Professional Documents
Culture Documents
M 63
ATHENS 2010
DIFFUSION DE BOCCARD - 11, RUE DE MEDICIS, 75006 PARIS
ISBN 978-960-7905-54-3
The Nationale Hellenic Research Foundation
Institute for Greek and Roman Antiquity
48 Vasileos Constantinou Ave., GR 116 35 Athens tel.: 0030. 210 72 73 673-4
Printed by: .
Aghiou Pavlou 26, Athens Tel.: 0030 210.82 39 095
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Preface
xi
A. D. Rizakis, Peloponnesian cities under Roman rule: the new political geography
and its economic and social repercussions
19
43
59
75
89
S. B. Zoumbaki, Elean relations with Rome and the Achaean Koinon and the role of Olympia
111
129
155
173
193
205
217
235
253
291
A. Lo Monaco, Feasts and games of paides in the Peloponnese of the Imperial period
309
M. Melfi, Rebuilding the myth of Asklepios at the sanctuary of Epidauros in the Roman period
329
341
M. E. Hoskins Walbank, The cults of Roman Corinth: public ritual and personal belief
357
375
407
421
431
The internal borders of the Peloponnese as depicted on the map are an approximation only, as their precise location varied
over time.
Abstract: The present article deals with the production and circulation of coins in the Peloponnese in the aftermath
of the Achaean Leagues surrender to the Romans, as well as during the Imperial period. In the first phase, which
comprises the period from the middle to the Late Republican period and down to the Early Principate, the partial
and selective operation of certain mints (silver and bronze coins) is most probably linked to military-political events
during Romes expansion. Thus the local mints contribute each time that the Roman generals confront the last Hellenistic rulers of the East or fight each other in the internal Roman power-struggles which were played out on Greek
soil. The coinage of the Peloponnesian cities of the Roman period, with very few exceptions which concern colonies
founded during the Late Republican period, is largely inaugurated by Augustus and his dynasty. However, it had neither
the same lifespan, nor the same starting point, nor was it uniform for all the cities. Special stress is laid on the circulation procedure, the characteristics of which differ radically between the two periods: the cosmopolitan polyphony
of the numismatic horizon of the Late Hellenistic period becomes more introverted, while local values (Roman
Provincial coins from Peloponnesian mints) or Roman issues in precious metals [aurei, denarii (plus antoniniani)]
and heavy copper coins (sestertii, dupondii, asses) play their role according to place and era.
and at Dyme and then at Patrai, and the establishment of pax Romana after 31 B.C.
Aside from the degree that the Peloponnese was
a rich territory with extensive arable lands, pastures,
fish and timber, this region was not well known for
surplus producing or for large-scale exports. Arcadia was famous for its milk, which it was believed
to have medicinal properties. Messenia was mainly
an agrarian area. Agriculture and animal husbandry
were the main resources of the Argolid. Sicyon,
formerly renowned for its olive groves, during the
Roman times was mostly known for brick manufacturing. At Tainaron the iron mines as well as the
quarries of black and green marble were still active.
For the city of Patrai literary sources point to a significant manufacturing activity (wool workshops),
moreover with export activity, while archaeological data attest to ceramic production and more
particularly lamps. Finally, at Laconia, except for
purple dye manufacture, celebrated was also the
breeding of excellent horses, many of which were
forwarded to Rome.1
I. Touratsoglou
2. On Atticus see Ameling 1983. Especially for Eua: Spyropoulos 2001. For Ti. Claudius Tychicus, see RP I,
ARG 104 [3] and the article of Pirart in the present volume, supra pp. 33-34 n. 130. For Olympia, Mallwitz 1972.
For C. Claudius Tychicus, the son of the above-mentioned Ti. Claudius Tychicus, see RP I, ARG 105.
3. Rizakis 2001a, 181-97. For the Peloponnesian upper class see recently, S. Zoumbaki, The composition of
the Peloponnesian Elites in the Roman Period and the Evolution of their Resistance and Approach to the Roman
Rulers, Tekmeria 9, 2008, 25-51. For Italian traders settling in Peloponnesian poleis, see Rizakis forthcoming, n. 27.
4. Deshours 2006.
236
237
I. Touratsoglou
8. Grandjean 2000, 323-24. An overall review of the economy of the Peloponnese in the Hellenistic period is
to be found in Rizakis, Touratsoglou 2008, 69-82.
238
Map 1. Geographical and chronological repartition of coin hoards with Achaean League triobols.
