanthsaid:(Mon,Sep8,201404:44:15PM)

Hifriends.
AcctomyopinionReservationgoodifthepersonscomingfromtheeconomicallyweakersectionsofthesociety.
Butnowthethingisdifferentwhybecausethepersonsfromtherichandalsotheygetareservationthenhowwe
canjusticetopoorpeoplesoithastobechangeotherwisetheeconomicpositionofacountrywillnotchange.We
havetodependonothercountriesforthesmallthings.Indiahaslotoftalentedpeoplebuttheirknowledgenot
usefultothecountry.Becauseofreservationwheneverwerevisethereservationsystemthenonlyweachieve
theeconomicgrowthanddreamIndia.
Ratethis:+2

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/reservationsintheprivatesector/

11/21

1/21/2015

ReservationsinthePrivateSectorGroupDiscussion

AbhisekDashsaid:(Mon,Sep8,201401:56:43AM)

Dr.BRAmbedkar,madethisreservationfor20years,keepinginmindthatIndiawillbeadevelopedcountryafter
20years.Butno!,IndiaisstillaDevelopingCountryanditsallbecauseofitsowngovernmentwhotakethemuch
advantageofreservation.Governmentwantsvote,andforthattheyneedthepeopleofIndia.Theyaremaking
thisreservationasabasefortheirvotes.Clearlyspeaking,Reservationisandwillcreateamassdiscrimination
amongus.EarlieritwasnamedDiscriminationoncaste,nowitwillbeDiscriminationonReservation.Ifthiswill
continuethen,what'sthevalueofthetalentofastudentwhostruggledtogetajob.Nowthepresentscenarioof
Indiainnotbad,morethan70%peopleareingoodeconomicstate,butstilltheyneedreservation,WHY?This
reservationwillcreateabadenvironmentineveryPrivateSectors.TalentiswhatdrivestheoutcomeofPrivate
Sectors,notreservation.Ifreservationwillbeimplementedinprivatesectors,thenwebetterstopourstruggleof
gettingagoodjob,stopdreamingofgettingintoMNCs,becausethoseplacesarereserved.Sowhystruggle?
Whytorun?Forwhatwewillrun?Forsomethingwhereisnotrecognitionoftalents,aplacewheremycaste
comesfirstthenmytalent.
Thedayprivatesectorswillimplementreservation,fromthatday,thehopeofdoingagoodjobwilldie,andour
countrywillremainasthedevelopingcountryforever.
Ratethis:+8

AbhinavJadhavsaid:(Sat,Sep6,201401:56:09PM)

Hieverybody.
Reservationinprivatesectionshouldnotbeallowed,becauseithurtsdevelopmentofIndia.Itshouldbegivento
peoplewhoreallyneeditlikeEBCpeoplereallyneedit.Reservationismainreasonforbreakingunityofour
nation.

Ratethis:+11

Aloksaid:(Thu,Sep4,201410:23:31PM)

WellfriendfirstofallIamalokandandIamagreewithmostoftheabovestatementsbutIwouldalsoliketoadd
somepoints.Wellthewordreservationwascoinedbydrbhimraoambedkarandhecomprisedthiswordin
constitutionforprovidingextraprivilegetotheweakersectionofthesocietyonthebasisofcast,creedand
communitybutforonly20years.Andmydearfriendsaswearelivingin2014itmeanswehavepassed68years
fromourfreedomthattimethesituationwasdifferentbutnowthesituationisdifferentandthereisnoneedto
followthatrulewhichwasenacted68yearsbefore.
Butasforthecurrentsituationofmanyofthefamiliesstillreservationisrequiredforwhombelongtoeconomically
lowsectionofthesociety.Ithinkgovernmentshouldconductfreshsurveyforgettingdataoftheeconomical
conditionsofIndian.Andgovernmentshouldstartafreshreservationpolicyonthebasisofeconomicalconditions.
AsthediscussionisaboutprivatesectorandinthiscaseIamagainstreservationbecauseifprivatecompanies
recruitemployeeforthesakeofreservationdefinitelycompanywillgettheunskilledstudentsandthiscanhamper
theprogressofcompanyandtheprogressofourcountryalso.Sofinallyinprivatesectoritisnotrelevanttogive
opportunityforthesakeofreservation.
Thankyoufriends.
Ratethis:+30

Ranvijaysaid:(Wed,Sep3,201411:51:04PM)

Iamtotallyagainstthisreservationsystem.Ifamanofgeneralcategorywithgreatabilityinrespectivefield
doesn'tgetjoboradmissionthenitisinjusticetohim.Inademocraticcountrywhereeveryonehasequalrights
andjustbecauseofhiscaste,ifheisnotgettingtheactualtreatmentwhichheactuallydeservethanthisisone
ofthemajorissuewhicheveryoneshouldworry.Governmentshouldmakeactivedecisiononthis.
Ratethis:+3

SourabhSaxenasaid:(Wed,Sep3,201407:38:39AM)

Accordingtomypointofview,bornqualitiessuchascasteshouldnotbeasuitablecriterionfordecidingthepost
orrankofaperson,ratheracquiredqualitiessuchasknowledgeandabilityshoulddecidetheirplaceforthem.
Ratethis:+3

Saikiransaid:(Mon,Sep1,201411:25:57PM)

