Professional Documents
Culture Documents
discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/269577237
CITATIONS
READS
495
7 authors, including:
Gopa Chakraborty
Shaju K Albert
12 PUBLICATIONS 35 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
SEE PROFILE
Thomas Paul
Arup Dasgupta
SEE PROFILE
SEE PROFILE
Materials Characterization
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/matchar
Metallurgy & Materials Group, Indira Gandhi Center for Atomic Research, Kalpakkam 603102, India
Chemistry Group, Indira Gandhi Center for Atomic Research, Kalpakkam 603102, India
a r t i c l e
i n f o
Article history:
Received 4 June 2014
Received in revised form 12 December 2014
Accepted 13 December 2014
Available online 15 December 2014
Keywords:
Martensite
Tempering
Embrittlement
Carbide
XRD
TEM
a b s t r a c t
Martensitic stainless steels nd extensive applications due to their optimum combination of strength, hardness
and wear-resistance in tempered condition. However, this class of steels is susceptible to embrittlement during
tempering if it is carried out in a specic temperature range resulting in signicant reduction in toughness. Embrittlement of as-normalised AISI 410 martensitic stainless steel, subjected to tempering treatment in the temperature range of 673923 K was studied using Charpy impact tests followed by metallurgical investigations
using eld emission scanning electron and transmission electron microscopes. Carbides precipitated during tempering were extracted by electrochemical dissolution of the matrix and identied by X-ray diffraction. Studies indicated that temper embrittlement is highest when the steel is tempered at 823 K. Mostly iron rich carbides are
present in the steel subjected to tempering at low temperatures of around 723 K, whereas chromium rich carbides (M23C6) dominate precipitation at high temperature tempering. The range 773823 K is the transition temperature range for the precipitates, with both Fe2C and M23C6 types of carbides coexisting in the material. The
nucleation of Fe2C within the martensite lath, during low temperature tempering, has a denite role in the embrittlement of this steel. Embrittlement is not observed at high temperature tempering because of precipitation of
M23C6 carbides, instead of Fe2C, preferentially along the lath and prior austenite boundaries. Segregation of S and
P, which is widely reported as one of the causes for temper embrittlement, could not be detected in the material
even through Auger electron spectroscopy studies.
2014 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Martensitic stainless steels (SS) nd extensive application in steam
turbine blades, marine turbine blades, compressor blades etc. due to optimum combination of strength, hardness, and wear and corrosion resistance [1,2]. To achieve the desired microstructure and mechanical
properties, martensitic SS in the as normalised condition is subjected
to an appropriate tempering heat treatment. However, for a given duration of tempering, a continuous decrease in hardness with increase in
tempering temperature often does not take place due to the complex
nature of the tempering behaviour. Instead, in certain alloy steels secondary hardening is observed during the tempering heat treatment. Signicant reduction in impact toughness with fracture mode changing
from ductile to intergranular is also observed, which is referred as temper embrittlement.
There is a difference in opinion in the published literature on the
cause of temper embrittlement in this class of steels. Some researchers
have identied the main cause for this embrittlement as secondary
hardening due to heterogeneous carbide precipitation [3,4] whereas
others have pointed out that segregation of impurities like P and Sb at
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: gopa_mjs@igcar.gov.in (G. Chakraborty).
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.matchar.2014.12.015
1044-5803/ 2014 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
82
In order to identify the various precipitates formed during tempering at 723, 823 and 923 K, X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis was carried
out with Cu K-alpha radiation source at 2/min scan speed on precipitates extracted by dissolving the matrix from the corresponding
specimens. The dissolution of the matrix and extraction of the precipitates were carried out electrochemically using a solution containing
10 vol.% of hydrochloric acid in methanol with specimen as anode and
platinum electrode as cathode maintained at a potential difference of
1.5 V. Specimens were polished up to 600 grit emery paper and dissolution was carried out for 24 h before extracting the precipitates. Filter
paper of pore size 0.1 m was used for vacuum ltration of the solution
and the precipitates collected over lter paper was transferred on glass
slide for XRD analysis.
