Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Manila gold trader hit with US$17.4 million tax evasion charge
Source: http://www.digitaljournal.com/article/340457
By Antonio Figueroa Jan 4, 2013 in Business
Manila - The intensified campaign of the Philippine government to snare tax evaders got another boost after a
Manila gold trader was charged before the Department of Justice (DOJ) by the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR)
for under-declaration of income tax.
Estela V. Sales, BIR deputy commissioner, identified the violator as Teofilo T. Oraa who was found to have
willfully supplied incorrect information in his annual income tax and for failure to pay the correct taxes for the
year 2009.
Oraa, Sales pointed out, violated Section 254 and Section 255 of the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997,
which makes an under-declaration of taxable income by over 30 percent constitutes prima facie case of fraud
tantamount to tax evasion.
Documents show that Oraa sold refined gold and silver in 2009 to the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP), the
countrys central bank, in the amount of P1.116 billion (US$26.57 million), but failed to declare all his income for
that year.
A BIR comparison of the gross sales he declared in his income tax return (ITR) showed only P0.634 million
(US$15.095 million) while the net payment he received from BSP that same year reached P1.115 billion
(US$27.875 million), which is 175,796% higher than his sales declaration, or a discrepancy of P1.114 billion
(US$26.523 million).
For the violation, he was assessed by the government a deficiency of P731.67 million (US$17.4 million) in income
tax for 2009, inclusive of surcharges and interests.
Earlier, the BIR clarified that gold sellers should pay 34 percent, or nearly five times more than the seven percent
tax required on gold sales, which, in 2012, Congress wanted to suspend.
Under the Tax Code, if the individual annual income is over P500,000 (US$11,900), the tax should be 32 percent,
which is definitely lower than the income level declared by gold traders who sell their items to the central bank.
More than a month earlier, two gold sellers were also charged by the BIR separately.
Junrie Daitol Tenorio, a Cebu City-based gold trader sold gold to BSP worth P3.95 billion (US$94.047
million)during a five-year period, but failed to file the required tax returns. He did not also pay the income taxes
due on the taxable years.
On the other hand, Francois Joseph Xavier Rast, another Manila trader, was also slapped a tax evasion case for
owing the government P558.03 million (US$13.286 million) for taxable years 2006 to 2009.
Rast, who sold gold and silver amounting to P872.62 million (US$20.766 million) to the central bank, was found
to have failed to declare all his income for the taxable years and grossly under-declared his income by over 30
percent, which was equivalent to P775.07 million (US$18.454 million) in unpaid tax returns.
Small-scale gold mining output, is the main source of the central bank's gold reserves, which hit a record high of
$10.4 billion early this year.
POROUS ARCHIPELAGO
The problem extends beyond gold to other minerals, which are being smuggled out of the porous and
inadequately policed borders of the archipelago.
The Philippines has one of Asia's richest trove of minerals with reserves of gold, copper, nickel, chromite,
manganese, silver and iron worth a total of around $1 trillion.
Foreign investors are circling around one of Asia's hottest emerging markets. The $225 billion economy grew 6.4
percent in the first quarter, second only to China among Asian economies. But mining investment has been held
up for various reasons, including a moratorium on new projects until Congress passes long delayed legislation
governing the industry.
That has left the field largely to small-scale miners, who fall under local regulations and are often in collusion
with the officials governing them.
CHINA CONNECTION
The record-breaking bull run in gold prices over the past decade has spurred small-scale gold mining, much of it
illegal, across the developing world.
The Canada-based Artisanal Gold Council estimates it now accounts for 15 percent of global gold supply - a
$20.5 billion industry that employs 10-15 million people.
Like the Philippines, some countries have tried to tax the output, only to find that just diverts it into the black
market. Sierra Leone announced last week, for instance, it is cutting taxes nearly in half on gold produced by
small miners to reduce smuggling.
An estimated 40-60 percent of Burkina Faso's small-scale mining out is smuggled out of the country, officials
there say.
In Mongolia, a spike in black market demand from China has spawned a small army of "ninja miners", so named
because of the large green pans carried on their backs that look like turtle shells. As in the Philippines,
Mongolian producers are obliged to sell their gold to the central bank and it is subject to a 10 percent tax. The
lion's share, however, is being smuggled across the border to China, which overtook India as the world's top
gold consumer last year.
Chinese citizens have swelled the ranks of illegal gold miners in Africa and elsewhere. That prompted a warning
in May from China's foreign ministry after dozens were arrested in Ghana: "Recently there have been many
incidents of Chinese citizens alleged to be involved in illegal gold mining", it said, and urged them to apply for
work and residence permits.
PUZZLING STATISTICS
The Philippine government is aware that gold from small-scale mines either passes through traders in the black
market or is sold directly from mines to foreigners coming in on a tourist visa, Leo Jasareno, head of the Mines
and Geosciences Bureau, told Reuters.
"We have heard a lot of rumors about that - that it is being sold in Binondo (Chinatown)," he said.
Traders and officials say it looks like much of the gold is going to Hong Kong, the main conduit for gold flows
into China.