OurCountryhasthesayingthat"ALLAREEQUALBEFORELAW".But,Idon'tunderstandwhyarethese
reservationsfor?Iftheyreallywanttogivereservations,itshouldbegiventoeconomicallybackwardpeopleand
physicallyhandicappedpeople.Duetoreservation,mostofthetalentedpersonsnotgettinggoodchances.Andif
thereservationisintroducedinprivatesector,ourINDIAwon'tdevelopforever.
Ratethis:+27

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/reservationsintheprivatesector/

12/21

1/21/2015

ReservationsinthePrivateSectorGroupDiscussion

Neerusaid:(Sun,Aug31,201404:51:51PM)

Iammyselfareservedcategorystudent.Istronglyfeelthatreservationsystemshouldberevived.Atthetimeof
independence,thingsweredifferentandonthecontemporarybasis,ithastobebasedonfinancialstatus.Buton
theotherhandwecan'tignorethepartialitybeingpractisedonthebasisofone'scaste.So,eliminationof
casteismholdsequalstakeforinclusivedevelopmentofIndia.AccordingtodatabyNSSO,only2%ofboysand0%
ofgirlshavebenefittedfromreservationintheirprimaryeducation.
Ratethis:+9

AnutashPareeksaid:(Wed,Aug20,201408:34:23PM)

Goodevening,friends.
Iamfairlyagainstreservationsystemifreservationisgivesthengivesthosepeoplewhoneedsofitforeg.
Economicbackwardpeople,handicapspeople,inallcastesystemnotinst/sc/obc.BecauseofthisIndiaisnot
growthrapidlyandunreservedpeoplenotshowntheirtalent.
Atpresenttimeallpeoplesareeducatedbuttheyaredependentonreservationsysteminsteadofthisthey
showedtheirtalentfordevelopourcountry.
Soremovethereservationsystemascasteismbasis.
Ratethis:+22

S.Kumarsaid:(Wed,Aug20,201403:28:27PM)

Icouldn'tseeanyofthefriendsabletocommentwiththehelpoffactdata.It'sageneraltalkformanyofthem
withoutarealitycheck.Peoplecanunderstandeasilysomeoneabletomakeitwithfactdataofreservation.Most
ofthepeoplesviewisagainstreservationsystemwhichotherwisepromotedecelerationofdevelopment.
Myopinionisthatthepeopleneedtospeakoncastsystemanditseliminationfromsocietyratherthancaste
basedreservation.Thelevelplayinggroundshouldbesametoallandallowthemtocompeteeachother.
Ratethis:+8

Santhoshsaid:(Wed,Aug20,201403:04:57PM)

Inourcountryreservationisinhighrate.That'sacurseofournation.Weshouldstopbymovingtowardsthe
reservationsandfreethingsthatwasgivenbythegovernmentintheelectionpromises.Wemuststandourone
legsandalsohelpournationtostandandlookingupwardthanothercountries.
Ratethis:+1

Aasthasaid:(Wed,Aug20,201412:34:03AM)

Inmyopinionreservationdoesnotcreatehealthyenvironment.Reservationshouldbegiventoonlythosewho
reallyneedsit,likepeoplewholacksintermsofmoney,butreservationintermsofcasteisnotgood.Forexample
therearereservationinalmostalltheexaminationsforhighereducation,andingovernmentjobs,duetowhich
mostofthetime,thedeservingcandidatedidnotgetthechance,andthenondeservingcandidatebecauseof
reservationgetsselected.Soinmyviewsitshouldbebanned,andaletsdevelopanation,havingreservation
free,whereeveryoneisequal,andeveryonehasequalopportunity.
Ratethis:+13

ShubhamKharwalsaid:(Sat,Aug9,201412:23:33PM)

Accordingtomypointofviewwhenreservationisimplementedbythegovernmentbythinkingonlyasocial
welfaremotivethatitwilluplifttheweakersectionofyoursocietySCandstmainlybutwiththepassageoftimeit
becomeaspoonfeedingtothelowercastepeopletodayin21stcenturyasbyanexamplewhenwetalkforthe
developmentofprivatesectorthereservationinprivatesectoristotallyambiguousitnotonlyharmtheprivate
sectorbutalsoprovideawaytothatpeoplewhohidefromcompetition.Thereforereservationisonlygiventothe
needyphysicaldefectpeople.Astodayprivatesectorplaysaimportantroleinthedevelopmentofofanycountry
economy.
Ratethis:+14

Samisaid:(Sat,Aug9,201410:57:59AM)

I'mfullyagainstwithreservationsystem.ItishavingabadimpactonIndiandevelopment.Ithinkamancando
everythingifhetry.Weallareeducatedperson.Andweknowthathardwork,willpower,dedication.Foraperson
withthesequalities,theskyisthelimit.AsaobccastIsayreservationsystemhavetoremovefromourmindas
wellasourcountry.
Ratethis:+22

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/reservationsintheprivatesector/

13/21

1/21/2015

ReservationsinthePrivateSectorGroupDiscussion

AnuoGguptasaid:(Mon,Aug4,201403:03:19PM)

Higuys.
Iamtotallyagainstofreservation,butifthereservationisgivenonthebasisofgenderdifference(maleofemale)
andforthosepeoplewhoarehandicapsthenitisfine.Butifitsgivenonthebasisof"cast"thenitsnotrightand
notgood.Reservationshouldbegiventothosepeoplewhoactuallywants.Eg.handicaps,economically
backward,etc.
IfcastsystemandreservationsystemremainsinIndiathenIndiawillneverdevelop.Wehavetotreateveryone
asequal.HenceIamagainstofreservationsystem.
Ratethis:+43