An attempt was also made to identify possible segregation of the impurity elements like S and P by measuring their concentration at the
grain boundaries of specimens tempered at 723, 823 and 923 K using
Auger Electron Spectroscopy (AES). These studies were performed at
the freshly fractured surfaces of the impact tested specimens as well
as after sputtering the surface with Ar+ for 3 min and Differential
Auger spectra were recorded.
AISI 410
Cr
Mn
Si
Fe
0.14
11.2
0.9
0.46
0.01
0.003
Balance
500
80
(a)
(b)
60
Hardness (VHN)
83
40
20
800
900
1000
400
300
900
1000
Temperature (K)
Temperature (K)
Fig. 1. Variation in (a) impact toughness, (b) hardness with tempering temperature of 410 SS.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(f)
Fig. 2. Fractographs of 410 SS samples in different heat treated conditions: (a) normalised and tempered at (b) 723 K, (c) 773 K, (d) 798 K, (e) 823 K and (f) 923 K.
84
tempered sample reveals lath martensite structure with very ne precipitates within the laths. Images of samples tempered at 823 and
923 K clearly show tempered martensite structure with precipitates
decorating the lath boundaries (Fig. 3bc). For specimens tempered at
823 K, precipitates are present within the lath as well as along the lath
boundaries (Fig. 3b). However, after tempering at 923 K, precipitates
are found predominantly along the lath and prior austenite boundaries.
Further, ne precipitates are seen in specimen tempered at 723 and
823 K, whereas, precipitates are relatively large in size in specimen tempered at 923 K.
Fig. 4 shows TEM micrographs taken from carbon extraction replica
of the steel tempered at various temperatures. The steel specimen
tempered at 723 K contains predominantly elongated needle like
(length width) carbide precipitates (Fig. 4a), which is rich in iron
(Fig. 5a). The average iron to chromium ratio of the carbides as determined by energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS) is 4.7. The specimen subjected to tempering at 823 K contains precipitates with three
different morphologies elongated, nearly globular and globular (indicated as 1, 2 and 3 in Fig. 4b). EDS analysis (Fig. 5bd) of the precipitates
indicates that elongated precipitates are iron rich carbides (similar to
those observed after 723 K/1 h tempering) and globular precipitates
are chromium rich carbides (un-labelled EDS peeks are from copper
grid). In the case of nearly globular carbide, there is substantial presence
of both Fe and Cr. For 923 K tempered specimen only globular precipitates can be detected, which are chromium rich carbides. The size of
the precipitates is also considerably large in this specimen. A qualitative
comparison of the volume fraction and morphology of the precipitates
extracted from specimens subjected to these three tempering
heat treatment indicates that volume fraction of the precipitates after
723 K heat treatment is considerably lower than those obtained after
the other two heat treatments.
In order to identify crystal structure, selected area diffraction (SAD)
of few chosen precipitates were taken. Fig. 6(a) and (b) shows micro
diffraction patterns obtained from the iron rich lenticular precipitates
observed in the steel tempered at 723 and 823 K, respectively. Analysis
of the pattern revealed that they are belonging to Fe2C type (HCP).
Fig. 6(c) shows a SAD pattern taken from the chromium rich globular
precipitates observed in steel tempered at 923 K. These precipitates
were identied as M23C6 (M = Cr, Fe) (fcc) type.
(a)
XRD analyses of the precipitates extracted by electrochemical dissolution of the matrix of the specimens tempered at 823 K and 923 K are
shown in Fig. 7(a) and (b). The quantity of precipitates collected by dissolution of 723 K tempered sample was too less to carry out XRD studies
using them. The results of XRD analysis also support TEM observations.
In 823 K tempered specimen different types of carbides are present. The
presence of eta-carbide (Fe2C) can be detected along with M23C6 carbides (Fig. 7a). For 923 K tempered specimen only M23C6 type carbides
are found. Further, for 823 K tempered specimen, highest intensity is recorded for Cr15.58Fe7.42C6, whereas for 923 K tempered specimen
highest intensity is recorded for Cr22.23Fe0.77C6 carbide indicating
change in chemistry of the M23C6 carbide with the increase in tempering temperature (Fig. 7). This decrease in the Fe content in M23C6 carbides is an indication of progress of tempering.