Hong Kong's top source of gold imports from 2005 to 2010 was the Philippines, official data from the Chinese
territory shows. Philippines gold shipments to Hong Kong hit a peak of 81,471 kilograms in 2010, way above
imports of just 11 kilos nine years earlier, and were steady at 81,192 kilos in 2011.
Hong Kong customs regulations require all trade- or business-related gold shipments be registered with
authorities, but they do not put restrictions on gold carried by passengers.
Official statistics in the Philippines, reflecting legal exports, show gold exports to Hong Kong in 2010 and 2011 at
just around 3 percent of the total volume recorded by Hong Kong authorities.
The Philippines data represents only shipments by big mining firms with supply contracts, as exports of gold
from small-scale mines are banned. Officials from the statistics office could not explain the discrepancy, saying
the data was based on Customs records.
China, which strictly controls gold imports, does not publish trade data for the metal, considering it a state
secret. Hong Kong's data, however, is used as a proxy for Chinese demand.
Gold exports in the first half of this year from Hong Kong to China soared six times over the same period a year
ago.
China's gold output reached a record 361 metric tonnes last year, but in the first half of 2012 alone, China
imported more than 380 tonnes of gold from Hong Kong, the Hong Kong Census and Statistics Department said
on its website.(www.censtatd.gov.hk.)
HAND-CARRIED SMUGGLING
Foreign gold buyers have been coming in droves to the Philippines, where they can buy the metal cheaper in the
black market, said a 42-year old jeweler, who asked for anonymity to protect her family business.
"Whether they make it into smaller nuggets or smaller sheets, that's what they take with them, hand carried," she
said. "They know they can get gold cheaper here."
Rozzano Rufino Biazon, head of the Philippines' Bureau of Customs, agreed "hand-carried smuggling" accounts
for much of the outflow of gold.
He explained that the Customs agency only has 40 offices to cover all airports and ports in the archipelago,
which also sends huge shipments of other minerals - chromite, nickel and copper - to China.
Biazon cited as an example of the difficulties he faces a recent case in which nine cargo vessels shipped 75,000
metric tonnes of smuggled chromite to China from a private port in Zambales province, 50 miles from the
nearest Customs office.
TAX FACTOR
Traders and officials say the biggest factor behind the spike in the gold smuggling trend the past year is a 2
percent excise tax and a 5 percent withholding tax approved in 2008 but which the Bureau of Internal Revenue
only started enforcing last year. The tax is imposed on gold sales to the central bank, so is usually borne by the
traders.
Tagum city, the provincial capital of Davao del Norte, is the biggest gold-buying centre nearest to Mount
Diwata. Known as the "city of palm trees", Tagum has become one of the fastest-growing cities in the
Philippines, driven by the small-scale gold-mining boom.
Gold traders in Tagum say if not for the tax, they would rather sell to the central bank than in the black market
where prices fluctuate fast.
"Our mark-up cannot even cover (the tax) because of the tight competition and the fast turnover of supply," said
one trader who asked for anonymity. "As far as I know, no one is selling to the central bank anymore," said the
trader, who buys and sells at least 100 kilograms (3,215 troy ounce) of gold monthly.
Diwa Guinigundo, a career central banker and now deputy governor of the central bank, said the drop in gold
sales to the central bank is likely to persist if the current tax regime remains.
"The ball is with them," he said, referring to the Bureau of Internal Revenue.
But like the Customs Department, the Bureau of Internal Revenue has marching orders to prop up state
revenues to pay for an array of public infrastructure projects -- needed to lure private investment and drive
growth, perhaps earn the Philippines investment grade status from ratings agencies for the first time.
Internal Revenue head Kim Henares said smuggling was a long-standing problem even before the agency's July
2011 imposition of taxes on gold sales.
"The revenue regulation stays," Henares declared, referring to the tax on gold sales. If smuggling was the
problem, she said, then it was up to other agencies to tighten controls on the movement of minerals.
HARDER TO MINE
Tax or no tax, sustained demand for gold and firm prices will keep miners on Mount Diwata pounding on the
rocky walls of its deep tunnels to extract gold ore, with some using illegal dynamite to blast it out.
The gold is harder to find these days, and the ore not as rich, but the work is far more remunerative than it used
to be, miners say.
"In the 1980s, one bag (of ore) could produce 5 to 10 grams of gold, but the price then was just 160 pesos ($3.82)
per gram," said George Cantilla, a 51-year-old underground mine supervisor who has been working in mines
since finishing college.
"Now, you get tiny amounts of about 0.2 gram per bag, but the price now is so much higher."
