You are on page 1of 37

Free Cash Flow

Concept of free cash flow


Future cash flows generated from an investment that are free to
distribute to the investors (including stockholders and creditors)
that determine the value of the investment.
Financial cash flow presents free cash flow (FCF); by free, we
mean it is after necessary expenses (reinvestments) needed for
continuing operations.
Financial cash flow differs from accounting cash flow
The accounting cash flow statement determines accounting cash flows,
which explains the change in cash and equivalents.
The cash flow statement mixes cash flows from operating and
financing activities, so it does not directly give the information on
financial cash flow.
Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 1

Free Cash Flow


FCF=(R-E)*(1-t)+t*Dep-cap exp- change in WC

The FCF formula


Cap. Exp

Free cash flow (FCF) = OCF NCS NWC


Operating cash flow (OCF): from a companys normal

business activities; typically calculated based on EBIT or


net income.
Top down!

OCF = EBIT + Depreciation Taxes


= EBIT( 1 Tax rate) + Depreciation
where, Taxes = EBIT Tax rate

Bottom up

OCF = Net income + Depreciation + (1 Tax rate) Interest expense


where, Net income = ( EBIT Interest expense)(1 Tax rate)
Unleavened CF , irrelevant to capital structure!!
Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 2

Free Cash Flow


Investment on fixed assets
Net capital spending (NCS), or capital expenditure, represents
the amounts paid by the firm for investments in fixed assets,
which is the net money spent on fixed assets less money
received from sales of fixed assets.

NCS is a function of how fast a firm is growing or expecting to


grow. High growth firms will have much higher capital spending
than low growth firms.
Given changes in net fixed assets, NFA, and depreciation, net
capital spending is calculated as:
NCS = NFA + Depreciation
Note: Ending NFA = Beginning NFA Depreciation+ NCS
Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 3

Free Cash Flow


Investment on working capital
Increase in net working capital, NWC, represents the firms
investment on its working capital.
NWC = Ending NWC Beginning NWC

In accounting terms, NWC is the difference between current


assets (cash, inventory and accounts receivable) and current
liabilities (accounts payable and debt due within the next year).
For valuation purposes, the calculation of NWC needs to exclude
the effects of non-operating current assets and liabilities (next slide).
NWC= cash+inventory+receivable-payable

Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 4

Free Cash Flow


Non-operating CA and CL
Some components of the accounting measures of current assets and
current liabilities (such as excess cash and debt interests) are not
operation or production related, and hence their changes do not
adequately reflect requirement for working capital investment.
Cash: When a company increased its cash by increasing
retained earnings (reducing dividend payment), does increased
cash mean reduced free cash flow?
Short-term debt: When a company changed its capital structure
by borrowing less while raising more equity capital, does the

reduction in short-term debt mean reduced free cash flow?

Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 5

Free Cash Flow


Therefore, a cleaner definition of working capital from the cash
flow perspective is:
NWC = Non-cash CA Non-debt CL
As any investment in this measure of working capital ties up cash,
an increases (decreases) in working capital will reduce (increase)
FCF in that period.

Working capital calculated using above formula tends to be


volatile from year to year. So, alternatively, we often determine
NWC as a proportion of revenues.
This alternative method is the percentage-of-sales approach to
financial forecast, which is to be discussed below.

Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 6

Free Cash Flow


Example: The Gap, as a retailer, has substantial working capital
needs. The following table reports its current assets and current
liabilities at the end of the 2013 and 2014 financial years,
respectively.
Current assets

Cash
Inventory
Other non-cash CA

Current liabilities

2013

2014

$466

$350

$1,462

$1,704

$285

$335

2013

2014

Accounts payable

$806

$1,067

Short-term debt

$392

$395

Other non-debt CL

$778

$702

Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 7

Free Cash Flow


The following table summarizes the calculations of NWC in years 2013
and 2014 as a percent of revenues.
Suppose that revenues will grow at 13% in 2015, 9% in 2016, and 7% in
2017. If NWC will change proportionally with sales at the average percent
of sales during 2013-2014, predict changes in NWC for 2015-2017.
History
Non-cash CA
Non-debt CL
NWC
NWC as % of revenues
NWC
Revenues

2013
$1,747
$1,584
$163

2014
$2,039
$1,769
$270

1.4%

2.0%
$107
$13,673

$11,635

Forecast
2015E

2016E

2017E

$263
1.7%
-$7
$15,450

$286
1.7%
$23
$16,841

$306
1.7%
$20
$18,020

Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 8

Free Cash Flow


Example: Calculating FCF (using next two slides)
OCF = EBIT + Depreciation Taxes = 694 + 65 208 = $551
NCS = Ending NFA Beginning NFA + Depreciation
= 1,709 1,644 + 65 = $130
Based on operating CA and CL:
NWC = Ending NWC Beginning NWC