AES studies carried out on fracture surfaces could not detect any evidence of P and S segregation at the grain boundaries in specimens tempered at 723 K, 823 K and 923 K. It should be noted that as the beam size
is in micron levels, the resolution of the AES used in the present study is
limited and it may not be able to detect segregation in sub-micron
levels. Further, specimens examined were those fractured using impact
testing machine; not those fractured in situ in a mechanical stage of AES.
4. Discussion
AISI 410 SS in normalised condition comprises of lath martensitic
structure, which is hard (522 VHN) and of low toughness (impact
toughness = 59 J). It is already mentioned that during tempering heat
treatment at 838 K cracks had developed on a component (the sprocket
of the fuel handling machine) made of this steel. Results of the present
study indicate that this martensitic class of steel shows drastic fall in impact toughness when subjected to tempering in the temperature range
of 748 K923 K. Hence, it is reasonable to attribute the cause of cracking
observed in the sprocket material to the embrittlement observed in this
steel. In search of causes for this embrittlement, two probable metallurgical effects were investigated, rst is segregation of impurities like P, S
at grain boundaries and the second one is the precipitation sequence
and morphology of carbides during tempering. The former could not
be detected even by AES; but signicant changes in the precipitation behaviour of the steel with tempering temperature could be identied.
(b)
(c)
Fig. 3. FESEM micrographs of 410 SS samples tempered at (a) 723 K, (b) 823 K and (c) 923 K.
(a)
(b)
85
(c)
(3)
(1)
(2)
Fig. 4. TEM micrographs of 410 SS samples tempered at (a) 723 K, (b) 823 K and (c) 923 K.
400
(b)
Normalized Intensity (counts)
Fe
300
200
100
Cr
Fe
Cr
(c)
Fe
(a)
300
200
100
Fe
Cr
Cr
300
10
100
Cr
Energy (KeV)
10
Energy (Kev)
400
Cr
(e)
300
200
100
Cr Fe
Cr
300
200
Fe
100
Cr
Fe
0
1
Energy (KeV)
10
Energy (KeV)
400
(d)
Fe
0
1
Fe
200
0
1
400
Energy (KeV)
Fig. 5. TEM-EDS spectra of AISI 410 SS samples tempered at (a) 723 K, (bd) 823 K and (e) 923 K.
10
10
86
(a)
(b)
(c)
Fig. 6. Diffraction pattern taken from (a) Fe2C precipitate (sample tempered at 723 K) along b1546N zone axis, (b) Fe2C precipitate (sample tempered at 823 K) along b1213N zone axis, and
(c) M23C6 precipitate (sample tempered at 923 K) along b132N zone axis.
3.Cr15.58Fe7.42C6
150
6.Fe2C, Cr21.34Fe1.66C6
100
1
1.Cr22.23Fe0.77C6
4.Cr15.58Fe7.42C6
5.Fe2C, Cr18.93Fe4.07C6
50
(b)
2.Cr22.23Fe0.77C6
200
Intensity (counts)
150
1.Fe2C
(a)
Intensity (counts)
250
making the steel again ductile and the fracture mode changes to
mixed; a combination of intergranular and ductile (Fig. 2f) with a corresponding increase in toughness.
The temperature range of 773848 K appears to be the zone of
transition for the different tempering behaviours described above. Accordingly, both the types of carbides observed in the specimens are tempered at 823 K. Further there is almost a bottom plateau for variation of
toughness with tempering temperature in this range; with toughness
value being higher both above and below this range of tempering
temperatures. It is also interesting to note that the chemistry of
the alloy carbides observed in specimens tempered 823 K is different
from those tempered at 923 K. Although the alloy carbides identied at high temperature tempering are of M23C6 type; the volume
fraction of these carbides with substantial Fe content (Cr15.58Fe7.48C6)
is more after tempering at 823 K than that of 923 K (Fig. 7a). After
923 K tempering, most of the carbides present are Cr22.23Fe0.77C6
(Fig. 7b).