($1 = 41.77 Philippine pesos)
(Additional reporting by Rujun Shen in Singapore, Polly Lam in Hong Kong, Karen Lema and Erik dela Cruz in
Manila)
(Reporting by Rosemarie Francisco; editing by Bill Tarrant)
BIR digs BSP gold trade mine, sues Unregistered Bulacan trader for 2.22B tax evasion
https://tuklasinnatin.wordpress.com/2011/05/12/bir-digs-bsp-gold-trade-mine-sues-unregistered-bulacantrader-for-2-22b-tax-evasion/ (SOURCE)
The Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) today filed with the Department of Justice (DOJ) a complaint against
another Bulacan gold trader AURELIO S. BARING (Baring) for five (5) counts of attempt to evade or defeat
tax, fifteen (15) counts of failure to file Quarterly Income Tax Returns, and five (5) counts of failure to file Annual
Income Tax Returns and to pay tax, in violation of Sections 254 and 255 of the Tax Code.
Sometime in August 2010, Baring was included in the list given by the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP) to the
BIR containing the names of individuals who had gold transactions with the BSP.
Investigation revealed that Baring listed his addresses at 91 St. James LFS, Viente Reales, Valenzuela City;
Tugatog, Valenzuela City; and Saluysoy, Meycauayan, Bulacan. He was not registered with the BIR and neither
did he register with the Department of Trade and Industry.
Furthermore, the BIR discovered that Baring sold (refined) gold to the BSP in the years 2005 to 2009 amounting
to P3.21 billion. A certification of the total sales and net payments received by Baring and copies of the Letters of
Delivery and Sale detailing the number of pieces and the weight of the gold sold signed by him were obtained
by the BIR from BSP.
Despite receiving taxable income from his gold transactions with the BSP, Baring however failed to file his
Quarterly and Annual Income Tax Returns for taxable years 2005 to 2009. Not only did he fail to file twenty (20)
tax returns during the period in question, he also did not pay his income taxes due on the same taxable years.
Baring was assessed deficiency income taxes for five (5) taxable years in the aggregate amount of P2.22 billion,
inclusive of surcharges and interests, broken down as follows: P555.35 million 2005; P649.43 million 2006;
P179.04 million 2007; P823.21 million 2008; and P16.11 million 2009.
The case against AURELIO S. BARING is the forty-third (43rd) filed under the Run After Tax Evaders (RATE)
Program of the BIR under the leadership of Commissioner Kim S. Jacinto-Henares. (reytdlc)
Antonino said the BIR should explain in a hearing the result of the implementation of the gold tax in the last 12
months to enable members of the House ways and means committee to act on the troubling decline in gold
reserves.
Patrick Caoile, treasurer of the Philippine Mine Safety and Environment Association, said the BIR clearly
"miscalculated" the gold tax as it not only failed to deliver the targeted increase in revenue, but also put at risk
the country's gold reserves.
"The BSP needs to replenish its gold reserves. The BSP normally gets its gold from small miners but since the
gold tax forced them to ship out their haul outside the country, the BSP will be forced to buy gold from other
countries and at a premium. It is possible that we might be buying the same gold that came from our small
miners," Caoile said.
He said the tax would work if the government forced all miners to sell all their gold to the government.
"It's been more than a year since it sapped the gold tax, and I doubt if the BIR has seen the pot of gold it has been
looking for. The least the BIR should do is to take long, hard look at its gold tax policy. There is nothing bad in
saying mea culpa," Caoile said in a phone interview.
Prices to go up
Caoile warned the BIR against taking a hardline stance on the gold tax in the face of expectations that gold prices
would shoot up from $1,700 to $3,000 per ounce amid a further weakening of the US and European economies.
"Many investors believe that the [reelection of US President] Barack Obama will lead American planners to
double the money supply and increase inflation, an excellent scenario for higher gold prices. If our gold
continues to go out due to the gold tax, our central bank will be forced to buy gold at higher prices," Caoile said.
The Philippines, the world's 18th largest gold miner, produced just over 1 million troy ounces of gold in 2011,
worth $1.6 billion at current prices, said a Reuters special report titled "Philippines' black market is China's
golden connection."
The report, which came out in August, said about 56 per cent of that came from small-scale miners.
Foreigners on tourist visa
Leo Jasareno, MGB head, told Reuters that the government was aware that gold from small-scale mines either
passed through traders on the black market or was sold directly from mines to foreigners coming in on a tourist
visa.
"We have heard a lot of rumours about that - that it is being sold in Binondo (Chinatown)," he said.
Traders and officials say it looks like much of the gold is going to Hong Kong, the main conduit for gold flows
into China.
Hong Kong's top source of gold imports from 2005 to 2010 was the Philippines, official data from the Chinese
territory shows. Philippine gold shipments to Hong Kong hit a peak of 81,471 kilogrammes in 2010, way above
imports of just 11 kg nine years earlier, and were steady at 81,192 kg in 2011, according to Reuters.
Hong Kong customs regulations require that all trade or business related to gold shipments be registered with
authorities, but they do not put restrictions on gold carried by passengers.
Official statistics in the Philippines, reflecting legal exports, show gold exports to Hong Kong in 2010 and 2011 at
just around 3 per cent of the total volume recorded by Hong Kong authorities.
The Philippine data represent only shipments by big mining firms with supply contracts, as exports of gold from
small-scale mines are banned. Officials from the statistics office could not explain the discrepancy, saying the
data were based on records of the Bureau of Customs.