9. Theory launched by Thompson 1968, supported by Price 1987, 95-103 and followed by Touratsoglou, Tsourti
1991, 171-84. Opposite views concerning prolonged continuation of the Achaean League issues with no interruption
until the first quarter of the 1st c. B.C. expressed first by C. Boehringer, and supported by J. Warren, J. Kroll and C.
Grandjean are to be found in Warren 1999, 99-109 and in Grandjean 1999, 139-46. See also Grandjean, Guerra 2000,
300-05 and Boehringer 2008, 83-89. he recent monograph by Warren 2007 does not seem to follow for the bronze
coinage the low chronology previously accepted by her. Views supporting the traditional dating are expressed by
Lakakis-Marchetti 1996, 147-56; by Tsangari 2007 and recently by Oikonomides, Lakakis-Marchetti, Marchetti
2007, 379-426 (negative review of this article is undertaken by A. Walker, in ANS, Winter 2008, 53-58).
239
I. Touratsoglou
10. The recently published book on this subject by Benner 2008 summarizes the latest opinions on this matter
based mainly on the propositions of A. Walker in LHS Numismatics, Auction 96, 8-9 May 2006.
11. See for the period Rizakis 2001b, 81-82. Especially for the minting activity of Antony in the Peloponnese see
Amandry 1982/83, 1-6. Lately, on coin production at Patrai during the Late Republican Period, see E. Haug, Local
Politics in the Late Republic: Antony and Cleopatra at Patras, AJN 20, 2008, 405-20.
12. Lucullan (flats) or Lucullan coinage: Kraay 1968, 15. Grandjean 1999, 141. Touratsoglou 2006/07, 245.
13. icolet 1992, 287-89.
14. A. Walker, LHS Numismatics, Auction 96, 8-9 May 2006 (Coins of Peloponnesos. The B[asil] C. D[emetriades] Collection), nos 671, 692.1 (Elis), nos 756, 758-59 (Messene), nos 926.4, 926.6 (Lakedaimon), no. 999 (ythera).
Cf. Kroll 1996, 49-73 and id., 1997, 123-36.
15. De Callata 1991/92, 11-20. See also Dreyer 2000, 39-60.
16. Touratsoglou 1993, 18, 21-22.
17. Id. 1987b, 885-90.
240
Mints
S = Silver, B = Bronze
Commentary
Historical events
Elis (B)
146=>
90s-80s
90s-60s
Lakedaimon [S]
Sicyon [S+B], Argos [B]
Early 1st c.
Early 80s
mid-80s
86
80s
80s-50s
80s-60/50s
1st half 1st c.
60s-50/40s
Sulla
Mithradatic Wars
(89-86)
50-25
37/35-31
Aigeira [B]
Elis [S], Argos [B]
Messene [S+B], Patrai [B],
Elis [S], Lakedaimon [B]
Corinth [], Dyme [B]
(colony), Lakedaimon [B]
Aigion [S+B], Lakedaimon [B]
mid-30s
30s
30s
32/31
Patrai [S+B]
Patrai [B]
mid-20s
Messene [B]
20s
Patrai [B]
Lakedaimon [B]
mid-20s
mid-20s
Messene [B]
Late 1st c.
Civil Wars
[Pompeius - ulius
Caesar (49-48)/ Brutus ctavianus+arcus
ntonius (44-42)]
Early - mid-1st c.
mid-1st c.
40s-30s
40s
Civil War [Octavianus . Antonius (<-31)]
[Messene (B)/
eagle and tripod
countermarked
on Messene (B):
180 B.C.]
ime of Octavianus/
Augustus
[Messene (B)/head
of Octavianus
countermarked
on Messene (B):
180 B.C.]
[Lakedaimon(B)/
head of Octavianus
countermarked on
Lakedaimon (B):
35/31 B.C.]
Source: LHS Numismatics, Auction 96, 8-9 May 2006 (Coins of Peloponnesos. The BCD Collection).