Madurisaid:(Sat,Aug2,201402:28:05AM)

Hi,
Inmyopinionreservationsshouldbegiven.ButitshouldbegiventothepeoplewhoareIneedofitimmediately.
Itmeanstheeconomicallybackwardpeople,etc.Butallofthemdonotgetit.Itmeansthatonlysomepeopleare
gettingintermsofeducationbutremainingpeoplearenotgettingthereservationthoughtheyaretalented.It
meansifaforwardcastestudentistalentedenoughbutnotgettingreservation.Itmakeshimdisappointedtohis
life.Thereforereservationshouldbeequallygivenbasedontheireconomicalstatusandalsobasedontheir
talent.
Ratethis:+17

Prudvisaid:(Fri,Aug1,201407:47:21PM)

Hieveryone.
Inmyopinionreservationsystemisnotimplementingincorrectway.Thepoliticiansusingthissystemasfortheir
advantage.
AndalsobythissystemIndiaisnotdeveloping.Ifreservationsystemisintroducedinprivatesector,thissector
alsonotdevelopedwell.AndalsoeconomicalgrowthofIndialost.Because,ifyoucanseeninpublicsectorthe
qualityofeverythingisless.Butinprivatesectoreverythingisqualityevenasmallthing.Becausetheyrecruits
onmeritbasis(75%to95%),theydon'twantcaste(SC/st/obc).Butpublicsectorrecruitsoncaste.
Qualitymakesanything,butcasteruinseverything.
Ratethis:+14

Viveksaid:(Fri,Aug1,201412:31:20PM)

Wealreadyhavingsuchreservationissueingovernmentsector.Sothereisnoneedtoapplysuchsickrulesin
privatesector.Peoplehaverighttogetwhattheydeserveaccordingtotheirknowledgeandwhattheyare
capableof.
Ratethis:+20

Sharadsaid:(Wed,Jul30,201401:31:42PM)

Accordingtometherearepeopleeconomicallybackwardinallthecastes&alsoeconomicallystable.Thebenefitof
reservationdoesnotreachtotheactuallyrequiredpeopleasthereservationisgivenonthebasisofcaste.The
reservationshouldbegiventopersonwhoareeconomicallybackward&nottotheparticularcaste.Sothe
benefitscanbeusedbytheactuallyrequiredpeople.Onthebasisofcastethebenefitsaretakenbythe
economicallystablepersonalso.
Ratethis:+18

Ridhimasaid:(Sun,Jul27,201409:17:39AM)

Accordingtomethisreservationsystemisruiningourcountryandthepeople.ItisthegovernmentofIndiawhich
upheldthatallareequalbeforelaw.Thenwhythis?itistruethatbeforeandafterfewyearsofindependencethis
wasveryessential.Butnowthetimehaschangedandeventhethoughtsofpeople.Theyareeducatednow.And
nolongerbelievethosesuperstitions,sowhenpeoplearereadytocompetewiththeirownabilities.Whyisthat
reservationstillthere?So,inmyviewreservationshouldbegiventothosewhoareeconomicallybackwardand
notforthecaste.Weshouldkeepinmindthatweareallhumanbeings.
Ratethis:+23

Mannsaid:(Fri,Jul25,201410:15:52PM)

Accordingtomethereshouldbeequalitybuthowcanweignorethesepeopletheyevenhavenotgot
opportunitiesinpastwecanturnpagesandlookintothehistorytheyweretreatedlikeanimalstheywerenot

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/reservationsintheprivatesector/

14/21

1/21/2015

ReservationsinthePrivateSectorGroupDiscussion

allowedtostudyevennottotouchanybodybycoiningthemas"untouchable".TheseSC/ST/OBCarethosewhich
liesbelowBPL.
Now,howequalitycanbeconsidered?eveninpresenttheydon'thavemoneytosupporteducationandthe
competitionisamongthesereservedcategorypeopleonlybutnotamongthosegeneraltheyarenotadmittedto
anygeneralseatsandneithergeneralsareadmittedtoanyreservedseats.
InthelastIwouldaskaquestionassumethere'saracecompetitionandsomeplayersareplacedveryfarfrom
startinglineandthenaskedtowintheracewhatwouldbeprobabilitythattheywillwintherace?theansweris
nullandthese"some"playersarereferredtoasreservedcategorypeoplehowwilltheywiniftheyarenot
supported?ifallaresayingtomaintainequalitythenfirstmakethesepeopleinapositionwheretheyare
providedalltheneedsthenwecanremovethereservations.ALLISUPPORTISTHETERM"EQUALITY".