The strong demand for gold in the Philippines is also shown by foreign groups placing regular ads in
newspapers announcing "buying events" for gold jewellery at swanky hotels in Metro Manila.
The announcements, usually full-page ads, have been going on for months.
Gold trader from Taguig City gets minted for tax evasion
Posted on November 29, 2012
Source: http://www.gov.ph/2012/11/29/gold-trader-from-taguig-city-gets-minted-for-tax-evasion/
A November 29, 2012, press release from the Department of Finance, Bureau of Internal Revenue
The Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) today filed a criminal complaint with the Department of Justice against
Francois Joseph Xavier Rast, proprietor of Rast Metalor Phils., for four counts of attempt to evade or defeat tax;
and four counts of willful failure to supply correct and accurate information in his Annual Income Tax Returns
(ITRs) and to pay the correct taxes, for Taxable Years (TYs) 2006, 2007, 2008, and 2009, in violation of Section 254
and Section 255 of the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997, as amended (Tax Code).
Rast, a registered taxpayer with business address at 708 VFP Bldg., II, Veterans Center, Taguig, was included in
the list given to the BIR in November 30, 2012, by the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP) containing the names of
individuals who had gold and silver sales transactions with the BSP.
Documents show that RAST sold to the BSP in the years 2006, 2007, 2008, and 2009 (refined) gold and silver
amounting to P118.15 million, P209.54 million, P306.93 million, and P238.06 million, respectively, or for a total
amount ofP872.68 million. A certification of the total sales and net payments received by RAST and copies of the
Letters of Delivery and Sale detailing the number of pieces and the weight of the gold and silver sold signed by
him were obtained by the BIR from BSP.
Investigation by the BIR disclosed that RAST willfully failed to declare all his income in his Annual ITRs for TYs
2006 to 2009. A comparison of the gross income he declared in his tax returns with the net payment he received
from BSP in the years in question revealed that he grossly under-declared his income by more than 30% (P775.07
million). The same conclusion was also uncovered from his Quarterly VAT returns for the said years in question.
Under Sec. 248 of the Tax Code, an under-declaration of taxable income by more than 30% constitutes a prima
facie case of fraud tantamount to tax evasion.
RAST was assessed deficiency income taxes for four taxable years in the aggregate amount of P558.03 million,
inclusive of surcharges and interests, broken down as follows: P35.58 million 2006; P146.87 million
2007; P220.09 million2008; and P155.49 million 2009.
The case against Francois Joseph Xavier Rast is the 137th filed under the Run After Tax Evaders (RATE)
program of the BIR under the leadership of Commissioner Kim S. Jacinto-Henares.
bir.gov.ph
When you mine, you destroy the environment. Thats why you compensate the government... Under our law,
everything found under the earth is owned by the government and you should pay government for that,
Henares said on Mornings@ANC.
Henares pointed out that the problem is not taxation but law enforcement of local government units and the
Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR).
With BIR Commissioner Kim Henares refusing to give in to calls from lawmakers to suspend the gold tax,
Ungab said the government should at least ensure that it would implement it more efficiently and plug the
loopholes for smuggling.
Its a good issue to look into. We need to control the industry. We have to check what is doable. But personally,
I feel this will not be finished within this Congress, Ungab said.
But for the Mining and Geosciences Bureau (MGB), all the government had to do was to give a little
encouragement to small-scale miners and tighten up against the illegal mining of the precious metal.
We just have to convince them that it pays to pay taxes, MGB director Leo Jasareno told the Inquirer, adding
the BSP had started meeting with small-scale miners to urge them to sell their gold to the government.
He agreed that the drop in sales of gold to the BSP was alarming. In previous years, an average of 30 tons of gold
was sold annually to the BSP.
But last year, only 5 tons were sold to the BSP, mostly by large-scale mining firms, he said. We could expect
that the rest were sold by small-scale miners in the underground market.
Environment Secretary Ramon Paje estimated the drop in gold sales to the BSP at 80 percent but would not say if
it was due to the gold tax. With a report from Jeannette I. Andrade
Originally posted: 10:58 pm | Monday, November
Benguet solons seek income and excise tax exemption on small-scale gold mining
By Philippine Canadian Inquirer on September 18, 2014
Source: http://www.canadianinquirer.net/2014/09/18/benguet-solons-seek-income-and-excise-tax-exemptionon-small-scale-gold-mining/
MANILA, Philippines Two lawmakers from gold-rich Benguet province have proposed to remove income and
excise taxes on gold sold to the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP) to curb the smuggling of the precious metal
out of the country.
House Bill 4951, filed by Rep. Nicasio Aliping, Jr. of Baguio City and Rep. Ronald Cosalan of Benguet, seeks to
amend Sections 32 (B) (7) and 151 of Republic Act (RA) 8424, or the National Internal Revenue Code, as
amended, so that gold sold by small-scale miners to the BSP will be exempted from the payment of income and
excise taxes.
