Professional Documents
Culture Documents
JUNE/JULY
APRIL 2008
MOTORCYCLES
MEDIA AND STOPLIGHTS 101
CONCERNS
In the past it has been reported that the Motorcycle Safety Advisory Council has been pursuing the problem with
It traffic
seems light
that this problem
sensors is of concern
not recognizing to everyone,
motorcycles whether
waiting theygreen
for the ride light.
or not.It The
can following is anIn
be frustrating. example of this
pursuing what
your ICMS is doing to address the issue. It may never change, but ICMS won’t give up the position either. Fair and
issue thereporting?
balanced Council hasYoumet with Mr.
decide. engineers
Cranorfrom
was the Ada member.
a HOG County Highway District (ACHD) and is continuing to
address this problem. Somewhat heartening is that ACHD, who happen to control the majority of the intersections
in Ada
Letter to County, has beenMay
KBCI regarding paying attention.
5th news report:
ACHD recently started a publicity campaign “Getting the Green” to help. There are 270 intersections that are
The Idaho Coalition for Motorcycle Safety would like to thank you for providing coverage of our Motorcycle
supposed Rally
Awareness to detect
last waiting
Saturday.vehicles. Mostatof5:30
Your report the was
timejust
they
asdetect
we hadmotorcycles
hoped. Theas they should.
message However,
to motorists if you
to watch out
forhave
and an be unusually long wait ACHD
aware of motorcycles on ouradvises
highways thatwas yourthebike
solemayintent be of
in our
the event
wrongand place
youtoassembled
be detected.a storyThey
that
recommend that
accomplished you position
our goals. youragain.
Thank you bike tires along the yellow sensor marks or other designated area installed in
With
the that message
pavement. It in mindthen
should we did not want
detect your to address the
presence. helmet
If you findissue. We are notwith
an intersection anti-helmet
sensors but
thattostill
discuss
won’tthe issue
work
changes
call ACHD the focus
Traffic of Department
our event and at therefore
387-6190the andmessage
ask thatistheylost.better mark that intersection.
In your 10:00 story you turned our message into an opportunity to discuss helmets. The Awareness Rally does not
In happen.
just any event, be patient.
It takes Sometimes
about five months itofisplanning,
the timing of the green
meetings light you permits,
with officials, are waiting for and not and
proclamations any many
failureother
to
things to make this event happen. This is hard work by a few volunteers. To have our message trumped by other issues
detect.
in the media is disheartening. There are many ways to make motorcycling safer in Idaho and motorist awareness
is There
but one.areThe
times whenTransportation
Idaho a motorcycle will not trigger
Department the traffic
reported in 2006signal.thatIn56%
this of
case, you
fatal may proceed
motorcycle with caution
accidents were of
the single vehicle variety. This would lead us to believe that 44% of fatalities involved another vehicle. Farcycle
through an intersection. However, only do so if you have been stopped at an intersection through an entire more
often than
of the not, signal.
traffic it is theAlso,
faultyou
of the
mustother vehicle.
yield The numbers
to oncoming traffic. tell us thisRefer
Be safe! is a very
to yourimportant issue,
motorcycle worthyprovided
manual of media
attention.
by the DMV Still, for
it seems
more that all the media
information really
on this wants to talk about is helmets.
exception.
This case can be made by a story that you aired at 4:00 on Monday. You reported the unfortunate death of Dean
Cranor in a collision with an automobile that had violated his right of way. You stated that Mr.Cranor was not wearing
This
injuries. TheIssue:
A SPECIAL THANKS
a helmet and died at the scene and also that his wife, who was wearing a helmet was transported to a hospital with
seriousIn story then turned into an editorial about the use of helmets. You used figures from the front page
of the motorcycle portion of the NHTSA web site to help make your point. A through investigation of those numbers
National
would reveal their Helmet Law
inaccuracies.
I.C.M.S. would like to thank the following donors for their generous
NHTSA has them there for all to see to promote their helmet law agenda. So, Mr.
Cranor’s death was used as an opportunitysupport
Remembering: to onceat our Annual
again promoteCan the Dance on November 27, 2007. Through an
use of helmets.