Ratethis:+16

16

Mishtisaid:(Tue,Jul22,201408:58:31PM)

Hieveryone,
Indiaisgettingmorepoorduetothisreservationsystem.ManyskilledandtalentedIndianswhomainlycoming
underGeneralcategoryareleavingIndiainsearchofgoodopportunitiesandthusspendingtheirknowledgeon
othercountriesdevelopment,justbecauseIndiaisnotrealizingtheneedofthetalentedpeoplefordevelopment.
AndifthereservationsystemisremovedandcandidatesaretakenforjobsbasedontheirmeritthenIndiamay
havemovedforward.
IfapersonunderSCcommunityhasgotaGovernmentjob(Engineer,obviouslybyreservation)itmeansheis
earningahandsomeamount(4.5LPA)withmedicalandotherfacilitiesthenwhyhisSon/Daughteraregiventhe
SCreservationagain.Onwhatbasisheiseconomicallydown.
Notonlythat,Inpowerplantoperationsevenifthereisasmallmistakeitisgoingtodamagethewholesystem,
thenwhythelesstalentedpeoplearerecruitedforthesakeofreservation.
Yes,therearealsostudentsunderSC/STcommunitywithgoodmerit,thenwhytoaccomplishthereservation
systemtorecruitthem,Letthemcomeoutoftheircommunityshellandcompetewiththeiragedcandidateswith
samequalificationbasedontheirtalent.
ThankGod,PrivatesectorsarebasedonmeritasitneednotshowcasethepeopleforvotesasPoliticiansdo.
Politicianscanhavethissensiblethinkingwhytheprivatecompaniesareofferingmoresalariesandhavehigh
turnoversjustbecausetheyhaveselectedtalentedpeople.
Finally,RESERVATIONSYSTEMishavingabadimpactonIndia'sdevelopment.
Andifatallthissystemcannotbeeliminatedtheninsteadofcommunitycertificatesforrecruitmentandchoosingof
college,theGovernmentmustaskfortheParentsPaySliptocheckfortheireconomicstatus.
Ratethis:+67

AnilKumarReddysaid:(Sat,Jul19,201404:44:28PM)

Hellofriends.Inthatpresentsituationreservationisusefulonlypoliticians,notforstudents.Theycrashentireour
lifeandalsoourtalent,basedonthesereservations.WhyI'msayingthatisforexampleifastudentget90marks
outof100,hedon'tgetthejobbecauseofhebelongsto"OC"candidate.Butanothercastperson(sc/st)get70
marks,hegetthejobbecauseofreservations.
Whatisthat?Thisiscorrectforus?Ourministersandprimeministerscansayforus"alltheindiansareequal"so
thenthatsituationgettingthejobsarealsoequalbutwhythereservationisimplemented?basedonthese
reservationmostofthetalentpersonswillgotoothercountries.Thenhowtodevelopingourcountry.Finally
what'smyanswerisreservatiocanbeavoidthenalsoourIndiawillbecomeanumber1Place.Thankyoufriends
andthankyouforgivingthisopportunity.
Ratethis:+8

Shanusaid:(Sat,Jul19,201412:53:53AM)

Allofusknowthatwehavearightcalledasrighttoequalityinourconstitution.Butthepracticalscenarioofthe
reservationsystemdoesnotproveit.PEOPLEFROMGENERALCASTEHAVINGSAMEECONOMICBACKGROUNDARE
NOTGETTINGWHATTHEPEOPLEFROMSC/STAREGETTING.Soisthiscalledtherighttoequality?Themainmotto
ofthereservationsystemwastoraisethepositionorstandardofthepeopleofthebackwardclasses(i.e.people
havinglowincomeandlowstandardofliving)inthesociety.Buttoday'sscenarioisquitedifferent.Peoplewhoare
nowabletostandontheirownfeet(maybeduetothissystemonly)findithardtoleavethissystem.Sonand
daughterofrichpersonswhocaneasilyaffordtheexpendituresoftheirchildrenareavailingthissystemtilldate.
Theresultofwhichisbeingbaredorentertainedbythegeneralcastepeople.Nowthissystemhasbeena
burningproblemforthegeneralcastepeople.Thatthedaywhenthegeneralcastepeopleformssome
associationanddemandageneralcastekota&createakindofunwantedenvironmentinthesocietyisnottoo
far,can'tbesaid.ThegeneralpeoplearereallyfindingithardfortheirProgressineducationaswellasjobs.This
reservationsystemshouldonlybeallowedforreallypoorandpeoplefrombackwardcommunity.

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/reservationsintheprivatesector/

15/21

1/21/2015

Ratethis:+4

ReservationsinthePrivateSectorGroupDiscussion

Saikumarsaid:(Wed,Jul16,201412:19:47AM)

AspermyViewinIndianEducationReservationisonlyforwhoareunabletogetMoneytoStudyEducationand
goodknowledgepersonsalsoAccordingtotherankbasedandcastebasedeverythingRemovethereservation
systemthenIndiawilldevelopinallaspectsandmoreStudentswillgetbrightfuture.
Ratethis:+3

Anisaid:(Tue,Jul15,201403:37:59PM)

Hieveryone,
Afterreadingbelowstatedviewsoftheparticipants.Itisclearthateveryoneisfedupwiththissystemofcaste
basedreservation.
Butreservationinitselfisnotabadthing,theproblemariseswhenitisgiventounworthypeople.
SowhatIfeelisthereshouldbereservationstoaverylimitedextent,buttheyshouldnotbecastebased,
insteadtheyshouldbegivenconsideringtheabilityandthefinancialbackgroundofthecandidate.
Becausetherearepeoplewhoarenotfinanciallysoundanddonotenjoytheluxuryandopportunitywhatother
peoplewithequalcaliberastheirsdo.
Sothesecandidatesshouldbegivenspecialconsiderationthroughreservation,whetheritisprivateorpublic
sector,sothattheirtalentdonotgoinvain.
Ratethis:+7