In the bills explanatory note, the legislators said the desire among small-scale miners to avoid paying taxes
levied on gold prompts them to sell in the black market where gold ends up being smuggled out of the country.
Section 17 of RA 7076, or the Peoples Small-Scale Mining Act of 1991, mandates that all gold produced by smallscale miners in any mineral area shall be sold to the BSP, or its duly authorized representatives, which shall buy
it at prices competitive with prevailing world market rates regardless of volume or weight.
However, the lawmakers noted that the excise tax on gold is assessed against the BSP in the absence of proof
that the gold miner or producer has paid the said tax.
The BSP thus collects outright the 2-percent excise tax on gold based on the gross amount of gold sold. In
addition, the BSP withholds 5-percent of gross payments as creditable withholding tax, Aliping said in a
statement.
This has adversely affected the gold-buying operations of the BSP which resulted in a significant plunge in its
purchases of gold in 2012 and 2013 as compared to 2011. So that from the 554, 994 fine troy ounces of gold
purchased by the BSP in 2011, its purchases drastically dropped to only 32,888 fine troy ounces in 2012, and
down further to a measly 17,778 fine troy ounces in 2013, Aliping added.
Cosalan said any depletion of the BSPs gold inventory would affect monetary stability and the convertibility of
the Philippine peso.
The banking and credit system will consequently suffer to the detriment of the economy, Cosalan added.
The proposed law would encourage miners and traders to sell their gold to the BSP rather than in the black
market, the legislators said.
The BSP would thus be able to maintain adequate international reserves to meet forseeable net demands for
foreign currencies, Cosalan said.
HB 4951 is now pending at the Committee of Ways and Means chaired by Rep. Romero Quimbo of Marikina
City.
With report from Cyra Moraleda
many cases, an excessive withholding tax rate only results in huge amounts of creditable withholding taxes in
the taxpayer account if the amount withheld is higher that the income taxes payable.
The new regulations also added a paragraph to the requirement of proof of withholding and remittance of the
5% withholding tax to enable sellers/possessors to claim the costs and expenses associated therewith. This
addition amplifies the importance of the withholding of tax on purchase of minerals, failure of which will cause
the disallowance of the costs and expenses to sellers/possessors.
As certain ambiguities of RR No. 7-2008 have been addressed by th recent issuance, buyers of minerals,
regardless of whoever is selling, can now be assured that the 5% rate is the correct withholding tax.
The presscon was attended by NSCB Secretary General Jose Ramon Albert, National Statistics Office (NSO)
Administrator Carmelita Ericta and Statistical Research Center Executive Director GervasioSelda Jr. who came
all the way from Manila to help in the media event.
The 2012 GRDP performance indicated that among industry sector (mining and quarrying, manufacturing,
construction, and electricity, gas and water supply), mining
and quarrying contributed only P1.6 billion in 2012, a sharp decrease compared to P4.1 billion in 2011 and P5.9
billion in 2010 computed at constant 2000 prices.
Director Lim of NEDA said that the decline of minings contribution is due to stoppage of miners and traders in
selling their gold produce to the BSP after the imposition of the 10-percent creditable withholding tax.
She said there was a need to educate the miners and gold traders on the importance of selling their gold to the
BSP, adding she does not see the possibility of the BIR back-tracking and suspending the tax in question.
Well just have to convince them that the taxes they will pay would enable the government to implement
projects that will eventually benefit miners and their families, Lim said.
Another government official who declined to be identified said that BIR will soon file charges for tax evasion
against small-scale miners and gold traders who are not dealing with Bangko Sentral or are not reporting
accurately their income to the BIR.
He said the BIR had established the identity of small-scale miners and gold traders.
When interviewed about the problem, veteran small-scale miners and former Diwalwal barangay captain Franco
Tito suggested that government review the tax because this is reason the gold traders have stopped selling to
BSP.
Kasagaran man gud sa mga minero, sir, may mga utang sa gold buyer mao nga didto sila mobaligya. Ang mga
gold buyer mao nag black market kay sumala nila dako na ang ginakuha sa central bank unya gamay lang ang
ilang patong kada gramo sa ilang gipalit sa mga gagmayng minero, (Usually, the miners are indebted to the
gold buyers, so that they sell their gold to them. The gold buyers are the ones selling to the black market,
because according to them, the central bank now deducts a lot of taxes from them, despite the fact their mark-up
per gram is very minimal), Tito said.
According to veteran business writer Carmelito Q. Francisco, the high prices of gold in the international market
also prompts gold buyers to decide to sell to the informal market, instead of the Bangko Sentral.
The bill also seeks the amendment of Section 151 of RA 8424, as amended, so that Gold sold by small-scale
miners to the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas pursuant to RA 7076 shall be exempt from the payment of excise tax.
Provided, however, that if excise tax thereon was paid prior to the sale of gold to the BSP, the taxpayer may file
a claim for the refund or credit for excise tax paid.