= (1,243 291) (1,008 271) = $215


FCF = 551 130 215 = $206

Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 9

Free Cash Flow


Global Corporation
2012 Income Statement ($million)
Net sales (Revenues)
Cost of goods sold (COGS)
Depreciation
Earnings before interest and taxes (EBIT)
Interest paid
Taxable income (EBT)
Taxes (at 30%)
Net income (NI)
Dividends
Addition to retained earnings

$1,509
750
65
$ 694
70
$ 624
187
$ 437
$109
328

Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 10

Free Cash Flow


Global Corporation
2012 and 2013 Balance Sheet ($millions)
Assets
Current assets:
Cash and equivalents
Accounts receivable
Inventory
Total current assets

2011
$104
455
553
$1,112

Fixed assets:
Property, plant and equip.
$1,233
Intangible assets and others
411
Total fixed assets
$1,644

Total assets

$2,756

2012
$160
688
555
$1,403

$1,280
429
$1,709

$3,112

Liabilities and Equity

2011

2012

Current liabilities:
Accounts payable
Notes payable
Accrued expenses
Total current liabilities

$232
157
39
$428

$266
98
25
$389

Long-term debt

$408

$454

Owners equity
Common stock and
paid-in surplus
Retained earnings
Total equity
Total liabilities and equity

600
640
1,320
1,629
$1,920 $2,269
$2,756 $3,112

Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 11

Adjusting Earnings
Obtaining most recent financial information
Constructing trailing 12-month data

7/1-6/30
1.1-31/12 China

From most recent half-year or quarterly reports


Most recent annualized earnings

Most recent balance sheet items


May have to use some items from latest annual report

Example on the next slide


Make sure earning is updated

Obtaining the updated earnings information is particularly

important for smaller and more volatile firms.

Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 12

Updated Financial Status

Sept 2009

Mar 2010

Sept 2010

Mar 2011

Sept 2011

April 11
Bs: direct use half yearly
INCOME ITEM:
Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 13

Adjusting Earnings
Adjustments for R&D expenses
R&D expenses are to generate future growth, so are long-term

investment in nature.
Accounting standards however require that all R&D spending be

expensed in the period in which they occur. Hence,


R&D expenses are included in operating expenses.
R&D expenses do not show up on the balance sheet as part of
the total assets of the firm.
To capitalize R&D expenses

Correct earnings & shareholder equity for R&D expenses


R&D assets need to be amortized.
Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 14

Adjusting Earnings
The effect of R&D expenses on equity
Adjusted equity = Equity + Value of R&D assets
As capital investment, R&D expenses increase long-term assets
and hence equity, and are amortized over time.

The assets from R&D expenses equals the sum of all unamortized
portions of all previous years R&D expenses.

The effect of R&D expenses on earnings


Adjusted operating earnings = Operating earnings

EBIT

+ Current-years R&D expenses Amortization of R&D assets

where amortization is the total amortization of all assets from R&D


expenses of previous years.
Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 15

Updated Financial Status

Year 1:
Adjusted
Equity :

Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 16

Adjusting Earnings
Adjustments for lease expenses

Operating lease vs Finance lease


OL shorter than item life
Else for 10 year VS 30 year

Operating lease expenses are financial expenses, but are

treated as operating expenses (often revealed in footnotes).


Converting operating leases into debt
Adjusted debt = Debt + Value of lease commitments
where value of lease commitments equals the present value of lease
commitments discounted at kd.

The effect on operating earnings


Adjusted operating earnings = Operating earnings
+ (Operating lease expenses Depreciation on leased assets)

Operating earnings + Value of lease RD


Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 17

Adjusting Earnings
Extraordinary and unusual items
Earnings that can be used as a basis for projections should
reflect continuing operations, and not one-time items.
One-time expense or income items (e.g., a large restructuring

charge): should be excluded in the calculation of earnings.


Some items may appear less frequently than annually, but still

recur at some regular intervals (e.g., every 3 years). In this case,


one option is to spread the expense out by calculating its effect
on earnings annually.

Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 18

Forecast and Cash Flows


Forecast using the percentage-of-sales approach
When most balance sheet and income statement accounts

vary with sales, we can obtain the financial statement forecast


based on a sales forecast.
With the percentage-of-sales approach
We start with sales forecast.
Then based upon it, we determine pro-forma (forecasted)
financial statements.
Then the needs for external financing can be identified.

Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 19

Forecast and Cash Flows


Determine the growth of company

Sales forecast
Sales forecast is the starting point of financial forecast, and is

key to long-term planning.