241
I. Touratsoglou
. Imperial Times
a. The coinage of the Peloponnesian cities of the
Roman period, besides very few exceptions that
have to do with colonies founded during the Late
Republican period,22 is largely inaugurated by Augustus and his dynasty. However, it does not have
the same lifespan, neither the same starting point,
nor is uniform for all the cities. The remark, though,
that the initiation of minting for the majority of
the Peloponnesian cities is placed during the early
imperial times, in the Iulio-Claudian era, finds its
parallel in the analogous activity of the cities of Asia
Minor and not only there mainly under Augustus. However, more specifically, the visit of Nero
in the Peloponnese and the declaration of the freedom of the cities is interpreted as the starting point
for the coinages of Sicyon and Messene.23
Regarding other cases, while the initiation of
coin production for a few cities obviously coincides
and is related with the pilgrimage of the philhellene emperor Hadrian,24 the association on some occasions with Commodus remains unsatisfactory; in
spite of the suggestions by Ch. PapageorgiadouBani.25
b. Coin circulation evidence (excavation stray
finds) in association with the conclusions based on
the study of hoard evidence of the imperial period
(savings hoards, grave hoards, emergency depositions, etc) lead to the following remarks:
. From the beginning of the imperial times the
deposition therefore and the circulation of precious (gold and silver) issues is evident. This phenomenon is restricted to major urban centers
(Patrai, Messene) with intense development and
obvious close relations commercial or not to
Italy, as well as with a prosperous ruling class. Ex-
Mint
Iulio-Claudian Dynasty
Patrai (Augustus)
Corinth (Augustus)
Dyme (Tiberius)
Lakedaimon (Claudius)
Sicyon (Nero)
Messene (Nero)
Hadrian
Aigion
Elis
Argos
Epidauros
Commodus
Troizen
stricted in the depositions-savings and in the circulating currency in the Peloponnese. However, their
percentage and not only of the local coins in
Patrai, Argos, Nemea, Corinth, Kenchreai, Lousoi,
Sparta and Messene is not negligible and reflects
an extensive variety in provenance (mainland
Greece and Asia Minor). In any case, the coin production of Lakedaimon and Corinth (during the 1st
c. A.D.) seemingly overshadows that of the other
mints.
D. The antoniniani of the 3rd c. A.D. a currency
employed particularly for paying soldiers should
be considered to be imported and to be interpreted
as booty taken by the Goths and the Herulians in
the Northern Balkans (Danube Provinces) or even
in areas where Roman forces encamped; these
pieces were never reclaimed by their owners. Finding antoniniani in hoards alongside with the barbarians descend route (Sparta) or inside their
escape route (Patrai), could be explained as depositions or accidental losses during the desperate attempt of their owners to get away.28
26. De Cou 1905; May 1962; Bellinger 1930; Edwards 1933; Hohlfelder 1978; Agallopoulou 1994; Grandjean 1997,
115-22; Hoskins Walbank 2003; Knapp, MacIsaac 2005; Oikonomides 2008, 94. Additional information was provided per
vocem, per discum electronicum or per epistulas by P. Marchetti (Argos), J. Baker (Sparta) and Kl. Sideropoulos (Messene).
27. Touratsoglou 2006, 158.
28. Touratsoglou 2006.
243
I. Touratsoglou
Hoards
Bibliography
Content
Burial date
Messene
To be published
A.D. 4
Patrai ca1976
(villa urbana)
CH 4, 1978, 75.
A.D. 47 onwards
Patrai 1971
(monumental Roman
building)
A.D. 96 onwards
Patrai ca 1978
(villa urbana, burnt)
Gonoussa,
Sicyon 1934
NMA
Under S. Severus
or Caracalla
Sparta 1955
Sestertii + Dupondii
(1st c. to Gordianus III)
Lousoi
Oikonomides 2008
Under Philippus I
Under Volusianus
Skarmingas,
Pylia 1953
Under Valerianus I
Corinth 1930
(theatre)
Under Gallienus
Corinth1936
(South Stoa)
Under Gallienus
Corinth
AD 18, 1963,
B 1, 5-6.
Under Gallienus
244
Patrai 1976
(below the citadel)
Under Gallienus
Under Gallienus
Akriai
(near Gytheion)
Unpublished
Under Gallienus
Sparta
(Magoula) 1939
Under Gallienus
Sparta 1964
(Akropolis)
Oikonomides 1966,
376-82.