Taxes discourage small miners from selling gold to the BSP, official says
Source: http://www.bworldonline.com/content.php?section=Nation&title=taxes-discourage-small-minersfrom-selling-gold-to-the-bsp-official-says&id=95890
Nation
Posted on October 10, 2014 07:44:00 PM
By Carmencita A. Carillo, Correspondent
DAVAO CITY -- Gold purchased by the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP) from small-scale miners have
plunged, no thanks to several taxes collected on sale transactions by the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR).
The Philippines central bank is only able to purchase 20,000 troy ounces from small-scale gold miners, from a
previous high of 900,000 troy ounces, BSP Deputy Governor Diwa C. Guinigundo said.
Data from the Mines and Geosciences Bureau indicate that the gross production value in small-scale mining as
collected by the BSP stood at P42.9 billion in 2010, fell to P34.1 billion in 2011, then significantly plunged to P1.2
billion in 2012 and only P300 million in 2013.
As of the first quarter this year, purchase value was only P40 million.
Mr. Guinigundo blamed the situation on the BIRs policy of collecting 2% excise tax and 5% creditable
withholding tax at the BSPs five buying stations since July 2011.
The decline in the number of gold sold to us by the small scale gold miners is significant due to the BIRs policy
to collect taxes right at our buying centers, Mr. Guinigundo said on Tuesday during the 2014 Awards
Ceremony for BSP Stakeholders in Mindanao.
Mr. Guinigundo said the 900,000 troy ounces of gold they used to purchase is estimated at P51.5 billion, which
would have contributed $1.2 billion to the countrys gold reserves.
From 2012 to 2013, were lucky if we can even make two to three gold bars a month, he said.
Each gold bar weighs approximately 12 kilos.
Neither the government nor the miners benefit from the existing arrangement.
Everybody appears to be at the losing end because the BSP is not able to build up its gross international
reserves (GIR) and the BIR is not able to collect the taxes from the small miners, he said.
The small scale miners, meanwhile, are also put at a disadvantage by getting low prices in the black market.
Buyers know they (miners) do not want to sell their gold to the government, then they are being offered
uncompetitive rates for their gold, Mr. Gunigundo pointed out.
Section 17 of Republic Act 7076, the Peoples Small Scale Mining Act of 1991, provides that All gold produced
by small-scale miners in any mineral area shall be sold to the Central Bank, or its duly authorized
representative.
Small-scale miners are not allowed to use hydraulic and compressor methods and are limited to extracting
50,000 metric tons of ore before processing per year.
The MGB estimates about 3,000 registered small-scale miners in the country, who are limited to gold, silver, and
chromite extraction.
BSP has gold buying centers at its offices in the cities of Zamboanga and Davao in Mindanao, and Naga, Baguio
and Quezon City in Luzon.
Mr. Gunigundo said some members of Congress from the areas where BSP has buying stations are already
looking into the possibility of amending Republic Act 8424 or the National Internal Revenue Code to exempt
small scale miners from the excise and withholding taxes.
BSP reported gross international reserves of $80.43 billion as of end-September, slightly lower than the $80.87
billion as of August.
The decrease in reserves was attributed to the revaluation adjustments on the BSPs gold holdings and other
foreign currency-denominated reserves as well as payments for maturing foreign exchange obligations of the
national government.
The GIR is composed of central bank assets held in different currencies, gold and special drawing rights with the
International Monetary Fund, as well as foreign exchange deposits of the government and other state-run firms.
Gold, which remained the second largest contributor to the reserves at $7.569 billion, was also lower than the
previous months $8.050 billion.
BSP data shows that foreign currency holdings increased 42% from $858 .4 million in August to $1.216 billion in
September while the reserve positions increased by 1.2% from $597.6 million to $604.5 million during the same
period.
Trading of Philippine gold with BSP falls 92% in Q1; smuggling blamed
Source: http://business.inquirer.net/64361/trading-of-philippine-gold-with-bsp-falls-92-in-q1-smugglingblamed
Kristine L. Alave
@inquirerdotnet Philippine Daily Inquirer
8:56 PM | Sunday, June 10th, 2012
Read more:
MANILA, PhilippinesDespite rising metal prices worldwide, the amount of gold traded in the country
plunged by an unbelievable 92 percent in the first quarter of the year, leaving the Department of Environment
and Natural Resources (DENR) to wonder where the precious metal all went.
From 7,493 kilograms of gold worth P14.11 billion purchased in the same period in 2011, the gold purchases of
the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP), the only authorized agency to buy and sell gold, went down to a dismal
618 kilograms worth P1.35 billion in the first quarter, the DENR reported.
Given the continuing high price of gold and the increasing number of small-scale mining areas, the decrease in
gold purchases by the BSP clearly means that the gold output is going to the blackmarket and smuggling,
Environment Secretary Ramon Paje said.
He said the Presidential Anti-Organized Crime Task Force should investigate this.
Although the gold output has been declining in 2012, it has so far been markedly higher than the quantity
brought to the BSP, the DENR said. In the first quarter of 2012, the DENR said actual gold production
plummeted by 65 percent to 4,056 kg, with the value dropping by 57 percent to P9.33 billion.