RajshreeDwivedisaid:(Sun,Jul13,201412:59:13PM)

Reservationhadbeenimposedwithamotivetoenhanceandsupporttheeducationallyandsociallybackward
classes.Thecriteriawhichhasbeendevisediscaste,whichforaperiodoftimewasneededinIndia,butcertainly
itisnotmadeforindefiniteperiod.
Thecriteriaofreservationshouldbechangedtosomemethodwhichcalculateitonthebasisofthefinancial
status,resourcesavailableetc.Forinstancetherearetwopeonsoneofthegeneralcategoryandtheotherof
reservedcategory,bothofthemcannotsendtheirchildtocoachingforanyxyzexam.Bothhavethesame
resourcesandfacilitystilltheopportunityforthereservedwillbemore.
Socriteriaiswrongnotthereservationpolicy.Bychangingcriteriainspecifiedtimeandbyapropercommittee,it
canbefreedasapoliticiantoolusedforvotebank.
Ifproperlyimplementeditwillbebeneficialforthesociety.ItshouldbeONLYimplementedintheprivatesectorif
abovementionedthingsaretakencare,otherwiseunreservedcategorywillbebetweenScyllaandCharybdis.
Ratethis:+4

Rajansaid:(Wed,Jul9,201406:58:07PM)

Whenwesaybackwardcommunities,whatweactuallymeanisthecommunityofpeoplewhohavealower
income,lowlivingstandardsandlesseraccesstoresourcesthanwhatwecallissufficient.Ratherthanclassifying
backwardcommunitiesonthebasisofcaste,certainquantifyingtechniquesshouldbedevelopedwhichcan
quantifybackwardnessofanindividualbasedonwhichhecanhaveaparticulargradeofbackwardness.Religion
andcastearenotagoodcriteriatojudgebackwardcommunities.Asasuggestion,familyincome,assetsowned
bythefamilyaccesstoresourcesetc.Arecertainmeasureswhichcanbeincludedwhiledevelopingthe
backwardnessindex.Thisapproachwoulddefinitelyhelpinproperdistributionoftheadvantageofreservation.
Thiscouldbeimplementedinprivatecompaniestoowhereafterselectingtalent,theywouldchoosepeoplefroma
backwardbackgroundwithoutcompromisingontalent.
Ratethis:+3

Nitishsaid:(Wed,Jul9,201406:11:52PM)

Reservationshouldbeonthebasisofincomelevels,notoncastebasis.Castesareconsideredforthepoliticians
votebankonly.InIndiathetalentshouldbeincreasedbygivingmoreopportunities.Inuppercastealsothereare
backwardpeopleandinlowercastesalsotherearepeoplewhosettledwellonthebasisofcaste,thatpersons
whosettledmustwithdrawtheirsonsorfuturegenerationsonutilisationofreservationssothatotherswhoare
backwardcanbeutilised.
Ratethis:+5

Piyushsaid:(Tue,Jul8,201404:32:11PM)

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/reservationsintheprivatesector/

16/21

1/21/2015

ReservationsinthePrivateSectorGroupDiscussion

Accordingtome.Ithink,Everyonehereistalkingaboutthedisadvantageofreservationortheirhatenessfor
reservation,butIwanttotellyouallmyfellowsthatIndiaisstillapoorcountryandinourcountrypeoplearestill
treating#DalitsandSC/STverybadly,EvenSOcallededucatedpeopleofmetrocitiesarealsotreatsbad!somy
pointisjustthat,Iknowgeneralcategoryguyscansaythatreservationisnotgoodasitisdifficultforthem,But
thegroundrealityisverydifferentfromyourthinking!SOIdon'tthinkthatreservationinprivatesectorwillraise
newhopes.Ithinkeveryoneisjealousofreservation.
BeforetalkingaboutreservationallIwanttosayisjustthatfirststopbehavingonthebasisofcastthentalk
aboutstoppingreservation!
Ratethis:+20

19

KratikaPandiyasaid:(Tue,Jul8,201409:00:54AM)

Afterthe66yearsofindependence,ifuptillnowthereservationsofseatsforminorityclassesindifferentstates
i.e.SC'sandST'sisgoingonthenIthinkthisisalsotheobstacleinthepathofthedevelopmentofIndia.
Sincetheeligiblepersondon'tgettheseatandtheSC'soccupiestheseat.Fortheserviceorjobseatsare
reservedwhichleadstothesmallnoofseatsleftfortheothersi.e.littleprobabilityforgettingjob.
Forthestudentssickingadmissionininstitutionsforfurtherstudies,havetobuyformbutwhythecostisdifferent
forSC'sandothers?AtthehalfofthecostpaidbyothershavetobepaidbySC's.
Assumingthattheydoesn'thavemoney,Thenalsoafterseekingtothehighpostswhytheirwardsgetsthese
facilities.
ThecutoffmarksisdifferentforSC'sandothers.Thepersonwhopossesstheseatdidn'tgetitbecauseSC'sand
ST'stakeiteventheyhavelessqualificationsandmarks.
ThenthepromotionofSC'sandST'sgetat3yearsandgeneralafter5years.Theeligibilitycriteriaforanyexamor
forserviceisdifferentforothersandforSC's.ThatmeansWITHINTHESERVICEPERIODOF10YEARSSC'sAND
ST'sGET3PROMOTIONSWHILEOTHERSONLY2,Whysuchadiscrimination?
Besidesthisthepoliticiansmakeprofitofthisfortheirvotebankbypromisingthemtoincreasethereservation
percentage.ThisisaquestionamonguswhereshouldthepersonsnotcomingunderthecategoryofSC'sand
ST'sshouldleadsotheirisproperjustice,theydoesn'thavetositathomewithhighqualifications?