The report should have read that Mr. Cranor was riding his motorcycle in the
oversight, this was not included in previous
a lawful Twowhen
manner WheelanAdvocate.
automobile
• Ron Shepard
driver unlawfully violated his right of way and killed him. What was done instead was to make the victim the
perpetrator • he was not wearing a Giesler’s
because Mondt
Dave helmet. The Auto Repair;
report tells Cooper’s
the viewerAmerican Service; fine
that it is perfectly Country Repair
to break &
the law
by violating a motorcyclist’s right of way and kill him
Towing; Stix; because he wasGrizzly
Vigilante’s; not wearing
Sports;a helmet. The public
Whitewater Saloon;can then
Canyonthink
theTop Cop Retires
motorcyclist had it coming. This is wrong. Rim Bead Buddies; Cook’s Two Hole Bar & Grill; Woody’s Outdoorhe
The facts are that these incidents frequently kill the rider whether
is Star
wearingClassa helmetupdate
or not. Power; El Gallo Giro; Kim Young; Kathy Spangenberg; Chris Reeves;
So, although you reported our message so well on
Canyon Saturday
Honda; at 5:30,
Hpnotiq; you &
Hogs didHorns;
not hear it yourself.
4-E’s That American
Bar; Crow’s Mr. Cranor
was Upcoming
not wearing a Events helmet was not the cause of his death. An automobile driver killed him. That is the story. Please
Motorcycle Repair; Longhorn Lounge; Bass Mountain Shop; Kuna
take these comments into consideration the next time you air a story about the death of another motorcycle rider who
Readers Ride:
died at the hands of a motorist.
Smoke Shop; High Desert Harley Davidson; Sandstone; Boise Cycle;
Bill’s Bike Works; Judy Petersen; Nester’s; So Posh Spa; Red Rooster;
Sincerely, • Swan Falls Terrace Lakes; Green Thumb; DaVon Spellman; Josh Young; Big Twin
Lane Triplett
Cycles; RD’s Custom Cycles, Kahootz, Dave Mondt, Midge Auburn,
Chairman
and the Frontier Club.
Idaho Coalition for Motorcycle Safety
I.C.M.S. CALENDAR OF EVENTS I.M.C.S.
FOR 2008
Board of Directors
I.C.M.S. FUN VALLEY
I.C.M.S. SPRING FUN RUN These are the people who are willing to give their time
Saturday, April 5, 2008 and energy to help protect your rights and Keep Idaho
July 11-13
First Stop Veteran's Park,2008
Boise, Idaho Free.
Pine Idaho
I.C.M.S. MOTORCYCLE AWARENESS RALLY BOARD MEMBERS TERM
Live MusicSaturday,
FridayMay& 3,Saturday
2008 Night Chuc Coulter Legislative 345-6232 2007-09
Rodeo
Rally Starts at 11:00 a.m. at Sandy Point Park Justin Crawford
Allan Green
Awareness Rally 863-4280
Entertainment/
2007-09
2008-09
Leaves at 1:00 p.m. for ride to Boise
Camping Events Coord.
Brooke Hanson Editor 919-1620 2008-10
Auction
I.C.M.S. FUN VALLEY RALLY
July 11-13, 2008 Chris Lambing 761-2790 2007-09
BBQ
Pine, Idaho
Bart Patrick
Judy Petersen
Distribution
Treasurer/
344-4032
375-6117
2008-10
2006-08
Vice-Chairman
STATEWIDE FRIENDSHIP RUN Larry Platt Rodeo/Fun Runs 888-5836 2006-08
August 30 - September 1, 2008 Dave Spangenberg Products 884-2677
884-267 2006-08
Pierce, Idaho Mike Thompson 462-3995 2007-09
Lane Triplett Chairman 336-0052 2008-10
BENEFIT RUN FOR I.C.M.S. OFFICERS
Saturday, September 6, 2008 Mike Weiss Membership 375-9172 2008
Magic Valley, Idaho Kim Young Secretary 343-7452 2008
The Board meets the 1st Monday of every Month
I.C.M.S. FALL MEMORIAL RUN (provided it’s not a holiday) at 7:30 p.m. at Lindy’s
Sunday, October 5, 2008 Steak House, Boise (west of HP) Members’
First Stop Veteran' s Park, Boise, Idaho attendance is encouraged.
I.C.M.S. ANNUAL MEMBERSHIP MEETING The following are Area Reps for I.C.M.S. and
& CAN DANCE make this an effective statewide effort.