Paje said the taxes imposed by the Bureau of Internal Revenue on gold trade in 2011 may have led gold buyers
and sellers to trade underground or smuggle it abroad. This way, they could avoid paying the two percent
excise tax and the 10 percent creditable withholding tax to the government.
Prices of gold and silver were up by 21.95 percent and 2.68 percent, respectively. The yellow metal traded above
the $1,600 per troy ounce level, the highest of which was $1,743 per troy ounce recorded in February 2012,
according to the DENR.
DENR officials said it has been difficult to track actual production of gold, which was mostly mined by smallscale miners. MGB Director Leo Jasareno said they mostly relied on gold data from the BSP and the reporting
from established mines.
With the global economy still floundering, gold is seen as a safe haven for investment.
The DENR said it expected greater gold volumes in the coming quarters as big mining companies have been set
to operate in various parts of the country.
Reduce tax rate on BSP purchase of gold to curb smuggling -- Senate think-tank
By: Likha Cuevas-Miel, InterAksyon.com
May 22, 2013 7:20 PM
Source: http://www.interaksyon.com/business/62367/reduce-tax-rate-on-bsp-purchase-of-gold-to-curbsmuggling----senate-think-tank
MANILA - To curb the smuggling of gold out of the country, the government should consider reducing the tax
rate on the sale of the precious metal to the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP), a Senate think tank said.
According to the Senate Tax Study-Research Office (STSRO), gold smuggling continues given its status as an
economic indicator, a hedging tool against the US dollar, aside from being useful in industries. Economic
downturns push its price to shoot up--enough incentive for traders to smuggle the commodity out of the
country.
The Mines and Geosciences Bureau (MGB) earlier reported a drop in the country's metallic mineral
output because of the lower volume of gold that the BSP bought from small-scale miners.
BSP Governor Amando M. Tetangco said the new tax on gold purchases was to blame for the drop in
production.
The MGB said about 90 percent of the gold produced by small-scale miners is smuggled from Manila to Hong
Kong before entering mainland China. Some of it also enters Malaysia, the bureau said, adding that organized
crime groups may be involved in the smuggling of around 24 tons of the commodity.
Hong Kong statistics showed that from 2005 to 2012, the Philippines was the top source of imported gold,
peaking at 81,471 kilograms in 2010. In contrast, official Philippine statistics showed that gold exports to Hong
Kong in 2010 and 2011 comprised only three percent of total recorded volume. Official data represents
shipments made by big mining firms with supply contracts, since small-scale miners are banned from exporting
their gold.
STSRO said traders have enough reason to export rather than sell to the BSP. First, the price of gold in the
international market is higher than what the central bank would pay for. Second, the BSP in 2011 began slapping
a two-percent excise tax and a five-percent withholding tax on gold purchases.
"Considering that it is mandatory for small scale miners to sell its gold to the BSP, it therefore recommended to
evaluate the merits the tax impositions on gold sold to the BSP," STSRO said.
Aside from lowering the taxes on local sale of gold, the government should also consider rationalizing the tax
regime for mining, as stated in Executive Order No. 79. There should also be participation in the Extractive
Industries Transparency Initiative to create a centralized industry database, STSRO said.
On top of this, there should be a separate mining section in the National Internal Revenue Code, as
recommended by the International Monetary Fund, to clarify the treatment of components of income and
deductions of mining firms when computing their liabilities in addition to royalties.
Lastly, the STSRO said the anti-smuggling bill should be passed, with a separate provision on illegal export of
the precious metal.
Solons seek income and excise taxes exemption of gold sold to Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas
Total views: 617
17 September 2014 10:31:28 AM
Writer: Rowena B. Bundang, Media Relations Service-PRIB
Source: http://www.congress.gov.ph/press/details.php?pressid=8168
Lawmakers are seeking to remove the excise and income taxes on gold sold to the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas
(BSP) to curb smuggling of gold out of the country and enhance the BSP's gold resources.
The removal of such taxes would encourage small-scale miners and traders to sell their gold to the BSP rather
than on the black market according to Reps. Nicasio M. Aliping, Jr. (Lone District, Baguio City) and Ronald M.
Cosalan (Lone District, Benguet).
The solons' proposal is embodied in House Bill 4951, which seeks to further amend Sections 32 and 151 of
Republic Act 8424, as amended, otherwise known as the "National Internal Revenue Code.
Aliping said in order to promote the accumulation of gold resources and the sale of gold to the BSP, Section 17
of Republic Act 7076, otherwise known as the "People's Small-Scale Mining Act of 1991," mandates that all gold
produced by small-scale miners in any mineral area shall be sold to the BSP, or its duly authorized
representatives, which shall buy it at prices competitive with those prevailing in the world market regardless of
volume or weight.
However, Aliping said the excise tax on gold is assessed against the BSP in the absence of proof that the gold
miner or producer has paid the excise tax.
"The BSP thus collects outright the two percent excise tax on gold based on the gross amount of gold sold. In
addition, the BSP withholds five percent of gross payments as creditable withholding tax," said Aliping, a vice
chairman of the House Committees on North Luzon Growth Quadrangle, and on Higher and Technical
Education.