Perfect knowledge is impossible since sales depend on the

uncertain future state of the economy


Try to identify all valuable investment opportunities within the
company, and make reasonable assumptions about the future
overall market for the companys products.
Get help in estimating sales from businesses that specialize in
macroeconomic and industry projections

Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 20

Forecast and Cash Flows


Using historical growth information to predict future growth
Historical average growth

Technical analysis

Liner or log-linear regression models


More sophisticated time series models

Using information from analyst forecasts of earnings growth


Analyst forecasts of growth can be better because they can use

information other than historical, including other public information


and even private information.
More useful for more analyst coverage (e.g., for larger firms).

Less reliable for greater variation in analyst forecasts.

Understanding fundamental factors

Know about the company.

Managerial efficiency, payout policy, financing policy


The companys long-term plan
Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 21

Forecast and Cash Flows


Income statement forecast
For many income statement items that vary directly with sales

(e.g. costs), use historical data to determine their relations


with (as a percent of) sales.
For items that do not necessarily change directly with sales,

understand the specific mechanism. For example:


Interest expense depends on debt.

Dividends depend on the firms payout policy.


To obtain free cash flows, we only need to forecast income
items down to EBIT.
Interest / dividend.
Mature companies in developed countries hv stable dividend policy.
But China and HK don't usually pay dividend.
Not relate to SALES
Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 22

Forecast and Cash Flows


Effective vs. marginal tax rate
The effective tax rate is computed from the reported income
statement as: Effective tax rate = Taxes due / Taxable income
The marginal tax rate depends on the tax code and reflects what
firms have to pay as taxes on their marginal income.
Use the highest.

If the same tax rate has to be applied to earnings every period,


the safer choice is the marginal tax rate.
Most of the taxable income of publicly traded firms is at the highest

marginal tax bracket.


Most tax-reduction benefits cannot sustained in perpetuity.
Suffer loss. - MTR not useful in near future.

Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 23

Forecast and Cash Flows


The effect of net operating losses
There are tax savings for firms having large net operating losses
carried forward or continuing operating losses. There are two
ways of capturing this effect:
Approach 1: Changing tax rates over time (from zero to positive
and then to the marginal tax rate).
Change gradually from 0 to MTR

Approach 2: Valuing the expected tax savings generated by net


operating losses and the firm without considering the tax savings
separately, and then adding them up.
The second approach is often used when the firm already has
positive earnings but has a large net operating loss carried forward.

Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 24

Forecast and Cash Flows


Balance sheet forecast
For assets items that vary directly with sales, use historical data

to determine their relations with (as a percentage of) sales.


Fixed asset :%/sales

Notes payable, long-term debt, and equity generally do not vary

with sales; they depend on management decisions on capital


structure.
Change in the retained earnings portion of equity will come from

the dividend decision.


Ending retained earnings
= Beginning retained earnings + (Net income Dividends)

BS: State variable


IS: flow variables.

Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 25

Forecast and Cash Flows


External funding needed (EFN)

LTD/ SH equity : No relationship with SALES.


Imbalance: LHS&RHS.

External funding needed: the difference between the forecast

increase in assets and the forecast increase in liabilities and equity.


EFN = Total assets (Liabilities + Shareholders equity)
Understanding EFN

To support yr forecast , u need more fund to support


your asset. So need EFN.

Negative or positive EFN


Dealing with EFN: the firms financing strategy
Evaluating the financial forecast and plan
-EFN: asset requirement is less than what u load.
You may hv too much cash.
+EFT: need more Equity or debt.

+: need to decide how to get additional capital


; OR increase RE
-: make future investment or just pay dividend.
( special dividend )
Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 26

Forecast and Cash Flows


Get additional finance:

Growth and (internal & external) financing


At low levels of growth, internal financing (retained earnings) may
exceed the required investment in assets.
At high levels of growth, internal financing will not be enough, and
the company can do the following:
To increase profit margin (higher operating efficiency)

More realistic. !!!!!

To increase asset turnover (higher asset-use efficiency)


To reduce dividend payout (more internal financing)
To raise equity capital (cost of equity; stock market conditions)
To borrow money (cost of debt; credit risk)

Is the sales growth forecast realistic?

FF need revise and revise again and then


achieve balance.
This is called FINANCIAL PLANNING --company's LT plan.
Make sure it is realistic !
Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 27

Financial Forecast: Example


R&E Supply is a modest-size wholesaler of plumbing and
electrical supplies (in the heating, ventilation, air
conditioning and refrigeration industry), located in Little
Rock, Arkansas. Carl Miller Sr. started refrigeration and
electric supply with a single refrigeration and electric supply
store on East Markham Street in Little Rock, Arkansas in
1935.
The company currently has an annual revenue of $10 to 20
million and employs a staff of 20 to 50.

Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 28

Financial Statements for R&E Supplies, Inc.