Ratethis:+5

Vimalsaid:(Mon,Jul7,201411:15:00PM)

IfgovernmentgivesalljoboppurtunitiestoaSC/STcommunityalonethenwheredoestheothercommunity
peoplegofortheirsurvival.NosurvivorcansaythatallpoorpeopleinthiscountryareSC/STs.Ithinkthisisnota
mistakebythegovernmentalone.Itisamistakebyeverygovernmentofficials(especiallySCs)inallsectorofgovt
ofIndia.Thegovernmentofficialswantstogivethejobopportunitiesfortheirowncommunitymembers.
So,inpublicsectorthegovtgivefullmandatorytotheofficialsandtherecruitmentshouldbestrictlygovernedby
thecentralgovernmentatleastinupcomingdays.Torectifythisproblemthegovtshouldfixacommoncutoffinall
exams(NorelaxedcutoffforSC/STs).Iftheyreallybelongtopovertylinethenthegovernmentshouldgive
relaxationinexamfees,educationfees,etc.Butnotinacompetitiveexamcutoff.
Ratethis:+3

Sathyasaid:(Thu,Jul3,201405:11:12PM)

Ithinkreservationsarenecessaryfortheupliftmentofthebackwardcasteslikescheduledcastesandtribes
becausetheyarenotreachabletothemodernworld.Therearemanypeoplewhoaregiftedintheruraland
backwardareasbuttheyarenotgettingbetterhelpforreachingthemodernjobsinthemnccompanies.Because
oftheirignoranceandpovertytheyarenotseeingthemodernworld.AlreadytheIndiangovernmentisrecruiting
backwardcastestofulfillthereservationsinthejobs.Likethistheprivatecompaniesalsoshouldhireinthe
backwardareasforthesakeofscheduledtribesandscheduledcastes.Buttherearealsomeritstudentsinother
castesalso.
Sothejobsmustbenotcorruptionorcastebaseditshouldbemeritbased.
Ratethis:+8

17

Vijaysaid:(Tue,Jul1,201403:43:53PM)

Haifriends.Reservationalsooneofthemajorreasonforeconomydrawbackforthecountry.Talentpersonsare
notgettingopportunityinpublicsectors.Itspoilthegovernment.Buttheprivatesectorsaredifferentfromthe
publicsector.Theyrequireonlyquality.

Ratethis:+16

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/reservationsintheprivatesector/

17/21

1/21/2015

ReservationsinthePrivateSectorGroupDiscussion

NirajRaisaid:(Sun,Jun29,201410:52:57PM)

Istronglyfeelthatthetimehascometoeradicatethereservationsystemfromourcountry.Afterindependence,it
wastheneedofhourtobringreservationfortheDALITS.SoDr.B.RAmbedkarbroughtitforthem.Butnowthe
situationhasalmostchanged.Forinstance,ifapersonbelongingtoSC/STcriteriaisanengineer,thenwhyshould
thesamereservationshouldbegiventohischildren.
Ialsobelievethatreservationisweakeningourcountry.Becausepeoplegettingjobthroughreservationarenot
asmuchtalentedasunreservedpeople.
Inadditiontothese,reservationshouldbegivenonthebasisofeconomicalcondition,insteadcaste.
Ourconstitutionsaysthatweallareequal,thenwhytherearereservation.Thistimeneedstalentsoasto
contributeforthedevelopmentofourcountry,notthereservation.
Ratethis:+52

Sunilsaid:(Mon,Jun23,201404:20:20PM)

Reservation.Why?Reservationcanneverbeasolutionofanyproblembutitsitselfaproblem.Ourconstitution
saysthatweallareequalbutIdon'tfeelthatinourcountry.Ifallareequalthenwhythereisareservationto
particularsectionofsociety.Ijustgiveonesmalleg.Whichshowshowreservationisruiningourwholecountry.If
anST/SCcandidatebecomesanIASofficerstillhisson/daughterwillgetreservation.NowIjustwanttoaskone
question.HowtheyarebackwardwhentheirfatherisanIASofficerandcanfulfilltheirallrequirementrelatedto
studies,upbringingetc.IjustwanttoslappoliticianswhocannotstopthisreservationandusingitforVOTEBANK.
Ratethis:+33

AmritKumarsaid:(Sun,Jun22,201409:57:47AM)

HellofriendsIamAmritandIbelievethatthereisnoreservationcategoryinprivatesectorbecausebackboneof
privatesectorisqualityandquantityandifyouarecompromisingwithtalentandexperiencethenitshowsthat
ourquality,productivityandbrandvaluegetsdecrease.Ifthisthinghappenssoyouareoutofmarket.
Ratethis:+7

Swapnilsaid:(Sun,Jun22,201412:23:34AM)