Saturday, November 15, 2008
Mike Kelly Hailey 208-788-1642
R.F. Bonney
Bouney Idaho Falls 208-526-0135
Brenda Bolton Twin Falls 208-733-0151
Beverly Campbell Idaho Falls 208-589-7554
Norman Burch St. Maries 208-245-5094
208-245-4771
Newsletter design & layout by Paula
For More information on this publication or to
submit a letter to the Editor please write to P.O.
Box 2732, Boise, Idaho 83701 or fax them to (208)
345-2003. Also visit us at...
www.idahobikerrights.com
2
WHAT IS IDAHO COALITION FOR MOTORCYCLE SAFETY?
Idaho Coalition For Motorcycle Safety (ICMS) is a state motorcycle rights organization (SMRO). Whether you
ride American or foreign, big bike or small, even if you don’t ride at all, ICMS works to protect and promote your
right to free choice and to ride free. From fighting discriminatory laws and practices to creating and promoting
educational programs, ICMS and its members stand for the preservation and advancement of the motorcyclists’
lifestyle.
ICMS closely monitors legislative action, traces legal trends and maintains a strong link with other motorcycle
rights organizations to insure its members are as fully informed and current on developments as is possible.
The members of ICMS are actively involved in their communities by raising funds for various charitable
organization and food drives. Members also take an active part in the political process, from passing petitions
to contacting legislators. Although it is not required for membership, ICMS would like to encourage a high level
of involvement.
ICMS works closely with governmental and private organizations to promote rider education programs, greater
motorcycle awareness, and is a leading proponent for the fair and unbiased treatment of motorcyclists in the legal
arena.
Additionally, membership in ICMS is an opportunity to meet, socialize and ride with a diverse group of people
joined together for the common good. ICMS members know how to have fun as well as get the job done. Join
today and find out for yourself what UNITY is all about.
WHAT HAS I.C.M.S. DONE?
Idaho Coalition for Motorcycle Safety (ICMS) was incorporated as a non-profit educational corporation in
September 1985 with the intent of introducing a rider education program to Idaho and to campaign for public
awareness for motorcycles.
ICMS was instrumental in organizing the Steering Committee in February 1991. ICMS was successful in
defeating HB301 which would have required all riders to wear motorcycle helmets. The Steering Committee
continued to work on motorcycle legislation in 1991 and 1992.
In April 1991 ICMS was successful in having the Idaho Transportation Department form a Motorcycle Safety
Task Force which prepared legislation known as the Motorcycle Safety Program for Idaho.
In January 1993 ICMS became qualified as a political action committee.
In March 1994 ICMS successfully lobbied the passage of the Motorcycle Safety Program which provides for
motorcycle rider education and licensing for Idaho.
Since January 1993 ICMS has been the full time legislative watchdog in Idaho. In Washington, DC ICMS was
successful in having 100% of our delegation vote in favor of motorcyclist’s rights and the federal blackmail of the
states without mandatory helmet laws was defeated.
In March 1995 ICMS was successful in lobbying to change the law to make a more equitable means of funding
Rider Education for motorcycle riders statewide.
ICMS is a sustaining member of Motorcycle Riders Foundation and actively works with and supports the work
of MRF in Washington, D. C. and in April 1995 brought the Best of the West Seminar to Boise. ICMS also
hosted the Best of the West Seminar in Boise in June, 2005.
2002 ICMS lobbied and it was passed that insurance companies cannot discriminate against motorcycle riders
on health care.
ICMS publishes the Two Wheel Advocate, a newsletter to keep its members currently informed of all legislation
that may affect motorcyclists.ICMS continues to work to protect motorcyclists’ rights, in Idaho and nationally.
While individual motorcycles were not counted, a total of 865 waivers were signed with an additional 22 waivers for
minors submitted. There was great representation and support from various clubs, groups, and individuals. A wide
variety of motorcycles were present; from imports to choppers, Harleys and trikes, along with 6 scooters. This variety
of support reinforced the solidarity and unity of the event and reiterates ICMS’s goal to educate, promote awareness,
and to protect the rights and freedoms of all who ride.
4
The 2008 Awareness Rally was a Success Thanks to:
Rob Rock – Washington Group International, Tom Huston-American Resurgens Management Corp.
Boise Valley Riders, Motorcycle Police/ Boise Motorcycle Escort Service,
Christian Motorcycle Association, Paul Weimer, STAR/David Dickson and other Instructors
Advanced Sign and Design/Road Signs, RM Mechanical, Billy Blevins/ Road Block, Larry Gebart/ Channel 7
Idaho Statesman, Wayne Dzuback/99.1 FM, Natalie Hurst/ Channel 2,
Gwen Stark/50/50 and Merchandise, Angii Welch/Merchandise, Ken Phillips/Traffic Control,
Lorie Forbus 50/50, Dave Pennick/Traffic Control, Fuzzy and Mary/Coffee and Donuts, Midge Auburn
And Many Others!