December 31 ($thousand)

2002

2003

2004

2005*

Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 29

2002

2003

2004

2005*

Didn't issue additional and repurchase

Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 30

Financial Forecast: Example


Selected historical financial ratios
History
Annual growth rate in sales

2002
--

2003
23%

2004
17%

Forecast

2005
28%

Ratios tied to sales (%)


85
86
86
9
10
11
27
29
27
11
15
16

Cost of goods sold (% sales)


General, selling & admin. expenses (% sales)
Total current assets (% sales)
Current liabilities excluding debt (% sales)

84
9
28
9

Tax/earnings before tax


Dividends/earnings after tax

Other ratios in percent (%)


45
45
45
45
50
50
50
50

2006
25% Average.

86
12
28
14

45
50

Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 31

Financial Forecast: Example


Pro forma income statement, 2006
Income Statement (December 31, 2006; $thousand)

Net sales
Cost of goods sold
Gross profit
Expenses:
General, selling and admin expenses
Net interest expense (760 @ 10%)
15:LTD.
Earnings before tax
- assuming LTD doesn't change !
Tax
Earnings after tax

$ 25,766
22,159
3,607
3,092
76
439
198
$ 241

Comments
25% increase
86% of sales

12% sales

45% tax rate

Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 32

Financial Forecast: Example


Pro forma balance sheet, 2006
Balance Sheet (December 31, 2006; $thousand)

Assets
Current assets
Net fixed assets
Total assets

$ 7,214
412
7,626

Liabilities and Owners Equity


Current portion of long-term debt
Other current liabilities
Total current liabilities
Long-term debt
Common stock
Retained earnings
Total liabilities and owners equity

100
3,607
3,707
660
150
1,700
$ 6,217

External funding required

$ 1,409

Comments
28% sales
1.6% sales

As in 2005
14% sales
Existing debt
As in 2005
As explained

Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 33

Financial Forecast: Example


Balance-sheet items
Retained earnings: $1,700 = $1,580 + $241 - $121
External funding needed: $1,409 = $7,626 - $6,217

Interest expense
The interest expense is calculated for existing debt at the beginning
of the financial year, $760 thousands, without taking into account
any new debt needed in the year.

If interest expense needs to be calculated for both existing and new


debt, then there would be a circularity problem: On the one hand,
interest expenses depend on total debt, which in turn depends on
the external funding required; on the other hand, the required
$1409: need
at
external
funding depends on interest expenses.
- end of the year: NP. WONT affect current year interest expense.
-start of the year : CP! Change interest expense and then change the ETN again.
Complicated.
WE assume interest expense at the beginning of year based on existing level of debt !!

Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 34

Forecasting with a Computer Spreadsheet:


Pro-Forma Financial Forecast for R&E Supplies
ASSUMPTIONS BOX
A

1
2 Year
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15

Net sales
Growth rate in net sales
Cost of good sold/net sales
Gen., sell. & admin. expenses/net sales
Long-term debt
Current portion long-term debt
Interest rate
Tax rate
Dividend/earnings after tax
Current assets/net sales
Net fixed assets
Current liabilities/net sales
Owners' equity

B
2005 Actual

2006

$20,613

$760
$100

25.0%
86.0%
12.0%
$660
$100
10.0%
45.0%
50.0%
28.0%
1.6%
14.0%

$1,730
Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 35

16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40

B
Equations

C
Forecast

Income Statement Forecast (2006)


Net sales
Cost of goods sold
Gross profit
Gen. sell. & admin. exp.
Interest expense
Earnings before tax
Tax
Earnings after tax
Dividends paid
Additions to retained earnings

=B3+B3*C4
=C5*C19
=C19-C20
=C6*C19
=C9*(C7+C8)
=C21-C22-C23
=C10*C24
=C24-C25
=C11*C26
=C26-C27

Balance Sheet (2006)


Current assets
Net fixed assets
Total assets

=C12*C19
=C13*C19
=C31+C32

7,215
412
7,627

Current liabilities without debt


Long-term debt
Equity
Total liabilities & shareholders' equity

=C14*C19
=B7
=B15+C28
=C35+C36+C37

3,607
760
1,851
6,218

External Capital Required

=C33-C38

$25,766
22,159
3,607
3,092
76
439
198
242
121
121

$1,409
Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 36

Sensitivity and scenario analyses


Forecasting risk: the possibility that errors in projected cash flows
will lead to incorrect decisions, which is unavoidable because
uncertainty is involved in financial planning

Sensitivity analysis: identifying the sensitivity of a key decision


variable (e.g., external funding required) to a single factor (e.g.,
sales growth or the cost of goods sold), holding other factors
constant

Scenario analysis: determining the effect on our forecast by


changing a set of factors at a time

Scenario and sensitivity analyses generate various possibilities some are good and some are bad, which deepen our understanding
of the project and help us make a better decision (though we dont
get any guidance as to what to do).

Cash Flows and Financial Forecast 37

You might also like