Hioneandallpresenthere.
Reservationinprivatesectorisjustafoolishkiddything.ReservationwasgivenbyDr.Ambedkarforjust10years
fortheupliftmentofdalits,economicallybackwardclass,sothattheycanhavethereownstand,nowitsgoingtill
nowfornoreasons.Thatsverycruel.
Inthisworldofcompetition,preferenceshouldbegiventothetalentnottothereservation,forthebettermentof
thenation.
Ratethis:+5

Sudhakarsaid:(Thu,Jun19,201412:19:46AM)

AfterindependenceShriAmbedkarjibringreservationthroughIndianconstitutionwasthemostimportantneedat
thattime.Atthattimesomecompletesectionsofsocietyarelivingtheirlifeunderveryadverseconditions.So
reservationwasaveryimportantneedatthattimebutnowweareenteredinmodernIndiathingsarecompletely
changednow,almosttherewasadevelopmentinallsectionsofcountrynowtimehascometodosomerequired
changesinconstitutionandstopgivingreservationtopeopleonthebasisofcaste.Idon'tunderstandwhatour
politiciansaredoingtheknowverywellthatfordevelopmentofourcountryweneedmoreandmoretalent&
reservationiscreatingaprobleminfindingtoptalentthenalsoforvotebankthearesupportingreservation.
Ratethis:+9

Priyavartsaid:(Mon,Jun16,201408:56:40PM)

Hellofriends.
Reservationshouldneverbeonthebasiscaste,genderandreligionofaperson.Itcreatesdifferencesbetween
thepeopleanddeprivedpeoplefromthebasicRIGHTOFEQUALITYgiveninourconstitution.Ourleadershad
providedreservationstoupliftbackwardsocietiesbutknowourpoliticalleadershavechangedthedefinitionof
reservationtheyusethistoestablishtheirvotebankandtheyexploitminoritypeoplesfortheirinterests.
Ifgovtwanttoprovidethereservationitshouldbegiventophysicallyhandicappedandfinanciallyhandicapped
people.Theyactuallydeservethisprovision.
THANKYOU.
Ratethis:+11

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/reservationsintheprivatesector/

18/21

1/21/2015

ReservationsinthePrivateSectorGroupDiscussion

GurpreetKaursaid:(Thu,Jun12,201407:19:44PM)

Accordingtomyopinionreservationsshouldnotbeallowedinprivatesectors.Asweallknowthatcompetitionis
sohigh,astudenthastodoalotofhardworkandheorshehastogivehiscompletelifeforclearingoneexam.
Ingovernmentsectormostoftheseatsarereservedforbackwardclassesatlaststudentsbelongstogeneral
categoryareleftwithfewseats.Eveninsomegovtexamgeneralseatsareonly1or2.
Sostudentsofthiscategoryarefightingforthisfewseatsonly.Sothisdirectlyaffectsthefutureofstudentof
generalcategory.Sothesestudentshastoshifttowardstheprivatesector.Ifreservationsareallowinprivate
alsothenwherewillthesestudentsmove.Soinsomehowwearehelpingbackwardclassesbutalsotakingthe
rightsofotherpeople.Inthiswayourcountrywillremainasitisnoimprovementswillbethere.
Ratethis:+28

RickyRajsaid:(Tue,Jun10,201405:23:24PM)

Atthetimeofindependencereservationgivenfortheupgradationofbackwardorschedulecastesbecauseatthis
timetheireconomicalorsocialconditionwasnotgood.
Anddecidedtovanishthisaftersometimebutafter60yearsindependencereservationarestillcontinuedueto
poorpoliticsofourcountryourleadersusetheirreservation.
Systemvotebanktheycan'tunderstandwhatproblemfacebythestudentsorthepeopleofourcountrymany
skillpeoplenotabletofoundaccordingtotheirability.
Ithinkreservationisnotbadbutbythesystema/ctowhichreservationgivenisnotgooditcanbegivenby
economicorsocialconditionofapersonorfamilybecausetodaytherearealargenoofpeoplewhorequired
reservationsystembutcan'tfoundbecauseofthesystem.

Ratethis:+5

Geetusaid:(Tue,Jun10,201404:02:11PM)

InmyopinionitshightimeforIndiatoremovethereservationsystem.Itismakingtheyoungsterstoworkless
butrelymoreontheircastetogetajobingovernmentorganizations.
Butforthereliefofotheryoungstersthereareprivatefirmsthathirepeoplebasedonskillsratherthanontheir
caste.Thisreservationsystemhasmadestudentstocommitsuicidesbecausetheyarenotenrolledintheirdream
collegeseventhoughtheygetgoodmarksfromtheircounterpartsbelongingtolowercastes.
Thereservationsshouldonlybegiventothosewhoareeconomicallyandsociallybackwardsratherthanbasedon
castes.Thedifferentlyabledpeopleshouldalsobegivenreservation.
Ratethis:+11

RohitBhattacharjeesaid:(Wed,Jun4,201404:06:25PM)