He said small-scale miners and traders who seek to avoid payment of excise and income taxes sell their gold to
buyers in the black market. From the black market, the gold is smuggled out of the country, according to him.
"This has adversely affected the gold-buying operations of the BSP which resulted in a significant plunge in its
purchases of gold in 2012 and 2013 as compared to 2011. So that from the 554,994 fine troy ounces of gold
purchased by the BSP in 2011, its purchases drastically dropped to only 32,888 fine troy ounces in 2012, and
down further to a measly 17,778 fine troy ounces in 2013," said Aliping.
Cosalan, chairman of the Committee on Public Works and Highways, said by removing excise and income taxes
on gold sold to the BSP, small-scale miners and traders would be encouraged to sell their gold to the BSP rather
than on the black market.
"The smuggling of gold out of the country would thus be curbed and the accumulation by the BSP of gold
resources would be greatly enhanced. The BSP would thus be able to maintain adequate international reserves
to meet foreseeable net demands for foreign currencies," said Cosalan.
Cosalan further said any depletion in the BSP's gold inventory would affect monetary stability and the
convertibility of the Philippine peso. "The banking and credit system will consequently suffer to the detriment of
the economy," he said.
He explained the BSP has statutory authority to buy and sell gold in any form at prevailing market prices. Gold
buying is an integral mandate of the BSP to manage the gross international reserves of the country according to
Cosalan.
"The gold holdings of the BSP is determinative of the strength of the country's international reserve position and
also serves as security and hedge against inflation," said Cosalan.
House Bill 4951, now pending at the Committee on Ways and Means chaired by Rep. Romero S. Quimbo (2nd
District, Marikina City), seeks the amendment of Section 32 (B) (7) of RA 8424 so that excluded from gross
income and shall be exempt from taxation is "Income derived by small-scale miners from the sale of gold to the
Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas pursuant to Republic Act 7076."
The bill also seeks the amendment of Section 151 of RA 8424, as amended, so that "Gold sold by small-scale
miners to the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas pursuant to RA 7076 shall be exempt from the payment of excise tax.
Provided, however, that if excise tax thereon was paid prior to the sale of gold to the BSP, the taxpayer may file
a claim for the refund or credit for excise tax paid."
Central banks, especially those in emerging economies, have accelerated gold purchases in recent months to
diversify growing foreign exchange reserves, with official sector gold purchases in the third quarter surging
over five-fold from a year ago to 148.4 tons, according to the World Gold Council.
Data from the International Monetary Fund showed the BSPs gold holdings fell the most so far this year among
central banks, with Mexico, Russia and Thailand as the biggest buyers.
Paje said gold smuggling was a form of economic sabotage as it was affecting the countrys foreign reserves.
Subsistence miners
He dismissed the idea that miners were hoarding gold, noting that they must sell it immediately to take
advantage of the high prices.
Most of the gold miners are subsistence miners, who need to sell their find quickly, Paje said.
The major gold-producing areas include Camarines Sur, Camarines Norte, Compostela Valley and the Caraga
region.
Paje urged the customs and law enforcement officials to look into the matter, noting that this involves organized
crime.
Selling gold abroad is a complex operation as miners need traders and buyers along the way, said the
environment secretary.
King of metals
Gold remains the king of Philippine metals in terms of value, if not volume, according to the Mines and
Geosciences Bureau (MGB). It accounts for about half of the earnings of the mining sector.
Gold production declined slightly from January to September this year, but the metals value rose by 3 percent
to P50.5 billion.
In the first nine months of the year, the gold volume was 25,249 kg, down 14 percent from the 29,401 kg a year
ago.
According to the MGBs third quarter report, the countrys overall production value rose 15 percent to P90.02
billion from P78.58 billion in the same period in 2010. Prices of silver, copper and nickel also went up.
Silver production was up 9 percent to 32,951 kg, and earnings grew 178 percent to P2.2 billion
In its annual report last year, the central bank said it incurred P86.31 billion in losses as of November, nearing a
new record. This was traced from a 46-percent decline in revenues, particularly in miscellaneous income.
The decline in miscellaneous was attributed partly to lower trading gains of gold in foreign financial
institutions.
The BSP was established through RA No. 7653 as a replacement to the old central bank. The latter was folded in
1993 after it incurred huge debts and losses, which until now are being settled.
Henares said the policy on gold sales would remain being one of tax leakages the Aquino administration wants
plugged.
For Biazon, the Customs bureau has no other choice but to accept that the agencys job just got tougher.
The problem is that the means of bringing gold out does not pass through the regular channels. They are most
likely carried by couriers, he said.
(But) thats the policy of the DoF. We are standing with the BIR. Although, it is really a bit difficult to monitor
that kind of activity.
Biazon, however, did not discount that some gold may have not even left our shores and are just being diverted
to the black market.
With the data we have, it cannot be conclusive, but most likely, it is possible because these are other Its difficult
to trace that, he said.