Under Gallienus
The fact that at this time (end of the reign of Septimius Severus) the bulk of the active until then mints
ceases its operation, surely indicates a major event
for the region, possibly connected to the harsh economic status of the empire and the numismatic
paucity. It remains a fact though that the Severan
coin production in Peloponnese constitutes a sizeable quantity, never seen before in the region
(Maps 2 and 3).29
The interpretation given for this overproduction
of money is that the Peloponnesian coins in question, many of which had been found in excavations
in Syria, were presumably brought (sc. into Asia)
by auxiliary troops raised to help in the defence of
the frontier against Parthia; since the mints in-
Peloponnesian mints of the imperial period acting only under the Severi (A.D. 193-217)
Aigeira, Boura, Pellene
Zakynthos
Asine, Kolone, Mothone, Pylos, Kyparissia, Thuria, Tenea, Phlious
Asopos, Boiai, Gytheion, Las
Hermione, Kleonai, Methana
Heraia, Kaphyai, antineia, Psophis, Kleitor, Tegea, Megalopolis, Orchomenos, Pheneos, Phigaleia, Thelpousa
245
I. Touratsoglou
Zakynthos
Lakedaimon
Lakedaimon
Asopos, Boiai, Gytheion, Las
Argos
Epidauros, Troizan, Hermione,
Kleonai, Methana
Argos
246
Map 2. Cities off the Achean League (+) which struck Severan emissions (INJ 5, 1981).
247
I. Touratsoglou
248
Bibliography
Agallopoulou (P.), 1994:
,14..268.., Athens.
Alcock (S. E.), 2007: The Eastern Mediterranean, in
W. Scheidel et alii (eds), The Cambridge Economic
History of the Greco-Roman World, Cambridge, 671-97.
Amandry (M.), 1981: Le monnayage de Dym (Colonia
32. See Flament 2007, 579 who, pointing out that un bon nombre de thmes illustrs sur ces series coordones
figurent galement sur les monnaies romaines contemporaines ..., concludes that ces parallles parfois frappants
nous poussent evidemment penser que les sries coordonnes furent orchestres par le pouvoir romain.
33. For Asia Minor see K. Kraft, Das System der kaiserzeitlichen Mnzprgung in Kleinasien. Materialen und
Entwrfe, Berlin 1972. For Macedonia, I. Touratsoglou, Die Mnzsttte von Thessaloniki in der rmischen Kaiserzeit, Berlin 1988.
249
I. Touratsoglou
Numismatique grecque offerts Georges Le Rider,
London, 139-46.
, 2000: Guerre et monnaie en Grce ancienne; le cas
du koinon achaien, in J. Andreau, P. Briant, R. Descat (eds), conomie antique III. La guerre dans les
conomies antiques, Entretiens darchologie et dhistoire 5, Saint-Bertrand-de-Comminges, 315-36.
Grandjean (C.), Guerra (M. F.), 2000: Les monnaies du
Ploponnse de la fin de lpoque hellnistique: lapport de lanalyse lmentaire in Akten des XII. Internationalen Numismatischen Kongresses, Berlin
1997, Berlin, 300-05.
Grunauer-von Hoerschelmann (S.), 1982/83: The Severan Emissions of the Pelopennesus, INJ 6-7, 39-46
with pls 8-9.
Hohlfelder (R.), 1978: Kenchreai. Eastern Port of Corinth,
Leiden.
Hoskins Walbank (M. E.), 2003: Aspects of the
Corinthian Coinage in the Late 1st and Early 2nd centuries A.C., in C. K. Williams II, N. Bookidis (eds),
Corinth, the Centenary: 1896-1996, Corinth XX,
Princeton N. J., 337-49.
Knapp (R. C.), MacIsaac (J. D.), 2005: Excavations at
Nemea III: The Coins, Berkeley - Los Angeles.
Kraay (C. .), 1968: Coins of Ancient Athens, Newcastle upon Tyne.
Kremydi-Sicilianou (S.), 2004: Patterns of monetary
circulation in Roman Macedonia: The Hoard Evidence, Eulimene 5, 135-49.
, 2005: Belonging to Rome, Remaining Greek:
Coinage and Identity in Roman Macedonia, in Chr.
Howgego et alii (eds), Coinage and Identity in the
Roman Provinces, Oxford, 95-106.
Kroll (J.), 1996: Hemiobols to Assaria: the Bronze
Coinage of Roman Aigion, NC 156, 49-78.
, 1997: Traditionalism vs Romanization in bronze
coinages of Greece, 42-31 B.C., Topoi 7, 123-36.
Lakakis-Marchetti (M.), 1996: propos du monnayage
achen et des trsors qui le font connatre, in . , Athens,
147-56.
Larsen (J. A. O.), 1975: Greece and Macedonia from
Augustus to Gallienus, in T. Frank (ed.), An Economic Survey of Ancient Rome, New York, 436-96.