Thereservationsystemthathasbeeninplaceinourcountry,wasmeanttobeforthose,whowereoppressed,
anddidnothavethenecessaryexposuretoeducation,andopportunitieswhichwereavailabletootherclassesof
thesociety.Sadly,nowthatthestateandtheseverityofthecastesystemhasbeenreduced,thereservation
system,likeanyotherlawinthiscountryisbeingexploitedbythepeoplewhoarerich,anddonotdeserveit.
Theproblemwithreservationsinanysectoristhatpeoplewhoarebotdeservingofapositionofwork,getsthe
job,andthen,thequalityofworkisdiminished.But,westillhavetokeepinmindthosewhomighthavethetalent
andnecessaryskills,butaretrulyoppressedanddon'thavetheopportunitytoapplyforhighprofileprivatesector
jobs,whichwearegivenexposureto.
Thatisstillnoexcuseforintroducingreservationsintheprivatesector,butifreservationsintheeducationsystem
canbetightenedwithafewotherruleslikefamilyincomeandhistory,thenmaybethekidswhoreallyhavethe
talentmightcomeup,andcouldn'tcomeuptillnowforvariousreasons.Thepercentageshouldalsobereduced,
andarigorousscreeningprocessmustbeemployed.
Butallthisshouldbedoneonlytillschooleducation.Afterthat,everyoneshouldbetreatedequally,andfairly.No
matterwhatbackgroundyouare,youshouldbeselectedforyourtalentandabilityalone,andnootherfactor.
Ratethis:+5

ArunSreeramsaid:(Sun,May25,201410:11:27AM)

Reservationisforthepeoplewhoarenotskillful.Itisamendedasapartofourconstitutionsoastoencourage
thepeopletobecomeliterates.Butthissystemhasruinedthetalentedandtheskillfulpersonalities.Alltheone
whoarehighlyskilledandtalentedarenotgivenanypreferenceduetothisreservationsystem.Itisfarbetterto
restrictthissystemtillsomeextentoftheeducationsystembecausetheonewhoistalentedisnotcomingout
andhe/sheismadediscouragedbythissystem.
ReservationsystemmadeIndianpeoplegoabroadandsettlethere,therebyalltheskilledpersonalitiesare
involvinginthedevelopmentofforeigncountriesbutnotOurs.

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/reservationsintheprivatesector/

19/21

1/21/2015

ReservationsinthePrivateSectorGroupDiscussion

Reservationinprivatesectorleadstothesame.Itmeantthattheprivatesectordoesnotrequireatalentedora
skillfulperson.SothereservationsystemshouldbeavoidedinthePrivateorinthepublicsectors.Reservation
shouldbeencouragedtosomeextentandbeyondthatitistobeavoided.Otherwiseitisalosstotheentire
Nation.
Ratethis:+5

ThakurjiGuptasaid:(Thu,May22,201411:39:27AM)

Reservationisgivenforthosewhoarenotabletodosometaskwhichgeneralpeoplecando.
ButafterthedraftingofconstitutionofIndiaGovernmentismisusingtheReservationweaponforfightingin
electionwithothers.Andlowcastepeoplesarealsobenefittedbythegovernmentscheme.Inmypointofview
reservationshouldbegiventothosewhoarenoteconomicallyandsociallyequalwhetheritmaybeanycaste.But
providingreservationinprivatisationmayleadtonegativegrowthofIndianeconomybecausepeoplethenare
selectedbyreservationnotbytheirskillandtalent.
So,Inrealworldtherearealwaystoughcompetitionsinprivateorganisationinthatcasethatcanbewonby
skilledlabourwithgreattechnicaltalentwithmanagementvalues.
Ratethis:+21

SampadGangulysaid:(Tue,May20,201408:13:26PM)

AsfarasIamconcerned,reservationisneededforthatkindofpeopleonlywhoarenotphysicallyableandcan
notaffordinitiativeasmuchaswecantogetajob,astheyarenottotallyfit,reservationshouldbeintroducedto
thosepeoplesonly,otherwisewetalkaboutequalityandintheothersideweintroducethistypeofconcept,this
isnocool.
Ratethis:+4

M.Anuhyasaid:(Sat,May17,201405:12:56PM)

Hi,
IcansaythatReservationiskillingthe"Skillofpeople",duetothisstudentsarenotworkinghardtogainmore
knowledge.
Ontheotherhandwearehappythatprivatesectorarenotintroducingthesereservations,becausetheyare
lookingfortheskilledworkersandthatiswhytheprivateorganizationsareearningmoreprofitsthangovernment
organizations.
Knowledge&Intelligencearethemostimportantthingswhichmakesthecountrytomoveforward.
Ijustwanttosayonethingthatthesereservationswillbetheretodaybutnottomorrowbutourskillremains
withusuntilourlastbreath,andtherespectwegetfromothersdoesnotdependon"ourcastorreligionor
gender"dependsonwhatwehavedoneforoursocietyandhowdidweproveourselves.
Letusremovethereservations.Weareallequal.Weareindians.
Ratethis:+30

SpeakYourMind:

...

Pleasedonotusechatterms.Example:avoidusing"grt"insteadof"great".

Submit

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/reservationsintheprivatesector/

20/21

1/21/2015

ReservationsinthePrivateSectorGroupDiscussion

Relatedtopics:
ManagementEducationinIndia
WomenarebetteratMultiTasking
BrainDrainhastobestopped
PrivateEducationalInstitutions:GoodorBad
CricketasaNationalObsessionisaDetrimenttoOtherSports

20082014byIndiaBIX T echnologies.AllRightsReserved|Copyright|T ermsofUse&PrivacyPolicy

Contactus:info@indiabix.com
Bookmarkto:

http://www.indiabix.com/groupdiscussion/reservationsintheprivatesector/

Followusontwitte r!

21/21