5
SPRING FUN RUN
ICMS’s 18th Annual Spring Fun Run was a wonderful opener to
a new riding season. Justin “The Kid” Crawford reports, “With 93
sign-ins, we had a greater turnout this year than in previous years.”
The Winner of high hand was Jeff Hannes, low hand Anne Larsen.
The Kid also said,” I want to thank all of the Clubs and everyone
who attended. ICMS appreciates everyone’s support and we look
forward to seeing you next year.”
What prevents fatalities? Not mandatory helmets. But trained riders. Alcohol affects your riding
They avoid accidents and fatalities. skills so ride straight.
Riding a motorcycle takes
(Editor’s Note: It is hoped that soon the State of Idaho will be matching coordination, balance and,
trained riders’ numbers to accidents and fatalities. It is expected that most important, good
Idaho will find much of that same experience as Utah. Don’t want to judgment. Alcohol, more than
be a statistic? Take a rider education (STAR) course.) any other single factor, can
rob you of your ability to
think clearly and ride safely.
Ride Straight.
STATISTICS
Did you know that some of the statistics being used to promote mandatory
helmet laws ignore statistics collected by the same people. Those ignored
statistics tell a different story and that different story is that helmets are not
the answer. For example:
New Hampshire and Iowa have no helmet laws and the reported statistics
of fatality rates are 3.0 and 3.5 deaths per 10,000 motorcycles in 2006. And
the rates in Mississippi and Maryland, which have mandatory helmet laws,
show 20 and 12 respectively, per 10,000 motorcycles. Even the Insurance
Institute recognizes this.
6
ABATE OF CALIFORNIA ASKING FOR HELP
Many of you have been aware that over the last few years there has been a lot of litigation going on in California
over their mandatory helmet law. These various pieces of litigation in California are now narrowing down to one
important case and though in the past it has been just a few carrying the battle, now ABATE of California has
stepped into the fight. Now it’s getting very expensive.
Most have not understood that organizations like the State ABATE organizations (and like ICMS in Idaho) are
formed under strict legal restrictions that control what these organizations can do with their money if they want
to enjoy the exemptions from taxation, etc. The treasury of these organizations that are enjoying the exemption
cannot use their funds for the benefit of any individual. Helping someone out with their litigation, like fighting a
helmet ticket, is not the proper function for an exempt organization. As a consequence when asked for donations
and they don’t respond with a donation there can be hard feelings.
So the answer is that individual bikers can donate to support such an effort as this, but not the exempt
organization.
And, yes there have been occasions when these organizations have gone outside the limits. The “downed rider
fund” that many have is an example. But if they are using the exempt treasury, it is risky.
The California case is entitled Quigley v. California Highway Patrol, et al. The case has challenged the Highway
Patrol’s conduct in writing helmet tickets in the face of a court order not to enforce the California law. The
defect is that the law requires a rider to wear a helmet that is compliant with the federal FMVSS218 standard
for helmets. It is argued that neither the rider nor the officer can read that law and know how to comply with it.
The law can only be applied arbitrarily. The standard states nothing about a helmet’s fabrication nor what it is
supposed to look like. The law merely describes laboratory procedures that only appropriately trained engineers
would know how to follow. And if you follow the procedures you would destroy the helmet.
If you can’t understand it and you can’t follow it, the law is “vague”.
There is no list of “approved” helmets and a DOT sticker is not an approval because the Department of
Transportation does not “approve” helmets. In fact there is no entity that “approves” helmets. Depending on the
result of this lawsuit, many other states may benefit.
The whole analysis is an interesting exercise.
The bottom line for California is that they plan to win, but to do so is costing a lot of money and they’d appreciate
some help. Maybe do a fund raiser and send them the proceeds. If you do, contact ICMS and ICMS will make
sure the contribution gets to them.
(
(
(
(
(
(
(
NONPROFIT ORG
IDAHO COALITION FOR US POSTAGE
MOTORCYCLE SAFETY, INC.
PAID
PO BOX 2732 BOISE, ID 73701-2732
BOISE ID
A non profit organization
PERMIT NO 313