From the above discussion, it is clear that though alloy carbides of
the type M23C6 are the equilibrium carbides for this class of steels, the
carbides formed during low temperature tempering are of Fe2C type.
The size, morphology and distribution of these carbides are signicantly
different from those of the M23C6 type carbides. It can be noted that the
temperature range 773848 K is the regime when Fe2C type carbides
start dissolving and M23C6 type carbides start forming. Hence, both
types of carbides are present, one strengthening the matrix and the
other weakening the prior austenitic boundaries. Hence, toughness is
the lowest when both types carbides are present. After high temperature tempering, only alloy carbides, not Fe2C carbides are present at
the end of tempering treatment and accordingly impact toughness improves. It is quite possible that impurity segregation along the prior
2.Cr15.58Fe7.42C6
100
2
50
5 6
0
0
25
50
Two theta
75
25
50
75
Two theta
Fig. 7. XRD patterns of precipitates obtained from electrochemical dissolution of AISI 410 SS samples tempered at (a) 823 K and (b) 923 K.
87
References
[1] L.W. Tsay, Y.M. Chang, S. Torng, H.C. Wu, Improved impact toughness of 13Cr martensitic stainless steel hardened by laser, J. Mater. Eng. Perform. 11 (4) (2002)
422427.
[2] L.C. Lim, M.O. Lai, J. Ma, Tempering of AISI 403 stainless steel, Mater. Sci. Eng. A 171
(1993) 1319.
[3] G.V. Prabhu Gaunkar, A.M. Huntz, P. Lacombe, Role of carbon in embrittlement phenomena of tempered martensitic 12Cr0.15%C steel, Mater. Sci. 14 (1980) 241252.
[4] S.K. Bhambri, Intergranular fracture in 13 wt.% chromium martensitic stainless steel,
J. Mater. Sci. 21 (1986) 17411746.
[5] Yang Gang, Wang Chang, Liu Xin-quan, Liu Zheng-dong, Embrittlement mechanism
due to slow cooling during quenching for M152 martensitic heat resistant steel, J.
Iron Steel Res. Int. 17 (6) (2010) 6066.
[6] R. Guiliou, M. Guttmann, Ph. Dumoulin, Role of molybdenum in phosphorousinduced temper embrittlement of 12% Cr martensitic stainless steel, Mater. Sci. 15
(1981) 6372.
[7] K.P. Balan, A. Venugopal Reddy, D.S. Sarma, Austenite precipitation during tempering in 16Cr2Ni martensitic stainless steels, Scr. Mater. 39 (7) (1998) 901905.
[8] H. Tanczyn, Advances in the Technology of Stainless Steels and Related Alloys,
ASTM, 1965 (Chapter 12).
[9] Liu Ning, Deng Zhonggang, Huang Menggen, Effect of heat treatment on microstructure and mechanical properties of martensiticferritic steel containing 17%Cr and
2%Ni, Mater. Sci. Technol. 7 (1991) 10571062.
[10] J.C. Murza, C.J. McMahon Jr., The effects of composition and microstructure on temper embrittlement in 2 Cr1Mo steel, Eng. Mater. Technol. 102 (1980) 369375.
[11] T. Angeliu, E.L. Hall, M. Earsen, et al., The long term aging embrittlement of Fe12Cr
steels below 773 K, Metall. Mater. Trans. A 34 (4) (2003) 927934.
[12] Z. Qu, C.J. McMohan Jr., The effects of tempering reactions on temper embrittlement
of alloy steels, Metall. Trans. 14A (1983) 11011108.
[13] J.H. Bulloch, J.J. Hickey, Reverse temper embrittlement of turbine bolts during an
outage, Theor. Appl. Fract. Mech. 20 (1994) 141147.
[14] C.M. Fang, M.A. Van Huis, H.W. Zandbergen, Structure and stability of Fe2C phases
from density-functional theory calculations, Scr. Mater. 63 (2010) 418421.