Mallwitz (A.), 1972: Olympia und seine Bauten, Mnchen.
May (J. M. F.), 1962: Coins, in H. Payne, Th. J. Dunbabin (eds), Perachora, The Sanctuaries of Hera
Akraia and Limenia II. Pottery, ivories, scarabs, and
other objects from the votive deposit of Hera Limenia, Oxford, 456-60.
Migeotte (L.), 1997: La date de loktbolos eisphora de
Messne, Topoi 7, 51-61.
, 2008: Lorganisation de loktobolos eisphora de
Messne, in C. Grandjean (d.), Le Ploponnse
dpaminondas Hadrien, Actes du Colloque de
Tours, 6-7 octobre 2005, t. Ausonius 21, Bordeaux,
229-43.
icolet (.), 1992: propos de monnaies dElis portant des contremarques, BSFN 47.4, 287-89.
Oikonomides (Karamesini) (M.), 1966:
267..,
in . ,
54, Athens, 376-82 and pls 121-23.
, 2008: .
, in Amicitiae gratia. In
memory of , Athens, 93-96.
Oikonomides (M.), Lakakis-Marchetti (M.), Marchetti
(P.), 2007: Le trsor de Zougra (IGCH 261) et la circulation montaire dans le Ploponnse au IIe sicle,
in Gh. Moucharte et alii (eds), Liber amicorum Tony
Hackens, Louvain-la-Neuve, 379-433.
Papageorgiadou-Bani (Ch.), 2004: The Numismatic Iconography of the Roman Colonies in Greece. Local Spirit
and the Expression of Imperial Policy, Meletemata
39, Athens.
Papapostolou (I. A.), 2009: , in Patrasso colonia di Augusto e
le transformazioni culturali, politiche ed economiche
della Provincia di Acaia agli inizi dellet imperiale
romana, Atti del Convegno internazionale, Patrasso,
23-24 marzo 2006, Tripodes 8, Athnes, 211-51.
Petropoulos (M.), 1994: A in P.
N. Doukellis, L. Mendoni (eds), Structures rurales et
socits antiques, Actes du Colloque de Corfou (1416 mai 1992), Paris, 410-12.
, 2001: O in O
,A
B ,K M,K
H, Athens, 37-51.
Price (M.), 1987: Southern Greece in the Coinage of the
Greek World in the Late Republic, BAR 326, 95-103.
Rizakis (. D.), 2001a:
, in V. MitsopoulosLeon (ed.), Forschungen in der Peloponnes, Akten
des Symposions anlsslich der Feier 100 Jahre sterreichisches Archologisches Institut Athen, Athen
5.3.-7.3.1998, Athen, 181-97.
, 2001b: Les cits ploponnsiennes entre lpoque
hellnistique et lEmpire: le paysage conomique et
social, in R. Frei-Stolba, Kr. Gex (ds), Recherches
rcentes sur le monde hellnistique, Actes du colloque international organis loccasion du 60 e anniversaire de Pierre Ducrey (Lausane, 20-21 novembre
1998), Bern - Berlin - Bruxelles, 75-96.
, forthcoming: Supra-civic landowning and supracivic euergetic activities of urban elites in the Imperial Peloponnese, in Being Peloponnesian. Cohesion
and diversity through time, International conference,
University of Nottingham, 31 march-1 april 2007.
Rizakis (A. D.), Touratsoglou (I.), 2008: Lconomie
du Ploponnse hellnistique: un cas rgional, in
250
, 2006: Greece and the Balkans before the End of Antiquity, Hellenic Numismatic Society, Bibliotheca 8,
Athens.
, 2006/07: , in N.
Kaltsas (ed.), A-, Exhibition Catalogue,
Athens, 240-55.
Touratsoglou (I.), Tsourti (E.), 1991:
E : ,
in A. D. Rizakis (ed.), Achaia und Elis in der Antike,
Akten des 1. Internationalen Symposiums, Athen
19.-21. Mai 1989, Meletemata 13, Athens, 171-88.
Tsangari (D.), 2007: Corpus des monnaies dor, dargent
et de bronze de la Confderation tolienne, Athens.
Warren (J. A. W.), 1999: The Achaian League Silver
Coinage Controversy Resolved: A Summary, NC
159, 99-109.
, 2007: The Bronze Coinage of the Achaian Koinon.
The Currency of a Federal Ideal, London (review: W.
Fischer-Bossert, NC 168, 2008, 475-78).
251